TBI Symposium — 2013-02-23

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

TBI Symposium (TBI)
TBI Symposium (TBI)
TBI Symposium — 2013-02-23
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2013-02-23 – KR (4).mp3

UUID: b824c8c5-a737-4316-be14-e6416f92c24d

Teacher: —

Collection: TBI Symposium

Date: 2013-02-23

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 46 min

Words: 5,935

Because it is a structure which is actually taking energy from the outside to build up its interior level of order. In other words, it is a structure which is programmed to lead to a decrease of entropy. And this is one of the features of life. So this is what Ilya Prigogine called a dissipative system. It’s a very very minor category of thermodynamic structure which draws on the exterior to increase its own level of order.

Every one of us in this room is a dissipative structure. We eat three times a day and the food which we ingest, which is basically energy from the exterior, is transformed, first it’s broken down into proteins, eventually amino acids, the energy is used to recombine these amino acids and proteins and to build our bodies to maintain order. Now this, in my private opinion, is a core biological feature of life. Now it is not the case that every dissipative system is alive as we understand it. Certainly mammals such as ourselves are, bacteria are, then viruses are occasionally dissipative.

When a virus enters a cell, that virus takes control of the cell and uses that cell to increase its own degree of order by propagating itself. It is occasionally dissipative. Prions really technically are molecules, and we have certain molecules including crystals, which seem to build up order at the expense of the environment. So these are all dissipative structures. And therefore if we try to have a definition of life from the standpoint of physics of thermodynamics, and I think it’s as good as we can get and this is my private definition, Living systems are consistent or occasional dissipative systems which are the vectors of information.

They are dissipative systems as we said because they build up their own inner structure at the expense of the environment either consistently which is our case we do it all the time. If we don’t eat three times a day we are rather at least in my case I am rapidly in trouble or occasional systems as viruses which from time to time are able literally to reproduce. The other feature of life which is very striking is that life is always the vector of information. The vector of information in this case is information for self reproduction and this refers to the genetic code. Every single instance of life, biological life as we know it, reproduces itself.

So I think this is a good definition of life, in the present state of knowledge. The question is, what does this have to do with consciousness? Do they intersect? Where and how? Now once again relying on physics where I think which I think in this field gives us much firmer guidance than biology.

I mooted last year that consciousness can be understood from the standpoint of quantum mechanics. And I think really it is the best approach to understanding consciousness. So I won’t re enter into the details of that explanation. I will just point out that for some of the leading interpretations of quantum mechanics, which are known as the Von Neumann Interpretation and Wigner’s interpretation of the Von Neumann interpretation. A non material mind is a necessity of the theory.

Without a non material mind there cannot be a collapse of the wave function. What is now known as a state vector. Therefore from the standpoint of von Neumann’s interpretation of quantum mechanics which is an orthodox dominant interpretation, non material consciousness is non negotiable. It’s not an issue. How it is connected to the brain, that is something physics does not enter into.

But a material brain cannot cause a collapse of the wave function. From the standpoint of the orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics, biological reductionism is nonsense. I mean it doesn’t even enter the playing field. And I should point out von Neumann was the leading mathematician of the twentieth century. Then if this is the case, this could connect very closely to the Buddhist understanding of mind and of certain minds known as Pramanas, which are minds which give validity to the existence of phenomena.

Now I won’t enter into this in detail, we talked about it in August’s symposium. All I would say is that it is really astonishing that the Buddhist teachings which are 25 centuries old, should come so close to key findings of modern physics. Now my own background is in physics before I switch to Buddhist studies, then I am long since removed from the mathematics. I could probably write an equation or two but I couldn’t probably do a lot more than that. But I think I’m still able to assess what a valid account of basic physics is and what is not.

And clearly the accounts we get in core sections of Physics, specifically in Quantum Mechanics are completely at odds with the materialist presentation of the mind which is current nowadays. Then this leads us to the issue I wanted to get at at the beginning. What exactly is the relationship between life and consciousness? And we will define both in terms of physics. Life from the standpoint of Thermodynamics and Consciousness from the standpoint of Quantum Mechanics.

Life is simply a set of potentially dissipative systems. In other words, systems, something with an enclosure, with a membrane, with a boundary which can increase its degree of order at the expense of the environment. That is life. Conscious entities are any entities which can cause the reduction of a state vector. In other words, which can eliminate uncertainty in the measurement process in quantum mechanics.

