58 min · 3,050 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 58-minute exploration of Buddhist epistemology, Kyabje Rinpoche maps the hierarchy of minds from everyday perception to direct realization, distinguishing reflexive awareness, sensory consciousness, mental cognition, and yogic direct valid cognition. Using subtle impermanence as a detailed example, he traces the meditative path from analytical reflection through single-pointed concentration to the moment when non-conceptual realization spontaneously arises, likening the interplay of calm abiding and analytical insight to a fish moving through water without disturbing the current. He concludes by showing how this yogic direct valid cognition is the actual Dharma refuge. Pitched at practitioners already familiar with Buddhist philosophical categories.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0135 – KR.mp3
UUID: bdd2319c-a45d-4fdd-8318-97c220bef62d
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Tenets
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,054
So as usual, we will generate the motivation to listen to these teachings and the motivation should be that we are not attending these teachings for our own benefit. But that instead with the wish of benefiting mother sentient beings which are infinite in numbers, whereas we ourselves are only one. We attend these teachings and specifically with the motivation of placing them in a state of perfection, a state of full enlightenment. I will meditate on this for one or two minutes. So the reason for which Geshe lah insists in keeping with Rinpoche’s tradition or the generation of motivation before any teachings, including teachings of Buddhist philosophy such as these, is that it is in dependence on the motivation that the deeds which we perform become powerful and gain results.
And the orientation of their results is very much contingent on the motivation. In the same way as for instance, the steering wheel of a car decides the orientation of the steering wheel determines in what direction the car is going. So in the same way the steering wheel can be compared to our motivation and this is why the great scholars of yore also emphasized generating the motivation before engaging in reflection on Buddhist philosophy. And so last time, we had started to present minds in general. And when one presents what minds, one has to understand clearly the divisions of mind, the two broad divisions of mind, are divisions of mind into valid cognizers and minds which are not valid cognizers.
And the reason such emphasis is put on the notion of a valid cognizer, a Pramāna in Sanskrit, a Tsema in Tibetan is because these are the best minds. These are the best minds because these are minds which have an element of realization to them. Now this realization may be non conceptual or conceptual. If it is non conceptual, then we speak of a non conceptual valid cognizer. It is an unmistaken mind with respect to its phenomenon.
If on the other hand this realization has an element of conceptuality and analysis to it, if depends on reasons in other words, then we call it a a valid inferential cognizer. But because these are the best of minds, these are the ones which are first investigated, and then we have the other category of minds which are non valid cognizers as well. And then regarding the first category of valid cognizers, which is direct valid cognizers, we have to understand clearly the distinction between direct valid cognizers and the direct cognizers. So direct cognizers are non conceptual minds in general, such as eye consciousnesses, ear consciousnesses and so forth. And for instance an ear consciousness which hears a sound, but doesn’t really recognize it, what we call an inattentive ear consciousness, is a direct cognizer.
It is a non conceptual consciousness which hears a sound, but it is not a valid direct cognizer, because it actually does not engage its object powerfully. Its object appears, but it is not really engaged. We all know also this absent minded type of focusing where we see something, but don’t really not really aware that we are seeing it. This is a this would be a direct visual consciousness, but it would not be a valid direct visual consciousness. It would not be a valid direct cognizer.
So generally speaking, direct cognizers can be divided themselves into direct valid cognizers and then non valid direct cognizers. Non valid direct cognizers include what are known as subsequent consciousnesses, which are the subsequent instance of the consciousness, or for that matter inattentive minds. All of which lack some of the power of direct valid cognizers. And this is the reason for which our text continues at the very bottom of page 11, Geshe-la will skip the middle paragraph. The definition of direct, you should correct it, valid cognition is a knower which is non conceptual and unmistaken.
Now non conceptual here excludes conceptual consciousnesses. What this means is that direct cognizers are necessarily non conceptual. They necessarily proceed without a meaning generality. So what is characteristic of a direct cognizer is that that which appears to it is that which is engaged by it. This is fundamentally different from conceptual minds in which the appearing object of the conceptual mind, the meaning generality, is not that which a conceptual mind engages.
And then, I would suggest that you read privately the definition of a valid cognition on page 11 and the three aspects of the definition and what they specifically exclude. Because Geshe-la will pass directly to the definition of a direct valid cognition, in other words, the first subcategory of valid cognitions at the beginning of page 12, which as you will see is very similar. It is a new and unshakable non conceptual knower. So the term new here indicates that a direct valid cognition is necessarily the first instant of a mind. Unshakable means that it engages its object in an incontrovertible way.
It cannot be turned away from its object. Non conceptual Geshe-la explains, so these are minds which do not apprehend their objects through meaning generalities. And the term knower here is actually in general synonymous with consciousness. What it specifically does here is to exclude the possibility that direct valid cognition would be material. It is non material because it is a knower, because it is a consciousness.
