1 h 49 min · 9,486 words · 26 August 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 109-minute teaching on refuge in the Three Jewels, Venerable Thubten Dondrub introduces the foundational Buddhist practice of taking refuge with a Mahāyāna emphasis on bodhicitta — the aspiration to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all beings. He walks through the visualization of Śākyamūni Buddha as the object of refuge and explains why the Buddha is worthy of that trust: the Buddha’s complete fearlessness grounded in omniscience; perfect skill in teaching methods suited to each person’s mind; equanimity toward all beings regardless of praise or harm; and universal compassion that perceives the subtle sufferings of saṃsāra in every sentient being. Dondrub distinguishes between Theravāda and Mahāyāna understandings of omniscience, explores karma as the mechanism underlying all experience, and illustrates these teachings through vivid examples — a king who killed his parents, a monk who meditated lying down, a woman’s clairvoyant flashes. He emphasizes that while compassion motivates the path, it is understanding the nature of reality, emptiness, that actually liberates. The teaching is grounded in the Buddhist framework and suitable for both newcomers to Buddhism and practitioners already familiar with refuge.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014 08 26 DB Refuge in the Three Jewels Week 3 26082014.mp3
UUID: 633ceebc-b8c3-415e-93a3-d6e6cf1876a5
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Refuge in the Three Jewels (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2014-08-26
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 109.3 minutes
Words: ~9,480
Hello, yes. Buddha House technology is exciting! Good evening everyone, welcome to our third class on the subject of the Three Jewels of Refuge or Refuge in the Three Jewels which I think it’s called. So this topic is fundamental to the practice of Buddhism. The entry to the door to liberation and enlightenment begins with taking refuge so it’s a really important subject.
In the Mahāyāna tradition the purpose of taking refuge is to take refuge in order to practice the Buddha’s teachings, in order to benefit all sentient beings. Since this is the purpose of taking refuge in the Mahāyāna tradition then from our side it’s really good if we try to have a motivation that matches the purpose of the topic. As much as possible try at least we should try and have a good motivation for being here and studying. And in the Mahāyāna tradition the highest, best, all encompassing motivation we can have is bodhicitta, the wish to achieve enlightenment or to realize the full potential of our mind so that not only do we reach a point where there’s no way we can cause any kind of harm to any sentient being at any time in any situation but more importantly we reach a stage where we can be of perfect lasting benefit to all living beings. And the reason for wanting to achieve that is twofold basically recognizing how immensely kind sentient beings are, how we’re interconnected and interdependent on all of them.
We simply could not exist or function without them. So that’s one aspect and the other main aspect that helps generate bodhicitta is recognizing how all of these beings are so immensely kind who in fact have been our mother and father many times in beginningless Samsāra are in Samsāra. Are bound by delusion and karma, subject to taking rebirth over and over again in all the different realms of cyclic existence helplessly. So the more we think about these things we can generate that thought that no matter what I must use this in all my future lives to achieve enlightenment for their sake. So if you’d like to join in, there’s the traditional prayer that is said at the beginning of teaching.
So this is on page eleven or twelve of our book, student material in section one. So as one says this prayer, I would just like to make it clear, some people never pick this point up, that there is the prayer of refuge bodhicitta for teachings and on the next page there is the prayer of refuge in bodhicitta for meditation. It’s basically the same prayer but the third line is different. So in the third line of the prayer for teachings it says Dag gi chö nyen pa, by the merits of listening to the Dharma. So the student says Chunyan by the merit of listening to them or chö nyen means listening to the Dharma the teacher says chö shä, meaning teaching the Dharma so then in the prayer for meditation the third line instead it says Dag gi jin sog, which jin means giving, means etcetera.
So it’s referring to the six perfections. Hi. Are you registered for this course? There are six perfections, one of which is concentration so that’s why one says it as the fifth form for meditation. Anyway as we say this prayer whether we’re doing it at the beginning of teachings or at the beginning of meditation to make it more powerful one visualizes or tries to visualize or imagine Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as the source of refuge, inspiration and guidance.
So we visualize the Buddha seated on a throne held up by white snow lions. They symbolize the eight great protectors of the Mahāyāna teachings. So there are two lions at each corner. All the visualization you try to imagine in the nature of transparent light. And then on the throne is a lotus symbolizing the mind of renunciation, great renunciation above the lotus.
So you have a lotus and then above that horizontally a sun disc that symbolizes the wisdom that overcomes ignorance. Then above that a moon disc that symbolizes bodhicitta. Then above that one imagines Śākyamūni Buddha seated there above the moon disc having a hollow body of golden light wearing the saffron robes of a monk. Right hand extended with his right arm extended, the right hand resting on the right knee with the hands, the fingers touching the moon disc in what is called the earth touching Mudra because this is the Mudra that the Buddha displayed during just before he achieved or just after he achieved enlightenment when Mara was giving him a lot of trouble. Anyway, the left hand is in meditation posture supporting a deep blue begging bowl and this we imagine is full of wisdom nectar symbolic of the wisdom that overcomes the ignorance and all the causes of suffering.
