Four Noble Truths — 2014-11-12

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths — 2014-11-12
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-11-12 – KR.mp3

UUID: 0c1581a3-8916-4ff6-b283-0a1f56a6e2b5

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2014-11-12

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 33m

Words: 3,325

Regarding the generation of the motivation, ideally, one should generate a virtuous state of mind. But at the very least, one’s mind should be untroubled in the self same way as one can see the untroubled reflection of colors such as red, yellow, green or blue in untroubled water. Then when we speak of an untroubled mind, we refer to a relaxed mind. When the mind is troubled, great difficulties arise, leading possibly to insanity. In Australia, the exterior conditions are excellent.

The environment is extremely peaceful. If one goes for instance for a walk or some circumambulations at six or seven in the evening, there is no one to be seen. This is not at all like India where I lived, the village of Kushalaga which is filled with alcoholics and problems in the evening. Ideally, one’s mind in Australia should be as peaceful as the exterior environment. And therefore, ideally, one’s mind within oneself should be as peaceful as the exterior environment.

Then if one’s exterior environment is peaceful and one’s mind within oneself is peaceful, one can accomplish whatever one wishes to accomplish. If one’s mind is focused overwhelmingly, let’s say 90% on externals, then one’s mind is very close to be troubled. Therefore, the mind must be withdrawn inwards and in the process it will become untroubled. Then to have such a quiet mind, we do need a helper. And the best helper one can think of is Karma in causality or the Triple Gem.

It really is the same thing. Do you understand? Therefore if we rely on Karma and causality as our helper, as our friend, then things will go well for us in this life and things will go well for us in future lives. On the other hand, if we view as our main helper in this life, our husband or our wife, our partners, then at the very best they will be our partners for this life and they will not be our partners for future lives. Karma and causality causes no trouble in either case.

This is why Jatung Kapas said, develop conviction in the efficacy of karma and causality. It is important to think in these terms, whether it is easy indeed if one is ordained to do so, in general, one should do so as well. And, therefore, the faith we should have in karma and causality is similar to the face of the conviction a Christian has in God. The difference is that karma and causality, where do they exist? They exist within our own minds.

And virtuous karma is present within our mind stream. This virtuous karma will give rise in future lives to pleasant experiences, non virtuous karma as well is present within our mind stream, this non virtuous karma will give rise in future life to painful experiences. We have the choice of implanting virtuous or non virtuous karma within our mind streams. It is within ourselves. Karma and causality will produce its fruits from the next life onwards and even in this life, we will be at Eid and to reap the unmistaken crop of karma and causality, we must behave accordingly.

Then what troubles the mind? Anger troubles the mind. Desire troubles the mind. In brief, the afflictions trouble the mind. If we take the example of anger, when strong anger arises within our minds, probably if we analyze as an ordinary being, we will assume that the cause of the anger is another person, another party who is guilty, responsible of anger arising within our mind.

This is wrong. If we analyze carefully, we ourselves are guilty. We are responsible of the anger within our minds. So clearly, we are responsible of our inner suffering, our mental suffering. It is important in this context to distinguish between physical and mental suffering.

Physical suffering is suffering which is caused by exterior material entities. These exterior material entities are the cause of physical suffering and there is a somewhat tenuous relationship with mental suffering. Mental suffering on the other hand is an inner experience. If one conflicts the two and considers that physical and mental suffering are the same, this gives rise to great problems. It’s extremely important to differentiate physical and mental suffering, and this can be done through the study of Luric.

Then if we take the example of anger, independence on what does anger arise. Overwhelmingly, arises independence on living beings. It does occur that anger arises independence on matter, but it is rare. Then when anger arises in dependence on a living being, this living being which is the target or the focus of anger, how precisely do we perceive it? We perceive this living being, this person, as unpleasant, as someone which we cannot stand to see.

And the question we have to ask ourselves is, is this outlook inherent in the other person or not. If this outlook were inherent, if the unpleasantness was inherent in the other person, then clearly everybody else would also find this pleasant, this person unpleasant. This is generally speaking never the case, which means it comes from our own mind. Do you understand? Then clearly this anger arises from our own side, from within our own mind.

How does it arise? Through a repeated process of imputation or of projection of unpleasant qualities on the other party. This leads to the other leads to the other party being someone which we can barely stand to see. What is the origin of this anger? Its origin is the I.

I in Tibet, in English, not in Tibetan. In other words, self grasping. Then this is a difficult topic, but ultimately, meets the eye. Then in all of us, the I is very hard, very resilient. If we can loosen it a bit, then we will be we will be much happier in our lives.

Is a strange language. You cannot speak in English without saying I. It is unlike Tibetan other languages. This is the nature of the language. It’s a very interesting point in English grammar that if you do not formulate the personal pronoun I, the sentence is meaningless.

In Tibetan, however, it is unnecessary to give the personal pronoun. We just give the verb that’s sufficient. I I am I am drink. Drink? No.

I am drink. Am teaching. When Nisela says I am teaching in English, he must use a personal pronoun, I. If he doesn’t, it makes no sense. In Tibetan, you just say, I’m teaching.

