Mind Training — 2013-05-09

2 h 2 min · 12,298 words · 9 May 2013 · Buddha House Adelaide

Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Mind Training — 2013-05-09
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 122-minute teaching, Ven Thubten Dondrub guides students through the law of cause and effect, a foundational topic within the mind training (Lojong) practice. He begins with ritual preparation—mandala offering and refuge—then focuses on four essential aspects of karma: the certainty that causes produce corresponding effects; the multiplying nature of actions, where small causes generate vast results across lifetimes; the principle that experiencing results means one created the cause; and that karmic imprints never disappear until purified. Dondrub emphasizes how understanding these four factors should drive moral discipline in daily life, and introduces the four opponent powers for purifying negativity: regret, reliance on refuge and bodhicitta, remedy through virtuous action, and resolute determination. He stresses that the Gelug tradition prioritizes living ethically from the start rather than relying on purification alone, and connects this foundation to the Mahāyāna path of bodhicitta. The teaching concludes with reflection on saṃsāra—cyclic existence as a mind controlled by delusion and karma—and touches on the option of pure land rebirth. For serious practitioners studying the mind training tradition.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013 05 09 Mind Training.mp3

UUID: 5f879270-b864-43e9-9033-766d9476e439

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2013-05-09

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 122.6 minutes

Words: ~12,297

On page with our prayers. Page page five if people would like to join in. I prostrate to the gathering of dakinis and the three kayas who abide in the holy yoga of unbiased space, By your powers of clairvoyance and magic illumination, look after practitioners like a mother her child. By the teachings of the three supreme jewels possessing the power of truth, may inner and outer hindrances be transformed. May they be dispelled.

May they be pacified. May they be completely pacified. May all negative forces opposed to dharma be completely pacified. May the host of eighty thousand obstacles be pacified. May we be separated from problems and harmful conditions to dharma.

May all enjoyments be in accord with the dharma, and may there be auspiciousness and perfect happiness here right now. Obeisance to my guru and protector Mañjuśrī, who holds to his heart a scriptural text symbolic of his seeing all things as they are, whose understanding shines forth as the sun unclouded by defilements or traces of ignorance, who teaches in sixty ways with the patient love of a father for his only child, all creatures caught in the prison of Samsāra, confused in the darkness of their ignorance, overwhelmed by their suffering. You, whose dragon thunder proclamation of the dharma arouses us from the stupor of our delusions and frees us from the iron chains of our karma, whose powerful sword of wisdom hews down suffering wherever its sprouts appear, clearing away the darkness of all ignorance. I entreat you, O Mañjuśrī, whose princely body is adorned with the one hundred and twelve marks of the Buddha, who has completed the ten stages achieving the highest perfection of a bodhisattva, who has been pure from the beginning. O Mañjuśrī, O loving one, with the brilliance of your wisdom, illuminate the darkness enclosing my mind.

Enlighten my intelligence and wisdom so that I may gain insight into Buddha’s words and the text that explain them. So then we specifically make a heartfelt request to be able to receive the Buddha the teachings in our minds so that we can practice them properly, gain the unmistaken realizations. So we do this through the ritual of the the mandala offering, visualizing the Buddha in front of us or at least trying to visualize the entire field of refuge if you know how. If not, just thinking of the Buddha as the embodiment of all the Three Jewels of refuge and all their wonderful qualities and the embodiment of all one’s teachers of the past, present, and future. We think of the Buddha seated on the lion throne, lotus sun and moon with a golden body of golden light adorned with the saffron robes of a monk holding a deep blue begging bowl in his left hand.

And then we offer the mandala of the whole universe, especially everything beautiful in it, especially those things that we ourselves are attached to. So So we give up that attachment to free our mind to be able to understand the teachings. Offering making these offerings creates the merit to empower us to understand and practice and realize. So we try and do it as well as possible, trying to visualize, all the beautiful things as as much as possible. So thinking of the Buddha as appearing to remind us of our Buddha nature, to inspire us to realize it, we can then particularly focus on thinking of all sentient beings surrounding us, to encouraging us to to practice the Dharma by generating that wish to achieve enlightenment, by recognizing the immense kindness that we’ve received from every sentient being equal to the kindness that we’ve received from our parents of this life, our family members and friends of this life.

Everyone has given us this kindness over and over again in beginning this cyclic existence. And we depend on that kindness and particularly the kindness of the Mother which we have received from every sentient being. And yet all these beings are in cyclic existence and that means that they are subject to all the sufferings of cyclic existence and in fact the vast majority of these beings are trapped in those sufferings right now helplessly. So think that by thinking along these lines we can generate this thought that no matter what, I I must use this life, especially now that I’ve the precious human rebirth, I have to use this and all my future lives to free my mind of all confusion, awaken all good qualities, achieve the enlightened state. Because it’s only in that state that I can really effectively repay the kindness of all these beings, helping them to become free of cyclic existing existence, helping them to achieve peerless everlasting happiness.

So to do to accomplish all that I have to follow the path to enlightenment and that involves generating bodhicitta, maintaining that mind and developing it more and more. And so for this reason I will study this text, the Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun’ because it is exactly on that topic. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create by teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So then we can think that the Buddha is pleased with our motivation and shows this by now coming to the crown of our head and when directly above our crown, imagining that the Buddha then dissolves into blissful golden light so that that light then can pour down into us blessing our mind.

And then we enhance that positive state by doing the nine round breathing exercise just for a short time to establish a calmer, clearer, more concentrated mind so that we can use that mind to listen to and think about the Buddha’s teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you very much. So I think last week we were on page thirty five. Page thirty five.

Yes. Just keep going. Hold on. Yes. One’s committed.

I think we do we do that? Have we we have actually covered it. Have we? We’ve well, we finished them. Did we?

Yeah. Anyway just quickly to remind you in covering the topic of law of cause and effect this text only covers one point and only does it very briefly and that is about the four aspects of karma. Firstly that there is a certainty between or usually it’s said that karma is definite meaning that before there is an effect there has to be a cause and the nature of the cause determines the nature of the effect. So that is something definite it never ever ever ever ever changes in any way. That’s something quite fixed and definite.

There has to be a cause for something and the nature of the cause determines the nature of the effect. The second fact the second essential aspect of the law of cause and effect is that I mean these things are presented in slightly different orders in different texts. Here the second one mentions the multiplying nature of actions meaning that we engage in an action that takes a certain amount of energy and time to do that and that generates a karmic imprint and that karmic imprint when it ripens brings a result that can last far far far longer than the amount of time that it took to generate the result because the imprint can be generated in moments. But the result from that imprint can last many lifetimes. And not just human lifetimes but but many non human lifetimes which you know are vastly longer than any human life.

