Tenets — 2014-08-09

Tenets (Ilia Durovic)
Tenets (Ilia Durovic)
Tenets — 2014-08-09
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-08-09 – KR.mp3

UUID: 426e02f7-a244-4f72-95eb-2631a2f0a84a

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Tenets (Ilia Durovic)

Date: 2014-08-09

Duration: 2h 50m

Words: 20,386

So welcome back everybody. Gilly will continue with the topic Internal Critiques of Materialism within from physical physics to quantum mechanics. Thank you, Ilya. Thank you very much. And I hope all of you have had a good cup of coffee because you’re gonna need it.

Me too. Perhaps more than anywhere else, it is this afternoon that the meat of this simple regime will lie. Then, I’ve kept it very unmathematical, largely because frankly everyone agrees about the maths, nobody agrees about what it means. So we’re going try to talk a little bit about what it might mean, and it is particularly important for us. As you remember, this morning we covered briefly what materialism was historically, its Western and Indian backgrounds, the long interview which I have called the age of faith, and the features of modernity of which we are all the product, of which materialism and realism are key components, as well as what I’ve called the technological component.

And then I wrote a series of arguments, preliminary arguments as we called them, which put materialism in question. The first was a private experience of consciousness, and then we talked of altruism and empathy, of preverbal ethical sense in infants, and of the poverty of stimuli argument in linguistics. Then separately, each of these arguments has a fair bit of weight. When you start taking them together, they have a substantial amount of weight, and they raise a lot of questions. However, as far as materialism and realism are concerned, perhaps no argument has more weight than that of what is known as the status of the observer in quantum mechanics.

This is not a theory, it is an established reality in quantum mechanics. The theorems exist. There’s a lot of disagreement, about their meaning, and there has basically been, since I studied physics since thirty five years ago, a gentleman’s agreement in physics. This is something we shall not talk about. So when you start studying quantum mechanics at university, it’s very striking.

You do the math, and if you go at the math and you come to the your your teacher after the classes, and you ask him, so this is the awkward question. Right? What exactly does this mean? You know? You’ve got an entity which can be both a particle and a wave depending on the intention of the observer.

It’s a bit odd. And there’s no one inside. Your professor will come out with his private theory, and it might be the discontinuity of space, the discontinuity of time, the non material nature of the phenomenon. But if there’s anyone inside, he will tell you, we really don’t know. We just do the maths.

So this has been going on for more than eighty years, and this is the reason why in this morning I wanted to cover with you Thomas Kuhn’s understanding of scientific development, genesis of scientific theories, and paradigm shift. The example I gave you this morning was drawn, from a very classical element of physics, a transition from Newtonian physics to the special theory of relativity, which concerns us a little. But the reason I wanted to cover this with you is because I think with quantum mechanics, we are in a period of crisis, and we have been in a period of crisis for more than eighty years. We are in the midst of a shift of paradigm, and basically, the resistance is so great, it’s not happening. This paradigm shift is going to have to occur, you will see that the data is just piling up, so at a certain point, as far as physics is concerned, it’s simply going to have to occur.

Then the other sciences lag far behind physics, largely because they do not have to address the microscopic realm, biology to much lesser degree chemistry. Chemistry does address quantum phenomena, biology basically does not. So they can afford for the time being to remain on a prequantic paradigm. You will find that both biology and chemistry function very much on a Newtonian model. And it is unsurprisingly from biology and chemistry that, the sirens of materialism are most to be heard.

Dawkins is a biologist, Dennett is a biologist, most of those who are vociferously critical of the non material nature of consciousness are biologists, and not to put too fine a point on it, they are one and a half century behind the curve. So but you have to say things bluntly at a certain point, you know. And I a long time ago, the book was translated in 1983 in English, but it was actually initiated in the nineteen thirties. Fritz London and Baruch were the founders of quantum chemistry, said quite clearly, one can doubt the possibility of establishing philosophical truths by the methods of physics, but it is surely not outside the competence of physicists to demonstrate that certain statements which pretend to have a philosophical validity do not. All this afternoon’s, conference will be dedicated precisely to deconstructing these statements.

So when contemporary biologists quite casually reduce the the mind to the brain, and therefore the mind to matter, it has to be pointed out that even within a materialistic context, as Kelly makes it very clear, the advances in physics are so great in the last century that even the reduction of the mind to the brain is not a straightforward statement. Matter is not what we thought it was. It has become glaringly obvious in the last one hundred and twenty years after well, ‘5 Einstein’s famous photoelectric paper, where for the first time light was treated as a particle, and then Einstein’s famous equation, linking matter and energy, it has become very clear that we don’t have a very clear understanding of what matter is. So even a stark materialist who reduces the mind to the brain is making anything but an obvious statement in the light of contemporary physics. This is something I think biologists may be verbally aware of, but it does not seem to penetrate much deeper than this.

Then we will address the gist of our conference, which is quantum physics and the critique of three components of the common sense view of reality realism, locality, and determinism. In this respect, thought Escher’s drawing of the hand drawing itself is excellent. It really summarizes the problem of observation in quantum mechanics. The observer observing the phenomenon defines by his observation the observed phenomenon, which in turn interacts with you. You have a feedback loop between observed and observed phenomenon.

Before entering into the quantum description of reality, we have to move backwards a little bit, and we will keep all of this very unmathematical and philosophical. It makes it more simple for all of us to quote to classical physics and to the way classical physics understands causality. And by the way, the way some of the Buddhist schools of philosophy understand causality too. So in classical physics, for two phenomena, a and b, to be causes, first, they must exist out there. This is the hypothesis of realism.

You exist, and I’m sure this will shock you, whether I’m in the room or not. And if it doesn’t shock you, then you’re a very advanced person. That is real. Then if two phenomena are causally related, the cause must come before the effect, and they must be spatially contiguous, this is locality. You cannot have this is a locality is often formulated in very naive terms.

You cannot have two phenomena which are hugely removed in distance, so we’ll be formulating this in terms of the speed it takes light to connect two phenomena, hugely removed in distance which are causally related. This would violate the special theory of relativity. Really necessary correlation or determinism, whenever b occurs, a has occurred. So whenever the apple hits the ground, someone dropped the apple. This is classical causality.

And now if we flesh it out a bit, studying the hypotheses of classical physical causality one by one, we can see that if a causes b, you have an observer on the outside, outside of a and b, that’s your hypothesis of realism. You have anteriority, a occurs at t zero, b occurs at t one, the arrow of time is if you wish is unidirectional. You have locality, they are somehow together. It might be a distance of a couple of meters, a distance of a couple of kilometers, but in physics nowadays, they cannot be so far removed that there’s a causal relation which occurs faster than the speed of light between these two objects. Right?

And finally, there must be necessary correlation. In other words, whenever we observe b, it is certain indefinite a has occurred. This is classical physical causality. Now all of this is going to be turned on its head in approximately half an hour. So you have half an hour to enjoy reality, and then we are all going to get hopelessly confused.

And I hope I will be able to bring us out of confusion somewhat. Now quantum mechanics was discovered, I would say unintentionally, by Max Planck, the last of the great classical physicists. Planck had absolutely no desire, I suppose, stumble on something as odd as quantum mechanics. He’s told a very classical problem in physics, which is known as the black body radiation problem. You take something which is known as a black body, which is basically at a constant level of temperature, and you study this relationship between the temperature of the body and the frequency of the radiation, electromagnetic for instance, if you heat the body to a very high temperature, what we would call light, which is radiated.

It’s a difficult problem mathematically, but it didn’t seem to be anything particularly transcendental in terms of meaning, and it’s very interesting because, for instance, all the light bulbs we have in this room, basically, hinge on the black box effect. So Max Planck was basically hired by the great the greatest German light bulb company of the of the period, this is late eighteen eighties, it was just nascent, right, to try to find a way to make more efficient light bulbs, and to try to find a way to make more efficient light bulbs, he figured he had to solve the black body problem. What’s the relationship between basically heat and radiation, and how much electricity do you have to put in a filament to cause radiation and radiation of which frequency? It seems quite straightforward. But what, Planck found is very disturbing from the standpoint of classical physics, is that in such a black body, the levels of radiation are not continuous.

In other words, you don’t have a steady stream of radiation. Let’s say, imagine, the black body radiates at one gigahertz, one gigahertz and one hertz, one gigahertz and two hertz, one gigahertz and three hertz. This doesn’t happen. You have jumps in the levels of radiation. This is completely abnormal.

There is a theoretical necessity of his analyses. And these jumps are called quantas. Planck accepted this as just sort of a mathematical trick to try to understand the black body. The black body radiated energy discontinuously. He didn’t attach too much importance to it, and for some fifteen, twenty years really, Planck did not fully understand the import of his research.

It’s Einstein in nineteen o five who understood that this was inherent to the process of radiation of energy. It was not something accidental and extraneous. And this is the beginning of quantum mechanics. This is the first counter intuitive result in quantum mechanics which contains many. In pursuing on Planck’s research, one of the most brilliant physicists of the twentieth century, Heisenberg, studying the classic atom you always take as an example in quantum mechanics, a hydrogen atom is very simple.

There’s one proton and one electron. They discovered something even more embarrassing. Generally speaking, if you have a hydrogen atom, and this is a a depiction of a hydrogen atom, it is in a series of discrete states. So it’s angular momentum, which is if you wish to think of it as the rotation rotational component of the electron, it’s not far from the truth. It’s discrete.

It does not have all of the states between zero and one. Can be either zero, one, or two, and the orbits of the electron are also discrete. They are quantas, in other words, discrete states. But what Heisenberg found to his great embarrassment studying the behavior of the hydrogen atom is what is known as his uncertainty principle. Some of you may have heard about it.

For a given particle, let’s say an electron, the product of the uncertainty of the position, which is delta x, by the uncertainty of the quantity of movement, which is a speed if you wish, a product of the mass by the speed, is necessary necessarily greater than a constant. You just go to h over two p. In other words, if you know delta x with 100% certainty, as was delta x is zero, right, you know the position was a 100% certainty, delta p becomes infinite. In other words, you have no idea regarding the mass or the velocity of the particle. If on the other hand, you know delta p with a 100% certainty, there’s just no variation of p, delta p becomes zero, then the position is totally unknown.

In other words, you cannot know at the same time for a subatomic particle its position and its mass. It is impossible. You can do approximately both. You can wear one perfectly and the other not at all, or the opposite. You have in other in other words, it would seem according to Heisenberg’s principle, an inherent limit to what we can know.

Now Heisenberg understood this in very pragmatic terms. It seems his understanding was perhaps incomplete. Heisenberg understood this as a statement regarding the experimental means used. That if the experimental means used to understand the position with 100% certainty were applied, those experimental means would hinder the understanding of the quantity of motion, the momentum, and the opposite. This was the understanding of the nineteen thirties.

Most quantum physicists nowadays believe it’s a fundamental property of matter. There is an inherent unknowability in matter at the subatomic level. Already in this respect, Heisenberg himself had to acknowledge that quantum physics had moved far away from nineteenth century physics, very far away indeed. For classical Newtonian physics, you can know theoretically, I mean, in practice you wouldn’t do the calculations, but theoretically, you can know everything about a particle. Its position, its quantity of movement, its angular spin, anything you want to know, it’s all there in the equations of classical mechanics.