And this very powerful sense of I arises naturally, doesn’t it? And now, in the context of generating the motivation, we will try to generate a motivation not to engage in the 10 non virtuous deeds. If we’re not able to do this precisely, at least we should generate the motivation not to engage in mistaken karmic behavior. Therefore, one should strive to generate a firm conviction in karma and causality. This firm conviction in karma and causality is none other than a firm conviction in the dharma which the Buddha taught and is practiced by the Sangha.

Independence on this conviction, one should try in turn to experience the unmistaken ripening of karma and causality. This is the path one should follow and not going in a temple, folding one’s hands and praying. This may not lead to any benefit. In Vinaya, there is an extremely detailed analysis of the basis on which non virtuous deeds arise. Do they arise independence on exterior material conditions or do they arise independent on living beings?

In other words, do they arise independence on non living or living beings? In our case, we do not have to engage in such detailed studies since in Vinaya, the objects of abandonment are countless. Whereas in our case, there are only 10 objects of abandonment, the 10 non virtues. This is what we should study. You understand?

10 non virtues. Yeah. Yeah. Then this is what one should study, and I’d like to ask you to list the 10 non virtues. Lily, do you understand?

Malice. And wrong view. Alright. That’s enough for you. Okay.

If you could speak up a little bit. It’s no problem if you don’t remember listening to someone who reads or recites them and try to remember them as he recites. The best is to recite them in sequence. The three non the three physical non virtues, the four verbal non virtues, which makes seven, and the three mental non virtues. Literally in Tibetan, the three of body, speech, mind.

Yeah. Matthew. Anasuji? It’s very important to memorize the 10 non virtues in sequence because they are listed in terms of their importance. These three physical virtues are listed from the heaviest to the lightest.

Killing is the heaviest, then stealing, then sexual misconduct which is the lightest. The phonon virtues of speech are listed from the heaviest to the lightest. First lying, then divisive speech, then harsh words, and then idle talk. In the case of the three of mind, it is the opposite order which is adopted, from the lightest to the heaviest. First, covetousness, then ill will, then wrong views.

So some of you got the order of the 10 non virtues mixed up. Try to remember them in sequence because a sequence defines or identifies the weight of the non virtue. For instance, if you take the three physical non virtues, if you remember that killing is the first physical non virtue, you will know immediately it is the heaviest. Then you will study to try to understand why it is the heaviest. That is what improves your study.

Mhmm. And then maybe do you understand? Yeah. Yeah. Please.

Same. Not forgot your name. Could you repeat the first one, please? One. Look, I’m eager.

If you all speak softer than this, your translator risks to fall on the piano. My ears cannot stretch that far. So first three are can you hear? Not yet? Okay.

So killing Machipalent. Misconduct. And sexual healing sexual misconduct. The the verbal ones are The makimigua. Lying.

Is he? He’s the heaviest. And then I don’t think I didn’t really memorize them properly. When you the others recite them, take them down a note. It’ll be of benefit to you.

Oh, yeah. Yeah. It’s like Hello? And you gave them last time, but when you gave him, you put ignorance instead of wrong views. It’s wrong views.

And Karen? Karen? From the case attachment Mhmm. Yeah. Yeah.

The order was a bit mixed up. Very important, you know, when you sigh. Order. Order. And Susie?

Is mind is covetedness ill will No. Same. Wrong views. Mhmm. And he’s going back to the third one of speech.

So the way to remember these is in terms of three subdivisions, body, speech, mind, three of the body, four of the speech, three of the mind. So the way to study these is to ask, for instance, on which base, on which foundation do they arise. If we take the case of killing, for instance, it necessarily arises on the basis of a living being. It cannot arise on the basis of a nonliving being. Then we should investigate regarding theft and sexual misconduct, what the base is.

If we take killing, killing’s base is necessary necessarily a sentient being whose continuum is different from ours. Now let’s take the case of stealing quickly. What’s the base of stealing? Sexual misconduct. What’s the base of sexual misconduct?

Then that’s for the three physical ones. What about the four verbal ones and lying? What’s the base of lying? So in the case of lying, the base of lying is both a person and speech. Since if lie a lie is not understood, it is not the kind of lying which is accrued.

Mhmm. And in addition, speech must be uttered. Mhmm. What about divisive speech? In other words, it depends on beings or persons other than oneself and on speech.

What about harsh words? What basis does covetousness arise upon? Spell. In Tibetan, to covet, serve the mind. It arises on many basis, not only possessions, but also living beings.

What about ill will? Living or non living Yes. Indeed. Overwhelmingly living beings, but also it happens to arise towards things. What about wrong views?

Instances which are given are the four noble truths, the triple gem, and karma and causality. So this is how one should study. And to take the example of the four verbal non virtues, one should analyze why the first ones are heavier and the latter ones are lighter. At this point, it is important to understand what is the opposite of the 10 non virtues. In other words, the 10 virtues are.

