1 h 28 min · 3,233 words · 22 October 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 88-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche addresses a widespread confusion about the path of the small scope: what must practitioners actually abandon and cultivate? Using an education analogy—high school provides foundations for university, not vice versa—he clarifies that this foundational path focuses entirely on karma and causality. What to abandon: the ten non-virtues of body, speech, and mind. What to cultivate: virtue. He then examines the non-virtuous deed of killing in precise philosophical detail using the Abhidharmakośa, identifying the four components that must be present for a deed to be complete: base, thought, deed, and conclusion. The teaching concludes with an extended Q&A addressing practical edge cases—capital punishment, sleepwalking, suicide, and cases where intention is severed from outcome.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-10-22 – KR.mp3
UUID: 05d29932-dea8-4f50-a27e-71179a437688
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Emptiness
Date: 2014-10-22
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,229
In the context of the explanation of the path of the being of the small scope, it is, in my opinion, extremely important to understand what precisely is to be abandoned and what precisely is to be practiced in the context of the path of the being of the small scope. We can see that one is often confused and wonders whether what is to be abandoned in the context of the path of the being of the small scope is also to be abandoned in the context of the path of the being of the middling scope. And what is to be abandoned in the context of the path of the middling scope should be abandoned as well in the context of the path of the being of the great scope. One can understand both the objects of meditation and the objects of abandonment in the light of one’s object of observation or one’s goal towards which one proceeds or progresses incrementally. This is something we can understand if we take the example of studies leading, for instance, to a future profession projected as a doctor.
If we want to become a doctor, then before attending university, will have to go to high school and we will have to finish high school before entering university. Now clearly, these subjects studied in high school act as a foundation for one’s university studies. It is however inappropriate to study university topics in high school, and likewise, once one is at university, one does not study the topics which one studied when it was in the when it was in high school. It is finished. Likewise, when one trains, for instance, for the path of the being of the great scope, one must initially have trained in the paths of the two previous scopes, the being of the small and of the middling scope.
Then I would therefore like to ask you a question at present. What is the object of abandonment at the level of the path of the being of the small scope, and what should one practice at the level of the path of the being of the small scope. If one does not know this, one is in the delicate situation described in Lam Rim Chenmo, in which it is said verbally, they say they are practitioners of the great scope, but in their minds, there isn’t even the practice of the being of the small scope. In brief, my question to you is, what is the object of abandonment of the being of the small scope? What is the object of practice of the being of the small scope?
I can’t remember all of them but on the small scope I think the object of abandonment would be the eight worldly concerns, the apprehension that I will be around for a long time and attachment to this life and the object of practice in the small scope would probably be the abandonment of the 10 non virtues, the cultivation of the 10 virtues and the practice of patience and generosity. Please would you repeat? Well, the microphone is closer to Jill, so let us be practical. The object of abandonment is attachment to this life, and the object of practice is modifying one’s behavior according to the law of cause and effect. Okay, so the object to be abandoned is attachment to this life and the practice of the being of the small scope.
Six topics of meditation, reliance on the spiritual teacher, precious human rebirth, and the rarity of this precious human rebirth, death and impermanence, fear of rebirth in the lower realms, and then conviction that the triple gem will protect oneself from that, and then karma and causality. Your answers were very verbose, whereas I wanted something simple and concise. You remember the passage in the Lamrim which says, the beginning of practice is karma and causality. This is the answer I wanted. Karma and causality is the beginning of practice, and therefore, what is to be abandoned is simply nonvirtue.
What is to be cultivated is the opposite of nonvirtue. It is virtue. This is what is to be abandoned and to be practiced by the being of the small scope. And the big difference between the practice of the being of the small and of the middling scope is that in the practice of the being of the small scope, it is the abandonment of of sin and the practice of virtue, which is the main practice. This is not absent in the practice of the being of the middling scope, but it is not the main practice.
The main practice for the being of the middling scope is respectively the abandonment of the first two truths, the truth of suffering and of origin, and the attainment of the two last truths, the truth of cessation and the truth of the path. And, therefore, when one tries to specify the non virtue, which is the object of abandonment of the being of the small scope, It is explicated in the Abhidharmakośa of Vasubandhu, in which it is said, 10 of the objects of abandonment. These are the three non virtues of physical non virtues, the four verbal non virtues, and the three mental non virtues. The 10 virtues to be practiced are their exact opposites. Then to give you an example of a non virtuous deed, we shall take the non virtuous deed of killing.
Killing means to deprive another being endowed with consciousness, whether it be a human being or an animal of its life. It is technically in Tibetan to cut the life. This is a non virtuous deed because it is a fault whether one is a layperson or a monk. It is a fault for a layperson, but it is as well a fault for a monk. Why is a deed of killing a non virtuous deed?
A deed of killing is a deed performed by an agent who is a person against a patient who is another person. This g this deed is motivated within the agent by the afflictions. It is performed, in other words, under the sway of the afflictions. And the afflictions themselves, which give rise to karma, fall under the sway of ignorance. Because a deed is performed under the power of ignorance, it is a non virtuous deed.
