Awakening Heart — 2014-06-14

2 h 35 min · 20,561 words · 14 June 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
The Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2014-06-14
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 155-minute teaching, Ilia Durovic examines bodhicitta—the heart of Mahāyāna Buddhism—through rigorous philosophical analysis and practical meditation instruction. He opens with a sharp challenge: before practicing bodhicitta, you must honestly examine whether reincarnation, suffering in cyclic existence, and the possibility of enlightenment are real to you, not merely intellectual abstractions. Durovic walks through the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta (equanimity, recognizing all beings as mothers, recollecting their kindness, developing love and great compassion, wholehearted resolve, and bodhicitta itself) and the complementary lineage of equalizing and interchanging self with others. He grounds the teaching with Ian Stevenson’s verified cases of reincarnation and neuroscience research on compassion meditation, then covers the critical distinction between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna practice: both cultivate love and compassion, but only Mahāyāna practitioners commit themselves wholly to attaining enlightenment for the sake of all beings. The core instruction is incremental: meditation on real individuals, not abstract beings, and honest self-examination of one’s actual motivation before each practice. Pitched at serious practitioners willing to question their assumptions and align their spiritual ambitions with examined conviction.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-06-14 – KR.mp3

UUID: e70c2402-01d8-412b-9cf9-81a31133bc85

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2014-06-14

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~20,563

A very warm welcome on this chilly day to Tibetan Buddhist Institute and to another of the very informative and challenging conferences/seminars with Ilya Djurovic. I’m sure that everybody here knows who Ilya is. As I often say we are very privileged to have Ilya’s bifocal view having been ordained in the Tibetan tradition at Sera and being an independent scholar in the West, Ilya is able to bring to us a unique Western understanding of these ancient teachings which are relevant to us in the modern world moment by moment. And of course the topic today being bodhicitta is at the heart of what this centre is all about. So we will be having a short break, tea break, part way through.

I think you all know where the facilities are through the kitchen and thank you for your kind donation of a few dollars, dollars 8 non members, 5, just to help for members, just to help with the running of the center. So without any further ado, it’s my great privilege to hand you over to Elliot. Thank you. Thank you very much. Then as the weather is cold, it’s very appropriate that we deal with the topic of developing a warm heart.

And I would assess your development and compassion as a necessity for heating. So if all of us develop a very warm heart, we can turn the heater off. But for the time being, we’ll talk about the theory. Chris put it very nicely. bodhicitta is very much at the center of what this center is all about, and it is the very inner core of all of the Tibetan Buddhist traditions, all the Mahāyāna traditions.

But in many respects, Tibetan Buddhism is perhaps to this day the most complete Mahāyāna tradition. Then I wanted to cover this topic in two parts. Last time we covered, if you wish, the theory. You cannot develop something without knowing what it is. So we talked about bodhicitta, and I will try to recapitulate what was said last time as briefly as possible.

In a nutshell, there’s no better definition of bodhicitta than that given by Maitreya. bodhicitta is the wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of others. Thank you very much. This is perhaps the one verse every monk of the three seats knows. There’s really nothing to add.

So in a sense, you could take those two lines and go and meditate for twenty, thirty years in a cave, and your life would be very well spent. Different items at the monastery would memorize the entire treatise, but those two lines are the essence. And then, obviously, once you understand the bodhicitta, the bodhicitta referred to here is conventional bodhicitta, the wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of others, others being every conscious being, in other words, every sentient being. Then one studies the various subdivisions of bodhicitta. Conventional or ultimate bodhicitta.

So conventional bodhicitta is what we referred to just now. Ultimate bodhicitta is the realization of emptiness, the direct realization of emptiness in the mind of a bodhisattva, a being who has, in other words, generated conventional bodhicitta. Then we have, as I mentioned last time, longing and engaging bodhicitta. Longing bodhicitta is a wish to engage in this practice. Engaging bodhicitta is a committed approach of the bodhisattva, who, based on this wish, practices for what amounts to an infinite amount of time, its sweet countless eons, the six perfections.

And then last time I mentioned some more refined divisions of bodhicitta, which are more poetic, but which I find very helpful for practice, such as the two divisions of bodhicitta given by Maitreya. It’s a very little bit of this issue of the generation of bodhicitta. But I went yesterday on a on a drive with my wife to the Lobosol to get some items for my wood heater. And it was very helpful the driver was very helpful to to for today’s conference. Because as I was driving in the Australian countryside, I suddenly realized just how alien all of this must sound to you.

There’s nothing in Australia or Australian culture which bridges the gap between what we teach here and where you are in society. Absolutely nothing at all. And then, obviously, my task is to present Buddhist philosophy and the Buddhist teachings, but I’ve tried to bridge the gap with contemporary culture. And really, I think for these presentations and the teachings here at the center to be of benefit to you, you have to ask the really difficult questions, and you have to have the courage to come up with your own answers even if they are uncomfortable answers. So when it comes to bodhicitta, the entire concept of bodhicitta hinges on past and future lives.

If you don’t accept past and future lives, then you have seen you cannot train life after life for others, and why would you of any way? It also hinges on the Buddhist concept of saṃsāra, which means a cycle of one’s own past and future lives, which are actually profoundly unpleasant. Again, you really have to ask yourself if this is true or not. And you must have the courage to say no if you really think it’s not true. Otherwise, the practice is never gonna impact your mind.

And then after this, obviously, the very difficult question is, if we take for granted that we are reincarnating beginninglessly, and that overall, it’s an awful state of affairs, Is there a way out? There’s absolutely no guarantee if you are trapped in a prison that there is any way out apart from your death. So you have to ask yourself, is there a way out? And is this way out something which I realistically can practice or not? Now if there isn’t, which is for instance a position of many ancient schools of Indian philosophy, which said, yes, there is such a thing as reincarnation.

It’s basically a ghastly state of affairs, but there’s nothing we can do about it, so we stop there. That’s a rational position. So you have to see, is there a way out? Is what is taught by all of the other Indian schools of philosophy, the distance of your liberation from the suffering of cyclic existence, is this true? Or is it just a fantasy?

Because again, a human life is a very short affair. So if what is being presented, for instance, in Buddhist philosophy here is just one of the viewpoints of some particular Asian nation, I would put it to you, you have better things to do with your time. And I actually have better things to do with my time as well. So the question of whether this is all true or not, you must ask yourself and you must answer. And it can’t be a wishy-washy answer.

Yes, it’s probably true because my teachers say so and after all, the center’s very present. I don’t want to be told I can’t come anymore. What would I do with my spare time and my Saturdays if there was nothing, you know, here? So this is of no benefit to you, and frankly, it’s no benefit to the spread of authentic Buddhist teachings in the West. So these questions of truth, you must ask.

When it comes to bodhicitta, these are particularly powerful questions because you have to ask yourself, is such a thing as bodhicitta possible? I mean, is it actually possible to be totally selfless, to practically practice exclusively for others? And is someone who is aiming for full enlightenment exclusively for others practicing something realistic, or is this someone who is profoundly deluded and who is trying to attain something impossible and therefore wasting his time? So these are questions you have to ask yourself. And for this, you have to ask, once you have established to your own satisfaction that reincarnation is a reality, that reincarnation is basically an unpleasant state of affairs, and that you yourself want out, that others are very want out, and that there is a way out.

And within these way outs, there are two options. The egotistical and the altruistic option. The egotistical option is liberation, which for a large part of my life I felt was a realistic option. And the altruistic option is for enlightenment. Now you have to ask yourself if both of these options are realistic and which one deep down within yourself you want to attain.

We’re not talking of what’s happening up here, we’re talking of experiences which occur not even in the heart, but at the level of the gut. Now you can and I remember I used to try to identify people who were of the Mahāyāna type when I was in India. It is true that there are people of the Mahāyāna type, and there are people of the Mahāyāna type. Within the Sangha, it’s very clear. I remember once I sponsored an excursion, a pilgrimage actually, to a mountain circuit to a hermitage, close to Sera Monastery, which had a big group of western monks.

So we all went there, and it’s quite a quite a hike. You have to go up and up and up and up and up. And one of our monks had asthma. So basically, at the level of the first third, he started struggling. A little respirator, but he just couldn’t make it.

And we had, in our group, two monks who forged ahead and one who stood behind. Then looking back on it, thought, yes. It was clear to me at that point that with those three monks, you could see that of the two who forged ahead, they had the Hīnayāna lineage. The Hīnayāna karmic imprints were powerful. Their goal was their own liberation.

The rest was basically lip service. And perhaps the one who stayed behind might have had the Mahāyāna type, since the focus was more on others. This is something which is deep inside us. You will not know it by coming to the center, and you will not know it by volunteering. If you’re fortunate in your life to experience deeply stressful experiences, it’s at that moment it will come out.

Your karmic background will come out, and it is something we have to work with. So this is a predicate I wanted to give to you. Reflect carefully by yourselves. Is all of this possible? Is bodhicitta possible?

If bodhicitta is possible, there must have been bodhisattvas in the path. Who were these bodhisattvas? You must be able to give examples. So look at history. Are there millions in history who would qualify?

bodhicitta is not a small thing. Is there really such a thing as full enlightenment, or is it an Indian myth? Like the myth of salvation in the West. If there is such a thing as full enlightenment, who is fully enlightened? And then do we ourselves want to reach that stage or not?

It’s perfectly legitimate not to go that route. You’re perfectly entitled not to want to be fully enlightened, not to want to be liberated. Actually, like many Asians, to subscribe to past and future lives, but to have no particular intent of making any effort to for getting a higher rebirth. So these teachings must be tested against reality. It’s precisely because this test against reality has not been occurring that our Western Buddhist community remains very unstable.

Becoming a Western Buddhist amounts to acquiring a philosophical system, some sort of structure, and there is tremendous intellectual excitement in this. One is basically exposed to different viewpoints, one debates, one analyzes, and one does see with such students that as soon as the effect of novelty decreases, they will leave. It has been an intellectual experience. It has not been an existential experience. Intellectual experiences are a dime a dozen.

You might study art history, you might study physics. These are intellectual experiences, but I’m not sure if it’s just an intellectual experience that what we offer here is useful to you. If it’s something which can transform your life, then it is. So this conference only would make sense to you if you believe in the existence of cyclic existence, karma and causality, you really believe there is full enlightenment and someone has attained it, and you yourself would like to attain it. Then this conference would be meaningful.

Otherwise, it would be a presentation of Buddhist philosophy, and I could have given it at the University of Adelaide, which I don’t do because it’s completely useless, basically. Why is bodhicitta so critical? bodhicitta is so critical because as Je Tsongkhapa’s disciple Namka Pel said, it is the criterion of being a Mahāyāna practitioner. It is really what differentiates Mahāyāna from Hīnayāna practitioners. And what is very particular about bodhicitta is that it is a motivation.

It’s an intention. It is not related to the wisdom aspect of the path. And here, I would like to represent what I presented last time about intention and motivation and talk with you a little bit about what an intention is. This is very alien to us Westerners. We assess deeds in function of their results, and we get caught in the quandaries of the result versus the means.

We all know the expression, the end justifies the means, which is adopted by the cynics and the brutes, basically, of all societies. It is a corridor which does not arise in the Buddhist context precisely because in the Buddhist context, it is the intention underlying the deed, which is the ethical base on which the deed is assessed. And that intention is opaque. From the outside, we have no way of assessing the intention of another person. It’s impossible.

