DB Refuge in the Three Jewels — 2014-08-19

1 h 51 min · 10,959 words · 19 August 2014 · Buddha House Adelaide

DB Refuge in the The Three Jewels (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Refuge in the The Three Jewels (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Refuge in the Three Jewels — 2014-08-19
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this two-hour session on refuge in the Three Jewels, Ven Thubten Dondrub explores the philosophical foundations of Buddhist practice. After grounding students in the three motivational levels of refuge—protection from suffering rebirth, liberation from cyclic existence, and the Mahāyāna aspiration to enlighten all beings—he addresses a central question: does enlightened mind actually exist? Drawing on arguments about the nature of consciousness itself, Dondrub contends that mind is formless, knowing, and naturally blissful, and therefore possesses Buddha potential. He supports this through evidence of clairvoyance and extraordinary human capacity, concluding that if ignorance can be removed through wisdom practice, then enlightenment is possible. The teaching culminates in how visualizing and taking refuge in Śākyamūni Buddha directly reconnects us with our own mind and Buddha nature. Dondrub emphasizes that refuge is not about external salvation but awakening our innermost potential, framed as mindcare and the restoration of authentic wisdom.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014 08 19 DB Refuge in the Three Jewels Week 2 19082014.mp3

UUID: 8d3ab7a6-e737-4132-86cc-0841dd2c9cc4

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: DB Refuge in the Three Jewels (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2014-08-19

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 111.5 minutes

Words: ~10,955

Good evening everyone. Welcome to our second class on refuge in the Three Jewels. This topic is about one of the key practices of Buddhism which is taking refuge. If one really wants to follow Buddhist path or the Buddhist teachings, take them seriously to any extent, then this involves at some point committing to the teachings and therefore taking refuge in the Buddha, the Buddha’s teachings and the great practitioners of them. So this is really the beginning of Dharma practice and it is the door to liberation and enlightenment.

So it’s a very important topic. As I mentioned last week there are three reasons for taking refuge or three levels of motivation for taking refuge. The first is to be able to protect oneself from suffering rebirths. And the second, the more deeper level of motivation is to eventually become free of all suffering, to be free of all the suffering of cyclic existence. And the deepest level of motivation for taking refuge or practicing refuge is to help every sentient being without exception to become free of all suffering and to be able to lead them to peerless everlasting happiness.

So this is Mahāyāna refuge So we can try and have that motivation now for studying this subject, wanting to understand what refuge is, what the objects of refuge is, how to take refuge in order to be able to take care of the mind properly not just for a good, not simply in order to have a good rebirth after this life, not simply to be able to eventually become totally free of cyclic existence and all its limitations and suffering, but with a thought that may I be able to eventually by taking refuge, practicing refuge, relying on the Buddha’s methods, may I be able to eventually realize the full potential of my mind, achieve enlightenment so that as an enlightened being I am in a perfect position to repay the kindness that I have received life after life from every sentient being. I have received this in every possible form from every sentient being many, many times and most particularly I have received the kindness of a mother from all sentient beings many, many times. And all of these beings, like myself, are trapped in cyclic existence. But since the vast majority of sentient beings right this moment have far more suffering than myself with far less ability to make sense of their suffering, to modify it, transform it and particularly no freedom to eliminate it.

Being aware of that one can develop the wish to realize the full potential of one’s mind, to be in a position to repay sentient beings in the best way by helping them to become free of all the causes of suffering and more than that helping them to create the causes that eventually lead to everlasting happiness, which is another term for enlightenment. So in studying the teachings right now we can try and generate that bodhicitta motivation. So if you’d like to join in, there’s the traditional prayer which is on page fifteen, the prayer of refuge in bodhicitta. So it’s the Mahāyāna refuge prayer that was composed by the great Indian master, Lama Atisha. And as we as we say this prayer to make it more effective, more powerful, it’s on page twelve of the student material.

We can visualize Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us. We imagine the Buddha seated on a golden throne adorned with many jewels. It’s held up in space by snow lions. There are two at each corner, so a total of eight. These represent the eight great protectors of the Mahāyāna teachings of the Buddha.

Then on the throne there is a lotus, a multicolored lotus with many petals that symbolizes the mind of great renunciation. Above that, a golden sun disc symbolizing the ultimate wisdom of emptiness that frees the mind from all suffering, all ignorance, the cause of suffering. And then above the sun disc is a moon disc that symbolizes a pure white moon disc symbolizing the mind of bodhicitta and then seated directly above the center of the moon disc is Śākyamūni Buddha having a magnificent body of golden light, a holy body of golden light, wearing the saffron robes of a monk, holding a deep blue begging bowl in his left hand which we imagine is full of wisdom nectar that overcomes the causes of all suffering. So we visualize the Buddha in front of us as our possible or actual source of refuge, inspiration and guidance, and the very embodiment of the Three Jewels of refuge. So the historical Buddha is like the embodiment of all the Buddhas, all the Dharma, all the Sangha.

At the same as we visualize the Buddha in front of us, And we can think the Buddha is appearing there in front of us to remind us of our own Buddha nature, own Buddha potential, and encouraging us, appearing to inspire us to realize our Buddha potential. And so at the same time as we visualize the Buddha we try and think of all sentient beings surrounding us. So since it’s extremely difficult, if not impossible, I can’t say impossible, but very difficult to imagine all sentient beings, at least we should try and think of those beings that we’re most connected to in this life. So traditionally we imagine our mother of this life on our left, father on our right. And then behind us, we put the rest of our family, all our friends and helpers in front of us.

We put the people we don’t want to think about but we should, those who dislike us, who may have harmed us. We put them there not to generate negative thoughts towards them but to sort of force ourselves to realize that these beings in past lives and later in future lives will have been, will be kind to me. They are suffering sentient beings like everyone else. So they deserve my compassion, not my aversion. So at least try and have a thought of those beings, but as much as possible, try to open one’s heart and mind to an awareness and concern for all the other beings of cyclic existence.

Thinking that no matter what, I must use this all my future lives to achieve enlightenment, not only for my own sake, but in order to repay the kindness of all these wonderful beings. And so that depends on following the path. That, depends on understanding the path. That depends on studying the teachings. And the very entrance to the whole practice of of Dharma, the entrance into the path to enlightenment depends on having refuge.

