1 h 11 min · 7,883 words · 3 October 2010
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A symposium talk surveying Western philosophy of mind, from monism and physicalism through dualism to idealism, and placing Buddhist schools within these views as cognitive dualism. It contrasts Buddhist analysis of the mind with the physical sciences’ study of matter, and describes valid cognition and syllogistic reasoning in both traditions. A question and answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 12m
UUID: 45364ed3-1854-4d3a-a815-253803a4db92
Date: 2010-10-03
Words: 7,879
I’m just handing out a sheet from really from yesterday on the philosophy of mind. And it’s just something that I put together on reading different, doing some research on the philosophy of mind and different basic views that categorize the relationship between the mind and the body. Now, I did cover it yesterday, but I thought handing this sheet out might be useful. It’s not fully comprehensive by any means and the categories that I’ve put people into may be incorrect, but anyway, it’s worth just thinking through the issues. It just gives us a little bit of information about the entire issue of the mind body problem.
And perhaps, just to cover a little bit. Has everyone got the sheet? So it’s a very rough summary. There are a lot of extra material with this that I haven’t included. You can see the numbers for the notes, but there’s no notes.
But if I gave you those, it would be about 20 pages long, so I didn’t include it. And there’s a lot of you know variations, but this is really just the rough overview. And the philosophy of science is dealing with the mind body that we have and trying to explain what the mind body is. And Buddhism is quintessentially a view of the mind body. So, the integration of Buddhist view into Western the western world in part will be Buddhism being included in this sphere.
Now, I’ve included Buddhism here, and I’ve called it cognitive dualism, just getting away from the term Buddhism, and cognitive idealism, because Buddhism doesn’t fit at all into monism. Now, what we’ve got there is a monism, then a dualism right at the very top and another monism. And then underneath, we have materialism or physicalism, and again, dualism, and then idealism, and then a rough definition of what these are. So this is just to give us a, a know, rough idea, a rough map to to use. Within monism on the far left, we have this view that the neutral, a neutral substance that is neither physical or mental, but mental and physical states are properties of this substance is what is asserted to be the mind body.
Just there is just one neutral substance in which manifests as mind and body and that is what we are. All the states of a human being, all the intricate what realities of what a being is, is included within this one mono substance. Then, we have materialism or physicalism on the second level that we roughly define as matter is the only substance, all consciousness is the result of material interaction. And that has strong or weak, we could call it strong or weak versions. The stronger version would be reductive physicalism.
So reductive there meaning everything within us can be reduced to the physical. All mental states and properties will eventually be explained by scientific accounts of physiological processes and states. And this view is quite pervasive, it’s represented in our culture. And within that, when if we go down a bit further, we see that there’s behaviorism, which is a variation, and that here would be defined as mental states are not interior states, meaning the inner interior states that we feel and so forth, on which one can make introspective reports. Well, that really would go against the whole idea of Buddhism, where mental states are exactly in a state upon which we can base valid, introspective reports upon.
So that’s quite it’s good to know what behaviourism asserts. In fact, mental states are just descriptions of behaviour or dispositions to behave in certain ways, made by third parties to explain and predict others behaviour. So, really what we are is just physical states that exhibit behavior and this behavior is observed by others. That’s quite a limiting view of what we are. Type identity theory, then there’s another theory also, token identity theory.
Type identity theory, a mental state m is nothing other than a brain state b. That’s also has quite quite a few people follow this particular view, That really there is nothing else than the brain activity, and all our mental activity is simply brain activity. And and of course, are from the point of view of philosophy, these are quite nihilistic views because if we’re just reduced to that of course, we cannot survive the destruction of our physical body. Functionalism, which tends to take on the example of a computer and the software of a computer to explain how the mind works. Mental states are seen in terms of an empirical computational theory of the mind.
Like our the mind is the software, the brain is the hardware, both are physical states and that’s sufficient to explain what a human is. And then, eliminated eliminated materialism, not all aspects of our common sense psychology, will find reduction to a mature cognitive neuroscience, will find reduction to a mature cognitive neuroscience and that a non reductive materialism is mistaken. Right. So they’re just examples of views of the mind body in the physicalist or the materialist section here. So then we have a slightly weaker form, is the non reductive physicalism.