And the Buddhist scriptures, the Buddhist texts state that to understand fully the 10 non virtues, one must initially understand the unfortunate consequences of the 10 non virtues, which are suffering both for future lives and even for this life. At this point, once one understands for instance, the faults of the non virtuous deed of killing, then one engages in restraint towards the towards engagement in the basis of the deed of killing. And this is a non virtue the virtuous deed of abstention from killing. And, therefore, it is through understanding the faults of a nonvirtuous deed and restraining in engaging in the basis of that non virtuous deed that the corresponding virtue is accumulated. For instance, in the case of killing, if one understands the faults of killings and on that basis, abstains from engaging in the deed of killing, this is a virtuous deed.

Otherwise, if one merely abstains from killing, this is not a virtuous deed. Generally speaking, of the 10 non virtues, nine, the non virtues from killing all the way up to ill will are natural non virtues. The tenth non virtue, Ram views, is not a natural nonvirtue. There is an important difference in this respect between non virtuous and virtuous deeds. If one engages in the deed of killing on a base which is appropriate for such a base, the non virtue of killing is accrued.

On the other hand, the mere abstention from killing on a base, which would be a base for killing, does not lead to the virtue of abstaining from killing. There is a difference. Then at present, I will take questions. So within the 10 non virtues, nine are natural non virtues. In other words, whether one is a dharma practitioner or not, if one engages in the first nine non virtues, one accumulates nonvirtue.

At this point, the doubt might arise. After all, if one merely engages in a deed on a basis, which is appropriate for their deed, such as the deed of killing, the non virtue of killing is accumulated. Is the converse true regarding the virtue of abstaining from killing? In other words, if one just abstains from killing on a basis, living being, which is appropriate for abstaining from killing of, does one accumulate virtue? The answer is no.

One does not accumulate virtue. One must also be aware of the faults, the defects of killing such a being. There is asymmetry in other words. As Shantideva says in his Bodhi Satva, Chariavatara, therefore, restraining from non virtue out of heedfulness continually, one will accumulate merit as vast as space. Clearly, if one restrains from nonvirtue with such such an intention, then one will accumulate vast amounts of virtue.

Even while while sleeping. Therefore, the accumulation of these nine virtues is quite difficult. It is not enough to merely abstain from committing the non virtues on a given basis. When once one has reached that point whether one sleeps, one eats, or one is walking around, one will accumulate virtue. These are the benefits of ethics.

Yeah. Need to wrap up your question. With regards non virtue of wrong views, Jill and I have got a couple of questions that are related to each other. Does the person committing the wrong view need to have understood, for example, what the three jewels are and to have fully understood it, not just to sort of hear the words or something, to actually understand it and then deny it for them to have a wrong view? Or is it enough for them to just be extremely sceptical and deny it straight out.

No. I don’t think it is necessary to have understood the qualities and the characteristics of the triple gem to accumulate wrong views with respect to the triple gem. Sorry, mister. So just to clarify, would the person need to have believed that the triple gem does exist and then That’s one of the forms of wrong views. And another.

The other question that came out of our discussion group earlier was again regarding wrong views. It being a mental non virtue is the deed complete if the denial of say the Triple Gem is a mental denial or does it have to be a verbal denunciation? No. The case of wrong views is a case of mental non virtues. Therefore, it is not necessarily related to speech at all.

It can occur exclusively within the mind. Okay. So with wrong views, if someone hasn’t been introduced to Buddhism or but don’t know about the philosophy at all, would they be already committing that non virtue? There’s no definiteness. It’s not because one isn’t a Buddhist that one is accumulating wrong views.

No definiteness. It’s not certain, in other words. I just had a question about If there was a person who was hoarding a vast amount of food and you stole from that person to feed a starving child, is that a non virtue? Yes. It would be an un virtuous deed of stealing.

So in the Buddhist treatises, your question is good, but in the Buddhist treatises, you accumulate the non virtue of stealing. Good, clever, but Good question, but the fold is accumulated. So Geshe asked if he will think about it. He asked me to give an example I have. Imagine someone who’s quite silly and has a car accident, and then holds his car responsible for the accident and kicks the car.

Then there is in will towards the material object. So it is definitely a thought whether it is vandalism. In other words, whether vandalism is ill will is another question since the mind of these young people is troubled. Then for it to call count as a non virtue, the mind must be able to understand the consequences. Just further on to my question was asked earlier about lying about So in the example you mentioned in the Jatakas, the Buddha was a merchant on a ship with 500 other merchants and realized that one of the passengers was a criminal planning on murdering all these merchants, and he killed the criminal out of compassion.

In this specific case, the criminal had a clear plan to murder these 500 other passengers, and to save them, the Buddha killed him. One must differentiate here between two motivations. The profound or the core motivation is compassion. The proximate motivation is killing. Since approximate motivation is a motivation of murder, a complete deed of killing will have occurred.

Mhmm. With regarding abstaining from the 10 wrong virtues and in here there’s an example of abstaining from killing a sheep would I actually have to have the opportunity to kill that sheep in order to actually abstain from killing it? Or would it be enough for me to just see the sheep, know that I couldn’t kill it, but in any case, decide to abstain from killing it? Yes. You need to have the opportunity to kill the bases which would be killed to be able to abstain from this.

Yeah. Yeah. Here, stop today tonight. Thank you. Yeah.

Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top