These two intersect. They intersect at the level of all the species we are aware of. Humans, mammals, reptiles are both living systems. Our bodies clearly increase their degree of order at the expense of the environment through nutrition, And they are conscious entities because a human being through observing a microscopic experiment can cause the uncertainty in at least one component of that microscopic experiment to disappear. He causes, he or she causes the collapse of the wave function.

Now we can see how important it is to distinguish between life and consciousness. Many talks I have heard on the two topics they are simply equated. This leads to fundamental misunderstandings down the line. Life is a process of exchange of energy, in other words of thermodynamics. Consciousness is a problem, a process involving the relation between a non material phenomenon, mind and the rest of phenomena.

That non material phenomenon through observation can cause uncertainty to disappear. This is what consciousness is. Something which has both these features we call in the West a human being, a dog, I don’t know if dogs can cause a collapse of wave functions but why not? I’m sure there was a cat involved in the picture if maybe serves me well, why not a dog? And perhaps even smaller organisms than this.

So having clarified what we will be talking about, I’d like to remind you of some of the topics I brought up here over the last two years. The non material nature of the human consciousness. And here I have attached pictures of two leading, one leading researcher in near death experiences, a Dutch cardiologist Pim van Lommel. And one of these most striking cases of near death experience, Pamela Reynolds who was clinically dead for several minutes in an Operating Theatre in a controlled environment and had memories of the events which occurred during that period when sensory input was impossible. Her eyes were closed, her ears were shut with a special resonator which was used by the anesthesiologist to determine whether there was actually consciousness or not which is a big issue in anesthesia.

And yet after she was literally resurrected, the term is not inappropriate, she reported events she could not have known. It’s a very strong argument for the non material nature of consciousness. But what I’d like to do here is to remind you of the arguments which have been presented here for the non material nature of the human mind. We have arguments from Physics, Psychiatry, Medicine, Linguistics, neurobiology and psi. From physics I mentioned the the von Neumann interpretation of quantum mechanics.

And from psychiatry we have covered here several times children or human beings who have clear verified memories of past lives, verified by a psychiatrist Ian Stevenson, who is chair of the department of psychiatry at the University of Virginia. Then we have evidence for the non material nature of the mind from medicine. These are the verified near death experiences, where someone dies, is brought back and actually has memories of something they had no way of knowing. We have clear evidence from linguistics, the so called poverty of stimulus argument of Noam Chomsky, which basically in a nutshell says that if a child is said to learn language from his mother, the amount of information the mother gives a child is insufficient for that child to learn his mother tongue. Therefore the child must know the language from some other source.

What other source is a huge question mark. My suggestion is it is previous life acquaintance. Because the poverty of stimulus argument stands, the amount of data the mother provides to the child by speaking when she holds the child and the child looks at her mouth and listens actually can be measured, can be estimated. That amount of data is insufficient for the child to construct the rules of the language and to learn to speak. This is established.

The question is why? Chomsky goes out on a very big limb, the theories we won’t enter into here, so called universal theories of language, or generative theories of language. But I think a much stronger argument is simply previous life acquaintance with the language, which in turn does not make it necessary to acquire the rules all over again. The next argument which I think is a weaker argument, but it is an argument in favor of the non material nature of consciousness comes from neurobiology and it is simply that there is not a single solid account of consciousness in neurobiology. Those of you who are interested are welcome to look up Koch and Crick’s neurobiology of consciousness.

I may have listed it in the biography, bibliography. These were two of the leading neurobiologists of their age. Crick has unfortunately passed on since. And they did their best just a couple of years ago and they were not able to provide a convincing account of consciousness as consciousness. You can provide a convincing account of memory but not of consciousness.

Finally the most sensitive data is the data from PSI. In other words from ESP. I presented two years ago here very strong data from the Princeton anomalies lab. Robert Jahn’s data on psychokinesis. In other words control of matter by the mind.

Jahn was the dean of the engineering faculty at Princeton University. He actually destroyed his career pursuing this line of research and eventually became a pariah, but before becoming a pariah he was in many senses the father of NASA’s space program. To give you an idea of the caliber of the gentleman. The second category of PSI data I presented was the data on telepathy. I do mainly on Russian sources Vasilyev and his collaborators at the University of Leningrad which have very strong data confirming the existence of telepathy over very great distances in excess of 1,000 kilometers.