And so there we have a definition, for instance, although the brain is all there is to the mind, the predicates and vocabulary used in mental descriptions and explanations are indispensable and cannot be reduced to the lands language and lower level explanations of physical science. In other words, although there is just the brain, the descriptions of the mind have a certain level of validity and that level cannot be reduced to just the synapses or the neurons or whatever other physical activity occurs in the brain. Then we move to dualism, and then we have weaker and stronger forms of dualism, where mental phenomena are in some respects non physical. So this is what Ryle calls the what? The official doctrine, and by that he means that it’s officially or it’s people in general accept it without being able to explain it, that it does appear as if the mind and body are separate, and when the body dies, the mind will in some way continue beyond.
But, it’s more a folk a folk belief, an uneducated folk belief from the point of view of the experts in this field of the philosophy of mind. So, when we look at this dualism that is perhaps generally believed amongst the population, then we have things like property dualism, predicate dualism, substance dualism of Descartes and so forth. And they have like a weaker form, property dualism is where the mind is a group of independent properties that emerge from and cannot be reduced to the brain, but it is not a distinct substance. So although we loosely put that into dualism, still they’re not looking at a separate substance, so therefore it’s a weak, a very weak form of dualism, in fact it could be a weak form of monism. And then another one is predicate dualism, while there is only one ontological category of substances and properties of substances, usually physical, the predicates we use to describe mental events cannot be re described in terms of, or reduced to, physical predicates of natural languages.
So, there’s this gray area in the middle here, where philosophers are not willing to go to the logical outcome there and say that everything is just physical, but there’s a bit of a gray area where these mental properties, our feelings, our qualia, our you know, all these significant things about a human existence are probably physically related to the physical, but we don’t wanna go the whole way of saying that they’re completely physical. We leave a slight door open and then, under those three forms that crossover from monism to dualism, or physicalism to dualism, we have various other theories such as property dualism, epiphenomenalism. For instance, epiphenomenalism espoused by Huxley was that mental phenomena are causally ineffectual. That you know, our thoughts don’t really have an effect on anything. Physical events can cause other physical events, and physical events can cause mental events, but mental events cannot cause anything.
They’re just a phenomenon that somehow manifests above supervenes, above form, but they’re like bubbles froth on on water, they don’t do anything, they don’t cause anything. So this would definitely go against the whole idea of karma, where karma intention is seen to be the key ingredient in an individual interacting with the world. Our thoughts do cause us to act. We can affect the physical reality around us. The mind can affect the physical world.
But epiphenomenalism certainly denies this. Anomalous monism, for instance, the one under that, physicalism is true and the mental states must be physical states, but all reductionist proposals are unsatisfactory. Physicalism is true, therefore, really everything does ultimately tend to the physical, but all reductionist proposals are unsatisfactory. There’s no way that they can be reduced to that, it’s sort of a contradiction in a way. But there is a tendency there to want to, you know, go to the extreme physicalist view of the mind body, but an understanding that it’s difficult to explain away the human nature, the feelings, all the aspirations and so forth of human being, and just claim that they are the firing of a c fiber or neuro physiological activity within the brain itself.
We’re not just that, there is a reluctance to go that far. Emergentism, or actually supervenience, also this is an important theory as well, that mental states supervene on physical states, but are not reducible to them. Emergentism, a form of non reductive physicalism that involves a layered view of nature, with the layers arranged in terms of increasing complexity and each corresponding to its own special science. Very complex theories and really one has respect for the science for philosophers working in this field for the great the very detailed theories that are worked out. Still, when I think it is useful that we’re aware of these theories and what their implications are.
Now, when we go to a strong form of dualism, we come up with the model of Descartes. The mind is independently exist an independently existing substance. Now, this has been criticized at great length and it did never, it really didn’t live up to its I guess the potential that Descartes felt that it had, he wasn’t able to really successfully argue for it. But, and in fact, there are so I’ve lost it. I had something I want to say, can’t find it.
But, one of the problems here with dualism and this is something that Buddhist philosophy also has to address is how the mind and body interact. And, he was not able to demonstrate a logical or an authentic or even a possible means by which the mind and the brain actually interact and give rise to a functioning being. How in fact the mind and body can interact. This interactionism as it’s called called is opposed on different levels such as how do you actually explain that something which is non physical, like consciousness itself, actually impinge or affect something which is physical. Something which is non physical doesn’t have a specific place or site.
