Rinpoche’s Story – 2016-03-26 – KR

1 h 26 min · 4,028 words · 26 March 2016

Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story (Khensur Rinpoche)
Rinpoche's Story - 2016-03-26 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches the 37 facets of enlightenment, covering the seven subdivisions and their eight outlines: object, mode of meditation, boundaries, etymology and supremacy. It explains the progression from renunciation through the path of accumulation and preparation, the five powers and five forces, and their links to calm abiding and the Four Noble Truths. It ends with a question and answer session with students.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 27m

UUID: dee54273-7e0f-4664-8e1c-666291cf7420

Date: 2016-03-26

Words: 4,024

I remember when I started my studies at Sera, I was a ranked beginner with my friends and we were supposed to study colors to learn how to debate the white and red colors. Khensur Rinpoche was then teaching an advanced class of collected topics of Dura called the eight subdivisions of consequences. So we didn’t have a clue what was going on and we would doze off. And Rinpoche had a very skillful means, he had a long switch and he would tap us on the head. So I remember that very well.

Then obviously the goal of Collected Topics or Dura is strengthening one’s logical capacities, literally entering the path of logic. Dura is called the magical key which opens the gateway to logic and until one has entered the path of logic, then it is very difficult to study, one becomes easily bored and one falls asleep through lack of enthusiasm. Then once one has found the path of reasoning, there is no difficulty. I remember when Rinpoche taught we would show up at 03:00 and we were lucky if Petri started before five or six, we just had to wait. And I remember even though Khensur Rinpoche had the responsibilities at that period of Abbot of Sera Monastery, nonetheless he kept us a beginner class and he taught us everything.

He taught us how to debate, he taught us how to give answers to questions, everything I remember very clearly. Then I remember that once I entered in the path of collected topics, the path of logic, then after that, there was no difficulty at all in attending Petri. In other words, the daily or every two day classes in Buddhist philosophy and unless I was seriously ill, I never missed whatever important work we had, it was always set aside for Petri. Obviously when you engage in a lot of hearing, attending a lot of teachings, then it stays in the mind and the enthusiasm increases. Then after completing my Geshe degree, I went to Gyume Tantric College for one year and received teachings on tantra.

We had many teachings on tantra. I had at least three classes a day in addition to Gyume monastery’s ritual monastic obligations which are extremely heavy. We would start prayers around three or 03:30 in the morning and the first session which was self initiation of Guhyasamaja would typically last until 07:30 uninterrupted every day. Then at Gyume monastery, most of the Gyume monks, pure monks of Gyume do not rely on any text, it is all memorized and obviously they are uttering these rituals in tantric voice which is almost incomprehensible. So in our case, we were trained in the sutra tradition and we find it often difficult to follow.

Then obviously if you’re from Sera Je, you go to Gyume to complete your tantric training at Gyuto, the higher tantric college, it’s exactly the same thing I think. Once one has been trained in the great monasteries in the studies of the five collections of texts, Paramita, Madhyamika, Abhidharma, Vinaya and Buddhist logic, Pramana. Then when one enters the Tantric monastery, there is no difficulty whatsoever in Tantric studies. One just has to become familiar with the new Tantric terminology. Then the system at Gyume Monastery is somewhat different.

Normally they don’t have their own individual teachers of Sutrayana. These are typically Geshe’s who are brought in from the great monasteries, some of whom remain at Gyume monastery to teach. The Sutrayana is very important. Then when we attended His Holiness’s teachings and empowerment at the period, it was very difficult because often we couldn’t hear a thing or we find it very difficult to understand. Then it is easy to fall asleep in the heat.

But now obviously the conditions have improved and one puts effort thanks to enthusiasm. So first one listens and obviously one tries after listening to collect everything one has heard and understand it. But even if one doesn’t understand a lot, nonetheless, the karmic imprints of having listened are definitely implanted. Then the 37 facets of enlightenment are all mental factors. These are all parts of consciousness and as such a topic is a bit difficult because you have this long list of mental factors, concentration, pliancy, enthusiasm, aspiration and so forth.

