1 h 18 min · 3,095 words · 26 August 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 79-minute session, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen delivers a detailed explanation of the Vaibhāṣika Buddhist school’s philosophical views on liberation, reincarnation, and the Buddha. He covers the sevenfold structure of Vaibhāṣika tenets—including their understanding of afflictive and non-afflictive obstructions, the path toward liberation, and the three final vehicles—and explains a distinctive and counterintuitive Vaibhāṣika position: that Arhats (accomplished practitioners) experience complete cessation of consciousness at death, severing their continuum of existence entirely. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen addresses why ordinary beings have past and future lives while Arhats do not, explores how the Buddha himself, having attained final nirvana, no longer exists according to Vaibhāṣika doctrine, and answers students’ probing questions about karmic imprints, the nature of physical form, and the purpose of pursuing liberation if it leads to annihilation. The teaching concludes with structured debate among students. Suitable for practitioners studying Buddhist philosophical schools and those interested in comparing different interpretations of nirvana across Tibetan Buddhist traditions.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-08-26.mp3
UUID: f76e2929-93e6-4978-89a5-aab589ae9732
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Tenets
Date: 2014-08-26
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,097
Let us therefore generate the motivation for a couple of seconds. So within the presentation of the four systems of Buddhist tenets, as you remember, we are covering the Vaibhāṣika system of tenets. And the systems of tenets are presented in terms of the presentation of the basis, the path, and the result. If you look at the presentation of the sevenfold subdivision of the Vaibhāṣika school on page three, The Vaibhāṣika school is explained in terms of the presentation of definitions, divisions, etymologies, the mode of asserting objects, subjects, selflessness, grounds and paths. The mode of asserting objects and the mode of asserting subjects are the basis.
Regarding the presentation of the path, this includes a presentation both of the objects of abandonment and of the antidotes. And the objects of abandonment, as you remember, include a presentation of the afflictive obstructions and the nonafflictive obstructions. The afflictive obstructions have been explained. As to the non afflictive obstructions in the higher schools of tenets, these are referred to as the obstructions to omniscience. The term obstruction to omniscience is not used in the Vaibhāṣika school.
Instead, it refers to non afflictive obstructions. What example can be given of non-afflictive obstructions? The example given is that of the karmic imprints or the residues of grasping at a self within the mental continuum of a hearer or a solitary realizer, The reason for which the example is given within the continuum of a hearer or solitary realizer, is because hearer or solitary realizer, arhats, have abandoned the seeds of grasping or apprehending a self. Even though they have abandoned the seeds of grasping at a self, they have nonetheless not abandoned the karmic imprints of grasping at self. And these karmic imprints subsist as obstructions within the mental continuum of Arhats even though they are no longer able to give rise to grasping at self.
This is akin to someone who casts a very powerful shadow and who walks, let us say, out of the temple. When he’s walking out of the temple, part of the shadow is still cast in the temple even though he himself is no longer there. So this is for the presentation of the path. As to the result, it was approached briefly last time. Each of the vehicles has its own result.
Specifically, as was mentioned, hearers, or śrāvakas, and solitary realizers, both have the same object of abandonment, is self grasping. And both have the same object of meditation, which is selflessness. They differ however in the amount of time required to attain their object of attainment. Solitary realizers must meditate for a very long period of time, 100 eons. Whereas hearers of sharp acumen can realize their goal in three lives.
A doubt might arise in this respect why is there such a difference between hearers and solitary realizers. This is partly due to the fact that their attainments are not the same.
Therefore, from the standpoint of of this Vaibhāṣika school, when a hearer or a solitary realizer, a Śrāvaka or a Pratyeka Buddha becomes an arhat, they are said from that point onwards to have what is known as a Nirvāṇa with remainder. This Nirvāṇa with remainder, they will have until the time at which they relinquish their body. In other words, until the time at which they die. This Nirvāṇa is said to be with remainder because they continue to live within the body which they were born in due to contaminated karma at the beginning of the life during which they became an arhat. And even though due to their extraordinary level of realization, they no longer experience mental suffering, they do experience until the time of their departure the full lot of physical suffering.
