1 h 24 min · 9,085 words · 30 April 2015 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 84-minute teaching, Venerable Thubten Dondrub guides practitioners through the second week of Heart Sūtra commentary, exploring how ignorance works and why understanding emptiness matters. He begins with the two aspects of ignorance: false appearances of inherent existence and the grasping mind that clings to them as real. Drawing on Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s teachings, he explains that while even advanced meditators perceive things as solid and independent, the crucial difference is that they don’t believe this false appearance. Dondrub walks through practical daily-life applications: noticing how we project qualities like beauty or badness onto objects when these depend entirely on our mind; recognizing how conflicts arise from assuming our view of something is objectively true while another’s is false; and understanding how the mistaken belief in an independently existing self drives suffering. He digresses into the four opponent powers for purifying negative karma, emphasizing that regret—not guilt—is what opens the path forward. The session concludes with extended Q&A about obstacles on the path, ignorance versus negative karma, and how the Buddha perceives both ultimate emptiness and conventional reality simultaneously. Suited for those with some familiarity with Buddhist psychology and ready to grapple with abstract philosophical concepts through concrete examples.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Heart Sūtra Week 2 2015 04 30.mp3
UUID: f8bb3c28-defc-48d6-8805-80834ce7d86d
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Heart Sūtra (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2015-04-30
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 84.3 minutes
Words: ~9,091
Right. Okay. So the Heart Sūtra is one of a number of sutras about the nature of reality, what are called the wisdom sutras or the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras, the perfection of wisdom sutras. So these come from the Mahāyāna tradition of the Buddha. The Heart Sūtra is the shortest of these Prajñāpāramitā Sutras and it condenses the meaning of all the other ones.
That’s why it’s called the Heart Sūtra, the very essence of all the others. So the longest of the remaining existing Prajñāpāramitā Sutras is one hundred thousand verses. So the Heart Sūtra is condensed into twenty-five verses. So to really understand it, one needs to have studied all the other much larger sutras and receive commentaries on them. So to really get into this, one has to have studied a great deal in the past.
So I haven’t done that myself. I’ve done a little bit of study in the past. Unfortunately, I got sent out to do all sorts of things in dharma centres instead of study. But so I I can only just give a a a few general points about this sūtra. But even so, it can be difficult to understand various things.
I just like to remind people that if you find some of the things difficult to understand, you’re not familiar with the concepts and whatever, don’t get too upset and think, oh, this is rubbish or too difficult and it’s therefore not worth trying to understand it. Is really important to try to understand it. And at first, of course, anything that we’re not familiar with is difficult to understand. And but through the power of familiarity, which is one of my main themes, through the power of familiarity, what starts out as being very difficult can become more and more easy to understand until it becomes completely understood. What starts out as something very difficult to do through the power of familiarity can become spontaneous and natural.
That and that works both ways with negative things. If we become negative if familiar with what is negative, we take on those qualities very qualities very quickly and easily. If we become familiar with what is virtuous and beneficial, then we can become, you know, that can become our nature. We can just be spontaneously kind and compassionate, if through the power of familiarity. So that’s really important.
And that’s the meaning of having a precious human rebirth, that we have the freedom, the greatest freedom, to study the wisdom teachings of the Buddha. This is the real opportunity to do that. So even if we don’t have a complete understanding of them in this life, we’re starting the process of putting imprints in our mind that will ripen in future lives. This is also one of my little teaching themes, is imprints, because this is one of the things I’m holding onto in the hope that something good will happen. I read this many, many years ago from Geshe Ngawang Dhargyey, wonderful book he wrote.
It was based on oral teachings he gave where he said, You shouldn’t expect. It’s not very wise to expect too many results in this life. But what we should have strong faith in and understanding is that whatever Dharma practice we do, whether it’s listening to teachings, studying texts, meditating, putting them into practice. All of that, apart from whatever results we get in this life, what we should definitely have faith in is that all of that is creating positive karmic imprints, merit, and that will have tremendous results in future lives. One of which, one basic but incredibly important result, is that when we have another human rebirth, we will be just instinctively drawn to the Dharma, attracted to it, interested in it, and the more we’ve engaged in some of these various practices, the more easily they will come to us and we will be able to build on them.
So if we spend some of this life familiarising ourselves with the wisdom teachings of the Buddha, which may be very difficult in this life, but it means we will make a connection with them. We will be drawn to them in future lives like a magnet. We will meet them again, and we’ll have we will understand we we will be what’s the word that His Holiness uses? We will we will admire them. Yeah?
We will have great admiration for them and be attracted to them and have energy to practice, you know, study them, and it’ll be easier and easier. That’s how merit works. So that’s really important. So that’s one reason to study the Heart Sūtra. So the main reason, of course, is to help us to eliminate eliminate our ignorance, to reduce and eliminate our ignorance, which is the source of all our suffering, by opposing it with the right view, learning the right view.
And by learning the right view, that helps us see what our wrong view is. The more we understand what the actual way the more we understand, according to the Buddhist teachings, how things actually do exist, how we exist, how phenomena exist, the more we understand that, we have a what? What is it? Understanding? No.
Yeah. Yeah. It is an understanding, but it’s a A model. Yeah. To contrast how what what how we believe things are.
