Lam Rim — 2014-11-01

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — 2014-11-01
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 61-minute teaching, Ilya Kadri offers a framework for understanding Buddhism in relation to other world religions, moving from a comparative method to a deeper examination of core metaphysical views. He begins by showing how all major religious traditions—Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, Confucianism, and Buddhism—share broadly similar ethical methods: virtues like simplicity, contentment, ethics, and kindness taught across traditions in remarkably parallel ways. But Buddhism differs radically at the level of wisdom or ultimate view: it rejects a creator God and posits impermanent, constantly changing consciousness. Kadri then analyzes the Semitic monotheisms (Judaism, Christianity, Islam), tracing their roots to Abraham and their emphasis on faith over reason, before pivoting to the Indian philosophical context—the Vedas and especially the Upanishads—where pessimism about worldly existence and the ideal of monasticism first emerged. He argues that understanding whether one is mentally rooted in a Semitic or Gangetic (Indian) universe is foundational before committing to Buddhism, and illustrates how Western converts often experience destabilization by importing Christian cultural assumptions into Buddhist practice. The talk serves practitioners considering serious Buddhist engagement and those seeking clarity on doctrinal boundaries.

File metadata (for organising)

File: four-noble-truths-2014-11-01-kr

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Four Noble Truths

Date: 2001-11-14

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~8,205

Well, it’s 02:00, so it’s a good time to welcome you on this rather windy day to another of Ilya’s very informative and no doubt challenging seminars. And today’s topic of course is wisdom in Buddhism. I think we all know Ilya and his work here at the Tibetan Buddhist Institute. And I think you all know where the facilities are. We’ll have a short break partway through.

And thank you for your kind, nominal donation. So without any further ado, I’d just like to hand straight over to you, Ilya. Thank you very much. It’s a good pleasure to see you here today for what will be the last seminar of the year. I had actually planned on giving a much more technical presentation today on the difference between the Sautrāntika and Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika viewpoints, but it seemed wiser to return to the basics.

There’s not a lot of point in going into very advanced topics which are impressive but of little benefit. And then next year, I will continue with these presentations at the rhythm of one every two months. I used to give them as you know at the rhythm of one per month, but attendance unfortunately plummeted. Then it seemed more realistic to offer them at the rhythm which was accessible to the students. And next year, is going to be highly focused.

I am at present thinking of dedicating the entire year to the study of karma and causality from this point of Stevenson’s research. So this will be a series of conferences exclusively on this topic, since I think this is both accessible for all of us and it’s immediately beneficial. Advanced topics like emptiness are difficult to understand and often we cannot put them in practice. In keeping with my usage here, I will talk less about Buddhism and more about what precedes Buddhism. It used to be that one could take for granted that the background in the history of religions and philosophy was something everyone had, and that students came to Buddhism, if you wish, at the end of a long personal progression.

Things have changed a lot in the last twenty five years. It’s really since His Holiness the Dalai Lama received the Nobel Peace Prize, Buddhism has become in many senses, a mainstream religion in the West. People enter centers who would never have come before, and one cannot anymore assume that there’s been this long personal progression, perhaps through Christianity, through Hinduism, via philosophy, leading eventually to an understanding of Buddhism. Typically, people come to centers when they are faced with difficulties in their lives, whether they are personal difficulties, health problems, psychological problems, and the image of Buddhism is excellent.

As a result, they tend to appropriate Buddhism in a very unexamined way, and as we will see this creates great problems, in particular, a very great instability, of the students. So I’d like to start with one Buddhist concept before presenting a vision of the non-Buddhist religious traditions from a Buddhist standpoint, as a prelude to understanding of the Buddhist difference. Every form of religious practice from a Buddhist standpoint can be subdivided either into method or into wisdom. And I find this template very useful if we apply it to other religions. So from a Buddhist standpoint, method is a totality of the behavioral aspect of the path, the generation of compassion or bodhicitta, but renunciation for that matter, it is, for instance, the totality of the path of the being of a small scope, with perhaps the exception of meditations on subtle impermanence.

Wisdom, on the other hand, refers exclusively to the understanding of selflessness. Now, the Buddhist difference lies at the level of the wisdom aspect of the path, not at the level of the method aspect of the path, and we’re going to be talking of the method aspect of the path first from the standpoint of the great religions. So I have listed some, it’s a non exhaustive list of the great world religions, and you can see that between Buddhism, Christianity, Islam, if it’s well understood, Judaism, Hinduism, Confucianism, I didn’t have space to add Taoism. The method aspect of the path is actually, broadly speaking, shared. There are differences, but the consensus is quite astonishing.