And the intensity of the result is also far greater where you know a little bit of anger when we you know we can engage in a negative action motivated by anger. So the anger that motivates us is a painful state of mind, but the painful result from that is just inconceivably greater in its intensity and of course lasts infinitely longer. So that’s something to bear in mind very much. So and of course this applies in the other way that the positive imprints, you know, we can engage in a positive action. It can only it can take a very short time to do it but the result can also last lifetimes.

And yeah, the positive state of mind which we engage in that action may, you know, have a certain intensity and and that state of mind is a positive state of mind. But the the result, the effect, brings a far greater intensity of positivity, can we say that, and happiness than the happy state of mind that generated that action. So that’s also something to remember to encourage us to do. So then the next two factors are think we did cover them to some extent last week. Third one is not having to face the consequence of actions you have not done.

So this is kind of the reverse of the first one for an effect there has to be a cause. So this is just emphasizing that if we are experiencing an effect we have created the cause. If we’re not experiencing an effect something you know good that we want or something unpleasant that we didn’t want and we can think you know how come this good thing I wanted hasn’t happened? How come this bad thing I hold it Didn’t want happened. No.

I’ve put too many things there together for my tiny mind to cope with. Anyway, let’s keep it simple. You know, we want something good and it hasn’t happened. Why hasn’t it happened? Because we didn’t create the cause.

If we don’t create we may have tried to do something to bring about some good result, but if it isn’t the actual cause, we don’t get the result. Alright. So, yeah, if we haven’t created the cause, we don’t get the result. If we are getting a result even if there’s something we didn’t want and didn’t plan and think and we feel, think, believe that we didn’t actually do anything to have this unpleasant result in fact it does mean we created the cause. Maybe not in this life but certainly in a past life.

And that follows into the next of the four factors which is: once committed actions do not fade away. So I’m not sure about the translations here. Maybe that is the correct translation to say actions fade away. But what what it really means is, like, I I mean, actions do fade away. If you kill someone, it does you know, you don’t kill someone forever.

You know, you kill someone for a short time. You know, it takes a short time, usually, I think. I haven’t done it in this life. To kill someone. But what it’s referring to is that there is a karmic imprint generated by that and that imprint doesn’t fade away.

It just doesn’t go away. It it will it will ripen sooner or later. Yeah. And similarly the positive imprints The action that generated them of course comes to an end. The effects of an action done in this life also come to an end in this life.

Right? You do something in this life and you know it plays out and some things have an effect for a very short time. Some things we do in this life can affect us for the rest of our life but then we die and that finished. But the karmic imprint, that doesn’t fade away until it ripens. Once it’s ripened and brought its result, then it fades away.

But what this means is the imprint itself once it’s generated, once it’s created in the mind, it stays there and if it’s not purified, if it’s a negative imprint, if we don’t purify it, if we don’t get around to purifying it properly then it will ripen. And and and with the positive imprints, unless we dedicate them we did talk about this, didn’t we? I never got went into any detail. Maybe a little bit of detail tonight. If we don’t dedicate those positive imprints, then they can be destroyed by our negative thoughts, particularly anger.

So every time we get really angry, our positive imprints can be destroyed. The the potency of them can be either completely annihilated or reduced a great deal so that when the imprint ripens it brings a far less positive result than it could have done. So that is why in the tradition we are encouraged to consciously dedicate all the good things we do. Firstly to have that conscious motivation of doing things and trying to make it the best motivation especially the bodhicitta motivation because that is the best motivation because that and doing something with the best motivation will make the strongest imprint and then having done the action we’re encouraged to dedicate that imprint for two reasons. One reason to protect it and the other reason is to make sure that by dedicating it the imprint ripens in a specific way, in a Dharma way.

Because if we don’t dedicate it to a specific cause, then it can just ripen in just any kind of worldly happiness. Which is, you know, if we’re trying to practice the Dharma, we don’t want all our good karma just to ripen as pleasure. Do we? No. No.

We don’t want that. No. So there is a story that when the Buddha at some point was talking to some of his monks about, you know, karma and yes. Well, there’s two points. One, they were getting very depressed seeing how very easy it is to engage in negative actions and therefore accumulate enormous piles of negative imprints and they were saying, well how is it possible to get anywhere in the spiritual path if it’s so easy to create negative karma then all this karma will constantly rife and we’ll be suffering and there’s no way to progress.

And so the Buddha said, but all negative imprints can be purified. So this is getting carried away from here because it doesn’t talk about this but it is good to mention it here. So the Buddha said that all negativities can be purified by applying the four opponent powers and they need to be applied as quickly as possible, as strongly as possible, sincerely as possible, and we need to apply all four of them to bring about purification. And we need to do it a lot. It’s not as though you can engage in a negative action and then just run home and sit down for a few minutes and apply the four opponent powers and that imprint is purified.

Unfortunately, it is nowhere near as easy as that. The Buddha said it is possible to purify but it takes a lot of time and effort. This is why Lama Tsongkhapa tradition is called the Gelugpa tradition the Gelug pa the virtuous tradition because Lama Tsongkhapa argued that it’s much wiser to avoid negative actions in the first place to live a moral life rather than to engage in negative actions and then having to purify them. So Lama Tsongkhapa emphasized a great deal how virtue is the very basis of the spiritual life. Whether one wants a good rebirth, whether one wants to get out of Samsāra, whether one wants to achieve enlightenment and especially if one wants to achieve enlightenment quickly through the Tantric path we have to base it on living a moral life, observing the law of cause and effect as carefully as we can.

So just very briefly, the four opponent powers are: the power of regret. So that that is the most important one to develop sincere regret for one’s negative actions, not feeling guilt because guilt is a it itself is not really a virtuous state of mind. It’s a type of ignorance and tends to lead us it sort of just drags our mind down. It doesn’t give us the energy to do virtuous things. Whereas regret is a type of wisdom in a sense because it recognizes this action is negative.

It will bring suffering. And because of that, it has within it already regret has some kind of energy that leads us away from doing negative things again. So that is a positive state of mind. So regret and guilt can sometimes look or we can think they’re similar, but in reality they are quite different states of mind. And so this is what we need to develop is regret.

That just that clear awareness that this action is negative and is going to bring me suffering. So then another of the opponent powers is the power of of reliance which has two aspects relying on two things. The basic reliance is on the triple gem, the Buddhadharma, regenerating one’s reliance on on the Triple Gem. In other words, yeah, generating regenerating, strengthening one’s refuge. Because if you check up that all negative actions are done either because we have no refuge in the triple gem, because at the heart of refuge is the Dharma, and at the heart of the Dharma is the law of cause and effect.

That is, you know, the in many ways, you know, the heart of the Buddha’s teachings is said to be emptiness. But that is a very, very advanced teaching and in order to realize and understand emptiness one has to understand the law of cause and effect. And all the teachings of the Buddha are connected to the law of cause and effect. So in a very important realistic way the teaching on the law of cause and effect is the heart of the Buddha’s teachings. It is the single most important one.

