Lam Rim — 2015-03-14

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lam Rim (Ilia Durovic)
Lam Rim (Ilia Durovic)
Lam Rim — 2015-03-14
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-03-14 – KR.mp3

UUID: 6459aad6-e4c3-4fd7-9bcd-208e79f71de6

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Lam Rim (Ilia Durovic)

Date: 2015-03-14

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 10m

Words: 9,297

That’s for the video app. Okay. Flight strikes with the video camera. Okay. So how far can I walk?

Nice short and cheap walk. I’d find one. Okay. About 200 meters. No.

I mean, in terms of your video coverage, is it okay if I move? I’ll wind it out. Okay. The toilets are located through the kitchen just behind us here. There will be a short break for a quick cup of tea and biscuits halfway through, So Ilya’s presentation today, which obviously he will talk about empirical evidence for the four general characteristics of karma.

Thank you. Thank you very much. It’s a pleasure to see a lot of old friends and a couple of new faces as well. These conferences are part of a process which we started at TBI shortly after I came to Australia, that would put it around 2010, to try to see how much of the Buddhist philosophy of life can be rooted in empirical verification in scientific reality. A fair bit, a surprising bit.

Over the last couple of years what I have tried to show is that there is strong evidence for the existence of reincarnation. Evidence used by scientists, psychiatrists mainly such as Doctor. Ian Stevenson. And Stevenson himself who was chairman of the Department of Psychiatry at the University of Virginia, later on the Division of Personality Studies, said that he felt there was enough evidence at present for a rational, in other words a non religious person, to believe in reincarnation. So I’ve tried to present this data over several years because I realized at a certain point that our students certainly here in Australia, where it seems perhaps more extreme than in other Western countries, would attend teaching after teaching.

But they were in a constant state of suspension of disbelief. They would attend the teachings and one would have the impression that somehow the teachings were resonating within them only to stop seeing that person a couple months or even a couple years later, without any further explanation. And then one realized a posteriori that all along, the person had just been going along with the program, if you wish, without ever checking from his or her own side, was this true or not? Now this is just the basic question we have to ask and it’s this itinerary where we ask is this true or not to which I invite you, to proceed with me. We’ve been walking on this path for the last four and a half, five years.

The evidence is incomplete but there is evidence and some of it is surprisingly strong. So the evidence for reincarnation, as I mentioned is very strong. I’ve covered it many times at TBI. And then I thought really we had to go one step further and ask what evidence, if any, there is for karma because that is the crux. That human beings reincarnate there’s a lot of evidence for.

That human beings may reincarnate as animals, Stevenson has some evidence for. That there are reincarnations in lower rebirths than the human or animal rebirths, there is also some evidence for from near death experiences. When you put it all together, it starts to paint a pretty convincing picture that there is something before this life and there is something after this life. And what goes on and on is the mind or some part of the mind. But this leaves one question unanswered.

Is this process of reincarnation just random? Which seems to be pretty much the viewpoint in new age. It just happens and you’ve got no real control over where you go, where you end up and what the conditions are. Or, is it something which is not random? And in that case, we do want to understand how it functions.

Then I thought perhaps the best way into this topic was through a metaphor. I will initially present this metaphor or this example of the Buddhist understanding of cyclic existence. Reincarnation in other words. Then I will present very briefly some of the aspects of karma I am going to try to get empirical verification for. And then I will cover a series of cases of recollected past lives, recollected through hypnosis, and I will try to show the karmic links.

And I should say before covering these cases, there was one case I was very hesitant to cover because it is a case of extreme brutality. It’s one of the best cases. Unfortunately, when people do go to a psychiatrist in these situations, they go because they have big problems. And when you regress them, find the source of these problems are also rather awful situations in the past. So it’s a very clear case.

If you are uncomfortable with this type of material, you might want to skip the second part of the presentation. We will try to apply the material from the Buddhist understanding of philosophy to a case regressed by Doctor. Woolgar and to two cases of Stevenson’s. So what exactly is the Buddhist understanding of cyclic existence? This is a supermax prison in The United States.

Most of you know what a supermax prison is. It is where one keeps the most dangerous convicts. Now if you run a prison, what is the key to running a prison effectively? The key is to ensure that the convicts forget that they are in jail, number one. And number two, that they remain distracted.

If you do that you will avoid an inmate uprising. If the convicts do not forget that they are in jail and they are not distracted you will have a convict uprising on your hands. And in Australia, I think, you may not have them. It’s a great American specialty. They end badly.

So if you were running a perfect prison, people would not be aware that they are in jail. There would be so much distraction that they would be oblivious to the fact. And they would have no sense of what is happening on the outside. Ideally, there would be no windows giving to the outside world and no windows or openings in the door showing the inside of the jail. You would eventually forget what was going on.