We can try to reduce it from their behavior, but that is not certain. And the intention is and in addition opaque to the person themselves. The Christians have a very strong tradition of what the French call, the examination of one’s own consciousness, which is something we could learn a lot from because it is this attempt to delve into the other or deeper parts of one’s being to see what really is going on. It is this we must engage in to try to find our intention. And it is only when we have assessed the actual intention that we can then try to transform it.

But if we are unrealistic about our actual intention, it’s impossible to transform it. If, for instance, we think we are profoundly idealistic and working for the benefit of others, and deep down, we’re basically adding brownie points to our curriculum vitae, then we are profoundly unrealistic about our motivation. So when it comes to motivation, most of the motivations we have are spontaneous. It’s something we are oblivious to. They are conditioned by karma and by the society we are born in.

But it is possible to generate artificially a motivation. And the meditation’s goal is to generate artificially a worthy motivation. And there are specific ways to do it. If one does it by the book, I can really vouch for the fact it’s been thirty years now. I can vouch for the fact it works.

If one doesn’t do it by the book, it either doesn’t work or doesn’t work well. So a contrived motivation generating a contrived motivation is a painful process. It is akin to hammering a piece of iron into shape. The iron, in other words, mind resists every single inch of the way. You must put effort and you must know how to wield a hammer.

The hammer is meditation. The iron is the mind. The key to transforming in motivation, to generating an artificial motivation, which is better than what we are stuck with at present, is that it can only be done step by step incrementally, and it can only be done through going from one motivation to the one immediately above it. You cannot jump. You cannot make big leaps.

If you make big leaps, you will not generate a solid contrived motivation. So clearly, if you want to generate a contrived motivation, it is like walking. You must know where you are at present. In this course for self examination, you must examine your actual motivation. For instance, if we take today’s teaching, why did you come?

Now perhaps the official motivation was I came because I wanted to learn more about bodhicitta. Then that may or may not be the true motivation. You must dig and be comfortable with facing unpleasantness. It could be you came because frankly, you had nothing to do this afternoon. Right?

Or it could be you came because you have a lot of friends here. It becomes a social event. In Asia, frequently, Buddhist centers are business meeting points. People come because they want to make contact. They come with a big deck of visit cards like this, which you pass around, you know, which gives you credibility.

If you’re Buddhist, you’re an honest person. Then for yourself, you must find this motivation within yourself. Let’s say you came because you’re a bit bored, and it’s always pleasant at TBI, and the tea is good, at least when TENSIVE makes it. Then I think we can all agree this is a fairly mundane motivation. Right?

So first you have to establish that that’s where you stand. That’s who you are. Then if you want to improve your motivation, you start with that. And all the which is taught here is just a way of changing your motivation. Once you’ve established that you’re here for the tea, then the next step is to try to move beyond the tea.

Right? So let’s assume that your main attachment is tea. Right? You would meditate on the unpleasantness of tea. If your main attachment were people, right, you were here to make friends.

You would meditate on the fact that friendship is illusory, unstable. If your main reason for being here is that you were lonely, then you would meditate on the fact that, eventually, at the time of your death, you will be alone. Nobody from the center will be with you. Then you start changing that base motivation into something better, but you must progress incrementally. And therefore, an actual contrived motivation can only be generated incrementally.

It is a very long process. We are talking of years. If at the end of one’s life, one’s motivation has swift switched from something mundane to, let’s say, the motivation of the being of the small scope, this is a very big thing. This is not something which is easy to do. It’s nice that Dalai Lama mentioned the story of a he’s a kamakagyu practitioner, kagyu monk.

I’ve never met him. I know of him. Who spent it was almost sixty years trying to meditate on compassion. And at the end of his life, when he met his holiness, he said that there had been some progress. And his holiness was delighted.

And this is a well spent life, and this is realistic. Most of what we propose in the sentence is not realistic. It’s not realistic to propose tantric practice at the level we are at at present. We present the totality of the path. But realistic practice is practice where you take yourself as a standard, and you try to improve your situation from where you are, and it takes time.

So the goal is to move from this painful process where each time before you engage in a deed, you must generate the motivation, and you must do it by the book. The stages of the being of the small, of the middling, of the great scope. If you want to generate a good motivation to practice, you have to do an overview meditation of the Lamrim, which is a painful process. Once you’re familiar enough with the Lamrim, it’ll take you ten minutes. When I practice my sadhanas at home, I take ten to fifteen minutes to establish the motivation.

The sādhana is less important than the motivation. Much less, actually. So instead of this, our goal is this. A vast river which naturally flows. This is a spontaneous motivation, and the motivation of a bodhisattva is characterized by this.

It is not just spontaneous, it is powerful. Like a vast river flowing into a delta. Such a motivation is no longer generated artificially, but it had to be generated artificially for years, in the case of bodhicitta, lives. It does not arise within one life if there’s been no prior training. Now what are the differences between contrived and spontaneous motivations?

As far as Dharma practice is concerned, this is where we stand. Our motivations are contrived. We must generate them again and again before each practice we engage in. If that motivation is not generated, whatever so called deed you engage in will not lead to corresponding karmic consequences. For instance, if you, let us say, an example which we talked to one of our friends here, you abstain from a defrauding Centrelink out of fear of getting caught.

Right? Then this does not even enter the spiritual path. This is fear of the police and the law. You at the level of the worldly motivation. You may be a law abiding citizen, but not more than that.

If you don’t defraud Centrelink and claim benefits you’re not entitled to, actually because you’re afraid of karmic consequences in future lives, you have begun to be a Buddhist practitioner. Right? That’s a bit of a small scope. If it’s sincere, then you don’t think of the police, you think of the fact that you will suffer from poverty in future lives, from what amounts to theft. Right?

Defrauding central link is theft. You know? Then if you don’t defraud Centrelink because you want to attain liberation, and this interferes with attaining liberation, you are definitely being of the leading path. I don’t know anyone in that category already. And if you don’t defraud Centrelink because you think, if I defraud Centrelink and others defraud Centrelink, then eventually people who really need help will suffer.

Then that is the beginning of a Mahāyāna motivation. You’re not trying not to claim benefits or money you’re not entitled to, which is theft. Right? We all agree. It’s a theft widely practiced in Australia.

But you’re not doing this out of concern for others. Then that is a Mahāyāna motivation. Then in our state at present, as far as Dharma is concerned, we have no spontaneous motivation. At least no spontaneous motivation of a dharma nature. In our ordinary deeds in life, we have almost exclusively spontaneous motivations.

We are unaware of our motivation. We come to the center, we don’t really know why, we don’t examine the motivation. We meet people we don’t really know why, we engage in business we don’t really know why. If the motivation is examined, generally speaking, it is fairly ugly. It’s not very nice.

And therefore, our goal is to start by training with contrived motivations in the dharma context to give rise to spontaneous motivations in the dharma context, and in the worldly context to examine our motivation constantly. Now this calls for a very powerful development of vigilance. Part and you’d excuse me for the example, but part of your mind must be like the ASIO. Right? So your mind is a battlefield of terrorism.

And there’s part of your mind here which is checking. Checking and spying on the rest of your mind to see what the motivation is, what are they up to. And if they’re up to no good, you counter and you transform. This is vigilance. So 90% of your mind is engaged in whatever activities you engage in.

And in daily life, not just in calm abiding meditation, 10% of your mind checks, why am I doing this? And it doesn’t satisfy itself with casual answers. You’re like an interrogator. You put the mind on the chair, you put the lamp on, and you start asking the hard questions. You know?

This is of great benefit for one’s inner development. Then perhaps the first time you do this, would experience a fair bit of depression. Because what comes out is not always very nice, but it actually is the way we are. We have to work with who we are. And then on that basis, we can progress upwards.

So this is what Je Tsongkhapa refers to in the context of renunciation when he says, when through meditation, in other words, the practice of generating a contrived meditation, that’s what we’re talking about, not even one instant of longing for the marvels of cyclic existence arises. And the marvels of cyclic existence are basically everything. Right? Money, women, cars, jobs, whatever passport you want to have, trips to Bali, etcetera. That’s the marvels of cyclic existence.

Well, not even one instant of longing for that arises, and day and night, the mind striving for liberation arises. In other words, it arises spontaneously in your dreams as well. When you’re dreaming and you see a beautiful landscape, a feeling of disgust arises. Then truly, you have generated a spontaneous renunciation. Right?

Now you can extend this to bodhicitta. This is what a spontaneous motivation is. Then I would like to show you that these things are possible. And there is a fair bit of data now from biology, which shows clearly that there are transformations within the actual brain structure associated with compassion meditation. We don’t have time to do a lot about this.

I talked about it two years ago, I think. It’s professor Davidson from the University of Wisconsin who’s doing most of the work in this field. He was a secret student of his holiness when he was at Harvard, and he was basically told by his thesis director that if he was planning on getting tenure, he might want to turn down the Buddhist aspect of his life, which he did. And it’s just a couple of years ago that having attained tenure at the University of Wisconsin, being well established, he felt he could come back out in the open some thirty years later, basically. And he started doing research in the effect of Buddhist meditation, empathy meditation on the brain.

Now what is striking is that he found that there are actual transformations of the brain structure, specifically very powerful activation of an area called the insula, which is related with empathy. In those Lojong practitioners of compassion meditation. And Lojong here means practitioners who have in excess of ten thousand hours of meditation, which corresponds to some twenty, thirty years of regular meditation. This is what one is talking about, to transform the mind in-depth. Now, this work is well known.

This research started to come out some fifteen years ago. It ties in quite nicely with what is known as neuroplasticity, the transformation of the brain structure in function of the thought patterns. What it does show, I think undeniably, is that Buddhist meditations the existence of Buddhist meditations work. There’s no debate now. We have clear evidence.

It does not show that the mind is nonmaterial. That’s a completely different issue. But for a long time, his holiness the Dalai Lama and other scientists felt that the potential for empathy was specific to vertebrates. Clearly, if we want to develop something like bodhicitta, we must start with something which is already there because otherwise, we have nothing to work with. And the something which is already there is a feeling of empathy or kinship we have with other members of our species, and within the family, the feeling of closeness to a member of our family.

So it was thought for a long time this was exclusive to vertebrates and specifically to mammals. And there were some rather appalling experiments done in the nineteen fifties and sixties to demonstrate the scale of empathy within mice. Then it makes rather for rather horrible reading, but what it clearly shows is the level to which empathy is profoundly ingrained within the very being of the mice, who respond with great terror at the electric shocks inflicted on another mouse, and eventually, withdraw in a complete state of shock. But what is striking is that now there is, and this is just basically this year, clear evidence of empathy among insects. Then the author of the study, Karen Hollis, who’s professor of psychology in The States, had to tread very, very carefully with this one because you could probably torpedo your academic career if you claimed that insects showed true empathy.

But what she found was that a particular species of ant showed very clear, altruistic, and empathetic behavior towards ants which were trapped in a web or under sand. Some of this behavior is known. It is known has been known that ants will, for instance, pull other ants out of a trap by their limbs. But this was much more extreme than that. Professor Hollis set up the experiment in such a way that the ants were trapped by a web, and the ants wishing to rescue them actually had to try to cut the limbs of the web to pull imprisoned ants out, which they did.

And you can see here, it is really quite haunting. The so called rescue behavior is well known, but what is very uncommon is the degree of discrimination and effort which this species of ant engages in to help its congenerates when they are trapped. They bite and tug at the snare, and those species directed rescue exclusively towards nest mates, treating other individuals, even conspecifics, in other words, other ants of the same species with aggression, thus highlighting the ants’ discriminative capacity. This behavior, and you can see the author has to be very careful with what she says, resembles behavior that has been labeled empathy in rats. So we have clear evidence of empathy in the insect world.

