54 min · 2,192 words · 28 October 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 54-minute exposition of the Cittamātra (Mind-Only) tenet system, Kyabje Rinpoche traces philosophical debate between Buddhist schools to isolate why Cittamātra solves a logical problem lower schools cannot. He explains Cittamātra’s core claim: not merely that the self is empty, but that external objects are not ultimately external—a refutation the lower schools do not reach. The crucial point: lower schools assert indivisible particles that somehow produce impermanent objects (a logical impossibility), while Cittamātra asserts particles are divisible and reduce ultimately to subtle wind, which is of the nature of mind. Two examples drive this home—how anger colors someone’s appearance as offensive, how lust makes them appear attractive—showing phenomena arise in dependence on mind. In the Q&A, he addresses quantum mechanics, consciousness, dream versus waking awareness, and tantric applications. For practitioners with existing knowledge of Buddhist philosophy.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-10-28.mp3
UUID: c0aec5c0-1faa-468b-96cc-5749741d95b0
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Tenets
Date: 2014-10-28
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,191
So as usual, we’re generating motivation for receiving these teachings first. As you remember, the lower tenet systems, in other words, the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika tenet systems have as their main object of refutation a self of persons. Therefore, they teach the selflessness of persons. It is with the cittamatra system that the uncommon object of refutation of the greater vehicle tenet systems appears for the first time, this is the self of phenomena, excuse me. Therefore, the Cittamatras teach a selflessness of phenomena, and this selflessness of phenomena refutes the self of phenomena which is asserted by both the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika schools of tenets.
And the reason for which the two lower schools of tenets, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika, accept a self of phenomena is because not only do they teach the existence of exterior phenomena, but in addition, they explicitly teach that these exterior phenomena are truly established. This is the object of refutation of the Cittamātra school. And it is therefore of great benefit to reflect on the similarities and the differences between the definitions of the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika schools. They are similar in all respects except for the fact that the Vaibhāṣika School of Tenets does not accept the existence of reflexive consciousness, whereas the Sautrāntika School of Tenets accepts the existence of reflexive consciousness. And the uncommon feature of the Cittamātra school of tenets, which makes the Cittamātra school of tenets and its proponents into proponents of tenet systems of the great vehicle, is this refutation of the self of phenomena, which in the case of Cittamātra is a refutation of exterior things.
Therefore, the position of the Cittamātra school is explicitly that there are no exterior objects, and therefore, implicitly that phenomena and the mind which apprehends phenomena are established as being of one entity. And therefore, our intuitive sense, which is propelled as well by the lower schools of tenets, that first phenomena are established, and in dependence on that establishment of phenomena, minds apprehending these phenomena arise, and that these phenomena are the object conditions of the minds apprehending them, is actually the foremost object of refutation in the mind only system, which asserts that phenomena and the mind apprehending that phenomena are not subsequent but simultaneous. So where phenomena do appear as existing externally to the consciousness apprehending them as existing on the outside of an interior consciousness. From the standpoint of the Cittamātra school, this exterior appearance of form is mistaken. So the position regarding exterior objects of the lower schools of tenets, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika, is that coarse exterior objects are composed of subtle partless particles which conglomerate in ever greater number to eventually create these coarse entities perceived by the senses.
Likewise, when these coarse exterior entities are analyzed into ever subtler parts, eventually analytically one encounters partless particles. These partless particles are asserted by certain schools of tenets to be permanent. If they are permanent, this would lead to the conclusion that coarse phenomena which are constituted of permanent partless particles would have to be phenomena arisen from permanent entities. Then in this case, they would be effects arisen from permanent phenomenon. However, these effects would perish instant by instant, whereas their causes would not, which is contradictory.
Then the position of both the Vaibhāṣika and the Sattrathika schools of tenets is that coarse phenomena are constituted of subtle, inseparable particles. The only minor difference between these schools of tenets is that for the one, there is no space between these particles, and for the other, there is. However, this position is incompatible with reason. Since it is very difficult to see how a table such as this one could be constituted of particles which actually have no connection with each other. This is the reason for which the Cittamātra school asserts that there is no such thing as partless particles.
