Karma – 2012-08-12 – KR

1 h 34 min · 12,205 words · 12 August 2012

Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma - 2012-08-12 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk opens with quantum physics and locality, then turns to karma. It explains projecting and completing karma, the features of karma (definite, increasing, not experienced unless accumulated, indestructible), and the four forces of purification. It describes what makes a deed of killing complete and ways to reduce or amplify karmic weight, including through vows and the object of the deed. A question on capital punishment is answered at the end.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 35m

UUID: 4263aa6a-ad21-4b97-8234-9653d400d736

Date: 2012-08-12

Words: 12,201

Now each of these three points is problematical from the standpoint of quantum physics. Anteriority is problematical especially from the standpoint of the special theory of relativity. We will not talk about it too much today. Locality as we will see is highly problematic from the standpoint of quantum physics. Necessary correlation as was explained yesterday is problematic because the phenomenon before observation is described by a wave function which is probabilistic in nature and this has led to the famous statement that quantum mechanics leads to the collapse of classical causality.

So these are not tried questions for us. Since Buddhism is built on causality, have to see whether the quantum mechanical assessment of causality and perhaps its destruction has a major impact on Buddhism or not. And the question I would like to address with you today is what locality is. This is a rather nice way of putting it locality is just beads on top of each other. Locality is so central in eco-physics, it is simply taken for granted.

The core idea is that phenomena can act upon each other only if they are next to each other or if the action of phenomena A is mediated by some means which impacts phenomenon B. It seems self evident. I can only move my laser pointer if I touch it or if I grasp a pole and I poke it. But I cannot from a distance with no relation whatsoever to my laser pointer move the laser pointer. And this led Newton to his famous statement that one body can act at a distance through a void without the mediation of anything else is to me so great an absurdity that I believe no man who has in philosophical matters a competent faculty of thinking can ever fall into it.

So the Newtonian understanding of locality is the following. You have all seen these pendulums which illustrate what is known in physics as a conservation of the quantity of motion. One bead hits the group of stacked pendulums here and the last bead at the end pops up. You have transmission of the quantity of momentum, that is mv, through contact. This is the traditional classic Newtonian understanding of locality.

Poor Newton unfortunately, just after having said this, was hoisted on his own petard. Because one of Newton’s fundamental discoveries is what is known as a universal law of gravitation. And unfortunately, the universal principle of gravitation is strongly non local. It formulates the attraction between two masses separated by an arbitrary distance d, which can be as great as possible and says simply that the attraction is proportional to both masses multiplied divided by the square of the distance which separates them which is classical in basically all analysis of fields in physics and multiplied by a constant G which we talked about yesterday as well as the three fundamental constants of the universe. The problem is or the problem was for Newton that there is nothing to connect m one and m two.

They can be infinitely separated and nonetheless they attract each other. And Newton famously said in this in this context, Fingo, I basically make believe. I make believe there is some type of contact even though I know there isn’t. It was a gigantic embarrassment for physics and for Newtonian physics in particular. This embarrassment remained present until Einstein formulated the general theory of relativity.

Before the first time it was possible to actually explain gravitational attraction in terms of locality. And this was done as you may have heard through assuming the existence of a substratum of the universe, space time, which was actually deformed by the presence of mass. So the famous experiment which was made in the late late nineteen twenties, if memory serves me well, demonstrated the parallax of the light emitted by a star and demonstrated that the light, the trajectory of the light was actually deviated by the mass of the Sun. You can see here that the actual trajectory would be this one without the gravitational presence of the Sun, but it is deviated by the presence of the Sun. This deviation is local.

The beam of photons is affected actually by local curvature of space. So this seemed to be a clear indication of locality. There can only be action when there is some type of contact, contact between very very strange things between for instance a beam of photons and the underlying curvature of space. Unfortunately, Einstein who formulated this theory, in trying to demonstrate the invalidity of quantum mechanics brought the whole contraption crashing down. By formulating what has become known as the Einstein Podolsky Rosen theorem, perhaps better known as the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paradox, which is perhaps constitutive of modern quantum mechanics.

Einstein as you know famously said God does not play dice. And Wall Einstein was open to a statistical understanding of physics in general. He clearly felt that the uncertainty principles which are present in quantum mechanics between what are known as non commutating operators were totally at odd with any understanding of the world he could have. Einstein subscribed to what is known now as a realistic local vision of the world. In other words, for him, the world really existed apart from the observer and the world was local.

You had only action of phenomena on each other through some type of contact. What Einstein and his two younger colleagues, Podolsky and Rosen, Podolsky actually drew up the paper and it’s very badly written, Einstein complained about this after. What Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen did was to take quantum mechanics of which we talked briefly yesterday and to demonstrate that if quantum mechanics is true, the universe is non local. This flies, we will see rather quickly why, in the face of core premises of the theory relativity. And as far as Einstein was concerned, this was sufficient to demonstrate that quantum mechanics in its state when the paper was composed in the nineteen thirties was an incomplete theory.

Einstein did not reject quantum mechanics but he considered quantum mechanics was part of a greater whole, that there were aspects of reality which are inaccessible, the so called hidden parameters which once discovered would enable one to pass from a statistical description of reality in which certain key elements of a particle are unknowable simultaneously to a much more classical description of reality. In the abstract of this paper and if you have time I’ve listed it in the bibliography, you might want to read it. It’s three four pages. There is not that much mathematics and it is perhaps perhaps the most important paper in physics in the twentieth century. I think to my knowledge it’s the most quoted.

In the abstract Einstein says in a complete theory there is an element corresponding to each element of reality. A sufficient condition for the reality of a physical quantity is a possibility of predicting it without in any way, disturbing the system. In quantum mechanics, in the case of two physical quantities described by non commuting operators, in other words the position of a particle and its quantity of motion. For instance, in other words, the position of a particle and its speed. The knowledge of one precludes the knowledge of the other.

This is what is known commonly as Heisenberg’s principle. The product of the uncertainty regarding the position of a particle by the uncertainty regarding its quantity of motion is greater or equal than H onto P. Then if this is the case according to the authors one is led to the conclusion that description of reality as given by a wave function, in other words as given by quantum mechanics is incomplete. This paper was paid lip service by the founders of quantum mechanics not only because of the tremendous prestige of Einstein but was otherwise quietly passed under silence in the same way as you will pass the peccadillo of a gentleman turned 40 who has a much younger mistress but who otherwise is highly respectable. It is something one doesn’t talk about in good society, one makes believe it hasn’t happened.

The problem is that Einstein was onto something much more important than was ever suspected at the period. One of the leading Irish physicists in the nineteen sixties, John Bell, did something which was quite unpopular at the period. Instead of working with quantum mechanics, he started thinking about quantum mechanics and thinking about the fundamental principles. Specifically what Bell did was he tried to find equations which described local systems. We spoke a little bit of locality previously and locality seemed to be something self evident.

