Four Noble Truths — 2015-11-25

Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths — 2015-11-25
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-11-25 – KR.mp3

UUID: 4f0508f3-67f9-4d03-834f-119f74c9fe23

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2015-11-25

Duration: 1h 34m

Words: 4,771

My bad. All probably understand that the principle topic of the path of the being of the middling scope is the Four Noble Truths. So what is the object of attainment of the path of the being of the middling scope which we will attain ourselves one day? It is liberation or the state of arhathood. What are the means to attain this object of attainment?

It is a noble truth of the path. What is the object of abandonment? It is the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Therefore, the principal topic of the path of the being of the middling scope is the Four Noble Truth. Now, this is the uncommon specificity of the Buddhist teachings.

The topics of meditation shared with the being of the small scope are topics we find in the other religious traditions. And many of the topics found in the greater vehicle, such as interchange of self and others, or for that matter aspects of the seven fold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta have similarities with the other great religious traditions. Now when we refer to what is to be relinquished and what is to be appropriated as far as the Four Noble Truths are concerned, what is to be relinquished are the first two truths, the truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. What is to be appropriated are the two last truths, the truth of cessation and of the path. This is extremely important.

We say that the Buddhist teachings is profound. What is there in the Buddhist teachings which is specifically profound? It is not the path of the being of the small scope since large swathes of this are shared with other religious traditions. It is not the path of the being of the great scope since there are also elements of this within the other great religious traditions. What is profound within the Buddha’s teachings is the presentation of the four noble truths within the path of the being of the middling scope.

If this were not the profound part of the Buddha’s teachings, what could we posit? When we say that the four noble truths are the profound part of the Buddhist teachings, how is that the case? What is your understanding? What was in the Four Noble Truths is related to emptiness? No, the truth of the path has no particular relation to emptiness.

It’s a truth of cessation which has a relation to emptiness. Principally emptiness is related to the noble truth of cessation and there is a lesser relationship to the noble truth of suffering. Then it is indeed in terms of the noble truth of cessation that Buddhadharma is said to be particularly profound. This is the element of the Four Noble Truths which makes it particularly profound. The mode of profundity as far as the presentation of the Noble Truth of Cessation is concerned, that is another affair altogether.

It depends on the schools of tenets. So clearly you are not people who have just started to hear about the Lamrim, you have heard extensive Lamrim teachings and specifically you have heard teachings regarding the path of the being of the small and of the middling scope. So if I were to ask you what practicing the path of the being of the small scope entails, first, one must know the number of topics or objects of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope and then one has to try to gain some type of sensation, some type of experience of this. I am not talking of realization because that is difficult to obtain, but some type of feeling of the object of meditation. The same is true for the path of the being of the middling scope.

Then obviously the best would be to actually meditate on the Lamrim but since many of you seem to be unable to do this, then at least try to think a little bit about it when you have time and if even that is not possible, then the most important topic of the Lamrim is death impermanence. This is what we should focus upon because when we think at the time of death, what will happen with me? What will I take on with me? What apart from this practice is meaningful? And our minds will be transformed.

It is said that through meditating on death and impermanence, at the beginning, we will obtain the foundation of the path. Then in the middle, we will put effort in our practice and at the end, we will reap the results of our practice. This is a very profound piece of advice for ordinary people such as ourselves who find it difficult to practice. Then we seem to find it very difficult to generate the motivation before the teachings. If we are unable to do this, then the best is just to meditate on death and impermanence.

This is the best there is. And therefore, we should reflect first on the number of topics of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope and then the number of topics of meditation of the path of the being of the middling scope and their meaning. And within these, the most important object of contemplation is relinquishing non virtue and appropriating virtue. Then I would like to ask you at present, how many objects of meditation or how many topics of meditation are there in the path of the being of the middling scope? Then in your answer, since these topics of meditation are given in sequence, please don’t give them in a haphazard fashion, give them in sequence and precisely.

Middling. Another. So you know at least the objects of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope, do you? How many are there? Precisely.

That’s correct. And likewise, how many topics of meditation are there in the path of the being of the middling scope? No. Five, sorry? Which?