Because if we haven’t got that, we won’t get all the other bits properly. So that’s why we need to purify, we need to re establish our refuge because we engage in negative actions either because we don’t have any refuge in the law of cause and effect or we’ve kind of forgotten it or we’ve denied it. So we need to really regenerate that state of mind. And what is refuge? Sorry, I’ll just repeat all my stories again.

The objects of refuge are the Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha. But what does it mean to take refuge or have refuge or to go for refuge? What does that actually mean? You know, most many of you here, if not most or all of people here are Buddhist. You have refuge.

You say you’ve got it. But what does that mean? What does it mean? Well no. Well, that’s the objects.

What does take going for refuge mean? It well, I’m gonna tell you. Oh, no. Go on. Sorry.

No. No. Okay. Sorry. Well, my understanding of what what it is is that its refuge is understanding that and this comes from understanding the Buddhist teachings.

Through understanding and having faith in the Buddhist teachings, realize that our mind is the source of all our experience, that if we want less suffering, more happiness, we have to take care of our mind. So refuge is having that determination, that commitment to protect the mind and cultivate the mind and using the Buddha’s methods to do so because one’s come to the conclusion that the Buddha’s methods are complete, perfect, and especially they’re unbetrayable. They work. They’re complete perfect. Work completely, perfectly and they’re unbetrayable.

So one uses those methods to take care of the mind and refuge is that determination to take care of the mind seeing that if I don’t, I will suffer. I won’t have any happiness. So I think that’s what taking going for refuge is, taking refugees or doing refuge is. It’s taking care of the mind moment by moment using the Buddha’s methods as much as one knows those methods. And yeah.

Any disagreements on that Or additions? Okay. So right. So the other part of the power of reliance is bodhicitta, of trying to generate some degree of bodhicitta because again at the heart of bodhicitta there’s all sorts of definitions of what bodhicitta is and how to generate it but at daily practical level what bodhicitta involves is giving up self-cherishing in every way and cherishing others more than self. And again, if you check all negative actions of body, speech and mind of body, speech and mind are created when we’re under the control of the self-cherishing thought.

So by trying to generate bodhicitta, at least the effortful bodhicitta, this is the very opposite. So it helps purify the mind. So then the third opponent power is the power of remedy, means doing a virtuous action, a very strongly positive virtuous action to counteract the negative one. But that positive action needs to be done not just one time, two times, but a lot. That’s why in the Tibetan tradition in all the four schools we are encouraged to try to find the time in our life to do the Vajrasattva retreat which takes about three months where you involves reciting the Vajrasattva mantra a hundred thousand times because this is considered to be one of the most powerful purification practices.

And also one is encouraged we are encouraged not only to do that retreat in our life but at least one time but also to do the Vajrasattva practice every night because every day we engage in negative actions for some way or another and so we need to at least purify a little bit. In the teachings it says if you do the Vajrasattva practice in the evening, just doing the twenty one mantras, that helps to stop the expanding aspect of karma, which is the third factor we talked oh, no. What was it? The second factor. The karma is expandable.

The result is far bigger than the cause. So to stop that expanding effect it’s very good to do the Vajrasattva practice at night. So there are a number of very powerful virtuous practices to do. The Vajrasattva practice is one of the most important and also the practice of making prostrations to the thirty five Buddhas. So this again is a practice that is in the tradition is encouraged to do every day if we possibly can.

And also there is a retreat, one of the Ngondro retreats, the preliminary practices of doing a hundred thousand prostrations to the thirty five Buddhas. That also takes about three months to do if one doesn’t fall apart in the meantime with broken knees and things like that. The glorious founder of our tradition, Lama Tsongkhapa, went to a place called Volga in in Tibet, and he did three and a half million prostrations. He did a hundred thousand prostrations to each of the thirty five Buddhas on a rock, and he wore a groove in it. I think I’ve mentioned here before I went to this place, saw the rock.

It was broken in half during the Cultural Revolution. But yeah. So these are the practices. Of course, this is something His Holiness. If you see pictures of the daily life of His Holiness, movies that have been made, His Holiness does these prostrations every morning.

Not a hundred thousand but some. Yeah. Okay. So and the the fourth opponent power is the power of a resolution, which is making the determination to avoid that action as much as possible for as long as possible. So if we if if we apply those four opponent powers in our life to negative actions, then we can purify negative imprints.

But if we don’t do that at all, they don’t get purified. And as we did talk about last week, as Joe brought up the question, you know, we do negative action you know, in any day, we could say we do some negative actions and some positive actions, but those things don’t neutralize each other. Negative actions generate negative imprints. Bingo! And positive actions generate positive imprints and each ripens separately.

BUT when you apply the Four Opponent Powers that is the way to purify the Negative Imprints and part of that involves doing specific virtuous actions specifically directed to counteracting the Negative one. So in that case it’s a little different. Right? But it has to be also combined with the other opponent powers for it to have that purifying effect. How that exactly works, of course, no one can say except the Buddha.

Right? But this is what the Buddha has taught. So this is something that is very much encouraged in the Tibetan tradition to use this precious human rebirth to purify negative actions. Right. Yeah.

Purification. With the things in this life, yes. I mean, the more you direct it to specific things, but also I mean, were the there were the ten non virtuous actions, right, which are the general category of negative actions we engage in, although there can be many, many more. So when you purify, you purify you you think of purifying all the negative actions of body. So any so you can specify of killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, but you can also think in your mind, may I be able to purify any negative action I’ve ever done with my body?

Right? So once you know you’ve done in this life, it’s important to think about. But through the power of inference, we can know by logic that we must have in past lives engaged in every negative action of body possible. So you think, well, I’ve done that. So may I be able to purify all of those negative even though I can’t now remember them, but I must have done them.

So it it has that. It will work. That’s yes. Definitely. This is not something made up in the Tibetan tradition, by the way.

This is based on the Mahāyāna Sutras. And the practice of prostrate for example, the practice of prostrating to the thirty five Buddhas, that’s all explained in a particular Sūtra. Okay. So we’ll just, yeah, just carry on in the text. Just so I think although I think we well, maybe I read these last week, but we’ll just quickly go through them.

So the especially exalted praise says the Brahmin say that virtues and misdeeds can be given away and transferred but you teach you meaning the Buddha teach that actions done do not fade away and actions not done have no consequences. And the King of Meditative Stabilization Sūtra which is one of the very important Mahāyāna Sutras says, It is impossible not to encounter the results of your deeds, but you won’t feel the results of those done by others. I mean, this is also one of the reasons to to indicate how our mind streams are separate. Because a lot of people including some Buddhists like to think we’re all one mind and we just think we’re separate minds. But if if we were one mind, I could do a virtuous action and you’d get the karmic result.

Or you do a negative action and I’d get the suffering result. But it doesn’t work like that. Because we are separate mind streams, if I do a negative action, my mind gets the negative effect. Alright? If I do a positive action, my mind gets the effect.