Particles are divisible, and they are ultimately composed, it would seem, of elements of air. Now this is a very delicate point. Therefore, for the Cittamātra school of tenets, the boundary of divisibility or partition of particles is subtle air. In other words, through dividing particles indefinitely, one eventually reaches subtle air. Subtle air is asserted to be the core constituent from which the universes arise over one cosmological cycle, and this is intimately connected with the view of anuttara yoga tantra.
And therefore, the the Cittamatras consider that while there is no such thing as indivisible particles, there are nonetheless subtle and ever more subtle particles. They in no way deny the existence of subtle or ever more subtle particles. What they deny is their indivisibility. In this matter, it would seem that the view of the two lower schools comes to be very close to that of the non-Buddhist Hindu schools. And therefore, the Cittamātra criticized the view of the Vaibhāṣikas and the Sautrantikas saying, what precisely is the cause or the origin of these so called partless particles whose existence you assert?
It is very difficult for the Vaibhāṣikas or the Sautrantikas to offer any cause or origin for these partless particles. And therefore, the view of the Cittamātra school of tenets is that in the forward progression, the expansion of the universe from the state of subtle air forwards in its development, as well as in its contraction, eventually the totality of the universe is rooted in subtle air, which ultimately is of the nature of consciousness. Therefore, the Cittamātra view counters forcefully the position of the Vaibhāṣikas and the Sautrantikas regarding the existence of partless particles, and asserts only the existence of particles composed of parts, of divisible particles, asserting in addition that these are of the nature or of the same substance as consciousness. Thereby, the Cittamātra school propounds the subtle selflessness of phenomena. In as much as for the Cittamātra school, the ultimate division of particles which are endowed with parts leads to consciousness.
The Cittamātra school asserts that all phenomena are of the nature of consciousness, and this explains the name Cittamātra mind only. For instance, in the same same way as we stare at our own face in a mirror, likewise, according to the Cittamātra school, it is the appearance of objects within consciousness which is engaged by consciousness. And we can see this in our own experience. For instance, if we are possessed with a tremendous rage towards somebody, then everything that person says and does, and actually their very appearance is offensive and disagreeable to us. This is purely the effect of the anger within our mind.
Likewise, if we are possessed by tremendous lust for another person, everything that person says, does or engages in is extraordinarily pleasing and attractive. This is once again the reflection of lust within our mind. These examples should make it easy to understand the mind only position and its profound import. The Cittamātra view is of extraordinary benefit to understand the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view. Since for the Cittamatras, all phenomena are established as merely of the nature of mind.
However, for the Prasangikas, all phenomena are established as mere mental or nominal imputations. It is clear that the main difference between the Cittamātra view and the Prāsaṇgika view is that for the Cittamatras, phenomena are established from their own side, whereas for Prāsaṇgika they are not. Then if you have questions, now is a good point to ask them. It seems like the different schools, the Cittamātra, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika all relate quite clearly to modern day science’s understanding of the world around us. So specifically the Cittamātra view and the view that’s espoused by quantum mechanics.
Those seem to be concordant with science. So trying to understand how the refutations work and how they link with our modern view. How the reputations? Refutations would work in light of our view of modern science. Reputations of what by what?
Well especially the Vaibhāṣika or the Cittamātra school versus the Sautrāntika school? In the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika views are views which both accept the existence of composite phenomena, and clearly in the systems of tenets, the indivisible particles are not composite phenomena by their very definition. Then as Geshe-la explained, one faces a fallacy of impermanent phenomena arising from components which are permanent causes. And if this is the case, then one could say that the Cittamātra view has won the debate, and the Vaibhāṣikas and Sautrantikas are to be banished. As I said in Tsongkhapa’s Essence of Eloquence to engage in the subtle generation stage, a view which teaches the mind of clear light is indispensable.
This is a bit a chicken and egg question, sorry. But Geshe la, could you clarify? I’ve written the ultimate division of particles leads to consciousness in the Cittamātra school. But I thought consciousness was beginningless. So, or is this just one particular consciousness?
Does it refer to mind? Do you understand my question Amir? No I don’t. Okay, so I’ve written if that’s correct, the ultimate division of particles leads to consciousness. Well I would have thought if anything it would have been the other way around.
The consciousness, if we were by that meaning mind, is beginningless. So where do these how do these particles lead to consciousness? No. These are not contradictory indeed. The uttermost division of particles, which is basically ineffable, leads to subtle wind, and this subtle wind is of one nature but of different isolates with mind.
