Mind Training — 2013-05-16

1 h 48 min · 13,570 words · 16 May 2013 · Buddha House Adelaide

Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Mind Training — 2013-05-16
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Ven Thubten Dondrub delivers a 108-minute commentary on the Seven-Point Mind Training, focusing on the foundational preliminaries that prepare a practitioner to generate bodhicitta. After opening prayers and refuge formulas, he turns to the main subject: renouncing obsession with this life by contemplating precious human rebirth, impermanence, and karma. He then explores the heart of the evening—the six sufferings of cyclic existence—walking through each: the uncertainty of relationships and conditions, the dissatisfaction inherent in sensual pleasure (illustrated with Nāgārjuna’s image of a leper seeking relief from maggots by fire), the suffering of repeatedly abandoning bodies, entering wombs, rising and falling between high and low states, and being fundamentally alone. Throughout, he weaves in vivid stories and sutric passages to anchor these teachings, culminating in an extended explanation of why even ordinary happiness is not true pleasure but subtle suffering that obscures the mind’s natural bliss. The teaching is pitched at practitioners with some Buddhist background and emphasizes that understanding these sufferings is not depressing but liberating—the necessary motivation to stop perpetuating saṃsāra’s causes.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013 05 16 Mind Training.mp3

UUID: 1cde0d36-c2c6-48a5-9482-25ed72506b4c

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2013-05-16

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 108.6 minutes

Words: ~13,569

Our tradition and it’s a commentary on a text called the seven point mind training that was written about three hundred years before that. And so I’m trying to comment on the commentary on the seven point mind training. So since this is our class that is designed is meant to be for people who have at least some background in the Buddhadharma although everyone’s welcome to attend we do this class in a traditional way with lots of prayers and bits and pieces. So if people would like to join in, we start with a prayer book on page page five, the lion prayer to the lion face Dakini. And and if you could scroll down because we’ve passed that point.

We’re a bit further up. We’re onto the section called the drawbacks of cyclic existence. Anyway, I prostrate to the gathering of dakinis in the three chakras who abide in the holy yoga of using space. By your powers of clairvoyance and magic illumination. Look after practitioners like a mother her child.

By the teachings of the three supreme jewels possessing the power of truth, may inner and outer hindrances be transformed. May they be dispelled. May they be pacified. May they be completely pacified. May all negative forces opposed to dharma be completely pacified.

May the host of eighty thousand obstacles be pacified. May we be separated from problems and harmful conditions to dharma. May all enjoyments be in accord with the dharma, and may there be auspiciousness and perfect happiness here right now. Next page. Obeisance to my guru and protector, Mañjuśrī, who holds to his heart a scriptural text symbolic of his seeing all things as they are, whose understanding shines forth as the sun, unclouded by defilements or traces of ignorance, who teaches in sixty ways with the patient love of a father for his only child, all creatures caught in the prison of Samsāra, confused in the darkness of their ignorance, overwhelmed by their suffering.

You whose dragon thunder proclamation of the dharma arouses us from the stupor of illusions and frees us from the iron chains of our karma, whose powerful sword of wisdom hews down suffering wherever its sprouts appear, clearing away the darkness of all ignorance. I entreat you, O Mañjuśrī, whose princely body is adorned with the one hundred and twelve marks of a Buddha, who has completed the ten stages achieving the highest perfection of a bodhisattva, who has been pure from the beginning. O Mañjuśrī, all loving one, with the brilliance of your wisdom, illuminate the darkness enclosing my mind. Enlighten my intelligence and wisdom so that I may gain insight into Buddha’s words and the text that explain them. So now in order to offer the Mandala of the universe, we we think of the Buddha in front of us as the very embodiment of the Three Jewels of refuge and all their wonderful qualities.

Also thinking of the Buddha as the embodiment of all our perfect teachers of the past, present and future. And we offer the mandala symbolizing the whole universe as a way to accumulate some merit that enables us to be able to understand the teachings. We it’s also a way to reduce our attachment, that acts as a hindrance to understanding the teachings. And, yeah. That’s it, I think.

So the important part of doing the mandala offering is to try and visualize all the beautiful things of the universe as much as possible and having that heart heartfelt wish to be free of attachment to all those things so that our mind is open to be able to hear the Dharma properly, to be able to practice it properly and gain the authentic transformative realizations. So still thinking of the Buddha in front of us, then we try to generate strongly as possible and sincerely as possible the best motivation for being here and studying the Dharma. So and that best motivation is the bodhicitta thought wishing to free our mind of all negativities, awaken all positive qualities, achieve the state of enlightenment so that we are in a position to be able to perfectly benefit all sentient beings by helping them to become free of all causes of suffering, helping them to establish all the causes that lead to peerless everlasting happiness. And it’s only by doing that that we can perfectly repay the kindness that we’ve received from all sentient beings. So to generate that thought of bodhicitta, we really do have to have a sense right now of of how much we do depend on others, that we are interconnected with every sentient being, always have been, always will be, either directly or indirectly, and we especially depend on their kindness and especially the kindness of a mother and father, which we’ve received from every sentient being many, many times in beginningless cyclic existence.

So while we remain in cyclic existence, we depend on the kindness of others. To get out of cyclic existence, we depend on their kindness. To achieve enlightenment, Also, we depend on their kindness. So they are very kind. And But the sad fact is that these very kind beings that we depend on so much in so many ways are suffering in cyclic existence.

And most of them are experiencing far greater than suffering than ourselves right now with far less ability at the moment to make sense of their suffering to reduce it, transform it, or eliminate it. And in their attempts to become free of suffering, in reality the vast majority of beings most of the time are in fact creating the causes for more suffering to perpetuate their own cyclic existence. So if we think about these things strongly, allow them to be able to feel this situation, we can generate the great compassion that leads to the mind of bodhicitta thinking that no matter what, I must use this in all future lives to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all mother sentient beings. So to strengthen that thought, we try and have a strong sense of all these living beings surrounding us, at least those we’re connected to in this life. So we think of our mother on our right, father on our left, family, friends, and helpers behind us, harmers in front, and then as much as we can, opening our hearts and minds to an awareness concern for all other beings of cyclic existence.

So to achieve enlightenment, we have to, follow the path, and that actually involves to be able to follow the path through enlightenment we have to generate this wish, this bodhicitta wish to follow that path and achieve enlightenment. So this text, the mind training like the rays of the sun is about generating bodhicitta, increasing it, and transforming everything good, bad, into the path to enlightenment. So one can think that for this reason, for the sake of all sentient beings, I will study this text and put it into practice as much as possible. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings?

So we can imagine the Buddha pleased with our motivation and showing this by now coming to the crown of our head. And when directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha dissolving into light so that that light can then pour down into us, blessing our mind. And then very briefly we can do some breathing meditation such as the nine round breathing exercise just to help establish a calmer, clearer, more concentrated mind so that we can use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddha’s teachings tonight. Okay, thank you very much. So just to remind everyone, this text is about bodhicitta, is the determination to achieve enlightenment.

But the text, the original text, the seven point mind training text says that in order to generate bodhicitta and strengthen it, firstly we have to train in the preliminaries. So these develop our mind, strengthen our mind so that we have a basis to be able to actually generate bodhicitta. So firstly, we have to turn our mind away from obsession with thinking of only this life because why? Because there are other lives to come. We’re going to die and we will have a life after this life and then beyond that while we remain in Samsāra.

