1 h 48 min · 12,677 words · 23 May 2013 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Ven Thubten Dondrub offers a 108-minute teaching on mind training and the cultivation of bodhicitta, the awakening mind determined to achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings. He opens by noting this session falls during Saka Dawa, the holiest month in the Buddhist calendar, and emphasizes the extraordinary opportunity presented by a precious human rebirth to practice the Mahāyāna path. The core teaching walks through the preliminaries—renouncing attachment to worldly life and recognizing the pervasive suffering of cyclic existence—as necessary groundwork before authentic bodhicitta can arise. Dondrub then explains the two forms of bodhicitta: conventional bodhicitta, the sincere motivation to achieve enlightenment, and ultimate bodhicitta, the wisdom realizing emptiness. He clarifies why bodhicitta is essential to both the sūtra path of the six perfections and the tantric path, and distinguishes the Mahāyāna pursuit of universal enlightenment from the Theravāda path of individual liberation. Throughout, he stresses that bodhicitta is not a vague wish but an authentic determination that transforms the mind and protects against negativity, illustrated through analogies of seeds, diamonds, and armor. The teaching concludes with questions on nirvana and the integration of inner practice with outer benefit.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013 05 23 Mind Training.mp3
UUID: 27a861e6-2dbf-4812-b7ea-d359b55d9bba
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Mind Training (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2013-05-23
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 108.4 minutes
Words: ~12,674
Welcome to our Thursday night class on the mind training like the rays of the sun. So before we start, I’d just like to remind everyone it’s a bit late for a reminder, but we’re right in the middle of Sakadawa, the holiest month of the Buddhist year. This is the month, this is the fourth lunar month and on the full moon of this month this is when three different times the first time the Buddha manifested being born, the second time on this fourth lunar month during the full moon he manifested achieving enlightenment, and then he also manifested passing into parinirvāṇa. So the full moon is on Saturday. So this is the super holiest day of the whole year.
So I’d really encourage people to so it’s believed that everything we do positive and negative especially on this day is very the karmic influences far far greater than at any time so it’s a time to really put effort into practicing the Dharma avoiding negativities especially trying to do good stuff during this month, especially that day. And so here at the center we’re going to take precepts at six o’clock in the morning, the eight Mahāyāna precepts then setting after that. People can come along and help set up water bowls, make water bowl offerings, offerings in general, light offerings. In the afternoon at two o’clock we’re going to recite the Golden Light Sūtra and in the evening we’re going to be doing a light offering and Śākyamūni Buddha Puja. So you’re welcome to take part in all of these things or some of them or one of them or none of them if you wish, but at least please remember this is a very special day so if you can’t make it to the center then try and do some good stuff at home.
Yes, I think that’s it. So if there are some people planning to come and take the eight Mahāyāna precepts and especially if they’re going to do it for the first time, I can’t spend time now explaining the precepts and I won’t have time to explain them that morning. But you could borrow from the center. I can give you the book if you’re interested. The eight Mahāyāna precepts so you can read what they are.
So it’s important to know them. Yeah. What what’s involved. Okay. Okay.
Alright. Alright. Yeah. So we this is our traditional night where we try and do all the traditional things as much as possible. We start with prayer of the lion-faced dakini to eliminate obstacles.
This is on page five of the little prayer book. I prostrate to the gathering of dakinis in the three chakras who abide in the holy yoga of unceasing space. By your powers of clairvoyance and magical emanation, look after practitioners like a mother, her child. Akasamaraja Dharasamara Ipe Tayatha Gate Gate. By the teachings of the three supreme jewels possessing the power of truth, may inner and outer hindrances be transformed.
May they be dispelled. May they be pacified. May they be completely pacified. May all negative forces opposed to dharma be completely pacified. May the host of eighty thousand obstacles be pacified.
May we be separated from problems and harmful conditions to dharma. May all enjoyments be in accord with the dharma and may there be auspiciousness and perfect happiness here right now. Obeisance to my Guru and protector Mañjuśrī who holds to his heart a scriptural text symbolic of his seeing all things as they are, whose understanding shines forth as the sun unclouded by defilements or traces of ignorance, who teaches in sixty ways with the patient love of a father for his only child, all creatures caught in the prison of Samsāra, confused in the darkness of their ignorance, overwhelmed by their suffering. You whose vajra thunder proclamation of the dharma arouses us from the stupor of our delusions and frees us from the iron chains of our karma, whose powerful sword of wisdom hews down suffering wherever sprouts appear, clearing away the darkness of all ignorance. I entreat you, O Mañjuśrī, whose princely body is adorned with the one hundred and twelve marks of a Buddha, who has completed the ten stages achieving the highest perfection of a bodhisattva, who has been pure from the beginning.
O Mañjuśrī, O loving one, with the brilliance of your wisdom, illuminate the darkness enclosing my mind. Enlighten my intelligence and wisdom so that I may gain insight into Buddha’s words and the texts that explain them. So then we offer the mandala as a way to request the teachings and as a way by thinking of offering the whole universe, especially everything beautiful in it, especially those things we’re most attached to. This is a way to eliminate or reduce our attachments, and it’s a way to accumulate merit which is the basis for being able to understand the teachings correctly, put them into practice properly and gain the authentic transformative realizations. So we visualize Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as the very embodiment of the Three Jewels of refuge and all their perfect qualities.
Sort of thinking of the Buddha also as the embodiment of all our teachers of the past, present and future, thinking that the Buddha appears in front of us to remind us of our Buddha nature and to inspire us to realize it, to awaken it. So now it’s important that, as we still think of the Buddha in front of us, that we try and generate a strong, sincere motivation, trying to make our motivation the best one we possibly can. And the best motivation we can have for studying the Dharma, and particularly this text is bodhicitta. The wish to, the determination to achieve enlightenment so that one is in the position to be able to repay the kindness of all sentient beings by helping them to become free of all causes of suffering, helping them to achieve their own enlightenment and the state of peerless everlasting happiness. And that determination to achieve enlightenment arises from and wishing to benefit sentient beings comes from realizing how much benefit we have received from sentient beings.
And not just in this life, but in every life we totally depend directly and indirectly on all sentient beings. So while we remain in cyclic existence, we will depend on and actually we will receive so much kindness from sentient beings to get out of cyclic existence. We can only do it depending on sentient beings. And to achieve enlightenment, we can only do it depending on sentient beings. So we are immensely indebted to all sentient beings.
And yet, sadly, these kind beings are suffering. So we need to so the more we realize that, we can generate this wish to help them become free of suffering, help them to experience real happiness. And especially when we realize that sentient beings, the vast majority of all living beings, are experiencing far more suffering than ourselves right now with far less ability to make sense of their suffering, reduce it, transform it or eliminate it. And in their confusion trying to be free of suffering, trying to experience happiness, in reality most beings most of the time are in fact creating the cause to prolong their own cyclic existence, to prolong their suffering. So thinking like this we can generate that wish to achieve enlightenment.
