Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-06-16 – KR.mp3
UUID: 8af3cf23-1654-4e68-b43a-2fca84a632a7
Teacher: —
Collection: Lam Rim
Date: 2012-06-16
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 34m
Words: 11,791
I hope you had a relaxing tea break. There’s a lot of food for thought here. And we will now go to the second part of this conference. As you have seen the case of James Leininger is by all accounts a strong case. Stephenson’s research was often criticized by colleagues who said that most of his data came from countries in which traditionally people believed in reincarnation.
Stevenson himself addressed this criticism by focusing on Western cases. And I have chosen to present today three Western cases to show you just how strong some of these cases can be. We will now be addressing an aspect of Stevenson’s research, cases of the reincarnation type, is much more disturbing for a western audience because it stretches very much the boundaries of what we think is reality or reality as we know it. It is the presence of birthmarks or birth defects which are connected with past life experiences and specifically with the mode of death. These cases are found worldwide.
This is a case of Jatinder Agbo, a young child from Nigeria who recollects a head wound in the previous life as a result of which the head was tightly bandaged before death. The previous personality was buried with the bandage and you have this very uncommon birthmark on this child. It is one of the unverified cases unfortunately. Many of the cases which involve violent death and murder are unverified because of the very nature of crime. It is much more difficult to trace what happened.
Now if we look at the general incidence of birth deformities, broadly speaking, it varies between approximately zero point three percent and two percent of all live births. This depends vastly on the countries, with some countries like Scotland having very high incidences. Some populations like the Afro Caribbeans having very high incidences. Other populations having low incidences. However, specific birth defects can be exceptionally rare and these are frequently the birth defects which are present in Stevenson’s cases.
So this was the main topic of Stevenson’s work, Reincarnation in Biology. Those of you who have the courage to read it, I cannot recommend something better to ground your religious practice as a Buddhist or as a Hindu in reality. This is one of the pages of Stevenson’s summaries. Birthmarks corresponding to surgical wounds and other skin lesions. It gives you a sense first of the universality of the cases which range from Alaska through Turkey, Japan and Nigeria.
And the care with which Stevenson verified these cases trying to trace death certificates and attempting to find whether the wound reported in the autopsy corresponded to a birthmark or a birth deformation. And I would like to present one of the strongest cases that Stevenson has in this field. It’s quite a haunting case. It’s a Turkish case. The case of a young child called Semi, and I don’t know how to pronounce his name, I believe it is Tutushmush, who was born in 1958, and who suffered from a rare birth deformity, which is microtia of the right ear.
If you look at the pictures, can clearly see the right ear is severely underdeveloped, whereas the left ear is normal. And young Semi in addition suffered from what is known as hemiplegia. In other words, a disproportionate development of the left side of the face and a reduced development of the right side of the face leading facial asymmetry. What is striking in this case is that in addition to suffering from these birth deformities, Semi Tutushmush had extremely clear memories of a previous life in which he was murdered. Before his birth, his mother had an announcing dream in which he dreamt that a man with a bloody face entered the room.
He told her that he had been shot in the ear. He refused to leave and said he would be moving in with them. Now as we said, announcing dreams are a fairly frequent feature of cases of the reincarnation type. They’re not universal, but it happens in almost thirty percent of the cases. I think in the West, people are not very sensitive to dreams, but in more traditional cultures, dreams play a very important part in life.
When little Simi was nearly one and a half years old, he started talking about his previous life. His first words, the first words a child uttered were the names of the murderer of his previous life, The man who had killed the previous rebirth he remembers, a certain setting of faithfully. Semi Tutushmush said that Isaac Dierbekli came upon him while he was resting in a field and shot him point blank in the ear with a shotgun. At four years of age, when he could walk, he by himself walked to the neighboring town of Hatun Khoi, where Semi Fesley, the previous rebirth he remembered lived with his family, he introduced himself to the family. This against strong opposition from his own family.
If we look at the life and death of the previous incarnation, Selim Fesri, we can see that he was born in 1911. He lived in a neighboring village some two kilometers away called Hathom Khoi. He was just a farmer who was resting in a field one day, was shot by his killer who purportedly mistook him for a rabbit. I can only suggest wearing glasses. I never heard of a case like this one.
But he survived the wound for some six days and was able to convey that he had been shot by someone from his village. Isadir Bekley, his killer, we cannot say his murderer, was sentenced to three years in jail and always insisted the killing was accidental. It was a hunting accident. Stevenson was able to trace the post mortem autopsy of Selim Fesli. And this is one of the passages in the post mortem autopsy on the right periatal area of the skull and the right frontal area, there were six calls made by buckshot.
The shots penetrated the brain causing eventually the death of Selim Fesley. Now what is striking is the reaction of the young child, Semi, upon meeting Isa Dirbekli whom he did not know the first time. The first time he met him in Hatun Khoi, the neighboring village to which he kept going, Isadir Bekli after jail had had to start selling bottles of brandy. He broke some of the bottles of brandy and going up to Isadir Bekli said, you killed me. Now if we look at the attitude of young Semi towards Salim Festli’s family, the family of the previous rebirth.
The little boy forbade the widow from remarrying. He behaved like the father of Seymour Festi’s adult children. He actually gave a dowry of a 125 there, which is a lot of money for a little child to collect to Hassan upon his engagement. And he broke into tears when he heard that widow Katibbe had eventually passed on. It’s actually said that he fainted when he was taken to her tomb in the cemetery.
Keep in mind, this is a little child. So these are very powerful emotions which it is quite difficult to explain without appealing to reincarnation. The attitude of Semi towards Isadir Bekley, the murderer of Selim Fessley, is also quite striking. After throwing repeatedly stones at his liquor stand, he pledged to kill him. He started pledging to kill Isadir Bekli from the age of four onwards.
He was convinced the shooting was intentional because he claimed Isadir Bekli had spat in his mouth after killing, after shooting him, to prevent him from speaking. It is a traditional Turkish way of preventing the victim of a crime from reporting what happened. Bekli himself took this seriously since he lived in fear for his life. And up to 1973, Selim would still come to Hatun Khoi, trying to find Isadir Bekli to kill him. It is only by 1976, in other words, at the age of 18, that he gave up any thoughts of revenge.
The thoughts of revenge therefore haunted him for all his childhood. These are some of the 21 statements, I haven’t listed them all, which were verified statements made by Selim, verified by Stevenson. He remembered his previous name, Selim Fesli. He remembered the name of his wife, his daughters. He remembered the name of his sons.