The equation Bell found and we won’t enter into it is a fundamental inequality for any local system which is realistic. In other words for any system which exists independently of the observer and which in addition satisfies locality. In other words, there is no action on an element of the system at a distance without some intermediary means of action. You might even say a vector if you want. Now Bell’s inequalities have to be verified for any system which is realistic in the sense in which Einstein gave to this term.

In other words, basically realistic in the sense of classical physics, the world out there, what most of us consider things to be. Bell’s inequalities must also be verified for any deterministic system, although there is debate about this one. And most importantly for us, they must be verified for any local system. So it seemed pretty obvious that they would be verified until attempts were made to try to see if there were exceptions to Bell’s inequalities. And fortunately or unfortunately, depending on one’s viewpoint, these exceptions were found.

It was specifically found in Alain Aspect, the French physicist who did much of this work, that if two photons, in other words two particles of light, which are entangled, in other words we would say in colloquial English which have a relationship. They have let’s say the same source. In other words, can be described described by the same wave function. Move at a very great distance from each other. And then a transformation is affected on one of these photons.

It may be for instance polarized. The other photon instantaneously responds in kind. Now this is a tremendous embarrassment from the standpoint of the theory of relativity, because if you are at distances which are so great that the speed of light, the speed at which a signal is transmitted in the physical universe takes a sizable amount of time to pass from one photon to the other, how is it possible that there is an instantaneous correlation or anti correlation in the behavior of the two photons. If you are going to say that signals are transmitted at a speed greater than the speed of light, relativity collapses and relativity is strongly verified. However, this violation of Bell’s inequalities has been verified over and over and over again.

First with electrons and now we had a series of experiments, this is the Innsbruck experiment, which is one of the best in recent years, one of the most complete, with photons. In other words, what these experiments show is that two photons which were initially entangled, however great their separation in distance behave as one. Now this is extremely problematical for the classical presentation of causality but more important importantly for the classical presentation of locality because there’s no means of action of the one or the other. There is strong debate about the consequences or the meaning of the violations of Bell’s inequalities. The violations of Bell’s inequalities can either mean that realism in Einstein’s sense is force.

Now this is broadly something which is already negated by the orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics. So you’re sort of stuck in this one. You either use quantum mechanics and you assume that there is a merging of the subject and the object in the act of observation or you use a theory of relativity and you assume that subject and object are two radically different things. Both are valid within their own spheres. So this violation of Bell’s inequalities puts in question realism, it puts in question determinism, which was already broadly speaking by orthodox quantum mechanics and it puts in question locality.

The main conclusion which can be drawn, I think it’s the main conclusion drawn at present by physicists from the violations of Bell’s inequalities, is that quantum mechanics is complete. In other words, mechanics is not a temporary theory, an incomplete description of reality because we don’t have all the necessary parameters to explain for instance the behavior of an electron. Quantum mechanics is actually the way things are And therefore the account which we gave yesterday of the relationship between the observer and the observed phenomenon and the formulation of a particle and the features of a particle in terms of a state vector which can only be reduced by the act of observation is actually what seems to be the true nature of things. This is therefore of great interest for Buddhism. And the question we have to ask is, is the presentation of causality and non or I would say non causality and non locality in contemporary physics compatible or not with Buddhist thought?

And if it is not, we shut down TBI and go to the beach because there is no Buddhist teachings apart from causality. So in other words, is Buddhist causality affected by the violations of Bell’s theorem? Now here I’ll just briefly show you a template, if I can, of the various models of causality in Indian thought. I won’t talk about it a lot because it was covered in one of the conferences this year. Broadly speaking, Indian thought is divided in two schools regarding causality.

The so called Satkaryavada and Asatkaryavada school. The Satkaryavada school, which is the school of all the non Buddhist traditions, assert that cause and effect are of one nature. In other words, Summa Sumarum, there is no true causality for this school. The effect is just an unfolding of the cause. Buddhist schools on the other hand assert that cause and effect are of different natures.

In other words, the effect is not an unfolding of the cause, it is something other. From a Buddhist standpoint, there is true change. In other words, there is true impermanence. From the standpoint of the non Buddhist schools there is no true change. All of the Buddhist schools without exception the Vaibhashika, Sautrantika, Cittamatra and Madhyamika assert that cause and effect are of different natures and that there is indeed true impermanence.

This is a core Buddhist tenet. It is the main, how do you say English, the main obstacle in the debate between Buddhists and Hindus in India. Now if we assess which of the Buddhist schools are compatible with the violation of Bell’s inequality, we can see that of the four Buddhist schools of tenets, the Vaibhashika and the Sautrantika school are realistic, in other words, they believe that the world exists out there and they are strongly deterministic. They have what we will call a very square vision of causality. The cause occurs before the effect, it is real and out there.

These schools are refuted by the violations of Bell’s inequalities and therefore can only be temporary schools from a Buddhist standpoint. They’re refuted by contemporary scientific discovery. On the other hand, the two Mahayana schools, Cittamatra and Madhyamika, are non realistic, non local, and non deterministic schools. Both of these schools withstand the test of modern physics very well. As we said yesterday, these two schools are compatible with quantum mechanics with the possible exception of the Svatantrika Madhyamika sub school and we can see that these two schools and in my opinion Svatantrika Madhyamika as well are compatible with the violations of Bell’s inequalities.

This goes a long way to explain the tremendous interest among contemporary physicists for Buddhist philosophy. My family has a long history of involvement in scientific research. I think I’m the only one who is not a scientist in the family, basically. And I remember we had just basically an endless stream of professors from the Polytechnicum, Swiss Polytechnicum coming over for supper at my father’s. The physicists were all Buddhists or Crypto Buddhists.

It’s quite interesting. It just it’s a matter of how crypto they were about it. But anyone who started working with quantum mechanics privately would start talking of just this sort of stuff. Summa sumarum wall, the violation of Bell’s inequalities pose great problems for the realistic deterministic local schools and therefore invalidate the Hinayana Buddhist traditions. They do not invalidate the Mahayana Buddhist traditions and I think there is quite strong corroboration of the position of the Mahayana schools of tenets from quantum mechanics in general.

If you are going to be a quantum physicist and you’re going to be religious, this is the place to be. And at present we can pass to the core focus of today’s presentation which is a presentation of ethical causality, in other words, karma. And here who else to show a representation of than Acharya Vasubandhu in a great statue from Kokoji Temple in Japan. Vasubandhu, as you know, is the author of the Abhidharma Kosha, the greatest Hinayana presentation of Abhidharma. His half brother Asanga was the author author of Abhidharma Samuchaya, the greatest Abhidharma presentation of the Mahayana.

