Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-08-12 – KR (3).mp3
UUID: 219f1f12-bd8a-4ad5-8240-dff6c10c41b5
Teacher: —
Collection: TBI Symposium
Date: 2012-08-12
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 42m
Words: 12,409
Sorry. It’s on. Okay. Thank you. Okay thank you Chris.
Thank you. I will do my best to keep everybody entertained as I do know that on the last day of most conferences at least which I attend most people are gallivanting around the city where they’re usually visiting in some exotic location. Here I’ve got the onus duty of providing the last presentation so I will do my best to keep people amused. On that note before this completely disappears Sorry. Before and suddenly it just stopped.
I was about to give my presentation. Don’t if there’s a good omen or not. Yeah. That doesn’t work here. What have we got?
Choose an operating system. Uh-oh. Uh-oh. Let’s see if I can escape. For some reason it’s decided to reboot so you’ll just have to excuse me on that.
Just to give you some background I guess this is my bread and butter and when I was asked to provide a small presentation on the global financial crisis from a Buddhist perspective I actually struggled and the reason being nearly on the well it is true quite regularly on a yearly basis I’m asked to make some comments either on television or radio or in the news about my views on all this and usually I actually decline any invitations because most of the time when I hear people on the news they will usually say something that I completely disagree with and say they’re utter rubbish. So I prefer to say nothing than pretend as if I know something. So there’s been one occasion which was a few years ago where I provided a public lecture at the University of Adelaide and it was very well attended. We had a few 100, a couple 100 people and it was actually recorded on a podcast. The reason I mention this is because it’s one of the few times I actually made a prediction that actually materialized to be correct which was that going back some years ago things started to look rosy again.
Directly after 2008 the economies in Europe and also in The United States seemed as if they were recovering quite quickly and my prediction at the time was that they’ve got to be kidding themselves. Debt doesn’t disappear that quickly away. So that’s my claim to fame basically at the end of the day. It is a dismal science and maybe it was basically expected habitual for me to give a negative forecast given the fact that economics is a dismal science and I’m an economist. So that’s probably how he ended up with me getting it that right.
So with no further ado what I’ve decided to do is do something a little bit different to what maybe people would expect and just highlight a couple of interesting features that some of you may not know about the financial markets and how they actually operate. So what I’m going to have a look at from the current show and try to put a Buddhist perspective on this and I’m being very liberal here with a terminology that I think you’ve seen before so you have to excuse me. There’s a bit of tongue in cheek in this. We’re going to explore why money does not inherently exist but rather it’s a dependent arising and we’re also going to examine why debt actually is an illusory phenomenon. In fact believe it or not when I was putting this slide for together the longest time I spent on anything was this damn sentence and the reason being statement I couldn’t work out whether it should be phenomenon or phenomena because is debt plural or not?
And that really caught me up believe it or not. So settle for this. Have to excuse if my grammar is incorrect. If someone would like to correct me you’re more than welcome to but I’m hoping I got that right. We’re also going to have a look at the conditions that the current global financial crisis basically manifested from and also why wrong views lead to trouble ahead.
Okay, so what I want to first do is establish what money is and I think everybody could believe quite easily that before money exists as we know it today what we had was a barter system. So if you wanted to buy one cow you might have to trade 10 geese for it or 20 chickens, whatever the relationship would be. And the reason why money as we know it has come about is because there are more efficient ways to trade and the way we trade of course today is through what we call a medium of exchange. Something that basically we accept can be used as a way, as a medium to exchange one product or service for another. Is everyone happy with that?
Okay. So the question is what can be a suitable medium of exchange? So my first question here is whether gum trees serve that purpose. There’s loads of gum trees here in Australia. Can we use that if we pretend the Australian dollar completely disappeared from the face of this earth?
Can we just quickly switch to gum leaves? Gumtree leaves. No. What’s wrong with gumtree leaves as a medium of exchange? Well that’s right.
If I wanted to purchase a new computer how many gumtree leaves do you think I might need? I think a whole horde of them, right? Because I’d be going out in the forest and just piling them in. The problem is of course, as I think you can guess, is that there are too many gum tree leaves. The scarcity matter comes into play.
What about shells? A better. A bit better. Indeed so much so better that in ancient times they were actually the form of money. This picture I should have actually recorded where they actually came from.
This picture was taken from shells that were recovered from an ancient Chinese coastal site where they’re conch shells where they actually would be beaded together to form beads, rows of money basically. So the more you collected the more worth you would be but of course because they’re not as easy to find at least the ones that would be considered suitable as a medium of exchange they had some value to it. So yes, you can start off with shells as at least the first inkling of something you can use instead of basically the barter system to trade. What about large brocks, big boulders? Sorry?
Yeah, maybe if they have some precious metal in them it might have some value. Generally speaking do you think this will be suitable or not? Not Not very practical, right? Hoarding a boulder around with you. Well believe it or not in Micronesia they were very popular.
These are called Rai stones and they were a means of working out people’s wealth. The more Rai stones that you owned and of course they weren’t very portable, right, so you couldn’t put them in your purse or your wallet and go down to the shops to purchase one, the more valuable or more wealthy you would be. In fact, they usually were made in one island and shipped to the other. And if a sailor or two died or there was blood spilled on the rock because of some family dispute, the value of these race stones increased. So the more sort of flowery story you could give for the history for the stone the greater the value.
And of course in small communities you could probably keep a track record through just an oral tradition of who owned what. So it was sort of a way of actually keeping track of wealth because as long as everybody agreed that this stone was owned by Mr. And Mrs. Smith then everything was hunky dory. But today this is not something that’s really practical is it?
So the problem here that we have is portability. The fact is that you can’t very easily drag it around with you and find it on general basis to actually trade with. What about cigarettes? Yes they can work. Where do they work today?
That’s right in jail and also in detention centres, in internment camps during the Second World War they were very popular. The reason being they were rationed out on a regular basis so you had a constant but also fixed supply that every individual would take. Of course if you were a chain smoker you were basically very poverty stricken in these situations But if you could hold up from smoking, well then the world was your oyster. You would exchange one cigarette for, I don’t know, a bar of soap or some extra chocolate, whatever else was given. So basically cigarettes do work because they’re portable and there was a restriction on how much you could get within the confines of a jail prison encampment or detention encampment.
