Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-08-27 – KR.mp3
UUID: acf11353-a5bb-4cc6-bdda-498ed4cb2c17
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2014-08-27
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 36m
Words: 3,927
So at present, we will generate the motivation to listen to these teachings. And when we say to generate the motivation, we do so because at present, generally speaking, our mind is under the sway of the three poisons. However, should our mind be under the sway of a virtuous state of mind, there would be no necessity to generate the motivation. As Buddha Shakyamuni said, I believe in a sutra, just as I am the doctor and the dharma is a medicine, you are the patients. And in this context, we ourselves are indeed in the situation of patients who are seeking for cure for their ailment.
Now, should a patient seeking for cure for his ailment gather lots of medicine and instead of putting this medicine to practical use, stack it on a pile, in a pile in front of him, what benefit would there be? We ourselves, therefore, attend the teachings of the dharma, and I myself explain as much as I can the teachings, but we attend the teachings to put them in practice. The lamrim should be generated within us. It should be for our own sake. We should not view the lamrim as a movie or a show on the outside of us, but instead as something which should be for our own benefit.
As a king in a passage which we quoted previously said, I look at the thoughts within my mind as I look at the blemishes on my face within a mirror. Then if the Lamrim is seen as a means to subdue inappropriate states of mind, then definitely over time, there will be improvement. Then I believe that the benefits of the lum rim are to lead us to the point where we no longer attach complete importance to exterior object. This is not to deny that they have some importance, but we do not attach complete importance to them, and we understand that inner happiness arises from deep within the mind. And therefore, as said, whatever is not engaged in out of a virtuous frame of mind either leads to the lower rebirth or is only of benefit in this life.
Therefore, there is one category of practitioner who after reflecting on death and impermanence reflects on the lower rebirth. As was mentioned, there are two such categories of beings, and if we refer to the outline of the path of the being of the small scope, we can see the subdivided into two, generating a mind which strives for future worlds or future rebirth, and teaching the means for happiness in future worlds or future rebirth. Now, the first subdivision includes training the mind in an understanding of death and impermanence of the suffering of the lower realms and of karma and causality. However, let us take a being who has turned away from the vanities of this life, who already from the beginning is not attached to this life. Does such a being fall within either of these two categories of the being of the small scope or not?
This is a doubt we should have and it’s a doubt I would like you to examine. Then if one doesn’t examine or study the outline of the lumbrim catholic, this doubt will not arise. These doubts are worth having. Then, basically, we should reflect on future lives, but it is in a sense irrelevant whether future lives exist or not. It is not future lives in general which matter.
It is our own future lives and what sort of a future life we will have. Then, ideally, we would generate definiteness by means of a valid cognizer regarding future lives. But if that is not possible, at least a conviction which cannot be overturned, this would be excellent. Then looking as said in the gradual stages of the path regarding future lives, The reason for this is that the intended trainees of the Lamrim were Tibetans, and Tibetans basically without exception believed in the existence of past and future lives. They believed in this out of a profound faith without any particular rationale.
Since they have not studied, and without study, there is no rationale which can be given for the existence of past and future lives. But if I were to say to a Tibetan, if you keep on behaving in this way, things are gonna go poorly for you in future lives, they would be terrified. This is obviously not our case. So for us, it is important ideally to generate definiteness by means of a valid cognizer in the existence of future lives. And if this is not possible, at least a conviction which cannot be overturned.
But this is difficult without study. And, therefore, it is important for us to generate a conviction in the existence of future lives, but not any conviction, a conviction which is rooted in reasons. When this conviction arises, then it will be very easy for us to practice dharma. Let us take an example, the example of worldly affairs. We know very well that for a job to be well done, there’s a certain way in which the job must be done.
And if we have a good worker and he does a job well, the result will be in keeping with his efforts. And even though the person engages in great efforts to complete the job, they face no particular difficulty in doing this because they know this is how the job has to be done and at the end there will be a good result as a result of these efforts. The same thing is true for dharma. Once we are convinced in the existence of future lives, then whatever hardship we endure for the practice of dharma will cause us no inner difficulties, instead we will rejoice knowing that we will reap the fruit of this in the future. Dharma is totally unrelated to this life.
