Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-11-04 – KR.mp3
UUID: 9e747f10-6ab9-4342-9e6a-ac51bcf65054
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2014-11-04
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 11m
Words: 2,593
As you will as usual, we generate the motivation for receiving these teachings. From within the four systems of in Buddhist philosophy, all the schools of tenets tenets beneath the Prasangika Madhyamika School of Tenets accept the existence of inherently existent phenomena, phenomena established from their own side and phenomena established by their own characteristics. The lower schools of tenets not only assert self characterized phenomena, phenomena existing from their own side and phenomena which are inherently established, they by extension assert the existence thereof. And the reason for this, contacte, the reason for this is that just as when the lower schools of tenets search for the person within the collection of the aggregates, they find something which is the person, and for these schools of tenets, this is typically the mental consciousness. Likewise, these schools of tenets consider that when phenomena are investigated under analysis, something is found.
Therefore, they consider that phenomena are established on their own side, characterized established by their own characteristics, and inherently established. It is precisely because the lower schools of tenets consider that under investigation phenomena are findable, that they assert that phenomena are established by their own characteristics, established from their own side, and inherently established. Clearly, the lower schools of tenets do not engage in an in-depth analysis or investigation of phenomena because if they did so, they would eventually encounter the view for which under investigation phenomena are unfindable. Therefore, the viewpoint of the lower schools of tenets is considered a warm view from the standpoint of Prasangika Madhyamika. There’s a quote in the Madhyamaka Alamkara, which unfortunately I don’t remember on this topic.
Prasangika Madhyamika view is a supreme system of tenets, the highest system of tenets from within the four system of tenets, Vaibhashika, Sautrantika, Chitamatra and Madhyamika. And as you remember, Madhyamika itself is subdivided into Svatantika and Prasanika Madhyamika. It is only the Prasangika Madhyamika view, which is not at odds with reason, and as Je Tsongkhapa said in Kangalakshin Yinpo, the essence of eloquence differentiating the interpretable from the definitive, One whose utterances are at odds with logic cannot be a being which is a valid cognizer. Then in the two lower schools of tenants, the Vaibhashika and the Sauthentika, is asserted a collection of form which is an exterior base. This is something which becomes evident to us when we reflect on our natural perception of entities such as this temper, which seem to exist outside of us.
Then spontaneously, innately, we view the phenomena, the forms, which we perceive as exterior forms which are constituted of constituents which are exterior as well to our consciousness. So this is why the two lower schools of tenants, Vaibhashika and Sattrhandika, we could just say Sautrantika for that matter, consider that the exterior world, the environment and the beings which live within it, is constituted of an exterior base, a collection of forms which concatenate into ever greater numbers to eventually constitute coarse form, coarse matter, and the universe as we know it. Therefore, when one analyzes the universe and its constituents, eventually, one reaches the partless particles which are asserted by these two schools. Therefore, the two lower schools of tenets consider that it is this concatenation of forms which are an exterior base, which gives rise to the coarse forms which are perceived by us. This perception of coarse forms as exterior to consciousness is an innate perception.
For these schools of tenets, under analysis, when one breaks down these coarse forms, eventually one reaches indivisible particles. These particles are asserted as the foundation of form, and it is on their basis that the coarse forms arise. It is for this reason that these schools assert the existence of exterior objects. As to the continuum of this subtle matter, it can be traced back indefinitely in time. The Chitamatra school, on the other hand, counters the assertions of the Vaibhashika and the Sautrantika schools.
Specifically, it rejects the existence of indivisible or partless particles. Rejecting the existence of partless particles, it also rejects the existence of exterior objects. This assertion that exterior particles exist, specifically, the mind which apprehends the existence of exterior particles is called by the Chitamantra school, the apprehension of a self, of phenomena. Such an apprehension of the existence of ex exterior particles is identical in meaning to the apprehension of form and the valid cognizer perceiving form being different substances or is identical to the apprehension of blue and the eye consciousness perceiving blue being different substances. When role of the Chitamatra school asserts that all phenomena are established as being of the nature of mind, the Prasangika Madhyamika school asserts that all phenomena are mere nominal imputations.