Obviously if you’re outside in the real world it’s a different matter. You can purchase as many cigarettes as you like and if the cigarettes worth more than how much you paid for it then again you’ve got what we call an arbitrage situation. You can become very wealthy so it doesn’t really exist. The most useful and popular method for a medium exchange is to utilize some form of precious metal either gold or silver. The first broad usage of coinage existed in the Lydia Empire, Lydia Empire which was in during the sixth seventh to seventh century BC.
So Lydia basically is what we would be termed today as being part of Turkey and Greece. Very ancient civilization and these are the first coins that we could actually we’ve actually discovered that was in broad usage. You’ve got basically a lion head here and a stamp of I’m not quite sure what on the other side. But they you actually see quite a lot of them. Roman coinage is so was so prolific that today if you go down to the CBD into one of the coin shops you can purchase a Roman coin for not too much much money maybe $50 $60 despite the fact of course these are more than a couple thousand years old.
The reason being they were mass produced. So Roman coins, coinage by far were probably the best example of an ancient medium exchange system that used principally gold and then silver. So the features of a good medium of exchange are that you need that medium exchange to have some form of scarcity so there’s not an over abundant supply. There’s no point using gum tree leaves because you can pick as many as you like and then of course you’ve got massive hyperinflation essentially. That’s what basically happens.
You need some form of portability so coins are very easy to maneuver around. Large race stones aren’t so they’re not really practical. And also acceptability. We must accept the fact that one person to another believes there is value in that in that medium of exchange. So when we’re using precious metal people around the world instantaneously agree that yes this is worth something.
People seem to home into gold and silver in particular. Okay so the next concept I want to talk about is something called coin debasement because it will lead on to something I’ll talk about shortly. So I’m going to give you an example of what coin debasement is through what’s referred to as a denarius which was one of the first silver made coins, Roman coins for that matter. Initially they were constructed in actually February. They weighed roughly 4.5 grams of pure silver.
However, as the Roman Empire experienced more and more problems they started wanting to find a way of how they actually still could pay for their soldiers and all the other issues that they were facing with in terms of infrastructure building roads etc etc that they needed to have some type of shortcut. So the easiest way to actually make money is not dig out more silver and produce the coins but basically cheat. So how do you do that? Well during the Claudian dynasty dynasty (so it’s between forty four BC and seventy AD) they reduced the actual weight of the coinage to four grams even though it had the same medium of exchange value. Nero himself reduced it by another 0.2 grams and by the third century AD it was roughly only consistent of 2% silver.
So it had moved basically from being nearly pure silver over a few hundred years to 2% silver. Now why would you do this? How easy is it to produce a 4.5 gram silver coin relative to a non precious metal coin that maybe just has 2% silver in it? Well it’s much easier isn’t it? So what is actually happening here as you actually de base as we call it de value the coinage?
That’s right. You’re basically being able to produce more you actually create inflation which makes the situation worse. But from the government perspective this is a good way of initially cheating the public ourselves in believing that the coin still has the same value. Because there’s a time delay between when you start adding less or start when you start taking less silver into the coin and people catching on to the idea. So this is one of the first examples of how hyperinflation actually can manifest itself through what we call coin debasement.
Nowadays of course we actually have banknotes and here’s a very nice banknote because one of from it’s a Bank of England have been producing banknotes that recognized within their sovereignty for probably one of the longest periods of time in modern era. The reason why I actually wanted to show you this is because if you read very closely under the Bank of England it actually has a little statement and I’ll read it out to you. I promise I promise to pay the bearer on demand the sum of £5 So my question is what is that £5 Technically speaking of course if you rock up to the bank today and say I want my £5 they’ll look at you very strangely either call the security guards to take you away or just sort of like sort of back off. They were talking about £5 of sterling silver. In fact technically speaking £1 when they were initially created was equivalent of $2.40 silver pennies.
So you could either ask for silver pennies or alternatively you could ask for the pounds in silver sterling. Of course the relationship in terms of value of a £5 note today and that of silver is very different. You’re better off with a silver than the British pound. But that term still exists because it is actually a very old traditional conventional way of actually producing the banknotes in The United Kingdom. The reason I’m mentioning this is because this is actually what we call a promissory note.
The banknote itself has no value unlike the coinage I showed you before. Even if it just had 2% silver it had some value by itself particularly the 4.5 grams of near pure silver. You could walk around even if you went to another country, another domain, another empire that did not accept Roman coinage. They would still take value in it because they were accepted as silver. So with promissory notes you’ve got a piece of paper.
The only way you can maintain that value is that you can swap it for something that has value. So we call this a commodity currency or commodity money because even though the bank note itself by itself has no value you can trade it in for something that does. It’s accepted by the bank as something that has value. The first promissory note that existed or that we’ve actually dug out, not me personally, is from the Song Dynasty. It’s referred to the Jiaozi and it dates back to roughly the tenth century and it’s a nice interesting picture.
You’ve got various different stamps here and then at the end at the bottom you’ve got a picture of a couple of laborers or merchants trading goods. So this is the first sort of example we have of a promissory note being used in circulation by a particular sovereign essentially. Now I come on to my first question. I haven’t got too many slides so I’m hoping that you ask as many questions you like otherwise we will be finishing quite early. Today what is the Australian dollar based on?
That’s a good answer. It’s not right but it’s a good answer and the reason being if we go back to 1975 we had something what was referred to as a gold standard otherwise known as a Bretton Woods system whereby the US dollar was pegged to a certain amount of gold and then every other currency was pegged to the US dollar. So you’re not far off but it’s not what either the US dollar or the Australian dollar is now related to. Yeah you’re getting much more closer to the truth. Anyone else before I give the answer away?
Sorry? Very good, very good. Yes, again you’re getting very close. So really the answer is nothing. So, it does not have intrinsic value.
A definition of what fiat money is is a currency where the money itself that’s traded, the medium of exchange has no intrinsic value. Basically has no value by itself. You can’t go to the bank with 5 Australian dollars presented and asked for something of real physical value. It’s just paper money. That’s what fiat money is.
So how do we have value from it? Well it comes back to what the last couple of gentlemen mentioned. It’s purely related to confidence. It’s purely contingent dependent upon how much we believe the value is. Nothing more nothing less.