So we try to visualize the Buddha in front of us and at the same time we try to visualize all sentient beings surrounding us. Quite honestly apart from trying to visualize all sentient beings it’s very difficult to even think of all sentient beings. Therefore one needs to try and make it realistic as possible, meaningful as possible, so at least we should try and think of or visualize the people that we’re connected to in this life. So our mother on our left, father on our right, then behind us, which we would like to put them in front, but the psychology to reduce our attachment is to put behind us the rest of our family, friends and helpers. And the people we dislike or who dislike us or want to harm us or have harmed us.
We would like to put away behind us but the idea is to put them in front to make us start to realize that these people are in essence no different than any other sentient being. They have been my kind mothers and fathers in past lives, will become my mothers and fathers in future life. They are suffering in Samsāra like everyone else. So in reality they deserve my compassion, not my aversion. And my aversion to them is causing me far greater harm than my aversion will ever harm them.
Better to give it up and feel compassion for them. Or try to. So at least we try and think of that group of people. But as much as we can we then try and open our minds and hearts to being aware and concerned for all the other beings of cyclic existence. At least trying to think of all other human beings but then also all the animals because they are sentient beings as well.
Then if one can believe in the other sentient beings such as the beings in the preta realms, the hungry ghost realms, the hell realms, the different beings in the god realms, in the Bardo state, we try and think of all of those as well. And think no matter what I must achieve enlightenment for their sake. So that depends on following the path, that depends on understanding studying the teachings and an essential teaching is refuge. Taking refuge is the beginning of Buddhist practice. So for the sake of all sentient beings I will study this subject.
I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the Sangha, the supreme assembly. By the merits I create through teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So then we can imagine the Buddha pleased with our motivation for studying. The Buddha shows this by firstly dissolving the lion throne into light that absorbs up into the lotus sun and moon. And the Buddha then seated on these comes to the crown of our head, turns to face the same direction as ourselves, then dissolves into blissful golden light.
And imagine that light pouring down into you through the crown of your head. Imagine this generates a very blissful feeling throughout your whole being. Blessing your mind to be able to understand the teachings, blessing your mind to be able to put them into practice, blessing the mind to be able to actually gain the complete realization, especially of refuge in the triple gem. So then briefly we can do the nine round breathing exercise as a way to allow the mind to become a little bit more calmer, clearer, concentrated, so that we can use that level of mind to listen to and think about the Buddhist teachings tonight. Okay.
Thank you very much. So whole basis of the Buddha’s teachings is about the mind. So if we start to develop some belief that we have a mind, not just a brain, that our mind is not something produced by the brain or it’s not the brain, it’s not something that is a byproduct of the brain, but it’s very unique phenomenon, the most important thing in the universe that gives rise to all experience, knowing and feeling. The more we start to understand that, which we may have some belief in that already ourselves somehow, or by studying the Buddha’s teachings we come to develop some understanding of it. The more we understand that we have a mind then that leads to understanding that if I want less suffering, more happiness, then the vital thing, the key is to take care of the mind.
That’s the most important thing in life in any situation is to take care of the mind. And taking care of the mind has two aspects: pacifying and eliminating the negative aspects of the mind which come from ignorance, which are not a true aspect of our mind. But these are the factors which actually bring about our suffering. So that’s one aspect of taking care of the mind. The other aspect is cultivating the positive potentials of our mind which are the true aspects of our mind which are, the Buddha discovered, the actual source of happiness, every kind of happiness up to and including peerless, everlasting happiness.
And so to do that, to take care of this mind, which is something that goes on and on and on forever, that can give rise to horrendously horrible experiences but inconsiderably wonderful experiences, we need a method. We need a complete, perfect, unbetrayable method. That can only come from a perfect source, not an imperfect source, only come from a perfect source. So that, the Buddhists argue, is the enlightened mind. So the Buddha mind.
The mind of a Buddha, an enlightened mind. So the word the Tibetan word that translates the Sanskrit word Buddha is Sangge. So Sangye has those two syllables Sang and Ye, I can never remember which is which but think Sangye refers to anyway it has these two meanings. Sang means purified I think. Hold on.. I’m not sure which is which but anyway these two syllables may have the meaning of being completely free of all faults having eliminated all faults and developed all good qualities.
In a nutshell, a very simple way, that is what an enlightened mind is. It has no negative qualities. The mind is completely free of them in a way that they can never come back, even for a moment and the enlightened mind possesses all good qualities fully developed, fully functioning spontaneously all the time in such a way that they never decline even for a moment. They are all functioning. So we have that potential within our mind of Sangye that we can eliminate all negative qualities in a way that they will never return.
We can awaken all the positive qualities because we have all the potential for every positive quality. We can awaken them all in a way that they will always function, every one of them, all the time in a way that they never decline. They’re fully functioning spontaneously all the time twenty fourseven. That’s the enlightened mind. So we have the potential for that.
So to develop our potential for enlightenment we need to rely on the Buddha. Because if we rely on something less perfect than less complete then mistakes can occur. And if that’s the case, then we will continue to suffer, we won’t be able to get out of saṃsāra, we won’t be able to achieve enlightenment, we won’t be able to benefit and repay the kindness of mother sentient beings. Last week I was supposed to talk about the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, if you check your outline of the course. But instead I talked about whether enlightenment was possible because I think that’s a really important topic to think about.
