1 h 59 min · 11,472 words · 7 May 2015 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 120-minute teaching, Ven Thubten Dondrub introduces the Heart Sūtra, one of Buddhism’s most condensed texts on the nature of reality. He opens by establishing the historical and philosophical context: the Buddha taught three turnings of the wheel of Dharma, with the second turning at Vulture’s Peak focusing on the perfection of wisdom—the subject of this sūtra. Dondrub walks through the sūtra’s opening passage, where Avalokiteśvara responds to Śāriputra’s question about how to practice profound wisdom. A central theme emerges: the distinction between Theravāda (individual vehicle) and Mahāyāna approaches, particularly regarding whether all beings have Buddha nature and can achieve enlightenment. Dondrub explains the four Buddhist philosophical schools and argues that the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika school presents the highest view, understanding emptiness through dependent arising. He illustrates this with concrete examples—a flower with parts, a letter Z on paper—showing how we instinctively grasp at inherent existence when things actually arise only through causes, conditions, parts, and mind-labeling. The teaching is dense with philosophical scaffolding but pitched at serious practitioners already engaged with Buddhist study and meditation.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Heart Sūtra 3 2015 05 07.mp3
UUID: 793d00a8-679f-407c-b8e5-11817ad9f96c
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Heart Sūtra (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2015-05-07
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 119.8 minutes
Words: ~11,469
I prostrate to the Ārya Triple Gem. Thus did I hear at one time the Bhagwan was dwelling on Vulture’s Peak Mountain in Rajgriha together with a community of monks and a great community of Bodhisattvas. At that time, the Bhagawan was absorbed in a concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time, the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then, through the power of Buddha, the Venerable Śāriputra said this to the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, how should any son of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom?
He said that, and the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, said this to the Venerable Śāriputra. Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this, correctly and repeatedly, beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Form is empty. Emptiness is form. This is not other than form.
Form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors and consciousness are empty. Śāriputra, likewise all phenomena are emptiness, without characteristic, unproduced, unceased, stainless, not without stain, not deficient, not fulfilled. Śāriputra, therefore in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odour, no taste, no object of touch and no phenomena. There is no eye element and so on, up to including no mind element and no mental consciousness element.
There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on, up to and including no ageing and death and no extinction of ageing and death. Similarly, there is no suffering, origination, cessation and path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment and also no non attainment. Therefore, because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell in the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear. Having completely passed beyond error, they reach the endpoint of nirvana.
All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly, completely awaken to unsurpassable, perfect, complete enlightenment in reliance on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequaled, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as truth, since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared. Tadyatha, Gate Gate, Pāragate, Pārasamgate, Bodhi Svāhā. Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva, Mahāsattva should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that.
Then the Bhagawan arose from that concentration and commended the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying, Well said, well said, son of the lineage. It is like that. It is like that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom, just as you have indicated, even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagawan having thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding in their entirety, along with the world of gods, humans, asuras and Gandharvas were overjoyed and highly praised that spoken by the Bhagawan.
I prostrate to the gathering of dakinis and the three places who abide in the holy yoga of pure space by your powers of clairvoyance and magical emanation. Look after practitioners like a mother, her child. Tadyatha, Gate Gate, Pāragate, Pārasamgate, Bodhi Svāhā. By the teachings of the three supreme jewels possessing the power of truth, may inner and outer hindrances be transformed. May they be dispelled.
May they be pacified. May they be completely pacified. May all negative forces opposed to dharma be completely pacified. May the host of eighty thousand obstacles be pacified, separated from problems and harmful conditions to dharma. May all enjoyments be in accord with the dharma, and may there be auspiciousness and perfect happiness here right now.
Obeisance to my Guru and protector, Mañjuśrī, who holds to his heart a scriptural text symbolic of his seeing all things as they are, whose understanding shines forth as the sun, unclouded by defilements or traces of ignorance, who teaches in sixty ways with the patient love of a father for his only child, all creatures caught in the prison of Samsāra, confused in the darkness of their ignorance, overwhelmed by their suffering. You, whose dragon thunder proclamation of the dharma arouses us from the stupor of our delusions and frees us from the iron chains of our karma, whose powerful sword of wisdom hews down suffering wherever its sprouts appear, clearing away the darkness of all ignorance. I entreat you, O Mañjuśrī, whose princely body is adorned with the one hundred and twelve marks of a Buddha, who has completed the ten stages achieving the highest perfection of a bodhisattva, who has been pure from the beginning, O Mañjuśrī, O Loving One, with the brilliance of your wisdom, illuminate the darkness enclosing my mind, enlighten my intelligence and wisdom, so that I may gain insight into Buddha’s words and the texts that explain them. So these are the preparatory prayers.
So now one more is offering the mandala. This is the tradition to request the teachings. So we visualize Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as our source of refuge, inspiration and guidance, and make an offering of all the things in the universe, a mandala of the whole universe, especially the beautiful things in it, especially those that we are most attached to. So we make that offering as a way to request the teachings, to overcome our delusions that are obstacles to the practice of the teachings. And by making this offering we accumulate lots of merit, which is the basis for being able to understand the teachings, practice them, and realize them.
So in Lama Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo, the great exposition on the path to enlightenment, when talking about the mandala offering, all that Lama Tsongkhapa says, and Rinpoche thinks this is very wonderful, all that he says about the mandala is, Visualize clearly. That’s the most important thing. But with a mind, someone’s visualising with the mental consciousness, visualising the offerings, but that mental consciousness should be mixed with that mental factor of wanting to give. Really wanting to give. Recognizing that the teachings are the most precious thing in the entire universe, so therefore willing to give the whole universe in order to receive the teachings.
And of course, don’t worry, this is not about me teaching. This is being able to really receive the teachings from the Buddha. So now as we continue to visualise the Buddha in front of us, and particularly we focus on thinking of all sentient beings around us, trying to have that awareness of how they are all incredibly kind to me, I totally depend on them, and yet all of them are suffering in saṃsāra. So no matter what, I have to achieve enlightenment, to repay their kindness by helping them become free of all causes of suffering, helping them to achieve peerless, everlasting happiness. So to achieve enlightenment, that depends on developing the wisdom that destroys which is the only thing that can destroy all those obscurations that are covering the mind, which has Buddha potential.
So when those obscurations are completely removed, omniscience is achieved. So to get rid of those obscurations, I have to develop the wisdom, realising the true nature, the empty nature of myself and all phenomena. So for this reason, I’ll study the Heart Sūtra which is on this subject. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma and the Supreme Assembly by the merits I create through teaching the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings?
