2 h 53 min · 23,105 words · 23 August 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 173-minute teaching, Ilya Djerovich—a scholar-practitioner and former Sera Je monk—gives detailed instruction on calm abiding (śamatha), the foundational concentration practice of Buddhist meditation. He covers the six preliminary conditions for practice; the eight-point meditation posture; how to select a meditation object matched to your dominant affliction; and two complementary frameworks for tracking progress: Maitreya’s five thoughts and eight antidotes, and Asaṇga’s nine mental abidings. A central warning: many Tibetan practitioners have mistaken subtle sinking—a progressive dulling of mental vividness—for genuine deep meditation, resulting in sharp memory loss and mental decline. He directly addresses Western lay practitioners with families and jobs, showing how even modest daily concentration amplifies Lamrim study. Throughout, he stresses the absolute necessity of a single qualified teacher and unbroken lineage, grounding technical instruction in vivid personal accounts from his teacher Geshe Rabten and forty years of dedicated practice.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-08-23 – KR.mp3
UUID: ff2a89fc-cece-47c2-90c3-30fe6953b2fb
Teacher: Ilia Durovic
Collection: Meditation
Date: 2014-08-23
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~23,109
Good afternoon everybody. It’s lovely to see you here and welcome to the conference with our esteemed translator Ilya Djerovich on a very important topic for us all who are looking to find a way out of suffering, calm abiding and the contemplations. I think we all know Ilya, so I won’t take up time to introduce Ilya. But other than to say how privileged we are to have Ilya’s bifocal view on the Dharma, having been a former monk at Sera Je Monastery and having completed the studies equivalent to that of a fully qualified Rabjampa. Also well versed in Western thought.
So bringing this bifocal view, we are very fortunate to benefit from Ilya’s wisdom this afternoon. There will be a short break halfway through and I think we all know where the facilities are. So without any further ado, I would like to hand over to Ilya. Thank you very much. It’s a pleasure to see so many familiar faces, and I would like to thank Chris and Aaron for the hard work they provide in making sure that, these conferences at TBI and activities at TBI in general, proceed very smoothly.
Then this is the second time, actually the third time I have presented calm abiding as a topic in the last two years, once in the context of the twenty thirteen symposium, once last year in the context of the three trainings, and this year in the context of the culmination of Lamrim, since basically calm abiding is the topic which ushers, Je Tsongkhapa’s section on insight in Lamrim Chenmo. And in the conferences over the last three years, I have endeavored to follow Lamrim Chenmo to take the key topics of Lamrim Chenmo and present them in a way, which is accessible to a modern Western audience, and, examine them, in the light of, our modern knowledge. As you remember, Je Tsongkhapa himself said in the essence of eloquence, one who accepts tenets which are at odds with reasoning is not suitable to be a being who is a valid cognizer. In other words, the very foundation of the Buddhist teachings is that the Buddhist philosophical positions must be compatible with experience and with logic. Then logic has not changed since the fourteenth century in which Je Tsongkhapa lived.
Experience has changed considerably, so it’s necessary to confront the Buddhist teachings with modernity, specifically with scientific data, and see very simply whether they are true or not. Then what is not true, we can discard. What is true, we should keep on. And this is something, I think some of the more traditional Western students, often the newer students as well, are very uncomfortable with, because it involves a strong critical stance. It’s necessary because the only true foundation for any type of solid spiritual practice is precisely this conviction in the truth of what one is practicing.
Otherwise, it has no impact on the mind. And, within the context of Buddhist teachings, obviously, the very essence, if you wish, is that one wishes to transform the mind in keeping with reality as one understands it. So first one assesses reality using using reasoning. This is what is called wisdom. One studies reality to see whether reality has this feature or that feature, one finds that for instance, let us say phenomena are impermanent, but we perceive them as permanent.
Phenomena seem to have a self from their own side, but actually if we analyze them they don’t. And then from the Buddhist standpoint, the root of our suffering is precisely this discrepancy between the way things are and the way we misperceive them. So after after having determined how they are through logic, and this is logic which must be compatible with modern science and physics, so this is something I talked about during the, symposium a couple days ago, then once we have determined how they are, we must change the way we look at them, we must change the way we perceive them, and this process of transformation of the mind is done through what is known as meditation. Now the English term meditation is rather unfortunate, has a very heavy connotation in English and actually in most Western cultures, which it doesn’t have in Tibetan. The Tibetan term for meditation is gom, and gom is related to the verb kompa, which simply means to be accustomed to, to be habituated to.
Meditation is simply the repeated habituation of the mind, But not repeated habituation with anything, repeated habituation with the way things are. So this is the twin play or dialectic, if you wish, of wisdom in meditation. Wisdom determines the way things are and then one meditates on wisdom to transform one’s mind and see things as they are. Therefore, for training in wisdom, study is indispensable, not just study of the Buddhist classics, but study of the modern understanding of phenomena. This means some understanding of biology or physics and perhaps to a lesser degree of chemistry, as well as an understanding of the Buddhist texts.
And then meditation is merely concentration. Now concentration is something which transcends the boundaries of the religious traditions. All of the great religious traditions have endeavored to train their practitioners in concentration. In the monotheistic traditions, this contemplation, contemplatio, it was as it was called in Latin, was a contemplation of God, where the mind was focused single pointedly on God as an object. And I will, indicate to you at the end of this conference, in my opinion, the so called mystical experiences in Christianity, Judaism, and Islam, but in Hinduism as well, are simply nothing else but the results of concentration.
And we will see during this conference that when concentration reaches a certain level, which we call calm abiding, there are very particular experiences of bliss, of single pointedness and so forth which arise. So we are very fortunate, I would say, in the Buddhist tradition that really of all the religious traditions which relied on concentration, none has gone so far in analyzing the phenomenon of concentration, formalizing the training, as the Buddhist traditions, and this applies to all Buddhist traditions, Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna. There are however pitfalls, and in the case of calm abiding there are major pitfalls which are dangerous, and which can cause a very sharp decay of mental capacities. A large number of Tibetan practitioners between basically the ninth and the fourteenth century practiced calm abiding in a mistaken fashion. Confusing what we will call later on today, subtle sinking with good meditation.
And I have seen Westerners who have mispracticed calm abiding, and have seen myself the results. It’s very clear if you know, you know, what the signs of poor practice of calm abiding are, you can easily recognize them. If calm abiding is practiced wrongly, in other words, if instead of training in calm abiding, one ends up by enjoying subtle sinking, a very rapid result is a sharp decline in memory. Normally if one practices calm abiding correctly, memory should increase in potency. Someone who has calm abiding has something close to the dharani of memory.
In other words, someone who actually has attained calm abiding has basically total memory, total recall. What you could call eidetic memory, you look at something and you remember it, it’s a sign of calm abiding. A powerful memory is a clear sign of someone who is very developed in concentration. When the memory starts declining as a result of meditation, the person becomes absent minded and woolly, this is a very clear sign of wrong practice. If this continues, the person ends up in a state of complete confusion.
And this is a reason for which it is critical to practice calm abiding in keeping with correct instructions, and in this respect, the Gelug tradition is particularly fortunate because Je Tsongkhapa reformed the practices of calm abiding and the understanding of emptiness in Tibet, relying on the great Indian treatises and on his own experience. So this path of practice of calm abiding is one which presents no risk. Otherwise, the risks are considerable. Now, I mentioned this in the past, but I always, I’m afraid that, our listeners feel that perhaps we are biased by the tradition we belong to. So I asked my wife Mandy to sit in today, and, I thought I would ask her, some questions about how the practice of calm abiding is seen in Thailand today.
So Mandy, in ordinary Thai society, what do people think of the practice of śamatha or calm abiding? And this is something I have heard repeatedly from Theravāda practitioners. So it’s a clear case where it seems that in Thailand the lineage of transmission, of correct practice, of śamatha is lost. And then obviously, when one trains in śamatha, as we will see, it is important not only to train correctly, but to select a correct object of observation. Now the Thai tradition presently at least, in the past I cannot say, but presently thank you Mandy by the way, thank you very much.
Presently in the Thai tradition, the focus of people who train in calm abiding seems to be the attainment of what they call paranormal powers. Then as a result, they focus on symbols of the elements, which are called, which are of the color of the corresponding element, yellow for earth, red for fire, and so forth. This leads to a mastery of the bodily elements, but unfortunately, when you focus on an element, it can lead to a destabilization of the ratio of the four elements in the body, and this can lead to major physical problems as well, heart problems for instance, if one focuses on the fire element. That is to say that I would heartily encourage you, if you choose to train in the Buddhist path, to train under the guidance of a fully qualified and competent teacher, and to stick to one tradition. You have complete freedom and choice in the matter, but, certainly in the case of, this tradition, there is a strong complementarity between studies and meditation, which has been the hallmark of the guru tradition really from day one.
And this perhaps a great strength of this tradition. Then I should point out that these problems in the mistaken practice of calm abiding are the reason for which when I was asked here by, I think it’s someone from Chris’s institution, Queen Elizabeth Hospital, how beneficial calm abiding could be for the treatment of mental problems, I said to him, I think he was an assistant in mental care, a nurse, a main nurse, director of palliative care. I said to him that basically calm abiding was never designed to treat psychiatric problems. Meditation is not there to treat psychiatric or psychological problems. It is there to lead to the transformation of the mind in the light of wisdom.
If one has psychiatric or psychological problems, from depression up through schizophrenia and paranoia, then we should go to a psychiatrist or a psychologist. We are not equipped to handle these problems. In the case of calm abiding, someone with mental problems who trains in calm abiding may face a great increase in the mental problems because of calm abiding, which is why I systematically have discouraged this. And all my teachers, before training someone in calm abiding, ensure that the person is very rooted psychologically and physically, one needs to be physically strong for these practices. The same thing is true for mindfulness of breathing.
There’s been a tremendous interest in anapanasati or satipatthana, mindfulness, as a means of treating mental problems. Now it is somewhat unfortunate. It smacks, in my opinion, of a rather classic Western pattern of recuperation of elements of the Eastern spiritual traditions. Again, mindfulness was never designed to treat depression or anxiety or mental problems. Mindfulness is the means to train in wisdom in the Theravāda tradition, is designed to enable one to gain realization of the three marks.
Specifically to gain realization of impermanence and of the lack of self. Then one needs to be psychologically sound to practice mindfulness. It is true that when someone is anxious or depressed and they practice mindfulness at the beginning, there may be some benefit. But as I said to a good friend who is a psychiatrist and who talked about this topic several times at TBI, these practices of meditation were not designed for this, and I I I warned him about this and suggested that those who participated in the program he had created should seek training from a well trained Theravadin monk before trying on their own to practice mindfulness and teach it to others. Then the last time we met, he told me that one of his close colleagues, a psychiatrist, who was instructing others in mindfulness, experienced a strong dissociative episode as a result of her mindfulness practice, and she needed psychiatric help.
So I give this to you as a preview because I know the motivation of the people who attend our center are very mixed, and, this is something I have said I’ve been saying for more than thirty years. When I started out at Tashi Jong, I had a little notebook with the names of psychologists and psychiatrists to which I would refer people. We are not equipped to handle mental problems, we are not trained, and if people have mental difficulties, those have to be addressed separately. Then meditation starts when the mind is more or less stable, and the goal of meditation, as has been emphasized repeatedly by all our teachers, is not this life. It starts with the next life.
So what exactly is calm abiding? Calm abiding is practiced within two contexts, within sūtra and within tantra. The practice is exactly the same, and the object of observation is different. In sūtra, the practices of calm abiding are part of the method lineage, which is transmitted down from Maitreya via Asaṇga and so forth. So this is a fresco of Maitreya Bodhisattva in the complex of temples of Ajanta.
As you can see, Maitreya is represented as a southern Indian, black of skin. And according to the sūtra, which I would heartily recommend you to read, you have a bibliography which lists it there, the Samdhinirmochana sūtra, every single attainment whether worldly or supra supra mundane is due to calm abiding. So calm abiding is, if you wish, the minimum and sufficient use level of concentration. This is why, although there are higher levels of concentration, which are called the dhyanas or the contemplations, in the Buddhist tradition, we are satisfied with calm abiding. Once one has attained calm abiding, one has sufficient concentration to be able to meditate on emptiness and eventually to attain full enlightenment.
The higher concentrations would be nice, but they are unnecessary. The jnanas are completely unnecessary from a Buddhist standpoint. Now the cultivation of the dhyanas is the great specialty of Hinduism. So Buddha Śākyamūni’s root teachers, Udraka Ramaputra for instance, was a great specialist of the dhyanas. It is said that he attained the four dhyanas.
Buddha Śākyamūni himself attained the four Dhyanas. So Buddha Śākyamūni progressed far beyond calm abiding, but in his teachings, he made it very clear that calm abiding was simply was sufficient. And calm abiding is the root of our mundane and super mundane virtuous qualities because it enables one to transform one’s mind for mundane purposes. It is said that a direct result of calm abiding is a paranormal powers, clairaudience, clairvoyance, telepathy and so forth. So in the case of telepathy, had direct experience of this with my teachers in the monasteries, and calm abiding is also sufficient concentration for all of the higher Dharma attainments.
