Calm Abiding – 2013-03-29 – KR

2 h 4 min · 6,713 words · 29 March 2013

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding - 2013-03-29 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk opens a three-day teaching on calm abiding, explaining why it is essential for both sutra and tantra. It covers six prerequisites, including a suitable place, few desires, contentment, pure ethics and abandoning tumult. It then turns to the five faults, the four antidotes to laziness, and holding one object steadily in memory, with sinking and agitation noted. Student questions follow.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 2h 5m

UUID: 34ab522a-3ec7-4c9b-9ab7-f7a4dee52872

Date: 2013-03-29

Words: 6,709

So from today onwards, for three days, I will explain how to train in calm abiding. Calm abiding is extraordinarily important. The reason for which it’s extraordinarily important is that irrespective of whether one is practicing sūtra or tantra, without calm abiding there are no attainments. There is no way to gain definite ascertainment without calm abiding. In addition to being of benefit for the practice of both sūtra and tantra, the training in calm abiding is also of benefit in the short term to subdue mental suffering.

Constantly scattered outwards by mental conceptions which give rise in turn to suffering. It is this suffering which can be subdued by calm abiding. And we can see for ourselves that even though we are able to focus on virtuous deeds, we are able to do so for seconds, seldom for minutes or longer since our mind is constantly scattered outwards. A mind may be compared to a firefly which is carried around by the wind and never settles anywhere. This is also how our mind functions.

However, if we train our mind in calm abiding, it will be able to stay in an extremely solid and fixed fashion on its object. So we will see further some explanations of the great importance of calm abiding. And since we’re engaging in such practices, a sound motivation is extremely important for the next three days. We will try to generate the motivation to be of benefit to other beings in a durable fashion. So before benefiting other beings, we first must achieve our own aims and our own goals.

Because if we do not fulfill our own purposes, we will be unable to fulfill those of others. And therefore, with the motivation of placing all sentient beings in a state of unalloyed and stable happiness, we ourselves must set as our own goal, the goal of attaining full enlightenment for that sake. And therefore, we should generate the motivation for the following three days that the roots of virtue which we accrue during these teachings be all dedicated to this goal of attaining full enlightenment. And therefore, for the sake of leading all sentient beings out of suffering to a state of full and utter happiness, taking this as our main goal, we shall now meditate for one minute on trying to attain full enlightenment with this as our goal in mind. Most if one wishes to explain common common abiding, most probably the best way to divide the outline is into six.

The first of these subdivisions, if one wishes to attain calm abiding, is what prerequisites are necessary to do so. The second outline is the actual means of realizing calm abiding. The third outline is in dependence on that, the means of realizing the nine mental abidings. Then the following outline is how to do so independence on the six forces. And after this, the outline which presents how to obtain the nine mental abidings in terms of the four mental engagements.

So calm abiding is of the nature of concentration or Samādhi and concentration is a mental factor which allows the mind to remain single pointedly on its object of observation. So calm abiding has the feature of being a shared or a common practice to both Buddhists and non Buddhists. In the case of the non Buddhists, calm abiding is practiced as a gateway to the attainment of the formless dhyanas. However, in our cases, we engage in the practice of calm abiding motivated by a renunciation which wishes to escape from cyclic existence and by a mind wishing for higher rebirth in future lives. Without calm abiding irrespective of whether we practice the Suthrayana or the Tantrayāna, we will not be able to practice effectively.

Just as if we wish to pour water, we must pour it in a container which can receive it and hold it. Likewise, we need calm abiding as the container for both the sūtra and the Tantrayāna. And therefore, it is extremely important at the beginning to obtain a calm abiding which focuses the mind stably on its object of observation. The foundation of cyclic existence or the root of cyclic existence is the ignorance which grasps at a self. And the antidote to that ignorance which grasps at a self is the insight which realizes selflessness.