Now this is the Buddhist understanding of cyclic existence. We are prisoners in a jail cell. And before being brought in this jail cell, we are administered a sleeping product, a somnifer, which ensures that we will forget everything we knew before entering the cell. This cell is our only reality. Not only that but in the ideal jail cell there is no window giving on the outside to remind one of escape and there is no window on the door to show on the other cells.

So one ends up by believing that this cell is all there is. That cell is our life. If there were a window on the inside of the jail, we could see from our jail cell, other jail cells, and we could realize that there are other possibilities. If there were a window on the outside of the jail showing the outside world, we would realize there is such a thing as freedom. Clearly, if there is a window on the inside of the jail from a Buddhist standpoint, we have what is called a precious human rebirth.

We are aware of the process of reincarnation. And if there is a window on the outside world, we are aware of the existence of liberation from the jail. Now, our situation in the jail cell is that we are given as many games and distractions as we want. Unbeknownst to us, everything we do in the jail cell is constantly supervised by video and audio cameras. And a steady record of this is kept.

At the end of our stay in the jail cell, the guards come to fetch us. And they met out punishment in accordance with our behavior. Before we get the next injection to be put to sleep and transferred to the next jail cell, if our behavior has been in keeping with the laws of the prison, we will get a random casual beating. If we’re lucky, we will get no beating at all. This is a death process.

On the other hand, if our behavior over several states in different jail cells is considered to warrant punishment, in addition to a beating we may be tortured for a long time. Sometimes a very long time. This corresponds to a bad death. A death from cancer, a death from Alzheimer’s, which is really torture for one year, two years, five years, ten years. At the end of that torture, we’re put to sleep and we’re transferred to a new jail cell.

In that new jail cell, we don’t remember what happened in the past. Now within this jail, some of the prisoners, because they behave well, get promoted to the best position I know of in jail, librarian. Others don’t behave well and face repeated beatings or worse. From the Buddhist standpoint, this is what cyclic existence is. We go from life to life, in each life forgetting what happened in the previous one.

There are rules. There’s a mechanism which affects what affects us or what happens to us life after life, but we don’t have a clue what it is. A very few number of people realize that there is such a thing as reincarnation. And what is happening to us now is not random. And what will happen to us in the future is affected by what we do now.

And they try to find the laws, the rules governing reincarnation, how this works, how one should behave to reduce the total amount of pain, to increase the total amount of happiness. And these are what we know as beings of the small scope. Then some advanced beings realize that the whole process is actually like playing against someone with loaded dice. If you play against someone with loaded dice, you may win once or twice, you will lose your shirt in the long run. If you play against the prism, the rules of the prism guarantee you will eventually lose.

And they wish for escape from the process. These are the beings of the middling scope. These are the convicts who basically have seen through the opening in the wall that there is a world outside and do everything to get there. All alone, they don’t trust anyone else, they take care as we say the states of number one. This is much more advanced in terms of spiritual practice than being almost a stooge cooperating with the authorities of the prison, trying to better one’s lot.

The highest category of being realizes that all prisoners are in the same soup. This is a revolutionary. Instead of escaping himself alone or herself alone, he or she wants to lead all the prisoners in an uprising against the system. These are bodhisattvas. You have therefore four categories of beings.

Those in a jail cell who don’t even realize they’re in jail. Those in a jail cell who realize they’re in jail and figure they better learn the rules of the system to better their lot. Well the first category is worldly beings, the second category are beings of the small scope. Those in the jail cell who want none of the system and want to break out. Those are the beings of the middling scope.

And those in the jail cell who want none of the system and want to lead a general uprising. Obviously the most dangerous of the lot are the fourth category. The revolutionaries of the bodhisattvas. A bodhisattva will often work inside the system to corrupt the system from the inside. So this is the Buddhist understanding of cyclic existence.

Now, I will try to present it in a more formal fashion. Many of you are familiar with this. For some this may be new. And we will see how to apply this and to see whether this is true or not. Because really, either it is true or it is false.

Then if it is true, the way most of us live makes no sense at all. We are in the category of people in the jail cell who don’t even realize they are in jail. And then, if it is true indeed, we have to choose to be one of the three categories of beings. Work with the system, break out, or lead a rebellion. Those are the three options.

And on the other hand, it is perfectly possible that this is completely false. It’s just an Asian philosophical construct. In that case, I would suggest that we stop coming to these teachings. Because I have no time to waste frankly. I have a busy life and I’m sure you have no time to waste either.

So you have to decide for yourselves, true or not true. And you can wait a time to decide this. But you can’t wait forever. You don’t have the time and I don’t have the time. So this is something we have to think about and if we decide something, then we have to behave in keeping with it.

You know. So if it is false, okay, go off, have fun, do whatever you want, you know. It was nice meeting you. And if it is true, then at the minimum one’s behavior must change in keeping with the rules which govern karma and causality. And that’s what we shall be talking about this whole year.

