1 h 50 min · 10,480 words · 2 September 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 110-minute session, Venerable Thubten Dondrub continues his six-part series on refuge in the Three Jewels by examining the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha that make them worthy objects of refuge. He opens with three levels of motivation for practice—from seeking a good rebirth, to liberation from saṃsāra, to bodhicitta, the wish to benefit all beings. The core teaching revolves around the Buddha’s omniscience: the Mahāyāna understanding that an enlightened mind knows all phenomena, past, present, and future, unmistakenly and simultaneously. Dondrub explores how this omniscience, inseparable from perfect compassion, makes the Buddha a trustworthy refuge, then unpacks the sixty-four qualities of the Buddha’s speech and the symbolic power of Buddhist statues. He discusses the Dharma as a perfect medicine reflecting the Buddha’s mind, and the Sangha as experienced practitioners who have realized emptiness. Throughout, he emphasizes that taking refuge means committing to the law of cause and effect and transforming one’s mind through the Buddha’s methods, not magical thinking. Pitched at serious practitioners in a long-running course series.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014 09 02 DB Refuge in the Three Jewels Week 4 02092014.mp3
UUID: c6dd93ab-afa0-4ecb-ac6e-ea86b6b93de4
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: DB Refuge in the Three Jewels (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2014-09-02
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 110.8 minutes
Words: ~10,480
It’s alright. Is it on? Good evening everyone, welcome to the fourth of our six classes on the topic of refuge in the Three Jewels. So to make this time as beneficial as possible, particularly to make it a Dharma action, that is an action that becomes a cause for us to experience less suffering and more genuine happiness, then that depends on ourselves generating the right motivation. So the basic motivation is from a Buddhist point of view, the minimal motivation, Dharma motivation, spiritual motivation is wishing to take care of one’s mind in order to create the causes that will lead to a good rebirth for oneself.
A much deeper motivation is wishing to practice the teachings in order to free the mind completely from cyclic existence, to eliminate the causes of all suffering. But the most profound motivation that we can have for studying and practicing the Buddhist teachings is the bodhicitta motivation wishing I do like this, this is kind of nice. Although you could always move closer but this is pretty good at the moment. The deepest motivation is bodhicitta where we develop this wish to work on our mind, to realize the full potential of our mind, to achieve enlightenment so that we can be of perfect lasting benefit to all sentient beings by helping them to become free of all causes of suffering, helping them to establish the causes that lead to peerless everlasting happiness. And the reason for doing this comes from recognizing how immensely kind sentient beings are to ourselves, how we are totally dependent on them in every possible way.
Especially we depend on the kindness of a mother and we have received this from every sentient being many times beginningless saṃsāra. Diana, may maybe you need a cushion. Cushion. Cushion. Cushion.
Sorry. So the more we recognise the kindness of others that develops the wish to that leads to developing the wish to repay that kindness. And then when we see how all sentient beings are trapped in cyclic existence like ourselves but are experiencing much more of the suffering aspects of saṃsāra than ourselves so helplessly, then we can generate the wish to repay that kindness by helping them to become free of suffering and all the causes of suffering. And more than that helping them to achieve, peerless, everlasting happiness. So this is the very best motivation that anyone can possibly generate.
So we can try and generate that now especially as we say, if you would like to join in, the prayer of refuge in bodhicitta which is on page eleven of our student material. Section one, page eleven. So as we say this prayer to make it more effective we think of the Buddha in front of us as our possible or actual source of refuge, inspiration and guidance and thinking of the Buddha as the very embodiment of the Three Jewels of refuge and at the same time trying to have a sense of all sentient beings surrounding us. So at least thinking of those that we are most connected to in this life starting with our parents on either side, family, friends, and helpers behind us, those who harm us in front. Then, as much as possible, we try to include all the other beings of cyclic existence.
So to achieve enlightenment, to benefit others, then that depends on following the path and that depends on to be able to follow the path correctly, that depends on understanding the path, that depends on listening to the teachings. And we can understand that the whole path to enlightenment or the whole process of practicing and taking care of the mind that leads to every possible benefit starts with genuinely taking refuge in the Three Jewels of Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. So it’s for this reason that we study this topic. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the supreme assembly. By the merits I create through listening to the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings?
So then if you find it helpful, imagine that the Buddha is extremely pleased with your motivation and shows this by coming to the crown of our head seated on the lotus sun and moon. And then when directly above our crown we imagine that the Buddha dissolves into blissful golden light so that that light can then pour down into us, blessing our mind to be able to understand the meaning of refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. So then we can reinforce that positive state of mind by just briefly doing the nine round breathing exercise so that our mind can become a little bit calmer, clearer, more concentrated. K. Thank you.
K. I had a bit of a disaster day today whereby not much got accomplished. I have been teaching Discovering Buddhism for about ten years now. So today is the first day I failed to mark the homework. During the discussion group time I will try and quickly do it if I can.
Or if not, I will get it to you next week. Anyway, so last week I started talking about the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, so I’ll try and complete that tonight. Because traditionally when we talk about the topic of refuge in the triple gem then it mentions how there are two reasons for taking refuge. Firstly, there is the reason of understanding our potential for suffering so wanting to avoid suffering. That’s the basic reason and there are three levels of reasons for taking refuge.
Firstly, wanting to avoid the suffering of a lower rebirth, then wanting to avoid the suffering of cyclic existence altogether, And then the most profound reason for taking refuge is the Mahāyāna reason, fearing the suffering of others, wanting the suffering of others to cease. It’s wanting to help them become free of the suffering of cyclic existence. So one takes refuge in order to achieve enlightenment. So these are the three levels of reasoning for wanting to take refuge in the triple gem. Then on the other side, one takes refuge in the triple gem of Buddha, Dharma, Sangha having come to the conclusion that it’s only the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha that are the complete, perfect, unbetrayable refuge.
