Tenets — 2014-06-10

1 h 26 min · 2,945 words · 10 June 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets (Khensur Rinpoche)
Tenets — 2014-06-10
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 86-minute session at the Lorig-Tenets junction, Kyabje Rinpoche completes the Mind and Mental Factors review by examining afflictions, then introduces Buddhist philosophical schools. He classifies the six main afflictions and traces how 20 subsidiary afflictions branch from them, explores the four changeable mental factors with emphasis on sleep, and teaches a practical point: establish virtuous motivation before sleep and upon waking to transform those hours into virtuous mental activity. The session’s core is why Tenets matter—they provide the wisdom to eradicate mental suffering, not mere intellectual frameworks. Rinpoche previews Tenets as more systematic than Lorig, organized clearly around ground, path, and result. A Q&A addresses technical questions: whether ignorance functions as main mind or mental factor, how envy arises from both desire and anger, and the distinction between dissimulation and deceit. For practitioners with prior Buddhist study.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-06-10 – KR.mp3

UUID: 7a77d703-b39c-4213-ad56-bd238021568c

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Tenets

Date: 2014-06-10

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,947

So as usual, we will generate the motivation to receive teachings. So there’s a little bit left in Lorig regarding afflictions which Geshe-la would like to present.

You know? So regarding afflictions, generally speaking, afflictions are mental factors. Actually, it is probably correct to say that whatever is an affliction is necessarily a mental factor. A tentative definition for an affliction is a mental factor which whose activity is to give rise to unsuitable states of mind. Such afflictions include anger and so forth in every single case.

These afflictions give rise to troubled, mistaken state states of mind, which for this reason are called unsuitable. Mental factors and main minds are probably included within consciousness from within the six fold division of consciousness, the five sense consciousnesses and the mental consciousness. Moreover, in my personal opinion, the ignorance which apprehends the true existence of a self is also included within this consciousness. Now, this is a rather sharply debated topic, but we shall set the debates aside for the purpose of this presentation. The afflictions which arise, in dependence on this, can be coarse afflictions such as anger or on the other hand, virtuous states of mind which also arise out of ignorance.

This is a somewhat difficult topic for you to understand since the ignorance which grasps at the self existence of phenomena is an affliction. All ignorances are afflictions and are mental factors. And this ignorance is similar to a main mind, which itself is included within the sixth category of mental consciousnesses. As is said in the root text of Abhidharma, the Abhidharma sūtra, abandon unsuitable behavior and turn away from inappropriate states of mind. The inappropriate states of mind, which I refer to here, are the ignorance which grasps at true existence, which is a component or a part of mental consciousness.

When precisely on the grounds and paths does the potency of this ignorance dwindle? It dwindles on the ārya paths. As is said, one who has realized truth is no longer impelled and therefore on the ārya paths under the power of its antidote, which is the wisdom realizing selflessness, the potency of the ignorance which apprehends true existence is reduced. As is said, ignorance engages both virtue and non virtue indeed motivated by the ignorance, which is cognate or similar to a mental consciousness and which acts as a mental factor, one engages in activities such as, for instance, generosity or ethics, which will give rise to a virtuous future rebirth, albeit one impelled by ignorance. Since training in the six perfections, in other words, generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm, concentration and wisdom are all mental factors without exception, They have a main mind with which they are cognate or similar, which is included within the sixth subdivision of minds, which is mental consciousnesses.

This can be one of the numerous main minds or one specific main mind. Then irrespective of whether such mental factors engage in virtue or non virtue, they are impelled by the ignorance which misapprehends the true existence of the self. This is the meaning of the line. They engage both virtue and nonvirtue. As is said in Dharmakīrti’s Pramānavārttika, the nature of the mind uncontaminated by the afflictions is clear light.