According to Heisenberg’s principle, there is an inherent limitation to our knowledge at the subatomic level, fundamental limitation. And as I explained to you, therefore, certainty regarding the position of the particle according to Heisenberg’s principle means complete uncertainty regarding its momentum and reciprocal. Now for Heisenberg, it is measurement, and this has always been the leitmotif with Heisenberg and his great mentor Niels Bohr. It was the act of measurement which was basically at fault. It was not possible to do the measurements with sufficient accuracy.

This did not reflect a fundamental issue in knowability. Can you see how critical this would be? If we’re saying that there’s something which is unknowable. It’s quite basic, and it is this issue of knowability and observation which has been at the center of quantum mechanics really from the nineteen thirties onwards, and it is precisely this issue which is of critical importance to us because it brings to the fore the nature of the mind, the knower. And it leads us to the main topic of this conference, which is observation and quantum mechanics.

Now the issue of observation in quantum mechanics and the nature of the observer, in other words, experimenter, was an issue which was debated and fought with the savagery of jungle warfare by the greatest physicists of the age. I think it’s fair to say nobody really agreed with anybody else. And some of the greatest minds of the twentieth century have tried to answer the question of whether quantum mechanical theorems have merely implications for observation, core observation, or if they have fundamental implications for the observer. There are a series of schools in the matter. The orthodox interpretation, the so called Copenhagen interpretation, is that of Niels Bohr of Heisenberg himself, and remains, I would say, mainstream nowadays.

Although it is dwindling as far as the number of adherents are concerned because the data is piling up against it. This school asserts that the problems we encounter in defining the status of the observer in quantum mechanics, the impact the status of the observer has on the phenomenon observed and on measurement, are all due to the problem of measurement at that level. They are not due to the fact that, for instance, the observer consciousness might be non material. From Neumann, Fritz London and Wigner, some of the greatest minds of the twentieth century are of the opinion that the observer is necessarily non material. It’s a necessary corollary in quantum mechanics of the act of observation.

For a moment, to give you an idea, he is the creator of modern computer science. He’s also the creator of game theory, one of the greatest mathematical minds who ever lived. Great Hungarian physicist. So So the quantum paradoxes appear with perhaps one of the most famous quantum paradoxes there is, the double slit experiment. Einstein had established that light can behave either as a particle, a photon, or as a wavelength.

Both descriptions are appropriate. But what is really puzzling, and this is known as the double slit experiment, is that in function of what the observer chooses to measure, light behaves as a particle or as a photon. It seems as if the intention of the observer influences the observed phenomenon. If the observer I’m sorry. I must make sure myself not to disappear.

If the observer, for instance, chooses to measure light as a wave, that act of measurement suddenly brings out diffraction, which is a typically wave like phenomenon. We have a case of diffraction in the back right now. If on the other hand, the observer chooses to measure particle like features of light, that choice of the observer brings out particle like behavior. It seems as if the intent of the observer, the one’s a physicist experimenter, affects how the phenomenon manifests. There’s nothing in classical physics, which is even remotely close to this.

So this seems to intimate or to imply a very close link between the observer and the observed phenomenon, and all the debates in quantum mechanics have hinged about what the nature of this link is. Now basically, what happens when something which is being measured manifests as a wavelength or as a particle is what is known technically as wave function collapse. Every particle in quantum mechanics is described by a function. It’s a mathematical function, describes all of the possible states of that object. And according to quantum mechanics, it coexists in all of these possible states until any measurement is made.

At the point at which that measurement is made, the particle, and forgive me for the use of the term, chooses to manifest as a particle or as a wave at one level of energy or at another possible level of energy. Until measurement has occurred, all you can deal with is a wave function which describes the totality of the possible manifestations of a particle. And the interpretations in quantum mechanics hinge on how this wave function is understood. The Kopenhagen school, which is basically the dominant school, that of Niels Bohr, that of Heisenberg, as well as von Neumann’s school, both consider that this wave function understanding, the totality of the possible states of a particle, is indeed the dominant way of understanding particle behavior, and they may disagree regarding what causes a wave function collapse. In other words, what causes a particle to manifest as a particle or a wave at energy level s two, s one, or whatever.

There are other schools of thought which do emphasize wave function collapse, which we shall not talk about here. Everett’s multiple universe hypothesis and so forth, which are very far away from our topic, some are discredited, like David Bohm’s hidden variable synthesis is basically discredited nowadays. So if what we are dealing with is, if you wish, a packet of possible states for a subatomic particle, and what determines the manifestation of one of those states is a wave function collapse. The question which arises is what causes this wave function collapse? And this is where the schism, if you wish, in quantum mechanics has occurred.

The Copenhagen School considers that it is measurement with the intrusion measurement applies, which causes this collapse. But some Neumann, London, Wigner, and pretty much everyone else consider it is not measurement. It’s the actual consciousness of the observer which causes the collapse of the wave function, and this debate has been ongoing since the nineteen thirties. I will assure you, most difficult part is behind us. It starts to get a little bit more manageable now, and as we talk about it, I hope these very strange concepts will become more evident.

Now, I would say that it is precisely this disagreement which is critical for us. Because if the collapse of the wave function is caused just by the act of measurement, by interference with a subatomic system, that is basically trite. It’s not terribly meaningful from our standpoint. If as von Neumann believes, is a fundamental feature of subatomic reality, it is the act of knowing a subatomic particle, which causes that subatomic particle to manifest as a wave or as a particle in one energy level or another. This is of fundamental importance for us, certainly as Buddhists.

This is a massive indication of the Indian schools of philosophy, not just Buddhism, but also Vedanta. And therefore, we shall enter into a bit more detail, on this topic. One has to always address the position of one’s opponent first, and therefore we shall first talk about the Copenhagen interpretation of the role of the observer. As held by some of the two greatest minds of twentieth century physics, the Danish physicist Niels Bohr and the German physicist Werner Heisenberg. Both considered that the transition from the possible to the actual, from this packet of possibilities to an actual particle or wave of a given energy, depends on the act of observation.

It does not depend on the act of registration of the result by the mind of the observer. It is the act of observation with, let us say, for a subatomic particle, maybe maybe bubble chamber, who knows, maybe an electron microscope, various apparatuses which actually interferes with the state of the particle and causes this packet, which we call the wave function, to take a value. Now this is the Copenhagen interpretation. The act of measurement disturbs things, if you wish. This, however, is not at all for Neumann’s position, And von Neumann’s position, I would say, is mathematically and physically much more elegant.

It is very problematical because it implies a complete reassessment of our fundamental world view. Von Neumann starts by analyzing, and I there’s a he never get a huge book just to this topic, I spare you the details. The system observed, which is subatomic set of particles, and he subdivided this into one system observed, a measuring instrument, and an actual observer, and he pointed out that Bohr and Heisenberg’s understanding implied that the measuring instrument and the actual observer be seen as one. Then when they are seen as one, you cannot make a differentiation, and you are in the position of having to say, it is actually the measuring entity which causes the collapse of the wave function. But if you move what he called the von Neumann cut, which is the division between the observing complex and the observed system backwards, After all, the measuring instrument participates in the quantum quantum phenomenon.

This only leaves the actual observer as possible source for the wave function collapse. And von Neumann considered that any material entity, by the very fact it was material, could not cause the collapse of the wave function. Since it was not different in kind from the, let’s say, the neutron, the neutrino, the electron, whatever, which was being observed by its means. It itself actually can be written as part of the wave function. Something which was removed from the wave function had to cause a collapse, and that which was removed from the wave function was the actual observer, which therefore in von Neumann’s formalization of wave function collapse is necessarily nonmaterial.

Since if the observer is material, the observer can be subsumed as here in the system observed. Then you would have nothing which would cause a wave function collapse. Do you understand his point? What he is saying is everything which is material can be described by the so called wave function, and this wave function collapses, we know it collapses. So it is something which is not material, which causes a wave function collapse.

What is non material? The physicist. In this case, the mind of the physicist, the mind of the experimenter. So in von Neumann’s formalization, mind is necessarily non material. If you wish in a simpler example, which is only very approximate because we’re not dealing with subatomic phenomena.

Imagine we wanted to measure the temperature of melting iron. The measurement instrument is a thermometer, and then with the eye, one observes let’s say, imagine melting iron is melting at 2,500 degrees on this, just imagine. You observe this, and this data is transmitted to the brain. All of this is material. All of this can therefore be described by one wave function.

The collapse of, let’s say, this wave function cannot be caused by this because this is material. Therefore, we need something removed from this, removed from the brain, which is able to cause the collapse of all of this as a wave function or of this as a wave function, and that which is removed from the brain has to be nonmaterial. If it were material, it could be described as part of the wave function. And this is of extraordinary importance of course, because if von Neumann’s position is correct, and we’re speaking of a position which has the endorsement of some of the leading quantum researchers, then there is proof not only that the mind is nonmaterial, but that the mind must be nonmaterial. After that, it is up to biologists and others to come up with mechanisms for us.

That doesn’t concern us. They haven’t come up with mechanisms yet, but they’re going to have to. And the data has been piling up, especially since the late 1960s. We’ll talk about some very recent data from Austria which makes a very strong case for von Neumann’s hypothesis. So Henry Stapp describes this rather aptly when he says that von Neumann moved the cut step by step until at last the entire physical body of the observer and of all observers, not everything else, was shifted to below the cut and described in terms of quantum mechanics.

Then the psyche, other words, the mind of the experimenter is shifted completely outside of the physically described world, which implies that the mind of the observer is necessary necessarily non material. If it is not non material, it cannot cause the collapse of the wave function. And the collapse of the wave function is a given. We know wave functions collapse. Then this is as close to the sharp wooden stake driven in the breast of the vampire of materialism as it gets.

It doesn’t get much much closer than this. This is the closest you will get to a demonstration of the nonmaterial nature of mind. And it led Fritz London to state the apparent point of departure of the theory, in other words of Newtonian mechanics, the idea of an observable world totally independent of the observer was a vacuous idea. Strong words indeed. The formalism of quantum mechanics implies a well defined theory of the relationship between object and observer, a relation quite different from that implicit in naive realism.

And this was written, believe it or not, in the nineteen thirties. The book was translated in the nineteen eighties in English, London wrote in French. And as London adds, and this is a very powerful critique of Heisenberg’s understanding of the act of measurement as causing the collapse of the wave function, a coupling within measurement with a measuring device is not yet a measurement. It’s a very powerful statement. If you have a subatomic particle and you actually plan on observing its characteristics and you couple it with a measuring device, that coupling with a measurement measuring device is still not a measurement.

It is the moment the consciousness of the observer observes the data that you can speak of measurement, and this is a distinction Heisenberg does not make. We note, and I skip, the essential role to play by the consciousness of the observer in this transition from the mixture to the pure case. The mixture is basically the wave function for all its possibilities. The pure case is a collapse of the wave function, or what modern physicists know as a reduction of the state vector. So you can see here that really since the 1930s, one of the central philosophical debates in modern physics, in quantum physics, has been the nature of the mind.

Everyone agrees on the theorems, there’s no disagreement. All the physicists agree that delta x delta p greater or equal to h and two pi is general agreement. Nobody agrees on the meaning of these theorems. There are two broad camps, the first which say it can all eventually be reduced to our meddling with very subtle particles, and the other camp which says, something more fundamental is at work here. It’s the actual act of consciousness which causes all of this.