There are many other things that are objects of refuge for people in the world but one comes to the conclusion that the Buddha is the perfect refuge, the complete refuge. Therefore one can trust in the Dharma which consists of the teachings of the Buddha and then one takes refuge in the Sangha who are the realized practitioners of those teachings. So the Buddha is said to be like the doctor, the perfect doctor. So when one takes refuge in a sense one realizes that one has a terrible sickness. The worst sickness of all which is the sickness of the mind, of ignorance, that we have this terrible sickness polluting and obscuring our mind.
And that sickness is the cause of every other sickness, physical and mental. All our suffering and all our sickness comes from ignorance. So the Buddha is the perfect doctor who has eliminated that sickness from his own mind and unlike other doctors who apply other remedies, prescribe medicine invented by other people, the Buddha invented this medicine. He discovered the medicine himself, applied it to himself and experienced the result. So the Buddha is the perfect one can look at the Buddha as the perfect doctor and the Buddha’s teachings, the Dharma, are the perfect medicine which we have to take.
You just don’t buy the bottle of medicine and put it on the shelf. One has to practice it. So the teachings are the perfect medicine and then one can see the Sangha who are the realized practitioners of the Buddha as like a nurse, the perfect nurses because these are people who can help us practice the Dharma because they themselves have practiced it perfectly or are practicing it perfectly. So they have far far greater experience than ourselves of how to practice, in what way, what sort of dosage of the Dharma one needs at any particular time. So they are the skilled perfect nurses.
These are the Three Jewels of refuge. It’s important to know the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha because the more we know the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, the more faith we will have and that faith will inspire us to practice what the Buddha taught using the Buddha’s methods and relying on the Sangha. And by putting the teachings into practice, then we get the result. We get the taste of the Dharma ourselves. And by practicing the teachings, hopefully we will get some authentic experience and that experience that the teachings work will increase our faith and therefore our practice and therefore we progress like that.
So it’s really important to know the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. So as I was mentioning last week, the Buddha is the main refuge and the Buddha is the perfect refuge basically because the Buddha’s mind is free of all negativities and possesses all good qualities. And particularly the Buddha, because the Buddha’s mind is completely unobscured, free of all obscurations, then the knowing quality of the Buddha, Buddha mind is operating completely, meaning that the Buddha’s mind is omniscient. I mean, when we yeah. That’s the unique feature of enlightened mind.
It is omniscient, knowing all things all the time unmistakenly. So only enlightened mind has this quality. So, yeah. So one can, in talking about the qualities of the Buddha, one can look at the good qualities of the Buddha’s mind, the good qualities of the Buddha’s speech, the good qualities of the Buddha’s body and the good qualities of his enlightened activities. But all of it, all of these various qualities that one can talk about are all simply elaborations on the fact that the Buddha’s mind is omniscient, all knowing.
And by that it’s knowing everything in an unmistaken way, completely unmistaken. So one could just simply say the Buddha is a perfect refuge because the Buddha is omniscient. But if we leave it at that it’s kind of very vague. It doesn’t lead us to really exercise our mind to think about what omniscience means. And as I was pointing out last week, if you remember, there is a difference in interpretation of omniscience between the Theravāda system and the Mahāyāna.
So in the Theravāda system omniscience basically refers to the fact that the enlightened mind can know anything if it directs it to that. If there’s something that is an object of knowledge then enlightened mind can know it. But the Mahāyāna version but it doesn’t mean that the Buddha is knowing everything all the time. But the Mahāyāna idea of enlightenment is something much more mind blowing because it means that according to the Mahāyāna understanding the enlightened mind, the omniscient mind knows every object of knowledge all the time. It knows all objects of knowledge all the time.
Not just some objects of knowledge but everything that does validly exist. The Buddha mind knows it, is knowing it all the time. So the Buddha’s mind knows all sentient beings all the time but also all inanimate phenomena all the time. And it knows the past of all inanimate things and all sentient beings, the present and the future. In each moment, the Buddha knows the past, present and future of everything.
Unmistakenly, unmixed, nothing confused. This is very hard to conceive. That’s why the Buddha’s qualities are said to be inconceivable. But our tiny mind can try and get some rough idea of this. But if you try and think about it, if a mind is capable of knowing something and there are people who have some kind of clairvoyance, So the mind is capable of knowing much more than we think.
And if we train our mind, there are more things that we can know. For example, if we train our mind, our memory can improve so that we can hold more things in our mind, recall things more clearly. So if the mind can know something, even the obscured mind can know something, if the mind has nothing obscuring it, why wouldn’t the mind know everything? If it can know this, why wouldn’t it know that? Why wouldn’t it be able to know everything?
Why why would there be some things that the enlightened mind couldn’t know? It doesn’t make sense. Especially when you think that from a Buddhist point of view the meaning of the word phenomena is defined as something that can be known by mind. So if there is something that can be known, if something validly exists, it can be known by mind so the omniscient mind can know it and completely, unmistakenly, because there’s nothing obscuring the mind from knowing it there’s nothing obscuring the mind that would make the mind know things in a mistaken way. Alright?
So that is why the Buddha is the perfect refuge, really, in a nutshell, because the Buddha, enlightened mind, is omniscient, unmistaken. One of the you know there are many epithets for what the Buddha like Sugata and Tathāgata and Bhagawan and all these various words and praises of what the Buddha is. One of the quite sounds like the most boring epithet for the Buddha but actually is the most important profound one is that the Buddha is a valid knower. Is the the valid knower. The Buddha has the mind that is completely valid.
It is the only completely valid mind. It is completely unmistaken. So the Buddha’s awareness or omniscience permeates in seeing everything about the past, everything about the present, and everything about the future. So if we take ourself, so therefore why is that therefore we can think of the Buddha as being the perfect refuge for myself? Because the Buddha’s mind knows everything about my past.
Everything. Every single thing. And knows that all the time. Is fully aware of everything about my past all the time. And not only that, the Buddha is fully aware of everything about my present, every moment.
So because of that, the Buddha can help me, really help. That’s of course if you accept that there is enlightened mind, which of course depends on accepting that there is mind. But once you accept there is mind, you have to accept the enlightened mind. Yes? Alive.