So for this reason I will study this subject. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create through listening to the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So if you find it helpful, that the Buddha now comes to the crown of one’s head. And when directly above the crown of one’s head, the Buddha turns to face the same direction as ourself.

So as we visualize the Buddha above us, firstly, let’s just spend a little time practicing the nine round. No. Let’s leave that. No. Yes.

Yes. Let’s do that. We just practice the nine round breathing exercise, which I hope people read about and tried during the week. So just leave the Buddha on the crown for the moment and just focus on your breath. And although you’re breathing through both nostrils in and out, one starts the nine round breathing exercise by, as you breathe in, focusing, being aware of the breath coming in your left nostril.

As you breathe out, focusing on the breath going out your right nostril. So do that for three round three breaths. Then for the next three breaths, as you breathe in, focus on the breath coming in the right nostril. As you breathe out, focus on the let the breath going out the left nostril. And then for the final three breaths of the of the cycle, focus on the breath coming in both nostrils and focus on the breath going out both nostrils.

So do that for a couple of cycles. Then recalling the Buddha on the crown of one’s head, make a heartfelt request to the Buddha for one’s mind to be free of all agitation existing in the mind right now, for the mind to be free of all suffering, all its causes, all the negative imprints obscuring the mind that were created by following disturbing thoughts. Imagine so make a request for the mind to be free of all suffering, all causes of it, all obscuration, all limitations. Think the Buddha happily responds by sending this blissful white light and nectar from every part of his body, and this pours into you as you recite the mantra of the Buddha. So that blissful white light and nectar pours into you.

As it does so, you imagine all those negative things leave your mind in the form of black liquid, and this pours out from the lower part of your body. It dissipates, becomes completely nonexistent. So then concentrate very strongly as much as you can on imagining that now from every part of the Buddha’s body, this blissful golden light and nectar pours into you, filling your whole being, pervading your whole being. And imagine that this awakens, it blesses your mind, and it awakens all your own positive qualities, all your Buddha potentials of great wisdom, love, compassion, generosity, kindness, forgiveness, courage, optimism, patience, every good quality. Imagine that all those qualities within you begin to blossom and flourish as this blissful golden light and nectar pours into you from the Buddha.

Okay. Thank you. Our course is about what the Three Jewels of refuge are, why we should take refuge in them, or why we need to take refuge in the first place, why we should take refuge in the Three Jewels of refuge, and how to do that. Very briefly, the reasons for taking refuge are: Refuge is something, there’s various kinds of refuge and they all claim to offer some kind of protection from some kind of difficulty and problem. So if we think we’ve only a small problem, small difficulties that we need protection from, then our refuge doesn’t need to be very great.

But if we start to realize that we are in cyclic existence, forced to take because of negative imprints in our mind, forced to take rebirth over and over again, that we’re going to have to experience death, aging, sickness, and so many other problems over and over and over again while we have an uncontrolled mind, we start to realize we have lots of problems or the potential for a lot of suffering. Therefore, we need a really profound, all encompassing refuge. Especially if we start to understand that the source of our suffering is our own mind. It’s not the external world as we tend to believe and most people tell us, but the external world and everything in it, people and so on, These are just conditions for our suffering. The real cause is our own mind.

So this is the basis of the Buddha’s teachings that we have a mind which is not the brain and it is our mind which is the very source of all happiness and all suffering. So if we start to realize that, then we start to realize and we start to understand that our mind is something that is never going to cease. It’s it will always exist. And in every moment of its existence, our mind is experiencing things. And with every moment of experience there is some kind of feeling, either a suffering feeling or a pleasant feeling.

There are also, as I said last week, neutral feelings, but neutral feelings aren’t a problem. It’s the presence of suffering feelings and the absence of pleasant feelings which is the problem for us. So this is what our mind does and there is nothing that will stop the mind giving rise to experience. That’s it. Nothing can stop it.

Our mind simply won’t go away. It is this phenomena that just I don’t even think the word phenomena is the right word, is it? Technically phenomena relates to stuff. I don’t know what the actual term is, ‘noumena’ or something, isn’t it? Something like that.

Anyway, our mind is simply always present, always giving rise to experience. So if we understand that, even if we don’t understand it, but start to feel that that is true, have some sense that that is true, then it becomes obvious that we need to take care of our mind, that this is the key thing to do in life, in every life, and in every day. The most important thing to do is to take care of our mind. Not our body, our possessions, our reputation, all this and that, but our mind. Because that is what is going to the more we put effort into taking care of our mind, the less suffering and confusion we will have, the more contentment and well-being we will have in this life.

But more importantly we’re laying the groundwork to have better rebirths, to be able to get out of cyclic existence, to be free of it and to achieve enlightenment. So to take care of them, we need a method. As I was saying last week, especially if we understand that our mind goes on and on and can give rise to incredible suffering. So this is why it is so important to understand the Buddhist concept, or it is not uniquely Buddhist concept of saṃsāra, which is referring to our mind controlled by delusion and karma. Controlled by ignorance, Because of ignorance, there are delusions, disturbing thoughts.

Because of disturbing thoughts, we have negative imprints in our mind. So all of that, the the mind obscured in that way is saṃsāra. It gives rise to this Samsaric world of limitations. The mind in saṃsāra, although the mind has in its very nature is pure and perfect, has this Buddha quality, this Buddha nature, this Buddha potential, the obscured mind has the potential for incredible suffering That we can take we are forced by our karma to take rebirth. So even if we just get reborn as a human being, there are so many suffering experiences as a human being to undergo.

We in Australia, I know it’s practically impossible to imagine the sufferings that so many human beings in the rest of the world are experiencing right now. But we are subject to those as well, that we have the potential for them. This is what the human mind can give rise to if we create the cause for it. And it’s so easy for the obscured, uncontrolled mind to give rise to those causes, to create those causes. But also, if one can start to see that animals have minds, then one can see that there is that potential to experience the suffering of the animal realm.

If one creates even more negative actions, the mind can give rise to the experience of the hungry ghost realms, the hell realms. There is the suffering of the Bardo state, the in between state between births. And then there is the very very subtle suffering, the very so subtle, it looks like happiness of the God realms. But all of these rebirths don’t last. We cycle over and over and over again.

