1 h 16 min · 11,135 words · 5 October 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a session on the four noble truths, explaining that paths are minds arising from uncontrived renunciation or bodhichitta, while cessations are permanent absences that cannot be minds. The teacher contrasts Buddhist tenet schools on the last two truths, the self and continuum, and the role of faith versus reasoning in practice. Much of the talk is a question and answer session on these points.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 17m
UUID: be5310d6-9dbd-4674-bdd8-7cf4dda912be
Date: 2015-10-05
Words: 11,131
We didn’t have the dictionaries, nobody had received especially the correct transmissions. Berzin sometimes was just making it up as he went along. Really. There’s one whole teaching on 13 deity Yamāntaka, he got to basically the next day because nobody had received this. We didn’t know what the words meant.
Right? Then I came in the next generation but even then there was a lot of trouble with some terms, you know. And it’s mainly thanks to Jeffrey Hopkins that things have stabilized, you know, and now things are on a better grounding. You can actually study Buddhism and English without ever learning Tibetan. And when I was young, it was not possible.
If you wanted a serious knowledge, you needed Tibetan. Then there’s one thing I wanted to cover with you briefly and then I’ll take all your questions. It was something which came out this morning very clearly. The confusion regarding the noble truth of cessation and of the path. Then there’s a very simple thing to keep in mind.
All noble truths of the path are minds. As minds, they are impermanent phenomena. Okay? Now a path in Buddhism is not like a path in daily life. A path is a mind and specifically it is either a mind which has arisen as a result of uncontrived renunciation or a mind which has arisen as a result of uncontrived bodhichitta.
Without either of those two minds, you do not have a path. Okay? Then you can summarize these two statements. Since uncontrived bodhichitta can only arise after you have generated uncontrived renunciation, a path is defined in the seventy topics as a mind, as a mind which arises in dependence on uncontrived renunciation. So once you’ve generated uncontrived renunciation, then in dependence on that you can generate any of the five paths of a hearer or a pratyeka buddha, the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning or you could even generate the paths of a bodhisattva if you can generate bodhichitta, in dependence on renunciation.
Without uncontrived renunciation, you do not have a path within your mind stream. You may have meditated on impermanence, may have meditated on emptiness, these are not paths. Now the noble truth of the path is a mind which is a path. So we don’t have the noble truth of the path in our mind streams. We train to get reached that point.
Now, the noble truth of cessation is always a permanent phenomenon. It’s an absence. Therefore, it cannot be a mind. All minds are impermanent, they change on an instant by instant basis. Noble truths of cessation are absences.
So some of you gave us for the noble truth of cessation, the absence of the afflictions. I think it was Sylvia, that’s excellent. It’s an absence. As an absence it’s permanent. Emptiness is a noble truth of cessation.
Selflessness is a noble truth of cessation. But, the wisdom realizing selflessness is not a noble truth of cessation because it’s a wisdom, it’s a mind, therefore, it changes instant by instant, it’s a noble truth of the path. Okay? So the wisdom realizing selflessness is a noble truth of the path. That selflessness it realizes is a noble truth of cessation.
It’s reasonably clear, isn’t it? Do you see the difference? So the wisdom realizing selflessness is a noble truth of the path, and it’s a path as well. Selflessness is not a noble truth of the path, it is a noble truth of cessation. Then the Buddhist schools disagree regarding the last two truths.
The different schools of tenets, thank you, Shushu, the different schools of tenets disagree regarding the last two truths. So depending on whether you are a Vaibhāṣika, a Sautrāntika, a Svatantika Mādhyamika, a Cittamātra, a Prāsaṇgika, You will present the noble truth of the path and the noble truth of cessation differently. Right? Then we won’t go into that too much but basically to put it in a very very summarized way, the Hīnayāna schools of tenets consider that there are both selflessness, excuse me, that there is only selflessness of persons and therefore only selflessness of persons is a truth of cessation. The Mahāyāna schools of tenets consider that there is both a selflessness of persons and of phenomena, therefore these are both noble truths of cessation.
That we will cover in tenets and next year Geshe lah has agreed to teach grounds and paths. Then if you can attend that after studying tenets this year, then you have a very solid understanding. Then I think you can almost go and study by yourself basically. I think, honestly. Then, do you have any questions?
Same thing. Keep in mind Geshela presented the view in keeping with Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, the highest system of tenets, there are other schools of tenets, lower schools of Buddhist tenets which say you can identify something as the I within the aggregates. But the way Geshe did it I thought was very helpful for us. In other words, instead of just studying Buddhist philosophy, which is a bit dry and abstract, look within yourselves and see when you say I, what is that thing? And I must say I think the natural answer is the mental consciousness, right?
I think normally if you look in yourself and you want to identify the I, you say it’s the mind, right? It’s fairly straightforward as an answer. Now how that answer diverges from the Hindu assertion of the existence of the Ātman is that the Buddhist mind is impermanent, it is fragmentary and it is dependent. It’s not permanent, it is not one and it is not independent. So that already, that’s a Vaibhāṣika view but it’s already incredibly powerful for the mind.
If you think that my I changes instant by instant, faster than I can think, That my I is fragmentary, it’s constituted of parts and that my I is dependent, that already is very powerful for the mind and that is not even close to the Prāsaṇgika view. There is at least one so called western gauche, you know, so called because he never really got his geshe degree, Michael Roach, know, who says that he has understood the view and when he talks about it, he’s talking about the Vaibhāṣika view, you know. Then it’s bit of an object of ridicule in the great monasteries, you know. The Vaibhāṣika view is really very profound in and of itself, but it’s got nothing to do with the Prāsaṇgika view. So you can see there’s a very big difference between the Vaibhāṣika assertion of an I which exists, a person which exists, but which is impermanent, which is composite or fragmentary and which is dependent and the Hindu assertion of the Ātman, the soul, which is permanent, which is one and not independent.
And that Hindu assertion of the Ātman, I think, is identical to the Christian assertion of the soul. I think there is no distinction. I have degrees in Christian theology, I never could see a distinction between the two. Then do you have other questions? I do have other questions, but just on that raised the question that the Hindu version of Ātman seems to be a description of emptiness.
Is that right? That it’s permanent phenomena? Emptiness is a permanent phenomenon. But the Hindu Ātman is a mind, it’s self conscious. The Hindu Ātman is the person, you know.
