Tenets — 2014-06-17

2 h 1 min · 2,665 words · 17 June 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets — 2014-06-17
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 121-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche introduces tenets (drubta), the foundational Buddhist system of realization that stabilizes understanding on the path to liberation. He clarifies what tenets are (definitions and divisions within doctrinal systems), who propounds them (committed practitioners), and how they function in Buddhist philosophy. Breaking down the Tibetan etymology, he explains that realizing tenets means understanding the basis (the two truths), the path (compassion and wisdom), and the result (the two bodies of a Buddha)—with nothing beyond this framework. His core teaching centers on what it means to assert Buddhist tenets: one must accept the triple gem as refuge and, most crucially, recognize the Dharma itself as the actual antidote to suffering. The session closes with interactive Q&A and paired debate, the traditional monastic method for stabilizing philosophical understanding.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-06-17 – KR.mp3

UUID: 39c7d3ea-4988-4753-bc91-f969d11720ea

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Tenets

Date: 2014-06-17

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,670

As usual, we will generate the motivation to receive these teachings. So the term tenets, drubta in Tibetan, is understood by some as what is ultimate or one’s method of view. Others understand it as the system of Dharma. So one must distinguish between tenets, propounders of tenets, and transforming the mind through tenets. Tenets are a series of distinctions and divisions.

Propounders of tenets are persons or living beings. Regarding the function of tenets, the function of tenets is to differentiate elements of texts, not necessarily Buddhist texts. There are tenets of non-Buddhist systems. So regarding what is understood by tenets, it is not necessarily the case that tenets or one’s system of views is necessarily related to Dharma. If we take the case of the materialists of ancient India, the or the, clearly, they had tenets, but just as clearly, these had no relation to a dharma as we understand it.

Then as to a person who is a propounder of tenets, this cannot be measured purely by the tenet system. Then, if we analyze the etymology of the term tenets in Tibetan, drupta. Drubta has two syllables, Drub and Ta. The first syllable Drub refers to realization, realization of what? Realization of the system of tenets of whatever scriptural system one relies upon.

Through reasoning, through analysis, one investigates the scriptural system and one investigates the quotes up to their source. This is the meaning of the first syllable of drubta, drub, to realize. The second syllable ta in Tibetan means boundary. Here, it refers to the fact that there is nothing beyond this view. This view is the boundary.

Tenets can be understood from the standpoint of the view. And they are rather closely linked, in my opinion, to the topic of mind and mental factors which we covered in Warwick, albeit mind and mental factors are a presentation largely from the standpoint of experience. Not only are there Buddhist systems of tenets, there are non-Buddhist systems of tenets. For that matter, I suspect that one can speak of scientific tenets. I suspect there are tenets which underlie contemporary science.

Then when one speaks of tenets, one is actually referring to one’s own system. And the understanding one has of one’s own system must be stable. Then it is important in life to have one’s own system of tenets, literally one’s own outlook. If one does, one is a stable person. Otherwise, as the Tibetan expression goes, one is like a cow which is led around through the hook in its nose.

Then it is important to be a person who is a pro pounder of tenets. And for this, one must have tenets, one pro pounds. Then within our own presentation of tenets, in as much as tenets are postulated from the standpoint of the view, homage is paid to Ārya Mañjuśrī. And then the topic is subdivided into definitions, subdivisions, and the classifications, the meaning of the classifications. And we shall at present begin to present the establishment of the Buddhist view.

Generally speaking, there are a finite number of tenet system. It would be marvelous to present them all, but difficult. Realization of the Buddhist view is contingent on the features, in other words, the uncommon features of the Buddhist view. Generally speaking, the Buddhist teachings are subdivided into the method component of the path, which involves the presentation, for instance, of love and compassion, and the wisdom component of the path. And these uncommon features of the Buddhist view are part of the wisdom component of the path.

As Jetsün Chögyi Gyaltsab says, even though one has realized both definite emergence and bodhicitta, since it is impossible to sever the root of cyclic existence through them, put effort into realization of interdependence. This underlines the importance of the view. The differentiation of Buddhist tenets is fourfold. There are four schools of tenets, and they are presented from the Coarser to the Subtler Schools of Tenets. Now one should put special effort in this.

So on page two of your presentation of tenets, regarding the first, the definition of a person asserting tenets, excuse me, regarding the first, the definition of a person asserting Buddhist tenets is a person who accepts completely the triple gem as a place of refuge and asserts tenets which disagree with places of refuge other than these. This is a very profound definition, which we shall analyze in detail. Page two, middle of page two. The triple gem in the definition refers to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. In this context, the Buddha gem refers to the enlightened beings from Buddha Śākyamūni himself all the way down to one’s root guru.

