1 h 4 min · 2,795 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 65-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche examines the Sautrāntika school’s analysis of negative phenomena—a foundational distinction in Buddhist philosophy. He carefully unpacks three key non-affirming negatives: uncompounded space (mere absence of obstructive contact), the truth of cessation (the Dharma refuge), and emptiness of the person. For each, he explains how the mind apprehends them through negation rather than positive appearance. He then contrasts these with affirming negatives, using simple examples like “he is not a bad person”—where negating one thing allows something positive to dawn to the mind. A central focus is how conceptual minds function through self-generated mental images, or generic images, which differ fundamentally from direct sense perception. The teaching is aimed at practitioners already engaged with Buddhist tenet studies.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0129 – KR.mp3
UUID: ca7c94f4-fd7b-4024-9f48-7c29a2126aeb
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Tenets
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,793
And then we will generate the preliminary motivation as usual. Rinpoche has many times explained the mode of generation of bodhicitta. We must realize that we have been cycling endlessly in cyclic existence because we have failed to generate bodhicitta in the past, and therefore we must generate a strong resolution to generate bodhicitta at present. Now generally speaking, there are two main sources of this process of endless cyclic existence, which are respectively the ignorance which apprehends a self and self-cherishing. Both of these have to be eliminated, and through training in bodhicitta, the initial practice towards this is possible.
Another reason for which training in bodhicitta is absolutely fundamental is that on the basis of the generation of bodhicitta, as Rinpoche explained, the sevenfold cause and effect reasoning and the interchange of self and others, it is possible to transform any deed we practice, any source of virtue we practice into a cause for full and complete enlightenment. So, while the path is the practice of the Bodhisattvas with this motivation of bodhicitta as its underlying factor, the result which we are striving for is that state of full enlightenment for the benefit of all beings. So last time, we started explaining the fourth of the seven outlines of the Sautrāntika School. The fourth outline deals with the explanation of phenomena, and Geshe-la gave the definition of established basis, which are phenomena which are established by a valid cognizer, and then gave the twofold division of objects or phenomena into conventional truths and ultimate truths before passing on to an alternate division of phenomena into positive and negative phenomena.
All phenomena are either positive or negative phenomena and the easiest way to understand what is meant by a positive and a negative phenomenon is through examples. For instance, a house or this table are positive phenomena, which are understood positively through their characteristics. On the other hand, a negative phenomenon is a phenomenon which is understood through the negation of a positive phenomenon or for that matter a negative phenomenon too, which is its object of negation. So to put it simply Geshe-la says, the negation of a house, non-house, the negation of table, non-table, are negative phenomena. Negative phenomena generally speaking are divided themselves into two broad categories, affirming negatives and non-affirming negatives.
Now there is some debate between scholars whether affirming negatives are actually negative phenomena or not, but within the limitations of this school, the Sautrāntika school, they are considered to be negative phenomena, and therefore this is how we will present them. Now regarding the general definition of negative phenomena, which is given in your translation on page 10: that which is realized by means of the mind which apprehends it eliminating its object of negation, the first paragraph of page 10. As Geshe-la explained last time, what is implicit in this definition is the term directly. So it is that which is realized by the mind which apprehends it through eliminating directly its object of negation.
Otherwise there are a large category of phenomena which are actually positive phenomena and which are understood through the mind eliminating indirectly an object of negation. Do not qualify for this definition. And then as Geshe-la explained, there are two divisions of negative phenomena, non-affirming and affirming negatives. The principal category of negative phenomena which is of interest to us are non-affirming negatives. Instances of these are given on page ten, second paragraph of your text, such as uncompounded space, the truth of cessation and emptiness.
If we analyze clearly what exactly is meant when we say for instance that uncompounded space is a non-affirming negative, what is meant by uncompounded space is a mere absence of obstructive contact. That mere absence of obstructive contact is a mere negation, which does not imply anything. This mere negation is considered in the Sautrāntika system to be a permanent phenomenon, and such a mere negation of obstructive contact, the absence, if we touch a table, there is obstructive contact, but the space in between or the space above is qualified by the mere absence of this. This mere absence of obstructive contact cannot be perceived directly by a sense consciousness.
For instance, it cannot be perceived directly by a visual consciousness, whereas a visual consciousness perceives directly the color or the shape of a table. Now, one might wonder by which consciousness such a mere absence of obstructive contact, in other words, uncompounded space is perceived. It is perceived mainly by a conceptual consciousness. A conceptual consciousness concludes from the absence of obstructive contact, the existence of a phenomenon which is not perceived directly by the senses.
