58 min · 3,339 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 59-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche walks through the complete worldview of the Cittamātra or Mind Only school of Buddhist philosophy—the third tenet system and notably more subtle than its predecessors. After establishing proper motivation for the study, he presents the Mind Only understanding of persons, objects, afflictions, emptiness, and the paths to enlightenment. The central puzzle is a single distinction: Mind Only does not assert that all phenomena ARE mind, but that all are OF THE NATURE OF mind—a difference grounded in how karmic imprints generate both shared and private perceptions. Rinpoche examines two subtle emptinesses of phenomena, the second being the most difficult: form’s lack of being established by its own characteristics as the basis for the designation ‘form.’ Pitched at serious practitioners engaged in systematic study of the tenet systems.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0149 – KR.mp3
UUID: b90b52d6-d90e-49d1-87b3-aaa8b354679a
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Tenets
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,335
And, basically, it is crucial when we listen to the Dharma to generate a good motivation as Geshe-la has explained many times. And, the reason for which we listen to the dharma to start with is because without the activity of listening, there would be no way of understanding the dharma. But, listening in and of itself is not sufficient. We need a motivation which makes this dharma fruitful. So, the lowest such motivation would be to aspire for future benefit in future lives for oneself.
Preferably, one should aspire for a state of liberation from suffering. But, ideally, one should generate the greatest motivation of all, that motivation which aspires to place all sentient beings in a state of freedom from suffering and endowment with happiness. And, with that as a goal in one’s mind, to strive oneself for enlightenment. So, with this in mind, let us meditate a couple of minutes on generating such a motivation. So generally speaking, when we study tenets, what is the reason for studying tenets?
Tenets are different philosophical systems which were explained by the Buddha for the benefit of different categories of beings because beings have different outlooks, different philosophies of life. And, although there is an ultimate system of tenets, nonetheless, Buddha explained several lower systems for the benefits of the trainees. Generally so far we have explained completely two lower systems of tenets, the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika systems and we have at present started the explanation of the Cittamātra system. Now the differentiation between these systems of tenets is mainly a differentiation in terms of their view. Generally speaking, the system which is being presented here, the mind only of Cittamātra system is more difficult than the preceding systems.
There is a reason for this. In the same way as for instance someone who is living in a country, even if he were to know his country fairly well, would need many years to know his own country inside out, all the towns, all the cities and so forth. But once he knew it inside out would be able to navigate throughout his country with great facility, in the same way, each of the tenet systems is presented as a complete view of reality. The mastery of which enables one to understand completely not just the reality of this life, but the reality of future lives and of the paths leading to liberation and full omniscience. This is no small matter.
Therefore, it is quite understandable that mastering a system of tenets, just one system, is not easy. But, there is great benefit to this because once we have mastered a system of tenets, then when we meditate, we can draw in all the reasons which are necessary in our meditation for whichever system of tenets we have chosen to subscribe to. Otherwise, if we were just studying this out of pure intellectual interest, it would probably not be wanted for Geshe-la to explain it as we would not be qualified students. So, is why for each tenet system and specifically for the mind only system we are studying at present, the complete layout of the world view of the system is presented. In the mind only system, for instance, there is a complete presentation of what beings are or persons are from the standpoint of the mind only school, what objects are in general, what the perceivers of objects, subjects are.
Then there’s a complete presentation of afflictions according to the mind only school. A complete presentation of the mind only school’s understanding of emptiness and then a complete presentation of the paths which are the states of mind generated through meditation leading up all the way to the ultimate goal. So, such a complete presentation obviously is exhaustive and does take some time. It is not the case, however, that one enters in extraordinary detail. Geshe-la says the example one could give is that of someone who scales the top of a mountain.
From the top of a mountain such a person can see the layout of the land beneath him. He can see the rivers, the individual villages, the areas. He will not be able to know how many inhabitants there are in a village or a town, but he has this broad view of the landscape. This is what we are trying to do with the study of tenets. And then, within the sevenfold division of the mind only school, Geshe-la presented last time the two first divisions.
