Tenets — 2015-11-24

Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets — 2015-11-24
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-11-24 – KR.mp3

UUID: 3b7ca041-96e4-41e4-a1f7-090990abcc0c

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2015-11-24

Duration: 1h 26m

Words: 4,398

To summarize in brief, the difference between the schools of tenets is that all of the lower schools of tenets from Vaibarshika and Sautradiqa all the way up to Sautradiqa Madiamica consider phenomena to be established from their own side, to be established by their own characteristics and to be inherently established. Then since on the other hand, Prasangika Madhyamika considers that no phenomenon is established by its own characteristics, it becomes easier to understand. All the lower schools of tenets consider phenomena to be established by their own characteristics. Prasangika Madhyamika considers no phenomenon to be established by its own characteristics. Now, to understand this issue, one must first posit a person.

What is a person? The central concept is the experience of the maturation of karma and the accumulator of karma. Such a person is considered after analysis, after investigation by the lowest schools of tenets as established by its own characteristics. Now what precisely is the mode of establishment by its own characteristics for these lower schools of tenets? The person, in other words, the accumulator of karma, the experience of the fruition of karma, the experience of both happiness and suffering, is a continuum, an uninterrupted continuum.

In other words, the karma which is accumulated by the person in this life will mature in future lives. Now this body which is the object of imputation of the person cannot be even according to the lower schools of tenets the person since this body obviously is relinquished at the time of death. So this immediately ushers the issue of past and future lives. This body does not come from previous lives and does not move on to future lives. Now if we look at coarse consciousnesses, such as the sensory consciousnesses, can they be the person?

Likewise, they cannot. They cannot because even in this life, the continuum of course consciousnesses ceases for instance, during sleep, during a coma, when one falls unconscious and so forth. So what precisely is the person for these lower schools of tenets? It is a subtle form of consciousness. Now according to the Chitamatra school, that which is found when one seeks for the person is none other than the mind basis of all or the alaya vijnana.

There is a rationale for this even though this is a presentation of the Chitamatra school and these schools call what they find here lineage or it is also called the Buddha nature. So in other words, the lower schools of tenets identify the person with a subtle form of consciousness And they distinguish between two types of persons, persons which are imputedly existent and persons which are substantially existent. Persons which are imputedly existent refers to the person which in every day eats, walks, meditates and so forth. The person who is substantially existent refers to that subtle consciousness. Now these two persons, the imputedly existent and the substantially existent person are not of different natures, they are of one nature.

Since the majority of the lower schools of tenets assert that the person is actually findable under investigation within the aggregates, and that when one investigates, one can identify as the person a subtle form of consciousness. It is independence on this, that they are led to assert that the person is established by its own characteristics, is established from its own side and is inherently established. All of the lower schools of tenets consider all phenomena to be in this way. Now Prasangika Madhyamika does not distinguish between imputedly existent persons and substantially existent persons. For Prasangika Madhyamika, all persons without exception are imputedly existent.

There is no such thing as a substantially existent person since persons are not established by their own characteristics from their own side or inherently established. In other words, for prasanika madiameka, all phenomena since they’re imputedly existent, all persons are mere conceptual imputations out there on a basis of designation. Prasangika Madhyamika therefore asserts that the person is merely imputed by conceptuality out there. There is no person which is not dependent on conceptual imputation, and here by conceptuality what is understood is the innate conceptuality which we talked about previously. In other words, for prasanika madhyamika, persons are not established from their own side, they are not established by their own characteristics and they are not inherently established.

Now why is this school called the consequentialist or Prasangika Madhyamika School in Sanskrit? The term Prasanga, consequence in Tibetan tel gyuk, can be understood in terms of two components. Telwa means consequence and gyurwa means to transform, to turn. So the consequence is that which transforms a false understanding into its authentic one. So when we speak of Prasangika madhyamika or consequentialist, the Tibetan term telgurwa indicates by tel the term for consequence and by georah transformation.