Tonight just briefly I’d like to talk about the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha because traditionally there are two reasons to take refuge especially in the triple gem of Buddha, Dhamma, Sangha. One side is to avoid suffering and particularly in the teachings it says the basic reason for taking refuge is to avoid the suffering of the lower realms, A bad rebirth. A deeper reason is to avoid all the suffering of saṃsāra and the most profound final reason for taking refuge is of one’s fearing others’ suffering, wanting to relieve not just oneself from suffering but all sentient beings and therefore wanting to become a Buddha to do that. So anyway, simply the cause for taking refuge is to avoid suffering and of course what is implied in that is because one wants happiness. Firstly for oneself, for future life, secondly the happiness of nirvana but then deeply more the most wonderful wish is for the happiness of all sentient beings.
And then on the other side the reason for taking refuge in the triple gem is of Buddha, Dharma, Sangha is having realized coming to some conclusion that the Buddha, Dharma, Sangha are the perfect refuge. The complete unbetrayable perfect refuge. And why the Dharma and Sangha are the perfect refuge is because of the Buddha. So the real refuge is the Buddha. So we need to understand firstly have some reason to believe that enlightenment enlightened mind exists and then if we have some belief in that we need to really understand more and more or know something about the qualities of enlightened mind.
So this is a very big subject in itself discovering Buddhism is only an introduction to all those things so I can only talk in a basic way about these things in this course. Traditionally in this topic of why the Buddha is the perfect refuge, It talks about these four qualities of the Buddha that make the Buddha a perfect refuge. So one of these is that the Buddha is, or the first of these, is that the Buddha is completely fearless. Only an enlightened being, only a Buddha has eliminated all negative qualities from the mind and only a Buddha has awakened all positive qualities. So as a result of that Buddha mind, enlightened mind is completely omniscient knowing everything unmistakenly.
One of the special things to think about but I don’t think I can really explain it because probably I understand it myself but for example we’re knowing things all the time and some things that we know we are knowing correctly and some things that we know about we are knowing incorrectly But the trouble is when we’re knowing things we don’t know if we’re knowing them correctly or incorrectly. We may think we’re knowing things correctly. In fact we always assume that whatever we know is correct and if someone points out that we are wrong we can be quite shocked. So even if when we are knowing something correctly we can’t be a hundred percent sure that what we know as correct is correct. Even if lots of other people say so.
Just because lots of other ordinary people say this is true doesn’t make it so. But one of the features of enlightened mind is, and I can’t explain how this works but I have faith it’s true, is that enlightened mind knows it is correct. Because it is fully knowing that what it knows is correct. One thing that people seem to like about Buddhism is the statement that the Buddha made when he first achieved enlightenment where he says I’m not sure when he said it but the Buddha said, don’t believe what I say just because I’m a Buddha. Check up yourself.
Because then if you check up and come to this understanding as well, then it’ll be much stronger. But I think some people interpret that as well the Buddha wasn’t really sure if he was right or wrong. Of course the Buddha wasn’t saying when he said don’t believe me just because check up yourself. He wasn’t saying I’m not completely sure if I’m right or not. The Buddha was a hundred percent sure that he was a hundred percent right.
But he’s saying don’t believe me through blind faith. It’s much better that I’m telling you the truth but you check up yourself that it’s true. Because when you when you discover that it is true from your own side, that discovery will be more powerful than if you just blindly believe. Right? So the Buddha knew that he was right.
So he’s completely fearless because the Buddha knows enlightened mind. Sorry if I keep implying that Buddha is man, but enlightened mind anyway, enlightened beings know that they are knowing correctly. That is a quality of unobscured mind. And so mind, although being a person possessing an enlightened mind such as Śākyamūni Buddha is completely fearless. In the sutras what one of the things I like about Buddha Sutras is how the analogies they give are very very down to earth and very realistic and particularly related to the time of the Buddha which was a very agricultural society but also a place in India at that time of the Buddha had lots of jungle and forest and wild animals and whatever and the Buddha was often compared to a lion.
He was said to be the lion among men and the teachings of the Buddha are often called the lion’s roar of the Buddha because when a lion roars in the jungle all the other animals shut up. Everyone goes completely silent. And so Buddha’s teachings are said to be like a lion’s roar because the Buddha can, when he says something, he knows it’s true, that no one can actually contradict it and say that’s wrong. Of course they can say it, but they can’t prove it because the Buddha knows that what he says, he shares, she says is one hundred percent right because the Buddha has an unobscured, unobstructed mind and no one else has. Well, other Buddhas do, but no other being has a pure unobstructed mind.
So a Buddha is fearless in what they say. Not based on stupidity and ignorance and arrogance, but knowing that they know what is correct. I don’t know if you find that acceptable or not. But anyway, the Buddha is fearless and the Buddha makes four fearless proclamations. One of these, the first of these, is the Buddha is fearless in proclaiming his own realizations of possessing all good qualities and skills.
The Buddha knows, Buddha mind, enlightened mind knows that it possesses all the realizations. It knows it has all the good qualities, all the skills, positive skills. So therefore one can take refuge in that because one can take refuge in all of these qualities and realizations and skills. One can depend on them. The Buddha knows that these are complete and perfect and unbetrayable.
Also the Buddha can make this fearless proclamation of his own cessation of all obscurations. The Buddha knows that every obscuration has been completely and totally removed from his mind in a way that it will never return. So the Buddha is completely fearless in knowing and proclaiming that. So we can take refuge in that mind. The Buddha is also fearless in being able to proclaim what other sentient beings need to eliminate from their minds.