However, that insight realizing selflessness must itself be rooted in a calm abiding focused on selflessness. Otherwise, it cannot arise. To be able to investigate clearly and powerfully selflessness, we initially need a mind which abides stably on selflessness. Like a painting on the wall, we need in addition to a lamp to observe this fresco which is clear that the lamp not flicker and that the light be stable. Having calm abiding, we will be able to swiftly gain realizations of both the precious human rebirth of leisure endowment and of death and impermanence.

So even though there are these side benefits from the attainment of calm abiding, Nonetheless, its main benefit was clearly indicated by Śāntideva when he said, since an insight which is endowed with calm abiding is able to destroy the afflictions initially strive at obtaining calm abiding. There is no definite sequence in whether one should train initially in calm abiding before obtaining bodhichitta or whether one should obtain bodhichitta first and then train in calm abiding. It is up to oneself. However, once we have obtained calm abiding, whichever of the three paths we train in, we will be able to train in with uncommon efficacy and potency. And therefore, it is extremely important to train in calm abiding, and I will try to explain it in as clear a way as possible so you can understand with no difficulty.

So from my side, I hope to be able to explain calm abiding as clearly as possible. And from your sides I hope that you will not only be able to understand the explanation but that you will actually put it in practice and become those who have gained calm abiding. And to do this, it is important to understand what is necessary as a prerequisite for abiding, what is necessary during the actual session on calm abiding, and what is necessary at the end of the session. This is how one should proceed. So initially, since numerous prerequisites or preconditions are necessary to obtain calm abiding.

I shall explain these six prerequisites. So I explained these to you in a concise fashion during the teachings on Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama, but at present, we shall do so in an extensive fashion since we have the time. Then Geshela feels that it would be of the greatest benefit if during his explanations but please, only occasionally when you have serious doubts, you should raise your hands and ask the questions which disturb you. If there’s something you do not understand, do address it. This is the Shastra system of teaching in which as soon as the student has a doubt on the topic, he immediately asks the question.

Otherwise, if one waits, one forgets the question or never asks it. Then if you have good memories, it is a different matter altogether, and you can wait until later to ask your questions. Then if what Geshela thinks is meaningful and purposeful, you find meaningless and purposeless. Or if what he thinks is meaningless and purposeless but you find it meaningful and purposeful, please ask your question immediately so that we can progress. So I shall at present explain the six favorable conditions which are the indispensable preliminary for attaining calm abiding.

So initially, I will explain the meaning of a harmonious place in which to train in calm abiding, and such a harmonious place has five qualities. So the first characteristic of such a location is that it is easy to gain one’s livelihood there. It is easy to to get what is needed to survive. This means that one should easily be able to get food and clothing without having to go off to some village or some far off place. And such a location should also have been blessed by holy beings.

Then the attainment of karma abiding will be easier due to the blessing of these beings. However, even if we are unable to find such a place which has been blessed by the presence of holy beings, it is critically important not to practice in a place where there are beings who have broken their vows or their samaya. One also must find a good place in which there are no carnivorous animals, there are no thieves, there is no violence, and so forth. It makes no difference whether we have a courageous or even heroic disposition and feel we can stay in such dangerous places to practice. If we do stay in such places, hardship and difficulties will happen.

The third characteristic is that such a place must not be one in which we experience the suffering or suffering from heat or from coldness. Then one needs to train in concentration to have friends who have a similar view and outlook to one’s own. So it is not indispensable to practice concentration to dwell alone nor is it indispensable to practice concentration to dwell in the company of friends of a similar outlook. However, how many friends or companions we have, they must have a similar outlook to us. However, if one is a beginner in the training in concentration, it is far preferable to have companions with oneself, at least one companion who is of a similar outlook who shares one’s own view of things.

However, if one has companions or friends here, these should not be companions of pleasure and fun or heedless companions. We are not talking here of friends with whom you have a nice meal. Talk a long time about the practice of calm abiding and never engage in any practice. As Comte Jean Paulin, a great scholar and practitioner said, those with whom we chat and amuse ourselves who have beautiful faces and enjoyable means, those are the friends of sin. Therefore, those with whom we enjoy being and with whom we chat willingly tend to be sinful friends.