This is therefore a speech statement which transforms. What qualifies it to be considered as a consequence or a prasanga? It must fulfill three criteria. The reason of the consequence must be verified. The pervasion or the necessary entailment must be validated by valid cognition and the cc’s must be established.

Whether you understand this or not, I don’t know. So to give an example of what would be an authentic consequence, an authentic prasanga, let us take the following consequence. It follows that the subject sound is uncompounded because of being permanent. This is a valid consequence for someone who accepts the three criteria. The first is that the subject sound is permanent.

The second is the forward pervasion of the necessary entailment. Everything which is permanent is necessarily uncompounded. The third is the opposite of the thesis, which is that such a person accepts that sound is composite. For such a person, this consequence is the valid consequence. Why is this the case?

This is the case because for someone who accepts that sound is a composite phenomenon, when we assert it follows that sound is not a composite phenomenon, that person will naturally say, which means why, literally no. But, the moment that person says or literally no, we give the reason. Sound is a non composite phenomenon because it is permanent. At this point, the person has no answer because for this correct recipients, recipient of a correct consequence, such a person accepts that sound is permanent, in other words, the subject is in the reason and this person also accepts that everything which is a reason is a predicate. In other words, everything which is permanent is necessarily non composite.

He or she is therefore led to the unwanted consequence that sound is not composite when his core assertion is that sound is composite. So at this point it is said that it’s a technical term of Buddhist logic, the three circles are complete. What is meant here is that the opponent is led to an unwanted consequence. The opponent accepts that sound is permanent and the opponent accepts that everything which is permanent is necessarily non composite. But the opponent does not wish to accept that sound is non composite, even though in fact based on the two first elements, two first circles, he unavoidably accepts this.

Therefore, when one delivers this consequence, it follows that the subject sound is non composite because of being permanent. The opponent is led to put in question one of the two elements of the consequence, either sound is not permanent or everything which is permanent is not non composite. Since everything which is permanent is non composite, the only thing which can be put in question is that sound is permanent. And therefore one day the opponent will be led through the power of this mere consequence to the understanding that sound is impermanent. The difference here between the Prasanika Madhyamika and the Svatantika Madhyamika school is that for Svatantika Madhyamika, such a mere consequence is not sufficient to lead to the predicate the subject sound is impermanent.

In addition, an autonomous syllogism, which has three components of so called three modes, verified by three valid cognizers is also necessary. These three valid cognizers have to be established by their own characteristics. This is rejected by Prasanika Madhyamika. So in brief, Prasanika Madhyamika says that no phenomenon is established by its own characteristics. So in brief, the difference between Prasangika and Svatantrika Madhyamika and the lower schools of tenets is that Prasangika Madhyamika does not accept that phenomena are established by their own characteristics and all of the lower schools of tenets do.

Specifically, Prasangika consequentialist madiamikas consider that through a mere consequence, it is possible to lead the opponent to the understanding of the correct predicate. This is not accepted by the lower schools of tenets of which is Svatantrika Madhyamikas, who consider that it is only possible to lead the opponent to the correct predicate by means of an autonomous syllogism of which the three modes are necessarily ascertained by valid cognizers which are established from their own side. So this is a difficult topic for you and it is not terribly important to understand the etymology of prasanika. You will notice for instance that in the definition of prasanika madhyamika on page 30 of Jitsynjugi Gyaltsin’s treaties, Prasanika Madhyamica are Madhyamica’s who do not accept true existence even semiotically by means of the verbal statements of a mere consequence renowned to others. What however it is important for you to understand is first the distinction between Buddhist and non Buddhist schools of tenets.

Non Buddhist schools of tenets assert a person who is a self, an Atman in other words. Buddhist schools of tenets refute the existence of such a person. The second thing which it is important for you to understand is the various presentations of the coarse and subtle selflessness of persons within the various schools of Buddhist tenets. So within Jean Pierre Del Padores great treaties on tenets outline, The first sub outline, which is a presentation of the basis of view is complete. The second, the means of ascertaining the view is complete.

