TBI Symposium – 110731-001

1 h 2 min · 9,399 words

TBI Symposium (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Symposium (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Symposium - 110731-001
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A talk presented as a mathematical and conceptual inquiry into whether all sentient beings, who are infinite in number, can all reach enlightenment within a finite time. It draws on a Nirvana Sutra passage on Buddha nature and the idea of infinity, using examples such as the Ganges sand, coastlines, Hilbert’s Grand Hotel, and a binomial growth model to argue that infinite sets can be placed in one-to-one correspondence.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 3m

UUID: 207d8277-3404-40a3-a177-dd48b83c2be4

Words: 9,395

Today and I hope you don’t mind if I stand up and the reason being, you can guess, an academic by profession and so I love walking around when I’m lecturing mainly because it calms my nerves down. Now usually to say, why would I need to calm my nerves? And the reason being is that I guess on a weekly basis it’s not uncommon for me to present to students with a number of over 500, 600 present without me raising you know a sweat bead whatsoever, but that’s in my comfort zone and unfortunately should I say that what I’m presenting today is a little bit outside of that. So, I spent I don’t know how many years in the profession of economics and finance. My specialty is in something called econometrics, which is a bit of a messy word.

It basically means statistics and we’d like to call it something other than statistics cause it usually puts people to sleep as soon as you mention that word. So, sorry. Unfortunately, I’m going to start off with a few apologies and it’s probably the worst thing to do. If you know how to do presentations, you’ve got to come in confident and you’ve got to basically, you know, enthuse the public that you know what you’re talking about rather than sort of going, oh well, you know, I want to apologize first of all that although I’ve been a practicing Buddhist and when I say practicing, I mean I do follow the Buddhist faith, but it doesn’t mean I know very much at all about Buddhist philosophy. And so unfortunately, I lack the knowledge base that a lot of the other presenters that have presented yesterday and also today have that I don’t.

Don’t. Secondly, and this is probably the greatest disappointment because some of you might have woken up this morning thinking well you know, I don’t really want to come in so early at 09:00 but then again there’s this guy who’s going to tell me when I’m going to be enlightened. So maybe I should. Unfortunately, I’ve got no bloody clue when we’re going to be enlightened. Having said that, the reason why I’ve called my topic When Will All Beings Reach Enlightenment because it is a side product, a side question that gets answered with something that’s been bothering me for over a decade and I’m going to explain what that question is and how we can actually resolve it, at least in my mind and when I say resolving the question, I’m looking it from the perspective of being able to come to a Western style mathematical logical conclusion that adheres to what the Buddhist Sutras state.

So, that’s what I’m looking for and indeed some remarkable, I find it remarkable insights can be shown for things that were developed 2,000, or more than 2,000 years ago, which is just incredible. Okay, so on that note, what I’d like to also do is thank three particular people who’ve been extremely instrumental in being able to come up with framing the question, but also working out a solution for me. The first one is a gentleman called Nigel Bean. He is the head of applied mathematics at the University of Adelaide and we spent probably over a month, not you know day to day, but over a period of one month trying to come up with a resolution to how to work out this question And so, he has been extremely instrumental. Elio of course, our resident translator, very important as well because when I first posed the question to him, he suggested that I try to solve it via a mathematical route, which I did and fortunately for yourselves just before you start walking out, I’m not going to present any mathematics.

I’ve actually tried to wash it all and I’m present concepts instead. Conceptual issues that explain how the maths work. And finally of course to Khensur Rinpoche, when I presented my results to him and this is my experience every time I’ve met him on an individual basis at least. When I would ask him questions I’d walk out from the meeting feeling a little bit perplexed and disappointed I should say. I’d walk away thinking well that didn’t really give me what I wanted and I After some reflection and I guess this explains how slow I am, sometimes it takes a few weeks, sometimes it takes a few months, something would dawn on me and going wow, this guy knew what he what he was saying.

It makes absolute sense. So I’m going to explain what that eureka moment was for me as well later on and how he also played a very important role in in in this question. Okay. So I’m no further ado. Let me actually explain to you what is this question I’m going on about.