And in the Samadhiraja sūtra, Buddha Śākyamūni distinguishes between calm abiding and insight. Calm abiding is mere concentration. Insight is an analytical operation, generally based on calm abiding, and we will talk later of the difference between calm abiding and insight as formulated by Je Tsongkhapa. It’s beautifully done, beautifully done. So the key point, excuse me, of calm abiding is that calm abiding is non discursive as opposed to insight.
Non discursive means that there is no analytical activity occurring during calm abiding. When one trains a calm abiding, one is focusing on an image. That image is not analyzed, it is merely focused upon. Insight involves analysis. It can be analysis of the features of the image, it can be analysis of emptiness, it can be analysis of impermanence.
Analytical meditation would belong to insight, calm abiding would belong to concentrative meditation. And therefore, Je Tsongkhapa points out that calm abiding is a common core in India certainly of Buddhist and non-Buddhist traditions. Now in the monotheistic religions, Christianity, Judaism, and Islam, there are no formal instructions on calm abiding or concentration. It may have occurred as a byproduct of contemplation. In my opinion, as I mentioned earlier, the experiences of the mystics have strong features which are correlated to calm abiding.
And therefore, in theory, it would be perfectly appropriate to start study calm abiding with a Hindu yogi. Calm abiding in and of itself is not a religious practice, it’s merely the training and concentration, and I would suspect that top academics would have exceptional capacities for training in calm abiding. Someone who has spent his or her whole life studying and focusing would have natural predispositions. A clear sign of someone who has great potencies for calm abiding is a powerful memory. The more powerful memory the memory, the more powerful the capacity to train calm abiding.
The weaker the memory, the weaker the capacity. Now in the Buddhist tradition, there are several sources for calm abiding, literary or textual sources. The root source is the Samdhinirmochana sūtra, which is translated by John Powers. It’s reasonably well translated. I would encourage you to read it, it’s not difficult to read.
It’s in your bibliography published by Dharma Publications. Then the other main source is Maitreya’s Mahayānasūtrālamkara, the ornament of the Mahāyāna Sutras, which is translated by one of the students of Robert Thurman. It should be in your bibliography as well. And then we have two other treaties. These are minor treaties of Maitreya, the middle between the extremes, Madhyāntavibhāga, and the Śrāvakabhūmi of Asaṇga.
These four treatises were drawn upon by Kamalaśīla when he went to Tibet to compose his stages of meditation, we were very lucky to have Geshe Yama Rinchen teach them here. The stages of meditation, the Bhāvanākrama, is if you wish wish the very foundation on which much of our practice should be built. Then I was somewhat saddened to be honest with you when Geshe Yama Rinchen came, that so few of our students attended his teachings. Sadly, because we never said that to you, it would have been inappropriate, but in addition to the fact that Geshe Yama Rinchen is the foremost living scholar of Sera Je monastery, Geshe Yama Rinchen’s, closest friend is a lifelong meditator in Bhutan, and actually attained calm abiding. So Geshe Yama Rinchen asked him some very detailed questions, but what the actual experience of calm abiding is.
It’s very rare to be able to receive teachings from someone who actually has met somebody who has calm abiding. Calm abiding is not easily obtained. A merit teacher had attained calm abiding, Geshe Rabten, and taught it to others. And Geshe Yama Rinchen’s closest friend, a very famous Geshe, had attained calm abiding, and he based his presentation of calm abiding on that. So those of you who didn’t attend, you missed a lot.
Now what are the preliminaries for the attainment of calm abiding? Calm abiding actually is both very easy and very difficult. It’s very easy because if you do it by the book, all of the things being equal, you will get it. It’s very difficult because it’s not possible to skip steps. So I I don’t know of a single westerner who ever attained calm abiding.
A friend of mine, George Dreyfus, Geshe George Dreyfus, and Alan Wallace were both students of Geshe Rabten in Dharamsala, and both wanted to attain calm abiding. Then obviously, Geshe Rabten was famous for that attainment. His students asked him to teach calm abiding to the Geshes in retreat. So they asked him permission, and then they went in a retreat in Dharmasala with, you know, the instructions, etcetera. And it said if you have the instructions, you get it after six months.
And after six months, they were nowhere close to calm abiding. Then some of you may know that Alan Wallace has almost makes a living now of teaching calm abiding, right? I think he never attained it. Wallace and Dreyfus came back to see Geshe Rabten, and they they were quite despondent, and they said, you know, we’ve just been doing this and we never never got anywhere. And, Geshe Rabten just burst into laughter, and he said, well, I knew you wouldn’t get anywhere, but you weren’t in the mood to listen to anything.
So I thought, just go. Mean, what am I supposed to say? Now, why wouldn’t they be why wouldn’t they gain attainments? Simply because the preliminaries aren’t there. The most important element for obtaining calm abiding is the preliminaries.
If you get the preliminaries and you get correct instructions, and you forget your own ideas about how things should be done and do it by the book, it happens. It may not happen in six months, but it does happen. If you don’t have the preliminaries or you are an artistic meditator, who basically fiddles here and fiddles there and changes this and changes that, it will not happen. So what are these preliminaries? They are trite, but they’re very important and you’ll see why.
There are six core preliminaries. Some are more relevant to the to us than others. You must have easily obtained food and clothing, this means somebody must take care of your livelihood for you. You cannot work or study while you’re training in calm abiding. Somebody must cook your meals for you, and somebody must take care of your laundry and your food.
And you must be living in a sound area, which in the West is quite straightforward. Have worthy friends, it is said that you should not, at least if you’re a beginner, you should not be completely alone, because it is easy for mental problems to arise, but you should not have a lot of friends either. One or two friends who are also in retreat is sufficient, and there should be, and this is difficult in a few people by day and little noise by night. Little noise by night here is very difficult. Now noise is described as the soul on the side of the meditator.
You will never get anywhere with your meditation practice if there is any noise around you. You must live in an isolated area with no noise. If you are aiming for some type of realization and meditation practice, if you just want a little bit of basic daily meditation, it’s a different situation. Having few desires generally implies that you have some type of vows. This can be ideally these would be monastic vows, but at the very least you do need lay vows.
And we’ll talk in a minute or so for of the importance for this. You must have contentment, in other words, you must be satisfied with whatever you have. Your retreat hut may be somewhat grotty and the food may not be very nice, but, it’s not a culinary experience. I was going to go on a retreat once in America. I think it was a Vajrapāni Institute.
I had some retreats I had to do and I couldn’t do them in India. And I looked on the website and my goodness this was not a retreat center. The $75 a night, with a brook and the key selling point of the retreat huts was the satin sheets. Then I I thought obviously we are not in the same world. So clearly, if anything less than satin hurts your delicate skin, then perhaps you would have a hard time finding some conditions to practice calm abiding.
I think we still have that, you know. Then giving up being busy means giving up all of your ordinary social contact, telephone calls, emails, you know, SMSs, letters, watching the news, you know, reading anything unrelated to one’s practice. Pure ethics is connected to having few desires, and totally abandoning fancies and desires. Now the reason for which you have two main emphases within the preconditions is as follows. The first emphasis is on ease of living and no interference.
This is pretty evident. You’re trying to draw the mind inwards. Anything which causes you to be busy on the outside is an interference. But most fundamentally, calm abiding entails drawing the mind so heavily inwards that the sense consciousnesses become powerless. When you have engaged in calm abiding, you are unaware of the exterior world.
You do not see, hear, smell, taste, or feel. If someone were to stab you with a long pin, you would not feel a thing. And I mentioned to some of you, I had direct experience of this with Geshe Rabten and it was done to him for medical reasons, and there was the body was dead like a rock. For this to happen, for the mind to be so heavily drawn inwards from the senses, you need preliminary training, and the preliminary training is ethics because Buddhist ethics draws the mind away from the objects of desire. If you’re unable to subdue the coarse wandering of the mind towards, let us say, food or other objects of desire, it will be impossible to practice calm abiding.
There’s no point in even starting. It’s it’s a fantasy to think that you can go through daily life going to nice restaurants, and let’s say if you’re young enough dating around, and at the same time attain calm abiding, it does not happen. The first step to attain calm abiding is an ethics where the mind is drawn inwards. The mind is no longer at the mercy of the senses, and the more the mind is drawn inwards, the closer you will be to calm abiding. So ideally, to train in calm abiding, you should have full monastic ordination, the full set of vows.
If that is not possible, novice ordination. If that is not possible, lay vows. If that is not possible, then you have to try to maintain some type of ethics on your own. Without ethics there will be no attainment of concentration. This is not a moral position as it might be, let’s say in Christianity, it is simply due to the nature of the mind.
The moment you lose control of the mind, that the mind is always out there running after the latest car, latest computer, the latest watch, when you go into meditation to meditate on whatever object of observation you have, you will have so much coarse agitation, let alone banishing coarse agitation, you’ll be unable to banish subtle agitation. There will never be any progress possible. Even if you progress a little bit during the meditative sessions, you lose whatever you had between the sessions. So for this reason, the preconditions for attaining calm abiding are at least as important as the instructions. If you don’t have the preconditions, you will not attain calm abiding.
It will not happen. If you have the preconditions and you have received correct instructions and you put them in practice, you will attain calm abiding. So as I mentioned earlier, it’s both very easy and very difficult. And when one trains and calm abiding, it is important to have a correct posture, which is known as the eight point posture of Vairochana. Seven physical points and one related to the control of breathing.
So the seven physical points are summarized in this verse by the great Geluk, yogi Kelsang Gyatso. Legs, hands, and spine make three. These are the first three points. Brought to four by teeth, lips, and tongue. Teeth, lips, and tongue altogether are one point.
Eyes, head, shoulders, and breath are four. These are the eight practices of Vairochana. And I’ll give you a demonstration of how one should sit. So first we will cover together, then I’ll show quickly here. One’s leg should be in Vajrasanā, which is reverse Padmasana, for those of you who’ve done lotus, but I can’t adopt it anymore, so you’d excuse me, I can still do Padmasana, but Vajrasanā is beyond me.
The goal of this posture is actually exactly the same as in yogi, it’s a bandha. Bandha in Sanskrit means to bind. The etymology is the same as in English. What are you doing? You are locking yourself in position, because when you actually enter in calm abiding or higher concentrations, you will lose the awareness of your body.
If your body is not locked into position it will fall as a rock, you have no control, you know. So the first point is that your legs should be locked in this way, because if your legs are locked in this way, you can either fall forwards or backwards, nor sideways. If you’re in half lotus, you will have to use a meditation belt, Because if you’re in a half lotus, you will always tilt to the side of the leg which is on top. Right? So you can see here, my apologies, If you sit in half half lotus, once you start meditating deeply, you will naturally tilt in this direction.
So you need a meditation belt which is locked in this way, it can be a yoga belt, they’re the best for this, nice thick, you know, fabric, not a string, locked in this way so that you will not tilt over. Then the best posture would obviously be Padmas, would be Vajrasanā, which I cannot adopt. And maybe, despite my old age, I’m still pos still able to sit in Padmasana. It’s a clear case of the spirit is willing but the flesh has other ideas, you know. Maybe not.
I have to listen to one’s flesh from time to time. Then The hands should be in the position of equipoise, four fingers beneath the navel. The position of equipoise means that once two hands I’ll basically show this here, a set like this. The left hand beneath, the right hand on top, both thumbs touching, and depending on the size of your fingers, the thumb thumbs may move down a bit, and it should be somewhat below your navel. Now normally your wrists must rest on your thighs, you hold this up in the air, obviously you’d be unable to concentrate for any duration of time.
Now the most important point in this posture is a straight back. Your back must be as straight as you can make it, and for this you need a firm and elevated cushion. So most meditation cushions are useless in this respect, like our cushions here, our sitting cushions, these are not meditation cushions. So this would be a good meditation cushion, this actually blocks a foam inside, they do not sink under your weight, and if you sit on it, you will see that it’s quite easy for the spine to be erect. When the spine is erect, the head must be bent down slightly, not a lot like the head of a swan.
When shoulders must be level, this is actually very difficult to get right, you’ll find that as tension builds up, typically one of the two shoulders is going to start rising, sometimes both, you know. You want to loosen the shoulders, and your arms should be nicely spaced here. You don’t want your arms to be clamped against your body. Then regarding the mouth, your lips must be slightly open, your teeth in the natural position, which means not quite touching but close, and your tongue should touch your upper palate directly behind your teeth, simply because once you engage in higher levels of concentration, this keeps the mouth humid, and quite frankly you risk to start drooling. So this basically prevents saliva from flowing from the mouth.
Now the eye posture is certainly in the Indian tradition, transmitted by Maitreya in Asaṇga, it entails keeping the eyes half open, focused on a point in front of one’s nose. The historian has always comments that it’s a point much closer to the nose of a westerner than to the nose of a Tibetan. In my case it’s probably the tip of my nose, that’ll do just fine. The goal of keeping the eyes half open is to maintain a modicum of sensory stimuli at the beginning of training in calm abiding. Beginners find that it’s much easier for them to meditate with closed eyes.