And so it’s difficult for consciousness therefore to act on the brain, which would be at the interface of consciousness and physical matter, body. If consciousness has no place, how can it interact interact with the brain? And Descartes was not able to answer this, or extensively describe how these two separate substances may coexist. Now, we have another form of dualism here in which I’ve put in the Buddhist Vaibhāṣika, the Sattrantika, the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika schools into what I’ve labeled as cognitive dualism. Now, it has shared some aspects with the Descartes theory.
In fact, within Buddhism, the mind and the body are seen to be different substantial continua or streams that interact. And they interact for instance on the, you know, at the interface of the brain and the mind. This interaction is described for instance in the Buddhist presentation of the five Skanda or the five aggregates, the 12 bases, the 18 elements. But one thing about Buddhism, and this is where Buddhism more becomes the science of the mind and modern natural sciences become the science of matter. Because Buddhism is really focused on explaining the mind in great depth and has not really shown us how the mind itself interacts with the brain in a very subtle way.
It hasn’t investigated matter in a very subtle way. In fact, is clear when we read the Abhidharma material because Buddhism did not discover the periodic table in chemistry for instance. And it its idea of atoms is quite primitive. The physical universe is made up of in the desire realm of atoms that have eight particles and these are the subtle particle of earth, wind, water, fire and the subtle particle of an object of sight consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness and body consciousness. These are very subtle particles, and an atom is made up of those.
Now this of course, when you read through the Abhidharma literature, you look at this and you think, oh my god, you know, if the scientists read this, then, you know, there’s no way that the Buddhist are gonna be able to defend this position, it’s just rubbish. And true. What I suggest here is that the Buddhist were not so interested in finding out the subatomic nature of matter, they were much more interested in looking at the mind itself. And so in focusing on the mind, they’ve neglected a deep study of the physical universe. And this is a fault, you know, there’s no way around it.
These days when Buddhist talk to scientists, this is an area where Buddhism has not excelled, they’ve not developed this area. On the other hand, the sciences, the physical sciences have gone into great depth, they’ve discovered the periodic table, they’ve developed complete theories about atoms and molecules, shells surrounding atoms, how atoms can join together, share electrons, what is the, you know, what is an atom composed of, and so on. There’s a lot of absolutely brilliant work that’s been done by the sciences in terms of investigating the subtle nature of matter. And this is an area that Buddhism really has to stand back and, you know, understand the great advances that have been made. And the praise that’s due to science in order in science and actually having uncovered this area.
And it is necessary to acknowledge this. When what Buddhism does talk about in terms of the interaction is it talks about the five aggregates, but the five aggregates are really the summary of the mind body issue because the five aggregates are form, the form aggregate, then feeling discrimination, karmic formation and consciousness are all conscious elements of awareness. So, the first aggregate is body, the second or the second group, the next four aggregates are mind. And so Buddhism seeks to explain these. It expands those then into the 12 bases.
And the 12 bases are the six types of consciousness that we possess, like eye consciousness, ear, nose, tongue, body consciousness and mental consciousness, and there are sense bases that exist beyond that, such as the eye sense base, the ear sense base, nose, tongue and body sense base, and the mental sense base. So within Buddhism, the interaction of the mind and body is explained in terms of we can see here the 12 bases. Now, the bases themselves probably, I think as I look at the literature, not only include the physical sense base, such as the eye itself, but also within the eye, the apparatus within the eye that manages to collect the light data, that’s altered by the lens of the eye and so forth, but also the nerve ending that connects the eye to the brain and that area of the brain that actually engages visual images. That is all part of the sense base. So too with the ear, the nose, the tongue, and the body.
So, in fact, when Buddhism is talking about these sense bases, it’s also including the brain that is utilized in the processing of this data. The sixth sense base is the mental sense base and that is the mind. So out of the 12 bases, just one of them is consciousness. And that is the sense base which is the support of all conscious activity. What it implies is that mental awareness is supported by the sense base of of of the mind itself, the previous moment of mind.
What how we can also explain this is that The brain itself, the physical aspect of the brain acts as a sense base, but consciousness does interact, but with in especially in terms of the senses, how the senses actually focus and engage the external world. The thinking processes themselves are based on the mind itself, the main sense base of our conceptual awareness, which is our main type of mental awareness. The actual direct sense base for that is the mind itself or the previous moment of mind. Anyway, without going into too much detail on just how this interaction is described, the standard portrayal of this is through the these three fundamental categories, the five aggregates, the 12 bases and the 18 realms or the Dattu and so forth. I call Buddhism here cognitive dualism because the emphasis is placed on the mind itself, the cognitive aspect and it’s dualist in a sense that it does assert that there are these two streams that do interact.