So it can help us see that the way we are grasping at how we exist and how things exist is something different, it’s false. It helps us to identify our wrong view. And the more we can realise that I’ve got this wrong view, that then in our daily life, we can try to let go of that wrong view, not to grasp so strongly at it. There are two aspects of ignorance, this mental factor which is the root of all our suffering. One aspect is that it creates this false appearance and that false appearance is called the appearance of inherent existence or true existence.
So that’s one aspect of ignorance, and the other aspect of ignorance is that that that that same mind that creates that illusion grasps that that illusion is real. So my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, says that the main problem is not so much that things appear in a false way to us, that they appear to inherently exist. The real problem is that we grasp that that is true. And to get rid of that false appearance, that is that that is very difficult, but to stop grasping at that false appearance, there’s more possibility of that. Yeah?
For someone like an Ārya bodhisattva, remember Ārya bodhisattvas from last week and first level Ārya bodhisattvas? A first level Ārya bodhisattva is someone who is directly perceived in meditation for the first time. They’ve directly perceived with their mental consciousness the empty nature of themself. They’ve got they’ve momentarily, in meditation, eliminated temporarily, not permanently yet, temporarily eliminated the view of an inherent existence of self, and they’re directly perceiving the space like emptiness of the self. But when they come out of that experience, out of meditation, then even for an Aria Bodhisattva, who is an inconceivably advanced being, everything still appears to be inherently existent.
The the false appearance still exists in their mind. Yeah. Even for an Ārya being. But the big difference between them and us, because we have this false appearance too, is that when we have it, we’re having right now, we grasp that that appearance is real. Whereas Bodhisattvas who have these Ārya Bodhisattvas who’ve had this direct experience, they don’t, you know, they have this appearance of something looking inherently existent, but they don’t believe it.
They don’t grasp it as real. So it doesn’t affect them in in the same negative way our grasping does. Did that make sense? Yeah. So this is what Lama Zopa Rinpoche encourages us to try to do in our daily life, is not to grasp at things so much as being real.
There’s grasping in the sense of attachment, but here we’re talking about grasping at our appearances, you know, holding onto them that whatever appears to my mind, it really is like that. It’s so helpful to train to have some space in the mind where we can even momentarily tell ourselves, oh, maybe it’s it’s not like this. Just because that’s what seems to be happening, it doesn’t have to mean it is like that. So we can do that. That is not absolutely impossible.
We can’t do it all the time, and probably we can’t do it for a very long time, but sometimes, for a short time, we can do that. You can do that. We can do that, if we try. And through the power of familiarity, we’ll be able to do it more and more. Reciting the Heart Sūtra helps us do that because it’s reminding us how things actually are.
And especially if we start to understand more and more what this very condensed text is saying, then it’s even a greater reminder. You know, when I was when I was in school, it was approximately one hundred years ago, when you, you know do you call those things? Mnemonics or something? When you learn the colors of the rainbow, which is ROYGBIV, red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo, violet. So once you know that there’s those colors and you say ROYGBIV, it brings to mind the colours.
So once you have understood something about emptiness and you read this, it all comes back. It all pops up. And especially if one has got a really, really deep understanding, all you have to do is recite the mantra, Gate Gate Pāragate Pārasamgate bodhi svaha, and bingo, it all appears to the mind for someone who has really studied and meditated a lot. So we haven’t done that yet, but we can start. We’re starting.
So it’s great just to put the imprint of the Heart Sūtra in our consciousness because we’re creating the imprint, the connection with this most profound teaching. It’s just a very easy way to put positive imprints in the mind. And just to remind you folks who do know, and just to let you know, some others who may not know, in the Tibetan tradition, we are encouraged to purify our mind as much as possible of negative imprints. We need to put as many positive imprints in our mind as possible and stop putting negative imprints in our mind from engaging in negative actions of body, speech and mind, and we also need to try and purify or eliminate the negative imprints already there because we’ve put many in there during this life and certainly in all our past lives. So there is a basic fundamental method to purify the mind of negative imprints, and this is the method or technique of applying what are called the four opponent powers.
And one needs to apply all four of them together as strongly and as sincerely as possible. So just very quickly, the four opponent powers are the power of regret, developing not guilt, but a strong regret for one’s negative actions, and regret recognises that something is negative and that it’s going to bring suffering. Regret is a virtuous mind. It is a type of wisdom because it’s seeing the conventional truth of something, that that is a negative action, what I’ve just done, thought or said, that is a negative action and it can only result in suffering. Law of cause and effect.
The nature of the cause, if you create a cause, it will have an effect and the effect will be the same as the cause. So a negative action motivated by disturbing thoughts will only have a negative effect. It will have an effect, and the effect will be negative. Now where am I going there? Yes.
No. I know that. So so, yeah, so regret is a type of wisdom that clearly sees the truth of something and doesn’t deny it, opens the mind to that, whereas guilt is a type of ignorance in itself. And by seeing something is negative and is going to bring us bad results, already within that guilt, that regret, is a wish. You you’d have to say not to do that action again.