At the time of their relinquishing their body, in other words, at the time of their death, they are said to have a nirvana without remainder. This means, strictly speaking, that their continuum is severed. In other words, they cease to exist from that point onwards. If we take the case of our teacher, Buddha Śākyamūni, when Buddha Śākyamūni sat under the Bodhi tree and, as we say, reached full enlightenment, he became an arhat. And from that point onwards, experienced a nirvana with remainder.
The remainder referred to was his body, which was the product of contaminated karma from previous lives and which was present before Buddha Śākyamūni entered into the session of meditation, which led to full enlightenment. Indeed, according to the Vaibhāṣikas, once a practitioner has reached the level of preparation, the level of warmth, excuse me, of the path of preparation, from that point onwards, he enters into one continuous session of meditation, which leads him to the final liberation of his corresponding vehicle. Upon attaining the final liberation of his corresponding vehicle, the practitioner is left with the body whose karma caused its existence before attaining the level of warmth of the path of preparation. Therefore, Buddha Śākyamūni, upon his death, upon his relinquishing his aggregates, would have entered in one of the three final vehicles taught by the Vaibhāṣikas. The final vehicle of a hearer, of a Pratyeka Buddha, or of a Bodhisattva.
The Vaibhāṣikas do not recognize the existence of the Mahāyāna and do not do not use the term. Therefore, they refer to the final vehicle of a bodhisattva. Now this notion of final vehicle is a difficult one for us to understand, but it is quite present in the teachings. Vaibhāṣikas accept the existence of only one supreme emanation body for our age, Buddha Śākyamūni. And they consider that when Buddha Śākyamūni entered in Parinirvana upon relinquishing his aggregates at death, he ceased to exist.
In other words, his continuum was interrupted. They do not accept the existence of which are accepted by the higher schools of tenets starting by the Cittamātra school. For these higher schools of tenets, there are bodies of enjoyment, the Sambhogakāya, remain until the end of cyclic existence. Clearly, since Buddha Śākyamūni lived only eighty years for the Vaibhāṣikas, he could not have remained until the end of cyclic existence. So the Vaibhāṣikas view is a very commonsensical view come similar to the one nowadays.
Then it is a little bit odd from our standpoint for to put such effort in eradicating the afflictions just to cease to exist. Moreover, the traditional lines of reasoning establishing the existence of future lives on the basis of the existence of a continuum of consciousness are not applicable within the Vaibhāṣika school. If one were to say, it follows that the subject has future consciousness because of having present consciousness, the pervasion would not be established for the Vaibhāṣika school, and the counterexample one could provide is that of an Arhat who has a remainderless nirvana. The continuum of the Arhat is severed. So why precisely do the Vaibhāṣikas assert the severance of the continuum upon attainment of a remainderless nirvana?
This is something we must examine. The Vaibhāṣikas clearly do not accept the existence of pure lands as the Mahāyāna traditions do. Then it seems that the Vaibhāṣika understanding of reincarnation is the following: The present body we have, which is the support of our consciousness, is none other than what we know as contaminated aggregates. These contaminated aggregates are of the nature of the truth of suffering. And the cause of the truth of suffering, as Dharmakīrti said in his Pramānavārttika, is ignorance for which the afflictions are cooperative condition.
When one has attained the state of an Arhat, one has severed, eliminated ignorance. Having eliminated ignorance, which is the main cause of contaminated aggregates, it is impossible after this to generate contaminated aggregates again. Therefore, at the time of their remainderless nirvana, one would simply cease to exist. This is something which is a rather difficult point and which we should reflect upon. Buddha Śākyamūni alone abandoned both the afflictive obstructions and the nonafflictive obstructions.
According to the Vaibhāṣika systems, all arhats have indeed abandoned the afflictive obstructions. They have not abandoned the nonafflictive obstructions. However, when they attain a remainderless Nirvāṇa, in other words, when they relinquish their bodies, even though they have not actually abandoned the nonafflictive obstructions, we use the term abandoning the afflictive obstructions because the base of the afflictive obstructions, which is a mental continuum, has ceased to exist. And as the base has ceased to exist, as a result, the nonafflictive obstructions as well have ceased to exist.
