Tenets

48 min · 6,447 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Tenets (Ilia Durovic)
Tenets (Ilia Durovic)
Tenets
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 48-minute Q&A session, Kyabje Rinpoche clarifies the first three limbs of dependent origination—ignorance, compositional factors, and consciousness—then explores how karma accumulates and ripens over multiple lifetimes, sometimes spanning thousands of years. He illustrates with the extended example of a slave who steals food, whose karmic imprint doesn’t mature until 2,000 years later. The discussion moves into documented reincarnation cases from Ian Stevenson’s research, particularly the striking case of Vijayaratne, a Sri Lankan murderer reborn with physical deformities—a paralysed right arm and atrophied pectoral muscle—matching the wounds he inflicted. Throughout, Rinpoche emphasizes that understanding the 12 limbs is essential for recognizing how afflictions and karma drive the cycle of rebirth, and how deliberate choice in accumulating virtue can shift one’s trajectory.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 12 Limbs D1Q&A – KR.mp3

UUID: b6fc54ff-5a08-4731-a1ce-4b0e76e1ed32

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Tenets

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~6,441

I drop a hint in TBI suggestion box. Specialist, the staff. Very good. Then what are your questions? We’ll be very focused.

So what are your questions on the three first limbs? Please. What I am asking about is the extent to which the first limb is the cause of the second limb is the cause of the third limb. The way in which the presentation this morning, because of not seeing ignorance as beginningless in the sense that it had that there is a cause for the ignorance. And then looking at ignorance from some starting point at birth rather than seeing the preexisting moment in a mind leading to that state of mind at the time of birth, I became confused about the extent to which this beginning was in ignorance was what impelled the second limb and in turn the third limb.

And you confused me. So to recapitulate, Geshe this morning tried to distinguish several things. He first gave a theoretical presentation, and then he gave an experiential presentation. Then these two sometimes fit and sometimes don’t fit. There’s no guarantee that because this is a theoretical presentation, your experience of it is gonna be one and the same.

So the first limb is known as initial ignorance, beginningless ignorance if you prefer. That is ignorance grasping at a self. Then that acts as the root of afflictions which deposit the karmic imprints which are accumulated at the second instance of the second limb, compositional factors, into the third limb, consciousness. Now it’s not the case that there is an explicit causal relationship between these three. They’re linked.

But you certainly cannot say for instance, that the compositional factor in the second limb is the cause of the consciousness in the third limb. That consciousness is the repository of the karmic imprint. Then what that consciousness is, that depends on the schools of tenets. That’s another question altogether. For most of the schools of tenets, it’s a mental consciousness.

For Cittamātra and the schools of tenets which accept the eight consciousnesses, it’s a mind basis of all. For Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, it’s something else altogether. So that’s a bit the relation between the three. And what Geshe-la was asking was basically, in your personal experience, when does this first limb of ignorance appear for the first time? Then you gave various examples of what I thought of frankly, was that of the first time an infant suckles.

That’s a very clear manifestation both of desire, and when the breast is taken away of anger, as far as I know, I don’t have children, you know, that’s my understanding. Those of you who have, have more direct experience than I do, you know. Then, at birth, at birth a child cries, but what that crying means, we don’t know. And in the womb, then, there are a lot of reports my mother said that she spoke to me and I answered. I can’t say.

But, you know, my mother spoke English that I’m sure of. Then I’m also sure I didn’t answer in English. She said I kicked. You know, that was my speech. Right?

Then does that mean that the beginningless ignorance was present? No. It doesn’t. Then, obviously, from a Buddhist standpoint, from a theoretical standpoint, innate ignorance is present continuously. But that’s not what Geshe-la was asking.

What Geshe-la is asking is, what is the first instance in your personal experience of this ignorance which is the first limb. Right? Which will give rise to the afflictions and basically act as a motor of cyclic existence. Then, I think we have to be fair with Geshe-la. Geshe-la is a monk, so the experience of children is limited.

So, you know, if something doesn’t fit with your experience as parents, then I think you keep your experience as parents. And maybe give it a greater importance. Does that go towards answering your question? Yes it does. Good.

So, this first moment in this life of a manifestation of this ignorance of self grasping, that has been caused by a previous moment of mind. For sure. That’s a given. That’s a given. Then And that might be Alaya Vijñāna with the stored karma?