So thinking the Buddha is pleased with our motivation, we can imagine the Buddha now approaching the crown of our head and when directly above our crown, we imagine the Buddha turns to face the same direction as ourself and then dissolves into blissful golden light so that that light then can pour down into us, blessing our mind. So then briefly, we can do the nine round breathing exercise or any other breathing meditation, you know, just to let the mind become a little bit calmer, clearer, a little bit more focused so we can use that level of mind to listen to, think about the Buddhist teachings tonight. Okay. Thank you. So I think as everyone is aware, the Heart of the Perfection of Wisdom Sūtra is a very condensed teaching, condensing just the very essence of what the Buddha taught about the true nature, the actual nature of how the self and phenomena exist.
So to really understand this sūtra, one has to study the philosophical teachings of the Buddha, and it is those philosophical teachings which go into the nature of reality. So I’ll talk a little bit about that later on, but firstly, we’ll just read what we’ve covered so far, which is not very much. Sorry. So all sutras start in the Tibetan tradition, they place they have the name in Sanskrit to show that this is an authentic sūtra. It’s not something made up in Tibet, but this is following the authentic lineage of the teachings.
And when it says, Thus did I hear it one time, so this is referring to Ānanda, who was the Buddha’s attendant for many years. So he heard all these teachings. So the Bhagawan is referring to the Buddha, who was dwelling on Vultures Peak Mountain in Rajgriya. So Rajgriha was the capital of the capital of Magadha, where at the time of the Buddha, the king was Bimbisāra. So he was I think it was him or his father who was the one of the first rulers of the princely states of India to he was the first one to become a a disciple of the Buddha.
Because unlike Buddhism in the West, which has kind of moved from the bottom up, first with us old hippies or young hippies at the time, with no money and no status, became Buddhists. Now you have all sorts of university professors teaching Buddhism and etcetera etcetera. Whereas in India, the first disciples of the Buddha were from the very upper, the highest classes because the Buddha himself was a prince, Prince Siddhartha. And so he attracted all of these extremely powerful people, and so king I think it was king Bimbisāra’s father, actually, who became his first the first king of the princely states who became one of his disciples. So the Buddha was teaching a great community of monks, meaning that they were all arhats, and a great community of bodhisattvas.
At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. So I forgot to mention this before, but the term categories of phenomena is really referring to all the different aspects of phenomena. All the different types of phenomena in Buddhism are subsumed under three categories. There are the five skandhas, the form skandhas, and the other four skandhas of the mind, which is feelings, discriminations, compositional factors, and primary consciousnesses. So then another way of just looking at categorising phenomena is to talk about what are called the twelve sources.
So this is talking about the six sense consciousnesses, the eye consciousness, the ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness, body consciousness, and the mental consciousness, and the objects of those consciousnesses. So, of course, the object of the eye consciousness No, no, start again. So when we talk about the twelve sources, it’s talking about the eye and the object of the eye, which is shapes and colours, then there well, visual objects. No. We won’t go into the details.
Visual objects, then the objects of the ear, which is sounds, objects of the nose, which is smells, objects of the tongue, which is taste, objects of the body consciousness, which is tactile sensations, and then the object of the mind, which is thoughts. So that makes twelve things, the six organs. In this case, the mind is said to be an organ, it’s not a physical organ, but it can be classified that way. And then there are the objects of those things. Yeah.
So then the other category of phenomena, another more detailed way of talking about all the categories of phenomena are what are said to be the eighteen constituents. So this is the twelve sources plus the six consciousnesses. So you’ve got the eye, the eye consciousness, and the object of the eye consciousness. So then you’ve got the ear, the ear consciousness, and object of the ear consciousness, which is sound, like that. Alright?
So that makes eighteen constituents. So you’ve got the five aggregates, the five aggregates, the twelve sources and the eighteen constituents. So in this way, that includes all phenomena because you’ve got the body and all the things that the body experiences, which is all other phenomena. Okay? So the Buddha no, sorry.
Yes, the Buddha was absorbed in the concentration on all of these categories of phenomena called profound perception. So he was looking at the emptiness of all of these things, all phenomena. Alright. So this was taking place at Vulture’s Peak Mountain, which is just outside of the Rajgriya, the capital of Magadha. Also at that time, the bodhisattva Mahāsattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature.
Alright. Inherent nature. So this, I’ve mentioned before, this is a key concept to understand, this inherent nature, because this is referring to the false way things appear to us. They appear to inherently exist, whereas the way they actually appear toward the unmistaken mind, which is what the Buddha has, and in this case Avalokiteśvara, is things appear empty of inherent existence, or completely lacking that inherent existence. So what inherent existence is, we’ll just leave for the time being.
I tried to talk a little bit about it last week. I’ll talk more about it now later on, but we’ll just sort of progress in the sūtra a little bit more. It then says, then through the power of Buddha, the venerable Śāriputra said this to the bodhisattva, mahasattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara. In other words, Śāriputra was inspired unknowingly by the Buddha. He was influenced by the Buddha to ask this question of Avalokiteśvara.
Right? And the question that the Buddha influenced Sharaputra to ask Avalokiteśvara was, how should any son of the lineage train who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom? So just before we progress, I hope I can remember this. Yes. So there are said to be three kinds of sutras.
So generally, when we talk about a sūtra, of course there are the Pāli Sutras, which contain the teachings of the individual vehicle, which are really only about achieving one’s own freedom from suffering so that one can achieve enlightenment. And then there are the Mahāyāna Sutras, which are about their ultimate aim is to achieve enlightenment. Generally speaking, when we talk about a sūtra, it’s a teaching given by the Buddha at one time, given by the Buddha, spoken by the Buddha. That’s generally what a sūtra is referring to. But reality, not all sutras actually were directly spoken by the Buddha.
There are two other categories of sutras. Some sutras were spoken by disciples on behalf of the Buddha, and sutras were spoken by a disciple due to the influence of the Buddha. So this sūtra, the Heart Sūtra, is an example mainly of that third category. It’s an example of categories two and three. It wasn’t directly spoken by the Buddha.
It was spoken by a disciple of the Buddha, which was Avalokiteśvara, but it was spoken under the influence of the Buddha because the Buddha influenced Śāriputra to ask Avalokiteśvara a question, and the rest of the sūtra is mainly Avalokiteśvara speaking, not the Buddha. Right? Good. No. Yeah.