So unlike before the Bretton Woods system where you could trace back the value of a US dollar to gold and that’s why the more gold you hoarded the more valuable your currency was. So those of you that like watching old James Bond movies might have seen the film Goldfinger I think it’s called and it’s related to someone wanting to break into Fort Knox. Nowadays when I talk to Fort Knox to my students people sort of just like look at me saying what are you on about? They wouldn’t have heard about it. But Fort Knox at one stage held significant proportion of all gold had been dug out of the earth and it actually held gold for other countries as well.
Many countries still hold a significant amount of gold. Switzerland for example I think even today still has about 10% of gold reserves in the world. But the relationship between gold and the currency has dissipated over time. The reason that occurred is because during the 1970s there was a couple of events that took place including the oil crisis but generally speaking the the Western countries were growing at a very fast rate. So much so that they could not dig out gold quick enough to print money related to it.
So if you can’t print money as quickly as you like, does anyone know what type of sort of impact you have on the economy? It’s actually called a monetary restriction. You’re actually restricting the supply of money which means people can’t trade as much as they like and that basically leads to problems with how the economy functions. So they decided to do away with gold. So what you’re left up with is something called fiat money.
Never existed before in human civilization until recently. Value by itself is nothing. It’s purely related on how much you believe there is value. So the definition of intrinsic value means that there is some value inherent value to the objects, good or service that you provide. A lot of us are working and so basically if you’re a service provider although you might not be able to produce anything physically people will still demand your service for something.
In return you would want something. So your service has value and that basically has intrinsic value. That’s how we define it. But the medium of exchange that we use today doesn’t. Today’s $5 Australian note has no intrinsic value.
You can eat it. You can’t eat it, Troy. It’s simply a piece of paper. You can’t trade it in for something of physical value. Its value is contingent on society’s confidence in accepting or agreeing it is a medium of exchange.
So keep that in mind. So the next thing that I said we’re going to look at is the history of debt. Today’s banking system is a product of the three major monotheistic religions With the exception of one case which I’ll talk to you about in a second. If we go back in time a thousand odd years ago, usury or reverts referred to in the Atlantic terms was forbidden. So does anyone know what usury technically is referring to?
That’s right. The idea of charging interest for giving somebody money was basically forbidden. You could not do it. You could take out a loan but it was wrong to charge interest. There’s actually quite a few and I’ll talk about that in a second.
It’s a very good point. Yes there are quite a few loans out there which do not charge interest absolutely. The loan was for a medium exchange and not for the underlying purpose so this is quite interesting. I won’t spend too long on it because you could really delve into a lot of depth philosophically as to what is actually being traded here. The concept of why usury was forbidden was that if you lend somebody money you’re actually lending them the medium of exchange.
How can a medium of exchange then demand a fee? What is rightful to charge maybe is to say well if I lend you money and you’re going to invest it in a business I should earn a portion of that money in your business. That’s effectively a share ownership. There’s nothing wrong with being a share owner, but as soon as you split the relationship between capital and entrepreneurship, you have a very strange mix and the reason being if to an entrepreneur, let’s say you want to start up a restaurant and you just need some capital for that and the capitalist comes down to you and says okay, well I’ll lend you the money to set up the restaurant, but in return I want a 5% interest on my loan to you, then that 5% interest is not related to how successful your business is. So I’m hoping people can understand there’s a split here between the entrepreneur who’s trying to make the money and how much the return should be for the loan or the capital.
So modern society, Western society actually merged the two together. We don’t have a problem with it. Lending is not an issue but for the initial monotheistic religions it was a significant problem. So earning a return on a medium of exchange was considered wrong. The exception was though with Judaism.
It did allow for Jews to lend and charge interest to Gentiles and since that date basically they’ve had a reputation as being money lenders. Now the reason behind that of course I guess that at that time the Jews did not think that the Gentiles we had to abided by a different rule. So there was no problem actually lending them with interest. Over time Christianity softened its stance because of the fact that it basically grew at a very fast pace particularly over Europe and there were economic pressures to actually find the way of actually getting hold of loans and unfortunately for the well unfortunately but basically the Christians at the same time although they needed the Jews to get hold of the money they also like killing them which is very bad for business. At the end of the day, you’re basically culling the means of actually getting hold of money.
So the relationship there was very tenuous to begin with and there was a papal decree believe and I haven’t done my research on this so I really need to check my facts. At one point in time which declared that it was a right to lend money to each other and at that point in time Christians would then start lending money and charge interest. The history of debt is quite interesting because the way we talk about debt today which is that of charging interest for a loan was considered actually quite alien if you go back in time even though today it’s considered second nature. So today strictly speaking only in the Islamic faith are you supposed to not engage or offer alone and this is referred to as Sharia law and it’s actually quite popular. If you go to any major neighboring country where Islam is the prevalent religion you actually find Sharia law in practice alongside Western banking systems.
So we talk about this in some of our courses that we offer at the university. For example, Indonesia and Malaysia have a Sharia compliant banking system where you can basically get a loan and you can deposit money but you don’t charge interest on it. Now before you all rush out and start converting to Islam, I just want to highlight the fact that just because you can get a loan without charging interest doesn’t mean that you’re not paying a fee. So it’s just basically it’s the interest is removed and replaced with another mechanism. Just so you have an idea of what those type of mechanisms can be, it can be in the form of a lease whereby let’s say you want to buy a house and this happens here in Australia.
Most major banks, Australian banks will offer you a loan without interest if you ask. It’s not very popular, advertised but it will be done for you if you claim that you are Muslim, you strictly follow these rules. Then basically what they will provide you is the principle and they will say okay we own the house, you rent it from us. After a certain number of years you own the house. Now the way the Australian banks deal with setting out what the rental charge is they obviously cheat as well.
They base it on the interest rate but technically speaking they are trying to repackage the model to make it sellable, marketable to Muslims. Most Muslims that I know of basically go with the Western banking system. In fact, there’s some research that’s been recently shown that the major users of the Malay, Sharia compliant, Islamic compliant banking system in Malaysia are actually the Chinese Malays that are based there. And the reason being they’ve worked out you can actually get better rates in the Islamic banking system than you can from the Western banking system. Who uses these products is not necessarily related to their religion at the end of the day.