Now it is the reason I introduced this, and I won’t enter too much into the mental capacities of known vertebrates. The reason I introduce this is because this is the working material with which we generate bodhicitta. If something like this is not present, we have no stuff, if you wish wish to generate bodhicitta. So now passing to the Buddhist component of this presentation. There are two lineages for the generation of bodhicitta.

The lineage of Nāgārjuna to the right, and the lineage of Ārya Maitreya to the left. They were eventually fused in Tibet to create one lineage with a particularly sophisticated way of generating bodhicitta. Now as you remember, we talked at the beginning of this presentation of the fact that if you are going to generate a motivation like bodhicitta, you must progress step by step. And which steps you follow are critical. Here we have some twenty centuries of meditative experience condensed in the method to generate bodhicitta.

Nāgārjuna lived around 150 CE of the common era in Maitreya, Bodhisattva Maitreya manifested to Asaṇga around the same period. So we have a full basically of almost twenty centuries of meditative experience into various steps needed to transform an ordinary mind like ours into something as exalted as bodhicitta. And the Tibetan Buddhist tradition is particularly careful in these matters. One only engages in the practice of something which has been transmitted in a reliable fashion. So the lineage of transmission must be known.

In this case, I haven’t listed them all. There would be approximately 15 for each lineage. But the lineage going from Maitreya passes through Asaṇga, and then through Haribhādra, and a series of Indian masters down to Atisha. And the lineage from Nāgārjuna passes from Nāgārjuna to a series of masters up to Shantideva, the author of the Bodhicaryāvatāra, then down to Vidyakokila, the elder and etcetera, to Suvarnadvipi, the great master, the Indonesian master from Sumatra. And Suvarnadvipi gave these core instructions to Atisha.

It’s in Atisha that these two lineages fused. They fused in Atisha, but he taught some publicly and others secretly. And we will talk about that a bit later. Now the way you proceed is best understood if you look at the outline of a text such as Lamrim Chenmo. You see exactly how one proceeds if one wants to transform one’s mind.

You want to develop certainty about the sequence of the stages to transform your mind. First, you show that the root of Mahāyāna is compassion. And then you try to understand that compassion is beneficial through the totality of the path. Then you understand all the other instructions in generating bodhicitta as lying either before or after compassion. They’re either causes or effects of compassion.

And then this is something which we shall see in greater detail later. But the centrality of compassion is clearly taught in works such as the Dharmasamgiti sūtra. All of the totality of the Buddhist teachings can be summarized in one teaching, and that is great compassion. So if you were to set aside all other practices and train in great compassion, you would have the essence of the Buddhist teachings. Everything else is a branch, is a corollary of this.

The wisdom aspect of the path is a corollary of this. And then as we mentioned, we have two lineages for generating bodhicitta. The seven fold causal generation of bodhicitta from Maitreya and the interchange of self and others. So I will first present the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta, which is present implicitly in the main work Maitreya transmitted to Asaṇga in a vision, the Abhisamayālamkāra. This is Asaṇga at the feet of Maitreya at the end of a twelve year meditative retreat in which he actually saw Maitreya in his true form.

We would say in the West that this basically is a mystical experience. An experience probably in an altered state of consciousness. Asaṇga had no awareness of the passage of time. And it is said that when he returned to earth from Tuśita, 50 years had passed. Personally, I read this as a meditative Samādhi, which lasted for a very long time.

And in which Asaṇga received the transmission of texts which we study to the present day. And I should point out, and it’s quite striking, that the style of the texts of Maitreya, which Asaṇga received, is completely different from that of Asaṇga. It’s very difficult to see how Asaṇga could have composed them. Asaṇga as a writer was quite prolix. He was quite verbose.

He never said in one line what could be said in 10 lines, and he never said in 10 lines what could be said in 10 pages. Now this Maitreya has exactly the opposite. Maitreya never said in one verse what could be said in one word. And it is a big problem when you study Maitreya’s texts, is that it is just so packed with meaning that you need commentaries and commentaries on the commentaries to understand them. Now what is striking is that Buddhist historians attribute Maitreya’s works to Asaṇga.

They say Asaṇga could not have traveled to Tuśita, have received these texts, etcetera, therefore he must have composed them. When you read them, it’s impossible. It’s absolutely impossible. I mean, if you wish, it’s a bit the same thing as being told that the speech by Tony Abbott is actually the work of Julia Gillard. It’s you read the speech, you know it is not possible.

It’s exactly the same thing. So what is the seven fold causal generation of bodhicitta? It is the simplest way to generate bodhicitta. It is a step by step procedure. It is a step by step procedure which assumes that you have already generated some type of renunciation.

This is where it starts. In other words, that you are at the end of the path of the being of the middling scope. Then once you are at that point, you train initially in equanimity, which is not even counted within the seven fold cause and results. And once that is achieved, you have four causes of great compassion and two results of great compassion, with the final result bodhicitta. Now this would be memorized.

And when you meditated, you could do it in one of two ways. If you are a beginner and you want to have a general overview of the path, you would meditate, let’s say, a couple minutes on each step. Until you got a sense of the step, you pass to the the next one. It’s a way of memorizing the practice. If you actually were trying to gain the experience, and this is how Pabongka Rinpoche himself meditated, This is how the great Tibetan masters meditate.

He would meditate on equanimity however long it took to generate equanimity. So this takes typically years. It doesn’t take months. What it means is you are totally equanimous, impartial, neutral towards all persons. You have neither friends nor enemies.

You have leveled the working surface. And then once after, let’s say, two years or five or ten years, depending on the person, that has been obtained, you will then pass to the next meditation, which is the most difficult one. Recognizing all beings as one’s mother, sentient beings of you all. And spend however many years it takes just doing that. There is no rush because you will take whatever realizations you have into the next life.

A one life span and one stage is one spent. Now, I cannot encourage you too much to read Lamrim Chenmo. The key points for meditative practice are scattered throughout Lamrim Chenmo. Je Tsongkhapa wrote Lamrim Chenmo for us. People who do not study, who want to try to meditate, and perhaps don’t have the possibility of having teachers, or have easy access to teachers.

And one point that Je Tsongkhapa makes in Lamrim Chenmo, which is very powerful, is why is it we know, all of us know, so many people who have been attending centers for years, been meditating on compassion for years, and who are rather often human beings? Short-tempered and difficult and temperamental. It seems to to clearly indicate the meditation is not working. Otherwise, they would have improved. So something is wrong with the practice.

And Je Tsongkhapa’s point is that when you train in any of these attitudes, impartiality, love, and compassion, you cannot use only a general object. In other words, the sort of fantasized human being or sentient being you never have never encountered in the distance. You must work with a real sentient being you know, like a human being. It could be your dog. It could be your cat.

And once you have generated let’s say you’re training in impartiality. Once you have generated impartiality towards this being, only then can you start to extend it. This is an absolutely critical point in generating motivation. It is why most of the Western practitioners I know certainly in the center seem to fail, because they’re working with this abstract being. Then they generate a feeling of strong compassion towards an abstract being, but they don’t have strong compassion towards any individual person.

There’s no benefit. Right? So as Je Tsongkhapa says, once this has occurred and you have a transformative experience, in other words, would say you experience compassion towards one being, then you split it to two, then three, then four, then eight, and then you continue like this. This is how you increase the scope of compassion. So this is perhaps the central point in meditating on generating bodhicitta, without which it is pretty much guaranteed we will fail.

So how does one generate equanimity? Equanimity is like an ocean. The waves arise, they settle, the ocean is unaffected. Someone with equanimity equanimity is totally unaffected by what happens to him or her. It is said of the Buddha that the Buddha’s attitude to two beings, the one who is offering perfumed water and the other who is slowly sawing off his arm is exactly identical.

In other words, there is perfect equanimity. Equanimity is not compatible with what we call love. What we call love is an affliction. It’s a form of possessive desire. Then by definition, the possessively desire one person and allows everyone who interferes with your possessive desire for this person, and it is threatened that this is not equanimity.

So love for one’s children, in this sense, for one’s partner, is something which will be reduced by equanimity. Once you generate equanimity, your children and the children of others are the same. Your partner is a person like every other person. And in this basis, for instance, you can see jealousy could not arise. You’ll be delighted if your children left you to find better parents, you’ll be delighted if your partner left you for a better partner.

There can be no jealousy. So how do we train equanimity? In equanimity, we start in precisely this sequence. We start by training with people we don’t care about, because we have something like equanimity towards them already. They don’t matter to us.

And once we have basically, if you wish, it’s a bit like music where you give the the la, right, the a. You settle the tone. You have this neutral tone. Then you bring those who are your friends back down to this level, and you work with your friends, and then you bring those who are your enemies up to this level. The goal here is before starting to work, in other words, creating bodhicitta, to have a perfectly plain surface.

Otherwise, if you have some of you may be a handyman. If you have a work table with pits and protruding bits, you can never do serious work with it. Your work table must be plain. Right? Likewise for a field.

And then on this basis, we can generate eventually true love, true compassion, which are not egotistical, which are not self centered. Everything we call love and compassion at present is egotistical and self centered. So we train in this sequence initially with those we are indifferent for equanimity. Then after having equanimity towards those who are indifferent to us, which is quite easy, basically, We generate equanimity towards our friends. Right?

And then towards our enemies. And eventually, we reach a point where we see everyone in the same way. Not just human beings, animals, insects, in Asia, spirits. Asians have a great fear of spirits. I say to my Asian friends, spirits are beings like us.

There’s no difference. Right? The only difference is that they are persons you don’t see. They see you, you don’t see them. You know?

So how in practice does one generate equanimity? Kamalaśīla, the great Indian master who traveled to Tibet is our source for this, specifically his Bhāvanākrama. There are two meditations. The first is about his holiness where he always teaches. All living beings are equal to us in wanting happiness and not wanting suffering.

This, if we reflect, is obvious. In this room, not one of us wants to suffer. Every one of us wants to be happy. Then we have perhaps different religions, different cultural backgrounds, but in this respect, we are completely identical. Then why should one treat one person better than the other?

All of us are the same. The second meditation is more problematical for Westerners, because it hinges on a profound belief in past and future lives. If you profoundly believe in past and future lives, and you think in this life, let’s say in my case, my best friend is Christian Orthodox monk in Switzerland and a Tibetan geshe at Sera. In the previous life, probably they were my enemies. Then I don’t have enemies, but if I had a big enemy in this life, in the previous life, he would be my friend.

Then why should I discriminate? The only difference between the enemy and the friend in this life is the moment at which I consider them. There’s no difference otherwise. Right? From this time point of this life, one is an enemy, the other is a friend.

Most of the previous life, it’s exactly the opposite. One’s a friend, the other’s an enemy. Why make a distinction? And then if you stretch this back enough in time, you wonder why make a distinction at all. Now here, clearly, and this is a rather sharp point in Lamrim Chenmo, it is not you’re not denying the existence of friendship and enmity.

You are trying to eliminate the bias. Clearly, and this is the aspect of Je Tsongkhapa’s thought which I always find very enjoyable. Je Tsongkhapa is profoundly rooted in reality. If someone has just scratched your brand new car, he is your enemy. There is no question.