So if we just think about this life, that is the precondition for all our disturbing thoughts to become active attachment and aversion. We engage in negative actions and that prevents us creating the causes to have a good rebirth. Instead, we create the causes to have a suffering rebirth. So the first thing is, the first preliminary, is to turn our mind away from obsession with this life. The ordinary things, the meaningless and harmful things of this life.

And the way to do that is to think about well, there’s many things to think about, but the the the three things that this text emphasizes, like essential things to think about, precious human rebirth, recognizing that we have the precious human rebirth, the optimum chance to practice the Dharma, then thinking about trying to realize that everything is impermanent, everything that we’re attached to obsessed with is impermanent, including ourselves. We are going to die. So that helps us turn away from obsession with this life. And the third thing is to think about the law of cause and effect to realize that the actions that we do in this life have effects far, far beyond this life. The effects in this life are nothing compared to the effects of what we do in in the future.

Right? If we really understood that, if we really got that, then we would change our behavior a lot. Yeah. Right. So now so then the third fourth of the preliminaries is taking this to a deeper level.

Because if we think about those three things, they will help us renounce this life, give up obsession with this life. It doesn’t mean give up this life and become a miserable, hopeless being. Quite the opposite. It will free our mind to do what is really meaningful and ensure that we get a good rebirth so that we move away from we we enter a path away from suffering towards greater happiness. So then the next preliminary, the fourth of preliminaries, is to develop the mind that gives up the idea, gives up on the idea that one can be happy in cyclic existence.

Remember, what is cyclic existence? It’s our mind controlled by delusion and karma. So one of the very fundamental insights of the Buddha is that it is impossible to be happy, to have any happiness, any real genuine happiness when while the mind is controlled by delusion and karma. It’s just simply impossible. But we think the opposite.

We think that without really controlling our mind, gaining understanding and mastery of our mind, we think we can be happy, that we will be happy and free of suffering. Or we’ll be able to control most of our suffering and be happy. Right? But the Buddha is telling us, forget it, folks. Yeah.

This is a complete, you know, fantasy. It will never work. It’s never worked for anyone in the past, anywhere in the universe. It’s not working now, and it won’t in the future. It is impossible to have genuine happiness while the mind is controlled by delusion and karma.

First noble truth, sorry to bore you with this, first noble truth is that ordinary existence, which it means Samsaric existence, which means our mind controlled by delusion karma, is in its nature suffering. Right? Not just painful, but unsatisfactory, unfulfilling, incomplete, imperfect, frustrating, annoying. Yeah. Something like that.

Not what we really want. So we have to realize that and and to renounce our obsession, our attachment to cyclic existence so that we can become completely free of suffering. So the way to do that, the the basic thing is to understand that what is what is, as it says here, the drawbacks of cyclic existence or in other words, to realize the suffering nature of our own cyclic existence. The more we understand this, we will want to give up that suffering by stopping the causes. Right?

Because there are causes for our suffering, and if we in effect in if in our ignorance we keep perpetuating those causes, we will continue to suffer. And and the what happiness that we do experience isn’t genuine happiness. It’s just illusory. It’s just impermanent. It’s not what we really want.

So anyway, tonight’s a bit of a heavy topic. For those people who’ve been just doing discovering Buddhism, I’ve already gone through these six sufferings already one time. So so now I’m doing it again tonight. So you should be experts on it. Anyway, so there are many ways of looking at the suffering of cyclic existence.

One can think of the suffering of the lower realms. There’s there’s the suffering of the god realms, and there are what are called the six sufferings, the eight sufferings, and the three sufferings. So this this particular section talks about what are called the six sufferings of of cyclic existence. In other words, while we have a mind controlled by delusion and karma, we will experience definitely these six kinds of sufferings in this life. If we don’t have them in this life, we’ll have them in the next or the next or the next, but we will have them over and over and over and over again.

This is the point we should try to see. Alright. Because sometimes and I’m sorry just to belabor this point. But sometimes when people hear about the suffering of Samsāra, they think, oh, it’s not so bad because, you know, I’m in Samsāra. I’m I’m not suffering so much.

Yes. I’ve got some suffering, but it’s not so bad. I can deal with it. What’s the big deal? But, of course, we are in the the best part of Samsāra.

Having a human body and a healthy body and mind, we we we have you know, we don’t experience much suffering, but we still have the potential to experience every kind of suffering and not just one time. But if we don’t get out of Samsāra, if we don’t stop the causes of Samsāra, Samsāra will go on forever, which means our suffering will go on and on and on. And forever means there is time to experience every kind of horrible suffering and the worst versions of it, not just once, but many times. This is the Buddha’s message. Not a happy thing to hear, but it’s very liberating, in fact, because it can motivate us to stop the causes of suffering.

And anyway yeah. So what are these six sufferings? The first one is said to be the the suffering of uncertainty. So it says, in cyclic existence, relationships with friends and enemies are very changeable. Things of this world are not at all reliable.

They are miserable. So because everything in cyclic existence is impermanent, it changes. And that’s why everything is uncertain because although things are impermanent, most of the time, we are unaware of this fact. Much of the time, we are living in denial of it. We believe things are permanent.

We think, you know, at one level, we know we’re going to die, but we grasp that that we’re permanent. We think our relationships will be permanent. You know, our wealth will be permanent. Our knowledge will be permanent. Our health will be permanent.

Our youth will be permanent. The government will be permanent. If you don’t like the government, then you you, of course, you hope it’s impermanent, but and so on. But we grasp at this permanence. But in fact, things change.

And it’s and and when it does, it’s usually unexpected, and we suffer. Yeah. So nothing is really certain in cyclic existence because things can look very solid and real and permanent, but in a moment, they can change. The the most wonderful friendships can change in a moment. Empires collapse in a moment.

Everything is really unsure. Alright? Friends become enemies. Enemies become strangers. Blah blah blah.

Like that. So that that that becomes a condition for a lot of suffering to to occur in our lives because we we can never be a hundred percent why we’re a deluded being certain of anything. Does this person really like me? Are they really honest? Are they always honest?

Are they always kind? We just don’t know. We just hope they are, but we we can’t be certain. So in the friendly letter, is a a a it was actually it was a letter written, a very friendly letter written written by the great Bodhisattva Nāgārjuna to one of the kings of one of the princely states of India at the time. And in that, he says, your father becomes your son, your mother, your wife, and your enemies become friends.

The opposite also takes place. Therefore, in cyclic existence, there is no certainty at all. So in one life, you know, you know, you have someone who’s your father in the next life that, you know, the person who was your father dies and in your next life, maybe they may be reborn as your son. We just don’t know. Everything is uncertain, which is a lot now it now was me to tell the story, which probably most of you have heard probably fifteen times.

But some of you haven’t, so I’ll tell the story. So once upon a time, Śāriputra, who was one of the main disciples of the Buddha, was going on his daily begging round, and he came across a small village. And in that village, there was a house and the Śāriputra could was an arhat, he had clairvoyance and everything. But anyway, there was a young man sitting outside his house, and he was eat he was holding his baby lovingly in his arms. And while he was holding his baby, he was eating some fish.

The man, the young man was eating some fish, and he was throwing the bones under the table where the family dog was eating the bones. And every now and again, the the young man would kick the dog away. Right? It’s a very kind of basically nice scene, what looks like kind of homely scene. But because Śāriputra was an arhat and had perfect clairvoyance, he could see that in reality, the son the the young the the the baby that the the the young man was lovingly holding was the the incarnation, the rebirth of his neighbor who had been carrying on with his wife un unbeknownst to him, although he hated this man, but the man had died and had been reborn as his son.