Right? If one recognises this is gonna bring me suffering. So there’s some kind of positive energy there moving away from negativity, whereas guilt is a type of ignorance. And it doesn’t give any energy to go in a positive direction, and quite the opposite. You know, guilt says, oh, I’ve done something bad, you know, I’ve done something terrible.
Why have I done something bad and terrible? Because I’m a terrible person. Why am I a terrible person? Because I’ve done something terrible. Why have I done something terrible?
Because I’m a terri naturally terrible person. Why am I an actually terrible person? Because I just did something terrible. Therefore, I might as well kill myself or just keep in doing terrible things because I’m a naturally terrible person, and I can’t do good things. I don’t even have to try because because it’ll be hopeless because I’m a hopeless person.
So I’ll just keep doing terrible things. Yeah. It just spirals down into darkness. Whereas a regret is a very clear mind that just simply says, oh, that was a disaster. It’s not because I’m a terrible person, just a little bit dumb.
A little bit ignorant. Confused. Temporarily confused. Yeah. Yeah.
Won’t do that again. So that’s the first power, is the power of regret. Then I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to take this make this too long because I’m I’m trying to get to a point here, believe it or not. Then there’s the power of of there’s the power of reliance, which is reliance on one’s refuge and bodhicitta.
Those two things make up the power of reliance. So these are two very virtuous states of mind which counteract the mind that engages in those negative behaviours. The reason we engage in negative behaviours is because we don’t have refuge or we’ve forgotten our refuge or we’ve denied it. And also we engage in negative actions because we don’t have bodhicitta, we’ve lost it, or we’ve lost it. bodhicitta, mind wanting to only benefit sentient beings.
So one tries to put the imprint of those states of mind back into our mind to counteract the very opposite states that engage in negative actions. The third power is the power of remedy. Oh, so no, leave that, forget that. No, don’t forget that. Another of the four.
There’s no particular order in these four opponent powers. There is the power of resolution, which is deciding to do a virtuous action. No, no, no. The power of resolution is deciding not to do that action again as much as possible. And then the fourth one, which is the point I’m trying to get to, the fourth power, purifying power, is the power of remedy, which is to consciously, to do a specific virtuous action to counteract one’s negative behaviour.
So in the Lamrim teachings, the Graduated Path teachings that go through the Four Opponent Powers, mentions that there are six especially powerful, virtuous actions that are good to do as the power of remedy, because they are so virtuous, they really have they create an enormous amount of merit, therefore at the same time they have the great power to purify the mind. So the most powerful of these is to meditate on emptiness, the nature of reality. But of course, unfortunately, that is the most difficult one to do, to be able to meditate on emptiness properly. But another one, another of the six most virtuous actions to engage in to purify the mind, and very virtuous actions to engage in generally, is to read sutras. Because the sutras are coming directly from the Buddha.
Right? They they most sutras are believed to be the speech of the Buddha, straight from the heart, straight from the mind of the Buddha. So to read those is putting an incredibly, unbelievably powerful imprint in the mind. We are putting the thoughts of the Buddha into our mind. I mean, is why in general we are encouraged in the Tibetan many people don’t like doing prayers.
It’s all very religious and goody goody stuff and ritualistic. But all the prayers that we do have an incredible history and profound meaning, and they come from the minds of incredible beings. Like the refuge prayer we say, know, the Sangye Chödang Tsog Kyi prayer was composed by Lama Atisha, who, His Holiness says, was one of the greatest Dharma practitioners the world has seen, the one most kind to Tibet because he brought he revived Buddhism in Tibet and inspired so many people, and his teachings are still practiced in Tibet. So that refuge prayer is like this is not like some, you know, pop singer composing or some poet, you know, thinking up some nice words. This is like the deepest expression of the realization of an inconceivably amazing mind.
Yeah. And so every time we recite it, you know, that something of that is going into our mind. We we and and and you look what’s going is going into our mind most of the time, whether we like it or not, especially in this day and age, our mind is getting full of garbage, full of garbage. Drivel. Drivel garbage and rubbish.
Very difficult to escape to escape it. So to sit down and say, is just great, or in in English even. Yeah. And all the other prayers, but then something like the Heart Sūtra. So it mentions reading the sutras as very good, but especially the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras.
And the shortest one is this one. This is the essence of all the other ones. So fantastic to do, to study this and read it. And the purpose and, yeah, so that’s good in itself, but we should the purpose of being here and doing all of this is to try and put this into practice to some extent, right, in our daily life, to make us aware that we are experiencing things all the time, things are appearing to our mind. I personally find just this word appearance is very helpful.
That part of our ignorance is grasping all this real solid stuff. It’s all really solid stuff. It’s really real. But in the text, so much, it talks about things are just appearing. That’s all they are.
They’re just appearances. There’s just an appearance of this. An appearance also doesn’t mean just appearing, like, in the sense of something you see, but there is an appearance of, you know, when you touch something with your fingers, there’s a sensation there’s an appearance of a, you know, smooth sensation. Yeah. Or there’s an appearance of a taste to your tongue or, you know, to your body.
Or your ears, there’s an appearance. Something appears. A sound appears to your ear. Appear to your ear. Yeah.