It is easily more than 90% of the method aspect of the path, which is common to all the world religions. And by the method aspect of the path, mean for instance, what Christians used to call the virtues. Now, what are, these elements of the method aspect of the path? All world religions, the great religions, teach some basic virtues, simplicity, contentment, awareness of transience, ethics, and kindness. This is a shared body, whether you are a Christian, a Jew, a Muslim, a Buddhist, a Hindu, a Taoist or a Confucian, these are values you will find in your own religious tradition, often expressed in a remarkably similar way.

All of this would fall basically within the method aspect of the path, except a particular form of the awareness of transience. And if we look at some passages from the great world religious scriptures, we can see this. It’s very striking. Let’s take the virtue of simplicity. Whether we look at Christian, Taoist, or Buddhist texts, the teachings are the same.

The Christians, the Sermon on the Mount, Christ says, blessed are the poor in spirit for theirs is the kingdom of heaven. In the Dhammapada, one of the root texts of Pāli Buddhism says, leave behind the path of darkness, and following the path of light, let the wise man leave his home life and go into a life of freedom. In a solitude that if you enjoy, let him find joy supreme, free from possession, free from desires, and free from whatever darkens his mind. And in Lao Tzu’s Tao Te Ching, the fundamental treaties of Taoism, therefore the sage puts his own person last and yet it is found in the foremost place. He treats his person as if it were foreign to him and yet that person is preserved.

These lines could just as well have come from Śāntideva’s bodhisattva Bodhicaryāvatāra. So if we pass to the next main virtue, which is taught by all the world religions, contentment, there is no difference between the Buddhist view of contentment and the Christian one. We find in the Epistles of the Philippians by Saint Paul, I know what it is to be in need and I know what it is to have plenty. I have learned the secret of being content in any and every situation, whether well fed or hungry, living in plenty or in want. How is this different from the passage in the Dhammapada of Buddha?

He who wanders without a home in this world, leaving behind the desires of the world and the desire never returns, him I call a Brahmin. These are the same teachings. It is often said that Buddhism is unique in its understanding of impermanence, this is incorrect. There are very clear teachings on coarse impermanence in all the great world religions, not in subtle impermanence, but coarse impermanence definitely, and we can see it in these passages regarding the awareness of transience. So I quoted from Ecclesiastes, which is my favorite book in the Bible, it is the wisdom section of the Bible, world is meaningless says a teacher, meaningless, meaningless.

What profit is therefore man in all his work which he toils under the sun, a generation goes, a generation comes, and the earth remains forever. Such a man has some type of realization of impermanence. And Śāntideva, the great Mahāyāna author says, but all my foes will cease to be, and all my friends will cease to be, and I will also cease to be, and likewise everything will cease to be. There is no difference. Then, if we pass to ethics, which is perhaps the inner core of all the great religious traditions, many of you know passage in the book of Psalms, blessed is the man who does not walk walk on the path of iniquity.

You find something almost identical in the Upanishads. Death said, the good is one thing, the pleasant another. It’s extraordinarily profound. These two having different objects chain a man. It is well with him who clings to the good, he who chooses the pleasant misses the goal.

And in the Dhammapada, Buddha Śākyamūni taught the essence of the teachings on karma, by oneself evil is done and it is oneself who suffers. By oneself evil is not done, by oneself one becomes pure. No man can purify another. I think you will agree with me, there is no difference in the core intuition of these passages. Finally, regarding kindness or a good heart, the Dhammapada teaches, for hate is not conquered by hate.

Hate is conquered by love. This is a law eternal. Whereas Christ in the gospel of Matthew, the sermon, actually it’s not in the sermon of the mount, but the gospel of Matthew says, a good man out of the good treasure of the heart brings forth good things, and an evil man out of the evil treasure brings forth evil things. There is no difference in the meaning of this passage in the Gospel of Matthew with what you have often heard the great Buddhist teachers say, which is that all deeds proceed from the mind. The meaning is exactly the same.

So there is a broad consensus on the method aspect of the path. It’s not only broad consensus, is a massive consensus. And this is what has enabled the meeting, the spiritual meeting of His Holiness, with Pope John Paul II. It is also why Nāgārjuna, in his Precious Garland, the Ratnāvali says in verses forty three and forty four, in brief the view of nihilism is that the results of karma do not exist, is non meritorious and leads to evil. It is explained to be a wrong view.

In brief, the view of eternalism is that the results of karma exist, is meritorious and a concordant cause for a happy rebirth, it is explained to be a correct view. This passage is extremely important, because Nāgārjuna, who is the foremost exponent of the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view, makes a very sharp difference between the view of nihilism and the view of eternalism. The view of nihilism is an unmitigated evil. We would call the view of nihilism nowadays materialism. The view of eternalism, which is basically the view of all the religions apart from Buddhism, from Nāgārjuna’s standpoint, is seen in the most positive of lights.