And to make that wish stronger, more sincere, more realistic, we try and think of all these kind beings surrounding us, at least those that we’re strongly connected to in this life. So we think of our mother on our left, father on our right, family, friends and helpers behind us, harmers in front, trying to have a sense that they also are very kind to me. They may be harming me in this life, but in past lives, in future lives, they will be immensely beneficial. So they deserve my compassion as well. And then as much as possible we try and open our hearts and minds to an awareness and concern for all the beings of cyclic existence.
At least trying to think of the human beings of this world. So to achieve enlightenment, that means following the path to enlightenment, but that involves entering the path to enlightenment and that comes from generating bodhicitta and maintaining that state of mind and all the practices that go with it. And that also involves being able to deal with every kind of difficulty along the spiritual path. So this text is all about all those things. So we can think that for the sake of all sentient beings, I will study this text.
I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create by studying the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So now we can imagine the Buddha being very pleased with our motivation, showing this by now coming to the crown of our heads, and when directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha then happily dissolving into blissful golden light so that that light can then pour down into us, blessing our mind. And then just for a short time, we can do some breathing meditation, such as the nine round breathing exercise to help strengthen, create, generate a more calmer, clearer, more focused mind so that we can use that mind to concentrate on listening to and thinking about the Buddha’s teachings tonight. Okay.
Thank you. So our topic is generating and practicing bodhicitta and but as the original text that this commentary is based on the seven point mind training says, firstly, we have to train the mind in the preliminaries. So these are preparing the mind to be able to actually generate authentic bodhicitta. So the preliminaries are generating the mind renouncing this life renouncing our attachment to the ordinary things of this world giving them a value and an importance that they simply don’t in reality possess. So the way to do that is particularly by recognizing our precious human rebirth that we have the optimum chance to practice the Dharma, recognizing that everything that is wasting our time through attachment and aversion is impermanent and we ourselves are going to die, could die at any moment and only the Dharma is going to help us when we die.
Not some abstract dharma floating outside but our own dharma experience. Only that is really going to help at the time of death. And also to understand more and more the law of cause and effect that everything we do has effects far beyond this life. So the more we reflect on these things and integrate them into our life then we will develop this mind renouncing attachment to this life and directing our energy more and more to making sure that we create the causes for a good rebirth. And the second preliminary is then a much more major step comes from realizing that even if I get a good rebirth in Samsāra over and over again I’m still going to be involved in suffering.
I’m not going to escape suffering even having a good human rebirth and so on. So by thinking about the suffering of our own cyclic existence, the suffering that is intrinsic to having a mind controlled by delusion and karma, which we all do have. So the more we realize that while we allow our mind to remain controlled by delusion and karma we will continue to experience suffering. And even the happiness we experience is really just illusory, impermanent. It’s not what we really want.
So when we realize that, we will develop the mind renouncing cyclic existence, being determined to become free of cyclic existence. So when we’ve developed those preliminaries, which are kind of major strategies, major work projects that could take actually lifetimes to accomplish. It’s only then that we have the basis to be able to actually generate bodhicitta. So one could think, well if it’s going to take so long, why bother? So you have to eradicate that thought from your mind instantly because even if it does take a long, long time it is the most wonderful thing to do.
It’s the most beneficial thing to do for oneself and others. And the process of directing the mind in this way gives the greatest happiness and satisfaction anyway. Everything anything less brings something far, far less. And in a sense thinking it’s going to take a long time is a completely false way of thinking because we’re never going to cease existing anyway. We will always be existing.
And what if we exist in Samsāra? The only way to exist in Samsāra is suffering. So what’s the point of that? When we can use the situation to reduce our suffering more and more, eventually eliminate it and then reach the point where we are in a position to help everyone not only reduce their suffering but eliminate it and achieve peerless, everlasting happiness. As the Americans say, it is a no brainer.
The only thing to do is generate bodhicitta. There’s no point just staying in saṃsāra. Especially now when we’ve found the precious human rebirth, the optimum chance to get out of it. So at the end of that section, page forty-one, yeah, just a bit further down. Just go down a bit further. It says — oh, just no, just back up. That last paragraph. Yeah.
Think, so think about the eight kinds of suffering explained above. So we were talking about this last week. In this way think about the three sufferings of cyclic existence in general. So I tried to briefly explain those three kinds of suffering. The most important I think for us as I tried to say quickly last week was to understand that what we call happiness is a type of subtle suffering.
For an Ārya being, someone who has realized the true nature of themselves and phenomena, for Aryas and Buddhas and Bodhisattvas everything that we call happiness is just a type of suffering. Yeah. But they wouldn’t have a bar of it. Not a bar of it, whatever that means. A bar of Yeah.
It’s just suffering. So if you think about them from many angles, you will come to see the disadvantages of cyclic existence from a broad perspective. If you think about them intensely, you will develop a strong understanding. So in other words this is telling us what we should do. We should think about these things from many angles, not just from one point of view but try and see from many points of view how all of the life in cyclic existence is suffering that one does experience, will experience, has experienced the eight sufferings, the six sufferings, the three sufferings, just suffering.
Yeah. If we look at it from many angles. Yeah. Not from the rosy glow that we would like to look from, which we’re taught, you know, the Women’s Weekly version of everything, but the realistic one. And then it goes on to say, if you think about them intensely, and so in other words we shouldn’t just superficially think about these things because this is not going to change our mind.
If you just say, oh yeah, life’s suffering. Yeah. Oh yeah, that’s right. Yeah. Oh, there are eight sufferings.
There are eight sufferings. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, there are six sufferings. Yes.
Yes. Yes. There’s three, four, five. There’s millions. Yes.
That’s not gonna do anything. Right? We have to think about these things intensely in order to destroy this neurotic mind that believes, you know, life is a bowl of cherries. That we and that we can make this world we can make this world perfect. As imperfect people, we can make it perfect.
That’s impossible. It’s just impossible. So if you think about these sufferings intensely, you will develop a strong understanding. And if you think about them for a long time hint hint we should think about this for a long time you will develop a lasting understanding of the disadvantages of cyclic existence. When understanding the disadvantages of cyclic existence gives rise to a determination to be free, you should know that the precious awakening mind is the main supreme path to liberation from cyclic existence and that this should form a part of the training in the awakening mind.
Okay? So this term determination to be free is what is translated in English as renunciation. The Tibetan term which is translated as renunciation is nge jung. Nge jung means the determination to be free. That’s what renunciation is.
Free of what? Not just suffering but especially the causes of suffering. Because so many people think, oh, renunciation, what a horrible idea, giving up happiness. Renunciation isn’t about giving up happiness, it’s about giving up suffering and especially its causes. Because everyone wants to give up suffering.
You know, there’s no one in the world, you know, cats and dogs and cockroaches want to give up suffering. But the trouble is we don’t want to give up the causes. That’s the problem. We are attached to creating the causes of suffering. But when one decides to give up the causes of suffering, that’s renunciation.