If we don’t do anything about it, it’s endless. We just, you know, have some pleasure sometimes in the god realms or as a human being, but then there’s the sufferings of human beings and certainly the suffering of the lower realms. This is the potential of our obscured mind. So we need to sort of it’s not something pleasant to hear about. We don’t want to believe in it, but this is what the Buddha taught.

This is what the Buddha discovered. The Buddha didn’t create suffering. The Buddha didn’t create saṃsāra. Didn’t create this world. The Buddha just simply perceived what is going on and why it goes on.

Unfortunately, the Buddha discovered how to unravel it all. And it unravels by taking care of the mind properly so that at first we can subdue the disturbing thoughts, eventually eliminate them, and as we do that, the more we subdue the disturbing thoughts, Just like with a garden full of weeds, the more you get rid of the weeds, the more you give the chance for whatever you plant in the ground to grow. No matter how many seeds, know, good seeds of vegetables and whatever you put in the ground, if you don’t get rid of the weeds, these really good seeds potentials won’t be able to ripen and flourish. But if we get rid of everything that’s clogging up the ground, then everything can flourish very easily. So the more we pacify these disturbing thoughts, the more the positive potentials of our mind which are always there can start to flourish.

And then we can learn how to cultivate those so that they blossom even more for our own and others benefit. This is the reason to take refuge. As I said at the beginning of the talk, there are three reasons to take refuge. Three levels of suffering to avoid. The first is the suffering of a bad rebirth.

The second level of motivation is wanting to take refuge and practice refuge, meaning taking care of the mind, using the Buddha’s methods in order to eventually get out of saṃsāra so that one doesn’t experience any suffering of any kind. And the the the most profound level of motivation, the most wonderful motivation is bodhicitta, take wanting to take refuge, practice the Buddha’s teachings in order not only to free oneself from suffering but everyone from suffering. And more than just freeing them from suffering, helping them to realize their own inner potential, their own Buddha nature. So we need a valid refuge, a refuge, a method that is complete. It’s a method that covers all aspects of the situation and it’s perfect.

There’s no mistakes about it in any way. It’s not just ninety nine percent correct or works ninety nine percent of the time but all of the time it is one hundred percent correct. Works one hundred percent all the time if one practices it properly. So we need a method that is unbetrayable. As I said last week, such a method can only come from a perfect source and from a Buddhist point of view that perfect source is the enlightened mind, the enlightened mind of the Buddha.

So this raises the question which I would like to try to deal with tonight, which is pretty arrogant of me because it is immensely complicated, but I am only going to do it in a very simple way. But it is something that for those people who are already Buddhist but those who are maybe thinking to follow the Buddhist path, it is really important to think about, which is, do Buddhas exist? Do they really exist? Does the enlightened mind actually exist? Or is this just another fantasy that human beings thought up to make themselves happy?

Which is what a lot of atheists would say, like Philip Adams. It’s all just made up to keep us happy. We just don’t want to think that there’s only this life and that’s it and there’s blackness afterwards. So people made up God, made up Buddha, I don’t know what else they made up. The historical Buddha did exist, but was he really a Buddha?

Did he achieve what was claimed? Does enlightened mind exist? So this is really the big question. Is it possible? Anyway, this is practically an impossible thing to really answer or prove but I’d just like to make a few points.

The first point is the key point but I can’t prove it in any way, unfortunately. But the key point about all of this is does mind exist? Does mind exist at all? Because as some of you who know me have put up with my talks, I think this is one of the key questions of the world at the present time: does mind exist. At the time of the Buddha and after the Buddha passed away for many hundred years of years in India, the Buddhists and the non Buddhists had huge debates between them of who was right and who was wrong.

And the tradition was that if you won the debate, had to convert over to the religion of the person who defeated you. So these debates were really of deadly serious and there was a huge amount at stake. So there were all these debates between whether the Buddhist view was right or not. Of course in Buddhist literature the Buddhists always win, They’re always right. But now scientific materialism is not only attacking the belief in a creator God, which of course Buddhism doesn’t accept, but scientific materialism also rejects the idea of mind itself, that there’s only the brain.

So scientific materialism, which is becoming the dominant philosophy or even, dare I say, religion of the world, is really just saying there’s this life and that’s it. There’s nothing else. Which may be true but is a very, very depressing view in the long run, I think. Many people say Buddhism is very depressing because it’s always talking about suffering. But it talks about suffering because the Buddha says if we get rid of that suffering we can achieve this state of everlasting bliss and joy.

Buddhism says that everybody has Buddha nature. Buddhism is an incredibly optimistic system of religion or philosophy or whatever you want to call it. So the whole of Buddhism is based on the acceptance that there is mind. I don’t think there’s very much in the Buddhist teachings trying to prove that mind exists. It was just taken for granted that, of course, any intelligent person, any sane person knows that mind exists.

But these days, this is not the case. And of course, with scientific materialism, there is a lot of apparent evidence that shows that the brain explains everything. If you zap this part of the brain, this happens. If you chop this bit of the brain out, this happens and therefore that proves that that’s all there is. So it’s very difficult to disprove that, but what in a nutshell Buddhism is saying is that, yes, all of that stuff is true up to a point, but there is something more than that.

That there is this sub no matter what scientists say, they don’t touch the subjective experience of people. The subjective experience of people. There’s no way they can sort of indicate that their theory is that the brain explains everything. They can do that, but they can’t actually disprove that mind, as the Buddhists see it, doesn’t exist. And there’s much evidence that the mind does exist.

But I’d like to be able to prove that, but that’s a huge topic. The first of the DB modules, but even then we only look at it very briefly. Let us start with the assumption that we all believe that mind does exist, because if we don’t start there, I’m lost. But if we do accept that the mind does exist and it’s not just the brain, but it is something formless, which is able which experiences. I don’t know how many of you are convinced of this or not convinced of this yet.

Some of you have been coming to DB for quite some time. So I’m assuming that you do agree that the mind does exist. Some may be not convinced yet. Anyway Sorry? But I think scientists would say that that’s just rearranging your neural pathways, which Buddhism wouldn’t disagree with, that if you change your mind, your neural pathways will change for sure because Buddhism, especially the tantric explanation of the mind, talks about three levels of mind.