We now rejoin the topic which Adela and Richard were talking about, which is that of the core karmic deeds, in this case the 10 non virtuous deeds. There are far more than 10 but Vasubandu chooses this subdivision to privilege some of the most problematical deeds. They are presented here in terms of growing karmic intensity, from the least important, which is the verbal non virtuous deed of gossip all the way up to the most important, the physical non virtuous deed of killing. And then the orientation changes at the level of mental non virtue, we move from the least important mental non virtue desire or covetousness to the most harmful wrong views which precludes any type of spiritual attainment. Now the analysis of Karma is the most profound aspect of the Buddhist teachings.

It is also the most beneficial for us. There is tremendous interest among Western students and Western audiences for the more philosophical aspects of Buddhism, the presentations of emptiness, especially in the Mahayana schools. This is a very limited benefit. It is very difficult to gain a good understanding of emptiness without intensive study and one only studies emptiness to be able to escape the net of karma. However, it is perfectly possible for someone who has a working life to gain a sound understanding of coma.

This sound understanding of karma enables one to lead a karmically beneficial life. One engages in karmic engineering. What I called in previous talks, one has a karmic strategy. This is the easiest and most powerful way to inflect one’s life in the long run towards ever greater happiness. And therefore, the study of karma in detail must come before any study of Buddhist philosophy and specifically any study of emptiness.

Since the study of emptiness can actually be harmful if emptiness is misunderstood and as mentioned previously, the study of emptiness is meaningful only for a practitioner who believes in past and future lives and who believes in the operativeness of karma and wishes to escape from past and future lives through meditation on selflessness. Otherwise, the study of emptiness is a complete waste of time. Now karma itself is subdivided into two broad categories projecting and completing karma. Projecting comma is the karma which actually gives rise to a complete future life at some point in the future. Completing comma fleshes out the details of that life.

Projecting karma can be virtuous or non virtuous. Completing karma likewise can be virtuous or non virtuous. If the projecting karma is virtuous, one will be reborn in the higher realms. In the Buddhist description of the higher realms, where the proportion of happiness is greater than the proportion of suffering. If the projecting karma is non virtuous, one will be reborn in one of the lower realms with the proportion of suffering is greater than the proportion of happiness.

The boundary is this ratio of suffering to happiness of approximately fifty fifty, which is at the lower reaches of human existence. If completing karma is virtuous, whatever life one has here will have happy events within it. If completing karma is non virtuous, whatever rebirth one has taken will have unhappy events within it. So if we look at the four logical possibilities, we can see that what is dominant is a projecting karma, which may be good or bad. Then the completing karma complements it.

If the projecting karma is good and the completing karma is good, one has a good rebirth and good conditions, such as a wealthy Swiss citizen. I think that’s as good as it gets even nowadays. Then if the projecting karma is good and the conditions are bad, one ends up as a poor Indian beggar. One is still a human being in terms of rebirth, but one is destitute. If the projecting karma is bad and the completing karma is good, it doesn’t get better than a dog in Australia.

And if both projecting karma and completing karma are bad, a dog in India is what one is looking at. So you can see if you look around you, numerous cases of people with good projecting karma, they are born as human beings, but bad completing karma, nothing works out for them. Or the opposite, I think prime examples are my wife’s, Westies, Bobby and Mindy, who have terrible projecting karma because they are dogs and are completely inarticulate and fantastic completing karma because they have someone who has a master’s in microbiology who spends her time feeding them sweets. That’s as good as it gets. Now, what are the general features of karma?

And I think this is the most beneficial meditate meditation we can engage upon. It’s what I started engaging in when I was 19 as a young man. It has been with me all my life. It has helped me tremendously. Karma is definite.

Karma is an increasing function of time, one does not experience karma which one has not accumulated and karma is indestructible. What do we mean when we say that karma is definite? And here the image of the Abacus does indeed spring to mind. The Buddhist presentation of karma is not moralistic. It’s a very big temptation for those of us with a Judeo Christian background to see karma as as Richard was saying about the Pintupi people, payback time.

That is not what karma is. It is a psychophysical law. It’s a psychophysical law which was discovered by the Buddha based on his own enlightenment. And the Buddha and the great beings of the past in India designated as virtue those deeds whose consequences they saw in the multiplicity of lives to be happiness. And designated as non virtue those deeds which they saw in the multiplicity of future lives as suffering.

In other words, virtue and non virtue are designated on the basis of the consequences of the deed. The Buddhist understanding of ethics is strongly consequentialist as we said yesterday. Karma is an increasing function of time. This is very difficult to understand and my personal suspicion is that and I have no proof for this, karma can best be understood in terms of chaos theory. There are certain results of chaos theory which tie in rather nicely with karmic theory.

You all heard of chaos theory which is a mathematical mathematical model for describing extraordinarily complex systems such as the weather for instance. And you have all heard of the famous example of the butterfly flapping its wings in China and causing down the line a hurricane in South America. Now this is very much how karma works. You are dealing with an extraordinarily complex system which ties in perhaps the totality of phenomena. We do not understand it fully.

But one small deed which seems trite, given time, builds up until the consequences are gigantic. And the factors which are necessary for chaotic motion are present in our account of karma. For chaotic motion, we need a strong dependency on initial conditions. This is clearly the case with weather, but if we reflect on how karma operates, can see how this could be the case for karma as well. Likewise, for the manifestation of this strong amplification involved in chaos theory, we need recurrence.

In other words, need a feedback function, a feedback loop. Now we will see at the end of this presentation that there is a feedback loop in Karma. That deeds which are committed lead to predispositions which lead to great facility in committing the deed again and I personally feel this goes a long way to explain karmic amplification. According to Pabongka Rinpoche, karma increases as a linear function of time. I personally suspect, in other words, doubles every day.

I personally suspect that it’s more an exponential function and that Patongka Rinpoche just gave a linear function for simplicity because he was addressing an uneducated Tibetan audience. It doesn’t make sense for it to be linear. You’d expect something on the model of N e to the x plus something, you know. The third feature of karma is that one does not experience a result which is not accumulated. In other words, if we experience a karmic result which can be either a sensation of happiness or suffering.

The cause for this karmic result can only have been sown by ourselves in some past life. It is impossible to gain such an experience without having accumulated oneself for the cause. As a corollary of this, it is impossible for us to be happy because of the virtuous karma accumulated by another and it is impossible for us to be unhappy because of the non virtuous karma accumulated by another. Therefore, there is no such thing as intercessionary prayer in Buddhism. Praying for others is meaningless.

We cannot accumulate virtuous karma for them. We cannot purify their non virtues. We are in this matter totally alone. Hence Rinpoche’s great dubiousness at TBI when Lama Chöpa was offered and there was this endless stream of requests of prayers for the sick. Sickness, the suffering of sickness is a result of one’s own past karma.