Okay. So anyway, this is I don’t know if you’ve ever noticed this bit or you should have, but whether you’ve ever thought about it, noticed it and thought about it, especially the the women here. I’m sure you must have done this. But in in this paragraph here, Śāriputra asks the question, how should any son of the lineage practise? Yeah?
And and in response, later on, Avalokiteśvara says, Any son or daughter of the lineage. Right? So that’s interesting. And what is more complicated? So every translation of this sūtra that I’ve read and this one we’re using here is the official FPMT translation which is really very good.
And there are older ones. All of the ones I’ve read are like this, where Ānanda says, How does any son of the daughter train? And Avalokiteśvara says, Well, any son or daughter. But in this text, which is a commentary on the Heart Sūtra by the Dalai Lama, he seems to escape that and just says that Śāriputra says, How does any son or daughter of the lineage practice? So I’m not quite sure if in the Tibetan tradition there are different versions of this sūtra.
There are different versions of the Heart Sūtra. The Chinese version is much shorter than the Tibetan one. Anyway, I find that kind of interesting, but my understanding of what this is about is that Śāriputra is an Arhat. He is not a bodhisattva. And so his interest so he comes from the tradition of the teachings about the individual vehicle that the Buddha gave.
And according to the so the teachings that are preserved in the Pāli Canon and the teachings of the Mahāyāna are all from the Buddha, but there are some very significant differences between them. Of course, one obvious difference is that the Pāli sutras emphasise achieving nirvana, liberation from saṃsāra, Whereas the Mahāyāna Sutras say, We have to achieve more than that, we have to achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings. So that’s one difference. But another significant difference is that according to the philosophical outlook of the Pāli Sutras, the idea of Buddha nature doesn’t exist. That does not exist in the Theravāda teachings.
It’s only in the Mahāyāna Sutras that the concept that every mind has Buddha nature exists. And because of that, because the Mahāyāna Sutras say every mind has Buddha nature, it means every sentient being has the potential to become a Buddha, so we should try. So it doesn’t make sense according to the Pāli Sūtra to try to be a Buddha because most sentient beings don’t have the potential to become Buddhas. Prince Siddhartha did. They they don’t deny the Pāli Sutras do say that there are such things as bodhisattvas, and bodhisattvas can become buddhas, but this is a very rare thing.
I mean, it is rare in some ways, but is the ability to achieve enlightenment or the potential to achieve enlightenment only exists in a very, very rare number of beings, and Prince Siddhartha was one of those. But the vast majority of sentient beings don’t have that potential, whereas the Mahāyāna Sutras say, every sentient being, every mind has Buddha nature. So that’s significant. And also, what I’m the point I’m trying to get to is that in the Pāli Sutras, one of the underlying ideas is that not only can what the most one can achieve is liberation from saṃsāra, nirvana, but to do that, you have to be a man. You have to be reborn a man.
That’s the view. So that’s why Śāriputra is saying, how does a son of the lineage practice? Because only a son of the lineage so in his mind, only a male could achieve enlightenment. If a male can only achieve nirvana, then for sure, only a male could achieve enlightenment. But later on in his response, Avalokiteśvara, who is a bodhisattva, who is a follower of the Mahāyāna teachings, says, he doesn’t know, nastily pointed out in reply he says, Any son, not just some, any son of the lineage and any daughter of the lineage can achieve enlightenment.
So when it says, just go back to that paragraph, any son of the lineage, son of the lineage is referring to there are three lineage, it is believed sentient beings have well, if you okay. Don’t know how to put this. Anyway, there are three lineages of sentient beings. There are those who have a natural inclination to follow the path to liberation. Oh, okay.
Have to explain. The teachings about achieving nirvana, freedom from saṃsāra, there are two kinds of arhats who have achieved freedom from saṃsāra. There are what are called śrāvakas, that Sanskrit term which is a śrāvaka, and that term is translated in English as a hearer. So what this refers to is a person who achieves enlightenment, sorry, nirvana by hearing the teachings directly from a Buddha and then putting those teachings into practice. So for example, Ānanda, the Buddha’s disciple, Śāriputra, Maudgalyayāna, all these people were arhats and they were Śrāvaka arhats.
They heard in that life teachings directly from the Buddha, put them into practise, and achieved liberation and experienced the state of nirvana. There is another kind of arhatship/arhat which is much more rare, These are called, in Sanskrit, they are called Pratyekabuddha. That term is translated in English as a solitary realiser. So these very rare beings hear the teachings, of course, from the Buddha at some point, but after many, many lifetimes later, they achieve liberation from saṃsāra in isolation, you know, far away and unconnected with all other living beings. So their solitary realisers.
You know, they’ve heard the teachings at some point, but then long after the Buddha has departed the world, many lifetimes later, these beings achieve liberation, some nirvana. So these are called solitary realisers or Pratyekabuddha, of which there are two kinds, but I won’t go into that. So these refer to the two kinds of lineages. There’s the lineage of the Shravakas, the hearers, and then there’s the lineage of the solitary realisers. So there are some people who have this natural inclination or potential to achieve nirvana by hearing the Buddha and achieving nirvana more or less in that lifetime or very quickly soon after.
Then there are other sentient beings who have this other lineage or potential which is to become a solitary realiser. And then the third kind of lineage is the bodhisattva lineage, those people who have a connection with the Mahāyāna teachings. This is why the Buddha taught many different things, because the enlightened mind sees the different potentials and personalities and characteristics of sentient beings. Some people argue, well, why didn’t the Buddha teach just one thing? It keeps it simple.
Well, that sounds great, but people have very different personalities and ways of understanding and so on. So if there was just one teaching, it wouldn’t help everyone. So the Buddha taught according to the minds of different people. And one will discover that among Buddhists, there are people who feel very comfortable with the Theravāda teachings, the teachings of the individual vehicle, and the idea of achieving enlightenment seems just completely ridiculous. Some people would argue it’s kind of very egotistical.
So they have no connection with it, no belief in it. But then there are other people who have some admiration hopefully us, who who have, you know, some admiration for these teachings and and think, oh, this is possible. This makes sense in some way. So hopefully we are all sons and daughters of the Mahāyāna lineage, because here that’s what it’s referring to specifically. There are these three kinds of lineages, but specifically here, Śāriputra is asking about, what about the sons of the lineage who are connected to the Mahāyāna teachings?