Said, sinful friends are not beings with large horns on their heads. Instead, they are our close friends who speak pleasantly with us, enjoy or make us enjoy our time with them, and because of whom our time to practice concentration is wasted. These are the friends of sin. And since we ourselves are beginners, we should associate with those who themselves are putting great effort in the practice of virtue so that we ourselves do so as well. Otherwise, if we associate with people for whom this has no importance, then this will be an interfering factor for ourselves.

And the following prerequisite which is necessary is to have literally all of the requisites for happiness. This refers to having received previously all of the initiations, the commentaries, as well as the teachings which are necessary for one’s practice. And therefore, mainly it is extremely important to be learned in the key points of one’s practice. Then some believe that before engaging in retreats or in meditation, they must put great effort in getting the right house, the right food, and so forth. This is not what is referred to here.

Then it is said that, some people who have this mistaken view of retreats, don’t obtain the prerequisites they need, put effort before at accumulating food and whatnot, and during their retreat instead of meditating pass their time casting more divinations. Then instead of meditating, one’s time for meditation is wasted in divination. Then there is no hope if one practices like this for one’s meditation to yield any food. And therefore, it is extremely important before meditating to have received all the empowerments, all the commentaries, all the instructions one needs for one’s practice. And then when one engages in meditation, one will not experience a hardship of having doubts regarding one’s practice and so forth.

For instance, as will be mentioned later on when we talk about subtle sinking, numerous practitioners of yore in Tibet confused good concentration with subtle sinking and practiced concentration which was blended or mixed with subtle sinking. The reason for which this is extremely dangerous is because subtle sinking shares features with good concentration. Specifically, subtle sinking has both a good factor of abiding on the object of observation and has good clarity. And therefore it resembles good concentration to a high degree. This led to widespread confusion among the meditators of former days in Tibet.

So I will explain this in great detail when we talk of the nine mental abiding and will not enter into it at present. The second prerequisite is to have few desires. This means to have little desire for both food and clothing and so forth. And the reason this is an interfering factor for training in concentration is that if one wishes for luxurious food and clothes, then one will have to work hard and perhaps go away to get it and this acts as an interfering factor for generating concentration. The third prerequisite is contentment.

And contentment here refers to not wishing for fancy food, clothes or possessions and to be satisfied with whatever one has. Since if one is satisfied with whatever one has, one will not strive to get fancy or expensive items. Otherwise, it harms one’s concentration. These two last prerequisites to have few desires and to have contentment are not exclusive to training in calm abiding. They are extraordinarily important for the general practice of dharma.

If we have many desires and if we lack contentment, let alone not obtaining calm abiding, we will not be able to practice dharma correctly. The fourth prerequisite is to have pure ethics. Ethics is in general the foundation of all qualities. In addition, it is the basis on which one obtains rebirth as a human being or as a deity. It is indispensable to obtain calm abiding to subdue the mind’s tendency to be distracted outwards and to bring the mind back inwards.

To obtain good concentration, our mind should be focused on its object and not be distracted outwards. To do this, it is critical to subdue the body, the speech, and the mind and to prevent them from being turned to non virtuous deeds or thoughts. And then if our mind is subdued and is prevented from being distracted outwards to non virtuous deeds, it will be much easier to focus the mind on its object of observation and to have a stable factor of abiding. The fifth prerequisite is to abandon tumult or turbulence. And there are two types of tumult, bodily or physical and mental tumult.

Mental tumult refers to the fact that the mind is disturbed or agitated by numerous conceptions. Whereas physical tumult refers to one’s being scattered or distracted by numerous worldly or material affairs. If either of these is present, we will waste a large amount of time in meaningless and literally trueness activities. And therefore wishing to give rise to concentration, we should forego distraction and try to abandon all meaningless activities. Then if we train in this way with few desires and with contentment, definitely harm abiding will occur.