The prayers of others are neither here nor there. They are of tremendous benefit for the person who makes them, indeed. And in a very specific category of case, where there is a strong karmic relation between two persons, it is possible for prayers to be of benefit, but of limited benefit. These are the prayers of a teacher for students or students for the teacher and the prayers of siblings for siblings or relatives. So the Judeo Christian idea of intercession repairs mediated by the Almighty basically for the benefit of others is very very satisfying.

It gives one a sense of solidarity. It is however at odds with core Buddhist teachings. As Buddhists, we are alone with the responsibility for our own destiny. Finally and perhaps unfortunately, karma is indestructible. Indestructible.

It is like a diamond. Then I found a picture of a black diamond. You can have a white or black diamond in your mind. But until karma is purified, it is indestructible. It dwells within our mind either as a treasure chest or a time bomb depending on our situation, ready to be opened and bestow its riches on us or ready to destroy us.

And in this context, it is critical to understand the procedure of purification. There can only be purification through application of what are known as the four forces. The force of the base, the force of repudiation, the force of restraint and the force of the actual application of the antidote. Without these four forces, in the case of the base, we have to understand that non virtuous deeds can only be accumulated with respect to sentient beings, in other words, or Buddhas. And if they are accumulated with respect to sentient beings, generate the most beneficial mind for others, bodhichitta, which in our case is contrived, and if it is accumulated with respect to the Buddha’s, we take refuge.

So we have to identify the base. Then the force of repudiation is the force of regret, but it is much stronger than regret. The Tibetan term is This means profound remorse. I often choose to translate it as guilt, playing intentionally on the strong western hostility to guilt. Guilt in and of itself is neither a positive nor negative state of mind.

Guilt at the thought of non virtue committed is an extremely positive state of mind. Guilt at the thought of virtue committed is an extremely negative state of mind. Guilt is unpleasant. But eliminating unpleasantness is not the goal of Buddhist meditation and this ties in with the question Chris was asking yesterday. The Buddhist viewpoint is the long run viewpoint.

To suffer agonies of guilt in this life at the thought, let us say, of an abortion one has undergone is an extremely beneficial way to spend this life. Because it is almost certain that as a result of this guilt, the non virtuous deed of killing will not mature. Then this life will be unpleasant, but in the future there will be benefit. If we limit the focus of the teachings to this life, the chances of our getting things wrong are quite high. Now there are after repudiation, there is the application of the force of restraint of which Adela and Richard spoke very eloquently.

This is restraining from future performance of non virtue. Tibetan term here is which means to tame, to bind, to restrain. And finally the actor, which is to be frank with you the least important part of the four forces. Milarepa famously said said, with repudiation, with remorse, there is no non virtue. Then the actual antidote can be traditionally one of six types of antidotes.

One can invoke the name of the Buddha’s, one can use mantra, sutra, meditation and emptiness, performing offerings or making offering to the representations. If one has studied and one’s understanding is sound, the supreme form of elimination of non virtuous karma is meditation on emptiness. In our case, it is difficult. Then we try to bring in the picture the force of mantra and so forth. But the critical issue here is remorse.

However, even with the application of the four forces, purification of non virtuous karma is not easy. And I mentioned this in another talk, it’s what I’ve called the darkness of karma. Je Tsongkhapa says in the Lamrim Chenmo, it is not definite that some particular person can eliminate their karma. Nonetheless, confession is not senseless. For if you do not confess sins, you will experience sufferings that are greater and of longer duration than if you had confessed them.

There is no automaticity in the purification to the application of the four forces and specifically of confession. In the Roman Catholic church, for instance, there’s automaticity. If you confess to your priest and you perform the requisite, let’s say, you will be cleansed of your sin. As Buddhists, unfortunately, we are in this matter far more alone. We confess to the Buddhist, to the Bodhisattvas our faults.

We apply the antidotes generating the four forces with no guarantee. We put effort. The greater the effort, the greater the chances of purification. Total purification is not easy. Those who do the purification retreats know that the signs of total purification are not easy to get and the person changes fundamentally.

The issue which I would like to address now is that of comic completeness. This is the beginning of karmic engineering. The comic strategies we can use to, on the one hand, reduce the weight of whatever non virtuous deeds we engage in, and it is, I think, we can take for granted a given that we will engage in non virtuous deeds, and increase the power of the virtuous deeds we engage If we are realistic about ourselves and we practice in this way, over the years it is a given our situation will improve and life after life it will. So what is critical here is to understand what a karmically complete deed is. A karmically complete deed is a deed which leads to a complete result, another life.

Then what we want is for all our virtuous deeds to be complete and all our non virtuous deeds to be incomplete. Because there is no certainty regarding the maturation of an incomplete deed. There is certainty regarding the eventual maturation of a complete deed. Once a deed is karmically complete, it is exactly like the arrow in the yuumi in the bow of this Japanese bowman. Energy is stored ready to be released.

That it will be released is a given. So for virtue, our goal is to guarantee the release. For non virtue, our goal is to try to preclude the release. For a deed to be karmically complete according to Je Tsongkhapa, it must have four components. A basis, motivation, performance and completion.

If any of these four components is absent, the deed is not complete and it is not certain it will lead to a result. And then Asanga in a more detailed presentation which Je Tsongkhapa summarizes presents motivation of the three points: perception, actual motivation and affliction. Every deed we engage in, we must analyze in the light of these four points. If it’s a virtuous deed, we must make sure all four are present. If it’s a non virtuous deed, we have to try to eliminate one of the four.

Typically motivation or perhaps completion. Then the deed is weakened. It will not lead to an impact. And I will take a dark example largely because my mother was stationed in China at the end of World War two and saw many atrocities, a complete deed of killing. This is the execution of a not the execution, the murder of a Chinese prisoner by Japanese soldiers in Nanking during the so called rape of Nanking, where Chinese were used as objects.

If we take such a deed and we try to analyze it, the question is what makes the deed complete? The basis, the first point as we said, according to Je Tsongkhapa must be any living being including oneself for a deed of killing. But according to Asanga, it has to be another living being. Killing oneself is not killing. It is a non virtuous deed.

Suicide is non virtuous deed for Asanga, but it does not qualify as killing because the author of the deed destroys himself. I personally subscribe to Je Tsongkhapa’s view on the matter. The motivation, as we said according to Asanga is subdivided into three. Perception, motivation and affliction. Perception must be correct if the mind is deluded under the influence of drugs or alcohol, the deed is not complete.

Motivation, there must be a wish to perform the deed. If one has a car accident and kills someone involuntarily, it is not a complete deed of killing. In other words, it will not necessarily bear a karmic fruit and an affliction must be present, any affliction. It does not have to be anger. It can be desire or ignorance.