And, therefore, ideally, we would orient our minds 100% towards virtue, but this is not easy. If we can, therefore, orient our minds 60 or 70% towards virtue, then over time, our mental disposition will increase in power and our situation will improve. As Shantideva says in the Bodhisattva Acharya Avatara, after having paid your employee this body, his salary, put him to labor at your service. And indeed, after having taken care of one’s body and one’s health, one has to put one’s body to one’s service to enable one to get a higher rebirth in the future. Then clearly, if one has focused one one’s mind 100% on virtue, one will have given up, one will have abandoned the body of this life.
This is very difficult to do. However, we can focus our mind mainly on virtue, in the direction or the orientation of virtue. And therefore, please let us generate together for a couple minutes a good motivation to listen to these teachings. This should be a motivation to subdue, to tame one’s unruly minds and with this as a motivation to listen to the teachings. So the issue arose last time whether it was necessary to meditate whether the sequence of meditation on the topics of the Lamrim was definite or not.
The answer is it is not definite. Since, for instance, if we take the issue of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. If you look at the outline, you can see that it is subdivided into two, inciting one to take the essence of such a base of leisure and the manner of taking such an essence. The manner of taking such an essence in turn is divided into various cycles of meditation of the lamrim. Now clearly, someone who already is taking the essence of such a human rebirth of leisure and endowment does not really need to engage in meditations on the human rebirth of leisure and endowment.
They are for those who are not taking the essence of this rebirth yet. Then we had broached the topic of refuge. And as you remember, the sequence of topics of meditation leading to a refuge within the practice of the being of the small scope are first reconnecting death and impermanence, and then meditating on the sufferings of the lower realms. These are presented in terms of the sequence in which they must be generated in the mind stream to lead to refuge. So, initially, one meditates on death and impermanence that generates definiteness regarding this, then on the sufferings of the lower realms, and then on refuge.
In this context, a doubt arises. Clearly, someone who has meditated on death and impermanence has turned away from the vanities of this life. Then, what sort of refuge and why is it necessary for such a one to generate refuge after that? That is already an extraordinary achievement in its own sake. Then someone who has definiteness regarding death and impermanence will be someone who has turned away from the vanities of this life.
How does someone who has turned away from the vanities of this life proceed then towards refuge? Clearly, at the time of death, there are two possible fears we experience. The first is the fear of being separated from our worldly possessions. The second is the fear which arises in the mind upon dying when one thinks, where on earth should I be reborn? What will happen to me?
Someone who has turned away from the vanities of this life will not experience the first fear, but will definitely experience a second fear thinking, where on earth shall I be reborn? And this is what leads to refuge. Do you understand? Really? Oh, Good.
Good student. And at this point, when one wonders where shall I be reborn, one searches for something which can protect us from the sufferings of cyclic existence in general and of the lower realms in particular. It is not, however, the abstract sufferings of cyclic existence and of the lower realms we need protection from, but the sufferings of our own cyclic existence in our own future lower realms. And when searching for this, one finds the the certainty that the triple gem alone can offer such protection. At this point, one goes for refuge to the triple gem with a certainty that the triple gem protects from suffering in the lower realms.
But this is not sufficient for pure refuge. In addition to searching for refuge, independence on this fear, one needs a second cause. This is the conviction in the capacity of the object of refuge to protect us from such suffering. When these two are conjoined, one has pure refuge. This is really important.
Do you understand? Really? It’s really good. When they should ask you to understand, you’ve understood everything. You see, when you ask Tibetans, have you understood?
No one dares to say, I have understood. Right? They just say, but you all have understood. See, you never Tibetans never say, I’ve understood when you ask, have you understood? An example is given in this matter of Geelong’s bhikshus who have attained the state of an Arhat.
They bear a particular name. It’s a topic which is difficult to understand. That’s very good. If you have understood, you say you have understood. If you haven’t understood, you say you haven’t understood.
And, therefore, when in addition to having within one’s mind stream, the first cause of searching for or taking refuge, which is the conviction that the triple gem can protect us from the suffering of the lower realms and of cyclic existence in general. In addition, we have the conviction in the qualities of the triple gem, which enable the triple gem to do this, then full refuge will be generated. So within the presentation of refuge within your outline at the back of liberation of the palm of your hand, if you follow there, you can see that refuge is subdivided into five points. The first of which is independence on which causes does one go for refuge. This has been presented.