So how do we create debt? It’s quite interesting and the way it basically functions today is and this is sort of a simplistic example is that you start off with $100 You walk into the bank and the bank takes that $100 from you as a deposit. It keeps 10% for itself as a reserve and the reason it does that is because if we have a lot of people putting a $100 into the bank or at the same time, well roughly at the same time, it’s very unlikely that you’re going to come back at the same time withdrawing. So you might come back and ask for your withdrawal but not everybody else will. So they’ll keep a little bit of money in reserve just so that when somebody does want their money back there’s enough in there to give it to you.
But the rest, the other $90 gets shipped out in the form of a loan. So you might come to the bank and say oh I need a loan and the bank manager say no problems we can actually loan you $90. Now whose $90 is that? That’s right. The person who deposited it, but it doesn’t look like it, right?
Because the person who’s deposited still thinks that the money isn’t there. So that person who’s actually just took out a $90 loan and they don’t usually do this as a bit of an exaggeration goes to another bank and deposits that money. That bank keeps $10 and the other $81 the other 90% is lent out to another person. Now this can continue on. This is actually referred to as a multiplier effect.
What effectively is happening is that banks or banks are actually creating money. They’re creating money from nothing. The reason they are able to do this is because the debt that’s being handed out is actually money from somebody else that not actually being utilized. This is a standard procedure that’s been going on for many, many different, many different years. Now how does the bank earn interest or earn money should I say?
Well the principle is actually very simple and it’s based on the interest that’s charged for the loans and those which is given to the depositors. So if you deposit money in your bank you’re going to want something in return. So that will be in the form of interest to the depositor. If you loan money then you’re going to want to return from that and the borrower, which might be yourself, actually has to pay interest. As long as the interest that the borrowers are paying is larger than the depositors the bank’s making money.
Very simple idea. Everybody sort of happy with that? With fiat currency creating debt is simple and does not require supply of the underlying commodity as with commodity currencies. The reason I’m pointing this out is that really the banks are free to actually create as much debt as they like and in fact governments can actually print as much money as they like with no restriction at all. If we go back to the gold standard you could only print money if you had enough gold in your bank vault.
That relationship doesn’t exist anymore. By charging an interest rate you change the demand for money and the supply indirectly through bank issuance of loans. So I’ll give you a very simple example. If I’m a banker and I charge very low interest rates are you more likely or less likely to seek a loan from me? More likely, right?
It’s more enticing. The value of your loan is less. The reason why it’s less is because you’re being charged less interest. So the lower the interest rate the less valuable your loan or money is. A country where there is little confidence in this in this state should have a high interest rate.
The reason being and I’m looking from a demand perspective here so I’m swapping it around a little bit is imagine if you’re thinking of investing in Afghanistan and you’ve heard the First National Bank of Afghanistan has just opened and it’s charging an interest rate and here in Australia we’ve got a 5% interest rate. I’m just making it up. What do you think the Afghanistan interest rate would be? Would it be higher or lower? It would have to be much higher, right?
Because if I’m going to deposit my money in Afghanistan, I really have to think that the regime is going to be stable and hang out for another few years, right? So the more risk that there is inherent in the state, the greater the incentive they must provide you to invest in them. That’s the general gist of how interest rates are sort of supposed to be set if they’re let to their natural habitat. They’re left alone. At the same time the lower the interest rate the cheaper it is for you to get a loan.
So now we’re moving on to the GFC and how what I’ve just talked about plays a role in all this. My question is what started the global financial crisis and I think what I’ll show you I’m hoping will be a little bit of a surprise. So anybody want to risk saying something silly? Yes. There’s a truth in that.
I actually cover a little bit of that. Yes, that’s true. There was one significant event at the end of day and you can trace it sort of back to it. I don’t think you would guess? Not to the banks but yes you could definitely say it was unethical behavior.
Sorry? You’re very good sir. That’s correct. Nineeleven. So you’re thinking what does 9/11 have to do with the GFC?
Well I do remember Iliad making a comment at the end of yesterday where he said sometimes do gooders can make a mockery and a mess of things in the future and basically the story of the GFC is very well that. People having good intentions that leading to repercussions in the future that aren’t so very healthy. So I’ll explain how that materializes It’s relating to the interest rate. That’s why I wanted to cover it a little bit. Alan Greenspan was the chairman of the Federal Reserve which basically in The United States controls money flow and when 9/11 occurred he was very worried that this would send, plummet The US into a recession.
In fact they closed down the stock market for a couple of days. There was a lot of talk about how they can rebuild confidence immediately because there was even discussion about how the US dollar would just completely collapse because at that time the mindset of people is that they really didn’t know what was going on. They really thought they were at war and so this really created a bit of a historical atmosphere within the country. Alan Greenspan decided probably the safest way to move the economy on is to encourage people to continue to produce, to continue to get up to business activities. Now if you want to encourage business activity based on what I’ve just talked about before, what do you think you’d want to do?
You’ll lower interest rates. The cheaper the interest rate the more likely you’re going to buy that car because now you can afford it because you’re paying pretty much nothing on the interest. You’re willing to actually open up another business in another state because the cost of facilitating that is through a very low interest rate. So business, construction, personal expenditure is encouraged with low interest rates. Interest rates did actually drop before 9/11 I should point out but basically in 2001 there was a dramatic drop in the effective rate that the federal funds were charging for money.
Dramatic drop. And at that low base a lot of unscrupulous people started making money. Now this topic is not about who are those people who basically were corrupt because there’s a whole line of them and it gets boring going through naming these people and who they are and what they did and it doesn’t really serve any purpose. Purpose. So rather I’m going to try to focus on something slightly different and that is basically how at the end of the day you can can try to do what you like and try to do the right thing and it still messes things up and this is basically a story of that.
So with low interest rates you are of course encouraging house loans and to a certain I’ll mention one because it is very dodgy. In The US they have a system whereby it’s quite complex actually. You have something called Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae and they actually are government sponsored institutions that provide money to banks to lend money to individuals for houses. Now the bank over here have people employed on commission and they’ve got very big smiles on their faces. I’m sorry about my drawings but these eyes aren’t really matching up either so sorry.
These people here are selling, they’re mortgage agents. They’re selling loans to people who really can’t afford the interest or they won’t be able to afford the interest in their future on the loans. At the moment they’re very low. It looks like they can. And these mortgage agents get paid on commission.
So the more they sell of these loans the happier they are because they get their commission and the bank doesn’t care. Why doesn’t the bank care? They’re getting money from the government and I won’t go into this because it gets very complex unfortunately but they actually securitize these loans and ship it off to New York to the investment bankers who then sell it around the world to places like Iceland who have got no clue what they’re purchasing. But basically what you’ve got are people running around selling loans to everybody and you actually had one loan which was called a ninja loan. And I keep on forgetting ninja.
