Tenets

56 min · 3,134 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 57-minute presentation on Sautrāntika philosophy, Kyabje Rinpoche explains how this Buddhist school categorises phenomena and mind. He first unpacks the division of all objects into the single and the multiple — what is truly single versus what only appears so, what is truly multiple versus what is falsely so — with examples using vases, pillars, and the concepts of past and future. He then turns to the central question of subjects: what transmigrates from life to life across rebirths? This leads into a detailed exploration of consciousness itself. He defines mind as “clear and cognitive,” explains Buddhism’s emphasis on understanding mind, and divides minds into valid and non-valid cognizers, exploring what makes a cognizer “valid” in this school. For serious practitioners of Buddhist philosophy.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Line in 0133 – KR.mp3

UUID: afad0769-597f-4d91-b28c-477d5942838b

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Tenets

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,134

So as usual, we should generate the motivation to receive these teachings. And generally speaking, the motivation, a good motivation should be generated both by the teacher himself and by the students. It helps to reflect that from among all qualities, which are possible, the qualities of the mind are superior to all other qualities. And from within mental qualities, none can be said to be greater than the mind of bodhicitta. So therefore, reflecting of this, about this, let us generate the mind of bodhicitta.

And therefore, from the one side, we should reflect on the infinite sufferings of the quasi-infinite number of beings and generate the strong wish to free them from those sufferings. And from the other side, generate a powerful awareness that at present we are unable to do so in our actual condition. And therefore that we have to reach a state where this is possible. And this state is a state of full enlightenment. And keeping these two reflections in mind, I.

E. That the sufferings of beings are infinite and that we can only free them if we attain full enlightenment, then take the resolve to generate the mind of bodhicitta. This mind of bodhicitta is a mind which aspires for full enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings. And when we reflect on how such a mind can be generated, it becomes obvious that the only way it can be generated is through attending Dharma teachings first, then reflecting on the meaning of the teachings, and then meditating on the meaning of the teachings. Therefore, with this as a motivation, we should listen to these teachings and try to generate this mind first.

So we are at present explaining the second of the four Buddhist schools, the Sautrāntika School. And as is made clear on page eight of your transcript in the bottom section, the Sautrāntika School is explained in terms of a sevenfold division of definitions, divisions, etymologies, asserting objects, in other words phenomena, subjects, selflessness, and grounds and paths. We are present at the level of the fourth of this seven fold division which is a mode of asserting objects or phenomena. And there are several different objects which are presented. We saw last time one division in positive and negative phenomena.

We will at present see alternative divisions of objects. And then the various divisions of phenomena which have been explained are first, the division of phenomena into conventional and ultimate truths according to the Sautrāntika School. Secondly, what we should have explained last time, the phenomena, division of phenomena in terms of their appearance into positive or negative phenomena. And today, we will approach the division of phenomena into the single and different or the single and the multiple, which is a division of phenomena in terms of their enumeration. Now when phenomena are divided into the single and the multiple, the single and the different, the single itself is divided into the truly single and the single which is forced, so the forced single.

Likewise, the multiple is divided into the truly single and the falsely multiple. The multiple divided the truly truly multiple and the falsely multiple. Tibetan is a language that does not make a distinction between multiple and different. And they are therefore on paragraph three of page 10 of your text, alternatively, if existence are divided from within the two subdivisions, the single and the different or the multiple as we said. The first, I.

The single is divided into the deceitfully single and the truly single. Instances of the first, I. E. The deceitfully single are objects of knowledge. Objects of knowledge here refer to the totality of phenomena.

Phenomena are characterized as being knowable. The knowability means that they are called objects of knowledge and generally characterized phenomena. Both of these are deceitfully single, because actually as categories they are permanent. Instances of the second are either truly single are thing and impermanent phenomena. Thing and impermanent phenomenon are actually synonymous in the Sautrāntika school.

They refer to all phenomena which change instant by instant. Because they change instant by instant, the Sautrāntika school considers them true. Secondly, fourth paragraph of page 10, the difference also is divided into two. The deceitfully different and truly different. It is the first of the two, the isolator of vase.

The isolator of vase refers actually to mere vase. It is vase without any extraneous additions. It is also said to be the contrapositive of vase. The eyes of the vase is the eyes of the pillar. Instances of the second, in other words instances of the truly different are phenomena such as the two vase and pillar.

This is not vase first and pillar after. It is the conglomerate of the two seen as a couple. We can call the conglomerate of the two even though there’s nothing which is it. Nonetheless, we can call the conglomerate of the two a phenomenon. And then, both the past and the future are permanent.

In other words, for the Sautrantikas, both the past and the future are conceptual constructs. For the present is synonymous with things. The present, in other words, is synonymous with impermanent phenomena and is true. So the definition of past and actually it is perhaps more of an instance in a definition, but it can function as a definition is that part of the first instant of a thing which ceases at the time of the second instant of a thing. So a thing is an impermanent phenomenon and at the time of the second instant of the thing, the former instant, the first instant of the thing no longer exists.

