1 h 54 min · 6,228 words · 31 March 2013
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk opens with generating bodhichitta motivation, drawing on the kindness of mothers, the Buddha’s unique capacity, the Six Perfections, and how to train the mind in concentration and virtue. It then surveys the Buddhist tenet systems from Vaibhashika and Sautrantika through Chittamatra, contrasting their views of selflessness of persons and phenomena with Madhyamaka. It closes by saying the afternoon will cover Svatantrika and Prasangika Madhyamaka.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 54m
UUID: e61e01af-d6dd-47e1-8c49-c37739b46e14
Date: 2013-03-31
Words: 6,224
So regarding the generation of the motivation, we should today generate the motivation to attain the state of full enlightenment for the sake and for the benefit of all mother sentient beings. Whatever virtue we are able to practice, we should practice for the sake of all beings. We must understand that every single sentient being without exception has been our mother. There is not a single sentient being who has not been our mother. This is something we are not aware of at present.
Whenever a sentient being has been our mother in the past, he or she has extended to us the very self same kindness as our mother in this life. Everything we know in this life, how we how to walk, how to eat, how to speak, we have learned through the kindness of our mother in this life. Likewise, our mothers in previous lives have done the same. They have given us food when we were hungry, water when we were thirsty, clothes when we were cold. It is probable that without the kindness of one’s mother, we would not have survived the period extending from the moment of conception within our mother’s womb all the way up to the period a couple years after birth.
It does occur indeed for difficult situations to arise between mothers and children in this life. However, Geshela feels it has almost never been the case that a mother has been unkind to her child from the moment of conception onwards. If one’s mother is of a somewhat choleric nature or short-tempered, it can happen that when her viewpoint in that of her child differ, there may be disagreement. It is therefore extremely important when one has grown up to set aside whatever difficulties there may have been between oneself and one’s mother and to recollect exclusively the kindness one’s mother showed to us where we were in her womb. We do see at CERA people asking asking numerous questions on how to train in recollecting the kindness of the mother and repaying her kindness when there have been a lot of difficulties with one’s mother in this life.
I have always answered to these questions that the period ranging from the moment of conception in one’s mother’s womb through pregnancy during which she is careful about what she eats and she is careful to take care of her child all the way to delivery and the first few years after birth are probably for most of us periods in which we are the recipient exclusively of maternal love and care. And this is what one should recollect. Then as the child grows up because of the afflictions in the mind of the mother and the afflictions in the mind of the child, it does occur for a strong disagreement to arise between mother and child. And I believe that apart from the occurrence of occasional disagreement with one’s mother due to afflictions both in the mind of the mother and the child, the nature of the relationship between mother and child would be a true loving relationship. It would be completely inappropriate even in the case of such difficulties to see one’s own mother as one’s enemy.
Instead, it is the afflictions within the mind of one’s own mother which are to be seen as one’s enemy and was one must find means to pacify one’s mother’s mind. And then thinking in this way, we will have the opportunity to extend the reflections regarding the benevolence our mother has extended to us with her love to all sentient beings who were our mothers in the past. And then if we reflect on the great sufferings, these mothers of past lives, mother sentient beings experience within cyclic existence and nonetheless we wish to gain freedom from cyclic existence for our own sake alone, this would be a source of great shame and would be miserable behavior. Even from a worldly standpoint, we call the behavior of someone who even though his mother has fallen in a pit of misery runs around having fun and laughing with friends, vile and despicable behavior, don’t we? And therefore, we should not think only of ourselves and of our own happiness.
Instead, we should think of the happiness of all beings which surround us. And we should therefore train both in a love which wishes all beings to have happiness and in a compassion which wishes all beings to be free from suffering. And then if we reflect whether we have at present the capacity to lead beings to such a state, we clearly do not. Let alone ourselves not having this capacity, both the hearers and the solitary realizers who have abandoned all afflictions do not have this capacity either. And for that matter, even though Bodhisattvas accomplish the benefit of numerous sentient beings, they by no means accomplish the benefit of all sentient beings.