I’m not even spelling it right. That’s right. No income and no job or assets and assets. Ninjas. So basically people were getting loans.
They didn’t have a job. They didn’t have any form of wealth or income. Yet they were still offered these loans. Now to a certain extent yes these people can’t be blamed for taking out these loans but later on I do have something to say about people who do go into debt but I’m excusing these. There are a lot of ignorance out there unfortunately.
People are uneducated that were caught up on all this. So with low interest rates the banks went crazy in getting these mortgage agents out there to issue as many loans as they like. They weren’t worried about the risk because they had securitized and passed on the risk to the investment banking industry in New York. So they were actually excusing themselves from the risk that they actually initially would have to deal with. So this relates to quantitative easing.
The reason I’ll talk a little bit about this because it relates to my discussion about fiat money and also surprises most people as well. Have you all heard the term quantitative easing? Because it’s come up in news before. You’ll hear that the US government and this happened recently last few years still hasn’t got the economy spurred on enough so it’s going to create monetary allowance of $500,000,000,000 of quantitative easing. It’s not an illness.
It’s actually an economic turn that explains how do you actually produce money in the economy. Now the more money you produce in the economy it does try to spur on business activity and I’ll explain how that works because it’s very interesting at least I think how it functions. So first of all you start off with the Department of Treasury. We’ve got a Treasury here as well in Australia and they’re the ones that offer government bonds. They’re called Treasury bills or T bills for short in The US and they’re going to issue them with very low interest rates.
So much lower that about a quarter of percent to a half a percent in The US. We all know that The US is highly in debt, right? Truly I don’t know what value is. It keeps on changing but it’s a lot of money. Who is going to buy these Treasury bills which is basically an IOU?
Well initially it was the Chinese. Now they’re pretty peed because of course the quantitative easing that I’ll talk about devalues US dollars. They’re not really buying it in bulk anymore. Definitely not. With such low interest rates what’s the value?
Why would you actually get an IOU from the US government which you’re not guaranteed you’re going to get back or very likely you will though but you’re only going to get a half percent interest? The Federal Reserve, that’s right sir. So the institution that’s purchasing these Treasury bills is the actual Federal Reserve. The reserve that are responsible for printing money. So how does the Federal Reserve which is also part of the US government afford it?
It prints money. I don’t know if it’s just myself but this is quite absurd. So you have one government institution selling bonds but they know Norm’s going to buy it because the interest rate is so low. Doesn’t matter. They’re not planning on anyone else buying it other than themselves.
They buy it and how do they afford it? Well because they don’t have any money. They’re cash strapped. They print money. So you can do this because with fiat money as I’ve mentioned before the dollar is not pegged, not related to any particular physical asset.
So you can print as much as you like. My next question though is why do you go through this process? Defeat a banking system. So basically who’s got all these extra dollars now? The Treasury.
What does it do with it? It gives it to the banks. The Treasury walks to the bank and says here’s a stack of cash. I want some return on it, but other than that do what you like. Now here’s the crux of all of this.
The purpose of quantitative easing is to encourage the banks to lend. How do you encourage them to lend? Well, if their return on some safe asset like Treasury bills is so low and I’ll go back here just to highlight this. Remember they make money from charging interest, right? If the interest they can get from safe assets is very low and they’ve got all this cash and they have to do something with it they will start lending to the public.
They will start giving money to businesses. They will start giving money to individuals. The money they’re handing out though, is it real or not? Worse than that. It’s been fabricated.
So as the money gets flooded into the economy who is losing out? Anyone that has a US dollar is losing. I’ll give you another example and this comes from a very famous case of how an economist called Milton Friedman explained that changing the money supply doesn’t really lead to any economic differences. If we all had a thousand dollar bills in our a thousand dollars in our wallets and purses today and then a helicopter came round and dropped a million dollars all of us and we’re a society with just us, TBI. Would we be any richer in real terms?
No. As long as there’s not one body hogging all the money. We split up the money individually. We’ve just basically got more dollar bills. So effectively what’s happening here though is something even worse.
You start off with your thousand dollars but someone comes along and starts dumping extra money devaluing your own your thousand dollars. So those that held the value before just like with a coin debasement those that actually had silver coins that were a 4.5 grams of pure silver are losing out because there’s a medium of exchange it was still considered identical not really but considered identical to that basically that had only 2% silver. At the end of the day you’ve got a situation where you’re debasing the value of your own currency so that everybody, the taxpayers that are out there are actually losing out. So the story for the GFC in The US was based around the events that occurred at 9/11 where Alan Greenspan decided to drop the interest rate to encourage growth in the economy because they were worried about a recession when in fact they probably didn’t need to be. It’s easy in hindsight to see they were mistakes.
But it led to a growth of debt and that debt basically got worse and the way the US government has tried to solve it is by printing money and that necessarily hasn’t basically solved the real problems economy. In the Europe it’s slightly different. In the EU it’s slightly different. Historically northern continental countries particularly Germany have low interest rates and a lot of this is related to social economic conditions. I found Ilya’s course in Tibetan quite interesting because you can you can definitely trace language having an impact on culture.
One good example of course is the the word for guilt or not guilt should I say the word for debt in in German which is Schuld which means guilt. So embedded in the culture particularly in Germanic to a lesser extent in Anglo Saxon countries debt is not considered necessarily good. It’s perceived as being relatively negative. I can’t speak for all other type of cultures but definitely you’ll see in German speaking countries if you’re in debt you’re not really looked upon very well. Whereas in Australia of course which has one of the very highest private debt ratios in the world, in fact it might even be higher than The US, having a credit card is the way to go.
In fact if you don’t have a credit card, you’re just plain weird. There’s something wrong with you. So there is a definite difference in how people perceive debt and its usage. For political reasons, the German banks were encouraged to lend to southern continental countries that historically had very high interest rates. So Greece, Spain, Portugal very high interest rates throughout its history and the reason why the German banks lent to these countries at low interest rates is because the EU stepped in and said look we’re all part of the EU now.
We all have the same risk. The German banks didn’t really believe it saying you’ve to kidding me. But the EU said look if something goes wrong we’ll sort you out. Don’t worry about it. Nothing’s really going to happen anyway.