He remembered the name of his murderer, and he remembered the details of the murder. I listed only the main statements in yellow are the principal ones. Every single one of these statements was verified. Now you can imagine that a case like this is not a case the family has any interest in encouraging. This is a very loaded case for all involved.
In volcanic cultures, revenge is a time honored tradition. It draws young semi’s family, which has nothing to do with what happened, into potential open conflict with an accused murderer. The family had no interest whatsoever in encouraging this case. And yet, the insistence of the child was such that eventually they had to acknowledge it. What makes the case, however, exceptionally interesting is what are the birthmarks on semi.
And this is the next step in our analysis of cases of the reincarnation type. You can see, you have microtia of the right ear which is extremely rare. It occurs in one twenty thousand to one thirty thousand births. In addition, and I will show you this in more detail in a couple of minutes, there are small fistulas and ear pits in the right ear, which occur only in zero nine percent of births in Caucasian children. And finally, we said, Semi had hemifacial hypoplasia, which is relatively rare as well.
It occurs in one to three thousand up to one to five thousand cases. Now, if we look at the microtia of the right ear, you can clearly see the difference between the normal left ear and the almost absent right ear. Keep in mind that Semi remembers in his previous life as Selim Fessi being shot in the right ear. In addition, if we look at the face, you can clearly see hemifacial hypoplasia. The previous rebirth was shot in the right side of the head with major damage to the right side of the skull, the parietal area of the skull with at least six buck shots penetrating, into the brain.
If we look at the diagram Stevenson made of Semi’s ears, you can see six small depressions. I didn’t list them all, are called facets in French. Stevenson took his notes in French. Six small facets on the diminished ear. These seem to have corresponded to the points of ingress of the buckshot.
So if we engage in an analysis of the case, the previous rebirth was Selim Festli, who died in 1958. The child we are considering is Semi Tutushmos, born in 1958. Selim Festli lived in Khatun Khoi. At age three, just going on four, Semi Tutushmush went alone to Khatun Khoi, two kilometers away. Selim Festli was married to Katibbe.
Little Semi Tutushmush had profound attachment to Katibbe and forbade her remarriage. Selim Festi was shot by Isadir Bekli. Semi Tutushmush harbored a deep hatred of Isadir Bekli and planned to murder Issa Diabecchi throughout his childhood until he was 18. Selim Festi was shot in the right ear. Semi Tutushmush had fistulas and depressions in the right ear.
There were shotgun pellets embedded in the right ear of the skull which seemed to correspond to these fistulas and depressions. And Selim Festi had important damage to the right parietal area of the skull. Semi tutus mush had underdevelopment of the right area of the skull. This is one of, the stronger cases, of the reincarnation type involving birth deformities. What would be extremely interesting would be to study the statistical prevalence of these cases within cases of the reincarnation type and contrast them with the prevalence of such cases in the population at large.
It hasn’t been done. I did some preliminary work for this conference, but the data is very hard to get. And the problem is much of the data Stevenson collected has only been partially processed. But if there is a true connection between traumatic damage to the body in the previous life and birthmarks or birth deformities in the present life, then certainly much of the medical model of the understanding of birth deformities has to be put in question. We can no longer say that birth deformities are exclusively genetic.
And I would like in this context to show you the next video, which is an extremely interesting video on the BBC learning channel of no more a case of, birth deformity, but actually a case of tumor connected in a young child with experiences in the previous life. Again, this occurs in a western family which has no belief and no interest in the existence of past and future lives, and as you will see, which found the experience quite disturbing. Oh, my apologies. I’m sorry for these captions. Is this the end of life or the cue for a new beginning?
Millions believe in reincarnation. Is there proof it really happens? Do people pass through many lifetimes, and can they bring back memories of having lived before? It’s three hundred and fifty years since the bloody battles of the English Civil War, but this man says he remembers fighting in them. And therapies now encourage people to relive the violent moments of their death in previous lives.
But what can be known for certain? Scientists are trying to assess the evidence from those who claim to have lived before. Will they prove the case for reincarnation and reveal what brings those memories to the human mind? Many religions believe in reincarnation. But for most people raised as Christians, it’s not something they expect.
So when memories of past lives hit them, it can come as an unwelcome surprise. I had never heard of something like this. I never was a believer in reincarnation, etcetera. I mean, it’s not something I’m too pleased with. I I really don’t I mean, I’m enjoying my life, but do I wanna keep coming back and back?
I don’t know about that. For Patricia Austrian, the agony of World War one’s trench warfare and muddy battlefields belonged only in the history books until her four year old son told her that he’d been there in a previous life. From the start, Patricia had been puzzled by her youngest son Edward’s bizarre phobia. Ever since he was one years old, he was really fearful of dark, gray, drizzly damp days. He was very anxiety ridden and would become quite clingy and whiny.
He was also constantly ill and used a strange name for the throat problems which plagued him. He kept referring to this area of his throat as my shot. I thought that he was describing the hurt in his throat because he had tonsillitis severely always. He was always very sick. But then Edward’s parents were horrified to discover he had a growth in his throat, a severe type of cyst.
It was pretty big, very noticeable. It looked like a swelling in his throat. Edward’s doctors decided to remove his tonsils in preparation for further surgery. That night, after his operation, he suddenly told his mother a graphic firsthand account of a soldier’s death in the trenches. My name was James.
I was 18 years old in France. Now remember, this is a four year old child. We were walking along through the mud. It was damp. It was rainy.
It was cold. My rifle was heavy. I remember looking out and seeing fields of trees, and then there was desolation. I heard a shot come from behind, and it went through. Someone else hit me square in the back of the neck, and I felt my throat fill with blood.
Believe me, that sent a chill for me. It seemed that Patricia’s son had just told her of a violent death in a previous life, in more detail than a four year old should have known. An obvious explanation would be that the boy had read something or seen it on TV. But according to past life research, these experiences fit a familiar pattern. Carol Bowman became fascinated by past lives after her own young son spoke of strange memories.
She’s compiled a book based on children’s experiences and believes they should not be dismissed. Usually, the parents are resistant to what the children are saying, and they will say to the child, you saw this on TV. Right? Or this is something you heard, and the child will be very insistent and serious. No.
This really happened. And I think in our culture, parents don’t want to believe this. And it’s the children that eventually convince them that this is real. I found through my research that children up until about the age of five have these past life memories spontaneously, just naturally. And I think this is just a natural part of a young child’s development, something that we really haven’t looked at in the West.
A previous life experience, I was not convinced that this was real. I thought this was the ramblings of a child. But what made Edward’s parents change their mind was something else that happened. At the same time that Edward spoke of being shot in the throat, his growth suddenly disappeared. Stephen Levine was also surprised.