How should such a person practice to the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom. Although in general it is said that there are these three kinds of lineages, also according to the teachings, ultimately everyone will become, you know, enter the bodhisattva lineage, because ultimately everyone will achieve enlightenment, which we talked about last week briefly about how people become arhats, but at some point the Buddhas somehow encouraged these arhats to enter the bodhisattva path, that there’s more to do. They have to purify their mind of these subtle obscurations and achieve enlightenment. So it’s particularly in the Lotus Sūtra that talks about these things, how all beings have Buddha nature and all beings will achieve enlightenment. This is why it’s quite a short sūtra, why it is such an incredibly popular sūtra, because it’s so inspiring to think everyone, no matter how deluded one is, one has this Buddha nature within.
It’s really important to try and meditate and think about one’s Buddha nature. That this is the very, very nature of our mind. It’s not some kind of nice topping. It is our mind is pervaded by Buddha nature. Our mind has the potential of every good quality.
Every mind has the potential of every good quality. Every mind has the natural, the nature of bliss, perfect bliss. Every mind has the potential of perfect wisdom, perfect love, compassion, etcetera, etcetera. That is our Buddha nature. In a very general way of talking about what Buddha nature is, Very technically, what our Buddha nature is really referring to is in the Gelugpa tradition, which we follow here, it is referring to the emptiness of the mind.
That’s what our Buddha nature actually refers to. So he said that, so Śāriputra said that, and the bodhisattva, mahasattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara, said this to the venerable Śāriputra. I’ve forgotten what Śāriputra means. Śāriputra basically means the son of Shari. Sari was his mother.
Putra means son, so he he was the son of Sari. Śāriputra, I’m not sure. Anyway, Śāriputra. So now Avalokiteśvara responds to that question where he very significantly says, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage. So any sentient being or any human being, male or female, who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom I say human being because it’s really, you know, as a human being, one practises as a male or female dog.
One can’t really do this practise or as a preta or in the hell realms. Any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this, correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. So this is what we have to do if we wish to practise the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom. So what that activity is meditation, right? Or looking into the nature of ourself and all phenomena.
And of course, a son or a daughter of the lineage does wish to do so because they have the wish to as a bodhisattva, they have generated the wish to benefit all sentient beings, to lead them to enlightenment, so they themselves, a bodhisattva, wants to achieve enlightenment, and they know to achieve enlightenment, they have to free their mind of all obscurations, so they have to develop this wisdom, because it’s only this wisdom that’s going to free our mind. So they do have this wish, so this is something that we need to cultivate, this wish to develop this wisdom. And that will come also from understanding that we are suffering, there is a cause of that suffering, And while that cause of suffering exists, we will continue to suffer. Our suffering is never going to mysteriously stop. And none of the ordinary things that we are doing to try and overcome our suffering, like have lots of money and friends and go here and there and whatever, none of that is going to stop our suffering at all.
In fact, much of it can just make it worse in various ways. So what we have to do is study the teachings until we reach the point where we really understand that I have to get rid of the causes of my suffering. And that also comes from realising my suffering is not just referring to having toothaches or getting cancer or Ebola or growing old. It’s about being reborn in saṃsāra over and over and over and over and over again and experiencing every kind of suffering over and over and over again, including the inconceivable sufferings of the lower realms. As I often say, Lama Zopa Rinpoche once said, if you could experience the mind of a dog for one night, you would never sleep again.
Many people think dogs, you know, are having such a terrific time, wonderful time. People want to be dogs, and people want to be dolphins and porpoises or birds floating and flapping in the sky. Wouldn’t that be wonderful? No, it wouldn’t. It’s suffering in in so many ways.
Yeah. And what we have to remind ourselves is as we are now, our suffering is nothing compared to most human beings. It’s nothing. Yeah? And then human suffering is nothing compared to the suffering of the lower realms.
And then, you know, even the suffering of one lifetime in the lowest realms is nothing compared to endless suffering in the lower realms. So none of that’s gonna go away automatically, just disappear, because the cause is there, so it’s gonna go on and on and on. So we have to think about that, you know? In the context, to think about it without anything to balance that could drive us crazy and want to commit suicide. One has to think of it in the context that we have the precious human rebirth.
We have met the dharma, we have faith in it, we have all the opportunity to practise it, we have the freedom to practise it. So we need to motivate ourselves, develop this wish to do so, not only for our own sake, but then to think, you know, the suffering of others who have been so kind to me. So, yeah, then we develop that wish to develop, you know, to develop this wisdom and especially recognizing that we’ve got the greatest freedom to do that now. The greatest opportunity, the optimum chance, the precious human rebirth is the optimum chance. It doesn’t mean we we will necessarily develop this wisdom in this lifetime.
That would be pretty amazing if we did. But at least we’ve got the chance to start this, to begin to make really significant imprints in our mind. That’s why it’s so good to read the Heart Sūtra over and over and over again, to put the imprint in our mind. And the more we read it, that might encourage us to think, to develop the mind, oh, I wish I really understood what this was talking about. And that would encourage us to study the teachings, hear teachings, and study them and meditate on them and so on, and want to purify the mind so we could understand it more and accumulate merit so we could understand it more, because that’s what we have to do.
Because no matter how many teachings we hear, even from people like His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, unless we purify our mind and accumulate merit, we won’t get it. We really won’t get it. We may think we’ve got it, but we won’t completely get it. So we have to meditate on how our five aggregates are also empty of inherent nature. They are empty of everything else.
I am empty inherent nature. Everything is empty of inherent nature. So what does that mean? I don’t know. Vague idea.
So maybe to put this into context, some context, do you reckon this will be able to hear me from over there? Yeah. The the Buddhist teachings, as you all know, are usually divided. A quote is the the teachings of the individual vehicle, which is contained in the Pāli Canon. Canon with one end, isn’t it?
It’s not a canon. It’s the canon. The Pāli Canon. And the only surviving school that follows this system is the Theravāda tradition. Right?
There were how many schools? Twelve? I can’t remember now. I think twelve different schools following these traditions after the passing of the Buddha, but the only one surviving is the Theravāda tradition. And then there is the Mahāyāna.
So there are many forms of the Mahāyāna existing these days, and one of them is, of course, the Tibetan tradition. And within that, there are four schools. Four, yeah, four schools, one of which is the Gelug, and that’s us. Right? So another way of so also, in the teachings, it talks about the in general, the the teachings of the Buddha refer to as the turning of the wheel of Dharma.