But if one listens to these teachings over and again, it is definite one’s understanding will be enhanced. So within the seven fold subdivision of the 37 facets of enlightenment, we have basically finished the three first ones. The close placement of recollection, the four correct abandonments and the four legs of magical emanation. Then four remaining sections still remain, they are on your chart, the five powers, the five forces, the seven branches of enlightenment and the eight branches of the path of an arya being. Now, ideally, you would memorize all 37 mental factors and the seven subdivisions of the 37 mental factors.

But if you are unable to do this, then at the very least, you should memorize the seven subdivisions of the mental factors and sequence and understand what the eightfold presentation of each topic is. So this is a skillful means to prevent you from sleeping. So you’ve asked me many questions, now it’s my turn. So I will ask you questions on the four close placements of mindfulness and what are the eight subdivisions? You gotta write them in your mind.

Generally it’s good to have your notes but we want to rely on one’s inner knowledge. You’re gonna go slowly if have to translate. So Mi Kul, object, yes. Tull, Gopa, Sanyi, Satsang, Mo, Probably they’re all there. Then you were all shouting, it would be nice if one had contributed.

So after reciting for yourself these eight subdivisions, you should go through them mentally and ask yourself what they mean and this is what meditation is all about. So, Jetsun Chokyi Gyaltsen, the author of this monastic textbooks, skill and means is evident in his summarizing each of the seven subdivisions into eight topics. What is the definition of a close placement of mindfulness of recollection? Can you? Could you answer?

Really? Then I am gonna ask you now questions individually and only the person to whom I ask the question is to answer. Okay. Alright. Sylvia, what is the definition of a close placement of recollection?

Yes. What is the object of the close placement of recollection? Yes, yes, that’s it exactly. That’s what he said. What is Richard the mode of meditation on the close placement of mindfulness?

Richard. Yes. Our friend behind Richard. Yes. Behind the in front.

Excuse us. What is the mode of meditation on the four close placements of recollection? What’s the mode of meditation of the four close placements of mindfulness of Ascendi? What are the divisions of the close placement of mindfulness, Mark? So you should posit the four placements of mindfulness on body, on sensation, on mind and on phenomena.

You ask some? Joe, what are the boundaries of the four close placements of mindfulness? The boundaries. Monica? What are the boundaries of the four close placements of mindfulness, Monica?

It. So Judy, what are the divisions of the close placement of mindfulness? And then Strive. Is that your one name? Strive?

Stremi, yeah. What is the purpose of meditating on the four close placements of mindfulness? Oh, recollection, yes, yes, exactly. So Shaya, how does one establish the supremacy of the four close placements of recollection of the Mahayana, the eighth outline? Yes.

Then, beyond. Yes. What is her name? What is the name of the lady behind Shyam? Yolanda.

Yolanda. Yolanda. Okay. Nice to meet you. An easy one.

What is the or what are the objects of the close placement of recollection? Diva, what is the mode of meditation on the four close placements of recollection? What is the definition of the four close placements of recollection, Susan? Jill, what’s the purpose of meditating on the four close placements of recollection? What is the object of the four close placements of mindfulness?

Okay, that’s good. And she is next to Jill. Margaret, what are the divisions of the four close placements of mindfulness? What’s the definition of the four close placements of recollection, Valerie? What is the etymology of the four close placements of recollection?

Then that doesn’t matter but within the four correct abandonments, what is the object of the four correct abandonments, the first division? The four correct abandonments. Then this is okay even though you haven’t memorized them, if you can read over the material again and again, you will become more familiar with it and will understand it well. I I woke you up from your sleep now. So the foundation of the 37 facets of enlightenment is a stable state of renunciation which is none other than a stable state of mind striving for liberation from cyclic existence after generating sadness at the thought of psychic existence.