Now in turn, the first or second paragraph on page 12 divides Direct Valid Cognition into four categories: reflexive, sensory, mental and yogic direct valid cognition. These are actually reflective sensory, mental and Yogic cognitions, which in addition are qualified by being non conceptual, in other words direct, and by being valid, in other words being unmistaken, and being the first instant of a consciousness. And then the definition of the first, I. E, reflexive direct valid cognition, the third paragraph of page 12 of your text, is a new unshakable non conceptual knower which is oriented only internally and is a single apprehension. So for those schools which accept the existence of reflexive cognition, reflexive cognition is that component of every single mind which cognizes itself instead of cognizing the object of that mind.
This is something which I explained a couple of lessons ago. And the understanding of that is necessary to understand clearly the meaning of this definition. So in new unshakable non conceptual knowers, these are the characteristics of direct valid cognition. New refers to the first instance of the mind, unshakable the fact it is incontrovertible with respect to its object. Non conceptual means it does not understand its object through a meaning generality.
This we have seen already. But in addition, reflective consciousnesses are said to be oriented only internally. What this means is precisely that they do not apprehend an exterior object as consciousnesses. They are merely that factor of the consciousness which apprehends itself. Therefore they are said to be oriented only internally and they are said to be a single apprehension.
So the term single here, nyer zhen in Tibetan must be understood clearly. It refers to the fact that for those schools which accept the existence of reflexive cognitions, these reflexive cognitions are neither minds nor mental factors. So as you know generally speaking minds are divided into minds or principal minds and mental factors which accompany the principal minds. But a reflexive cognition belongs to neither of these categories. It’s merely that component or that factor of the mind which apprehends itself.
Hence, the meaning of the general definition of a reflexive consciousness that which apprehends the aspect, actually its own aspect. In other words, it apprehends itself. And then, the definition of the second category of direct valid cognizers, which is sensory direct valid cognition is a new unshakable non conceptual knower. In other words, a direct valid cognition, which arises in dependence on a material sense organ, which is its uncommon controlling condition. Here, we have to understand the meaning of the material sense organ.
Material sense organ here does not refer to, for instance, in the case of the eye consciousness, the actual coarse physical eye organ. That is not what is referred to. What is actually referred to by a material sense organ is a subtle visual organ which is very much of the nature of light, one could say, whose main function is to perceive light colors and shapes and which is the result of karmic imprints in the minds of the being, which causes it to arise. So it’s not the physical eyeball which is referred to, nor for that matter, the coarse external ear, the coarse nose and so forth. So these are the uncommon controlling conditions of their respective sensory direct valid cognition.
And what is generally implied here is that a sensory direct valid cognition arises in dependence on three broad categories of conditions. The first are their controlling conditions, in this case the for an eye consciousness, the eye sense organ. Because the eye sense organ is a controlling condition of an eye consciousness, An eye consciousness cannot, for instance, perceive sounds because sounds cannot be perceived by an eye sense organ. Likewise, an auditory consciousness, because it arises in dependence on a subtle ear organ cannot hear sounds and so forth. Then the second category of conditions on which these consciousnesses arise are their object condition.
The object condition of these consciousnesses is actually their cause. To give a simple example for instance, the eye sense consciousness which perceives the statue of a Buddha, such as the one behind us, will have as an object condition, the statue of the Buddha. And the third condition for the arising of these consciousnesses are the immediately preceding conditions, which are the immediately preceding instant which gives rise to them. So, three conditions are necessary for the arising of an eye consciousness. It’s controlling condition, its object condition, and its immediately preceding condition.
And then, in the middle of page 12 on your text, definition c, The definition of the third, I. E. Mental direct valid cognition, is a new unshakable non conceptual knower, in other words, is a direct valid cognition, which arises in dependence on the mental sense organ, which is its uncommon controlling condition. Generally speaking, Geshe-la says that mental direct valid cognition is quite rare in the minds of ordinary beings. Since in the minds of most ordinary beings, mental cognition, mental direct cognition is an inattentive mind.
In as much as it is an inattentive mind, it cannot be a valid cognition. There are exceptions such as those instances of ordinary beings who develop paranormal powers. And for such beings then, there would be in their continuum instances of mental direct valid cognition. But otherwise for most ordinary beings, these are quite rare. And these are defined as direct valid cognitions, which instead of arising in dependence on a physical sense organ, arising in dependence on a mental sense organ.
The mental sense organ is a previous instant of mental consciousness. It is not a physical organ as for the second category. As for the fourth category of direct valid cognition, yogic direct valid cognition, This is generally speaking also a direct valid cognition, in other words it is a valid cognition which is non conceptual. However, its uncommon controlling condition is slightly different than that of the others. It is not actually an organ, but it is a specific union of calm abiding and insight on specific objects of meditation.
And therefore, in the fourfold division of direct valid cognition, We have two broad sub categories of direct valid cognition. We have reflexive direct valid cognition, which Geshe-la explained first, which is a reflexive mind, in other words a mind engaged in auto cognition. And we have non reflexive valid cognition, are the three remaining categories, which are sense direct valid cognition, mental direct valid cognition and the final category Yogic direct valid cognition. Now from within these four categories, the supreme category of Direct and Valid Cognition is Yogic Direct and Valid Cognition. This is the category which really encapsulates all the virtues of Direct and Valid Cognition And the definition of a Yogic direct valid cognition is given on page 12 of your text, section D.