So I’m not pushing you to swim but I’m pushing you quietly down the jetty. Know that you shall be pushed in the water by the end of the year. But I really think this way of looking at things is much more productive than just coming to the center indefinitely without ever taking position and eventually drifting away. There is no benefit for anybody in this approach. The question of truth is a question everyone asks in daily life.

You sign a contract, which is basically what we consider most important in life. You know, you want to know if basically the bank is indeed going to give you the money for the mortgage and the bank wants to know if you will be able to pay the mortgage. Right? And it’s not a matter of interpretation or a feel good, as all of you who have dealt with banks probably know. So if we apply this in daily life, this should be applied all the more so to something much more important, which is spiritual practice.

So from a Buddhist standpoint, what is the cycle of lives which a Buddhist view as a jail and they call samsara? It is the sum total of our body and our mind. In other words, the contaminated aggregates. But not the body and mind just of this life. The body and mind since beginningless time, which has been trapped in these jail cells, jail cell after jail cell.

Then sometimes you’re into good jail cells towards the middle of the jail. Sometimes you’re the librarian and you have your own sleeping room and an office. And sometimes you’re in the cells no one talks about, the punishment cells in the basement where there’s no light and unspeakable things happen. But we have been going through every single one of these. And therefore Samsara is a continuum.

I just put four lives because I am restricted by what PowerPoint deems meaningful, but there is an infinite number of lives here. It is not just a continuum. It is a contaminated, in other words, a harsh, unpleasant, painful continuum. And when we speak of the aggregates in Buddhist terms, the term aggregates is very significant. It means a pile of something.

So an aggregate of wheat is a pile of grains of wheat. The aggregates which constitute the person are groups. There is the body, which we call matter or form. And there are four mental aggregates, four parts of mind. Sensations, in other words feelings, discrimination, the capacity to say this is a small table whereas that is an electrical plug.

Compositional factors which is mainly karma but also is a category in which we fit everything else, and consciousness. The person from a Buddhist standpoint is just the sum of these five components. And the reason for the division is simply to demonstrate that there is no soul. Now Buddha Shakyamuni could indeed have divided the person into two parts, body and mind, three parts or 400. But he chose a five fold division and this is the one we have inherited.

For yourselves, a two fold division of body and mind might be easier to handle. It is, Samsara is in other words, the contaminated continuum of body and mind, life after life after life after life. And therefore, from the Buddhist standpoint, all beings can be subdivided into four categories. Worldly beings, it’s pretty much everybody. This life is what there is.

You may pay lip service to the existence of a future life or not, but it makes no real difference to how you behave, certainly in important matters in life. You focus on the here and now. Your health, your relationships, your money, your fun. That’s it. Then, obviously this is nice and fine when you’re young, right?

When you’re young, you’re healthy, you have fun, you have relationships and if you’re lucky, you have a bit of money as well. Then as you grow older, obviously there’s fewer and fewer relationships. Eventually there isn’t any at all. There’s less and less fun because you really can’t sense anything. In my case, instance, eyesight keeps dropping.

There will be a point I won’t be able to see anybody in this room. And then obviously money as you grow older, first obviously your wealth increases until you hit around 45 or 50. And then from that point on you start spending more and more on your health. You can accumulate less and less money and your situation becomes worrisome. Depending on the country and the civilization you’re born in, it may be very worrisome or moderately so.

This is a lot of worldly beings. Then we have from a Buddhist standpoint three paths. The path shared with the being of the small, middling and great scope. These correspond to the beings we talked about in the jail cells. Worldly beings are prisoners who don’t even know they’re prisoners.

They’re playing monopoly with each other. Beings of the small scope are prisoners who know they’re prisoners and want to figure what the rules of supermax are. How do you keep the guardians happy? They’re keeping an eye on you all the time, you do want little punishment at the end and next jail cell you want to be on one of the higher floors, not down below in the basement where there’s no accountability. Then the being of the middling scope, as we said, is the person who has been in a jail cell where there is a window and can see there is something else than jail.

If you don’t know there is something else than jail, you cannot be a being of the middling scope. You must know that liberation or what we know the truth as a truth of cessation exists. If you don’t believe in it, you will not make the efforts to escape. Why escape to run into another war? And the being of the great scope, obviously as we said, is a revolutionary who wants to lead the jail and all its inhabitants in an insurrection against the system.

So these are the three Buddhist paths and some of these paths are shared with non Buddhist religions. Specifically, non Buddhist ethical religious traditions, whatever they consider for the future, that the jail has rules. You can know them and you can apply them to better your lot next time around. And this is a case of most of the great religions. Christianity, Judaism, Islam to a degree, Hinduism.

In every single case, through teaching basic ethics, teach one how to better one’s lot next time around. Therefore, from a Buddhist standpoint, their path has shared elements with that of the being of the small scope. The true Buddhist path starts here. The being of the small scope or the path shared with the being of the small scope is not a true Buddhist path. Since Hindus really are doing the same thing.