All Buddhas are alive. That’s one of the qualities of you achieve the another term for someone who has become a Buddha is that they have achieved the deathless state. They don’t die. So they are definitely alive, the mind is existing. Yes, there are many Buddhas because everyone has mind so people are practicing, following the path, gaining realizations so people over the centuries have achieved enlightenment.
And also before this in far distant times. Because again according to the Theravāda view of the history of the Buddha, Prince Siddhartha was a prince, got married, had a child, left the palace, experienced all these austerities for six years then became a Buddha and then started teaching the Dharma. But according to the Mahāyāna version Śākyamūni Buddha, Prince Siddhartha was a Buddha billions of lifetimes ago. He achieved enlightenment inconceivable a long time ago and he just manifested being born as a human being, as a prince and going through all those things for our sake. One could say there are two kinds of Buddhas, although the qualities of all Buddhas are the same.
For example, John, John, at some point if you practice, because you are practicing, then you will at some point become a Buddha. And hopefully everyone in this room at some point will become a Buddha with the qualities exactly the same as Śākyamūni Buddha. But there are other Buddhas such as Śākyamūni Buddha who are called teaching Buddhas because they manifest as Buddhas and introduce or reintroduce the Dharma into a world where the Buddhist teachings don’t exist and they teach those for others. So these are founding Buddhas. So everyone who becomes a Buddha doesn’t do that.
But someone like Śākyamūni Buddha does that. According to the Mahāyāna, I think this is even according to Theravāda too, are in a period of time wherein one thousand teaching Buddhas will appear. And Śākyamūni Buddha is the fourth of those thousand Buddhas. Because according to the tradition, Śākyamūni Buddha’s teachings are going to last for five thousand years. And they are declining From the very time of the Buddha the teachings decline in the sense that the people being reborn into the world are more obscured, have heavier delusions, less faith, so the practice becomes more corrupt.
And so with time it becomes harder and harder to be able to practice the teachings and gain the realizations. And they become more the practice the people practicing or claiming to practice become more corrupt and everything. So eventually the teachings die out and everything. Then there’s a really dark period of time where things are truly horrible. And then again another Buddha appears and starts the whole process again.
So Maitreya Buddha will be the one to come in the future, will be the fifth Buddha of this period like that. Anyway, there are infinite numbers of Buddhas, infinite numbers. Don’t worry, you don’t have to say that, I will tell you. What do you mean? By the way, for those new people, emptiness is referring to the nature of reality.
This is the main teaching of the Buddha because realizing the nature of reality opposes ignorance, which the Buddha discovered as the cause of all suffering. So the Buddha has perfectly realized this emptiness and has taught it. So what what is the problem? So the Buddha is experiencing emptiness all the time. One of the unique features of the Buddha’s mind is that only a Buddha is able to experience the conventional and the absolute nature of anything and everything at the same time.
So there is the conventional truth and then there is the ultimate truth. And the ultimate truth refers to how everything is empty of inherent existence. This is another big topic of the Buddhadharma. So for an advanced practitioner, if we practice the teachings eventually we will be able to understand what emptiness really means and then at a more advanced stage we will be able to actually directly perceive it. But we will only be able to perceive it in a state of very deep meditation.
Out of meditation things will again appear to truly exist from their own side. But a Buddha is able to experience the conventional nature of things and the ultimate nature of things simultaneously. And the Buddha can do this with everything, all things, the past, present, and future of all phenomena and all sentient beings all the time. That is why the Buddha is the perfect refuge. Else wanted to ask a question?
Trish? Well apparently yes. Determinators, I knew that question was coming. No, it doesn’t. No, it doesn’t mean they’re predetermined.
I don’t really understand this, but as I said, and you possibly will agree with me, that there are people who are not crazy or lying who have some ability to see future. The future may only be tomorrow. Some people see things that happen further along than that. I know a couple of people, just very, very ordinary people, who have had experiences of seeing something in the future. My way of understanding it is, which may be completely wrong, so this is not official Dharma, this is just my own theory is that in any situation anyway, the essential teaching of the Buddha related to emptiness is dependent arising.
Everything arises depending on many factors. So at any one time a whole lot of factors are operating and because of that something has to happen, something has to arise because of those factors. So the Buddha can understand that, can perceive that, that depending on this many factors happening, this will happen. And so the Buddha can also see that if that factor changes then this will happen. But if that factor changes, that will happen.
And if that factor changes, this will happen. So in that way the Buddha can see the future but it doesn’t mean the future is fixed. If you roll a ball down a hill then you know you don’t have to be clairvoyant to know the ball is probably going to reach the bottom. There’s very few things that are going to stop it. Know you can tell that.
You can know by logic you know, that the ball is going to run down to the very bottom. So I kind of like that. The Buddha can see all the possibilities, can see all the things changing and therefore if it goes like that, that will happen. If it goes like that, that will happen. If it goes like that, that will happen.
And once what you know, once we’ve set things in motion, you know, it’s not exactly predetermined, but it’s pretty inevitable that that that will happen. Like, if if you if you let a ball run down a hill, it’s pretty inevitable that it’s gonna go right down to the bottom. There’s not much that’s gonna come along. You know, Superman is probably not going to come along and stop it. Yeah.
It’s pretty inevitable. It’s not predetermined. It’s just how things go. Yeah. Partly.
Yes. Yeah. And dependent arising and just how things work so the Buddha can see those things. But there’s nothing controlling everything, some external thing controlling it. There are factors, there is the law of cause and effect, there is dependent arising.
So the Buddha sees all these things. We can’t, we don’t. But because enlightened mind, unobscured mind can, that is the perfect refuge. Because the Buddha can see if you do that, this will happen. If you do that, that will happen.
So do that and don’t do that. When do I have to stop? Twenty past. Everything is related to the fact that the Buddha is omniscient but also that omniscient awareness is pervaded by great compassion. There is nothing obscuring because also that goes along with omniscient awareness, unmistaken awareness that we get angry with people because we don’t really see, we don’t really know what is going on for that person.