What this implies, and both of these streams in a sense are not regarded as having a particular beginning, the stream of consciousness that any individual has exists within a substantial stream that is beginningless. And the reason for that is that the substantial cause of consciousness is either a previous moment of consciousness or a latent predisposition within the mental stream that can give rise to consciousness. In other words, consciousness cannot substantially arise from matter. It can be influenced by matter, but it cannot actually be caused or it cannot the stream of matter can never become conscious consciousness. The stream of consciousness can never become matter.
So, from this point of view, then the whole idea of reincarnation is established. That if the mind itself can only be caused by previous, substantially caused by previous moments of consciousness, then there’s no way that it can arise substantially from matter, from the matter that we inherit from our parents as the union of the egg and the sperm, that DNA and so forth, that can never act as a substantial cause of consciousness that we possess. It can only come from a previous moment of consciousness and this is also born out within the epistemology within Buddhism, when epistemology seeks, for instance in the works of Dharma Kirti, to justify rebirth or prove rebirth, he’s using just this argument of the continuum of the mind itself and the substantial cause of this moment of mind must have been a previous moment of mind. There is no other substantial cause possible. So therefore, when we look at the embryo, the first moment of the embryo and the consciousness of that being, its substantial cause must have been a previous moment of consciousness, which pre existed the first moment of the embryo.
That stream of consciousness, by this reasoning, if we take it back, then there can be no beginning to it. Similarly, can be no end to it because the consciousness itself, is defined as that which is clear and knowing or clear and cognizant, has always existed as the nature of consciousness. Sel Rigpa, the component of clarity and cognition exists in an unending stream that’s impermanent, continuously changing, but it has no cessation, it has no beginning, it has no end. saṃsāra, which is the the five aggregates, the contaminated five aggregates, also has no beginning because the mind has no beginning, saṃsāra has an end because the contaminated mind can be stopped if the correct antidote to that contamination are applied. And that is possible because the mind is impermanent.
Because the mind is impermanent, existing within the stream, then various elements of the mind can be stopped. Things that are not essential to the actual nature of the mind, such as the impurity that exists within the mental continuum can be stopped. Because that impurity is not the essential nature of the mind, which is this clear component of clarity and cognizance. Clarity and knowing. So this is the what?
The official theory within Buddhism. Now, one thing is that as science develops more of an interest perhaps, in these issues, it will apply itself more to disproving this, which will be a very good thing. Because the more light that is brought into this area, I think the more benefit potentially there’ll be. If it can be disproved, it needs to be disproved. As the Dalai Lama once mentioned that, you know, in going to the West, well, if science can prove the existence of a self, then Buddhists will have to accept it.
Absolutely. If it’s proven, there’s no other option. And if this is not the correct theory of mind, then it should be disproved. Because so much of our future hangs on this question. Our future is right there.
This is the our essential issue. What is the mind? What what is this essential component of us as a human being? From a Buddhist point of view, the essential definition of a human is the five aggregates. The five the mind body continuum.
That is what we are. The I, I is imputed on the mind body continuum. So, need to know what that is, in understanding what the I is depends on understanding what the mind body continuum is. And one of the deep, philosophic issues of our day, and past days has been what who am I? If we can understand that, then we understand what where the I has come from, and what its potential is, what its future will be.
So these are issues that are really very important. And we need to address them, I think that goes with that saying, we either address them now or in future, but as we all know, the future never comes. Okay, then also in the strong substance dualism field we have underneath other theories such as interactionism. Now, interactionism is something that Buddhism would accept, mental states such as beliefs and desires causally interact with physical states. So, Buddhism does accept a form of interactionism, But, the status of this interactionism is very important, the status of the mind.
And from another perspective, Buddhism also has a very sophisticated philosophy on ontology, on the nature of what does exist. On the the whole idea of emptiness, lack of true existence, lack of inherent existence, lack of substantial existence, and so forth. These are areas where the Buddhist Buddhist philosophy has developed a great expertise. And why is this expertise necessary? Because this is, you know, the final ground of our identity as beings.