The one view, the Kitamatra view, is extraordinarily beneficial to lead to an understanding of the second view, the prasamika view. The Chitamatra school considers that the assertion that partless particles or if you if you prefer ultimate particles exist is an assertion which is at odds with reason. And they attack the view of the Vaibhashika in the Sautrantika, pointing out that should such ultimate or partless particles exist, then in as much as they are composite phenomena, impermanent phenomena, and entities, they would necessarily have to have causes and conditions and challenge the Sautrantika and Vaibhashika to present such causes and conditions, which the latter are incapable of doing. As a result, the Chitamatha assert that the affirmation of the existence of partless or ultimate particles is an assertion which is at odds with reason. So if we analyze our natural means of perceiving the exterior world, we can see that our sense consciousnesses enter in contact with form and that form, in other words matter, is spontaneously perceived as exterior to our sense consciousnesses and unrelated to consciousness.
This is the meaning of exterior objects. The Chitamatras consider that the conception which apprehends exterior objects is the conception which apprehends a set of phenomena, and by extension, that the sense consciousnesses which are contaminated with the appearance of phenomena as exterior to these consciousnesses are sense consciousnesses which apprehend exterior objects. So if the Chitamatha school of tenets refutes the existence of partless or ultimate particles in accordance with the view of the Vaibhashika and Sautrantika view, what according to the Chitamatra school of tenets does one encounter under ultimate analysis of matter or form? According to the Chittamatra school, under ultimate analysis of the particles, which constitute matter, one eventually encounters a subtle wind or a subtle energy. This is unrelated to the coarse wind, which we are accustomed to, but is linked to the wind mind complex.
This is actually the basis of the physical universe. So last time, there were several questions regarding the compatibility of exterior objects or the negation of exterior objects, should I say, in the Chitamatra school, and their assertion on the other hand that other pirate phenomena are established by their own characteristics, are established on their own side, and are inherently established. To understand this one must explain what it means in the Chitamatra school for a phenomenon to be established by its own characteristics. For Chitamatra, even though the phenomenon which appears as exterior to consciousness is not exterior to consciousness, nonetheless that phenomenon which appears for instance to the eye consciousness, arises independence on karmic imprints within the mind which generates simultaneously that phenomenon and the consciousness perceiving it. That is the ground on which the Chitamatra asserts that that phenomenon is established by its own characteristics.
So it is a common assertion of all of the schools of tenets that impermanent phenomena arise from causes and conditions. However, for the Vaibhashika and Sautrantika schools of tenets, these exterior causes and conditions are exterior phenomena just as the phenomena they give rise to. For the Chitamatha school of tenets, the causes and conditions of phenomena are within consciousness. They are karmic imprints. And, therefore, the assertion by the Chitamatra school that phenomena are of the substance of the interior mind, or are established as being of the substance of the interior mind counters and refutes the view that phenomena are merely established as exterior entities.
This refutation is none other than the affirmation of the subtle selflessness of phenomena for Chitamatra. And therefore, the affirmation that phenomena are mere exterior entities to consciousness is the object of refutation, and the absence thereof is simply the subtle selflessness of persons. Therefore, in brief, for the Chitta Matras, phenomena are established as of the substance of mind. This is something that we can understand if we take the example of our perception in a state of great anger. When great anger arises within our mind stream, consequence as of a very powerful sense of I, the person towards whom we feel great animosity and whom we perceive as it were on the outside appears suddenly to have an extremely unpleasant face.
Now from the standpoint of the Chitamatra School of Tenets, what actually appears, what is focused upon the mind is the what is focused upon is the aspect of the mind of anger. It is the aspect of the mind of anger which appears as the face of the person. This leads us to an understanding of the thoughts of anger. The Chitamagra school is furthermore divided into true and false aspectarians. There are minor differences between these two subschools.
The true aspectarians The two aspectarians include Vasubandhu and the great commentator on the Vinaya Munabhadra, And the fourth aspectarians include among others, Dignaga and Dharmakirti. The subschool with the most most delicate positions is that of the two aspectarians, which assert the existence of eight collections of consciousness and three final vehicles. Regarding the eight collections of consciousness, as you know, most schools of tenets assert the existence of six collections of consciousness, the five mental consciousnesses, and the five sense consciousnesses, and the mental consciousness. But the two aspectarians, in addition, assert the existence of the alaya vajnana, the mind basis of ore, and of the afflicted consciousness. Then I will explain the eight collections of consciousness and specifically the alayavijnana and the afflicted consciousness later.