But an omniscient mind, unobscured mind, sees this person as suffering. They are doing negative things, but this is because they are suffering and the Buddha can see the whole past history of why this person is suffering and can see the future suffering this person is going to experience because of the negative things they are doing. So there’s a mind that is experiencing that not just knowing it abstractly intellectually but experiencing it. For example, we can know that someone tells us that this particular fruit that we’ve never eaten tastes delicious. You know this person’s not lying so you know this fruit, fruit X from country YZ that you’ve never been to tastes delicious.
So one knows that. But then there’s the biting into that fruit. That knowing is completely different. That is a direct experience. Yeah.
That’s completely different. You know, we all know about New York, but I don’t know how many people here have been to New York. Knowing about New York and being in New York, experiencing it is completely different. Different. So the Buddha is experiencing everything directly all the time.
Yeah? So the Buddha is directly experiencing every person’s state of mind and what they feel and know and etcetera and is knowing what is happening what has happened will happen to them. So how do you how do you experience that? With compassion. You can’t there’s no way you can experience that with hate.
Because hate arises from not knowing what oneself is because hate is harming oneself. And hate arises because one feels, believes that I can be hurt. I hate you because you’re going to hurt me. But someone who is really experiencing themselves knows that I can’t be hurt. I can’t suffer.
An enlightened mind cannot suffer. So there is nothing to fear, nothing to hate, nothing to be worried about, stressed about. So the only thing an enlightened mind can experience is compassion. It can’t feel hate or any of those pathetic, negative things that we experience. So that omniscient awareness is pervaded by perfect compassion for everyone all the time, no matter what they’re doing.
Perfect love, perfect acceptance, perfect everything. So that’s pretty good refuge. The Buddha loves us, has compassion for us, no matter what we do. No matter what we do. So we need that kind of refuge because we all make mistakes.
We all do wrong things, bad things, harmful things. But the Buddha still loves us, still has compassion for us, doesn’t give up. Someone could have lots of compassion and love but they could at some point just give up thinking oh, guy is just hopeless. Omniscient mind, the energy of omniscient mind never declines. It just goes on and on forever.
The omniscient mind has this endless enthusiasm, endless patience. As I have tried to say, one can imagine that minds can be so obscured that it may take lifetimes and lifetimes before even that person, that being is in any position to understand even one tiny, tiny aspect of the Dharma. And yet the enlightened mind can wait that long to appear to that being, to teach them that thing in some way, not necessarily as a Buddha, but in some form the Buddha can manifest to help that person when the time is right. So the Buddha is waiting for us all the time to be able to nudge us along. And that nudge may appear in all sorts of ways.
Some good, some what look to us as good ways, they may appear to us as bad things, but actually it could be the Buddha helping us. That is maybe just a little bit about the enlightened mind. There are millions of things that could be said. Else could I say? Yes, so for example the intention to benefit others, that aspect of the Buddha’s mind never declines.
The Buddha’s enthusiasm never declines. Buddha’s mindfulness of others never declines. The Buddha’s concentration never declines. The Buddha has perfect concentration. There’s not the slightest moment when Buddha mind is distracted.
The Buddha’s awareness of reality never declines. So because of these things one can say the enlightened mind is the perfect refuge. And then there are the the qualities of the Buddha’s speech which if sorry. Oh, no. Why am I so technically hopeless?
The Buddha’s speech is said to have sixty four qualities. I could bore you by reading all sixty four, but I won’t. I should give you a handout of this, but anyway. Example, listening to the Buddha’s speech it makes the mind pliable, it goes straight to your mind, it is very sensible, perfectly correct, unstained, very clear, it’s harmonious, it’s suitably encouraging, it cannot be faulted, it is pleasing to hear, it tames your mind, is never harsh or cruel, It refreshes the body, soothes the mind, makes the heart happy, gives rise to happiness and bliss, never leaves one disappointed, is worth knowing completely, is clear in all its details, is it it’s inspiring, makes one know things completely, causes one to fit details together to make sense, It’s logical, pertinent, has no redundancies. Like that.
It’s complete, joyously exhilarating, pervasive. It stimulates growth. And it is said that when the Buddha speaks, a Buddha manifesting as a Buddha speaks, then people from speaking different languages can understand the Buddha in their own language. So the Buddha makes a sound, but everyone can understand it. Also when a Buddha speaks, different people understand what the Buddha is saying in exactly the way that they need to understand it for their benefit.
Not misunderstand it, but understand it in a good way for their own benefit. So then there are the good qualities of the Buddha’s body. So the Buddha has the ability to manifest in countless ways from the mind. The Buddha can appear in all sorts of ways to benefit sentient beings. Traditionally the Buddha is depicted as in the statue behind me, but the Buddha can appear in countless other ways to benefit sentient beings.
The Buddha is appearing in infinite numbers of ways all the time to benefit sentient beings. But even this particular aspect of the Buddha is something that is beneficial for the mind. And all the different deities and forms of the Buddha all connect with particular qualities that we have. So in our world now, our world, especially the first world, is full of images. Like if you think about in the Middle Ages, there was hardly any kind of images existing in the world.
And if you except like in in the Christian West, if you went to church, you would see some statues and maybe some paintings on the church, which people had incredible devotion to, and but they was and would have been seen as incredibly, like, magical, these incredibly beautiful statues and paintings. Because where else would an ordinary person see anything like that? Because there were no books. Only very, very, very rich people owned a book because they were all hand painted and whatever. No one could afford a painting.
Only the very rich. There was no television, no movies. So there are very few images. But now there’s billions of images and unfortunately most of them come from the advertising world and everything. They’re all about attachment and delusion.