If I do a negative action, I can have a negative affect on you, but not you don’t get the negative effect. The effect comes to the person who creates the cause. The affect can come to others. I can do some nice things or actually right now I’m trying to do a nice thing you know trying to teach the Dharma or talk about it. That’s supposed to be good karma so it should hopefully is having a good effect on you.

But the effect of teaching the Dharma, I will get. Me. Yes. Yes of course. Yes that’s what karma is all about.

Oh! No, if you have the conscious intention to do so yes yeah yeah Yeah. Right. No. Yes.

Yes. I suppose you could say that. Yeah. We have negative connections with people. I mean, that’s why we have enemies.

That’s why we have friends and enemies because we have a karmic connection with this person and we like them. And, you know, both people like each other because, you know, there’s some kind of good karmic connection. And then you can just look at another person and develop this incredible aversion. You don’t know anything about them, but, you know, you look at them and feel this intense aversion. And this is probably because there’s some kind of negative karmic connection from the past.

But what what for example, like what? Well, if you scream at someone, they’re going to get angry. So that that I mean, just the mere screaming of them is, you know, a negative action. Yes. Yes.

Yes. Because of that. Yeah, to some extent. Yeah, sure. Sure.

Yeah. But, you know, you can take take the example of of, you know, someone who is a monk in the West. So some people when they look at monks or nuns makes them happy. And other people, you know, get very unhappy and angry and all sorts of things. So the the monk or nun, by being a monk or nun walking around the streets, has no intention to make someone angry and upset and blah blah.

So that is definitely then that the per who gets angry and just by looking at a monk or nun or something, that is definitely their negative mind and their negative karma and so on. Because the person doing it, you know, you could say is generally, you know, in a note the object of the anger is in a you know, has no negative attitude and whatever. But when you get angry at someone, you’ve directed your anger at someone and they in turn get angry, you know, we can’t say you’ve actually caused them. We often use that expression, but if that if that was the case then, yeah, then things get very, very complicated and, you know, we would get angry and we we there wouldn’t be any negative karma involved because, oh, you caused me to, but you have become the condition for someone. Your behavior has become the condition for someone to become angry.

So in that case, I think there is some karma involved. Oh yes, of course. Any comments? Alright. That’s why the his holiness says if we can’t help sentient beings, at least don’t harm them.

So the best offering is a peaceful mind and and living according to the law of living a virtuous life, then you’re you’re in every way reducing, you know, you’re directly harming them by screaming and yelling or indirectly by, you know, acting as a condition for them to generate negative minds ets and therefore negative behavior. So then the transmission of discipline says even after hundreds of eons actions are not exhausted Meaning the imprint of the action that potency isn’t exhausted. If they meet with the assembled conditions then embodied beings will meet with their results. That’s an important thing to remember that even if we’ve created a negative action if the conditions don’t come together the negative imprint can’t ripen. Even if we’ve created a virtuous action, but the positive conditions don’t come together, that positive imprint won’t ripen.

That’s why if we you know, even if we have millions and billions of negative imprints in our mind, if we can if we practice the Dharma as much as possible, maintain a virtuous mindset, have the mind of refuge, and on the basis of refuge engage, know, live a good life, that that by keeping the mind in a positive state, that to a large extent prevents the neg you know, well, to some extent, unfortunately not completely, but it does help stop all the conditions coming together where negative whereby negative imprints ripen. No. It it it it reduces the imprint, the potency of the imprint. Oh, I should make this point again. Sorry.

This is getting longer than I meant. But also with purifying the mind. When you’ve I’ve explained this before, I think. I don’t know about to this group. If you take the example that say this is one karmic imprint.

This is a karmic seed and this liquid inside is the potency of the negative imprint. So that’s the you know, imagine it’s full up. So if this seed isn’t purified and one day it ripens, then all the liquid pours out, all the suffering comes out, producing all this suffering. But purifying negative imprints is like boiling the water inside. So if you purify completely, you boil away virtually all the water.

If you purify a little bit, half heartedly, then maybe you’ve still got half the water left so it will ripen half suffering of what it could be. But the thing to understand is that even the most potent powerful effective purification doesn’t eliminate a hundred percent. Some bit of the negativity ripens and purification forces the negative imprints to ripen in this life. If one is really lucky and does some powerful purification, it forces the negative imprints to ripen in this life in a small very, very small way. So that’s a good sign.

If you have some if you are doing some purification and you get some suffering, this is a good sign. Because it means the karma has ripened. What you know, what could have brought us into the lower realms can just ripen as a a toothache or something. Okay, quickly moving along. So remembering the certainty and multiplying nature of karma that an action not done will yield no result and that once done an action will not fade away, will obstruct all that gives rise to the path of black actions.

Yeah. So remembering these four things will help us it it will obstruct, yeah, the engaging in these negative actions. So we have to meditate on these things. We have to reflect on them over and over again, try and see the validity, the logic of it, or the psychology of it. And this will give us the wisdom energy to avoid negative actions.

So this is what Horton Namkha Bel is saying, and this is something that Lama Zopa Rinpoche often says that just just by reflecting on these four aspects of karma, by being mindful of them in our daily life, this will help us to hold back from engaging in negative actions. Because what is what is stopping you from doing negative actions? If it’s just kind of social, what, social disapproval or social embarrassment, that only stops very superficial kind of negative behavior. Yeah. And it’s not changing the mind in any way.

It’s not subduing the negative mind. It’s just a kind of sneaky getting along with things of avoiding obvious stuff because I’m not going to get away with it or people won’t like me or whatever. So what if we don’t see that these actions are negative and they’re going to bring all this tremendous suffering to myself, what is going to stop us? So many people in the Buddhadharma make the point, oh, why is it always presented from a negative thing and saying, you know, blah blah blah. Why can’t we just be motivated to do good things by love and compassion?

Love by love. But actually this is having compassion for oneself. I mean, this is a point I tried to make many times that practicing the law of cause and effect is the practice of love and compassion for oneself. And it starts to become for others as well. If we compassion is the mind not wanting suffering and its causes.

So if we have actual compassion for ourselves, we will stop engaging in negative actions. If we have compassion for others, we will stop engaging in negative actions because we are creating the causes for their suffering. So if we really had compassion for others, like we were just discussing, we would try and control our behavior. And the more suffering we see that comes from our behavior to ourselves and others, the more we will be motivated by motivated to avoid negative actions. This is what this is wisdom energy.

Lama Yeshe always used to talk about developing wisdom energy. Wisdom is seeing what is true. And that has incredible energy. I mean, he always used to say you have all this wisdom inside you. You just have to cultivate it.

You know, let it come out and act on because the more we act on our wisdom, we also liberate our wisdom more and more. So it’s just being wise to avoid negative action. It’s being wise and compassionate and loving. Because also if we do engage in virtuous actions, it will bring us happiness. And it will bring others happiness.