It’s also much more problematic the moment you have progressed a bit, because drowsiness will sit in and you will become accustomed to associating drowsiness in meditation. So from the beginning the eyes should be open. Now for myself it is much helper to much easier to meditate with eyes completely open, but not everyone is comfortable with that. I just keep my eyes open and what is in front does not matter. The big advantage is a high level of sensory stimuli at the beginning, and if you want to do it in this way, I would suggest that you sit as in the Zen tradition in front of a monochrome wall, a white wall.
But the easiest is just to adopt the tradition we have from Asaṇga, which is close your eyes slightly and focus on the tip of your nostril. Finally, you should be mindful of your breath, and this means that your breath should neither be too rough nor too subtle. There is an intimate relationship between breath and consciousness, which is developed in much greater depths in tantra. If your breath is rough, you will naturally notice if you breathe swiftly and deeply, you will naturally give rest or agitation. If your breath is too subtle at the beginning, you’re simply going to drift off.
So these are the key points, and they are not negligible. I don’t think I forgot anyone. Marpa, a great yogi, the master of Milarepa, said, there is more meditative experience in my posture, Marpa, than in all of the so called meditation of the yogis of Tibet. And this was said in the eleventh century. In other words, this posture is conducive to realizations.
Now there’s a very profound explanation of each of the key points of this posture in terms of tantra, but it cannot be given here. Specifically, in the Mahāyāna or Paramithyana tradition, this posture favors pliancy. And as we which we will talk about later, the bliss associated with meditation. And this posture prevents any harm from happening to the body, you know, while you meditate. Now most of our students are probably unable to sit cross legged.
You can gain calm abiding seat seated in a chair. It’s not connected how you sit. But if you want to meditate in a chair, you need a chair with armrests, so you don’t fall to the side, and somehow you have to brace yourself in the chair. I would say probably just take a meditation belt and brace yourself in the chair, so you don’t fall off the chair. A chair like this would not be appropriate.
You need a big armchair, and, you don’t want a comfortable one. So you want if you’re gonna do it in a chair, a chair which is hard, and the back should be elevated so that your own back is straight, and you sit with legs out like this in a cross-legged position, but you must actually block your body, lock yourself in the chair with the equivalent of a meditation belt. And then you apply all of the other features. In other words, your eyes are half open, focused single pointedly on a point, the object of meditation in front of yourself, your back is straight, but slightly straight, but your neck is slightly bent, your shoulders are level because you can carry a lot of tension in your shoulders, your arms are resting on your thighs, and your right hand is resting in your left hand with two two thumbs meeting beneath the navel. And I’m quite convinced you could attain calm abiding in this way.
Now on the basis of which consciousness is calm abiding attained. So those of you who study logic, you know that there are six or five sense consciousnesses and one mental consciousness. Which of these gives rise to calm abiding? This has been an ongoing debate in Tibet, it’s a debate in other countries in Asia in which calm abiding is practiced. So you can see how interesting this is because Je Tsongkhapa says in the middling Lamrim, some after having stared with their eyes at a representation set out in front of themselves, this is a statue of the Buddha, immediately engaged in meditation.
And this was refuted from the ninth century onwards by Yeshe De, whom Je Tsongkhapa relies very heavily upon. Concentration is not established within sense consciousnesses, but within the mental consciousness. Now the informal practice of calm abiding in Thailand, which involves focusing on a flame, is an attempt to train calm abiding using the visual consciousness. So my wife’s grandmother trained in this way, which is a very powerful concentration, but I do not think it is possible to attain calm abiding, based on a sense consciousness for a very simple reason. Calm abiding by definition entails the withdrawal of the mind inwards.
This can only be done with mental consciousness. If you focus on an image, let’s say a flame, or let’s say a sound, yes, you can enhance your concentration greatly. But you will never gain calm abiding because the mind is focused outwards. And we will talk about the criteria of calm abiding, the main of which is this experience of what is known as pliancy, which is the ecstasy associated with concentration. And therefore, within the various consciousnesses we have, it is considered that calm abiding can only be attained on the basis of a mental consciousness.
And within mental consciousnesses, calm abiding is a conceptual consciousness. One here is I think among westerners who are tired of studies, a lot of criticism of conceptuality. It’s quite common in Buddhist centers. Calm abiding is a conceptual experience, there’s nothing non conceptual about calm abiding. You have an image in front of you, which is kept in front of you through the power of memory.
One of the best books on calm abiding is the book by Geshe Gedun Lodroe. I think we have it in the library. It was a marvelous Geshe from Gomang monastery, who died very young, but was another great one of the greatest scholars of Gomang monastery. And he points out precisely what we talked about earlier, that the uncommon feature of calm abiding is precisely that it is withdrawn inwards, and this that this mind is serviceable. In other words, you can use it for whatever you want to use it for, to meditate on impermanence, on a statue of the Buddha, or on emptiness.
It is at your disposal. Sense consciousnesses are turned outwards, and sense consciousnesses are not serviceable. If I look at this chair, I have no choice about this chair’s appearing to my eye consciousness. It imposes itself on me. Certainly the red color does.
So you can see that calm abiding entails the increase of the mental consciousness, and this increase in the power of the mental consciousness occurs at the expense of sense consciousnesses. When you have attained calm abiding, you will be oblivious to everything. It is said that once a yogi enters in calm abiding, he only leaves calm abiding because he has decided before entering in calm abiding when he would leave. There is no exterior means to bring him out of calm abiding. You can’t shake him or pinch him or burn him, and bring him out of calm abiding has no impact.
The yogi must have decided beforehand, I will come out of calm abiding in ten minutes, twenty minutes, or when I have finished this contemplation. And during calm abiding, the yogi is unaware of this decision. The yogi is single pointedly focused on the object of meditation. This is all that appears, nothing else appears. There are no other thoughts.
So I mentioned among many of you were not there, I’ll bring this one up again. When my teacher Geshe Rabten got cancer, my father was the cancerologist who was asked to treat him, and we had some tests to do, so we went we thought there would be metastasis, so there might be metastasis of the cancer from the liver to the spine, and we had to check therefore the electrical activity of the spine, the responsiveness of the spine, and in those days, I don’t know nowadays, but in those days within a very primitive fashion, electrodes were inserted in the spine, you’d basically pass electrical currents between these electrodes and you’d study the nervous responses on an oscilloscope. This was done by a neurologist. It was done under general anesthesia, general partial anesthesia. When he went to see this neurologist, a Swiss neurologist, he wanted to put Geshe Rabten under anesthesia, and Geshe Rabten refused.
And the relation was quite difficult with this neurologist who seemed to view us as as, religious illuminati. Then Geshe Rabten refused anything which would cause a drop in mindfulness, and the doctor said that he could only then perform the tests if we signed a waiver, which Geshe Rabten did. Then Geshe Rabten entered into calm abiding and his body became like a rock, and I was there, was his translator. As far as I could detect, there was no breathing whatsoever. The doctor became extremely worried.
He wanted to stop immediately. And I said to him, this is, you know, this former meditation instructor of His Holiness. He was an advanced meditator, you just do what you have to do, you know. He did the tests, he was very distressed by the fact that there was no physical response of Geshe Rabten to the test, the neurons functioned fine, but he told me that he expected the Geshe Rabten to go spastic when the currents were passed in the spine, none of this happened. And then when Geshe Rabten left the state of calm abiding, the attitude of this neurologist had changed completely, and he asked me point blank, he said, is this man?
He said, what I have seen is medically impossible. This was in 1987, Late nineteen eighty six, early nineteen late nineteen nineteen eighty seven. This is a calm abiding practitioner who has obtained calm abiding and who is able to basically turn his sensory consciousnesses off, just as you were to turn the power off in a building. Now, once one has adopted the posture, what does one focus the mind upon? There are limitless objects of calm abiding.
It’s entirely up to you which one you take. You could train your calm abiding on a laser pointer, just as you could train as Saint Jerome seems to have done on the skull. The object is entirely up to you. Certainly, the shamans in Tibet and in India train using the horns of buffalo or goats. The object of observation is entirely up to oneself.
It’s an object on which one trains in concentration. When I was a young teenager, I did not have the privilege of receiving instructions of calm abiding. We didn’t have the Internet in those days, I had no Buddhist books. So for some reason, I was very interested in this, and I wanted to train my powers of concentration. Then I did this in a very painful and complicated way.
I had a silver ring with a piece of iron ore, of pyrite, I had bought in Paris, and I set it on the stand, and I observed it under all the angles, and then when I had observed it carefully, I would visualize it in space in front of me, but then, because I cannot receive instructions, I thought I must have complete control of the object of observation, therefore I will wait it to rotate slowly in space in front of me, and I must see all the features as it rotates. And this was extremely difficult. It’s very difficult. I had to visualize a ring of pyrite, and as you know, pyrite is quite jagged, and to visualize it rotating, it’s completely unnecessary for the development of concentration. So it’s a big plus to have these instructions.
It makes life much simpler. Now as we said in principle, can use any object you want. But calm abiding is not a religious practice. It’s purely developing concentration. Therefore you want that time spent concentrating on an object to be of some benefit.
We should therefore use an object of observation which is beneficial to oneself. There are several ways to go about this, and one of the key points in choosing the object of observation is self knowledge. So I don’t know if you have noticed when you start meditating, as you start meditating, especially if you start entering into a pretty good concentration, typically some very powerful emotions will arise. And for some people it might be strong anger. The slightest noise provokes anger.
For some people it might be desire. The slightest noise provokes desire. For some people it might just be mental dullness. This is due to one’s mind habit mind’s habituation with this affliction. When we start training and concentration, the mind is withdrawn inwards.
Whatever affliction is dominant within our constitution will then arise very easily to the front. And then one should choose an object of meditation which counters this affliction. So for this, you have to do a bit of experiments experimentation by yourself to see whether you are someone who has a dominant affliction, one of the five main afflictions, or you’re one of the lucky or unfortunate ones in which everything is basically equally present. Maybe some of you have nothing at all, in which case I’m delighted to hear that. So if you are, and most people have a dominant affliction, you have to identify that dominant affliction.
Are you more of the angry temperament? You’re someone who’s pushy. Are you more of the desirous temperament? Someone who’s always trying to get something. Are you somewhat arrogant?
You have to find what the dominant affliction is, and since this dominant affliction is going to come up to the surface when you start meditating, a very skillful means of training the mind is to choose from the beginning as object of meditation, not just any object, but why don’t you counter your dominant affliction. So what this means is that if you have identified desire as your dominant affliction, you will meditate on the foulness of the human body from the beginning. You take as your object of meditation, it might be a skull, it might be a bloody hand, whatever. If it is anger, from the beginning, your object of meditation will be love. If it’s ignorance, it’ll be a complex topic like the 12 links.
Pride, another complex topics like the 18 constituents, which basically brings pride down, because you are visualizing the actual functioning of the six consciousnesses, the six organs, and the six objects, then it gets quite dizzying. And finally, discursiveness, you would focus on the inhalation and exhalation of breath, what Westerners sometimes call mindfulness meditation. And I think because most Westerners tend to be extremely discursive, it’s part of our culture. We are very top heavy, overly intellectual. Westerners love mindfulness.
Then it sort of calms the mind, and that experience of calming for a very fretful anxious person is is very pleasant. So discussiveness would be excuse me, breath would be one object of meditation for someone who is very agitated mentally, and agitation is perhaps the dominant affliction, a mental affliction of Westerners. With Tibetans, the opposite. Tibetans typically, only Tibetan suffers from dullness. So instructions which cater to Tibetans cannot cater to Westerners in this respect.
Now a skillful object of meditation is proposed by Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakośa. It’s translated in English. I would recommend those of you who are interested to read it. And it is meditation on one’s body as a skeleton. It’s a very powerful antidote to desire, and you can train in calm abiding with this as an object of meditation.
And we’ll cover this, and then I can see on your faces that the call for tea is there, some of our students are in meditative equipoise already. So there are three ways to practice meditation on firmness, or meditation on the skeleton. For beginners, experienced and advanced practitioners. A beginner meditates enters in the meditation posture, the eightfold meditation posture, and visualizes his own body in the entire universe as of the nature of bone. White, dry, and dusty, and sets his mind on this focusing upon it, and attains calm abiding on this basis.
Then an experienced meditator would visualize the topmost part of the skull as bony, and the universe as of the nature of bone. But the way Geshe Rabten taught us to do this was from the beginning to the most advanced practice, which is perhaps the most beneficial. One visualizes a circle of bone on one’s forehead. So actually one thinks that someone has taken a cookie cover and removed the flesh here, and you can see the bone. It’s not bloody, it’s just white and gray and dry.