The gross mind that we are operating now definitely works through the brain. It depends on the brain. But Tantric Buddhism says that this is not the only level of mind. There’s much more to the mind than that aspect which depends on the brain and the nervous system. What is?

But what is? Another level of mind. Is it your mind? It is my mind. It’s not external.

Good. Yeah. Anyway, it’s very complicated territory. One yeah. What the mind is, I’m trying to prove that it does exist.

I think this debate will go on for a very long time and this is something His Holiness is very keen on encouraging debate between scientists and Buddhists and meditators about this relationship between the brain and the mind. Are they the same, different, are they dependent or what? Anyway, let’s assume that the mind does exist as this don’t know if I’ve ever really checked that, but one of the points I’ve made before is if you read material by scientists about the brain and the mind, they often, in the one article, will use these words interchangeably, which is very unscientific of them. They will just switch all the time. What about it?

I’m not really sure. Because there are scientists who do accept that the mind does exist in some way but a lot of scientific materialists don’t. A lot of scientists who are scientific materialists say that don’t have to talk about mind. Everything can be explained by the functions of the brain. And here’s this proof and this proof and this proof.

It is a very, very complicated thing. But I think what many Buddhists would argue is that although all the scientists have done this experiment with the brain, they themselves have never subjectively looked at their mind very much whereas Buddhists have. And you can’t simply dismiss all the experiences of Buddhists over hundreds of years, you know, of advanced meditators as kind of delusions, being delusional. Well you can, but it’s not very scientific, especially when you meet some of these practitioners and they’re not delusional. Anyway, just very quickly, if we can assume that mind does exist, that it is something formless, that love and hate are not electrical impulses, but something because they do exist.

Love and compassion and hate and jealousy and pride and kindness are things that exist. We all agree they exist, right? But how do they exist? In what form do they exist? Buddhists say they don’t exist in any form whatsoever.

They’re formless because they’re consciousness, they are mind, but they certainly exist. So let’s accept that. The mind is which is formless and it knows. So my argument is if mind exists, Buddha nature exists. And if Buddha nature exists, then enlightenment exists because there are people who have realized their Buddha potential, their Buddha nature.

So how can we establish in some way that the mind has Buddha nature or Buddha potential? My primitive way of doing this is to suggest that the mind is that phenomena, that thing, that whatever, that knows. That’s what it does. Is the that I’m going to use the word phenomena. I can’t.

It is the phenomena which knows. So right now we know things in a very limited way. Sometimes what we know is correct, sometimes it’s incorrect, sometimes it’s partial, sometimes it’s complete, sometimes it’s direct, sometimes it’s conceptual. But our mind is knowing. But the Buddhist view is that the mind is prevented from knowing correctly because it is obscured.

And what is obscuring the mind is our ignorance, our disturbing thoughts. And to some extent we can know this ourselves right now that when we try to know something, if we really check what prevents us knowing it fully, as completely as we would like, is that we’re not able to focus on knowing that thing completely because there’s all this other stuff going on in our mind. For the average person, most of the time, they are not conscious of all this rubbish going on in their mind or all this other activity. But if one starts to meditate, one starts to realize, oh, I can’t concentrate. So many people say, oh, I’m not a meditator.

Are other people who are meditators. I’m not a meditator because when I try, all these thoughts come up. I never have them other times, but when I try and meditate, I get all these thoughts. Actually, they’re there all the time. We’re just not aware of them because most people don’t try and focus their mind or be aware of what’s going on in their mind.

My simple argument is we have some sense of our mind being obscured. Not just a sense, some experience of it being obscured. I think we all have some sense that I could know this experience and understand it better, but something is stopping me. Because sometimes we can think about and know something quite clearly and at other times it’s a big blur. So just imagine if everything that was right now obscuring our mind which we are conscious and unconscious of, all of that was stopped, eliminated from the mind.

And there was nothing stopping the mind from doing the one thing it can do that no other phenomena can do, which is to know. Then the mind would just know. So my argument is, well maybe it’s not a very good argument according to scientists, but if there was nothing stopping the mind from knowing, it would know everything. Why wouldn’t it? Especially That, just that.

If something can be known, then why wouldn’t the mind know it? If there was nothing stopping it knowing it, There was no inner thing preventing it. Especially when you consider that, you know, there are like even just from an ordinary point of view, there are people who are recognized as geniuses, who know and understand far more than the average person. And what we tend to think is that their mind, brain, is something completely different than ours. But it seems to me that it’s that is just suggesting the potential of anyone’s brain or mind.

Whether if you interpret it as the brain, then everyone everyone’s brain has that potential. If you interpret that that person’s genius as their mind or an aspect of their mind, it shows that actually every mind has that potential. And then if you think about the fact that the fact, excuse me. Maybe I shouldn’t use that word. The claim that there are people who are clairvoyant, is completely dismissed by scientific materialists, but there are millions of examples of people who are clairvoyant.

And some of this, of course, is rubbish. They’re complete charlatans. There’s no doubt about that. But there are many, many cases of people from ordinary people who have clairvoyant experiences. Maybe only once in their life.

But there are other people who have it regularly. And there are of course, in Buddhism, one there is the one can train the mind to become clairvoyant, not just what’s the word, without any control, but deliberately. And there are many, many examples of meditators who are able to know future events, read people’s minds, etcetera, etcetera. But maybe you know some people who’ve had at least one clairvoyant incident in their life. It may be a very simple thing of of of knowing something like there there are many people many many many many stories of people who like, when someone who’s very close to them is having something terrible is happening to them, then the per that person has some strange feeling, sensation, dream at exactly this or more or less the same time or at the same time as what is happening to this person they’re very close to.

So how does scientific materialism explain that? I don’t know. But that indicates some kind of simple form of, I don’t know, clairvoyance is the exact term for it, the ability of the mind to know something. Yes but there’s millions of these. Wish I could use all the proper Yes but the brain can’t do that.

A physical thing can’t do that. Extra sensory perception is something that shows, is an indication of mind, of something formless knowing something. Physical matter by definition, can’t know the future or know another person’s thoughts. Anyway, I read this is getting away, this is going to go forever. This was meant to be very short.