He will now present the third division, which is etymologies. And, the etymology of the mind only school is best understood through breaking up the term mind only. So, what the mind only school does not assert is that all phenomena are mind. The Mind Only School does not assert that all phenomena are mind. It does assert that all phenomena are of the nature of mind.
There is a capital difference here because when we assert that all phenomena are of the nature of mind or are of one nature with the mind which perceives them, what is being asserted is that all phenomena which are perceived arise at the same time as their perceiver, the mind which perceives them from a karmic implant which is implanted in the mind. So the phenomenon is said to be of the same nature as the mind which perceives it. They are also asserted as knowers of aspects and those who assert mere cognition because they believe that all that is perceived is the aspect of a phenomenon which is in nature of the mind and they are said to be practitioners of mere cognition and here the meaning is the same as saying that they are mind only practitioners. And, as Geshe-la explained the last time, the mind only school is a school which does not accept the existence of exterior objects. The two lower schools, the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika School, are schools which do accept the existence of exterior objects.
However, the Cittamātra school, the mind only school, considers in keeping with the lower schools that all impermanent phenomena, what they call all other powered phenomena, are actually truly established. They consider that non truly established phenomenon, phenomenon which are non true are not functioning phenomena. So, this respect their assertions are similar to those of the lower schools. On the other hand, all both the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika assert the existence of partless particles. This is not the case for the mind only school.
The mind only school asserts that there is no such thing as partless particles and that every particle can be infinitely subdivided. Technically speaking, they do not assert the existence of an exteriorly existing particle in addition since they consider that every particle which is perceived is actually of the nature of the mind which perceives it. So, have finished the presentation of the third outline on page 20 of your text. And then the middle of the page 20, we have passed through the fourth outline, the mode of assertion of objects. If one divides objects of knowledge, there are two subdivisions, ultimate truths and conventional truths.
So regarding the fourth outline, there are two subdivisions, ultimate truths and conventional truths. Now generally speaking, when we speak of ultimate truths in all the schools, we refer to the most subtle mode of existence of phenomena under analysis. And, the presentations of ultimate truth diverge in function of the schools of tenets. So, for instance, in the Sautrāntika school, we will have a selflessness of persons, which is a person’s absence of being an independently existing entity. At the level of the Cittamātra school, we will have various selflessness asserted such as for instance phenomena’s emptiness of being truly established as a basis of designation of the name designating them, which is one of the selflessnesses asserted by the Cittamātra school.
However, fundamentally when we analyze the term ultimate truth, it can best be understood in two parts, ultimate and truth. The first qualifier ultimate refers actually to the mind which apprehends these phenomena called ultimate truth. Such minds are called ultimate minds because they are in ultimate analysis yogic direct valid cognizers. Therefore, they are ultimate minds. The minds which perceive selflessness will be yogic direct valid cognizers.
On the other hand, the second part of the term truth refers to the mode of appearance of the phenomenon from its standpoint. Its mode of its appearance and its actual mode of existence are one and the same. Therefore, it can be said to be a true phenomenon. For this reason, such phenomena are called ultimate truths. And the definition of an ultimate truth is that which is realized by a direct valid cognizer realizing it directly through the dispersing of dualistic appearances.
This definition can be interpreted as follows. The direct valid cognizer being referred to is a yogic direct valid cognizer. Yogic valid direct cognizers, in as much as they are non conceptual, realize phenomena without the mediation of a generic image. So, this is the meaning of this first part of the definition. And, the second part, through the dispersing of dualistic appearances, means that for the Cittamātra school, when conventional phenomena appear, they appear in a dualistic way and this dualistic mode of appearance is the mode of appearance of conventional phenomena, the mode of appearance of phenomena as exterior entities or exterior phenomena which are truly established.