And the fish that was he was eating was the incarnation of his father who kept a pond of fish at the back of the of the house. And because of the bad karma of keeping and killing fish, he had been reborn as a fish in the pond. His son had then killed the fish and was now eating this fish, which was the incarnation of his father. And the dog that he was kicking under the table who was also eating the bones of the fish was the incarnation of his mother because of her attachment. She’d been reborn as the dog in the family, so she was eating the bones of the of what had been her husband and being kicked by her son.

That’s Samsāra. Everything’s really not sure. But that could happen, you see. That could happen. So in one in one sūtra, it says, at times, enemies turn out to be friends, and similarly, friends turn into foes.

Likewise, anyone can become your father or mother, and even your parents can become your foes. Because friendship is changeable like this, the intelligent shun attachment. The misconceived thought that relations are pleasant is replaced by the joy of engaging in virtue. So we have to remember what is attachment. It’s attachment is not liking something, but it is a mind based on craving that exaggerates how good something is far beyond what is there.

And because of that, attachment is the mind that becomes dependent on a person or thing, you know, and can’t separate. Like the idea of attachment, you’re stuck. So it’s painful to be to separate because one craving tells us that this object is is wonderful, is happiness, is permanent. So if this applies to things, but also with people and our relationships, our attachment tells us this, you know, this situation is happiness. It is permanent.

It will always be like this. And we become dependent. And we suffer because it also produces attachment, produces expectation. Yeah. In our mind, we we mix it up with love.

You know, I love you. But how much of our I love you is attachment. And we say, I love you. Why do I love you? Because you make me happy.

So you have to always be like that, the way I like you to be, because the way you are makes me happy. So you have to stay like that. And that’s what I love, this permanent one that makes me happy. If if you don’t stay like that and make me happy, then I don’t love you anymore. Yeah.

So that was really just attachment. Because attachment is not about the the other. It is about me. It’s what you know, I love you. I like you because this this is doing something I want.

It’s not about what what you want. It’s about what I want. And it wants things to be permanent, to always stay the same, and nothing ever does. So it’s a recipe for suffering. While things seem to be permanent for a while because things do stay kind of the stay same for a while, it’s okay.

But with time, things change. And then the suffering comes, the obvious suffering. So this is one of the the sufferings that is inherent, intrinsic to our existence while we have delusion and karma. That we we we have attachment. We we see things as impermanent and so on.

And so there’s always this suffering of uncertainty. One can also see it in in the in the aspect that because our mind is obscured, apart from attachment and everything, we can never be sure that what we what we experience is true or not. We can think something is like this and be completely convinced of that, you know, this person is like that or this is like that or this operates like that. And we make you know, we make we may be completely sure in our own mind it’s like that. But we don’t actually know because our mind is obscured.

You know, a very boring but very profound term for the a Buddha, an enlightened mind, is which is very revealing of what the enlightened mind is, it is called the valid knower. The enlightened mind is really the only valid knower because everything that an enlightened mind knows is valid. It’s a hundred percent accurate, true, perfect. There’s no tiny mistake, misconception, projection, anything whatsoever. And the nature of that knowing of a Buddha, of pure mind, is that what you when you know sorry.

You know you’re knowing correctly. Whereas for us, we may have this arrogance that thinks I’m right and I’m always right, but we actually deep down, we don’t know. We don’t know if we’re right. And sometimes, because of that little niggling thing, we have to put up this pretense that I’m right even more than usual. Some part sometimes for the sake of others, but sometimes for our own sake to, you know, I gotta be right.

I couldn’t be wrong. That’s too scary to be wrong. But we’re never sure. We we just don’t know because our mind is obscured. So that’s suffering, if you think about it.

It’s suffering not to really know what’s going on. And, of course, we don’t even we’re not even certain about ourselves. We don’t really know ourselves. We’re not sure of who we are. That’s suffering.

Even in quite ordinary ways, apart from the very profound way of knowing the the non inherent existent nature of ourselves, We we don’t even know what we’re capable of. We would like to think, oh, I would never do that bad thing, but we don’t know given, you know, if the conditions were there. Right? So that is intrinsic. That is inherent type of suffering for an obscured mind.

It won’t go away. It will never go away while there’s an obscure if we don’t have an obscured mind, if we don’t have saṃsāra, finished. But while there’s saṃsāra, that’s there. That suffering is there. And we can deny it and try and live a life in denial of it, but the Buddha is saying that the the whole path to enlightenment is about facing the truth.

Right? The truth is what is going to set us free. Not that any any denial of any truth is suffering and and brings suffering. So we have to look at this ourselves and decide, is it true or not? Is this true?

And if if it’s true, that means, I know, this is this applies to me. So am I going to just let it happen? Or will I seize this opportunity, this precious human rebirth to do something about it? Suffering number two. If that wasn’t enough, there’s more.

You’ve got to laugh about this appeared somehow. The second suffering that we’re we’re all subject to simply because we we’re in cyclic existence is that the suffering of dissatisfaction. So, again, in the same text by Nāgārjuna, he says, this is a really interesting thing to reflect. Of course, this doesn’t make much sense if you don’t believe in mind and the continuity of mind and future lives that but the whole of the Buddha’s teachings is based on the belief or from Buddha’s point of view, it’s not a belief, but direct perception that we have mind, which is not our brain. And our mind being something formless like space is indestructible.

So it goes on and on and on forever, which means we take while we’re in Samsāra, we take rebirth again and again and again and again. So if that’s true, which is the basis of the Buddhist teachings, it follows as Nāgārjuna says, each individual has drunk more milk than the four great oceans. I’m not quite sure what the four great oceans are, but anyway anyway, if you just take all the oceans on on just on this planet, we we’ve had so many taking our human rebirths, in our human rebirths, the the the mother’s milk we have drank in all our rebirths as a human being would fill all the ocean more more than fill all the oceans of this earth. And yet we’re still not satisfied. We’ve drunk all this milk.

We’ve Apart from milk, we’ve drunk a whole lot of beer, champagne, Woody’s lemonade. Do they still make that here? Yes. We’ve all this stuff. Gallons, not near oceans of it.

Oceans of it, but not satisfied. And there’s still more to drink. Oceans, more to drink. If we just thinking of taking rebirth as a human, we will drink oceans and oceans and oceans of stuff, and we still won’t be happy with it. There are bottles of wine you can buy.

Well, I can’t buy them. Well, even if I not probably most of you couldn’t buy them either. They cost thousands and thousands of dollars. I think I read something about there was a bottle of something that cost two hundred thousand dollars. Two hundred thousand dollars for a bottle of wine.

So we’ve drunk oceans of two hundred thousand dollar bottles of wine, but it hasn’t made us happy. I did I I I have to confess I waste some of my precious human rebirth watching Google News. And there was a thing on there some time ago about some guy. He broke up from his girlfriend. So to make himself happy, he went to some restaurant and ordered this dessert that cost.

How much did it cost? It was some obscene amount of money. It was thousands of dollars. It was some kind of little thing that had gold stuff and diamonds or something sprinkled up. I I don’t know how you could even eat it, but he he spent, I think, thirty thousand dollars on one one dessert.

But I don’t think it made him happy. Yes. Right. But, you know, we could eat mountains of them, and we still we have eaten mountains of this kind of stuff. And it it goes on to say, the same text says, understand attachment to objects of desire as being like a leper seeking for comfort when tormented by maggots, he sits by the fire but finds no relief.