So this completes the presentation of the Vaibhāṣika system. At present, if you have questions, please ask them. But it does lead to another question, which is a following. Given the fact that contaminated aggregates which make our body consist of of carbon, although I’m under the impression that they are because they are existent, truly existent, No, you cannot say in the Vaibhāṣika system that our form aggregate is the result of karma.
Because our form aggregate is actually the result of physical processes such as eating, drinking and so forth which leads us, for instance, to increase in height and weight and so forth. It is our general contaminating aggregates, the set of all the aggregates which are indeed the product of karma. But these are not formed as a totality, these are non associated compositional phenomena. It’s really very strange when one thinks of the fact that the Vaibhāṣikas put such effort to obtain a state of liberation, one of the three final liberations, which is a cessation of their continuum of their existence. They consider the body, which is an effect of maturation, to have ultimately arisen from ignorance.
So once one severs the root cause ignorance, and incrementally, all the consequences disappear. No. They believe you disappear. You you are annihilated. You cease to exist.
Then the same position is found in the Cittamātra school for the Śrāvaka and Pratyekabuddha. In other words, some of the Cittamātra sub schools teach a cessation of the continuum for Śrāvaka and Pratyekabuddha. There are considerable difficulties within this view of the cessation of the continuum. For instance, it is possible for someone who is definitely of the hearer or solitary realizer lineage, upon attaining a Nirvāṇa with remainder to reflect on the benefits of compassion and bodhicitta and then to engage in the bodhisattva path. The term Mahāyāna is not used.
It’s a Bodhisattvayāna for the three vehicles. Chris had a question, I think. So where do they stand in the view of rebirth and reincarnation? Definitely they accept past and future lives, but they accept past and future lives impelled by ignorance. In our case, for instance, we have past lives due to ignorance.
Likewise, the arhats have past lives, but they have no future lives. So therefore for them the Buddha doesn’t exist. So they don’t pray to the Buddha. I am assuming then that they are making offerings to the historic Buddha in their mind as well as the Dharma but not to an existent Buddha. Would that be correct?
The refuge of the Vaibhāṣikas is rooted in the notion that if one eliminates the obstructions from one’s own mind and one practices, one will become like the Buddha. And this is one of the reasons for which there are different schools of tenets higher and lower. And when one realizes the unsatisfactory nature of a lower school of tenets, one can move towards a higher school of tenets. But first one must understand the lower school of tenets. So if the continuum is severed, where does the welfare of beings of the final three vehicles?
I don’t think I quite understand that. Where does that fit in? Mental continuum of bodhisattvas is not severed at the beginning. It is when the bodhisattvas, say, become arhats, that the impelling capacity of lives has ceased. So at the end of that life, they will stop to exist.
Their continuum will be severed. So, Molly had some questions. I would summarize them. The first is, the Vaibhāṣikas do not accept the existence of a Sambhogakāya, but do they accept the existence of a Nirmāṇakāya? They do accept the existence of a Supreme Nirmāṇakāya.
The says indeed, the Vaibhāṣika do not accept the existence of a Sambhogakāya. And a Nirmāṇakāya, which, for instance, would be reborn in a pure land is not accepted either. The only Nirmāṇakāya which is accepted is a supreme Nirmāṇakāya, which would be Buddha Śākyamūni. I think I should have answered your second question. So when we speak of the severance of the continuum, it is important to understand that this does not happen to ordinary beings like us.
Our continuum continues to be propelled by afflictions. But when one has attained the state of an Arhat, for instance, a Śrāvaka or a Pratyekabuddha Arhat, then one has abandoned ignorance. And at the end of that life, one’s continuum will be destroyed, will be severed. So just to clarify, therefore, there are no present existing Buddhas from that point of view because they have all ceased to exist. Yes.
They don’t exist. Then from the standpoint of the three times, you could say, in the present time, there is no Buddha for the Vaibhāṣika system. Natalie? Just a question from last week, I managed to catch up from the I didn’t come last week but I caught up with Judy and I just wanted to clarify about talking about the seed and the karmic imprint and that they can be the same as each other but the seed and that they were non associated compositional factors. I can understand that the seed is made up of mind and matter and so it can be a non associated compositional factor.