As a doctor, Edward’s father knew that he’d witnessed something unusual. The experience that I personally had with these type of growths is that they never go away. So I was not only pleased but but surprised and and I didn’t know what to make of it. My schooling was he’s gonna develop cancer in that growth. Open mouth wide.
Edward’s doctor, ear, nose, and throat specialist, Steven Levine, was also surprised. Good. Excellent. I’m not sure what I can make of this story of Edward’s remembrance of a past life. I, as a physician and scientist, can only observe things.
And then if I can explain them, that’s fine. But there are some things that I just can’t explain. This is one. It’s an interesting case. It’s, a clear case not of a birth deformity but of a tumor in an area which was wounded in a previous life with the disappearance of the tumor in this life once the catharsis of the recollection occurs.
And it is yet again a strong case. It’s not a verified case, but a strong case precisely because it occurs in a family which has no particular desire to experience this sort of case and for whom this is actually rather disturbing. So we will now address a very different category of cases, memories of previous lives in a certain through hypnotic regression. This is a fundamentally different type of case. Until now we have addressed spontaneous memories.
They arise in the child and these are by far the strongest cases for providing some type of evidence for reincarnation. There can be among these cases cases where there is no vested interest whatsoever in the child having these memories. These cases are verified, some of them relatively easily, but they present one major problem. Almost always a child recollects only one life. It is very difficult to go beyond that.
Through hypnotic regression, it is possible to examine several recollected lives. The problem which arises is that of the veracity of the memories. A pioneer of this technique was the French scientist, Colonel Albert Rochard. And as you can see, the history of hypnotic regression can be traced back to the middle of the nineteenth century. A Russian prince, excuse me, prince Golitsyn was the first to have regressed a Hessian washer woman.
Now, I don’t know if you still have washer women in Australia, I would imagine not. But washer women were not terribly educated. And this Hessian Bavarian, in other words, washer woman, once regressed, started speaking in very articulate French, which she had never studied. And we collected a memory as an aristocrat who had actually assassinated her husband. Golitsi Rochard himself regresses 19 subject subjects.
I’ve spoken about these cases last year. I will not speak about them this year again. And there are several other cases which are famous. The most famous of all is perhaps the search for Bridey Murphy, which it is now pretty well established was a case of cryptomnesia, in which the American housewife who remembered being this Irish lady in the nineteenth century in Ireland, in Cork County, actually had a neighbor who, when she was younger, spoke in Irish brogue, and she learned whatever Irish brogue she knew from this lady. However, there are sound cases, which occurs with hypnotic regression, and one must distinguish between sound and unsound methodologies.
I personally feel that the procedures of Alberto Rocha, the pioneer in the field, Netherton and Helen Wambach are cases of sound procedures. The approach is broadly speaking scientific. There is no particular vested interest in eliciting these memories. There are other practitioners who seem to me to have unsound procedures. Psychiatrist Doctor Arthur Gurtham, for instance, eventually got caught up in his research.
To such a point that it was very difficult to know whether he was still an objective observer. The search for Brady Murphy, there were clear commercial interests. And in the case of Carol Bowman, there are commercial interests. And I think Carol Bowman is primed to believe in these cases. So that raises questions about the objectivity of her work.
Hypnotic regression presents certain advantages. As we said, one can study several lives. In other words, one can try to detect patterns over lives, which leads us to some sense of what karma might be. Secondly, hypnotic regression, as it’s not spontaneous, reduces this bias towards violent previous deaths, which is a feature of all of Stevenson’s cases. And finally, and this is quite uncommon, it allows the statistical study of the social milieu of the previous lives.
We will talk about that today. It is a fascinating domain. Hypnotic regression, however, presents major problems. The first is the actual induction of memories by the hypnotist, which is perhaps the biggest problem. Especially if it is done casually by hypnotists who have a vested interest in believing in the issue, it is very easy to induce a memory in the client.
The second, as for spontaneous cases, is cryptomnesia. Remembering something one had forgotten. Then we have naturally the generation of cathartic fantasized personalities, personalities which represent our wishes. I always wish to have a chock full of hair, but I’m sure if I am regressed, I will imagine I was leonine in my hair, you know? And more fundamentally, all the psychiatrists who regress patients to past lives claim to heal the patient from phobias or failures in this life through the regression.
There’s no explanation of why this is happening. And for that matter, Stevenson himself pointed out that all of his cases have phobias and failures. They remember clearly, but none of them seems to be healed by the recollection. So there are sharp critiques of hypnotic regression. Martin Orne, who is a professor of psychiatry, points out that those who promote these things are not malevolent, but they want very badly to believe.
And this is why one has to handle the cases of hypnotic regression, cum granos alis, a very large grain of salt. Whereas one can be much more confident of the spontaneous cases of the reincarnation type. Stevenson himself says, most of the children I have studied recall traumas in great detail that doesn’t stop them from having phobias in this life. So before we move any further in the issue of hypnotic regression, it has become a bit of a fad among new age practitioners in the West to be regressed. I would like to actively discourage you from going that route.
Hypnotic regression brings with it problems of its own. If the memories are traumatic, they can be unmanageable. And if the hypnotist is not trained in the management of these traumatic experiences, US subject may be left to handle things you may not be able to handle. So I am not presenting this to encourage anyone to go that route. I’d like to go on record as saying that I discourage it.
I think there is one legitimate usage of hypnotic regression, it is for psychiatric patients. Patients whose ailments do not respond to conventional treatment and certain psychiatrists Brian Weiss, Woolger, Netherton have felt the need to try to find the source of these ailments. And it is through this typically that they become interested in regression to past lives, because suddenly the patient is talking of something which happened in 1725. It is giving a wealth of details, which seems very difficult to understand. But the first problem we have to address with hypnotic regression is, is it a reliable source of information or not?
And in this respect, a now forgotten figure, doctor Helen Wambach, a clinical psychologist from the University of Iowa, did extraordinary work. What Wambach did was she regressed large numbers of volunteers, in slightly in excess of 1,000 volunteers, and studied the accounts of their past lives they gave, trying to correlate this statistically with what was known of the historical period concerned. And her premise is fascinating. Her premise is that one should study the group as a whole because if one studies large number of cases, typically, if hypnotical regression is just the fulfillment of fantasies, most of the memories should be the memories of glamorous historical figures. I was Napoleon, I was Cleopatra, I was a pharaoh in Egypt.