So it’s the practice of actual love for ourselves rather than self-cherishing. And it’s the basis for developing love for others. That’s why I say, you know, the law of cause and effect. All the Buddhist teachings are connected to it because it’s the basis of morality is the practice of loving kindness and compassion, and that leads to bodhicitta. To develop bodhicitta, we have to develop great love and great compassion.

And that starts with developing actual love and actual compassion for our self. Okey doke. So to be very mindful of these four things in our daily life, we have to meditate on them. We have to imprint our mind with the understanding of these things over and over again. Horton Namkha Bel says because basically these are notes that Horton Namkha Bel took listening to oral teachings of Lama Tsongkhapa when he explained the seven point mind training.

So really this is Lama Tsongkhapa talking to us, this book. You must earnestly engage in white wholesome actions and since training in the precious awakening mind so firstly, on the one hand we have to avoid the negative actions and we must earnestly engage in white wholesome actions. And since training in the precious awakening mind meaning bodhicitta is considered to be the principle and supreme virtue, all of them should be part of that training. In other words, all the wholesome actions we engage in and all the effort in avoiding negative actions should be all part of the training in bodhicitta. Because the initial the the most basic spiritual motivation from a Buddhist point of view is working to get a good rebirth.

The next highest is to achieve liberation. The highest motivation is to achieve enlightenment to benefit others. But in trying to follow within the Tibetan tradition though which teaches the Mahāyāna which a Mahāyāna tradition the Mahāyāna traditions encourage us to try to have the bodhicitta motive even though it’s the most advanced motivation. We are encouraged to try to do everything with that motivation from the beginning. So when we’re working to have a good rebirth, there are people who only want a good rebirth.

Right? They they don’t want to get out of Samsāra. They don’t want enlightenment. They just want a good rebirth. So but to have to have to achieve enlightenment, one has to get out of Samsāra.

To get out of Samsāra, one first has to have a series of good rebirths. So what we’re trying to do is have developed the wish to get out of Samsa to get a good rebirth, but not just for the sake of a good rebirth and not just to be part of the process of achieving liberation, but we want a good rebirth because we want to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. So everything we do, we should try and do it with that perspective that this is part of this huge project, this wonderful project of achieving enlightenment. Right? So there are many many other aspects to the Law of Cause and Effect about you know yeah So this is just one small part that has been emphasized to how helpful it is and necessary to understand these four basic factors and to and to use them in one’s life.

To base one’s life on that understanding. Any questions? Because I think we’ll take a break now because it’s almost break time and there’s a new topic. So before starting that. We should avoid are the ten non virtues.

Right? Avoid the the three of body, which is killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct. Then there are the four of speech, which is, lying, division of speech, harsh speech, and meaningless idle gossip. And there are the three negativities of mind, negative actions of mind, which is covetousness, ill will, and wrong views. So these are the in in trying to follow the Buddhist path, and in order to at least get a good rebirth, we have to base our behavior on those guidelines of avoiding those ten non virtues.

Because if we engage in any of those with all the the the factors present, then the imprints from those negative actions do not become the cause of a human rebirth, but a a very suffering lower rebirth. So the conscious avoiding the conscious avoiding of those actions, knowing them to be negative, is a virtuous action. Right? Killing is a naturally non virtuous action. Consciously avoiding it is a virtuous action.

The mere not killing of something isn’t a virtuous action. You know, if there’s an ant, you know, over there on the carpet, so the fact that I don’t kill it now is not a virtuous action. But if I was walking along and, you know, I was just about to put my foot down and I could see if I put my foot down, this little ant will get squashed. And I don’t put my foot down or I put it somewhere else. That is a virtuous action.

That is the virtuous action of non killing, and I did it because I say, this is an act of killing. This is negative. This being will suffer. I won’t do it. So that is a virtuous action.

And those actions, the avoiding of the ten non virtues, become the cause of a good rebirth. As a human being or in the God realms, the basic cause is engaging in virtue, avoiding the ten non virtues, doing the the so there are the ten basic virtues which are avoiding the ten non virtues. And then there are I don’t know what the term is in Buddhism even if there is one. But there there is the the virtue of avoiding non virtue. And then there is, like, the super virtue of of like, there’s the there’s killing.

There’s the the virtue of which is negative. There is the virtue of not killing, and then there is the super virtue of saving life. Right? And protecting it and nurturing it. And there’s the the negativity of stealing.

There’s the virtue of not stealing when one could steal, when one had the opportunity to steal. And then there’s the super virtue of sharing and giving. Right? And, like, there’s the virtue oh, the the the non virtue of lying. There’s the virtue of not lying, and then there’s the super virtue of saying something really truthful.

And there’s the virtue of harsh speech like insulting someone. Then there’s the the the virtue of not insulting them when, you know, like they insult you so you’ve got the opportunity to respond back. You think I’m stupid. What about you? What know, blah blah blah.

So there’s the the virtue of not insulting and then there’s the super virtue of saying something kind and and encouraging, praising. Alright? So this is what the basic practice is as a Buddhist, what we should be doing. You know, pure avoiding negativities, purifying things, the the the imprints from negativities, and engaging in the virtue of avoiding non virtue and doing super virtuous things. Of which some of these things like directly in terms of virtue, there are things that directly benefit sentient beings now, but there is the other super virtue which may not necessarily benefit sentient beings directly a lot in this life, but is super virtuous, which is just the practice of Dharma in general, like coming to teachings.

Being here isn’t directly benefiting apart from it directly benefits ourselves, but it doesn’t direct necessarily directly benefit anyone else in this life. Although if we practice it, you know, we will. And also meditating, studying texts and so on, doing retreat. These things don’t necessarily directly benefit people. But but because they are transforming our mind, there will be at some point great direct benefit to sentient beings.

So the practice of Dharma itself is super beneficial. Right? Or or I should say the formal practice of Dharma because not killing people is Dharma practice also. Being nice to people is Dharma practice. But you could be meditating on developing loving kindness towards sentient beings in retreat for, you know, thirty five years where you never see any other people.

But that is super virtuous practice. Am I making any sense? Yeah? Good. Okay.

Tea break. Thank you. Okay, so the topics we’ve covered of the precious human rebirth, death and the law of cause and effect. These preliminary meditations and practices that are particularly about turning the mind away from being obsessed with this life so that one can engage in Dharma, create the causes for a good rebirth. So the next of the preliminaries, the last of the four preliminaries that are talked about here, there are many more of course, but these are the four that are just singled out as being really vital ones to reflect on as preliminaries to working on bodhicitta is thinking about the the draw the drawbacks the drawbacks of cyclic existence.

And the more we see the drawbacks of cyclic existence, meaning the suffering of cyclic existence, the more we will renounce it and and seek liberation from cyclic existence. Yeah. Developing the determination to get out of cyclic existence. Because we have to get out in order to achieve enlightenment, we first have to get out of cyclic existence. Because while we’re in it, can’t really help others completely.