This act of consciousness is necessarily non material, otherwise it will be part and parcel of the phenomenon observed. Can you see how far reaching this is? And that’s why I told you to get a big cup of coffee before this conference. Numerous paradoxes were actually developed on this fame on this basis. The most famous one is probably that of Wigner’s friend.

These are paradoxes involving the collapse of wave functions, which clearly intimate that what causes a collapse must be the non material mind of the observer. In Wigner’s paradox, you have to imagine that you have two physicists, two friends, doing an experiment on a particle. One is inside the lab and one is outside. The one inside the lab is observing the system, and has done whatever measurement he plans on doing, And obviously, by observing it, or Heisenberg would say by doing the measurement, the wave function has collapsed. Whatever it was has manifested, let’s say, either as a particle or as a beam in a certain energy state.

But his friend outside the lab has not done the measurement. So for that friend, the wave function has not collapsed. So we have a situation in which if it is indeed the act of measurement which causes the collapse of the wave function, we have simultaneously a collapsed and non collapsed wave function. In other words, a paradox. And the question is, how do we resolve Wittner’s paradox?

Wigner himself pointed out that if this were the case, the same physical reality, one particle being observed in the lab, would be described by two different wave functions, one which had collapsed, the other which had not collapsed at the same time, which is obviously impossible. And therefore, that it has to be the consciousness of the first observer in the lab, which causes the collapse of the wave function. So Wigner’s paradox lends a lot of support to von Neumann’s hypothesis, that it is the consciousness of the observer which causes a collapse of the wave function. I told you I would stretch your minds and I think I may be looking at your expressions. Do you have any questions before I go any further?

Yes, please. We want to touch the mind immediately, but it’s a pretty superficial question probably. If he is outside the line, outside the authority, then he is not performing the measurement. No. And therefore, sure, the connection with the argument is relevant.

In other words, how does he know that the wave function has not collapsed? He wouldn’t know. How could he know? He wouldn’t know. How do we know that to him he doesn’t know?

That gets even more complicated if you have a third observer. That gets even more complicated. But the basic question is, what causes this collapse? Then the stakes are very high, because if it actually is the mind which causes a collapse, that means that there is an intimate relationship between mind and matter, which is something which has been denied by old modern science. So intimate that just observing something can cause it to change.

If that is not the case, we return to the classical model. So because the stakes are very high, people have basically or physicists have been trading paradoxes since the nineteen thirties. Much of the data at present confirms, especially since the late nineteen nineties, for Neumann’s hypothesis, it’s become quite embarrassing, and I’ll show you how embarrassing it has become. A leading physicist has actually declared that the universe is mental in Nature magazine. And if you’ve heard of Nature magazine, it’s one of the two leading science magazines in the world, general scientific magazines.

Then, obviously, for us it is difficult to understand these arguments, but what I’m hoping to do is to make it clear that we are at a point where a rational, modern, twenty first century westerner can subscribe to the idea of a non material consciousness without any hesitation. And then if consciousness is non material, this obviously opens the door to a lot of other things. Where did it come from? Where does it go? What exactly is its relationship with matter?

Some issues we can answer, some issues we will find difficult to answer. But my goal is to show you that when we look at the sum total of the data, the data points very strongly towards the Indian schools of philosophy, so strongly that Wigner himself actually converted to my knowledge to Hinduism to Vedanta. As you may know, Oppenheimer, the father of the American atomic bomb, was heavily influenced by Vedanta and Buddhism. Heisenberg was heavily influenced by Buddhism, precisely because it is the Indian school of thought which explore this relationship between mind and matter. Then we can only follow in their footsteps.

Do you have any other questions before we continue? Yes. You made two statements. You said we know that wave functions collapse, and then we’ve got the paradigm about they’ve not collapsed if you’re not observing. Why could it not be that the observer actually is not observing correctly, that it’s fallacy?

I mean, how do you know it’s collapsed? You only know it’s collapsed is it not true that you only know it’s collapsed because the observer sees it collapsed, while a non observer doesn’t see it collapse? So could it be a misunderstanding? Not really, the collapse of the wave function the wave function is a mathematical entity, right? Its collapse simply means that the various possibilities, the various states of energy and so forth a particle might take are some even used to one.

Then that is something the observer sees with his measuring instruments. The electron might have dozens of energy levels, but suddenly it has only one. That’s a collapse of the wave function. Now the question is, we know that happens, but what causes it? Is it, as Heisenberg and Bohr say, the measuring instruments which cause this collapse, or if you wish, could use another term, this concretization, or is it something else?

Now von Neumann’s critique is how could the measuring instruments, which are themselves material, therefore part basically of a larger wave function, cause this collapse? And as London pointed out, after all, nobody ever says that when I’ve connected measuring instruments to something to be measured and there’s no one in the lab, this is a measurement. It becomes a measurement when there is someone there to register the information. So the debate really hinges on whether it’s a measured instrument or that which observe the observation, the the measurement, which causes a collapse of the wave function. If it is that which observes the phenomenon which causes the collapse of the wave function, then for von Neumann, for Wigner, for London, that which observes must be non material.

And if it is a physicist, it is not the physicist’s body, which is material. It cannot be the physicist’s brain, which is material. There must be something else which cannot be written mathematically as part of the wave function, and that something else is what we call mind. It’s the closest we come to a demonstration of the existence of mind. I I understand that.

Yes. What I don’t understand is why the observation itself can’t be faulty. It could be. It could be. But in many cases, these are just thought experiments.

It’s not like with Wigner’s friend, I think I assume nobody ever did the experiment. Right? Wigner just constructed the idea, what would happen if? Right? So you work from the premise that the observation is not faulty.

If the observation were faulty, you probably would not have a collapse of the wave function. Probably. That’s my question. Polotically, these guys applying the materials? Well, that I don’t know.

I would like to talk about it with you after with pleasure after the conference. So you can see already that we are far removed from classical physics, and we’re far removed from the common sense view of reality. It does go further than this, however, because it seems, based on some theories we shall be talking about pretty soon, that what we know as locality in realism must be put in question as well. Locality is a fact, you remember, that phenomena can affect each other when they are relatively close to each other. Realism refers to the fact that phenomena exist outside of the mind.

Like, if whether I am in the room or not, that electrical plug exists. I think all of us naively would agree that’s realism. My presence in the room or not does not affect the existence of the electrical plug. This principle of local action or locality was rather aptly summarized by Einstein in one of the most famous papers in the twentieth century. External influence on a has no direct influence on b.

There’s no other principle of local action. In other words, this principle underlies physical laws as we normally know them. If it were to be proven wrong, we would be dealing with the universe orders of magnitude stranger than anything we know. And yet, it seems to be. And it seems to be with something which is known as quantum entanglement.

Quantum entanglement starts with a paradox, Einstein’s attempt to demonstrate that quantum mechanics is incomplete. So Einstein never brought in the idea that the positions of particles could never be described by anything more than a wave function. And he considered that all the paradoxes of quantum mechanics, such as for instance, the impact of the observer on the collapse of the wave function, was simply due to the fact that there were some characteristics of the particle as yet to be discovered. Once they were discovered, it would be possible to write good, solid, classical, deterministic equations, and all of these would turn out to be due basically to ignorance of some characteristics of subatomic systems. Einstein entered this position to the end of his life.

He formulated a very famous paradox with two colleagues, Podolsky and Rosen, to show what would happen if this were not the case. And this paradox, which is perhaps one of the most famous paradoxes in science in the twentieth century, runs basically as follows. If this were not the case, in other words, if quantum mechanics described reality as it is, if there are no supplementary parameters, this is the name given to this, theory. Then once two particles are entangled, in other words, once they have interacted with each other, However far the moon they are, in space and in time, millions of light years, they can still be described as one system, and anything which affects one of the particles instantaneously affects the other particle and reciprocally. Now this is a case, this flies smack in the face of all of Einstein’s work on the theory of relativity, And it is profoundly counterintuitive.

If the spin of one particle were to change in the Andromeda galaxy, instantaneously, the spin of a particle which had been entangled with it, let’s say, one billion years ago, would change on earth. Einstein considered this demonstrated that quantum mechanics was incomplete. Since if this were true, the theory of relativity would actually be false because you’d have translite transmission. And when Einstein published his paper, it was sort of obviously, Einstein was Einstein, right? So you had to to give credit, but there was this general feeling, the old man is a bit out of touch, you know?

But it turns out that Einstein put his figure finger on the way things are. What Einstein thought was a paradox, it was impossible, is actually exactly what happens. And this we will talk about in a couple of minutes, been fleshed out by an Irish physicist, Bell, who, working with Einstein’s results, thought he was just developing the paradox further and that some experimenters would demonstrate this was impossible. Experiment after experiment, they’re difficult to conceive these experiments, but experiment after experiment has confirmed that indeed when particles are entangled, they affect each other, the change in each other’s physical status affects the other particle instantaneously, whatever the distance. Another great physicist who drew on these paradoxes was Schrodinger.

You probably have all heard of Schrodinger’s cat. Schrodinger points out that it is very easy to devise an experiment in which the indeterminacy we spoke about at the quantum level, the fact that we for instance cannot know simultaneously position and quality of momentum of a particle, can be spread upwards, contaminate the macroscopic realm. In this experiment, it’s a thought experiment, I can pretty much guarantee no one ever did it. Even a German physicist would not be so harsh with a pussycat. This experiment involved a pussycat, and Schrodinger’s it’s a thought experiment, if there are any animal lovers among you.

Schrodinger’s experiment hinged on subatomic material, which had a fifty fifty chance of triggering a Geiger counter. Now a Geiger counter is macroscopic. Right? So you have a dose of radioactive material, which may or may not emit, let’s say alpha alpha rays to trigger a Geiger counter. Now if it triggers a Geiger counter, the Geiger counter cause a hammer to fall, this hammer breaks a bottle of cyanide, and the cat which is in the cage dies.

If alpha rays are not emitted and the Geiger counter is not triggered, the hammer does not fall, cyanide is not released, and the cat lives. The problem is we have a state of complete uncertainty regarding whether or not these alpha particles will be emitted. That’s nice and fine for the alpha particles. But as a result of a Schrodinger’s thought experiment, we actually have a state of complete uncertainty about whether the cat in the box is alive or dead. We have, in other words, a contamination of subatomic indeterminacy upwards.

Subatomic indeterminacy becomes macroscopic indeterminacy, And it is in reality impossible to formulate a quantum classical boundary. When I was at university, there was a classic that you were dealing with a given system and you actually would choose to treat it classically or in terms of quantum mechanics. But in reality, it’s an arbitrary choice. At a certain point, your choices become absurd. So if you treat a subatomic system classically, you get paradoxes.

And if you treat a large scale macroscopic system like a table, cortically, it’s so complicated that, you know, you go dizzy. But in truth, you cannot distinguish between the two. You do have a continuum. And therefore, it is not possible, in a nutshell, to quarantine quantum paradoxes. You cannot have and I think it is perhaps one of the big problems of modern physics, a quantum ghetto in which everything strange happens.