Obtaining everything you desire and consuming much on a daily basis, yet still to be dissatisfied is the greatest disease. And that’s what happens to us. We the nature of desire is that you follow desire, you get the object, you experience the object, but every time we follow desire, we create the imprint for more desire. When you meet the object, the desire doesn’t stop forever. It just temporarily stops.

You’ve just created the cause for another desire. And and what does that mean? We when we are desiring something, craving something, maybe I should use that word to distinguish it from desiring to achieve enlightenment, is a good state of mind. When we crave things, it means our mind is dissatisfied. That is the nature of craving.

It’s it’s disturbing the mind. It’s a it’s a dissatisfied mind. It’s always telling us there is something the nature of desire, craving, is that it tells us that there is something or someone out there separate out from from me that is beautiful, that is good, that is happiness. Right? So the so the underlying that’s the obvious message of desire and attachment is that beauty and goodness and happiness is out there.

It’s not in here. It’s out there. So the underlying subliminal message, which is even worse, is that there isn’t any goodness or happiness or beauty inside. So every time we we follow desire, we are reinforcing that belief to some in some subtle way that there’s nothing really good in here. It’s all out there.

And so that makes dissatisfaction. That is suffering. That is cyclic existence. So we always have to find this happiness out there. And by looking for it out there and working to get it out there, of course, there’s no time to find that there is actually a lot of beauty and goodness and happiness inside.

So to be dissatisfied is actually the greatest disease because it doesn’t allow us the time to to be healthy, to work for real health, mental health. So there is no satisfaction in sensual pleasure. And if you think especially about what is taught in the sūtra of avoiding sorrow, you will feel great concern. Because in that text, says, the water in the ocean bears no comparison. Oh, here we go.

With the molten copper you’ve drunk again and again in hell. So in one of the hell one of the many hell realms, there are many hell realms of great suffering suffering created by our mind. The in the in one of those hells, the experience is like it doesn’t really matter whether it actually happens, but the mind gives rise to the experience as though you’re drinking molten metal. So a lot of suffering. Right.

The amount of filth you’ve eaten when you were born as a pig or dog would be much greater than Mount Meru, the king of mountains. As a vessel for all the tears you have shed when parted from friends and relatives in cyclic existence, the ocean would not be big enough. So, you know, all our tears have filled all the oceans of the world many times. If all the heads cut off in the course of mutual conflicts were to be piled up, the heap would reach beyond the realm of Brahma. Yeah.

So unfortunately, we have horrible illustrations of that even in even now because if you’ve seen pictures of what happened in Cambodia and the killing fields of Cambodia, there are pictures of, like, mountains of human skeletons and so on. Just appalling things. So and that’s just in a couple of years. If you’ve if you if you add what you know, we have killed people life after life. So if all our dead bodies and people killed us, if you put together all the dead our previous dead bodies and all the dead bodies of the people we’ve killed, you know, it’s just mountains and mountains.

I think Born many times as a famished worm, the amount of earth and dung you’ve eaten would fill the great ocean of milk right up to the brim. So all these little, you know, worms who, you know, who produce this dirt. So we’ve done that millions of times. And sorry, the message is it will continue if we don’t get out of cyclic existence. Just a simple way to reflect on this, which is really useful to try to reduce our attachment is that there are so many things that we as ordinary people think that if I had this, if I only I could have this, I’d be happy.

If only I I had this job or I lived in this kind of place or I had this kind of relationship with someone, you know, and I had this many children and I had that, I had that kind of car. And I had this amount of money coming in every year. If only I had these things, then I’d be happy. And if only I looked like this, if, you know, if only my body was a little bit longer or wider or parts of it, you know, were rearranged a bit better and so on, then I’d be happy. So what this point is making is that, in fact, all of these things that we think, if only I could have them, we’ve had them in past lives.

Not just once, but millions and millions of times. That’s that’s the implication of cyclic existence. It’s beginningless and endless if we don’t do anything about it. So there’s been time to experience every every good thing and and every bad thing, and we’re still not satisfied. So what’s the so the point is, why bother chasing after all these worldly things?

Because we’ve had them in abundance before, and it didn’t make us happy. And if you look at all the people still in the world who’ve got all the stuff, they’re not really happy. And if you look at the life of the Buddha, the Buddha, Prince Siddhartha, started out. He started out with all the good stuff. He was a prince.

You know? He was good looking. He won all the sports contests. He married the most beautiful princess in India. He started out with the whole shebang.

Like, he was like a movie star, and then he chucked it all in. I mean, that’s the story. You know? That’s, you know, hint hint what we should do. So, as explained, however much worldly wealth you acquire, it is nothing but seduction.

You should feel apprehensive, thinking of how the same could happen to you if you do not make further effort. In the words of the spiritual friend, Geshe Potowa, from the first, you must face so many ups and downs here in cyclic existence, but nothing worthwhile. Think about this until you’re convinced. So that’s what all the great practitioners in the past have done, and they renounced cyclic existence and freed their minds. So that’s what we have to do.

We have to really check up. Is it true that these things that this is what we are likely to experience or and are experiencing? If so, why continue to create the causes? Because now we’ve we’ve met the Dharma. We’ve we’ve got the freedom not to do those things.

Third suffering is the disadvantages of having to discard our body over and over again. So it says the bodies assumed by each sentient being have to be discarded. If their bones did not rot, they would be greater than Mount Meru. The friendly letter by Nāgārjuna says, the heap of each sentient being’s bones would equal or even be greater than Mount Meru. And so Mount Meru is meant to be at the center of the universe far bigger than Mount Everest.

But even if we just take Mount Everest as an example, it’s saying that all the heaps of bones of all our pre if if we could assemble all the bones from our previous bodies, they would be bigger than if if they hadn’t rotted, that’d be bigger than Mount Everest. So why is this suffering? Because we take a body, we get reborn. We’ve we’ve we’ve taken this body, and we’ve got attached to it. It’s mine.

It’s me. We I we one level of our ignorance identifies that our body is actually me. So but then we have to die, so we have to separate from this body. And there’s a lot of suffering because of the attachment to to leaving this body. So then we get another body, but then and we get attached to that, but then we we have to separate it from that.

Then we get another one, but we have to separate from it. So that’s saṃsāra. That will go on without ever ceasing if we don’t do something about it. Right? If we don’t control our delusions, if we don’t eliminate them, then they will be active, and we follow those delusions and create the causes for all these sufferings.

And similarly, there’s the disadvantage or the suffering of entering the womb over and over again. So it it says the earth would be insufficient to count the number of one’s mothers with pellets of of soil the size of juniper berries. So if we if we made a took a little bit of soil and the size of a juniper berry, which are juniper berries are about that big, aren’t they? Maybe even a bit smaller than that. So if you were to take, you know, little bits of earth and roll them up into balls that big, you know, this was my previous mother, the mother before that, mother before that, then you’d use up all the soil in the earth and you still wouldn’t have covered counting the number of mothers one’s had and therefore the number of births one’s had.

Right? So there’s the suffering of having to go into the Bardo state. Then there’s the suffering of entering into like, even just if we can just consider being reborn as a human being, then we have to enter into the womb of a human being. Not very nice. Stuck there for nine months.

It’s dark and smelly. Because, you know, one is conscious there. You know? There’s a lot of this is yeah. I don’t know about people who think it’s okay to have abortions.