And the last presenting the two truths is basically complete. Then Jean Pierre D’Orte’s treatise on tenets continues with a presentation of the two bodies which are the result of means and wisdom within the path. In other words, a presentation of salam or grounds and paths. This we shall cover next year. So we have completed during almost two years now a presentation of tenets.

And this presentation of tenets focuses mainly on the wisdom aspect of the path, in other words, the view. Grounds and paths, Salam in other words, has elements from both the wisdom and the method aspect of the path. In as much as it presents the five paths, the path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, of meditation and of normal learning in sequence as well as their respective grounds and is the means for us to improve ourselves when we meditate. Otherwise just to study a topic like that and set it aside would be rather odd. It is extremely important to understand that there is definitely a relationship between Lamrim, the stages of the path, and Salam, the grounds and paths.

And interrelating the topics of Lamrim, definite emergence, bodhicitta and the view with grounds and paths is extremely important. So Grounds and Paths is in brief a presentation of how the mind through habituation with emptiness becomes ever more subtle, progressing through the various paths of accumulation of preparation, seeing, meditation and normal learning. Eventually, thanks to this habituation with emptiness, is possible to completely abandon self grasping. This is what Salam is about. Then Salaam is nowhere nearly as difficult as tenets which refer to the view and since I understand that you will have a fair bit of time over Christmas, then I would like to encourage you to study the section on what is called one’s own system, hung look in the English translation of Salaam prepared by Bill McGee.

I have made it available in the past, I’ll make it available again for those who are interested and Geshe-la would like you to try to memorize that English section, memorize the definitions and the divisions of the Shravaka Buddhas, Pratyaka Buddhas and Bodhisattvas. Then there is a close relationship between the three principles of the path, especially definite emergence and Salam. If we take definite emergence for instance, at the level of the presentation of the grounds and paths, it occurs within the path of accumulation and then on that basis there is further development. So at present, when generating the motivation, I would like you first to meditate carefully on the distinction between Buddhist and non Buddhist systems of tenets as best you can. And then within Buddhist systems of tenets, the distinctions of the coarse and subtle selflessness of persons in the various systems of tenets.

After this, I will take your questions, after the recitations obviously. So do you have questions regarding the difference between Buddhist and non Buddhist systems of tenets? Only systems of tenets. Please pass the paper around for the emails. I won’t be able to send you the Salam text otherwise.

Do we have hands on? Okay. So this was already explained and you wrote it down. But to repeat the presentation, the non Buddhist Indian philosophers accept the existence of an Atman which is from their standpoint the substance of the mind. They consider as was taught that basically, there is a self which can be found within the five aggregates.

And that this self which can be found within the five aggregates is the ruler of the aggregates. Its relation to the aggregates is that of the ruler to the ruled. The self is the ruler and the aggregates are the ruled. Or if you prefer to use a metaphor, its relationship is that of a king to his court. The court depends on the king for their existence.

The king does not depend on the court for his existence. The court here are the aggregates, the king is the Atman or the soul, the self. Now this Atman is considered to exist because at the time of death, when the body is incinerated, then the body is destroyed and something must move on. And this is why the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, the Tirthikas assert the existence of an Atman or a soul which is permanent, one and independent In opposition to the Buddhist schools of tenets, which assert the existence of a person which is empty of being permanent, one and independent. This core assertion that a person is empty of being permanent, one and independent is one which one must understand to understand Buddhist systems of tenets.

The otherwise, there is no difference between Buddhist and non Buddhist schools of philosophy. There is no difference between Buddhism and the other religious traditions regarding the development of love, of compassion, training in generosity, training in ethics, training in forbearance, training in perseverance and so forth. No difference whatsoever. Then the other traditions have something akin to love, compassion and even bodhicitta. So the only difference is the presentation of selflessness.