And then you get out of the ghetto, and you have the rules and the police, and things go pretty much normally, you know. There’s no such boundary as Schrodinger’s paradox illustrates. It’s very easy to conceive of a situation in which quantum phenomena propagate upwards, and this will be quite relevant for the second part of this talk where we will talk of psi. That is where this becomes quite meaningful, because it’s very possible that we have quantum contamination. Then there is one last topic I must address, and I must thank you for your patience in these difficult issues, which is so called violations of Bell’s inequalities, which are actually development of the Einstein Podolsky Rosen theorem we spoke about previously.

Bell just formalized Einstein’s paradox on the assumption that it would be fairly straightforward to demonstrate that such events never occurred. Entangled pairs of particle particles would not affect each other at huge distances instantaneously. Unfortunately, well, fortunately, depending on the viewpoint, the French physicist Alain Spee demonstrated that this is very much the case. He spent his life devising ever more complex experiments, demonstrating that realism, in other words, the worlds existing out there as we know it, in locality, in other words, the fact that phenomena can only affect each other when they’re close-up, are probably fantasies. Now, that’s inequalities must be verified for the physical world to be realistic, deterministic, and local.

Unfortunately, one can devise experimental setups in which they are not verified. And this raises the basic question of those three features, realism, determinacy and locality, which is to be rejected or are all three to be rejected? So there’s a lot of evidence that realism probably has to be put into question. There is some evidence that determinism has to be put into question, and there’s a lot of evidence that locality has to be put into question. And this is an ongoing process.

Basically, year, we have new experiments, mainly from Austria now, which show that Einstein Podolsky Rosen theorem and the Bell theorem, which were really devised as paradoxes, are not paradoxes. This is the way things actually are. And the world at the subatomic level is much stranger than we ever thought it could be. And this strangeness unfortunately seems to spread upwards. So one of the experiments was Alain Aspect’s experiment.

I won’t enter it. It’s a classic where you have a source of light, two beams of light, two photons, and these photons are polarized at a great distance from each other, and you find that the polarization of one photon affects instantaneously the polarization of the other. A clear confirmation of the violation of Bell’s inequalities, a clear confirmation that as far as we know Einstein was wrong. And therefore, if we try to describe the state of affairs in physics nowadays, and I wish you that we’re coming to the end of the physics section, it’s gonna get a little bit less heavy and more interesting, but we had to to do this, and there is a matter of doing it this morning or now. What we find is that classical Newtonian physics functions with large systems and at low speeds.

If the speed is low compared to the speed of light, and we’re dealing with macroscopic systems, classical Newtonian physics which is realistic and local functions just fine. As we start moving towards microscopic systems, eventually we do have to switch over to quantum physics. Now it takes to be at the molecular level, at the level of a molecule of ammonium typically, there’s a lot of debate about this one. How small you can grow before you need to rely on quantum physics. Likewise, as you start approaching speeds close to the speed of light, you have to pass over to relativistic physics.

Now relativistic physics is realistic in local, other words, for relativistic physics, the world exists out there, and things can only affect each other if they are quote unquote close. Quotient physics is nonrealistic and non local. And this contradiction, if that’s basically what it is, between the core features of quantum physics and the core features of relativistic physics underlies, I would say, all of the research in physics after World War two. All of the research in physics has huge on trying to consolidate quantum physics and relativistic physics, and so far it has been a dismal failure. Both exist, both work in their respective spheres of application, both are contradictory with each other in terms of their core hypothesis.

And some of the latest research by Simon Gröblacher, who’s a brilliant young physicist in Vienna, indicates that the situation is probably stranger than Bell ever thought. Not only is it the case that realism is basically at odds with quantum mechanics, But even a large number of non local realistic theories are also at odds with quantum physics. And therefore, as some traditional physicists had suggested, just giving up the concept of locality is insufficient. It may very well be we will have to give up the concept of exterior reality as well. So to summarize this rather dizzying amount of material, where do we stand at present?

And I should point out, this is basically theoretical data. According to one of the dominant schools of interpretation of quantum mechanics, mind is not a material phenomenon. Cannot be a material phenomenon. It’s necessarily non material. And we have very strong empirical evidence of both non locality and non realism.

Therefore, according to quantum physics, we are at present in a situation where we’re dealing with a collapse of the materialist realist paradigm. And this collapse has become evident especially after the publication of Bell’s theorems in the late nineteen sixties. From 1930 to 1960, the debate was ongoing between physicists such as von Neumann and London, who were not realists on the one hand, and Einstein who was a realist on the other hand. Bell’s theorems in the confirmation of the violation really has settled matters. And this is why I wanted to talk with wanted to talk with you this morning about Thomas Kuhn’s concept of paradigm shift and, the notion of paradigm shift in a crisis.

We are, as far as physics is concerned, in a crisis. We have been in a crisis since the nineteen thirties. The crisis has become acute from 1966 or so with the publication of Bell’s theorems. It is a crisis which involves the rejection of the Korman model, which underlies the western view of reality. The view of a physical world out there, which is observed by an observer who is independent of this world.

This view is basically being rejected. In addition, there is overwhelming evidence that observers, by definition, must be nonmaterial. In this led Richard Kahn, professor of physics at the University of Maryland. He would always do this just before retiring, I’ve noticed this inside. He retired, and as he was retiring, he published an open letter in Nature, which I think as westerners interested in Buddhism, you will enjoy.

Keep in mind this is a professor of quantum physics. The universe is entirely mental. One benefit of switching humanity to the correct perception of the world is resulting joy of discovering the mental universe of the universe. We have no idea what this mental nature implies, but the great thing is it is true. Beyond the acquisition of this perception, physics can no longer help.

You may descend into solipsism, in other words, I only exist, expand to deism or something else if you can justify it, Just don’t ask physics for for help. And this was nine years ago, 07/02/2005. As peer reviewed, I’m just always struck by the fact it’s a year of their retirement they publish these things. But it is, I think, we would say in French, an open hearted statement by a physicist who feels at a certain point in his career, he does have to state things the way they are. This has led some leading physicists to raise the issue of the mind brain interaction.

It’s undeniable that the brain is an important component for mental activities. If the mind is non material, how do they relate? In my opinion, the mechanisms they propose are premature. Then it’s a bit presumptuous to say this because Sir Roger Penrose and Henry Stapp, certainly Penrose, they are the greatest living physicists. More I think really, I would say the jury is in on the non material nature of the mind, but it’s getting there.

As far as physics is concerned, the evidence is strong. When it comes to the mechanisms between the brain and this non material mind, frankly, don’t have a clue. Then I think it’s important in these fields to acknowledge that one simply does not know. So what Stapp proposes is interaction, quantum interaction, at the synaptic level between the axon and the dendrone, largely because you are dealing with phenomena at the quartic scale. You’re dealing dealing with the exchange of calcium ions.

The neuronic phenomena can be treated cortically, but because they can be treated cortically, in no way proves that they are quartic in this context. And, Stapp’s hypothesis is that the quantum state of the nerve terminal, in other words, quantum excuse me, the quantum state of the synapse here is a mixture of states. And this material mixture of states, which is in the state of indeterminacy, collapses due to the operation of the nonmaterial mind. It is at this point according to Stapp that the interaction of non material mind and material brain and nervous matter would occur. Then there’s no evidence whatsoever, and Unfortunately, for Stapp there’s been a very powerful rejoinder.

An American physicist Max Tegmark analyzed Stapp’s ideas to see whether it was possible or not with the temperature levels we were dealing with at the synaptic level. According to Tegmark, it does not seem that there is anything quantum mechanical occurring at the synaptic level. I feel that the jury is close to being in regarding the non material nature of the mind, and data is accumulating pretty much by the day now regarding the non realistic nature of the universe as we know it. I think the mechanisms of mind brain interaction remain the complete unknown, and it must be acknowledged. Then one can make proposals, but at present there is no data, neither here nor there.

And now, we come to the fun part. So you’ve all been very good. Thank you very much. It’s not easy material, neither for yourselves nor for myself, but I thought it was worth covering. So after these theoretical arguments, and I cannot emphasize how strong for Neumann’s argument for the nonmaterial nature of the mind is, do we have empirical data confirming that the mind is nonmaterial?

We do. We do, and we have some rather strong data coming from psi research. Then I think you will look at psi research in a different light after this preliminary presentation of the possible non material nature of the observer causing the collapse of the wave function quantum mechanics. So to the present day, much of this research occurs at the University of Arizona, my former alma mater, the University of Virginia, and the University of Edinburgh, where things have been, developing, considerably. When it comes to psi research, the research in other words in paranormal phenomena, one can really speak of paradigms at will.

There is no compromise, and no quarter is given. Much of the Tsai research I represent here is government sponsored psi research, often of a military nature, then some of these documents have been declassified, so I’m able to present them here. And you will find that the assessment of this research is strikingly different in function of the source. So in the case of The United States, for instance, The US has had a very active program of psi research since the nineteen sixties at least, as a response to Soviet research in the field. This program was covert.

It became public in the late nineteen eighties and caused a huge scandal. And a congressional committee demanded independent assessments of the results of these programs. We have two independent assessments, both by independent organizations at the request of the US government, giving exactly opposite results. In September 1995, the first by doctor doctor Jessica Utts from the University of California Davies, a statistician, states that psychic functioning has been well established. The statistical results are far beyond what is expected by chance, such consistently consistency cannot be readily explained by claims of flaws or fraud.

This was on 09/01/1995. Twenty eight days later, another assessment by the American Institutes for Research, also requested by the US government, came to exactly the opposite conclusion. A statistically significant laboratory effect has been demonstrated, but evidence has not been provided that the causes of the hits are due to the operation of paranormal phenomena. In other words, we are left in a bit of a quandary. Then I think that Kelly, the author of Irreducible Mind, has hit the nail on the head.

There is a core bias among mainstream scientists that psychic phenomena are impossible, must be impossible, and cannot be but impossible. And therefore, any explanation is better than the most evident explanation of a possible psi phenomenon. And the key goal seems to be to prevent the accumulation of that. Now, we will see that there is a fair bit of data, some of it quite strong, initially from the former Soviet Union, where the functioning of psi phenomena was basically taken for granted, and one investigated their possible usage, and later from The United States. And for us this is of considerable importance because it provides a powerful vindication of the notion of a non material mind.

Clearly, if phenomena such as telepathy, psychokinesis, remote viewing do indeed occur, it’s very difficult to account for them if the mind is just a byproduct of the brain. It seems impossible. Then the combination of strong theoretical arguments for the nonmaterial nature of the mind from quantum physics and empirical data would make a very strong case indeed. So what criteria should we have for psi which intimates that mind is nonmaterial? It has to be easily testable in controlled conditions.

It must be credible. In other words, it cannot stretch the dominant paradigm excessively. Levitation, for instance, would probably stretch the dominant paradigm excessively. You would prefer any hypotheses to that that your test subject is floating 10 feet in the air. And you would need a large body of data.

Then what psi satisfies these criteria? Telepathy clearly does, psychokinesis does, and we will see tomorrow cases of the reincarnation do. So in the case of telepathy, telepathy has been studied quite extensively, and there has been two broad categories of studies. Incidental accounts of telepathy from anthropologists, ethnologists, and researchers often among tribal populations who stumbled on the phenomenon by accident, and the systematic study of telepathy. The incidental accounts are often surprisingly strong.

They’re surprisingly strong because the author has no bias in favor of telepathy. The author of the study is typically studying, for instance, aboriginal behavior, you know, in Australia or let us say the Zande in Africa. The focus of the study is different. These cases often present very strong cases of telepathy, and frankly, any account of telepathy in such a study is detrimental to publication and to the author’s reputation. There’s very little to be gained.