We need to know this. Because also Buddhism asserts that understanding this ground is the essential way of purifying the mind itself. So, this issue needs to be looked at. Now, in other if we look briefly at some other forms of dualism, such as psychophysical parallelism, mind and the body having distinct ontological statuses, state I perhaps, I’m not sure, do not actually influence one another. Although they’re distinct, they have no influence over one another.
Instead, they run along parallel paths, mind events causally interact with mind events, and brain events causally interact with brain events, and only seem to influence each other. Interesting. That’s the mind is running along on its course, the brain is running along on its course, and not much conversation going on. Not an easy position to to maintain, but that arose because of the problem of defining how the mind and the brain interact. How you can have a non physical mind interacting with a physical brain.
They gave up at this stage. Okay, we’ll call it they don’t interact. It’s psychophysical parallelism. They exist in parallel streams. It doesn’t really solve much, that view.
Occasionalism. All supposedly causal relations between physical events or between physical and mental events are not really causal at all. While body and mind are different substances, causes whether mental or physical are related to their effects by an act of God’s intervention on each specific occasion. That is a how complex is that theory? It is like well, Occam could not be satisfied I think with such a theory.
So then, just finally, we’ll just have a quick look at monism. The other extreme of monism is idealism, where everything reduces or tends to reduce to the mind itself. And in the weak form, mental matter is mental substance, matter is a property of mind and so forth, there’s many different ways this could be described. And there’s another Buddhist another two Buddhist schools that fit here into what might be termed a type of cognitive idealism, the idealism of Buddhist Chitamatra and the Mādhyamika Svatāntrika. Now, the Chitamatrans have a wonderful view and the Tibetans often refer to the the great benefit of studying this particular view because it does give one an insight into the nature of karma.
In this from this point of view, there is no external reality whatsoever. There’s just the reality of the mind. Form does exist, but form is not composed of atoms and molecules. It’s merely form that appears to consciousness, it’s not separated in space from consciousness and it arises the mind becoming aware of form arises because within the mental continuum, seeds continuously manifest or awaken, giving rise to both the subject and the object simultaneously. And within that scenario, we become aware of the external, of an apparent external universe.
Now, the great example for this procedure is a dream, where in a dream, the dream world doesn’t exist external, externally. But still there is an experience of the dreamer and the object dreamed as being, an external physical reality. For the Chitamatran, this is precisely what waking reality is. So there is no external physical universe, and just the whole idea that there are atoms and molecules is fundamentally a misconception because that’s the way it appears to be. And so from the Chitamatran point of view, the external world and the mind are of the same substance, the same energy.
And when one understands they are of the same energy, the same substance, one understands emptiness or non duality. Still, even within the Chitamatran view, the mind and physical form, even though they are the same substance, they are not the same because they are distinct entities. And form is not regarded as being mind, but just simply being of the same substance as the mind. Form does not take on the function of knowing, but it’s an object of the sense perceptions, but it’s not not mind itself, but the same substance as mind. And the Mādhyamika and Svatāntrika have a higher view, they don’t assert true existence as the Chitamatran do.
The Chitamatran think that the mind truly exists and it needs to truly exist because the whole system requires a stable anchor of the mind itself. If the mind doesn’t truly exist, it’s very difficult to establish the philosophy of mind only. There’s no there’s not a stable basis for it to do for that to occur. So they have no problem with asserting the mind to be truly existent. And they have recourse to scriptural authority to also assert this.
There are other issues as well, if we can go into the transcendental idealism of Kant, all we can know is the mental impressions that an outside world creates in our mind. Our minds can never perceive the outside world directly. So this is an interesting, an important view from a great philosopher in the Western tradition. The absolute idealism of Hegel, finite qualities are not fully real because they depend on other finite qualities to determine them, and so on. Panpsychism, mental experience and properties may be at the foundation of physical experience and properties.
And so on, there are many there are theories here that are idealistic in their tendencies. And then also, strong a strong form of idealism would be really that everything is just the mind, that all this physical the physical world is the mind itself, which would imply that it actually is is clear and cognizing, the table itself would be aware of the external and so on. That’s now perhaps the subjective idealism of Berkeley tends to that, all knowledge through the senses and experience is nothing but sheer illusion, and only in the ideas of the pure understanding, ideas of pure understanding and reason is their truth. Now, that would be going to an extreme. Okay, we have just this chart here, it’s just useful to know anyway where I think Buddhism fits in this chart, and Buddhism does fit into the dualist or the monist or the idealist categories, and it doesn’t at all fit within the physicalist monistic views.