Someone who kills, let’s say in Australia someone who uses insecticides thinking well of anyway animal insects have no sentience, it doesn’t matter, is killing under the power of an affliction. Now if we analyze perception, you can see that you have correct and incorrect perceptions. Correct perception is perceiving the basis which is alive as living or if the basis is dead, it is perceived as dead. Incorrect perception is perceiving the basis which is living as dead or the basis which is dead as living. In other words, for correct perception within the context of the deed of killing, you have to perceive a living being as alive.

Otherwise there is no possibility to perform a complete deed of killing. Motivation can be either general or specific. A general motivation is the most dangerous of all. This is a motivation which is I will kill whatever happens. Then in such a motivation whoever you kill, all other things being equal, gives rise to a karmically complete deed.

If however the motivation is focused, I will only kill this prisoner. Such a motivation is less dangerous karmically because if you kill another prisoner, the deed is not complete. Finally, the affliction. It can be any of the afflictions. You can kill out of jealousy, a form of desire, you can kill out of anger, you can kill out of ignorance.

Sacrificing animals with the thought that it brings benefit to be a case of killing under the force of ignorance. Finally, performance is irrelevant. The means used are totally irrelevant. Whether one kills by oneself or one orders another to kill, the deed of killing is complete. In the case of abortion which Anila brought up, if one gives advice to another to perform an abortion, the deed of killing is complete, all other things being equal for oneself.

A chief of state such as Lincoln or or Hitler, we talked about yesterday, who initiates a war with all of these karmic elements present and with the thought many will die but this is necessary, bears karmically the karmic burden of all of the dead killed in the war. So the non virtue of the chief of state is millions of times greater than that of the individual soldier. An individual soldier with a specific perception, seeing an enemy charging him, might kill that enemy motivated perhaps by fear for his own life. The deed actually is quite weak. He’s killing one person.

The motivation is fear for his own life. It is not hatred of the other person. Then it isn’t probably you have to analyze, probably a complete deed of killing, but the maturation will be far less heavy than to say a chief of state, let us say Hitler, who initiates a Vernichtung policy, a policy policy of annihilation, and says, I will ensure that all those of Jewish origin are exterminated. Then such a person is responsible for the totality of deeds done under his orders. The karmic weight here is extremely heavy.

Finally, the fourth criterion is there must be completion. It is not enough to intend the deed and to perform it. The victim in the case of killing must die. If one shoots someone and he does not die as a result of the deed, the deed of killing is not complete. So the four factors to return a bit back which are necessary for a comically complete deed, in other words, a deed which will necessarily bring a result in the future is the basis, the motivation, the performance, and the completion that the deed is has led to its fruition.

For killing this means, in the case of a human being, a human being, motivation, the perception of the human being as living and human, the intent to kill, and motivation by an affliction, by anger. A Bodhisattva who for instance were to kill out of compassion, let us assume for instance someone who killed Hitler out of compassion, would not accumulate a complete deed of killing. There has to be performance of the deed and completion. I know of one such case. An old family friend of ours, major Archie Jack, who basically brought me to my interest for Tibet, was stationed in Tibet in the nineteen thirties.

He had competed in the Munich Olympics. And war in Tibet, he had been following the rise of Nazism in Germany, he spoke about it with members of the Tibetan government. And they said there is a very great practitioner living in the hills who, through meditation, has acquired, the power to kill at a distance. Do you have a picture of, this terrible man, mister Hitler? And Archie didn’t travel around with a picture of the Fuhrer on him.

I think it was quite understandable. And he said he didn’t. Then they said, well, without a picture, nothing can be done. And I remember Archie tell Archie telling us, he said, I have often wondered if I had had a picture, what would have happened? Now the deed of such a meditator who kills with the motivation to help others to prevent a war is not a complete deed of killing.

If the compassion is powerful enough and this does not concern us, this concern this type of practitioner, it becomes a virtuous deed. As I said, this does not concern us. But for such a being, there is great flexibility in the means used to help others. Returning to complete deeds, what is the path of a complete deed of killing? One starts out with, for instance, the death of a prisoner.

This is the goal. Then the prisoner has to be alive to be killed. He has to die intentionally. He cannot die by accident or let’s say in the process of an operation. In addition, a delusion must be the cause of the death.

If it is a virtuous state of mind, it’s not a complete deed of killing. The prisoner must actually die as a result of this delusion, of this deed, and critically, the prisoner must die before the killer. In war, if you were, for instance, if a short soldier were to shoot an enemy soldier and himself died before the enemy soldier has died, the karmic deed of killing for that soldier is not complete. He will already have taken rebirth, at least have entered the Bardo before the enemy soldier has died. Then this is not to say this is not a non virtuous deed, but one cannot say it is a complete deed of killing leading to the full result maturation to be expected from a complete deed of killing.

So the first step in karmic engineering is to understand what a complete deed is and to ensure that all our virtuous deeds are complete and all or as many of our non virtuous deeds as possible are incomplete. The next step is to bring in the picture karmic amplification. Karmic amplification can be brought in the picture through vows and pledges, which are general karmic amplifiers and individual deeds have also the potential for amplification. Vows are the most powerful karmic amplifier at our disposal. They amplify everything, virtue and non virtue.

For someone who has some type of restraint and who understands karma and causality, vows are the most powerful means to progress on the path. But vows are a two edged sword. If you hold a sword the right way, you can, for instance, cut. If you hold a sword the wrong way, you will cut yourself. Vows can destroy us, because we are dealing with amplification.

In the same way as if you have a really bad Hi Fi system, you don’t connect it to a very powerful amplifier to your very fancy B and W speakers because there will be no speakers left at the end of the day. You have to have a very clean source to use high amplification. So karmic amplification occurs, and we will talk about that in a couple minutes, using the weight or the strength of the deed or by the three categories of vows. The vows of individual liberation, which are the lay vows and monastic vows, bodhisattva vows and tantric vows. These are the easiest vows to keep.

Monastic vows are physical vows and the body is relatively easy to control and monastic vows are partly verbal vows. It is also relatively easy to control speech. By the time we pass to Bodhisattva and especially tantric vows, we are moving into the mental sphere. It is very very difficult to control the mind. Tantric vows can be broken like this and the amplification is very great.

Therefore, for one’s own sake, one must be very careful not to load in the circuit more amplification than one can control. If one does not have lot of control over one’s behavior, it is better to stay at the level of ordinary karmic deeds. One understands karma and causality, one doesn’t take any vows, one is very careful about what one does, one will improve over time. If one takes on vows, this is the reason I for instance are no longer ordained, one must keep every one of those vows. A fully ordained Buddhist monk has 227 or two hundred fifty fifty three vows depending on the tradition.

Each vowel which is not kept is one source of negative karma. Each vow which is kept is one source of positive comma. One must think very carefully. Then bodhisattva vows, we have the 18 root root vows, the branch vows, we have the tantric vows. Every single vow we take is potentially an endless source of virtue within our mind.