And in the context of training for calm abiding astrology, the practice of astrology of divination or for that matter going to the neighboring village all counts as tumult. Such practices such as a practice of astrology, of divination, of medicine or going to the neighboring villages have been taught by the holy beings to be clear interferences to the attainment of calm abiding by ordinary beings such as ourselves. And therefore to obtain calm abiding it is critical to have very few activities. And finally, it is important to abandon the conceptions which focused focus on the objects of the senses. And if we focus on the impermanence of the five objects of the senses, it will be quite easy to abandon the conceptions which are attracted to them.

To obtain calm abiding, it is therefore indispensable to have these six prerequisites. You will notice that no mention is made in this context of money or wealth. So obtaining these is not particularly difficult unlike obtaining great wealth or money. And therefore, if one intends to train in concentration, it is indispensable before engaging in the training to make sure one has these six prerequisites. If we have these six prerequisites and we put great effort in the training and concentration, it is said we will obtain it within six months.

It’s not a long period of time, is it? So this refers specifically to abandoning what is meaningless, meaningless talk, anything which actually is not related to obtaining happiness in future lives. If one is greatly involved in worldly affairs, trying to get good clothing, trying to have friends, then this will cause interferences with the practice of concentration. Many of those who train in concentration live as hermits in the mountains since it is either easier to gather the prerequisites in this way. So if we wish to obtain calm abiding, these are the prerequisites we must have.

Then regarding the actual training in calm abiding as is said in Maitreya’s Madhyāntavibhanga, the middle between the extremes. It arises from the causes which rely on the eight applications which abandon the five faults. And since calm abiding arises through the eight mental applications which abandon the five faults, it is initially extremely important to clearly identify these five faults. And since these five faults are interfering factors preventing the attainment of concentration, I shall explain them clearly. To obtain calm abiding, it is critical to rely on the instructions of a holy Guru.

We should train in calm abiding, relying on the instructions in Maitreya’s Madhyāntavibhanga, his Mahāyāna Sutralankara, Asaṇga’s Śrāvakabhūmi, and Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama. If one doesn’t rely on the instructions in these great treatises and relies on some so called oral instructions from some minor and unimportant teacher, one can waste one entire life as a hermit on a mountain peak and gain no attainment whatsoever. There have been numerous cases of meditators who have relied on the so called oral instructions from minor teachers and have spent their whole life training in subtle sinking on mountain peaks. Such a human life, let alone not leading to the attainment of calm abiding, is a wasted life. On the other hand, if we rely on the core instructions of Ārya Maitreya, of Asaṇga, and of Kamalaśīla, it is definite that our time spent in meditating on calm abiding will be well spent and our life will be meaningful.

And specifically, one should rely on the teachings of Je Tsongkhapa who himself rooted all his teachings in the great treatises of ancient India which were mentioned but in addition gained a direct vision of Ārya Mañjuśrī and clarified all his doubts regarding these issues by asking questions directly from Mañjuśrī. There will be a great benefit if we rely on the instructions of Je Tsongkhapa the great who himself was rooted not only in an understanding of the great Indian treatises but had direct experience of meeting Mañjuśrī face to face. Then if one does not practice in this way but one relies on some cryptic oral instruction from some unknown teacher, there is a very great risk that one will gain attainments no one has ever heard of nor has ever had before. And one should therefore rely on these instructions for all the practices of karma abiding ranging from the completion path of or the completion stage of Anuttara Yoga tantra downwards to the simplest forms of training and concentration. There is no way to attain calm abiding apart from eliminating the five faults through the eight mental applications.

And the first of the five faults to be eliminated is laziness. Laziness is a tremendous obstacle to the attainment of calm abiding which distracts us from calm abiding and leads us to focus on worldly affairs. There are four antidotes to laziness. Of these four, the foremost antidote is pliancy. Excuse me.