But I would also again emphasize that a dialogue is required with science, and we’re just in the initial stages of developing such a dialogue, and the dialogue is going to require the terminology to be sorted out, because the terminology within Buddhism is so specialist and it’s arriving, or it’s rising within a particular, well, world view civilization that is quite different than the western from that world view or from the roots of western civilization or even from the roots of Western scientific culture as developed from the time of Descartes with the scientific revolution. At present, it’s hard to have a conversation because the terms are not agreed on. The there is no common terminology established. So this is something that will occur in future because inevitably these issues are going to bump up against each other. And at some point, much more extensive and fruitful dialogue will occur.
Well, just wanted to bring that up. Now, today is actually we’re going to talk on the emotions a little bit. And Buddhist, perhaps a little bit about Buddhist psychology. And again, where we are today is we inherit the psychology from Western, from the West, we have a particular psychology itself that is rooted in early the early Greeks, and Aristotle, Plato, and so forth. It’s influenced Western psychology is influenced by biblical studies, and biblical scholars such as Aquinas and so forth, influenced by the Arabs and their know, and their ways of treating mental disorders and so forth.
And then the medieval Europe, how medieval Europe has adopted influences from the Middle East, from earlier periods of Greek philosophy and so forth. But then, probably with the scientific revolutions and so forth, we have seen quite significant breakthroughs in Western psychology. Now, this is a huge field and we really don’t have time to go into that in-depth. Just to say that there are different roots in the presentation of Western psychology and Buddhist psychology. For instance, just to list a few like the development of Structuralism through William Wandt and where which focused on the breaking down of mental processes into the most basic components to understand the basic elements of consciousness using a method known as introspection.
This method of introspection also exists within Buddhism and just to diverge a little bit at this point, one of the what we’re looking at here within science, within Buddhism, are valid systems of gaining knowledge about what we’re investigating. Scientific method itself has proven to be incredibly successful. It’s a valid pramāna, as you would say, valid means of gaining valid insight into the nature of what’s being investigated, the scientific method, which is based on processes rooted in Greek logic and so on. Similarly, in India, there are similar processes occurred from time of the Buddha even probably with roots prior to the Buddha of methods of gaining valid information about the world around us. So often this is within India for instance, it was based on syllogistic reasoning, understanding the nature of conception, understanding that conception develops a valid conclusion about a particular object, independence on formulating a correct reason about the subject that is being dealt with.
This pramāna really is directed at that field which is obscure, it’s not directly accessed by the senses. We can gain valid awareness of the gross physical universe often just by applying our senses to them, right? We look at something and we can understand it. We hear something and we can understand that it’s sound, what type of sound. We can have a valid appreciation of that sound merely by the gross ear consciousness that apprehends that sound.
Similarly with the eye, can develop a valid awareness of the shape or the color of a particular object just by looking at it and that’s a valid Pramāna, it’s a valid awareness of that object. When we go to the next level, which is the level of obscure phenomena, then the senses are not useful. The senses are not powerful enough to penetrate. For instance, with impermanence, with the subtle nature of atoms and molecules, the senses are not of much use. The only way that we can access these are of course through conception, and conception is able to access these subtle realities through using valid reasoning, that valid reasoning is based on the formulation of correct syllogisms or consequences.
This process exists not only in the East but of course in scientific method in the West. The difference probably is the way that the East has investigated the mind and using the process of syllogistic logic and the process of introspection to examine the nature of the mind itself. And also, this process of introspection has relied on methods of refining the mind to give the mind greater clarity on subtle and obscure issues such as impermanence, understanding impermanence, understanding selflessness and so forth. Now, these methods of purifying the mind are set at a great length and they’re fundamentally it’s the they’re based on the practice of ethics and in order to refine the mind you must establish ethics to begin with, there’s no way of purifying the mind without having a basis of ethics. Then on that basis you purify the mind by developing single pointed concentration, so that you eliminate distraction, because what is the main obstacle to developing insight is distraction.
Not being able to hold the mind on the topic, not being able to focus clearly and steadily on a particular thing for an extensive period, enough time in order to be able to penetrate to the meaning, such as selflessness or impermanence. So the methods of developing higher insight within Buddhism are fundamentally based on purifying the mind and developing the state of Samādhi or single pointed concentration, that is a state where the mind is perfectly clear and at rest, like a clear water. And just as if we try to see something on the base of a river, if the stream is clear and still, we can see clearly what’s at the base. If it’s not clear and still, we can’t see what’s at the base of the water. Similarly, these issues such as impermanence, the momentary nature of reality, we cannot understand unless the mind is still.