But every vow we break becomes a source of very great non virtue, then our goal is not excuse me, I will be blunt. Not to gain status, not to impress others, but to improve ourselves. At the end of the day, at the time of death, we are alone. Our vows can work for or against us. If we keep them, they will work on a very large scale for us.

If we break them, vows are our worst enemy, which is why the His Holiness the Dalai Lama does not encourage the conversion of Westerners. And if Westerners choose to convert for their own sake, they must keep refuge precepts, patimoksha vows, bodhisattva vows, if they choose to take them, tantric vows, if they have the great courage to take them. Well, if they do not keep them, it is not a matter of making up excuses or not. The vow by its nature, the pledge, the oath by its nature works against. Tibetans are very wary about taking tantric vows.

Tibetans don’t take the great tantric initiations like Westerners. And I think we as centers are at fault by promoting the great tantric initiations. Bodhisattva vows are not taken lightly by Tibetans. Not likely. So what type of karmic amplification is there through weight?

In other words, the first category here. Karma can be amplified through attitude, performance, the absence of an antidote, clinging to the perverse or the basis. Now I can only recommend that you read the section in Lamrim Chenmo on this topic which is very profound over and again to try to gain an understanding of how to improve your own lot. Karma which is weighty due to attitude is due to the intensity of the affliction. Something which is done with great anger, with great desire, with great ignorance, by that fact becomes extremely heavy.

The greater the anger, the greater desire, the heavier the deed. Therefore, an easy way to reduce the karmic weight of the deed is to reduce the affliction. If one is going to one cannot control oneself. One is let’s say, let’s assume in many parts of the world you have to kill to eat. You want to eat a chicken for supper, it has to be killed.

Then you want to generate as profound sorts of compassion for the chicken as you can. The deed of killing is reduced. Karma then becomes weighty due to performance. It can be weighty due to delighting in the deed, encouraging others to do it, premeditating it, doing it over and again, doing it with elaboration, such as torture, and inflicting it on someone who is defenseless. If we take the example of abortion, we can see that by its nature abortion is already weighty due to performance, because abortion is inflicted on a fetus which is defenseless by definition.

In addition, if one rejoices that one has aborted, the deed which is the deed of killing becomes heavier. If one writes articles about the right to abortion and demonstrates in the favor of the right to abortion, the deed becomes heavier again. If one talks carefully with the doctor, premeditating it longly, the deed is yet heavier again. And finally, if one uses as many countries of Eastern Europe abortion in state of birth control, then the deed is yet again heavier. Finally, I’m told, I do not know this for a fact, that in Australia you allow late abortions.

Then late abortions, which can be horrific deeds, are definitely done with elaboration. There is great suffering for the fetus, which certainly the case of some late abortions has to be cut up alive in the womb for being extracted. You can imagine the weight of such a deed karmic. We’re not talking here of legality. We’re talking of karmic ethics.

Now if in addition antidote is absent, then the deed is able to pursue its own root of karmic amplification. If there are no vows, no antidote is applied, there is no shame, no merit has been accumulated and there is no understanding of the teachings, the deed can become very swiftly very powerful. And it is one of the great weaknesses of modern Western cultures and I regret to say it’s one of the very great weaknesses of Australian culture, that it is a culture in which shame and guilt are discouraged. Whenever Rinpoche has spoken to me, Khensur Rinpoche has spoken to me privately of Australians, he has always said they are shameless. And this in Tibetan terms is a major indictment.

This means that not only does a person engage in non virtue, but the person is ostentatious and rejoices in the non virtue they engage in. In other words, there is an automatic amplification built into the culture. Shame and guilt are not things to be avoided. Shame and guilt are worthy states of mind if one is embarrassed by one’s deficient behavior. They attenuate the karmic weight.

They are to our advantage. Then clinging to the perverse is the classic cases of ignorance and benightedness. When one believes that what is wrong is good. Meditating in meditating in favor of sexual misconduct from a Buddhist standpoint, for instance, meditating in favour of homosexual marriage is a clear case of clinging to the perverse. We have to be very clear here regarding the distinction between what is Buddhist ethics and what is legal.

These are two very different things. We may have to live in societies which not accept Buddhist ethics. That does not mean we from our side have to abound in their direction. Any structure which promotes sexual non virtue is by its definition problematical. Finally, the basis can act as a source of great amplification.

A close friend is the basis which is perhaps which amplifies perhaps the least. And a fetus already entails more amplification, especially if it’s the mother’s future child because of the closeness of the relation. Then parents, in order of kindness, whichever parent is kinder to us, is obviously the one towards whom the deed is amplified more. Monks, bodhisattvas, and then the weightiest basis is obviously one’s spiritual teacher, which is the most dangerous person for oneself. If one cannot relate correctly to a spiritual teacher, it is better not to have a spiritual teacher.

In addition, one must distinguish between deeds which are powerful in terms of recipient support object and attitude. This is somewhat complementary to the previous account of karmic amplification. Deeds which are powerful in terms of recipient are the triple gem, the guru and parents. This is pretty evident. And in this context, one has to point out the great danger of a certain category of recipient, which tends to be collectivities.

The non virtue we commit towards is almost impossible to purify. Specifically, it is generally considered to be impossible to purify non virtue committed towards the Sangha as a community. The reason being that the members of the Sangha are constantly changing. As a result, theft from the Sangha is a deed which is considered impossible to purify. It can be reduced through donations to the Sangha but to actually eliminate the karmic consequences.

We’re not talking here of wishful thinking but of a karmic analysis, a consequentialist analysis of ethics. The Sangha in this respect is an extremely dangerous recipient. Any community is a dangerous recipient. The TBI for instance as a donor center is a dangerous recipient. Those of us who come regularly to TBI must be careful not to use what belongs to TBI without permission, to get blanket permission from Tenzing or from Carol or from Chris to use, let’s say, tea, not to just go in the kitchen and put a tea bag casually.

If we do this without permission, without actually being a member of TBI, we actually have accumulated the karma of stealing from the community. And this is it’s a small deed, it’s just a tea bag. But when karmic amplification is brought into the picture, such deeds can have very unwanted consequences in the future. For this reason, it is very important for us to try to understand this. Then these can be powerful in terms of support.

The self same way as a block of iron, as a block will sink in water and the same amount of iron shaped into a vase does not sink. Depending on how one configures the deed, the deed will have greater or lesser weight. Specifically, if there is no regret, if there is no restraint, if the deed is concealed and if in addition there is no virtue done, even the smallest deed can become extremely heavy karmically. For this reason and it is unavoidable that we will do non virtuous deeds, it’s a given. Once we know what they are, we should immediately regret them, practice restraint, publicize them, not perhaps in the center, but go to our teacher and say this is what I did.