Well, the ālaya vijnana itself, no. But the afflicted mind, yes. Then those are very technical debates. When the afflicted mind appears, we can enter into this, but it’s dizzying. It’s dizzying.

From a Buddhist standpoint, it is at conception that this life begins. Right? So the first instant before conception, one is a Bardo being, as Natalie, you know, pointed out in her very cogent example. Then a distinction is made between conception and birth. Birth is an exterior phenomenon.

So the infant after, you know, maturing in the womb, basically, that comes into the world. Then a series of limbs from the fourth to the seventh limb cover this process of maturation of the fetus. Then this is a lot less interesting for us now in the twenty first century than it was, let’s say, two thousand five hundred years ago, just because embryology has made tremendous progress. So the analysis which is made of the transition from the fourth limb, name and form, to the fifth limb, the six sources. The sixth limb contact and the seventh limb sensation is an extremely accurate analysis from an embryological standpoint.

It’s surprising me. So I did a presentation or two here just on this topic. There’s a sūtra called the Garbhavakranti sūtra, which was taught by Buddha Śākyamūni, the sūtra of the Entry in the Womb, which teaches the process of birth. It’s astonishingly accurate. But frankly, we have all the discoveries of modern embryology.

We can go, if you’re interested in that, in levels of detail which are impossible at the period. So what is interesting in this but we won’t talk about that now because that will be maybe if Geshe-la can cover the topics he’ll cover tomorrow. What is interesting in the transition from the fourth to the seventh limb is the very clear analysis of the development of the embryo as a perceiving entity. That’s what these four limbs are about. The appearance of the embryo, the appearance of sense organs which are nonfunctional.

Then that’s the six sources. Then contact, which means that everything is pre functional. It’s on the edge of operativity, if you wish. You have sensory organs. You have objects.

And then the final limb sensation is the first time sensation occurs. None of these limbs presuppose any afflictions. Right? So afflictions arise in the 12 limbs at the level of the limb of craving. Craving is desire and appropriation or what you call grasping is intensification of desire.

Now do you have any questions about the first three limbs? Yes. Okay, so I did get a bit confused this morning, Ilya, so please excuse me if this goes for a little bit longer than a normal question should. But my understanding with beginningless ignorance is that and this innate self of I, and when I mentioned the moment, the first moment of mind in this lifetime, I mention that because when we get conceived you know, we are told that the Bardo being sees the mother and father copulating and then comes in and they come in because of anger. So we are propelled by one of our afflictions into the next birth.

And if we’re propelled by afflictions and that impelling at that moment seems to also include beginningless, an innate self of I, an innate understanding of I that comes in to the, you know, that sees the parent and wants to be with the opposite sex parent. So that’s why I got confused. I think I understand the problem. You see, when we talk of, and Geshe will probably cover this tomorrow. When we talk of one cycle of 12 limbs, right, we’re talking of one cycle in which at some point back in time, there was ignorance. And that ignorance gave rise to afflictions and to a karma, which was deposited in the mind.

That’s a third limb. And then that karmic imprint deposited in the mind can have stayed there for tens of thousands of years, millions of years. As long as you want. And when the eighth and the ninth limbs, in other words craving and appropriation cause that karmic imprint to mature. And that might be, let’s say, ten thousand years down the road at the time of death.

That’s when karmic imprints impelling karma mature typically. At that point, that triggers the appearance of a tenth limb, which is the limb of existence. That is a karma immediately preceding birth in the following life. And then the next life starts, and at that point, you have the development of the embryo, which is the fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh limb. So that is one cycle of 12 limbs.

Now during that one cycle of 12 limbs, there will have been countless manifestations of other ignorances, other afflictions, other karmas accumulated, which are completely unrelated. That’s not what we’re talking about. We’re talking of one cycle of 12 limbs beginning with ignorance and the afflictions, which imprints one karma, which precipitates a rebirth. That’s the meaning. Not just any event.

An impelling karma precipitates a rebirth. So to give you an example, let us imagine. What can we take? Let us imagine that well, I’ll draw on the memory someone who is at the center told me about. Let us imagine that someone was a slave.

Let us say two thousand five hundred years ago. And during that life as a slave, the three first limbs were activated. There was ignorance. Out of ignorance and grasping desire arises, poor slave was hungry and he stole food, you know. So during that life, the three first limbs are activated.