And then what I want is in a meditation posture, one visualizes that all the skin and the flesh of one’s face disappears from this area downwards, and a skull is present here but one’s body is still fleshy. And one keeps moving downwards as if the flesh was being wiped out, down, down, down, all the way to one’s feet, and one is a skeleton seated in a yet colored universe. Then one continues visualizing that from the area around oneself, the temple or one’s room, then the entire country, all living beings in the country, the entire world become bone and skeleton. When this is complete, one focuses on any element of this one chooses. It might be the circle of bone here, it might be one’s own body as skeleton, this is your object of observation.
It’s a very powerful counter to desire, because you are simultaneously meditating on foundness and death. Very powerful. So it is said that a great practitioner, was probably not yet an Arhat, but Buddhaghosa describes him as an Arhat. If he was an Arhat, what happened could not have happened. Was walking in India, Buddhaghosa is the equivalent for the Theravāda tradition of Je Tsongkhapa.
He basically wrote the great summa, the sum of the Theravāda tradition, the Visuddhimagga. So this practitioner is walking, and he came upon a very beautiful young girl. He was a monk. She looked at him, and she smiled radiantly at him. And when she looked at him, desire arose in his mind.
The moment she smiled at him and he saw her teeth, the bone nature of her body arose in his mind and revulsion arose. So this would be the impact of such a meditation. If you do such a meditation daily, you know, please don’t blame me if you divorce. I had a classmate, you know, He’s now a professor of Buddhist studies at the University of Michigan. He’s very bright.
And, he was not ordained at the University of Virginia. And he came to me once and he said, I have a problem and I want to ask you how to handle it. I said, well, do my best, you know. He was seeing this girl and he said, you know, I’ve been saying to her that I really find her body repulsive and filthy, And she’s very upset with me, and she wants to break up. And what do I do?
And I said, well, you know, I mean, obviously, I’m not saying it’s true, it might be. But you can’t say that, can you? I mean, those are monastic levels of practice. Then they did break up. I don’t know if he kept telling this to ladies, you know, I’m not quite sure what the impact would be, but keep in mind when you start engaging in these levels of practice, your social life will change.
It will change. I think your life will become more meaningful, but your social life may suffer, and with a very understanding partner as you say this to her. Now I will complete the presentation of objects of meditation, and then we will have our tea break. Now objects of meditation, and here the distinction is important for newly achieving calm abiding, in other words achieving calm abiding for the first time can only be conventional. Normally you can have two types of objects of meditation.
You can choose as an object of meditation, a statue of the Buddha, a bone, a book, these are all conventional objects of meditation. Or from the beginning, you can choose as an object of meditation emptiness. Now generally speaking, it’s considered pretty much impossible to attain calm abiding from the beginning on emptiness, because you have to first identify the object, which is difficult, and then in addition that to that you have to train calm abiding. So people who take emptiness as an object for attaining calm abiding, typically will take it later on in the process. And as we mentioned, you can use any object you wish, but training in calm abiding amounts to training and concentration.
If you do not attain calm abiding and ninety nine point ninety nine percent of the people who start never attain calm abiding, all of that time spent concentrating on the horn of a rabbit would have been wasted. You may have some better concentration and that’s it. So you should choose an object of concentration which will be of help to you later on at the time of your death. And in this respect, this is the advice of Kamalaśīla based on the Samādhi Rāja sūtra, it is preferable to focus on a representation of the Buddha, because at the time of your death, let’s say you’ve spent you’ve done a calm abiding retreat of three months, you never got calm abiding, but you reach, let’s say, the fourth mental abiding. Okay.
You never got calm abiding, so those four months or three or four months are pretty much wasted. At the time of your death, it would be very easy for you to visualize a statue of the Buddha if you have used it as a support. Then that establishes a strong connection with Buddha Śākyamūni in future lives. So if you’re going to train in calm abiding, since realistically, I don’t know of a single Westerner who ever attained it, and among the Tibetans you can count them on the fingers really of one hand, it is better to focus on a meaningful object. Then the meditations I mentioned earlier on the skeleton are very powerful.
I’m not quite sure what will happen to you in your future life if you visualize a skeleton in the death process. So in that respect you have to think a bit, and we will talk after the break of changing objects of observation. Generally speaking, it’s to be avoided. But if you’re gonna do it, there’s a point where you can do it. And now I think, Chris, to me, we have a ten minutes tea break, then ten minutes for me means more like five minutes.
And in Australia, I know ten minutes tends to expand. So let’s find the middle way and have it be a true ten minutes. Thank you. This brings us to the topic of changing objects of observation, And basically, when it comes to changing objects of observation, there’s one oral transmission: don’t. It’s a huge hindrance to the development of calm abiding.
One has to basically choose carefully an object of observation and keep it until one has attained calm abiding, and then after that one can change. Now it happens that one has chosen unwisely. If one has chosen unwisely, it is said that you can change at the level of the third mental abiding. In other words, the third mental abiding, we’ll talk about them in a couple minutes, is when you no longer lose the object of observation. At that point, if let’s say you started out, for instance with a skeleton as your object of observation, and you find that it consistently gives rise to fear, which hinders the meditation, at the level of the third mental abiding you would change to an image of the Buddha.
But the generic object of observation recommended by all the great teachers in our tradition is simply the body, a statue of Buddha Śākyamūni. There are no interferences, it’s of benefit to the mind, and it leads to a reduction of the afflictions. So you have these uncommon objects of observation I mentioned earlier, such as skeletons and so forth. If you have very powerful afflictions in your mind, and you find for instance, it is impossible for you to focus on the representation of a Buddha. The benefit of meditating on one’s own skeleton is the reduction of desire.
So if someone has very powerful desire within their mind stream and it interferes with the meditation, then when the skeleton is an object of meditation, this desire will not arise. It’s immediately countered by the fact that one feels basically well, even if one’s a medical scientist, the skeleton’s a little bit you know? Not something you’d have at your coffee table, right? Then, if such powerful desire is not present, the best generic object of meditation is an image of the Buddha. Simply because it is of benefit at the time of death.
It’s a very simple practice at the time of one’s own death. I suppose an alternative would be the picture of one’s own teacher. I’ve never heard this said, but definitely it could be done. Is at the time of death if you can clearly visualize Buddha Shakyamuni, your own teacher, things should go quite well. Then I take all the questions at the end unless it’s something which overwhelms you, at which point by all means.
So obviously, as I mentioned previously, when you train a calm abiding, you draw the mind inside. Then whatever delusion is strongest in your mind stream would become spontaneously manifest. It’s always been there, actually. The tension connected with anger, the craving connected with desire has always been there. But because you’re drawing the mind inwards, suddenly it becomes apparent and it hinders the meditation.
So to progress in your meditation, you need to find a means to bring this down, and that is where the choice of uncommon objects of meditation can step in. And now the crux, how to attain calm abiding. So it will be vain to expect to understand all of this in one conference. You will have to go back over this material at home. The easiest presentation you’ll find in Pabongka Rinpoche is Liberation in the Palm of your Hand.
If you’re already somewhat familiar, I would really recommend to read Je Tsongkhapa’s section on calm abiding in Lamrim Chenmo, volume three. There are two broad methods for generating calm abiding. One which is due explicitly to Maitreya and one which is due to Asaṇga and Maitreya. They’re equivalent and complementary. A well trained Geshe would rely on both.
For yourself, if it is perhaps difficult, can rely on one or the other. The first is the five thoughts and the eight antidotes, and the second is the nine mental abidings. Both will lead you to calm abiding. So we’ll first talk about the five thoughts and the eight antidotes, and I will give you the quote in the Madhyāntavibhāga which lists them. Maitreya says, I assert, and these are the five thoughts, laziness and forgetting the instruction, sinking and agitation which are counted as one, non application and application I added intemperate in brackets as the five thoughts.
If you eliminate these five thoughts you will as a result attain calm abiding. If you’re focusing on an object of meditation, the process of eliminating these five thoughts leads you to calm abiding, and then the remaining section explains how to eliminate them. You can see why you would need the instruction of a teacher. Dwelling in what dwells cause and effect, not having forgotten the object, recognizing sinking and agitation, the actual application to abandon those when they are pacified entering into calmness, in other words calm abiding. This is basically coded.
It is coded to prevent someone who does not have a teacher to practice exclusively on the basis of this text. Precisely for some of the reasons we talked about earlier. So one’s guru in ancient India, one’s teacher would actually explain what the eight antidotes are. What dwelling means, what what dwells means, what cause and effect, let’s say effect refers to pliancy for instance, but you would never know that from the term effect. So let us look at these in detail.
First the five thoughts, as we said laziness, forgetting the instructions, thinking and agitation, non application, and intemperate agitation. How do eight antidotes counter five faults? Because there are four antidotes which counter the first one, which tells you something about the importance of the first antidote laziness. Now this is not really laziness as you and I understand it. It’s not laziness which involves spending an afternoon on the beach.
It’s a rather different type of laziness we’ll talk about, and this laziness has four antidotes, which are faith, which Maitreya calls dwelling, and aspiration which dwells, enthusiasm which is the cause, the cause of what, the cause of calm abiding, and pliancy which is the bliss associated with calm abiding, which is the effect, the effect of what? Of the attainment of calm abiding. So you can see laziness itself all alone has four major antidotes. This is therefore the most important fault preventing one from attaining calm abiding. The next fault is forgetting the instructions, and forgetting the instructions is once again a coded term, it’s a euphemism.
It means forgetting the object of meditation. It does not refer to forgetting the teachings, and its antidote is what I have called recollection, literally memory. Dran pa means memory in Tibetan. So the antidote to forgetting the object of meditation is memory. You will not attain calm abiding without a powerful memory, and a sign of good training and calm abiding is that memory becomes like a steel trap.
Someone who has trained well and calm abiding has total recall. The third antidote is sinking, and the third fourth is sinking and agitation, which are grouped as one. They manifest from the fourth level upwards, and their antidote is vigilance. We’ll talk about all of these in a couple of minutes. The fifth thought is non application, and its antidote is application.
Application of what? Of the antidotes. And the sixth, excuse me, the fifth is in temperate application, in other words application when there is no need. And its antidote is non application, just allowing the meditation to proceed. So you can see how profound this one passage of the Madhyantavibhagga is, and you can see it would be impossible to understand it without oral instruction.
The thoughts you could understand with a very sharp mind. The antidotes I don’t think you could. So we said that laziness is the foremost thought at the beginning. What are its antidotes? What precisely is laziness?
The first form of laziness is a laziness of neutral deeds, in other words doing everything except meditating. In the context of training and calm abiding, deciding that you’re not going to meditate anymore but do some prostrations is a form of laziness. Then you have laziness attached to bad deeds, then clearly in the context of training and calm abiding, deciding that you’ve just had enough of the day, you got to go to the pub and have a couple pints, is a clear case of the laziness of non virtuous deeds. Alcohol will only harm your practice. And the third form of laziness is discouragement, which is quite close to what we call depression in the West.
This feeling that one simply can’t do it, this lack of self confidence. So a certain amount of inner steel is necessary for these practices. Now you can see how these four antidotes would clearly be antidotes to laziness. If you have faith and aspiration in calm abiding, then the laziness of not wishing to engage in the practice will not arise. Enthusiasm for the practice is necessary as well, and then clearly the experience of pliancy, which however is an experience you gain at the end of your practice, is a foremost counter to laziness.
It’s an extraordinary experience of ecstasy and bliss, and when this arises, you actually cannot stop from wishing to meditate. So clearly these four antidotes combined are very powerful counter to laziness. Now the following thought is forgetting the instructions, in other words forgetting the object of meditation. You are meditating a bit as this picture, know, things are going well and you start to be moved into the and eventually there’s only fog all around you. No object of meditation, this is not meditation.
Then if your practice moves in this direction, please stop, because not only is it not helpful, it’s actually harmful. So here we’re going to rely on the great treatises. Bhāvaviveka, the great propounder of Sautrāntika Madhyamaka, has a verse in his heart of Madhyamaka, in which he says, after binding securely the wayward elephant of the mind, the mind is compared with an uncontrolled elephant. With the rope of recollection, in this verse recollection on memory is a rope which ties the mind to the object of observation. This is what keeps the mind on the object of observation.
To the firm pillar of the object of observation, one will overpower it gradually with the hook of wisdom, and this is an uncommon passage of this stanza. Normally the hook refers to vigilance. Here I think Bhāvaviveka uses wisdom, it probably has to be interpreted as vigilance. So what precisely is recollection or memory which prevents us, as we said, from forgetting the object of meditation. And here Vasubandhu makes it very clear in his Mahayānasūtrālamkara commentary, his commentary on Maitreya’s ornament of the Mahāyāna Sutras.
What is the difference between recollection and vigilance? Recollection, in other words memory, does not allow the mind to leave, to scatter from the object of observation. It binds the mind with the object of observation. Vigilance understands what’s happening if the mind leaves. This is as clear definition as I have ever seen.
So recollection and vigilance are fundamentally different. And Asaṇga adds that recollection is a non forgetfulness of a familiar thing and has a function of sorrow non distraction. Now these passages in the great treatises are very profound. Each word has a specific meaning. For instance, in Asaṇga’s definition of recollection in his great treatise in Abhidharma, Abhidharmasamuccaya.
