1 h 0 min · 3,788 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 60-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche systematically presents the Sautrāntika School’s framework of valid cognizers—the minds and sources that reliably apprehend reality. The core focuses on correct assumption, a non-valid cognizer subdivided into five categories, each illustrated with logical reasoning and concrete examples. He then explores which beings, utterances, and types of consciousness themselves serve as valid cognizers, stressing that reliable teachers like the Buddha must have realized the Four Noble Truths and teach in accord with reason and Buddhist texts. The talk concludes by examining coarse selflessness of persons through three negations: permanence, unity, and autonomy. Suited to practitioners with prior training in Buddhist philosophical concepts.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0144 – KR.mp3
UUID: 7bdfe090-962c-4177-ae43-7afc45017bad
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Tenets
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,781
The Buddhas themselves who have attained this state were not Buddhas from the very beginning. At the beginning, they also trained in the path. And for that matter, they did not even have fully qualified bodhicitta at the beginning. They themselves had to train in bodhicitta in the same way as we are aspiring to do. So therefore, we should follow the path which they have shown us and train progressively so that we can attain enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.
And with this in mind, we should listen appropriately and carefully to the teachings. Okay. Okay. So we have we are proceeding through the two broad categories of mind, minds which are valid cognizers and minds which are not valid cognizers. And this is generally a fairly difficult topic to understand, but it is important because all these minds are crucial for the realization of both impermanence and selflessness.
Broadly speaking, when we consider the whole category of impermanent phenomena, this category includes form, non associated compositional phenomena, and consciousness. And of these three broad categories of impermanent phenomena, the most difficult to understand is consciousness. However, it is also the most important for us to understand. And within consciousnesses, can make a clear distinction between those beneficial states of mind which are valid cognizers, in other words which are unshakable or incontrovertible, and those minds which although not unshakable, not incontrovertible, are nonetheless powerfully beneficial states of mind such as the minds which we call here correct assumption. Now within the category of minds which are not valid cognizers, there are, as mentioned on page 14 of your text, five subdivisions, subsequent cognition, wrong consciousness, doubt, correct assumption, and inattentive awareness.
Geshe-la explained last time the three first of these subdivisions, subsequent cognition, wrong consciousness, and doubt, and started explaining correct assumption. Correct assumption is detailed on page 15 of your text, and as is clearly indicated by its definition, a correct assumption is necessarily a conceptual consciousness. There are no correct assumptions which are not conceptual states of mind. So an introduction to the topic of correct assumptions is the following series of reflections. All of the minds within our mind stream, which although they are not valid cognizers, think for instance with respect to the triple gem or another topic of this nature, yes, probably the triple gem does exist.
Yes, it must exist. While relying only partially on reasoning, all such minds which are beneficial minds are actually correct assumptions. These are minds which as their definition in the middle of page 15 indicates are factually concordant conceivables, in other words their understanding of phenomena is in keeping with the actual mode of existence of phenomena. And these are minds which are beneficial because they can progressively be strengthened and eventually become a valid cognizer. The definition of a correct assumption is a factually concordant conceiver which is not unshakable with respect to the object it conceives, The term conceiver and the verb conceives indicate both that these are conceptual consciousnesses. In other words, are consciousnesses which understand their object through a meaning generality, which is the appearing object of these consciousnesses.
And the fact that it is not unshakable means that this mind or not incontrovertible means that this mind has a strong conviction with respect to its object without having actual certainty. For instance, if we were to take an example, the case of the impermanence of persons, then we would reflect again and again on the fact that persons are impermanent using various reasonings such as the fact that they’re able to perform functions, that they are made phenomena, that they’re generated, and then a strong conviction would arise within our mind that the person is actually impermanent. Now, we say that the correct assumption in question conceives that the person is impermanent, but it has not realized that the person is impermanent. The difference here is that as it conceives it and it is not an unshakable mind, it can still fall away from that understanding. Whereas once it realizes it, then from that point onwards it cannot fall away from that understanding.
To give an example, Geshe-la says he will take himself based on his own studies. He has an adequate or mediocre correct assumption that he himself is not truly existent. This is based on many studies, reasonings, the instructions of his teacher. So, the mind which senses that he is probably not truly existent is stronger than the mind which apprehends him as truly existent. But, it is not incontrovertible.