Right? Then that theft of food deposits a karmic imprint within the consciousness. It’s a third limb. And that karmic imprint remains in that consciousness, let’s say, and I’m constructing for two thousand years. After two thousand years, in the life immediately preceding this one, or let’s say in this life, that person who has been reborn as a human being at the time of death feels tremendous desire.

That’s craving the eighth limb. That desire intensifies. That’s appropriation. And it triggers that karmic imprint from two thousand years ago of theft. Now if that karmic imprint was a powerful one, let us assume it was theft from another slave who was also starving.

Then that will create a tenth limb of existence, which is a very powerful karma precipitating a next rebirth. And if it is powerful in this case, it might be rebirth as a or rebirth as a destitute beggar again. And when one is reborn, let’s say, in a beggar family in India, then at that rebirth, you have the fourth limb, name and form. Then a couple of weeks later, you will have the fifth limb, the six sources, which is the appearance of the sense organs in a very primitive non operative fashion. They have just appeared.

If you look at the embryo, it’s very interesting. I showed you here some slides. It’s fascinating. The sense organs are nascent, but nonfunctional. Alright?

And this is followed by the sixth limb, which is contact. The sense organs are functional, but don’t function yet. And they can perceive an object, objects to be perceived. And the moment they operate, you have the limb of sensation, the seventh limb. And then at that point, you have a process which after a couple months leads to a child being born.

So at that point, when the child is born, you have the limb of birth, the eleventh limb, and then the rest of the life of that child is a limb of aging and death. Aging begins at the moment of birth. At the death of that child who is born as a pauper in India, that cycle of 12 limbs is complete. Do you understand? This is how karma operates.

So what is very interesting and powerful about the 12 limbs is that they enable one to understand just how karma operates. How the afflictions cause the accumulation and the maturation of karma. Alright? And then when you understand something, you can counter it. Right?

So those of you who have had difficult experiences in this life, and many of our students have now, you have to keep in mind, especially if these are difficult births. If you are born with congenital physical problems, or if you are born in an extremely poor family, have to struggle for a living, you know. Then the result is always similar to the cause in type. So you can get a fairly good sense of what karmic cause could have caused this. Right?

And then you can construct a theoretical. It’s not the case in practice, but a theoretical set of 12 limbs which leads you from the accumulation of that karmic cause at some point in the past far away to this result. When you see how that operates, then you definitely will not want to experience this again. Right? So exactly the same thing is true for virtuous karmic imprints.

The 12 limbs operate both for contaminated non virtuous imprints and contaminated virtuous karma. We’ll get there. Do you understand how this works? Now during this cycle, you’ll have a lot of other afflictions not part of that cycle. Lots of other instances of ignorance, they’re not part of that cycle.

But if they are powerful enough, they give rise to another group of 12 links. Then Nāgārjuna says that he does not assert any sentient being apart from this endless wheel of 12 limbs. There is, in other words, no soul. There is no core. There is nothing apart from if you want to visualize it, imagine this rosary has 12 beads.

Right? One group of 12 limbs, another group of 12 limbs, a third group of 12 limbs, a fourth group of 12 limbs, all interwoven with each other, each maturing at different times. And Geshe will go into this. I don’t want to do too much of that here, but 12 limbs can mature at the minimum over two lives and at the maximum over three lives. There’s no other possibility.

They never mature over one life, and they never mature over more than three lives. But those two lives normally are separated by hundreds of thousands of years. It’s very rare for them to be subsequent. The three lives, each of the life is separated by a couple hundred, a couple thousand or more years. The very rare cases in which they are immediately subsequent is, let’s say, you take two lives to make it simple, when the deed accumulated is extraordinarily powerful.

Then it can mature immediately in the next life. Very powerful afflictions. If, let’s say, if it’s a crime or karmic misdeed that the recipient is very weak and has been hurt in a very bad fashion. There’s been great rejoicing in the mind of the perpetrator, then it is possible for this to mature immediately in the next life. So do you start to understand how the twelve limbs operate?

Ilya, are you saying that very bad deeds, negative karma deeds in this life will only mature in the next life? None of it happens in this life. Exceptionally, and that’s really the keyword here, it can, at the end of the life. But it’s certainly not this sort of rather naive Western understanding of karma where it operates within one life. If the deed is heavy, and there you have to study Lamrim Chenmo, it’s some of the most useful studies you can do.