A similar passage is to be found in Maitreya’s Uttaratantra. In both cases, these passages indicate that eventually, through a continuous process of purification, eventually, one day, we will experience the true nature of the mind. Numerous examples are given in the Uttaratantra about this. For instance, it is said that the main mind is akin to water and mental factors to the flow of the water, or the main mind is akin to space and mental factors are akin to clouds within space. These afflictions, specifically, which troubled the mind are subdivided into the six main afflictions and the 20 subsidiary afflictions.

The six main afflictions, which are desire, anger, pride, ignorance, afflicted doubt and afflicted views, are called main or root afflictions because they are at the root of the other afflictions. Whereas the 20 subsidiary afflictions are belligerence, hatred, concealment, spite, envy, miserliness, deceit, dissimilation, haughtiness, violence, non shame, non embarrassment, lethargy, agitation, non faith, laziness, heedlessness, forgetfulness, lack of introspection, and distraction. The first two, belligerence and hatred, arise from the first main or root affliction of anger. The third, secondary affliction, concealment is linked or arises from desire. The fourth, spite, arises from anger.

The fifth, envy, also arises from anger. The following four secondary afflictions, miserliness, deceit, dissimilation, and haughtiness are probably linked with desire. The following, a certain affliction, violence arises from anger. Whereas the derivation of the eleventh of the 20 secondary afflictions, non shame is unclear. That of the twelfth non embarrassment is one which arises from ignorance.

And the following eight, lethargy, excitement, lack of faith, laziness, heedlessness, forgetfulness, and non introspection are linked with ignorance. The reason, therefore, for which these secondary afflictions are called secondary is because they are linked with a given root or main affliction. At the level of a first ground bodhisattva, in other words, bodhisattva on the path of seeing and above, where afflictions indeed present in the mind stream, they will not be main or root afflictions since if they were main or root afflictions, they could give rise to the secondary afflictions. The last of the 51 mental factors are the four changeable mental factors, which are sleep, regret, investigation and analysis. Sleep and regret are definitely So these are the four changeable limit of factors.

If we take the first of the four changeable mental factors, sleep, generally speaking, sleep is a neutral mental factor. However, if sleep is influenced by previous reflections on bodhicitta or for instance on selflessness, it can turn into a virtuous mental factor, whereas it can also turn into a non virtuous mental factor under the influence of other reflections. For this reason, is critically important to generate a good motivation before going to sleep. Then, whether one sleeps five, six or seven hours a night, those five, six or seven hours turn into a virtuous state of mind. Likewise, when one rises in the morning, it is important to generate a virtuous motivation upon rising.

Then the rest of the day will be virtuous. Engaging in such practices, one can turn a complete cycle of twenty four hours into virtuous activities. Then for most of us who are oblivious to the fact that we are falling asleep and have fallen asleep, sleep is merely indifferent or neutral. Sleep is a strange state of mind since none of us is actually able to remember the actual instant of falling asleep. Oddly enough, it does happen that one rises instantaneously from sleep.

The following changeable or changing mental factor is regret. Regret can both be virtuous or non virtuous. An instance of virtuous regret would be bitterly regretting a non virtuous deed of great power, which we have engaged in in the past. An instance of virtue, of regret which is non virtuous, would be after making extensive offerings to an object worthy of offerings, to then look back on one’s deed and say, my goodness, I should never have offered that much. At this point, one has incurred great non virtue.

So the relevance of the Lorig from the standpoint of Dharma practice is as follows. The totality of the states of mind which bind us to cyclic existence are mental factors. Ignorance is a mental factor and so are all of the afflictions without exception. Likewise, the totality of the states of mind enabling us to engage in practice on the path are mental factors: wisdom, concentration, insight, śamatha and so forth. Then this completes Lorig, and the transition from Lorig to Tenets is a particularly fortunate one, since Lorig, as you know, ends with a presentation of the afflictions and the means to target the afflictions is through wisdom, and this is the specific topic presented in tenets.