Right? The turning of the wheel of Dharma. But there are said to be three three turnings, not just one, but three turnings of the wheel of Dharma. So the first one, the first turning of the wheel of Dharma was at was at the Deer Park. Sarnath.
Sandhoff. Yeah. What’s it called? Sandhoff. The Deer Park.
Sandhoff. Yes. Sandhoff. Yeah. Yeah.
Oh, let’s let’s say the Deer Park. So this is where the Buddha taught sorry. My writing is terrible. Oh, that’s even worse. Deer park.
That’s a disaster. Deer park. The deer park. So these are the teachings that that the Buddha I think I’m having flashbacks to when I was a high school teacher. I think it’s still in my mind.
Studying to expect people throwing things at the Deer Park. So in those teachings, this is where the Buddha taught the basic teaching on the four noble truths, and this is where the teachings of the individual vehicle were laid out, were set out. The second turning of the wheel of Dharma is at vulture’s peak. And this is when the Buddha taught teachings about Anyway, the the Prajñāpāramitā texts. Gosh.
This is too low. I think I have to make some excuses anyway. So of which the Heart Sutras one. So in alright. And then the third turning of the wheel was at Vaishali.
This is all the also the place where the Buddha first ordained women, where the first women became nuns. The first nun was his stepmother, Mahaprajapati, who who looked after him after his mother died. Vaishali. So this is the third turning of the wheel. Okay.
So this is also a Mahāyāna teaching. So as a result of those three turnings of the wheel of Dharma, according to the Tibetan tradition, there are four philosophical schools which talk about the nature of reality or systems of tenets. Systems of tenets. A tenet is an established belief, an established belief. So we as ordinary people don’t have tenets.
We just have ideas and blind faith things like that, generally speaking. A tenet is where someone has a belief in something that is based is very strongly established in their mind because they have very strong logical reasons to believe that. They have this whole philosophy behind that belief. So in Buddhism, there are four schools of tenets, four four tenet systems. So the there is one of which is called the Vaibhāṣika.
Another one is called the Sautrāntika. Right. The third is called the Cittamātra, And the fourth school was called. So these two schools are part of the two schools. They belong to the system of the teachings about the individual vehicle.
I’m trying to avoid the the politically incorrect term, the Hīnayāna. You know? That’s the old term. The individual vehicle. And these two systems are Mahāyāna systems, So I I won’t go into lots of details about these, but so there’s some differences between these two schools.
The one big difference between okay. So all of the four schools of Buddhism talk about selflessness, but what they mean by that varies a great deal. It varies a lot. So one big difference is that because they argue that, for example, in India, all the various Hindu schools or what are now called Hindu schools, but there were many, many sort of systems, religious and other philosophical systems existing in India. They all shared a basic belief that there was a a self, which is which is referred to by the term Ātman.
The Ātman. And all the Buddhist schools reject the idea of the Ātman, that things are things are selfless. So things don’t truly exist. So the big difference between the two schools that belong to the individual vehicle and the two schools that belong to the Mahāyāna is that these two schools both agree that the the self of the person doesn’t truly exist or doesn’t inherently exist. But external phenomena really exist the way they appear.
They they’re really there like they appear. But the person, that is selfless. That the person lacks this truly existent quality. The person doesn’t truly, inherently exist from its own side under its own power, is not substantially existing at all. But everything else really exists the way it appears.
So that is a huge difference between those two schools and these schools. Before I continue, No. I’m just thinking I don’t get anywhere. Sorry. In in Tibetan Buddhism, particularly in the Gelugpa tradition, the the lamas who’ve gone through the studies, they argue, and I think I agree with them.
I should. I’m thinking just a little dodo, that in all it is within here no. Sorry. I wish I could teach. This this middle this this term means middle way.
And, actually, it has two subschools. One is called the Sva Tantrika, and the other one is called the Prāsaṇgika. All of these have subschools too, but we won’t go into that. This school, the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika School, is said to be the actual view of the Buddha. This is this philosophical view that we need to study and understand in order to destroy ignorance.
This actually is it is this school that correctly identifies the wrong view and shows us how to destroy it, so that we can directly perceive the actual way we and all phenomena exist. So one would then think, well, if that’s true, if this is the actual view that we I need to get out of saṃsāra and and also achieve enlightenment, I should just study that. But the Tibetan lamas say no, because this system is very, very subtle and very easy to misunderstand and make very serious errors with it. So their argument is to be able to eventually actually reach the point of genuinely understanding this view, one has to first understand this view, then when you’ve understood that, to get a right understanding of this, because when you understand that, you’ll be able to understand this view, then you’ll be able to understand this view, and then you’ll be able to understand that. So that’s why it takes twenty years to become a Geshe.
So are we studying we’re not studying the first and second tenets, are we? The the this sūtra is from this point of view, yeah, in a very, very condensed form. It doesn’t go into any of the details, but all of the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras are actually from this point of view, the highest view. The argument is that the Buddha first taught the four noble truths according to these more simple philosophical views for those people who were not, I think, ready to accept the idea of vast vehicle enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. But for those who were, hence it says there was a great assembly of monks, but also a great assembly of bodhisattvas, He taught the Mahāyāna, and he taught the Prajñāpāramitā, the very profound teachings on how everything, everything, lacks inherent existence.
Nothing Although things exist, they don’t truly exist at all. They completely lack inherent existence. So even the greatest minds at the time and ever since have completely understood this teaching. You can go to universities where there are very clever philosophers who teach and write books saying that what the Buddha meant by that is that nothing exists. But of course that’s not what it means at all.
When Buddha says things don’t truly exist, it doesn’t mean they don’t exist at all. It means they don’t exist in a particular way, that they things do exist. But the way things do exist, according to the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras, is something very, very subtle, very profound, because as Rinpoche says, when when one actually gets this view, one realizes that although things don’t inherently exist, they just barely exist. They just barely exist. What the way we are experiencing things now according to the Buddha is a complete delusion.
It’s a complete delusion. The way we experience ourselves, this this board, other people, the floor we’re standing on, everything is a complete illusion. And the way things do exist is. It’s just it’s not an illusion, but it’s like an illusion. That’s pretty scary and very confusing, difficult to understand what that really means.
So because after the Buddha taught that, a lot of people freaked out, the Buddha then sort of backpedaled. Oh, I’m sorry. Didn’t really, but and then taught the third turning, which I’ve forgotten. Sorry. I’m such a poor monk and scholar.