Studies about emptiness are basically not useful for us. Because as lay people, almost no lay person has the time to study emptiness correctly, has the understanding, has the time to meditate. But studying karma is really useful because we can engage in what I used to call karmic engineering or karmic strategies. Then none of us is able to abstain completely from non virtuous deeds. But the key is to use strategies so that the non virtuous deeds we engage in are weak or weakened, and the virtuous deeds we engage in are strong or strengthened.

That we can do if we understand how karma operates. Then if we don’t understand how karma operates, it’s like throwing dice. But throwing loaded dice, loaded towards non virtuous deeds. Right? So the case, to answer your question, in which a deed would mature at the end of this life would be, for instance, if it was committed at the beginning of this life.

And it was a deed for instance, very heavy non virtuous deed towards one’s parents, let’s say, parricide or matricide, or towards one’s spiritual teacher, or towards people who have been extraordinarily kind to us. Then at the end of this life, there would be signs of the incipient maturation in the next life. That would not be the full maturation of the karmic deed. And there’s a debate which we won’t enter into whether karmic imprints mature over one or multiple lives. So that’s a debate we can ask Asaṇga and Vasubandhu.

It’s a major debate. But you would typically see, and I’ve seen many cases among people I know, for instance non virtuous deeds accumulated with respect to the spiritual teacher are particularly heavy because of the kindness of the teacher to us. The classic maturation is insanity, that I’ve seen many times. You know, people who disturb the mind of the teacher experience something which is similar in type to what they caused, and that is a dramatic disturbance of their own mind, which manifests typically as insanity at the end of their life. And in really a couple of cases I know, cancer.

And just for clarification, when you told the story about the slave and the first three limbs, if that consciousness is still in embryonic form, I couldn’t quite understand how the karma was accumulated as you stepped your way through the limbs. I don’t know, the slave accumulates a karma as an adult. Okay, so that’s from previous one. The slave, the example I gave was a slave accumulated the three first limbs two thousand years ago, stealing food from another slave who is hungry. And then, that karmic imprint, the second limb deposited in consciousness, that matures, let’s say, two thousand years later.

You understand? Eli, just the results similar to the cause in type. I’ve never quite understood the, you know what is the basis of the connection or the mode in terms of one being’s mind and another or the environment for that matter. You know being born in poverty, the actual interconnection. That’s a question you asked in Cittamātra.

So you are persistent in your inquiries. It’s very good. It’s very good. That’s a way to get places. Well, obviously, it depends on the school of tenets.

Right? So if you take the two lower schools of tenets, which are realistic, in other words, they consider that the exterior world exists independently of the mind perceiving it, then the explanations are a bit complicated to give. Right? If you take the two higher schools of tenets, Cittamātra and Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka for sure, which are non realistic in the sense that they consider that the exterior world and its perception depend on the mind perceiving it. They disagree regarding the mode of dependency and the mode of appearance.

Then the explanation is much easier to provide, and I think Geshe-la went a very long way towards that this morning, when he explained precisely how the maturation of a deed of murder would have to occur. You are curtailing the happiness of another person and inflicting great suffering. And that suffering which you inflict intentionally, intention is crucial here, is a suffering which you yourself would experience. And because of the similarity in type, there is a similarity between the modes of suffering. And if you look at Stevenson’s research, specifically if you take European cases of the reincarnation type, it’s very interesting.

There are a couple of cases which show this very clearly. So European cases of the reincarnation type Stevenson collated cases of recollection in European sources, which he had not necessarily investigated himself. And what is very interesting is one of the cases was a man who went, he was British I believe, but I have to check. It’s been a while since I looked at the case. To see a doctor for recurring migraine headaches, which are almost insupportable.

And, eventually, the doctor sent him to a psychiatrist who had him regressed, you know. Then, as I mentioned in my conferences on hypnotic regression and past life memories here, hypnotic regression is not very reliable as a source of information. But sometimes it is very interesting. So I’ll give you this case with all reserves. The psychiatrist found that the first memory he had was of being the assistant of an executioner whose job and again, this is interesting because he would not have known that, was to lift the hair of the victims who are at the point of being executed so that the axe could bite.