Dongle Kingemi, So Tenzil Hamo, you mentioned that there were seven topics of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope. Could you list them? Small scope. In sequence and louder please. Then, it’s not sufficient to know that there are seven topics of meditation the path of the being of the small scope, one must list them in sequence and not in a helter skelter haphazard fashion.

There’s no benefit whatsoever in practicing in that way because you will gain no attainment of any type from meditation. This is not a way to meditate. So today we’re gonna go about it differently. I’ll ask you to list these seven topics of meditation. Okay, Yeah.

Good. Good. Very good. Very good. So these are the eight topics.

The human rebirth of leisure and endowment, its rarity, its great meaningfulness, death and impermanence, the suffering of the lower realms, refuge, karma and causality. So when you want to meditate on the path shared with the being of the small scope, you must meditate in sequence on the objects of meditation, the seven objects of meditation. Otherwise, there’s no benefit in this practice. Now for the path shared with the being of the middling scope, what are the objects of meditation? How many are That’s it.

That’s. The topic of the path shared with the being of the building scope is the four noble truths. Then if you enumerate the topics of meditation, it’s the four noble truths. Do you understand? So if someone asks you what the topics of meditation of the path of the middling scope are, you just can answer if they are four, it’s a four noble truth, the truth of suffering, of origin, of cessation and of the path.

So this is how one should proceed. One should reflect on these topics over and again until they enter into our brain or our mind whichever makes you happier. Then if you just take notes and close your notebook, there is little or no benefit. They will not be in your mind and even if you look at your notes, it is unclear whether you’d understand what you wrote or not. So it’s excellent that you take notes, but when you go home, you should reread those notes and try to integrate them with your mind.

If you don’t do that to them, that and you just set your notes aside, it’s a form of laziness and sloth. So, some of you gave the precise enumeration of the seven topics of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope. That’s how one should proceed and for the path of the being of the middling scope likewise, one should proceed in sequence through meditating on the noble truth of suffering, of the origin of suffering, of cessation and of the path. So what are the topics of meditation of the path of the middling scope? Please list them in sequence.

So it’s exactly as Sezenkhan was said, then you should reflect on this over and again. What is the object of attainment of the path of the middling scope? What is the means for the attainment of liberation? It’s better to say the truth of the path. This is the wisdom realizing emptiness.

What is the object of abandonment? So you can either say that the object of abandonment of the path of the middling scope is cyclic existence or the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering or just the afflictions? So therefore, when we say that Buddha dharma is profound, it is profound because of the four noble truths and the four noble truths are profound because of the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation. So what is the mode of profundity of the Noble Truth Association? The Noble Truth of Cessation is profound because it refers to emptiness.

This is a cessation within our continuum. Now, the noble truth of cessation is emptiness. What precisely is emptiness? An instance of emptiness would be the selflessness of the person. When we say that the person is empty, we mean that the person is not established by its own characteristics or it’s not established from its own side.

But this is not easy to understand. It is easier to understand by saying the person is not established from the side of the aggregates. So what precisely is meant by this? This is a topic I have explained many times here but in a nutshell, the person is not established from the side of the aggregates. This is what is meant by emptiness.

Now, the non Buddhist scale schools of tenets are completely unable to assert the existence of a person or an I which does not exist from the standpoint of the aggregates. For that matter, the lower schools of tenets are also unable to do this. This is therefore the reason for which Buddha Dharma is said to be uncommonly profound. And from the standpoint of Prasangika Madhyamika, all phenomena are mere conceptual imputations. Then we can therefore understand that we ourselves are mere conceptual imputation but it is easier to understand this with referred, with reference to others.

Though this other person, this girl, this man, this being are mere conception imputations. What is meant here by mere conception imputations? Conception here refers to the innate conception which identifies as this is this or that is that. The conception which thinks this is this or that is that is the imputing conception. Then when one thinks about it in this way, one can understand what is meant when one says that the I is a mere conceptual imputation and does not exist at all from its own side.