That is the determination to be free. Because one realizes the only way I’m gonna be free of suffering is to give up the causes. Right? It is very simple, but we don’t get it. We haven’t got it.
You know, if you look at, for example, the war in the civil war or whatever you want to call it, the troubles in Ireland, which went on for hundreds and hundreds of years. But even just in, you know, this last century, the whole of the last century, you know, people in Ireland were killing each other. They were the same people, you know, exactly ethnically the same people that belonged to different religions, and they killed each other because one was Catholic and one was Protestant. And the only reason that stopped was because eventually the leaders of both sides worked out, oh, this doesn’t work. They finally got it that all they were doing was creating the cause of suffering, not the cause of happiness.
They finally got it. Even though they were suffering all the time killing each other and killing themselves living miserable lives they didn’t get the point that all they were doing was creating the causes of suffering. It looks so obvious, but when you’re in it, you don’t get it. And we are in suffering. We are in Samsāra, and we just don’t get it.
We think it’s okay, and I’m not really creating the causes of it. We just don’t get it. But we can. We can. Because we do have this wisdom and we have the precious human rebirth and we’ve got the Buddhas and we’ve got Buddha House and we’ve got some amazing teachers, not wandering around.
His Holiness is coming soon very soon. Anyway, so this concludes so once when we’ve got that we should realize that the best way to get out of Samsāra is to practice bodhicitta because this would not only take us out of Samsāra, it will lead us to something far greater than just nirvana, just liberation from suffering. It will lead us to this enlightened state where we spontaneously, continuously, perfectly, joyfully benefit all sentient beings. Okay. So this concludes the way to think about the preliminary teaching.
And before I go on, I just have to make something I’m supposed to be reminded, but the person forgot to remind me. I was just politely waiting. At some point last week or the week before, if you can remember, the topic of dedication came up, how important it is to dedicate the merit of what we do whenever we do positive things with our body, speech and mind. It’s really important to dedicate those imprints. There are two reasons: the dedication protects those imprints from being destroyed by the arising of very heavy, disturbing negative thoughts, especially anger.
Just like our negative imprints can be greatly modified by doing virtuous actions as a counteraction to purify. Unfortunately our positive imprints can also be greatly reduced by our negative states of mind. So the Buddhists explain that if one dedicates the merit, then that protects it. And the Buddha in one of the sutras gave the analogy that it’s just a rough analogy, it’s not very scientific so don’t, you know, the scientists among you don’t get too itsy bitsy about this. If you were to take a drop of water and put it on a hot rock it would evaporate almost instantly.
Right? But if you put that drop of water in the ocean, it’s protected. It won’t evaporate instantly. Yeah. So the Buddha said that when one dedicates merit, especially dedicating it to enlightenment, then it enters like this because all the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas have this wish to benefit all sentient beings.
There’s this vast oceanic thought influencing the whole universe in the direction of benefiting sentient beings. So when we dedicate our actions to this same purpose, you know, those actions are protected by that universal mind of great compassion and bodhicitta. Whereas if we don’t dedicate it, then those imprints are left all alone by themselves and can be easily harmed. And the other reason to dedicate is that dedication involves directing that imprint to bringing about a specific cause. If we don’t dedicate to a specific cause, then those positive imprints, when they ripen, they will just ripen in a very, very ordinary, worldly, samsaric way.
Some kind of happiness, some kind of pleasure and then it’s finished. But if we dedicate those positive imprints to enlightenment then they become part of the causes and conditions that enable us to achieve enlightenment. Right. And as well, they bring every other kind of worldly benefit as well. So dedicating our merit is really important.
And ideally if we can dedicate, consciously dedicate as soon as we’ve done something virtuous then that’s best because that’s really protected it straight away. But most of us probably can’t do that. Never think of it. So that’s why it’s really good at the end of the day not only to purify our mind of whatever negativities we’ve done by applying the four opponent powers but also to rejoice in the good things we’ve done because that increases the merit and then dedicate that to enlightenment. Okay.
So now we’ll just carry on with the text. So now we’re entering the main part of this. Remember this text which we are going through called the Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun is a commentary on another text called the Seven Point Mind Training. So the mind training here is referring to training the mind in bodhicitta and everything associated with bodhicitta. So the text says: There are two approaches to the basic practice of developing the precious awakening mind.
So awakening mind is bodhicitta. So the two approaches are that dealing with the process of training in the conventional awakening mind and that involving the process of cultivating the ultimate awakening mind. The former, that is the conventional awakening mind, includes an explanation of how we are able to enter the great vehicle, the Mahāyāna, only by activating the altruistic mind of enlightenment and is followed by a description of the actual techniques for cultivating the precious awakening mind. The later type of awakening mind, which is the ultimate awakening mind, dealing with the development of the view of emptiness, will be dealt with later. So this text is really special because it talks about the two kinds of bodhicitta.
Conventional bodhicitta, which is the one we normally when we use the term bodhicitta, we’re normally referring to conventional bodhicitta, which is this mind seeking enlightenment in order to benefit all sentient beings. Right? That’s what we should generally understand by bodhicitta. Right? But then there is the other kind of bodhicitta which is called ultimate bodhicitta which is a technical term referring to the wisdom realizing emptiness.
The wisdom, that mental factor that is directly experiencing the true nature, the actual nature of oneself and all phenomena which in Buddhist terminology is called shunyata or which we translate as emptiness or voidness. Right. So ultimate bodhicitta is about developing that wisdom, realizing emptiness. Because one needs that to actually achieve enlightenment. Conventional bodhicitta motivates us to achieve enlightenment.
What will actually bring it about is ultimate bodhicitta, the wisdom realizing emptiness. Right? Just like a little bit I think I’ve mentioned this before but what is the antidote to suffering? What stops suffering? Attachment, detachment, Awareness, awareness of one’s actions.
The awareness of true reality. Yeah? Yeah? Oh, yes. Sure.
Yeah. I got the yes. Mhmm. Sorry? Removing ignorance.
We’ve got removing ignorance. Anyone for compassion as the antidote to suffering? Mhmm. Self-cherishing. It sounds good.
Yeah. But actually, I would have thought most people thought that maybe because I always thought that the antidote to suffering was being compassionate, especially the antidote to other people’s suffering was being compassionate, but it’s not. Compassion doesn’t stop suffering. Okay. The point is how do you get that?
How do you get no. The antidote to suffering, of course, is realizing emptiness, destroying ignorance. Destroying ignorance by realizing the true nature of things, realizing emptiness. That is the actual antidote to our own suffering and the antidote to everyone’s suffering. Whereas compassion is what motivates us to stop the suffering of our self and others.
If we don’t have compassion, we won’t be motivated to stop it. Compassion is the mind that wants to stop suffering. If we have real compassion for ourselves, we will want to stop our suffering. If we develop compassion for others, we will want to stop the suffering of others. But those wonderful states of mind don’t actually bring the cessation of suffering.