It is a foundation for the good life. And this is crucial to understand the position of His Holiness the Dalai Lama regarding religious conversion, which I will mention in a couple of minutes. So you can see that from the method aspect, from the standpoint of practice, of life, of motivation, of the development of the virtues and the qualities, there is really no difference. From the standpoint of wisdom between Buddhism and Christianity in particular, there is nothing in common. Christianity teaches the existence of a creator, an omnipotent God, who allowed his only son to be crucified on the cross, so as to bridge the gap between creation and himself.

It teaches that the world has a beginning and an end, and the end is the last judgment where all human beings will be judged, other living beings do not qualify for judgment. This has nothing in common with the Buddhist viewpoint. So we can see massive concordance at the level of method, and certainly as far as Christianity and Buddhism are concerned, tremendous differences as far as wisdom is concerned. Now this has made His Holiness the Dalai Lama to say not once but so often, I believe he actually mentions it at every single teaching he gives in the West, certainly everyone I have ever attended, that he discourages the conversion of Westerners to Buddhism. It used to be a caveat that it would be good to think carefully, nowadays generally speaking, His Holiness discourages this conversion.

For the very simple reason that the appropriation of another religion is a very destabilizing event. It is difficult for the person to convert to a new religion to be stable in their practice. They have a massive cultural heritage, which generally speaking, boast of the practice of their father’s religion. In our case, Christianity, in the case of a Jew Judaism, in the case of a Hindu Hinduism. It is therefore much better to practice the religion of one ancestors for normal people than to convert, simply because as we mentioned earlier, as far as method is concerned, the core of the great religions is the same.

You will all the great qualities which are taught in the Buddhist scriptures from the method standpoint, if you practice as a Christian, as a Jew, as a Hindu, as a Muslim. And if that is your religious background, you will be more stable. So to show you the impact of the destabilization conversion causes and why his holiness has become very explicit in his warning to Westerners about conversion, these are the statistics of Karma Ling, a country center in France which had some 10,000 students over thirty years. Of the students who attended on year one, ten percent were still attending after five years, and after ten years it was three percent. So this is basically a failure rate of ninety seven percent.

Now this corresponds to my personal experience in some thirty years, it corresponds to what I have seen at TBI. If I look at the students in this room, I think apart from Chris Ridley and Anne Jansen and Joe, nobody else was here, and Julian, nobody else was here in 2007 when I first came to Australia. In 2008, as if none of you were either there in Sandy. You were there. So we’re looking at what?

80 to 90% of your students. Where did everyone else go? Now when one practices a religious tradition, one is practicing not for this life but for future lives. So if one is unstable over a time span of three or four years, one cannot talk of future lives. Basic stability is absent.

I’ve asked several times management at TBI to provide me with pictures of the teachings considered which you gave in 2007 and 2008. I want to show you the contrast who was there in 2008 and who is still there now. Our attrition rate is frightening. It is frightening largely because of the destabilization due to conversion and because of lack of understanding, because of a lack of appropriation of the wisdom component of the path. So it has become a bit of a caricature in France, and I think it applies to Australia too.

As you know, France is a Roman Catholic country, and the Tibetan country tradition has been extraordinarily influential. I mean, when I was a young Buddhist in the nineteen eighties, Kalu Rinpoche traveled to France, there was like a swathe of conversions followed him. Then what was very odd was it was often very devout Catholics who passed from Roman Catholicism to the Tibetan Buddhist tradition. And I’ll never forget a marvelous old French agent, an aristocrat, Jacqueline de Piffontaine. I was visiting her.

She was an old sponsor of the monastery, late seventies, early eighties, and she was setting out little bowls filled with oil lamps in front of the Buddha. And as she was setting them out, had to pour the oil in a brass lamp and put a piece of cork and put a wick and light up. She said, you see, I became a Buddhist because I really dislike all of this formalism and this ritual in the United Catholic church, and then she went on lighting her brass lamps. So the French have nicknamed these people catho-bouddhistes, Catholic converts to Buddhism. And this for us is the risk.

The risk is to focus on externals, and for our conversion to be an epidemic phenomenon, and this leads to a departure later on. So, clearly, there are people who have a connection with the Buddhist teachings in the West. Just as clearly, are many people who come to centers who will be much better served by going to a church. The only way to separate the two is some type of understanding, and this comes through study. And this is why so as the Dalai Lama has been so forceful in his emphasis on studies at TBI.

If we study, we will understand the difference between Buddhism and the other religious traditions. Then we can make an educated decision, not an emotional decision, the way based on the generally good image of Buddhism, the wish to belong to a community and whatnot. And these studies must be very focused studies. We must study the other religions to understand what their core position is, and then study Buddhism to understand what the Buddhist difference is, and then we have to stop, and we have to ask ourselves, is this something I believe in or not? Then if we don’t believe in it, the time spent in a Buddhist center is not time well spent.