So when you think about it like that, you know, that’s actually what it is. It’s something just appearing to your ear consciousness, your eye consciousness, your your nose consciousness. It’s just something appearing and coming and going, passing through. So these types of things we should try to be aware of in our daily life if we can, more and more, to check up how we are experiencing things and how we are seeing them so solid we see ourselves so solidly. And sometimes we see ourselves more solidly than at other times.
When we take ourselves, sometimes it’s possible to catch oneself taking oneself very seriously. Yeah. It’s kind of embarrassing when you catch that When one one is, you know, who? Me? You’re talking to me like that.
But you and you check. When we’re taking ourselves seriously, it’s something very that that is a very concrete mind, you know? We’re making ourself and the situation, somehow it becomes so solid. Yeah. And kind of dead.
It’s all locked in and very difficult. Very very serious. But it’s just all an appearance to the mind, to our ignorant mind. That was an introduction. Any questions?
Yes? Just wondering. You mentioned that when we are starting on the dharma and there’s we attract obstacles. Why is that? And how do we I just I try to say why.
I mean, how do we not be a form of the track because there’s obstacles coming? Partly by just recognising that that’s what tends to happen, can happen. Yeah. That’s the nature of existence. Does it mean that obstacle comes a lot more quicker because you attract?
Don’t get too caught up in this. It doesn’t mean you will always attract obstacles, sometimes this can happen. Especially when I mean, in the teachings it makes the point that especially when someone is on the verge of gaining some realization about something, particularly then when obstacles can occur because something so beneficial for that person could potentially happen, and that’s when things can start to go wrong. So you have to be on your guard. Yeah.
Can I ask something just about what you’re talking about previously? What are the two aspects of ignorance. When you were Yeah. You’re saying talking about mood, false appearances in the first aspect and the second aspect in the grasping Yep. Of the mind of those appearances.
And you went on to talk about the four opponent opponent powers to purify the mind of negative Mhmm. Mhmm. Are you referring to those as those powers as being applicable to read the mind of the ignorance you described? No. No.
No. No. No. The four opponent powers helps us get rid of the negative imprints that have been created, negative karmic imprints. The only thing that’s gonna get rid of ignorance is wisdom.
Yeah. Yeah. Of course, if we get rid of ignorance, all the negative karmic imprints will go as well at the same time. So then you could think, Oh well, I won’t bother to purify my negative imprints. I’ll just wait and get rid of ignorance and, you know, we have to try and get rid of our negative imprints as well first because Yeah.
The negative imprints are preventing us from Yes. Practicing in some way. They are. Yes. Right.
You’ve got it. Kind of. Not really. One more question before we break. Anything?
Okay. Thank you. Tea break. Oh, whatever you think. Anyway, milk and wine.
Whatever you look. Whatever comes to your body mind, girls. Okay. So the sūtra says, thus did I hear it one time. So this is Ānanda speaking, who had heard the Buddha give many, many teachings.
So the Bhagawan was dwelling on massive vultures mountain in Rajgriya, together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. So the monks were all ārya arhats. At that time, the Bhagawan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception or in other translations, that term profound perception is translated as appearance of the profound. So anyway, that’s referring to the fact that the Buddha was meditating on the true nature of all things, the empty nature of all things. So that appearance of the true nature is something very, very profound, very, very subtle to actually realise, but the Buddha has realised that completely.
So I mentioned for a bodhisattva, an ārya being who has perceived emptiness, when they’re out of meditation, things still appear inherently existent, but they don’t believe that. They don’t grasp at it. Whereas for a Buddha, one of the unique features of the Buddha’s perception that distinguishes him from other Ārya beings is that the Buddha is perceiving the empty nature of things all the time. There is never a moment when things appear as inherently existing to the Buddha. The Buddha is having that direct perception of the true nature of things all the time.
He is seeing the ultimate and also a very special feature of the Buddha’s awareness is that and completely unique to the Buddha, is that the Buddha perceives the ultimate truth of things and the conventional truth at the same time, simultaneously, all the time. So the Buddha is seeing everything all the time. So the Buddha’s mind is omniscient, so it’s seeing absolutely everything all the time, and it’s seeing the conventional nature of things all the time and the ultimate nature of everything simultaneously. So right now, we are seeing the conventional nature of this cup as a cup, the dependently arising cup. But why are we seeing that?
We can’t see the empty nature of it. But the Buddha can see the empty and experiences the empty nature of this cup and the conventional nature of the the conventionally appearing cup at the same time. So he doesn’t see it as a soul? No. Not in any way.
So can he see through? He’d see the molecule. Oh, everything, yeah. But remember, when we’re talking about solid, it doesn’t mean solid. No.
It can mean that, but Because even from an ordinary point of view, solid things aren’t very solid anyway. Right? Mhmm. You know, these are made up of atoms, they say, you know, an atom has, you know, there’s so much space and blah blah blah. Actually, was a little thing on the FPMT web of Lama Osel, a little teaching Lama Osel gave recently where he was saying he’d been reading something about physics and how they say that actually all the solid matter of the whole universe, or at least on this planet, could actually fit into the size of a sugar cube.
So things aren’t all that solid. But when we talk about, like, inherent existence creates the illusion of solidity, don’t take that in a too solid a sense. It’s kind of more it’s like how we you know, when I was saying when we when we look, you know, when we take ourselves seriously, you know, everything seems very solid. Do you know what I’m talking about? Don’t take it literally.