The true Buddhist path starts when you realize that you’re in jail and you want to get out. And therefore, if we try to summarize this, the being of the small scope wants to stay on the good side of the jail. The being of the middling scope wants out. And the being of the great scope wants to lead an insurrection. So what are the criteria for this?

The criteria is a motivation of the person. You are a being of the small scope. If you have what is known as limited renunciation, this means if you have given up on this life, you’ve given up on this jail cell, it’s not good enough for you. You want to go to one of the higher jail cells. You want to be librarian, that’s your goal in life.

Then, I’m sorry, I could choose chef in the restaurant, but I thought librarian up there and the ethereal spheres would be very nice. You know? So that is a being of the small scope. You understand how the system works, because otherwise you can’t be a being of the small scope. Then the path shared with the being of the middling scope is characterized by the motivation of renunciation.

You’ve given up on the jail as a whole. In other words, being a librarian isn’t good enough. You understand that the librarian is still a prisoner. And then the being of the great scope has what we know as bodhicitta. This means that such a being wants to lead all other inmates to freedom.

The presence or the absence of this motivation decides whether or not you are one of the paths. In this room, probably nobody is on any of these three paths. Because there is a fundamental change in behavior when someone has such a powerful, uncontrived motivation. It’s not something you construct in meditation. It is there day and night.

Just like material success for many people is there day and night. By day they work to earn money, by night they dream they’re enjoying it. So in our case during this year, we were focused only on one path, which I think is the one we can hope to try to move up to. It’s a path of the being of the small scope. And the path of the being of the small scope, since it is a path where one tries to gain a higher rebirth, is the path in which the understanding of karma is taught.

To be a being of the small scope, it is not sufficient to believe in reincarnation. You must in addition believe that your behavior in one life affects your experiences in future lives and that there are rules about this. And then you set out to learn these rules for your own sake. It’s a very sensible thing to do. If those rules, those laws exist and if in this life we have been hammered repeatedly, then we can’t do a lot about what’s happening to us in this life.

But if you’ve been hammered repeatedly, you don’t want it to happen next time. Then you can change things in your behavior now so that next time the going is easier. And hopefully the time after that, even easier. And for most people that’s all there is. Most Buddhists in Asia are not interested in liberation, let alone full enlightenment.

But are sincerely believed, sincerely convinced that they can improve their lot over the lives. That’s good enough. Then to do this one must understand karma and causality. If one doesn’t, one may have the wish, but one is tossed left and right like a cork on a wave. So according to the Lamrim, what is the path of the being of the small scope?

There are two steps. Initially, you generate a mind wishing for better future lives. And then you put in practice the means for that. These two steps are sequential. You cannot put in practice the means for having better future lives if you don’t believe they exist and if you don’t believe you have some sort of control.

So I won’t enter in details in generating the mind wishing for future lives. It hinges first on recollecting one’s death in this life. And remembering that one will die is a profoundly transformative, experience. You will live differently if you think of your own death, especially on a daily base. Everything becomes much clearer.

There are things which are meaningful, not a lot of them. And there are things which are useless, a huge amount of them. And when in addition you realize that you really don’t know when you will die, and none of us in this room can guarantee that they will be still among the living tomorrow, then you will be in a hurry. For someone who has meditated on the uncertainty of the time of death is in a hurry. Because the axe is falling from how far up we don’t know.

We know it’s falling and we know that when the blade touches our neck it’s over. Then if one truly believes in karma and causality one is in a hurry to put things on one side. And then after recollecting one’s death, the certainty of one’s death, the uncertainty of the time of death, one recollects that at the time of death we can’t take anything with us. Nothing we work for in this life can go with us. Each one of us has his own private fantasy.

For some it’s money. You can’t take a penny with you, however much you have. For other it’s a perfect body. However handsome or beautiful your body may be, it will turn into a decaying heap of meat within a matter of days. For some, it is other things like relationships, for women especially.

The boyfriend. And the boyfriend has to stay behind, right? So at that point, when you understand that it is certain you will die, there is no way to know when, and in addition, you can’t take anything with you, the question arises, is there something you can take with you? If there isn’t, we stop here. We all go to the beach and have fun.

If there is, the question is what? If reincarnation exists, the what is the mind? So it is the mind which must be the recipient of effort. And then if the mind goes on, obviously the question is where? Once you realize that reincarnation is a reality and you study a bit the evidence for existence not only of higher realms like ours, but of reincarnation as an animal, reincarnation as a spirit, or even reincarnation in the hell realms at the bottom of the jail, then it becomes very evident to you that there is one thing you don’t want and that’s to reincarnate at the bottom of the jail.

And you will do whatever it takes for that not to happen. Now the question arises, what does it take? You’ve decided that you don’t want to end up in the nameless cells in the basement, in the dark, where they do horrible things to you. You can see what happens in this life to human beings. Imagine if there are lower realms what might happen in such places.