So they too lack this capacity. And the only being which has the capacity to accomplish the benefit of all beings from the smallest of insects onwards is the Buddha himself. May Buddha’s body, speech, and mind solely accomplish the benefit of beings. For that matter, every single beam of light which emanates from the Buddha’s body accomplishes the welfare of countless sentient beings. Buddha is alone in having the capacity to accomplish the welfare of every single sentient being without exception.
And therefore, to accomplish the welfare of every single sentient being completely, we must initially attain the state of a Buddha. And even though the state of full enlightenment is somewhat distant at present, nonetheless, if we practice the path, then the state of full enlightenment will become closer and closer, won’t it? For that matter, if one relies correctly on the path of secret mantra and puts great effort in addition to being fortunate, then one can attain full enlightenment in this very life. However, even if this is impossible through relying on secret mantra in the next life or future lives, one will definitely attain full enlightenment. The reason for this is that every single one of us has in his mind the Buddha type or the Buddha nature.
And what this means is that the afflictions are adventitious or secondary within our minds. They do not penetrate into the actual nature of the mind and therefore, they can be separated from the mind. To give you an example, silt does not actually penetrate into the very nature of water. As a result, water can be purified. And at the end of the purification process, we are left with pure water.
Likewise, the mind can be freed of the afflictions. Then there is no other means to eliminate these afflictions than the deeds of the Buddhas. And if from our sides, the very depths of our heart, we put effort, there is no doubt we will attain such a state of full enlightenment. And even though one does not attain the state of full enlightenment quickly, one should nonetheless not let one’s enthusiasm and perseverance flag. If one compares the practice of generosity by Bodhisattvas with one’s own practice of generosity, it is like comparing space and earth.
Bodhisattvas, for instance, when they practice generosity, let alone not giving all let alone giving all their possessions, are ready for that matter to give their bodies without any cupidity. Bodhisattvas, some bodhisattvas are ready to give their hands or their limbs for the sake of other sentient beings if there is necessity. To give you an example, it is said that Āryadeva gave one of his eyes to another living being. Because he had trained well in generosity, he had no difficulty in offering a part of his body to others. For instance, there was a man close to Sera whose kidneys were deficient.
And when he heard about this, one Sera Je monk donated one of his kidneys. And that monk experienced no particular mental difficulty in donating his kidney. On the other hand, for ourselves, we can see in India that when we give money to the beggars, we give them 1 or 2 rupees and then say, please go away. And it is because of this powerful cupidity within our mind that we cling to our possessions and to our belongings and do not give them to others.
And then if we practice in this way, not practicing generosity correctly, we will experience hardship in future lives. And then if we practice generosity correctly in future lives, we will experience great material prosperity. For that matter, in this very life, we will experience material prosperity. And therefore, this is a little bit odd really because the more we practice generosity and the more we give away, the more we shall receive. The more stingy and greedy we are and the more we cling to our possessions, the less we shall receive.
Likewise, regarding the practice of ethics by bodhisattvas, bodhisattvas engage in ethics not only when they are awake, but for that matter even when they are asleep in the dream state. And then in our own case, let alone behaving immorally and unethically in our dreams, when we awake from our dreams, our immoral and unethical behavior is as extensive as rain falling. Likewise, regarding forbearance, even should someone attack a bodhisattva and try to tear his flesh to pieces or to break his bones, there would be no anger in the mind of the Bodhisattva, merely forbearance and patience. However, when this happens to him, would reflect that as a result of this anger, the other party would be reborn in the lower realms during future lives and great waves of compassion would overwhelm him. In our own cases, forget practicing forbearance in these extreme situations.
A blow to the head is sufficient to inflame our anger. Even for that matter, if just as someone were to pinch us with a needle, somebody else were to jokingly make a somewhat sharp comment, our anger would immediately be inflamed. And therefore, it is very difficult for us to practice authentically generosity, ethics, forbearance And therefore, it is most important at present to train in generosity, in ethics and in forbearance as much as one can. Please enhance your practice in these as much as possible. The more we train in these practices, the closer we come to full enlightenment.