When Asaṇga says the non forgetfulness of a familiar thing, this is really very interesting. You cannot remember what you are not familiar with, and therefore one of the first obstacles when training in calm abiding is non familiarity with the object of meditation. You simply have not observed the object of meditation carefully enough. If you take the statue of a Buddha as an object of meditation, you should choose one statue, not a generic statue, one specific statue, and you must observe it basically almost with a magnifying glass over and again, because you must visualize all its features. It must appear with perfect clarity in your mind’s eye, in your mental consciousness.
When your eyes are crossed like this, you must see it in space here, and you must see all its uncommon features. So this is only possible if extreme familiarity has been acquired. Now as mentioned, after forgetting the object of meditation, the next thought is sinking and agitation as a group. Sinking and agitation, one’s mind is basically like a ship on a wild sea. When there is agitation the ship is cast upwards and almost comes out of the ocean, and when there is sinking it is drawn downwards.
This is very much the experience one has during sinking and agitation. As Asaṇga points out that agitation is intimately connected with desire. In other words, if your mental disposition is one in which desire is strong, when you start training and calm abiding, agitation will be predominant. It’s a certain fretfulness of the mind. The mind is always being scattered, you know, wondering what should I do next week?
Should I go to what’s what’s the name of your musical festival this year in in March and May? Nobody ever comes to the teachings. Woman and Yes. Woman. Woman.
Woman. Woman. Okay. Woman is one of the biggest obstacles to teachings at TBI. So, you know, you’re meditating on the statue of the Buddha in your mind is that Woman Adelaide, you know.
If it’s not this year’s woman, it’s next year’s woman, right? Or the other classic excuse for not attending teachings is the birthday of your children, right? Which I gather must be a very happy event for parents. Oddly enough, all the parents I meet during those events are very stressed, but so you know, you’re not going to teachings because the birthdays of your children, then you visualize a statue of the Buddha and your mind is already preparing the birthday of junior one month away. This is agitation.
Right? So how does one counter agitation? As we said, agitation involves the mind being too heightened. You have to bring the mind down. A very effective way of bringing the mind down is meditating on one’s own death for most people.
In other words meditating on impermanence, but not the philosophical concept of impermanence, but the fact that, let’s say in my own case, is certain that fifty years from now I will be decaying at the bottom of a pit. You know, it’s a given, you know, and everyone would have forgotten my my very name, and every one of us is in the same situation. So when your mind is agitated and is thinking of romance, then you bring it back, you know, through reflecting on your own impermanence and death. Agitation is not difficult to understand. Sinking is the problem.
And as Je Tsongkhapa says, precisely because sinking is not clearly identified in the great treatises, and especially subtle sinking is not clearly identified, it’s very easy to confuse sinking with good concentration, especially the subtle forms of sinking. So in Tibet this was a main topic of debate regarding calm abiding, and it has remained a topic of debate until the present day. There was a whole school of Tibetan or schools should I say of Tibetan yogis, who considered meditating with subtle sinking as the supreme meditation with supreme relaxation. I think those were the precise terms they used, because indeed it’s very comfortable, No particular effort. What happens is basically at the level of the fourth or the fifth mental abiding, you actually have subtle sinking, and you think you’re already at the level of the ninth mental abiding, and you just stay there.
And with subtle sinking, as we will see pretty soon, the object is clear, and it’s stable, and there’s no effort. The object lacks however a certain luster, a certain limpidity, and that eventually leads to a progressive dulling of the mind. And over time you pass from subtle sinking to coarse sinking unbeknownst to you. Maybe you feel you have entered into the cloud of unknowing or something like that. And then as Sakya Pandita put it, you know, such yogis are meditating to be reborn as animals.
There’s a direct result of such a mental dullness is rebirth as an animal. So what exactly are the various types of dullness? Dullness can be neutral or virtuous. For instance, you are meditating on an object of meditation, the object becomes less clear. That’s not a thought.
It’s certainly not a non virtue. It’s a thought in the context of meditation. That would be sinking. Or it can be non virtuous, then it would be lethargy. If you are attending a teaching by His Holiness the Dalai Lama and you enter into meditative equipoise every one of us enters in every twenty four hours, then that is non virtuous.
That’s lethargy. And then a third factor of dullness corresponds pretty much to depression, zhum pa in Tibetan. It’s just lack of courage, dishearteness. This is too difficult. I’ll never be able to do it.
My life is too short. Then depending on the topic involved, this can be virtuous, neutral, non virtuous. If you’re talking of dharma, it’s definitely non virtuous. If you’re talking of partying and you say you can’t keep up with the partying, that’s also dishearteness, but probably it’s a virtuous state of mind. So it’s really thanks to Kamalaśīla that we have a better understanding of sinking.
Kamalaśīla compared it to being blind. If the mental of observe object of observation does not appear clearly, one suffers from sinking. Or as Je Tsongkhapa puts it in a much sharper fashion, if one loses the mode of apprehension of the object of observation through withdrawing the mind excessively inwards, this generates sinking. And this is a very powerful passage, as really many of the passages of Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo. Because what is the cause of sinking?
The cause of sinking is drawing the mind too much inwards too quickly. Exactly what leads to sleep. Then as a result of drawing the mind inwards too much, the apprehension of the object by the mind dwindles and disappears. You lose the object. First, it becomes dull, then duller, then duller, then you’re not quite sure if you’re meditating or not.
You know? This is not non duality, it’s sinking. So someone was asking me over the tea break how you counter sinking. Easiest way to counter sinking is to meditate powerfully on the ball of light, as small as possible. The greater you’re sinking, the smaller the ball of light and the more radiant it should be.
If your sinking is very strong, it should be on top of your crown, or alternatively if you have problems visualizing something on top of your crown in front of your eyes. Then practitioners who are better educated in Dharma can try to meditate on the clear nature of the mind, the clear light nature of the mind, but I would suggest just a ball of light. It is much simpler and very effective. The one thing I have not mentioned is location of the object of meditation. Normally when one trains in calm abiding, the object of meditation is visualized in space in front of oneself at a distance of approximately one arm span, which means approximately 40 centimeters.
But there are two other possible locations which are not usually used when one trains of calm abiding, but can be used nonetheless in terms of personal preference. The first is on top of one’s crown, and the second is in front of one’s navel. Now this is my private opinion on the topic based on my own experience. If one is suffering as a person from extremely strong sinking, it is helpful to visualize the object of meditation on top of one’s crown. If as a person one is suffering from extremely strong agitation, it is helpful, but this is really strong, not just normal agitation.
It’s helpful to bring the mind down and visualize the object of meditation at the level of one’s navel. But for most of us, it’s recommended to visualize it in space at approximately 40 sentient beings distance in front of oneself, and the size of the object of meditation depends on one’s own capacities of concentration. Basically, if one visualizes a representation of the Buddha, it should be one thumb in height. But there’s a fair latitude one has in this matter. It once again depends on one’s own mind.
If one’s mind is pretty loose, rather dull, then it is helpful to shrink the image on this visualizing, because this fosters greater concentration. If on the other hand, one’s mind is pretty tight, we say uptight in The States, I don’t know if you use the term in Australia, quite uptight, a bit bouncy, then you don’t want an object of meditation which is too small, this fosters agitation. Instead, you’re visualizing the the Buddha, you might visualize him the size of your hand. The key is that the object of meditation must be clear, as clear as possible, and it must be stable. So if you tighten the concentration too much, you may find that the object of meditation seems to wobble a bit.
This is a sign of excessive concentration. It’s a sign of the beginning of agitation. You have to reduce the concentration. If the object of meditation loses its clarity and becomes a blur, that’s a sign of insufficient concentration. You have to increase the concentration.
So in this matter, one handles meditation exactly as those of you who play a string instrument as according a violin or a cello. If the string of the cello is too loose, then your note will be too low. And if the string of the cello is too tight, you know, it will be too tight, too high. Right? So when it comes to stable concentration, you have an area in which concentration is both stable and clear.
This is where you want to be. Above that, if you tighten the concentration, subtle agitation will settle in, and that typically manifests as a certain instability of the object of meditation, and if you tighten it even more, coarse agitation may settle in, at which point your mind will have a tendency to leave the object of meditation. On the other hand, let us say you have stable and clear concentration, and you focus too much on the stability. Stable. And then eventually, the stability becomes quite remarkable.
It’s quite an experience when it happens, you really do think you are doing well. But as a result of this great stability of the object of meditation, there is a slight lack of limpidity. It’s almost like a glow which isn’t quite there. That is subtle sinking. And when that lack of limpidity translates into a lack of clarity, actually the object is always there.
You don’t lose the object in coarse sinking, but where you had a statue of the Buddha, now you have a still statue of the Buddha, but if they say if I was actually seeing it, I would be seeing it without my glasses. It’s like not all the features are really visible. That is called sinking. So if we analyze the various factors which have to be present, and this is really due to Je Tsongkhapa’s analysis, this table is my own work, but the analysis of these factors we owe to Jetsungkapa. These are the factors which all must be present leading up to pliancy.
You need stability, you need limpidity, you need clarity, you need intensity, and eventually you need a blissful experience called pliancy. Now stability is present in coarse sinking. The object is stable. You have no limpidity, no clarity and no intensity, but the object is stable. When you move up to subtle sinking, and this is why subtle sinking is so dangerous, you still have stability, you have some limpidity in some clarity, but the edge isn’t there.
The ngar in Tibetan, the intensity isn’t there. Then it is extremely easy to confuse this with the ninth mental abiding. In subtle agitation, you have all the factors of clarity. Limpidity, clarity and intensity, but stability is not fully there. As we said, you have the sense that the object in meditation is waving, but it starts waving really, then you you basically on the edge to of having coarse agitation, but it’s just like this, you know.
Then the factor of stability is not completely there, and in coarse agitation, once again in agitation you have the factors of clarity until you lose the object, but the stability isn’t there at all. Now when you reach the ninth mental abiding, which we’ll talk about in a couple of minutes, you have all of these four factors, but you don’t have the ecstasy, the bliss, what we call pliancy. And with calm abiding, in addition to these four factors, you get pliancy. Now this is very much a chart based on my own work, it’s something frankly you have to study the great text and you have to check your own practice. Various Geshe’s would agree or disagree with specific points, specifically what the features of subtle sinking are and what the features of subtle agitation.
This is something you have to check-in your own practice and you have to see if you can identify as you meditate these four factors. Stability is easy and clarity is easy. Limpidity and intensity are more difficult. Limpidity is a particular clarity is the same thing as if you’re seeing something through a film of water and something without water. When you see something through a film of water, you don’t have the same impurity as when you see it without that film of water, both are clear.
Or seeing things, making a picture with a good objective, and making a picture with a cheaper objective. And intensity is quite particular, it’s almost like a glow around the object. The object is vibrant. The object has a certain energy. So in this respect, there’s an extraordinarily profound quote by Sthiramati about the relationship between recollection and vigilance.
Recollection is the cause of vigilance, and since many of you are attending Geshe-la’s class on Tuesday, I’d like to ask you why this quote is so profound and what it means. When we say recollection is a cause of vigilance, and Sthiramati is, if you wish, the father of the technical understanding of calm abiding in Tibet, so he’s one of the very very great Indian yogis and scholars. What are the major consequences of such a statement? What are the major consequences if recollection is a cause of vigilance? Where are we talking about teachings?
We’re talking of calm abiding, recollection is a factor of memory, vigilance is a factor of noticing whether there’s distraction or sinking or not. If we say that memory is a cause or recollection is a cause of vigilance, What what are the consequences of this statement? No, who always talks about reflexive consciousness here? No, no. If one thing is a cause another thing is an effect, what does that mean about their relationship?
Very good, yes. Excellent, excellent, which has to be there first? Yes, excellent. That’s point number one. So recollection comes first and yes, that’s the first point.
In other words, first point, you cannot have vigilance if recollection was not there first. Right? So if something is the cause of something else, the existence of the effect necessarily implies the former existence of the cause, right? Chris, you are the son of your parents and the fact that you are among us implies as Geshe-la would say with 100% certainty that your parents must have existed. There is no debate about this.
Right? Your parents must have existed. So if the effect exists, the cause must have existed. Is the opposite true? Yes, Sam?
No, it’s not. Why not? What example can you give me of a cause which exists and its effect does not arise? Give me an example of a cause whose effect never arises. Yes.
For instance, yeah, exactly. It’s exactly it. You have a seed which is a cause, then the seed does not necessarily give rise to a crop, to sprout, right? If you plant it in the Australian Outback, then it can stay there for centuries, because the conditions, water, manure and so forth, are never present. So the existence of the cause does not entail the existence of the result, Right?
A lot of conditions are also necessary. The existence of the result necessarily entails the existence of the cause. So what does this mean here? If you have recollection, you don’t necessarily have vigilance. Right?
Definitely. For sure, recollection is the foundation, Without recollection, no vigilance. With recollection, no guarantee of vigilance. With vigilance, you must have had recollection, right? That’s what we agreed upon, but there’s another point.