Then the fact that the I is not established in the slightest from the standpoint of the aggregates is profound and the mind which understands this is the wisdom which realizes the emptiness of the I. Then, for ourselves it is difficult to understand that the I is not established from the standpoint of the aggregates since we have this natural innate sense that the eye is established from the standpoint of the aggregates. And this natural feeling that the eye exists within the aggregates, this is nothing else but the ignorance which grasps at an I. Then the I’s not being established from the standpoint of the aggregates is reality. The way things really are.

The I being established from the standpoint of the aggregates is the outlook of ignorance. These two are opposite and as the understanding that the I is not established from the standpoint of the aggregate increases, The ignorance which grasps the I as being established from the standpoint of the aggregates decreases and eventually vanishes. As we repeatedly reflect on the fact that the I does not exist from the standpoint of the aggregates, eventually our understanding will deepen and this will reduce the strength of the ignorance which grasps at the I as existing from the standpoint of the aggregates. Now, this is something which is not easy to do. Certainly all of the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India were completely unable to do this.

They cannot accept the existence of emptiness since emptiness means precisely that the eye does not exist from the standpoint of the aggregates and they accept that the I exists from the standpoint of the aggregates. Then there’s no point in talking too much at present. As we said, the topic of meditation of the path of the middling scope is the Four Noble Truths. Could you please give me an instance or an example of the Noble Truth of suffering? Yes, that’s one possibility.

There are many options for instances of the noble truth of suffering. What are the other examples you have? Gotchi. Yes. Leger.

Another. Chris? No, you can ask your question as after. Answer my question first. Matthew?

Then the best examples here are examples where the noble truth of suffering is linked or related to the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Suffering arisen from anger and so forth. Then instances of suffering which can be eradicated through medicine such as a headache or stomachache, it’s preferable not to give them here as examples. Yes, the noble truth, excuse me, the suffering of change is an instance of the mere noble truth of suffering but what I would like here are instances of the noble truth of suffering, which are directly related to dharma practice and can be eliminated through dharma practice. And the noble truth of the origin of suffering?

Another, then just just lay. Lay. Do you know, please? Yeah, yeah. Another.

And instances of the noble truth of cessation. Another, Chris? Realizing No. It’s only the number of association. Sorry.

I didn’t hear. Yes. Another. And, know, choose a cessation. Me?

Emptiness. Tony. Monica? When we banish ignorance. Yep.

So, most of you gave correct answers for the examples of the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. However, regarding the noble truth of cessation, things were more complicated. Many of you said emptiness. Emptiness is not the noble truth of cessation. The noble truth of cessation is emptiness.

But if you want to give an example of the noble truth of cessation, the example you should give is the abandonment which is an abandonment of the afflictions. This does not exist at present within our mind stream. You should not say abandoning the afflictions, but the abandonment which is an abandonment of the afflictions that is the precise answer. Now, that’s for the Noble Truth Association, the Noble Truth of the Path. Precisely.

Are there numerous and many instances of the Noble Truth of the Path? Yes. Okay. Another? Sorry?

Another? The mind of wisdom realizing selflessness. Yes, most of the answers were correct. The main answer is an instance of the noble truth of the path is the wisdom realizing selflessness. The reason is because to abandon the ignorance, which grasps at the self, one must counter it with its antidote.

And its antidote is none other than the wisdom which realizes selflessness. So present, we will generate the motivation for a couple of minutes and since these explanations were about emptiness, we should try to meditate a little bit about emptiness and specifically about the mode of existence of the I. So I have nothing special to add. We have completed the presentation of the path of the middling scope this year and next year we will begin the presentation of the path of the being of the great scope with its uncommon features both from the standpoint of the view and of method. If you have the opportunity, please avail yourself of this opportunity to come.

Then from my own side, I derived great benefit from having to explain the path shared with the being of the small and the middling scope to yourselves. Thank you very much. I hope from your side you derive some benefit from these explanations. Then from my side, I can say there was a great benefit in presenting these topics. I sincerely hope there was benefit from your side and then there will have been shared benefit.

Then Shaya, you said you had a question. I’ll take only your question. Yes, one question. So the mental unease arising from the afflictions. And I’ve pondered this for many weeks and listened to the examples we give about suffering.

