Tenets — 2014-08-12

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets — 2014-08-12
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-08-12 – KR.mp3

UUID: 6a1f2e72-ad68-4a64-80eb-ed9bfb650d21

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2014-08-12

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 25m

Words: 3,175

Regarding generating the motivation, it is easier to generate a virtuous motivation when one’s mind initially was in a virtuous state. If that is not the case, and one’s mind has fallen under the sway of desire or of hatred, it is much more difficult to generate a virtuous motivation. It is therefore necessary to bring one’s back one’s mind back to a neutral state, and on this basis, to generate a virtuous motivation. Bringing the mind back to a state can be done as was explained previously through the nine full cycle of breathing. Let us therefore generate a good motivation for a couple seconds.

So I will ask you at present three questions. Think carefully before you answer the questions. The first is the definition of evaibhashika. The second is the uncommon mode of presentation of the three times in the Vaibhashika system of thought. And the third is regarding indivisible particles.

Do you accept their existence or not? And give reasons in both cases. So the first question, what is the definition of Then if you don’t know the definition, the meaning of is okay. Let’s just answer verbally. Then would the others please present the definition of a Vaibhashika in keeping with your understanding?

Pretty much the same as Rao. So existence of phenomenon three times, don’t accept reflexive consciousness, except indivisible particles. So, obviously, you should answer in keeping with the text. Right? The definition should be in accordance with the text.

When you say accepts outer objects as substantially existing, what do you mean? Basically, that is probably okay, but it is best if you can formulate the definition as it is given in Jisuncuki Gilson’s tenets. A Vaibhashika is a person who asserts lower vehicle tenets accepting outer objects as truly established and not accepting reflexive consciousness on page three. Do you understand? Everyone, So does everyone understand the definition of a Vaibhashika?

100%? Yeah. Yeah. Good. So the second question, the presentation of the three times.

So this is an important question. The presentation of the three times is uncommon or specific to the Vaibhashika. What is the difference in the presentation of the three times and why? An example is the appearance of the table being the same yesterday, today and tomorrow. It’s the same table.

It’s unchanging. So when I I say the specific or the uncommon presentation of the three times in Vaibhashika, it’s because it’s different from that in the higher schools, such as the Sautrantika, the Chitamatha, and the Madhyamika. What is that difference? The nature of phenomena don’t change over time they have a wild phenomena exist, while they’re in existence and could be perceived they their nature doesn’t change while the characteristics do think higher schools see that their nature is impermanent as well. So there’s a quality of permanence of phenomenon.

I think that the Vibhavashikas hold that the past, present, and the future are all truly existent. They are not dependent upon one another. They have an independent an independent reality. So the past is the past. The present is the present, and the future is the future.

And that there is a continuum of in in the in the case of of phenomena other than, I guess, including mine. But for example, the table. The table has a continuum that is truly existent in each of those times until it is destroyed. In the higher schools such as the Prasangika Madhyamika, The uncommon Vaibhashikha view of the three times, which differentiates it from the higher schools of tenants, is to take the example of the table in front of me, that the Vaibhashikas, broadly speaking, agree with the common sense view that yesterday’s table, today’s table, and tomorrow’s table are the same. The nature of the table does not change, it is merely incidental features of the table which change.

Therefore, they do not accept the disintegration instant by instant of the table. The example which is traditionally given is that of milk transforming into yogurt, where the potency and the taste do transform, but the color does not. So the Vaibhashikas do accept officially at least that phenomena are impermanent and that persons lack or persons are empty of being permanent one and independent. But in practice, if we were to take the case of this table, if Ayrbashikha would say, this table is not impermanent because yesterday’s table, today’s table and tomorrow’s table are the same. On the other hand, a Vaibhashika would not accept that this table is permanent because this table is eventually destroyed.

The higher schools of tenets, on the other hand, consider that at the very instant of establishment or creation of the table, that table is of the nature of destruction and destruction proceeds onwards. So this is the uncommon difference of the Vaibhashika presentation of the three times and that of the higher schools of tenets. And then the third question, indivisible particles according to Vaibhashika. I would like you to reflect and after reflection take position. Do indivisible particles in accordance with Vaibhashika exist or not?

If they exist, give a reason for their existence. If they don’t exist, give a reason for their non existence. Chris? According to the Vaibhashika, partless particles indivisible particles exist. Although they are invisible, they are they have six directions, the particle points and the apex and the sphere.

None of these points that make up the directions of the particles is in contact with the other. They are separated by space but are nevertheless invisible. And that they do not they are not dependent arisings. They have inherent existence. And You said they are in space.

Right? There’s no contact, you said? They they have no contact. And so not they’re not that it’s What I’d like to ask you is, do these Vaibhashika partless particles exist, or don’t they exist? Why?

Why? Why? You know? Because there are not dependent arisings. Because of all the penurizers.

I agree with what Pamela said about them, but I’m not scientific but I think if you get right down to a final thing that is essentially established from its own side, you know, that this truly exists, not a dependent arising, I have a problem with that. I’m saying that by Roshikazar. No, but I thought you said you thought they truly existed. No, thought the question was about personal view. Yeah, personal view.