However, over time, through repeated training, this mind in his continuum which apprehends himself as non truly existent would eventually turn into a valid cognizer. So there are five subdivisions of correct assumptions which Geshe-la will explain in the middle of page 15 of your text. So of these five divisions, the first is a correct assumption which does not have a reason, the second is a correct assumption which is contradictory with its reason, Third is one which does not ascertain its reason. The fourth is one which is not established by its reason. And the fifth is one which although it has a reason is not ascertained and they will be detailed at the bottom of page fifteen and sixteen of your text.
So the first correct assumption is a correct assumption which does not have a reason. The example given is on the bottom of page 15 of your text, an awareness which apprehends sound as impermanent in dependence on the mere statement sound is impermanent. Now this would be a correct assumption which accepts without any justification the fact that sound is impermanent merely based on someone telling you that. Now this is not the valid reason for realizing that sound is impermanent. And the first category of correct assumptions is called a correct assumption which does not have a reason because in the case the example reason given, just stating that sound is impermanent to someone is not a reason which establishes that sound is impermanent.
The second category on page 16 of your text is the correct assumption which is contradictory with its reason. The example given is an awareness which apprehends sound as impermanent by means of the reason of being empty of being able to perform a function. Now, the syllogism in question would be the subject sound. It follows that it is impermanent because it is empty of being able to perform a function. Sound obviously is not empty of being able to perform a function.
So one who, a subject who realizes or who conceives should I say sound as impermanent on the basis of its being able to perform a function is generating a correct assumption which is contradictory with its reason because the reason given is not valid for that subject since sound is able to perform a function. The third category of correct assumption is a correct assumption which does not ascertain its reason and the example given is an awareness which apprehend sound as impermanent by means of the reason of being an object of ascertainment. So, the syllogism here would be the subject sound. It follows that it is impermanent because of being an object of ascertainment. Now, an object of ascertainment generally speaking is synonymous with phenomena in general or objects of knowledge and clearly sound is an object of knowledge.
It is an object of ascertainment. So the reason sound is present in the, the subject sound is present in the reason object of ascertainment, but you cannot say that everything which is an object of ascertainment is necessarily impermanent since there are permanent phenomena. So when we say the subject sound, it follows it is impermanent because it is an object of ascertainment. This is a correct assumption which does not ascertain its reason since sound is not an object, since, excuse me, an object of ascertainment is not necessarily impermanent. So the fourth category, I mixed up the names, you must excuse me.
The third is a correct assumption which does not ascertain its reason. The fourth is a correct assumption which is not established by its reason. That’s the one we are dealing with at present. So a correct assumption which is not established by its reason would be for instance on page 16 of your text, an awareness which apprehends sound as impermanent by means of the reason of being an object of apprehension of a visual consciousness. So the syllogism here would be the subject sound, It follows that it is impermanent because it is an object of apprehension of a visual consciousness.
Now, generally speaking, everything which is an object of apprehension of a visual consciousness is necessarily impermanent, but sound generally speaking is not an object of apprehension of a visual consciousness. This does not pervade in all cases since for instance for the omniscient eye consciousness of a Buddha, sound is indeed an object of visual consciousness. So what is implicit with his reasoning is an object of apprehension of visual consciousness for an ordinary being. And the fifth correct assumption is a correct assumption which although it has a reason is not ascertained. The example is given towards the bottom of page 16 of your text, an awareness which apprehends sound as impermanent by means of the reason of being a product.
So, the syllogism here is a subject sound. It follows it is impermanent because it is a product. So it is indeed the case that sound is a product and it is also the case that everything which is a product is necessarily impermanent. So the syllogism itself is valid, but this is a syllogism in the consciousness of a person who has not realized everything which is necessary for the syllogism to be potent for it. Generally speaking, when we try to understand the impermanence of a subject such as sound, there are several ways to realize it.
It can be realized in terms of the definition of sound which is the definition of impermanence which is that which is instantaneous or which changes instant by instant, which is difficult to understand since it is generally asserted that one instant according to certainly the Sautrāntika School is one sixty fifth of the period of time it takes to snap one’s fingers. So what is being said is that sound changes in units of one sixty fifth of the interval it takes to snap one’s fingers and because this is difficult to understand, it is often easier to understand the impermanence of sound through the reason of sound being a made phenomenon, and this is an easy reason to understand which because all made phenomenon are necessarily impermanent leads us to an understanding of the impermanence of sound. And at present we are moving on to the fifth division of non valid cognizers at the bottom of page 16 which is inattentive awarenesses. The definition of an inattentive awareness is an unmistaken knower which is endowed with a clear appearance of its unascertained object. So inattentive awarenesses are non conceptual minds because they are non conceptual minds, they are unmistaken minds and that they are minds to which their object of engagement does not appear by means of an appearing object which is a meaning generality.