It is really content contingent on the intensity of our practice how close we come to full enlightenment. And therefore, we should take the firm pledge to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. And then we should practice with this as a goal, compassion and love as well as engage in the practices of generosity, of ethics and so forth. Therefore, please today generate the motivation. May these words roots of virtue which I have accumulated lead to my attaining full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.
And therefore, reflecting carefully on the object and the aspect of bodhichitta, let us meditate well on bodhichitta. This concentration is the capacity to focus our mind single pointedly on an object. If we train in concentration day after day, week after week, year after year, this capacity to focus the mind single pointedly will increase. And if we train specifically in what is known as meditation, in other words, capacity to focus the mind single pointedly, then our minds will enhance indefinitely. It is definite that our minds can be increased in whichever quality we reach wish to enhance in them, such as goodness, kindness, and so forth.
Since the foundation of this enhancement of concentration is the clear and cognitive nature of the mind, concentration can be enhanced indefinitely in the same way as clarity and cognitiveness can be enhanced indefinitely. Since the practice of concentration is rooted in this factor of clarity and cognitiveness of the mind, there is no being who cannot train in concentration. Since the basis of concentration is that component of clarity and cognitive cognitiveness then in the same way as concentration can be enhanced likewise that which it is based upon which is clarity and cognitiveness can also be enhanced leading this eventually to the attainment of omniscience or knowingness. For this to happen, the foundation of concentration which is that clarity and cognitive nature of the mind must be stable. Otherwise, if they are not stable, such as for instance the warmth of water, then this will not happen.
So with warm water, as we keep on heating the water or the temperature of the water increases, the amount of water being heated decreases through evaporation and eventually disappears. Therefore, the base on which heat is applied is unstable. This is not the case with the mind. Then check this for yourself. If you put water on a boil over a fire for three or four hours, it will probably all evaporate, and what you will be left with will be a damaged pot.
And therefore, since the basis, in other words, water to which heat is applied is not stable, it is impossible to apply continuously heat to water. However, if we ourselves train in concentration, then the capacities of concentration of such a person increase continually. Eventually, through the force of habit in concentration, we will no need no longer need to put effort in initiating concentration. It will start to the force of habit. It is possible for this enhancement to occur even without effort.
Louis, so for instance, a jumper. And we can see this clearly in the example of a jumper. Someone who trains in long distance jumping will be able to reach a certain maximum jump in function of his training. Then after that, irrespective of how much he trains, he cannot jump further than this. For instance, if through a training program we reach a point where we can jump 10 full feet, Then having jumped those 10 feet, it is impossible for us to jump any further from that point onwards without a new effort.
However, in the case of concentration, concentration increases in function of the initial impetus of effort. And there is no need after this for additional effort as in the example of jumping. In the case of virtuous states of mind such as kindness and compassion, after the initial effort has occurred through the force of habituation, they can increase indefinitely. If we take the case of desire, this is very clear. If we desire an object or a person and we do not apply the antidote to this desire but give the desire free rein, it can increase infinitely, can’t it?
For instance, if we have desire for a person and we give this desire free rein and it increases infinitely at a certain point, desirousness will be so great we might desire the possessions of all beings. Likewise, if we have desire for a being and we allow this desire to become boundless or infinite, then we will experience extraordinary mental suffering and turbulence as a result of this. You should all have direct experience of how letting desires have a free rein and become very powerful is harmful to yourself. Likewise, with concentration through the force of arbitration, one’s capacity to concentrate on an object of observation with a strong factor of stability can increase infinitely. And therefore, it is important to enhance however much concentration we naturally have as much as we can and to cause whatever desire and anger are present in our mind to abate as much as possible through applying the antidotes.
Let alone a concentration, it is all of the roots of virtue which we should foster within our mind. And if we train in the virtues, then through the process of habituation, they will develop indefinitely. If we take the example of compassion, the wish to free sentient beings of suffering, for someone who has trained in compassion, compassion, it arises spontaneously and increases through the force of habit without any effort. For someone who has not trained in compassion, even when they put effort at generating compassion, it often does not arise at all. Therefore, we must train initially with great effort to give rise to compassion within our mind stream and after training with great effort, eventually even with a very small amount of effort, compassion will arise.