Now the question is, what means do you use? And there are two means for the being of the small scope. The first is refuge, and the second is karma. Refuge simply means finding someone who can protect you while you figure how the system works. You’ve just landed in a supermax American jail and you’re a shrimpy little guy and everywhere around you you have huge black guys and huge white guys with tattoos.

What do you do? You find a protector. Right? Then you want a good protector. Someone who’s not gonna beat you up.

Someone who understands how things work. Because you alone, you can’t do anything. You don’t know how it works and you don’t have the strength to fend for yourself. Then if you don’t have a protector, you will be prey. Right?

So when you’re looking for a protector, you’re looking for someone who understands how the jail works. In other words, who understands how cyclic existence works. Many people claim they know how this work. In India, there were many teachers. But there is something which is quite unique about Buddha Shakyamuni’s teachings, and I think it’s unique in the history of religions, that Buddha did not appeal to faith.

He said at the beginning, obviously, you know, that’s all we have. But Buddha instructed his students to rely on reason and experience. And this is unique. This alone should incite you to throw a second look at Buddhist teachings. Because if you look at the other great religious teachers, the message has always been, hail, here I come, believe.

Then everyone can say this. So when we speak of examining the teachings in this way, obviously initially we need enough conviction to start the process. And this is why the second aspect of teaching the means for happiness in future lives is generating a face of conviction in karma. Enough conviction that this is how things work that you’re actually going to study it a little bit. If you have no conviction whatsoever, you’re not even going to start.

And karma and causality are the protector for the being of the small scope. When we speak in the context of refuge of Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, Buddha, if you wish, is your protector in the jail. The big guy who’s been around and knows how things work. Dharma are the rules of the jail he teaches you. Sangha are his friends who will help you.

Then think for yourself. Apply this example to your lives. If you were in that situation, is this a rational way to go about things? You don’t know what’s happening. You know you’re weak.

You know the weak get targeted. You need a protector. How do you choose a protector? What does he have to know? It’s irrelevant if he knows electronics.

But it’s very relevant if he’s fully aware of what the gods want and don’t want. What the gods want and don’t want is karma. Do you understand this example? I’m sorry, it’s a fairly harsh example. But I chose it for that reason so that it would resonate a little bit.

And you can choose milder examples if you want, but I think you will find in the cases I cover in the second half of this conference that this is pretty much unfortunately, the way it seems to be. So how do we generate this face of conviction in causality? The root of all happiness. And this is an image, Japanese statue of Vasubandhu, the great scholar of Abhidharma who perhaps taught in Abhidharma Kosha karma in greater detail than any other scholar. Ubbadhase Daswamin says, the Brahmin say that virtue and sin may transfer to others like receiving a gift.

You, Buddha taught that what one has done, in other words karma, never perishes and that one does not meet with the effects of what one has not done. You could replace in this quote the Brahmins by the Christians, the Muslims, the Jews, the Hindus. In every single of the great religions, there is transference of virtue or transference of merit through prayer typically. This is absent in Buddhism. We are alone in the jail cell with our own experience.

The karma we have is what we experience. There is therefore, and I’ll qualify this statement in a couple of minutes, there is no efficacy of prayer in Buddhism. If you believe in the efficacy of prayer for others, you are bringing a Christian heritage with you. This is not part of the Buddhist teachings. If it worked, if prayer for others really worked long ago, Since there are many enlightened beings, all of us would be a lot better off because they do pray for us.

So we are alone. We are alone with our own past karma and more importantly the karma we accumulate now. So what is critical for our future is karmic engineering. Now when I speak of the efficacy of prayer for the benefit of others, it has to be quantified clearly. It is true that the prayer of close relatives and spiritual teachers can help.

But it is very transitory. I had direct experience of this in the monasteries. When I was ordained, I was responsible for a very large project, the creation of a monastic university close to Sera. Then as a result, I had close connections in the circle of the protector of the monastery. These are the deities which protect the monasteries.

And I did repeated pujas for this project. And I had a friend who was an Austrian architect in his fifties, who for years had been straddling the line between being a lay person and becoming ordained. He just, he would waver. You know, he really wanted to but wasn’t quite sure he could keep the vows. And during one of the protector pujas, I had the merit dedicated to his clarifying his situation.

So I was sponsoring the puja, I participated in the puja, he did not, but I dedicated the merit to this. It was very striking, I did not tell him. And the next day he came to me, he was absolutely radiant. He said, I’ve made up my mind. I will get ordained.

I’m gonna make the arrangements. Then I said, that’s a little bit hasty, isn’t it? Do you want to think about it? He said, no, no, my mind is set. I have wavered for too long.

I said, good. Then how do you want to go away? He said, we will speak to so and so for the ordination ceremony. Then I thought such enthusiasm is never a very good sign. So I will just sit a little bit because it’s really awkward if we have to cancel everything.

Then I was supposed to meet him the next day. Somehow, I couldn’t meet him. Came day three. He had a really sheepish look on his face. I said, yes.