In the Buddhist understanding of causality, can cause an exist an effect exist at the same time? Sam says no, but he’s shaking his head, he’s not saying it, he’s shaking his head. Does anyone else have a position? Please feel free, I mean, it’s not icy here, we’re not gonna we’re not gonna harm you if you have non dogmatic positions. Can a cause and an effect coexist?
Like what? Emptiness is what? Emptiness is permanent phenomenon, it’s not the cause of anything. And this is an absence, right? Take an example, a simple example of a cause.
Take a seed. Have you ever seen a seed at the exact same time as a sprout it gives rise to? No. It’s either a seed or it’s a sprout. When it’s become a sprout, it’s no longer seed.
When it’s a seed, it’s no longer a sprout, right? This is true change. So what does this mean in this context here? Yes. Yes.
Yes. But there’s something else I’m driving at. You can’t have recollection of vigilance at the same time. This is what Sthiramati is saying. You see how profound his statement is.
One short line and Sthiramati has said, if you have vigilance you necessarily had recollection. If you have reconnection, there’s no guarantee in that basis you can get vigilance, but without recollection you will never get vigilance, and recollection and vigilance never coexist at the same time in the same mind. It’s a very powerful statement. Isn’t it? And there’s something else the statement implies.
When two things are in a causal relationship, what can we say about them? This case is the two minds. Right? Recollection is a mind or memory. Vigilance is also both both mental factors actually.
One is a mental factor, the other is a mental factor. There’s a same type. So what is being said by Sthiramati is that vigilance is basically a form of recollection. Just as for instance, if a sprout arises from a seed, the nature of the seed and the sprout are not unrelated. Right?
I mean, a sheaf of wheat is not going to arise from a chilli seed, it’s not going to happen. Recollection and vigilance are intimately related. So all of this is very helpful for one’s practice in my opinion. I mean, when you’re checking your own minds, you have recollection. Then, where you have powerful recollection, according to Sthiramati, do you have vigilance?
Sthiramati implies no. Right? When vigilance is present, because vigilance is precisely the checking component of the mind, then the recollection which gave rise to it can no longer be there. Right? But they are closely related.
If that recollection is not there, the vigilance which checks cannot arise. So if one instance it’s a bit technical, but if one instance of mind which perceives the the object, that’s recollection, holds it if you wish, and that gives rise to the second instance of vigilance which is checking, right? Now when that’s instant of vigilance is there, this first instance of recollection is no longer there and cannot be there. So we will leave this aside, but I just wanted to show you how you take a passage from the great treatises, and you have to extract the very essence of these passages, they’re not novels you can just skim through, you know. They are really a very profound import.
So this presentation of the five thoughts and the eight antidotes according to Maitreya leads us to a, for some people, simple presentation of the nine stages of mental abiding. This is Asaṇga at the feet of Buddha Maitreya. And these are listed in Maitreya’s ornament of sutras. Sorry for Kamalaśīla. After focusing the mind on the object, continually do not be distracted.
Having quickly understood distraction, patch it again on that. The intelligent over and again withdraw the mind inwards. Then by seeing the qualities, the mind is subdued in concentration. So seeing the faults of distraction, I will pacify dislike for that. The arising of desirous minds, happiness, and so forth, I will pacify thus.
Then those who are attained and enthusiastic actually apply to the mind and attain dwelling within. Through familiarity there is no application. Each of the letters in orange refers to the key point of one of the nine mental abidings. The first mental abiding you actually have to focus the mind on the object. The second you focus continually.
The difference between the first and the second is that during the first the mind is focused but does not stay on its object. During the second you lengthen the focus. The third you patch it, literally in Tibetan len ten jog pa, you put it over again and again. You have some continuity, but you keep losing the object, so you keep having to patch your concentration if you wish. Then the mind is drawn inwards, which is a key point in the actual generation of concentration, this inward process of the mind.
The fifth mental abiding is subjugation or taming of the mind. The sixth pacification and the seventh thorough pacification. So pacification is used two times by Maitreya. So the seventh mental abiding is called thorough pacification. Then we have the eighth and the ninth which is meditative equipoise.
In the ninth, as we will see soon, you no longer apply any of the antidotes, the mind is just focused on the object of observation. So let us look now in detail at the mental abidings. In the first mental abiding, the mind can be focused on its object. So when you start training in calm abiding, the first question to ask yourself is do you have are you able to visualize the object of observation or not? So does something appear?
When I last presented this topic here, with more than half the students nothing appeared to the mind. So we did a test, meditated together, I think it was pretty much half, meditating on the image of Buddha Śākyamūni nothing appeared, just blankness. Then they are not even on the first mental abiding. Something must appear to be in the first mental abiding. Then partly this is karmic heritage, also frankly was if heavy drug usage or alcohol abuse in the past, then, you know, this has a big impact.
But once one is on the first mental abiding, in other words, you actually have an object, you actually can see something with your mind’s eye, right? However, unclearly, then you are on the first mental abiding, and one of the features is that it’s discontinuous. In other words, you keep losing the object through agitation. It’s not even agitation, it’s so costly, just lose the object. You don’t even know you’ve lost it.
And during the first mental abiding, you have a very strong impression that you are much more agitated than you ever were before. Discursiveness seems to increase. It’s not true, it’s simply that for the first time we realize how agitated and troubled our minds are. Then the main obstacles are laziness, as was mentioned, and forgetfulness which refers to losing the object of meditation, and the antidotes are the four first antidotes Maitreya lists: faith, aspiration, exertion, and recollection, which at the beginning is very difficult. You keep losing the object, you have to go back to the object again and again, Frequently, if one doesn’t have good vigilance, one is not even aware that one has lost the object.
Well, it is gone, and one has gone with it, and five minutes later one realizes that one’s thinking about the islands of Fiji, and one has to go back to the object, you know. Then the second mental abiding, the mind stays longer on its object. It’s still discontinuous, there’s no difference in this respect, and you have the impression that your discursive discursiveness is decreasing, it’s not decreasing, your concentration is improving. The main obstacles are the same and the antidotes are the same. So the first two mental abidings are very similar.
In the third mental abiding, the pauses between the moments when you lose the object or longer, you have this continuum focused on the object for longer, it is still discontinuous, and the object the obstacles and the antidotes are the same. So these three first mental abidings can basically be understood as one group. They’re a group of interrupted concentration. You can’t even speak of concentration at this level. Now, if you no longer lose the object of meditation, you start immediately at the fourth concentration, the fourth mental abiding.
So if you start training and calm abiding and from the beginning when you focus on an image of the Buddha, is there and it stays there for as long as you wanted to stay there, be it hours or minutes, and your mind never wanders away, that means you are starting directly at the fourth mental concentration, the fourth mental level. And this would occur either because you have in a previous life meditated on calm abiding, or because through your job, your education, you have very good concentration. Both are possible. You would expect that say a good mathematician to basically start directly at the force mental abiding. It would not be a surprise at all.
So during the fourth mental abiding you no longer lose the object. Your concentration is continuous. It’s at present that agitation and sinking become major obstacles, because before you could even talk about them the object wasn’t there. Your mind will be, oh, then come back. And therefore, it’s at this point that vigilance becomes important, and I think here you can understand Stiramati’s quote a bit better.
Why is that the case? Because in general, the recollection which was generated during the first three mental abidings acts as the cause for the vigilance which is present in the fourth mental abiding. And from this point onwards, what increases vigilance ever more. The object is no longer lost, recollection has done its duty if you wish. The elephant is tethered tethered, excuse me, tethered to the pillar of the object of recollection.
And then as we increase vigilance, so called power, or the force of vigilance is generated, and probably now there’s a lot of debate about this one. During the fifth mental abiding, you have no longer coarse laxity, coarse sinking, and coarse agitation. It’s at the fifth mental abiding that the very big problem which beset meditators in Tibet arises. You are continually focused on the object of meditation, recollection is strong, vigilance is strong, there’s no coarse sinking, and there’s no coarse agitation. Everything is going really well.
And your object of meditation appears clearly, you’re happy. It’s at this point you have to ask yourself at the level of the fifth mental abiding, is the object of meditation limpid and is it radiant or not? If it is limpid and radiant, you’re doing fine. If it is not limpid and radiant, subtle sinking is present. So this is Je Tsongkhapa’s main contribution to the topic of calm abiding.
Then, through not identifying subtle sinking, many of the great meditators of the past in Tibet and up to the present day would stay at the fifth mental abiding, and then subtle sinking, which was seen as a plus basically, would increase, and eventually would lead to coarse sinking. And the person would meditate, or the meditator would focus on an object of meditation with subtle sinking for most of his life. The direct result of this is a sharp decline in the powers of memory and analytical faculties. So as we said earlier, a clear sign of wrongly practiced calm abiding is that one’s memory weakens and one’s mental capacities weaken. I’ve seen this several times now.
It’s always quite quite striking when you see it, and the person does not recognize it in addition. When calm abiding is practiced correctly, one’s memory increases, and one’s analytical faculty should increase as well. Then at the level of the sixth mental abiding, we have the opposite problem. Subtle agitation may be present, because one starts to tighten the concentration to try to fight against subtle sinking. The danger of subtle sinking is there, one tightens and one tightens a bit too much.
So one goes a bit overboard in the opposite direction. And at the seventh mental abiding, neither subtle sinking nor subtle agitation is any more of a real danger. So at the level of the seventh mental abiding, one is almost there. The difference between the seventh and the eighth mental abiding is that of effort. In the seventh mental abiding, excuse me, one must put effort during the meditation.
In the eighth mental abiding, one just initiates the flow of focus, the object of mental of concentration, and from this point onwards no effort is required. Then as you can see, subtle agitation and subtle sinking have been abandoned. In other words, when we say abandoned in Buddhist philosophy, it means they will never ever arise again. They haven’t just subsided, they no longer arise. And during the ninth mental abiding, no effort at all is required at the beginning of the session.
The mind focused on the object stays on the object without effort from the beginning onwards. Neither recollection nor vigilance is any more necessary. So if we look at these in terms of the four attentions, which I find very helpful myself. It’s a different way of presenting the nine mental abidings, which is adopted by a Sangha. The two first mental abidings, mental placement or mental focus and continuous placement, are attention through concentration. Concentration is particularly important during these two, and during the remaining seven third to seven, we’re dealing with interrupted attention.
Interrupted because during the third mental abiding, the object of observation is still lost, right? We still have to apply a reconnection, and from the fourth to the seventh, because we still have to struggle against agitation, coarse and subtle, and sinking coarse and subtle. Then the eighth single pointed concentration is called uninterrupted attention, because after initial an initial amount of effort during the first instant to place the object, no effort is required. And the ninth is exertionless, because no effort is required during the first instant. Do you see the difference?
I think these four attentions are very helpful way of understanding the nine abidings. And this is something we have to understand through experience, so this is just the template. You for yourself, when you start training in calm abiding, would have to answer the question. Am I on the first mental abiding at all? Or haven’t I even started?
If I’m not on the first mental abiding, then how should I handle it? So for instance, if you cannot get a mental image of the object of meditation, the first step is to see whether you can get a mental image of anything. And take a case of for instance your parents or your friends. When you think of your parents, does a mental image of your parents face or their body appear or not? So if it appears, then you can have a mental image.
Then it’s just a matter of effort. Then if it doesn’t appear, then I don’t know what to say. So if the face of your parents or your child does not appear when you think about them, then perhaps visualization is going to be a big problem. If it does, that means the potential is there, it’s just a matter of training. At the beginning, it is not easy to visualize.
This time it becomes easier. Then the big question which arises here is once we have attained the ninth meditative equipoise of exertionless attention, have we attained calm abiding or not? And if not, what’s the difference? So the answer is we have not attained calm abiding. We have perfect concentration.
From the beginning, you just focus the mind on the object of meditation and it stays there effortlessly. But perfect concentration is not calm abiding. In addition, one needs to experience pliancy, in other words, the bliss, physical and mental bliss, arisen from calm abiding. When the physical and mental pliancy have arisen, then one has attained calm abiding. And this is what Buddha Śākyamūni teaches himself in the Samdhinirmochana sūtra.
Without having obtained physical and mental pliancy, one is not dealing with calm abiding. It’s called a wish which is concordant with calm abiding, a very advanced level of concentration. It’s precisely this pliancy which is evoked by this depiction of Asaṇga flying with Buddha Maitreya, because one of the sensations of pliancy is one of extraordinarily lightness in the body. One’s body feels like cotton. So pliancy arises in a very precise sequence.
There are first the signs of pliancy, followed by mental pliancy and physical pliancy. And after these two pliancies, the bliss of physical pliancy first and then the bliss of mental pliancy arise. And when the bliss of mental pliancy has arisen, at that point one has calm abiding. And then through repeated meditation actually, this bliss decreases, you know, but one remains in a state of calm abiding. Now what is the omen of pliancy, the sign of pliancy?