And training in this way over and again with effort to give rise to compassion eventually with very little effort, compassion will almost spontaneously arise. Then when it arises spontaneously, this is uncontrived compassion. Likewise for bodhichitta. For beginners, one must put tremendous effort for a bodhichitta to arise. And then over and again through putting great effort, one becomes accustomed to generating bodhichitta.
It arises with less and less effort and eventually it will arise spontaneously. It will have become uncontrived bodhichitta. And then when finally after putting effort over a long period of time, bodhichitta arises spontaneously without the slightest effort in a stable and durable fashion, such a being in whose mind it arises can be counted as a Mahāyāna being. And we have all generated the bodhichitta through effort during these teachings. It is entirely at present up to our own effort whether eventually bodhichitta arises spontaneously or not within our minds.
When it does and we are sure of that, we will have become great vehicle practitioners. Then when this bodhichitta arises spontaneously, we can be given the famous name of bodhisattvas. Then it is entirely in our hands where the bodhichitta arises or not. Likewise, it’s entirely up to us whether we become Buddhas or not. However, if all we think about is the happiness of this life and we crave for it, it is difficult to become a bodhisattva or a buddha.
Since most of us in this room are no longer quite young, it might be wise to stop thinking about this life. These are the main reasons for starting to think seriously about future lives. We should look at our maximum lifespan. Very few if any of us will live beyond 100. Then however old we may be at present, we should estimate how many years are left to us and ask ourselves what exactly we plan on doing during these remaining years.
There may not be a lot of time left for most of us, and that time must be spent well if we want this human life to count as a meaningful human life. If I take my own case, I am past my 40 year of age. If I have the ambition to live until 80, then I have thirty five years left to year to live. Thirty five years passed really quickly. Then it is a given that we will transmigrate to a future life even though the scientists aren’t quite sure of this one.
Then without dedicating too much thought to this life, we should start thinking seriously about future lives. And then as a side effect, this life will benefit. It’s very difficult to be happy in this life if your main focus is on the happiness of this life. The reason for this is very simple because if you really want to be happy in this life, it passes through the unhappiness of others. You deceive others.
You lie others. You inflict violence on others. And then since the happiness of this life passes largely through non virtuous deeds, forget future lives, even this life will not go well. And therefore, it is extremely important to enhance as much as one can whatever virtuous thoughts one has. Just as with the training in calm abiding, we must progress incrementally through each of the nine mental abidings and after the ninth mental abiding, we will eventually attain calm abiding.
And then when we have attained calm abiding, whenever we place our mind on an object, an extraordinary sense of ease and happiness will arise both in our bodies and minds. However, merely through placing our mind single pointedly on an object, it is very difficult to attain liberation or full enlightenment. Therefore, it is within the setting or the context of calm abiding that we should train in wisdom, in other words, in insight. It is wisdom which analyzes self grasping and specifically the conceived object of self grasping and understanding that it does not exist applies its antidote. And when this antidote, which is the wisdom realizing selflessness arises through careful analysis of its object of refutation, then at this point, an uncommon bliss which is the bliss of insight realizing selflessness will have arisen within our minds.
And as the power of this wisdom realizing selflessness increases ever more, in turn, the potency of the ignorance of self grasping decreases ever more just as as the intensity of the light of a lamp increases, darkness fades. Since the root of suffering is the afflictions and the root of the afflictions is the ignorance of self grasping, once we eliminate the ignorance of self grasping, we have eliminated the afflictions and not the slightest trace of suffering will arise. And therefore, effects arise principally independent on whatever their cause is. If we want to eliminate an unfortunate or harmful effect, we must eliminate its cause. Then to give you an example, if you wish to use a good field intelligently and the field is covered in weeds and so forth, before you sow the seeds to have a crop, you do want to get rid of the weeds, don’t you?
Those of us who were raised on farms have first hand experience of this one. And I’m a farm boy, so I have some experience in this. Then the nomads don’t really understand a lot about this. And therefore on the basis of calm abiding, one must give rise to insight. Now there are various types of insight.