So once we have generated a state of mind which through understanding the faults of psychic existence wishes to be freed from it, we have generated a state of uncontrived renunciation which strives for liberation from cyclic existence. So once we have generated a stable state of definite emergence, then we wish to understand what it is which prevents us from attaining liberation and when we search for the source or the origin of this, we find the afflictions. When in turn we search for the source or the origin of the afflictions, we find the ignorance which apprehends a self. And this ignorance which apprehends a self, misapprehends the self as existing inherently or from its own side. That which counters it is the wisdom which understands that the self does not exist in the slightest from its own side and merely exists nominally.

So generating this, we eliminate ignorance, in turn we eliminate the afflictions and we are able to progress to liberation. As is said in Jetsun Tsongkhapa’s concise Lamrim, the Essence of Eloquence, if one does not understand the origin of the truth of origin, then one is unable to sever it and indeed if one does not understand the origin of psychic existence, one is unable to put an end to it. So we shall now pass to the presentation of the fourth sub topic of the 37 facets of enlightenment, which are the five powers. The reason for which the five powers are presented after the four legs of magical emanation is because the main focus of the five powers is calm abiding and not any calm abiding, it is a calm abiding which is focused on the four noble truths. For this reason it is presented after the four legs of magical emanation.

So that’s the way it is. Please listen carefully. So once one has generated an uncontrived mind of renunciation which is saddened with psychic existence and strives for liberation, one has entered the path, one has actually entered the path of accumulation and this is on your handout, the first path on the second page. Now within the path of accumulation, the three first subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment are included. In other words, the four close placements of recollection, the four corrective elements and the four legs of magic elimination begin with the path of accumulation.

So when in the context of the path of accumulation, a concentration which focuses on the Four Noble Truths, in other words, whose object of observation is the Four Noble Truths is accompanied by a wisdom which repeatedly examines these Four Noble Truths that induces an insight. This insight is what leads to the fourth subdivision of the 37 facets of enlightenment which is the five powers within the 37 facets of enlightenment. So the transition from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation occurs by means of a meditative equipoise. What is this meditative equipoise? This meditative equipoise is a calm abiding focused upon the four noble truths within which the factor of wisdom examines the Four Noble Truths.

This induces an insight. So, While on the path of accumulation, is the concentration which focuses on the Four Noble Truths is a wisdom which arises, which has arisen from hearing or from thinking. It is not yet a wisdom which has arisen from meditation. It is when one passes to the path of preparation and a mind of calm abiding focuses on the Four Noble Truths and within this calm abiding focused on the four noble truths, a wisdom examines the four noble truths and induces an insight that the wisdom arisen from meditation has arisen. So this is the purpose of training in the five powers.

Then the five powers from within the 37 facets of enlightenment are subdivided also in eight. The first is the object. The object of the five powers are the four noble truths. So what is Now within the third subdivision, the mode of meditation, what is the mode of meditation on the five powers? When the transition from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation occurs and therefore when a concentration which is focused upon the four noble truths becomes a calm abiding and through the factor of wisdom, insight is generated.

This gives rise to a bliss or a happiness arisen from conviction through understanding how the noble truth of suffering gives, arises from the noble truth of the origin of suffering and how the noble truth of the origin of suffering gives rise to the noble truth of suffering. Independence in turn on this bliss arisen from conviction, a great faith in the objects of refuge, the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha arises. So here this concentration has both an object of observation and an object of appearance which are the triple gem. Now when the bliss arisen from conviction which observes the triple gem has occurred, one becomes a stream enterer. So now what is the purpose of the five powers?

The purpose is since at the level of the five powers, we are at the level of heat and peak of the path of preparation to pass up to the level of the forbearance and supreme placement on page two of the grounds and paths. Now what is the definition or the nature of the five powers. It is on page two of your definitions. A sapience which has independently generated an ARIA path which is its result. Now the fifth topic, the subdivisions.

When the five powers are subdivided, they are subdivided into the power of enthusiasm, the power of recollection, the power of concentration, the power of wisdom. Excuse me, go on down. The first is the power of faith, the second is the power of concentration, the third is the power of recollection, the fourth is the power, I repeat, the first is the power of faith, the second is the power of enthusiasm, the third is the power of recollection, the fourth is the power of concentration and the fifth is the power of wisdom. So one progresses incrementally through these five powers. Initially, when one observes the object of observation, the Four Noble Truths, faith arises.