But in Scientific American, not Scientific American, what’s it called? New Scientist. There was a very interesting article once by a scientist about this very point about how when scientists, for example medical scientists, are experimenting with a new medicine to see if it works against a particular cure, against a particular disease and you have to have some kind of scientific control but there has to be a correlation. There has to be a side is it? Does anyone know the terminology?

Control Yeah, there’s control groups but there has to be a certain kind of relationship between this and to show that there is a definite relationship. There has to be a mathematical correlation. What? Statistical correlation between this and that. And so if there’s a certain statistical correlation they say yes this proves that this does that and so that’s accepted totally.

It’s a fundamental scientific methodology and whatever but when people come along with same statistical correlations for paranormal events, this is totally dismissed. All that, that doesn’t prove a relationship at all. Even though the correlations are far higher than for many, many scientific experiments. Yeah. Statistically significant correlationships.

Yeah. Yeah. Even though there is the statistical correlation. Yeah. Anyway yeah.

Where am I? What was that along? So there are many indications that there are these people who are able to be clairvoyant etc. Etc. Which I would argue is an indication that this is not something unique to some people, it is just simply showing a potential of all minds.

If one mind can do it, all minds can do it. Because all minds are the same. It’s not different kinds of minds. Minds work at different levels because of different obscurations, but the nature of the mind is the same. It’s just formless and it knows.

Yes. Yes. Yes. No, there’s not proof but some indications. Yes.

Yep. Yes. It seems. The Buddhist view isn’t that there is just one consciousness. We have separate consciousnesses, but they are all of the same nature.

Yeah, eventually. Yeah, that is what clairvoyance is. You can link in to other people’s consciousness to some extent. Yeah. And when when at at level of Buddhahood, well, they’re all linked in.

There’s no barriers. So at at that level, you can say all the Buddha’s minds are just one mind at that level. Anyway, back to my argument discussion. So the mind has this potential to know and so if that potential wasn’t obscured in any way then the mind could and all these indications of how even the very limited mind is able to have some clairvoyance, extra sensory powers, etc, etc, then the mind could know everything. If there’s something to be known, the mind will know it.

There’s nothing to stop it. The mind has that potential for omniscience to be to know everything. Yes. Yes. Yeah.

Yeah. There’s different kinds of mediums and clairvoyances and some of it is a bit kind of shonky and very limited but there is a very technical form of in Buddhism if you achieve Samādhi and then there is what is called śamatha, calm abiding. After that by doing some exercises, some technical exercises you achieve clairvoyance where you can remember your past, start remembering your past lives, and you can read the minds of other people. Yeah. So and this is not something uncontrolled like many mediums and whatever.

This is something very, very precise. Yes. Again, scientific materialists would say dismiss this as all rubbish. The problem with all of this is most practitioners who have these abilities won’t show it or talk about it because it is not good to go around displaying these things and claiming that. But every now and again, some Lamas do give some indication that they have these ability or some of these Lamas have these abilities.

My my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, on a number of occasions, has, you know, definitely shown that he is clairvoyant. You know, many students have had that experience of him knowing their minds, reading what is going on, knowing things about them. Yeah. Many things. Oh, yeah, sure.

That was dismissed as historical, but I’m just saying people right now can do this. Yeah. Haven’t got anywhere. Sorry. Oh, no.

Is it tea break time? Sorry. Have I been wasting your time? Oh, no. I haven’t even started yet.

That was was the beginning. Okay. Tea break. One of the aspects of the enlightened mind is that it is completely blissful. There is no suffering, total bliss.

One way one can indicate that we have that potential within us is as I mentioned I think last week, if you check when one meditates, focuses on an object, then the mind calms down. When the mind begins to calm down, means when the agitation, the disturbing thoughts in the mind are less active, some natural quality of the mind is able to one becomes more aware of that, and that experience is a pleasant experience. One hasn’t added something to the mind when we meditate. One has allowed something which is unnatural to the mind, which is all the disturbances and agitation to decline, to reduce. When that happens, this more natural part of the mind comes to the surface and that experience is pleasant.

For me that indicates that there is some indication of the natural bliss of the mind, which is what the Buddha is talking about. We are always looking for happiness in the external world, but this perfect bliss is actually something that exists potentially within our mind all the time. This is part of our Buddha potential. So part of our Buddha potential is this bliss. A part of our Buddha potential is the ability to know, to know everything.

When nothing is obscuring the mind then the mind is able to know completely. Whatever it directs its attention to, it can know it. So if an obscured mind has some ability to be clairvoyant, to know things from the past into the future in distant places. As I’ve often told people, a friend of mine who was living in oh, he is French and he was living in France. He was a student of Lama Zopa Rinpoche, my teacher, who’s depicted in that picture over there with the nice little lights around it, received a letter from Lama Zopa Rinpoche telling him to be very careful that he was in something quite bad could happen to him soon.

About two days after the letter arrived, he was beaten up in the streets with bottles smashed over him and everything. So this letter came from India. It was written by my teacher when he was in India to one of his students in France. So the letter would have taken, especially in those days, a couple of weeks to arrive. Not that my teacher has an obscured mind, I shouldn’t say that.

Other people also have there are many stories of people having some kind of clairvoyance even even just for one one time. So that indicates a potential of our mind. So and that’s that that can happen even with an obscured mind. So imagine when the mind isn’t obscured at all if what the mind can know. It cannot not just know because this right now our our sense consciousnesses know things directly.

We have direct perception of shapes and colors, direct perception of sound, direct perception of taste. But our mental consciousness right now being obscured knows things mostly indirectly via concepts. But the potential of the mind, the mental consciousness, is to know things directly, direct perception. This is the really amazing thing. This is what the Buddha is telling us.

This is the real potential of our mind. But also, if you think about it, check up. All of us have some ability to be kind, patient, generous, intelligent, loving, compassionate, forgiving, and so on. And one can see people who are far more patient and tolerant and kind and generous and compassion, and brave and optimistic than ourselves. Is this because they are inherently different?

