1 h 9 min · 3,134 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 69-minute teaching, His Holiness the Dalai Lama instructs on the Buddhist philosophical schools of tenets through the lens of emptiness. He begins by establishing that the understanding of emptiness is transformative across all three scopes of the Lamrim path, contrary to the common impression that it belongs only to advanced practitioners. He then walks through the precise logical analysis of the self: how the I appears to us as substantially existent, why it remains unfindable when sought within or outside the five aggregates, and how this unfindability reveals not non-existence but dependence on imputation. Using the example of a match striking a matchbox to produce flame, he illustrates how the imputed person arises only at the confluence of the basis of imputation (the aggregates), the imputers (sound and conceptuality), and the nominal designation itself. He concludes by establishing the fundamental distinction between the falsely existent inherently existing I and the validly existent merely imputed I. Pitched at serious practitioners studying Buddhist logic and philosophy who are ready for sustained analytical meditation on selflessness.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 150804_001 3.mp3
UUID: f2f3a432-2e65-437b-9e2c-21162a6c3524
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Tenets
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,131
Tuesday, 08/03/2015. Tenets will be taught by Geshe-la, translated by Herinder B. Excuse So Wall Lily is trying to fix the public address system. We will first generate the motivation and then meditate. Yeah.
Regarding ascertaining the various systems of tenets, the differentiation between the various systems of tenets is made in terms of the view. In this respect, Āryadeva says in the Four Hundred, even with little merit, nonetheless, generating doubt, cyclic existence, existence is torn to shreds. The meaning of this stance is that if one generates doubt leaning towards the factual regarding cyclic existence, it is generated. It is torn to shreds. This is extremely important.
His holiness, Dalai Lama, has said that just through mere repeated reflection on emptiness, the afflictions linked to this life. And this refers to specifically to focusing on the vanities of this life will be torn to shreds. Now in the context of the Lam Rim, the graduated stages of the path, emptiness is explained within the path of the being of the great scope, specifically within the explanations of calm abiding and of insight, and in particular of insight. It is not explained within the context of the paths of the being of the middling and the small scope, and this is probably something shared with all the Lamrims. This might lead to the mistaken impression that it can only be practiced at the level of the great scope and induce wrong indolence.
There is no definiteness regarding emptiness having to be to be generated within the context of the path of the being of the great scope. And this is very clear when we look at the five paths, the path of accumulation, of preparation, of vision or sight of seeing, of meditation and of no more learning. An understanding of emptiness must be generated at the level of the path of accumulation. It is not the case that to generate this realization of of this understanding of emptiness at the level of the path of accumulation, one must understand the qualities of the grounds and of the paths of the Bhumis and of the Margas. Actually, at the very least, it is possible to have generated an understanding of emptiness at the level of the path of the being of the small scope without having all of the realizations of a practitioner of the small scope.
Even though one lacks the realization of a the being of the small scope nonetheless, if one reflects repeatedly on emptiness and fuses this reflection with an examination of the great treatises, it is definitely possible to acquire understanding or even realization of emptiness. And for myself, this has been a big source of reflection. I have wondered if it is actually necessary to have any of the realizations of the being of the small scope to gain an understanding of emptiness. I am far from sure that this is necessary. Therefore, I am far from sure that it is necessary to have generated uncontrived renunciation, which is the gateway to paths to generate an understanding of emptiness.
In this case, the understanding of emptiness can accompany us through training in the paths of all the beings of the three scopes, a small, middling, and great scope.
Then, obviously, you see, to gain realizations of the path of the being of the small scope, one must have countered the vanities of this life. Then are we saying that if one has not countered the vanities of this life, it is impossible to gain any understanding of emptiness? In this case, we are wasting our time here. The overwhelming majority of those who would have generated an understanding of emptiness without having entered in the path of the being of the small scope would be beings of exceptionally sharp faculties, sharp acumen. There might occasionally be beings of duller acumen within that group.
So there are passages both in Je Tsongkhapa’s Three Principal Aspects of the Path and more importantly in Töngshe, one of his short praises, which refer to this explicitly. In this, Jetsün Rinpoche says, after engaging in the activities of hearing, thinking, and meditating, and gaining ascertainment, go into a hermitage and relinquish the troubles of this life. The troubles of this life refer to the vanities of this life. The meaning of this passage is that after engaging in the activities of hearing, thinking, and meditation on emptiness and gaining some type of experience of emptiness, one then withdraws from worldly affairs from the troubles of this life, which refers to the vanity of this life and as a result, one’s experience of emptiness blazes greatly, increases greatly in intensity. As this passage reads, engaging in these three activities of the conquerors of hearing, thinking, meditating.
The conquerors here refer to the fully enlightened beings or the state of full enlightenment. One then matures one’s continuum through meditation and turns away from the vanities which refer both to the vanities of this life and of future lives. At this point, one’s goal will have been accomplished. Exactly. Great hopes.