We can be of some benefit, but not complete benefit. While we are suffering, you know, we won’t be able to completely eliminate the suffering of others. So we have to get out of cyclic existence and that comes from having the wish to and that comes from seeing how cyclic existence is in the nature of suffering. Which is the first noble truth, the very first thing that the Buddha taught which is that ordinary existence is in its very nature suffering. So what is meant by ordinary existence?

It’s referring to cyclic existence or Samsāra. So what is Samsāra? This is a term that is used a lot in the Buddhadharma. Samsāra, nirvana, Dharma, karma. Half the time most people have no idea what these terms actually mean.

So what is Samsāra? Samsāra is not a place. It is not this world. Samsāra refers to the actual meaning of Samsāra is according to Lama Tsongkhapa’s definition, Samsāra is the mind, our mind, one’s own mind under the control of delusion and karma. That is what Samsāra is.

What would yeah. That’s what we’re trying to become free of. Free our mind of being controlled by delusion and karma. Because while the mind is controlled by delusion and karma, we will suffer and engage in negative actions, and these ripen at the end time of death and cause us to take rebirth and another suffering rebirth, another rebirth. Even in the happy realms such as the one we’re in now although there’s pleasant experiences we still suffer as a human being.

We suffer because of our body, we suffer because of our mind. And in the in the in the higher realms of the gods, the different kinds of god realms and demigod realms, there’s far more bliss, happiness than in human beings. The suffer the suffering is very very subtle but even in those realms of cyclic existence the mind is still ultimately even still controlled by delusion and karma in the the the in the very refined levels of the God realms, the the delusions aren’t active anymore, but they still exist and the ignorance still exist. Negative karma doesn’t ripen so much, but the cut the negative karmic imprints are still there waiting to ripen because remember, they don’t go away. Even in the god realms, they’re there.

So all of all of that existence is in its nature suffering. So Samsāra specifically refers to one’s own mind controlled by delusion and karma. But because the mind is controlled by delusion and karma, it creates the cause to be reborn in all these unsatisfactory states of as a as a human being, as an animal, a hungry ghost in the hell realms, in the demigod realms, as a desire realm god, a form realm god and a formless realm god. These are all the different kinds of limited experiences that the Samsaric mind gives rise to. These are the potentials of the Samsaric mind.

Alright. So that Samsāra yeah. So Samsāra includes that idea of not just the mind right now being controlled by delusion karma, but because of that, the mind cycles into in through these different kinds of rebirths. We go up into the god realms, down into the hell realms, up into the human realm, round and around, but we don’t go beyond it. We just don’t go beyond it.

What will take us beyond it is eliminating the causes. And just being a good person doesn’t create the cause to get out of Samsāra. Being what we think of as a good person, being kind, compassionate, generous, blah blah blah, all these things. They won’t actually none of those things will actually cause us to get out of Samsāra. None of them.

Because they are the direct sorry. Because Samsāra has causes. The causes of our being having a mind controlled by delusion and karma is delusion and karma. So we have to to stop creating negative karma which ripens the suffering we have to stop our delusions. We have to eliminate them.

And the only thing that eliminates our delusions is developing well, our delusions exist because of ignorance. And the only thing that is gonna eliminate ignorance is developing wisdom. The wisdom that sees things as they are. Because the nature ignorance is that it experiences things, to put it very simply, in a way which they are not. We experience it ourselves, ignorance experiences me in a way that I am not.

It creates an illusion about me which we think is me. Ignorance creates an illusion about things, about the world, which is not there but which ignorance believes is the truth. And it’s only because of that ignorance that we have disturbing thoughts. Ignorance creates the illusion that things are out there under their own power, under their own control, from their own side, with their own qualities. So we see this object as truly beautiful from its own side independently of me, separate, not really depending on me.

It is really beautiful. And because we have that belief, it’s more than a belief. I don’t think we’ve got a word to cover what it is. We and only because of that ignorant perception conception do we have craving desire. And then, you know, there is something else which we see, person, object, place, situation, we you know, ignorant the the mind obscured by ignorance sees that thing, experiences it as really bad and ugly and horrible from its own side under its own power.

Not really anything to do with me. It’s really like that. And because we experience it like that and only because we have that experience do we have aversion and anger and hatred and fear, etcetera, etcetera. And then because of those two basic delusions, we have a whole network of others, of pride and jealousy and fear and anxiety and doubt and depression and everything else. And then we act on them.

So those disturbing thoughts are suffering and we act on them, create negative imprints, and since the effect has to be the same as the cause, when the imprints ripen, it ripens as more suffering. So that’s Samsāra. cyclic existence. So well, the twelve links specifically explain how we take rebirth in a a you know, again and again in cyclic existence. Yeah.

But cyclic existence is referring to it’s not well, the point I’m trying to make is when we think what we tend to do is when we think about Samsāra and cyclic existence, we think about the whole shebang out there. But what it’s and that’s true to one extent. But what it’s really referring to, cyclic existence is referring to me, my cycle, you know, cyclic existence. There’s many cyclic existence. I’ve got one, you’ve got one, you’ve got one, we’ve all got one.

And because of that you could talk about cyclic existence that includes all the individual cyclic existence. But when when we’re talking about trying to get out of, you know, cyclic existence, etcetera, etcetera. And when we talk about what is the nature of cyclic existence, we should really understand it’s talking about us as a deluded being. Alright. Yeah.

And so what we need to understand is our cyclic existence not only has suffering, but it is. The whole nature of cyclic existence is suffering. Like, the nature of fire is that it is hot and burning. There’s nothing else to fire other than hot and burning. There aren’t cool spots or or or anything else.

All of fire is in the nature of hot and burning. What the Buddha taught, teaches, is that our Samsāra is in the nature of suffering. It’s all suffering. There’s a funny oh, maybe you don’t think it’s funny. But in the lamrim, there’s a story about what what what does it go like?

There was this very, very poor family where this mother had many kids, and she was extremely poor. So the only food she could get for her children was turnips. And so she would try and cook them in different ways for the kids. She would cut them in different ways and she would boil them and mash them and roast them and I don’t know what whatever. But she would try to cook them in different ways.

And one day just one of the little kids say, you know, I just I just don’t want this. It’s it’s all turnips. It’s all turnips. And, you know, the lama says, that is cyclic existence. It’s all turnips.

Every even the happiness we get is just turnips. The llamas tell the story much better than that, but that’s the essence. It’s just all turn it’s just you know, our happiness is just suffering cut up in a different way. It’s just a little bit maybe a bit more salt to make it tasty. Look make it look tasty, but that’s it.

