Vinaya – Ethics – 2016-03-26 – KR

1 h 50 min · 5,070 words · 26 March 2016

Vinaya - Ethics (Khensur Rinpoche)
Vinaya - Ethics (Khensur Rinpoche)
Vinaya - Ethics - 2016-03-26 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues a weekend retreat talk on the 37 factors of enlightenment. The teacher explains the four close placements of mindfulness, meditating on the body and sensations as sources of suffering, and breathing meditation to settle the mind. The talk then covers the four correct abandonments and the four legs of magical emanation as steps toward calm abiding, followed by a question and answer session.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 50m

UUID: e3b67a8e-b9a4-4805-a4b2-b3a0082df4ed

Date: 2016-03-26

Words: 5,066

So since we have a special opportunity over this weekend, we should adopt a different attitude from the normal one we have and should view this period as a retreat and take something akin to the vows of a retreat behaving differently. And therefore we should engage in the practice of virtue and try not to waste our time. At present, we have the opportunity to do this during this weekend. Generally speaking, when we have to work and so forth, this is not possible. Therefore, let us try to engage in virtue and not waste our time at the center.

So I mentioned yesterday the importance of this attitude but you may have forgotten so I will mention it again today. During a small retreat like this one, one should restrain one’s body and one’s speech and in addition one should as much as possible try to abstain from the 10 non virtuous deeds. Specifically, we should focus our minds on the Lam Rim and at the center in general we should try only to talk about the Lam Rim and to think about the conditions which are requisite for its practice. And then in addition, when one returns home, one slows down and rests a bit but the next day in the morning when one gets up, one tries to get up as early as possible, at the very least at 05:30 and then one should go through the objects of all the cycles of meditation of the Lamrim, the path of the being of the small, middling and great scope and then one will definitely gain some type of experience. And then one should engage in these preliminary practice and visualize whichever teacher one is connected to.

Imagine nectar flowing from his body and then engage in the cycles of visualization of the lamrim. This is what a retreat is. A retreat is not so much visualizing deities and so forth as changing the way one thinks for instance by the means of the Lamrim. Kensur Rinpoche gave a very important piece of advice to us. He said that beginners like us when we engage in retreats should always have the texts pertaining to the retreat open in front of us.

Then since we’re not accustomed it’s easy for us to forget and we can check immediately in the texts. Otherwise, if we rely only on our own knowledge and and we forget something, then our minds go for a walk, don’t they? Then one has to stand up and go and find the text in one’s library and heaven knows where one’s mind has gone in the meantime Or if it is a group retreat, you can’t get up at all and then you can’t do anything. That’s an excellent piece of advice since for beginners like us the moment we forget something, we can check the text in front of us and if we keep forgetting, we keep checking from time to time where we are. Then ideally obviously we would have memorized the material but this is not always possible.

In addition, a physical text is far preferable to a computer because you don’t have to open it and fish around for things and obviously if there’s no electricity, no computer. It’s a very great piece of advice and therefore I repeat it to all those who have faith in Rinpoche and rely on him. Some disciples of Rinpoche who have faith in him during their retreats always have a copy of the lamrim open on the table in front of them and whenever they forget some things they check-in it. Now this is excellent. There’s no retreat without Lamrim.

And however long one meditates whether it’s for one minute, fifteen, twenty minutes, an hour, a day, a week. In our case it is difficult, so maybe fifteen or twenty minutes. Then if we focus carefully on the Lamrim, we will accumulate virtue. So if you protect these retreat pledges as I suggested and put effort, then definitely you will get powerful and meaningful dreams such as seeing your spiritual teacher and so forth. Do you understand?

So what is a retreat without meditation And what does meditation refer to? As was said many times, the body and the speech follow the mind. The mind itself follows the afflictions. So what we are seeking for is a means to prevent the mind from falling under the sway of the afflictions. This is meditation.

So what we need is stable recollection, a strong memory and powerful concentration. If these three are present, there will be no doubt that the factor of appearance of the object of meditation will be clear. So if we were to enter immediately in the practice of the path of the being of the middling scope, what would we focus upon? We would focus on the truth of suffering Since as is said, if one does not understand the faults of the truth of suffering, how is it possible to generate the mind striving for liberation? Said by Jetsongkapa in his Song of Realization.

So how precisely do we focus on the truth of suffering? Do we focus on this house, car and so forth? No. We must focus on the thoughts of the truth of suffering. So here I will present the way to meditate.