So this is the, thought of Je Tsongkhapa. There is no definiteness regarding the point where a realization of emptiness occurs. For some, it occurs when the, path of the being of the small scope has not even been generated within their mind stream. For others, the majority perhaps, it occurs when the path of the being of the small, the middling, and part of the path of the being of the great scope has been generated. Therefore, we should have great hopes that through studying emptiness, we will gain some experience.
As His Holiness the Dalai Lama mentioned during the teachings in the Blue Mountains, quoting Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, The establishment is followed by the truth on this basis, refuge. The meaning of this verse is the establishment refers to the two truths. This in turn gives rise to an understanding of truth which is here the four noble truths, and on this basis one generates a taking of refuge which cannot be relinquished, which cannot be counterverted. So as His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said, through repeated reflection, study, and habituation with emptiness, eventually the afflictions of this life will not even arise within our minds. And these are the coarsest afflictions focused on this life.
And this is in keeping with the passage of the 400 in which says, through mere doubt, existence is torn to shreds. This is a very profound statement. One should understand, however, that the various schools of tenets have various explanations of emptiness. The selflessness of persons within the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika would probably not qualify as an emptiness as we understand it. That would begin with these subtle selflessness of persons, persons being empty of being substantially existent autonomous entities.
How and then after this, obviously, we have the Cittamātra and Svatāntrika Mādhyamika presentations of emptiness. But the emptiness referred to here in these passages is the emptiness. So why is it the case that a realization or an ascertainment of emptiness leads to a dwindling of the afflictions? Because at this point, all phenomena appear to us as illusion like. They appear to us if you wish as a movie or a film.
When we’re watching a movie, we all know that a lot of nonsense is going on and how much of this has anything to do with reality is open to question. Likewise, once all phenomena appear as illusions, desire, lust naturally declines. And, therefore, we should try to rely on these instructions. His Holiness the Dalai Lama gave during the Blue Mountains teachings based on Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, in which Maitreya says, after relying on the foundation, train in the truth and eventually generate a refuge. Here, the foundation refers to the two truths.
The truths themselves refer to the four noble truths. And this in turn gives rise to what is known as an incontrovertible refuge, a refuge one cannot or will not relinquish. This is not something which will happen easily. It will not happen automatically. Such an understanding of emptiness calls for considerable effort over time.
Therefore, this will not happen easily on the basis just of these casual teachings we have here where you struggle to understand what is said. Instead, you must find time, and having found time, you should engage in retreats for one week, for ten days. And during this period, reflect carefully, deeply on what you have understood about emptiness. This is a critical point for the practice of deity yoga. Since there is no valid deity yoga without an elimination of ordinary appearances.
And since we ourselves are ordinary in our present state, how can we hope to eliminate ordinary appearances? Then all you can do is recite mantras by the hundreds of the thousands. Now when we refer to ascertaining emptiness in the context of the Prāsaṇgika view, on which basis are we ascertaining emptiness. It will be difficult to do this on the basis of exterior phenomena such as this building objects and so forth. Instead, it is on the basis of the I or person ourselves that this must be done.
So what precisely is this I? All of these schools of tenets, even the wrong ones assert the existence of an I, which is the I which meditates, which walks, which experiences, the I which we say is the accumulator of karma and the experience of the fruition of karma. We all know that this is the I referred to when I say my father, my mother, my children, and so forth. Now I will not explain the object of refutation. You will all become terribly confused, but let us just examine where this I is or what it’s related to.
Is it related to the outside world or to our continuum? Obviously, it’s not related to the outside world. So it has to be related to our continuum, contaminated aggregates. So definitely, it’s related to the basis of imputation, the aggregates. Whether it exists within the basis of imputation, the aggregates is a completely different question.
That is something we must examine.
Then let us examine in turn whether the self is within or is one of the five aggregates. The five aggregates are the aggregates of form, sensation, sensation, discrimination, compositional factors and consciousness. So let us first take the aggregate of form. Is the I the aggregate of form? Is the I a part of the aggregate of form?
Is it for instance my hand? Obviously not. And if we examine the remaining four aggregates, in other words, the aggregates of sensation, discrimination, compositional factors and consciousness, which from the standpoint of Buddhist systems of tenets are all consciousness, And we ask whether the I is any of these aggregates or within these, then let us take the second aggregate, the aggregate of sensation. Is the I the aggregate of sensation? Obviously not.
If it were to be, the aggregate of sensation would become something very strange indeed. Is the I any of the remaining three aggregates? Discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness — neither. So when we seek for this I within the five aggregates, for instance, within the form aggregate from our head to the soles of our feet and back up to our crown, it is unfindable. Such an ultimately findable I is unfindable within any of the five aggregates.
For that matter, when we search for it both within ourselves and on the outside, it is unfindable in both places. This is quite strange. It’s not an understanding which arises easily without considerable reflection. It is at this point that some students of dull acumen unable to find the I, say the I does not exist at all. And in this way, sink into the abyss of nihilism, denying the existence of the accumulator of karma and the experience of the fruition of karma.