Then if we have the opportunity, it would be excellent to reflect in-depth on these topics. It would be vain to assert with a very limited level of analysis that such views are at odds with reasoning since they are merely at odds with our coarse ordinary perception. These are the views of great beings. How great indeed were Dignaga and Dharmakirti, Vasubandho, and Gunabhadra who lived between one thousand and fifteen hundred years ago, and they did not dedicate a couple minutes of reflection to these topics as we would, in which case we would probably be called extraordinary thinkers. They did dedicated long periods of time and we can see how close the results are to reality.
Exactly. 100%. 110%. Then in our cases, it is said to be extraordinary when we dedicate one hour of our time to dedicate on these to meditate on these views. But it is not such a short period of time which should be dedicated to such reflection.
It is long periods of time accompanied with intense study and meditation, and then there is some hope that we will gain some type of feeling and experience. Otherwise, it is vain and illusory to think we can gain any type of feeling or experience just by dabbling in the topic. In my personal case, for instance, these Tuesday teachings on Buddhist philosophy take twelve to thirteen hours of private reflection to prepare them in addition to my perusal of Buddhist texts. We will understand well the Chitamata view, and we’ll be hesitant to assert that it is at odds with reasoning if we start from the assertion of an exterior base of phenomena, which is a position of the two lower schools of Tenetzivai Bashica and the Sautrantika, and see where that would come from, and then view the Chitamatha assertions on it or regarding it and see where it is asserted to come from. Then I shall stop here for today, and I will take your questions.
Please, only one question, no double max, no two questions wrapped in one. You have to differentiate between persons and matter. When one refutes the existence of exterior phenomena, one is refuting the experience of form and matter. Cats are persons. That’s not the right way of looking at it.
The way of looking at it is to take the example of the wool and to ask where the wool comes from, what its causes and conditions are, what it is constituted of, and to analyze ever deeper. And if one does this, then we will start to understand the Chitamatra view. This is how the Chitamatrans analyze things. Another question. Understand the thoughts of anger.
The example of the unpleasant appearance of the face of someone with which we are angry was given to illustrate the cittamatra view that exterior objects do not exist. They are merely of the nature of the mind. So, one has to distinguish in your question situations in which the is collectively apprehended and situations in which it is individually apprehended. When the fan is collectively apprehended, the fan is apprehended as a common object of appearance and appears to the eye consciousness of all apprehending it. However, under investigation or analysis, the fan will then appear to you in an uncommon mode of appearance, and this is specific to you and unshared or uncommon with anyone else.
The reason for this is as follows. When we collectively apprehend the fan, we perceive our eye our eye consciousnesses perceive the fan in terms of a common factor of appearance. However, when we apprehend it individually, we perceive it in terms of an uncommon factor of appearance, which for the Chittamatra school is of one nature with our own individual eye consciousness. My own individual eye consciousness is of a different nature of your individual eye consciousness. Otherwise, if this were not the case, our two consciousnesses would be of the same substance, and there would be numerous unfortunate results such as solipsism.
It is impossible for us to perceive something unrelated to our culture. Really. And therefore, the assertion in the Chitamatra that all phenomena are established as being of the nature of mind is extremely profound. This is taught by the Petri Gains when they assert that for Chitamatra all is impaired by karma, and we have a quote in Shantideva’s Bodhisattva Acharyavatara, I think in the ninth chapter, in which Shantideva says, which human being created these fires, these infernal helpers, and these houses? None other but the mind.
We’ll enter next week in the rather complicated topic of the uncommon factors of appearance. No. That wouldn’t be correct. For the Chitamoto school, conventional truth is the mere appearance of phenomena such as the cup, the table, and so forth. So we shall stop here for the questions and at present we have discussion.
I’d like you to discuss the following topic. The correctness or incorrectness of the respective views of, on the one hand, Vaibhashika and Sautrantika, for which exterior objects are rooted in exterior causes and conditions, as opposed to the Chitamatra view, for which phenomena are rooted in causes and conditions which are the karmic imprints present within the mind. For twenty minutes. Mhmm. Two by two as usual.
Mhmm. Paired differently than last time. Mhmm.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.