Then we should have no animosity towards this person. But you cannot say that intentionally scratching your brand new car is an act of affection. And if someone has offered you a very nice piece of cake, and clearly he is your friend at that moment, But that does not mean attachment should arise. You can maintain that distinction between someone performing a benevolent deed and from what’s inside not having attachment to that person, and someone performing a malevolent deed without from inside having animosity towards that person. Then we will address the most difficult part of this conference.

Recognizing all living beings as having been one’s mother in a previous life. This is perhaps the most difficult topic to realize in all of Lamrim. It is said so by the Tibetans. It is particularly difficult for Westerners because their belief in reincarnation is fragile. And for this reason, I’m going to represent two cases I’ve presented here, which was studied by Ian Stevenson, verified cases of reincarnation.

In other words, cases of young children who remembered a previous life, and professor Ian Stevenson, who was department chairman of the department of psychiatry at my alma mater at the University of Virginia, studied these cases. He studied some 2,500 of them. He would actually interview the child and try to verify the memories to see if what the child remembered corresponded. For instance, the child remembered his life, his name in a previous life, and Stevenson would check whether indeed there was such a person. Then the names of the family members which a child remembered from a previous life, were they true or not?

The name of where he lived, was it true or not? So when these cases were confirmed, these were known as verified cases of reincarnation. And the two cases I would like to present, one before the break and one after, are of particular interest because both include memories of previous lives as an animal and as a nonhuman being. Now, I should point out that Steven Stevenson himself has made very clear that he had a bias against non human rebirth memories. I think largely because he was chairman of the department of psychiatry, his research was hugely controversial.

It was bad enough if people remembered being human beings. Forget remembering being a cricket. So you have to draw the line somewhere, and I think he drew it at this. But some of the cases with nonhuman rebirth memories, you will find the account in his footnotes. So you have to be a reader of footnotes.

The first case I would like to mention is that of Giratne, which is a Sri Lankan boy, you can see here at the bottom, who had memories of three different previous rebirths. Of the few rebirths, one was verified. It was a human rebirth, which ended in his execution. The second seems to have been a rebirth in a hell realm, and the third seems to have been a rebirth as a bird. Obviously, these two rebirths could not be verified.

Then if we look at and I’ve summarized the boy Vidjarati remember remember, this is the young boy being considered. He was born in 1947, so he’s an older gentleman at present. And in this life, he has been rejected by women. He has suffered from repeated psychotic episodes, in which he behaves like a bird and tries to make a nest with twigs. And his right arm and digit are atrophied as well as a chest muscle.

So you can see that from birth, the fingers of the right arm are atrophied, and he suffers from what is known as hypoplasia. In other words, basically an absent pectoral muscle. Now what is striking is that he has clear memories of having been his father’s brother in a previous life. A young man called Rattang Hami, who died in 1928. He has clear memories of having been betrothed and rejected by his second wife.

It is unclear, but it seems that she preferred someone else to him. And he has clear memories of murdering her. Sharpening the with which the knife, which was he murdered her, it’s a long sinuous knife. Then returning to the village to murder her, striking her with his right arm into the chest. Now you will note that it is his right arm which was atrophied, and the chest where the blow which was dealt to his betrothed, which is hypertrophied.

These seem to be karmic results of the deed of murder in this life. Then he has very clear memories of being executed on the gallows. He has clear memories of having pooches recited by the monks. And he made an oath on the gallows to his brother, who was desolate to see him die, to return to him. The next memory he has is exclusively a memory of fire.

He says, I remember being hung, and then there were flames. This may be a memory of a hell rebirth. And he has memories of being a bird and flying from tree to tree. He has no other memory of that rebirth, but, he seemed to be, according to the psychiatrist who treated him, very good at making nests. So I don’t know what the psychiatrist based himself upon, but now, clearly, this is a case where you have a human rebirth with a verified previous life as a human being, and two hypothetical lives with as in a lower rebirth, which cannot be verified.

Approximately eighteen and a half years was spent in the lower realms after the deed of murder. And you can see these may, or probably were, bekarmic maturation of murder. And in the first life, after those two lower born rebirths, you have events in the life of the person, which correspond karmically to the results of the deeds which were done in the previous life. Vijayakatay, in his first life, murdered his wife. He was rejected by women.

He murdered in a fit of tremendous anger. When anger, chronically, is generally the cause for insanity in future lives, He suffered from psychotic episodes. He struck with his right arm. It is the right arm which was atrophied. He struck his betrothed in the right part of the chest.

It is his own pectoral muscle which was atrophied. You’ll be glad to know that although when he was a teenager, as Vijayakumar, he felt that he had behaved quite correctly, and would do this again if the circumstances arose, Later on in life, his outlook changed for the better. So this is a clear case where what we have, I would say, is strong evidence of a previous rebirth as a human being. That was gathered by Stevenson. It was verified, Very clearly verified.

So Vijayakatay remembered the names of the members of the family in the previous life. The details of his rebirth in this life were encountered by the family. It was a family shame. Nothing was ever said about this uncle who had actually been a murderer, hanged on the gallows. So his family was particularly surprised when he knew details he had no access to.

Keep in mind, this is basically not an urban society. We’re in Sri Lanka, in a third world country, not a lot of documents. It seems very difficult for him to get this information. And it is not information which is to his advantage. He was not remembering the rebirth as Mary Queen of Scots.

He was remembering the rebirth as basically a jealous man who was hanged for murder, which is not what we would like to remember. Then I think we will take a break, and I will talk briefly of the next case, the case of Vanasiri Adhikari after the break. A young Sri Lankan boy who had extremely clear memories of multiple past lives, and as a result, chose to become a monk at age 12. And by age 18 was considered the mentor of most of the monks in his monastery. The very natural renunciation arose just through these memories of again and again and again repeating the same mistakes.

Then enjoy the tea. I’m told TBI’s tea is one of the best. So the next case of reincarnation I’d like to present to you in the context of our discussion about mother sentient beings is that of a young Sri Lankan boy called Vanasiri Adhikari. You can see basically his life here. He also he doesn’t make any one of us any younger.

He’s well in his fifties. In this life, very powerful karmic imprints. Vegetarian, a deep wish to become a monk as a child, and my mistake I said 12 years old, even at the age of 16. As a child, clear memories of a series of previous lives. He clearly remembers being first a dental mechanic at an unspecified period of time, near Colombo, the capital of Sri Lanka, injuring his finger while grinding teeth and dying in a boating accident.

This is an unverified rebirth. Then he has clear memories of a verified rebirth, in other words, Stevenson found the person and verified that the events in that person’s life corresponded to those described by the young child. A man called Ānanda Mahipala, who by Sri Lankan accounts was not a very good person. In other words, he was not only a meat eater, not vegetarian, but also a hunter, which is considered in Buddhist societies a great sin. But a kindly person despite this.

Then he has clearly memories of being a rabbit, a hare, and it is striking that he has two only two memories of that life. He remembers eating grass, and he remembers being shot. Nothing else. Which corresponds with the sort of memories you’d expect an animal to have. If you have pets, you can see that probably their mental horizon is very limited.

Sleep, the same as dogs, sleep, food, fun. Sleep, food, fun. And maybe in the entire life of the dog, one or two big events. This seems to correspond. And he has memories of something his mother never mentioned to him, which is being her infant son who died basically shortly after birth.

This was never mentioned in the family. Then what is striking is that as a result of these memories, early on, the young boy was attracted to temples and chose to become ordained against the wishes of his family. And you can see it likewise the karmic unfolding here. Specifically, can see between lives two and three, from a Buddhist standpoint, how a hunter and a meat eater would be reborn as a rabbit who is hunted and eaten. Right?

And the life after this, the life of a hunter is a life of someone who kills frequently. The forest life, the life after this, is a life with a very short lifespan of one month. It’s a karmic maturation of killing, right? First karmic maturation is a lower rebirth as a hare. Motivation probably was not very bad, probably it was to feed himself, probably it was not done with great cruelty, because rebirth was an animal rebirth, not a herbal rebirth.

And it didn’t last a long time by all accounts. Then, some one thousand eight hundred years ago, Asaṇga said, I have difficulty seeing a place where you have not been born, gone to, or died in the distant past. I have difficulty seeing any person in the distant past who has not been your father, mother, uncle, aunt, sister, master, abbot, guru, or someone like a guru, as Asaṇga said. And you can see in the light of Stevenson’s research, this is remarkably contemporary as a statement. And then, I would say for this point, realizing that all sentient beings are once mothers of yore, the best approach is an in-depth study of Stevenson’s works.

We have them in the library. You can order them on the web to generate a very powerful conviction in reincarnation. Without that, you would not be able to start to realize this point. Once one has realized that all living beings are one’s mother of yore, recollecting their kindness is easy. These are pictures of mothers performing deeds of kindness for their children, A she-lion protecting her cubs against the male.

A mother protecting her child in China during an earthquake. A mother found buried alive with her child in her arm whom she attempted to protect. A she bear protecting her cubs. So it is thanks to the kindness of our mothers in life after life after life that we are here, certainly in this life, every one of us has had a mother, whether he or she knows her or not. And for most of us, our mother has been extraordinarily kind.

Know? And it’s something which always shocks me in the West, which is that when I speak to people in developed Western societies, in Australia it’s quite extreme, but you do see it in Europe and America, you have the impression the person, germinated from a spore. Like, there’s no family. They have no father, they have no mother, they don’t know owe anything to anybody. Somehow, they are completely self sufficient, which is obviously false.

And, this extreme self sufficiency, this fantasy of self sufficiency makes a very unhappy people, who never acknowledge their debt to others. Where we stand because someone taught us to walk and to stand, we speak because of our mothers. I mean, it’s now established. Without the vision of the mother’s lips, not one of us would be able to pronounce a single word of the human language. Most of our basic skills we owe to our mothers.

And then, I am more widely traveled than most people, and I have seen many cases of mothers making astonishing sacrifices for their children, working as prostitutes, to try to send their boy or their girl to school, you know, doing things which are inconceivable. In this country, you have probably little experience of this, you know. The moment we connect the kindness of one’s mother, one’s human mothers, and then animal mothers who sacrifice their life, you know, for their cubs, then the feeling of very powerful death is here. Very powerful. And this is why Chandragomin says, when you see that your relatives are engulfed in the ocean of cyclic existence, and as they fall into a pit of fire, there is nothing more shameful than to work for your liberation.

Neglecting, this is such a powerful mind, those whom you do not recognize due to the process of death and rebirth. This is why. It’s just because of our forgetfulness, because of the experience of the subtle state of mind with the death process, we do not remember who was our mother. But in my case, was born in 1962, in August. Then in July 1961, I had another mother.

And the closest I feel to my mother in this life is exclusively due to memory. Because there’s no difference between the kindness of my mother in this life, post 1962, and the kindness of my mother in 1961. The mother of the previous life, no difference. There’s a difference of memory. Once you become profoundly convinced of reincarnation, then since the mind is beginningless and bodies are beginningless, you cannot say of somebody that they have not been your mother, or your father, or your brother, or your uncle, or a friend.

In this room, for instance, if we meet in this life, it is because we met before, otherwise, it would not have happened. Then how we met who we were, I do not know. But certainly we met before. Then the only difference between friends and relatives in this life and friends and relatives of past lives is memory. And if we cannot be sure who knows our mother, father, sister, brother, teacher in a previous life, then we should treat everyone in that way and assume they were.

I do not know whether we can, based on logic alone, assert that every single mother sentient being, every single sentient being has been our mother in a previous life. I am convinced that based on logic, we can assert that every sentient being we ever encounter must have been our mother in a previous life, and not just our mother. Because the fact of encountering them entails a karmic connection. There is a friend of mine who is very mathematically inclined. We did some work together.