The term terminology for it. But it’s basically the the the view of the of the Cittamātra School where he he kind of of which is a view that’s much more easy to accept, just put it that way, for the time being. Not quite so threatening as this view. So in this way, were introduced to the idea that things don’t exist the way they appear, and then people were taught progressively more profound things about how things are existing. So people could we could gradually work our way to that acceptance so we don’t reject it.
So anyway, the big difference between those two schools and the Mahāyāna schools, philosophical schools, is these schools argue that the self doesn’t truly exist, doesn’t inherently exist, phenomena do. Whereas these schools, they all say that the self doesn’t truly exist, doesn’t inherently exist, and also phenomena don’t inherently exist either. Don’t truly exist. So that’s a big difference. So in trying to understand the wrong view we have, there are a whole lot of terms that are used such as substantially existing, truly existing existing from their own side existing under their own power.
There’s some terms, and also the term inherently existing. So each of these terms has its own particular meaning, and the different schools use these different terms. But the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika school, which remember is the highest view, the correct view, they argue that in reality, all of these terms have the same meaning. Because The Cittamātra school is referred to as the mind only school because they have this very particular view, this Mahāyāna school, there’s there’s subdivisions of it that really there isn’t any external reality at all, that everything is just a projection of the mind. That’s all.
Everything is just mind. There’s no there isn’t anything there isn’t any actual external phenomena. Everything is just mind. But the Madhyamaka school says that there there is external reality, but how it exists is something very, very, very subtle. That things really do depend on the mind.
That couldn’t exist without the mind. The way they exist depends on the mind. The way we experience them depends on the mind. But that things aren’t just a chair isn’t just your, you know, mind. So there’s a very subtle difference.
So the the Prāsaṇgika school the term Prāsaṇgika means consequence. Because what they do to refute all these other school the Buddhist school they refute all the non-Buddhist schools, but they also say all of these schools here, all these philosophical Buddhist systems, they’re also they’re partly correct, but they’re not completely correct. And how they do this is they use the system of logic of consequences where they point out, well, you you know, that you believe this, but if if you say this is true, then what about that and what about that? They show the logical consequences of a person’s argument to to reach to to probably show the the absurd consequences of believing in something. I wish I could give a particular example, but I can’t.
I know if anyone can think of any, but, you know, just simple examples. But But, anyway, that’s what they do. That’s one of the system ways they they establish their own position by pointing out all the flaws in the logic of of all the other systems. So all of the other systems, what they do is they, you know, depending on what system it is, some schools will say, well things don’t substantially exist, but they do inherently exist. Some say they don’t truly exist, but they do inherently exist.
Things don’t exist from their own side, but they don’t but they do inherently exist. So all of the other the the the all of the Buddhist schools except the Prāsaṇgika try to say that there are some things that inherently exist. In other words, that they must really, really exist. What what else is possible? For example for example for example, the Prasangikas say that to us, this flower appears to inherently exist.
If it and my teacher says, If things inherently existed the way they appear to our consciousness, to all our consciousnesses So when we see something, it appears to inherently exist. When we smell something, it seems to smell inherently. It has an inherently existing smell when we hear things that what we hear, mental it appears to inherently sound that way. Like, if we hear a beautiful sound, we think that beautiful sound inherently exists. It’s it’s that’s really how it is.
It’s beautiful from its own side under its own power. It’s got nothing to do with me. Right? So all of our senses have this experience of things inherently existing. It’s but it’s only the mental consciousness, which is a big problem, that’s the most important part of our mind, it’s only the mental consciousness that grasps that that inherent existence is true.
All the sense consciousnesses experience inherent existence, but they don’t grasp at it, whereas it’s the mental consciousness that on top of that grasps that that inherent appearance is actually true. Anyway, my teacher says, if things inherently existed and they don’t, but if they did, it would logically follow, it would be a consequence, it would logically follow that things did not depend on anything. Because if you say something inherently exists or truly exists, it’s it’s it it’s when we experience things that way, it’s like the beauty is there from its side under its own power. Or that when we see this thing, and we I’ve we looked at this a little bit last week, that when we look at this, we see a daisy? Yeah.
Yeah? And we we we think we we see a daisy because from its side, it is somehow communicating to me that it is a daisy. Yeah? But actually the only way we can know it is a daisy is by depending on many, many things. By being told it’s a daisy, by being able to remember it’s a daisy, by being able to relate the term ‘daisy’ with a flower and a particular kind of flower with a particular shape and colour and blah blah blah.
So actually the only way we can experience this as a daisy is depending on many things. But in the when we just in the emotional moment of experience it, it doesn’t appear to depend on anything. Right? This is what we have to check. You may not believe that.
You may not accept that, but check out because this is what the Buddha says. So it’s worth checking, especially if you are a Buddhist, if you’ve decided the Buddha is okay and quite intelligent. In fact, very not just intelligent, but has pure unmistaken mind. Alright? And this object, this flower, which we, you know, we have this one word flower, a singular word implying a theme, a flower.
But when we investigate, this flower has many parts. And, of course, we understand a flower has parts. Yeah. Petals. Steady.
Steady. I mean, pistils or something. Stamens. I don’t know. So we we know that a flower has parts, but I would ask you to really check out to try and see the difference between knowing something has parts and understanding that the only way this object exists is depending on parts.
Because if you check the way we say it, we say and I think this is the only way we can say it because this is the way we actually experience things. This flower has parts. So that implies there is this thing. There is an existing flower that’s already there, and it’s got some parts. But that’s not the way a flower exists.
You can’t have a flower that has got parts. You have to have the fluff parts for the flower to exist. We’re so conditioned, aren’t we? Oh, very a lot times. A lot of times.
Oh. But can you see the difference Yeah. Between saying that he had this flower has parts? We understand that. But we don’t understand that this flower or when we think about it, we can understand that we don’t experience it this way, that the only way this thing exists is depending on all the parts.
There’s not there’s not a preexisting flower that has parts or acquires some parts, but there is no flower without the parts. Of course, you could argue, and if I take that petal off, you’ve still got a flower. But and this is kind of a wobbly flower wobbly petal, so it’s somehow not quite complete. You know? So anyway, what the Buddha is telling us is that in reality, the only way anything that exists is it exists depending on causes and conditions.