Because the Buddha knew what had to be eliminated from his mind and did it so the Buddha knows what has to be eliminated from our minds and can explain that, proclaim it completely. Right? So this is something that we can trust. And also the Buddha is fearless in explaining, proclaiming all the opponent forces that we have to rely on in order to get rid of all our obscurations. So the Buddha not only knows he himself has eliminated these obscurations, he knows all the methods to get rid of them because the Buddha used them.
So the Buddha can fearlessly proclaim all of those methods to others without any fear of contradiction saying this isn’t right, it doesn’t work and so on. So no one else can really do that. There are a lot of people who write books saying this is the way, this is what to do, proclaiming that they are being inspired by this person or that person or God’s talking through them or Christ is talking through them or Mohammed’s talking through them or people talk about the Buddha talking through them. But they don’t really know what they’re talking about. Only enlightened mind does.
I’m getting some very grim looks from people. Does anyone want to make a comment? Okay. So the second of these four features is that the Buddha possesses perfect skill in means to guide others away from suffering. Because the Buddha is omniscient there is nothing obscuring the Buddha’s mind.
The Buddha knows exactly what is appropriate for each person to pick up for them. Although of course there’s general paths to follow, we all have to follow the same path to a large extent but within that path there are many things to do and at different times and different people need different so there’s the one path. For example, the one highway to one place there are many different cars, big cars, small cars, slow cars, fast cars, bicycles and buses and whatever. So there is the one path to follow but different methods to get there in a sense. So the Buddha knows because the Buddha’s mind is completely unobscured exactly what is suited for each person.
So there are so many different methods the Buddha taught to suit the minds of different people. So for this reason the Buddha is a perfect refuge. So there are teachings for people who have great anger, great desire, very stupid, have a lot of pride. Whatever delusion one has there is a method to overcome it and suit that kind of person within the general teachings of the Buddha. So there are many stories given.
So the Buddhist teachings aren’t sort of dogmatic that you have to do this. In a sense there are things we have to do avoid the causes of suffering but what one person needs to do maybe isn’t at a particular time suited for another person so the Buddha taught something else. For example one of the classic stories that is told to illustrate this which I always mention is the story about one of the king I think it was King Bimbisāra I can never remember that India at that time was made up of many small kingdoms and one of the princes of one of these kingdoms in order to become king killed his father and his mother so that he could become king. After he’d done that, sometime later he developed a lot of guilt, that he’d killed his father and mother realizing this was probably not a very nice thing to do, killing his father. And he started to go quite crazy, lost his mind for some time.
So one of his advisors told him to go to the Buddha and see if the Buddha could help him. So he went to the Buddha and the Buddha told him, Oh, don’t worry, killing your father and mother is terrific. Wonderful. Good. Excellent thing to do.
And because he trusted the Buddha, because the Buddha was famous for being very holy, who never lied, know, only said what has been beneficial and kind and compassionate, this king completely trusted the Buddha and all his craziness died down. He returned to normal and carried on his life. But he kept thinking about that it was very strange of the Buddha to say something that was completely contradictory to what he normally taught. Killing anyone was bad, let alone your mother and father. And so the story goes that eventually he realized that what the Buddha was really saying that by killing your father and mother what he really meant was all the delusions ignorance, and that inspired him to overcome his delusion and ignorance, and he eventually became an arhat.
Sorry? An arhat? Yeah. An arhat? Someone who is free of saṃsāra.
And of course, the point is that the Buddha knew that by saying that to him at that time, that would be the result. He didn’t say this untruth just to be a nice person and to be liked by the king. He said it because he knew what the karmic result would be: being omniscient and knowing exactly what fits the mind of various people. And there’s also a story about one monk who was a very bad meditator. There’s the eight point meditation posture, how you should sit like this and keep your back very straight and blah blah blah.
Every time this monk tried that he fell asleep so the Buddha told him that you should meditate lying down because in a past life you were a cow. If you meditate lying down you’ll be fine and he was. So the Buddha has guidelines. The teachings of the Buddha are guidelines they’re not dogmas. It’s exactly like that if you don’t do this you will fry in hell.
Are guidelines that we know are skillful means to get us out of trouble and move us along the path. So the Buddha has the perfect skillful means. We all try to be skillful in what we say. Hopefully we all try to be skillful in what we say. Sometimes when we get to know a person we know, oh it’s not very good to say this to this person or talk about that or behave like this with this person so you try and avoid that.
With this person you do that and this person you do that. So one tries to be skillful but the Buddha has the perfect skillful means that not just keep people temporarily happy but the perfect skill that will lead someone to complete enlightenment. So if we were lucky enough to be able to read all the sutras of the Buddha one would discover that many of the sutras contradict each other. But this is because the Buddha taught that sūtra for a particular person or group of people because it fitted their minds. And it was taught with the understanding that this was a limited teaching, a skillful means to lead them to something better in the future.
So one has to be a Buddha to be able to do that, to teach something that is limited and maybe not a hundred percent true, but with the understanding that this point, which is not completely true, will lead to the ultimate truth and not to something even more untrue and confusing. For example, the main aim of the Buddha’s teachings is to be able to understand the nature of reality because it is that wisdom that will destroy our ignorance which is this complete misunderstanding of how things exist. So the Buddha taught various versions of reality because to suit the minds of different people because the highest teaching about the nature of reality is very very very difficult to understand and very very easy to misunderstand. So the Buddha taught other ways that are not completely true but are extremely helpful and can lead a practitioner to eventually understand the highest truth. So that is the skillful means of a Buddha.