It’s at this point that the fundamental distinction as far as the view is concerned must be clearly understood. When we seek and are unable to find this fantasized I, what we are seeking for and are unable to find is an I which exists from its own side, a truly existent I. The mere I, however, is not sought for and is not unfindable. The mere I is not nonexistent. So when this inherently existent I is sought for, it is unfindable within the aggregates.
It is non existent. However, the I exists. Then the question which arises is, it’s a different question. If it exists, what is its mode of existence? So what is its mode of existence?
Apart from being a mere nominal imputation out there on the aggregates, there is no I within the aggregates from their own side. This is its mode of existence. Understanding that the imputed phenomenon, the I, imputed by conception and sound on the basis of imputation, which which is the aggregates, is nonexistent within the aggregates, one will have an understanding of emptiness. Then at this point, considerable difficulties arise if we ask this I, what sort of phenomenon is it within the Buddhist analysis of phenomena? Is it a compounded phenomenon, an impermanent phenomenon?
If it is, then it must have causes and conditions. In this case, what can we posit as causes and conditions for this I? This becomes very difficult to do. In a naive non formal setting, we tend to believe that this I is merely the product of the spermatozoa of our father fertilizing the ovum of the mother. But this is a position which is extremely difficult to defend.
Because, clearly, if this I is a mere nominal imputation imputed by conception and sound on a basis of imputation, then how could it be something which arises from causes and conditions? For instance, when sound and conception impute, they do this on the basis of a discrimination which says, this is yellow, this is blue, this is black. Then clearly in this context, where is causality? So when we say arising from sound and conceptuality, this is what we mean. So here, it is a sign of a very good understanding if we can say this merely imputed I arises just from sound and conceptuality.
It arises from a mere nominal imputation. And it it is at this point that we can say the imputed phenomenon, the I, is not truly established because of being a dependent arising. And therefore, in the syllogism, the subject, I, or if you prefer the basis of imputation, the person, it follows that it is not truly established. In other words, it follows that it is not established from its own side because of being interdependent or because of being dependent origination, then dependent origination here has numerous meanings. In this context, the specific meaning is because it is a dependent origination arising from sound and conceptuality.
So here, the imputed phenomenon, the I or the person is imputed on the basis of imputation, which are the five aggregates by the imputers, which are sound and conceptuality. At this point, we can say that the I or the person arises at the intersection or the confluence of these three in the self same way as when you strike a match on the gritty surface, you strike matches upon. The match alone and the gritty surface alone cannot generate a a flame. It is only through striking the matches with contact that the flame arises. So in the same same way as if we have a match and a matchbox, the match alone cannot give rise to a flame and the matchbox alone cannot give rise to a flame.
It is a contact between the match and the matchbox which gives rise to a flame. Likewise, if we take the person, it is not the basis of imputation alone, which gives rise to the person, nor is it the imputers, conceptuality and sound, which give rise to the person, but the two together give rise to the person. So it is at this point that one can gain a better understanding of the king of reasons, the royal syllogism, which in a simplified form, reasons reads the subject, the basis of the subject, the imputed phenomenon, the person is not truly established because of being a dependent arising. There is little here which enables us to understand. So if we flesh this syllogism out, it would read as follows, the imputed phenomenon, the I or the person.
It follows that it is not found within the basis of imputation, the contaminated aggregates, because it is a dependent origination arising through sound and conceptuality. So we have completed the presentation of the foundation, the view in keeping with the outline in Jampal Sampel’s Tenets. And next week, we shall start the presentation of the two truths, which can best be understood in terms of the foundation, and this will lead us to a presentation of the result. We shall stop here for today. Since we have little time, I will only take two questions.
Short ones, please.
Because it is conceptuality which thinks this is form. This is yellow. This is blue. It is a function of conceptuality. Simply because it is the selflessness of persons which counters the view of the transitory composite, the innate grasping at a self, which is what gives rise to cyclic existence.
If we were for instance to meditate on the non ultimate establishment of the table in front of Geshe la, this would be of little benefit in eliminating the afflictions within our mind stream. And also another question? Because without sound, it would be very difficult for us to interact with phenomena. Conceptuality would be powerless. For this reason, it is sound and conceptuality which are the imputers.
So it’s a difficult question. Clearly, someone who is deaf would be unable, for instance, to study at. He would be unable to understand any of the teachings. Then Geshe la was asking me how the deaf study here, and I I mentioned the procedures, and I suggested that perhaps if we broaden the concept of sound to include sign, then, that would cover the deaf people very well because the deaf learn a meaning through signs, through pointing, through symbols. And as Geshe-la said, clearly, deaf people have an innate sense of self.
So for tonight, please discuss the following topic. We all understand that our self has a powerful relationship with the basis of imputation, the aggregates. What exactly is that relationship, and is the self present within the aggregates or not? We shall then start the discussions by twos as usual. Thank you.
Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.