What actually brings it is realizing emptiness. So conventional bodhicitta is the mind that wants to bring about liberation, enlightenment for oneself and others, but it’s the ultimate bodhicitta that actually achieves it. Yes. Yes. Well, an arhat has an arhat has the wisdom realizing emptiness, but they don’t have bodhicitta.
Remember? For what? For what? What? Oh, no.
Of course, you don’t have realize emptiness floating in the air. Of course, you have to what we were talking about, you have to have renounced this life. You have to have realized the suffering of this life. Then you renounce the suffering of saṃsāra altogether, and you need to develop some compassion, loving kindness, morality, blah blah blah, all these things. But all of these are secondary to the actual direct antidote to ending suffering which is realizing emptiness.
Yeah? The other yeah. The things I mentioned but not necessarily both. Because remember there are two main paths that the Buddha taught. And so there are two major Buddhist traditions that teach God, I’m so — limited mind.
I can barely speak the English language. There is in the world right now, there are two major Buddhist traditions. There is the Mahāyāna tradition that is taught in, you know, for example, the Chinese Mahāyāna, there’s Japanese Mahāyāna like Zen and Chan and Pure Land and there’s Tibetan Mahāyāna Buddhism. And then there is the other tradition is the Theravāda tradition. So the Theravāda tradition, that tradition preserves the teachings about and the practices about the path to liberation, to nirvana.
And the Mahāyāna tradition preserves and presents the teachings about the path to enlightenment. Right? So there are two paths and a tradition that teaches one path, and there is another path and a tradition that emphasizes that other path, right? What am I trying to say? What was that all about?
So Yes. Yes. That’s what I’m trying to talk about. Yeah. So in following the path to liberation that is taught in the Theravāda tradition, you have to realize emptiness and you have to renounce this life.
You have to renounce Samsāra. You have to develop morality, generosity, the six perfections to some extent, you know, etcetera etcetera. But the whole aim of that path is for yourself to become free of suffering. Right? So there’s nothing in that tradition and path about bodhicitta.
Developing yourself to be a vast benefit to others. You purify your mind and awaken your good qualities for your own sake. Finished. Of course you’re nice to other people because if you’re not it harms you. But the main emphasis is everything is so I will get out of Samsāra.
Whereas the Mahāyāna tradition teaches the Mahāyāna path which is encouraging us to develop ourselves so we can get everyone out of Samsāra and more than that so everyone will achieve their true nature and become a Buddha. Right? So also just to clarify a little bit, maybe this is boring tiny technical technicalities. But when we talk about ultimate bodhicitta, it’s referring to the wisdom realizing emptiness, but it’s referring to the wisdom realizing emptiness in the mind of a being who has bodhicitta. Whereas, you know, you can’t talk about ultimate bodhicitta in the mind of an arhat because they don’t have bodhicitta.
They have the wisdom realizing emptiness, but it’s not in the mind of someone who’s generated bodhicitta. Okey doke. Yeah. Well, the motivation is different, and the state of nirvana and enlightenment is vastly different, vastly, vastly different, which we’ll come to in our discovering Buddhism program. So I don’t wanna talk about it now.
But basically, an arhat this is very no. You’ve destroyed my whole my next week’s DB class. Basically, an arhat, as a human being, we can become an arhat. Right? So as a human arhat, of course, a human arhat has no delusions, no negativities, and has developed a lot of love and compassion.
Right? So, of course, they help sentient beings while they’re a human being, but they die. You know, the body decays eventually, and the mind separates from that body and then the mind absorbs into this state of nirvana and in that state that arhat has no awareness of anything other than the bliss of their mind, which is great for the arhat. He or she, well, although you can’t talk about he or she then because there’s no body at all, there’s just mind. So that being is blissed out forever, but they have no awareness of anything else.
So they can’t benefit other sentient beings because they’re not even aware of them, let alone aware that they’re suffering. They’re not even aware of their mere existence. Whereas a Buddha has I’ve never actually checked with the Lama on this. We should actually they just sent out in the Dalai Lama organization, questions. Okay.
Sending questions for his holiness. Is the bliss of an arhat equal to or is the bliss of a Buddha equal to or greater than the bliss of an arhat? Are they having a better time? In other words, the bliss of an arhat. I would have to go for: the bliss of a Buddha is higher.
But the special feature of a Buddha is that even if they’re experiencing the same bliss as an arhat, they are totally conscious. They’re not absorbed in that state. They are fully aware of everything. This is the amazing thing, literally everything all the time. So they’re totally aware of all sentient beings, totally aware of all the suffering of sentient beings, and totally aware of all the causes of all the suffering of all sentient beings.
And they totally know all the answers to all those causes of all sufferings of all sentient beings. And there’s nothing restricting them helping. And there’s everything pushing them. I mean they can’t help but they just spontaneously benefit sentient beings. Not just, you know, yeah, all sentient beings all the time.
Forever. Mhmm. Because the mind’s forever. It doesn’t stop. So once you’ve got that, you’ve got it forever.
It doesn’t cease. Oh, well, yes. There’s yes. Yes and no. See, it gets very complicated.
Well, it’s not that complicated. It’s just that there are different interpretations of different things in the different Buddhist traditions. See, this is taking up the Discovering Buddhism program now. You see? Because there is a different view, the Theravāda tradition has different views than the Mahāyāna tradition about quite a few things.
And it starts to get complicated. So it’s just easier to say in general that once one achieves and becomes an arhat, it goes on forever. But there are subclauses. Certainly you never start suffering again. That’s for sure.
You never go back into Samsāra. That’s impossible. That’s the whole point of achieving nirvana is once you’ve got it, Samsāra can never start again. Are we getting anywhere tonight? I hope this is not boring.
Sorry. Anyway, I think it’s quite important to understand these things to clear them up. Oh, okay. So we have to appreciate the value of the awakening mind. Since it is necessary to embark upon the great vehicle, the Mahāyāna, as pointed out above, you may wonder what is the entrance to such activity?
How do we enter into the activity of benefiting all sentient beings? In stating that there are two aspects to the great vehicle, the practices of the transcending perfections and those of secret mantra, Buddha, the conqueror, has made it clear that there is no great vehicle practice other than these two. So in other words, if we take the Mahāyāna itself, you’ve got the Theravāda tradition and then there’s the Mahāyāna. And within the Mahāyāna there are two types of Mahāyāna practice. All Mahāyāna is about achieving enlightenment so there is what is called the sūtra path which is here referred to as the path which is the practice of the six transcending perfections of generosity, morality, patience, perseverance, concentration and wisdom.
It’s also called the causal vehicle because you have to create all these causes to achieve enlightenment. It’s also called the exoteric vehicle because it’s exoteric. It’s not secret vehicle. It’s something that the Buddha taught openly to everyone. And then the other type of Mahāyāna is the tantric path or the vajrayana.
The tantric teachings of the Buddha, which are the secret teachings. They were kept secret for many reasons. Partly because if Tantra is practiced without the proper preparation, it can be very dangerous. So it’s kept secret. In other words, it’s only taught originally, not so much these days, but originally, it was only taught secretly by teachers to their students.