The insight we need is the insight realizing selflessness. While the non Buddhist practitioners do give rise to calm abiding and independence on calm abiding give rise to insight, the insight they train in is not an insight which realizes selflessness or emptiness. The insight which we need is an insight which is superior to calm abiding. The term insight in Tibet is means superior, superior sight. And the selflessness which we must realize is a selflessness in keeping with the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view.
Generally speaking, there are multiple types of coarse and subtle selflessness. Then we can posit the selflessnesses of the schools of thought from the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika school downwards as coarse selflessnesses and the selflessness of the Prāsaṇgika school of thought as subtle selflessness. Now clearly, this is not the viewpoint of the lower schools of tenets. The Vaibhāṣikas, for instance, consider that there is no selflessness more subtle than the one which they themselves accept. Then it is clear that every school of tenets considers its own presentation of selflessness as peerless and unequaled and considers that it is the only school which follows the middle way without falling into either the extreme of eternalism or of nihilism.
And even though the Vaibhāṣika system of thought has numerous faults, the Vaibhāṣikas do not see them. This is no problem. We all know that we are totally blind to our own thoughts and that the person who says I am not a good person is rare indeed. The selflessness which is taught in the Vaibhāṣika school is the selflessness of persons. The two lowest schools of tenets, the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika, both accept a self of phenomena.
Neither accepts a self of persons. It is the two lower schools of tenets, the Hīnayāna schools of tenets which assert the existence of a self of phenomena. None of the two higher schools of tenets assert the existence of a self of phenomena. They assert both the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. The Vaibhāṣika’s system of tenets are broadly speaking subdivided into four.
And this fourfold subdivision of the Vaibhāṣika School arises from the fact that they consider that one of the root texts which they rely upon, the Prātimokṣa sūtra was taught in different languages. Some assert it was taught in Sanskrit. Some assert it was taught in Pali. Some assert it was taught in a language of the East Of India. And as a result of this, they have ended up with slightly diverging tenets.
And these four schools of Baibashika tenants are further subdivided in the sub schools, each of the schools sub schools having slightly different assertions and we end up with 18 different sub Then apart from the fact that they disagree on minor topics such as the language in which the Prātimokṣa sūtra was taught and small issues of tenets, Geshe-la has never heard that they fought with each other. Apart from these distinctions of tenets between the four main schools and the 18 sub schools, there was no major disagreement between the schools and no difficulties. Originally in India, there were numerous different religious systems or systems of thought, but there seems to have been basically no tension between them. It is later on in Indian history that due to the increase of prejudice, bias, and partiality such tensions arose. What is important for us is to practice in accordance with the teachings which we accept.
However, to impose our views on others or fight with them is of no benefit either for them nor for us. If two sincere religious practitioners, Buddhist and one Christian coexist in the same society and they practice in this way, let alone not harming each other, their own practice will lead them to help each other. This is most important. This is why I mentioned it to you. Within these 18 systems of thought, there is one uncommon one, the so called Vatsiputriya system of thought.
These are Vaibhāṣikas who assert the existence of a self of persons. And therefore since they assert the existence of a self of persons from the standpoint of tenets, they cannot be said to be Buddhists. Yes. Persons.
Persons. One school, the school, one subschool. Then the remaining 17 schools all assert a selflessness of persons and don’t affirm the existence of a self of persons. Moreover, the two lower schools within the four schools of tenets, the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika, both assert the existence of exterior objects. The reason for which the Vaibhāṣika, excuse me, and the Sautrāntika School assert the existence of exterior phenomena is because they assert the existence of ultimate particles which constitute phenomena for instance, Geshe-la’s cup.
If one examines it very carefully, eventually one will reach these ultimate particles of substance. So these schools of tenets, Levi Bashikas in the Sultratikas assert that objects of sight such as cuts, sounds, and so forth are all constituted of ultimately smallest particles, you would say perhaps atoms or quarks, and that when these concatenate, eventually they constitute the object. And they therefore assert the existence of exterior phenomena, phenomena exterior to consciousness because if we take the case of a coarse bulky object like Geshela’s cup, they assert that this cup exists independently of the consciousness perceiving it since there are ultimate constituents of the cup which can be eventually discovered. And they assert that these particles, these ultimate particles have no directional components. In other words, these particles don’t have a northern, eastern, southern, and western side.