Then when the mind is still, can apply a syllogism to understanding what the impermanence is. For instance, the classic syllogism that’s presented is, you know, take a vase, it’s impermanent because it’s produced. It’s produced from causes. On that syllogism alone, if one contemplates that, also without distraction, then over a period of time, by applying that, one will come to an understanding of impermanence. But, there’s many different ways you can apply the syllogism and contemplate the syllogism in order to generate the understanding of impermanence.
Or selflessness. But one, in the syllogism you have to understand the three aspects, the subject, the predicate, the reason, you have to bring them together with various types of conception. There’s one conception that understands it understands the position property of a syllogism. The first method of the syllogism, the second method of a syllogism, the first method is that the subject is pervaded by the reason, the second is that the reason pervades the predicate, the third is the opposite of the predicate pervades the opposite of the reason. One has three separate conceptions that one brings up and applies it, one is aware of them at the same time.
Through this process of applying the three elements of the syllogism, it’s possible to establish the thesis, that is that the subject is the predicate. But one needs to hold them, juggle these, it’s like a juggler with three things. We need to have them all there together for the penny to drop. When they’re there together and they’re clearly held, especially by a mind that is not distracted, such as a mind with Samādhi, then one can break through to impermanence. But that does require an enduring well, one needs to be able to endure in that state for a certain period in order for the result to occur.
Similarly, not only with ontological issues, with even establishing the nature of consciousness, that is also done through introspection, viewing the mind itself indirectly. We can’t directly look at the mind, but we can indirectly be aware of our own mind. And indirectly, we establish its existence by our own mind. But the mind can’t look at itself. But especially when the mind is purified by the process of eliminating distraction and the other faults of the ordinary mind, then it becomes much easier for us to understand the nature of the mind.
Also, when one develops single pointed concentration, then it’s possible from the point of view of Buddhist philosophy to establish extra sensory perception. This depends basically on developing Samādhi, developing a stream of single pointed awareness that is the gateway to developing, for instance, the capacity to understand other people’s minds and so on. Understand one’s past lives, be able to see, remember back through the stream of consciousness that one has, through the process of death into one’s previous life, follow that stream of consciousness back for many, many lifetimes through having developed Samādhi. So just in in closing, I just want to say that there are different parameters or modes of generating valid awareness that exist in science and exist in Buddhism, but they’re actually quite similar. And probably within Buddhism you also have this commitment to introspection as the means of understanding the mind itself, along with a syllogistic method for developing an understanding of external, the external world around us.
And I think that probably in future the dialogue will more and more center on the possibility of this introspective method of understanding the mind. Because if the mind is not physical, then there’s no way that the natural sciences are going to be unable to uncover the mind in that way. Buddhism implies that the only way you can do it is indirectly by your own mind itself. Unless you have extra sensory perception that understands the minds of others, and then perhaps you could But that’s, you know, an obscure method. Okay, I think I’ll stop there.
Yes. Yes. That they seem to be working on really, really different levels. How has that been? Yes, well, that’s right, the traditional Buddhist forms of introspection haven’t really been what conducted for that purpose, to come up with a set of statistics or to aid in developing a theory of the structure of the mind.
But, you know, that’s it’s possible that I think, you know, to ask meditators to engage in these sorts of exercises could be very useful, and I could imagine that there would be scenarios, especially in relation to this, the Buddhist structure of the mind, the, you know, the 51 mental factors, how they interact, to actually have meditators specifically report on some of those groups of the 51, you know, the five omnipresent, you know, like feeling, discrimination and so forth. Just when does discrimination, you know, when does it activate? Feeling, how does feeling interact with, you know, things like discrimination and so on. Because there are many assumptions within the Buddhist system about how the mind works, like the five omnipresent mental factors like feeling and so forth, are always present, at least on a subtle level. But one of the and a major issue for us is our feeling.
It’s a second aggregate. It’s if we can deal with our feelings, we’ve more or less got things sorted out. To understand where the feelings are coming from, is it coming from our discrimination or, you know, what is the order here? Because of those five omnipresent, feeling, discrimination, intention, contact, attention, those five, all occur instantly when one, you know, focuses on an object. How do they and because they occur instantly, they don’t act as cause and result of each other.