I mean, we could go into a lot of analysis here. Basically, Ātman in Sanskrit derives from a normalized form of Aham, I. Right? The personal pronoun Aham. Then it is I ness if you wish.
Then accepting or not accepting the Ātman is distinguishing feature between Buddhist being Buddhist and being Hindu. So it is perhaps the most important thing you can draw from this weekend. If you accept an Ātman, an I or a soul which is permanent, one and independent, you are not Buddhist. If you accept that with reincarnation, you are Hindu. Then there are numerous varieties of Hindus we should not enter them.
There’s Advaita, Vedanta, Advaita, Vedanta, Jaina is in many senses part of the Hindu, you know, complex but the distinction as Geshela made very clear between being an insider and an outsider, a Buddhist and a non Buddhist, is selflessness and nothing else. Regarding that there can be no doubt and in Western centers a big doubt obviously arises regarding the fundamental mind, the mind of clear light, which is why it attracts so much interest. The fundamental mind is not permanent and it is not unitary and it is not independent. The fundamental mind, the mind of clear light is impermanent, it changes instant by instant, it is composite and it is dependent. It is in no way some sort of closet ātman.
We don’t have such a thing. And there is no God. So I remember no one would ever tell me her name but there was a western nun here who said, was I told that Buddha House when asked if there was God in Buddhism, it depends what you mean by God. Then that is a sign of great confusion. There is no God.
You know, don’t bring him in through the back door. In Hinduism there is, Bhagavan exists. Then the relationship between God and karma in Hinduism is a very vexed question. Whenever we debate with the Hindus that’s where we get a field day, right? Because there’s karma and there’s God and God intervenes to make exceptions to karma and you know, it becomes very very messy.
Oh, do you have other questions? Could you just clarify again? Noble truths are minds except the third noble truth. Yeah, that’s a very good way to put it, exactly. Well actually that’s no, we have to be careful with that one.
Not all noble truths. The noble truth of cessation includes components which are mine and components which are not the noble truth of origin of suffering includes components which are mine and components which are not mine. Everything which is a noble truth of suffering is not necessarily a mind. Everything which is a noble truth of the origin of suffering is always a mind. Everything which is a noble truth of cessation is never a mind.
And everything which is a noble truth of the path is always a mind. So the causes are always a mind, the origin and the path. Yes, yes, yes, you could put it as an issue. In those terms, yes, yes. That actually wasn’t a question, I just wanted clarification of that before before we moved on.
Now I heard this locution in on day one in the morning, so that’s asking you to hearken back quite a ways. I’ll do my best. But I have here the four noble truths are entirely logical so they may not in essence be dharma. What does that mean? It’s a very powerful statement Geshela made.
So I was delighted to hear that. So I didn’t get that I didn’t get No. He made it repeatedly. It’s it’s a fruit of his own personal analysis. So this is what happens when you get a very good Geshe.
Yeah. You get carried places you might not want to go. Yeah. You know? The sign of a good Geshe that a good Geshe follows logic first.
Yeah. You see, His Holiness made the distinction between Buddhist science, Buddhist philosophy and Buddhist religion. Now Buddhist science is those elements of Buddhism which may or may not be compatible but with modern science but which are verifiable as was the main criteria of scientific discovery. So let’s say Buddhist cosmology will be part of Buddhist science, then it’s discredited, you know, this always has been explicit, I mean if you read Vasubandhu’s Abhidhamma Kosha, it is clear that Vasubandhu meant that Mount Meru existed literally, well there is no such thing, you know, and the sky is blue because we’re facing the blue side of Mount Meru and the moon and the sun are of the same size and they’re revolving or pretty much the same size and they’re revolving around Mount Meru, Mount Meru, this is a primitive cosmology. It is scientific because it’s basically falsifiable.
You can device a test to demonstrate it false, it has been proven false, it is only of historic or ritual interest to us, that’s Buddhist science. There are other aspects of Buddhist science which are massively confirmed. For instance, the assertion that all matter is impermanent, which is something which western philosophers were definitely not taking on board. I mean I had the strangest conversation with, well Pamela knows him, the dean of the faculty of philosophy at the University of Adelaide, privately over lunch told me at the end, he was ready to take impermanence on board. Then, I must recognize I he stopped me dead in my tracks.
I thought, wow. It’s like it’s been four centuries. Right? It’s been You a know? I mean, it’s like this is like a non issue.
Yeah. You know? So this is an aspect where Buddhist science has been confirmed by modern physics. Then we have Buddhist philosophy and finally we have Buddhist religion which is those things which are unprovable if you wish logically. Now the four noble truths are always put within Buddhist philosophy, but Geshela’s point is, if it is possible to empirically establish that all human experience is either the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change or pervasive suffering, And if it is possible to establish that this truth of suffering is rooted in the mental afflictions and there’s a lot of work in cognitive psychology which is going very much in this direction, those two truths for sure are no more no longer part of Buddhist philosophy.
They’re part of Buddhist science. And then it’s really no longer dharma as we understand it. Yes. That is, I mean his understanding of dharma is not something which benefits the mind but something which is beyond what can be scientifically established. It’s an alternate definition of dharma, right?
Then the latter two truths, the truth of the path and the truth of cessation, to establish those scientifically would be very difficult, I don’t see how. But I imagine if we were to study, for instance using fMRI, you know functional magnetic resonance imaging, the brains of Achat’s and it was possible to demonstrate somehow that an arhat would never generate a negative mental state again, then that would be pretty much proven, pretty much. It’s not that far fetched, mean we do have people like Davidson who are doing a lot of research at the University of Wisconsin on the neurological correlates of meditation. How far that research goes, we don’t know. So, it’s a very interesting point I think.
Have you done the studies on naive meditators compared to experienced people? Exactly. And with the generation of bodhichitta? Exactly. So like, for example, with metta practice.
Matriarchy, yes. They’ve established certain things. And it’s not just one location in the brain, it’s several. So there are global aspects. So it looks like it’s an evolution in the sense of developing bodhichitta.
It may be the same with the realization of emptiness as well. I think No one’s actually done that study, but certainly with the bodhichitta, it looks like it’s an evolving thing and developing parts of the brain. We don’t know a lot about it, but it’s happening. It’s a work in progress. I think the weakness of Davidson’s work is not the neurobiology, the weakness is distinction between various forms of meditation.