It’s a very particular sign which experienced meditators have described. It’s the sense that one’s brain is sinking within one’s skull pan. And it seems to be because the brain is the only part of the body in which pliancy does not occur. Now I have no explanation for this, but it is universally attested by those who have attained calm abiding that the omen or the sign just before pliancy, is that one’s brain feels as if it’s sinking inside one’s hand. And there is an ongoing debate about the nature of physical pliancy.
Everyone agrees that mental pliancy is a mental factor, but opinions are very divided about physical pliancy. The Tibetan tradition in general following Sthiramati considers physical pliancy to be a subtle form of matter. For a long time I was much more sympathetic to the first position, which saw physical pliancy as a mental factor associated with the sense consciousnesses. I’ve come to understand the underlying rationale of Sthiramati’s position, but this I think that would really have to experience oneself. And you have been handed out a chart of training in calm abiding them.
These are very popular, so I’ve translated this from Tibetan. Both with the Tibetans and now Western students. Generally speaking, the top Geshe’s don’t like them. I never forget when I gave this to Geshe Yamarinshe, his first question was, who composed it? Then I couldn’t answer.
So a top Geshe wants to rely on the sources, not on secondary or tertiary sources. The sources are Maitreya’s works, Asaṇga’s works, Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama, the Samdhinirmochana sūtra. This is a later interpretation, largely by an artist. It’s helpful at the beginning, but you must keep in mind several things. It’s almost certain that whoever made this chart did not attain calm abiding, and it’s not clear whether they actually studied it in-depth or not, and if so with whom.
So it’s helpful at the beginning, but don’t rely on it too much. It helps to remember things. So you can see at the beginning, the black elephant symbolizes the completely uncontrolled mind led by agitation, and one is unable to even catch up with one’s mind. Right? Then well I won’t criticize the drawing, I just explained the drawing, because this may be better like that.
The monk or the practitioner pursuing the mind is pursuing it with two implements. The noose, which is recollection or memory, and the hook, which is vigilance. Right? So up to basically the third the third mental abiding, the monk does not even engage the mind. Right?
During the third mental abiding, patch placement, the monk through recollection is actually able to connect the mind to the object of meditation. In other words, the mind no longer loses its object of meditation, but he cannot still apply vigilance. You can see he’s still holding his hook, and the elephant and the monkey agitation have become partly white. The mind has become partly virtuous, and according to this drawing for the first time subtle sinking is present in the form of a hare. Then there’s not a single text which corroborates this.
So this is the drawer of the chart’s opinion. Right? You have to be very very aware of this. When you start really training and calm abiding, you should rely on the texts. It’s much safer.
As the monk progresses through close placement, eventually he is able to apply vigilance in the form of the hook. Now really during close placement the hook should already be applied, right? And during pacification, he no longer really needs to apply either recollection or vigilance. During thorough pacification, after the initial effort which is symbolized by the blackness on the behind of the elephant, no particular effort is required, and during single pointed concentration no effort whatsoever even at the beginning. However, to attain śamatha, it is necessary to have attained pliancy first, which is symbolized by the monk flying and holding this silk scarf, I assume.
And finally having attained calm abiding, one then uses the mind of calm abiding to focus on emptiness, to analyze emptiness actually, and this is symbolized by the monk engaging in the practice of insight, holding the sword of wisdom. As I said, you want to be very careful with these charts, they’re very helpful at the beginning, but don’t deduce too much from the chart. Your deduction should be based on the passages we quoted of Mahayānasūtrālamkara, Bhāvanākrama, of Madhyaanthavibhaga, then the Samdhinirmochana sūtra, and if you have the opportunity in the future, if you want to study this in-depth, it is one semester of study in the great monasteries at Sera Je, a topic called Samahita, which is basically Dhyanas in the formless realms, then you study and debate in-depth and debate it, and then one can get a very solid understanding. The charts are just to give you a sense of what is happening. Now, points out that since there can be no pliancy in the desire realm, in other words the realm we are in, in which our minds are basically benighted by the objects of desire, Once pliancy has been generated, one is no longer a being of the desire realm.
One is a being of the higher realm. As a result, those who train in concentration and progress to the higher Jnanas will be reborn in the form and the formless realms of the God. They would not be reborn as human beings. For a very simple reason, because one of the immediate results of pliancy is a sharp decrease in the afflictions. The afflictions are not abandoned as a result of pliancy as Hindus think.
In Hinduism it is believed that through concentration alone would abandon the afflictions. But when one has generated calm abiding, let alone the Jnanas, then one is no longer particularly disturbed by desire, anger, envy, and so forth. So if you ever hear of a Buddhist master who claims to have realized calm abiding, and who is behaving intemperately, you can be 100% sure that these claims are false. Because once calm abiding has been generated, there is really very little if any desire. It is said to be non manifest.
There is very little if any anger, because the mind is no longer focused on sense objects. And the person will no longer be a being of the desire realm. So this is a personal criterion you can use to assess those who claim to have attained abiding or the higher Jñāna’s. As we said after generating calm abiding, you must generate insight, and in this respect, it’s important to understand why insight is necessary. Concentration alone does nothing to sever the roots of cyclic existence.
So concentration it is not possible to be freed from cyclic existence. We will continue to be reborn again and again. Wisdom is necessary, and this wisdom must be generated within concentration. This is what is known as insight. Specifically, insight has occurred when through analysis of the object of wisdom, pliancy arises.
And this is an extraordinary passage of Je Tsongkhapa. You have to distinguish between calm abiding and insight. If you have for instance calm abiding which is focused on emptiness, the object of calm abiding is emptiness. But calm abiding as we said is a non discursive mind. So that calm abiding which is focused on emptiness has pliancy, yes, but it is not analyzing emptiness.
Is that mind a wisdom in your opinion? No, it’s not a wisdom. When does insight arise? Insight arises according to Je Tsongkhapa, when after attaining calm abiding, we then take emptiness as an object and analyze emptiness, and this analysis of emptiness must give rise to its own pliancy. Now the way it is often said that this is done is, and this for us is very difficult to imagine, but basically that within the river, if you wish, of calm abiding, focused let us say on emptiness, you keep emptiness as the object, there is a stream inside that river of analysis.
That stream of analysis analyzes the object. That is insight within calm abiding. And when that analysis gives rise to its own pliancy, its own experience of ecstasy as a result of analysis, then you have attained true insight. This is a union of calm abiding and insight. Now if you think this is a mental fantasy, you can refer to the experiences of scientists such as, let’s say, great mathematicians or physicists, who describe particular experiences of bliss when they demonstrate theorems.
So I studied mathematics when I was younger, and I remember very clearly, there’s a very powerful experiences of almost like bliss when you demonstrated a theorem. There was a particular concentration, and obviously it is a very strongly analytical activity, that analysis when it was led to fruition gave an experience of really, perhaps not ecstasy, but a very powerful experience. I think this is this gives one an idea of what the union of calm abiding and insight might be in a completely different field, a secular field. Now at the end of this presentation of the Buddhist understanding of concentration, where does this leave us in relation to the other religious traditions? Specifically, there are a large number of non-Buddhist religious traditions, which have strong accounts of mystical experiences, which have transformed the person, and basically are seen as corroborating their own religious tradition.
So I listed three great mystics. Perhaps the father of Western mysticism, Plotinus, a great neo platonic mystic, who lived in Alexandria approximately around the thirds in Egypt, in other words, the third century of our era, a Greek philosopher. Then the Greeks great Sufi and Persian mystic, Rumi, and one of the greatest Western mystics, a Lutheran mystic, Jacob Boehme, who was a German shoemaker. Now if we look at Plotinus’s account of his own mystical experience, this is what he says. Many times he was lifted out of the body, becoming external to all other things and self-centered.
He beheld a marvelous beauty and acquired identity with the divine. This has been the root in the West of the notion of contemplation of God as leading to union with God. And this union with God is seen as a supreme goal of the mystic. Be he Christian, Muslim, or Jewish. Christian, Jewish, and Muslim mysticism have all relied on Plotinus’ experiences of the union with the divine.
Then after this experience comes a moment of descent back into the body, and descent of the soul in the body. And clearly something happened to Plotinus, and it is something we as Buddhists must account for. My personal suspicion is that Plotinus’ mystical experience, just as the mystical experience of Jacob Boehme in 1600 here, are experiences of Samādhi, perhaps a full śamatha. I cannot say if it’s full śamatha or not, but they are experiences of the union with the object contemplated In the case of Plotinus, Plotinus was contemplating God. Eventually, through concentration, he united with the object of concentration, just as when we meditate on calm abiding, when we train calm abiding.
Eventually, when we see the image of Buddha Śākyamūni in front of us, there is no sense I am here in the image of Buddha Śākyamūni is there. There just is the image of Buddha Śākyamūni. So the the actual experience of calm abiding is a non dual experience. There’s nothing particularly holy about non duality. Non duality is a direct product of concentration.
So should this be the case, Plotinus’ experience of divine union could be a direct result of the concentration manifested during his contemplation, and then Jacob Boehme’s mystical experience, which arose as a result of focusing on a pewter dish, could also be the result, direct result of concentration. Then this is something I leave to you to examine for yourselves. We have to account for these mystical experiences in the other traditions, which have had a great impact. Then if they are true in the sense the Jews, Christians, and Muslims understand them to be true, then we are wrong. It’s as simple as that.
So if it is true that Plotinus or Rumi united with God, then we who deny the existence of God are wrong. If they did not unite with God, we have to account for their experience. We can’t just make believe it didn’t happen because it’s happened many times. I mean, there’s a great mystics of the cloud of unknown in the Christian tradition, John of the Cross, Teresa of Avila, Meister Eckhart, the list is long. And all had the same experiences.
I mean if you read the lives of the great mystics, the mystical experience, if you’re interested in this this, I can really recommend William James’s varieties of religious experience, where James attempts to analyze religious experience from the standpoint of comparative psychology. But if you read the experiences of the great mystics, their experience is remarkably similar. Then they consider that there is something out there they have united with. If that pretty is the case, our position is wrong. We shouldn’t be here.
If we say that is not the case, have to account for their experience. And I think from my personal standpoint, the best way to account for it is simply, it is an experience of a Samādhi, in other words concentration, perhaps of Shamatha, because these experiences involve non non duality, the experience is inexpressible, it’s nonverbal, which experience of calm abiding, when you focus on the object of meditation is. The experience involves ecstasy and bliss, which experience of calm abiding involves too. And it’s a transformative experience from which the person basically moves on into a new life. So I think calm abiding with the Samādhi provide a good account for the mystical experiences in the non-Buddhist traditions.
Then this is what I wanted to cover with you today. I’m sorry it’s gone a bit over time, but we have fifteen minutes for questions. When we commenced, this there were preliminaries and, I feel that I don’t have a specific preliminaries days of course is it possible to do them in a retreat to start calm abiding through a retreat and then can you break the cycle of calm abiding that if you were able to attain a certain level through a retreat, can you go back? You do what you have to do. What can I say?
Basically, yes and no. If your goal is to attain calm abiding, the way to do it is to gather all the conditions, go and retreat, it’s done in retreat, that’s how it’s done, and stay in retreat until you attain it, and do only that in retreat. Typically you would be doing 18 sessions a day, so you would not do retreat, let’s say the way you do for instance, you engage in deity yoga retreats, where you do four sessions a day of two three hours. You would do sessions of not more than five minutes. Five minutes at the maximum at the beginning, maybe up to ten later on, and your goal is for perfect focus on the object of meditation.
The moment the focus dwindles, you stop the session. Then you wouldn’t do anything else. You wouldn’t socialize, you wouldn’t read, you wouldn’t follow the news, you should be in an environment as we said with no noise, ideally few or no human beings and few or no animals, and you would continue these 18 sessions a day until you got calm abiding. Then if you have to interrupt the retreat, then you would leave with whatever concentration you had, which is good. Let’s say if you manage to get to the fourth mental abiding, that’s very good.
It’d be very helpful in Namibian meditation. There’s no question. What would happen if you went back and retreat three, four, five years later? We don’t know. If you kept up a daily regimen of practice, if you went back and retreat and you were lucky, you might start again at the fourth mental abiding.
If you were unlucky, you might have fallen back to the third or the second or even all the way back to the first, depending on your lifestyle. If you have been very socially active going out, it was a lot of agitation. A lot of agitation, a social life, then your concentration would dwindle most unavoidably. Then it’s sort of an ongoing debate among those who occupy with these matters, whether one can lose calm abiding or not. There is a general feeling that you could lose it, yes.
That if you attain calm abiding in this life, and then you stopped meditating completely, you might not be able to return to calm abiding when you engaged in a meditative retreat. You have to start maybe at the eighth or the ninth mental level. And clearly there are people who have strong predispositions for calm abiding, which comes from having practiced it in previous lives. Then they might start their practice at the fourth level. So I know of one case in Burma of a young girl, I think she was 18 years old, who obtained calm abiding in two months.
She was a layperson. Then you have to keep in mind this is a traditional Buddhist society, so this would be someone with very pure ethics, who probably did not drink, might have been vegetarian, would have lay vows, probably very pious, then obviously all the conditions are there. And if there are previous predispositions in addition to that, she might progress very fast. Does that answer your question? Lama Zopa Rinpoche and Geshe-la made it very sure that what we taught at the center was to be very practical.