So how’s it going? Shall we shall we go forwards? Then the hemming and the hawing started. Eventually, turned out he had changed his mind but not quite and wanted to think about it a bit more, etc, etc. This is the effect of the dedication of merit for another.

There is a flash in the pan. It can be of help if from their own side the person is doing a lot. It tops things up, in this case, he basically was my employee, so we were comically close. But if that closeness isn’t there and the person isn’t trying hard from their own side, then there is no benefit. And this is why Quetzu Rinpoche was always quite dry when at the end of the Lama Chippa there were dedications for sick people.

It is not done in the monasteries. And it is especially not done for people one is very distantly related to. It is a Christian practice. In the Orthodox Church, in the Roman Catholic Church, you have the list of the sick people given to the priest and they are prayed for during the Eucharist because it is said God intervenes because of this intercession. This does not exist in Buddhism.

So it’s something which is important for us to understand. We are alone with the karma we have accumulated. Now, what are the four general features of karma? Since after all, if we’re going to engage in karmic engineering, we must understand how it works. Karma is definite.

It increases over time. You cannot experience something you have not accumulated the karma for. And it is unfortunately indestructible. And I will cover these fairly briefly, and then, after giving a couple more general, subdivisions of karma, we will address examples and you will start to see what this means. So when we say karma is definite, it’s a little bit like an abacus.

What this means, as Jetsongkhapa puts it in Lamrim Chenmo, is that what is called virtue can only give rise to happiness. And what is called non virtue can only give rise to unhappiness. Now in reality, This we largely know because of Buddha’s meditative realizations and his enlightenment. Buddha Shakyamuni was able to see down the causal chain and he called those deeds which led to happiness virtue. And he called those deeds which led to suffering non virtue.

Those deeds which led neither to suffering nor to happiness he called neutral deeds. And these are basically or this is if you wish the core of the Buddha’s teachings for beings of the small scope. What if we engage in it in this life will lead to happiness many lives from now, in the next life or if the deed is very powerful at the time of our death? Some deeds even earlier. And what will lead to suffering?

What is more troubling is that karma is an increasing function of time. And in this respect, points out, and it’s something which I always found very troubling, that internal causation, in other words, karma within the mind, has an amplification over time which external causation, the one of physics and so forth, does not have. In other words, if you look at external causation, if you kick a football, it will travel a certain distance and that can be calculated. Then it stops. Now your kick is the cause, traveling that distance is the result.

Those of you who have any background in math and physics, the energy you transmit to the ball with a kick is exactly the amount of energy the ball receives and releases in rolling minus friction. It’s the law of the conservation of energy. With Karma, it doesn’t work like that. And why is something which is difficult to understand. A very, very small deed which seems insignificant will increase in the mind stream over time and can lead to huge results.

In the positive or in the negative sense. Now if this is true, we have to be particular particularly wary of the accumulation of karma. We can be overwhelmed by something very very small given enough time. And my personal suspicion is that this is simply because karma is very similar to the mechanisms involved in chaos theory. So all of you have heard of chaos theory probably.

A butterfly flapping its wings in China causes eventually a hurricane in Argentina. Simply because you have a series of mechanisms which basically spread the very small disturbance of the butterfly flapping its wings and lead to something huge. Now for a system to elicit this type of behavior, what is known as chaotic motion, two factors are necessary and they both seem to be present with karma. A chaotic system is one which is very sensitive or very dependent on initial conditions. That’s certainly the case with karma.

And it is a system with a feedback loop, what is known as recurrence. And that is the case with karma and we will see how. Deeds performed in one life lead to effects in a future life which feed back into the mindset of that life and lead to effects down the line. This is a recurrence or the feedback loop and all of you know feedback loops from science and so forth and oscillators, you know. This is a feedback loop which underlies karma.

Now how karma increases is an open question. In Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand consider that it’s a linear increase, it doubles every 24. I personally don’t think so. I think this is just what could be explained in Tibet because the Tibetans have many great qualities, but skill at mathematics is not one. And, if you ever meet one of my old friends who is now almost a Geshe at Serraje, a western monk, he tells me the most traumatic experiences are when he has to do the accounting for his kangchen with Tibetan monks.

And he’s an engineer by training. He said they all sit down, they roll up metaphorically their sleeves, just simple accounting, right? Adding and subtracting. And they say, okay. Then you have 12 monks by groups of two, each must do the accounts.

And everyone has to agree. Nobody ever agrees. They get different sums, you know, and I remember once a marvelous old Geshe, I had to calculate with him how much to pay for a puja I had offered. And he said, I’ll do it. I’m experienced.

You know? And then he started, and I started to go dizzy. He was like squaring the number of the monks and dividing by the space and multiplying by something. And I said, please, Geshe, I will just do it myself. Was just very simple.

Number of monks multiplied by donation, then you subtract whatever other donations there were I gave. But this took us an hour and a half. So for this reason, when I hear Tibetans talk about anything related to mathematics, I tend to practice the suspension of disbelief. And this is why I allow myself to believe that the increase of karma is not linear but probably exponential, which is what you would expect. Then one does not experience the results of karma which is not accumulated.