And the second is to which object does one go for refuge? To which object does one go for refuge? To the triple gem. In other words, to the Buddha, to the Dharma, and to the Sangha. And one must ideally generate a valid cognition of these.
But if this is not possible, at least conviction in them. Why is it definite that there are three objects of refuge and neither less nor more? There is a being who has taught refuge. We can take Buddha Shakyamuni as this being, our teacher. Then the actual refuge are the teachings and the commentaries, of Buddha Shakyamuni.
And, ideally, we should generate a valid cognition of these, or if this is not possible, at least generate excuse me, a valid cognizer of these, or if this is not possible, at least generate a strong conviction in them since it is those scriptures and commentaries which protect our mind. Finally, who practices appropriately these teachings, who else if not the Sangha. Now if we understand the triple gem in this way, we can take refuge rationally. Otherwise, just to take refuge, saying I take refuge into Buddhadharma and sangha is not terribly helpful. Let us take, for instance, his holiness Dalai Lama or, teacher in whose minds there are valid experiences and realizations.
Independence on whose teachings did valid experiences and realizations arise in the minds of these great beings, independence on the teachings of Buddha Shakyamuni. So if we understand it in this way, we can take refuge in the triple gem rationally. Do you understand? Then we take refuge in the authentic teachings, the scriptures, the commentaries, the shastras, which were taught by Buddha Shakyamuni and those who follow it. It is for this reason that we have three objects of refuge and not one object of refuge.
Otherwise, you would have one object of refuge. And therefore, we are shown the path these great beings have taken to the attainment of all the grounds and and paths from the very beginning until their complete attainment, and we are encouraged by them to follow this path. As we are encouraged by them to follow this path, when we engage in this path, we have true refuge, and this true refuge is a refuge in three objects. If on the other hand, we do not engage in the path and we normally have faith alone, then perhaps three objects are not necessary, perhaps one object will be perfectly okay. Now when one attempts to understand the difference between being a Buddhist and a non Buddhist, it is critical to understand what is the triple gem protects from.
The triple gem protects from the fear of the lower realms and of cyclic existence, and these two fear must be fears must be understood as protected from conjointly. Why is this the case? The triple gem protects and gives refuge through leading to liberation. This is the means whereby the triple gem gives refuge and protects. However, it is clear that if we are reborn in the lower left, and this is up to us to analyze, it will not be possible for us to attain liberation.
Therefore, on what basis is it possible for us to attain liberation? It is possible for us to attain liberation on the basis of a happy rebirth. What are we talking about when we talk of a happy rebirth? Precisely what we have now, and we need happy rebirth after happy rebirth after happy rebirth. Therefore, the triple gem protects both from the lower rebirth and from the sufferings of cyclic existence in general.
And the topic of refuge is subdivided, as was mentioned, into five. Independence on which cause does one go for refuge, to which object does one go for refuge, what is the criterion of having taken refuge therein, what are the advantages of having gone for refuge, and what are the precepts of refuge. It is extremely important to understand these five topics. So we shall stop here for today, and if you have questions, I will take a couple of questions. Actually I noted that you said dharma is totally unrelated to this life that confuses me a bit does that mean nothing I take from dharma will affect me in this life or have I misunderstood that?
Dharma practice will lead to happiness in this in this life in the following way. When you engage in the practice of dharma, your contentment with whatever happiness you have will increase, and you will no longer seek to increase your wealth, to increase your general situation, health, and so forth. As a result of this, you will have happiness in this life. Contentment with the happiness one has is the foremost road to happiness. It is precisely because we lack contentment that we are unhappy.
Then another question. My question is similar to the one that I had last time. A stable refuge and a good rebirth are still two different things, aren’t they? Does make sense? So if one has pure and authentic refuge, in other words, refuge which has arisen independence on the two causes.
The first is the conviction that the triple gem can protect us from the general sufferings of cyclic existence, as well as the specific sufferings of the lower realms. And the second is the profound conviction that the triple gem has the power and the capacities to do this. When such a refuge has arisen, then naturally one puts in practice the refuge precepts. And putting in practice the refuge precepts, I believe it is certain one will not be reborn in the lower realms. Sam, here come.