The weakness in Davidson’s works is that he does not distinguish carefully between various types of meditation. Right. Like you have analytical meditations which give rise to bodhichitta, so he demonstrated the insula is activated, it’s very clear and ambiguous, but he does not distinguish between the neurological correlates of fixative or concentration meditation and the neurological correlates of analytical meditation and I assume there would be very big differences. So I think you see Alan Wallace doing that work That I’m brain not aware of. Okay, because he’s been doing that now for a few years.
He’s doing it in, I think it’s Thailand. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
Yes. He’s doing that. So someone donated a brain scanner and various other stuff. Yes. Yes.
Yes. So, you know, there’s a lot of money behind it, and it’s associated with Berkeley and a professor there, a lady professor, so they’re doing the studies in ADHD with meditation, but I think he’s also doing it with other types of meditation. You see what you would need and that is where Davidson is quite unique, you need someone who is internationally recognized in his field, then it took a lot of courage, actually took his holiness to push him out of the closet, you know that. I mean, he was practicing satipatthana when he was at Harvard, at Harvard, and his thesis director said to him, look David, you can get a PhD and get a good job or you can practice satipatthana. Then he put satipatthana behind him and he met His Holiness by accident some twenty years later.
And His Holiness said, you know, and we see the results. But what we need in addition to someone with that type of impeccable reputation is we need a collection of realized meditators with different types of meditative practices. And it’s difficult to get people like that. It’d be very interesting to see for instance what the neurological correlates of tantric meditations are, but the great yogis, they do not accept these tests. Like His Holiness said once that he had, you can imagine the authority His Holiness wields in the Tibetan community, right?
He had asked that practitioners of tummo, of inner heat cooperate with neurologists. Tummo is one of the rather well researched forms of meditative activity and he’d asked some Ladakh meditators in particular who are highly realized and he just refused. And Khesilas was very proud of him. I remember him saying, this is really, you know, the sign of a true practitioner that the vows and the pledges, you know, first, you know. But that would be the way forward and if that was done, then it would be interesting I think a lot of what we consider to be Buddhist philosophy would become Buddhist science and would become science.
I’m not saying everything could, but a lot could. It’s not that simple. Mhmm. Because one type of meditation depends on progress and proficiency. Yes.
Other types of meditation. So, you know, unless you’ve got a stamp, you’ve reached grade a in this one, you know, your grade a plus or whatever, and you would be wanting to compare not apples with apples, you were wanting to see the so called best meditators with the novice meditators and you need to get ratings and whatever, I don’t think it’s actually going to work. It’d be very difficult. Because really your final I mean what do you bring to the time when you meditate on emptiness and you realize emptiness? It’s not just the basis of one kind of meditation.
All your knowledge is coming to that point. What you’d have to do, but you can imagine what this would call for, you would have to follow the meditative life of one meditator in retreat over twenty, thirty, forty, fifty. That’s what we’re talking about. Right? Then now I don’t think it’s gonna happen but in the future maybe, you know.
But what Geshela the point Geshela was making this morning is that the Buddhist claim is a very powerful claim. The Buddhist claim is that the core of the Buddhist teachings are accessible to logic and or empirical experience. Not everything. The subtle teachings on karma are not, but Buddhism does not stand and fall on those. But the other aspects of the Buddhist teachings, in other words, the four noble truths, the teachings about the two truths, conventional ultimate truths, the nature of the mind.
All of this is claimed to be accessible to logic and reasoning. Then it is up to us to assess it on that basis. And that is why Geshela and this is a typical Geluk Geshe position is very critical of faith based practice alone. You know, simply because faith is not a solid foundation. If there is nothing else, which was the case in Tibet, people were poorly educated, then then one makes do with what there is.
But I have many Christian friends whose practice is exclusively based on faith and when they face the tribulations of life, often it collapses. Often. Poor noble truth as such, was the influence of karma and what role karma is playing in this really. To me it’s, there is a large role and also genetic, I mean if we were looking at a non Buddhist aspect, would be looking at genetics, we would be looking at DNA, we would be looking at intergenerational changes and things like that. And all of that actually affects the western style eye in medical terms, which is different from the eye we’re looking at.
I’m just saying that their karma has to play a big role. Karma plays a huge role. Geshela did not cover it because actually this teaching, I proposed this topic to Geshela for the, long October weekend because we are covering the path of the middling scope during the whole year. So Geshela is teaching on karma every Wednesday and he’s been doing this since what February or March. But karma and afflictions are both the two components of the noble truth of the origin of suffering.
Then if you look at Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo, there’s a huge section on karma, I encourage you to read. Then your point about karma and genetics is a well taken one and that’s why I have presented here numerous cases of children recollecting past lives and who were identical twins. Then there are not that many cases which are studied by Stevenson but there are a couple. The zygosity was established in most of those cases by blood testing and one case I presented here was that of the Kaskapa twins, Sri Lankan twins. I presented another case more recently of the Pollock twins.
Now in both cases what is striking is these are children who are genetic twins and yet manifest very strong physical and behavioral differences even though they were raised in exactly the same families. In addition, they have memories of previous lives which explain to a large degree the differences they manifest. In the case of the Pollock twins for instance, one of the twins had a birthmark on the side, the other did not. One was shy and recessive, the other was very forthright and aggressive. One was very bright, one was very dull and in a previous identical twins, no identical twins.
The the part of twins is case is presented in European cases of the reincarnation type by Stevenson, a very interesting case and the Kakshapa twins case is presented in volume two of reincarnation in biology. It’s a stronger case in my opinion but it comes from Sri Lanka so I have downplayed it a bit. But in the case of the Pollock twins what is striking is that in a previous life, in the immediately preceding life, these two twins were also sisters but they had different ages. They were not twins in other words. One had studied more in school, the other had not and both died at the same time in a car accident.
One had severe wounds to the side, the other did not. The one who had severe wounds to the side had in the subsequent life birthmarks in that area which the other did not. The one who had studied a bit more in school, I think she progressed to eighth or ninth grade was brighter than the other twin and she also happened to be more how shall we say, direct and she had been more direct in the previously collected existence. So these cases are rare, but these are the cases which enable us to distinguish between the karmic component and the genetic component as you were saying. Then we just have to hope that there are more cases like this discovered by the team at University of Virginia and that we will be able to clarify things more.