So my personal feeling is if you look at all this data, we have made a very strong case for the fact that the mind is not a product of the brain. There is a relation between the mind and the brain, but the mind is independent of the brain. And if you wish to convince yourself of this, I would strongly suggest that you draw on the bibliography in your own work to try to see how much this is the case or not. Now if the mind is not a product of the brain, this is a game changer isn’t it? Then we take everything we have been taught, we put it on the table and we have to reassess everything.

Because that means that the mind can exist independently of the brain. In which form is unclear, but it can. That means that there can be a before the brain for the mind and an after the brain for the mind. What we know as past lives and future lives. Suddenly, the view of the Indian religious traditions becomes much more convincing, doesn’t it?

For this reason, I think for westerners, this is the crux. If you spend ten years of your life establishing beyond doubt that the mind is not a part of the brain, instead of meditating on Lamrim, and instead of doing retreats and coming to teachings, that time is better spent. Because once that is established, you will be unstoppable. Until that is established, you will be floundering in a morass of doubts and uncertainties, and this is the toing and froing and the endless stream of tourists we see in Buddhist centers. So, look into this if you are interested to try to get a sense of what the mind is.

It is not irrelevant for us. The mind is our fundamental experiencer. Everything I say to you and everything you hear in this room is mediated from my mind to your mind via sound. Now, this connects directly to the Buddhist typology of the lower realms. Because from the Buddhist standpoint there are three lower realms.

One which is visible to human beings, the animal realm. One which is basically invisible, except for mediums, which is a realm of spirits and preytas, and one which is considered totally invisible, the hell realms. Now, I would say that a very large proportion of Western Buddhists, if they accept reincarnation at all, tend to think of reincarnation as happening from human to human. They are quite ready to recognize that animals exist, few are actually ready to recognize that human beings can reincarnate as animals. And typically they are in a state of prolonged discomfort regarding the existence of spirits and the hell realms.

It is a topic which is not brought up in polite western Buddhist society. It is however foundational for one’s practice. So the question here is very simply, is this true or is this false? And if it is false, then we can just drop it. But if it is true, it does have far reaching consequences.

Then these realms have to be addressed differently. In the case of animal realms, we all agree they exist. The problem arises from the fact that many westerners don’t believe animals have minds, in other words non material minds, and do not by extension believe that reincarnation as an animal is possible. So for animals we will start by demonstrating not that they exist, we all agree, but that they do have minds and that one can reincarnate as an animal. Then, this is perhaps meaningless to you but very meaningful to me.

It’s a small Pomeranian, very similar to the dog of my first teacher, Geshe Raptan. He was given to Geshe Raptan and he taxed Geshe Raptan’s patience greatly. Since as you know it seems that the smaller they get the more noise they produce. Then he was a noise factory but blindly devoted to Geshe Raptan and unlike myself who tends to discipline the dog with a rosary, Geshe Raptan had a spray and he disciplined at the distance with water. Then I remember living in fear of little Norbu.

I would go to see Geshe Raptan for teachings and have this little creature just bouncing hysterically and barking. But what struck me was my father treated Geshe Raptan, my father was a very famous cancerologist in his final years and upon Geshe Raptan’s death, little Norbu would disappear. He literally disappeared, we thought he was dead, we couldn’t find him. And it’s after a week hiding in Geshe Raptan’s room that we found him sleeping on Geshe Raptan’s old robes, monastic robes. He hadn’t eaten in other words and drunk for a week.

Then the Tibetans were very touched and they did their best for him. But he refused to eat and to drink and he died. Then I was very struck by that. It’s extraordinary loyalty of this little animal who obviously could not understand who his master was, but who had features of consciousness which really are among the noblest features of human consciousness. And that led me a little bit on the path of reflection which we will be talking about today.

Which is that there is no legitimate reason, if we accept that the human mind is non material, to say that the animal mind is material. In other words, if we have established that the human mind is separate from the brain, I hope to show to you that the animal mind also is separate from the brain. And the first thing I would like to address is the notion of a continuum of consciousness in evolution. I think the evolution of species is an established reality. Then if we continue, if we accept the evolution of species as a reality and we accept what I think I have basically shown over the last two years that the human mind is non material.