In other words, one does not experience happiness or suffering unless in a previous life that karma was accumulated. Can you see how this precludes any efficacy of prayer? If prayer worked, you would be experiencing a happiness, you did not accumulate the karma for. And you’d experience it through the prayers of another person. You see the problem, do you?

So as you can see, if you have not accumulated the karma that is the cause for an experience of happiness or suffering, you will in no way experience the happiness or suffering that is its effect. Then this leaves us very alone, doesn’t it? The last of the main characteristics of comma, the four characteristics, is that karma is indestructible. This means that if a karma has not led to its karmic result, it stays in our mind stream. Now the Tibetans always compare this to a seed.

I have always preferred the image of a time bomb. It’s like a buried bomb there in the mental continuum waiting for something to hit it to explode. And you do see cases like this. I remember a case which struck me because in different terms this was very much a case of the maturation of a karma. It was a German engineer who was arrested for pedophilia.

And, during the trial, this man who had everything, who had never had these tendencies before, wealthy, influential, married, said that he had seen such pictures on the web and that they triggered something uncontrollable within himself. And from this point on, he could no longer restrain his behavior. This is a classic description of the maturation of a karmic imprint. The comic imprint is there like a time bomb. It’s hidden.

The person is oblivious to it. The right conditions arise, they trigger this and you have an effect which is uncontrollable. And we will be talking in a couple of minutes after the break of precisely one such cases and you will see how you have these uncontrollable effects manifesting life after life. So after presenting the four general characteristics of karma, in other words, karma is definite, is increasing, one cannot experience results one has not accumulated and karma is indestructible. I would like to look at karma from the standpoint of the result, what you experience.

What happens when a karma matures? Literally, a palace in Dubai or a jail cell somewhere in the third world. One of the extremes. And there are broadly speaking three types of results. It’s very helpful as a subdivision to understand how karma matures.

You have karma which leads to a new life, a rebirth. This is called the effect of maturation. You have karma which is similar, or an effect which is similar to its cause. And you have an effect which causes you to be reborn in a certain setting. Now the maturation effect, the rebirth, is the karma which causes rebirth as a child, as a human being, instead of being reborn as a dog.

In other words, it gives rise to one life. The causally concordant effect is something which is it sounds much more technical but it’s something all of us experience a lot more. These are experiences within this life which are concordant, in other words similar, with their cause something we did in a previous life. For instance, we kept keep getting into scuffles, fights and being beaten up in this life. Now this is a causally concordant effect which arises from ourselves having preyed on others in previous lives.

How far back? We cannot say. You will see in the examples after the break, it is very far back at times and this is quite disquieting. So causally concordant effects are effects which resemble the karmic cause which created them. Now we can move from this life back in time using logic.

Clearly if this is true, and let’s say for instance, we are born to great wealth in this life, then being born to great wealth obviously is wealth we did not earn at all. It just landed in our lap. It’s probably the sign of generosity in a past life. Let us say in this life we have very fretful and troubled minds, easily disturbed, filled with anxiety and fear for no obvious reason in this life. Then the causally concordant karma which leads to this is having induced fear and anxiety in another’s mind many many previous lives ago.

Through understanding this, we can understand how to change our own behavior so as to no longer experience this in future lives. Do you understand? The environmental effect is being born or living in one area instead of another. In Australia, for instance, you have exceptional conditions. This is an environmental effect.

An environmental effect of good karma in past lives. For instance, you have an excellent system of law and order. There’s very little crime, let’s say, Adelaide. And this is the karmic result for each one of us who lives here of having protected and sheltered others in previous lives. Being reborn, let’s say, in Afghanistan during the war is an environmental effect of having harmed others, of having delighted in war, of having fought in wars oneself and damaged the environment of others.

And let me then give you an example of karmic maturation using these three effects with something very simple. I think probably all of us engage in at one point or the other. This is not a major non virtue like killing, stealing, or even adultery. It’s something very tried. Something you are even encouraged to do.

People say, you must talk true. Tell it as it is. The karmic maturation of harsh words. Harsh words, a non virtuous deed of speech defined as words which induce a feeling of pain in another. It does not matter whether they are true or not.

It’s irrelevant. If you utter these words with the intent to harm the other, if the other hears these words and experiences suffering, you have accumulated the non virtue of harsh words. So if in life number one, one were to utter harsh words which induce sadness in another person, Then harsh words may or may not lead to a ripening effect, in other words a rebirth. It’s not a very heavy karmic deed. You might not have a lower rebirth because of this.

If they are not very heavy harsh words, let’s say harsh words to your parents or to your spiritual teacher, probably you will be reborn as a human being. Harsh words to one’s parents, especially if they are very hurt, if they have been very kind to oneself, to one’s spiritual teacher may lead to rebirth as an animal or lower. But I would assume you are reborn as a human being. What will be the causally concordant effect? Others will be harsh and unforgiving to you and you will suffer from depression as a result of their harshness and unforgiveness.