It is not when all beings will reach enlightenment, as I said, that’s a side product of what what I was actually after. So I’m gonna begin with citation, a quote from the nirvana sūtra, which is a Mahāyāna sūtra. Some of you may know about it. It particularly is focused on Buddha nature. And if you’re interested in a translation of it, I think there are three volumes of it by a Japanese gentleman with a surname of Yamamoto.

It’s very prevalent in Zen Buddhism from my understanding. And I’ve highlighted one particular segment of it that to me is core to the question I want to ask. So I’m just going to give you just a half a minute to have a quick read of it. As I believe we are Mahāyāna Buddhists, we all believe that we have Buddha nature, which basically ensures you could say that we all have the potential to reach enlightenment. But within the sutras, sutras, it also states something very particular which is hopefully my point is going to work, yes.

All sentient beings will have in future ages the most perfect enlightenment. And this bothered me for countless years, countless And years. I can’t believe actually I’m standing here today presenting to people a conclusion to it which is just amazing for me. There are many things in Buddhism that when I read I just take for granted. I don’t know why it is but it just so happens that certain things that seem very etherical and esoteric, go, yep, that makes sense, doesn’t matter.

But there are a few things that I just constantly think, well this doesn’t work. Now, I’m going to explain to you why I don’t think this works. How many sent and I’m gonna ask everybody a number of questions throughout this presentation and I’m gonna my first one I’m gonna ask and I’m sure you all would know the answer whether you’ve attended any of Khensur Rinpoche’s teachings or you’ve picked up any Buddhist texts. How many sentient beings are there? Sorry?

Innumerable. Innumerable. Okay, thank you. It’s a very good word. I usually would hand out chocolates to keep my students awake in my lectures, but unfortunately I didn’t bring any today.

So, I have to make an apology on that as well. So, yes, there are an innumerable number of sentient beings not only I guess you could say in this universe, but in any of the realms. So, then the question at least that irritated me is how can you actually ensure that all beings will reach enlightenment if there are and for a lack of a better word, what’s a modern Western word to explain in innumerability? Infinity, right? There’s an infinite number of sentient beings.

Infinity, and we’ll talk about this in a second, because I’m going to be asking you these questions. So, how many sentient beings are there? Well, as many sentient beings as there is space in the sky, there’s no limit to space. Space is immeasurable and similarly there’s no limit to sentient beings, their number is immeasurable. So another word there.

So the problem to me, and in fact let me ask you the question, because maybe it’s just my convoluted mind that creates problems which usually is the case. What is the problem? Yes, yes or taking it one step further because I guess my basis is in statistics. The an infinite number, can you ever reach an infinite number? No.

So if they’re an infinite number of beings, how can they all become enlightened? That was basically the question. There’s a contradiction there and that contradiction puzzled me and as I said before, it really annoyed me and and I started questioning many other things when I started reading different texts. Can I trust it? You know, essentially speaking.

So this is the lemniscate which is basically the inverted number eight and that basically represents infinity as we know it in the western world at least. It was designed I think in the 1500 by a Catholic monk if I’m not mistaken to explore what an infinity was. Okay, so let me ask yourselves what is infinity? Can you give me an example of it, of something that’s infinite? Space.

Potentially yes, that’s true, that’s very good. Can we count the amount of space there is? No, okay very good. Anybody else? There’s many definitions.

No one’s I usually tell my students there’s no such thing as a bad question, but in fact there is. A bad answer should I say. Okay. So if we want to work out a definition, I’m gonna start off with the Latin word for it which is infinitas, which implies unboundedness, something that’s unbounded. And essentially you can look at, you can consider sometimes space as being unbounded.

But really if you want something of a more general description that everybody can understand, there’s always one place that you can rely on to give you that definition. Probably the best source of encyclopedic knowledge, which is the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy. So what does that say? It’s bigger than the biggest thing ever and then some. Much bigger than that in fact, really amazingly immense, gigantic multiplied by colossal multiplied by staggeringly huge.