What is striking is certainly in the case of the Sri Lankan twins, the karmic component is much more important than the genetic component. It’s very striking. These are genetically identical twins and there are substantial differences in heights which is really astonishing. Twins raised in the same family, the same conditions. If you look at the picture, I’ll if I present this again you will see it’s really astonishing, the faces are very different.
These are the Kakshapa twins now, Sri Lankan twins. The faces are very different. Probably. For sure. But they were tested.
Genetic aspects because identical twins have the same DNA. So it depends on the interaction of environment on that DNA. You can’t really have a tall twin and a short twin, or major facial differences because they’re not identical then. Identical twins you cannot tell apart. That is the dogma.
They were tested. They were tested. Then if you put the tests in question, I would say you have to contact the division of personality studies, find the address of these twins, I think they’re probably still alive, you know. And then the tests are easy to make now, you know. Stevenson relied on blood testing which was considered perfectly acceptable at the period.
But you see this raises many questions because if this is true, I’m not saying it is but we do have nonetheless a leading scientist who says these were identical twins and there were major differences. If this is true, then the balance of power between karma and genetics leans in favor of karma against genetics. Then this is to be examined. There’s not a lot of these cases. I mean, Stevenson has less than half a dozen, you can imagine how difficult it is to find identical twins who spontaneously have memories of previous lives which can be verified.
I mean, it’s it’s quite a combination, right? And the best thing which could happen to Buddhist studies would be for large scale funding for the division of personality studies at the University of Virginia to resume. So as you know, their work has basically stopped after the GFC because there’s just no money, you know. Do you have other questions on the four noble truths? If there is no continuum of the eye, please.
Talk about the continuum of the conventional eye. What would be the problem if there was no continuum of the eye? Yes, and there’d be no karma or causality of any type. So that the I has a continuum is basically essential to all of the religious traditions which affirm that there is life after death or maybe even in the case of Buddhism and Hinduism life before birth. This applies to all the religious traditions.
Then the problem is more how do you establish this continuum? So for all of the schools of tenets up to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, it’s pretty straightforward. One of the elements of the aggregates is identified as an example of the I, typically the mental consciousness. Then this mental consciousness is said to be uninterrupted. Then obviously at death, coarse consciousness ceases but you can posit a subtle consciousness which is uninterrupted.
So you can maintain a continuum of the eye. This becomes much more problematic in Prāsaṇgika madhyamika where the I is a mere nominal conception imputation. Then, how you maintain the I’s continuum is something you’d have to bring up in tenets. Tenets class on Tuesdays. But I think you can maintain that the imputation on the I is continuous.
If you cannot, karma collapses. Imputation of the I is continuous. On the eye is continuous. Do you have other questions? Please.
Eye and the fundamental mind are both the same and the continuum are all the same thing that travels on to the next To put it very, very simply, why not? Yes. Yes. I mean up to Svatantika Mādhyamika, you could say that. Prāsaṇgika would not say that the I is a fundamental mind.
Prāsaṇgika would say that the I is merely a name or a thought, a conception in other words, put on the fundamental mind, then that viewpoint is a difficult one. It seems to separate the two. Yes, So I think for us the viewpoint that the I can be identified as one of the mental consciousnesses is the more self evident viewpoint. It’s the simpler way of putting it. And then later on when you are comfortable with that viewpoint, you have to examine whether it really stands the test of reason or not.
Now that takes time. These things are not easy, you know, just step by step. Step by step. Please. Okay.
Could you comment a little bit more on the on the group’s gaseous position again as against a faith based practices? Like, I have seen a lot of rainbow tree, like, really prominent rainbow trees, can see, Rinpoche, Rinpoche, in Nyingma tradition or another tradition, they are very faith based. And guru yoga in guru yoga, the guru is taken as the Buddha himself. And I find this kind of belief very contradictory to the kind of belief that’s holding by Keshe la and I find it’s splitting my head. It’s not contradictory.
It’s meant for different types of people, different trainees. Clearly, if you are dealing with someone who is uneducated and or who has no interest whatsoever in studies, all that’s left is faith, right? Well, there are two paths. Ārya Asaṇga says there are two paths. For the students of dull acumen faith, for the students of sharp acumen reason.
Then if the person is either uneducated or not interested in study, you rely on what there is. There is faith. Then you rely on faith. 99.99% of the Tibetans and of the Buddhists throughout Asia practice exclusively based on faith. That’s all there is.
If you speak to my wife, you look at my wife’s family, it’s completely a faith based practice. You go to the temple every two weeks, Buddha is like God, you pray to Buddha to get preferment. The temple in her hometown gives military promotion so you pray to be promoted to colonel, you know. It’s ridiculous but that’s the way it is, you know. Then obviously, does this have anything to do with what Buddha Śākyamūni taught?
That’s another question. Right? If you look at Buddha Śākyamūni’s teaching, there’s no relationship. But if you’re dealing with very simple people and Rinpoche had many very simple students from Tibet, then he would just say just recite manis. That’s all the person can do.
And here when His Holiness came and before that this was also Rinpoche’s project, this is a center for study. This is in keeping with the Buddha’s thought. When the Buddha said to his disciples, monks and scholars do not accept my words as such, instead test them as a goldsmith tests gold. Burn them, rub them and taint them, I think is a term. Then this is only possible for someone who studies and analyzes.
Then if the person is unable to do that, then one has faith based Buddhism, but faith based Buddhism and Christianity are twins. Apart from some differences in belief, you know, once you start practicing a heavily faith based Buddhism, you’re very close to the great monotheisms. So my teacher at Sera, Yama Rinchen, he used to joke, you know, he said, yeah, in Tibet, you know, we have some Tibetans, you know, because he said, actually Tibetans are quite blunt, he said, they’re quite stupid, right? So he said, you ask them where is Buddha and say, oh, he’s up there. And then when they want to praise someone like His Holiness, they say, yeah, His Holiness.
He’s greater than a Buddha. He’s a bodhisattva. This is actually what he said, right? Now, this is a sign of great ignorance. So in this matter, I think we should not blindly imitate the Asians.
We should try to go back to the original message of Buddha Śākyamūni, of his great disciples, of the great pandits of ancient India and the best representatives of the Tibetan tradition. And in the Nyingma tradition, obviously some of the teachers are dealing with very simple students in Tibet or even in Taiwan or China. Then it is better for the student to have faith in the spiritual teacher than to have nothing. But such blind faith in the spiritual teacher is something which is potentially very dangerous. And this is why His Holiness the Dalai Lama has warned warned explicitly in this room, all of us against the so called Chugi Gyalpo, the kings of dharma.