And should evince a skewed distribution of gender and race. The sample which Wambach worked with comprised at the beginning some 70% of female participants. Typically, people do not like to recollect a gender which is different from their present gender. You would expect the recollections to be skewed towards the present gender distribution. So this is what Wambach was examining.
Secondly, typically, if these are fantastic fantasized cathartic personalities, one would want to recollect being of a dominant race, being of a better social status, and perhaps recollecting a better life. And this is something which can be examined statistically, this precisely what Wambach did. Her first sample included eight fifty cases, the replication study included three fifty cases, And the gender ratio of the first sample is heavily biased towards women. Almost eighty percent of women and 12%, me, it has to be 22% here, my apologies, 22% male. Then, Wambach studied the distribution of social class in the recollected memories.
If these are fantasized cathartic personalities, then you would basically expect everyone to recollect a life as a Roman senator, as an English nobleman, as a French lady, yet this is not the case. One finds that over the periods of time between 2,000 BC and basically AD eighteen fifty, between 7080% of the memories are memories of lower class people. Lower class in Wambach’s definition of lower class are people who have to work for others and have little or no freedom. Few are memories of middle class people and interestingly enough, we see that those memories increase during the periods where we know historically that prosperity was on the rise, which is broadly speaking up to 1,000 BC and then basically after the year January. Upper class memories are exceptionally low up to after the fifteenth century.
This is in keeping with much of what we know of the distribution of classes in ancient societies. As some of you know, in the Greek polis, in the Greek city, anything between 25% of the population were citizens. Only men were citizens, women were not citizens, they didn’t have the right to vote, and much of the rest of the population was composed of slaves. So, in terms of the demographic distribution of social class in the recollections, the memories are not fantasized. In terms of the distribution of race, it is particularly interesting, in that most of the memories recollected, broadly speaking, up to the beginning of the Christian era, are memories of Asian, Indian, black and near Eastern rebirths.
And almost without exception, Wambach’s patients were white, they were Caucasian. This corresponds to what we know of the distribution of population up to the beginning of the Christian era. Most of the population was distributed in Asia, Africa, The Middle East. There was very population, or very few population settlements in Europe, and obviously The United States had not yet been discovered. Then the Caucasian population skyrockets.
This corresponds broadly to what we know happened after the spread of the Roman Empire. Keep in mind, this is data collated over 1,000 cases. It would be impossible for these 1,000 people, almost impossible to to fix their accounts with each other, so that statistically this fit the historical data. So I feel Wambach studies are the most, the strongest proof yet that hypnotic regression is a valid tool of investigation. Then gender distribution is broadly speaking even.
As you remember, we had 78% of female participants. Yet under analysis, approximately 50% of the recollected rebirths were male and 50% female. Finally, an analysis of the type of food eaten in each time period corresponds with what we know. Meat was eaten very little up to basically the year January. And it is really in the development of capitalism in the in the Hessian states, with the increase of prosperity that the consumption of meat skyrockets.
You can see that the typical food of hunter gatherers, wild animals, roots and fruits, was largely eaten really up to the beginning of the Christian era and starts to drop quite sharply after that. This corresponds as well with what we know of historical development. The consumption of cereals however increases sharply. Finally, world population in terms of the distribution of memories fits clearly what we know of world demographics. Both samples are symmetrical, the first and the second sample, we see that there is an explosion in the number of cases we collected after 500 AD and specifically after 1,500.
We know that world population explodes at the Renaissance. So very few memories of human beings from the period where there were very few human beings. This is remarkable. This is remarkable because if these were fantasized personalities, we would expect everyone to remember a rebirth as a man of Cromanian or a lady of Neanderthal. Yet they do not.
Unfortunately, Gwambach died very young. She died in 1985, and her work has not been pursued. However, it gives legitimacy to the study of, these cases using hypnotic regression. And I would like at present to present a strong case of hypnotic regression. The case of the past life memories of Captain Robert Snow, who was captain of the detectives in the Indianapolis Police Department in The United States.
It’s a strong case for several reasons. First, because captain Snow was, as captain of the detectives and as a practicing Methodist, a very no nonsense practical man who had no interest whatsoever in reincarnation, and for whom memories of a past life were a major professional and, conjugal problem. And secondly, because once the memories were elicited during a session, to which he had volunteered to go on a dare, he used his training as a detective to verify the memories and was able to verify them. This makes the case extremely interesting. Captain Robert Snow met, a colleague who was a psychologist working for the police department, who who used hypnotic regression at a cocktail party and she challenged him to be a man and to go and be regressed.
And he must have had a couple too too many cocktails because he accepted. And then spent the next couple of months trying to, these are my words, chicken out of it. But eventually embarrassment was too great. And he agreed to go and be regressed. And he tape recorded the session.
We will hear the tape recording in the last video. But when these memories occur occurred, his wife said to him, look, you’re a police captain. You’re not supposed to be involved in stuff like this. Believe me, people won’t understand. There was tremendous pressure from the beginning on Captain Snow not to talk about these memories.
His background is a strict Methodist background. No belief whatsoever in past and future lives. I quote him, the only Americans who believed in reincarnation were and weirdos, captain of detectives at the Indianapolis Police Department, and underwent hypnotic regression on a dare. His first regression is quite haunting. He remembers standing in the valley, and when he looks down, he sees a pair of dirty, grenally feet with hairy legs.
And he remembers being covered with a fur and carrying a tree limb. He was male. He had no name, no mate, and no offspring. And he only remembers apart from this dying alone on the floor of a cave and seeing his body from above. His only statement regarding this life was this was a bad life.
If lives or recollection of lives induced by hypnotic regression are true, this is what we should expect to encounter. Because most of us have led this sort of life. Meaningless lives as non entities dying young, dying perhaps as children with considerable suffering. Such a case is at face value fairly convincing precisely because it is at odds with everything you would expect if you were fantasizing a previous life. The second life is even more convincing, because he actually remembers being a female teenage virgin, serving as a priestess in a temple.
He describes, and you have to keep in mind how these hypnotic regressions occur. The subject has a series of flashes, of visions as it were. This is all that is given. There is very little text. And the subject constructs some type of meaning based on these visions.
Snow says, it looks like Greek architecture, it’s pillars in a circle. It’s on top of a hill. I live with a lot of other girls. We bring things down to the altar every day. It’s cold where we live.
We’re all pretty and we’re all virgins. Well, obviously, this is not a memory a police captain would be very keen to have. Right? Then he remembers he’s very coy about this one, losing her virginity. And then sees herself riding a cart with an old man and her daughter and recognizes the daughter as his stepdaughter in this life.