Uh-huh. And in my own instance if someone is praising me at work and I feel happiness from that, even though it’s not mental unease, I feel that’s I connect with that as a state of suffering as well. So I guess when I view the Four Noble Truths, I view it as a presentation of the truth of existence Of existence. Of existence. And so why is our definition of suffering only restricted to the mental unease from the afflictions when all of our experience mentally is in the nature of suffering is my You can definitely include these other forms of suffering within the noble truth of suffering.

Then we shall stop here. Stop here tonight. Please, I would like to, give a few words. Alright. It’s a very special night and, it’s the end of the year, And we have a lot of beautiful pictures here if you like to have.

But before I do that, some of you already heard last night, but I have to Dear members of TBI, Tibetan Buddhist Institute is a honor to host the visit by Gishi Chamba Doji, Gishi Jamian Tenzi, and the venerable of San Ramje. We are most fortunate that they agreed to come and again construct the mandala to our center. This is the Chenrezig mandala is dedicated to world peace and His Holiness 80 the birthday and long life and of our Kinsu Rombucha, Lof Sampalin in Taiwan. His parent presently, he’s not well. And also, you know, super return to our beloved Rombucha.

And Jain Rising, as you know, the Chenrezig is the Tibetan name of Avalokiteshvara and Buddha of Compassion and is represented at the center of the mandala by lotus flower. There’s one thing, you know, the the the lab rang, you know, which is the household of Rumbuche and when Rumbuche is alive, you know, Rumbuche take care of the household in a and of course, you know, that his guideline to our work for that. And now I have a still responsibility for that. And just a word few words here. The monks the monks are from our precious teacher’s labrang household and therefore we have responsibility to ensure their welfare is taken care of as this was Rinpoche’s responsibility in the past.

However, we cannot fulfill our obligations towards this without help. So this what we need help is that in the past, I have Rinpoche and myself, we have built the Monks Quarter in a very, very minimum cost because we don’t have the fund. So we built the mud brick with the mud as a normal you put a cement in a between brick but we put in a mud. So it’s actually mud brick wall and rendered round. And we put tile and wood and over number of years, you know, the the because the land was actually in a field, you know, the in a the farm field, so there was a lot of white ant taking over all the roof and I have take off the roof and then I have a bit which and myself, we have a little bit more fund and put the concrete pillars and etcetera and put a slab on our top, take the roof off and the but it still keep the wall.

So, but now I have another face, a little bit problem and so we need some, the present, know, there is a lot of leakage and etcetera, you know, the leaking from the roof and the dampness from the wall and because the wall is not solid cement, so there is lots of ants come around always. And so, okay. Their living condition are just this is what we wrote here. Living conditions are sorry, my eyes are terrible deplorable and is the same of all the monks in the household. The building is very old, decaying and dilapidated and urgent need for repair from leaking roofs and very damp walls and it is beyond their scope within the monastic system in the funds repay.

So hence, their visit to Australia to raise the much needed and urgent funds. Other monks are still, still there is the monks escaping from Tibet and find their way down to Serum Monastery and of course they need to be accommodate. So not only, so terrible, repair is critical, there is a great need for the more quarters. So what we have you know the bottom part is leaking. There’s not much solution we put on top but we, because in the bottom there’s some rooms are three, some rooms are two monks staying together.

So we want to put the extra room on the top, around ten, twelve rooms. And then of course, you know, the new monks come, we have can accommodate for them as well. So I’m asking if you or your friend, relatives are in the position to financially so that when the monks return to Sera, they are able to go ahead with the task of the rebuilding and the repairing. So if you would like to anything regarding this, you know, please contact me. And so I know you all of you have helped in so many ways for center and all different projects, you know, the stupas and the scholarships among sponsorship, you know, and the repairing here at the center, there’s no, you know, not forget that, you know.