So to train correctly in pliancy, we need initially to have enthusiasm. And to train correctly in enthusiasm, we need a wishful striving for concentration. To train correctly in that wishful striving, we need a faith which understands the qualities of concentration. What is referred to here as laziness is that absence of faith which does not wish to engage continuously or for long in the practice of concentration. Then if that laziness is present at the beginning combined with a lack of faith or lack of trust, then one will not wish to engage in the practice of concentration.

Just as in worldly affairs, if someone does not wish to do something, then we must use coercion to push them to do it. And therefore, the foremost obstacle to training and concentration is laziness. There are the four antidotes to laziness. The first of these antidotes is trust which sees the numerous qualities of concentration on the one hand and understands the numerous faults of distraction on the other hand and through such trust in turn one wishes to engage in concentration. Then once this trust is present, the wish to train in concentration arises naturally and spontaneously.

And therefore, the trust which trusts in the qualities of calm abiding and is wary of the thoughts of distraction is the first antidote and independence on this trust. Naturally, the wish to train in calm abiding arises. And then once this wish which is striving for concentration has arisen, independence on a trust which believes in the qualities of concentration, then a delight which wishes to engage in concentration arises. This delight is enthusiasm, the third antidote to laziness. And then once this enthusiasm which is a delight in the training and concentration has arisen, as a result of this, pliancy arises and this pliancy is the foremost antidote to laziness.

So these are the four antidotes to the first fault. These four faults are in a causal these four antidotes excuse me, are in a causal relationship with each other. In other words, the first antidote is the cause of the second, the second of the third, the third of the fourth and reciprocally the fourth is the result of the third, the third a result of the second, the second the result of the first. Therefore, once the first has been well generated, in turn, the other remaining three will be well generated. And therefore, once one has generated this trust which sees the qualities of calm abiding and is wary of the fault of distraction, one’s mind in turn will not be distracted outwards and will be focused on the object of observation.

Once this happens, concentration will increase and one will easily obtain the siddhis. Then once one has obtained such a Samādhi, such a concentration, not only will one’s concentration be powerful, but the afflictions within one’s mind will abate. And there will additionally be the benefit of being able to realize easily all of the aspects of the path from the gateway of the path, relying on the spiritual friend or relying on the spiritual friend all the way up to full enlightenment. These are the benefits or the qualities of calm abiding. Yes, please.

So the antidotes to laziness are four fold. The first is trust or faith. I have used trust because faith is a word which has connotations in English. Then the second antidote is independence on this trust in the qualities of concentration, a wish which strives or which aspires to concentration. So wishing is a second antidote.

And it is through quelling the lack of faith in the qualities of concentration that one can give rise to wishing for attaining or the attainment of concentration. Then the third antidote to laziness is enthusiasm which arises as a result of wishing for concentration. And then through this third antidote, one engages forcefully in the training in concentration and concentration dawns. As a result of which you get pliancy. So these are the four antidotes to laziness.

Trust, wishing, enthusiasm and pliancy. Is that clear? It is because laziness is such a major obstacle that these four antidotes are explained in great detail. So initially, to give rise to this trust which understands the qualities of concentration, one must know the qualities of concentration. And this is why it is explained that once a concentrated mind abides firmly on its object of observation, as a result of this, one can gain whatever attainment or siddhis one wishes to obtain.

In addition to this, once one has attained concentration, in turn, one will obtain easily the clairvoyances, the paranormal powers and so forth. In addition to this, one will be able to actualize the totality of the paths ranging from how to rely on the spiritual teacher all the way to the highest attainments of the generation and the completion stage. These are the qualities or the advantages of concentration. Then you can see that through reflecting on these qualities of concentration, joy and great a great desire to train in concentration will arise. Just as if we were to study one treatise and we’re told that independence on this, we would become learned in many, we would definitely study that one treatise.

And then the trust in this would naturally give rise to a wish to do so. And then once such a wish arises, naturally, one would put effort in engaging in whatever work was required for this, wouldn’t one? And then one would naturally with such effort, with such enthusiasm, achieve one’s goals, wouldn’t one? Then obviously training in this way, any laziness or indolence would disappear, wouldn’t it? It’s akin to that example.