But we have a particular feeling when we look at a cup or something, and the feeling arises in relation to our eye awareness focused on the on the glass. We’re thirsty and we look at it and a feeling arises of you know, a positive feeling, I’m thirsty, I can quench my thirst and so on. But that feeling, what conditions it? Because the previous moment of feeling might have been a thought, might have been thinking about my mortgage. And that conception, holding my mortgage may have had a negative mental feeling associated with it.
But I look at it and suddenly I have a positive feeling. Is there any relationship in that stream of feeling? There are different types of feeling, one’s a mental feeling, one’s a physical feeling that arises with eye consciousness. There is a lot that needs to be explained, and I think that can be used. I don’t see why not.
Line up a 100 meditators, give them various tasks, to really sort out these issues. And I think there is no other method than the introspective method. I don’t think Brain scans are are really also very useful, and that can also be incorporated into this. We’re not yet, and that’s one of the reasons why further work needs to be done. And also there’s remarkable progress being made in these apparatus.
There, it’s amazing what is being done these days. So yeah, that’s it’s really Yes. Oh, then it can. Yes. Well, you can have with the intention there is on a mental level and it’s that conception to look at the glass arises, then one actually looks at the glass, has a sense awareness focused on the glass.
So they’re different, but they occur at the same time while we’re looking at the glass, we’re thinking about the glass. And they have different feelings associated with them. There’s a physical feeling and a mental feeling occurring at the same time. And they have an effect on the being themselves that possesses both of those consciousnesses simultaneously. It is complex, and actually to sort out the mind and the way the mind functions, know, has been said to be the great breakthrough of Buddhism, that you know this was the great achievement of the Buddha to clearly set out what what is happening in the ordinary mind.
You know, as an example, the questions of King Milinda, this Greek Bactrian king, and one day he asked Nagasena, his preceptor, what is something that the Buddha has done that is really difficult? And Nagasena said, well, consider, oh king, if you went to the the banks of the Arabian Sea and you took a mouthful of water from the sea and you tasted it, could you tell where the water was from? And the king said, no, that would be too difficult. And he said, so too, The minds and mental factors are completely mixed like the waters of the Indus and the Sutlej and all these other rivers that pour into the But the Buddha has been able to differentiate the different mental factors like which are like different streams entering an ocean and set them aside, set them apart, and explain them, and how they interact. So, it’s an extremely difficult thing to to establish, to work out, but it’s difficult, but attaining enlightenment is probably even well, as difficult.
Have to actually do it eventually. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think that’s a fair description.
Yeah, science in the sense of just well, in Tibetan for instance, Senrig, it implies the application of logic and valid verifiable means of gaining knowledge. So in that sense, yeah, the Buddha could be said to be a scientist. Yes. Well, I’m not sure if Yeah. But when you’re looking at the mind itself, whether that’s can be classified as empirical or not is another huge issue.
Yeah. I don’t Could that be could that be claimed to be empirical if you Yes. Yeah, I think there is and it will take it’s going to take a long time to put in the pieces by which are really, as Robert pointed out, a proper dialogue can really occur. Yeah. Yeah.
I think so. I think that will be negotiated. Yeah. Yeah. I agree.
Yeah. Yes. Yes. Yes. Exactly.
This whole issue of validity. And, of course, this comes up in validity of knowledge and of course this comes up in Buddhism as well and the works of Dignāgā and Dharmakīrti and all that area of looking at conceptual understanding and how it can arise, correct concept. Yes, no, think that’s a common thing moving from one discipline to another, just to be able to integrate them and understand where they interface and how they should be approached and integrated. Yep, this is a huge area. I take this slight pause and jump in Ian’s breath to to say that we have hit quarter two.
And if you would like to hold that thought, I’m sure this is a shared illusion. And if we if we can take our various aggregates hopefully all together. My ear sense power detects all I’ll impose on that a joke from Joe. If you’d like to enter through this cavity then have some repast but beforehand join me once again in thanking Jampa on the floor. And then we will reassemble promptly at two and Ilya will be the final speaker before we then come together as a panel where we can address further questions.
And don’t forget the questionnaire at the back. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- valid awareness pramana (Skt); tshema (Tib)
- A new non-deceptive cognition. There are two types: valid perception, such as the eye consciousness seeing a flower, and valid inference, such as inferring fire from seeing smoke. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.