The teacher knowing very well that the student was prepared. So no one else was told about these things. So it was kept secret. It’s also called the effect vehicle because one of the aspects of Tantra is that you try to experience the effect in the present moment, the effect of being a Buddha now. You imagine that you’re a Buddha.
Rather than creating all the causes, you bring the effect into the present moment. Sounds easy, but it’s much more complicated than that. So anyway, here it’s saying that the Buddha is saying in the Mahāyāna there are only these two kinds of Mahāyāna, the sūtra vehicle and the vajrayana or tantric vehicle of Mahāyāna. There’s no other two. Furthermore, the entrance to each of them is only by means of the awakening mind.
In other words, to follow the sūtra vehicle to enlightenment, to follow the Tantric vehicle. The only way is to generate bodhicitta first. One has to have bodhicitta. Right? So many people are interested in Tantric Buddhism because they hear it’s the secret, esoteric, very special, very mystical, lots of magical powers and blah blah blah.
And it’s the quick path. Everyone is intrigued and wants that and think, well, I’ll just practice that and leave everything else. But what all the true masters emphasize is that you have to have all the groundwork and especially you have to have bodhicitta to practice tantra because the whole idea of tantra is to achieve enlightenment quickly. And why achieve enlightenment quickly? Not in order to avoid a lot of difficult practice over a long time.
That is not the reason. The reason to achieve enlightenment quickly is to stop the suffering of others quickly. Not to stop one’s own suffering quickly, but to be able to get others out of saṃsāra and achieve enlightenment quickly. So that’s why you have to have bodhicitta. To practice tantra properly, you have to have this wish to enlighten all sentient beings.
It just doesn’t work without it. My teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, who was a great master of sūtra and tantra, once said, one of his many super simple, utterly profound statements is that what makes tantra special is the three principal paths of renunciation, bodhicitta, and wisdom. Without those three things, tantra is nothing. It’s just a kind of parlor game. Yeah.
What is it? I can’t think of the word. Yeah. Well, yeah, it’s superficial. It’s just a technique.
It becomes a dead technique. It will have some effect, of course, but it won’t produce the real result if one hasn’t got the foundation, which is renunciation, bodhicitta, and wisdom. So the moment it, meaning bodhicitta, arises in your mental continuum even if you have not generated any other quality, but of course you would because you can’t generate bodhicitta without already having lots of good qualities. Anyway, you become a follower of the great vehicle. On the contrary, the moment it meaning bodhicitta is lost, you fall to the level of the hearers and so on, that is, fall to the level of those just seeking liberation, even though you may possess such qualities as an understanding of emptiness.
Such a falling away from the great vehicle is referred to in many great vehicle scriptures and can also be established by reason. So what that is saying is that having generated bodhicitta, it is possible to lose that state of mind. One can generate it, but later one gives it up. And when you give it up, your mind falls to becoming a follower of the path leading to just liberation. But this text being part of the Mahāyāna tradition is encouraging us to always have this thought to achieve enlightenment.
So whether you are considered a practitioner of the Great Vehicle or not depends simply on whether you possess this attitude, that is the attitude seeking enlightenment. In fact, the great vehicle is indicated by nothing but the presence or absence of this very state of mind. In other words, what distinguishes the great vehicle, the Mahāyāna, from the Theravāda practice is bodhicitta. That’s the main distinction. I mean, in fact, there are other distinctions, but that is the super essential one.
The motivation is quite different. Yeah. In this context, the guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life says: The instant the awakening mind is activated, those bound up in the prison of cyclic existence come to be known as sons or daughters of the Buddhas gone to bliss. In other words, they become Bodhisattvas. And today I’ve been born into the family of the Buddhas and have become a son of the awakened ones.
This shows that as soon as you generate the awakening mind, you become a son or daughter of the conquerors, meaning the Buddhas. Meaning, by saying you become a son or daughter, it means that you have the potential now to become a Buddha. Just like someone who is the son or daughter of a particular person. They have the I suppose you have the genes of your father or mother. So a bodhisattva has the genes, in a sense, the mental genes to become a Buddha once you’ve generated bodhicitta.
So in the life story of the exalted Maitreya, it says, O child of my family, here are some analogies. The awakening mind is like a diamond, even a fragment of which surpasses all other kinds of valuable ornaments such as gold, which retains the name diamond and can eradicate all poverty. So even a sliver of diamond is still a diamond and has all the qualities of a diamond and is still valuable. So the awakening mind, bodhicitta, that wish to achieve enlightenment in order to enlighten every sentient being without exception, that is the most precious state of mind just like a diamond is the most precious ornament. You can’t there’s no comparison.
Yeah. There’s absolutely no comparison. You can’t think of a better state of mind to be in than wanting to benefit every sentient being perfectly. Can you think of a better state of mind? O child of my family, in the same way the precious diamond like mind, which gives rise to omniscience, even when it is weak, outshines all the golden qualities adorning the hearers and solitary realizers.
So even a weak form of bodhicitta is far more impressive than the qualities of the arhats. So there are two kinds yeah. There are two kinds of Arhats, folks. There are what are called hearers and solitary realizer Arhats. The Sanskrit for a hearer is a Śrāvaka.
So a Śrāvaka arhat or a hearer arhat is a being who becomes an arhat by listening to the teachings of the Buddha, being born at the time of a Buddha, hearing the teachings of a Buddha and practicing them. So all, you know, Śāriputra and Maha Maudgalyayāna and all these people, Ānanda, they were hearer Arhats because they were born at the time of a Buddha or when a Buddha’s influence is still existing like at the present time. And so they heard the teachings, practiced them, and achieved nirvana. Whereas solitary realizers are a very unique kind of being who are born in times when Buddhas have not appeared in the world, but they are born into the world having met Buddhas in previous lives. So they’ve got the karmic imprints of the Dharma in their consciousness, but they’re born in these times when the Dharma isn’t flourishing at all and they practice secretly by themselves and achieve nirvana, become Arhat.
So they’re solitary realizers. So the Sanskrit term for a solitary realizer is a Pratyekabuddha. Pratyekabuddha. Of which there are two kinds. I can’t remember the two kinds.
One is a rhinoceros like Pratyekabuddha, and I can’t remember what the other kind is. Maybe no. I shouldn’t say it. I can’t remember why they’re called rhinoceros like, But I think they’re the very solitary ones. No.
No. No. They’re a very rare yeah. No. No.
Not something to worry too much about. I personally don’t I don’t spend too much, you know, lose sleep thinking about Pratyekabuddhas. Okay. So even though your conduct may not be distinguished, if you have engendered such a mind, you are referred to as a bodhisattva, an awakening warrior. The protector Nāgārjuna writes in his precious garland, and of course Nāgārjuna was a bodhisattva, if you and the world wish to attain unsurpassable full awakening, the source is the awakening mind, which should be as stable as the king of mountains.