That part or that element of cessation of existence of the first instant of a thing is called the past of the second instance of a thing. Likewise, the element of non production of the third instant of a thing, at the time of the second instant of a thing, or of a phenomenon, is called the future of the second instant of a thing. The way to understand this Geshe-la says, is to understand that phenomena are changing instant by instant. And there is an endless stream of instance. And at one given instant, the former and the future instant actually do not exist.

Nonetheless, the cessation of the existence of the object at the time of the former instant and its non production for the future instant, both can be conceived of conceptually. In as much as they can be conceived of conceptually and our existence, they are permanent phenomena. So for instance, if we were to take the time honored metaphor of the seed, at the time of the planting of the seed, the crop which will arise from the seed, which is the future of the seed, has not yet arisen. So we cannot say that that crop, which is the future of the seed, is an impermanent phenomenon. But the future of the seed at the time of the planting of the seed is an existing phenomenon and is a permanent phenomenon.

And there are many debates regarding the three times, past, present and future with future posited in the Sautrāntika School as each instant of a phenomenon, as it happens. And these debates hinge actually on an understanding of the nature of mind in the different schools, and more fundamentally on the differences in presentation of emptiness. Both the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. So we have finished a presentation of the fourth outline, which is a presentation of phenomena in general, according to Sautrāntika. And at present, we are passing to the presentation of the fifth outline, the presentation of subjects, which is actually somewhat more important.

So Geshe-la would like to insist on it more. And the first thing which is presented or the first topic which is presented in the fifth section at the bottom of page 10 of your translation on the presentation of subjects is an instance of persons. Now the reason for this is that there is considerable debate between the Buddhist and the non-Buddhist schools specifically in India, on what precisely reincarnates. What it is which passes from life to life, And what actually reaches either the liberation of the Tīrthikas or the liberation or full enlightenment of the Buddhists. Now that which reincarnates from life to life and reaches liberation of enlightenment is the person.

Therefore, it is very important to posit a clear example of the persons in all four schools, all four Buddhist schools according to their understanding. Because it is that, the person, which accumulates virtuous or non virtuous karma, and which reaches liberation or full enlightenment. And then moving onwards in your text, Sautrantikas assert, on the bottom of page 10, the continuity the aggregates is an instance of a person, and that the mental consciousness is an instance of a person. Two instances of a person are therefore given. The first instance of a person, that the continuum of the aggregates is an instance of a person.

In other words, it’s a continuum of the aggregates which moves from life to life. This is the position of the Sautrantikas following scriptures, and is a position which they share with the main Vaibhāṣika school, the Kashmiri Vaibhāṣika school. This can be said to be a somewhat lower position. The higher position is the next position, which is that the mental consciousness on page 11 of your text is an instance of a person. In other words, what is being asserted here is that it is the mental consciousness, and the mental consciousness alone which transmigrates or reincarnates from life to life.

What precisely is meant here by the mental consciousness? The mental consciousness does not refer to all consciousnesses. It for instance does not refer to the sense consciousnesses whose base are the sense organs. It refers only to that consciousness whose base is the mental organ and within that both to primary and secondary minds, but mainly to that principle characteristic of consciousness, the mental consciousness, which transmigrates from life to life. Now the first instance of a person, which is the instance of the person accepted by the Sautrāntika as following scripture, that a person would be the continuum of the aggregates, needs careful analysis and explanation.

Generally speaking, this refers to the continuum of all five aggregates. In other words, the form aggregate, feeling, recognition, volition and consciousness. But this is not always the case. Generally it is the case, because it can be said that this continuum of the five aggregates, including the form aggregate, is uninterrupted from life to life, since at the time of the death of a being in this life, the Bardo being which arises at the time of death also has a form aggregate, albeit a subtle form aggregate. And therefore, the continuum of the form aggregates is not interrupted.

They just change aspects. So this is valid for beings of the desire realm, such as for instance, gods, demigods, humans, animals and hell beings. In every single case, with some perhaps some exceptions, there is a body and therefore there is a continuum of all five aggregates. This is however not valid for gods from the formless realms for which there is actually no form aggregate, even a subtle one. And for that matter, it cannot be said that there are any of the other three aggregates.

In other words, feeling, recognition and volition. With the exception however of the gods of the formless realm, this statement that an instance of a person is a continuum of the aggregates, and generally of the five aggregates, does hold. And then moving onwards with our text on page 11, from within these two assertions of the selflessness of persons, the first is that of the Sautrantikas following scripture. In other words, the Sautrantikas following scripture. It’s another name for that school.

And the second is that of such as the Sautrantikas following the seven treatises on valid cognition. These seven treatises are listed in footnote 80 of page nine of your text. The Dharmakīrti’s seven treatises are the analysis of relations, ascertainment of valid cognition, the commentary on Dignāgā’s compendium of valid cognition, the drop of reasoning, the drop of reasons, the proof of the existence of other continuum, in other words, other minds, and reasoning for debate. And then, Now, generally speaking, subjects can be divided into persons expressive sounds and minds. Persons for instance are really called subjects because they have minds.