And such a deed is therefore non virtuous for two reasons. First, because it is performed motivated by ignorance. And secondly, because the karmic result of such a deed of killing is rebirth in a future life in a lower realm. Rebirth in a lower realm of the nature of suffering is a characteristic of nonvirtuous deeds. What would be an instance of a virtuous deed?
An instance of a virtuous deed would be that physical and verbal restraint from committing a deed of killing out of an awareness that this is a non virtuous deed leading to suffering. Such a physical or verbal restraint is a virtuous deed because it originates not in ignorance but in a wisdom which understands the nature of karma and causality. So the topic of the practice of the being of the small scope is not terribly difficult to understand nor is it terribly difficult to engage in. Then the answers you gave to the object of abandonment included the concerns of this life and the eight worldly dharmas. It is not unrelated, but these refer to mental transformations more than to the actual path of the being of the small scope.
And therefore, the essence of the path of the being of the small scope is an ethics which abandons the 10 non virtuous deeds. And it’s such an ethics relinquishes the practice of the 10 non virtuous deeds. When one’s physical and mental behavior has been well restrained in this fashion, one can say that this human life has become meaningful. Then when one wakes in the morning, how should one proceed? One should start by thinking, I have not died yet.
This is a good day. I shall turn this day into a meaningful day. Then turning it into a meaningful day merely through reciting one’s commitments seems very difficult to me. And therefore, as I said, it seems difficult that the mere recitation of one’s commitments should turn into virtuous practice. For that matter, if we wish to practice after waking as a being of the small scope, mere meditation is insufficient.
So after bringing to mind death and impermanence, we must engage in activities which are part of the links of karma and causality influenced by this, and go about our daily affairs, the walking, working, speaking in such a way as to accumulate virtue. And, therefore, it is within the context of reflection on death and impermanence that in this very life today, one should choose to engage in virtuous deeds. This practice of the being of the small scope is a beginner’s practice. It is not difficult to engage in. It is not difficult to understand.
And it is on this foundation that eventually one will be able to enter into the practice of the being of the middle scope, focusing upon the four noble truths, which is more subtle and more difficult to understand. When we speak of the topic of karma and causality, we refer simply to engaging in the abstention from, the 10 non virtuous deeds and engaging in the practice of the 10 virtuous deeds. There is nothing else but this. As Candrakīrti says in his Madhyamakāvatāra, An ordinary being on the on the basis of ethics will attain a higher rebirth and thereby, eventually, over time, will become a hearer, a solitary realizer, and a bodhisattva. Therefore, this practice of the ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues is the foundation.
Let us therefore generate in meditation for a couple minutes the motivation of practicing karma and causality correctly. The topic of karma and causality is subdivided into three. A general presentation of karma and causality, a specific presentation of karma and causality, and how to, or the manner of engaging and turning away from respectively virtuous and non virtuous karma after thinking about these. So the first sub topic has been presented last time. The second sub topic, a specific presentation of karma and causality is subdivided into three.
The first two topics are reflecting on non virtuous karma and causality, and reflecting on virtuous karma and causality. So the first subtopic reflecting on non virtuous karma and causality refers to the 10 non virtuous deeds of body, speech and mind which one should be able to identify. We have three physical non virtuous deeds which are killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct. Four, verbal non virtuous deeds, which are lying, divisive speech, harsh speech, and idle talk. And three, mental non virtuous deeds, which are covetousness, ill will, and wrong views.
The first seven non virtuous deeds are non virtuous deeds performed by the body or the speech. The last three are mental factors which arise independently of either the body or the speech. So we shall take one non virtuous deed to enable you to understand precisely what it takes for a non virtuous deed to be complete, and this will be the non virtuous deed of killing. For the non virtuous deed of killing to be complete, four components or four factors must be present. The base, the thought, the deed, and the conclusion of the deed.
So let us examine these four factors one by one. What is the base of a deed of killing? If we take ourselves as an example, the base for ourselves performing a deed of killing is a being endowed with a mind who is different from us. What is the thought? The thought has several components.
The first is discrimination. This must be an unmistaken discrimination or an unmistaken perception of the other being. The second factor is motivation. There are numerous motivations. One can be motivated to engage in killing out of anger, but one could also kill out of desire to consume, for instance, the flesh of another being.
The third factor is the deed. This deed can either be direct or indirect. A direct deed would be to kill another being through usage of a firearm, a knife, or poison. An indirect way of proceeding would be to say to a third party, go forth and kill this one. The final component of the deed is the conclusion of the deed.
This is the death of the other party, with the caveat that the other party must die before oneself dies. If the other party does not die before oneself dies, but after oneself has died, then the deed, karmically, is not complete. Once such a deed has been performed and the victim’s consciousness has departed from its body, then a potency is deposited within our own continuum, which will cause us to experience either a future lower rebirth or sufferings within a future rebirth. And therefore, for a deed, for instance, a deed of killing of a living being to be complete, these four factors, base, thought, deed, and completion of the deed must all be present. And therefore, if we take the case of killing or murder, it is considered a fault.