He recollects having been sold in slavery to this old man, who was kind to him, but dies shortly, and he, or I should say she, is unable to take care of the child and gives child as a future vestal virgin, that is what what it amounts to, to the ancient temple. The end of life is bleak. I go to a city, it’s really poor. I have something to do with fish. I’m old now and I’m cleaning fish.
And the memories of the death, I could feel myself wrapped up tightly in something and suffocating, water all around me. I was fighting, but I was trapped and couldn’t breathe. I just kept swallowing water. The last thought, I felt my mind deluged with a tidal wave of guilt over the abandonment of my daughter. From a Buddhist standpoint, you could say the one major non virtuous deed in that person’s life came back to haunt her at the time of death.
The abandonment of her child. The third regressed life, however, is the one which is of interest because it is the one which he was able to verify. He sees in his third regressed life that he must be living in the late eighteen hundreds because there’s gas lights and horses. He sees his own body wearing shiny shoes and carrying a cane. He drinks wine.
He knows his name or his nickname is Jack. He sees himself fighting with someone called Amanda over money. He sees himself in a room full of windows and skylights and thinks he must be an artist because there are paintings. He sees himself painting the portrait of a hunchbacked woman. And he sees the portrait in such detail that he actually as a detective endeavors to trace the portrait.
It took according to my estimate almost two years to trace this portrait and the artist which painted it. The portrait was in a private collection and had not been exhibited in the twentieth century. Then he in his recollected memory says, I don’t like doing portraits, but I need the money. Sees himself five years later with Amanda playing the piano in France. Remembers he didn’t have children and then a statement out of the blue, they said she died of a blood clot.
We don’t know who she is. It turns out to be the mother of the previous personality. Finally, Snow was so haunted by the case that he engaged in self hypnosis to try to elicit more data and the number 1917 kept appearing. And his death, I found myself out of the woods and looking through the windows on the 2nd Or 3rd Floor of a large mansion. I can see one of my paintings, it’s hanging above a fireplace.
It’s a bottle with fruit in it and there’s a big sun behind it. The death clearly here had already occurred and snow seems to be recollecting the intermediate state. Then haunted by this collection of memories, which was elicited during two sessions of hypnotic regression. The first on a dare, the second to try to flesh it out and then self hypnosis in which he got a date 1917. Snow decides he’s going to investigate this case and as a detective, he identifies the points which are verifiable and tries to trace them.
The one memory he has very clearly is a memory of a painting, the painting of a hunchback woman. So he tries to trace the painting and all artists of the period who could have painted a hunchback woman. He’s unable to do so. However, visiting the Indianapolis, Museum of Art, he sees a painting of William Chase who was a famous, painter of the period, and upon seeing this painting suffers from acute vertigo and shock, so extreme he actually has to leave the museum. And he has a very clear sense, I painted this.
This is his account. At the American Gallery in Indianapolis, though I never seen the painting by Beckwith before or knew what Millie William Chase looked like, I knew instantly which painting was Beckwith’s. I felt a huge surge of electricity running down and out of my arms and a return of the vertigo so strong that I became unsteady on my feet and had to get out of there. Snow becomes convinced he is a reincarnation of a forgotten American portrait painter known as Carroll Beckwith. And he tries to trace elements in the life of Carroll Beckwith to see whether or not they fit his hypnotic regression.
He says, even with the pitifully small amount of information about Beckwith, I had confirmed 10 of the scenes I had seen fall under hypnosis and had disproved none. Snow was able to find the painting of the old woman with the hunched shoulders. It was not listed in any art book. It was not exposed in a museum. Snow, in the state of despair, eventually traveled to New Orleans with his wife, and entering, in an art gallery casually sees in front of him the painting of the hunchback woman.
Goes into a state of considerable shock. The art gallery owner, as all art gallery owners, is convinced that it’s an aesthetic rapture and suggests that he would be happy to sell the painting for quite a reasonable price, saying that Beckwith has not been exposed in the twentieth century, and this painting was in private hands. Snow isn’t quite sure whether he should buy the painting or not. When he returns to New Orleans again, the art dealer has gone bankrupt. The painting is no longer available.
And there is actually to this day no copy of this painting. Then Snow tries to investigate Beckwith’s life and eventually finds that Beckwith left a journal in New York. The I think it was the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. A journal of some 17,000 pages, which Snow travels to New York to read from beginning to end. It takes him almost one year to do it.
And he is able to corroborate the key points of his hypnotic regression and the life recollected as Carol Beckwith. Carol Beckwith is forgotten portrait painter, was born in America. Against strong family opposition, he studied painting, but could only make a living painting portraits, which he loathed. He was known for a naturalistic style and bright colors. He drank wine, whereas in America at the period, the main drink, as you know, was whiskey.
He was a bit of a dandy, using, a bamboo cane and wear wearing, I think you call them in English, swats, those particular shoes. Spats. Spats. Spats, precisely. Traveled to France to study, returned to America, and eventually passed on.
Now if we try to analyze the patterns, and keep in mind these patterns are weaker in the cases of hypnotic regression than in spontaneous memories, because the memories are more jumbled. The first memory of captain Snow, 2,000 BC, no offspring, died in poverty alone, died shivering and forlorn, perhaps some sort of a caveman. The second memory as a Vestal Virgin in Greece, daughter given away, died in poverty alone, died in drowning. The third memory is Carol Beckwith. No children, wife barren.
Tremendous fear of poverty. Beckwith was obsessed with money all his life and fought with his wife over it. Chronic rheumatism, strong hostility to abstract and modern art. And Snow himself is a very discreet man, so we do not know a lot about him. But you can see within the three lives clear patterns.
No offspring, daughter given away, no children. Poverty, poverty, fear of poverty. Died cold, perhaps wet, died drowning, Beckwith suffered from chronic rheumatism all his life. Then Beckwith himself had a strong hostility to abstract and modern art, which was carried through to Robert Snow. So this case shows clearly the interest of hypnotic regression as a technique.
More one gets much less data and it must be examined much more carefully. It is possible to track patterns. Then I will cover briefly the, work of doctor Morris Netherton and then we will have, perhaps half an hour for questions. As I mentioned, Netherton elicits memories of past lives without hypnosis using key words in the person’s speech which are identified and which he considers are crystallizations of traumatic past life experiences. I mentioned the famous life is hard.