This is what one must understand and then one must see that within the four schools of tenets, the difference between the schools of tenets is posited from the standpoint of the view, the various forms of the subtle selflessness of persons and of phenomena, not in terms of love, compassion and so forth. And therefore, they assert the non Buddhists assert the existence of a self or a soul which does not depend on the aggregates which is independent from the aggregates. The Buddhists assert that such a self or such a soul does not exist is non existent and assert instead that the person depends on the aggregates. And by aggregates here, one refers to the five aggregates, the form, sensation, discrimination, composition of factor and consciousness aggregates. Now, this is self evident if we take the example of a child.

When a child is born, we call him a child, then merely because of the aging of the form aggregate eventually we will call him a youth, and then much much later, we will call him an old man because his hair is gray and he is toothless. This is done exclusively on the basis of the aging of the form aggregate, which shows that there is no person independent from the aggregates. Do you understand? I have a stupid question. How does Atman differ from the Alaya in Chitamantra?

Alaya, sorry. So normally we are positing ourselves from the standpoint of Prasangika Madhyamika which does not accept the existence of vijnana. But if we look at it from the standpoint of cittamatra, then for cittamatra, the alaya vijnana is a consciousness. It is a subtle consciousness to which we have no access at present and it is said to be truly established. It is however different from the self because it is impermanent and the self according to the non Buddhist schools is permanent.

So this is our last class of tenets for the year and I hope you will be meeting every Tuesday for the next couple of weeks to discuss about tenets. The topic I would like you to discuss about is the two truths according to the various schools of tenets, Vaibhashika, Sautrantika, Chitamatra and Prasangika and if you can, to eventually focus on the two truths according to Prasangika Madhyamika, is important. And you obviously will be attracted to one system of tenets instead of another. But however, whichever system of tenets you like, you should not just say, I like the system of tenets, you must understand it and study it in-depth to have a rationale for your understanding. Otherwise, it is rather meaningless to say I like this or that system of tenets with no explanation.

Now, you are obviously free to study and feel attracted to whichever system of tenets fits you best. Every system of tenets is of benefit because these Buddhist systems of tenets were designed to weaken the hold of the grasping at an eye. And they do this through demonstrating that the object of observation of ignorance, the so called eye which exists independently of the aggregates does not exist. Obviously the system and in as much as it describes reality is supreme, but it is not for everybody. Then this was a very worthwhile opportunity to present tenets.

It was worthwhile for myself because I was able to study and read about these topics. It was worthwhile about yourselves because you were able to listen about this. Topics such as tenets are topics which will not remain in your mind if you merely study them and set your notebooks aside. They will only remain in your mind if you think about them carefully and if you ask the basic question, is this true or not? Otherwise it will not stay.

I do not say from my side I have any realizations. I tried to present as best I could and we were fortunate to have a good translator who has experience, complete experience of these topics and we should not waste this opportunity. Try not to waste it next year but try to attend the teachings. Then if you don’t do that, my coming here and teaching for an hour is a waste of everybody’s time and I would suggest that you stay at home in front of television drinking beer. You only come here because there is some benefit for your minds.

That is the goal of study. I have nothing left to add. Thank you. I would like to give a few words. This is now towards the end of the visitor Gishis and also Gishis going back to India.

Gishila and myself is almost everything is confirmed on the fourth, but the visitor Gishis, I’m still waiting for the waiting list, flying back with our because there’s a date change. So is this soon? Okay. Probably, I have a few people question and ask, you know, the why they do Mandala and etcetera. And I would like to read this few words here and I’ll read this one for everybody and put this on, dear members of TBI, Tibetan Buddhist Institute honored to host the visit by Gishee Jambhajat Doji, Gishee Jamian Tienzin, and the venerable Lobsang Ramji.

And we are most fortunate that they agreed to come and again construct a mandala at our center. We had two mandalas done, you know, the Chenrezig, such a beautiful, and also the Medicine Buddha. And this Chenrezig, Saint Mandala, is a dedicated to world peace, his holy supporting Dalai Lama’s eightieth birthday and long life and also for the super return of our beloved Rinpoche. And Chenrezig is the the Tibetan name of Avalokitesvara, the Buddha of compassion and represented at the center of the mandala by lotus flower. Okay.