The Dharma gem is the actual refuge. It is what actually protects us from suffering. Whereas the Sangha gem at present is one which we do not experience as fully characterized, but we experience an approximate Sangha gem. And the first section of this definition, a person who accepts completely the triple gem as a place of refuge is particularly profound since it intimates that such a person must accept completely the actual refuge, which is the Dharma. In this context, as is said, it is oneself who should protect oneself and not others.

And there is another famous quote in this matter which says, I have taught you the Dharma. Use the Dharma to attain your own liberation. Specifically, when it is said that the Dharma is the actual refuge, what is meant by this is that it is through the Dharma that it is possible to counter the afflictions which one’s mind is to be liberated from. It is extremely important and beneficial for us to understand the Dharma, which is the actual refuge here, as what enables the mind whose nature is clear light to be directed towards the mental factors of virtue, as opposed to being directed towards the mental factors of non-virtue. Indeed, the mind’s nature is stable, but it is mental factors which are virtuous or non virtuous which inflect it in one direction or the other.

Otherwise, if we understand by dharma, something which is related to the fully omniscient beings, this is not germane to us. It is much more helpful to understand as Dharma, something which can affect and transform our own mind. In my opinion, therefore, within the definition of a person asserting Buddhist tenets, Someone who accepts completely the triple gem as a place of refuge is someone who accepts completely the Dharma as a place of refuge. This is how it must be understood. If one understands it differently, there is a risk that this definition will subdivide into three.

Instead, what I would propose is that one understand it as stating that one’s goal is the attainment of ārya buddhahood. With the attainment of ārya buddhahood, we have the attainment of buddhahood, therefore, of the buddha jewel. And in addition, as we are ārya beings, we have become the Sangha jewel as well. This is therefore how I suggest that we understand a person who completely accepts a triple gem as a place of refuge. The interpretation of the second part of the definition and asserts tenets which disagree with places of refuge other than these refers to the fact that once one is a propounder of Buddhist tenets, one’s goal is to eliminate the root of the afflictions, the apprehension of a truly existent self.

That which counters the apprehension of a truly existent self is selflessness or emptiness. In keeping with the line in the three principles of the of the of the path, therefore put effort in the realization of selflessness. This is therefore the position one should adopt and one rejects all other positions. And the final part of the definition with places of refuge other than these refers to accepting places of refuge other than a presentation of the basis of the path and of the result in accordance with Buddhist scriptures. In this context, the basis is a presentation of the two truths, obscure or conventional truths and ultimate truths.

The path is a presentation of method and wisdom, method including both love and compassion, whereas wisdom refers to the wisdom realizing selflessness, and the result refers to the attainment of the two bodies, the rupakaya and the dharmakaya. So how do we understand drupta, tenets, in terms of basis of path and of result? The first syllable of tenets, drup, to realize, refers to a realization of the basis, the two truths, the path, method and wisdom, and the result, the two bodies after a thorough analysis of the various presentations of basis, path and result in the various schools of Buddhist tenets. The second syllable ta, boundary in Tibetan, refers to the understanding that there is nothing beyond this presentation of basis, path and results. Therefore, if we analyze summarum, the definition of a person asserting Buddhist tenets, it is twofold.

This is a person who accepts completely the triple gem as a place of refuge. And the second component, and who asserts tenets which disagree with places of refuge other than these. The first part of the definition, a person who accepts completely the triple gem as a place of refuge, refers to a person who identifies as the crux of the triple gem, the Dharma, and takes the Dharma as their focus. The second part of the definition and asserts tenets which disagree with places of refuge other than these refers to a person who understands that the only possible antidote to the delusions is the realization of selflessness and does not search for any other form of wisdom. This is how Tenet’s Drupta is to be understood.

One realizes and one understands that there is nothing beyond the tenet systems one has accepted. There are the first three topics which I would like to remind you of from today’s teaching. The first is the concept of tenets. The second is the definition of Buddhist tenets. The third is the purpose of identifying tenets.

Then we will at present have a session of question and answers. I will take a couple good questions. And after this, you will pair off by groups of two, not more than two, and discuss with each other the topics which are covered today, specifically these three topics. This is akin to debate. This is what is used in the monasteries.

It is extremely important because it leads to a stabilization of one’s viewpoint. This is a very good opportunity to do this because otherwise, if we don’t, you will forget the material. After all, you do do live far away. It’s a long way to home. It will be gone from your minds.