But I can’t understand how karmic imprint would be a non associated compositional factor because it seems to me to be only of mind. No. The karmic imprints of self grasping are not consciousness. They are non associated compositional phenomena. If the karmic imprints of self grasping were consciousness, then the consequences would be very strange because then those karmic imprints themselves would grasp a self, and that is not the case.
So I’m I’m probably confusing consciousness with mental factors, I think.
No. There’s no relation. Both mind and mental factors have components linked to self grasping. The karmic imprints which give rise to self grasping, or we see the karmic imprint of self grasping, are not consciousness. So we speak of the karmic imprints of self grasping before self grasping has arisen.
And as mentioned last time, the difference between the seeds of, let’s say, a karmic phenomenon and the karmic imprints of self grasping is that the seeds can give rise to something the karmic imprints cannot by themselves. I wanted to clarify things in my mind, and please cut me off when I get too long winded. Regarding wording that we’re using regarding effective, the word effective entity. So a thing is that which is able to perform a function, and in the description of impermanence or permanence, one effective entity produces another continually. I understand the term effective entity to mean something like this table has the effect of obstruction in that you can put stuff on top of it, or that water has the effect of quenching one’s thirst.
Then I was wondering if you could translate that. Maybe complete your question because I have to understand what you’re going towards. So there’s the effect of obstruction, obviously, or the effect of water quenching the thirst. That might be something like the physical processes that Geshe was talking about in response to Ralph’s question. But it seems to me that the actual, say in the instance of water, the water causes my thirst to be quenched but the substantial cause of the quenching of my thirst would be something more like generosity.
In the example you gave of someone who drinks water, neither the drinking of water nor the generosity of the giver is a substantial cause of one’s thirst being slaked. One’s thirst being slaked is the result of numerous cooperative conditions: drinking water, being given water, the generosity of the giver, and so forth. But none of these is a substantial cause of one’s thirst being slaked. Thank you. Is Geshe-la able to clarify a little bit about the definition that Vaibhāṣikas have of why the body suffers?
And the reason I ask is because obviously, how can a bodhisattva perform the welfare of beings if they cease to exist? One can understand bodhisattva performing the welfare of being before he is relinquishing his body in the Vaibhāṣika system. He or she would engage in great effort for the sake of others, and in this process, will perform the welfare of beings. Then we can understand this if we look at our present situation. Buddha Śākyamūni no longer exists according to the Vaibhāṣika school, but through his kindness we at present have access to, for instance, the perfection of wisdom sutras in a 100,000 verses, 25,000, 8,000 and so forth.
This remains of the Buddha’s deeds. Mhmm. So let’s ask another thing on that end. I thought the Vaibhāṣikas were only concerned with their own liberation. That was one of my questions.
So why would they strive to be a bodhisattva who’s trying to save other people? I thought they were just after their own liberation from cyclic existence No, that’s not the case. The bodhisattva path exists in the Vaibhāṣika school, and they accept the existence of enlightenment as well as a result of the bodhisattva path. So we will stop here and now start the debate. I would Geshe la, I would like you to debate on the three final vehicles, the final vehicle of the Pratyeka Buddha, and Bodhisattva.
Why the Vaibhāṣikas assert three vehicles in the Vaibhāṣikas school. Why the Vaibhāṣikas assert a severance of the continuum for at the end of this life, not for us, but for. Why is this the case? What is the rationale? Then you pair up by twos.
Different pairs from last time, please. Just to remind you, you’ve seen the, the magazine is now available. And, not this Saturday, but the following Saturday, Geshe la will be giving a public talk here at 03:00, three to four, developing happiness within. The flyers will be here tomorrow that starts spreading the word. And then there’s also a fire regarding the October Saturday and Sunday of long weekend in praise of dependent arising.
Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- Bodhisattvayana
- The Bodhisattva's Vehicle, another name for Paramitayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
- The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- sambhogakaya enjoyment body; long ku (Tib)
- The enjoyment body; the form in which the enlightened mind appears in order to benefit highly realized bodhisattvas. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.