Right? So I did not know this myself, but hair basically interferes with decapitation, at least with the primitive means used in the middle ages. And he remembered being the assistant at the execution of a noblewoman, and lifting her very it must have been very beautiful blonde hair, and feeling great pity for her before the decapitation. Then the second memory was set in the early nineteenth century, and he remembered being a young train mechanic whose job was to inspect the steam engines at the period. And he put his hand inside the wheel, you know, wheels had spokes in those days, to inspect the underside of the train engine and felt a blinding pain.

The train which had been blocked slipped and his skull was crushed. Right? We assume because, obviously, he died instantaneously. All he remembers is the pain. Those are the two memories he had.

Now the case is interesting because of some features. First, unless you are a historian, highly specialized in medieval history, you would not know that hair had to I studied medieval history in considerable depth. I didn’t know that the hair had to be removed from the neck, you know. Then among the many fantasies you could construct, why would you construct the fantasy of being a train mechanic putting your head in the spokes of a train? Again, that’s a bit mysterious.

And you can see the similarity of type in the experiences. So we can assume, if the memories are true, that the memory of helping the executioner would have been the three first limbs of one cycle of 12 limbs. Right? Ignorance, there probably in this affliction, which is a continuous state of anger or hatred or maybe in the case of that boy, just cupidity, the need for money. Right?

And a non virtuous deed, participating in the killing of another human being. Right? So those would be the three first limbs, let’s say, in 1250. Right? And then you have a complete maturation in the nineteenth century.

So that complete maturation would occur in dependency on the life just before that as a young train mechanic. The life immediately preceding that, let us say he was born as a human being. At the time of death, he would generate craving, appropriation, and this would trigger this karmic imprint. And that would cause rebirth as a young man who would experience his death. Alternatively, you could say that the maturation occurred in the life in the twentieth century.

And that it was immediately before that, that you had craving appropriation, which gave rise to rebirth as a man who would suffer from migraine headaches. Both readings are possible. Karma is very complex. When you study, and we did that together here, cases such as those reported by Netherton, an American psychiatrist, of multiple memories of past lives, what you find is over these memories a repeating pattern. Life after life, this only covers remembered lives.

Life after life after life after life, there’s a leitmotif. So it seems that cycles of 12 limbs give rise to other cycles of 12 limbs. Right? Then you know your own lives, you know your weaknesses, you know. Then this comes from somewhere.

Right? So it’s important to analyze where it might come from, and then to try to inflect the behavior. Change completely for us is difficult. Inflect is the beginning. You inflect now long enough, you will have changed.

Alright? Then I said to all of you, I really encourage you to take up Stevenson’s work. Sit down with his two big volumes, Reincarnation and Biology. If you don’t have time, take European cases of the reincarnation type. You need to generate a strong conviction in the existence of your own past and future lives.

Step one. And then you have to understand how this works. When we speak of saṃsāra, this is it. Samsāra is not the table. Samsāra is my own cycle of past and future lives.

And to understand how it works, the best way is first to do a superficial reading of Tsongkhapa’s section on Karma. In Lamrim Chenmo, just don’t go to Experience Karma in general. What makes weighty deeds? What makes light deeds? And then you take the 12 limbs and you try to see in the cases where you have multiple lives how you could fit those experiences in the 12 limbs.

Then your understanding will become very deep. Then you have other questions. Can the maturation occur separately in two separate incidents, two separate lives? That’s a big question. Asaṇga says yes.

Vasubandhu says no. Then based on my very limited perusal of Stevenson, I think Asaṇga is right. But you see, you have to really analyze carefully what’s meant by maturation. So within the 12 limbs, we’re talking of impelling karma. Karma which impels a rebirth.

Right? So there was another case I gave you here. I’m sorry, we have problems with the projector, so I didn’t bring my computer for projecting because it just flickers. It was a case of Vijayaratne. Some of you, maybe Chris remembers.

Do you? The case of Vijayaratne? From okay. You don’t remember. Then the case of Vijayaratne is very interesting because you can see exactly how Karma operates.

Do you remember? His fiancee. Exactly. Yes. Yes.

But there was something before that, wasn’t there? I’ll cover it quickly for you. This is in Stevenson’s Reincarnation and Biology, I think volume one. Then Vijayaratne was a young Sri Lankan who was betrothed, and in Sri Lanka betrothed amounts to marriage, like in many traditional cultures. And his wife to be, rejected him. Then he was overwhelmed by anger.