It’s different in the monasteries, we live all together, but you all live far away from each other, then by the time you get home, you will have forgotten everything. So at present, I will take a couple brief questions. And after that, we will start the debate. Amala, Natalie. In relation to the triple gem, Geshe-la said that we experience in terms of the Sangha gem we experience an approximation of this gem.

Is he referring to us here in the West or just in this actual time? Then, generally speaking the Sangha are the helpers which enable us to gain liberation from cyclic existence, they are therefore necessary. And in the context of a proximate literally a factually concordant Sangha, what is referred to is a substitute for the Sangha. Does that answer your question? So I said, Geshe-la, probably you feel that only that if someone is ordained, he is a Sangha jewel.

This is not the case, right? A Sangha jewel is only an Ārya being. Ordinary monks are not the Sangha jewel, right? He says it’s okay. If you want to view only monks as the Sangha jewel, it’s okay.

It’s acceptable. I see all my brothers and sisters here as Sangha Jewel and Tenzin as Sangha Jewel because they’re all helping me. They’re all what? They’re all helping me. It’s alright to view as Sangha jewel people who don’t interfere with your Dharma practice.

It’s alright. It’s not a mistake. But the most important is to identify the Dharma jewel. So the teacher of the Dharma is the Buddha. The actual excuse me, the teacher of the the refuge is the Buddha.

The actual refuge is the Dharma. So this will be debated about. Many people hold a position that they don’t necessarily follow through to its logical conclusion like scientists, some scientists and so forth. Would that classify as a propounder of tenets, People who just say, I think this and I think that. Would that qualify for the definition of propounder or is it somebody who is very clear about their position and asserts say a materialist view?

You could posit such people as the proponents of tenets. I mean, they don’t lead their tenets to their logical conclusions. And another another question. Doctor, we have heard boundary as in there’s nothing beyond. Is that mean related to is that the same meaning as a state of no more learning?

As in a normal learning as in the state of arhat. Arhat. You know, nothing beyond It’s an excellent question. Actually, it doesn’t refer to the sense of there is nothing beyond this in the etymology of the ārya or noble being, instead it means that for oneself, when one has endorsed a tenet system, one believes that there is nothing beyond this tenet system for oneself. That’s the meaning.

Do you understand? Earlier, I believe Geshe-la said that there are an infinite number of tenets in Buddhism. In Buddhism, I don’t know. No, not in Buddhism. Okay, so it’s really I’m clarifying that.

So it was not an infinite number of tenets in Buddhism, it’s just an infinite number of tenets. So, there are four tenet systems in Buddhism. These are subdivided into multiple tenet systems, but they are not numberless or measureless. However, there are measureless tenet systems in India among the non-Buddhist tenet systems. Within the sevenfold division of modes, a person who has conviction would by this definition not qualify as a person asserting Buddhist tenets because they haven’t, they don’t accept completely or haven’t followed through fully.

Conviction in what? In the triple gem, as to qualify for a person asserting Buddhist tenets. So a a proponent of Buddhist tenets is someone who actually knows Buddhist tenets, understands Buddhist tenets. There are countless persons who have faith in Buddhist tenets. They don’t qualify.

Then we will stop here for the questions. So pair off by two, please. And the topics of debate, as we should have said, are what tenets are, what Buddhist tenets are, what it means to be a propounder of tenets, and briefly what the triple gem is. The triple gem. What is it?

The triple gem. No. It’s difficult if it’s too long, but things went very well, Geshe-la says. Are you tight? Yes.

Tight? No. I’m tight. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Very important. It’s very important to engage in these discussions later on when you reflect on your systems of tenets, the understanding will arise with no difficulty at all. Then we have cases in the great monasteries of monks who never forget their tenet systems and the details of their tenet systems. This is the result of a tremendous accumulation of merit in past lives and we hope to see this among you at So do you have within your mind the wish to improve your studies?

100%. Good, good. Very good. Good. Very Some of you understand.

[unclear]. Yeah. Very, very good. Very good. 100%.

Then write down your questions, and Geshe-la will answer them next week. There’s a puja on Saturday at five for those interested. Thank you. Five 05:00? Oh, Sunday.

Sunday. Sunday. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
tenet system drubtha(Tib)
A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
two bodies of a buddha sang gye kyis ku nyi (Tib)
The truth body or dharmakaya, the result of the wisdom side of the practice and the form body or rupakaya, the result of the method side of the practice. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top