A wisdom which realizes directly either subtle impermanence or the coarse and subtle selflessness of persons, in dependence on a Samādhi, in other words, concentration, which is a union of calm abiding, śamatha, in other words, and special insight, which is its uncommon controlling condition. Geshe-la is going to enter into this definition in some detail. And if we analyze carefully the objects of Yogic direct valid cognition according to the Sautrāntika School, there are three. Yogic direct valid cognition can realize subtle impermanence, the coarse selflessness of persons or the subtle selflessness of persons. Now the process whereby Yogic direct valid cognition gains for instance the realization of the subtle impermanence of phenomena is the following.
Initially one would engage in conceptual analytical meditation on impermanence. First on coarse impermanence which is the fact that all phenomena eventually or most phenomena, most impermanent phenomena have an end to their continuum. In other words, disintegrate or for human beings or sentient beings they die. Then this is only the first step of realization of impermanence, since the on the basis of this realization one has to in turn meditate on subtle impermanence, which is the fact that the dying process is continuous, that phenomena die instant by instant, and beings as well die instant by instant. So meditating on this again and reflecting on this again and again, we will eventually gain a conceptual, unmistaken and incontrovertible understanding of this.
The first instance of this conceptual mind is an inferential valid cognizer of subtle impermanence. This is a valid cognizer, a powerful beneficial mind which transforms our being, but it remains a conceptual mind because it apprehends subtle impermanence, the transitory nature of phenomena through a meaning generality, in other words, a generic image. Then, we engage in single pointed meditation on this again and again. As we engage in single pointed meditation again and again on the subtle impermanence of phenomena, the initial distance between the object which is meditated upon, the impermanence of phenomena, and the mind which is meditated upon it, eventually decreases. They become closer and closer.
As they come closer to each other, the meaning generality through which impermanence or subtle impermanence is apprehended by the mind becomes weaker and weaker. And the mind in turn apprehends the subtle impermanence of phenomena in a clearer and clearer and more and more powerful way. Eventually, the meaning generality of subtle impermanence will have completely disappeared and subtle impermanence would be apprehended non conceptually, directly and nakedly by the mind. At that instant, one would have gained direct realization of the subtle impermanence of phenomena, and this qualifies as a yogic direct valid cognition of subtle impermanence. Generally speaking, one can be said to have attained shamatha when this uncommon feeling of bodily and mental pliancy arises and it is possible for the mind to remain focused on the object of meditation.
This specific case of the example Geshe-la gave, subtle impermanence indefinitely for weeks, months or even years without the mind undergoing any difficulty or without there being any physical hardship. Now the condition for the arrival of a yogic direct valid cognition is a an uncommon controlling condition which is a Samādhi, which is a union of calm abiding and special insight. Therefore most probably it is not possible to give rise to a Yogic direct valid cognition without at least calm abiding or Shine. There is some debate to know whether Shine is indispensable for entering the path of accumulation from within the five paths, the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no-more-learning. Generally speaking, most probably for the two lower vehicles, Shamatha or calm abiding is indispensable to enter the path of accumulation.
There is some debate regarding the Bodhisattva vehicle. However, it is difficult to see how one could progress on the three levels of the path of accumulation, the lower, middling and higher level without calm abiding. So then having given rise to calm abiding, one then focuses the mind single pointedly on the object of meditation. And what in general it is said that calm abiding is a mind which is totally focused on its object of meditation. Nonetheless, at this point one has to engage in a very subtle form of analytical meditation, since there is no vipaśyanā in the context of the union of calm abiding and vipaśyanā without calm abiding as a basis.
So the question which arises is how is this possible? It is said to be similar to the behavior of a fish in a river. A fish in a river swims in the river, but does not disturb noticeably the flow of the river. In the same way, the mind of śamatha is single pointedly focused on its object, which could be either subtle impermanence or the coarse or subtle selflessness of persons. And within the stream of that mind of śamatha, which is single pointedly focused on its object, a subtle analytical stream investigates the object.
As this proceeds progressively, the meaning generality or the conceptual image through which the object of meditation was being perceived starts to weaken until eventually through the power of the combination of śamatha and vipassana, eventually this meaning generality totally disappears. And at this point, one gains direct realization of one of the three objects of meditation and one becomes an ārya being. So this should be of benefit to us for understanding of refuge because the actual Dharma refuge is the yogic direct valid cognition, which is focused on subtle impermanence, the coarse and subtle selflessness of persons. This is the Dharma refuge. The Buddha refuge is the teacher of these yogic direct direct valid cognitions.
And the Sangha refuge are those who practice these. So it will be of great benefit if Geshe-la says from now on, you understand refuge in the light of yogic cognition. And time is over. Mhmm. Right?
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.