More details to come. Right. And also one thing we should try to understand about our cyclic existence is that until we meet the Dharma we don’t know we have ignorance. In fact many people would be deeply offended to say you have ignorance. Excuse me, I’m very intelligent, I’m very educated, I’m very blah blah blah.

I am not ignorant. But actually even the most intelligent educated person in this world has ignorance. This mental factor obscuring the mind. And so until we meet the Dharma we don’t know this and even when we meet the Dharma we may sort of know the words but we don’t really know, we haven’t identified our ignorance and what it does. We may have some vague rough idea.

But and so ignorance just breeds more ignorance. Mean how can I explain? We live in ignorance of being ignorant. And so we you know, I mean, ignorance has many meanings and the the the Sanskrit word that’s translated as ignorance is avidyā. So that that is referring to a particular mental factor that not only does too many negatives here when we use the word ignorance it often implies not knowing something.

Yeah? And particularly not knowing something that we should know. You know, oh, you’re really ignorant. You don’t know that. How, you know, how can you be that ignorant?

You know, you should know this. But avidyā, dharma ignorance, doesn’t mean just not knowing something. What ignorance does is it it it it not only fails to know things as they are, it actually creates a false appearance of things. It not only fails to experience the truth, it distorts the truth and creates an illusion which it itself believes is the truth. So the so that is the real problem, that ignorance.

But also there is ignorance in the sense of just not knowing things. So we don’t know that we have avidyā. We don’t know that we have this this innate ignorance which is the source of our suffering. And because we don’t know it, our ignorance continues and we we create the causes to perpetuate ignorance because because of ignorance, we have the the delusions arise, and we follow our delusions. And every time we follow our delusions, we are subtly reinforcing our ignorance.

Because just in a very simple way, the root ignorance creates the illusions that things are out there somehow not really connected to me, existing from their own side under their own power with their own characteristics. And because of that, then the delusions add another confusion by saying, this is really beautiful and this is really ugly. And we would only believe that because of the basic ignorance which is saying it’s like that. It exists separately, in dependence upon its own side. But so every time we we follow attachment, we are reinforcing the belief that this really inherently exists from its own side.

And every time we follow anger and pride and jealousy, we do the same thing. And we engage in negative actions, generate negative imprints. These obscure our mind which make it difficult to even question our reality, let alone, you know, actively try to understand things. So our ignorance just in a sense is self perpetuating because we don’t know that we’re ignorant. So that this is the amazing thing that by meeting the Dharma we once we meet the dharma and have some faith in it, we we we are in a position to start to undermine that entire process.

There is a Sūtra, which says something like, if you question if you doubt reality for one moment, everything starts to fall apart. It says it much better than that, but that’s the basic idea. If you if you develop a genuine doubt about yourself, reality of how it exists, even for one moment, everything starts to fall down. The whole illusion starts to crumble. But we don’t.

We look at things, we look at things, we hear things, smell, taste things, think things, and we grasp immediately that the way they appear to our consciousnesses, that is how they exist. We don’t question it. It’s always this is it. You know? I am like this.

You’re like that. It’s like this. This is good. This is bad. Totally.

We don’t question at all. And so Samsāra goes on. It’s like a it’s like a self perpetuating thing. But as soon as we meet the teachings, develop some faith, and we develop start to develop our understanding, then we can begin to destroy Samsāra. Because if if we counteract it, if we counteract our ignorance and our delusions, we can eliminate them.

But if we don’t, they they just they they have an energy that just keeps going and going. So I’m not going to get to this topic. Introduction. Yeah. So why you know, the the the immediate cause of all our suffering is the ripening of our negative imprints.

All all our suffering we’re experiencing, whatever suffering you’re experiencing right now right now is because some karmic imprint is ripening. Whatever suffering you’ve experienced today, this week, this month, this year, this life, is because some kind of negative karmic imprint is ripening. Why do those imprints exist in our consciousness? Because we created the cause for them. How?

By following our disturbing thoughts. Right? Mhmm. Oh yeah, you could. Yes, that’s good.

Getting upset. Yes, it’s very good. Yes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But the suffering itself is the result of something negative.

Yes, so looking at it in a positive way can be a creates positive imprints. Yeah. Yeah. Mhmm. Mhmm.

Right. So we suffer because of negative imprints. The negative imprints there because we follow the disturbing thoughts. So, you know, and we we have the disturbing thoughts because of ignorance. So to get rid of ignorance, we have to first subdue our disturbing thoughts and realize that the disturbing thoughts themselves are in the nature of suffering and following them only can only because of karma, the way karma works, cause and effect, then the effect of following negative disturbing thoughts can only be suffering.

So the more we realize how having a mind controlled by delusion and karma is suffering, we will be motivated to get rid of negative karma and delusions in our mind and to and we will understand the only way I can do that is to destroy ignorance, so I will. But to get that that determination to destroy ignorance, we have to recognize our own suffering, that we are actually suffering. And that even our happiness isn’t the happiness that we really want. Because the happiness that we experience in Samsāra is illusory. And it’s impermanent.

It doesn’t last. Not what we really deep down what we want is perfect happiness that goes on forever. And nothing samsaric samsaric mind cannot produce that experience because it’s obscured. As I think I’ve already said I’ve said it to the DB group a few times, possibly to this group already a hundred times. I’ll just repeat it one more time.

One of the first things I heard, Lama Yeshe, I actually heard him say listened. It really went in in nineteen seventy six is something along the lines of how can you think, possibly believe that you can be happy when you have a mind controlled by delusion and craving and attachment and anger? No matter how much money you’ve got, you know, power, good health, friends, family, how how can we possibly be really happy when we have craving and anger? And I thought, he’s right. Can’t.

Because those disturbing thoughts always get in the way. They always eat away whatever happiness we have. Because no matter what happiness one has with craving, craving is never satisfied. It always wants some something tweaked somehow. And then you see someone with a better one, you know, so there’s jealousy and so on.

So and with attachment, there’s anger to protect it and so on. There’s no way to be happy when the mind is like that. That isn’t happiness. That. One of the four seals of the Buddha Dharma is that nirvana is peace.

Right? nirvana that’s nirvana. That’s peace. When the mind isn’t disturbed in any way. In other words, when nirvana is when all karma and all delusion, all ignorance is completely eliminated from the mind.

So that it never comes back. So that is peace, nothing else. Meaning that is happiness. That is what we are all seeking, whether we know it or not. Nothing else is peace.

Only nirvana. Everything else is an illusion. It’s a trick. So we have to reflect on how cyclic existence, our cyclic existence just produces various kinds of suffering over and over and over and over again. Within a within a life that while we remain in Samsāra, we will we will experience sooner or later every kind of suffering.

Because we can, you know, we are in Samsāra now and we can make the mistake of hearing, you know, when we hear this expression that Samsāra is terrible. We have to get rid of it. We have to get out of it. And then you think, well, I’m in Samsāra, and my Samsāra is quite nice. I’ve got a home and a family and a nice job.