Often in text mentioned is made of the prerequisites for meditation such as reconnection, vigilance, concentration and so forth, but nothing is said really about what one meditates upon. So therefore when Jetsongkopas says, if one does not meditate on the faults of the truth of suffering, how can one generate the mind striving for liberation? What precisely is the truth of suffering to be meditated upon? It is I think appropriate to meditate on this body of flesh and of bone and on its faults, in other words our contaminated aggregates. So we should then ask ourselves after getting these aggregates, in other words this body and mind, have there been problems and difficulties or not?

When our aggregates are established, we can see that we experience suffering of the nature of the suffering of hunger, the suffering of thirst, the suffering of cold, the suffering of heat, the suffering of disease, then these are the defects of these aggregates. So it is only if one sees these defects that one will wish for liberation from these aggregates. If one does not see the defects, one will not wish for any freedom from the aggregates. This is how one should think. Then yesterday when I presented the definition of the close placement of recollection on page one of your definitions of the seven subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment, is suppliance which has entered the path through having included either a recollection or a wisdom meditating through the investigation of the general characteristics by pairs of body sensation, mind and phenomena, questions arose regarding what was meant by pairs.

So this term by pairs has a very profound meaning. It refers to both the own characteristics and the general characteristics of the object observed, in this case, the body. So what exactly are the own characteristics of the body? The own characteristics of the body are precisely that it is an appropriation of evil states. And this refers to the fact that from the moment of establishment of this body onwards, it has only been a source of suffering, the sufferings which were mentioned, hunger, thirst, heat, cold, disease and so forth.

If we do not understand this body as an appropriation of evil states, we will not be able to generate the mind striving for liberation from our contaminated aggregates and if we cannot strive, generate the mind striving for our liberation, then there is no meditation of the being of the middling scope whatsoever. So, when we therefore meditate on the own characteristics of the body, we are meditating precisely on the fact that this body is a source of suffering from its inception. This is what is meant as the noble truth of suffering. Our contaminated aggregates are suffering from their inception. If the realization of this is absent, then obviously there is no hope to gain an understanding of the truth of the origin of suffering, and then there is no hope to gain an understanding of the truth of cessation or of the path and everything goes to waste.

And therefore, if we take the close application of a close placement of recollection on the body as an example, then one should engage in a recollection or a wisdom meditating through the investigation of the generic characteristics by pair of the body. Then once one has meditated on the specific characteristics of let us say the contaminated aggregates or the body, At this point, one asks oneself how to put an end to this state of affairs and this is only possible through progressing to the general characteristics of the contaminated aggregates or the body. And these general characteristics are that the body is impermanent, the body is of the nature of suffering and obviously in addition, it is also empty and selfless. It is through this understanding of the general characteristics that we are able to put an end to the specific characteristics of the body. Otherwise it is not possible.

Do you understand? So you may have considerable doubt at this point when one studies the topic of the close placement of recollection in the great monasteries in the debate Courtyard. When one studies this topic, the issue of what is meant by the term by pairs is sharply debated. Does this refer to one mind which is realizing two different characteristics at the same time? No.

This refers in my opinion to one continuum of mind. So this is how one proceeds when we meditate on the close placement of recollection on the body by pairs focusing on its specific and general characteristics. Now if we move onwards to the close placement of recollection on sensations, one focuses as well on the general, the specific and the general characteristics of sensations and on the fact that pleasant sensations give rise to a craving for pleasant sensations and unpleasant sensations give rise to an anger, a hostility towards unpleasant sensations, both of which trouble the mind. This troubling of the mind is the fault of sensations and it is through contaminated sensations and it is through understanding the thoughts of contaminated sensations that one can generate the wish to be freed from them. And as for the general characteristics of sensations, it is as was explained before, based on the specific characteristics, one understands that they are impermanent, they are of the nature of suffering, they are selfless, and they are empty and this is how the antidotes are applied.

So if you meditate in this way on the body or the contaminated aggregates and the mode of abiding of the body of the contaminated aggregates and on the mode of abiding of sensations both pleasant and unpleasant. Does the object of meditation become clearer to you or not? Then ideally one should focus without distraction on the object of meditation but this is rather difficult. I think 60% focus is acceptable and then obviously if you have a 100% focus, marvelous. Then for beginners like us, if we think I won’t achieve anything if my mind gets scattered after three or five seconds, there is no hope because that is what we will experience.

So we have to build up our capacity and if we can focus without distraction for one minute, that is exceptional already. Then we try to establish a continuum of concentration and obviously at points our mind will get distracted. This is almost unavoidable but we should try to pull it back at once and if we do that, then it is okay and over time our concentration will increase. So if when we start to meditate on the aggregates as object of observation, our mind instantaneously is distracted, then obviously we have not even found the factor of appearance. In other words, the object of meditation.