As soon as the Dalai Lama always gives a case which changed his mind, I’m sorry, I know I’m putting quite a few of you on the spot when I say this, I can see the body language, but it has to be said and it is being said by all my teachers, so I am the last piece of my teachers. I repeat this all the more so because I have seen it in practice. His Holiness the Dalai Lama gave the case of one of his students, a Polish lady, and it really changed his outlook on the conversion of Westerners. She came to the Dharamsala in the early sixties, so this is just two or three years after the Tibetans had fled. She was one of the very early ones.

She gave up Christianity, renounced Roman Catholicism, converted to Buddhism, received all the teachings, the initiations, did retreats, whatnot. And then, on her deathbed in the early nineteen seventies, she asked for a Roman Catholic priest to come. She denounced Buddhism, demanded to re enter the Roman Catholic Church, received extreme unction and died as a Roman Catholic. This is after almost twenty years as a student of His Holiness, receiving every teaching, every initiation, doing the retreats, etc. His Holiness mentions this case almost every time he teaches in India.

He said, basically, we’re looking at fifteen to twenty years which are completely wasted. Maybe even harmful, if one is going to practice as a Christian, the belief in religious tradition in which there is no God is harmful to one’s practice. And this is an issue even here in Adelaide. I am told that there, is at least one nun who says in public that one must understand God from a Buddhist standpoint. Then this is what I have heard this several times now.

Then, honestly, this is, as His Holiness would put it, extreme confusion. Well, there’s no benefit in this. Therefore, what we shall do today is we’re going to ask what the Buddhist difference is. And then all of us are free. It is a very unique modern phenomenon that we are free to choose our religion.

We can choose to be Buddhist, we can choose to be Christian or any other religion, but it is very important to be sincere and honest in one’s practice. This has been extremely harmful to Westerners in the eyes of Tibetan masters. I have over my lifetime seen a big shift in the attitude of great Tibetan masters towards Westerners. When I started out in 1981, the attitude was, well, this happens, in other words, they don’t behave well, they don’t respect their teachers, they don’t study and whatnot, because they don’t understand. Now the shift has really occurred, and many great Tibetan teachers say this happens because they are by nature fickle, and it may not be worth going to the trouble, and there are great Tibetan masters who refuse now to teach in the West as a direct result of this.

So this is a very awkward state of affairs. It’s not something we want to see to continue and historians has really encouraged therefore people to be very careful in their commitments to study before. I mean, you do want to study the great religions before you become a Buddhist, not become a Buddhist for some emotional reason, because you saw a movie or whatever, and then study the great religions after and realize that really you have a lot of affinities for Hinduism, let us say. So what are the questions which have to be addressed regarding the view? And interestingly enough, these questions were summarized not by a Buddhist master, but by a Sufi master in a dialogue with his holiness, and I find them very powerful.

His Holiness mentions these over and again. The three questions we have to ask from the great religions regarding the view is, when the mind thinks I, what is thinking I? Does that I have a beginning, or does that I have an end? Now if we try to understand the great religions with respect to their position on this topic, In other words, the relationship between the I and what I would call the mind body complex, the bottom mind and with the body and the brain. There’s two big divisions.

Some religions assert an I which is separate from the mind body complex. This is a soul. And then some religious and philosophical traditions do not. Within those which assert a soul, we have the great family of the Abrahamic monotheisms, the Semitic monotheisms, which comprise Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, together as you will see we are dealing with almost two and a half billion human beings. Within the family of those not asserting an I, which is separate from the mind body complex, in other words refusing or rejecting the existence of a soul, we have Buddhism and materialism.

Buddhism asserts the existence of a consciousness which is impermanent and transitory. Materialism asserts there is no consciousness, there is just the brain. Now, all of the great religious traditions which assert was to examining these three questions, right, which assert that the eye has a beginning? All the Semitic religions do. God creates a soul at conception, the eye, the soul has a beginning, it has no end.

And the materialism also asserts that the mind has a beginning, the eye has a beginning, it is a certain level problem, problematic probably in the gestation where the embryo becomes conscious. Which religious schools assert that the eye has an end? A subset of Buddhist schools Hīnayāna assert that it is possible for the eye to disappear, and materialism asserts obviously the eye disappears at death. The Hinayana schools assert that when one becomes an Arhat, one severs all past karma, and at the end of that life there is no karma to impel one into a future life. For those of you who study tenets, these are the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika schools of tenets, and therefore the Hīnayāna schools assert that an Arhat at the time of death is extinguished.

His body obviously disappears and his mind ceases, and this is seen by these schools as a good thing, because life is seen as of the nature of suffering. The Mahāyāna schools do not assert this. So so statistically, what is the breakup of the great religions? You can see you have almost two and a half billion Christians, one and a half billion Muslims, a very small minority of Jews, some 15,000,000, it’s almost 1,000,000,000 Hindus, and a very small number of Buddhists, 400,000,000. The Buddhist position is therefore very much a minority position in the world religions, and if we look at the proportion of the great religions or the adherence of the great religions who believe in the existence of God and a soul, we can see that we are dealing with in excess of 90% of all religious practitioners.