Its interest is obviously that it avoids the use of hypnosis, and therefore it avoids the risk of inducing past memories. Then, Netherton himself is interested in three phases of the life of the subject, the prenatal period, birth and death. Most of his work is concentrated on these. It is actually in the last thirty years or so that Netherton has started working with regression to past lives when this setting was insufficient to account for the experiences of his clients. And this is one example which is given by Netherton in his, book Past Life Therapy, which demonstrates how a sentence which is drawn out of the conversation of a client eventually is used to trigger the recollection of a purported past life.
One of Netherton’s client, Alan Haster, who was a leading American lawyer. Lawyer’s first words upon entering in Netherton’s office is I’ve tried everything. He fears a collapse of his law practice. First marriage is a disaster. Second marriage he is facing divorce.
Then Netherton uses the sentence, I’ve tried everything, it’s hopeless, as a mantrum to trigger whatever experiences are associated with it. And he has Alan Hasler repeat the sentence exactly the same way as one would repeat a mantra. The experience of Alan Hasler is quite haunting. He sees himself on a farm which looks like a desert. There is no rain.
The climate has changed. He sees that there is no crop. My wife is going mad. She makes no sacrifices. She doesn’t see that there is no way for us to go on living as we have in the past.
They’ve taken away the house, we live in the barn. And here comes the key sentence. I’ve tried everything, but there’s no rain. Then his breathing becomes heavier, his speech slower, the wind is driving us crazy, the ground is just dust. I’ve worked so hard, it’s hopeless.
You can see here the two sentences which are used to trigger the experience. I’ve tried everything. It’s hopeless. Oh my god, she’s killed the children. She stabbed the children in the front yard, I have a pistol, running into the barn, I don’t know what to do except with the pistol and I fire it.
Nothing will grow, then a recollection of suicide, I’m glad to escape. In other words, rejoicing from a Buddhist standpoint at the time of suicide. Then if we analyze the karmic patterns, and I feel I can use at present the term karma. The present life is a life in The USA with despair, depression and marital problems. Possibly, nothing is said but we can assume this, a risk of suicide.
The previous recollected life is perhaps a life in the dust belt during the great depression. It is unclear, there’s no date. There is repeated habituation with despair and marital problems, murder, suicide as escape, and rejoicing in suicide. Then we can see the unfolding of a karmic pattern. We do not know how many lives separate these two lives, but we can see that the habituation with despair is carried over into this life.
Marital problems are carried over into this life. Suicide as escape and rejoicing suicide may be carried over into this life. So this is a great interest of hypnotic regression. It enables us to start working a little bit in this way. We must be very careful.
In this case, there is no verification of the previous life. It seems impossible to verify. No names are given. These occurrences must have been extremely common. However, and this is I think where hypnotic regression cases stand on their own, they have generally a very high level of internal consistency.
This is not a fantasy I would want to have if I was hypnotized. So it is certainly not wish fulfillment. And this leads me to the conclusion of this conference with two quotes. Stevenson’s famous quote, why do mainstream scientists refuse to accept the evidence we have for reincarnation? And something I find extraordinary, which is the comment by Eugene Brady, who was the editor of the Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases in ’79.
The problem lies less in the quality of the data Stevenson uses than in the body of knowledge and theory, which must be abandoned or radically modified in order to accept reincarnation. So what Brady is saying is that for reincarnation, the burden of proof must be inordinately large because it is at odds with so much of modern science. This is a very problematical viewpoint. It’s a very problematical viewpoint. If such a viewpoint had been adopted when, for instance, Galileo asserted heliocentricity, then no one would ever have accepted that the sun is at the center of the solar system.
Because it was at odds with the totality of medieval knowledge. A lot had to be abandoned. If this standard had been adopted for Einstein’s special theory of relativity, and even more so his general theory of relativity, for which there was almost no empirical data, then one would have been stuck with a Newtonian model of physics, because there was so much to abandon. Yet, this is the standard on which Stevenson’s work has been assessed. So in conclusion, I think there is in the cases of the reincarnation types, the spontaneous cases in children, at present strong if not very strong evidence that reincarnation occurs.
There are two thousand five hundred cases on record with Stevenson alone, there are other researchers. Eight ninety five verified cases, sixty five cases with autopsy and some thirty cases for which it is the only simple explanation. Regarding the data which is used to hypnotic, regression, I think we have to be much more reserved. It can be used I don’t know of a single regressed case which is unambiguous and convincing. Whereas I feel that Stevenson’s data is, James Leininger’s case I feel is extremely convincing.
The only way to explain it away is large scale fraud by both parents. Which is precisely why I chose it, because the parents had everything to lose. I don’t think if you are an evangelical businessman in Louisiana, you want to be seen as saying that your son has past life memories. Then the memory of the young child remembering being a soldier in the trenches in World War One, you could see the hostility of the parents to the idea and their bewilderment. These cases are, numerous and I think for us who are interested in Buddhist studies or who are interested in Hinduism, these cases provide a very solid foundation.
I think the most solid way forwards for us in our practice is perhaps to put aside some of the more advanced studies like glamoring temporarily and study and focus on these cases to generate a strong conviction in the actual existence of reincarnation. Then on that basis, it is possible to start engaging in meditation and studying Lamrim which is actually quite an advanced set of practices. Then I have finished what I wanted to cover with you today. Thank you very much. And I am wide open to your questions.
Should you have any? What would have to be abandoned? I don’t market things. I am interested I am interested in truth. Then, we’re not here for marketing.
The question I’m asking is not the one of benefits or harm, it is a question of truth. Is this true or not? If it is true, it is obvious that there is benefits in conforming society in one’s mind to the actual way things are. If it is not true, and that’s been my contention at this center since I came here, then we should shut down, go off and do something else with our lives. But what I would like to point out is that in the case of Stevenson’s research, it is the question of truth which nobody wants to ask.
Stevenson only has asked throughout his career that others attempt to replicate his work. Then this material has far reaching consequences for society. I don’t know if they are beneficial, but I think ultimately if we act in accordance with reality, there is benefit. Medicine would have to change, psychology would have to change, the law would have to change. Medicine, because we can’t provide purely physiological accounts for many diseases.
For instance, some of the deformations which Stevenson encountered, the case of tumor in a four year old child, have an etiology which is to be searched elsewhere than just in this life. So our account of medicine would have to change. There are traditional medicines which function on this model. Tibetan medicine functions, it is a traditional medicine, it’s not as effective as western medicine, but it integrates the understanding of past and future lives. Psychology has to change.