And then at that point, we have to find means to bring the mind back on the object of meditation. Then if when we try to focus on the object of meditation, we lose it at once, We have to seek for means to bring it back to this factor of appearance. And there are numerous means we can use. We can focus on the body of a deity of our choice. It can be Ariatara, it can be the Medicine Buddha, it can be Manjushri, can be Avalokiteshva or we can focus on the seed syllables of deities such as and so forth.

Then when I say focus, I don’t mean stare at the body of Buddha Shakyamuni Tara or Avalokiteshvara. There is no benefit in training and concentration there. Then the representations of Buddha Shakyamuni behind us are accurate representations and these are the basis on which in visualization we develop concentration. So what we wish for therefore is to visualize such a body in front of us in space. It can be either in front of the point between the two eyebrows or in front of the heart, it depends on our personal preference and this visualization must be clear and stable.

Then once that is present, we try to maintain it uninterruptedly. Then when you try to visualize, does something appear to your mind? So when we are unable to recollect clearly the object of meditation, this is due to weak memory or weak recollection and there are two possible causes for this. The first is agitation, where the mind is scattered outwards under the power of desire and the second is sinking, where the mind sinks under the power of fancies. But whatever the case, it is beneficial to engage in the practice of breathing meditation.

However, whatever the cause for the distraction, its foundation is fancies or unwanted conceptuality And here breathing meditation is very helpful. What is meant by breathing meditation is focusing on the expiration and the inspiration of breath. This focus on the outward and inward movement of breath naturally reduces fancies and ideations because we are focusing on only one thing. So how does one proceed? One can count one cycle of breathing meditation or 21.

Let us say we count 21 cycles. Initially one adopts an appropriate position with a straight back and then when one exhales, one focuses on the exhaling and if one inhales, one focuses on the inhaling. One does this 21 times and it is said that this reduces ideations and flights of fancy. So in our case we have to understand that we are breathing out and breathing in. Often the only sense we have of this happening is the sound.

So we proceed in this fashion if we are unable to focus on the object of observation of the previous teachings. And if we are able to focus on it, these breathing meditations are unnecessary. And then we would initially focus on the body as a source of suffering, as the noble truth of suffering, and then in dependence on this focus on sensations, pleasant sensations which give rise to craving and unpleasant sensations which give rise to anger as the noble truth of the origin of suffering. And therefore, let us meditate during a couple of seconds as follows. Understanding that this craving which arises from wishing for pleasant sensations and the loathing which arises from wishing to be separated from unpleasant sensations are the cause of troubling our mind, we seek then for the root cause of this craving and this loathing and we find them within the beginningless ignorance which grasp or apprehends a self.

Then striving to counter this beginningless ignorance leads us to an understanding of the noble truth of cessation and in dependence on this in turn generating the mind which wishes for liberation. In other words, uncontrived renunciation, we gain an understanding of the noble truth of the path. Let us meditate on this for a couple of minutes. And since we are in a quiet peaceful environment with remarkable favorable conditions, let us meditate in this way for a while. I think, really.

Good. So we’ll start with You are a good girl. And then the invocation. Generate the four immeasurables, perform the seven limb prayer, and then the two mandala offerings. So do you have at present questions only regarding the four close placements of recollection which we covered yesterday and today?

Please ask clear, simple questions with only a few words. Am I incorrect in assuming it’s a primarily analytical meditation? A primarily what? Analytical. Yes, in the definition what is said is a suppliance which has entered the path through having included either a recollection or a wisdom meditating through investigation of the general characteristics by pairs of body sensation, mind and phenomena.

So it is an analytical meditation. I listened to a little bit of teaching last night, so this is a question from the teaching yesterday. Is it the case that there is a close placement of recollection which is a recollection and then there’s a close placement of recollection which is a wisdom and then there’s a close placement of recollection, which is neither of the two, so neither a recollection or a wisdom. So are there three? So there is no definiteness or no certainty that a close placement of recollection is either a wisdom or a recollection.

The main mind involved is surrounded by mental factors such as concentration, wisdom, recollection and so forth, which are all involved. Another, the chart. Being only a source of suffering. There’s the distinction between body and sensation. Hunger and thirst experiences arising from sense organs.

Sense organs, sensations give rise to pleasant experiences and unpleasant experiences, both lead to suffering. Is that the sense in which the body is only a source of suffering? Or are you making a broader distinction between body and sensation which leads body only to be a source of suffering notwithstanding the fact that it gives rise to sensations that are either pleasant or unpleasant. So when we try to answer your question, You mentioned the case of thirst. Then thirst is actually a suffering which arises from the gustatory organ, the sense of taste.