Whereas these images come, this is Buddhist advertising, Buddhist advertising agency coming from an enlightened mind with an enlightened purpose. These images, even if we don’t understand them, have the purpose of benefiting our mind, of reducing our delusions and awakening our positive qualities, whereas much of what we see in our world now is consciously or unconsciously designed to awaken all our delusions, particularly attachment. So even if we don’t understand what these images mean, they have some positive impact on our mind because of the enlightened influence. It doesn’t really matter whether the actual Buddha looks like this or not because actually the real aspect of the Buddha is just space like mind which has no physical appearance whatsoever. But for our sake, the Buddha appears like that, like this statue.
Apparently he appeared like that in the world, something like that. But somehow when we look at these images Buddhist statues are very popular around the world. Even if people who aren’t Buddhists like Buddhist statues, They like to put them in their garden or as decorations in the home. And I’ve met many people who they say they feel that they somehow made a connection with Buddhism because when they were young some relative had a statue of a Buddha which they used to look at and think, you know, and then it made some imprint in the mind somehow because that image is somehow extremely powerful because the Buddha’s thought it up. It comes from enlightened mind.
And in fact, believe it or not, the Tibetan lamas say Buddhist statues may be Buddhas. That that statue there that looks like it’s made of bronze and whatever, looks like it was from ordinary appearances it was made in Nepal. Shipped here, made of bronze and made in Nepal. But it could actually be a Buddha. It could be the emanation of a Buddha.
Because the Buddha can appear in all sorts of ways as human beings, Buddhas can appear as Buddhas, Buddhas can appear as Bodhisattvas, as arhats, as good practitioners, they appear as Gurus, they can appear as dogs, trees, bridges, anything to benefit sentient beings. They can appear as books, they can appear as good people, they can appear as bad people, they can appear as murderers, prostitutes, any anything to benefit sentient beings. And they can appear as statues for the benefit of sentient beings. I think most Tibetans believe that the statue of the Buddha in the Jokhang temple in Lhasa is a Buddha, that it is actually a manifestation of the Buddha. They have incredible devotion to it.
And there are many stories of statues moving and talking. If you go to Bodh Gaya at the Bodhi temple, the main stupa, there’s an image of Tārā that is said to have spoken to Lama Atisha, who is this great Indian master who went to Tibet in the eleventh century. The refuge prayer that we say was composed by him. And when I went with Lama Zopa Rinpoche to Tibet in nineteen eighty five, We were shown around Sera Je monastery by this Geshe who had debated with His Holiness the Dalai Lama when His Holiness got his Geshe degree in nineteen fifty eight. This Geshe had been tortured by the communist Chinese.
They had stuck a nail in his knee, hammered a nail into his knee. So he walked with a limp now. So he showed us around Sera Monastery, and he showed us all these statues that had spoken, who talked to various people. Thus have I heard. The Geshe did but I didn’t understand it because it was in Tibetan. Lama Zopa Rinpoche translated for us.
Anyway somehow the image of the Buddha by looking at it, it creates some sense of peace and calmness and a sense of the mind being subdued. And just sitting in that position, somehow that itself just brings benefit to the mind. Just emulating that posture. So just very quickly the enlightened activities of the Buddha’s oh yeah the good qualities of the Buddha’s enlightened activities. So the Buddha has this endless energy.
There is nothing preventing the Buddha benefiting beings in countless ways. And this is what the Buddha does. The Buddha appears in all sorts of ways to help sentient beings. So the Buddha appears as a Buddha, as a Bodhisattva, but also the most profound way, the most direct way a Buddha can benefit another sentient being is by teaching the Dharma, teaching the path to enlightenment. And it’s really only human beings who can understand that.
You know, you can’t the Buddha can’t teach animals the Dharma. They don’t have the ability to understand. Right? So the Buddha teaches human beings and so the Buddha appears in this world as the great spiritual masters teaching the Dharma. So that is one way the Buddha appears.
But also the Buddha can appear as just an ordinary human being who may come along and be friendly to us, give us some words of wisdom that can really completely open up our mind and change our life. Because the Buddha is omniscient and knows exactly what’s going on in our mind then the Buddha can appear at the right time to say or do something. One could do an exercise should think of this as I always think of this as good things I never think of them when I said the homework but an extra bit of homework could be to think, to try and trace how did you get interested in Buddhism? What led you here tonight or to come to Buddha House or the very first Buddhist talk or encounter you ever had. There was something and before that there was something and something and something.
Different books you read or someone said something. Maybe the book you read, maybe the person who said something was Buddha. They may have looked like just ordinary Joe Blow, but you we we really can’t know Because you can’t judge as my mother used to say, you can’t judge a book by its cover. Someone may look like an ordinary sentient being, but there’s no way we can really know the mind of another person as we are as ordinary people. What looks like an ordinary person could be a Buddha.
Their mind could be enlightened. So the Buddha is not a problem for a Buddha to appear as a good person, a bad person, a tree, a dog. They have no ego so they’re quite happy to appear in all sorts of ways to benefit sentient beings and they do. Sadly we are so obscured we don’t often realize this. We don’t get the message.
But the Buddha tries again and again and again. I still haven’t finished. Okay. Break now?. Maybe we should have a discussion group but just very quickly for the sake of the homework.
What are the qualities of the Dharma? So basically the qualities of the Dharma are really a reflection of the qualities of the Buddha because Dharma, the teachings of the Buddha are a reflection of the qualities of the Buddha’s mind. So the Buddha’s mind is free of all faults, everything as it is, is pervaded by great compassion and perfect wisdom and loving kindness and so on. So the qualities of the Dharma is that they reflect the qualities of the enlightened mind and show us how we can achieve those qualities ourselves. So if we check the Buddha’s teachings, one can start to see how there is an emphasis on compassion and complete compassion for all sentient beings, not just some but for all sentient beings.
And that compassion is a reflection, is a response to suffering. The Buddhist teachings on compassion talk about many levels of suffering not just the obvious ones. So it is a complete so that is a reflection of how the omniscient mind sees everything is complete. So it’s not just about compassion for people experiencing obvious suffering but also the subtle suffering which we think of as happiness and the very subtle compounded pervasive suffering. And there are amazing teachings on patience explaining how anger is completely harmful in every possible way, in every possible situation.