He had a mathematician from the University of Laplace to picture. My background is math and physics originally, because you’re working with multiple infinites. Right? Infinite sentient beings, infinite time, infinite rebirths, and then you want to see whether you can establish actually that if infinite sentient beings in number reincarnate over infinite time, constituting infinite relationships, they would have been in every possible relationship within each with each other over the totality of time. And there’s a way of doing it in modern mathematics.

You basically look at what’s known as a cardinal of infinite sets. You’ve corners of natural sets and corners of rational sets, different things. But that’s a bit beyond our point here. But this friend who’s professor at the University of Adelaide, he said yes. I mean, he said it’s basically mathematically not only feasible but probable.

Depends on the basic parameters. So how do we recollect the kindness of our mothers? Once again, you don’t do it in the abstract. This is a key part of Je Tsongkhapa in Lamrim Chenmo. You take your mother in this life, and you visualize her in front of you, And then you go through every deed of kindness since conception because it starts long before birth, when our mother takes care of how she dresses, what she eats for our sake, and then the suffering of delivery.

Then the sacrifices she makes to suckle us. It is not a pleasant experience by all accounts, especially if you don’t have the amenities of modern medicine. You have all sorts of skin irritations and whatnot. Then, on her teaching us how to eat, teaching us how to walk, teaching us how to speak, protecting us from harm, taking us to school, my mother drove me to school every day, me and my sister, protecting us from all harm. Then if you’re in an abusive family, it is often the mother who protects the child from the anger of the father, the mother who takes some loads.

Isn’t it? This is the kindness of the mother. Then later on in life, if there is one person who’s always by your side, it’s your mother, isn’t it? I mean, it’s very striking when you read the accounts of, you know, criminals in the paper that their mother never gives up on them. It’s very striking.

The mother says, my boy is not very good, but you must understand. There’s something quite extraordinary, the love of a mother. So you start with the mother of this life, and then you imagine that every other mother you have had has been as kind as the one in this life. Keeping in mind you have no way of knowing for sure who has not beaten your mother. It’s very powerful for the mind.

Very powerful. Then you can see in societies where freedom of piety, this feeling of duty towards the parents is profound. How far it goes? This is a man who carried his mother, who is senile, we did in Taiwan, to the hospital. They don’t have the facilities you have in this country, you know.

And he has to he had to carry her in his arms to the hospital, feed her in the waiting room. The picture had a big impact in Taiwan. This is a sort of we speak of repaying the kindness of our mother. This is what we should be doing in this life already, not just in meditation. And then once we see all sentient beings as our mother from some distant past, then we reflect our mother is crazed by the afflictions.

She has no guide and there was no teacher. She’s approaching a frightful precipice in this life. What frightful precipice what are rebirths? If you fall, if you’re reborn as an animal, basically, you will not be reborn as a human being again. The odds of being reborn as a human being are tiny.

Once you fall down, there’s no way back up. And then, if you don’t take responsibility, who is gonna take responsibility? It’s shameful not to do so. Then one thinks in these terms, it is impossible to neglect other sentient beings. That it’s impossible to focus on liberation.

And you think, okay. If it is possible to attain full enlightenment, if such a thing exists, then I will do it. But here you need certainty that full enlightenment is possible, that the means taught in the Buddhist scriptures are means to full enlightenment. If you have no certainty, it’s just talk. Once that certainty is there, then whatever time it takes, you do.

Right? And then, after training in this way, we train in love, which is the foremost armor. It is described in the Abhisamayālamkāra as the armor against all danger. Remember, Buddha Śākyamūni overcame all the demons assaulting him at the point of full enlightenment through love. Not to meditate on Yamantaka like we do, but through love.

At this point, their weapons turned into flowers. This is obviously a mystical experience. It’s a very powerful mystical experience. And Je Tsongkhapa says, the conqueror defeated Mara’s army with the power of love. So love is a supreme protector.

Then when we train in love, we use a different sequence from the one when we train in equanimity. We always start training with those towards whom we have an emotion or a sensation, which is cognate with that we’re trying to generate. So in equanimity, we start with people towards whom we feel indifferent because it’s quite close to equanimity. When we want to train in love, we start with people who are our friends. Parents, children, partners, lovers, whatever.

There is a closeness. We train first in love towards them, then towards those who are a bit more removed, and then towards enemies. And then training in this way, you can see that you have the foot on initial trainings of the bases. Equanimity, recognizing all sentient beings as one’s mother, recollecting their kindness and repaying their kindness, which are the foundation for both love and great compassion. And in this context, a question which is frequently asked is whether one must initially generate love before great compassion or not.

This is a sequence which is given in Buddhist scriptures by Kamalaśīla. But, actually, the actual sequence is indefinite. It depends in other words on your own predispositions. And this is explicitly ascertained by Je Tsongkhapa. The cause and relationship between compassion and love is not definite.

You can generate the one first and the other after, or the opposite. And here we reach the core of the Buddhist teachings, great compassion. Now great compassion is not an easy experience, I would suspect. Buddhist teachings are not designed to make us happy in this life. And it is said that one of the great Kadampa Geshe, Geshe Langri Tangpa, who meditated exclusively on great compassion, spent his entire life crying.

He meditated on the suffering of beings, and he cried continually. So if you are interested in the Buddhist teachings to improve your mental well-being, then I think you have perhaps come to the wrong place, because we help you to learn how to cry all the time. But it is said that Geshe Langri Tangpa laughed once in his life, and that’s the little pictures I included there. Because as he was meditating once in front of his altar, he had a very beautiful mandala scent with lapis lazuli. And he saw a little field mouse come and tried to grab the lapis lazuli.

It was too big for her. Then other field mice came and they tried to help her. Eventually, she grabbed the lapis lazuli with four paws, lowered her back, and the other field mice pulled her away. And then he laughed. It is said to be the only time he ever left.

Maybe the story is true or not, I do not know, but it describes a bit the intensity of his practice. Clearly, it is impossible to create compassion for others if you don’t have compassion for yourself. And what is compassion for yourself? Compassion for yourself means understanding your own sufferings and wishing to be free for them from them. In other words, in Buddhist terms, compassion for yourself is renunciation.

If you train in renunciation, meditating on your own suffering, which you must initially understand, then it is very easy to generate compassion for others. Because once you realize they are in the same situation as you, then your heart goes out to them quite naturally. And this is why Je Tsongkhapa says, if you have developed an awareness of your own general and specific sufferings, the general are the three sufferings of cyclic existence, and the specific or suffering specific to a given realm, then you will easily generate compassion. Considering your own suffering creates a determination to be free, in other words, renunciation. Thinking that about that of others creates great compassion.

It is not possible, therefore, to leapfrog the stages in generating the motivation, as we said at the beginning. You cannot generate great compassion without having generated renunciation. Why would you feel the need to help others when you’re not even helping yourself? What is the criterion for generating great compassion? It is for compassion to arise spontaneously, without any particular need to generate it.

This is a criterion for a spontaneous motivation. Now in this context, the doubt may arise after all, are we saying that Hīnayāna practitioners have no compassion. It’s clearly false. Hīnayāna practitioners have the practice of compassion and of love of Maitri. Do you know?

Then what is the difference between the Hīnayāna practice of love and compassion and the Mahāyāna practice of love and compassion? Does anyone have an answer? We have Yes. But then is it here you’re speaking of love and compassion for others, which do exist in Hīnayāna. Would it be in your opinion?

That’s quite good. Any other suggestions? I mean, both have clear compassion for others and clear love for others. I mean, you can read the the Maitri sūtra in the Hīnayāna scriptures, you know, it’s magnificent treatises on love. But what is the difference?

Yes. That is very close. It’s very close. The difference is action. And you can see this is very striking in Je Tsongkhapa’s analysis.

Although Hinayanas, Shravaks, and Pratyekabuddha have immeasurable love and compassion, whereby they think if only sentient beings could have happiness and be free from suffering, they do not think, I will take on the responsibility to remove the suffering and to provide the happiness of all beings. In other words, their compassion does not lead directly to wholehearted resolve. Why? Then I have to ask you some questions because my voice is a bit hoarse. So why doesn’t compassion and love in Hīnayāna lead directly to the resolve to free sentient beings?

Could be could be if you know modern Theravāda Buddhism, you will understand why. Yes. Why? Mahāyāna takes responsibility. Yes.

But why doesn’t the Hīnayāna do so? There’s a reason. Yes. Yes. But the reason which is given by modern Theravāda masters in Sri Lanka, Burma, Thailand today, they recognize the existence of Bodhisattvas.

It’s not the case that in Hīnayāna they don’t recognize. They recognize the existence of bodhisattvas, they recognize the existence of bodhicitta, they recognize the existence of full enlightenment. Why don’t they try? Priority is liberation. It’s close.

Self liberation. Not What do I tell you at the beginning of the conference? If you wanted to practice really authentically, what do you have to do? Yes. That’s not quite Moderation, no.

The very beginning, I said you have to be convinced it was real impossible. Right? Theravāda does not consider it is possible and realistic to train in bodhicitta, become a Bodhisattva and attain full enlightenment. They say it happens, it is extraordinarily hard, and it isn’t worth the effort. Because even if one becomes a Buddha, one cannot really help others.

So you see that what happens is that it is exactly at this point that the distinction occurs. They have compassion. It’s not called great compassion, but it does not lead to the wholehearted resolve. They have love, but they do not consider, and it’s a very legitimate position, because it’s a position based on careful reflection and analysis, they don’t consider it is possible. And if it were possible, it caused for such a gigantic amount of effort, they don’t think it is realistic.

So what I have always found impressive with the Theravāda is the hard nosed analysis of what is possible and not. It is not enough to pay lip service to full enlightenment and go on with one’s life. The key to Mahāyāna practice is this commitment which can only occur if, as we said at the beginning, we are convinced that full enlightenment really exists, I can attain it, and it’s worth the trouble. For life after life after life after life, because we will not attain it in this life. Je Tsongkhapa has called the statement that wanting to attain full enlightenment in one life akin to Chinese communist propaganda.

You know? They’re very popular in western Buddhist centers because all of us are in a big hurry all the time. But that is not a realistic way to practice. So the transition here between great compassion and wholehearted resolve demands a conviction that it is possible to attain full enlightenment, that the means to attain full enlightenment have been taught, and that I myself or you yourselves have what it takes, in this case the Buddha lineage, which is the capacity of the mind, specifically the emptiness of the mind to become fully enlightened. Without that, bodhicitta becomes a wrong view.

Right? And however much lip service you pay to a wrong view, you would not put your head on the block for it. When the time comes to put your head on the block and the axe is raised, your head would not go on the block, because deep down there are doubts. Right? Then the wholehearted resolve really leads one to the point where one is almost there.

After that, we have bodhicitta. But I think Je Tsongkhapa’s analysis in this passage in Lamrim Chenmo is really critical. The difference between Hīnayāna and Theravāda, between Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna, is not so much in terms of love and compassion as what that compassion leads to. That compassion leads to whole heart and resolve, and for that reason, it can be called great compassion. It leads to a commitment, the commitment to do what it takes.

Right? And this is, the definition of bodhicitta I mentioned last time. To have generated bodhicitta is for the sake of others to wish for utter full enlightenment. So, as Nāgārjuna says in Bodhichittavivarana, there is no other means for establishing one’s own welfare than that of others. The Buddhas of yore beheld no means apart from bodhicitta.