Attempting to account for the human behavior through limiting it to whatever impacts early childhood based on these cases, if these cases are true, is highly insufficient. And then the law will have to change. Because one of the key features in, and I’m not a legal specialist, in the laws of most western countries is the issue of responsibility. Now, we can see here very strong compulsions from past lives. The question which arises is if past lives are recognized and there is a source to these compulsions, should someone engaging in a crime say under the power of such a compulsion be seen as a diminished responsibility?
So I’m sorry if I answered your question a bit bluntly, but I would like to shift the debate from one of benefit in marketing to one of reality. Because I feel it’s a one question which is not being asked. And this field I think is one field where research could easily be done. Does that answer your question? It will be huge.
Let me give you an example of how huge it would be. How would you address the issue of inheritance? I mean, we all function on a model of inheritance which is genetic. So you inherit property because you are the descendant of your parents, they pass on the property. Let us imagine for instance that James Houston was a wealthy magnate who had volunteered to join the US Navy.
Would James Leininger, who has clear memories of being James Houston, qualify as his heir? In Tibet, the entire model of inheritance was built on this. We had Tibet had two models of inheritance. A common model of inheritance which was genetic for the ordinary person, where the children inherited from their parents, and a model of inheritance for persons whose reincarnation could be established, who were generally reincarnated Lama, where the reincarnation bypassed the family and it was in the reincarnation lineage. This is very far reaching.
Are there other questions? I’m sorry? There was there was another rebirth. We don’t know which one. Or it is possible that there was a rebirth as a spirit.
A bardo state is a a state in which the mind is present in disincarnate mode and after a maximum of forty nine days, seven cycles of seven days, it must take rebirth. It can take rebirth as a being with a body, which is what we consider to be living beings or they are, although they’re not acknowledged in the West, they are spirits, they are beings like us, they just have a very subtle body. They can see us, we can’t see them most of the time. Then it is possible he was a spirit. We simply do not know.
Is that right? Exactly. It is clear that those two lives were connected in a chain of 12 links. Yes. Exactly.
Then what the connection is, we do not know. We do not know. It’s a big problem. I spoke about it with an old friend at some ten years ago, as I was covering this material with him, an old friend of mine who was a Geshe. Then from a Buddhist standpoint, the trauma, qua trauma, is not the actual cause of the birth defect in the future life.
Nor could it be. In this respect, from a Buddhist standpoint, Stevenson’s, interpretation is too limited. A Buddhist would say that that trauma is a result of past karma. It manifests as a wound which, let’s say, causes death in that life and that karma is still not completely exhausted and therefore in a future life it manifests as a deformity, a birth defect or whatever. Then based on Stevenson’s research and on cases, in which the memories are induced through hypnotic regression, I think it will never be possible to give a complete account of karma.
It is said in Buddhist philosophy that when one practices meditation and one gains single point of concentration, one can remember past lives. But that remembrance of past lives is not sufficient to generate a conviction in karma. Because there were the ancient Indian locayatas materialists who remembered past lives, but the chain of karma is so distant, so long, so subtle that they could not see within the limited, let’s say, ten, twenty or 50 lives they remembered the connection. Now we see with the regressed memories, it’s tentative. You can see sometimes like a pattern going through.
Where it goes, where it stops, like with the case of Robert Snow, you have three lives. One without children, the second with an abandoned child, the third without children, but Snow himself has two children in this life. Now what happened, we don’t know. We’re very much at the dawn of these investigations. Does that does that answer your question?
Normally, yes. Normally, you reincarnate in groups with which you have created a connection. Then this is by no means an iron fast rule, because we have an infinite number of connections. For instance, there are some people who are naturally attracted to Tibetan Buddhism and they are not attracted to Zen Buddhism. It is often not an intellectual process.
It is something in the background of the person which makes this connection. Others are naturally attracted to Theravada Buddhism. Others yet again, from early on feel a strong interest in Christianity or Islam or Judaism. Normally people reincarnate within their community, which is why conversion is pretty rare. This is also why His Holiness discourages conversion.
Because if you have been, let us say reincarnating as a westerner for, let us say, five hundred or eight hundred years among your human rebirths, and you have animal rebirths and other universes. Let’s say, among five or eight hundred years you have, let’s say, four rebirths as a westerner in a Christian society. Those Christian karmic imprints are very powerful. Then if you convert to another religion, you are struggling against four lives of comic imprints. Which is why, generally speaking, we see we see the conversion of Westerners to Buddhism is unstable.
Anything else would be surprising. Now, even though we ourselves believe in karma and causality, there is great benefit in those systems of thought which do not believe in karma and causality like Christianity. Because Christianity, Judaism, Islam, they lay the groundwork for ethics. That ethics guarantees that the Christian, the Jew, the Muslim gets a higher rebirth. Then in a sense it’s irrelevant whether they believe or not in higher rebirth.
They have something which enables them to practice ethics. But if you destroy that and they never become sincere Buddhists and don’t practice ethics, then as purely verbal Buddhists, they may reincarnate in the lower realms in future lives. Then it’s very difficult to get out. So once we start looking at practicing Buddhism from the standpoint of the reality of past lives, and conversion from the standpoint of the reality of past lives, I think as historians of Dalai Lama, one becomes much more wary about encouraging conversion. Does that answer your question?
Are there other questions? Yes. I think, basically, the only rebirth we can remember as human beings are other rebirths as human beings. Because I think a rebirth as an animal, let alone a rebirth, let’s say, as a spirit or in one of the hell realms, is too alien for us to understand. I mean, you would probably have if you had a rebirth as a hell being some very powerful emotions.
I think there’s nothing else you could really connect with that experience. So what you find when you study, especially hypnotic regression, is that the lives of human far between. Snow remembers three human lives over maybe 2,503. One as Carol Beckwith, one has perhaps the Vestal Virgin, which puts us maybe 500 BC, and one, heaven knows, between 2,050 BC. What happened in between?
It might it might be other lots where it’s all been lost in that time. We don’t know. We simply don’t know. It could be, but why, if they were just lives in between, didn’t he remember any of them? I think probably my personal view on this is that those lives in between were non human lives.
As an animal, then an animal life imagine that if you have pets, at the end of the life of the pet, what sort of experiences, mental experiences are there in the mind of the pet? Almost nothing. Food once a day, patting once a day, walking in the park, that’s for a dog. But if you have a cow, at the end of that life as a cow, what is there? What is there to remember?
Then you see in human beings some traits, for instance, particular affection for certain type of animal with no grounding in the person’s life, which makes one suspect some sort of connection. I know someone who said to me once, I love the smell, this a very pretty young lady, I love the smell of cow dung, it is so refined. Then I was sort of nonplussed, I suppose is the word. Where does this come from? And then she added, cows are some of the most beautiful creatures.