Tenets do not cover in detail the presentation of the method aspect of the path. The topic of tenets, in Tibetan is one which is presented from the standpoint of the transition from coarser to ever more subtle presentations of the view. This process occurs in the presentation of ever more subtle schools of tenets. Since really the differentiation of the Buddhist views and non-Buddhist views and any differentiation of the Buddhist views is contingent on the view. It is extremely important for us to study the view in detail and to delight in it.

Ideally, we will gain certainty or definiteness regarding the view, but if that is not possible, at least we should gain understanding. As Āryadeva says, merely through doubting it, cyclic existence is torn to shreds. Otherwise, from the standpoint of the method aspect of the path, there is no really substantial difference between the various schools of tenets since the practices of generosity, of ethics, forbearance, and so forth, as well as love and compassion are all present. Then, as I said, transform your mind through tenets. We’re going to get into the tenets pretty soon.

Then to transform your mind through tenets, you have to be a person, since only a person can transform his or her mind through tenets. Now within the category of persons endowed with a mind, we have two subdivisions, those whose minds will be transformed by tenets and those whose minds will not be transformed by tenets. Why is it the case that tenets are relevant? Tenets or Grub mtha are engaged in in the process of the search for happiness. Now generally speaking, one who studies tenets understands that from within the twin subdivision of suffering into physical and mental suffering, it is mental suffering which is to be eradicated, and that mental suffering can only be eradicated through the view.

It is a presentation of the view which is specific to tenets. Someone who is only striving for happiness in this life is by definition someone whose mind has not been affected or transformed by tenets. Someone whose mind has been transformed from its inner depths by tenets is someone who does not strive only for this life. Since it is through transforming one’s mind from its innermost depths through tenets that one can attain happiness, one must initially study in-depth the various schools of tenets before making one one’s own one specific school of tenets, one specific school of assertions, and then one must realize those assertions. The Tibetan term tenets has two syllables, means to realize, and this has just been explained by Geshe-la.

The second syllable means in Tibetan, the boundary. And one must realize that there is nothing beyond the boundary of one school of tenets. Then a propounder of tenets, Drubta Mawa, would probably one be one who after having realized his own tenets, literally the boundary of his own assertions, would propound it to another. Then, propounders of tenets or siddhanta in Sanskrit are subdivided into two, non-Buddhist propounders of tenets, Tīrthikas, and Buddhist propounders of tenets. Then in the case of the materialists of the nihilists of ancient India, the so called Lokāyata or Charvaka School, it’s a bit awkward to talk about tenets.

Technically, they do have their tenets, but since they are exclusively focused on this life, we will set them aside. Then we have to check for yourselves whether you are propounders of tenets or not and if you are propounders of tenets, what your system of tenets is. Then in the case of the nihilists, Lokayatas or the Cārvākas, we should put some thought into whether one can really speak of tenets of the Lokayatas or not. Well, I have nothing to add for tonight, so we will stop here. If you have questions, I’ll take a couple of questions.

Chris, behind you. Just to clarify about ignorance, my understanding tonight was that it was presented as both a main mind and a mental factor. Is it both? Generally speaking, with one exception, ignorance is a mental factor for all schools of tenets. For instance, in the Sautrāntika school, ignorance is a mental factor.

The exception is the Sautrāntika-Madhyamaka school, in which some assert that ignorance can be a main mind. All other schools of tenets consider ignorance to be a mental factor. On the issue of whether the materialists have tenets, would that be dependent on whether they have a presentation of a basis, a path and a result, I mean something to which they’re I’m not sure. Clearly, if they had a goal they were striving for, they must have had a means to attain that goal. What that means is I am not sure.

Thank you very much. Although the quality of the instruction and translation for LORIG were excellent I myself understood very little of LORIG despite doing nearly all the suggested reading. I wonder why we spent such a short time on Lorig, and I wonder how long we will spend on tenets. Studying a topic like Lorig, it is of benefit if everything one has read and studied remains firmly in the mind. Otherwise, if what one has studied and read does not remain firmly in the mind and is a bit uncertain, then it is far from clear whether there is benefit.