These cases are rife. You find them basically in small articles and anthropological journals. Obviously these are second, sometimes third party accounts, which limits their impact, but they are accounts of very strong cases, and we do have to take into account the body of evidence. There have on the other hand been systematic studies of ESPN telepathy, the most famous ones are basically those by J. B.

Rhine at Duke University, but they have diverged very widely in the results they have obtained, and this is largely contingent on their methodology. Broadly speaking, the systematic studies are either qualitative or quantitative. The qualitative studies focus on finding one or two exceptional candidates with exceptional capacities and investigating them. The quantitative studies focus on studying a large number of candidates with no particular potency and basically working through the numbers and trying to find a deviation from the norm. The best results by far in the study of telepathy come from the qualitative studies, which are initiated in England by the Society for Psychical Research, but were really developed by what I’ve called the Soviet School of Parapsychology, which has gone very far in the field, perhaps further than we could ever go in Western democracies, and a series of projects which were initiated by the US government, largely by the CIA, then they passed to under the control of the NSA, and eventually defense department.

Everything we know at present indicates these projects have become, you know, privatized. So qualitative studies have given surprisingly strong results. Quantitative studies, in the case of telepathy, have not. Now regarding qualitative studies, I would like to cover Russian research, which is extremely interesting. Some of it has been published.

The Russians basically started out with the data from the Society of Psychical Research, in The UK and its French branch, the Institute of Metamycosis. And the leading investigator in telepathy as a psi phenomenon was professor Vasilyev, who was professor of brain physiology at Leningrad University, and who focused on inducing 10 instances of telepathic transmission from a powerful transmitter to a recipient, and analyzing the physical modalities of this transmission, the speed of transmission, the distances over which transmission could occur. Then, the Soviet school has basically how can I put this one? Well, the Soviet school has elicited a ruthlessness, I suppose, in its investigation, which would not be acceptable among Western researchers, and this perhaps explains the very powerful results they obtained. Their goal was basically military, the control of thought and data transmission, especially data transmission.

The methodology was a systematic use of powerful emotion and aesthetic stimuli. Emotional shock, there have been rumors of the usage of torture. The focus is to understand the underlying neurological mechanisms, and the protocols were aimed not at producing large scale data verification, but strong empirical verification of a couple cases. Then Vasilyev’s subjects were tested inside a Faraday cage, which as you know precludes the transmission of electromagnetic radiation. And Vasilyev seems to have demonstrated, if one accepts his research, that telepathy is not electromagnetic.

Then if it is not electromagnetic, well, is it a bit of a loss to know what of the four physical fields it might belong to? We have four fields in physics, right? The strong, the weak, electromagnetic, and gravitational. Gravitation it cannot be, and strong and weak these are subatomic fields, it can’t be that either. So if Vasilyev’s work is correct, then we’re dealing with an unknown phenomenon, perhaps a non material phenomenon.

Then Vasilyev was able to induce telepathically instructions to fall asleep and to awake in subjects separated by distances of up to 1,700 kilometers at random intervals. If you look at some of the data he reported, you can see, which is quite striking, that the time taken for the telepathic construction, let’s say, to fall asleep to occur, to have an impact, is basically independent of the distance. It takes up to two minutes at a distance of a short eight kilometers, and it takes one minute at 1,700 kilometers. Clearly, are not dealing with fields as they are understood in physics nowadays. Then much of Vasilyev’s research is unpublished.

Vasilyev basically disappeared. Nobody really knows what happened to him, whether he was executed, became part, as was very common in those days, of the Soviet military establishment in one of these specialized cities. But some of his research was published, and that is what I presented so far. Some very interesting research was undertaken by one of his disciples, Ipolit Kogan, who also disappeared in the nineteen seventies. Ipolit Kogan concentrated on telepathic data transmission, using the mind to mind link as a means to transmit data just as you would use your modem.

On distances in excess of 2,500 kilometers. So in one experiment which was not published but mentioned during conference, he was allowed to attend in America with representatives of the defense department in the early nineteen seventies, he was able to transmit Morse code telepathically at distances of 2,800 kilometers. Then perhaps, Ipolit Kogan had been a little bit too forthright because upon returning to the Soviet Union, he basically disappeared. We don’t know what happened to him. Kogan was extremely interested in what we would call nowadays the bandwidth of telepathic transmission.

What amount of data can be transmitted by a trained operator? This was obviously of great relevance in submarine warfare. As you can see, certainly for the Soviet researchers, psi phenomena was a reality which was used and investigated. Then there have been reports of more extreme cases of psi phenomena studied in the former Soviet Union, perhaps the most famous is that Nina Kulagina, one of the most exceptional psychokinetic cases known. There has never been a clear explanation of how Nina Kulagina was able to perform her feats.

I have heard occasional accusations of fraud, which have never been able to provide a mechanism. She was investigated several times by Western researchers who traveled to The Soviet Union, so one has to take all of this with a grain of salt. But she seems to have been able to affect the heart rhythm of a supervising Soviet physician to a degree such that she let him close to cardiac arrest through concentration alone. Then this is mentioned in a defense intelligence agency report, which has been declassified. We have to take it as it is.

We have no more information on the topic. But the focus of Soviet research has been very interesting because, perhaps it’s a Slavic trait, the Soviets focused on the enhancement of psi phenomena through the use of emotion in exceptional subjects. Positive or negative emotion. Famous case is one of the experiments Vasilyev made, with his top subject, which was a Russian secretary. She was supposed to transmit one of these one of the Soviet equipments of the zenar cards to a percipient in another room, and she herself was in Faraday cage.

And just before the experiment began, Vasilyev, he recounts this in his description of the case, came up to her and falsely said, her son, who was six years old, had just been crushed by a tramway going to school. But first, they would have to do the experiment and transmit the image on the card, and then she could go to see him in the hospital. And then the, recipient in the other room recorded an extremely powerful transmission of a tramway, not of the card she was supposed to transmit, and actually drew it. Then Vasilyev felt this demonstrated, without any doubt, the impact of emotions on the clarity of the transmission. Clearly from an ethical standpoint, it’s rather appalling.

The quantitative study of telepathy was largely undertaken by Rhine at Duke University. It has had very mixed results. It has been highly criticized. Basically, working with large numbers of subjects, Rhine had to deal with what’s known as a very strong decline effect in which the results, the positive results declined sharply due to the boredom of the participants. You can imagine what it feels like transmitting thousands of these day after day to people in the next room.

You just go, you know, dizzy. And Rhine was seldom able to elicitate the strong ESP, strong psi Soviet and early French and British research elicited. In response to Soviet research, The US initiated, it seems in the late sixties, early seventies, a series of projects to investigate what was known as remote viewing, which used to be called clairvoyance, the capacity to see at a distance. And these projects have had a dizzying number of names and agencies. We have gone from project Skannit to Groflame to ICLP to project Sanskrit to project Stargate.

And at present, nobody really knows if there is such a project ongoing in The US or not. All these projects, after the late nineteen eighties seem to have been farmed out to private enterprise, such as the Humanities Foundation, for instance, of of c b Scott Jones in Virginia. You find a surprise surprise that the heads of these organizations are systematically people with close connections with the intelligence agencies. But it provides a lot of deniability for projects which are controversial in nature. One of the two most famous cases of psi data from these projects is a case of remote viewing involving Ingo Swan, one of the star projects of project scan eight, who seems to have been able to describe the operation of a sealed magnetometer, sealed in a vault in a building, to intelligence agents who were with him at Stanford University.

Then this was so shocking that basically, it led to his being hired by the project, you know. And Ingersoll Rand remained one of the mainstays of project scan eight under its various acronyms to the very end. However, the most striking known case of remote viewing is due to Pat Price, who was the most exceptional candidate used by project Sternrit at the Stanford Lutheran Institute. Pat Price had exceptional mediumistic capacities, and he was requested to actually see what was happening at a remote site in The Soviet Union, Semipalatinsk, which was of interest to the CIA. He made a sketch of what he saw, and this is his sketch, which is the sketch of a huge gurney.

And you can see when you compare this sketch with a drawing made by a CIA operative, the striking similarities. Then Pat Price met an untimely and unexplained end. It has been said he died of a heart attack. Many believe he was assassinated. All that can be said is his death was highly suspicious.

It was after collision with somebody in the lobby of his hotel that upon returning to his room, he was seized with convulsions and was basically declared dead within hours. What is quite striking is that the autopsy formulary were removed from the hospital to which Pat Price was taken and have never been found since. So some have said that Pat Price’s capacities were perhaps the cause of his demise. Others have said it was just a heart attack, with no way of knowing. But as of 1995, which is the last data I have, there was an average of 200 tasks which are assigned to these operatives by military organizations.

It’s a clear indication that such capacities seem to be considered real and perhaps legitimate, or seem to be considered real and legitimate as of 1995 by intelligence agencies. Then we must pass to the second category of psi phenomena, which has been investigated and may provide corroboration for mind body and mind matter interaction, psychokinesis. Psychokinesis, in other words, the capacity to move or affect matter with the mind alone, was investigated by Robert Jan, head of the Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research Center or laboratory, PEAR. Jan obtained remarkable data. Now I would like to give you some background regarding Jan himself to give you an idea of the caliber of the investigator involved.

Robert Jan was dean of engineering at Princeton, professor of plasma physics, founder of the electric propulsion and plasma dynamics lab at Princeton, and member of the NASA space science and technology advisory committee. He was a former foremost plasma physicist in The US. Perhaps unfortunately for him, one of his students wanted to write a master’s thesis on the possible effect of concentration on a random number generator. And Jan who had no particular interest in the topic accepted to direct the thesis. We can say that it is from this point onwards that his life spiraled downwards.

He was very surprised by the quality of the results she obtained, in dream, he decided he would try to reproduce them. Then John used a variety of random number generators. Some released the walls, others involved pendulums, some were electronic, there are some hydraulic random number generators, and he would ask volunteers to concentrate on the random number generators and try to affect the generation of random numbers in one direction or the other. Now what Jan found with his surprise was an extremely strong deviation from the expected once the number of runs became very high. Once one reached a couple 100 thousands of runs, Jan found what amounted to highly significant effects.

And what is quite striking is that these effects were independent of the type of random number generator used. Whether the random number generator was electrical, electronic, mechanical, hydraulic, the deviation was broadly the same, which seems to preclude this being an artifact of the random generator itself. In his book, The PEAR Proposition, general states that he considers such results unlikely by the order of 10 power minus 12, and this was one to 1,000,000,000,000. And these results are considered replicable on a large scale. Well, the key features of his research on psi has been that psi effects occur irrespective of the random generator number.

They occur over very large samplings, and in my opinion, they seem to suggest weak mind matter interaction at a non quantum classical level. So they seem to suggest what we mentioned previously, upwards quantum contamination. A contamination of quantum effects from the microscopic to the macroscopic. Well, Jerry isn’t in. Jahn’s research was hugely controversial.

It basically destroyed his career. He was a tenured professor at Princeton, so they had to keep him. But he was eventually given the laboratory in the basement of Princeton, and he had become an embarrassment for Princeton University. Then it’s a sign of his personal courage that he continued with his research despite the cost in terms of reputation and career. There has been some strong criticism of Jahn’s results from an Italian philosopher of science, and Robert Park, professor of physics at the University of Maryland, which hinges not so much on the experimental procedure used as the significance of the statistical indicator which Jahn used, which is considered to yield abnormal deviations when very large sampling is used.