This happened in his previous life, which was identified. And, he stabbed her, and then don’t ask me, I think it was the left it must have been the left breast. He was right handed. And she died as a result. He was hanged in 1928.

Then, just before death, he never regretted the murder, but he had Buddhist poojas performed. And he said to his brother he would return. And then, a couple years later, quite a while actually, it’s more like a decade or so, his brother’s wife gave birth to his child. And when the child was born, he had a striking resemblance to Vijayaratne and as a young child had memories of being Vijayaratne, recognized family members. Now what was striking was that the right part of his pectoral muscle had completely atrophied, was absent.

And the right hand was desiccated and atrophied. So he had clear memories of stabbing his betrothed because she refused to marry him out of jealousy. And at that point, he felt his behavior was fully justified, and he continued to feel that way into his early twenties. Now what is interesting is that he had memories of what happened between those two lives. He had first a memory of being hanged, and a memory of instantaneous blackness, and then fire.

And after that, he had a memory he could not describe, of feeling very, very light and fluttering from branch to branch. Those are the two memories he had. Now if we analyze, almost certainly because this was a deed committed in that life out of great hatred. His fiancee was innocent and powerless. He stabbed her repeatedly and let her die without going for any help.

And actually, murder was premeditated. When she rejected him, he went back to his home village to fetch a kris. I gather they use them in Malaya in Sri Lanka, sharpened it and returned to stabbing her. As a result, the deed was extremely heavy karmically, and he never regretted this deed until the time of his execution. And this would cause rebirth in a hell realm.

A deed of murder which is not regretted in which the person rejoices, you know, which has been premeditated causes a hell rebirth. And the memories immediately after death are those actually only of burning, only of fire. There’s nothing else, which might correspond to rebirth perhaps in the Avichi, and we cannot identify based on that. You know? Then it’s a short rebirth in the hell realms.

I forget the details of the case, but it’s less than twenty years. After that, there is a memory of rebirth as a bird. Now he cannot identify himself as a bird. All he remembers is being light, fluttering from branch to branch. That’s all he remembers.

But there are elements in the life later on which make it very clear. And then later on in that life as a human being, he suffered from repeated psychotic breakdowns. During these breakdowns, he was actually institutionalized. He would gather branches and twigs and make a nest, you know. Then, I don’t know how the psychiatrists interpreted that behavior.

Maybe Sri Lankan psychiatrists are more open than others. And he was completely unable to form a lasting relationship with a woman. So if we analyze in terms of the 12 limbs, during the first life you have the three limbs. Right? Ignorance, grasping at the self, very strong sense of self, which leads to great anger and hatred when rejected, which leads to a premeditated case of murder.

Murder with great violence, great savagery. Right? Then you have the karmic imprint is deposited in the mind, at the level of the second limb, and there is rejoicing in the deed, which amplifies the weight of the deed. There’s rejoicing and almost no opponent forces are applied. At the time of death, there’s immediate rebirth in the lower realms, in the hell realm, which would basically be, you have probably, at the time of the death, your three factors of maturation, the limb of craving, of appropriation, and of existence.

Craving would probably be more anger at the woman. Appropriation, intensification of anger and desire, then this triggers the karmic imprint of murder. Then if the rebirth is in the Avichi realm, you wouldn’t have any of the limbs such as name and form and so forth. The rebirth is one, it seems, in some sort of a mental abiding actually. So that would be one full cycle of 12 limbs.

Then there is nonetheless a rebirth as a bird after. Whether that is caused by the maturation of the murder or not, we do not know. No way to know. But it is clear that in the human life after that, the physical deformity is no longer due to impelling karma, but it is a karma of maturation due to the deeds of the previous life, because it is the arm which struck which is deformed, the right arm. And the right pectoral muscle is very striking, you know.

It’s what you strike with which was deformed. And then the instances of insanity, we cannot say for sure whether they are linked to the murder or not. So this is how you analyze. Then if you do this with Stevenson’s cases, and then when you apply this to your own life, your outlook on things will change. The difficulties we experience now, the seeds were sown in the past.

Then that we have no control over. But the future we have control over, especially if we understand how to proceed. Then it’s up to each one of us to do it or not to do it. It makes no difference to anyone else, frankly. If we do it, then we will improve life after life after life.