Now, both of these modes of dualistic appearances are set, in other words both of these modes of dualistic appearances are absent or dissolved in the context of the perception of an ultimate truth. Moving on within your text on page 20, the middle of the page, ultimate truth, suchness, the core phenomena, and ultimate state are all synonymous. Now, here when we refer to ultimate state, generally speaking, there are many subtle levels of existence of phenomena. For instance, Geshe-la was giving the example of the tablecloth in front of him. The tablecloth in front of him being an impermanent phenomena which has in other words a termination of its continuum is a fairly coarse level of the impermanence of that phenomena which is actually quite accessible to us.
On the other hand, the tablecloths subtle impermanence which means the continuous process of destruction the tablecloth undergoes is something which is not easily accessible to us. This is a more subtle mode of existence of that phenomenon, the tablecloth. However, from the Cittamātra standpoint, the most subtle, in other words, the ultimate mode of existence of this phenomenon, the tablecloth, is the tablecloth not existing independently from the mind perceiving it. In other words, the table cloth being of one nature with the visual consciousness which perceives the table cloth. This is the ultimate nature of the table cloth from the standpoint of the Cittamātra school.
And then, if one divides ultimate truths, there are two subdivisions, the subtle selflessness of phenomena and the subtle selflessness of persons. Generally speaking, the Mahāyāna schools accept a subtle selflessness of phenomena. All the Hīnayāna schools do not. Now, in this specific case, the Cittamātra school accepts that for instance that subtle selflessness of persons which is accepted in the Sautrāntika school, a person’s being empty of being a substantially existent is indeed a selflessness. It is a selflessness of persons for the Cittamātra school as well, but it is not accepted to be a selflessness of phenomena.
So, this is one of the major differences between these schools. Then, emptinesses in turn are subdivided into the 20 emptinesses, the 18, the 16, and the four emptinesses. These are various enumerations of the emptiness of phenomena. The most elaborate one includes an enumeration of the emptinesses of the senses, the emptinesses of the sense sources, in other words of the phenomena which give rise to sensory experience and the emptiness of the aggregates and as these are summarized one moves down from 20 to four emptiness. And then moving to the bottom of page 20 of your text, two instances of the subtle selflessness of phenomena are given.
Emptiness which is an emptiness of form and the valid cognizer apprehending form being different substances and emptiness which is an emptiness of form being established as a basis of engagement which is engaged by the sound form. Now, generally speaking, the Mind Only School gives these two instances of the subtle selflessness of phenomena, but the basis of the two subtle selflessness of phenomena are different. The first subtle selflessness of phenomena, emptiness which is emptiness of form and the valid cognizer apprehending form being different substances, applies to certain categories of phenomena such as impermanent phenomena, forms and so forth. It does not apply to phenomena such as space. Space in as much as it is a non compounded phenomena, therefore a permanent phenomena could not be said to be empty in this sense.
So, while this is an emptiness which is acknowledged by the Cittamātra school, the scope of the basis is smaller. On the other hand, the second subtle emptiness or subtle selflessness of phenomena is one which is asserted with respect to all phenomena. In other words, emptiness which is an emptiness of form being established by its own characteristic as a basis of engagement, which is engaged by the sound form, the same subtle selflessness of phenomena could be predicated of space. Generally speaking, although the Cittamātra school accepts a selflessness of phenomena, although they accept the same divisions of emptiness into twenty, sixteen, and four as the Madhyamikas, the meaning they give to these emptinesses is different. And regarding the second subtle selflessness, which is the most difficult point in the Cittamātra school, that emptiness which is an emptiness of form being established by its own characteristics as a basis of engagement which is engaged by the sound form.
The meaning of this second subtle emptiness of phenomena such as form is that when we see form, when we see the color blue, when we see objects in general, we attribute a name to them, a sound in other words which describes them based on long familiarity over many past lives with the object, which gives rise to the karmic imprints of attributing a name. This emptiness of, for instance, form existing as a basis of engagement of the sound stating form by its own characteristics merely means that form only exists as a basis for the sound attributing the name form to form, dependent on this countless process of habituation over past lives of the process of designation. Form does not exist by its own characteristics as a basis of designation of the term form. So, this is the key difficulty in the presentation of the mind only understanding of emptiness. Then the instance of the subtle selflessness of persons listed on page 21 of your text is that emptiness which is an emptiness of a person’s substantial existence as an independent entity.