Then the problem with this criticism is basically that it is never invoked for other experiments. It seems to be reserved for psi research, such as the research which Jahn undertook. And also, what is very difficult to take on board in Piedelicci’s criticism, is that Jahn’s results are consistent, strikingly consistent. Now you would expect if these abnormal results were due to the random generator or to statistical aberration, that such consistency would be absent. It’s not the case.

So, in my personal opinion, it seems difficult to criticize John’s research on this basis. What one can say is that because John’s research is heavily quantitative, like Rhine’s research at Duke University, the effects which are elicited are small. But convincing. In any other field of research, such such effects would be considered to prove the existence of some type of phenomenon. So in conclusion, I think what we can say is that von Neumann’s theory of the observer in quantum mechanics demands that the observer, in other words, human consciousness and perhaps animal consciousness as well, if animals can be observers of quantum phenomena, be non material.

Then we have a large body of evidence at present indicating mind to mind communication, in other words telepathy, and also mind matter interaction at the macroscopic level. All this seems to indicate that not only is the mind non material, but mind and matter are not separated by the type of inseccable boundary which is often considered to separate mind and matter in classical philosophy. There is course for a lot more research, but I think you can see how this might be relevant to those of us who are interested in Buddhist philosophy. And this is what I have to cover today with you. I thank you for your patience with some very difficult material, and I’ll be delighted to take your questions.

Thank you very much, wonderful presentation. I have a question about the double slit experiment because the more I hear about it the less I understand. I wonder if you could tell me when the wave function is like this and there is the interference pattern, say if when photon is behaving as a particle there’s a measurement of one, it goes into a little box or whatever. When it’s on the wave function there’ll be interferences at different points along that along the photographic plate or something used. Now do those interferences at the different points, do they equal say, if when the photon is seen as the particle, it has a value of one?

I’m not sure I understand your question. Yeah. Maybe I’m not. Basically, I’ll talk a bit about waves and particles, and maybe things will become clearer. If you think of waves, perhaps the best simile is waves and water.

Right? So if you drop one pebble in water, right, you have waves spreading outwards from that pebble. Right? So far so good. Right?

You take two pebbles, and you drop one pebble in water, and then shortly afterwards another pebble. What happens? You drop the first pebble, you have concentric waves spreading outwards. When you drop the second pebble, let’s say one meter away, you have a second set of concentric waves spreading upwards. When these two sets enter in contact, you have a phenomenon known as diffraction.

The waves add or subtract an amplitude in function of phase. You can see this. You have circle, circle, circle, and then suddenly you will have a very strange mixture of curves. This is typical wave behavior. Now when you are dealing with particles, there is no diffraction.

And it is the presence of the absence of diffraction, which determines whether we are dealing with what is known as undulatory phenomena, waves or particles. So what is striking with a double slit experiment is that when one sets out to measure diffraction, one finds diffraction. When one sets out not to measure diffraction but the impact of photons, let’s say, on a photoelectric screen, which generate an electric current, one finds indeed the impact of photons on a photoelectric screen. What the experimenter sets out to measure is what he finds. And the big question is, why is this the case?

It is everyone agrees on the experiment. The problem is how do we interpret it? With all the quantum mechanics at present, everyone agrees in the theorems, it is the interpretation which is a minefield. Then the data seems progressively to be favoring those who subscribe to a non material vision of mind. Seems to be.

The experiments are difficult to make, and obviously each time, one experiment is made, sometimes must be made. But you will find that it is in physics that one encounters the scientists most sympathetic to non material understandings of consciousness. And it is, for instance in biology, that one encounters the scientist’s most unsympathetic to such an understanding. Does that help? One slight small clarification.

So when the interference pattern is seen on the photoelectric plate there’s no way to measure the value of say for instance the whole interference pattern. So say if you fire five electrons through and you have a little device which captures them and measures them as a particle and you fire also five electrons through the double slit with photoelectric plate at the back, you can’t then add up the different I don’t know because I’m not a mathematician. You can’t add up the different diffraction patterns and get a quantity of five. So You can’t. But you well, we’re not dealing with electrons, but photons Right?

The energy level is exactly the same. Right? Yes. The question is Is that reflected on the photoelectric plate? Is the energy level Well, the energy you would you would calculate.

Right? You would know when you emit the photons. Right. So when they do the calculation of And the the energy level of particles and waves in this case would be identical. Right?

It’s not the goal of the experiment to measure that. Right. So it’s irrelevant. The idea is we’ve got a source of light. What happens when we choose to measure what comes out of that source?

And we find that it seems as if the nature of the phenomenon is contingent on what we choose to measure, which is very strange. That is something which is, from the standpoint of classical physics, totally aberrant. It’s as if you’d have a stream of cattle, coming out, let’s say, of TBI, and if you need goats, it’s goats, and if you need cows, it’s cows. Whoever heard of something like that? It’s when the cattle leave TBI that they’re either goats or cows.

Right? It’s not the case that you’re standing outside with someone who says, I want to buy goat milk, and suddenly the cattle is coming out and they are all goats. This is very strange. But basically, this double slit experiment, this is what we are dealing with. And the question which arises is why is this the case?

Now if you are saying that light is simultaneously a wave in a particle, it’s very difficult as a position to a code, because waves and particles have completely different behavior. Particles never exhibit diffraction. Waves always exhibit diffraction. Right? So the best explanation is one in which we consider light in terms of a wave function, and this wave function collapses, and I use the term manifest, it’s never used in physics, but manifests as a wave or a function or a particle in function of the experimental setup set up by the experimenter.

And then the debate which arises is, is it a function of the instruments of measure that this wave function collapse occurs, or is it in function of the intent in the mind of the observer? So the idea that it was in the function of the instruments of measure was, I would say, the classical idea of Nielespogen of Heisenberg, and it’s the easiest for us to take on board. Unfortunately, as time passes, there’s more and more data which is very strongly at odds with this. It’s not a coincidence that there’s a huge amount of interest in von Neumann’s formalization at present. Do we have other questions?

Yes, please. Was Jahn’s research replicated elsewhere? There were attempts to replicate some aspects of his research in remote viewing which failed, but that was not the main thrust of his research. To my knowledge, his research on psychokinesis, which is the main thrust of his research, has not been replicated, to my knowledge. Thank you.

Also in terms of science and sample size, we have to do power calculations to know the sort of sample size we’re looking at because of that problem that you’re talking about. So it be unethical just to do thousands or huge numbers without looking beforehand at whether you want to have a small sample size or a large sample size to show whatever effect you’re trying to find. I am not a statistician, so I really cannot comment on that aspect of his work. He himself seemed very satisfied with it, and he had a series of physicists working for him who were satisfied with it. Then What can one say?

I’m not criticizing, I’m just saying that it does occur in other areas as well, not just in physics, so it could be in health, medicine, science in general. Large sample problems, yes, yes. But that’s been the criticism which has been addressed to Rajan’s research, that the statistical techniques he used were not appropriate for the scale of the sample. Then one would like to think that someone in his position and with his background would not be open to that type of criticism, but who knows? It is a problem, and I guess to try to avoid that sort of pro those sorts of critiques.

Usually, people nowadays with some of the big experiments try to get statisticians on board early on so that they can raise those sorts of questions and it can be addressed before the experiment is designed. As you can see from the quotes I mentioned here, the US government asked two statisticians, independent statisticians, to assess psi research and they came to radically different conclusions within twenty days of each other. One from the University of California at Davis concluded that psychic functioning based on the government data given to her had been established beyond reasonable doubt, and another statistician from the American Institute for Research. These are, if you’ll forgive me for the term bogus institutions, which typically are basically government spin offs. It’s typical in The US, it’s how it’s done, you know, came to the conclusion that paranormal phenomena had not been established.

Same data, twenty eight days of interval with each with each other. Can see, it’s quite striking, and Jessica Utts, I’m not quite sure, did her career any good from the division of statistics of the UC Davis, consider that basically the data available for establishing psi research established it beyond reasonable doubt. Whereas, MD, Wells and Munford from the American Institutes for Research considered that there was no proof that this was due to the operation of paranormal phenomena. So we’re dealing, I think, with material which frankly is very threatening. It threatens the established paradigm, and this is not just an ideological threat.

This has huge impacts on funding, on endowments, on entitlement, on publication, then how much objectivity one can hope for is open to question. What were their questions? Not that I don’t know. I don’t know. Davies was a statistician.

But but to what level? So the the other one you mentioned was a was a doctor, so I had a PhD. Davies was a doctor of the division of statistics of UC Davies. Then one is entitled to assume that her results were displeasing to the powers that be because they came out on 09/01/1995, and twenty eight days later, that’s fast for research of that caliber, an evaluation of remote viewing research and application comes out from the American Institutes of Research saying exactly the opposite. And that’s the present state of affairs.

It had become very political in America. The evangelicals came into the picture, then they basically considered that the US government was funding, for practical purpose, Satan worshipers. You know? This is basically the level of the dialogue. You know?

And well, Thank you. I suppose when I read that sort of thing as a scientist, also look at the wording. So the wording here, evidence has not been provided that clearly demonstrates that the causes of the hits are due to the operation. So I I think the way that’s been written and, also, I guess, I would look to see where, where the work has been published in both cases. In this case, I have never heard of the American Institutes for Research, whereas I do know UC Davis, you know.

Then all I can do is present the data to you, you know. You have to make up your own opinions. I would say that when with this type of material, one tries to leave the enclave or the ghetto of Buddhist study centers, then one runs into big trouble. Big trouble. All those who have tried to investigate objectively phenomena such as telepathy, psychokinesis, or in the case of Ian Stevenson, of whom we will be talking tomorrow, cases of the reincarnation type, have basically faced tremendous professional difficulties.

John’s reputation was destroyed. Stevenson came close. Stephenson was going to be fired from the University of Virginia in 1966. It’s Chester Carlson who discovered the Xerox process, offered a huge endowment to UVA for Stevenson. There were members of the medical department which felt that even with an endowment of $1,000,000 at the period, they could happily live without Ian Stevenson and didn’t want him there.

Interestingly enough, we’ll see tomorrow with Stevenson’s research, no one has ever put in question his methodology. So my feeling is that the bias is so great that at present, it would be difficult for such research to be studied objectively largely because certainly in physics, we seem to be in a period of crisis of paradigm. And in such a period, there are huge vested interests which must be defended. Objective study is not part of these. And perhaps, from my personal standpoint, a strong argument in favor of much of this material is unambiguous government interest out of academia.

In the case of the US government and the Soviet government, the interest is clear to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars. Then, the military, in my limited experience, is composed of very practical people, who are really not terribly interested in dogma, but who are very interested in whether things actually work or don’t work. That level of interest over a long period of time is not insignificant, and that’s why I presented this data. It’s quite striking that in academia there is very little serious research at present on parapsychology. The funding isn’t there, you know.

And it’s it’s a way of committing academic suicide, literally. I mean, you’ve done a PhD, you’re planning for tenure, if you touch something like this, it’s finished. Something far less controversial than this, for instance, which is the impact of meditation on the brain fascinated Davison when he was doing his PhD at Harvard. You may have heard of Davidson. He did some very interesting research at the University of Wisconsin.