No. It’s just that they less obscurations in relation to those qualities and maybe because they have cultivated those qualities more. The fact that one can see people who are immensely compassionate is not saying that those people is not proving that those people are somehow significantly, inherently different from us. Many people go to listen to His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, and think, oh, He is wonderful, how fantastic, what a special, special person He is. But in one way, his holiness Dalai Lama is not special at all.

What what is special about his holiness from that makes him different from us is he practices. He’s worked with his mind, and we haven’t. What is not special about his holiness is his mind is exactly the same as ours. The wonderful qualities we see in his holiness is not because he is inherently, uniquely different from most of us. If he was, actually, there wouldn’t be much point listening to him.

There wouldn’t be much point listening to the Buddha if the Buddha was inherently different from ourselves. But the whole point about the Buddha is that the Buddha’s mind is exactly the same as your mind, is exactly the same as my mind. The only difference is our minds, if your mind is like mine, our minds are obscured and the Buddha’s isn’t. But the mind is exactly the same. That’s the wonderful thing about the Buddha’s teachings.

If the Buddha was somehow inherently different, then we wouldn’t be able to become a Buddha. It would mean we wouldn’t have Buddha nature. But the Buddha was a suffering, obscured person like us and discovered how to get rid of all of that and achieved enlightenment. Anyway, when we see these people who are so much apparently better than us, it’s just really indicating the potential of the mind, that we have that potential within us. These people have just developed their potential more than we have, reduced their obscurations more.

So if there were no obscurations, then it would it would follow that there would be perfect love, perfect compassion, perfect kindness, generosity, etcetera, etcetera. But the fact that we have a little bit of these qualities means that we have the potential for unlimited compassion and so on. This is our Buddha potential. We all have those qualities. If one thinks about it, if the mind wasn’t obscured and was able to know things accurately, which is its potential, if we allow it to know things, it can know them unmistakenly, completely, then if the mind was actually knowing things unmistakenly, completely, single pointedly, directly, not knowing in an abstract way, but experiencing, Experiencing something completely, unmistakably, vividly.

In other words, experiencing oneself correctly, experiencing other people as they actually are, through concepts and mistaken ideas and this is and that, but just simply directly experiencing other people as they are, then my argument is then no one wouldn’t have any hate. Yeah? No matter even though someone is being very harmful to oneself, very destructive to oneself and others, full of all sorts of horrible tendencies, one would know that that is is not the true nature of that person. One would know that that person is suffering. You you you would know it not just as information, dry, abstract information, but one would experience it.

So one wouldn’t hate, one wouldn’t have jealousy, one wouldn’t have pride when one was knowing things accurately, which indicates that these qualities are not a true aspect of the mind. Only an obscured mind has hate and jealousy and pride and fear and worry and desire and attachment. If one was knowing things as they were, one wouldn’t have those things. One simply would have love and compassion and acceptance and tolerance and forgiveness and courage, and there would be no fear, no worry, etcetera. Why wouldn’t there be?

Just simply because the mind knows, it indicates the mind has every good quality. The mind isn’t lacking any good quality. It’s there. Our mind, every mind, is a complete, perfect package. And it’s blissful.

The potential of the mind is blissful, complete, and perfect. Simply because it is mind. Simply because it knows, has the potential to know. Every mind is like that. That’s my argument in a nutshell.

So because the mind exists, so let me put it this way, if mind exists, it does have Buddha nature and if mind has Buddha nature then it follows, I think, one could argue, that at some point in time at least one person worked on their mind and realized their Buddha nature, got rid of those delusions and freed the mind and achieved, you know, was able to allow all those potentials to manifest completely. And that’s what enlightenment is. The enlightened mind is a mind in which all the negative potentials of the mind have been completely eliminated in a way that they can never return at all. The enlightened mind is a mind where all the positive potentials have been fully developed so that they’re fully active a hundred percent all the time in such a way that they never decline even for a moment. That’s what enlightenment is.

The enlightened mind is. So that mind is omniscient. It is omnipresent because mind is formless. You can’t say it’s, you know, the ability of the mind when all obstructions are removed, you can say it’s not as though the mind is a thing, know, every you know, it’s it’s like a blob of stuff over everything, but awareness is present, omniscient awareness is present everywhere. It’s here.

Why wouldn’t it be? What would be stopping it? Nothing is stopping it once the obscurations gone. So it’s omnipresent and that omniscient omnipresent consciousness is always pervaded by complete love. Complete compassion, total generosity, total wisdom, total kindness, total everything perfect and wonderful.

So that mind is pervaded by what in Buddhism is called spontaneous, skillful means. That the enlightened mind has the ability to know the enlightened mind knows the mind of every sentient being, what is going on and how to benefit them and does. Because there is nothing stopping that enlightened mind from doing so. There is a very nice analogy in the teachings, very simple analogy that the Buddha’s compassion and love etc. Or skillful means is like the moon in the sky, the full moon in the sky.

So when the full moon, well even any moon in the sky, when it’s up there, wherever there is water, whether it’s just a tiny little puddle or a giant ocean, whether it’s absolutely pristine pure water or disgusting muddy water, the moon reflects in it spontaneously. Meaning whether someone is totally insignificant or someone super special, whether someone is holy or completely evil, the Buddha’s compassion is with that person a hundred percent effortlessly. Couldn’t be any other way. Because the Buddha mind is knowing everything, and the only way a Buddha mind can know is with compassion. It can’t know with hate.

It’s utterly impossible. How could it? It’s it’s gone. And as one great Buddhist master, Śāntideva, says in his masterpiece, the guide to the bodhisattva way of life, If you defeat an ordinary enemy army, that army can run away or it will run away when you defeat them. But unfortunately, they can run away somewhere, regroup their strength, and attack again.

But if you defeat the delusions of your mind, if you eliminate the delusions from your mind, where can they go and how can they come back? People like from an ordinary point of view, people we all suffer from the point of view of a Buddhist we’re all kind of the point of view of a Buddha we’re all kind of crazy. We’re all deluded. We all have neuroses and psychoses and this is and that. But from a conventional point of view there are people who are sane and then there are people who have serious mental disturbances or various kinds of mental problems and people can go to psychiatrists and psychologists and whatever and people can receive treatment and sometimes that treatment does sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn’t for different people depending on the skill of doctor and the situation of the patient.