So literally. If it would Mhmm. You’re saying that Buddha sees it differently when we see it. Yes. So he’s looking at that car Yes.
Very, very differently than I’m looking at that car. Yes. Yes. So he’s But he can also see what you can see. As well.
As in he can turn it on and off. At the same time. At the same time? Don’t worry about what the Buddha sees No. You have to worry about what you can see.
That’s the point. That’s the point. I think it becomes very we can go crazy trying to work out what the Buddha is perceiving. But what the Buddha wants us to do is check out what we are experiencing or what we think we’re experiencing, because that’s the problem. The Buddha doesn’t have any problems.
We’ve got problems. So we have to work out why. Yeah. Are you wanting the Buddha wanting us to see beyond the object, like an energetics kind of No. No.
No. No. No. It’s nothing like that. No.
No. No. No. You you were saying that Buddha sees things differently than us. So I’m just trying to understand.
What do we see? What does that mean? Yeah, right. Well, he sees things as empty of inherent See, when we see this cup, we have to try and work out how our right now, we are experiencing this cup in a particular way, but because we are not great meditators or philosophers, We don’t even though we’re experiencing this cup in a particular way, and all phenomena in a particular way, we we are not conscious of how we are experiencing things, that we are experiencing things in a particular way. But the problem is the way we are seeing things or experiencing things is actually false.
It’s not the way they actually are, but we believe it is. So we have to try and check how things do exist for us. And to do that properly, we have to really develop a very calm, clear, concentrated mind. You can’t do it with a mind like that, which is what our mind is usually like. You need to make your mind like that in meditation, and then really check.
But, just in a very gross way, when we look at anything, it seems to be out there and it seems to be something separate from ourself. It doesn’t seem to have anything to do with myself. It is just there, right? And anyway, put it this way. If you check, this cup the only way this cup can exist is it exists depending on causes and conditions.
This this cup was produced. There were many conditions like the clay, the factory, the paint, and all of this stuff, the heat, and all the you know? So there’s the causes and, you know, the people working, the potter and the machines, all this. So it well, you know? So many causes and conditions made this cup, brought it into existence, and that’s the only way it could exist.
It it just didn’t magically appear. And also, if you check, this this cup can only exist depending on many parts. You know, it’s got a front and a back and a side and inside and out, the top and the bottom, and it’s got a handle, and the handle is made of parts. So it has many, many parts. Yeah.
And everything, as soon as you investigate, everything’s got parts. Parts. Parts. Bodies have got parts. Everything’s depend actually, when you check, exists depending on causes and conditions.
It depends on parts, and what is most fascinating is that actually this cup, for its existence as a cup, depends on our mind. Every time I try and do this, I can never find anything suitable. I don’t know what I’ve got. So Yep. We and we are proceeding with a couple of them to each other.
Not particularly. No. A little bit. So actually, this cup depends on causes, conditions, parts, our mind, and this is the only way this cup can exist. For a dog, a dog can see this thing, yeah, but a dog doesn’t see a cup.
It cannot see a cup. It doesn’t see it sees something here, but it and just like I see this, a dog sees this, but I see this phenomena as a cup. A dog doesn’t see it as a cup because the dog doesn’t have the mind that can label that a cup. But my mind labels this object a cup, and as soon as my mind labels it a cup, it appears back as a cup. But when we experience this, when we don’t investigate or think about it, we don’t experience this cup as depending on causes and conditions, parts, and especially our mind.
It just seems to be a cup. It doesn’t seem to, and it seems to be a cup. This is what the Buddha says, how we’re experiencing things, this cup doesn’t appear to our mind to depend on anything. Even though in reality it’s a totally dependent phenomena, it just seems to be there. And the one of the easiest way, I think, to understand this, especially how it depends on our mind, is, you know, do you think this is a nice cup?
Nice cup? Pretty? Nice? Beautiful? Something?
Yeah. I do. Nice cup. A little bit of gold on the top. Nice, you know, cup.
Nice blue. Nice blue. Nice blue. So when we when and we all have, you know, have different ideas of what’s nice and beautiful, but whenever we see something that we think, oh, I like this. This is beautiful.
When we see the beauty, the beautiful object, where is the beauty? How is this beautiful? What makes this beautiful? And sorry. Some of you many of you have heard me blab like this before, but, you know, if if we’re really honest, when we see something beautiful beautiful beautiful brocade, something, why we why do we think it’s beautiful?
Yes. You’re not supposed to say that, but that’s all true. Yes. Yeah. It actually it depends on many things, but when we see something as beautiful, it it we it’s like this object is telling me I am beautiful.
It just seems to be beautiful from its own side. Why do I think this is beautiful? Because it is beautiful. It’s really beautiful.
You know? Why do we, you know, eat a nice piece of cake? Oh, tastes nice. Where’s the nice taste? In there.
It it has a nice taste. It’s there from its side. That’s how it appears. It appears to be really there from its side. Can you you get the the something?
I’ll do it. I’ll do it. Wait a minute. Do you know what that is? No?
