1 h 47 min · 3,047 words · 10 February 2015 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 107-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche begins the year’s focus on Madhyamaka philosophical tenets—specifically their Svatāntrika and Prāsaṇgika subdivisions—building on last year’s studies of Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, and Cittamātra schools. He starts with foundational definitions: what a “propounder of tenets” is, and the essential gap between Buddhist and non-Buddhist systems. The core difference, he argues through analysis, rests on the concept of self. Non-Buddhist schools accept a permanent, independent self; Buddhist schools reject this entirely. He further divides Buddhist thought: lower vehicle schools accept indivisible particles; greater vehicle schools (Cittamātra and Madhyamaka) reject them. Within the greater vehicle, Madhyamaka alone refuses to posit even conventionally established true existence of phenomena. Extensive Q&A follows on tenet criteria, logical negation, and whether tenet-holding changes across a lifetime. He draws on Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen’s concise treatise of tenets.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-02-10 (2).mp3
UUID: 5eb666c7-243f-4490-8493-7c7a91562508
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Tenets
Date: 2015-02-10
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,057
So as usual before receiving such teachings we will generate the motivation. Good. Very good tea. Thank you. Geshe-la was asking Jampa Gyaltsen what precisely he had reached in his studies at Sera.
And Jampa Gyaltsen was at present studying bodhicitta, what is called the generation of the mind in the first book of Parchin. And Geshe la then asked him how this was going and he said very well. And he pointed out that this is actually the main topic of Abhisamayālamkāra, Maitreya’s great Shastra. It is both the main topic and the introduction. Moreover, in truth, the topic of the generation of the mind of the correct view and of the two truths which are all covered in the first volume of Parchin are all interrelated.
So we will pursue this year with the presentation of tenets, which was started last year. And as you remember, last year, we covered the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrantica view as well as the Cittamātra view. This year, we shall cover the Madhyamaka view, which is subdivided into two, the Svatāntrika and Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view. However, before entering into this, it would be good to talk a little bit about what tenets are. So what precisely is understood by tenets?
Generally speaking, there are two categories of tenets, the tenets of non-Buddhist or outsiders and Buddhist tenets or insider tenets. And tenets are basically the means to ascertain one’s own view. And then through understanding one’s own uncommon view, it becomes possible to realize or to attain this view. And then through reflecting on one’s own tenets, one will be able to understand one’s wishes and one’s happiness not only for this life but for the future as well. Then however many billions of human beings there may be, all are similar in wishing to attain their own happiness.
Then generally speaking happiness can be subdivided into two, physical and mental happiness. Setting aside wrong views on this topic, we can see that actual happiness is profoundly rooted in one’s interiority, in the interiority of beings. Then one can also subdivide beings in this world into two broad categories, those who propound tenets and those who do not. It is my personal opinion that the feature of beings who do not propound tenets can be said to be a focus on exterior physical happiness. Then to the
Of beings whose idea of happiness hinges on a focus on physical externality. I suspect that one could say that the feature of propounders of tenets or beings which are propounders of tenets is that their search for happiness focuses on an innermost mental experience. Then it’s up to oneself to examine whether one is a being which is a propoundary of tenets or not. And therefore, after having examined whether one is a being which is a propounder of tenets or not, in other words, whether one is a being who considers that happiness arises from within the mind or one is a being who considers that happiness is purely contingent on exterior material phenomena, one will see that as a being who is a propounder of tenets, one’s viewpoint is central. This is both an easy way to think about it and an easily understandable approach.
Then we have to analyze carefully the meaning of being a propounder of tenets in even greater depth than this. Then if we analyze the meaning of the syllables in Tibetan, propounder of tenets, we can see that the first syllable of tenets in Tibetan which means to establish refers to the complete presentation of basis, path and result. Which means boundary or limit refers to the sense that there is nothing superior to this. This is therefore a view or a position which one holds. The last two syllables, mawa, propounder or speaker indicates that one propounds or teaches his view to others.
Then within propounders of tenets, there are both insider or Buddhist and outsider or non-Buddhist propounders of tenets. When it comes to the non-Buddhist propounders of tenets such as the materialists, I am not sure whether it is possible in that school to posit base, path and result. So we have clarified the distinction between beings or persons which are propounders of tenets and persons which are not propounders of tenets. As was mentioned, within propounders of tenets there are two subdivisions: Buddhist and non-Buddhist propounders of tenets. What is the distinction between Buddhist and non-Buddhist propounders of tenets?
non-Buddhist propounders of tenets accept the existence of a self which is permanent, one and independent. Whereas Buddhist propounders of tenets do not accept the existence of a self which is permanent, one and independent. One and independent, I feel it is quite beneficial to root its analyses in one’s own personal experience, oneself, for instance, as the reader of a text and so forth since there are numerous possible explanations of a person which is permanent one and independent. Therefore what precisely is this person which is permanent one and independent? Then every one of us has this innate experience of an I.