When faith arises, independence on the power of faith, the power of enthusiasm arises and this power of enthusiasm generates a feeling of bliss or happiness which fortifies the power of recollection. Then at this point, the powers of concentration and wisdom arise. So when the five powers are shall we say exemplified by a human body, they are symbolized by the bones, the flesh, the joints, the skin and the heart. And this is a very beautiful metaphor but I will explain it tomorrow. Now the boundaries, these five powers are generated from the level of heat of the path of preparation on page two of grounds and paths all the way up to full enlightenment.

The etymology powers, these are called five, the five powers within the 37 facets of enlightenment because they have the power to generate the path of an arya being. And in brief, the eighth subdivision of the topic, the reason for which the five powers of the Mahayana are supreme is because they are upheld by bodhichitta whereas those of the Hinayana are not. Then the following subdivision is the subdivision of the 37 facets of enlightenment into the five forces. The differentiation between the five powers and the five forces is that the five powers are not able to abandon what is discordant with them and the five forces are. So the five forces are also subdivided in eight.

The object is the same as that of the five powers. But regarding the subdivision of the five forces into faith enthusiasm, recollection, concentration and wisdom. These five can no longer be overcome by their opposites. Their opposites would be the absence of faith and so forth. The difference between the five powers and the five forces is in the capacity to apprehend its object.

It is greater within the five forces and less within the five powers. Otherwise, there is not a great difference. So the five forces boundaries lie between the level of forbearance of the path of preparation and full enlightenment and in this respect, it is quite significant that in the Lamrim it is said that it is at the level of the path of forbearance, at the level of forbearance of the path of preparation that first one no longer is able to be born in the lower realms and secondly, that one no longer accumulates power or negative karma under the influence of ignorance. Then we shall stop here and if you have questions, I will take a couple questions. Jill?

Thank you, Geshela. I somehow missed with number three, the four legs of magical emanation. What the out of the eight subdivisions, what the purpose and nature of the four legs of magical emanation were? So the purpose of the four legs of magical emanation is very similar to its object. It is the multiplication of individual bodies and the subsumption of multiple bodies into one.

Then the definition is on page one of your definitions of the seven subdivisions. It’s very similar to the definition of calm abiding. A sapience which has entered the path having become a Samadhi relying on the eight applications, antidotes abandoning the five faults. The mode of what, So the mode of meditation is very similar to the definition. It is meditating upon having entered a path which is a Samadhi relying on the eight applications, antidotes abandoning the five faults.

So this derives from a definition of calm abiding in Asanga’s Abhidharma Samuccaya and even though there are minor differences of expression, the meaning is exactly the same. Another? I think a nilly. My question is regarding the elements and it’s also a bit about physics. So I’m not sure if Geshela can really answer it.

As I understand it, physicists study four forces which are variously called motility or energy or something like that. And the Dalai Lama makes a tentative link between four elements in Buddhist cosmology and the four forces in modern physics. So I’m wondering, would this study by non Buddhists, in other words physicists using whatever methods they use, constitute in any way the study into the elements, in other words the dhatu, so within the four close mindfulnesses, the first one is the study of the elements and I am wondering when physicists study these four forces, could it be in any way a study of the elements? No, I don’t think so. When we study the close placement of mindfulness on the body, we are doing it in terms of the own characteristics or the specific characteristics and the general characteristics of the body.

It is only when the scientists focus on the specific characteristics of something like the body that we could indeed say that they are engaging in a close placement of mindfulness on the body. So it follows then that physicists could never come to an understanding of selflessness or emptiness then because they lack the basis. No, not at all. Since basically for an understanding of emptiness, one would need an understanding of the four seals and scientists are proceeding very well in that direction. They accept that composite phenomena are impermanent as to whether they accept that contaminated phenomena are suffering or not.