I don’t if you’ve ever worked with cows, but they’re not exactly the cleanest of creatures. She said their eyes are so soulful. And perhaps there is something there. Does that start to answer your question? Human lives are rare.
I mean, if you start looking at hypnotic regression, you take for instance, Wambach’s data. She has very few human lives before May AD. These people were still there. Where were they? Nonhuman rebirths.
Not one is remembered. So if we have such difficulty in remembering an animal rebirth because the animal is already very alien for us, like a dog’s world. In a dog’s world, eye sense data is not important. Ear sense data is not important. What is critical is olfactory experience.
How would we remember that? Difficult. I think so. I mean, there is an interface between the mind and the brain. I mean, am a dualist philosophically.
In other words, the mind is non material. The brain is material. The interface is clear. It is clear that once the mind has reincarnated, if the brain is damaged, that it affects the functioning of mind within that brain. Once the mind leaves that body, that functioning is no no longer affected.
Then that brain is species specific. It’s clear. The human brain is specific to the human species, a canine brain specific to the canine species. In addition to this from a Buddhist standpoint, we bring in this life certain karmic proclivities, which make certain experiences accessible to us. I think this goes a long way to explaining the fact that animal rebirths are not often remembered.
There are cases I was going to present them, there was no time. Stevenson lists three cases from Sri Lanka of Sri Lankan children remembering animal rebirths. Then most of the rebirths you remember are animal. One is a rabbit, but the only experience remembered is being shot. One is a horse and the person does not have self consciousness as a horse.
The rebirth which is remembered is being big, tormented by flies, dark and not being able to see sideways. Then one infers, it is probably a horse. Are there other questions? Yes, please. He had informants he built over the decades, informants first in Sri Lanka, in Thailand, in Burma, in India, in Turkey, in Canada, eventually in The United States and Europe, who were local medical researchers, scientists or sometimes journalists with an interest in these cases and who would bring these cases to his attention the moment they heard of them or they hit the newspapers.
Then over the years, the caliber of Stevenson’s cases has increased dramatically because he started to have ground level contacts. For instance, last one Parisha is Stevenson’s main contact in the South Of India. She is a psychiatrist in Bangalore. Then she has village level contacts throughout Karnataka in Southern India. Then these cases are brought to her attention very swiftly before they pass through the newspapers, etcetera.
That is I think what has to be done for the future. How would you? He couldn’t rule it out. It is a weakness in these cases. These are spontaneous cases.
You you have to work with the given. Then What would you doubt did the mother perform the answer? Then we don’t know. We don’t know. I mean, the one thing which these cases cry for is more research, which means more funding, you know.
And I think it is perhaps for the twenty first century one of the most important areas of research because you can see how much our worldview would change if this was true. I think the most important question a human being has to answer is what comes at the end of this life. It’s the only question which is really worth asking. Until you have answered that question, everything else, what job am I gonna do, who am I gonna marry, What school will I send my children to? What suburb am I going to buy my house in?
All that is trite. If it’s all going to be taken away from you in a matter of a couple thousand days. So the most important thing in human life is to answer that question of what comes after death. For that, I think one must be very scientific, very stubborn and very hard nosed. We must look at the data.
Not of what society believes, but of what society does not believe. Once one has looked strongly at the data, one must reach a real conclusion. There is such a thing as rebirth or not. Or as the Christians would say, is only one future life. These are questions we have to take a position upon.
The goal of these conferences was to show you what the positions are and why it is not a luxury to take such a position. You can be a materialist, in which case there’s zero before and zero after. You can be a monotheist, generally speaking the Semitic monotheisms assert nothing before and one life after. The Indian traditions assert, generally speaking, an infinity of lives before and an infinity of lives after until liberation. But until you have decided for sure which of these three it is, you cannot live a meaningful life.
Once that has been decided, I think one’s whole life changes. Then the question is regarding these cases of the reincarnation type, is reincarnation random or not? Stevenson’s data shows that there is some sort of connection between the experience of the past life and the experience of the present life. It’s not random. Then the next question you have to ask is, is this connection enough to speak of some type of ethics?
Ethics means a conduct, a system of conduct or not. Is it just a case that if you can become accustomed to something in a past life, you will be accustomed to it in the present life or is there more? That is already the foundation of karma. If you can build on that to generate a real conviction in the existence of karma, then the next thing to know is what karma is, how karma, in other words, karma means deeds, how these deeds done in past lives operate. And then it becomes a vital importance for us to live strategically.
We can’t eliminate all non virtuous karma but the goal is to weaken it as much as we can. Then we don’t necessarily have the time to do retreats or to meditate but once we realize that this is coming in our face within a couple thousand days after our next death, then it becomes critical to live in a karmically intelligent way. For this one has to attend teachings. But I personally feel that what is lacking in a western audience is this powerful conviction that there are past and future lives. Once you are convinced of that and you can only be convinced of that on the data, then you must take a magnifying glass.
You must read Stevenson and see is there a connection between these lives. If so, what is it? Does this fit with the teachings of Hinduism? Does this fit with the teachings of Buddhism? Does this fit with the teachings of Jain or not?
It is not a matter of one’s own personal religious preference. It is a matter of truth, of reality. We have to find what is truth because otherwise, our lives are wasted. We have to set a very high standard in this matter. I think most of us have a much higher standard for our mortgage than we have for our spiritual development.
When you take a mortgage brother, you become as well informed as the leading mortgage lawyer in Australia. Right? I mean, what’s a floating rate? What’s a fixed rate? What, you know, is the policy of the Reserve Bank of Australia?
You are projecting yourself twenty, thirty years in the future. Then, when it comes to ethics, anything goes, right? So anything goes means that we are not fully convinced of the existence of past and future lives and of karma and causality. Does that go towards answering your question? Do you have any other questions?
Then what I would like to encourage all of you to do is to read this material. My mother in memory of one of her friends who passed on donated these books to the library. The some of the volumes are only for consultation at TBI, but you can still get them even though they are out of print on Abi books. You cannot make a better investment of your time than spend one or two years working through Stevenson’s works and then using that as a springboard to look at these cases of memories induced hypnosis. Don’t start with the ones induced hypnosis.
It’s too tentative. Start with a solid work and then once you have a good litmus test, move to those and then when you start studying for instance if you are Buddhist Lamrim, you would look at Lamrim with totally different eyes. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- real I
- The I that appears to exist inherently from its own side without depending on causes and conditions, parts or the mind's imputation. It is the object to be refuted. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.