The gustatory organ of the tongue is part of the body. So when we refer to close placement of mindfulness on the body and the body as a source of suffering, we’re not actually referring to all this so much as to for instance, the five sense organs which are a base for the five sensory consciousnesses which experience suffering. Great. I have a similar question on why meditating on the body maps the truth of suffering and why meditating on sensation maps to original suffering. In my opinion, the body is not only the source of suffering but partially also original suffering.

Say, for example, if the body also contains the brain, the brain has the limbic system. The limbic system is a a very primordial system that process a lot of emotions. And a lot of emotions, they are sensations as well. And second, why I say sensations not only the origin of suffering? Think sensation both suffering and origin of suffering.

Yes, I fully agree with what you say. The noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering are not contradictory and incompatible. They are in a causal relationship with each other. The noble truth of suffering is the cause of the noble truth of the origin and the noble truth of the origin is the result of the noble truth of suffering. And another?

Can I come back to experiences of of the sense organs in that case? Some of my happiest or most pleasant memories, recollections, I suppose, with Geshela in terms of listening with my with my ears, ear hearing organ, with seeing, and with eating. I can remember memories of going with taking Geshela to the opera to see Fidelio, watching the World Cup soccer, eating pizzas. Now I can crave for those experiences again and suffer afflictions as a result, will lead to suffering. But at the time, it wasn’t a suffering experience.

So in what sense is it only, is the body only a source of suffering in that sense? So the reason we say that the body is of the nature of suffering is quite straightforward. It is because this body is a direct or this physical basis, direct result of afflictions and the afflictions themselves give rise to suffering. Then likewise, all these pleasant experiences you mentioned are pleasant indeed, but then the wish not to be separated from them arises. That wish is a craving and that craving gives rise to suffering such as the suffering of the memories.

It’s very easy. We always view ourselves as the result of the offspring of our parents, of the union of the spermatozoa and the ovum of our father and mother but actually our minds are beginningless and if we take this body of ours, this body is actually a basis, this mind is a basis on which coarse anger arises. Without such mind and body, coarse anger cannot arise and coarse anger definitely is suffering. So we shall stop here for the presentation of the four close placements of recollection. The second of the seven subdivisions is the four correct abandonments.

So listen carefully, I think it is a somewhat easier subject. So there is a very elegant, beautiful connection between the first of the seven, seven subdivisions, close placements of recollection and the second a correct abandonment. In a close placement of recollection, the mind was focused with a powerful recollection on the four noble truths. These were, these are the actual general characteristics of the four close placements of recollection. Independence on this, a great sense of joy arises and a wish to abandon what is to be abandoned among the four noble truths and to practice what is to be practiced among the four noble truths and this leads one directly to the four correct abandonments.

The nature of the four correct abandonments is enthusiasm. Then the subdivision of the topic is identical. It’s subdivided into eight, the object of correct abandonments, how to meditate on it, the purpose, the nature, the subdivisions, the boundaries, the etymology and establishing the supremacy of correct abandonments of the Mahayana. So these four correct abandonments are listed on your handout, the 37 facets of enlightenment. This is the first subdivision of the topic, the object of the four correct abandonments, which are non generation of ungenerated non virtuous phenomena.

Here, ungenerated refers to the future non virtuous phenomena, which one does not generate. The second is abandonment of those already generated. This refers to previously generated non virtuous deeds, in other words past ones. The third refers to the generation of ungenerated virtuous phenomena, which refers to future virtuous phenomena yet to be generated. And the fourth is a generation of the aspiration to increase those already generated.

So the way of meditation, this is the second subdivision is to putting effort, enthusiasm and aspiration in not generating ungenerated virtuous, non virtuous phenomena, abandoning those which are already generated, generating ungenerated virtuous phenomena and generating an aspiration to increase those already generated. So here, the first two, four correct abandonments in the case of anger refer to not generating ungenerated anger within our own mindstream and abandoning the anger already generated. At present, a permanent abandonment of anger and of afflictions is not possible for us. We can just put effort in this and over time, eventually it will become possible. So what is the purpose, the third subdivision of the four correct abandonments?

It is to lead to the decline or the decay of what is discordant with the practice of virtue and the enhancement of what is concordant with it and this leads rapidly to the four legs of magical emanation concentration. Now, what is the fourth subdivision? The nature, in other words, the definition of a correct abandonment. This is on your definitions of the seven subdivisions. It is a sapience which has entered the path having become an enthusiasm, delighting and relinquishing the abandonments and appropriating the antidotes.