Therefore, the principle subject in the topic of the presentation of subjects is minds. And this is why at present, we will enter into a detailed presentation of the nature of mind. Now the definition of mind on page 11 of your text is clear and cognitive. So this definition of mind is an extremely subtle and profound definition which has to be analyzed carefully. One of its goals is to eliminate the assertions of those who do not accept the existence of the mind in the Buddhist sense of the term.

And specifically the Lokayatas, the Cārvākas, the ancient Indian materialists, who did not accept the existence of a mental continuum passing from life to life, and therefore did not accept the existence of past and future lives. Now such an assertion is obviously an assertion which is totally incompatible with the Buddhist viewpoint, according to which the mind is an infinite continuum, is totally beginningless in time, and which is also totally endless. And the reason for which such emphasis is put on an understanding of the mind in the Buddhist tradition is that all of the main levels of the path and qualities of the path which we strive to develop are mental. Liberation is a mental phenomenon. bodhicitta is a mental phenomenon.

Full enlightenment is a state of mind. For that matter, when we speak of the grounds and paths which lead to full enlightenment, these are not exterior grounds and roads. These are merely states of mind. So it is capital to understand how to generate these to understand the very nature of mind. And moreover, the nature of the mind, it is important to understand that the actual nature of the mind is good.

The mind is merely covered with adventitious defilements or stains, which can be eliminated when the mind is led to full enlightenment. Now the reason for which such emphasis is put on the nature of the mind, Geshe-la has explained. What however he feels makes the Buddhist tradition quite uncommon is the effort which has been put in understanding the mind. And he would encourage us all, irrespective of the texts we read, whether they be Buddhist or non-Buddhist, that we read texts which focus mainly on mind and the nature of mind. Since this is what is really of benefit.

And within the Buddhist tradition, what makes the Buddhist tradition rather uncommon is that the single pointed focus of the Buddhist tradition has been the nature of mind, the qualities of mind, and the development of mind, which have been investigated using analysis and reasoning. What is quite striking is that while there are disagreements between the various Buddhist schools of tenets regarding details, there is a broad consensus regarding the actual nature of mind and the process of mental development. And this is something Geshe-la feels, which is a very strong vindication of the Buddhist teachings and a clear indication that they are rooted not merely in reasoning and scripture, but also in experience through meditation. And then generally speaking, for the body has many divisions into coarser and subtler parts. The same can be said in general of the mind.

But the presentation of the subtler parts of the mind is the specific domain of tantra. There is no presentation within the Pāramitāyāna of various levels of subtlety of mind. And therefore even though the actual nature of mind is one where there is a gradation of subtlety and there is a fundamental most subtle mind. Since at present we are not dealing with the tantric level of practice, but only with Pāramitāyāna, it is a little bit inappropriate to talk about this, Geshe-la feels. And now we have reached the twofold division of minds on page eleven, third paragraph.

Mind has two subdivisions, valid cognizers and non valid cognizers. The definition of valid cognition, a valid cognizer is a new and unshakable knower. So the broad division of mind into valid and invalid cognizers is similar to that we saw in the Vaibhāṣika school. And the meaning of the term valid cognizer is according to some, that these are the main minds which can be said to be endowed with qualities. And the non valid cognizers can be said, generally speaking, this does not mean that every single instance of them is not, but generally speaking to be minds without these qualities.

For instance, inattentive perceptions or subsequent cognitions would be non valid cognizers. Now regarding the definition of a valid cognizer, each of the elements of the definition has a specific meaning and prevents a specific misunderstanding. The term new at the beginning of the definition, new and unshakable knower, refers to the very first instant of mind. This means that according to the Sautrāntika school, valid cognizers are necessarily the first instant of a mind. This is by no means a universal position, since some schools actually do not consider that it’s necessary for a valid cognizer to be necessarily the first instance of a mind.

Subsequent instances of mind can also be valid cognizers. But for the Sautrāntika, it’s only the first instance of a mind. The second term unshakable, sometimes translated in English as incontrovertible, in Tibetan has also various possible meanings. It fundamentally means that this mind engages single pointedly whatever it chooses to engage. It can also mean in more detail analysis, this is a mind which does not turn back away from its object of engage, which is why we have translated it as unshakable.

Finally, the term knower in the definition of valid cognition excludes the position of the Vaibhāṣikas according to which sense organs can be valid cognizers. A knower is necessarily a mind. A sense organ is not a mind. Therefore, a sense organ cannot be a valid cognition or a valid cognizer. So we will stop the class here for today since it’s 11:30 sharp.

You are all entitled to five minutes for tea or the vital necessities you get to choose. And then we come back here for discussions for half an hour. And after that, Geshe-la will answer questions.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top