There’s a lot of Tibetan and actually Chinese monks now in China who are promoting themselves saying they are dharma kings and basically attracting the blind reliance of others and independence on this blind reliance gigantic amounts of money, you know. Buddhism has become very corrupt, you You might want to speak to my wife to have an idea of how bad the situation is in Thailand. Then, we live in the final age of degeneration, we from our side, we have to be very very careful and that’s why His Holiness encouraged a practice based on reason. Reason. The last words Rinpoche said to me were we have entered in the final stage of the age of degeneration, there will be no pure monks left, focus on your commitments.
Those are the last words Rinpoche said to me. And even now, the degree of decay is frightening. So historians at Dalai Lama and Rinpoche have encouraged us not to take teachers lightly and to focus first on the Buddhist teaching and examine the teacher very carefully. In my life, I’ve been very fortunate. I have a very skeptical nature.
So when people make claims, I don’t believe them. Then my teachers I examined very carefully and if there was even a rumor, I never took someone as a teacher. The rumor was enough that because you can’t always verify a rumor, you don’t know, you know. Especially in the Tibetan community, you may not have the means to verify. A rumor was enough, I didn’t take the risks.
And as a result, I have never been disappointed in the teachers I chose. Then I know many western students who have, under the impulse of emotion, rushed into teacher student relationships and then have had great regret, You know? Yes, please. Is it because of the the Asian, they don’t have a lot of education. They follow as a blind faith as the westerner when when when Buddhism come to Western, everything is sort of like a structure?
No. I used to think like that but I think when West many westerners become Buddhist, they put their minds in the closet. It’s sad to say but I knew because of what I was doing in India and my contacts, I knew about problems long before they hit the internet or were talked about in the centers and repeatedly I tried to warn students against teachers which just became very problematic like Michael Roach. Back when Michael Roach was very well known, was a monk, know. I mean I heard some very clear rumors from the Tibetan government from people very close to His Holiness that I had a lot of western acquaintances who were just hypnotized By humor, I warned them without, I could not say too much but I said please be careful, there are problems, there will be difficulties.
There were other teachers in Australia I warned people about. It was never accepted. The relation to a teacher is an emotional relation which it should not be. The person falls in love with their teacher. They fall in love with some sort of private fantasy they have and then it’s luck of the draw karmically.
If the karma is good, then the teacher is a worthy object of such affection and if the person does not have good karma, then down the line things blow up. So in other words is when we enter to the Buddhism, we should also exam the teacher really carefully before we we take refuge. Right? You do not need to have a teacher to take refuge. You can take refuge from a monk and that monk is your preceptor and that’s as far as it goes.
Then here at TBI, we do not encourage people to enter in a teacher student relationship quickly. Geshela does not accept students at present. And Geshela does not accept to give tantric initiations at TBI either, you know. I no longer accept to translate tantric initiations in the West that’s finished, you know. Simply because there’s been too many problems.
Then from your own side, you should first study Buddhism in the texts, then you should check if the what the teacher said is in accordance with what the great beings of the past, all the way through Je Tsongkhapa, the great Kadampa Geshes and so forth teach and you should examine the teacher’s behavior with a very very sharp eye. It’s one thing to teach in the temple, it’s another thing on the outside, you know. And if you have any doubt, don’t enter into relationship. The Pratyaka Buddhas go very far in their practice without ever having a teacher. Now this one as the Dalai Lama has said, in the Gelug tradition, since we have a sufficient number of monks, you should not take a teacher who is not fully ordained.
The reason for that is that full ordination places a very clear exterior boundary on the behavior of the teacher. Otherwise, it is very easy to say and we have had this a lot in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition. There’s a pretty girl who comes to the temple, oh, you’re dakini and this and that and, you know, as Tenzin Palmo said once to me, she said, yes, the moment they start talking of dakinis, I run, you know. Right? So you have to be very very skeptical.
Have only teachers who are fully ordained in the ghetto tradition, have as few teachers as possible and rely on them well, then you don’t need to have a teacher at the beginning. As Ernest has said as an exception for western students, western students can attend teachings such as these teachings of Lamrim on the four noble truths etc. For as long as they want without taking the instructor as a teacher, until they assure. Once you take Tantric initiations, you must take the lama who bestows initiation as guru. There’s no possibility of finding a middle way there.
And then you see in this room basically Rinpoche started teaching in Adelaide when Chris? In 1988. So Rinpoche started teaching here twenty seven years ago. I can see in this room, one, two, three, four, all the students of Rinpoche, right? Rinpoche gave Anutara Yoga tantra initiations how many times?
How many times? And what were the last words of Rinpoche in 2011 before leaving for India? I was there, I translated I know. Rinpoche said, continue to attend the teachings at TBI regularly. Where is everybody?
They have Anuttara Yoga tantra initiations. So there there’s no margin. They took Rinpoche as spiritual teacher. Then you don’t have to follow what the teacher says to you about your investments. That’s another story.
Right? But the teacher, what the teacher says about dharma, if you have a teacher student relationship, that there is no no margin after that. So you see, what that shows is that the initiations were not taken seriously. That means a person cannot carry that. Then it’s better to let go, you know.
If any way none of us is going to gain any major realizations in Lamrim, it’s difficult. So tantric realizations my goodness, you know. So I covered something which is very unrelated to the Four Noble truth but I think it’s very important. Yes, Richard. Can I just go back to the visual system this morning about looking for the eye Mhmm?
The five sensory consciousnesses. Mhmm. Mhmm. And I’m just trying to understand why he was talking about the five sense cons that the five sense consciousness is essentially ceasing to operate during sleep or during a state of unconsciousness. I take it that this is because, I mean, they are at most dormant, literally dormant in the way that you are.
I mean, the body is dormant at that time, but as soon as you might hit somebody, they will immediately demonstrate the the extent of the continuation of the sense consciousness. So I take it that this teaching is really to demonstrate the nebulousness of this, the I that if you seek to find it amongst the mental consciousness, you’re going to be faced with a number of practical problems in that sense that it becomes increasingly nebulous. The problem you see is really if you’re going to posit or set yourself from the standpoint of a Prāsaṇgika position, the issue which is delicate is establishing that the eye cannot or an instance of the I cannot be given as a mental consciousness. The sense consciousness is just no debate. I think Geshela gave that example just to show how it worked.