And I also like this story of the man who had a very beautiful wife whom he was very attached to, but then I can’t remember why, but he became a monk, but he remained very very attached to his ex wife, you know, lusting after her. And so the Buddha then magically took him, magically, to the god realms where the goddesses are far more beautiful than any human woman. And he said, if you practice well, you will be able to be born among these beautiful women. So then this monk’s attachment to ordinary human women and his ex wife completely stopped. So this is the Buddha’s skillful means.
The third of these qualities, special features of the Buddha, is that the Buddha has complete equanimity, perfect equanimity. Whether someone harms the Buddha or benefits the Buddha, the Buddha has perfect equanimity. They give the analogy that if there were two people on either side of the Buddha and one person was massaging the Buddha with incredibly expensive massage oil, perfumed oils, praising the Buddha in every way, and on the other side was someone insulting the Buddha in every horrible way and chopping the Buddha’s body into little pieces. The Buddha’s mind would be exactly the same towards both of them. Yeah.
Complete equanimity. I like that one. We we need a refuge who who has complete equanimity whether we are good or bad, whether we praise the Buddha or insult the Buddha, whether we believe in the Buddha or not, then the Buddha has complete equanimity. So that’s the kind of refuge we need. Then finally the Buddha has a perfect compassion, great compassion for all sentient beings and works spontaneously for the benefit of all sentient beings.
So the Buddha has great compassion in the sense of it extends to all sentient beings friend, enemy, strangers. Buddha doesn’t perceive Buddha doesn’t have friends, enemies and strangers. People may be friendly to the Buddha, people may be indifferent to the Buddha, people may hate the Buddha But from the side of the Buddha, all sentient beings are equal. There is equal great compassion for all of them, great love for all of them. And that great compassion is special in that the Buddha understands, knows directly, perceives directly all the types of suffering of sentient beings, not just the gross suffering of suffering, but the subtle suffering, which is the suffering of change, which we think of as happiness, and even the most profound subtle suffering, which is called compounded pervasive suffering which is referring to the simple horrible fact of having these five aggregates of body and mind produced by and controlled by delusion and karma.
Simply because we have a body and mind that is under the control of delusion and karma, we are bound to suffer. We are suffering. It is unsatisfactory to have a body and a mind that are produced by and controlled by delusion and karma. For that reason, our body decays, grows old, gets sick, dies over and over again. We get another one and the same thing happens to it.
It gets sick, it grows old and dies and we get another one. In Samsāra, we get another one. Our mind has delusions. One delusion stops. If we get angry, anger stops, then there’s desire, pride, jealousy, this, that, up and down, around and around all the time.
Yeah. That’s suffering. Even when they’re not there, active, we have the potential for all of this. Even when we’re perfectly healthy, there’s the potential to experience every kind of sickness. When we’re young, we’re going to get old.
We’re not old yet, but we’re going to get old. There’s the potential to die any moment. There’s the potential for any delusion to arise any moment, and therefore to follow it, engage in all sorts of horrible negative actions, and create the cause for every kind of suffering. That situation is totally unsatisfactory. Right?
So the Buddha sees all of that. The whole extent of samsaric suffering in every sentient being. We can look at someone who looks incredibly beautiful, youthful, healthy, successful, rich, famous, loved and think, oh, I’d love to be that person. They must be so happy. But the Buddha looks at them and sees that they are suffering.
Because they are. And has great compassion for them. The Buddha doesn’t just see this momentary little bubble of success someone. The Buddha is able to see everything, past, present, future of everyone, so has great compassion for everyone in Samsāra all the time. So that includes oneself.
That’s the that’s the point. The Buddha’s compassion for us doesn’t stop when we win the lottery or when we’re healthy, but it’s there all the time while we’re in saṃsāra. Because every samsaric being, whether they’re in that lowest hell or the highest god realm, is suffering. So Buddha knows that. Not intellectually directly experiences our suffering.
He has direct, you know, complete empathetic compassion for us. So that’s the perfect refuge. It has compassion whether one is good or bad. Not compassion just for the nice people, but for all sentient beings. This is why the Buddha appeared in this world.
Because we’ve all created the cause of suffering. We’ve all done terrible things either in this life but certainly in past lives because of the you know, when the conditions are there, because we have delusion, we can get very angry, we can get very proud, very jealous, etcetera, etcetera, and do all sorts of terrible things. And we have. We have. Yeah.
When we look at someone and think, you know, I I I do the I’m guilty of this myself. You read things in the paper like what these, you know, terrorists do in in Syria and Iraq and think, oh, I could never do that. How could anyone do that? But the point is we’ve we’ve all done it in a past life. We’ve all done it.
It’s unbelievable, but we’ve done it. Hopefully we couldn’t do it in this life because our positive imprints are firing away strongly. But in past lives, because of the conditions, the negative stuff was there, strong. So we all have the potential, We have these imprints. If they’re not purified and got rid of, are gonna ripen this great suffering.
That’s why the Buddha came to this world and said, don’t engage in negative actions and purify the ones you’ve engaged in. Cause I don’t want you to suffer. I don’t want anyone to suffer no matter what they’ve done. I don’t want anyone to suffer. Yes, yes, yes, yes.