And clearly, this is the welfare of others and oneself over the infinite number of lives. If we were to circumscribe oneself to this life, there are many other means, charitable organizations, NGOs do a lot for others, you know. Whether it is ultimately of benefit is another question. Right? In this country, we have a very proactive social system whether people who spend their lives on welfare truly benefit is a very different question.

Right? If you ask for the person in the Lojong, it’s far from clear. Then over the cycles of lives, nothing is done, because the existence of the cycles of lives is not accepted. So this is the seven fold cause and effect or causal generation of bodhicitta, which I find the most helpful for my own mind because it is so incremental. But clearly, you must leave very solid foundations in terms of belief in past and future lives.

Otherwise, it will not take. With Westerners, the equalization, the interchange of self and others seems much more beneficial. It’s more general. It was, as mentioned, taught secretly in Tibet for many generations of teachers. Then ideally, should be combined with the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta.

It was mainly taught at Naranda University, and this is a picture of Naranda. Then it is simpler. You start with what amounts to a form of equanimity, equalizing yourself and others, typically through reflecting that others want to be happy and want to avoid suffering, so do I. And then the second point is to reflect on the thoughts of egoism or self-cherishing. The third point is to reflect on the qualities of altruism.

Then you have the actual thought of interchanging self and others, which means to interchange your own egoism for altruism. It doesn’t mean to put yourself in someone else’s shoes. It means to be as dedicated to others as you are at present, we are at present dedicated to ourselves. And finally, the core of the practice, is tomme, giving and taking, but this is linked with breathing. So I thought the drawing by Escher of two hands drawing each other is a very good metaphor of equalizing yourself and others.

And here we go very heavily on Śāntideva, since this is our main source. As Śāntideva says, whatever worldly joy there is arises from wishing others happiness. Whatever worldly suffering there is arises from wishing your own for your own happiness. Then I think this is very difficult to realize. You have to think very carefully about it.

If you focus only on this life, I think it is still true. It is clear that people who are dedicated to others tend to attract a lot of goodwill. And people who are seen as harmful tend to attract a lot of animosity. I think it’s true. Clearly, over many lives, if you accept the existence of karma, is definitely true.

People who work for the sake of others, life after life, will experience the results of virtuous karma. For instance, if you are born in Australia, you’re born with a good get a good education, a good family, this is a result of having taken care of others in a previous life. It’s not a coincidence. And if you’re born in a war zone and from early on you were told that as an Afghani cab driver to me here, the fullest value is revenge, this is a result of non virtuous karma. Clearly.

So over the cycle of lives, it is clear that altruism is the best policy. In this life, I think it is quite clear. And there’s a lot of data now from economics I haven’t presented, which shows that in a stable community, altruistic behavior is economically the best form of behavior from a classy materialistic standpoint. Right? Then before engaging in the practice of equalizing self and others, we have to ask ourselves, is this a rational practice or not?

Is it rational for me to put as much importance on others as on myself or not? And this can clearly be understood through understanding the mechanism of imputation. In our own case, for instance, every one of us is a product of two bodies which are not our own, our father’s body and our mother’s body. Everyone in this room is a product of the sperm of the of one’s father, just one material continuum, and the oven of one’s mother, mother another material continuum. Then everyone in this room has a very strong sense of his or her body as my body, which obviously it isn’t.

Right? It’s purely an imputation. The imputation, which our mind performs on this body, which actually comes from somewhere else. Then, if we can impute, this is my body, on a body which is a product of two very different beings, we can also transfer that sense of identity to others. The same process of imputation.

It’s not more illegitimate because others bodies are also unrelated to them. We take our body in this life at the time of conception under the force of our own karma. But that body itself comes from elsewhere. And this is precisely what Śāntideva says, in this famous stanza, therefore, just as you conceived I with respect to the drops of semen and blood of others, so you can be conditioned to cherishing others as you do yourself. It is not only possible, it is realistic and rational.

In 2011, another text of Shiksha Samuchaya adds, self and other are interdependent. And if we take the example of a river, the other bank is not in itself other. In relation to someone else, it is this bank. Similarly, self does not exist in its own right. In relation to someone else, it is other.

You are others in respect to myself. I am an other in respect to yourselves. The only difference between us is a difference of standpoint. Then, in the process of the interchange of self and others, I turn your otherness into my own personhood, if you wish, and my own personhood into otherness. We’ll understand this a little bit more when we start analyzing how to engage in this practice.

So these are the preliminaries for equalizing self and others. As you remember, the first point in this process. You can see why this process was transmitted orally and kept secret, because to practice it correctly is quite difficult. The sevenfold causal practice of the generation of bodhicitta, once you accept reincarnation, is much easier. Reflecting on the thoughts of egoism, this is Escher himself actually, an auto portrait of Escher staring at a globe with a reflection of himself.

This is egoism, I suppose, in painted form. Geshe Chekawa said that egoism, with self-cherishing, must be blamed for everything. This is what must be banished. Since, basically, once we believe in past and future lives, it’s obvious that our non virtuous deeds from previous lives are responsible for our suffering in this life. It is we ourselves who have created the causes, nobody but us, created them how?

Through self-cherishing, through egoism, through taking care of ourselves at the expense of others, again and again and again. But even in this life, people who are consistently egotistical typically end up in trouble with the law, don’t they? I mean, if you look at the people who end up in the courts, it’s rather rarely the altruistic types. It’s the people who keep pushing the envelope, whose business practices are ever sharper, you know, who are skirting the edge of the law, who eventually get in trouble. So even in this life, it is true.

And as Namka Pel puts it, we have within us an evil being who shamelessly blames all problems on our lamas, teachers and abbots, our friends, and those dear to us, our parents and relatives. I have lost count over the years of the number of times when translating, I have had to translate the recriminations of someone against their parents, against the state, against their friends. It is always somebody else. It is interesting. I can count on the fingers of one hand the numbers of times a person said, I am fully responsible for what happened to me, and I would like to know how to avoid it.

I can literally can come from the fingers of one hand. People fail the relationships. It’s their parents. They fail at their job. It’s, you know, whoever’s running the company.

They’re in problems. The state is not giving enough money. It’s nonstop. In other words, you have this constant or we have this constant attitude which blames all our problems on other. The foundation of practice is to switch this attitude.

Whatever problems we have are our problems. We created them single handedly. And it is up to us to accept them and to try to move beyond them. This is a rational approach. And we move beyond them through understanding how they arise, and this calls for an understanding of karma.

Namka Pel is very sharp. Know, he was a young disciple of Je Tsongkhapa, and he wrote about what Je Tsongkhapa did not want to write about too much. Very sharp. He says, due to the strength of our acquaintance with egoism over beginning this time, and I think you’d recognize this in all of us, if we hear the squealing of rats in a house, we are frightened of them with being our nose. Many other things rats could do.

Right? But it’s our nose they’re coming after. Hearing the clap of thunder, we worry that our heads will be struck by lightning, and coming to a haunted house, we are afraid. It is self-cherishing of this egoism which causes our fear. This entire attitude which views the whole world as revolving around our precious self.

Then such an attitude is a cause of great suffering. Because clearly, at the time of death, this precious self is finished, isn’t it? The mind may move on, but what we know as the self, the person, the memories is gone. And therefore, self-cherishing has harmed me in all my myriad lifetimes of existence. As Śāntideva adds, I am controlled by other words.

In in other words, I accept to put others in front of me. I am accept I accept to let others control me. And viewing it like this, it is wrong to aim for my own aims, with my eyes, etcetera, that are under others control. And this is the goal. One gives oneself to the welfare of others.

Whatever serves others best, one does. Not what serves one’s own goals. Then, when one does this systematically, a byproduct is that one’s own practice becomes very powerful. Very powerful. Inattention, anger, anxiety disappear.

There’s a lot of scientific data now, mainly from cognitive psychology, which shows that the practice of altruism leads to a very sharp reduction in mental problems of all sorts, specifically depression and anxiety, which are typically the ailments of self self centered people. When one is highly focused upon oneself, even the smallest thing creates great disturbance, doesn’t it? You know? And you you do hear this if you you go to coffee shops. Can you imagine they put, you know, that much soy milk in my latte when I ordered, you know, nonfat milk?

And the person becomes very disturbed over something which is extraordinarily trite. Because the self is very big. Right? And the key to happiness is to bring the self, the self-cherishing, down. And then the goal is through affectionately viewing others as below as dear and beloved as much as you can, develop an attitude that cherishes others to the degree to which you cherished yourself.

This is the actual interchange of self and others. Where before we put ourselves first, and for instance walked through the door and didn’t think too much about others, now we put others first, and we open the door for them. Where before we rushed in line to get the coffee first, we get it for others. This is a recipe to happiness. And then we have, and after all his friends have led the way in this matter, We have very powerful teachings on the practice of the equalization interchange of self and others in the West.

And I’d like to encourage you to study them as well. Jesus, whom many Tibetans consider a bodhisattva, his holiness has implied he was an emanation of Avalokiteśvara. They’re very powerful teachings on Lojong. If the sermon on the mount is not mind training, I don’t know what mind training is. Then who Jesus precisely was, we do not know.

To exterior appearances, he was a Jewish rabbi who had a reformation inside Judaism. For sincere Christians, he was a son of God. Many Buddhists view him as a manifestation of a bodhisattva in a different culture. Bodhisattvas manifest in all cultures. Bodhisattvas don’t wear a little card reading bodhisattva, You know?

And they don’t have to be Buddhist, to the outside at least. Then you can assess the needs of a bodhisattva by a couple of features. Obviously, we do not know the motivation, we have no access. But bodhisattvas typically work for a very large number of beings. You will find great bodhisattvas among political leaders, among religious leaders, among great scientists.

Typically, bodhisattvas by birth or by training have access to great power and wealth. This is what they pray for. If not great power and wealth, great influence. The goal of the Bodhisattva is to help large numbers of beings. And typically, the teachings of all the good Bodhisattvas, if they teach, are rooted in compassion.

Then if you read the passage passages in the sermon on the mount, they’re very powerful. Whosoever shall smite thee on their right cheek, turn to him the other one. This is Lojong. Any of the Kadampa geshes would have been proud to say something like this. I say unto you, love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you and persecute you.

And this is a central teaching of Christianity, which is identical to Śāntideva’s teachings of mind training. Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself. Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself. This is the equalization of self and others. There is no other commandment greater than these.

It’s very powerful for the mind. Very powerful. So this is why his holiness systematically encourages Westerners before they become Buddhist to look to Christianity. Then, not everyone has Christian karmic imprints, but many Westerners do. And, there are in Christianity very powerful teachings of mind training.

Very powerful. He’s always has repeatedly pointed out that the Christian teaching that we are all children of the same father is very powerful for the mind. The Buddhists, for instance, teach to generate love and compassion for others, that every living being has been our mother since beginningless lives. But the Christian teaching that we, our souls, are basically created by one God, and that all of us are therefore brothers and sisters on this earth, members of one family, is just as powerful to transform the mind. Then it depends on one’s karmic imprints what is more helpful for oneself.

For some people, the Buddhist presentation is much more helpful. They have a natural belief in past and future lives. Then they find the notion of a soul irrational, and the notion of a creator at odds with what they see a physical reality. For others, it is obvious there is a creator. It is obvious as creator is good, and nature is fallen.