This tenet system has many faults. So the problem arises under analysis. If we take for instance the particles which constitute the bell Geshela is holding and if in keeping with these two lower schools of tenets, we assert that these particles have no directional parts, so there is not a northern, eastern, southern, or western direction to these particles, then an opponent would say, well, look, are these particles touching each other or not? The problem is if they assert that they touch each other then there is one point where they touch each other and there’s another point where they don’t touch each other. Therefore, of the particles has parts which is counter their root assertion.
On the other hand, if they assert that they don’t touch each other then either they are on top of each other in which case the cup collapses and becomes tiny or it is difficult to see how they interact at all. Then I will re explain this. So if you take Geshela’s bell in the center and the watch, the cup, the porcelain cup and the cover of the cup surrounding it and imagine they are particles, then either they are touching the cup or not. If they are touching the cup, one one has to ask is there a point where they are touching the cup or not. Obviously, is such a point.
If there is such a point, the bell can be said to be subdivided into four. Then on the other hand, if we say that the point of contact of the watch with the cup and the point of contact of the porcelain cup with the bell are the same, that means that they are all in the same place. Then if on the other hand, they are all on top of each other, all these particles are on top of each other, then frankly, the bell tends to cease to exist and the speech of these vaibashikas is deceitful speech. Then, obviously, they cannot assert that there is contact between the particles which constitute the bell. But the question is in how does the whole thing hang together?
And what they assert is that each of the particles of the bell is separated from another particle of the bell by an atom of air, a particle of air. They ask the question or an opponent should I say, ask the question, so what precisely happens when you hit the bell with a staff? Is there contact between the particles of the staff and the particles of the bell or not? Then the Vaibhāṣikas have to say that there is no contact between the particles of the bell and the particles of the staff because otherwise the particle of the bell would have parts. So then the opponent says, how precisely when you hit the bell does the sound arise?
And the Vaibashikas have to answer, it is because of the atoms of air. Then the third school of tenets, the first Mahāyāna school of tenets, Chitamatra school, the mind only school, counters powerfully this Vaibhāṣika position by saying that there are no exterior phenomena. There are no phenomena exterior to the mind. And this absence of phenomena exterior to the mind is subtle selflessness. Please.
Please, if you could give her the microphone, the lady behind you. I’m just curious to know, if it is too subtle a point, why do they say or what is it why is it important to them that there is no north, south and east north, south, west and east of a particle? Particle. Why is this important? The reason for which it is important is that it’s actually a core assertion of the Vaibhāṣika system that these subtle most particles are partless.
And the reason for which it is extremely important that they be partless for the Vaibhāṣikas and the Sautrantikas is because if they are partless, one can speak of a self of phenomena. They cannot be broken up any further. But if they have directions, north, south, east, west, there can be contact on these points of directions, then one cannot say that they are partless and then one cannot speak of a self of phenomena. Because when we speak of a self of phenomena, what we are speaking about is the existence of phenomena which do not depend on anything else. They do not depend on their parts.
They do not depend on the perception of them and so forth. So clearly, if such phenomena do not depend on their parts, they cannot have parts and they specifically cannot have directional parts, an eastern, northern, southern, western part. If there are no such phenomena, then clearly we can speak of a selflessness of phenomena. Then precisely because the Vaishikas accept the existence of a set of phenomena, they face this major problem with their so called ultimate particles. Then the Vaibhāṣikas accept the selflessness of persons.
However, they accept a selflessness of persons because they consider that the person exists only in dependence on its basis of imputation which are the aggregates of a person. If they were to accept a self of persons, they would have to assert a person which exists independently of the aggregates which are its basis of imputation and they don’t assert such a self of persons. For instance, if we take the example of someone given the Tibetan name of Kashi, then Kashi does not exist independently of his aggregates. Form, feeling, recognition, compositional factors and consciousness. Kashi is an imputation on the basis of his aggregates.