This is the effect of negative actions from past. Well, there are only two other major explanations of it that you can come up with. One is there’s no reason whatsoever why it’s happening, which is the materialist view that there is no real reason why someone gets beheaded. They just happen to be in the wrong place at the wrong just bad luck. Boohoo bad luck.
So no matter how good or bad you are, it’s just bad luck, which, you know, what is bad luck or good luck? That doesn’t mean anything. What it means is what is it’s a cover up for saying there’s no reason for things to happen. It’s just chaos. Yeah.
You throw things up in the air and they land this way and that. That may be true. If that’s true, there’s nothing we can do about anything. You know? We’re stuck with it.
And the other one, of course, there is a god who, you know, arranged all this. Again, this is very difficult to some people understand it. I don’t. You know? Again, yeah, maybe god wants you to be beheaded.
Sometimes he doesn’t. I’m sorry. I don’t mean to be rude, but, you know, then there’s a Buddhist reason. If you create a cause for something, you get the result. If you do something negative and you don’t know it’s negative, you’re going to like, if if a a little child doesn’t know flame burns, they put their hand in the flame.
It’s gonna burn. Yeah? Just because they’re innocent and don’t know, the flame is not gonna stop is not gonna stop. Oh, I won’t burn you because you’re innocent. You don’t know.
If you put your hand in a flame, it burns. Yeah? So if you do an action, there’s a result. Whether you know it or not, that it’s good or bad, you get the result. Once you create the energy, the result comes sooner or later.
This is what the Buddha taught. When the conditions come together, the seed ripens. When you put a seed in the ground then when all the conditions are ready, know, now it’s spring and now things are blub, it’s almost spring, so all the things which are in the ground which require a certain warmth, humidity, blah blah blah now they’re starting to ripen. You have seeds in the desert know, that can stay in the desert for years and years and years. Then one day it rains, and kaboom, the whole desert blooms.
Yeah? What is the explanation? Yeah, anyway, I think if you study karma it’s very, very profound. It’s not simplistic at all. It’s unbelievably profound.
Because it’s all related to emptiness, is the essential teaching of the Buddha. Why does something happen to you and not someone else? Why does it happen to you? Well, that’s what I’m saying. Why does something happen?
There is only two other explanations. There’s no reason, or God arranged it, or then there’s the Buddhist explanation of karma, is related to the most essential, profound teaching of the Buddha, which is about the nature of reality. That the external world is not something external out there, but is something existing totally depending on your mind. It’s not which doesn’t mean it’s just made up by your mind, but for you to experience something, it’s being experienced by your mind. For your mind to change from one experience to another, there has to be a cause.
You know, one moment your mind is neutral, the next it’s happy, the next it’s suffering. Something caused that. What caused that? Yeah. It’s very profound.
karma isn’t something simplistic at all. It’s saying what causes your mind to change, to have this new experience. To take refuge actually this brings up a point I want to emphasize later on but when we take refuge, if you want to take refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, the actual refuge is the Buddha but in practice for us the main refuge is the Dharma, the Buddha’s teachings and there are many teachings of the Buddha but the essential one, the essential refuge, is the teaching of the law of cause and effect because all of the Buddha’s teachings are connected to that one, including the highest teaching about the nature of reality, which is the main teaching of the Buddha. Many people think the main teaching of the Buddha is all about compassion, but it’s not. The heart of the Buddha’s teachings is about emptiness, the nature of reality, because it’s understanding, experiencing that which is going to free us from suffering.
Compassion wants us to compassion is the mind that wants oneself and others to be free of suffering, but compassion doesn’t free you from suffering. It motivates you to to be free of it. But what actually frees us from suffering is understanding the nature of reality, because that destroys the cause of suffering, ignorance. Am I making any sense? All I get is some grim looks from people.
I try and talk to people. It would be nice if people communicated back to me sometimes. That is why you have to do many of these things. Yes, yes, it takes a long time. Yes, yes.
It’s not meant to be one way or another but this topic of refuge is particularly meant for people who have been studying some of it and now thinking about it. Anyway, you have to start studying the Buddhism somewhere. You just jump in. But really the teaching on karma is not simplistic. It is not simplistic at all.
I would say some of the other explanations of life are very simplistic. But to really understand karma you have to understand emptiness and the mind. Well that’s just an introduction to really understand these things. I have this quote, which I memorize it because I think it is just so fantastic, but it’s from a novel. And I think it’s one of the best explanations of karma I have ever ever read.
And I quote it a lot, but I don’t know it off by heart. By Doris Lessing. It’s from a novel I read which I never ever read, I gave up because I found it so worrying. But I found this quote in it which just blew my mind. It’s a novel called The Three Gated City or The Four Gated City.
I can’t remember. I don’t know if I have got this quote somewhere here. Probably not. If you remind me, I will try and find it and read it to you next week. Okay, the essence of it is something like she says something like, you know, you’re living in a peace time, and then all of a sudden, war starts.
A war starts. A bomb drop you know, you know, a bomb drops here, and and into the in into a peaceful life, you know, elements of war intrude. And but then after some time, everything takes on the aspect of war. Now what? And then she goes on to say something like, but how can a bomb drop?
Oh, how does she put it? That’s what a great novelist does. I can’t. But basically, she says, a bomb can’t drop into your life. Well, how can a bomb fall into your life if you haven’t created the cause for it?