It is obvious we are all related as human beings. Then, obviously, the Christian view is much more circumscribed, since it only covers human beings and not all conscious beings. But the Christian path is a path which is very powerful for the mind and less demanding in terms of study. And the experience, his own experience, and I can say sincerely my own experience now in more than thirty years, is that most westerners have powerful Christian karmic imprints. And it is not good to mix things up.

If you are if you want to be a sincere practitioner, be a sincere Christian or a sincere Buddhist, don’t be half Christian and half Buddhist, half Hindu and half Buddhist. It doesn’t work. Let me just examine for ourselves what is more beneficial for the mind. Because of our cultural heritage, Christianity is very much on the way, but still it is part of 20 centuries of Western heritage. His Holiness in every teaching I have attended in the West, everyone.

In Northern France, in Nottingham, in Hamburg, then in Sydney, in Melbourne, every time, His Holiness has said, westerners must check their Christian heritage, and his Holiness has warned against conversion. This warning comes from the fact that most conversion as such is a destabilizing phenomenon because you are passing over to another identity, And religious conversion sometimes is incomplete. And what is incomplete, there are difficulties later on. So for this reason, the best thing one can do is not to rush. Take your time.

Study carefully, think carefully, explore your own spiritual traditions. Once you have explored them, if they do not satisfy you, then explore the other great spiritual traditions. If Buddhism is what you sincerely feel attracted to, very good. But if you have major reservations, don’t sweep these reservations under the carpet because it creates big difficulties later on. These are the people who eventually after taking refuge, bodhisattva vows, tantric vows, walk away from everything, abandon their practice, and then they have to deal with the complications.

So when we reflect on the qualities of altruism, they are obvious. I took the example of bread since where I come from we eat a lot of bread. Bread cannot exist with the work of others. Someone has to cut the wheat. Someone has to knead the dough.

Someone has to bake the bread. Your baker has to sell you the bread. This one loaf of bread has demanded the work of tens of people In everything in our life, relies on the kindness of others. We speak, we work, we eat, it is the kindness of our mother. We drive a car, the kindness of the builders of the car.

We dress, it’s the kindness of those who made the clothing. We have electricity, someone is producing this electricity. The computers come from somewhere. There is nothing which is not due to the kindness of others. When we reflect about it in these terms, then our self-cherishing collapses.

At a certain point, we think, well, what is there which I have done? Very little. Very little. 99% comes from other, 1% from ourselves, and we are inflated like peacocks. And when you look at it and say, we deflate others, you know.

Then we do what we can for them. And then, as Śāntideva says, when I turn my gaze upon another, thinking I shall fully awaken through depending on this being, look upon him with open hearted love. Our entire practice, any spiritual attainment we can hope to attain, we owe to others. We cannot practice generosity without someone to give to. We cannot practice patience or forbearance without someone to annoy us.

We cannot practice ethics without someone to abstain from non virtuous needs towards. Our practice collapses without a teacher who is an other. And therefore, we should see all as spiritual teachers. And that is why Geshe Chekawa says, meditate on the great kindness of all beings. Then regarding the actual thought of interchanging self and others, the fourth point.

I took another Christian example. This is perhaps the foremost example in this century. To me it clearly shows that practicing Christian mind training, one can reach these very exalted levels, as far as the method aspect of the path is concerned. As far as the wisdom aspect of the path is concerned, there are some complications with Christianity. But the wisdom aspect of the path, we see with our study program at TBI, is not of great interest to most students.

It’s a method aspect which is really of benefit. Someone like mother Teresa clearly practiced the interchange of self and others. Very clear case. Someone who dedicated her entire life to others, very difficult conditions. Then this would be a typical example of a Kadampa mind training practitioner.

We have great Buddhist practitioners as well. We have great Muslim practitioners, I would imagine. You know? And finally, without the practice of Tonglen I could not think of an image for Tonglen. Tonglen is a practice of Tongwa to give in Tibetan and Langwa to take.

Giving and taking, but mounted on the breath. But one’s entire breath becomes the support for the activities of love and compassion. As one inhales, one takes upon oneself all the suffering of others. Not just human beings or animals, if you accept the existence of spirits, all spirits, hell beings, and not just the exterior sufferings, not just the suffering of suffering, but also the suffering of change, in other words, their happiness which is contaminated, and ultimately more pervasive suffering. All this one takes upon oneself.

One takes also all their non virtue, all the sins he have committed, and one prays that it mature upon oneself. Then everything good we have, without exception, we give away. Our virtues we give, the maturation of our virtue, in other words, our wealth, our happiness, strength, you know, everything we give to others. Therefore, as we inhale, we visualize the suffering of all beings coming within ourselves. Then, if we want to visualize in a sophisticated fashion, this penetrates in one’s heart and shatters, self-cherishing at one’s heart, seem like a black ball.

But this visualization is less important than that strong determination to take upon oneself the great suffering of others. I do sincerely hope that if, let’s say, they have to suffer from cancer, the cancer appears within us instead. If they have to suffer from depression, the depression appears within us instead. And then we give them everything we have, the result of our own virtues. As we exhale, all this leaves our body in the form of white light, and all beings receive whatever is appropriate for them.

This is what Buddha Śākyamūni practiced in this famous statue of Buddha offering his body to the tigress. Buddha met a famished tigress in a previous life, had nothing to give her to feed her cubs, and he lay down on the ground, and as she was too weak to eat him, he prepared his own flesh for her. This is the type of giving we have to engage in. This must be done without any lingering second thoughts. I will give all this, but it’s only a visualization.

I really hope it doesn’t work. Because then there’s no benefit. It is an attitude of complete giving away, which is so powerful. And when we do this, our self-cherishing collapses. And as a byproduct, we will be much more happy.

And therefore, what does one give? One gives one’s body, one’s possessions, and one’s virtue. Then at present, we are not able to give all these. We can certainly start by giving our possessions. All of us have far more than we need, we can give a little bit.

Then instead of taking a mortgage on the house, live in an apartment, give a little bit to charity, to poor people. Then after this, one’s body, one can give parts of one’s body without losing one’s life. One can give a kidney, one can give an eye. And if you train in this, in future lives you will be able to give more. And that’s virtuous, which for a true practitioner is the hardest thing to give.

And those, you imagine, you really accumulate for others, you give to others. Whom do we give to? To all. Those who do not practice spirituality at all, need them the most. These are all sentient beings.

Spiritual practitioners need them the least, the environment as well. As Namka Pel puts it, we owe sentient beings an immense debt, having eaten their flesh, grown their bones, drunk their blood, and warm their skins. Let those who want to eat flesh eat it, let those who want blood drink it, let those who want bones ignore them, let those who want skins wear them. Then if we reflect, even in this life, most of us wear leather shoes, the skin of another being. Most of us eat meat, the flesh of another being.

Most of us drink milk, it is stolen from the calf. A cow without a calf, a calf, who is not calved, cannot produce milk. The calf is then sold and killed. If we eat grain, to produce this grain, millions of insects have been killed through insecticides, machines. There is as a Geshe told me once, I used to be a vegetarian when I was a monk for a long time.

It was a very wise, Geshe, was a disciplinarian of Sera Je, he said to me, kha me gi kalam med. There is no faultless meal. I’m very wise. It’s true. There’s no faultless meal.

Maybe water, but you can’t survive off water. You have to filter it and there’s nothing left inside. And therefore, Geshe Langri Tangpa’s central advice, which is perhaps the core of Lojong, is give profit and victory to others, take loss and defeat upon yourself. Whenever you have the opportunity, others first, put yourself last. And this is not easy to practice.

Pänchen Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen summarized these two lineages of training in bodhicitta, the sevenfold causal lineage, and the interchange of seven others into one, which is really the uncommon oral tradition of the Gelug tradition. It is the most powerful way of training in bodhicitta. It’s a bit complex because there are 11 steps, but this leads to a very rapid transformation of the mind. You can see here how he did it. You still have the same base of equanimity.

Now what is in blue comes from the sevenfold causal generation, in yellow the equalization interchange of self and others. So you have your three first steps, recognizing all sentient beings as mothers, recollecting their kindness, and repaying their kindness. Which is the same as in the sevenfold causal process. And at that point you insert the interchange of self and others. And you can see how this would be very powerful, because at the point where you are meditating on how to repay the kindness of others, at this point, you switch over to the meditations on equalizing self and others.

This has a big impact on the mind. Then you remember the fruits of egoism in this life and all lives, the qualities of altruism in this life and all lives. You manifest the object of compassion, in this case others, as Je Tsongkhapa taught you start with one other, because you must realize it with respect to one other before realizing it with respect to many. And then you practice taking, that is taking the suffering of this one person, and once you have experienced a powerful sense of compassion, you manifest more than one person, as many as you can. Then you pass to the training in love.

You manifest one person whom you want to give happiness. And once you have given happiness to that person, you have an experience. Here we’re talking of an actual experience. You must experience something. At that point, you expand it to two, to three, to four, to five, ten, 20, and then evermore.

And then, it would be at this point you will practice giving and taking, between step 9.1 and step 10. You would actually visualize yourself as you inhale taking all the sufferings of others upon yourself. See that they really will ripen on yourself, and as you exhale, give all your happiness to others. Then it generates a great resolve. These forsaken beings are my mothers from past lives.

They have done more for me than I could ever repay. They are suffering. I must repay them. I will repay them. At this point you have great resolve.

And then you analyze, do I have the capacity to repay them? And when you look at yourself, I have only faults, I have no qualities, I have no power, others do not listen, I cannot teach, I cannot help. Who can teach? Who can help? Who has power?

Who has no thoughts and all qualities? A fully enlightened being. I will become a fully enlightened being. This is a great resolve. I will become a fully enlightened being for the sake of all others.

There you have bodhicitta. And this must be generated again and again and again incrementally. It’s an incremental contrived motivation until as you wake up in the morning it is there, as you go to sleep at night it is there. My teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, the former abbot of Sera Je said to me, the instant you wake up in the morning, generate bodhicitta. Then your whole day is basically for the sake of others.

Whatever you do. And this is why Nāgārjuna in the Bodhichittavivarana says, just as those Bhagavan Buddhas and great bodhisattvas gave rise to the mind of great enlightenment, Likewise, I as well will give rise to the mind for great enlightenment. From now onwards, until I have reached the essence, full enlightenment, for the sake of liberating the unliberated, of freeing the unfreed, of granting breath to the suffocating, and of utterly led beyond suffering, sentient beings who have not been utterly led beyond suffering. Now I would like to conclude with the marvelous stanzas from the dedication of Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva, which have sometimes been called the oath of the Dalai Lamas. During the intermediate year of famine, may I become food and drink for sentient beings who are poor and famished.

May I remain in their presence as various necessities. May I protect those without protection. May I be a guide leading those upon the path. May I become a vessel, a bridge, and a ship for those who wish to cross over the ocean. May I be an island for those searching for land and a lamp for those needing a light.

May I become a bed for those who need rest and a servant for all who want assistance. This is the vow of the bodhisattvas. Then, if we train our minds, at some point, we will be able to recite this from the depths of a heart, and I think our life would have been very, very well spent. Thank you very much. Then I’m happy to answer some questions if you have any.

What is idiot compassion? Who who mentioned that? Robina has her own own own outlook on things, but there’s not a Buddhist Hindu Buddhist text which uses that term. There’s no such thing as a deed of compassion. There is, however, taking upon one’s shoulders more than one can bear.

That exists. Then I think it is very important at the beginning to be fully aware of one’s strength, not to take on more than one can practice. Then clearly, working for the sake of others at one’s expense, that is compassion. That is what compassion is all about. And that is something one has to engage in in function of one’s strength.