I’m sure you said. Yes. Yes. Was gonna say, Pat was saying they truly exist. No.

No. Cause and effect. There’s a problem with cause and effect. No. No.

Maybe Pat needs the mic. No. No. No. Don’t exist totally dependent arising’s evanescence.

Vaibhashikas consider that the indivisible particle is an example of an ultimate truth, that is which is not destroyed when the mind apprehending it is eliminated. And they consider that is the conglomeration of these particles that makes up the an object. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

So Geshela is not asking what the Vaibhashika view is. Geshela wants to know what you think. Do you accept it or not? I try to accept the higher school view, which is that everything is an imputation. But in in in my daily life, I probably live as if things do exist truly.

So what does that have to do with particles? The literally said, in your answer, where are the partless particles? They they are the the conglomeration. I can only talk in abstract terms but I would assert that indivisible particles doesn’t exist because you just keep going into infinity but when I think about an object breaking it down in a continuous way so that’s where I’ve gone from an external object down to the sub atomic level and my mind just keeps going into infinity. You don’t accept.

So I can’t accept theoretically that that can exist. I think that the world is made up of atoms, which are not not partless. They have lots and lots and lots of parts. And the farther we look, the more parts they seem to have. Each of those things themselves, if they are indivisible, and not all of them are, so only electrons appear to be indivisible at this point.

They have aspects of properties, not they aren’t sort of things in themselves. They only exist in conjunction with other things. They’re not free they they don’t exist freely. And so I think that everything is pretty much nonexistent at an ultimate level. Lily.

I’m not sure if I recall Stephen Hawking’s assertions correctly or not but I can’t rely on quantum physics to describe emptiness because I recall Stephen Hawking making an assertion that a quantum particle cannot arise from no cause but an entire universe can. So whatever quantum physics does in terms of dividing particles they don’t necessarily take into account cause and effect. So I have to rely on logic as to whether a particle is divisible or not and logically if these so called indivisible particles have a top and a bottom they have parts. Whether or not the matter can be divided into two, three or four other bits, they definitely have parts. So there’s no indivisible particle.

So Geshela asked me whether I accepted the existence of indivisible particles in accordance with Vaibhashika, and if not, why? And I told him, no, don’t accept the existence at all because fundamentally, every attempt made by physicists to break up particles has basically failed or succeed in dependence on the amount of power used. And there’s no evidence at present that if greater amounts of power were used, presently considered indivisible particles such as quarks could not be divided at some later date. So for that reason, even though some physicists assert that quarks are the fundamental particles, but personally, I believe fundamental particles in keeping with Vibachika do not exist. So if you have understood the presentation of the three times and of partless particles in accordance with Vibhashika, and you are sympathetic to this view, this view would be your role.

And I have another question for you. Please explain the distinction between the view in Hinayana and Mahayana on the one hand and the method in Hinayana and Mahayana on the other hand. Then since this is a difficult topic, I will ask you to analyze it in terms of logical possibilities, which we explained briefly at TBI a couple of months ago. There are four logical possibilities or four moves between the view of the lower vehicle and the dharma of the lower vehicle. Something may be both the view and the dharma of the lower vehicle.

Something may be the view of the lower vehicle, but not the dharma of the lower vehicle. Something may be the dharma of the lower vehicle, but not the view of the lower vehicle, and something may be neither. And I will therefore answer the four moves because it’s a difficult question. So first, what is an instance of someone who is both a practitioner of Hinayana dharma and a holder of the Hinayana view? This would be a Shravaka who upholds the Vaibhashika system of tenets.

Then who would be an upholder of Hinayana dharma, but not of Hinayana view, this would be a this would be a Chitamatra Shravaka. Such Chitamatra, Shravakas do exist. Then who would be an upholder of Hinayana view, but not of Hinayana dharma? This would be a Vaibhashika bodhisattva. Since they are bodhisattvas who uphold the Vaibhashika view.

Finally, who would be neither an upholder of Hinayana dharma nor of Hinayana view, Arjana Gajuna. Someone who is neither an upholder of Hinayana dharma nor an upholder of the Hinayana view. And why is the differentiation between the Hinayana view and the Hinayana dharma made? It is made because someone who upholds the Hinayana view is someone who starts out of the premise of the existence of partless particles and constructs on this basis a presentation of the two truths, conventional ultimate truths, and of method and wisdom. On the other hand, when we speak of Hinayana dharma, we are speaking of a dharma practice focused on one’s own welfare alone, which begins with a presentation of the four noble truths or of the 37 factors of enlightenment.

So this is all I have to say on these topics. At present, we will pass to the seventh subdivision of the Vaibhashika School on page six of your English translation, the presentation of grounds and paths, and initially, a presentation of the objects of abandonment. The Vaibhashika considered that there are two categories of afflictions, which are objects of abandonment. The first are afflicted objects of abandonment and the second are non afflicted objects of abandonment. An instance of the first afflicted objects of abandonment would be for instance, the ignorance which apprehends a self of persons or the three poisons.