And when we examine this I analytically, we can see that this I cannot be guaranteed to subsist. None of us can assert, for instance, that we will still be around tomorrow, let alone twenty or one hundred years from now. Yet, from the standpoint of our mind, we have the innate conviction that we will be around twenty, let alone one hundred years from now. It is this which gives rise to the sense of an independence of the I. None of the Buddhist treatises assert the existence of such an I, an I in other words, which is permanent one and independent.
Instead, all the schools of tenets from Vaibhāṣika all the way up to Prāsaṇgika assert the existence of an I which is imputed on the aggregates, not necessarily merely imputed from the standpoint of the mind on the aggregates, but imputed on the aggregates. Such an I obviously is not contingent on the body. So this is for the distinction between Buddhist and non-Buddhist propounders of tenets. Now within Buddhist propounders of tenets, one must in turn distinguish between lower vehicle propounders of tenets and greater vehicle propounders of tenets. The distinction between lower and greater vehicle propounders of tenets hinges on whether one accepts or not the existence of form which is constituted of a conglomeration of indivisible particles.
Lower schools of tenets accept this, greater schools of tenets do not. So I made a slight mistake actually. The distinction between the lower and greater schools of tenets hinges on the non acceptance for the lower school of tenets or the acceptance for the greater school of tenets of the selflessness of phenomena. And such a selflessness of phenomena is also an absence of phenomena, material phenomena existing as a conglomeration of indivisible particles. So the issue arises in the context of the Sautrāntika Svatāntrika Madhyamaka School of Tenets, which does indeed accept the existence of such particles, but nonetheless does not accept the selflessness of phenomena.
Then the understanding of such particles in the Sautrāntika Sautrāntika Madhyamaka School is from the standpoint of the Sautrāntika Madhyamaka School itself regarding the selflessness of phenomena. Then within the proponents of great vehicle tenets, there are two subdivisions, the Cittamātra and the Madhyamaka.
In brief, the difference between the two is that the Chitamatras assert other powered phenomena to be truly established, whereas the Madhyamaka do not assert other powered phenomena to be truly established. And this leads us to the definition of a Madhyamaka, which you have on Page 25 of your translation of Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen’s tenets, Line three. A Madhyamaka is a being who is a propounder of great vehicle tenets and who does not assert even conventionally actual true existence. So for the presentation of Madhyamaka, we will rely on Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen’s concise treatise of tenets, which is translated here. And we will also rely, and since there is time, I would encourage you to do so on Jamyang Shayba’s great tenet treatise.
The section on Svatāntrika is translated by Don Lopez, and Chris sent you the reference in an e mail. Since this is the first session of the course on tenets this year, I would like to point out the importance of regular systematic attendance of the teachings to be able to progress in one’s study. Then obviously, you alone know how much time you have and it is true that this entails a certain amount of hardship but there is no such thing as study without some hardship. It is difficult to progress in a topic like this if one does not attend regularly. Then at present, I will take two questions from two different persons.
Please concise questions. And if there is time after, we will have make some space for more questions.
There is a difference in terms of their understanding since clearly propounders of tenets understand the origin thereof and non propounders of tenets do not. However, there is probably no difference in their experience thereof. Question is about the criterion or the measure of tenets. What is the measure or the criterion of having tenets or not? Then Geshe la says basically the criterion of being a being who is a propounder of tenets hinges on first having something which is established, drub in Tibetan.
And this is seen as something, which is peerless, which is unequal. At this point, one is said to hold a view of tenets. One becomes a propounder of tenets when one propounds this to others. To have tenets entails to be able to present basis, path and result. And difficulties arise in the context of the Indian materialist view, the Lokāyata or Charvaka view.
It is unclear whether one can posit basis path and result for this school or not. So it is unclear whether this criterion for tenets is actually a criterion for necessary entailment or pervading or not. Ani? And another question. So it is not the case that the statement sound is impermanent is asserted by some scholars to be an implicative negation because it implies sound or sound’s existence.
The scholars who assert that the statement sound is impermanent is an implicative negation assert this because they consider that it satisfies the definition of an implicative negation since the utterance sound is impermanent after negating its object of negation which is the permanence of sound implies sounds being impermanent. This implication is what warrants its being considered as an implicative negation. While indeed, the statement sound is impermanent does lead to the implication of the momentariness of sound, it does not lead to the implication of the non existence of sound. Since the mind which understands the statement sound is impermanent understands sound and understands thereby that sound is an existent, sound is a fabricated phenomenon and so forth. This can in no way lead to an understanding of the nonexistence of sound.
Yours is a good question since there obviously are great scholars who assert that the statement sound is impermanent is an implicative negation. For that matter, some assert that the statement sound is impermanent is an established phenomenon since there is a correct reason establishing it. Just one question. Just one question? What happened?
What happened? Jampa Gyaltsen’s question seems to be, if I understood it correctly, and as Geshe la explained it, as a child grows up, becomes a teenager and eventually an adult, goes to university, furthers his studies, Is it the case that tenets are always present? Is that your question? Right. And Geshe-la said, no, there is no certainty whether such a person is a propounder of tenets or not since being a propounder of tenets or not hinges on establishing a distinction between physical and mental happiness and in turn identifying the core of happiness as mental happiness.