Initially, we’re not able to do a lot of this. And if we do a lot of it, we get a lot of anger within ourselves, resentment, you know. At that point, there’s a risk we will walk away from everything, isn’t there? So the key is initially to understand that others are like ourselves. When we understand that they are like ourselves, it is not difficult to help them.

Where we were confused, they are confused. Where we were in need, they are in need. Now, where indeed compassion but I don’t think that’s what Robina meant. Where compassion must be qualified as compassion must go hand in hand with wisdom. Then it is not sufficient to have compassion.

One must be wise in the means of helping others. It is not always the case, let’s say in my case I learned this over the years, that giving money is the best way to help. Giving money may or may not be helpful depending on the circumstances and how wise a person is. Clearly, if you have someone who’s an alcoholic, who has addictions, money will be put to bad use. Then we must be wise in the means to help others.

And we must be wise in one’s own strength to help others. But one’s goal is very much to help others at one at one’s own expense. You know? Does that answer your question a bit? It’s very difficult.

Very difficult. It’s very difficult to help people with mental illnesses. Very difficult. Mental illnesses from a Buddhist standpoint find their origin in a very distant past before this life. They manifest biochemically in this life and the brain.

The biochemical manifestation is all that modern medicine understands. Then there are other aspects to mental illness which are very alien to the Western community, which call for very specialized skills. Some people who have mental illnesses, for instance, this is very much my private opinion, are cases of possession, you know, certain forms of schizophrenia, clearly, you know, certain forms of multiple personality disease. Then unless oneself has a lot of inner strength and experience, it is dangerous for oneself to deal with these cases, you know. So one must be wise, one must be wise regarding one’s own capacities, One must be wise regarding the needs of another.

And then in addition to this wisdom and compassion, one needs strength. If one’s strength is not very great at the beginning, then we must handle cases one can handle. And then, over the years, over the lives, one becomes more and more powerful, then it is possible to really help people. Yeah, definitely. I mean, the reason for which in the generation of very cheated one focuses on mothers is simply because probably the most intimate human relationship as a child is with her mother for most people.

Then for some it may have been a father. It’s clear that sentient beings have been our father since beginningless time. They’ve also been our teachers, friends. It’s not just our mother. But for most of us, that experience of closeness with the mother is perhaps the most powerful form of unconditional love we experience.

It’s very rare to experience that, for instance, in a marriage. It’s very rare to experience that from one’s children, I think. I don’t have any, but I’m told by friends who have them that children are very critical, you know. But normally, the experience with someone’s mother is very particular. Does that answer your question?

Ilya, I’m interested in understanding how we can bring bodhicitta into our practical everyday practice. For me, the centre and yourself and Geshe-la focus very heavily on reminding some of the preliminary stages to the path, so understanding that precious human rebirth, karma and causality. And great efforts have gone to make sure that there’s a strong foundation before progressing onto the path. I’m struggling with paired bodhicitta fits in considering our present condition. Can I ask for your view on how we can incorporate the two?

That’s an excellent question. Basically, there can be no bodhicitta without the foundations. bodhicitta is the roof of the house. You must have the foundations, the walls, infrastructure. Then bodhicitta is our goal.

At present, the way we would incorporate it is, first, we have to define exactly where we stand. This is a private matter. So each one of us, it takes time. Sit back. You don’t have to meditate while you’re doing this.

You can do it in your armchair. And ask yourself what sort of a person you are. Are you focused mainly on this life or not? I think probably most of us are focused mainly on this life. And within this life, what is your main focus?

Is it your job? Is it money? Is it family? Is it children? Is it your health?

What is the main focus? Once you have defined yours your present situation, your main practice should be targeting that. Let’s say, if you’re mainly preoccupied, let’s say, with money. Right? Then main practice must target the humanity of money, the vanity of money.

Money is transient, temporary, does not last, cannot buy anything meaningful with it. Where that is our main practice, we must regularly continue to do overview meditations on the totality of the path every day. It is during those overview meditations that one thinks about bodhicitta. This is where bodhicitta comes in the picture. bodhicitta at present, if you if we are at the level of a being who’s a worldly being focused on this life, we cannot generate.

It’s not possible. But this repeated familiarity prepares the mind. In the meantime, we are focusing on what is the main problem now. And let us say that instead of being worldly beings, like some Asians, some westerners too, we are mainly focused on future lives. Whatever we do is accumulating merit for the next life or the future lives.

Then our main practice must be the practice of the being of small scope. That’s our main purpose. That’s where it helps. We don’t need to focus on where on eliminating attachment to worldly affairs. That has basically been pretty much eliminated.

And if we were mistaken to focus on the practice of the being of the middle scope, it doesn’t help us. So we do mainly practices on death and impermanence, meditating every day on death and impermanence with the three roots, the nine reasons, etc. And every day, apart from that, we do an overview meditation on the Lamrim to familiarize ourself with the totality of the Lam Rim. But our main practice must be the one targeted to our present condition. So I think it’s largely because this has not been the way most westerners have practiced, that the Lamrim has had very little impact on most of the students.

The Lama is seen as some sort of template which is learned and then set aside where the student practices tantra, which we cannot practice. The base for the practice of tantra is the Three Principal Aspects of the Path. In other words, renunciation, bodhicitta and the view of emptiness, nobody has them. Tantric initiations are merely given to implant karmic imprints for the future. The main practice for most of us is first to counter the eight worldly dharmas and probably death and impermanence.

I think everyone in this room, your main practice should be death and impermanence. And basically focusing on the visualization and death and then meditating on the impermanence of just of oneself and all phenomena. This is what will change the mind. Everything else is presented to give one an overview. Does that answer your question?

Thank you very much, Ilya. I’m speaking as a rank beginner. So I’m looking at the first step, and that was developing equanimity, I think. In my own life, I think I’m developing equanimity from what I’ve had before. But it’s only the mental state that I think I’m achieving at the moment.

And it’s not complete. I’m just working on it. Does it imply that the physical application of our being the way we treat people does that just follow on from the mental process or do we physically have to almost force ourselves to be physically equanimity applied? So you make a couple of good points. First, I think it is a reality of the human condition that equanimity increases with age.

I think the older we get, the more experience we have, we look back on one life, that’s what we can see, then we see friendships change. Today’s friend is tomorrow’s enemy. Yesterday’s enemy is today’s friend. You know, someone who was totally different to us a couple years ago and now is now very close, then we have a certain amount of disillusionment with life, this beginning of equanimity. Then regarding action and behavior, a key element of mind training is that one’s exterior behavior, clothing and attitude should not change.

Obviously, if you are if one is behaving really badly, then that has to change. But as long as one is behaving like a normal person, there should be no exterior change. Because otherwise, this invites feedback from others, which is harmful to our practice. Instead, we should be as we have always been before. If there was any change, should happen inside.

It should be invisible. The more invisible it is to others, the better. And then the criterion of mind training is, as the, mind training treatises say, controlling the mind when it is wild unexpectedly is a sign of mastery. So mind training has not been successful if we can practice forbearance when we’re sitting in Samādhi. Right?

Mind training has been successful when someone basically almost hits your car, gives you the finger, and you don’t react, then mind training has been successful. Because it’s unexpected. Right? Then those people are very helpful. Because they show us exactly where we stand.

They don’t give big warning, here mind training time is coming. I’m gonna test you and then test you. Does that answer your question? Do you have any other questions? Then I have a question for you.

How are you going to put all this into practice? What if this is useful to you? That’s good. That that has been very useful. Anybody else?

How would you put it into practice for yourselves? Probably on the right path. And that my beliefs are correct. And that shouldn’t be in a big rush. Don’t rush.

There’s one thing which is very clear is that a French president actually put this very beautifully, François Mitterrand. He said, time does not respect what is done without it. That’s exactly it. So in one’s practice, it takes time. It takes a lot of time.

Anything durable takes time. And the other key point in practice is to mix one’s experience with one’s practice. Then in your case, are no longer quite that young, then you have a lot of experience. Then you have to draw on your experience and link it with the teachings. That transforms the mind.

Otherwise, if the teachings are here and the mind is here, there’s no big benefit. You do see people, they know the entire outline of Lam Rim by heart, they know everything, but the person has not changed. It must be linked to one’s experience. Excellent. I was just gonna say, you’re working with sick and dying people and I’ve practised on me, but I realised that in terms of actually resolving to actually take their physical illness, you know, I’ve taken what about the mental suffering.

And that suddenly hit me as a very helpful thing to do with physics. The mind is very slippery and will take bits and not others. And I think also what you said about a particular one person at a time and those that we are closer to. That’s a key point. I think that’s so helpful.

That’s a key point. You have this key point linked to experiencing meditation which is scattered throughout Lamrim Chenmo. And for yourself, with your mind of work, there was a practice of the great Tibetan Geshe’s up to the present day, but some of the very great ones who were killed in 1959 practiced this. They recited this stanza of bless me to take upon myself the suffering and so forth. Then they memorized it, and they recited it on their rosary.

You know, it is something you might find perhaps of use, You know? It doesn’t have to you don’t have to have a rose, but you can do it mentally. You know? And it’s very powerful because it covers the virtues, the roots of virtue, and all that it speaks in. Well, thank you very much.

Have a good weekend. If I could just say, know, thank you so much Ilya, because what our teachers tell us is to hear the teachings and then to contemplate. And so we have had a wonderful opportunity to contemplate on what our teachers present. You know, to tease it apart and to over a couple of hours just slowly work through what is, as Ilya has said, at the heart of what this center is about. I also think that, you know, Ilya has been described by our founder Rinpoche through Ilya’s own teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, who who said when he was here that Rinpoche said that Ilya is a yoga of yogis.

And in other words, Ilya is talking not just from his, you know, intellectual, but also from his experience. And I think that’s a very unique opportunity that we have. And so thank you, Ilya. We’re very, very fortunate to for you to give up your time to present such a powerful and and germane teaching. So in a traditional western way, if you’d like to join with me to thank.

You know, we have a full program and you’ve had a preliminary notice of the symposium coming up in August where Ilya will be presenting again, you know, very powerful east meets west on the nature of the mind. And have a look on the website and the flyers, and we’ll be redoing the flyer. So then there’s His Holiness’s birthday and many other activities. So if you’re not on our email list, then please see us and we can put you on. So thank you again.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is meant by "idiot compassion", and how should we balance compassion with our own limits?

No Buddhist text uses the term "idiot compassion", and there is no such thing as a foolish deed of compassion. What does exist is taking on more than one can bear. At the beginning one should be aware of one's strength and not take on more than one can practise, otherwise anger and resentment arise and one may walk away from everything. Working for others at one's own expense is true compassion, but it must match one's strength. Compassion must go hand in hand with wisdom about the means of helping. Giving money, for example, is not always helpful, as with an alcoholic or someone with addictions.

Does equanimity in how we treat people follow naturally from mental training, or do we have to force ourselves to act with equanimity physically?

Equanimity tends to grow with age and experience, as we see friendships change, with today's friend becoming tomorrow's enemy and the reverse, and we become somewhat disillusioned with life. As for outward behavior, a key element of mind training is that exterior behavior, clothing and attitude should not change. Only truly bad behavior needs to change. Otherwise outward change invites feedback from others, which harms practice, so any change should happen inside and be as invisible as possible. The test of mind training is controlling the mind when it is wild unexpectedly. Staying calm in meditation is not enough.

Scroll to Top