And regarding a non afflicted obstructions, Nivaya Bashikas do not use the term afflictions to omniscience, but an instance of non afflicted obstructions would be the karmic imprints for the appearance of a self, of persons. Other examples of afflicted obstructions would be the seeds for the apprehension of a self of persons, whereas examples of non afflicted obstructions would be the comic imprints for the apprehension of a self of persons. Mhmm. Then there is a difference between scenes and comic imprints. Since, for instance, the seeds arise independent on a previous potency within the continuum and we would say that the seeds of anger, the seeds of desire, the seeds of the apprehension of a self, of persons, exist within the continuum of ordinary beings.

These seeds, however, do not exist in the continuum of an Achat. Karmic imprints to this effect do exist, however, within the continuum of an Arhat. Therefore, whole whatever is a seed is necessarily a comic imprint. Whatever is whatever is a comic imprint is not necessarily a seed. Then today, we won’t have debate since I put you under a lot of pressure, but if you have questions, please feel free to ask them.

So the notion or the the meaning of obstructions to omissions exists within Vaibhashika, but the term obstructions to omissions is not used. Technically obstructions to omissions are obstructions which prevent the simultaneous realization of those truths, conventional and ultimate truths. I just want to correct myself from I think about a month ago when I asked a question regarding reflexive consciousness putting karmic imprints down and I went back and reread Alexander Berzin and he does not say that reflexive consciousness is responsible for putting the karmic imprints in. I misread his term mental impression and I thought that meant karmic imprint. So I just wanted to correct myself.

He would have been been in for a very big scolding otherwise. It’s a strange way of putting things. That’s why Geshela didn’t understand it. Another question? Do you have another question?

Good. Come. Come. Have you got have you got another question. Yes.

This is. If one conceives the tenet schools as different in terms of the basis, the path, and the results. Does is it appropriate to say that the basis relates to physical how things are physically and how things are mentally the nature physical phenomena, the nature of mental phenomena, that the path relates to the view relating to selflessness of either persons or phenomena and the objects of abandonment and cultivation and that the result relates to obstructions to liberation and obstructions to knowledge or omniscience. Is that is that is that an appropriate way? Do you want do you want to see my notes here?

I have a good memory. Well, first, the objects of abandonment are not part of, the result but of the base. And, secondly, within the path, you must include the the method component. The what? The method component.

Method component. Method. Method component. But isn’t isn’t I had put the objects of abandonment on path as part of method. I mean, I I was thinking of it as method, not as part of the basis.

No. It’s not possible to put objects of abandonment on the path. Objects of abandonment must be part of the base. The result that I mentioned was the extinguishment of obstructions to liberation and obstructions to knowledge. Yes.

Indeed, the extinction the extinction of the obstructions to liberation and to omniscience would be part of the result, whereas the extinguishing would be part of the path. We’ll be starting grounds and paths pretty soon. Molly? Go ahead. Oh.

Bad. Geshela, could you explain a little bit more the difference between karmic imprints and seeds? Because I’ve often used them interchangeably in terms of their consequence, how they what follows on from them, in what way are they different? Then next week, I will give a detailed presentation of the difference between karmic imprints and scenes. Under objects abandonment, is there an afflicted version and a non afflicted version for each of the different tenant schools?

And is the non afflicted object of abandonment, is that is that for is that for an Arahat? Definitely, in the Vaibhashika system, there are non afflicted objects of abandonment within the continuum of an Arhat, and examples of that are given. Yes. There is such a distinction made probably in the Sautrantika school. Because the presentation of grounds and paths in Sartratanka is identical.

Okay. Just the last time we met, which seems like an age ago, I did ask about the affirming negatives and the non affirming negatives and Geshela said he would explain about those next time. Because there are no non affirming negatives in the Vaibhashika system, I won’t explain it. But Baibashika does not accept non affirming negatives. For the general malas, the surface of persons is a non affirm is an affirming negative.

They don’t accept the existence of non affirming negatives. All the other schools do. And since the Sartrannikas don’t accept a presentation of non affirming negatives, it seems a bit pointless to explain what a non affirming negative is. However, since the Sartrannikas do accept a difference between non affirming and affirming negatives, I present the difference in that context. My vague common sense notion of the recall of memory or the memory process seems to involve something like reflexive awareness.

So I can kind of understand that a tenant system that believes in reflexive awareness I can kind of have this vague notion of how memories are recalled according to that tenant system but I have no idea how the Vibashikas assert memories are recalled when they have no reflexive awareness. I was wondering if Vigeshi could comment on this. It is the Chittamatras which assert that reflexive consciousness is a prerequisite for memory. This is not a position in asserted by the other schools. For instance, the Vaibhashikas consider that experience is sufficient for memory.

Maybe we shall stop here for today.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
shravaka nyen thö (Tib)
A hearer; a Hinayana practitioner who strives for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a teacher. There are four divisions: stream-enterer, once-returner, non-returner and arhat. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top