That’s what we think. You know, things just happen to us. But how can they just happen to us? That would make oh no, this is going into a huge territory. This sort of makes sense we believe, which is what we believe, that the world is just out there completely separate from us, and we’re just wandering inside it.
You know, a separate thing. There’s the reality and me wandering through it. Two separate things. The Buddha is telling us, although it looks like that very, very convincingly, it is not like that. This world is not separate from your mind.
It’s not only the Buddha discovered this completely but lots of philosophers and scientists are saying coming from different points of view are touching this point more and more such as someone mentioned last week, call those atomic physicists, the quantum physicist people who talk about when study the behavior of waves, if you look at them, observe them in one way, they behave in one way. If you observe them in another way, they behave in completely contradictory way. It all depends on the mind observing them. They’re not separate. That’s one thing.
But also if you study the philosophy of what’s his name? Mr. Wittgenstein what’s his name? Ludwig Wittgenstein I probably wouldn’t recommend studying it because there’s only about three people in the universe who can understand anything he wrote, but he also came to similar conclusions of nowhere near the same as the Buddha, but some understanding of how this world is not out there separate. Yeah.
It’s just not. Then karma starts to make a lot of sense. Anyway, now I’ve never see, your fault. It’s your I was going along very nicely. I was going to cover the whole topic tonight.
No, no, is good. I think it is better to do some of this than just to plod through something. Anyway, that is my excuse for failing to cover the topic. Are we up? Break.
Yes. Break time. So I hope I I’m Giants of technology. Yes. You said the quote.
Yes. Where’d you get that from? From the computer. Have the quote. Okay, is everyone here?
Quick! Alright, I got the first words correct. So it says, this is from Doris Lessing’s book, So a war begins. Into a peacetime life comes an announcement, a threat. A bomb dropped somewhere.
This was written in the eighties, by the way, and it’s even more relevant these days anyway. A bomb drops somewhere, potential traitors are whisked off quietly to prison, and for some time, days, months, a year perhaps, life has a peacetime quality into which warlike events intrude. But when a war has been going on for a long time, life is all war. Every event has the quality of war. Nothing of peace remains.
Events, this is the key sentence: Events and the life in which they are embedded have the same quality. But since it is not possible that events are not part of the life they occur in, it is not possible that a bomb should explode into a texture of life foreign to it. All that means is that one has not understood, one has not been watching. That is karma in a nutshell from Doris Lessing. Yeah.
Something can’t your life, our life is made up of events and you can’t have an event in your life which is what does she say which is foreign to it. So this is the one this is why the Buddha is the great refuge because the Buddha taught karma. Yeah. Buddha perceived it and then taught how how it works. And in a very profound complete way based on the understanding of reality.
So then in taking refuge one should know the good qualities of the Buddha. The main feature of course are the good qualities of the Buddha’s mind. So the distinguishing features of the Buddha’s mind is that it is omniscient, that it is free of all faults, completely as I’ve said, in a way they can’t come back, has all good qualities fully awakened in a way that they never decline. So that means the quality of knowing is completely unobstructed which means that enlightened mind is omniscient. All knowing.
Knowing everything. Anything that exists even the most subtle thing the Buddha knows. So one thing maybe just to go into a little detail is that there are two main strands of the Buddha’s teachings. Are what are called the are the Theravāda teachings of the Buddha which emphasize achieving nirvana, liberation for oneself, and then there are the Mahāyāna teachings that emphasize achieving enlightenment for the benefit of others. So there are various differences in those teachings even though they come from the Buddha but these are the skillful means.
The Buddha taught that system for people who were suited to that kind of path. And then the Buddha taught the Mahāyāna for those who were suited for that path. So there are some differences and one of the differences between these two systems is the understanding of omniscience. And So the Theravāda view of omniscience is much easier to understand and that view is that what omniscience means is that if the Buddha directs his mind, his or her mind to anything they can know it. There’s nothing obstructing the enlightened mind from knowing anything that exists but that mind isn’t knowing everything at the same time.
But whatever an enlightened mind wants to know it can know. So if I was a Buddha and I wanted to read Christina’s mind then I could but if and if I didn’t want to I wouldn’t. But the Mahāyāna view of omniscience is much more mind blowing than that. The Mahāyāna view is that the omniscience means that the enlightened mind is knowing everything all the time. So omniscient mind knows the minds of everyone all the time and never gets confused.
And not only knows the present of your mind but the past and the future simultaneously. The enlightened mind knows the past, present and future of everything and everyone all the time without getting confused about anything. Because the mind is that which knows and when it’s not obstructed from knowing it is knowing everything all the time. So for example, if you were to take a giant tree and chop it up into little toothpicks, billions of toothpicks and scattered them all over the universe then the omniscient mind would look at that toothpick and would know, oh that belonged to that part of the tree. You did hear me say the word future.
Because there is such a thing as the future. Yes. Because there are ordinary people who know something of the future. No, didn’t say you did. I don’t.
But I’ve met people, just ordinary people, well suppose they were well one wasn’t a Buddhist. No I wasn’t a Buddhist. People have flashes of clairvoyance where they see things in the future that happen. Very ordinary people. Maybe in the distant, not distant, in the very near future, tomorrow, next week, something.