What’s it made of? Metal. Right. Do do you know what that is? Brass bottle.
Brass bottle. Made of metal, made by a human being. This is metal made by a human being. So you know what this is. Why don’t you know what that is?
You can see this. You can see that. Why don’t you know what this is? Oh, you know. That’s it.
Sorry, Oliver. Who doesn’t know what does someone not not know what this is? Right. Okay. You know what that is?
Yeah. And like I said, that’s metal and it’s made by a human being. This is metal made by a human being. You’re seeing both of these things. How come you know what this is and you don’t know what that is?
It’s not very bright, are you? The The point I’m trying to make is when we look at this, because we know what it is, it just seems obviously that this is a brass bowl or it’s a gong. You know, it’s a but you know that, right? And so once we know what it is, and we only know what it is because we’ve been told, you know, or read or something, so depending on something, we know what that is. But once we know what it is, whenever you see something like this, it’s just obvious that that is a bowl.
It’s obvious, you know, it’s like it’s telling me I’m a little bowl. But if that was the way it actually existed, since this is metal and made by a human being just like that and you’re seeing this with your eye, you know, why don’t you know what this is? And the point is this thing, like absolutely everything, has no power, ability or whatsoever to make you know what it is. None. It can’t tell you that I am a dorgy and what a dorgy means.
It can’t tell you anything. It can’t even tell you it’s metal. It can’t anything. All of that comes from your mind. But when we look at it, when we look at anything, when we experience anything, it doesn’t, in the moment, when we don’t analyse, it doesn’t appear to depend on our minds.
It just appears as though that’s it, from its side. And if it’s beautiful, that beauty doesn’t appear as though that depends on my mind labelling it beautiful, it appears as though it is really beautiful from its side. So that appearance is false. It is a complete illusion. Because this this is, you know, this is this seems to be saying I am a bowl, but it’s not telling us I’m a bowl.
It it can’t. It never has been able to and never will. It can’t say I’m metal, I’m beautiful, I’m this, I’m that. Nothing. But it seems to.
And that’s the illusion we live under. This is good. This is bad. This is beautiful. This is ugly.
This is this. This is that. This is this. This is permanent. This is that.
This is everything. And we and and then we grasp that that is a hundred percent true. But in reality, it is a hundred percent illusion. Nothing nothing exists that way, and nothing can exist that way. So that’s what this Heart Sūtra is saying.
And it yeah. Because it goes on to say, also at that time, the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom, so he was doing this meditation on looking at actual nature of things and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. So remember we talked about the five aggregates last week, which is how we exist, the aggregate of body and the four aggregates of mind, feelings, discrimination, compositional factors, and primary consciousnesses. So Avalokiteśvara is perceiving this meditation on the true nature of things is that everything that makes up our being, all of that lacks inherent existence. It doesn’t exist from its own side under its own power the way it appears.
You know, our body just doesn’t exist as a as a yeah. Because inherent existence is sorry. The way things appear to us, they appear as though they do not depend on causes and conditions, don’t depend on parts, and it doesn’t depend on our mind. If that appearance if things did exist that way, it would mean that they were independent, not depending on anything. And so that appearance is referred to as inherent existence, That things appear to inherently exist.
They appear to exist as though they don’t depend on anything. They are just inherently really like that from their own side under their own power, that they are good, bad, beautiful, ugly, this or that, a dog or a cat, a tree or a cup from their own side. But they’re not. They appear to be like that, very convincingly. We’re all convinced of it.
We’re trapped in that illusion. But it’s it actually, everything depends on so many things, but most especially our mind. So we all have the karma to more or less see the same kind of cup. Right? We all see a white China cup with blue Chinese designs and everything on it.
Yeah. So we all have the karma to to experience something in that way and this world in a particular way. But also, we are experiencing the world with our own unique mind. And so we all live in our own little world, which is similar to other people’s worlds, but not the same. Because as I often say, even though I don’t really understand it myself, but, you know, as we sit in this room, we are all at a very, very, you know what’s the word?
I don’t know. Subtle way, so subtle that we’re not even conscious of it, we are all assuming that what we are seeing and experiencing in this room is what everyone else in the room is experiencing. But we’re not. Because we’re all in our own little room here. Because the room I’m in exists depending on my mind, not your mind, on my mind.
And the room you’re in depends on your mind, which is not my mind. It’s similar, but it’s not exactly the same. So that’s very interesting. And as I often point out, sorry, you know, if you check, when people have arguments and conflicts and difficulties with each other, there are many reasons for this, why we fight with each other and argue and disagree, but just consider that one fundamental reason is when we argue about something, is that I say, this is good, and you say it’s bad. So I say, you’re wrong, it’s good.
And you say, you’re wrong, it’s bad. And so we argue and argue. And the argument is based on the fact that when I say it’s good and you say it’s wrong, I am assuming, because I can see that it’s good, it’s really good from its own side, under its own power. It’s definitely really good. The only reason you’re saying it’s bad is because, A, you must be stupid, or you’re just being nasty, because it’s obviously good.
You know? And why are you saying it’s bad when it’s good? And then you’re thinking, why is he saying it’s good when it’s obviously bad? Because you can see that it’s really bad. There are two realities going on, and we’re assuming that there’s one.