I’m still not quite sure what what what when modern science believes a being becomes a human being. When when is the when do you become a human being from a scientific point of view? Because you’re not allowed to kill a human being. Right? That’s not good.

But if it’s in the womb, it’s okay because it’s not a human being. So when does it become a human being? One second before it pops out of the womb? Just as it’s halfway out? When it’s when the when when it’s you know, as soon as you’re out, you suddenly become a human being?

Well, from a Buddhist point of view, from the moment, you know, fertilization occurs, that occurs because consciousness has joined those physical substances, and that is a being. That is a sentient being. Why am I saying this? Oh, I so yeah. So the being in the womb is conscious.

Not conscious the way we are, of course, but there’s but, you know, a send some awareness and feeling going on. And and in the teachings, it says, like, when when a mother eats certain things, the the baby, the the tiny fetus can suffer as a result of that. If the mother moves violently, this can cause disturbance and so on. So just being in the womb is a type of suffering. And then, of course, coming out of the womb is suffering.

And then once you’re out, a whole series of other sufferings start. That’s saṃsāra. It’s the pits. And we like to tell ourselves it’s terrific. It’s wonderful.

Life is a bowl of cherries. But the Buddha is saying, actually, it’s really kind of a mess. But we have to put that in the context. Remember, you know, if if that was that was it, then that would be totally depressing. But why the Buddha is emphasizing this is because he discovered there’s a whole other way of existing, free of delusion, free of karma, free of saṃsāra, free of bodies that grow old, sick, and die.

There is the possibility of nirvana enlightenment. So we have to put all of this in that context. Otherwise, it gets really depressing. Right? If that was the that’s all there was, it would be totally depressing.

But we have to think about this to motivate ourselves to achieve this other possibility. Okay. The other quotation basically makes the same point. So then the next suffering before the tea break, which will be a slight not quite as suffering. When’s our tea break?

Who who’s in charge of our tea break? Ring in. Twelve minutes? Okay. If you can bear put up with more suffering.

The next one is the suffering of continually changing from high to low. So, again, the Nāgārjuna’s text, the friendly letter says, having been Indra, who’s the term for the king of the gods, the the desire realm gods, worthy of the world’s veneration, one falls again to earth through the force of action, through the force of karma. Or having been a universal monarch, once again becomes a servant in cyclic existence. Having long experienced pleasure fondling the breasts and hips of celestial maidens, this is in the god realms, one undergoes the unbearable contact of the crushing, cutting, and slashing operations in the hells. So before reading more of that, basically, what the suffering is that, you know, even in this life, we can we we can have the high of being healthy and then the low of being unhealthy.

We can have the high of being young, but then there’s the low of being old. Sometimes getting old is quite nice, actually. Some good things about it. Anyway, that’s also the and everything is suffering. There’s a suffering of being young.

There’s the suffering of being old and everything. But there’s there’s there’s the high of being rich, but, you know, you can become rich, but then you can become poor. You can become very powerful. You can become very weak. You can become the victimizer, and you can become the victim.

All of these things can happen even in just in one life. We go up and and even in one one day, our mind goes up and down. You know, we we can wake up full of optimism and smiling and happy, fall out of bed, trip, get really annoyed, spill coffee all over ourselves and everything, you know, then we get really black. And and then something someone says something nice and the mind goes up and then, you know, something else goes wrong and the mind goes down. So the mind goes up and down around and around.

And because also this is saṃsāra, we have good you know, we have created good actions. So karma the karmic imprints ripen as good things. But we’ve done because of delusion, we’ve engaged in negative actions. So that negative karmic those negative karmic imprints ripen as unpleasant experiences. And we have both positive and negative imprints in our mind all the time.

So some positive things, some negative things. So up and down, up and down all the time. All the time. Every day, all this life. And then as it points out in a broader context, you know, what in one life we’re a human being, then the next we could be an animal.

We can be, excuse me, fondling the breasts of the goddesses in the god realms. And and in the next moment, in the next life, we can be reborn in the in the hells. So up and down depending on what karma ripens. So this is suffering. It’s very to go for this this what Lama Yeshe used to call the yo yo mind of going up and down all the time.

Think of how following the pleasure of the grounds yielding at the touch of your feet while dwelling long on Meru’s peak. So this is where the gods live. The unbearable suffering of the fire pit in the swamp of filth will strike again. Having frolicked in lovely pleasant gardens waited on by celestial maidens, again, your arms and legs, ears, and nose are cut in the forest of trees with leaves like swords. This is one of the hell realms.

After resting in gently flowing streams on golden lotuses with beautiful celestial maidens, there’s a a a what’s the word? This is the male version. There’s a female version for all the ladies, of course. Again, you fall into the unbearably caustic boiling water of the infernal, forwardless river. Having attained the magnificent pleasure of celestial realms and even Brahma’s bliss of detachment, Again, you undergo endless suffering.

So many people find it difficult to believe in these different realms, but this is what the Buddha taught that we have this potential within us, not just to be a human being, but our mind can be obscured and experienced the level of being born as an animal or a a hungry ghost or in the different kind of hell realms of great suffering. But when our mind is less obscured, we experience these godlike states. These and there are many kinds of these god just like there are many kinds of hell realms, and there are many kinds of god realms. And one god realm is where the the gods called the Brahma gods live. And then there is the supreme Brahma who’s like the, you know, the head honcho Brahma in that in that god realm.

So we have been that being many times. So those beings live for millions of years and experience this incredible bliss for billions of years. They have these apparently incredibly bought beautiful bodies of light where you float around on lotuses. And I mean, this is just like some kind of human description because it’s begun we can’t conceive what it would actually be like. So they use human examples to give some suggestion.

So in India, lotuses are cons just like in the in the west, we think traditionally roses are, you know, the most beautiful flower possibly, generally speaking. In India, the lotus was considered the most beautiful and pure flower. So it’s used as a symbol in many ways of so floating around on lotuses, like, would be really nice. Yeah. And it’s incredibly beautiful.

It doesn’t mean I don’t think one has to take that absolutely literally. It just gives some sense that there’s there’s this incredibly beautiful environment where you just, you know, float around. Everything is easy. Everything you nothing is difficult. But that’s still just a samsaric experience because it doesn’t last.

The the the the delusions and karma is still there, but they’re not active while you’re in that realm. Just like at the moment, unless I’m really worrying you and irritating you, you’re not angry in this you know, everyone hopefully is in a reasonably, maybe slightly depressed state of mind during this talk, but maybe peaceful state of mind. But then we can go out back into the streets of Adelaide, and there’s so many things to make us agitated and annoyed and whatever. Yeah. But when one is in a pleasant environment, it’s very you know, the mind can be really nice.

So in these god realms, you know, it’s all beautiful. So the mind is at peace temporarily that the delusions aren’t active, but they’re still there. But so it’s still suffering because it doesn’t last. Yeah. As kindling for the fires of the hell without respite, when you have attained the state of the of sun or moon, the light of your body illuminates the entire world.

So that’s what these god realms are like. You’re you’re the the light coming from your body as one of these gods or goddesses is like the the light coming from the sun. But on returning to darkness, know, falling into the lower realms, even your outstretched hand not even your outstretched hand can be seen. So going up and down realms of light, realms of darkness over that’s Samsāra. These are all potentials of our mind.

So in one of the sutras it says, the end of all accumulation is exhaustion. The end of being high is to fall low. The end of meeting is separation. The end of life is death. Just to say something more jolly.