Geshele, could you please provide a wider definition around valid cognition of the triple gem and a fair conviction in the triple gem? When we define when you define that. I will explain later the difference in detail between the two. Another question? Geshela said, we take refuge in the authentic teachings taught by Buddha Shakyamuni and those who followed him is for this reason we have three objects of refuge and not just one.
So to clarify the definition of the Sangha are those that followed Buddha Shakyamuni, the teachers that followed Buddha Shakyamuni, is that the definition of? Generally speaking, no. The to be a member of the Sangha jewel, one must have attained the path of an Arya being. So for instance, if you have an ordinary monk who has not attained the path of an arya being, such an ordinary monk is not the Sangha jewel, but such an ordinary monk is terminologically a Sangha jewel. Likewise, the 12 branches of scripture are not the dharma jewel, but terminologically, they are called the dharma jewel.
Definitely. If you meditate on the suffering which the afflictions cause and fear that, this is a very effective means of giving rise giving rise to refuge since one basically views in this context Samsara as ephemeral and non truly existed. Geshela, I wonder if I could come back to the question that Sam asked and which you responded to and that was the difference in conviction and a valid cogniser and refuge. I don’t want Yashua to explain the technical part. My question is if I had been present at the teaching on Laurie that happened earlier this year.
And if I had been attentive, would I know automatically the difference, or is it much more subtle than that? It’s not such a difficult topic if you had attended, you would have understood quietly. This might be too general a question but, if I go to the doctor tomorrow and I’m given twenty four hours to live what is the most essential practice? Sorry I didn’t understand. If I go to the doctor tomorrow and I’m given twenty four hours to live, what is the most essential practice?
This is something you can only decide for yourself through thinking about things slowly over a long period of time. If tomorrow you went to the doctor and he said that to you, to to find what to practice on the instant would be very difficult. I didn’t wanna assume that he wasn’t already clairvoyant and could tell me. I didn’t assume that Geshela wasn’t clairvoyant and couldn’t tell me. Geshe mentioned that any activity we do without a virtuous state of mind will only be a cause for happiness in this life or lower rebirths.
Can Geshela clarify the virtuous state of mind he’s referring to? A virtuous motivation in this context would be a profound reflection on karma and causality, any reflection really on karma and causality or on death and impermanence. So to answer Sam’s question, the example I would give of the difference between a valid cognizer and a conviction would be the following. Imagine you enter the temple and you see your translator. When you see him, the thought arises within your mind stream, this is Ilya.
That is a valid cognizer. Then you think, yes, Ilya is an impermanent phenomenon which changes instant by instant. This is something you have heard over and again, you think over and again, you have conviction in, that is a conviction, but this is not yet a valid cognizer for you. Likewise, when you enter the temple and you see Geshela, immediately the thought arises, this is Geshela. This is a valid cognizer.
You are sure of the fact. Then with that, probably at the same time arises the apprehension of Geshela’s permanence. Deep down somewhere you are convinced that Geshela whom you are meeting today, Wednesday, is the same as Geshela you met yesterday on Tuesday. You do not realize that Geshela has been changing constantly and is disintegrating instant by instant from childhood onwards. Then when you reflect on that you say, yes, after all Geshela is an impermanent phenomenon.
This is the difference between a valid cognizer and a conviction. For instance, if you had the valid cognition, a valid cognizer, in other words, of the impermanence of this little table, then at the instant when you saw this little table, the thought this little table is impermanent and changes instant by instant would appear to your mind. Do I understand? Okay. Alright.
Good. A good idea. Yeah. Yeah. Objects of which they lead to liberation.
Would that be the correct interpretation of a valid cognition of the triple gem? Take an example of the Buddha. If we had an ascertainment through valid cognition of the Buddha gem, then we would have, at that time, an ascertainment through valid cognition of all of the qualities of the Buddha, which enabled the Buddha to protect us from the sufferings of the lower grounds. Just a couple of announcements. The flyer for the public talk with Geshela, not this Saturday but the following Saturday between three and four, the September 6, they are now available for you to take and put up in your favorite coffee shops, etc.
The little pizza place here has got them. Liquid espresso. So it’s amazing how interested people are and willing to put them up. So then two days of the long weekend in October, the fifth and the sixth, a great topic in praise of dependent arising. So that will be something to pencil in.
So again there’s some flies for that. And as Geshela said, have some chai.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- chulen
- Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.