Clearly, is a beneficial viewpoint for these people. 90% of mankind believes in a god and a soul, and builds its entire life on this basis. Which proportion of religious practitioners subscribe to the incarnation in Karma? It remains a minority. It is the sum total of the Hindus and the Buddhists.

Christians, Muslims, Jews, Confucians, for that matter, traditional Taoists do not believe in reincarnation in Karma. So the following chart is somewhat complex, but I think it shows the way forwards when one is trying to decide from one’s own side if one should study Buddhism and if one should become a Buddhist or not. If you take all the great religious traditions and investigate whether they believe in a creator or not, and what sort of a creator they believe in, because there is a big difference, you will find that there are broadly speaking three positions. Most of the world religious traditions are theistic, for them God is a person. You see this in the Bible, if you read the Old Testament, those of you who know the Old Testament, God has emotions.

There are repeated passages which refer to the anger of God, the love of God. God is a person. This is true for Islam and Christianity as well. For some religious traditions, God is an abstract entity. These are the deists.

You find this mainly in the ancient world, in Hellenistic and Roman civilization, in stoicism, and in the post Renaissance world, it is a mainstream position among those who want to maintain a presence of God. You find it in Voltaire’s work, in Rousseau’s work, many people nowadays are deists. This is an impersonal God. Voltaire said, God is to us like the captain of a ship to the rats on the ship. What care does a captain of the ship have of the rats?

This is a deist God. Such a God creates a universe, and the universe ticks by itself, it’s a gigantic clock, and what matters the ants in the clock. Finally, are religious traditions which are atheistic, they are overwhelmingly Indian. In India there are two, it is Buddhism, which accepts the existence of past and future lives in karma, and Indian materialism, which is subdivided in two, I won’t enter into details. Some traditions accept the existence of past and future lives, but say there is no karma, others don’t accept the existence of past and future lives.

So this template is very helpful to understand the position of the great religions, and before committing to a religious tradition, one must ask oneself, am I green, am I blue, or am I red? And these three positions do not intersect. There is no common locus. Then this has a very big impact on the position or the relationship of the great religions to human reason, what is called epistemology. None of the monotheistic religions consider that human reason is of any importance whatsoever.

For that matter neither do Taoism or Vedanta. For a very simple reason, if you believe that there is an infinite creator who created the universe by an act of will, and man is a tiny reflection of this creator, only that man must do is abide by the will of this creator, and in the case of the Abrahamic religions, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, this creator God has spoken. His speech is for the Jews the Old Testament, for the Christians the old in the New Testament, and for the Muslims the Old Testament, the New Testament, and the Quran, which is a final revelation. If you believe that such a God has spoken, his word is absolute. The will of a human being cannot be put on the same level as that of such a being, and this is what we encounter nowadays in The Middle East.

Islam for those of you who know Arabic means subservience, in the Rasam the root to bow, the Muslim bows. It is the purest form of monotheism. This has important consequences, They’re not trivial consequences as you can all see. Now there are religious traditions which validate reason as a means of ultimate analysis, and Buddhist is perhaps the only one. Simply because Buddhism is atheistic.

There is no God. What the Christians call salvation, our salvation, in other words, as Buddhists would say liberation, depends on us and on no one else. So in Buddhist situation, it’s been a considerable solitude. Then I would like to pursue the analysis of the opposite position, because we often understand ourselves through understanding our contrary. And therefore, I’d like to analyze in some depth Semitic monotheisms.

In other words, the religions of Abraham, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. These are the religions of the desert. If you have not been to the Middle East, you cannot understand monotheism. Monotheism arises in stark brutal worlds, where there is the sand and there is the sky, and there is nothing else. And Christianity, which is attenuated monotheism, arose in a part of the Middle East in Galilee, where actually there is a fair amount of greenery, it’s very, very striking.

And this goes a long way to explain the starkness, the beauty and also the harshness of the monotheisms. The father of all monotheistic traditions we now know is an Egyptian pharaoh who lived in the fourteenth century BC, Akhenaten. He was a spiritual father of Moses. Moses, as you know, was not Jewish, but Egyptian. The name is Egyptian.

And all of the monotheisms are rooted in one figure, and this figure explains us very much about the relationship of the believer in a monotheistic tradition and God. This figure is Abraham. Abraham in Hebrew, ab is father, is multitude, means father of a great number. He was a Chaldean merchant, perhaps mythical, we don’t know. The Abrahamic monotheisms include Judaism, the original Abrahamic monotheism, Christianity, and Islam.