Now regarding the phenomenon uncompounded space, one might wonder whether it is indirectly perceived by a visual consciousness which perceives, for instance, this carpet. The visual consciousness which perceives this carpet, perceives this carpet directly. It does not perceive the space between itself and this carpet directly. But Geshe-la says, it is rather good to assert in debate that it perceives it indirectly. In other words, it does perceive indirectly the absence of obstructive contact, in the same way as for instance, the visual consciousness which is looking at this carpet, perceives this carpet directly, and then indirectly perceives the absence of vase on this carpet, which is a negative phenomenon.
And then the second instance of a non-affirming negative is the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation, which is again given as instance on page ten, second paragraph of your translation. Now this is actually an extremely important non-affirming negative, since actually the truth of cessation is the actual Dharma refuge. When we say, we take refuge in the Dharma, we are taking refuge actually in the truth of cessation, in the continuum of ārya beings and above. The truth of cessation only exists in the continuum of ārya beings and above. And if you wish to understand what precisely the truth of cessation is, the truth of cessation arises in dependence on the abandonment of the ignorance which apprehends the existence of a truly existing self.
This is actually more presentation from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika. As we train the mind in the apprehension of selflessness, the ignorance which apprehends the existence of a self progressively decreases as a wisdom which apprehends selflessness increases. Eventually, when the wisdom which apprehends selflessness is completed, that ignorance which apprehends the existence of a self is completely eliminated. That absence of the ignorance which apprehends a self is the truth of cessation. So now specifically regarding the truth of cessation, which Geshe-la would like to elaborate somewhat upon, that yogic direct valid cognizer which cognizes the emptiness of the true existence of the mind, which is accepted as such in general by all Buddhist schools, is the basis for the Buddha nature.
The Buddha nature is actually that mere emptiness of the mind, which is what acts as the foundation for the ultimate attainment of full enlightenment. The yogic valid direct cognizer, cognizing this through familiarizing itself repeatedly with this, eventually reaches the point where all the objects of abandonment, which are the ignorance apprehending the true existence of the mind are abandoned, and at this point, this yogic direct valid cognizer of the emptiness of the mind becomes the fully enlightened mind, the omniscient mind through the abandonment of all objects of abandonment. So generally speaking, the assertion that the truth of cessation, the third of the four noble truths, the Dharma jewel, is an assertion which is common to all four Buddhist schools. The mode of positing the truth of cessation varies from school to school. The highest school, the Prāsaṇgika school, posits the truth of cessation as that mere emptiness of inherent existence of the mind.
This is also considered by the Prāsaṇgika school to be the Buddha nature. Now the schools from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka down, all the way to the Cittamātra school, have different ways of positing the truth of cessation. However, they all accept that the truth of cessation is that unstained part of the mind which remains after purification of the mind of all the objects of abandonment. It is therefore that unstained part of the mind which remains when all objects of abandonment have been abandoned. And since the assertion of such an unstained part of the mind as the truth of cessation is common to all schools, it is very important to understand it clearly.
So the being in whose continuum the truth of cessation has been directly realized is a being in whose continuum the causes of cyclic existence have been interrupted. Since from within the two, karma and afflictions, within the continuum of such a being, the coarse afflictions would have been completely interrupted, and immovable karma would also have been eliminated. This is the main reason for which the truth of cessation is identified with the Dharma jewel, which is the main object of our obeisance, and the main object of refuge, since it is that and that alone, which puts an end to cyclic existence. The Sangha jewel and the Buddha jewel are subsidiary jewels. They are objects of refuge in as much as the Buddha jewel teaches the Dharma jewel, and in as much as the Sangha jewel on the other hand accompanies one or helps one in the practice of the Dharma jewel.
But the actual object of refuge is the Dharma jewel, and specifically the noble truth of cessation. And the third example, always the second paragraph of page 10 of a non-affirming negative is emptiness. Now there are various presentations of emptiness in the four schools, Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra, and Madhyamaka. The presentation of emptiness which is alluded to here as the principle non-affirming negative in the context of Sautrāntika is the same as the subtle emptiness of persons taught at the level of the Vaibhāṣika school. In other words, a person’s emptiness of being a substantially existent autonomous phenomenon, and this particular type of emptiness is accepted in various modalities also by the Cittamātra and the Madhyamaka.
It is the principal emptiness in the context of Sautrāntika, because the Sautrāntika practitioners consider that the principle obstacle to our attainment of liberation, or full enlightenment for that matter, are obstacles which arise in relation to our own person, to our own self. Specifically they are first the apprehension of our own person as a permanent phenomenon, hence the importance of generating a yogic direct valid cognizer realizing the impermanence of the person. And then the apprehension of one’s own person as a substantially existing autonomous phenomenon. Hence the importance of meditating on an emptiness of that. Now the emptiness of the person being a substantially existing autonomous phenomenon is an emptiness, but it is an existent.