In other words, the four correct abandonments are enthusiasms by nature. Then the fifth subdivision, the divisions of this topic are exactly the same listed here. Non generation of ungenerated non virtuous phenomena and so forth. Then the following subdivision boundaries, the four correct abandonments are generated from the path of accumulation until full enlightenment. The seventh presentation, etymology, these are called correct abandonments because in the case of anger, let us say, one continuously abandons anger.

And the eighth outline of this topic, establishing the superiority of correct abandonments of the Mahayana occurs simply because correct abandonments of the Mahayana are upheld by bodhichitta. Then in some texts, a relationship is established between the four correct abandonments and the four forces of an antidote. It’s very elegant. This completes the presentation of the second, of the seven subdivisions correct abandonments. So this completes the presentation of the four correct abandonments and the four correct abandonments lead us immediately to the next of the seven subdivisions.

The four feet, did I translate feet or limbs? The four legs, the four legs of magical emanation. Now, this occurs because as the four correct abandonments are in nature an enthusiasm, an enthusiasm for the practice of virtue and for the abandonment of non virtue, the training in this enthusiasm eventually leads to an operability of body and mind which is none other than a mental and a physical pliancy. As you know there are two pliancies, mental and physical pliancy. So, we have progressed in this way from the four close placements of recollection on body sensation, mind and phenomena to the four correct abandonments, which are of the nature of an enthusiasm, an enthusiasm in the pursuit of virtue and an enthusiasm in the abandonment of non virtue.

This enthusiasm eventually leads to a great delight, physical and mental delight. This physical and mental delight which arise from enthusiasm are none other than physical and mental pliancy. So such an enthusiasm which is an enthusiasm in the virtuous direction through which we experience no hardship in the pursuit of virtue enables us for instance when we study the Lamrim to study it uninterruptedly and in-depth. When that enthusiasm is lacking, when we encounter difficulties in the study of Lamrim, immediately we start to drowse away. In other words, the physical experience of difficulty we have leads to mental drowsiness and eventually fall asleep.

And this is a clear sign of lack of enthusiasm. Now, once this enthusiasm in the accomplishment of what is virtuous and the abandonment of what is non virtuous is stable, it rapidly leads to the pliancies, physical pliancy and mental pliancy. And these in turn are the gateway for calm abiding. Therefore, this third subdivision of the 37 facets of enlightenment, the four legs of magical emanation is intimately related to calm abiding. So this topic, the four legs of magical emanation is once again presented in the light of eight sub topics and the presentation is very closely related to calm abiding albeit not identical.

The first subdivision is the object. The object here is the magical emanations which enable one to multiply one body into numerous bodies or to subdivide multiple bodies into one. Then the remaining seven subdivisions, please cover carefully by yourselves and we will cover ourselves later and you can ask questions. So I suspect that when we say that the object of the legs of magical emanations is to multiply one body into numerous bodies or to subsume numerous bodies into one. This must be very strange for you.

This is something which we are not presently able to do. Be careful, listen to me. So as we progress upwards from the close placement of recollection on body sensation, mind and phenomena to the four correct abandonments which are in nature on enthusiasm and these four correct abandonments in turn generate the two pliancies, physical and mental pliancy. We eventually give rise to calm abiding, which is a concentration in which both the factor of appearance and the factor of clarity of the object of meditation are perfectly present, and where we can focus on the object of meditation for days, weeks, months or years. Then we might wonder just how precisely is this possible, it’s astonishing.

It’s astonishing to us because we are overly dependent on the sensory consciousnesses which are dependent on the sense organs, which in turn depend on the exterior sense objects, which obviously are completely out of our control. So at present our coarse minds are totally under the control of the sensory organs and the sensory consciousnesses. But once we develop concentration and calm abiding, then we rely exclusively on the mental consciousness. And at this point, our mind is, has power over itself. Then as mind and wind are intimately or mind and prana are intimately associated, when mentally we choose to visualize a multiplication of a person into 10, the winds associated with that mind follow the mind and that multiplication occurs.

Likewise, when we choose to subsume 10 visualized persons into one, the same happens. Do you understand? Then this is possible because of the connection between mind and wind or mind and prana. For a mind which is only a factor of clarity and cognitiveness to cause this would be very difficult. So obviously at present, we have no experience of this because we rely only on coarse minds.

And coarse minds depend on the sensory consciousnesses when we bump into a table or a wall, there’s no going beyond that. But once we are able to actualize these subtle minds and rely on these subtle winds, then these limitations are eliminated. Do you understand? Think about this, it’s very beautiful. We shall stop here for this morning.

Yeah, yeah. Okay, thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top