But also the patient may achieve some improvement and then it declines. That’s because the treatment has only modified the delusion or the problem. It hasn’t completely eliminated it. It hasn’t totally removed the underlying most profound cause of disturbances in the mind. But the Buddha is saying that the most profound, deepest causes of all our confusion can be eliminated because they are not a true aspect of the mind.

So when that is done, they can never return. It’s impossible. When the basis of them is eliminated. And that all comes to understanding how our suffering arises due to our negative karmic imprints. They only exist because of following our delusions.

Our delusions only exist in our mind because of the fundamental cause which is ignorance, which is this mental factor that leads our mind, the mind being obscured by ignorance experiences self and all phenomena in a false way. So that ignorance has obscured our mind during beginningless time. But the Buddha discovered that that ignorance can be removed because it is not a true aspect of the mind. The true aspect of our mind is that it is wise. It has this ability, this potential to know things exactly, precisely as they are.

So this ignorance can be removed because it depends on many, many factors. So if those factors are eliminated, then ignorance can be removed. Anyway, it’s a long complicated story, but if one studies the teachings, one can see that this is possible. Ignorance creates a particular appearance to our mind of our self and things which we believe that appearance to be true. But by studying the Buddha’s teachings we can understand that although things appear in a particular way, they simply could not exist that way.

They just can’t exist that way. And when we start to understand that really deeply and combine that understanding with purifying the mind, accumulating merit, developing a concentrated mind in meditation, Due to all of those factors, that wisdom destroys that ignorance that creates that false appearance and grasps at it. And once that false appearance is destroyed, eliminated from the mind due to the power of wisdom, it can’t go anywhere. It’s gone completely so that it never comes back. So once that’s gone, all the delusions go, all the negative imprints go, all the obscurations from the mind go, and enlightenment is possible.

So people have done that. This is the point. We haven’t, but others have in the past. And one of them was Prince Siddhartha who became Śākyamūni Buddha. So enlightened minds exist.

And the point is that enlightened mind is the perfect refuge. Because that enlightened mind sees everything accurately without any mistake, sees it directly all the time. Yeah. It knows everything unmistakenly, all the time, spontaneously. And that mind has perfect love, perfect compassion, perfect generosity, perfect patience, has every perfect quality.

So that that mind knows how to, that mind, which has all those qualities, has the wisdom to be able to explain to us how to free our mind of all confusion, knows all the methods to get rid of every delusion, and knows all the methods to cultivate every positive quality in a way that won’t cause harm to ourselves, won’t cause harm to anyone else. So that’s why the Buddha’s teachings are the perfect refuge, because they come from that perfect unmistaken mind. And in taking refuge, the real refuge is the Buddha, the enlightened mind, but at our level we are not able to directly perceive Buddhas. We aren’t able to directly communicate with them. So for us the real refuge, the real protection is the Buddha’s teachings and particularly practicing them.

It is the practice of the Buddha’s teachings, applying these methods to our mind day by day as much as we can. That is what is going to protect us in this and all future lives from suffering and its causes. And that will help us achieve every kind of happiness until we finally achieve peerless, everlasting happiness. Anyway, this is the Buddhist argument. Any questions?

I meant to have people to have a discussion group tonight, but somehow next week it will happen. There was even yeah. But you you don’t even have one question to discuss. Does someone have a question? Yes.

Yes. What is the mind of the animal? It’s the same as the what do you mean? Yes, except it’s more obscured. So, because of that, animals communicate with each other very primitively.

Their intelligence is much less, of course. They may have some sense perceptions which are more advanced than us, but because they’re yeah. Because the brain is much more simple than and the gross level of mind operating through that, depending on that, can’t function fully. So the mind is only working in a very, very limited way. Buddhism doesn’t put them down so they can’t get they put them, you know.

Function very well in this life. Yes. Well, each life is a karmic situation that we are playing out. So someone in that situation of cause is not able to function very well as a human being so they can’t do very much with their mind in this life. But when they die, that calm is kind of played out.

Their next rebirth could be a good one. Who knows? Because every mind in every you know, the mind of every human being, the mind of of every animal, and the mind of every other sentient being in the different realms has infinite numbers of positive potentials, karmic imprints, many negative imprints. So the person who looks from a very ordinary point of view in an inferior situation now can be in a superior position in the very next life. Yes.

Buddhist way of saying it would be that it gets very complicated you have the karma to have some kind of physical or mental disability or problem but also there is the bad karma but the good karma to be born when that problem can be cured. So it’s not as though the karma is released but another good karma ripens whereby you may be able to be cured of that disease. Or there is a situation like there are many diseases existing in the world that can be cured by that have a cure, but a lot of those cures are only available, for example, in the first world. People in the third world can’t afford them. They don’t have haven’t created the karma to to have access to those those cures.

Yes, of course. That’s one practice but, yeah, I mean, the Buddhist teachings, there’s millions of Buddhist teachings to practice but particularly there are all the practices associated with the path to enlightenment, All the different mental trainings that one needs to do basically to develop renunciation, wisdom and bodhicitta. These are the three essential practices to engage in to bring about enlightenment. And within those, in order to develop renunciation, there are certain things to train the mind in, such as thinking about impermanence and death, thinking about karma, thinking about suffering. So one has to train the mind in all these practices.

It’s a graduated process from the simplest up to the most complicated which we go through step by step. Training the mind to in the most basic way what a Dharma practice is about or Buddhist practice is about counteracting the disturbing thoughts. So there’s all the different antidotes to each of the disturbing thoughts. So there’s training the mind to learn those antidotes and training the mind to apply them in the right way. So there is that.

In taking care of the mind we need this method. So the method has two aspects dealing with the obscurations, reducing and getting rid of those. That’s one side. And the other side is awakening the positive qualities. So we have a potential for love, but there’s a way of cultivating it.

There are meditations to activate one’s love. There’s the potential there, but we can activate it more and more. There’s meditations to cultivate compassion and patience, etc. Etc. So we need to learn all these things.

And that’s what refuge is. Doing refuge is training the mind in all these practices. Okay, I think that’s it for tonight folks. Has everyone collected their homework? Maybe Judy or Danny could you hand that one out please?