So from within the five faults, this is the first fault. The second fault is forgetting the instructions. When we train in concentration, we must retain the object of observation of concentration in memory. If we forget the object of observation of concentration, if we lose it, in other words, this is referred to as losing or forgetting the instructions. So clearly if we are training in concentration and we focus our mind on an object and then we drift away and forget the object we are focused upon, one cannot speak of any training and concentration.

Therefore, forgetting the instruction, forgetting the object of observation is a very big for, isn’t it? So memory is none other than that capacity to bring back to mind whatever object we wish to bring back to mind. Whereas concentration is at capacity of the mind to remain single pointedly on that object. And therefore, whichever object we wish to focus upon with concentration, we must first hold firmly within our memory and then focus upon it with concentration. So one can use whichever object one wishes to use to train in concentration.

There is no difference in the objects of observation. Non Buddhists train in concentration using twigs or pebbles as objects of meditation. And therefore generally speaking, it is up to the practitioner what object he uses to train in concentration. There is no difference. However, it is important to understand that wall initially before training and concentration, one should observe carefully the object one is gonna be meditating upon, let us say the bell on Geshela’s desk.

However, after this, one stops observing it with one’s eye consciousness and one trains mentally. It is not necessary to observe the object with the eye consciousness continually. Some scholars say that the way to train in a calm abiding is to stare fixedly at an object such as this bell without wavering one’s gaze. This is not an appropriate way of training in calm abiding. Calm abiding is trained in with the mind, not with the eyes.

And therefore it is the mind which has to remain single pointedly focused on its object of observation. It is not germane. It is irrelevant whether the eyes are focused on the object of observation or not. So even though the system of training and karma abiding through using the eye consciousness and focusing visually on an object was taught extensively by former Tibetan practitioners. It was forcefully countered by the great Fifth Dalai Lama.

And therefore, it is perfectly appropriate after observing carefully the object of observation to close one’s eyes and to focus on it mentally single pointedly. There is an account of an Indian yogi of yore who was unable to obtain calm abiding independence on various objects of observation and finally trained with the horn of an ox and was able to obtain calm abiding through focusing on the horn of an ox. However, in Je Tsongkhapa’s tradition, there is an uncommon reason for which one should use the body of a deity to train in calm abiding. And the two reasons for this are first that through training in this way, through visualizing the body of a deity, one accumulates a large collection of merit. But in addition, later on, when one engages in the practice of secret mantra, one will have strong predispositions for secret mantra.

There is, for instance, great benefit if one takes as one’s object the body of Guhyasamāja as one’s object of observation for training in calm abiding because later on when one engages, if one is a Guhyasamāja practitioner in the practice of Guhyasamāja, it will be quite easy to complete the generation stage of Guhyasamāja. Another advantage of such a way of training and calm abiding is that if we do this, then at the time of our death, it will be very easy for us to keep very clearly the image of the Buddha within our minds, and this will lead to a very favorable rebirth. So one must understand that even though Je Tsongkhapa recommends strongly to use the body of a Buddha as a support for training in concentration, it is in no way said that one cannot or should not train concentration using other objects of meditation. However, irrespective of the object of observation we choose to meditate upon whether it be the body of a Buddha or some other object of observation, it is extremely important never to change the object of observation once we have started until we have attained calm abiding.

Just as when we are using rubbing two sticks together to give rise to a fire, we must rub the sticks together continuously until the heat gives rise to a spark. If we have a stack of kindling and rub the sticks together in one place and shift them over somewhere else, we will never actually be able to light the kindling. Also, it is said that once one starts training in calm abiding, one does nothing else but train in calm abiding apart from sleeping, from eating, and from going to the toilet. However, if one practices for a couple of days, then because one is exhausted, one takes a break and goes off somewhere to relax then comes back and practices a bit more. There is no hope to attain calm abiding.