So the banks said okay fine and I point this out because you hear a lot of newspaper articles particularly from the Greek perspective which will argue well the Greeks were given all this money by the Germans and really you know the Germans should have not lent to us. Well it’s a bit of a cop out at the end of the day. The fact is that the German banks didn’t initially want to lend. They got into the act eventually and were quite happy at the end to lend but initially they weren’t and the reason being the risk profiles were very different. The risk of actually lending to a Greek business were quite significantly greater than that of a German business and there’s reasons for that as well.
So this led to a mass increase in private and public debt in these countries which of course nowadays they’re now having to pay back and find that they can’t. So historically the GFC, the Global Financial Crisis has a different base in the EU. It was due to the fact that the European Union wanted to encourage a feeling that the EU was one entity and that risk whether it came from a business down in the tip of Spain by the Rock Of Gibraltar or right up in the Northern Hemisphere was basically the same when it really was not. So this leads to me for the last couple of slides. Who is to blame for the global financial crisis?
If you speak to different people they’ll give you different answers so I’m just going to give you my humble opinion and that is that everyone is to blame and the reason being that the governments are definitely not without fault because they’ve basically allowed money to not reflect its true value. The way we reflect value in in money is through maintaining an interest rate that is relatively free to move and definitely in the case of Europe now and also in The US it was so dramatically manipulated that you created a situation where there was far more demand for borrowing than they should really have been. Secondly, so that basically led to fiat debasement and a misleading interest rate setting. Banks for encouraging debt culture and the corporations for encouraging Really basically if you look at it every single company and this is what companies are there for really is to sell their goods and services. No one’s going to you know you’re not going to walk up to a travel agent and travel agent says well look I don’t really know if you can afford this trip to The Bahamas this year.
Hold it out for another time. So basically every single firm is sort of responsible to some extent and the same with the banks because they did encourage the idea that debt is nothing wrong. And finally individuals because with the exception of unfortunately those that were tapped on the shoulder for ninja loans really at the end of the day people have to take responsibility for for their own actions and most of us particularly in Western society have a good standard of education. So much that we could at least work out that well if I’m going to take out a loan I know I’m going to have to pay back that and it’s going to have some interest attached to it. There are many cases where people say I didn’t realize I was going to have to pay 25% on my on my credit card but really it’s actually not that hidden.
It is made relatively public and people know it from other people’s experiences as well. So you have to take responsibility for your own actions. At least that’s my take on it. So I’m not excusing of course the mortgage lenders that gave out loans to people who couldn’t afford it such as the ninjas and those who really did not know how loans functioned. But everybody else I think is complicit really at the end of the day.
So I’ve got a very I guess morbid sort of cartoon at the end in terms of working out well who’s going to pay for all this debt and I apologize that I have to finish on this note. If I’d I’d given it some more thought and I realising this is going be the last presentation for today, I would try to end up on a high note. I have to excuse myself from that. So basically the people who are going to be paying for this debt are going to be our grandchildren. So we’ve got a little caption here of an EU Commissioner and a US Commissioner.
Behind them you’ve got the banks and the stock markets crumbling and reading out the public debt statement. We thank our grandchildren without whom these rescue plans would not have been possible and basically we call this an intergenerational wealth transfer which is quite common practice in economics and there’s actually nothing wrong with it believe it or not under certain conditions. So the last thing I’m going to say is that there is nothing wrong with debt as long as you can show that what you do with a debt is going to lead to a productive outcome. Furthermore that your economy will grow at least faster than the interest you’re going to be charged on the debt. There’s particular rules and the paradoxes in fact that lead to some very strange outcomes given certain conditions that I won’t go into but the basic premise is as long as your economy is strong and your growth rate is relatively decent then taking out debt is nothing wrong as long as you use it for good productive outcomes.
But unfortunately what’s happened particularly over the last decade or so that people, private individuals and public institutions basically taken out debt at very cheap rates for trivial matters and we’re left with a very high debt burden. Not in this country and it’s not because we’re smart although the politicians like saying this whether you’re a Liberal or Labor supporter it’s immaterial at the end of the day. We’re just very fortunate. True indeed. We are a lucky country.
We’re not a smart country. If we were smart we’d actually be doing something valuable with the resources that are dug out and then shipped to China. Instead, what’s happening is that we’re making some people who are quite obese really, very rich at the same time not basically looking at what we can do with it as a sovereign fund that some clever countries like in Scandinavia are in fact. So the reason why we are not in debt is simply because there’s a great demand in China for our resources and that’s simply it. We’d be stuffed as every other country if it weren’t for that.
That’s basically my little talk on the GFC. Hopefully you found some of it insightful and if you have any questions please go ahead and ask me. The plasma TV grant. Yes. So there is rationale in giving out a hoard of cash very quickly.
It does make sense. Ken Henry who was the treasurer in Australia up until recently is actually a very clever person. There was logic behind it. The reason being that the Rudd government at the time was very afraid that the whole world economy was going to go into meltdown. I have some friends who work in New York and it is true they were all scared this was going to be the end of the financial system that we know it.
And what does it mean the end of the financial system? It doesn’t mean you haven’t got a job at the end of the day when you go into work the next day. What it basically implies is that the medium of exchange around the world is no longer accepted Because once banks stop lending to each other they’re not willing to lend or take even deposits from others. The whole system just collapses. You actually have a medium exchange that people no longer accept.
The fiat currency which relates which has its reliability and confidence completely evaporates dissolves. So that’s what people were scared of. So the idea was quickly get people to spend money. It doesn’t matter on what because people are going out there spending money on whatever they’re keeping others in jobs. That was the idea.
Of course you can look back and say it wasn’t really necessary. The $1,000 grants that were given out to pretty much everybody was a waste of money. True, in hindsight the Australian economy didn’t really need that quick. An adrenaline injection to keep it going. Because at the end of the day you could say well by purchasing plasmas is just helping the Chinese economy at the end of the day and it’s not leading to a long term value proposition.
But you can’t tell that at that time. It wasn’t done so much for that. In terms of confidence out of interest for example Australia never actually offered bank insurance. So when you deposit money in a bank, although now they still do, the government will guarantee you a certain amount of that money if the bank goes bankrupt. Now The US has always had bank insurance up to I think a 100,000 US dollars and suddenly when there’s less confidence in the world’s currency systems what you found is that a lot of the European countries started also offering bank insurance.