It is considered a crime from a mundane, from a legal standpoint, and leads to punishment by the laws of the land. It is also considered a non virtue from the standpoint of dharma since it leads in terms of its maturation to the experience of suffering in future lives. Then I shall stop here for today and take your questions at present. If you could pass the microphone to Susan. I can hear you.
Hello? Just now you talk about a person that had an intention of killing but he die before the other person? Mhmm. Mhmm. So the karma of the intention, is it going to be in a continue?
It’s an excellent question. That’s an excellent question. Basically, the karmic potency of killing another being must be implanted within a living being. Then if the performer of the deed of the planned murder dies before his or her victim, there is no longer a living being in which to impart implant this potency of killing, of murder. So the karmic deed of murder would not have been accrued, but other non virtues would have been accrued.
Aloha. Aloha. And this? Just wondering in capital punishment if somebody gets the electric chair who pulls the trigger? Do they accumulate that karma?
Does the court system accumulate that karma Or is it non karma? In general, all involved would accumulate non virtue. However, whether they would accumulate a complete need of killing is open to question since, for instance, the executioner might very well execute without having an evil motivation to do so. Then there is food for topic in food for thinking in this topic. For instance, let us imagine, taking myself as an example, that I say to somebody, go forth and kill this third party, and after saying this, I fall into a deep sleep, a dreamless sleep, and my servant goes forth and kills a third party while I am in a dreamless sleep.
In a dreamless sleep, there is no mental consciousness present. Therefore, there is no basis on which the potency of karma can be implanted. So the debate which arises is, is karma accrued or not? And if so, how? Yeah.
Yeah. You have also question. I just wanted to talk, just ask a question about the base. Because the base, what Geshe-la was saying is that the base is, we see are being endowed as differently to us so we see them as different. So that’s actually like a thought isn’t it?
Like a thought. The base, well the base is actually what’s being described there is a thought. So why is that separated from the next section which is the thought behind the deed? When one speaks of the base, one is not speaking of a thought. One is speaking of a person or a being, a living being, who is different from oneself.
That is the base. And Oh, Susan. Just now, Geshe-la talking about person asleep and the servant go and kill another person. So I asked if a person got a problem with sleepwalking, sleep walking, and they kill another person. Is that also imposed on that person’s karma?
Rinpoche had never heard of these cases of somnambulism, but he said, for someone to accumulate karma, they must have awareness and memory. So where does suicide fit in with these four aspects of non virtue, of killing? So suicide is killing, but it is not a complete deed of killing since one is not killing a basis different from oneself. So the four components of the base, the thought, the deed, and the completion of the deed must be present and complete for the deed to be complete. Geshe-la taught earlier on that with the gosh I’ve got the wrong page sorry.
About the 10 non virtues and that the last three non virtues are mental factors which arise independently of either the body or speech. I don’t really understand how something, for example, like ill will towards someone else is dependent on body or speech. There is a distinction to be made between ill will on the one hand and anger on the other, and I think that is the source of your question regarding the relationship between ill will and a bodily or physical base. Anger can arise without ill will being present. Anger is a preliminary which leads to unsuitable states of mind, which can give rise to unsuitable physical or verbal deeds.
When ill will is present, there is a focus on the performance of a non virtuous deed. So ill will shares a component with anger, but it is not always anger. Yes, you know, I mentioned before that all four aspects have to be there for the the actual to be complete. I’m thinking of a situation where every so often I go and mow my lawn. Now there’s no intention to go and kill all the insects on the lawn.
I don’t know at the back of my mind that I’m going to kill those insects regardless of mowing the lawn. And I guess you may elaborate on that a little more. So the act of karma, of killing, is present, but the deed of killing is not complete. The deed of killing is not complete because the thought is not complete. You have not discriminated or perceived the insects.
In addition, you do not have the motivation to kill the insects. So the deed of killing is not complete. But the best is not to cut your grass at this. So to take the example of Grant regarding growing the grass, if we listen to the situation where one has to perform a sinful deed, then if one is unable to abstain from it, after having performed it, one should confess it and purify it through the four powers. Since as it is said, sin has one quality it can be confessed and purified.
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- four powers
- The four types of attainments often described in tantric initiations. They are: pacification (of delusions), increase (of realizations), control (of whatever needs controlling) and subduing (of negative forces). LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How does suicide fit with the four factors that make killing a complete non-virtuous deed?
Suicide is killing, but it is not a complete deed of killing, because the one who dies is not a basis different from oneself. For a deed of killing to be complete, the components of the basis, the thought, the deed and the completion of the deed must all be present and complete. In suicide the basis is not a separate being, so the full set of factors is not met, and the deed is not complete killing.