It depends on the parts, and it depends on mind. This is the way things in reality do exist, and it’s the only way they can exist. There is no other way that things can exist other than arising dependently. So this is the key argument of the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika, that the way to destroy the wrong view is to understand dependent arising, that things arise depending on causes and conditions, parts, and then the labelling mind. But this flower depends it it arises depending on many causes and conditions, you know, the seed and the soil and the sun and the moisture and all of these things and time.
And as a result of that, you have this flower. Yeah. Or you have the parts. You have all the parts. But the parts aren’t a flower.
All the parts of a flower are not a flower. This is a very interesting point. All the parts of the flower are not a flower. All the parts of the chair are not a chair. All the parts of the body are not a body.
All the threads in this carpet when you put them all together is not the carpet. What is it? All all the parts put together of anything is the base. The base to be labeled. Because the only way a flowering exists is you have to have a base, and your mind has to perceive or experience the base.
And then because there is the base, the mind, depending on the base, which depends on the parts, which depend on causes and conditions, depending on all of that, your mind, our mind experiences this object, this base, and labels it in that meaning conceives, it generates this conception flower. And then, because of all of that arising depending on all of those things, the causes and conditions, the parts, the and the mind labeling, depending on that, what arises back is a flower. The flower is not the base. It’s not the parts. It’s not the word.
It is something that one that arises depending on all those things. And that was like an illusion. In one section I attended. This name is Zopa. He didn’t actually draw this, but he he said to visualize it.
He said, so you have So what is that? Z. What is that? Please don’t be clever or anything. Just I’m not What is it?
It’s a zed. Right. That’s what we see. Yeah? We see a zed on this piece of paper.
Right? Don’t we? Mhmm. Yes. Yes.
We all do. I do. Yes. And the zed that we see, according to the teachings, is a zed that inherently exists. It just seems to be there from its own side.
Of course, you all saw me draw it, so you know I I put the zed there, drew the zed I drew a zed, and there it is. It’s really a real zed. It doesn’t seem to depend on anything. It’s just there. It’s obviously the zed.
But if you investigate, you cannot find an inherently, truly existing zed that does that is there from its own side. Wherever you look here, this seems to be the zed. But wherever you look on that, you can’t find a zed because if you just investigate that bit there, that is not a zed. And, you know, that bit there that bit there is you if if I just, you know, did that, that’s not a zed. And that bit there isn’t a zed, and that bit there isn’t a zed, and that bit there, and that bit there.
Nowhere can you find a zed. Is that that doesn’t depend on anything that is really there when you look. And if you think about it, all that is really here on the piece of paper are three straight lines. Yeah? And yet for us, Like, we see these three straight lines arranged like that, we see a zed.
So it’s really there. But we are we can only do that because we’ve been trained to. We were told when you see something like that, that that has a meaning. There’s a significance to it. Even that.
Mhmm. Even that. When we see apart from knowing the actual meaning, when we see that, we we instantly know that those three lines are not just arbitrary, that there is something meaningful there, and we actually know what the meaning is instantly. Yeah? But for many people, maybe from another culture or whatever, they wouldn’t even recognize that there’s any significance to those three lines, let alone what the significance is.
But we do. We we can’t stop doing that because it seems as though it is telling me. I’m sad. Obviously, I’m sad. But actually, it it totally depends on our mind.
And as Rinpoche says but I can’t remember I can’t remember the exact way Rinpoche says it now. There is a zed here, but there isn’t a zed on this paper. There is a zed appearing, but you can’t find a Z on this paper. When you look, at the most, you can only find three lines. And those three lines aren’t a Z.
Those three lines arrange in a particular way. So these are the parts of the zed, and those parts arranged in a particular way are the basis for a zed. And the only way a bay a zed can appear because if the zed isn’t there, even when we look, then you can’t see the zed there even though there is a zed. The only way the zed is appearing is because our mind is labeling this base a zed. So the zed is appearing to our mind.
It’s not there. It’s appearing in our mind. This is why Rinpoche says part of our wrong view is we see things out there. Yeah. Out there.
The zed is there, but it’s not. It seems to be there, but it’s something that is arising or like an illusion. It’s not an illusion because there is a zed. Zed does exist And one could think, oh, that was very clever or very stupid. And what was the point of all of that?
That that was just word games, party games, but actually, it may appear that way. But the whole of the teaching of the Buddha is about how we suffer because we experience things in a false way. We see things as truly existent. Meaning, we experience things as though they’re out there, not depending on causes and conditions, not depending on parts, but especially the real problem is that we think think we think we don’t think if we if this I don’t think we have there isn’t a word for it. We grasp instinctively that me, my body, my clothing, my possessions, everything, the whole world, the universe exists completely unconnected to the one line.
But it what this is showing is the only way anything can appear at all is depending on the mind. The only way we can know this is you know, why did this guy put those there? You know? What one immediately knows there’s some meaning. There’s no meaning there.
It’s depending on our mind. And there is no way those three lines from their side can make us think zed. Because if they because if they could, if it did, then you could bring someone in here from another country, you know, who’d never ever seen the English language before, and they would look at it and say, oh, this is it. Or just if someone was to draw a Chinese character here, and we would know what it says. Or someone wrote Greek, and we could put Russian or what?
Arabic. We would immediately because it’s just the lines on a piece of paper. Same. But we when we and if we haven’t learned these languages, no idea what it says. But as soon as that’s there, we know.
And and and it seems from its side to be telling us, but it isn’t. And the and the point of that message this is when we see beautiful things, this is this is where, you know, the problem really comes in when we say see beautiful and ugly things. It seems as though it’s beautiful from its side. It’s ugly from its side, it’s good from its side, it’s bad from its side, but it’s not like that. It appears very concretely to be like that, but it isn’t at all the Buddha is saying.
Nothing is like that. Tibra. Hold those thoughts. We’ll have questions after. I will ask you questions after the tea.
You check out where the tea is. It’s time to go home. Oh, sorry. I’m looking. Yeah.
It’s fine. What do we do? We have to cut off? What are Oh, yeah. And maybe because we can at least do some mantras.
Okay? Okay. Or something. Is that okay? Something.
Break and Yeah. Very quick tea break? Thanks. Actually, I go out your saying the pain healing day, doctor Peter Harriet. It’s actually my neuropsychiatrist.
He’s saying it from the pain clinic. Oh, really? And that’s when he actually that’s why I got email a few months ago about this sort pain. People from the RH and doctor Peter Harrier, the neuropsychiatrist said. And I said, no.
That’s what I said to him. That’s why I started a few weeks ago. I said then he said, yeah. I’ve been asked you on doing that. I said, well, I’ll be there.