And, you know, I’m going on holidays, you know, at the end of the year and blah blah blah. Samsāra is not so bad. Well, the point is this Samsāra isn’t so bad. But this isn’t the totality of Samsāra. This is the the best bit of Samsāra.

This is the the penthouse suite in the Hotel California. Yeah. But there’s a whole lot more to our Samsāra than this. So when our next Samsāra can be much worse than this one and then the one after that can be also terrible and the one after that. And one may be really better than this one, but the one after that can be a total disaster.

And it’s in you know, it’s Samsāra is beginningless and as a you know, if we don’t do anything about it, it can be endless. So that means there is time to experience everything horrible, not just one time, but billions of times. That’s what we have to reflect on, and that’s what we’re going to do next week. But you probably won’t come because now you’re forewarned that it’s all gonna be horrible. Yes.

But it’s great because it’s very liberating to understand this. It’s very liberating. It is the way to achieve liberation, and just knowing it a bit is liberating in many, many ways. So great subject suffering. But we’ll we’ll go into it next week.

Oh, you’re sure? Okay. Yes. About taking birth in a pure land. No.

Actually it isn’t mentioned that much but yeah. Yeah. We have as a dharma practitioner, we have two main choices of what kind of rebirth we should aim for. So one is to try and get another precious human rebirth. A human rebirth where we meet the Dharma, have faith in it, the opportunity, you know, the freedom to practice.

But the other kind of rebirth is to to be reborn in a pure land. So, yeah, this is probably a very good option to be reborn in a pure land because, like, coming back to this planet is maybe not such a good idea because this planet is getting worse by the day in many ways. Sorry? To a pure land. Or just briefly, what is a pure land?

Right. So we are we are this earth is an impure land. Right? Because it is the product of the samsaric minds of all sentient beings. Right?

Whereas a pure land is the product of the mind of a Buddha. Every being, when they achieve enlightenment, they generate around them somehow, please don’t ask me to explain this, a pure land due to the merit they’ve accumulated. They create with their mind a pure land where everything is the manifestation of the mind of that Buddha. And so yeah. So yeah.

In this pure in this impure land, there are good things and bad things, but even the good things are by because they’re they’re they are produced by delusion and karma, they’re contaminated phenomena that even the good things can act to set off our delusions. So this is a good thing. It’s pretty. But we can crave it, desire it, get attached to it. Our delusions can be activated by and, of course, then, you know, I I can get angry if someone touches my beautiful object, you know, takes it away, and so on.

And I can get jealous because someone’s got a better pot of flowers than me. I can get proud because my pot of flowers is better than everybody else’s pot of flowers. So even the good things set off our can’t not necessarily set off delusions. But everything because it’s contaminated phenomena, but everything in a pure land is the manifestation of the pure mind of a Buddha. So one gets one can get reborn there as a samsaric being with a complete kit of delusions and karma, but none of it will be activated because there’s nothing there to act the conditions aren’t there to activate it.

So everything you see is beautiful and perfect, but it doesn’t make you attached and jealous or proud or craving because it’s pure. It’s perfect. And every yeah. And it’s all set up by the Buddha to activate one’s one’s virtuous minds. And the Buddhas appear there and teach the Dharma.

Yes. Everyone. Yes. Yes. Yes.

You once you’re in there, you’re in there more or less. I think there were some kind of subclauses, but generally speaking, yes. The only the only, one of the reasons why the Pure Lands aren’t encouraged is that in a Pure Land, because there’s no obvious suffering, it takes much much much much longer to get enlightened there. But you you don’t experience any suffering there, and you don’t fall out of it, and you do progress, but it takes a long time because you don’t have the example of actual suffering sentient beings around you to be able to generate deep compassion. And so it takes much much longer because it has to be indirect.

Whereas where if as if you take rebirth as a human being with a precious human rebirth, you meet the dharma, etcetera, etcetera. There are problems because you’re, you know, know, you’re you’re negative. You there’s many things to set off your positive instincts, but there are things to set off one’s negative instincts as well. But one of the benefits is you’ve sorry. This doesn’t sound very good.

But you’ve got sentient beings around you, suffering sentient beings to practice with, to be generous to, loving, compassionate, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. And also as a human being, can practice Tantra and achieve enlightenment very quickly. You can’t practice Tantra in the pure lands, the or the ordinary pure lands. Sorry? No.

No. Because they don’t believe in pure lands. No. They don’t no. No.

This is a Mahāyāna this is a terrible Mahāyāna concept. Now because see, there there are some very oh, let’s not get on to this. Significant differences is between the Theravāda view and Mahāyāna view about the nature of Buddha nirvana and Buddhahood. Yeah. Because generally speaking, there may be some differences now because I think some Theravāda teachers have been influenced by Mahāyāna spreading around the world.

But strictly speaking, the the Theravāda view is that both not both arhats and Buddha’s when they achieve their state like when Buddha became Buddha, he, you know, he was a human being, became Buddha, you know, lived and died when he was eighty something, and then that’s it. Finished. His mind is gone. His mind doesn’t exist. So there can’t be pure lands because there aren’t Buddhas to create them.

So there’s no, you know, Buddhas floating around. No enlightened minds in according to the Theravāda. Because that’s gone, you’ve gone. This is completely different in the Mahāyāna because, you know, the mind goes on forever, which I think is much more logical sense. And be because, you know, the Buddha in the sutras, in the Pāli sutras, they talk about how the mind goes on propelled by karma.

But actually from a Mahāyāna point of view, that’s talking about the gross mind, of course. That that ceases. But there is the very very subtle mind. So that that always exists. And and that very subtle mind transforms into the enlightened mind.

So you have the enlightened mind always existing and always benefiting beings and creating pure lands. But the Theravāda view is that, you know, as a human being, you can become enlightened. Your mind become can become enlightened. But when you die, the that enlightened mind ceases. Just as like in our heart, as a human being, they have a mind free of delusion and ignorance.

But when they die, finished. nirvana’s finished. Nothing. So that’s very attractive for some people. I don’t find it attractive.

That’s why the Buddha taught these things because it fits the minds of some people. For other people it doesn’t. Yes. Because rebirth is karma. Yeah.

Well, Buddhas don’t get reborn. They manifest. Rebirth is a is a samsaric happenstance. Bodhisattvas who’ve got out of saṃsāra which is only the very highest eighth ninth tenth level bodhisattvas They we say they are reborn, but they they that’s through the power of compassion, not karma. That’s that’s a different thing completely from what we have to undergo.

Anyway, we’ve gone over time, and we’ve got all our prayers to do. Anyway, that was a little bit about Pure Lands. Yeah?

Key terms in this teaching

four aspects of karma
The four ways karma will ripen, either in this life or a future life. They are: the ripening result, the possessed result, experiencing the result similar to the cause and creating the result similar to the cause. LYWA
four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top