This is the early nineteen seventies, His thesis adviser said to him, look, I mean, you know, it’s up to you, but literally, you might want to stop attending these Vipassana courses if if you intend to get tenure and you intend to publish. And Davidson, I suppose, had little choice. He accepted, you know. He put his interest for Buddhist philosophy on the back burner, got tenure at University of Wisconsin, and then he met with Siswanathan Dalai Lama in ’19 what was it? ’98, I think, you know.

Siswanathan must have known about this because he said to him, you know, something to the effect of, don’t you feel you have to live in keeping with your principles? And Jefferson obviously had tenure at the University of Wisconsin, so, you know, he was once I don’t know in Australia, but in The US, once you have tenure, it is almost impossible to remove you. Then he started his research. I don’t know how it has affected his capacity to publish. Like with Stevenson, it’s very striking.

Stevenson was appointed chairman of, the medical faculty at the University of Virginia. I think he was one of the youngest chairmans in UVA’s history. UVA has generally, when I was able, was the second or third, medical school in the country. It was tops for medicine and law. Then, once Stevenson started his research on cases of the reincarnation type, within a matter of years he could no longer publish in mainstream journals.

And he actually had to create his own journal with other interested scientists, the Journal of Scientific Exploration, which was peer reviewed by those in the same field. Then luckily for Stevenson, he had tenure, he had a huge grant, and he lived in a limbo. That’s the price one pays, you know. And it is very interesting that his research has never been addressed head on. I find that very striking.

I mentioned tomorrow. What I’ll show you today but you see people say the sort of thing I will show you when they have retired or during the point of retirement. Nobody ever says this otherwise. A peer assessment of Stevenson’s research by Doris Kruman Willesdorf, who was professor of applied science at the Department of Physics at the University of Virginia. She was one of was, I think she’s no longer with us, one of America’s leading physicists.

Then she said this after retiring, you see, the statistical probability that reincarnation does in fact occur is so overwhelming established by thousands of already documented cases of remembered lives and strongly buttressed by the incidence of birthmarks in conjunction with many of his well documented cases that cumulatively, the supporting evidence is not inferior to that for most if not all branches of science with the physics cosmology or Darwinian evolution. And you have a similar comment by the book review editor of the Journal of the American Cases in which the evidence is difficult to explain on any other grounds. Yet the impact of Stevens research research in main science has been nominal. So I think main science does not concern us. Are not in academia here, you know, and I have no no future prospects of any type.

So thanks to Kensei Riberty, I can speak very freely without being afraid of any consequences. And you all, I think, are sympathetic to Buddhism, so, you know, I don’t feel I have to be very wary of what I say in front of you. But in academia, let’s say, if I were to make a presentation like this, my fate would be sealed. Even at the University of Virginia, when I was a student of Jeffrey Hopkins, we were in the religious studies department, a presentation like this, Jeffrey would have spoken to me after he would have said, you know, you want to be careful. I don’t know if that goes towards answering your question.

The statistical spy side, I cannot comment upon, but I have I’m just very struck that certainly in the case of the BSI research in the context of the Stanford Research Institute, two independent assessments were requested by the US government in a one month period in 1995, and they reached what, to some day we do, seems to be radically opposite conclusions. Thank you. That was really good to hear all of that. I guess what I would say, if you look at the second one, the con, they did say there was a statistically significant difference. They did.

Yeah. And then they came to the other conclusion or came to a conclusion. They did. That’s what’s quite striking. There is statistically significant laboratory effect and then it leads to nothing, right?

Yes. So evidence has not been provided that clearly demonstrates the causes of the hits. I think that’s the key. How would you provide such evidence? I don’t know whether they’re implying something that that something was done behind the scenes that caused it or whatever.

I don’t know if that’s what they’re implying. They they are contradicting the other person’s statistics. Fraud or who who knows what they meant. They they were just it it contradicts the second sentence does leave the reader with the impression that this isn’t right, but they’ve been very careful about how they’ve worded it. Shall I put it that way?

It had become very political. It had become very political. It was a matter of funding. Then it was a matter of evangelical support for the Republican administration. Then, you know In that context, how was Richard Conn Henry’s article in Nature received?

Because to talk about the mental universe, and then you were saying in terms of quantum physics Richard Con Henry published that the year he retired. Just as I will be talking tomorrow about Pim van Lommel’s research on near death experiences, Pim van Lommel was one of, well he was Holland’s leading cardiologist, and at the end of a long career that started, which started in the late 1960s, He retired, I think it was in 2002, and in 2002, the year of his retirement, he published an article in The Lancet, which as you know is Britain’s leading medical publication, on near death experiences, which he had encountered in his practice as a cardiologist for forty and some years. Then for forty and some years he had to keep his peace. Do you know? It’s quite striking if you look at the dates of these publications, it’s published typically within a couple months of retirement, when nothing can happen anymore, right?

Pretty much. I’ve got three questions. The first two are related. In relation to quantum entanglement, what constitutes interaction, and have not all particles been entangled at the point of the big Bang? Well, that’s a big question indeed.

All particles did interact, during Big Bang. What the effect of that one is, I don’t know. I mean, I don’t even know how you would address the math of that one. Interaction would mean, for instance, let us say, you excite an atom of hydrogen, and as a result of this excitation the atom emits two photons. These photons were emitted from the same source they have interacted, you know.

That is sufficient. Then they go their own way, their own route, however long, but what quantum entanglement is saying is that once you have a relationship with somebody, I’m sorry for those of you who have many relationships, you can never break away and get free. Right? There’s no such thing as putting an end to relationships in quantum mechanics. They keep haunting you.

Then your question is an excellent one. Entanglement is something one uses. Nobody really understands how it’s possible because it’s it’s a violation of the special theory of relativity, right, which states that fields in a vacuum cannot be transmitted at speeds higher than the speed of light. If you have instantaneous particles affecting each other instantaneously over millions of light years because they were entangled once 100,000,000 light years ago, and a change in the spin of one particle affects instantaneously the spin of the other particle. For instance, the classic case which is always given is if you create a pair, particle antiparticle, right, then they have opposite spins, right?

So you create this pair, it is stable with opposite spin. So one, we would say is they don’t actually turn, but you imagine that one is turning clockwise, the other is turning counterclockwise. And then they go with their separate routes, you know. And for some reason, millions of light years away, the spin of particle a shifts from clockwise to counterclockwise. Then instantaneously, the spin of particle b shifts from counterclockwise to clockwise.

And there’s no there’s no explanation. There’s no explanation. So Einstein, to the end of his life, subscribed to what’s known as the theory of supplementary parameters, which is that there were unknown parameters, which once they were discovered would make sense of this, and a great physicist like David Bohm tried to create a supplementary parameter theory, which unfortunately is very much at odds with Bell’s theorems. So those are those are big questions. We’ll talk about them tomorrow a bit.

My personal feeling is that the quantum paradoxes all arise from an attempt to describe an unobserved phenomenon. Now from the standpoint of Buddhist philosophy it is not possible to have such a thing as an unobserved phenomenon. An object and the subject perceiving it are interdependent. If you look at this interdependence, you can make sense of a fair number of the paradoxes in quantum mechanics, not all, but a fair number. Then the remaining paradoxes, which Richard Cohen was alluding to, frankly, and we will talk about this tomorrow, seem to vindicate three philosophies of reality: Vedanta, Chitamatra, and Prasangika Madhyamika.

These are the three philosophies of reality which are strongly compatible with the data from quantum mechanics. And, I have friends still in Switzerland who are working physicists, then, this is what they are interested in. This makes sense for them. Does that answer your question? The third question I had is a bit tongue in cheek.

I’d I’d love to hear your comment on the strong levels of altruism in a bull ant versus that of an academic who’s, scared of losing tenure. Yes. Well, that was insane. Right? It was a documentary I saw a while ago.

It was it talked about some research that was done quantum entanglement where scientists used people’s, like plugged people’s hearts up to monitors and printed out the, know, I’m not sure what they’re called, but the heart monitor. The ECG. ECG, yeah. And they were told both good and bad news and they noticed that in between the spikes at the heart that depending upon the news that they were given, giving the pupils that there were different I’m not sure what you call them but responses between the spikes so I was just wondering if you think there is a connection between quantum entanglement and ESP and the physical form responding to that, I guess. I can’t say normally.

I mean, the moment you pass above pretty much the molecular level, quantum phenomena normally are no longer operative. You have what’s known as decoherence. Then in that case, I don’t know. That’s interesting. I mean, you’d have to exclude a lot of other things, obviously.

You’d have to see how the experiment was done. You’d have to exclude unintentional cues from the experiment. It’s always difficult to do, you know. Then if the experiment was well devised, it could be an indication of precognition. Yes.

But unintentional cue is very difficult to eliminate. It could be. It could be. I mean, I have known many cases of precognition during my life, but what I’m trying to do is to I’m trying to build a very strong rational case for you. Then your experiences, you have to make by yourselves.

But there is a strong rational case to be made, and I think research in this field is really important. Then I was telling Chris a couple days ago that I am more optimistic about clinical research, for instance, on near death experience and academic research, because clinical research is more grounded in clinical reality, and clinicists typically are not in this well, suppose you can call it a bit of a dog-eat-dog milieu of academia, you know, and have a bit more independence. Certainly as far as near death experiences are concerned, we get some strong research from clinicians, and the academics have a much harder time finding funding. Sorry, I was talking with the cat behind you, is desperately trying to come in. Do we have other questions?

Thank you very much. I’ve read some historical accounts of Tibetans and so on, and they seem to have a high incidence of these psychic abilities. The messages on the wind and their ability to dream in a precognitive way and so on. So it seems they’re highly receptive recipients to messages possibly. The other question is, given that they’re if they are highly receptive recipients and good at receiving messages, They also generate altruism and engage in thinking of the suffering of others on a huge scale.

Yet they do not seem to be affected by the suffering of others despite so the greater their empathy increases, the less they seem inflicted by suffering. If they are really in tune to the sentient beings around them, what kind of thing would explain that phenomena if it is true? What would explain they’re not being affected by the suffering of others? Yes, even though they’re able to connect with minds of others and figure out, I assume that they connect to the minds of others and that’s how they know a certain thing is going to happen or a certain being’s continuum is right or so on. I assume they have those intuitive abilities.

But yeah, don’t seem to be affected in a really negative way, no matter the empathy they generate for other sentient beings. We’re shifting here from, I think, the realm of science to that of Buddhist philosophy, but in Buddhist philosophy come here, Buddy cat. It’s typical feline behavior. In the realm of Buddhist philosophy, clearly one’s karma is private. Then one’s suffering is a result of one’s own karma, another cannot experience it for oneself, however much they would wish to.

How one’s experience how I’m sure they perceive their emotions but they don’t experience them. How one’s mind appears to someone who has telepathy is a bit of an open question. Telepathy is, I would say, current, quite widespread in the Tibetan monasteries. Many of my teachers had it, I had clear proof really of it. Once they knew that I knew, it was more or how it worked, once they knew that I knew, we started making believe it didn’t happen.

Then I didn’t have to explain a lot of things anymore. It made everyone’s life a lot simpler. Then until they were sure that I knew and was sure and was not worried about the whole process, we’d go through the rigmarole of my explaining things and all that. These phenomena are widely tested in the Tibetan monasteries. Telepathy is just current.