So if we want to achieve enlightenment, we have to develop the wish to achieve it. It seems logical. Right? But until we’ve developed this actual state of mind which is determined to achieve enlightenment, then it’s not going to happen. And just to sort of give a very gross illustration of this is that probably every one of us here have wishes of what things we would like to do, things we wish I could have, I wish I could go there.
And we’ve had these wishes for a long time. Or I wish I looked like that. You know? But we don’t do anything about these wishes. They’re just wishes.
There’s no energy behind them. We just, oh, I hope it happens. Wouldn’t it be lovely to go to Paris or Tahiti or I don’t know. Wouldn’t it be lovely to be rich? Wouldn’t it be nice to meet Brad and Angelina or Mick Jagger?
I don’t know. Something. You know? But it’s just a wish. You know?
So bodhicitta is not like that. Oh, I’d like to be enlightened. I’d like to benefit all sentient beings. That’s rubbish. That’s nothing.
You know, that’s not bodhicitta. That’s just words. Anyone can say that. So we’re not talking about that. There’s something much more where you have this authentic, genuine determination to do something.
Because, again, you may have some wish to do something and you don’t do anything about it, but at some point you come to the conclusion, yes, I’m going to do it. Yeah. I am going to go there. I am going to whatever. I am going to become a movie star.
You know, I am gonna start a rock and roll band. I am going to become a painter. I am going to blah blah blah. You know? And it’s a completely different state of mind than just this vague, oh, yes.
Yes. I want to do that. Wouldn’t that be wonderful? Yeah. Alright.
It’s a little bit strange where it says even though your conduct may not be distinguished if you’ve generated bodhicitta you’re a bodhisattva. But someone who’s generated bodhicitta, their conduct has already been distinguished for a long time because you don’t generate bodhicitta overnight just like that. You have to have been practicing the Dharma and purifying your mind and cultivating great love and compassion and kindness and generosity for a very, very long time in a very, very powerful way before actual bodhicitta can arise. So, you know, people who generate bodhicitta are already outstanding great beings. So their conduct is pretty distinguished.
It may not be from the outside, one may not be able to tell because the nature of Bodhisattvas and people on the verge of becoming Bodhisattvas is they don’t have much ego. They’re not into showing how good they are. So, anyway, Nāgārjuna is saying that in order to achieve enlightenment, we have to develop this. Was that a bell? That couldn’t be.
More determined than that. We have to generate this mind sincerely, and we have to make it really strong, really stable, not wishy washy. We have to really keep it up. So we’ll take oh, just before that, a question? Any questions, suggestions, comments, qualms, queries?
Yes, yes there is. Yeah, well I was trying to avoid getting into this but now I don’t know much about it because it all seems very strange but according to the Mahāyāna tradition, if you achieve nirvana by seeking liberation for your own sake. Right? So then you enter that state and you absorb into that state for an immensely long period of time. But according to the Mahāyāna tradition and this is only according to the Mahāyāna tradition, not the Theravāda tradition.
But according to the Mahāyāna tradition, at some point how this happens I don’t really know or understand. But the Buddhas come along and sort of figuratively, metaphorically tap on this arhat’s shoulder which doesn’t exist because he or she doesn’t have a body and who’s just, you know, it’s like they’re asleep in nirvana and they wake them up and say, excuse me, sir, madam, you’re having a lovely time in nirvana, but you could be doing a lot more than this. And the Arhat says, really? What could I do? And the Buddha says, well, you could become a Buddha, and then you could help everyone.
And so then they enter the Mahāyāna path. So the Mahāyāna view is that eventually everyone will become a Buddha. Yeah. The Buddhas somehow. Tea time.
Thank you very much. Ten minute tea break. Self-service. There’s a long quotation from the Vajrapāni Tantra. I won’t read through that.
Basically, it’s just saying in the last bit, anyone doing tantra who has not accomplished the awakening mind should not engage in these practices. They should neither view nor enter the mandala. To them the gestures and details of secret mantra should never be shown. So this is illustrating that to practice Tantra one has to have bodhicitta. That’s the very basis of Tantra.
In fact, this is why the Buddha taught the Tantric path because there were those Bodhisattvas who had such incredible compassion for the suffering of others. They couldn’t bear the thought that it would take so long to achieve enlightenment according to the known method of achieving enlightenment that the Buddha had taught. And then the Buddha said to those special bodhisattvas, don’t worry. There’s a quick way. I’ll teach you that one.
And then it also says in the Array of Trees Sūtra, O child of my family, the awakening mind is like the seed of all the teachings of the Buddhas. It is like the field in which the positive actions of all wandering beings prosper. It is like the earth on which the whole world depends. It is like the son of the lord of wealth. So the lord of wealth, the son of the lord of wealth is referring to one of the deities called Vaishravana, who some of you may have heard of.
So in the maybe this is getting too complicated. But for some who have some background, in the Tibetan tradition, they talk about the three protectors of the teachings. There’s the protector of the base of the lowest scope, which is Kālarūpa, who’s the lord of death. So by understanding impermanence and death, that motivates us to renounce this life, which is the main practice of the being of lower scope. Then the practitioner of the middle scope is trying to get free of cyclic existence.
And the basis of that is practicing pure morality because from pure morality comes concentration and you need concentration to develop wisdom. But the basis is pure morality. So the protector of the middle scope is Vaishravana, the son of the lord of wealth. Because that wealth refers to the wealth of morality when you have the wealth of morality, you’re really in a very good position to get out of Samsāra. And then just quickly the protector of the highest scope which is the person practicing bodhicitta is Six-arm Mahākāla, who is an emanation of the Buddha of compassion, Chenrezig.
We don’t have no. Don’t have an example anywhere. So bodhicitta is like the father completely protecting all bodhisattvas. It is like the king of wish granting jewels which perfectly fulfills every purpose. There is a tradition that’s not just something made up by the Tibetans, but it’s in the Pāli Sutras as well that there is the belief that there is this thing called a wish fulfilling gem, which if you find one, and they’re very, unfortunately, very difficult to find because they’re at the bottom of the deepest oceans.
But if you get one and you do certain rituals, then any wish you have will be fulfilled except there’s one drawback that it only fulfills samsaric wishes. Anything in saṃsāra you can get when you’ve found a wish fulfilling gem. They just happen to exist apparently. What’s the point of crocodiles? They exist.
They just exist. I mean, what’s the point of having five fingers? What’s the point? We just do. What’s the point of having a nose like this?
Especially this one. What’s the point? We just have one. We could have had something else but this is what we’ve got. It is like the miraculous vase which acts to accomplish every wish.
It is like a spear vanquishing the foe of disturbing emotions. It is like armor guarding you from improper thoughts. So, you know, if we have bodhicitta, you know, if we really have this thought to perfectly benefit all sentient beings, then it is like a spear destroying our disturbing thoughts because we won’t want to follow craving, attachment, anger, pride, jealousy when we have bodhicitta. Even if we’ve still got the instincts for them, we will see that those disturbing thoughts are so contrary to what bodhicitta is trying to do. So it’s the best protection from the disturbing thoughts.