If we are going to say that the animal mind is a product of the brain, where in the process of evolution does suddenly this shift happen? And it’s a very, very odd shift. You have basically a little machine, that’s the traditional western account of animals according to Descartes, and suddenly that little machine generates something non material from its mechanical parts. This is basically nonsensical. I mean you have very major boundary problems.

And I would like to flesh out the argument by saying that if human consciousness is non material and I think I have shown that with those seven points, why should animal consciousness which can manifest eight major features of human consciousness not be non material as well? These eight major features we have verified in animal consciousness is altruism, empathy, self recognition, reasoning, memory, language, numeracy and even paranormal capacities. Now I will not speak of paranormal capacities because it is very controversial and I don’t want to enter into that here, but I will address each of the other features. So the question therefore we have to ask before we enter into animal consciousness is that of the boundary between consciousness and non consciousness. How far down do we go in the evolutionary scale?

Do we go down to ants? Do we go down to bacteria? Do we go all the way down to viruses? We agree they are alive. They are dissipative systems.

They increase their degree of order at the expense of the environment. The question is, are they conscious? Can they cause a collapse of the wave function or not? Then, I have no way of telling you whether an ant can cause a collapse of the wave function, but I have access to studies which make a very strong case for ants being very noble beings. Then those studies I think can sort of incline us in a certain direction.

Then if we ask what sort of a physical base consciousness needs to manifest? Clearly coarse consciousnesses, in other words lets say visual consciousness requires a physiological basis. We need an eye organ, we need a visual cortex, we actually need a cortex probably. So some type of neurological substratum is required for coarse consciousnesses. And this neurological substratum can be neural ganglia in worms or insects, or a cerebrum leading up to a fully developed brain.

But for subtle consciousnesses my contention is that a physiological basis is not necessary. Subtle consciousnesses do not need a brain, do not need neural ganglia, do not need a cerebrum. In other words, they survive death. And they can exist independently of the brain. So let us first address the issue of animal cognition and the non material nature of the mind of animals.

This is one of the most moving pictures I have ever seen. It is an elephant mourning his mother. The skull is actually the skull of this elephants mother. In India, where I lived many years, we have actually elephant graveyards. The elephants gather the remains of, it seems that they are graveyards as far as we can ascertain, of their progenitors.

And I am told this is the case in Africa, I don’t know for a fact. Then such a level of consciousness is troubling. So what are the features of consciousness which animals share with human beings? Altruism, empathy, self recognition, reasoning, which involve the acquisition of skills, and even surprisingly enough tool usage, memory, language and even numeracy. Certain animals can indeed count.

So I have taken data from the whole animal realm to try to show to you that it is not as many people think. The case that it’s only the higher primates, maybe the dolphins and the whales, who have language, who can perhaps count, who have some features of consciousness which are close to those of human beings because their brain is quasi human in its development. Therefore And I have drawn on data from the insect realm and I have even drawn some data from mollusks and cephalopods. Which I think really seems to cause the brain mind equation to collapse. So altruism I would like to give you examples from the insect world, and specifically from a category of ant, the Brazilian ant.

Which actually sacrifices its own life to protect the anthill. But it doesn’t sacrifice, the ant does not sacrifice himself when the ant hill is under direct threat. He sacrifices himself preemptively for the ant hill. And this is the first case note. I should point out these cases have been ever since the inception of Darwinian evolution a big problem for the theory of evolution.

There are ways to account for algorithm in the various theories of evolution, kin selection and so forth. But if you start looking at the cases, frankly it’s not convincing. It looks very artificial. So let alone that there is preemptive suicide among ants and this is a recent study in the American Naturalist of 02/2008. We have also clear instances of altruism among mammals.

I may have heard of the naked mole rat of Somalia. I’m sorry those of you who are members of the Liberal Party, but this is the closest example in the animal world to a communist society. It’s a very nice communist society. They share everything. I leave this open to your imagination.

The naked mole rat will actually sacrifice its own life for the colony in such a way that if a snake tries to enter the burrow, one mole rat will actually turn itself upside down in the burrow and get stung from behind by the snake so that it blocks the entrance of the burrow. Now this is a very striking case of altruism. So we have two clear cases of altruism. One among insects, one among mammals. But I could have produced dozens more cases we just limited by time.