This means that Kashi lacks a self of persons. If there was a Kashi which could be isolated from his aggregates, separate from his aggregates, then Kashi would actually be a self of persons. All these schools of tenants from Vaibhāṣika to Krasangika all assert without exception that persons exist independent on their aggregates. Then in that respect, there is no fault in the Vaibhāṣika assertions regarding selflessness. But they cannot present a subtle view of selflessness in keeping with Mādhyamika.
Then apart from some minor differences in the views of the two lower schools of tenets, Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika, the body of their view is similar. The differences are those such as the assertions by the Vaibhāṣikas that all objects of knowledge are things whereas for the Sautrantikas, all objects of knowledge are not things. Only impermanent phenomena are things. Permanent phenomena are not things. Then the Sautrantika view is slightly superior to the Vaibhāṣika view.
Specifically, the presentation of the two truths, conventional and ultimate truths is somewhat better within Sautrāntika than within Vaibhāṣika. Which school? The school considers phenomena which do not change instant by instant to be permanent phenomena. So this would include for instance space which does not change instant by instant. The Vaibhāṣika School does not consider that all things are necessarily impermanent unlike the Sartantika School.
The Vaibhāṣika School considers that things have both permanent and impermanent phenomena within them. The Sautrantika School, on the other hand, considers that things and impermanent phenomena are synonymous while permanent phenomena are not things, but they still are phenomena. And they consider that impermanent phenomena are phenomena which change instant by instant continuously whereas permanent phenomena are phenomena which do not change instant by instant, which do not change continually. Does that answer your question? So generally speaking, as far as the presentation of selflessness is concerned, there’s no big difference between the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrantika school neither accepts the selflessness of phenomena.
The following system of tenet, the third system of tenet is the Chitamatra school, the mind only school, the first Mahāyāna school. The Chitamatra school rejects the assertion of the Sautranticas and the Vaibhāṣikas that there are exterior phenomena and therefore that there is a self of phenomena. And they do this by saying that there are no such things as ultimate particles. Therefore, there is no self of phenomena. And therefore, the mind only school rejecting the viewpoint of the Vaibhāṣikas and the Sautrantikas that there are ultimate particles asserts the non exterior existence of phenomena and this is the subtle selflessness of phenomena.
Since the Chitamatra School asserts that such exterior phenomena as are asserted by the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautratika school do not exist in the slightest, this assertion is the uncommon feature of the Chitamatra school. Then the Mind Only School asserts the non exterior existence of form as a phenomenon to be the subtle selflessness of phenomena of that form. And identify that non exterior existence of form as the subtle selflessness of phenomena of that form. And therefore, the Chitamatra school through refuting the existence of exterior objects asserted by the schools of the hearers of the Shravakas posit a subtle selflessness of phenomena. Nonetheless, they assert that form and so forth are truly existent.
For this reason, it is considered a system of thought inferior to the Mādhyamika. Then this afternoon, I shall explain what the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika system, which is superior to the Chitamatra system is, and what the Prāsaṇgika system which does not accept true existence is as well. If you reflect carefully about it, an understanding of the presentation of selflessness in each system of tenets is extremely important. Then if we understand this, there’s no difficulty in being freed from the suffering of cyclic existence. Then if Geshela talks a lot about suffering, there’s a big risk we will suffer mentally as well.
Since this afternoon is our last session for these teachings, Geshela is not going to say a single word about suffering this afternoon. He’s only going to speak of the supreme view of Mādhyamika. We will stop here for today.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Why is it important to the Vaibhāṣikas that subtle particles have no north, south, east or west sides?
Partless subtle particles are a core assertion of the Vaibhāṣika system. For the Vaibhāṣikas and Sautrantikas, being partless means the particles cannot be broken up further, so one can speak of a self of phenomena. A self of phenomena means phenomena that do not depend on anything else, such as their parts or the perception of them. If particles had directional parts, with contact at those points, they would not be partless, and one could not speak of a self of phenomena. Because these schools accept such a self of phenomena, they face a major problem with their so-called ultimate particles.