It’s like armor guarding you from improper thoughts. Yeah. If we remember our bodhicitta. That’s why I always say, excuse me, sound pretty pompous. But in meditating, when we meditate, you know, to avoid the distractions and all the distractions come from the disturbing thoughts, particularly attachment, it’s so important to focus on the motivation at the beginning.
If we get the motivation right, especially the bodhicitta motivation, of course, it’s not the real bodhicitta, but it’s some kind of, you know, pseudo plastic version of bodhicitta. If we get that right, then that acts as an armor to protect us from distractions in meditation. Because when the distractions come, we will think, how can I follow this when I’m supposed to be doing this for the sake of all sentient beings? And if we’ve really got that thought, then when the distractions come, they seem so petty and ridiculous and embarrassing, we would never follow them. Right?
So, of course, not only in meditation, but throughout our life, if we have some degree of bodhicitta, it’s the best armor from all negative, improper thoughts, which harm ourselves, harm others. It is like a sword beheading the disturbing emotions. It is like an axe felling the tree of disturbing emotions. It is like a weapon staving off all kinds of attack. It is like the hook which draws you out of the waters of cyclic existence.
It is like the whirlwind which scatters all mental obstructions and their sources. It is like the condensed teaching that encompasses all the prayers and activities of the bodhisattvas. It is like the shrine before which all gods, humans, and demigods of the world can present their offerings. O child of my family, meaning a child of the family is someone following the bodhisattva way of life. The family of bodhisattvas, O child of my family, the awakening mind is endowed like this with these and immeasurable other excellent qualities.
So the awakening mind is explained in this way as the exclusive entrance for venturing into the great vehicle that enables you to accomplish the state of a completely awakened being. The moment it is born within your mind stream, all the obstructions from previously accumulated actions are burnt up. I don’t think we can take this literally. But what it does mean is that from the moment we generate authentic bodhicitta, all our obscurations, disturbing thoughts and so on, the imprints from those begin to be, the negative karma generated by them, all of it starts to be purified. This is why in purifying the mind, there is the practice of the four opponent powers.
The first is regret. The second is the power of reliance on the power of one’s refuge and the power of bodhicitta. Because if we try as a practice of purifying our mind, we try and generate or regenerate or reaffirm or strengthen our bodhicitta, then it’s doing this. Bodhicitta, as soon as it’s generated, starts to undermine all these negative imprints in our mind. That’s why we have to rely on the power of bodhicitta to purify our mind.
Yeah. Because it’s totally contrary. Bodhicitta is totally contrary to the mind that is the basis for all negativity and harm to our self and others. It acts to protect you from all miseries and fears. Partly because to generate bodhicitta requires great courage.
And bodhicitta is based on great love for all sentient beings and great compassion. And great compassion is inextricably mixed with courage. You know, to be able to feel your own suffering and open oneself to the suffering of others, one has to have courage. Right? So once one has developed some degree, some form of bodhicitta, this determination to achieve enlightenment for the sake of others out of great compassion, then one has this courage to face difficulties and all sorts of fears because you have this protection.
You’ve got this inner determination to achieve enlightenment, having realized that this is the best thing to do for everyone. It begins to provide you with the inexhaustible fruits of higher states of rebirth and the definite goodness of liberation. Yeah. Because in Śāntideva’s text about generating bodhicitta, the guide to the bodhisattva way of life, in there, it makes the point that he says something like, all merit, all virtuous actions done without bodhicitta are like a plantain tree or a banana tree or banana trees aren’t trees. They’re something else.
Anyway, a banana plant produces a bunch of bananas and then dies. Yeah. A banana plant shoots out, but that particular plant that has produced a bunch of bananas I do know this because in my hippie days, I worked in a banana place. But yeah. On a hippie farm, we had lots of bananas growing.
Yeah. So it produces a bunch of bananas and then dies. So the same with ordinary merit. You do a virtuous action. It produces a virtuous imprint and it ripens with one result.
And then when that result comes, it’s finished. But anything done with a bodhicitta motivation, Śāntideva says, the positive effects just keep coming and coming and coming. There’s not just one good result, but continuous benefits. So there’s no comparison between doing a good action without bodhicitta to doing a good action with bodhicitta. There’s no end to the good results of doing something with bodhicitta.
As Rinpoche says, you just offer one grain of sugar to an ant with bodhicitta motivation. Skies of merit. Skies of merit. Rinpoche means that. Skies of merit.
Not a little bit of merit. Not one bit of merit. Skies of merit. But Rinpoche is a bodhisattva, and bodhisattvas do not lie. They can’t lie.
Skies of merit. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And may this become a cause for my enlightenment to make every sentient being happy.
Yeah. It is like the quintessential butter arising from the churning of the ocean of scriptures. In other words, everything that the Buddha taught ultimately is about generating bodhicitta. That’s the Buddha’s aim. What he wants us to do is to generate bodhicitta so we can all become Buddhas.
That’s what the Buddha wants us to do. So it is like the seed that is the exclusive proximate cause leading you to the fully awakened state of being. So there are many causes to achieving enlightenment, realizing that one has a precious human rebirth. You know, that is a cause to achieve or it’s a condition, secondary cause to achieve enlightenment, realizing impermanence and death. Yeah.
But the proximate cause is generating bodhicitta. That’s the close one, the direct one. That’s what will really but, of course, you have to realize emptiness. But you have to have this wish to achieve enlightenment. Because if you just have emptiness, you’ll become an arhat.
So you have to have this determination to benefit all sentient beings. In realizing such benefits of the awakening mind, your heartstrings should resound with joy. Are your heartstrings resounding with joy at the moment? For although life as a free and fortunate human being generally provides you with an opportunity to practice doctrine. The wonderful discovery of the chance to practice the awakening mind specific to the great vehicle is sure to be a source of great encouragement.
This is an event of major importance. So one of the signs of realizing that one has a precious human rebirth, not just an ordinary human rebirth. There are seven billion sentient beings on this planet who have human rebirths. But very few of those seven billion human beings have a precious human rebirth because they don’t have all eight freedoms and all ten endowments. But if one realizes one has them, one realizes this is the optimum chance to practice Dharma, the optimum chance to get a good rebirth, the optimum chance to achieve liberation, the optimum chance to achieve enlightenment.
So realizing that makes the mind really happy. That is why I said it’s a very good if you’re ever feeling down and depressed, meditate on having a precious human rebirth. Because it should make you happy if we do it well to realize what an amazing opportunity I have. But then what Horton Kappel is saying here, who’s the author of this mind training like the rays of the sun is saying that on top of knowing you’ve got a precious human rebirth should make you happy. But then realizing you’ve got the chance not only to practice the Dharma in general, but to practice the Mahāyāna teachings of the Buddha, which are very rare.
One has got the chance to actually generate bodhicitta. This is really mind blowing. Major importance. I think the word these days is it’s awesome, man. It’s really awesome.