But if that happens you know, then if if if an ordinary person with a completely unobscured mind that hasn’t trained their mind can do that even just once for a few moments, what what is what why can we say that it’s not how can we say it’s not possible for a totally unobscured mind to see everything in the future? Anyway, I know this is a very vast thing. I’m just saying, you know, don’t remember what I said at the beginning of the course. Don’t try to understand everything at once. You know?
I don’t understand anything I’m talking about. You know but these are things to consider, to reflect. So when one thinks about these things one has to try and avoid that mind that says I don’t understand this therefore I’ve never heard this before so it’s wrong or it’s rubbish or this is too weird, it’s rubbish. Yeah? Yeah.
And the trouble is you’re hearing it from a little dodo like me, but what I am saying is also what I’m saying is wholeness, you know. I’m not making any of this up. I may not be explaining it very well, but sometimes people in their things say, you said this as as though this is my ideas. You know, Buddhism has been I everything I say is, you know, as far as I can do from the best of my ability, what I’ve been taught that’s in the teachings is not and the way I do it isn’t, you know, someone was saying, oh, you’re a very negative presentation, but I’m presenting how it’s done in the tradition. Yeah?
I’m not making it up. I’m doing it as the tradition does it, as particularly as my guru does it, but as as the tradition and the texts say. So many people want you to just talk about how everything’s so positive, but the Buddha taught from the negative. First, you have to deal with the negative. First noble truth, life is lousy.
It stinks. It is suffering. He never said, oh, it’s full of little pink butterflies and fluffy clouds. He never even said enlightenment was terrific. He said, ordinary life is crap.
You know, excuse me. First noble truth, ordinary life is crap. You know? And there’s a reason it’s, like, so lousy. Yeah.
What? That’s another course. It’s called Samsāra nirvana. It’s because of our mind. Okay.
Oh. Where are we? We’re not gonna have a discussion group tonight either. You can play me. Do you want?
You want? Okay, discuss. Okay, I’ll stop. Obviously sick of me. What is it?
Okay, do you have the questions from last week? I’ve got a few left over. So there are two discussion groups. Do you know which? But I haven’t covered half the things, so you won’t know your homework, how to do the homework.
I’ve got a few. Do you know which group you’re in? So my SPC has now stolen my piece of paper that had all the groups in. It’s on the board out there. Can you bring it in here so we can divide into two groups?
You are supposed to oh, yes, I have never told you. One, two, three, four, five. No, because I don’t want people. I’ve made the group so there’s not people who know each other and stuff. Try and separate people a bit.
Can you read them out? So if your name was called out, maybe you can stay go to this side of the room. Let’s go over there. And then, Christina, could you? There’s another one.
Sorry, they haven’t printed out very well. Somehow the, what do you call it, the formatting got lost in the ether somehow a bit unfortunately. One is your homework and one is a little handout that goes through those four fearlessnesses which I went through. Unfortunately, you won’t be able to do much of the homework, meditations because I haven’t covered the topics. So the daily meditation was for tomorrow to do the four features of Buddha.
So I talked about that. You have a handout on it. So you can do that. Then all of the other ones I haven’t covered. I was gonna cover them tonight, but didn’t.
So you can can think about them yourselves maybe what are the qualities of the Buddha’s mind. You can reflect on that a little bit yourself or just replace it by meditating just doing the Śākyamūni Buddha visualization and mantra practice as as I gave the handout from last week. So just do that. Does everyone have that handout from last week? The the I have a few left over.
Who doesn’t have that meditation on Śākyamūni Buddha? Yeah, only. Yeah, okay and you probably wouldn’t have got that because that was last week’s homework. Yeah. Right.
So Christina, were you here last week? I got the two things. The two things, you got both. Alright, okay. So everyone’s got everything.
Do you have? Yes, yes. Okay. So then just do that as the meditation each day. Okay, I think the daily mindfulness practice is self explanatory.
So I think that’s it for tonight. There was one person who did the homework who wrote in I think a greenish blue pen but they didn’t put their name. Could you please let me know who you are at some point? Because I try and that’s you. And you are?
Prue. You’ll prue. Okay. Sorry. Has someone got a pen I could borrow?
Just one second. Thanks. The blue pen. Actually, the the meditation sheet. The Śākyamūni Buddha one?
Yeah. Alright. And did you get this other one from last week there? You got that one? Yes.
Okay. Good. Okay, we can finish by dedicating the merit because we created some karma tonight. We’re creating karma all the time and doing actions all the time with our body, speech and mind. Tonight it was good karma hopefully because we had a good motivation, a good topic, there was a good action of listening.
And we completed it, so we should be happy that we did it. So that makes a complete positive karmic imprint so we can dedicate that, that it becomes a cause not just to have a good rebirth, not just to get out of saṃsāra, but it becomes a cause or condition for us to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. So the traditional dedication, if you would like to join in, that is on page eleven twelve of our page eleven. Can do this in English. Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I attain the state of a Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state.
May the precious bodhicitta, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Okay, thank you very much everyone. I hope there was some benefit coming tonight. Slowly we will learn something about the Three Jewels of refuge.
So for those people who feel comfortable to do so, especially those who have taken refuge, then the tradition is at the end of teachings to
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
- A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mudra chag gya (Tib)
- Literally, seal or token. A symbolic hand gesture, endowed with power not unlike a mantra. A tantric consort. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.