And the figure of Abraham, just as a figure of Moses, are figures of men who bows to a power which is beyond him. All of you who have gone to Sunday school know very well the story of Abraham who takes his son Isaac to be sacrificed, and who has his son gather wood to sacrifice him. And when his son is put on the altar at the point of sacrifice, an angel of the Lord descends and tells to Abraham to withdraw his hand, his faith has been acknowledged. As a matter of fact, historically, we now know that this account had a very different ending. The original myth of Abraham involves the actual sacrifice of Isaac by Abraham, and the account was rewritten by a Hebrew priest, we call him the Deuteronomist, to try to adapt it to the taste of the age.

Now what is the myth of Abraham about? The myth of Abraham is about faith which rejects any reason. The myth of Abraham is a myth which underlies Judaism, Christianity and Islam. If you want to understand Islam, you have to understand Abraham. So what are the core features of Semitic monotheisms?

With your permission, I’ll take my sweater off because theological conversation is heated, you see. No. No. No. It’s not necessary.

The core positions of all the monotheistic traditions as we said is that God is a person, that there is only one God, and then the traditions disagree regarding whether transcendence is radical or qualified, and whether there is an absolute dualism between God and creation or not. Knowledge of God can only be had through his revelation in a book, hence logic and experience are completely irrelevant. There’s a beautiful account of this in the book of Job, if you have forget forgotten what core monotheism is, read the book of Job, Jung found it very instructive. Job challenges God regarding the justice of his decisions and God manifests the totality of creation in the form of numerous animals of the deep in front of Job and says, where were you when I created? Who are you to challenge me?

This is a monotheistic position. For the monotheistic tradition the eye has a beginning, conception, but no end. The world is created by God and therefore this is critical, the world is good, creation is good, life is good, it may have faults for Judaism Christianity there has been a fall, but it is a fall from a state of goodness, and man in all the semitic monotheisms has a preeminent stature, he is created in the image and the resemblance of God, he shares something with the creator. This viewpoint is a religious viewpoint, but it underlies all of Western society and all of our values. When you speak of human rights, you are speaking within a monotheistic context, without being aware of the fact, because you never mentioned in that sentence animal rights.

Do you? When you speak of the importance of enjoying life, you are speaking in a monotheistic context, this is alien to the Buddhist worldview. From a monotheistic standpoint, life is a good thing, When as westerners we get married in churches, and a priest officiates we are speaking or viewing things from a monotheistic standpoint, and when our students at the center asks a Geshe to bless their marriage, they are speaking as epidermal Buddhists whose heart is Christian, because a Buddhist monk does not bless a marriage. A marriage is not a happy state of affairs, it’s an unfortunate state of affairs. The birth of a child is not from a Buddhist standpoint a happy state of affairs, it’s an unfortunate state of affairs.

So you can see that although many of us are no longer Christian, the dye goes deep within and we have to become aware of it, so that we can choose to transform ourselves or choose not to do so. So what are the inner dilemmas of revealed monotheism, the inner contradictions? The explanation of evil and suffering is perhaps the biggest one. This is theodicy, the judgment of God. Accounting for a first cause for the philosophically inclined is also an issue, and then, and this is an issue which Christianity addressed directly, how to account for any type of communication between God, the creator of the universe, who is eternal and transcendent, and ephemeral man.

Christianity accounts for this in a brilliant way through positing the existence of a person, Jesus Christ, who has both natures, the divine and the human nature within one person, and who acts therefore as a bridge. Islam and Judaism do not feel this is necessary and are comfortable with the radical transcendence of God, and the final dilemmas of reveal monotheisms, which probably has led to the collapse of Christianity in the West, is discrepancy between their scriptures and everything we know about the modern world and the universe. So I often feel that this picture encapsulates monotheism. There’s no image, because it is inappropriate to make an image of God. There is no ritual, because no ritual can control such a force.

There is just a creature alone in front of the Creator. It’s very powerful, very powerful. This world is a world almost every single one of us in this room comes from. If we do not come from it, our parents do, the values of a society are infused with it. So it is a world we must understand and then we must see within ourselves whether or not these are values we adopt and we must be very wary if we choose not to adopt them, because they will infuse much of our worldview.

Buddhism lies or is born in a radically different universe. Buddhism is born in the Indian religious universe, and Buddhism is rooted originally in the Vedas. So I will give the background of the Vedas and Upanishads, and then we will address the actual topic of this conference, which is the Buddhist difference, and I think you will see the Buddhist difference in a much starker light. This is a brief chart of the Indian religious traditions, broadly speaking all are rooted in the Vedas, with the exception of the schools which are born in the Ganges around the sixth century BC. The Upanishads which only partially accept the Vedas, and the so called Darshanas of the views, which do not accept the Vedas at all.