This effect is causally concordant with the cause. The harsh words you uttered which caused sadness in another are now uttered to you by another and cause sadness within you. Then in another life the environmental result is that you will live in a coarse blunt and indifferent environment where people aren’t kind or polite to each other. People are harsh with each other. You yourself may or may not be on the receiving end of that, but in your environment, it’ll be an American style environment, the law of the jungle.

Then after this cycle of ripening effect, causally concordant effect, an environmental effect has occurred, because of habituation with harsh words, you yourself will enjoy being harsh and critical towards others. It is something you will do with pleasure, Something you will justify. And this leads then to another life in which harsh words are uttered. And this I think is the root of karmic amplification. So we see with many of our students at the center that depression is, an endemic problem.

The root of depression is sadness caused to another. In a previous life, perhaps in this life, if the other is a very potent karmically charged being. And if you don’t want to suffer from depression, be kind to others. Make them happy. You will not suffer from depression.

And even in this life others will be kind to you. For sure in future life they will be. Then if we analyze, we can see the case of harsh words, if there is a ripening rebirth it would be a rebirth in the lower realms. In a rebirth after that one is reborn as a human being, that’s maturing result. The causally concordant result is depression.

And the environmental result is a harsh and unkind environment. And in some future lives, one is reborn as a human being with better conditions. But through habituation one likes to criticize, one is negative. And the environment effect is one lives with unkind, unforgiving people, which leads to a new deed of harsh words. Do you understand this mechanism?

And you can see why understanding it would be helpful to you. And there is one last topic I would like to cover briefly with you, and then all of us will have a short break. It is projecting and completing karma. Then I thought a tapestry illustrated this beautifully. Because after all, a tapestry, you have the tapestry as a whole, which is a projecting karma, if you wish.

What gives a future life, that’s projecting karma. And the completing comma is the details of the tapestry. There’s a tree, there’s two lovers, it looks like. One plays, this is awful, one of them plays the Scottish instrument. The The back back pipes, yes.

Well, it’s not going to last long as you can see. So projecting and completing comma, projecting comma projects one rebirth. Completing comma fleshes out the details in that rebirth. So all of us in this room have good projecting karma. Then our completing karma, that depends on the person.

Overall, I think it must be quite good. Then if we look at a grid to see the relationship between projecting and completing karma, Good projecting comma leads to a good rebirth and bad projecting comma to a bad rebirth. But good completing comma within a good rebirth leads in addition to good conditions. Not only are you born as a human being, but you are well off. Happy, good conditions, good country.

Then if you have good projecting karma but bad completing karma, you will be reborn as a human being but in bad conditions. You might be homeless. You might be reborn in India, in Africa, in difficult conditions. You still have a human rebirth but little can be done with it. Bad projecting karma, one gets a bad rebirth but excellent conditions.

One is someone’s pet rat. A rat perhaps, but like my dog Bobby with marvelous conditions. And then bad projecting karma and bad completing karma, a laboratory rat. An animal with hideous conditions. And there is one debate I would like to address briefly with you regarding projecting and completing comma.

The question is, in a nutshell, how many lives can one karmic imprint project? And there’s an ongoing debate. It’s been going on for two thousand years, so we’re in no hurry to take a decision. And as perhaps some of the sharpest debates ever, it occurred between two brothers, some of the greatest Buddhist scholars of all time, Vasubandhu and Asanga, half brothers. According to Vasubandhu, one projecting karma can only project one rebirth.

In other words, if you accumulate one powerful virtuous deed, you will be reborn, let’s say, as a human being as a result of that. And then it’s over. According to Asanga, that is not true. You have four possibilities. One projecting karma can project one rebirth, it can project many rebirths, many karmas may project one body, and one karma can project many bodies.

This looks much more complicated. But you will see, I think, in the examples we will cover after the break, that I personally suspect Asanga is right. Vasubandu’s presentation is much more appealing, but karma is complex, very complex, and it seems that one deed, if it’s powerful enough, projects a series of lives. Then we will be talking after the break of hypnotically recollected cases. It’s a bit of a loaded topic.

I wanted to cover with you cases which demonstrated how karma might work. It is not really possible with spontaneous cases in children. I found only two, three cases. I have already presented many times here. Then I didn’t want to re present old cases to you.

The best cases where we have many lives are the hypnotically regressed cases, where the person remembers a large number of past lives. These are also the ones where the risk of fantasy and projection is the greatest. So the case we will talk about after, the break is I think a strong case. There is some independent verification within the memories, which seems to confirm, the recollections. And then we will stop here for now.

We have a ten minute break. Then I’m terribly sorry I was raised in Switzerland, so I’ll be back at 03:20 in zero seconds. See you soon.

Key terms in this teaching

completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top