Yeah? And we are grasping that I am right. Why am I right? Because it’s appearing to my mind. You know, it’s right there.
And, of course, the and the same for the other person. Amazing. And then, of course, another person comes along and has another view. Right? And then another one has another view.
It’s amazing that we’re still alive together with each other. It’s all just me, though, don’t you? Yes. We do. Yes.
But see, it’s because we see things as inherently existing that they’re really there with very fixed, definite characteristics which are there, not coming from me, not dependent on me. They’re really there. Now I’m convinced they’re really there. It’s only because of that illusion, that ignorant illusion. It’s only because of that that we develop afflicted desire for something that is really beautiful.
This is really beautiful, which means it’s really good and it represents real happiness. So I want it. I want to be happy. And there it is, real happiness, real beauty, real goodness from its own side, and it’s out there, separate from me, independent of me, so I crave it. I need it.
I’ll I’ll put this goodness, this happiness, this beauty into me because it’s out there separate. So there’s that craving and desire for it. If we didn’t have that wrong view, we wouldn’t have desire, afflicted desire. We wouldn’t have this agitated, craving, discontent. And of course, the same, you know, because it’s really bad, we develop aversion and anger because it’s really bad.
And we get jealous because someone’s really got some something really better than me. It’s much better. It’s really good. I don’t have it. They have got it.
Or we develop pride because I’m really better than other people. So so it’s all due to our ignorance. So our our our disturb all those thoughts disturb our mind, and then we act on them and create negative imprints that ripen us more suffering. So it’s all due to this wrong view that we have of of stuff and ourself, and the two things feed each other because we we have a wrong view of self. We have a wrong view of other because we have a wrong view of other.
It reinforces our wrong view of self because yeah. One day we’ll get to the Heart Sūtra, but it’s, you it’s all about this. No, it’s all about what I’m saying, this Heart Sūtra is about this, this is exactly the inherent nature, and this applies to me, yourself, you know? We have a body, we have the five aggregates, there’s the body and all the aspects of the mind. So, you know, then there’s me.
Then we talk about me. Me, me, me, me, me. I, I, I, me, me, me, me, me, me, the time. So what is me? What is me?
Am I my body? Am I my mind? Am I both? Am I something separate? What what am I?
How does I exist? Quick answer. Deep down, what we are grasping at is we grasp just like we think there’s a real cup out there in dependence upon its own side. We think there is a real me that really exists from its own side under its own power, which is not the body and is not the mind. His Holiness gives the example in this commentary is that, you know, to some extent, we do identify that sometimes that we’re our body.
You know, when people praise, you know, say we’re nice looking, we think, you know, that makes us happy. We think, oh, you know, I I I’m nice looking. Or if someone says you’re ugly, then we get upset. Know, I’m I am ugly. But actually, they’re just talking about our body.
But deep down, there’s a sense that, you know, I I have a body. There’s a me that has a body. And His Holiness gives the example, if we had some terrible sickness in our body and by some miracle we could get a new body, would we take it or not? Change this body for another one, and most certainly we would probably, because we think I will have it, I’ll get a new body. So that shows how we, you know, deep down, there is a sense that there’s a me that doesn’t that is not this body.
And same with the mind. If our mind, you know, if we if we were had the chance, if, you know, His Holiness came along and said, well, I can give you a a mind free free of all delusions, a really blissful mind free of delusions. Would you like it? Yes, thanks. So we also sort of see that our mind isn’t us.
Sometimes we do, but deep down, there’s a grasping that there is a real me that doesn’t depend on the body and mind. Because we talk about my body, yeah? My body and my mind. There’s a me. We believe there’s a me that has a body, and there’s a me that has a mind, that owns, possesses a mind.
But that me is an illusion. It simply doesn’t exist at all. There is a me that does exist, just like there is a cup that exists, but an inherently existing cup doesn’t exist at all. That’s just an illusion. But there is a cup here, a dependently arising cup.
And there is a me here, but not a truly existing me. There’s a me that arises depending on the body and mind. I’d like to conclude because we’re by saying sorry. Most of you have heard me say all these things again before, but I think it’s really good to repeat them cause one day we’ll really get it, including myself. One very powerful but very sad way that shows how we are all ignorant and grasping at this wrong view of self, believing there is this inherently existing I that is not the body and not the mind, is that we all want to be happy.
We are all trying to be happy all the time. But how are we doing that? Even as Buddhists, we try to be happy by depending on external stuff. We think if I have enough friends, if I have enough money, enough possessions, enough food, enough nice clothes, a nice hair, you know, and stuff, if I have enough of these things and the things that I like, if I have the things I like in sufficient numbers, I will be happy. Right?
That’s what we think and how we live our life, yeah? Believing there is an I that doesn’t depend on the mind, but the I that does exist, and the only I that can exist, is an I that arises depending on the body and mind. It’s not the body, it’s not the mind, it’s not both, but it’s something that arises depending on them. And the point is that particularly I depend on my mind. So if my mind is like that, I am unhappy.
I am suffering. I am confused and agitated. So if my mind is out of control, it doesn’t matter how many friends, money, possessions I’ve got, I will never be happy. Never. While the delusions are going berserk, it’s impossible.