Therefore, this ultimate ineffable division of particles is of the nature of mind. Then this is not at all contradictory with the fact that mind is beginningless and endless, since beings are merely instances of mind. Have to think about subtle wind, most subtle wind. We’re not talking here of breath which goes in and out. We’re talking of prana.
We’re talking of this subtle most inner wind which dwells within us when we even stop breathing. I’m a little bit confused. According to the definition of the Chitamatran school, they don’t accept existence of external objects. And then just near the end, you said that the phenomena, they believe phenomena, is established from its own side. So the Cittamātra do not accept the existence of exterior objects as they appear to us.
This is a counter intuitive view since things naturally seem to exist outside of our consciousness to us. For Cittamātra, this is a mistaken view. It’s difficult for us to understand the meaning of what the Cittamatras intend when they say phenomena are established from their own side. If we analyze the process of perception for us, we can see that it seems to us that first something is established out there, and then after in dependence on this thing out there as an object condition, the visual consciousness for instance perceiving this entity arises. Now from the Cittamātra viewpoint, this does not withstand analyses, and when one investigates the components of things which seem to exist out there, eventually one reaches a mind.
And another? Just to follow on from that question then. So the Cittamatras, do I understand this right that they actually sort of contradictory hold the view that phenomena are established from their own side but that is also their object of negation? We will enter into this topic in detail next week, otherwise, I think we don’t get confused. Because when one asserts in the mind only view that phenomena are established by their own characteristics, it sounds similar to what is asserted in the other systems of tenets, but it is not.
Because what is not being asserted is that they are exteriorly established. With the Cittamatras, how would they see the mind in a dream and the mind in waking life? The what in a dream? The consciousness. Uh-huh.
The mind. Yeah. Yeah. The mind in a dream Uh-huh. And the mind in waking life.
Do they see them as different? So all of the tenet systems are similar in asserting that the main difference between the dream consciousness and consciousness in the waking state is that the dream consciousness is exclusively a mental consciousness without sense consciousnesses, whereas the consciousness during the waking state is or includes mental consciousness and sense consciousnesses. Then for certain schools of tenets, the elephant perceived in the dream state is not truly established. Just going back to the mind of clear light, I’m just really wanting to clarify this answer. Did you say that the mind of clear light is indispensable in understanding the Cittamātra position?
Not exactly, what is asserted is that to complete the subtle generation stage of highest yoga tantra, it is indispensable to either have the Madhyamaka or the Cittamātra view. Without either the Madhyamaka or the Cittamātra view, it is impossible to complete the subtle generation stage. So we will stop here, and we will at present discuss the ways by which the mind only view counters the assertion in Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika of impermanent phenomena being established as exterior entities. We can start as usual by groups of two different partners from last time, if possible. I’m okay, honey.
Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- generation stage kye rim (Tib)
- The first of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which one cultivates the clear appearance and divine pride of one’s chosen meditational deity. LYWA
- Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
- The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How do the finest particles lead to consciousness, and does this contradict the teaching that mind is beginningless and endless?
There is no contradiction. The uttermost division of particles, which is basically ineffable, leads to subtle wind. This subtle wind is of one nature with mind but has different isolates. So this ultimate, ineffable division of particles is of the nature of mind, and that does not conflict with mind being beginningless and endless, since beings are merely instances of mind. The subtle wind meant here is not the breath that goes in and out. It is prana, the most subtle inner wind, which remains within us even when we stop breathing.
How do the Cittamatra and other tenet systems understand the difference between mind in a dream and mind in waking life?
All of the tenet systems are similar in asserting that the main difference between dream consciousness and waking consciousness is that dream consciousness is exclusively a mental consciousness, without sense consciousnesses. Waking consciousness, by contrast, is or includes mental consciousness together with sense consciousnesses. Beyond this shared point, for certain schools of tenets the elephant perceived in the dream state is not truly established.
Is the mind of clear light indispensable for understanding the Cittamātra position?
Not exactly. What is asserted is that, to complete the subtle generation stage of highest yoga tantra, it is indispensable to have either the Madhyamaka view or the Cittamātra view. Without one of these two views, it is impossible to complete the subtle generation stage. The requirement is therefore about holding either of these views for completing that stage, not about the mind of clear light being needed to understand the Cittamātra position.