It is possible but it is very difficult to rely on an interior object such as the mind simply because it is difficult to identify the object. So in addition to the difficulty of training in calm abiding, you have the difficulty of identifying the object. If you can identify the mind correctly and consistently then you can train in calm abiding on that. Otherwise for instance in the Bon tradition one meditates on the letter A to attain calm abiding. This is perfectly possible.

So what Gesheera is explaining here is the means to actually attain calm abiding within a couple months or a couple years. Then clearly as lay people who have jobs, who have responsibilities, this is very difficult to do and a daily practice of a couple of minutes will definitely improve one’s concentration. If one trains everyday, let us say for five minutes in concentration, then clearly over the years one’s mind will become more and more focused, more and more concentrated. The virtuous deeds one engages in will become clearer and clearer and in the Lojong there will be benefit. So Geshela hopes you will engage in these daily practices of concentration.

There is definitely great benefit. In retreat or in daily practice? The most important thing in a daily practice is to try to practice every day at the same time whenever you have some free time whether it’s in the morning or the evening and to do this consistently every day. However, if you train a lot in calm abiding, you will grow fat. Therefore, be careful with your health.

Then there are four causes for growing fat. Gesheera will give you the old tradition. So the four causes for growing overweight are sleeping too much, eating too much, taking too much care of one’s body and training in concentration. Then if you are afraid of growing overweight, think carefully about practicing concentration. However, Geshela would prefer if you trained in concentration but ate less.

And therefore the longer we can meditate on concentration, the greater the benefits. Then if you wish to gain calm abiding within six months, a year, or two years, then you must practice in keeping with these teachings and focus exclusively on calm abiding, not go to the neighboring village, not practice astrology and so forth. Most of the Tibetans who train in calm abiding go in retreats on mountain cliffs. And some of those who are in mountain retreats go to visit the neighboring village when they have a moment of free. This is not good.

And therefore returning to the commentary on the five faults. The second thought is forgetting the instruction. In other words, the object of observation. This refers to forgetting the object one is meditating upon. And the antidote to this second fault, forgetting the instruction, is stable memory.

There is a difference in one’s capacity to attain, calm abiding or not, in function of the power of one’s memory. We can see that there are substantial differences between persons as far as the power of their memory is concerned. Some can retain everything which is said without forgetting anything. Others can only retain one or two points and forget everything else. And those who have a powerful memory have somewhat of an advantage in training in calm abiding, whereas those who have a weak memory are at somewhat of a disadvantage at training in calm abiding.

In any case, memory, a stable memory is the antidote to the second thought which is forgetting the object of instruction or the object of observation. And we should hold the object of observation with our memory in the same way as we hold a rosary firmly within our hand. When the object of observation is held firmly by memory during the session of meditation on concentration, two faults can arise, sinking or agitation. The foremost faults in training in concentration are sinking and agitation. There are numerous distinctions to be made between sinking, lethargy, agitation and scattering or dispersion.

We must understand these. If one does not understand clearly the distinctions between sinking and agitation, one is unable to understand the distinction between one’s friends and one’s foes. Sinking for instance is subdivided into two, coarse and subtle sinking. If one does not understand precisely what subtle sinking is, one may think that one has great powers of concentration whereas one is training in subtle sinking. Generally speaking, sinking is either neutral or virtuous.

Whereas lethargy is either non virtuous or neutral. Lethargy occurs when the mind is unclear. In that situation, one feels physically heavily heavy and dull. Then for Tibetan meditators especially, it was critically important to eliminate lethargy since if lethargy increases, one falls asleep and one falls off the mountain. Lethargy is the cause for the arising of sinking.

And as we said, sinking is subdivided into two, coarse and subtle sinking. Coarse sinking occurs when the object of observation is held by one’s memory and there is a strong factor of abiding but the factor of clarity is weak. Then I will stop here for today and explain subtle sinking and agitation later on and would like to take one or two questions at present. Geshela taught earlier this morning that it matters not whether you train in bodhichitta and then calm abiding or calm abiding and then bodhichitta, but how do you realise bodhichitta if you haven’t trained in calm abiding? One must distinction between distinguish between two types of bodhichitta, contrived and uncontrived bodhichitta or bodhichitta generated with effort and spontaneous bodhichitta.