One country that didn’t was Australia. There was suddenly a mass pull out of Australian dollars into the Euros into the US dollars even though they were perceived to be more risky than the Australian dollar because they were afraid that our banks may actually just simply go bankrupt. So the Rudd government actually stepped in and said okay we’re going to offer bank insurance. That’s a form of confidence that you want to place in. That’s sort of the thing that they would do.
Yes, it’s real money. Interestingly, the Chinese are in a bit of a pickle because they have over a trillion dollars of US dollars of treasury bills or government bonds and as The US prints more money their personal wealth declines. To make matters worth and The US is quite clever on this they’ve realised that they can still issue Treasury bills and to a certain extent the Chinese are forced to purchase them. Why? Not because it becomes dilute.
If The US Government were to provide an issuance of Treasury bills and the whole supply of those Treasury bills were not purchased it would lead to a massive drop in confidence of the US dollar and it would devalue the depreciate the US dollar. So to avoid that happening the Chinese are to a certain extent forced to ensure that every time the US government sells T bills it completes its full issuance of sales. Yes. That’s a good question, and I think I’d actually relate it back to I think at the end of the day and it’s very hard to actually execute this but it relates to what you talked about before and that is intention and motivation. Can’t have a system functioning where you have too much self interest at heart without rules and regulations or basic ethical doctrines in place to circumvent people taking advantage.
So I don’t really know if you can actually have and there are actually papers out there that talk about a Buddhist system of a Buddhist economic system and it’s sort of partly related to socialism and also the idea that you don’t simply grow for the sake of it. I don’t think it will work and the reason it won’t work is because there’s always an incentive for someone to take advantage of that. So the best you can do is come to an agreement of what we would consider to be a fair play. And this is how stock markets work. Many people don’t realise this but the stock markets and even the derivatives that are blamed for the collapse of the GFC that were traded in the stock markets are not to blame.
The reason being they are so well regulated, particularly in The US, it’s very hard to do something that’s corrupt believe it or not. The derivatives that led to the collapse of the GFC that I have not talked about are called swaps. They’re referred to as OTCs or over the counter. They’re traded not in a regulated environment and the reason I put that out there is because there’s been hundreds of years of development of the stock market. People have roughly got it sort of right of how people need to trade.
If you trade in the stock market, it’s very hard to go wrong in creating what we call a fair deal. A fair deal doesn’t mean that someone doesn’t lose or win but the exchange was done in the most transparent manner possible with both parties having roughly the same type of information. We call that an efficient market. So it’s a level playing field and that’s the best we can hope for. Well Cade’s pointed out very pointedly that we’re all dead in the long run, which is very true.
So by convention, it’s still what I showed you was actually a recent £5 note. So all pounds in sterling that are issued in Britain have that bearers demand term. But no, you can’t do anything with it because you’d prefer definitely the sterling silver than the £5 note. So every time it’s a very interesting case. China recently wants to move away from the US dollar as the world currency.
What it fails to realize is that in order to have a world currency, the currency must be actually held in various number of different countries. So the renminbi, the Chinese currency is basically pretty much contained within China. That’s not the case with the US dollar. The reason being it loves debt. The government loves debt.
The money that’s owed is from the treasury bills to have to be paid by the US government in US dollars. And they were they the treasury bills were issued for US dollars. So what you end up is a situation whereby China and many other countries around the world are inherently linked to the US dollar because they’ve taken debt out in that form. The US dollar, the US treasury bill is in the form of US debt. So it’s very hard to move away from the US dollar as being the world currency when everybody by and large is owed US dollars.
If you think about it, there’s pretty much not a single country in the world which don’t hold bills, US treasury bills, And because of that, they all have a stake in ensuring that the US dollar is maintained, particularly China. So they give mixed signals out. At one stage they will say, oh well, we want to move from the US dollar. At the same time, they’re trying to actually shift their US dollar treasury bills to somebody else. So it’s sort of they’re playing a game, basically, at the end of the day.
No. No. Because I don’t believe that in the present state of neurobiology, we fully understand what consciousness is even within the materialist paradigm, which is dominant in neurobiology. And therefore, Well, Australia is lucky. It has basically no debt despite the fact that both the Liberal and Labour parties make a big deal about debt and whether we’re going to pay it off next year or not.
There’s nothing there. It’s nothing. It’s trivial. Australia is very well placed. As long as it can ensure it has something else to rely on other than digging out stuff from the ground, which might be a problem here, then it has a rosy future actually.
That’s not the same unfortunately in The US and in Europe. I’ll one give example and it’s very unfortunate how things are playing out. General Motors offer very generous pension plans for their employees. So much so that it used to be the case that you only had to work for twenty five or twenty years and you’re guaranteed to retire early for the rest of your life. And the unions and the the corporation got together, and the corporation said we can’t afford this anymore.
The unions weren’t happy with this. And so what they decided was that, okay. We’ll put this discussion off for another ten years. And after that, we’ll come to an arrangement whereby we’ll actually stop offering these very nice, generous tools for pensioners. Now what you’re doing is delaying a very tough decision that you have to make, which is the fact that you’ve actually got a billion Chinese, which aren’t offered these very generous circumstances, working probably harder in terms of production.
And unless there’s a definite mindset change, you’re not going to have very fruitful outcomes from that. Another example is in Greece. They have 20 different professions which are considered to be risky, and therefore the state will pay for your pension for the rest of your life after serving twenty years. Guess what those type of professions are? Think it’s something that really would involve risk to your life.
One of them is a hairdresser. The idea is that you’re exposed for twenty years to the chemicals spraying hair so much so that you need no reprieve from that. Another one is a news anchor reader because the microphone supposedly contains lots of germs so you might get more illness from that. I think what I’m pointing out here is that you’ve got European institutions and American institutions which are offering too good a deal to their employees particularly relative to what the Asians are getting. And that needs to change.
Yes. A term for an aspect of consciousness at least. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Can I just start off by clarifying what I was intending to convey? And that’s that I mean, there’s a lot of different attributes of of mind and, know, obviously, there’s deep study of that in Buddhism, but in Western traditions there are certainly different kinds of levels of information processing which are characterized and which have been studied. But in terms of conscious awareness which is to say the contents of mind which we can readily give an account of, then it seems as if there is typically speaking, most wealthy people exhibit a certain limitation on the content there and that it is variable. Different people have different elements of work space.