So the Vedas are for India what the Old Testament would be for the West. Therefore Vedas, the Rigveda, which is a magnificent work, if you can read it in English, would highly recommend, it’s a work of great poetry, poetry, the Yajurveda, the Atharvaveda, the Samaveda. The Rigveda is the most philosophical of all, and the concept of the Godhead in the Vedas, because the Vedas are profoundly theistic, is a passage from nature worship to a very strong ethical stage, which really corresponds closely, I would say, to the nature form of Judaism, and then to a passage to a god of victory, which really corresponds to the Yahweh of the Old Testament, the god which leads the Hebrew into victory against the Canaanites. Then and this is where Indian religiosity differs profoundly from our religious traditions. Very rapidly from Indra onwards, and you can position this around 1,000 BC, Vedic religiosity becomes extraordinarily abstract.

The following dominant god is Prajapati, who is the god of the absolute, and god as he is known now in India is Brahman, who is one with being. So you could say certainly that India short circuited most of the steps which were present in the Semitic religion, and passed very quickly to the Greek conception of the Godhead. From Prajapati onwards, God is not a person. God is an abstract entity. He can best be understood as pure being, And if you read the cosmogonic hymns of the Rig Veda, and these go back anything between fifteen hundred and three thousand years before Jesus Christ, you can see how extraordinarily profound they are.

There was then neither what is nor what is not. There was no death, hence there was nothing immortal. That one, this refers to God, breathed by itself without breath, other than it there has been nothing. Who then knows who has declared it here, from whence was born this creation? The gods came later than this creation, all the gods of the Indian Pantheon are later trivial constructs.

Who then knows whence it arose? He, in other words, God, the fundamental God, Brahman, from whom this creation arose, whether he made it or did not make it, the highest seer in the highest seven, he forsooth know, or does even he not know. Keep in mind this was written at a period where our narratives of the Old Testament are bloodthirsty narratives of battles. And the fundamental features of Vedic religiosity is that it is henotheistic, in other words it accepts one God as main God with a multiplicity of other gods surrounding it to a subsidiary, but Vedic religiosity is henotheistic in the process of becoming an absolute monotheism. For the Vedas, the world is the actual evolution of God, the world is God.

The vedas are therefore realistic. The vedas do not subscribe to reincarnation, they teach existence of an afterlife an afterlife of light, they are profoundly optimistic, they view this world as a good thing and they believe that the main duty of man is sacrifice. Sacrifice performs the or the performance of ritual maintains the harmony of the universe. Finally, there is no priestly class. Every householder of the Brahmin caste functions as priest if and only if he is married.

Marriage is indispensable to perform sacrifice. Just as in Judaism and in Islam, the unmarried state is an unnatural state precisely because creation is viewed as a good thing. If you accept the existence of a creature creator, celibacy is inconceivable, it goes against the natural order. Then a very striking shift occurs in India in the seventh sixth century BC, and we don’t know why. At approximately the same time as such a shift occurred in China.

It’s a shift marked by extreme pessimism. It has been speculated that it is due to the widespread usage of iron in farm implements, which completely transformed society, destroyed the traditional order, and much of the ancient values. And this pessimism led to the world of the Upanishads. This is a very famous Indian yogi, Tatwale Baba, believe it or not, he was 80 when the picture was taken. Upanishadic thought represents a radical shift out of the world of the Vedas.

In the Upanishads, there still is monotheism and panentheism, in other words, God is with everything, but three new components are manifest. The goal of the practitioner becomes union with God. The Upanishads are profoundly pessimistic. This is the birth of Buddhist pessimism. Sacrifice which is external in the Upanishads becomes internal and what is the sacrifice?

It is Brahmacharya, celibacy, the ultimate sacrifice of the yogi. And for the first time reincarnation is taught. The teachings of reincarnation appear in India between the seventh and the fifth century BC. Another aspect of the Upanishads which is quite surprising is indifference to authority. It’s quite striking that the Upanishads and the Upanishadic seers often are very dismissive of the Vedas.

And the focus is on the nature of the self or the soul. The Vedas are completely uninterested in the soul. So we have a critical moment here in Indian thought, and this critical moment is very important for us as Buddhism Buddhists, because it is at this moment, in this milieu that Buddhism appears. Buddha Śākyamūni himself traveled in the milieu of Upanishadic thought, he had Upanishadic teachers, he broke away from it. He is a product of this world, and we can see in the Upanishads an anguish, which is absent in the Vedas.

Where are we born? Where do we live and where do we go? And they requested the lead me from the unreal, in other words, this world, to the real. Lead me from darkness to light. Lead me from death to immortality.

Monotheism is prevalent, again, the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, it’s one of the greatest Upanishads with Chāndogya. You have this famous passage, how many gods are there really? One he said. All the other gods are but the manifestations of the highest, the immortal, the incorporeal Brahman, and a man may meditate on, worship or discard also those which are its manifestations. This is henotheism which leads eventually to the radical monotheism which has marked India and which you find in the Vedanta.