Empathy is even more striking. This is a very sweet picture I think. And it flies in the face of the vision of the animal animal world as red in tooth and claw, which is so prevalent in the West. We have clear altruistic behavior among monkeys. This is when established.

And I’m sorry for these experiments which are ghastly, but since they were done I will draw on them. 10 out of 15 Rhesus monkeys preferred not to inflict an electric shock to another monkeyey than to have food themselves. In other words, they gave up their own satisfaction, their own nutrition to prevent discomfort from being inflicted on another monk. Then let alone this, these monkeys and this is a clear case of empathy were so traumatized by the suffering of other monkeys that in some cases one stopped pulling the chain and flicking electric shocks for five days and others stopped pulling them all together for twelve days. These clear instances of empathy.

We have an even more striking case among white rats. Where when albino rats are faced with the suffering of a fellow rat hoisted off the ground, which is more humane than electric shocks, they would consistently press a bar to reduce the subjects distress. If they were unable to do so, they would eventually enter into a state of shock. Keep in mind this is not suffering inflicted on the rat itself, but on a fellow rat. These are very powerful examples of empathy.

Then I’m not quite sure how the experimenters who did these experiments were able to continue doing them in good consciousness after seeing such behavior. But let alone altruism and empathy, we have more and more proven cases of self recognition in animals. It was long taught that only human beings could recognize themselves in a mirror and say this is me. It’s now established that elephants can, this is a dolphin looking at himself pictures of himself in the mirror and cavorting to see himself cavort and for that matter this is actually a magpie. You see the little spot which is painted here to see whether the magpie actually recognizes itself or thinks it is another magpie in the mirror.

The magpie clearly with a miniature cerebrum is nonetheless able to recognize itself. Therefore self recognition is present in mammals and in the bird realm, in the present state of knowledge. It goes much further than this. We have cases of advanced reasoning in mollusks, in cephalopods. This is an octopus opening a screwed up bottle.

And you can see the process by which eventually it unscrews the bottle. This is unlearned. Well, if anyone of you wants to teach an octopus to unscrew a bottle, it be my guest, But I don’t think you would have to. And actually some of the data which is coming out regarding the intelligence level of octopuses is astonishing. Astonishing.

So we said that the preeminent case of reasoning is tool usage, and here I would like to draw on the research from the Behavioral and Ecology lab at the University of Oxford. They have investigated crows and magpies, manufacturing tools and using them to empty tree trunks of insects. So this is an energetic crow trying to grab some very tasty maggots, but this is even more striking. This is Betty the crow who actually manufactured a looped coil of wire with which it will try to grasp a small pail containing fruit. Keep in mind that the tool was not made and given to the crow, The crow manufactured it to get access to the food.

Now in the standard neurobiological account of consciousness, the brain which is present here normally, normally should be unable to do this. Because a very limited, I don’t know if crows have cortexes or not, but I would imagine it is very very limited. Then one may crows may or some birds such as pigeons may have uncommon capacities for direction. But the manufacture of tools was considered a specific first specificity first of human beings and then of primates. And this is Abel and Betty with their toolbox.

All the tools they manufactured to try to get at those tasty maggots. So we can clearly, we have clearly established that reasoning and tool usage is present not only among the higher mammals, but among birds and even among octopuses. Memory is present it seems throughout the animal brain. The memory of bees has been studied in great detail and it seems to be a most robust process. Memory induced by a single learning trial lasts for days and by three learning trials in the flying bee for a lifetime.

Finally the two features which we have always been taught, certainly the Judeo Christian tradition differentiate humans from animals are language and numeracy. This is Washoe, the first chimp in history who was taught in the late nineteen sixties American Sign Language. She learned three fifty signs. And this is obviously the superstar of all animal linguists, Koko the gorilla who is still with us, well in her forties, who has over 1,000 American Sign Language words, and in the case of Coco understands more than 2,000 words in English. He was tested for IQ and has an estimated IQ of between seventy five and ninety five, which is that of a slightly substandard human being.

And then here, a picture is worth a thousand words. So I thought I would show you, if my computer allows me to do so. A very striking video, Coco became cozy human in many respects and eventually requested to have a pet And of all things for a thousand pound gorilla she wanted a kitten. Then you can So see here it stands out in people’s memories just because there’s an emotional surprise there. There’s a giant gorilla with a tiny, tiny, tiny helpless kitten and being gentle and loving towards that kitten.