That is something which is to be examined. They seem to have an understanding of surfaces and emptiness. But what is required as foundation for the path as I explained was uncontrived renunciation. And yours is very good question. However, it would be even better if instead of close mind placement of recollection on the mind, one spoke of close placement of recollect excuse me, instead of close placement of recollection on the body, one spoke of close placement of recollection on the mind.

Because on that basis then indeed, scientists would rapidly come to an understanding of emptiness but they seem to be proceeding in this direction. However, I should repeat that the foundation of the path is uncontrived renunciation. So it is really close placement of recollection on the mind which is of tremendous benefit. I explained several times that the close placement of recollection on the body illuminates the fact that, excuse me, the body is seen as the abode or the base of the self, close placement of recollection on sensation illuminates the fact that sensations are seen as the wealth of the self, but close placement of recollection on the mind illuminates the fact that the mind is seen as the stuff or the material of the self. This is critically important.

Another. According to my understanding, these parts of accumulation, this refers to the Hinayana parts of accumulation. I mean, on the uncontrived renunciation, while in the a subdivision of every topic, there’s positing of supremacy of the system according to the Mahayana tradition, which is the Mahayana tradition has bodhichitta motivation behind it. Then how does this map? Do I get a bit confused.

I think probably there’s 37 facets of enlightenment, it occurs in both Hinayana tradition and Mahayana tradition. Definitely occurs in Mahayana as well. You are thinking of the eighth outline, but the eighth outline is present for every single one of the seven subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment. And what it indicates is that these 37 facets of enlightenment, if they are upheld by bodhichitta, in other words, part of the Mahayana path are superior to the 37 facets of enlightenment if they are merely upheld by definite emergence. Then, obviously without the 37 facets of enlightenment, there would be no practice of the Bodhisattvas.

So the practice of the Bodhisattvas is to conjoin meditation on the four noble truths and the 12 links in forward and reverse fashion with the training in bodhichitta. Servi. Practitioners on the path do not develop bodhichitta or emptiness? Emptiness different obviously from Mahayana? Is the bodhichitta different from Hinayana bodhichitta? So Hinayana practitioners in the future will develop bodhichitta but at present they have not.

Because their goal is to attain liberation for their own sake and for this very reason they do not have bodhichitta. Is there a difference between the Hinayana view of definite emergence or renunciation and the Mahayana There is no difference between renunciation in the Hinayana and the Mahayana. So regarding the faults of the cyclic existence from which they seek escape from, there is no difference in the outlook of the Hinayana and the Mahayana practitioner. Regarding the ultimate goal which is strive for, which is a mere liberation or a full enlightenment, there is a difference. Then we shall stop here for today.

Time is over. I must recognize I’m a bit tired. Okay. Sorry. So we will perform a thanksgiving mandala.

It’s page nine. And then pray for his holiness’s long life, and for sentient beings and dedicate the merit.

Key terms in this teaching

Collected Topics dura (Tib)
A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
five powers
The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What are the purpose and nature of the four legs of magical emanation?

The purpose of the four legs of magical emanation is very similar to its object: the multiplication of individual bodies and the subsumption of multiple bodies into one. Its definition is very similar to the definition of calm abiding: a sapience which has entered the path, having become a Samadhi that relies on the eight applications, which are the antidotes abandoning the five faults. The mode of meditation is likewise very similar to the definition: meditating upon having entered a path which is a Samadhi relying on the eight applications, antidotes abandoning the five faults.

Does it follow that physicists could never understand selflessness or emptiness because they lack the necessary basis?

No, not at all. Understanding emptiness requires understanding the four seals, and scientists are proceeding well in that direction. They accept that composite phenomena are impermanent; whether they accept that contaminated phenomena are suffering still needs to be examined. They seem to have some understanding of surfaces and emptiness. However, the foundation for the path is uncontrived renunciation. Close placement of recollection on the mind is of tremendous benefit: on that basis scientists would rapidly come to understand emptiness.

Scroll to Top