So this again is a reflection of that pure love and compassion of the Buddha mind. So the Buddha’s teachings possess, you know, because the Buddha has every perfect quality, the Buddha’s teachings are about developing all these qualities in a complete perfect way. The Buddha’s teachings contain in a complete way the opponent powers to all of our delusions. Explaining how we can firstly modify, pacify all our different delusions, but then ultimately how we can eliminate them through developing the understanding of the nature of reality, empty nature of all things. And this is the particular super special wonderful quality of the Buddha’s teachings that it explains the nature of reality.
Something which is extremely profound but it shows the greatness of the Buddha’s mind that something that is so incredibly profound and subtle can actually be explained so that we with limited minds can understand it. It takes time and effort but if we apply our mind we can understand these teachings about the very subtle nature of reality. Especially if as the Buddha explains in the teachings we put effort into purifying our mind and accumulating merit. So the Buddha’s teachings being a reflection of the enlightened mind give us an indication of what the enlightened mind actually is. We’re not able to By studying the Buddha’s teachings we can start to see that these teachings are truly extraordinary, that they very far reaching and very, very profound.
So this gives us some kind of idea that enlightened mind exists, because these teachings are not ordinary. They come from a truly extraordinary mind. So then the Sangha, this is a term that in general applies to monks and nuns, ordained people, monks and nuns, bhikshus and bhikṣuṇīs and novice monks and nuns who are following the Buddhist teachings, the monastic community of monks and nuns. But the Sangha jewel is referring to people who are have gained like deep realizations, insights into the Buddhist teachings because they have practiced these teachings very intensively, very purely for a considerable period of time and have been able to gain these realizations. So although they are not a member of the Sangha, that is a Sangha actual object of refuge, may still not be free of cyclic existence yet, but they still are beings that we can rely on because they have at least gained a direct perception of the nature of reality.
So they are living lives of pure morality. This is a great basis for trust. Again, I’m not just talking about ordinary monks and nuns because they’re supposed to be living lives of pure morality but not necessarily are. But someone who is the actual Sangha jewel is doing so, is living a life of pure morality, has developed, has a subdued mind because in order to gain a direct perception of the nature of reality, for that to happen, there are many preconditions for that. So one of which is that person, male or female, has to have developed single pointed concentration.
The ability to meditate at a very profound level. And to do that one has to have subdued the mind, one has to develop the ability to pacify one’s delusions because it is the delusions that are the obstacle to developing a concentrated mind. A mind that is single pointedly focused on what one wants to focus on, something which is either neutral or especially virtuous or meaningful. Anyone can concentrate on something negative. That comes naturally.
That’s not single pointed concentration. Single pointed concentration, meditative concentration, is where the mind focuses effortlessly on something that is meaningful and virtuous. What do you mean? To achieve that or how long you can stay on it? That is a good question.
I think when you develop Samādhi you can more or less stay on the object for however long you like. There are nine stages of developing it. You achieve the first stage when you are able to more or less focus on the object for the length of time it takes to recite Om Mani Padme Hum twenty one times. So that’s about thirty seconds or a bit less. Let’s say thirty seconds.
So the first stage of Samādhi is when you’re able to keep your mind on the object for about thirty seconds. And then with the next stages it gets progressively longer. But also, you know, when you say you keep your mind on the object for thirty seconds, it’s still in a very how do you say your mind is on the object but not very strongly. Whereas as you develop the different stages your mind stays on the object longer but the experience is far more intense and there’s all these subtle obstacles that are removed. To gain a direct perception of the nature of reality one has to have developed not only Samādhi single pointed concentration but something which is a little bit beyond that which is called Vipassana or Vipashyana.
Samādhi, you can achieve that by how do you say that you don’t have to understand emptiness to achieve Samādhi but once you’ve achieved that, the main purpose of achieving Samādhi in the Buddhist tradition is so that you can meditate on the nature of reality because that’s what’s going to liberate us from suffering. But of course you don’t only meditate on emptiness, by developing Samādhi whatever you meditate on becomes one’s experience of it becomes very very complete and intense. So if you meditate on compassion in a state of Samādhi one is able to develop compassion and enhance one’s compassion much more completely and quickly. Or if you meditate on any topic with Samādhi, the experience comes more quickly, more intensively. But for us we meditate with a mind like that.
So it’s difficult to get much deep experience when the mind is still quite uncontrolled. I wouldn’t say complete vacancy. Are you relating this to emptiness? No, no, no. Yeah, but see when you meditate properly whatever the kind in Buddhism you have to have an object and so meditation involves developing an intense awareness of that object.
So there is always an object, not just kind of like nothing going on. But then you have a deep experience of it. Your mind stays on that object. So the object may be just your breath. There has to be an object.
So there’s two things. There’s developing concentration but then you apply that. But many people think meditation is just concentrating but that’s just one aspect of meditation. You develop, we try and develop concentration but in Buddhism, particularly in Tibetan Buddhism, aim, or maybe I should say in Mahāyāna Buddhism, the aim of the purpose of developing concentration is then to apply that concentration to developing a deeper intellectual understanding of the teachings and this will lead eventually to a non conceptual experience of them. Yes, but that’s what you have to do.
Yeah. There’s two I’m getting off the topic here, anyway there are two kinds of meditation. There is concentration meditation where you place your mind on one object and you let go of all thoughts basically except you need a little bit of thought to keep your mind on the you you have to be thinking about sometimes you need mindfulness to check whether your mind is on the object or if some obstacle is coming you have to think about how to avoid that obstacle and once you’ve done that then you stop the thought and keep your your mind on the object again. But eventually you reach a point where there’s just this your mind is absorbed single pointedly on the object and there’s no real thought going on. There is awareness but no thought.
The other kind of meditation is analytical meditation where you think about logically about subject. But again you try to do that in the context of being concentrated on what you’re thinking about. In other words, if you start thinking about something else you’re not concentrated on the topic anymore. So it’s possible to develop single pointed concentration and then you use that ability to single pointedly concentrate. You use that to think in a complex way about a particular topic.