And try to do some type of virtuous action as a remedy. If we do this, the power of the deed will be reduced. There is also power in terms of the object of the deed. There’s a great difference between making gifts, which even though it is virtuous, is fairly small virtue and performing the great gift of giving the teachings. Monks are poor but are able to perform far superior practices of generosity than lay people because they impart the teachings.

Finally, there is power in terms of attitude. Strong positive attitude such as bodhichitta and definite emergence in other’s renunciation greatly amplify any comma done under their influence. Delusions amplify any comma done under their influence and specifically anger and hatred has the dubious privilege of being able to destroy all the karmic seeds which we have accumulated. Great anger is really akin to a fire. I have seen cases And you see the person after a great episode of anger and something has been burnt inside the person.

One gets a sense that something very very precious has been destroyed. Now what are the karmic consequences? We can face a future in Dubai or a future as one of Al Qaeda’s jails in Afghanistan. And this is only within the human realm. As mentioned briefly, we had we have ripening effects, which is none other than projecting karma we talked about previously, which can be the actual rebirth in a future life, a higher or a lower rebirth.

We have causally concordant effects, which is the habituation to a certain category of deed. Through killing we become accustomed to violence, life over life over life. We have environmental effects as a result of killing, we will be born in harsh and violent environments in which sustenance for life is small. The ripening effect is simply the existence impelled. And in the Buddhist description of psychic existence we have a whole range of existence of which only two realms are visible to the exterior senses of a normal being humans and animals and even if you believe only in human and animal rebirth, think you can still construct a very good sense of calm and causality.

If you live or come from cultures which are less intolerant or less closed, then you can get a sense of the existence of far higher realms and far lower realms. And in this case obviously you want to avoid the non meritorious karma which causes rebirth in the lower realms and practice the meritorious karma which causes rebirth in the higher realms or even the karma which is born from concentration from Samadhi known as immutable karma, which is the only karma which can cause rebirth in the two realms of gods of the form and the formless realms. So as we mentioned in addition to karma of maturation, we have causally concordant effects and we have environmental effects. If we take the example of a single deed, let us imagine in the first life we perform a complete deed of killing of another human being. It must be complete, otherwise it will not impair another rebirth.

Its ripening effect, the first of the three effects we talked about in some other life. It’s life one plus k. It doesn’t have to be the next life, but it will be in one, two, five or 500 lives and if it’s complete, it is guaranteed unless there is purification. It will be rebirth in a hell realm. Depending on the intensity of the of the deed, it could also be rebirth as an animal.

If the deed was very very weak, the deed of killing with great regret, it might be rebirth as a human being with violent propensities in a harsh society. However, in the next life after rebirth in the hell realm, to cause any concordant effect, this is what is concordant with the deed, is having a short lifespan. Lifespan of another has been shortened as a result our lifespan is short and we know people like that. They go from accident to accident, from disease to disease. This is the causally concordant result of killing in a previous life.

We also know people who seem indestructible physically. This is the causally concordant result of non violence in past lives. Then the environmental effect will be living in a country in which food is bad, medicine is ineffective, let’s say India, or a country of violence and war, let’s say Afghanistan, Iraq. And finally, there is an enjoyment of killing through habituation. Such a person talks of killing, watches war movies, will carry weapons, will take martial arts training.

This is all part of the process which arose with the complete deed of killing. Now regarding the speed of maturation of karma, the most powerful karma can mature in this very life, at the end of the life. Karma which is accumulated towards parents, towards one’s teacher, with, let’s say, case of a deed of killing great violence, great anger, great hatred. Such a deed will mature in this life. And you can see this.

Alina was mentioning the cases of abortion. I knew a couple of cases, and I don’t know one single one which was happy later on in their life. And a surprising number of them developed cancers in the areas which are related to the area where abortion had occurred. Cancer of the womb, typically cancer of the uterus. Then from a Buddhist standpoint, this is a maturation in this life of a very heavy karmic deed because it is one’s own child which is concerned.

However, karma can also mature in the next life, this is a case of heavy deeds. And karma can mature in some future life, This is a case of lighter deeds. Then I would like very briefly here to evoke a metaphor for comma. I am not claiming that it is possible to analyze karma fully in this way but I personally feel that karma can be understood very very elegantly in terms of fractal theory. You may have heard of fractals.

Fractals are self repeating patterns. They’re surprisingly common in nature and they can be given a mathematical description. This is for instance a very beautiful fractal just generated from a general equation. Most equations would generate fractals are complex number equations and one just feeds the result of the equation into the equation again. This is what’s known as recursion.

Now in mathematics, fractals have some key features. They are self similar, in other words they are repetitive. If you look, if you take a magnifying glass and you look at the fractal, see the pattern repeating itself inside over and over again. They have fractional dimension. We will not talk about that here.

Fractional dimension is basically to give you an example. This is a two dimensional structure, this table, and the space here is a three-dimensional structure. We would talk of a fractional dimension if we took a two dimensional entity like a piece of foil, crumpled it up, and then uncrumpled it as smoothly as we can. It is no longer fully two dimensional and it can no longer be described fully as three-dimensional. Now this is obviously a metaphor but such structures can be created in mathematics.

Now these are quite frequent in mathematics and there was a very famous German mathematician, Weierstrass, who formulated in the late nineteenth century a mathematical oddity known as Weierstrass function, which is, which exists in every single point and is discontinuous in every single point, therefore cannot be integrated anywhere. It has fractal structure because if you look at it, take a magnifying glass, it repeats itself over and over and over again. But what is interesting for us is fractals in nature. We have cases of self similarity which are most of the mathematically generated fractals, it’s called Koch snowflake with a pattern repeat inside again and again. Quasi self similarity where there is broad similarity over and again and probabilistic or stochastic self similarity, which is the fractals we see in nature.

Coastlines can be described mathematically as fractals. This is a picture of Australia’s coastline. It is a fractal mathematically but for instance the vessels within the human lung can also be described very elegantly in terms of fractal theory. You see if you magnify the structure of the vessels, the overall structure of the larger arteries repeating ever more into the capillaries. All sorts of other natural phenomena can be described in terms of fractal theory such as this very beautiful cauliflower.

You can see clearly the recurring pattern or this ice crystal. Now it’s my contention that karma has a fractal nature Because if we look at a karmic deed, let us take a deed of killing. Rebirth k it leads to a hell rebirth. Let’s just assume it’s a hell rebirth to simplify analysis. It could be an animal rebirth, could even be a human rebirth.

But in rebirth k plus one, the following rebirth, that hell rebirth has led to a human rebirth with poor conditions and you have a causally concordant effect liking to kill which is actually related as well as the environmental effect to the hell rebirth. There is asymmetry between the two. In the following rebirth, you have a human rebirth with better conditions, rebirth k plus two than the previous one. You still have a causally concordant effect liking to kill perhaps less, one hope so, environmental effects which hopefully are also less, but as a result of these two a new deed of killing is performed and this is where the recursion enters into the picture. So I think we it’s not illegitimate to describe comma in terms of recursive functions and therefore there is some similarity between fractals and comma.