Nobody’s gonna say that the eye consciousness is the I, I don’t think so, you know. But the mental consciousness is a natural candidate. Right? So why the mental consciousness would not be the I from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika is something which needs work. It’s not easy to establish.
He was talking about not just deep sleep then from the point of view of the sense consciousnesses, although he did, but also from the point of view of the mental consciousness. Yes. Yes. Then there are many many ways to establish this. Deep sleep was given where Geshe also gave the example of coma, then in a coma the sense consciousness does not operate right.
A patient, sorry to interrupt, medical point of view is unconscious and may be on a ventilator. It’s been shown that if you cause them pain, they can react. They react, do they? So something’s happening. Now whether it’s just an automatic response, we know they can feel pain.
So it must be a mental consciousness or, I mean, you know, it’s their mind, they are feeling something and there’s a response. And I guess in deep sleep the same thing can happen because a person can be woken up by pain, heat, cold, you know what I mean, those sorts of things. So changes in the environment. So I don’t think it’s all that simple. No, it’s not and I think what I certainly would like to stand behind Gisela and encourage you not to be dogmatic in your Buddhist practice.
Don’t stop repeating as a mantra, all phenomena not inherently exist, they’re not established by their own characteristics, etc, etc. I’d encourage you instead to be scientific in your approach. Analyze within yourself, we have the laboratory of our own minds. Look within yourself and find a tenet system which you can endorse. The question is not what is the best.
The question what’s the best for you. So there’s one question which is one of the only questions I know which irritates His Holiness tremendously. So if you ever are lucky enough to have an audience with His Holiness, don’t ask this question. His sonniest cannot stand it when westerners ask him what’s the best practice. And it seems that it’s a question there’s only two questions westerners seem to ask His Holiness from what he told me.
What’s the best practice and can I be gay? You know? Don’t ask why, you know? Gay is many many, you know? So when you ask what’s the best practice, you are demonstrating something very basically wrong from a Buddhist perspective.
You’re demonstrating that you don’t understand the differences in the trainees. We are very different. There may be a tenet system which is excellent for one person and which another person cannot take on board and reciprocally. For instance, many people with a Chinese background are much much more open to the mind only system of tenets than to Mādhyamika because it’s spread much more in China, it has infused Chinese culture and there are major Chinese, there made a cosmic imprint. My wife is very open to mind only because she’s of Chinese origin.
One of her teachers was Theravada but with a strong connection with Chitamatra. Then for such a person, Chitamatra is the best system of tenets. Whether it is possible to attain liberation and full enlightenment from a Prāsaṇgika standpoint in Chitamatra or not is another question. Tibetans are very close to the Prāsaṇgika system for historic reasons and because the schools of Tibetan Buddhism which have spread in the West are schools which have taken on board the prasanika view, this is taught as supreme. But this is something we have to analyze for ourselves.
I mean Je Tsongkhapa himself and Lamrim Chenmo in several passages seems to accept the existence of a mind basis of all and this is what led Jeffrey who’s very sharp to ask His Holiness the question you don’t want to ask. Was Je Tsongkhapa maybe Chitamatra from the conventional standpoint and Prāsaṇgika from the ultimate standpoint or not? This is a big question mark for Je Tsongkhapa especially the early Je Tsongkhapa. So for yourselves, we have we have we’re very lucky here we have a tenets class. It’s very well taught by Geshela.
Come to the tenets class, do your best to understand and ask yourself what seems true for you. Then train your mind in that and when and if you become dissatisfied with that, then you can see for instance about moving upwards from the Vaibhāṣika maybe to the Sautrāntika view or maybe from the Sautrāntika to the Chitamatra view. You can be a Mahāyāna practitioner and have the Vaibhāṣika system of tenets. So Atisha’s teacher, Dharmarakshita was a Mahāyāna practitioner, they said he was a Bodhisattva and in terms of view he was Vaibhāṣika. The Vaibhāṣika view is a view which is very accessible to a modern westerner and I think the Sautrāntika view is very accessible to a modern westerner too.
Then the Chitamatra and Prāsaṇgika views, I think are only for westerners really accessible to people who have done a bit of modern physics. If you’ve done a bit of modern physics, then there are things in Chitamatra and Prāsaṇgika which really resonate. Otherwise, if you really enter in Chitamatra and Prāsaṇgika in-depth, things get very awkward. Who is the agent who is doing the acting? Yes, Andy.
Then we’ve gone very much question just about your question that you asked yesterday about trying to pick the 12 links into the last two truths in the rest order. So do you see now after the explanation of the noble truth of the path and of cessation why it would be very difficult? It is extremely difficult. So how would you do it? I would look at this bit of So what’s what’s the problem?
Can you can someone tell me simply what’s the problem in terms of the two truths, the last two truths? Well everything seems to be either the path or cessation and I don’t yeah. Okay, so far so good but that’s not the answer and after that then? If something is a path, it’s not cessation, if something is cessation, it’s not the path. Everything which is a path is impermanent, everything which is cessation is permanent.
Now if you have the 12 limbs in reverse order, right, the cessation of ignorance leads to the cessation of compositional factors leads etc. Cessation of consciousness, name and form, six sources etc. Every single one of these is a cessation which means every single one of these is what? Permanent or impermanent? Permanent.
Cessations are permanent which means the totality of this cessation of the 12 links goes where? Where can it go? Only in the truth of cessation, yes. So there’s no truth of the path left, right? Because truth of the path are consciousnesses and they are impermanent.
So what are you going to do then? It doesn’t fit, right? Yeah. That’s very difficult. But that’s the problem.
There was this It has to fit but it doesn’t fit. So yeah, now you have to analyze. Right? I’m very kind with you. You know how Geshe Yama Rinchen used to teach me?
First, he would say this and then I would go and debate three, four, five days and I’d come back and say, it all fits in the truth of cessation. Me and my classmates, we’ve proven this and then he demonstrate the exact opposite, you know, he destroy all our assertions, he go out, I say, I say what is it? Go go go go go. Then I come back after weeks and obviously I’d finally proved my teacher’s position, you know. And I come back and he did do this again.
And this is how we were taught. And that’s how you learn, right? So find your own answers. Cessation of name and form. What is meant by the cessation of six loci?