But it doesn’t it doesn’t do that. It doesn’t agitate your mind. Sorry? And you do that by the teaching. Well that’s what the teachings are.
All the Buddha’s teachings are, believe it or not, topics of meditation. In general this is related to concentration but one of the obstacles to developing concentration is what is called sinking and there are two kinds of it. There is gross sinking where your mind just goes really dull and sleepy and then there is a subtle version of it or levels of subtlety of that. And this could be mistaken for being concentrated because the mind becomes very still and clear up to a point. But actually it’s a kind of obstacle to progressing.
One has to be really alert to that. Because a lot of people get into meditation because they just want to experience kind of peace. But this is not the purpose of meditation in Buddhism ultimately. Well ultimately is to get the highest peace but in order to do that one has to train the mind. So the idea is not to meditate just to kind of have a peaceful experience, if you know what I mean.
Yes, yes, of course. That’s what happens. Yes, once you’ve got Samādhi, it goes on for hours and you don’t even breathe apparently. You stop ordinary a sign of developing Samādhi is your ordinary breathing has stopped. It looks like you’re dead.
Well I mean no, because you don’t go horrible and everything and stink and rot but actually there is no ordinary breathing going on. Cold. Good. Right. Okay.
Have we got time to discuss is this time for discussion group? No? Not now? I’ve ruined it. Some questions, more questions on refuge.
Does somebody want to say something? Comment questions. Yes, yes. Okay. Okay, no.
I think I’ve run out of things to say tonight anyway. Anyway, what more can I say? Do you have, yeah. Okay. Does everyone did people take the the discussion topics for today?
No. No. I don’t. Thanks. Okay.
I will ask you a question out of these five questions, which is number four. How necessary is it to have an external refuge rather than just relying on your own innate wisdom? What do you think? Do we all agree on that? We’re talking about the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha.
Do we need something like that? Do you think you need something like that or you’re just okay by yourself? Right. Yes. Younger people can be more receptive and older people can be more fixed in their ways but not necessarily.
Yes it does depend on the personal life. But I agree with everything you say Cheryl, I’m not quite sure how that relates to do we need an external refuge or not. Yes, I mean Yes, but here I’m talking about a good one, the right one. A little one. Yes, basically.
Yeah. So we all agree on that, do we? Pardon? I think there is a big danger of using a place as a refuge, even the Buddhist center as making the place and the people the refuge. Well I’m not sure if it’s even perfect but I think what I’m trying to say is you can mistake a Buddhist center for Buddhism.
It’s trying to present it but the place and the people can become the main thing whereas it should be the teachings that the centre exists for which is the refuge. Yes that’s true. That’s why hopefully the teachings are alive and being practiced at the center. That’s very important. Yes, yes.
Also I would like to make a big distinction between the Dharma and Buddhism. I think there is a big difference or can be unfortunately a big difference between the Buddhadharma and Buddhism. Buddhism can be something very conservative and cozy and blah blah blah, whereas the Buddhadharma is some and Buddhism can be very impure, whereas the Buddhadharma, the actual teachings of the Buddha are very pure and perfect and they’re very radical and quite threatening. Actually they’re not cozy and cute and lovely lovey dovey. They’re very threatening actually.
Quite scary in a good way. Whereas Buddhism can be very bland. One of the things Lama Yeshe always used to talk about, he never talked about Buddhism but he talked about the Buddhadharma and the Buddha being a student of the Dharma, a Dharma student. He never talked about Buddhists. He talked about being Dharma students.
And this is what we should be, students of the Dharma. Yeah. Someone who is trying to understand what the Buddha taught and trying to practice it. I think that that’s really important. But it’s true and the point I was trying to make is that really our mind can be very, very tricky.
Buddhist teachings emphasize particularly Lama Yeshe in his teachings one of the wonderful things about his teachings of the Dharma is that he emphasized that we do have wisdom and we should try to trust that but this is also a very tricky thing because what we make our mind is obscured and it’s obscured by ignorance and self-cherishing and selfishness and all these things and our deluded mind can tell us this is good and I’m doing this in the right way, but it’s not at all. Without a very deep understanding of the Dharma, then one can honestly mistake things that we’re experiencing as some genuine kind of insight or realization when in fact it’s quite the opposite. There are quite severe disturbed mental states that can be mistaken for realisations. And as I was trying to say in the teachings about Samādhi, greatest obstacle to developing single pointed concentration is what is called subtle sinking. And subtle sinking, some people who experience that actually think they have realized Samādhi but actually what they’re experiencing is the greatest obstacle to it.
So if you just rely on yourself, one won’t get any value. One needs people who have far more experience than ourselves. That experience ultimately depends on practicing the Dharma which depends on the Buddha. So we do need the external refuge to help us experience more genuinely our Buddha nature, I think. Yes indeed, thank you very much for that point.
You can do the discovering Buddhism, which is what Judy is saying, is you can do this discovering Buddhism modules many, many times because people come and attend one of these modules and think, now I’ve done that, I know that. But actually each of these modules is about subjects that one can study for a lifetime. Because that study is not just intellectual, it’s about practicing it. In Buddhism when they talk about study it means not just reading the words or making notes or something, means putting that into practice, one’s own mind, using Buddha’s teachings to understand one’s own mind and change one’s mind and check up the results. Every time you hear the teachings, the same teaching, one is hearing it with a different mind.
And if one’s practicing, that different mind is a little bit purer, more virtuous mind. So when you hear it again, one can understand a lot more. That’s very important. How long is a piece of string? When you read it?
Well, there’s no just fix one. There’s many, you know Well, you know, know there’s said to me so many teachings. Yes. Eighty four thousand. Right.
And each one can go on forever. No, I shouldn’t say forever but maybe some of them could. Actually they say Well what is considered the Buddhadharma, to be quite honest, not all of it was directly what is now especially in the Buddhist Tibetan tradition what is considered to be the authentic Buddhadharma. Not all of that was directly spoken by the Buddha. It has been taught by the great practitioners after the Buddha but through their realizations and elaborating, explaining in more detail what the Buddha taught or what the Buddha implied.