This is the subtle selflessness of persons asserted by the Sautrāntika school. It is also accepted as a selflessness of persons by the Cittamātra school, but it is not accepted as a selflessness of persons by the Mādhyamika school. Now regarding the presentation of conventional truths, which are defined as that which is realized by a direct valid cognizer realizing it directly in a manner endowed with dualistic appearances, This refers to phenomena which are not emptinesses, which dawn in a dualistic way to the non conceptual mind, in other words a direct cognizer perceiving them. And when we say that they dawn in a dualistic way, what is meant is that they appear to this non conceptual mind as different from the consciousness or different in nature from the consciousness which perceives them as exterior objects and as conventional phenomenon. Now if all of these three characteristics are present then most definitely they dawn in a dualistic manner to the mind perceiving them.
However, should one of these characteristics be present, it is sufficient to say that they dawn in a dualistic manner to the consciousness perceiving them and it is sufficient therefore to qualify them as conventional truths for the Cittamātra school. And then, moving on with a presentation of conventional truths at the bottom of page 21 of your text. The first, I. E, other powered phenomena, which refers mainly to minds in the Cittamātra school, and compounded phenomena are synonymous. While the second imputed phenomena and uncompounded phenomena, which are not ultimate truths, are synonymous.
An instance of the second imputed phenomena, Geshe-la says, would be for instance space which is an imputed, uncompounded phenomena in the mind only school too. And then they accept that all things are truly established and a common locus with the deceptive. Things here are impermanent phenomena. They consider that all impermanent phenomena are truly established. And when they say that they are a common locus with the deceptive, they mean that all impermanent phenomena, in other words, all other powered phenomena, are as is mentioned I believe in note two fourteen of your text, and Geshe-la has repeated this, phenomena whose mode of appearance and mode of engagement are different.
So, if phenomena are such that the mode in which a mind engages them and the mode in which they appear to the mind are different, then they are said to be deceptive phenomena. On the other hand, if they are phenomena such that the mode in which the mind engages them and the mode in which they appear to the mind are concordant, then they are said to be non deceptive phenomena. And they also accept on page 22 of your text that all suchnesses are truly established in a common locus with the true. All suchnesses here refer to all emptinesses which are generally speaking in the Cittamātra school non affirming negatives. So, the presentation of non affirming negatives in the Cittamātra school is similar to that in the Sautrāntika school.
The only major difference is that the Chittamatras consider that that emptiness of form and the valid cognizer apprehending form being different natures is not merely a non affirming negative, but is also actually an emptiness of phenomena. This is something which is not accepted by the Sautrāntika school. Otherwise, the presentation of non affirming negatives and of affirming negatives for that matter in both Cittamātra and Sautrāntika is identical. And then on page 22 in the middle of the page, however, although the five sense objects such as form and so forth arise upon an interior karmic substance, which is of one nature with consciousness, independence of the placement of both common and uncommon karmic imprints onto the mind bases of all, they are not established as exterior objects. So the meaning of this passage is that all five sense objects, in other words, what we see, what we hear, what we smell, what we taste, and what we feel, arise dependent on the placement in the ālaya vijnana in the mind basis of all of karmic imprints.
Now generally speaking, there are both common and uncommon appearances of sense objects. The common appearances are the appearances we all share. For instance, we all share a common perception of Geshe-la’s tablecloth. This is due to karmic imprints which give rise to the appearance of this tablecloth to the minds perceiving it, which have been placed in all our mind bases of all, which are therefore shared among all of us. However, in addition to that, each one of us shares his uncommon perception of Geshe-la’s tablecloth, and these are due to our own uncommon or private karmic imprints which give rise to this uncommon perception.
What is being asserted in this passage is that objects of the five senses do not exist independently as exterior objects, independently of the placement of both these shared and private or common and uncommon karmic imprints.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.