Well, that’s a good question. Cessations, cessation mean that something stops but it doesn’t just stop contingently. It stops once and for all to never resume again. Then I was going to mention this and before we stop, I would like to do this. If you’re going to meditate on the four noble truths, the best way to meditate on them after doing the basic work which was taught during this weekend is to meditate on the 16 wrong engagements which I translated on pages five and six of your handouts and this is extraordinarily helpful for the mind.
So the 16 wrong engagements of the noble truth of suffering is to see the contaminated aggregates as clean, happy, permanent and endowed with the self. This is a natural position especially for Westerners, right? If we take our body, which is a contaminated aggregate, we certainly view our bodies as clean, right? I mean, and to try to forget how unclean they are, we wash if anything obsessively. Then we have the wrong engagements of the noble truth of the origin of suffering and the wrong engagement of the noble truth of cessation.
And that answers Richard’s question because these wrong engagements of the noble truth of cessation, they give us a sense of what a cessation is. A cessation is not non existent. It’s not a cessation or liberation from just some features. It’s not a cessation liberation from just some features of suffering. And importantly, it’s not a cessation in which although suffering ceases for a while, it eventually resumes.
Now when his holiness teaches the four noble truths, his approach is to emphasize the analysis of these 16 wrong engagements and to encourage us to ask the question, does such a liberation exist? It’s not self evident at all. The immediate reaction is to say no. I mean the cessation of an affliction like anger, if by cessation you mean something temporary, everyone would agree but that is not a cessation from the Buddhist standpoint. To actually abandon anger or cease anger means that anger never ever again arises if you were to continue reincarnating during millions of lives, whatever the conditions.
Is such a thing possible? For that reason it is said to be a permanent phenomenon. So the biggest obstacle from his holiness standpoint to a practice based on the four noble truths is not believing that cessation are possible. There’s a big doubt in my mind for a very long time. Once you believe they are possible, a true cessation, a true abandonment, then the rest is quite straightforward.
But is such a thing possible? Because we’re not talking of making the afflictions non manifest through calm abiding, you know, for a very very long period of time. We’re talking of a means of eradicating them from the root so they never manifest ever again. And the close analysis of cessation clearly demonstrates that the only way to achieve it is by applying an antidote which is directly opposite to the root of the afflictions. That’s why what Susan was mentioning yesterday, those people who thought that through focusing on the eighth limb of craving it was possible to put an end to the cycle of the 12 limbs is a very understandable mistake but very much a mistake because it’ll never be possible to achieve a true cessation in that way.
If there is such a thing as a true cessation with liberation, it can only be achieved by uprooting the weed from the roots with all the roots as well. And then the steps are after, we’ll cover this briefly if you don’t mind going over time for five-ten minutes. The way to focus on the four noble truths is after meditating on the noble truth of suffering. The four characteristics of the noble truth of suffering, the four wrong engagements and understanding clearly that we have the noble truth of suffering within our continuum, physical and mental continuum, to then try to demonstrate to one satisfaction that the cause of the noble truth of suffering exists and that this cause is the affliction that is not self evident. A large number of modern westerners would disagree.
A large number of modern westerners consider that for instance desire which is an affliction is not a cause of suffering but a cause of happiness And I remember a big debate with some Muslim gentleman who had assaulted me with a knife actually on a train in India about anger and he was profoundly convinced that anger was a quality and it gave him strength. You know, it took a long time to calm him down. Well, we worked fourteen hours on the train together so I had to be very and I had to sleep, you know. It was not not easy, you know. But you see it is not self evident to believe that the afflictions are a source of suffering.
I think probably if we really believe that desire was a source of suffering, most of us would become ordained. Right? So deep down we don’t believe that. But then it’s not enough to believe that the afflictions are a source of suffering. The big question now is, is there a way to put an end to the noble truth of the origin of suffering or not?
And that’s where you pass to the four characteristics of the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation and the four wrong engagements. The four wrong engagements are very much present within our mind stream. Does liberation exist? We doubt. We think it is non existent.
Is it possible to just to get rid of some of the afflictions but not all? Right? That’s a very common belief. Maybe you might get rid of pride but desire the instinct of survival of the individual, how can you get rid of that, right? Then the most important one is, is it possible to have a true cessation in the Buddhist sense of the term?
In other words, an eradication which is complete, an annihilation of the afflictions. This caused me problems for many years, many many years. Because once you believe that, then the truth of the path is easy, right? It’s pretty self evident. Then you think okay, the only true eradication which is possible is something which addresses the very root of the afflictions.
What is the root of the afflictions? Under analysis, you can quite clearly see it’s a self and other dialectic. It’s very much of Martin Buber called the I right? And Once you start positing I and thou very strongly, both desire and hatred arise. Then I and thou posited strongly, in other words inherently existent from a Buddhist standpoint, they arise from an ignorance.
What ignorance? And then that is where the question, the central question is out of the view. Then all the Buddhist schools disagree. So there you have to study. The Vaibhāṣikas say that this ignorance is one thing, the Sautrantikas say it’s something else, the Chitamatra say it’s something else and the Prasangikas and Svatantika Mādhyamika disagree as well.
It’s not a minor question because if you do not target this ignorance correctly, you will never be able to attain a cessation. So once one is a practitioner of the path of the being of the middling scope, the question of which view is true is the central question. It’s not a question of which view is taught here, which view is dominant in the Geluk tradition, which view is dominant in Tibet or China, but which view is true? True, not just for you, true. For true for you, it’s a beginning.
You start training in that but once you have moved beyond training in that and your question is, you want to gain liberation, You want to eradicate the afflictions in your mind from the root. If you can’t target the root, you can’t eradicate them. And His Holiness once commented, he said, it’s a tragedy that so many great beings in Tibet wasted so much of their life and underwent so much hardship to achieve so little. Because many yogis around Je Tsongkhapa’s time labored under tremendous confusion regarding the view. Now in my own case, I basically believe that Je Tsongkhapa’s presentation of Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika is true with a capital T.
It’s a lot of work which went into that but each one of us must gain that sense themselves. Individuals of each of the various schools of tenets attained liberation based on their view of tenants? Okay, then you have not understood the noble truth of cessation. That’s a typical western relativistic statement, right? So everyone attains liberation on basis of their beliefs.