Mindfulness has been demonstrated to be able to increase it somewhat but within limits. Now there’s a lot of other aspects of mind which are not within that work space. There’s all kinds of other kinds of processing in Western psychology that would get acknowledged as outside that. But the particular target in this case is the fact that when people ruminate ruminate a lot with this process of sub vocal speech which is this string of talk which we fill our minds with a lot of the time, that can come to occupy this relatively limited aspect of consciousness. And so that then if we’re able to influence the content of that part of the workspace ourselves and we can leave less space.
But that doesn’t mean that that is intended to be conveying a sense that that is the whole of mind or the whole of consciousness. It’s a particular information processing register, but one that seems to be quite powerful in its potential effects on the rest of the mind and the organism because if we fill it with constant negative ruminations then it has effect on mood and that in turn predisposes to the rest. I was just clarifying what I was conveying. The workspace model of consciousness of which As far as coarse consciousnesses are concerned, it is a model which I think Buddhists can accept since coarse levels of consciousnesses, the main minds that we talked yesterday and the mental factors are limited in their capacities. However, as we move downwards into more subtle levels of consciousness, and these are mainly explained in the tantras, then the capacities of the mind expand dramatically in a way which is not recognized in western psychology or neurobiology.
The closest evidence we have of this is once again the accounts of mental functioning of people who have had valid near death experiences. They describe greatly accelerated mentation, high senses of joy, and phenomena which are not recognized in western psychology, visions, paranormal capacities, telepathy, and so forth. These don’t manifest at the level of the coarse levels of consciousness. Does that answer your question? And I think to come complement that even within the Western psychology, what is definitely recognized is that there are kinds of information processing tasks for which that attentional workspace that we are not talking about is not well suited and that there are kinds of information processing tasks, things like pattern recognition and the like, that actually you will often do better to suppress that and actually seek to not invite the processing into that space.
It’s better off done in preconscious levels processing that are outside of conscious awareness so where in our experience the answer pop up. We can actually learn that ourselves. A lot of us would adopt that kind of thing. A lot of us would know that if we’re trying to retrieve someone’s name that we’ve forgotten or an address, we bring our attention onto other things and we allow another part of the mind to do it. Or if we’re trying to well there might be things that involve kind of, you know, things that involve a sort of solution to a problem that has quite a lot of different elements, which is very nonlinear, we may come to realize that, you know, we may sleep on it, we may choose to divert ourselves from something, but, you know, into somewhat something else that occupies that space so that we can allow other parts of the mind to process.
So I think while not at the level necessarily while not at the level of the subtlety that Buddhism explores, there’s definitely an acknowledgement that in in Western Western Western psychology that there’s other forms of information processing that are better accomplished out of conscious mind or a popular for a reasonably accessible introduction introduction to that, do better than Thinking Fast and Slow by going back to it. Anyway, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
So it’s a so they’re really I I I spent a lot of time with this actually with with psychiatry registrars trying to get them to work on the kind of inner game. There are some things that are best best thought out by thinking and there are some other things that are best that are best done by not thinking. There’s kinds of things and things like empathic recognition and the like. You actually don’t wanna be thinking about how this person in front of you is. You you you want to be immersing yourself in the experience of being with them but you’re not really thinking about it.
That’s not going to happen. So I think that there’s a lot of that I think that you want to that there’s very helpful skills that we can gain that’s about knowing just how to deploy those different parts of our mind and how to pace I think that’s the best answer we can provide. The economists on the panel The only thing I’d added about points already raised before, which is that, you know, I think as long as you point out what the pros and cons are and and being as transparent as possible, you know, the choice at the end is not yours. It’s theirs. If you try to push something, But things are being tightened and there are rules of what you can do during a discussion.
You can’t palm off alone anymore. It’s pretty strict what you can and can’t say. So I’d I’d say the choice at the end of the day is the other person as long as you’re not trying to sell them something that you know they can’t pay back, really. Be sure you can look at yourself in the mirror. Mean, I’ve been closely I’ve been closely involved with this with banking, obviously.
I’ve been should be concerned if it’s going to be selling all of this all of these minerals to China and elsewhere. But we are affecting future generations who are losing that. Interestingly, since I’m working in the area of land rights, of course, government seeks to tell aboriginal people how they should be using money, that you should be concerned about intergenerational equity, then you say a 1% royalty in relation to this. And after the twenty years is over, then the future generations are not gonna benefit from this mine anymore, and they should be concerned about it. Now, of course, you don’t necessarily persuade people.
They’re going to say, well, stuff that. I’m gonna be around for another ten years. If that, I don’t care what happens to my children. They can jolly well look after themselves. Well, that’s what we’re doing.
And that’s you know, in maybe in your case, you’re they need people at my age that have children who are going to be complaining about it. I mean, I’m that’s fascinating. And I It’s not an area that we’ve specific we haven’t specifically worked in. And some of that is really because of who funds us. We’re funded by by kind of public mental health services at the adult side.
There’s another center that works in developmental and childhood side. That’s really a constraint. Also the mindfulness based cognitive therapy is that would that would be need quite a lot of adaptation in children because it’s quite a it’s a very intensive course. But there are a lot of meditation. Of course, there’s there’s a lot of cultures where the meditation in childhood is very common.
There’s there’s quite a lot of evidence of effects on academic performance and effects on emotional intelligence and the like. There I mean, there are studies regarding the effect of prayer on healing. They are hugely controversial because one is never quite sure who is behind the studies. In America, it tends to be evangelical or Baptist organizations which have a clear vested interest. There is some evidence of efficacy of care in healing patients who are unaware that they are being prayed for, but it is not very strong if you look at the sum total of the data.
And all I can say is from a strict close, and one can see a model of efficacy. Then to analyze this in terms of quantum mechanics is complicated because I just proposed a tentative model. How far it extends, we don’t know. It is clear that once the mind is fully trained, so I think none of us in this room at that level, once one has attained at least shamantha, one is dealing with a very different level of reality. One of my teachers had shamantha and she instructed So all I can say is that at that level, I think we are in a field which western science does not understand That would be a part of it, but a very small part of it.
I think there is an issue Thanks very much for the loan of that too. Graham. Okay. Thank you. Graham.
Key terms in this teaching
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.