Very quickly for the oh, What happened to the handout? Did everyone get a copy of the handout? There’s a handout which is called Meditation two Part two: Refuge asking for guidance. So that’s actually the reading for this week. It’s separate from the booklet.

For the daily meditation what I’m asking people to do is to check one’s posture according to the nine, you know, the eight point Vairocana posture. Anyone have any questions about that by the way? Of the physical posture? Everyone was okay with that? Clear about it?

Does anyone have any questions about the nine round breathing meditation? The nine round breathing exercise? Are we clear on that? That was okay? So it’s good to do that first.

The nine round breathing exercises meant to be done just a couple of times as just as a basic way to calm the mind. It’s not meant to be a meditation practice in itself. It’s like a preliminary to your actual meditation. It’s just to help to kind of reduce gross agitation in the mind. So having done that, the idea is then to cultivate this positive state of mind by generating the right motivation for the meditation.

This is incredibly important part of meditation that is emphasized in the Tibetan tradition to make sure that your motivation is really good. You have really worked on your motivation. To visualize the Buddha as I have briefly described. There is a little sheet of how to visualize the Buddha I have handed out. Then you recite the mantra say twenty one times and then after that there are a few little topics to meditate on just for a few minutes.

Tomorrow to meditate on the possibility of an enlightened mind, so to think about the things we talked about tonight, to see how the mind has this Potential and therefore there are people who have developed that Buddha Potential to consider that. Because there’s not much point coming to a course on refuge if one doesn’t have much belief that an enlightened mind exists. We should have some reasons for believing it, not just having some blind faith. So then to think about the qualities of the enlightened mind. What are the qualities?

Why is the Buddha’s mind the object of refuge? So to think about how the Buddha has this perfect wisdom, perfect omniscience, perfect compassion, perfect equanimity. This is what enlightened mind really is referring to, nothing else. Friday just to think a little bit about the need for taking care of mind meaning your own mind not other people’s minds. Just think about, do I have a mind?

Is it the source of my problems and happiness? Is my mind going to go on beyond this life? Therefore, I need to take care of it. Yeah. We are rushing around using up this life, trying to get money to take care of our body, you know, to take care of our reputation.

You know, we’re taking care of so many things, our house, our car, our clothes, our hair, our skin, our friends, our dog, cat, garden. But are we taking care of our mind? This is what we really have to take care of. That’s the argument, folks. We have to take care of our mind.

If our house falls down, sure, it’s a problem. But if mind collapses, this is a far greater problem. If our house looks a mess, that’s one thing. But if our mind is a mess, that’s something completely different. Think about it.

The Buddha’s message is our mind is vital. It’s our best friend and our worst enemy. It can be our best friend, but it certainly can be and is our worst. The uncontrolled mind is our worst enemy and the tamed mind is our best friend. So then think a little bit about how one if if if I need to take care of my mind, to think about how I need the right method.

And then to think on Sunday how the enlightened mind is the source of such a perfect method, is the only possible source of such a perfect method. Then again to think on Monday about the possibility of enlightened mind, to give confidence in that. And then on Tuesday to do the Śākyamūni Buddha meditation which is the handout I gave you, the brief form of that meditation. If you find any of these analytical meditations confusing or you can’t think of anything to think about, please try. But if that gets all totally confusing just go to the Śākyamūni Buddha meditation and do that one.

Okay. I think that’s it. Okay, so we can dedicate the positive potential we have built up tonight. Hopefully, some has been built up, some positive imprints, so we can dedicate that positive energy that it becomes a cause for us to be able to generate genuine refuge in the triple gem and as a result of that be able to follow the path to enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. Maybe just in conclusion, I want to make this small point that when we take refuge in the Buddha, in the sublime qualities of the Buddha and therefore in the Buddha’s teachings, the wonderful thing about this is it is leading us to take refuge in our own mind.

By having refuge in the Buddha, especially the Mahāyāna teachings of the Buddha, the Mahāyāna teachings of the Buddha are telling us, I have Buddha nature. This is my true nature. This deluded person I am now, which I have been for a very long time, is not my true nature. My true nature is to be a Buddha. That is a pretty wonderful message by taking refuge that we are reinforcing that belief.

Or we’re starting it and developing that understanding that I have this amazing mind that can be a vast, everlasting benefit to all sentient beings. That is a very, very wonderful message. So it’s a very wonderful thing to take refuge. Because by developing this faith in ourself, then we will want to develop potential for our own sake, but hopefully for the benefit of others. Right now, this kind of agitated mind we have is a bit dangerous taking refuge in that.

But even that mind has some wisdom so that is our refuge. We have to rely on our inner wisdom, and the Buddhadharma helps us develop that inner wisdom. And this is what Lama Yeshe, who brought the Buddha the the Tibetan Buddhadharma to the West, who started this organization, the foundation for the preservation of the Mahāyāna tradition, of which the center is a member, always emphasized that we have to use our wisdom. It’s always there. We have to access that and use it because the more we use it, the more it will develop.

Because that’s our potential. So taking refuge in the Buddha is not just some kind of strange external weird thing. It’s leading us to realize our own incredible Buddha nature. And the more we realize we have Buddha nature, we understand that everyone has it. Everyone has it.

And this is a wonderful way to develop love and compassion for others, to have tolerance and forgiveness for others because they have Buddha nature. Under all that horrible stuff is Buddha nature. That is a pretty incredible message that we need to give ourselves again and again and fill the world with. Due to the merits of these virtuous actions, may I quickly attain the state of the Guru Buddha and lead all living beings without exception into that enlightened state. May the precious Bodhimind, not yet born, arise and grow.

May that born have no decline but increase forevermore.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
nine-round breathing meditation
A meditation technique using nine inhalations and exhalations with specific visualizations to calm and clear the mind. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is the mind of an animal according to Buddhism, and how does it compare with the human mind?

The animal mind is the same in nature as the human mind, except that it is more obscured. Because of this, animals communicate with each other very primitively, and their intelligence is much less. They may have some sense perceptions more advanced than ours. But the animal brain is much simpler, and the gross level of mind, which operates depending on the brain, cannot function fully. So the mind works only in a very, very limited way. Buddhism does not put animals down because of this.

Scroll to Top