But it’s still what one can say the Buddha’s teachings because these are people who are genuinely following the path of the Buddha and just elaborating on things at our level. Example, The Buddhist teachings on the one hand are all about non harming. So anger is harmful to oneself and others. So any practitioner understands that especially when they look at their mind. So the great practitioners who have really looked at their mind and seen their own anger and worked out how to overcome it, understanding from the Buddhist teachings that it is harmful.
They have worked out all sorts of ways to subdue in a skillful way anger and they’ve written about it because they’ve experienced it. So although those writings are not exactly the Buddha never spoke them, They are the Buddha’s teachings because they are elaborating an essential point that the Buddha made. Well, depends on what topic. There are millions of Buddhists then you go to Śāntideva’s book called The Way of the Bodhisattva and you go to chapter six called Patience. It is the most wonderful, profound, but yeah.
But generally speaking, you you need a even yeah. You need a commentary. You need someone to explain it to you, ideally. I’m just trying to I think it’s chapter six, isn’t it? Or is it chapter five?
I have this book by His Holiness called Healing Anger The Power of Patience from a Buddhist Perspective. We have to stop now for tonight. Thank you very much for your attention. I hope there’s been something useful tonight. Did people cover the discussion topics last week?
Covered all of them? Okay. So maybe in conclusion I would just like to make this point that sometimes the idea of taking refuge or practicing refuge can seem like something magical that you take refuge or you practice refuge and all these things happen. What practicing refuge or doing refuge really means is the essential refuge for us is the Buddha’s teachings, the Dharma. And I’ve said this before but just to repeat, the essential Dharma teaching is the law of cause and effect.
All of the Buddha’s teachings are related to, connected to, dependent on understanding and practicing the law of cause and effect. So when we take refuge we are committing ourselves to follow the Buddha’s teachings, to practice them as much as possible. Applying them to our mind, understanding that our mind is the source of all happiness and suffering. So we have to work with our mind, we need a method and we’re going to use the Buddha’s methods because they’re complete and perfect. And the essential method is to observe the law of cause and effect.
So if we do that, which means avoiding negative actions of body, speech and mind as much as possible, we won’t create the cause for a lower rebirth. And by observing the law of cause and effect we engage more and more in virtuous actions of body, speech and mind which create the cause for a good rebirth. And so by taking a good rebirth, where we meet the Dharma again, have faith in it, have the conditions to practice, we will be able to take care of our mind a bit more in our next life and then in the life after that the life after that. And therefore eventually we will be able to get out of saṃsāra and we will be able to generate bodhicitta and follow the path to enlightenment. So taking refuge, going for refuge, doing refuge is taking care of the mind, applying the Buddha’s methods to our mind as much as we possibly can.
So that is what will protect us, not just sort of praying to the Buddha or yeah. So it’s not it’s not magic. But also if we have refuge, if we can think of the Buddha at the time of our death, then we won’t have a bad rebirth. Because what determines whether we have a good rebirth or not is the state of mind we’re in when we die. Because depending on the state of mind we are in when we die, a particular karmic imprint will ripen.
So negative karmic imprints ripen when the mind is in a negative state when we die. Positive imprints ripen if the mind is in a positive state when we die. So if we can think of the Buddha or the Dharma or the Sangha as we are dying with some real faith, some genuine devotion, the Buddha says there’s no way one can have a bad rebirth. Because if one is thinking of the Buddha, then the mind is in a virtuous state. If one is thinking of the Dharma, if one is cultivating at the time of death love, compassion, etc, then the mind is in a virtuous state.
If one is thinking of the Sangha with faith at the time of death, the mind is in a virtuous state. As I’ve said here before, once my teacher Lama Zopa Rinpoche said something which I found really encouraging. He said that even if as you’re dying you think of just an ordinary monk or nun with faith, just an ordinary monk or nun who doesn’t have any, especially, any realizations, but you you have admiration for what they represent. Yeah? If you think of that person as you’re dying, you cannot have a bad rebirth.
You wouldn’t take a bad rebirth if you had those thoughts. You couldn’t. Because, yeah, the Buddha teaches us not to take our life, not to take anyone else’s life but also our own. But to take one’s own life, you have to be in a pretty negative state. So this is not a good good time to die when the mind is in a negative state.
And it also comes from thinking that people commit suicide mainly I think because they think there’s not going to be anything at all afterwards. But there is. And it could be worse than what you’re trying you know, people commit suicide because some suffering is unbearable. But what could happen after could be even worse from a Buddhist point of view. So if one has any faith in the Buddhist teachings, one would not commit suicide or one would try not to even if one’s life was pretty miserable.
And one could try and think if one had a miserable life that that this is the ripening of my negative karma. So it’s okay. It’s happening now. It could happen it could be at worse time. It’s happening now.
So this is good. My suffering life is good. It’s a good thing. Yeah, and it’s not permanent. The mind, you know, and hopefully if one had some refuge.
But it’s true, I mean I know of some Buddhists who have committed suicide. But of course there are many levels of refuge. We can say I have refuge but that’s when one can really see if one has refuge. When one has a problem, what do I do to solve it? Do I practice the Dharma or do I just do another usual ordinary thing?
Blame other people, get drunk, you know, distract myself? Do we really have refuge or not? But if we have refuge, we would try to practice the Dharma. Finish. So if you would like to join in to complete the class, can dedicate the positive imprints, the time spent here.
May these positive imprints become a cause for us to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all suffering beings. Page eleven Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of the Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious bodhicitta, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. So if you have refuge or are thinking about taking refuge or would like to experiment with taking refuge then the tradition is at the end of the teachings we make three prostrations to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha.
We
Key terms in this teaching
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sugata Tib: de war sheg pa; Wyl: bde bar gshegs pa
- An epithet for a buddha, literally “excellent (su) gone one (gata).” LYWA
- tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
- Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.