And for us, the next life for most of us in this room is around the corner. It’s not far away at all, you know. If we don’t, as I was saying, it’s like throwing dice and having loaded dice, right, you don’t know what’s gonna happen. We have time for one very short question if you have one. Listening to that story keeps me thinking back to Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand where we talk about the length of time that’s experienced in the hell realm.

And then also it brings up issues of like once you go into the lower realms, how hard it is to get back into a higher realm. It’s pretty difficult. And it’s not all marrying up in my mind. It’s good you investigate like that. Basically, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand gives a general picture.

In the case of Vijayaratne, my personal understanding of the case or my personal analysis is that it is the Poojas at the time of death which shortened the stay in the hell realm. Any type of religious activity implies, even though it’s not overt, a form of repentance. That’s my own understanding of the case. Then, I think a big obstacle for most westerners is our discomfort with the idea that the human rebirth is very difficult to attain. The human rebirth, if you look at the statistics, is a minor minority rebirth on this planet.

If you consider that insects are conscious, then we are just, you know, a couple grains of dust on Buddha’s fingernail. And within human rebirth, a rebirth with leisure and endowment is almost non existent. Let’s say in Adelaide, no one has it. In this room, you are a couple who probably have it. If you are here out of interest in the teachings.

If you’re here because you had nothing else to do on Saturday, then probably you don’t have it. Right? You don’t. What’s a rebirth of leisure and endowment? Right?

It’s not having two limbs, two arms and speaking. Right? We do understand that. So Vijayaratne, did Vijayaratne have a rebirth of leisure and endowment? Probably in his previous life, than in his present life, he seemed he certainly believed in karma.

Difficult to say in his case. What I would say is study Stevenson’s work and note the fact in his work that of Netherton and the others who’ve studied these cases, that there are huge gaps between the memories of human rebirth. You’re talking of gaps of thousands of years in some cases. And why doesn’t the person remember? In my opinion, simply because they were in a rebirth where there was limited or non existent mental capacity.

One of the Sri Lankans has a series of lives in which one he remembers being shot while running away in the grass, and another he remembers nothing except not being able to see side by side and being stung by flies. And that’s suggestive, isn’t it? They used horse drawn carts in Sri Lanka. But there’s no memory I was a horse because there’s no self identity as a horse. Alright?

So if you’re reborn as an ant or a grasshopper, then there’s no self identity at all. There’s a spark of consciousness, a subtle mind, but there’s no neurological substratum to enable any type of mental activity. Right? Then that can continue a very long time. The problem is once you have been reborn as an ant or a grasshopper, then how precisely do you get out?

You get out only if there are previous karmic imprints, which can lead to human rebirth, and they have to be triggered somehow. Now you understand the 12 limbs. You need to trigger these virtuous karmic imprints. If they’re not triggered, nothing happens. Then, Dharma is a representation of how things are, not how things should be.

So I often hear students saying, all of us have Buddha nature, therefore all of us will be enlightened. It’s very nice. It’s very theoretical. The reality is it’s very difficult. The moment you start analyzing what it takes to be enlightened, it’s easily said, right?

To be enlightened you need a human rebirth first. A Bodhisattva could hover around a fly, but if the fly does not have the karmic imprints for human rebirth, and even if they have them, if the Bodhisattva cannot create the circumstances for that to mature, it is not gonna happen. Buddhism is not Christianity with a benevolent God who basically fixes the cosmos so that things happen. There’s some things which are just not possible. That’s why this debate, about all sentient beings attaining full enlightenment is a big debate in the monasteries.

In general, yes. The moment you enter in the details, and there are major Buddhist scholars such as the Sammatiyas, who assert that all sentient beings will not attain enlightenment. There are three final vehicles, you know. Then think about it, but think about it in light of the 12 limbs. And then I think we have to stop here for today.

Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

Avici narme (Tib)
The lowest level of hell. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

To what extent is the first limb of dependent origination the cause of the second limb, and the second the cause of the third?

The first limb is initial, beginningless ignorance, the ignorance grasping at a self. It acts as the root of afflictions, which deposit the karmic imprints accumulated at the second limb, compositional factors, and these are placed in the third limb, consciousness. There is not an explicit causal relationship between the three; they are linked. The second limb cannot be called the cause of the consciousness in the third limb. That consciousness is the repository of the karmic imprint.

Scroll to Top