Calm abiding is unnecessary to give rise to contrived bodhichitta since bodhichitta can be caused to arise periodically within our mind through effort. However, it is not possible to give rise to spontaneous or uncontrived bodhichitta without calm abiding. When we meditate to generate the motivation of bodhichitta as a preliminary to the teachings, we meditate for one minute or so. This is a generation of contrived bodhichitta. If calm abiding were necessary to generate such a contrived bodhichitta, then our practice of meditation would be a lie, wouldn’t it?

So I’m not quite sure what’s meant by it because it was referenced previously to an Indian guru who focused on a horn to achieve calm abiding. So what is actually meant by calm abiding? Calm abiding refers to reaching a point where one’s mind can be set on an object stably. It is set on the object and it never wavers, never changes from this object and this can last for as long as one wishes. It is ultimate concentration.

Calm abiding means to be able to set the mind on an object continuously and without interruption for however long one has chosen to do so indefinitely if need be. Geshela, regarding the the, mental fixation on an object, It seems to me that if one were taking a physical object like a statue of a Buddha, you’d have less room for the image changing or wavering because if you’re just thinking of the object of a Buddha, you might sort of change the colour of the robes or this or that. So I’m not entire I don’t quite understand why we need a completely mental object of fixation. That will be very difficult to meditate on an image of the Buddha you had never seen in reality. What you do is you take a statue or an image, a physical statue image, you observe it carefully, you memorize the features and once you have memorized then you visualize it.

So you cannot attain calm abiding through just staring at an object with the eye consciousness. It is the mind, the mental consciousness which attains calm abiding. Therefore, staring at the object alone is not sufficient. There will be some meditation tomorrow. And you will understand when we practice tomorrow, and you can stay for one second, two seconds, five seconds.

Yeah. Yeah. Just under prerequisites, before one starts, one should have all the empowerments required. Under prerequisites? One should have what?

One should have all the empowerments that one is that required. Empowerments? Empowerments. Geshela speak about that? No, there are no specific initiations which are required before calm abiding but in general there are initiations which are required before engaging in certain meditative practices.

Before calm abiding what is really required is instruction in how to practice calm abiding. There was a monk who engaged in training in calm abiding and felt he had attained calm abiding. So when he stopped his retreat, said, I have achieved calm abiding. He was examined by masters of and they found that he had not attained more than the third mental abiding. And these statements were due to the fact he did not understand what calm abiding was.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
completion stage dzog rim (Tib)
The second of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which control is gained over the vajra body. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
generation stage kye rim (Tib)
The first of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which one cultivates the clear appearance and divine pride of one’s chosen meditational deity. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
samaya dam tsig (Tib)
Sacred word of honor; the pledges and commitments made by a disciple at an initiation to keep tantric vows for life or to perform certain practices connected with the deity, such as daily sadhana recitation... LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How can you realise bodhicitta if you haven't trained in calm abiding?

It depends on which type of bodhichitta is meant. There are two types: contrived (uncontrived's opposite), meaning bodhichitta generated with effort, and spontaneous or uncontrived bodhichitta. Calm abiding is not needed for contrived bodhichitta, since it can be caused to arise periodically in the mind through effort. Spontaneous bodhichitta, however, cannot arise without calm abiding. For example, when we meditate for a minute or so to generate the motivation of bodhichitta before a teaching, we are generating contrived bodhichitta. If calm abiding were necessary for that, then our practice of meditation would be a lie.

What is meant by calm abiding?

Calm abiding refers to reaching a point where the mind can be set on an object stably. Once it is set on the object, it never wavers and never changes from that object, and this can last for as long as one wishes. It is described as "ultimate concentration." Put another way, calm abiding means being able to set the mind on an object continuously and without interruption, for however long one has chosen to do so, indefinitely if need be.

Scroll to Top