And just to give backgrounds where the monks live in Sera is actually live in Rinpoche’s compound, Rinpoche’s household. So next one, the monks are from our precious teachers, lab rang. Lab rang means household of Rumba ji and therefore we have responsibility to ensure their welfare is taken care of as this was Rinpoche’s responsibility in the past. However, we cannot fulfill our obligations toward this without help. Next one, I just want to give, you know, in a long time ago, in Rinpoche and myself, we have a small fund and we built monks Quarter by just the mud and tile and the wood.

And what happened was the wood was taken over by white ants and then because we built in a cheap because there’s no fund for Rumuch and myself. Then later I have Rinpoche and myself, we’ve got a little bit more fund and what I did was completely take off the roof but try to keep safe minimum cost. So what we did was put the pillar on around the house and keep the wall as it is and then we put the cement concrete. So that was quite some time ago. And now I just like to give you a next one.

This living condition are deplorable and is the same of all the monks in the household. The building is very old. Decay and what’s the word is this dilapidate. And so so and in a urgent need of repair from leaking roof, that cement that roof that the second we put and that is now leaking and also the wall, there’s the damp on the wall, roof and very damp walls. It is beyond Sorry.

Within the monastery system and fund the repair. So hence, their visit to Australia to raise the much needed and urgent funds. Other monks are still escaping from Tibet and find their way down to Sera Monastery and of course they need to be accommodated. So not only repairs are critical, there is a great need for more quarters. What we have decided is to repair the bottom part and then build the top part which is less cost because you don’t need to put the foundation etc.

So, and also it stops the leaking on that top first floor. And then of course the monks now are getting old. So there’s some of them are gishis and they’re sharing one room in a two monks and they would like to have some individual, the room that they can do practice and you know. So I’m asking if you or your friend or relatives are in a position to help financially so that when the monks return to Sera, they are able to go ahead with the task of rebuilding and repairing. Okay.

This is the usual. If you would like to, you know, talk to them about this, please don’t hesitate anyway. Give them my numbers there. Anyway, and warm regards from myself and and and and Lobsaan Rabje. Cost is quite high.

It’s around 85,000 to complete the whole thing. But, you know, we are we did Mandala here, but I didn’t mention and the race during that time, but it’s not a good time. So we have also very kindly Vietnamese community in a Vietnamese temple. And also the monks, they did lots of different pujas. So they raised, you know, we raised halfway, you know, of 84,000, 85,000.

So we raised around 34, 35, you know, it’s around a half really. And so if you would like to anywhere to help and during our Vietnamese Mandala time, there was a really great help and they work very hard and all the offer they receive is all goes to towards the the the this project. So I only ask this one because I have asked so many things. Sometimes I don’t like to ask, but there’s no choice for me. But we have a small gift at the back, you know, you can purchase.

You know, it’s a perfect time for Christmas gift, you know, for your friends. And we bought a few of the this kind of items during our mandala at the Vietnamese temple. So that’s that. And I have Dae Ching his her birthday cake at there and the beautiful cha. So and, of course, this Sunday, ninth, is farewell for Gishi and the visitor Gishis.

So please join and bring Plate to share. And if you would like to regard on this project, you know, if you in the past, I don’t have to talk this, Rinpoche will organize. So I have responsibility and so that I have to mention this in today here. And so and thank you very much for listening and yeah and there is a beautiful pictures of Shakyamuni Buddha for your altar if you want to, you’re more than welcome and there’s a white Tara and of course those who are practice Vajrayogini, there’s a beautiful one in Vajrayogini as well and of course if you would like to have His Holiness, these are the three you can take home And I’ll leave this letter here. You can read again.

And yeah. And those who haven’t taken the Vajrayogini, you don’t worry about. And, you know, you can take Vai Thara or the Shakyamun Buddha here. That’s all. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
shravaka nyen thö (Tib)
A hearer; a Hinayana practitioner who strives for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a teacher. There are four divisions: stream-enterer, once-returner, non-returner and arhat. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top