But these inattentive awarenesses are minds which do not retain their object of engagement. And the definition of inattentive awareness is an unmistaken knower which is endowed with a clear appearance of its unascertained object. So Geshe-la has explained the first part. It is an unmistaken knower, in other words a non conceptual mind. Indirectly clear appearance of its unascertained object, what this means is that far from its own side, the object appears very clearly to this non conceptual mind.
The mind because of its weakness does not engage the object, it does not ascertain it. And there are three categories of inattentive awarenesses, sensory, mental and reflexive consciousnesses which are inattentive awarenesses. The example of the first on the beginning of page 17 of your text is an auditory consciousness which apprehends a sound at the time when there is greater attachment to a beautiful form. For instance Geshe-la says if you were enraptured by the beauty of a flower and just staring at this flower, then any sounds which arose would be perceived by an ear consciousness which is an inattentive mind because it would appear clearly to the ear consciousness, but the ear consciousness would not engage them. On the other hand, if you were listening to some very beautiful music, then even if an object of form passed in front of the eye consciousness, the eye consciousness might very well be an inattentive visual consciousness because although the phenomenon appeared, it would not be apprehended by the eye consciousness.
And, an example of the second, I. E. An inattentive mental consciousness would be a mental consciousness which apprehends one of the five sense objects such as form and so forth in the continuum of an ordinary being. Now in this case Geshe-la says, one could for instance give the example of someone who goes on a walk and sees a beautiful building or panorama and then recollects this after the sense continuum has stopped. So between the first moment of conceptual recollection and the end of the sense visual sense continuum perceiving the object, there is necessarily one instant of mental consciousness and only one.
This one instant of mental consciousness in the mind of an ordinary being because ordinary beings are not aware of it is an inattentive mind. So this would be an example of an inattentive mind or an inattentive awareness which is a mental consciousness. And the third example of an inattentive awareness is an inattentive awareness which is a reflexive consciousness. Now since in the Sautrāntika system every mind has a component of that mind which is aware of itself, we call the reflexive consciousness of that mind, then since as Geshe-la explained, mental consciousnesses in the continuum of ordinary beings are inattentive awarenesses because they last only one instant, then necessarily the reflexive consciousness which apprehends that mental consciousness is also an inattentive awareness and that’s the example of an inattentive awareness which is a reflexive consciousness. So we have finished the presentation of minds which are valid cognizers and minds which are non valid cognizers and passing onwards to a general presentation of subjects at the middle of page 17 of our text.
In general, if one divides subjects, are three subdivisions, beings, speech and valid cognition. Moreover, if one were to divide subject, valid cognizers, then from within the three beings which are valid cognizers, speech and consciousness which are valid cognizers. Now, generally speaking, the main subject is consciousness. However, by extension, one can say that both beings and speech can be both subjects and subjects which are valid cognizers. A being becomes a subject in as much as it understands meaning.
So when a being understands meaning by that very fact, it becomes a subject in the same way as a consciousness is a subject. As for sounds, all the text says that in general sounds are subjects. This has to be qualified. This does not refer to for instance the sound of thunder or sounds which are produced by inanimate phenomena. This refers to expressive sounds.
In other words, sounds behind which is an underlying meaning. These sounds also function as subjects and can also be valid cognizers. And regarding the instance of the first which is beings which are valid cognizers, our text says our teacher the Buddha is such an example. Most definitely Geshe-la says the Buddha is a being which is a valid cognizer, a Pramāna being, but not only the Buddha, for that matter all Bodhisattvas and even all beings who have entered the path are beings which qualify as valid cognizers. So what exactly is meant by being which is a valid cognizer?
A being which is a valid cognizer is a being in whom one can legitimately have faith. One can legitimately have faith in such a being because such a being teaches incontrovertibly the means to be freed from the suffering of cyclic existence. And, the qualification for this is a realization of the Four Noble Truths. So, any being which has realized the Four Noble Truths is necessarily a being which is a valid cognizer. And for that matter, any being whose utterances are in contradiction with reason and logic is automatically disqualified from being a being who is a valid cognizer.