One one one thing we’re encouraged to practice is, you know, when you go home to your house or where you live, you open the door and you look at all the things inside, and then you think, when I’m dead, all this is gonna be scattered. Yeah? I have no control of I might write a will and saying this is going to be left to auntie Flo, but who knows whether auntie Flo will get it? Some somebody will swoop in, buy it all, take it to a shop and sell it. Yeah.

It’s all no control. So that’s that’s the end of accumulation is that it just gets scattered. It’s exhausted. And yet we’re so attached to all the stuff, you know, and rearrange it and everything. But at some point, it’s totally we lose all control over it.

You know, there are these very elegant shops called antique shops. It what is it? It’s full of dead people stuff. That’s what an antique is. It’s something for a lot that used to belong.

Well, if you belong to a live person, but that person is now dead. It’s dead people people’s stuff. I’m trying to give some balance, believe it or not. One has to think about these, what we see as negative, depressing things, but there’s a purpose, a positive purpose for it. Right?

But if we don’t think about this suffering, then we will it’s like if you have a disease, you know, a really terrible disease, but you look okay and you tell yourself, well, I look okay, so it doesn’t matter. I’ll just do I’ll ignore it. I won’t do anything about the disease. I’ll just do everything because I look okay and everyone tells me I look okay. But, of course, because we don’t do anything about it, the disease will kill us.

But we if we did something about it, the disease may not kill us. But this is even more because even if we stop one disease, we’re going to die. But here, you we we can work with our mind in such a way that we can bring about total cessation of all suffering so that we won’t just temporarily cease a problem or a suffering. We will be able to completely cease all problems so they never come back again. But we have to be motivated to do that.

And while we think everything is basically hunky dory that I can basically manage everything because it’s not so bad, we we won’t put the effort because, you know, practicing Dharma, changing the mind, it requires a lot of hard work. Oh, that was not a good point to make, was it? No. Yeah. Right.

But as a also to balance that, as Samsāra is hard work. Samsāra, just being an ordinary person, is very hard work. And it never that that work never comes to an end. But the hard work of practicing Dharma comes to an end. With a really good end, you get the result.

With samsaric work you never get the result that you want because it’s never status. It’s never really what you want. You rearrange it, but then it needs to be rearranged again. But once you’ve got nirvana, that’s it, folks. That’s it.

Finished. Faster. That’s what we have to remember. Just before we have our tea break, a question, complaint. We’ve had one complaint.

A question, disagreement, clarification. Yes, Sasha. Mhmm. Yes. Sorry.

What? It’s up. Well, it’s very nice while it lasts, and it lasts a long time. But that’s why in the in in the Dharma, the Buddha says, don’t bother working to become reborn as in in the god realms because even though it is very beautiful and lasts a long time, it doesn’t lead anywhere. So don’t bother with them.

Yeah. Gen yeah. Just very, quickly, there are three types of god realms. There’s the desire there’s the gods of the desire realm, and then there’s the form and formless realm, god goddess states. So to be reborn as a a long lived god in the desire realm, that depends purely on creating virtuous actions.

Yeah? And and one will get that result being reborn in those god realms. To be reborn in the form and formless realms is much, much more difficult. The only way you can be reborn in the because in those realms is you have to develop Samādhi, single-pointed concentration. And beyond that, you have to develop these very deep levels of meditation meditation absorption.

And if you develop those with just the motivation to experience the bliss of that kind of meditation, so it’s basically a worldly meditation, when you die, you your mind automatically kind of goes in to the level of meditation that you’ve achieved and you stay in that state for thousands of years. Billions of years. And that but and then the energy runs out eventually, and then one takes rebirth again in one of the other realms. Sorry. If you when it ripens, well, there’s many effects.

One effect is that you get killed. But another effect, one is that you have the tendency to kill. The you have that. Yeah. The instinct to kill.

But it doesn’t mean you would necessarily will kill, but one of the karmic imprints of any action positive or negative is the habit to do that thing, the tendency. No. The karmic result. No. There’s many other karmic results.

Yeah. Tea break. Thank you very much. Ten minutes. We’ve lost a few people.

Oh. Is your foot? Okay final suffering for tonight is here it’s called the disadvantage of having no companions or the suffering of being alone. So Nāgārjuna says about this, actually, as the disadvantages are like this, referring to all the other sufferings, take up the lamplight of the three kinds of merit for you enter the infinite darkness where sun and moon cannot reach alone. So this is kind of basically talking about leaving entering the infinite darkness is referring to end leaving this body going into the Bardo.

So we do this alone. So there is the suffering of being alone. Actually, doesn’t really say much more about it there, but in the in the Lamrim teachings, it it talks about the suffering of being alone is that, again, this is something intrinsic to cyclic existence because the the very root of cyclic existence is our ignorance, grasping that we and and all things somehow inherently exist from their own side under their own power. So because of that wrong view, that wrong experience, that creates the illusion of a self that is somehow seeming to exist almost in dependence upon its own side. And it and simply because we we grasp at at our own ego as being this almost independent phenomena, simply because of that, that creates the sense of other.

Because there is a sense of I, there is always the sense of other. And what that implies is because there is an inherently existing I, there is always inherently existing other. So there’s always that gap between oneself and others. So even though if we take human beings, human beings are always characterized as being social animals. We like to be with other people.

We we enjoy and need the company of others, and we like friendships and family and and lovers and so on. But because of our grasping at an inherently existing self, even with the people we feel closest to, there is always some gap that we don’t really know them. We can’t totally share their experiences. They can’t know our experiences. And so there is that sense of being alone.

So in the teachings, it talks about, you know, in the beginning, we are born alone. Now only we experience our being born. No one else our mother doesn’t experience it. She experiences giving birth, but she doesn’t give She doesn’t have our experience of being born, and only we experience our dying. No one else experiences it.

We have to experience that completely alone. And then in between, we are alone. Between birth and death, we are fundamentally alone. We are alone with others. Right?

That is our samsaric situation, that we are alone with others. So that’s what and and so that can produce I mean, being alone itself is not necessarily suffering. Being alone sometimes is nice. It’s good to be away from other people Sometimes, some people really prefer to be away from other human beings, all the time. Some people like it for a little time.

Some people can’t bear to be alone by themselves. It is quite unbearable for some people. But all of us experience, you know, the suffering of of being lonely at some point. So that’s the the obvious meaning of this of this suffering, of of the suffering of being lonely and the suffering that we have to experience when we don’t have support of people, family, friends, helpers around us just when we need it. So there’s that suffering of being alone when we need help.

But at a deeper level and so that can help one can think of many examples of how that occurs. And especially that can occur if this is one of the sufferings of old age, that as one gets older, you know, the longer we live, it means that we outlive our family and friends. And also, that means that if we’d live to be very old, we become dependent on we we yeah. We become dependent on people we don’t know, on strangers. So that is a suffering or can be a suffering.

Sometimes the strangers may be nice and kind, but in Samsāra, one can, you know, be with people who are not kind and helpful and caring at all as we can see in care facilities in our country. Some are good. Some are bad. Some are just truly horrendous places. So we will experience that suffering sooner or later in Samsāra if we stay in Samsāra.

But at a deeper level, what the the the really subtle meaning of this suffering of this being alone refers to being alone without the Dharma. So that is really horrendous suffering. To have to, you know, to experience suffering without the help of the Dharma, having no refuge, no faith. That is the worst kind of suffering in many ways, I think. Because what makes suffering really horrible is thinking, feeling that it has no meaning, that this is just you know, people commit suicide because life becomes meaningless.