Also, I believe that, you will find the presentation of tenets more straightforward since, it is done in terms of ground, excuse me, of basis, path, and result, and this is far more straightforward. For instance, the presentation of the status of persons in the various schools of tenets is similar except for the Prāsaṇgika school of tenets. Then, there are internal differences within the Cittamātra or Mind Only School of Tenet, which must be understood too. So I said, one of the big problems, obviously, is we don’t have debate. Right?

That it is not possible to have debate here in this context. And Geshe-la said, since there is no debate, then the act of asking questions and answering questions is really where you are going to learn the most. Just by way of clarification, the 20 secondary afflictions, number eight, dissimulation, when I look that up it says it’s deceit. And I’m just wondering what deceit considered, what’s the nuance with dissimulation which is one in the grouping of desire I think, is that. Generally speaking excuse me.

I’m gonna try to use the same terminology you have here. Generally speaking, dissimulation is the act of concealing one’s faults. Then there is a slight distinction between dissimulation and deceit. Then there’s a very nice tale about this, which will give you a sense of the meaning of dissimulation, which refers to hiding one’s weaknesses or one’s faults. It is said that Śāriputra and Maudgalyayāna, the great disciples of Buddha, asked Brahma the origin of the great elements, the elements, earth, water, fire, and air.

And Brahma was unable to answer, but he didn’t want to say Brahma was a supreme god of ancient India. He didn’t want to say, I don’t have a clue. Instead, turned to Devadatta who was there, and he said, in your opinion, what is it? Then this was a way of avoiding to recognize one’s own ignorance. It is dissimulation.

And? Just just a quick question about envy. Mhmm. As being a subsidiary affliction arising from, I heard correctly, from anger. Mhmm.

It it seems to me that that’s a boundary, that might be a boundary, rather, because envy first starts with desiring something somebody has, and then it can be turned into something quite hateful. But it seems to have a quality of growth You can definitely posit also that envy arises from desire. There are texts which refer to afflictions which arise both from desire and from anger, such as envy precisely. Then, if we think about this by ourselves, we will understand. So the Tibetan term, which I have translated as regret, could as well be translated as guilt.

I explained to Geshe-la the background of guilt in the Judeo Christian culture, which is why the term is so loaded for all of you. And then he said basically, the or guilt can either be non virtuous, neutral or virtuous, depending on the object. Generally speaking, it’s neutral. In training in the six perfections it was mentioned in the teaching that they are either a main mind or they are several main minds. I didn’t understand my point.

The Six Perfections and after that I didn’t catch it. That they were either several main minds a main mind. The six perfections. Was that sorry. Did I or did I misunderstand that?

You want to know what the six perfections are between minds and mental factors maybe? Didn’t you mention the six perfections tonight? Six perfections. So the six perfections are mental factors. They are never main minds.

Because they have their own specific activity. Any mind which has its own specific activity is necessarily a mental factor and not a main mind. Thank you. My question is just clarifying negatives. They’re also used in the presentation of the view.

So I just wanted to clarify a negative does not imply any positive in its place. Yes. Just concerning dreams, So a a dream, for instance, can be oriented towards virtue. When a dream is oriented towards virtue, you accumulate virtuous karma during that dream. Sake Dawa on Friday at 06:00 and then Ilya will be presenting the two fold the two methods for developing bodhicitta on Saturday at 02:00.

Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

changeable mental factors anyathabhava-chaitta (Skt); zhen gyur sem jung (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these are factors that can be virtuous, nonvirtuous or neutral depending on one's motivation and the specific situation. There are four: sleep, contrition, investigation and analysis. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

In the Buddhist tenet systems, is ignorance a mental factor, a main mind, or both?

Generally speaking, ignorance is a mental factor for all schools of tenets, with one exception. For example, in the Sautrāntika school, ignorance is a mental factor. The exception is the Sautrāntika-Madhyamaka school, in which some assert that ignorance can be a main mind. All other schools of tenets consider ignorance to be a mental factor, so it is not both in those schools.

Scroll to Top