A being who is a valid cognizer is a being whose utterances are necessarily totally compatible with reasoning and logic and are rooted in the Buddhist scriptures. This is an indispensable qualification. An instance of the second speech which is a valid cognizer would be the turning of the wheel of the four noble truths. Generally speaking, the turning of the wheel of the law, of the four noble truths is necessarily speech which is a valid cognizer. One might wonder however when in the turning of the wheel of the law, Buddha says to some beings that certain categories of phenomena are truly existent and to other beings that certain categories of phenomena are not truly existent whether both those speeches in appearance contradictory can both be at the same time speech which is a valid cognizer.
This is the case, Geshe-la says, because every speech must be qualified by the intention of the speaker and the intention of the Buddha behind teaching to certain trainees that certain categories of phenomena are truly existent and teaching to other trainees that certain categories of phenomena are not truly existent is the same which is to benefit beings. Therefore in both cases, these speeches which are part of the turning of the wheel of the law can be said to be speech which is a valid cognizer. And there are two other distinctions with regards to speech, which is speech which is correct speech and speech which is factually concordant speech. Correct speech is speech which is correct for the being. Factually concordant speech is speech which is in harmony with reality.
Now regarding speech which is a valid cognizer which is our second subdivision here, Speech which is a valid cognizer can only be said to be speech which is a valid cognizer if the recipient, the trainee who hears it, realizes it. If he does not realize it, does not understand it, then the speech will not be speech which is a valid cognizer. Therefore, we have three categories of speech. We have speech which is a valid cognizer, correct speech and factually concordant speech. The third subdivision of subjects is consciousness which is a valid cognizer.
This has already been explained. There are two examples, direct valid cognizers which are non conceptual and inferential valid cognizers. So we have finished five of the seven outlines regarding the presentation of the Sautrāntika School and we have reached the sixth outline at the bottom of page 17 of your text which is although short, the most important outline. It is a mode of asserting selflessness. So, regarding the sixth, the mode of asserting selflessness, the coarse selflessness of persons is asserted to be a person’s emptiness of being permanent, one, and autonomous And this has been covered briefly previously Geshe-la says, but it is crucial here to understand clearly what the meaning of the three objects of negation in this definition are.
The three objects of negation are permanence, unity, and autonomy. So the first two objects of negation are permanence and unity. Now with respect to permanence, what it may be difficult to understand that the person is changing instant by instant at the pace, we should not describe previously, we all can see clearly that we are different now from the way we were when we were children. So, clearly, this difference cannot have occurred without gradual and incremental change. And this clearly shows that the person which means all five aggregates are impermanent.
Regarding the second characteristic of the person, clearly if the person were one, it could not be constituted of parts such as the five aggregates, form, feeling, recognition, volition, and consciousness or to put it in simpler terms, body and mind. Asserting that the person is one entails asserting that somehow the person is something else than the body and mind or something else than the aggregates, which is clearly not the case. So clearly therefore regarding the second object of negation of the definition of the core selflessness of persons, there can be no such thing as a unitary or a person which is one if the person cannot be posited as separate from both body and mind which is not the case. Regarding the third object of negation of the selflessness of persons which is a person’s lack of autonomy or not autonomous, this refers to the fact that persons arise in dependence on causes and conditions. They are not autonomous, excuse me.
They are not phenomena which exist independently of causes and conditions. In our specific case, we have arisen from a series of causes and conditions all the way back to our gestation in the womb of our mother. And, the continuum leading from that condition to our present state, our continuum can be said to be processed if you want or impelled is perhaps a better word by substantial conditions and substantial causes which are previous instance of the same continuum. So since we arise in dependence on causes and conditions and we are not autonomous therefore, it is said that the person is empty of being permanent, one, and autonomous So, this definition of the coarse selflessness of persons is fundamental since it is the common assertion regarding the view of all Buddhist schools. So, if one says that someone is a Buddhist by view, this is someone who necessarily accepts that persons are empty of being one, permanent, and independent.
Anyone who does not accept this is not a Buddhist by view, even though he might be a Buddhist by faith. In other words, someone who takes refuge in the triple gem and has faith in the Buddhist teachings, but one who does not accept this does not qualify as a Buddhist by view. Now, there are refinements of the view in the other higher schools, but this is the common denominator which is accepted by all the schools. So we will stop here for now.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.