It becomes unbearable. It’s really amazing. I I think I’ve said this before just recently here, but I’ll just say it again because I only have about three thoughts in my head and I repeat them endlessly. I’m sorry. But it always amazes me that, you know, if you’ve ever read about the unbelievable, unbelievable suffering that people experienced in the concentration camps in Nazi Germany or, you know, in the Gulags in Russia, just but particularly the Nazi ones.

Just horrendous suffering. And yet those people didn’t commit some did, but most of those people endured that suffering. They didn’t commit suicide because somehow, despite that horrendous suffering, they must have felt their life still had some meaning. But then there are people who have nowhere near that much suffering, but their life they feel their life has no meaning, and they end it. I mean, a lot of young people these days, for very small reasons, end their life.

Yeah. And the reason is not why they end their life is probably not the reason they end their life. It’s just the the the some point, you know, something that sets it off. Underlying that must be some sense that their life has no meaning. I think I don’t know.

But the point I’m trying to make is that to feel that one’s life has no meaning and that the suffering that one is enduring has no meaning whatsoever, just kind of pouring down on you for no reason. This is really unbearable. And also you have no way, if you have no faith in any kind of religion or whatever, then you you there’s nothing you can’t do anything with the suffering. Right? But one of the great beauties you know, I can’t I’ve been oh, you know, I’ve supposedly Buddhist for thirty seven years or something.

Thirty six years now. I’ve been a monk for thirty five. Thirty six years. Thirty six years I’ve been a monk. But I can’t claim anything, you know, because because I don’t have anything.

I have no good experiences. You know, I’m a very bad practitioner. You know, no good qualities. Haven’t realized or understood anything. But the one the one thing that has helped from the beginning is that the dharma my I do have some faith in the dharma.

I have some understanding and some faith in it. And that you know, made the suffering in my life bearable. Yeah. That that is an amazing thing that to have. Because unfortunately, when you meet the dharma, some people think all your suffering will go away or if you become a monk or nun, suddenly you stop suffering.

Of course, it doesn’t. But actually, things can get a whole lot worse once you meet the Dharma. You realize how miserable you are. But the beauty is the beauty is that you’ve got something. You have some context to put it in and why it’s and and there’s some explanation of why it is happening which makes it bearable to some extent.

Yeah? So I’m eternally grateful to the Dharma for that. That is a great protection from all the mean, honestly, when I look at what the world maybe I’m I’m a bit of the half empty cup per person, I to admit. But and also I’m I’m also the other the what’s the other version? The full one because I, you know, I I believe in the dharma.

That’s something very positive. But anyway, what am I trying to say? Yeah. So with my negative mind, it seems to me that the world is becoming in many ways really gruesome, very crazy. Apart from all the absolute violence and horror and people blowing each other up, Just in our society, things are getting harder and harder.

I mean, people are getting harder. The the self-cherishing thought and the way people treat each other and government and banks and everything is so much more nastier, it seems to me, than when I was younger. People live far more stressful lives chasing after all these wonderful things of life. So everyone is so yeah. And people tell me about how in in how life and their work is so competitive, so much more than it ever was.

So I think if I didn’t have the dharma and I was living that life, I’d be I would I would be either crazy or I would have jumped off a cliff. No. I wouldn’t have jumped off a cliff because I’m too coward to do that, but taking a pill or something. What keeps me alive is the Dharma. There’s some meaning in all this craziness.

But if you don’t have that, even a little bit of it, it’s just horrible. You’re you’re you’re really alone. You have no protection from all the insanity that is going on and nastiness, I think. But when you have the dharma, you have some faith in it, you have you are not alone. You have a friend.

You have a real friend, one doesn’t become an enemy or a stranger. You have the perfect friend. You have the perfect protector, which is the Buddhadharma. And then you’re not alone. I I’m about to burst into a song that goes like that, but I’ll right?

But it’s true. You think about, you know, if you’re you have a lot of suffering, but there’s no way to make any sense of it and you’ve got no method to reduce it, you we then you’re really alone. No matter how many friends, you know, money, fame, blah blah blah, you’re alone. But if you if you have the dharma, you’re not alone. You’ve got something that really works, that really helps, which is and it’s always there in your mind.

I don’t mean dharma like a book. You know, that’s useless. Yeah. If you’re suffering and, oh, I’ve got the dharma book, I’ll stick it, you know. That’s not gonna well, this one’s Dharma understanding, it it that never if you’ve got it, if you’ve worked on it, you’ve got some Dharma understanding, some Dharma faith, some refuge, then that’s your greatest friend.

But the point is if we stay in Samsāra right now, what maybe we have is the Dharma, but people can and may again, we may think I wouldn’t I will never give up the Dharma. I will never lose my faith in the Dharma. This it can happen. It happens to people. If one doesn’t keep up the causes, you know, we we use up our you know, to have to meet the dharma, to have faith in it requires a lot and lot of merit.

Yeah. A lot. And we use it up. And if we use it up, our faith can run out. So the point I’m trying to make is slowly is that if we remain in Samsāra, we will take rebirths where we have no faith, where there is no dharma, there’s and we have and we can’t meet it.

And even if we meet it, we don’t have faith in it. And then we’re really alone with our suffering. Because there are people, you know, who have met the Buddha’s teachings. They study them as an intellectual exercise, but it doesn’t help them because they have no faith in it. These people, you know, brilliant brilliant minds write PhDs about emptiness and blah blah blah, but it doesn’t help them.

It might help them get an income and a doctor’s degree, but it doesn’t help their suffering because there’s no faith. Yeah. But if you have some faith, even if there’s not much understanding, but you have some faith in the Dharma, you have this incredible protection. So we can be reborn, you know, very clever, very smart, very educated, but we don’t have any faith. So we’re alone with our suffering, completely alone.

Nothing to help us. That is that is that is real suffering. So in conclusion it says, these six disadvantages or sufferings can be abbreviated in three points. cyclic existence is unreliable. Whatever pleasures are enjoyed in cyclic existence are ultimately unsatisfying.

And this has been so for beginningless time. That’s the message. The first of these points that cyclic existence is unreliable can be explained in four ways: Obtaining a body is not to be relied upon since it has to be discarded again and again. We cannot rely on receiving help or harm since nothing is certain. We cannot rely on finding prosperity because our position changes from high to low.

The fellowship of others cannot be relied upon since we have to go unaccompanied. The second point, which is whatever pleasures are enjoyed are ultimately unsatisfying, concerns the evident disadvantages of dissatisfaction. The third point indicates that because we have entered the womb over and over again, the origin of our series of births is untraceable. Do the abbreviated contemplation in this way. So this is how we should meditate on these six sufferings.

And to develop courage, Nāgārjuna in the friendly letter advises, Become disgusted with cyclic existence. The source of so much suffering. Not getting what you want, death, sickness, old age, and so on. So we have to become disgusted with our own cyclic existence, not cyclic existence in some abstract way, but the fact that we have a mind mind controlled by delusion and karma, we should get fed up with that because our mind in its nature is perfect and pure and blissful. It is Buddha.

And yet we it’s it’s obscured by delusion and karma, and so we instead of enlightenment, have Samsāra. Think about the eight kinds of suffering explained above. Just briefly in case you don’t know, the eight sufferings are: the suffering of birth, sickness, aging and death. And then there’s the suffering of not getting what we crave for, being not getting what we crave for, being separated from what we are attached to, and then meeting with things people and things we don’t want to meet with. And then there’s the suffering of the aggregates.