Coco signed the name for her new kitten. She called him All Ball because to her the cat looked like a little ball. Coco adored All Ball and they spent countless hours playing together. And yet it was by loving the little tailless kitten that Coco learned one of life’s hardest. I’m sorry we have some bandwidth problems.

Then I will skip to what I wanted to show you. Eventually the little cat died, Coco was told about this. And she was told in sign language. You can maybe see it at the bottom, my apologies. Yes, you can see it on the top as well.

She was told in sign language by her trainer of the death of her pet, which she did not know. And after being told about this, in a state of great distress, she responded in sign language with the sign language for sadness which is frown, tears. And then the signs for bad. Then it has often been asserted by those who criticize research on the animal cognition and specifically on animal acquisition of language. It is just, it is not actually language, it’s acquisition by rote.

Clearly in this case, Coco the gorilla was experiencing something she had never experienced before and created a makeshift sentence in sign language of three or four words. This is the same. And later privately, Coco Yes. You can This is quite troubling, isn’t it? For those of us who eat meat on a regular basis, it raises many questions.

And later My apologies for the bandwidth. Didn’t obviously one might think these are just the primates Privately Coco expressed her grief. Highly advanced primate. But it is very troubling when one finds that African grey parrots have phenomenal mental capacities. This is Alex, the African grey parrot of Irene Pepperberg, a working vocabulary of 150 words, and in terms of mental development was at the sub stage called as Piaget sub-stage number six in the development of a child in which a child becomes aware of the fact that when he doesn’t look at an object, the object is still there.

It’s actually a specific stage in a child development. His intelligence was on par with that of a five year old human being. When Alex died, he was actually given the rare honor of an obituary in The Economist. So to my knowledge Alex is the only grey parrot in history who had a full page obituary in The Economist, which as some of you must know is probably the leading financial weekly in the world. Then finally we have numeracy, I haven’t entered into this in detail because it is actually quite difficult to test, but it is established beyond doubt in the case of Rhesus monkeys, that Rhesus monkeys can count from one to nine and seem to understand the concept of abstract numbers.

So all of this has led and it is very striking that this comes not from a Buddhist milieu but from the milieu of neurobiologists and ethologists to the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness. Which is a declaration issued at Cambridge University after a colloquium in animal cognition. Keep in mind these are scientists, not religious practitioners. Birds appear to offer a striking case of parallel evolution of consciousness. Evidence of near human like levels of consciousness has been most dramatically observed in African grey parrots.

And the Cambridge Declaration of Consciousness continues. This is very striking. The absence of a neocortex does not appear to preclude an organism from experiencing affective states. In other words they are present in some of the lower organisms and humans are not unique in possessing the neurological substrates that generate consciousness. As a result of this, the assembled scientists actually called for a reassessment of animal rights.

Animal rights. Which is obviously a very sensitive topic since almost all of us eat meat. Scientific research certainly in biology you know is grounded in animal experimentation, often some of the most cruel forms of experimentation. If animals truly are persons like us and I think that is what I was trying to show by demonstrating, sorry, that their consciousness has these seven features, then there is no reason that they should not have the rights of a person. Then at this point we are still not fully in the Buddhist realm, but we are definitely in the realm of law.

Law. We all recognize for instance that human beings of lesser capacities have legal rights, and that is not because someone tested say at 80 in terms of their IQ that they do not have basic human rights. Yet here we have gorillas testing at between 75 and 95 who have no rights whatsoever. We have a grey parrot which has the IQ of a five year old child who has no rights whatsoever. A five year old child is protected by the law.

That gray parrot can be killed by anyone who wishes to kill him. Roasted and eaten. But then these are major reassessments for our societies. If this research is corroborated and more and more data is coming in, our entire relation to the animal world must be radically reassessed. Even if we not choose not to go the extra step, which I think we have to, and recognize that not only are animals conscious, but in addition that their consciousness is non material.

But even within the scientific framework, in which a non material consciousness is something which is basically taboo, certainly in the biological sciences. This data shows that the issue of animal rights is no more, no longer a fringe issue for a minority, but is an issue which demands consideration. With major changes in our lifestyles. Then at this point I think we will make a break for tea. I encourage you greatly if you have the time to go through some of the publications which were made.

Read them by yourselves and see whether this is convincing or not. And if it is, what we are basically going to do about it. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top