So, actually, he’s really he was actually amazed. I’m talking about what I’m using for pain from Buddhism teaching on meditation teachings and the visualizations that he said, that’s fantastic, man. He said, so I tried to help my clients too. This is super strong. Mhmm.
It’s killer. Oh, just I was quite Could you just just chuck a bit out or Okay. Reduce or just put more milk in maybe. That’s what I’ll put over there. Thanks, Dan.
That’s what I saw myself. That’s why he’s actually made a song. I said, I can’t wait to hear them and all the people here too. So what meditation teachings do you do to help with pain? I do.
Because I have to give a talk on this to him, and he’s present. Well, he’s medicine water. So my my my my stuff in different chamber. Jim down, also Daniel chamber. He’s now.
He’s not. You know, it’s yeah. This is more vital. So he’s. I Okay.
So I think we have to leave the Heart Sūtra there for the time being, because it’s almost time to finish. Unless you have one or two very simple questions. That’s a very good question. What does turning of the wheel mean? Would like to ask a lama that myself.
In a very simple way, it just refers to the teachings of the Buddha, but why the teachings of the Buddha are referred to as the turning of the wheel, I’ve never really found out other than, of course, when the Buddha first achieved enlightenment and thought there was no point teaching because no one would understand. Then the gods appeared in front of him and begged the Buddha to teach because they said that there would be some sentient beings whose obscurations were very thin and if they heard the teachings they’d be able to understand them and be free. And they offered the Buddha this thousand spoked wheel, a golden wheel. The gods of Brahma and Indra offered this thousand spoked golden wheel for the Buddha to teach. So then the Buddha taught.
So I presume it has something to do with that. But in my very disrespectful modern Australian mind, I often wonder, what did the Buddha do with that wheel? Put it on the mantelpiece, straight to the trophy room? Probably I’ll go to hell for some reason. I don’t know why the gods thought the Buddha needed a big thousand spoke golden wheel.
Anyway Sorry. Does that mean like, you know, how the equanimity goes and the currency? Like, it’s just like, is that just all made up? Like, is that What? Funny.
Is it just made up? Like, is it just a lie? I think that’s another question. But, of course, it’s you know, this yeah. When when you look at it, Money is just a piece of paper, then on that paper, we label it as valuable.
But this applies to many, many, many things. Think, you know, paintings, people spend what, ninety million dollars on a painting now. Not your average person every day, but there are people who will spend ninety million dollars on a painting. I mean, because it’s been labeled all these things, you know, that it’s very precious, it’s incredibly meaningful, it’s high art, it’s blah blah blah. And we all do that.
You know, people, you know, want to have certain clothes because they’re from a certain designer. You know, even your underpants. Calvin Klein. Yeah, Calvin Klein. Yeah.
And really, when you check that it’s just made of the same stuff. You know, it’s just cotton. I suppose I don’t have Calvin Klein underpants, I have no idea what they’re made of, but I assume they’re made of cotton like other underpants are. I know. It it really is just yeah.
Kinda crazy. But we believe those labels that this is very significant. This is very special, this is very amazing. If you have this, you know, this will you know, this is it. By the way, just quickly, one point.
I was making the point that the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika School is said to be the highest school, the actual view of the Buddha. So the proof of this is this book. This book is Lama Tsongkhapa’s in Tibetan, it’s called the Drang Nges Legs Bshad Snying Po. The literal translation of that is something like the definitive and interpretive teachings of the Buddha. And this has been translated by the glorious Professor Robert Thurman, and it’s been called The Speech of Gold: Reason and Enlightenment in Tibetan Buddhism.
So this is Lama Tsongkhapa’s masterpiece, even more amazing than the Lamrim Chenmo, because in this text Lama Tsongkhapa, he analysed all the teachings, the sutras of the Buddha, and through logic he shows that although in this sūtra the Buddha said this, it was just an interpretive teaching. It’s not what the final meaning of the Buddha, because this other sūtra contradicts it and this sūtra is what the Buddha really means. So in this text, which is virtually impossible to understand, Lama Tsongkhapa shows this by analysing all the different sutras that the other schools follow and say this is the actual meaning of the Buddha. So they argue that there are definitive teachings which are about the actual nature of reality, which is, Lama Tsongkhapa argues, is contained in the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras, which present the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view of emptiness, and all the other sutras that talk about the nature of reality are interpretive. You need to interpret them.
They’re only what’s the word, skillful means to lead beings eventually to the highest view. Within the Buddhist teachings there are what are said to be definitive teachings, and then there are interpretive teachings, and then within those there are statements which are meant to be taken literally and those which are not to be taken literally. So for example, the Heart Sūtra is a definitive teaching of the Buddha. But when it says there is no eye, no ear, you don’t take that literally because I’ve got one, I’ve got two, in fact, ears. That is not literal.
One doesn’t take that literally. Because what you have to insert after no is there’s no inherently existing ears and nose and tongue. There’s no inherently existing anything. It doesn’t literally mean there’s nothing at all. So one really has to understand all these things.
So we’ll try and progress to the end of the Heart Sūtra next week because it’s the last week, so we’ll rush through it. But if you don’t mind, we’ll just do a few more, maybe one moment of, I think if we have time, of the Medicine Buddha Sūtra. So I think hopefully everyone has got a copy of the of the mantra in their prayer book. Should have. So this this earthquake in Nepal has been a huge disaster for the people of Nepal and have very terrible consequences for many, many, many, many years.
So one of the things we can do is at least try and generate this good energy which we can send to all the people of Nepal, especially those who have died, who have been injured, who have been affected in any way. So we can imagine, try and visualize the Medicine Buddha as depicted in this beautiful Thangka. And as we recite the mantra, thinking that this very powerful, blissful blue light emanates from every part of the medicine Buddha’s body going out to all all those who have died, who have been injured, who are dying, who are disoriented and suffering in any way, and bringing them exactly what will benefit them in the best way. So we’ll recite the mantra out loud three times. We’ll just do the short mantra at the bottom three times out loud and then quietly for the rest of the time.
So now we can dedicate the merit of reciting the mantra, the merit of of being here tonight, that we quickly achieve enlightenment in order to be able to enlighten all kind suffering mother sentient beings. Page nine. Through the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhicitta mind not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore.
So go to page thirteen.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- eighteen constituents dhatu (Skt); kham (Tib)
- The six sense powers, the six consciousnesses and the six objects. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.