So these are the are the eight sufferings of cyclic existence. So it says think about these as well. In this way, think about the three sufferings of cyclic existence in general and each of the six sufferings in particular. So just briefly briefly, do I have time? Very briefly, the three sufferings of cyclic existence are the suffering of pain physical and mental pain which is obvious suffering which even animals understand.

Then there is the subtle kind of suffering, which is called the suffering of change. And then there is a very very subtle suffering, which is called compounded pervasive suffering, which basically refers to the fact that having a body controlled by delusion and karma, having a mind controlled by delusion and karma is the basis of every kind of suffering. So every being in cyclic existence has a body and mind controlled by delusion and karma. So even when they’re happy, there is still the potential for suffering. So that’s that itself is suffering.

Even when we’re perfectly healthy, we have the potential for sickness. So that is suffering. Even when we’re young, we have the potential to grow old. So that’s suffering. Yeah.

So anyway, I’d just like to talk briefly about the middle type of suffering, the suffering of change, because this is really important to understand. Because not because what the Buddha discovered is that not only is Samsāra in its nature full of obvious suffering, the suffering of pain, but even what we call happiness, which we waste our life chasing after, even that happiness isn’t happiness. It is called it’s a subtle kind of suffering, called the suffering of change. And if we really get that one, that should really help us renounce cyclic existence. So why why is so everything you can think of as an ordinary being that you’ve experienced or you’ve seen or know of an another ordinary human being experience as pleasure and happiness from a Buddhist point of view is just an example of the suffering of change.

All of it. And why? The obvious reason, the simplest, easiest way to understand it’s a type of suffering is because all of that happiness, all of that pleasure, simply doesn’t last. It just doesn’t last. Whatever wonderful experiences you we, each of us, have had in our life, they are now memories.

And whatever pleasant experiences we’re having now will become a memory. They won’t last, and we can’t make them last. Just the ordinary ones with samsaric mind. nirvana enlightenment, that lasts, but samsaric experiences, the pleasant ones just don’t last. So that’s the easiest way to just, you know, to understand it.

Another way, a bit more subtle, is to to to realize that we we label things as happiness simply because we have no idea what we can really experience. It’s it’s only very relative relative to some other kind of suffering, this looks like happiness. Or relative to the fact that we don’t know that we are capable of even far greater experiences, we settle and call this in our ignorance. We call this happiness. Just to to you know, as an illus simple illustration, if if we develop Samādhi, the ability to hold our mind single pointedly on an object, that involves subduing our disturbing thoughts.

When that happens, we start to experience some of the natural bliss of the mind. So when you achieve Samādhi or calm abiding, your body experiences this incredible ecstasy, this physical ecstasy and mental bliss. So this is far greater than any kind of happiness that we have ever experienced. And then then there’s the bliss that the gods experience. And that still samsaric stuff doesn’t last.

So what we call happiness is just nothing compared to that. But the the the most subtle way to understand this point that our happiness isn’t suffering is the most important one to understand, which I will now which I did at the DB and I will now or I always try to explain now and give the same example that I heard thirty six years ago, which is and some of you have heard this many times before, is that if you if if you’re standing, if you stand still for a while, just stand up, stand still, after some time it gets painful, really quite painful. So that’s the suffering of pain. So you sit down. This is just giving a rough idea.

Right? So sitting down after standing the pain of standing up, sitting down looks like happiness, pleasure. We label it happiness. Right? But after some time of sitting, it becomes uncomfortable, and there seems to be the happiness of sitting seems to turn into the suffering of sitting.

So then we stand up, and the what appears to be the suffering of sitting stops, and the happiness of standing starts. But after some time of standing, the happiness of standing stops, and the the the suffering of standing starts. That’s what appears to be happening. But in fact, something else is actually going on. Because if a court one of the fundamental sorry.

This is gonna go on a while. You can leave now. One of the very fundamental super fundamental teachings of the Buddha is the law of cause and effect. How if if there is an effect, it has to have a cause. And the nature of the cause determines the nature of the effect.

And this is definite. It never ever changes. So if something is an actual cause of something else, if you create that cause again and again, you will always get the same effect. Right? That’s fundamental.

So if sitting down was an valid actual cause of the pleasure that seems to arise when you sit down, the longer you sat down, the pleasure of sitting would continue. It would have to continue. Or to go back as I was doing in the thing. If you hit your head, it hurts. Yeah?

Hitting head with hard object is a valid cause of head hurting. And if you do it again, if you create the cause again, you get this I can tell you quite validly, it hurts. You get the same effect. And if you keep doing it, the effect will be and it will actually increase, and then I’ll kill myself and die. Right?

So because that’s you know, hitting hard object on head is actual cause of suffering. So if sitting down was actual cause of pleasure of sitting down, if you continue to sit down the pleasure should at least stay the same. If not, it could actually increase. But this does not happen. So this shows that sitting down doesn’t create the pleasure of sitting down.

Because if there was if there was real pleasure of sitting down at the beginning when you sat down, it the and you kept creating what was the actual cause of the pleasure of sitting down, that can’t turn into the suffering of sitting down. It just can’t. You know, if I keep hitting my head, it won’t turn into the pleasure some pleasure in my head. Because hitting head with hard object is always a cause of pain. Alright.

So in fact, what happens when you sit down, there is there is the moment you sit down, there is the suffering of sitting down. But we don’t notice it because what we notice is the gross suffering of standing up. That we notice that ceases. And relative to the ceasing of obvious suffering of standing, the subtle suffering of sitting appears to be pleasant. It appears to be happiness.

We label it happiness. But after some time of sitting, our gross mind forgets the gross suffering of standing, and we are more and more aware of the suffering of sitting. But it was there from the very beginning. The pleasure of sitting didn’t turn into the suffering of sitting. The suffering of sitting was there from the very beginning.

There was no pleasure of sitting. There was just subtle suffering of sitting which became more and more obvious until it becomes the suffering of pain. So we stand up and bingo. We it looks like we’ve got the happiness of standing, but we haven’t. The moment you stand up, there is the suffering of standing.

But it looks like the happiness of standing because the gross the mind notices the stopping of the gross suffering of sitting. And compared to that, the subtle pain of standing looks like happiness. But as we continue to stand, we forget the the suffering of sitting, and we become more and more aware of the suffering of standing. So there was no happiness at all. It was just an illusion to an obscured mind.

This is our life. This is our Samsāra. It’s it’s a con. We’ve been sold a pup. And we chase after this illusion with craving and get angry and proud and jealous, create negative imprints and and which ripen as the obvious suffering of pain.

That’s Samsāra. And all the time, there is this amazing bliss in our mind that we’re obscuring. We’re obscuring it, obscure it, obscure it. Buddha says, stop obscuring it. Renounce all this rubbish.

Work on your mind more and more. It will always give good results. If you work on your mind properly, it will repay you properly. Guaranteed. Everything else remember, everything in Samsāra is uncertain.

People work their guts out to become rich. Doesn’t happen. Some people do nothing. Money falls from the sky onto them. And then it disappears again.

Nothing in Samsāra is certain. Practicing Dharma guaranteed. Now I’ll stop. Sorry, it’s a bit I’ve got five minutes over and we’ve got a few prayers to do so you can save up your questions for next week if you come next week. Maybe it gets better.

The topic gets really nice into bodhicitta from next week on. So we’ll just quickly do the dedication prayers. If you

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
Mount Meru
The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top