And Geshe la was saying that the then Jampa Gyaltsen asked Geshe-la whether this is something which is in keeping with the scientific viewpoint or not. And Geshe la pointed out that for most scientists, mind can be reduced to matter, in other words, the brain. However, Geshe la also said, this is in keeping with conversations we had on quantum physics that for many scientists the view of matter is akin to that of Cittamātra. At present, we will start the discussion period. Please group as usual in groups of two different from whatever groups were last year and there are four topics this time.
The first is the distinction between a propounder of tenets and someone who is not a propounder of tenets. The second is the distinction between Buddhist and non-Buddhist tenets. The third is a distinction within Buddhist tenets between lower vehicle and greater vehicle tenets. And the fourth is within greater vehicle tenets the distinction between Cittamātra and Madhyamaka tenets. If you’re not able to cover all four of these topics, cover one or two carefully.
So for half an hour.
Mhmm. Anyway.
Yeah. Yes. Okay. I have a few announcement, and there’s lots of excitement here, lots of surprise. And so following week, the February 19 is the Tibetan New Year, and there’s there’s a 06:00, 6AM, Guru Puja, and as we always hold held that.
And so please, welcome. And, this is a very, very auspicious day for the first year of the lunar calendar.
So we usually, you know, to, you know, to see our first thing in the morning to our teacher, and it’s very appropriate here for us, you know, to see Geshe-la and have a Guru Puja together. And that’s that. And twenty eighth of this month, there is a public talk. So Geshe-la’s public talk. So please, you can take flyers and give it to your friends or invite your friends.
You know? And it would be fantastic. So that’s on February, 03:00. Yeah. It’s mentioned in a flyer if you can look at or in a in a website.
And there is a two thing in a in a March, Ilya’s Seminar on March 14. And please, same thing, you know, to, again, to take the flyers and bring your friends or, you know, to suggest, you know, this is the way we can help for our friends to bring into inner path. So it’s really more than you give a $100 or the thousand. You know? So there’s a tremendous benefit, you know, to encouraging your friend.
It’s called, virtuous friend. Alright. And, March 21 is a very special day. We have, members lunch, and we encourage the members, you know, this is our commitment for TBI. And if you are not member, you can always become member, alright, and supporter for TBI.
And that means for, you know, helping for sentient being. Okay? And the the Easter retreat is coming up, and it’s going to be the 12 links interdependent arising on the teaching. So please, you know, put your name down and, make sure you have a, you know, a wonderful weekend for that time. Okay?
And, of course, we will going to organize we unfortunately, Khensur Rinpoche is not an he’s not able to come this year, but we hope he gets better, and we he will come in next time. And, however, we still are expecting, you know, few monks, Geshes come arrive in here during our anniversary day. So there will be a lot of excitement on that day, And there will be a if the Geshes arrive, there will be a Mendrup Mandala, and lots of things happen. I won’t say now. Then, otherwise, you all know then it’s not much fun.
So so this this the next three months, you know, for and make sure, please, put in a Easter retreat. And, of course, you know, always come for the members lunch. We share with the lunch with our teacher, resident teacher here with the Geshe-la and Ilya and everybody else. And I think it’s very important, you know, to to to come, and that’s where you support. And, of course, Ilya’s seminar is always, you know, fascinating.
So must make sure those who are not Buddhist yet, you know, you can encourage and, you know, give them a this is a really we call a virtuous friend, so you can help. You know? And I’m going backwards now. Then the lunar. And Oh, yeah.
There is. Yeah. Fifth. Sorry. Yeah.
That’s I missed out. The day of miracle. Yeah. 7PM, we have Guru Puja. Yeah.
And I’m getting old. You know? My eyes not so good. So, you know, all that, you know, you can look at in our website. And please have a try.
There’s a lovely cake there, Natalie bought, you know. And thank you very much. Okay. Alright. There’s also and if I’m not wrong, we have previous Geshe-la’s teaching on tenants, and it’s a copy, but it’s a raw material.
It’s not edited. You’re welcome to order. It’s almost quite thick in this much. You know? But if you order, you know, we can photocopy and someone help me binding.
You know? That’d be great if you’re interest on, you know, previous teachings if you want to look at. As Anne and Joe, they, you know, tremendously put effort and worked very hard, you know, to transcribe. And but it’s you know, I would just warn, it’s not edited. So still, it’s beautiful.
You know? Okay. So that’s it. Thank you very much. And, also, it’s a very auspicious day today, you know, first day of the, you know, the New Year.
And it’s wonderful to see all of you. And Geshe-la is very happy. And, especially, we have a special visit, you know, And I would like to say, thank you so much. You know? And it’s when you sit there, it brings it all back all all memories.
You know? And, anyway and I hope you have a swift, you know, without any obstacles for your visa. So and you know? And then please come, you know, during your visit, Most welcome here. You know?
Also be this is your home. Okay? Thank you. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.