You see, either there is an objective basis to what we’re doing or there isn’t and if there isn’t, you can practice anything and gain liberation, right? You just have to believe hard enough in it, right? You did also comment before that there’s different trainings for different capacities and different Yes, but in the short term. Right. Like when you go to the gym and you start a training program, you’ll be started with certain weights and a certain diet and that depends on how you’re built at that point.
Then, I mean I don’t know a lot about gyms but I assume at a certain point there’s general agreement about how you train, right? So it’s the same thing here. When you start, you have to find the view which helps you the best. If you look, we’re going very much over time but we’ll cover this and then we have to stop. If you look at the graduated stages of the path, why are they thought they taught?
To help people from the very beginning to Not everyone is at the very beginning. I mean, we have people who are born in this life with renunciation. We have people who have born are born in this life with the realization of impermanence. We have other people who are born in this life with a strong disbelief in past and future lives. So everyone is not starting at the same level, therefore you need a staircase.
Those are the stages of the path. Now, the staircase covers all the possible trainees. People who have nothing, they start at the bottom. Actually, in the case of Lamrim Cemo, it doesn’t go low far down, far enough down. Lamrim Chenmo was written for Tibetans in a society in which everyone naturally believed in past and future lives.
We can’t reach the first rung. No, you can’t. Most westerners don’t believe that the mind is non material. So they’re not, they’re not at the first rung, which is the practice of the being of the small scope. We need to bridge that gap, His Holiness, His Holiness has said he will compose the Lamrim which will bridge that gap.
But all of these stages are given so wherever you are, there is a point you can enter this training and proceed upwards. Now, same thing is true for the view. If for instance, I think which is the case of most westerners, you are profoundly convinced that the world out there really exists, I think probably almost all of us in this room are like that. Then it is not going to work for you to study Chitamatra or Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika. It’s not going to work.
So you must start with a view which meshes with your view and stretches it a bit and that would be the Vaibhāṣika or the Sautrantika view. Most of the westerners like George Dreyfus for instance, he got his Geshe degree, you know, he studied Madhya Mica but in his heart, we were roommates I think I can say that, he’s a Sautrāntika, you know, his PhD was on Sautrantika, you know. He finds that view profoundly congenial to him, you know. It’s a realistic view. By realistic we mean that the ethnoch in the medieval sense of the term.
We mean that the outer world really exists. The two Hīnayāna views are realistic. Most westerners naturally find them easy to take on board. And then we start there and then we integrate that view and when we have grown so much we are uncomfortable with that view, then we see about moving upwards, right? So if we try from the beginning to enter any view which we are not comfortable with, then there’s no hope.
We’ll just pay lip service to it, it’s not going to change the mind. The Vaibhāṣika view can change the mind. Right? But, once you start speaking of attainments, certainly from my personal standpoint, considering that the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view is supreme and there are very good logical reasons for this, it is not possible to attain liberation or full enlightenment with the Vaibhāṣika, the Sautrāntika, the Cittamātra or the Svatantika view, simply because something is left which has existence from its own side. But liberation is far far away.
It doesn’t concern us right now. Right? Liberation is way down there. Full enlightenment is even further. So what concerns us now is starting to train.
Then we start to train, maybe in Vaibhashik, maybe moving up in Sautrāntika, a very good system of training, And then at a certain point, the doubts will start to arise about the exterior world. And then Chitamatra is very powerful. Because Chitamatha, was a big problem in the West with solipsism, right? Once you have understood Chitamatra, then you are ready perhaps to jump up either to Svatāntrika or to Prasanika Mādhyamika. Most of the Geshe’s at Sera, they are very honest about this, they say we teach Prasanika Mādhyamika but it is not our view, we just can’t take it on board, we ask for Svatāntrika Mādhyamika, because she reminded me, he said it’s prasanika view, he said it’s difficult difficult to understand, you know?
Because it’s a view for which there is nothing from the side of the object. And how can there be nothing from the side of the object without us succumbing to total relativism? So do you understand? Please don’t don’t in your practice get the idea that everything is basically one and the same. I had a marvelous professor of Hindu philosophy, professor Rao at the University of Virginia, he’s a marvelous man but he used to drive me up the walls because I would go in his class, I had a class, I had to take a class on Vedanta with you.
It was just it was in the doctoral requirements. And he would look at us with this typically Indian marvelous beaming face, he would say, all is one and all is in the Ātman. You know, it was just, you know, and he considered the Buddhists as crypto Hindus and the Christians as crypto Hindus and the Muslims as crypto Hindus, the true Muslims, everyone was just sort of in this big family, you didn’t want to be part of it but you were inside. So that view is very tempting, a form of syncretism, you know, but it doesn’t lead anyway. Then I think we really have to stop for today.
My apologies, we’re half an hour late but I thought it was interesting to cover these things. Thank you very much. So the dedication on page 10 in English, eight a to 12. As in missing the man Should we do Ilya, should we do a mandala? Should we do a mandala?
No. Yeah. So just eight a and then nine on. I dedicate whatever virtue I have ever collected for the benefit of the teachings and of all sentient beings, for the essential teachings of venerable Losang Dragpa to shine forever. O holy and venerable Lama, from the clouds of compassion, you are the source of all happiness and bliss.
O powerful Chenrezig Tenzin Gyatso, please remain until the end of existence. Should the situation arise where the supreme precious teachings no longer pervade, should they degenerate, then through the mind being moved by great compassion, may the treasure of benefit and happiness be revealed. May the jewel of supreme bodhichitta, which has not arisen, arise, and may it never diminish but increase more and more. May all father and mother sentient beings be happy and successful. May all the abodes of evil migration always be empty.
May all the prayers of all bodhisattvas, whoever they are and wherever they reside, be quickly accomplished.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- inner fire tummo (Tib)
- The energy residing at the navel chakra, aroused during the completion stage of Highest Yoga Tantra, and used to bring the energy winds into the central channel. It is also called inner or psychic heat. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Did followers of each of the different tenet schools attain liberation through their own view?
No. Saying everyone attains liberation on the basis of their beliefs is a typical western relativistic statement, and it means the noble truth of cessation has not been understood. Either there is an objective basis to the path or there isn't. From the Prāsaṇgika standpoint, liberation or full enlightenment cannot be attained with the Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra or Svatantika view, because something is still left that exists from its own side. The lower views still matter for starting training. People begin with a view that suits them and stretches it, like the realistic Vaibhāṣika or Sautrāntika, and move upward when that view becomes uncomfortable.