To the difference of the Semitic world, the Indian vision of the Godhead is panentheistic. God is in everything. Everything is God. In the Semitic world, God is different from everything. The creation is an afterthought.

It could very well not have occurred. You can sense a radically different relationship between a worshiper within the Semitic tradition and a worshiper within the Upanishadic tradition. For a worshiper within the Semitic tradition, this world world good is but a manifestation of God and what matters is God’s plan for the world. This plan has to be revealed, because man’s logic cannot reach such a level. For one subscribes to the Upanishadic view of the world, this world itself is Brahman.

If we want to understand Brahman, we just have to look around us in the flow of the rivers, the clouds, sky. And therefore Taittiriya Upanishad says, that from which these beings are born, that in which when born they live, and that into which they enter at their death, that is Brahman. There is therefore for the Upanishadic believer no salvation out there. Liberation, moksha, is just realizing that everything that is is Brahman. And the goal of the Upanishadic practitioner, the Sanyasin to this day in India is union with God.

This union occurs when one understands that one’s inner Brahman, one’s Ātman in other words, one’s soul is one with the outer Brahman, the famous Sanskrit verse thus art thou. However, the Upanishadic world is profoundly pessimistic, and this pessimism as I mentioned is probably a product of the age. It is something which is totally at odds with the Semitic traditions. That does not age as this body grows old, that is not killed when this body is slain, that this is the Ātman, the soul. That is a real thought of Brahman, which could contain all desires, that is the self free from evil, in Chāndogya Upanishad, one of the two great Upanishads.

Therefore for the Upanishads and the yogis, such sacrifice is meaningless. This is the ancient Vedic sacrifice performed nowadays in India by the Brahmin caste to maintain cosmic order. Such sacrifice is a misunderstanding of the actual internal sacrifice. And once again in Chāndogya Upanishad, what people normally call a sacrifice is in reality the life of a celibate student, and it is with the Upanishads that the ideal of monasticism is born in India. The celibate yogi who strives in the case of the Upanishads to gain realization of the unity of Ātman and Brahman and in so doing to gain liberation from saṃsāra.

And therefore the Upanishads teach we can garnish and they use a metaphor of the wheel, which Khensur Rinpoche mentioned, is used by Candrakīrti in the Madhyamakāvatāra, this is a metaphor which is universal in ancient India, you find it among the Hindus, Jains, Buddhists, And you can see in this passage of the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, a presentation of karma, which is identical to that of Buddhism. A man who is attached, in other words with desire, goes with his action, action is karma, to that very place to which his mind and character cling. Which in the end of his action, his karma, of whatever he has done in this world, from that world he returns back to this world, back to action. From life to life to life, impelled by Karma. Finally, the indifference to the Vedas is quite strikingly mentioned in a passage such as this one.

I know all these texts, but I do not know the Ātman. My knowledge is meaningless. Which leads to the core focus in the Upanishads, a focus on the Ātman. This is a statue of Patanjali, the great father of Rāja Yoga and the great Sanskrit grammarian. The self that is free from evils, free from old age and death, free from sorrow, from hunger and thirst, that is the self you should try to discover.

What the self is is highly debated. The Hidayanaka Upanishads says that it is a dreamless state. Other Upanishads disagree. The Upanishads are texts which are very frequently sharply at odds with each other. These are the reflections of Sanyasins, wandering philosophers and yogis.

So this leads us to the point I wanted to reach, to contrast the semitic monotheisms from which we come with the Gangetic traditions, because it is on this basis that we can enter into Buddhism. The Semitic monotheisms, Judaism, Christianity and Islam teach a radically transcendental God. A real world, a good world, linear history, and my apologies, one single, no past life and only one future life. The Gangetic traditions almost completely opposite. They teach that God is within nature, not radically transcendental.

They teach an impersonal God, not a person. They teach an illusory world. Their history is cyclical, and whereas the revealed monotheisms are anthropocentric centered on man, the Gangetic traditions are not. Man is not terribly important in the Gangetic traditions. Finally, it’s just teaching an infinite history, they teach infinite past and future lives, and instead of teaching as goal salvation, they teach us goal liberation.

The contrast is very helpful. Don’t you think? It is a different mental universe. So therefore before thinking of becoming Buddhist, should ask ourselves the question: am I mentally part of the Gangetic universe or not? And then within that Gangetic universe there are many religious traditions.

There’s Jain, there’s Buddhism, there’s Hinduism, there’s Vedanta, Advaita Vedanta, Dvaita Vedanta. Then we have to investigate. But this core question, what mental universe do I inhabit? Is one we must answer. And at present I think we can take our tea break.

We have reached the introduction of Buddhism. Buddhism within the Gangetic traditions, Buddhism as perhaps a rebellion against the Upanishads, but every rebellion is always rooted in that against which it rebels. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top