And that’s how we live our life, thinking we don’t take care of our life. We don’t take care of it at all. And we think I am going to be happy because we think there is an I that isn’t related to the mind at all. And that ‘I’ that is not related to the mind simply doesn’t exist. It’s just an illusion.
The ‘I’ that does exist totally depends on our state of mind. Therefore, the only way I can be happy is to take care of my mind. Case closed. Right. So so we can dedicate.
Don’t go yet. Oh, you can if you like, then. Having patiently listened to that ranting, once some merit hopefully has been created, so we can dedicate this to achieving enlightenment, to realising emptiness and depending on that, achieving enlightenment so that we can benefit all sentient beings. So page nine. Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state.
May the precious Bodhimind, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase faith in all. Due to these merits, may all the obstacles to Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s health and long life instantly removed. May Rinpoche remain and teach us until Samsāra ends, and may all his and Lama Yeshe’s holy wishes be instantly fulfilled. May Lama Osel Rinpoche have a long and healthy life.
May he be able to complete all his studies without hindrance and become a great holder and teacher of Sūtra and Tantra in this life. May he be of greatest benefit to all sentient beings. May all the obstacles to the quick success of the building of the Maitreya statue be instantly destroyed. May these great statues of Maitreya be accomplished exactly according to the wishes of Lama Yeshe and Lama Zopa Rinpoche. May all the centers and projects of the FPMT be free of obstacles to spread the holy Dharma of Buddha Śākyamūni, in particular the teachings of Lama Tsongkhapa.
May all sentient beings be free from suffering and achieve every happiness and the highest state of enlightenment. May all the students and friends who work so hard for the FPMT in the service of the Dharma and who dedicate their lives for Buddha’s teachings and to relieve the suffering of sentient beings have long and healthy lives. May they realize the path to enlightenment in their own minds as quickly as possible. May all those who rely on and who have made specific requests to Lama Zopa Rinpoche be free of all obstacles to having long and healthy lives, be able to achieve all the realizations of the path in this lifetime. May all the students’ activities please the virtuous friends in all their lives, may they be guided by perfectly qualified Mahāyāna virtuous friends, and may all their wishes succeed immediately according to the Dharma.
So normally we say this remembering the kindness prayer, but maybe Judy, do you mind if we could do some Medicine Buddha mantras? Can you dig that up? Just a few. We’ll just continue doing the long life prayers in the meantime. Page thirteen.
Savior of the snow land teachings and transmigratory beings who makes extremely clear the path that is unification of emptiness and compassion to the lotus holder, Tenzing Gyatso, I beseech, may all your holy wishes be spontaneously fulfilled. You who uphold the subduer’s moral way, who serve as the bountiful bearer of all, sustaining, preserving, spreading Mañjuśrī’s victorious doctrine, who masterfully accomplished magnificent prayers honoring the Three Jewels. Savior of myself and others, your disciples, please, please live long. Lord of Dharma, who in accordance with the various dispositions of those to be subdued, makes clear in the light of your well spoken advice the sacred Ganden tradition, essence of Buddha’s teachings, O foremost and holy Lama, to you who are supreme, O Lama, please, please live long. Since there’s been this terrible earthquake in Nepal and thousands and thousands of people have died and there’s been just terrible destruction and this is going to bring a lot of misery to lot of people for unfortunately a very long time in this very poor, corrupt country.
If we could just do some Medicine Buddha mantras, because my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, who is Nepalese, says this is a good mantra for the people who have died and for the people who have been affected anyway. So the mantra is on page nine where it says the common pronunciation. We’ll do that mantra just twenty one times. This is the Medicine Buddha here, so if you can try and visualise the Medicine Buddha sending out rays of blue light to all beings affected in Nepal, Helping them in whatever way is necessary, either to achieve a good rebirth or to be free of pain and harm and so on. On.
Okay. Thank you very much. So there will be a Medicine Buddha puja tomorrow night here at seven fifteen, especially dedicated for the people who are suffering in Nepal. So it’d be great if people could come. Unfortunately, I can’t come because I’m going to Broome tomorrow to teach until Monday.
I’ll be back Monday. So but if people could come along and add their good energy to towards the people of Nepal, that would be wonderful. Our mother monastery is in Kathmandu. It was quite badly damaged, and the nunnery also has been quite badly affected. So and Lama Zopa Rinpoche is in Nepal with Lama Osel who’s there at the same time.
So yeah. And the little village where Lama Zopa Rinpoche was born, which is called Thame, half the half of the village has been completely destroyed. So Rinpoche is sending lots of aid out there now because he yeah. So it’s really, really a very horrible, sad situation in such a yeah, with a country with very, you know, very poor and very, you know, limited infrastructure to sort of deal with something like this. Okay.
Anyway, thank you very much. We can finish if you feel com those people who feel comfortable to do so. We finish with three prostrations to the Triple Gem.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
- The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- transmigratory beings dro wa (Tib)
- Sentient beings who pass from one realm to another, taking rebirth within cyclic existence. LYWA
- tsog ganachakra (Skt)
- Literally, gathering - a gathering of offering substances and a gathering of disciples to make the offering. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.