So I’m wondering how to integrate this with the practices that they’ve given us. So Rinpoche for his part implied the importance of compassion in our practice. Geshe-la has focused heavily on the importance of the earlier parts of the Lamrim, etcetera. Combining might be very much a very long exercise for most of us given our lives. How do we use this teaching in our day to day, in your opinion?
Well, basically, you will attain calm abiding, it’s just not going to happen. Most of us, most of us students here are married, you have jobs, you have social lives, you’re Australian citizens, you live in Australia, it’s not going to happen. You’re never gonna take two years of your life, one or two years to live in a retreat center to do this, right? That’s why to my knowledge no Westerner ever attained calm abiding. Then the reason we present it is because it’s a template for training and concentration.
Concentration. Then if you’re going to meditate on Lamrim, the better the concentration, the more the impact on the mind. So if instead of meditating at the level of, let’s say, zero mental abiding, you were to meditate at the level of the first or the second mental abiding on Lamrim, this will have a great impact on your mind. If because you understand that present hatred and concentration, you were because when you meditate on the Lamrim, you alternate analytical and concentration meditations, right? So let’s say you meditate on death and impermanence, first you analyze death and impermanence, but that is not covered in the context of calm abiding.
But once you have analyzed death and impermanence, you focus for instance on the first root, my death is certain. And to be able to focus efficiently on that, and it’s that focus which will transform your mind, you must have as strong a power of concentration as possible. This is what teachings on calm abiding happen to attain. Then full calm abiding realistically realistically it’s not going to happen. You know?
It’s an option available for monks and lay yogis, who basically turn their back on this life and go into retreat until they gain calm abiding, and even then it’s not certain. But for us, it explains to us how to train the mind. So now we understand better what it means, for instance, not to be able to find the object of observation. If it is below the first mental abiding, then what it means to have found the object of observation, let’s say for instance, my death is certain. You actually have the object of observation.
You’re at least at the first mental abiding. Then what agitation and sinking are? This enables you to identify them in your own Lamrim practice. So that is a great benefit. And then any increase in concentration is good.
It’s good. Then clearly, if we were only to explain what was immediately and truly helpful here, I think the center would be empty. Right? So what is truly and immediately helpful is the practice of the being of the small scope, and within that, I think really it’s meditation on death and impermanence. But if we were to explain, like, I were to explain death and impermanence every two months for the last six, seven years, then I think there’d be nobody in the room.
Maybe Chris. Right? That’s what’s truly helpful, you know. Does that answer your question at all? There’s certainly a conception in our culture that meditation is about non analytical, you know, focusing on the breath, you know, the idea of just calming the mind.
What you’ve presented is the very much step by step understanding of what is going on. I wonder if you could comment on what you’ve talked about before, that the Chinese view, which does seem to be pervasive, that meditation is about non conceptuality. Yes. We’re in a different religious tradition there. I mean, the basic problem in China was that when the Buddhist teachings were transmitted to China, they encountered an extremely sophisticated civilization.
So Buddhism was transmitted to China around the year eighty five BC, under the rule of Emperor Ming Di. Then China had already in that period a civilization 2,000 years old, heavily influenced by a combination of Confucianism and Taoism. Buddhism had to adapt, and it adapted especially to Taoism. Taoism teaches that the the ideal of the sage is a state of complete non conceptuality, in which he is in a union with nature, with a Tao, with a universal flow of things. And ideally, as Jiang Tzu puts it, he becomes like a tree or a rock.
Then when Buddhism entered China, the Buddhist meditative tradition was basically forced into the Taoist mode, and this gave rise to what we now know as Chan. Well, there’s a lot of evidence that early Chan, was heavily influenced by Taoism. We find in the early Chan Sutras, for instance, repeated mentions of Taoist sages. And a large proportion of the chart of the sutras, which the Chan tradition relies upon, like the platform sūtra, are basically fabrications. So now it’s it’s proven beyond doubt.
They were actually forged as we know the monasteries where they were forged, and we think we know the authors. So this was established by Western scholars. They were forged to basically promote a certain viewpoint, which is that of this union of Taoism and Buddhism. Then there are other Sutras on which can realize, like the Lankavataka sūtra, which are authentic. There’s no question.
But the Sutras which developed this viewpoint of complete non conceptuality, these are Chinese fabrications. So I spoke about them last year during the symposium. Then, obviously, this viewpoint is very appealing to the Chinese. It was part of Chinese history and this fascination with nature. And the Chinese tried to spread it in Tibet.
So a Chinese monk, traveled to Tibet, and spread this view of Chan, which eventually fused with some views of Dzogchen. This is an ongoing debate about the degree to which Dzogchen is basically an adaptation of Chan, and the degree to which Dzogchen is an authentic Indian tradition. You know? And when Westerners encountered this, they loved it. Right?
I mean, Westerners have to study twelve years in school, and then typically four years at university, and they are they are in a state of mental exhaustion when they come to Buddhist teachings. The very last thing the ordinary Westerner wants is anymore study. Right? So typically we pre select in the Buddhist centers students who are in a state of rejection of elements of their culture, and often in a strong state of rejection of the intellectual elements of their culture. Then anything which is non conceptual is something they’re going to latch on to.
And you have the buzzwords in the centers. Non conceptuality, non duality, you know. Intellectual is a bad word, basically. Right? So all of this is actually harmful to the student, because there’s no particular way to develop the mind without conception.
Like right now, you and I are functioning in the realm of conceptuality. If we want to move to direct realization, we must rely on conceptuality as a crutch. If we don’t, there’s nothing we can rely upon. So it’s a long answer to your question, but does it help? It’s a very good point, because what you do want to keep in mind is when we talk of the two divisions of meditation, analytical meditation and concentration meditation, both are conceptual.
The medical meditation is conceptual. And everything we have covered today is conceptual. You have an image of the Buddha, visualize in space. This is conceptuality. Right?
Do you have any other questions? Please, Amanda. You were talking about how, if people focus on the Buddha, it creates a karmic link in the next life, and that’s beneficial. So in those descriptions you described of the people who believe in other religions and other gods Mhmm. Then that would be creating link to those gods also.
Mhmm. Very strong. Very strong, which is why as Buddhists, we discourage, proselytism. In other words, we discourage propagating Buddhism to non Buddhists, and we discourage conversion. So Geshe Lhundup Sopa Rinpoche has, every time he has taught in the West in the last fifteen years, encouraged Westerners to first investigate their own spiritual tradition.
Most of us in this room, in our previous human life, were westerners. Then, as westerners, it means most of us who are westerners were Christian. We bring Christian karmic imprints with us. The chances of having or having been an Asian in a previous life are small. Had we been an Asian, probably, there’s no certainty, but probably we would have been reborn an Asian.
Was this what we had known? You know, it happens that people cross races, but if you look at Stevenson’s research, it’s it’s surprisingly rare. So that means that we bring with us religious imprints, which are perhaps Christian or Jewish. Then we have a natural propensity to believe in the existence of a God, the moment we try some type of spiritual path, and the existence of a soul. Now with Westerners I have seen, especially modern Westerners nowadays, when I started people were much more influenced by the idea of a God, but now the idea of a soul is something which is very much present in the students at all centers.
They call it the fundamental mind or the mind of clear light, but in their minds it’s the soul. It’s not the Buddhist idea of mind as a continuum of instance of consciousness with nothing apart from that continuum to link them. Right? Then when people have those strong karmic imprints, right, they’ve been Christian ten, twenty, 30 times in the past, right? If they become Buddhist, they’re not going to become very authentic Buddhists.
And this is why his holiness has said, first check your own religious tradition. If it resonates with you, this is safer. As long as it’s one of the great religious traditions, it is of benefit to the mind. Christianity, Judaism, Islam, and it’s, you know, sophisticated forms, Hinduism, these are all of benefit to the mind. And if it doesn’t resonate, be very sure before you become a Buddhist.
That’s I think really what’s being said. Does that answer your question, Amanda? Stevenson. Stevenson. We have his books in the library.
Okay. And we have a simpler book, if I can remember the name. Yes, yes. What’s the author, Sam? New York Times chap, yes.
What’s his name? If you could show it to my man, it’s very good. He covers Stevenson’s research in a simplified form. Bit difficult. Old Souls is good.
Tom Schroeder, right? Yeah. Schroeder. Also Jim Jim Tucker’s Jim And Tucker’s book is very good. Summary of his book.
I can’t remember the name of it, but I’ve also got that. So you see, once you believe in reincarnation, you can see why the object you chose for calm abiding would be a big thing, right? Because if you’re focusing on an object 18 times a day for maybe six months, one year or two years, this is going to have a very big karmic impact. You ought to choose the object quite carefully, right? Then if you focus on a statue of the Buddha and you establish a strong karmic connection with Buddhism, then in the next life, when you little child and your parents take you downtown, and you see a Buddhist monk or a statue of the Buddha immediately, there’s an attraction.
Right? Then you don’t want to go to the temple, you don’t want to attend teachings, the connection will be made. Right? That’s a big benefit. Then if you meditate on the horn of a goat, I’m not quite sure what benefit there is.
Right? Do you have any other questions on calm abiding? Then what I would encourage you to do is try by yourselves. Calm abiding, the topic is not terribly difficult. It sounds a bit overwhelming, all these stages and paths, you know.
It’s just a breakdown of what happens. You have to make your own experiments in concentration. Don’t worry too much about subtle sinking, because chances are you’ll never experience it. If you can go if you can reach the fourth mental abiding you have done well in this life, it’s quite extraordinary. Normally people don’t go beyond the first, second or third.
They keep losing the object, you know. Obviously, calm abiding and the practice of calm abiding in no way means that you are a Buddhist. It’s a universal practice. You find it from shamanism to the great world religions, you know. So it doesn’t involve any religious commitment.
Then, if you have no more questions, thank you very much, and I hope this has been of some use. Well, thank you very much, Nilu, once again. I mean, just reminded me that, suggested that, when he was teaching here, he he pointed to the statue of Śākyamūni Buddha and said, you know, to use an object like this one. And I think we do have some copies. Aaron, you made some copies which we should try and make about it with people’s practice.
So thank you so much, Ilya, for summarizing in a short period of time the whole topic in such depth and clarity. And clearly, it is evident that you’re not talking just from theory but also from your own experience. And we’re very, very grateful for that. So thank you for helping to open up the topic for us in a very precise way in the tradition of the Gelug tradition so that we don’t have to fall into the mistake of our experience and get stuck there. But we can seek out authentic teachers and practice accordingly.
We’re so grateful. Thank you very much. And if you could just join with me in thanking Keep in mind what Mandy said at the beginning. That’s why I asked her to be here for the first fifteen minutes. Find a teacher in a good tradition, stick to him.
Because you can go wrong with meditation and then there are mental or physical problems and they can’t always be healed. Right? So I’ve met such cases, you know, then take my word for it, you really don’t want that to happen to you. So find a good teacher, the fewer the better, trust him and practice in keeping with his advice and the great texts, don’t go fishing. You know, when I was a young novice at Tashi Jong, we had an Italian cook.
He’s a very nice man. He’s a very pretty Italian girlfriend. And one day, I came in the kitchen and she was standing on the windowsill of the kitchen. I forget her name, Francesca, I think. I said, Francesca?
On the windowsill, right, one meter 30 above the ground. I said, what’s happening? And she looked at me and she said, I’m a bird. Then, obviously, something was seriously wrong. And we learned she had been practicing a tantra on the side based on Arthur Avalon’s books without consulting anyone.
She was interned in a mental asylum for, I think it was more than one year. The cook left, obviously, wanted to be close to the place she was interned in. I’ve seen many such cases, you know. So once you start working with your own mind, you’re working with a delicate tool. Then the great Buddhist meditation tradition has 2,500 years of experience with this, and a good practitioner, a good teacher has personal experience as well.
Then if you follow their advice, you won’t just be banging around. Right? If you don’t follow their advice, can cause damage. Then it’s really silly to attend teachings, to put effort, and to end up worse off than when one started. That is really silly.
I want to be much better off going to the beach and having fun. So please, you know, because I’ve seen this many times. It’s a it’s a western problem, you know, to sort of go fishing around and create one’s own little private soup, you know, and then there are problems, and these people they come to Tibetan teachers, I have to translate when they’re there, you know, and sometimes the teacher has enough power to heal them, but it’s basically like Penor Rinpoche would heal Westerners, the great Nyingma lama, Namkha Drimed, you know. Sometimes nothing can be done, know. So it’s calm abiding for instance, it’s a very very safe process of meditation if you do it by the book, And if you’ve lost a transmission, as Mandy was saying, it is viewed in Thailand as dangerous and not to be touched.
So you’re very lucky in this tradition, a very strong tradition of practice of calm abiding, it’s clearly explained, there are no risks, you know, And stick to these simple, clear practices which are powerful when explained. And thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- dzogchen
- Literally "Great Perfection", the practice to attain the mind's natural, primordial state. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.