Yeah. As it is said in the teachings many times, which I find quite moving to think that on this earth right now among seven billion people, there are billions of people on this earth right now who will never hear the word Buddha. They will never ever in their entire life hear the word bodhicitta, let alone have any idea what it means, let alone have any faith in it, let alone have the remotest chance to try and generate it. Whereas we have heard the word, we know we have the ability to understand what it means, and we actually have the precious human rebirth, the optimum chance to start generating it. This is truly, truly an event of major importance for not just ourselves, but for all sentient beings.
Because if we generate it, zillions of people will benefit. Zillions. And I hope you know how many there is in a zillion because I don’t. Yeah. Just to go back a little bit, Śāntideva’s book is truly one of the best books to read of all and study and practice.
Śāntideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life. And in the very beginning of that book, in talking about how amazing bodhicitta is, Śāntideva says something along the lines that this wish, bodhicitta is this wish to perfectly benefit all sentient beings. So he makes the point that even the gods have never had this thought to benefit all sentient beings. And, also, our parents who love us dearly, they don’t have this thought. Their love for us is nothing like the love the Bodhisattva has for us.
Because if we really and I’m not trying to insult our parents, but our parents, if they are probably but one can never be sure, but probably ordinary sentient beings with the mindset of ordinary sentient beings. So their love for us, their wish for happiness, their wish for us to be happy is samsaric happiness. I mean, they’re not conscious of that, but what they want us to experience is, from a Buddhist point of view, just samsaric happiness, which is, remember, actually the suffering of change. They want us to have a nice job, to look nice, to be nice, to behave nicely, to have a nice wife or a nice husband and nice children and a nice car and nice clothes, living in a nice area. Because they sincerely believe if we have all these nice things, then we’ll be happy.
And that’s all you can get. That’s what we ordinary people think. That’s it, basically. And a nice bank account, of course. But that’s it.
That’s what our parents and people who care for us want, us to have that happiness. But a bodhisattva sees that that happiness is just the suffering of change. They don’t want us to have just that. They want us to have peerless everlasting happiness. And they don’t just want that for us.
They are determined to do everything necessary and do it for however long it takes so that we can have not the suffering of change, but peerless everlasting happiness. It’s just an inconceivable state of mind that we ourselves don’t have for ourselves, Śāntideva says. Our love for ourselves doesn’t match the love a bodhisattva has for us because our love for ourselves is actually not even love. In most cases, it’s just self-cherishing, which is the great enemy of bodhicitta. To generate bodhicitta, one has to destroy, give up self-cherishing.
So on that note, we’ll stop for tonight, I think. We have to stop. If you’re interested, don’t take it if you’re not. And I won’t be upset or cry if you don’t take it. But there is I’ve made I made it a long time ago.
Just got it printed out tonight though. Something about bodhicitta. It gives you the definition of bodhicitta, the ten benefits, the three ways to generate it, and a few details. So if you’d like a copy, I’ll just put it over here and people can collect it at the end of the class. And if you do take a copy, bring it next week or study it, memorize it all so you know what we’re talking about next week.
Especially those people who are kind of fairly new, I would recommend taking this so they have some idea. Okay. Any questions to conclude? Yes. Right.
Right. Yes, yes. Yeah. Well, before this human environment is destroyed, we could possibly be reborn in another human realm that is operating in another universe or actually in the same universe as this one. So we don’t have just the choice of, the possibility of being reborn a human on this particular planet.
Yeah. Yeah. Oh, no. Of course, we should take care of it. Yeah.
Yes. Yes. Yes. That would be the best thing. What His Holiness says is something along the lines that, of course, the highest level of practice is to totally devote oneself to study and meditation.
But his Holiness says the number of people who can do that is very, very, very few. You know, we might like to think we’re in that group, but we’re not. Very, very few people have done the preliminary practices to be able to totally devote themselves to meditating all the time and so on. So his Holiness says, well yeah. That’s the best one.
Doing intensive retreat because this will bring the realizations that will bring liberation, enlightenment, and vast benefit to others. His Holiness says, if you can’t do that, the second best thing is to teach the Dharma, not like me, but, you know, the real teachers. And His Holiness said, if we can’t do that, if you’re not at that level yet, then the best thing is to engage in social activities to benefit sentient beings. Yeah. Yeah.
But, of course, it does mean not just that because as a Buddhist, we have to we do have to take care of our mind because the danger, the problem with very good ordinary people who dedicate their lives to doing social services things is often these people aren’t training and developing their mind. They have a reservoir of good imprints and love and compassion from the past. But somehow, often, all of that gets burned up in this life, and they don’t have the methods to really train their mind and develop their mind. So as a Buddhist, the aim is as ordinary Buddhists that we take care of our mind, we practice the Dharma to strengthen our mind, but also do what we can in a practical way to benefit others. But those two things have to go together because if you don’t take care of your own mind properly, you’re not gonna be able to benefit others much.
If you put all effort onto benefiting others and not looking after yourself. You know, as I often say, I’ll stop talking. I know I have this terrible habit. We say we finish and then I go on. But it took me years and years I travel, you know, not so much nowadays, but I used to before as a monk, I ended up traveling a lot flying in airplanes and being a monk of very little brain.
It took me a long time to work this out. But this whole thing you have to sit through the demonstration, the safety demonstration. They said, if the air pressure drops down, these yellow things will drop down. Put it on yourself first and then help other people. And they never said why, but slowly I worked it out.
Why is that? If you don’t put it on yourself first and you put it on the, oh I’m compassionate I’m gonna save you while you’re trying to save the other person you can die of lack of oxygen and then the person, the little kid you’re trying to save will die too so two people die but if you put the thing on first then there’s a chance you can save the child as well. And this is what, as a dharma practitioner, one has to do. One has to take care of one’s own crazy mind first. But the idea is to have why me first?
Because really I want to benefit others. And it is possible to have that mind authentically, not as a pretend that I’m really putting a lot of effort into taking care of myself because I really want to be of benefit to others and I don’t want to harm them. Thank you very much. So we can dedicate the merit. So we have to dedicate the merit to enlightenment.
Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of the Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. The object of refuge of myself and of all transmigratory beings in all our lifetimes is the embodiment of the Three Jewels, the all encompassing three refuges in one, the guru, the wish granting jewel, his holiness, the Dalai Lama, the master Padmasambhava, the Dharma king Songtsen Gampo and Trisong Detsen, the abbot Shāntarakshita and the numberless holy beings who preserved and spread the Buddhadharma in Tibet, and the Tibetan people who practiced and served Buddhism so faithfully for a thousand years, as well as those who along with many others died sacrificing their lives for
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- eight Mahayana precepts thegchen sojong (Tib)
- One-day vows to abandon killing; stealing; lying; sexual contact; intoxicants; high seats; eating at the wrong time; and singing, dancing and wearing perfumes and jewelry. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- Saka Dawa
- One of four great holy days of the Tibetan calendar, falling on the fifteenth of the fourth Tibetan month, Saka Dawa commemorates the Buddha’s birth, enlightenment and parinirvana. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.