It is therefore something we can meditate upon. If it were non-existent, we could not meditate upon it. So we have completed the presentation of the first of the two divisions of negative phenomena, which is non-affirming negative, principal categories of negative phenomena. Now to put things very succinctly, a non-affirming negative is a phenomenon which when it is apprehended is such that nothing appears to the mind. What appears is a mere absence.
This is why emptiness of truth and cessation are said to be non-affirming negatives. An affirming negative in Tibetan is dgag pa, is a little bit different. At the time of apprehending this phenomenon, something is negated, something else is nonetheless affirmed, and that affirmative portion does appear to the mind. So the examples which are given of the second subdivision, affirming negatives in your text, are that which turns away from not being seen. The explanation in Geshe-la is going to give relies on a very precise translation of the Tibetan, so you should look at note 97 of the text. It’s translated as non-non-thing. Now when a mind apprehends non-non-thing, to the mind which apprehends non-non-thing, thing initially has to appear. So because thing initially appears to that mind, then the mind apprehending non-non-thing is not a non-affirming negative, it is an affirming negative because it negates something indeed, but something else appears to it. To give a simpler example, Geshe-la says, take for instance the statement, he is not a bad person.
Now, when we say he is not a bad person, it is a negative phenomenon. We are negating that whoever is concerned is a bad person. So bad is negated. But implicit in this statement is an affirmation. The implicit affirmation is actually that he is a good person, that he is okay.
So that implicit affirmation dawns to the mind. For this reason, this type of phenomenon are called affirming negatives. They negate in one respect, but in another respect something positive does dawn to the mind. And the final example of an affirming negative given in your text is the example of the meaning generality, or the generic image of vase to a conceptual consciousness, it’s at the bottom of the second paragraph of page 10, or the appearance to the conceptual mind apprehending vase of that which turns away from not being vase. The Tibetan reads literally, the appearance of the conceptual mind apprehending vase of non-non-vase.
Now, it is very important here to understand the process by which conceptual minds function, what generic images are, and the differences between conceptual minds and non-conceptual minds such as sense consciousnesses. Conceptual minds are minds which understand phenomena, even in the absence of phenomena. For instance, if somebody describes a distant place to you, let’s say Paris, and you’ve never been to Paris, nonetheless as they describe it to you, the conceptual mind from its own side creates a mental image, or a generic image of Paris, which may or may not correspond with Paris. Since you’ve not been there, chances are it won’t correspond with Paris. For this reason, conceptual minds are said to be mistaken minds.
They’re not mistaken because they are fundamentally flawed in the way they function, they are mistaken because they apprehend phenomena through a self-created screen, which is the meaning generality. Now this meaning generality, if you were to take the example of vase and the conceptual mind apprehending vase, would be the appearance to the mind apprehending vase of non-non-vase. This meaning generality is said to be an affirming negative because there is a negative component, which is non-non-vase, which excludes all of the individual characteristics of vase, keeping only the bare outline of vase as something dawning to the conceptual mind. But to such a mind, a form of vase dawns or appears. Therefore, something positive dawns or appears.
Such an object is therefore called an affirming negative. Now this characteristic of conceptual minds, to put it very succinctly and very simply, is that from the Sautrāntika standpoint, conceptual minds apprehend phenomena mainly through the force of the mind itself. It’s the mind itself which creates the generic image of the phenomena which corresponds more or less with the phenomena it is recollecting or apprehending. Sense consciousnesses on the other hand apprehend phenomena from the standpoint of Sautrāntika mainly through the force of phenomena appearing from the outside. Now the importance for us to understand conceptual minds is that actually in our practice, conceptual minds are the most beneficial of minds.
They are the most powerful minds which help us the most. Therefore they are the minds we have to try to understand. They are also the most stable minds. They are much more stable than sense consciousnesses which are very unstable. So we will stop here today since we have only one hour.
So you have a five minute break, which means you have time either for the loo or for tea, but not for both. Okay. And now you have a five minute break. You can go for a toilet or have a cup of tea. The water is falling, and you just grab a quick cup of tea. Oh, you want to get water there. Bottled water may be easier for you. Anyway, if you haven’t got this tenets book, you just come forward to the office. If you haven’t stopped because there needs to be a softcover. If you had the, yeah, if you want to have a doubt, I think I have given in Wednesday. But if you want more, I’ve got some here.
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.