Or is it very hard for me to ask this, you know, but I have to ask this part of my responsibility after Rinpoche left and Gisela and myself, we have responsibility. So we can able to enter past. We have very kindly, you know, we did mandala constructed in a Vietnamese community in a temple and also monks visit in a, you know, the prayers in a Vietnamese family and of course all the offer they receive, they’re not taking in their pocket and it all goes for the fund for there to help. So far the cost of the whole entitled together is around 85 Australian dollar but of course we are very lucky and some are member here but the majority, a half of that, you know, we have raised and we’re grateful for those who are contribute from some of our members here and also the majority for that from the Vietnamese community. So I really appreciate for their support and of course, you know, our members here.

And if you like to, you know, to help towards on this, I really appreciate and thank you so much behalf of we have here Nawan Tibden and Gishi Chambadodje, Gishi Jameen Tenzin and Venerable Lawson Ravje, sorry. So thank you for, you know, for all this, you know, considering helping all the those who already helped, you know, thank you so much. And tonight is the last night. There’s a very beautiful cake out there and there’s quite a few different cakes and one is the Daejin’s birthday cake in Fireman and Sam on top and Natalie very kindly provide the cake and of course now we have two people I want to ask. Andrew, you want to say if there is a books available, is it?

Okay. There is a very special deal out there. The books, if you are interested in a book, very good buy. You can give not only for yourself, you can give for a Christmas present for your bringing to your friend into Indama path. And very good deal, know, I can’t believe it.

There’s no deal such that in an ad letter. The five book you buy for only $10 normally is $20.26, 30 but it’s only $10 for each book and $5 there is one free gift book which actually you get $5.50, actually six whole discount, but on top of that you get another free book. Then there is the other foyer, we have build No. Oh, I thought ten to five. I thought we changed.

No. Okay. That’s fine. Yeah. Anyway, please contact, know, see Andrew, all right?

That’s a lot of gift. And then there is a monks gishis they bought from India. There is beautiful stuff there. You can give small for your relatives or whatever. And there’s one thing, there’s a very special vajra and bell and those who have initiate or thinking about receiving initiation in the future, you can grab that because I tell you this is a very special craftsman from Rajbu.

You know, there’s a one special Raja making family. They, you know, bought from them. So there’s a very special vajra and Bell. So sound is beautiful and they look very beautiful and fantastic and there’s other things on the table. And I think you wanna say something?

I think my sales pitch pale pales in comparison next to Tenzin’s, but there’s the transcription of Geshela’s teaching on the four noble truths is, you know, the last long weekend teaching is now available. And the fifth part of liberation in the palm of your hand, so that was this year’s from May to August transcription of that is also available, which I’m sure, you know, all these transcriptions would be invaluable for our study and practice. This Sunday, farewell coming and it’s twelve noon onwards and you can bring a plate to share and towards the end we can compete with the Geshe-la, you know, with the basketball. But if you like to, there’s another announcement announcement I I would would like like to. To, 11:00 until eleven, 12:30 is climate, what do you call, demonstration or the, you know, it’s on.

And there is one very big climate demonstration organized on Tibetan, you know, Tibetan Plateau is suffering. So there’s a Tibetan exile government, you know, to create this. So His Holiness from the Tibetan exile government support for, you know, to support this whatever is the meeting is the host in France on this Sunday or the Monday, yeah. So anyway, if you like to join, you will see the Tibetans and their flag and His Holiness picture at the probably right at the front of the row. So if you’d like to join, please join there.

That’d be a really great cause and then after that you can come here. Thank you so much. Oh, sorry. And Geshe-la’s, they bought very beautiful pictures. His Holiness, Shakyamuni Buddha, White Tara.

If you are doing a Vajrayogini, you can also take a Vajrayogini picture there, beautiful. So this is free. That table is not free and that table is not free, sorry. Alright, thank you very much again. Okay.

Tonight, if you’re going to come for farewell, you can offer for Gislas for then. If you’re not going to come on a Wednesday Sunday, then you can make a offer now. Alright? You know? Beautiful child that yeah.

Cake. Yeah. Definitely. Natalie Magic, beautiful cake. Please make sure you have a cake and chai.

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
vajra and bell
Implements used during tantric rituals: the vajra, held in the right hand, symbolizes bliss and the bell, held in the left, emptiness. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top