Memories of past lives are very widespread. Psychokinesis, I know of a couple of cases, stronger than Jan’s data, much, much stronger. This didn’t occur in controlled environments, right? I can tell you, for instance, you know, one case. One of my teachers basically had clear premonitions of the September 11.

Very clear. It is said that it is possible if one concentrates on love, so a strong concentration, to experience in one’s body the suffering of others. Maitri Yogi was said to have those experiences, but obviously one does not have the karma to experience another’s person’s suffering. Then what karma is, is complex. Karma within the aggregates is a compositional factor.

Karma is at the interface of one’s mind and the reality one experiences. It is something which is very difficult to share. It’s impossible to share, actually. But Stevenson’s research suggests many cases where, at the a terrible event happening to a loved one Those cases are unknown. I mean, I’ve known of a couple.

I can’t really answer your question. I’ve known at least of one case of the teacher of a friend of mine who was killed experiencing the fear of death of this friend at the time of his death, some 1,000 and some kilometers away, like a very sharp pain in the breast. Then, obviously, he didn’t experience a death, but there seems to be a mental connection which allows emotions to flow. Certainly, the Russian evidence on telepathy, that’s why I presented it to you, seems to indicate that the amplifier for telepathic transmission is emotion, and all of the anecdotal evidence for telepathy corroborates that as well. Plus the existence of some type of connection between the parties: mother and child, friends.

More than that I cannot say. Do we have other questions? I was interested in you saying that at the level of quantum physics, people have vastly different opinions about what it all means. Have they is that discussed in any papers or are they just are they holding their keeping their powder dry or are they just exhausted having argued for so many? It’s a gentleman’s agreement not to talk about it.

So it was thrashed out in great details in the nineteen thirties and forties, with quantum physics becoming ever stranger. And then the reading of this gentleman’s agreement, that’s the best term I can find for it. We’re just gonna do the math. We go from point a to point b, we get the results. We’re not quite sure what the math means, but it works.

Like, if you take a wave function, a wave function, I’m trying to describe it to you in English, but it’s a mathematical reality. It’s a long thing you write on the board, you know. What it means, nobody really knows. Or if you prefer, everyone has his own opinion. And especially in the last fifty years with Bell’s theorem, nobody really knows where Bell’s theorems are going to take us.

The theorems are not terribly complicated to write, but the verifications of the violations show that Einstein’s view of a world in which, as he said, God did not throw dice, is fundamentally wrong. And every year which passes with every more detailed verifications of variations of Bell’s theorems shows that we live in a world which is non local, probably non deterministic, and probably a world which does not really exist independently of our minds. Now, this is something which the two Mahayana schools of Buddhist philosophy are quite comfortable with, but it is something with which most Westerners are profoundly uncomfortable with. Most scientists are profoundly uncomfortable with this. That’s why it was quite nice to read Richard Koons’ letter to nature.

You know. It’s a very very interesting period, that’s why I wanted to cover with you this morning Thomas Kuhn’s analysis of paradigm shift, because I think that is exactly the situation we are in at present. We’re in a paradigm shift which started in the nineteen thirties, it’s been eighty five, eighty four years now, and it’s a fundamental paradigm shift from a realistic deterministic local universe to a non realistic, non deterministic, non local universe in which mind is non material, then it’s been resisted very strongly because you can see why it’s being resisted. Take something very basic, like the double blind test you may have heard about. Right?

When you test, let’s say, a medical compound, you have subjects who receive it and subjects who don’t receive it, and nobody knows who’s got it or not. Right? Then you can eliminate the placebo effect. If telepathy is a reality, how on earth does a double blind testing procedure function? It can’t, right?

You have it’s impossible to preclude the possibility of one of the subjects knowing through telepathy that the other subject has received it and he has not, or through checking the mind of the experimenter knowing who got what. Then much of scientific experimentation as we know it goes out through the windows. So I think the resistance of working scientists to any change of the paradigm is quite understandable, but certainly in physics, we’re being forced in that direction. Yes. I would have thought the question what it means determines the boundary between science and philosophy, and that’s perhaps why scientists don’t engage in or engage less in what the meaning is of their finding.

Well, that was the position of the founders of quantum mechanics. That was Niels Bohr’s position, which is basically, we work with the data, we try to construct theories, we stick to the math, and we don’t ask too many questions. Then the problem is, more and more, one is dealing with incredibly counterintuitive phenomena, such as tunneling in quantum mechanics, where basically a particle can just pass from one point to the other without seemingly passing in any of the intermediate points. It’s becoming more and more awkward to to do the math without any real understanding of what’s happening. You’ve all heard of quantum computers and quantum cryptography, which are basically, you know, probably the next step forwards, in cybernetics.

Then it’s quite striking to think that maybe we have no clear understanding of the theoretical underpinnings of either. The math is understood. Empirical data is understood. Why things happen the way they do, we don’t understand. So it’s very, very awkward to have a situation where you are basically asserting this.

This is very strange. When you have okay. Classical Newtonian physics as a subset of relativistic physics or quantum physics, that’s okay. But this boundary here, with relativistic physics and quantum physics, this is bizarre. You have one cutting edge set of physics, special and general relativity, which is both realistic and local.

In other words, the world exists out there, and phenomena to interact must be somewhat close. And you have another cutting edge field of physics, is neither realistic nor local, and both work in their respective fields. It’s very odd. It begs the question that do we have a super theory, and that’s been the holy grail of the last 80. You know, there’s been numerous attempts, you know, to try to find a an overarching theory.

But what is interesting for us are the consequences of quantum physics. Relativistic physics, special theory of relativity, basically puts in question our understanding of space and time. This is less relevant for us. It’s interesting philosophically, but less relevant. But quantum physics addresses directly the status of the mind, and in so doing really opens the door to all the great philosophical and religious traditions which assert that the mind is non material.

If from a man’s understanding of the status of the observer is confirmed, then we will be able to say that certain philosophical and religious traditions are true and others are false. It’s something which is quite unique in human history. Because if fundamental man’s understanding is true, then we can say materialism is false. If the developments in our understanding of the Bell’s theorem are true, then we can say realism is false. Then I would say the two pillars of Western philosophy pretty much collapse.

So it’s a very exciting period to live in. I think it’s very distressing for physicists. My impression of biologists is that they sort of they leave these questions to the physicists. But it’s it’s interesting for us because what we do see at GBI is that our students face a lot of difficulty from these cross reductionistic models of the human mind, which typically come from neurobiology. Today, we’ve lost a couple of students to that.

And it’s worth pointing out that there is strong evidence that these are open to question. We have a question from this lady here, I think. In the documentary The Biology of Belief by Bruce Lipton, have you seen that? He’s a biologist, a genetic He used to genetically engineer muscle cells in petri dishes. And he did it for many years.

And while he was doing it, because he was a straight out scientist he sort of tripped over the belief because he would do things like take the DNA out of the cell and yet the cells still functioned so he started to question where the consciousness lie within the cell and as he took the different parts out of the cell there was still consciousness within the cell so it didn’t lie within the DNA and it didn’t lie within and he ends up being incredibly inspired and finding faith from science, funnily enough. And because he finds that really all of our cells are little antennas. And if they’re antennas and they’re picking up transmissions and where are they picking up transmissions from. So he was a biologist, just thought I’d let you know. He discovered going through science, which if my personal experience is pretty rare.

And he’s a very inspired man and it’s a very inspiring two part documentary. Available on YouTube, if you haven’t seen it. I haven’t seen it, so I can’t comment. Do you have any other questions? You touched on quantum physics supporting nondeterminism, and I wondered how karma and causality hold up in the face of nondeterminism in a quantum world.

We’ll talk about it tomorrow. In brief, what I would say is that within the four systems of tenets, Sautrantrika, Cittamatra, and Madhyamika, Vaibhashika and Sautrantrika are realistic and strongly deterministic, then they are not compatible with quantum mechanics. If and the evidence really seems to support this at present, quantum mechanics is a definitive description of reality, then there are only two schools of tenets which are compatible, Chitamatra and Madhyamika, actually really Chitamatra and Prasamika. Then the Chitamatra and Prasamika understanding of causality is very complex. It’s not at all the straightforward causality you find in Sattravikka.

Not at all. Quantum physicists who are philosophically inclined tend to towards idealistic systems like cittamatra or Vedanta. Minor was a clarification from this morning. From my perspective, whatever the answer to the question is, empathy is definitely present. But my question is, in this morning’s talk, were you asserting that empathy happens as a part of evolution or despite evolution?

Empathy is unnecessary For evolution. For evolution. I mean, if we consider that all behavior, certainly all animal behavior with nominal exceptions, is transmitted, and you have a large number of sociobiologists who have this opinion, then empathy is really very difficult to explain. Altruism can be explained in genetically related populations, as we mentioned this morning, but empathy really seems like a case of maladaptation. That happens despite evolution.

Yeah. Evolution would naturally weed out empathy, but yet empathy remains. Well, there seems to be no evolutionary advantage for an animal which has strong empathy. Like a rat who sees another rat being shocked, the example I gave this morning, would probably not be genetically related to the other rat. Then that reaction of strong empathy decreases his own chances of survival and is of no benefit to the rat being shocked.

So from an evolutionary standpoint, it’s a net loss. One doesn’t see what benefit the rat would derive. In the case of altruism, you can make the case that in closely genetically related populations, an individual who sacrifices himself is nonetheless able to further the transmission of his genes because he can be carried by other members of the population. But this case basically collapses when you’re dealing with populations which are not genetically related or very loosely related, and then all altruism, and there are numerous cases in these populations and primates especially, has to be seen as a case of extreme adaptation, which amounts to a form of suicide. Adam is very aware of this, and, frankly, altruism has been the stumbling block for all the theories of evolution up to the modern synthesis from day one from day one.

By the way, I do subscribe to the theory of evolution, just if you have any doubt. There’s no wrong. I just don’t view it as an all encompassing theory which accounts for everything. And when it comes to sociobiology, I am much more hesitant. It is clear to me that there are there is behavior which is transmitted genetically.

It’s just as clear to me that there is huge swathes of behavior which are culturally acquired, and in my private opinion, which are acquired through reincarnation. Then I think some of the ambient forms of explanation we are dealing with nowadays arise from the fact that we cannot invoke reincarnation as an explanatory model. Things become quite simple if you invoke reincarnation, you know. And if you don’t, you have to start start stretching and coming up with all sorts of very contrived explanations. Do you have other questions?

It’s been a very long day. Thank you very much for your attention, especially this afternoon. I hope you can see that there is some method to the madness of these presentations, and then at the end looking back, there is ground for irrational adherence to some of the Indian schools of thought. And I would like to point out tomorrow that Buddhism is privileged in this respect because key tenets of Buddhist philosophy are fundamentally in harmony with much of what we know now of basic physics. Thank you very much.

Thank you. Just to say, Illya, you’ve once again given us much food for thought, and we will all be dreaming about this tonight, I’m sure. And so I did forget to thank Susan St. Clair for feeding the body which has helped us to get through the day. So thank you so much Susan.

And we look forward to seeing you all and a few others who will be here tomorrow. Thank you. And please service us for the bibliography. It is food for the mind. Thank you.

I’m glad you enjoyed it.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top