We have self similarity in the fractal likewise within karma between the maturing deed, causally concordant and environmental result we have a modicum of self similarity and it is clear that in the self same way as fractals are generated recursively, so is karma. And this leads me to an application of what we have covered today, which is perhaps quite alien to a Western audience. That’s why I chose it. It is the issue of signs, omens and The westerners typically don’t believe in this. Typically, all Buddhist societies without exception do.

They are called dependent arisings. The white elephant, as you know, was the manifestation in a dream of the descent of Buddha Shakyamuni from Tushita into his mother’s womb. It is the supreme sign of auspiciousness in any Buddhist country. It is to this day in Thailand, the sign of the presence of the Buddha dharma in the country. If there is a white elephant in the country, the dharma, this is a sign of the presence of the dharma.

And there is more to this than just symbolism. I would like to illustrate this with an example tape taken directly from the life of Milarepa. Milarepa, as you know, was a young man of tremendous potential, who had committed heinous crimes, killed in excess of 20 people using black magic, and after repenting came to the great translator, Marpa, requesting him to become his disciple. In keeping with Buddhist usage to create good karma for receiving teachings, Milarepa made offerings to Marpa. He offered specifically a copper pot and he offered grain and beer.

But his offering was flawed because he offered the copper pot empty and the grain and the beer separately. Now this would seem to us trite but from the standpoint of Marpa, who understood much greater depth interdependence, the offering of the empty copper pot created the causes down the line for poverty and hunger, which actually plagued Milarepa all his life. Milarepa practiced in poverty and hunger. And Marpa very skillfully upon receiving this offering from Milarepa corrected the dependent rising. From his own side, he poured butter in the pot, taking it to his temple room and filling his butter lamps from this cauldron.

In so doing, he created a dependent arising for Milarepa’s future attainments. In addition, while Marpa was carrying this cauldron of butter into the temple room, he beat on it as a drum. You can imagine how Milarepa must have felt. He gives a cauldron of an empty cauldron and the teacher to be filled it with butter and walks beating on it as a drum to the temple room. It’s quite odd until you analyze what’s going on.

Beating on it is a drum, the drum is a symbol of fame and this indeed led to the two results which marked Milarepa’s later life. Milarepa gained attainments and he gained great fame. Why did the deeds mature so quickly? Largely because they arose within the context of a guru disciple relationship with great karmic amplification. Milarepa had tremendous faith in Marpa and Mahpa adopted him as a disciple and basically as a son.

So this is very alien, I thought I would bring it up. It is an instance of what I’ve chosen to call karmic supersymmetry. In other words, it’s a case where you see this fractal nature of karma, where events are basically how would you say in English? Are intertwined, almost entangled with each other. Then I would like to end with a picture of this beautiful great great wave from Hokusai, which is often taken as a metaphor for the fractal nature of reality and with this quote of Tsongkhapa.

Compared to the sins that are related to the teachings, the sins of the 10 non-virtues are insignificant. Precisely because with the teachings we enter in the realm of karmic amplification. And therefore it is better to be a simple ignorant layabout running around drinking beer, pot and gambling with no vows and no ethics than to have taken refuge, Bodhisattva and Tantric vows, and to act irresponsibly. The karmic results of someone who has taken great initiations and who acts contravening core precepts are very heavy. It is better never to have been born.

Thank you very much. I’m happy to take one question if yes, please. I think from a Buddhist standpoint, there can be no justification for capital punishment whatsoever. As long as there are options to keep dangerous criminals off the streets, capital punishment eliminates the possibility of any change. It closes the door permanently to the possibility of betterment in the criminal.

Then from a Buddhist standpoint, it is something, we have to reject completely. The only case capital punishment would have to be considered in is if it was impossible to imprison the criminal, he would be released once again and there was near certainty of his killing another person or many people. Then in a case like that, one would have to assess the issue of execution. So basically from a Buddhist standpoint, we have to meditate in favor of the elimination of capital punishment. Then it much depends on the motivation.

The judge for instance, may have the motivation of aiding society. Then it is possible, in that case, the deed of killing would not be complete. But there would be negative karmic consequences for the judge without question, a shortened lifespan typically. If the executioner had compassion at the time of execution, the executioner would not be complete. But that seems difficult.

Most probably the executioner is filled with righteous anger or even anger. Then the executioner experiences a complete deed of killing. But more importantly, the audience which is rejoicing in this experiences part of the karma of killing. For instance, I was very struck at the center after we learned of the think we have to call it the assassination of Osama bin Laden because that’s what it was. There was no trial of any type.

That some students actually rejoiced in this. And this is very dangerous for them. Irrespective of whether mister Bin Laden, was such a danger to society that he had to be killed or not, rejoicing in the killing of another being is tantamount to killing oneself. It’s very heavy comically. And there was great rejoicing.

I was very surprised. You know? That’s a sign of the ignorance of coma. Does that answer your question? Well, in terms of karma, in that case, the intention is not there.

The intention is not there. The motivation of the nurse is not the motivation of the people in the Operating Theater is not necessarily to kill the fetus. Now they will be stained by the karma of killing. It’s unavoidable, but not to the degree, let’s say, of a doctor who decides to perform the abortion, leads the patient on the Operating Table, performs the abortion and as a result of the abortion, the fetus dies. This is a complete deed of killing.

That doctor, however, would incur a lesser negative karma normally than the mother who took the decision to perform the abortion. Normally, you have to look at the state of mind because the doctor’s relation to the fetus is less, much less. There is karmic amplification from the standpoint of the doctor because the fetus is powerless. But from the standpoint of the mother, there is a very great karmic amplification. Then from the standpoint of the personnel at the operating Theater, there is little or no karmic amplification and one has to check whether the deeds are complete or not.

The best as a practicing Buddhist is simply not to work in certain activities. I, for instance, would never work as a policeman. I would never work in a situation where I might have to take decisions which are at odds with my own core Buddhist beliefs and this limits my activities greatly. But if you look at it in the Lojong, if karma exists, for each one of us to answer this question. If it exists, it makes sense to reduce the damage to us down the line.

And then if this damage has happened, then one purifies. One purifies. Regret is the greatest force. If one regrets this is something one never wanted to do, then it is said in one of the great Buddhist texts that it is unclear whether the karma will mature or not. And then in addition, one applies antidotes, there are strong chances it will not mature.

Does that answer your question?

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
Tushita Ganden (Tib)
The Joyous Land. There are two Tushita realms. One is the pure land of the thousand buddhas of this eon, where the future buddha, Maitreya, and Lama Tsongkhapa reside. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top