So there you go. So if you’re unsure what source you need to, if you don’t know where to get you know a good quote, just look at the hitchhikers guide. That’ll solve all your problems. So, Elio helped me with this. So, the Tibetan Sanskrit terms which are being used, and I’ll talk about this a little bit later on, because I wasn’t sure whether texts refer to, because I can’t speak, I can’t read Sanskrit script or Tibetan unfortunately, whether they do use a term which refers to infinite.

And the closest one we’ve got here is boundaryless, which is very similar to unboundedness. So, is some similarity there and I make the assumption that they are basically the same. Although, I’ll talk about my conversation I had with Khensur Rinpoche about this lasted quite a long time to come to the conclusion whether it was infinite or just a very large number. And that doesn’t make a difference to the results. Okay, so, the question I pose is, is it possible to show mathematically an infinity can be reached under some general assumptions?

Because essentially that’s what you want to do. Given the fact that there are an infinite number of sentient beings, is it possible for a period of time to exist in the future when all beings reach enlightenment? And in order to answer that question, there are three clarification points of clarification that need to be made. We need to have a view on reality, we need to examine what time is, and we also need to count the number of sentient beings. Is everybody happy with this so far?

Okay, good. So I’m gonna start off with the view of reality. Now the reason I put this up here is because in dialogues I’ve had with a number of people over different years, people come up with answers that were very much less than satisfied. Some people would say, oh well this is ridiculous because time is you know, a contingent phenomenon and in fact we’re enlightened anyway, we just don’t know it. So there you go.

But that doesn’t really solve the problem really for me, because I’m looking at it from a very conventional perspective. I’m treating the Sutras maybe not correctly, but I’m looking at them literally. So my question is from a conventional truth perspective can we answer this question rather than from some ultimate perspective. Also, I make some very basic assumptions from the Mahāyāna view which is essentially that all sentient beings have Buddha nature because we don’t assume that then we can’t have a situation where all beings reach enlightenment. Okay?

What is time? So this is another question I’d like to pose to yourselves. Anyone would like to have an answer? We’re going to answer. Yes sir.

Change. Change is a very good very good answer actually. Yes, change. Anyone else? So, part of what you mentioned, I’m actually going to deal with.

From a very, again Western perspective, whether there is beginningless time or not is irrelevant. What we want to do is work out what is time that we conceive as it. And so the quote that I’m going use is very similar to what the gentleman mentioned, is related to change. The first one is actually a throwaway comment that I got from a science fiction writer in the nineteen twenties whose name, I can’t recall right at this moment. I don’t believe in it, but I like the visual image it gives me.

Okay? So that’s this. Time, Time is what keeps everything from happening at once. The reason why I like that, because you can imagine where if there’s also time, there’s something everything just goes on like that, all in one split moment. So time is what ensures everything has a nominal place.

But in fact, generally speaking, when you ask people what is time, they’ll say time is actually movement. So what the gentleman referred to as change, in fact we need to go probably one step further and say well there needs to be a change of something and so what we need to look at is a course of events. So generally speaking, the way in which time is perceived is that there is a course of events and those events happen within time. Now, there are actually two main Western philosophic treatments of time which I’ll just briefly talk about and they’re not mutually exclusive and if one isn’t upheld doesn’t imply the other must be true. But essentially speaking, if you look at not only Western philosophy but also science, you can split time up between the views of Newtonian time and also that of Immanuel Kant and Lipsnitz.

So let me explain what those two are. So with Newtonian time, which you’re probably very familiar with, is that it’s actually dimension. We live in four dimensions and in fact if you look at modern physics it’s all built around these four dimensions. Even Einstein’s very famous you know theory of E equals mc2 etc. Time is very important and it basically ensures that it’s a measurement of the sequence of events.

Kant posed a very different type of view on what time is and it relates to what the lady mentioned there, which is basically it’s purely an intellectual intellectual construct made up by humans. There’s nothing that moves through time and time is not a container. So, you look at the English language and in fact, I will, I’m going to show you something that’s quite, I find remarkable anyway. It’s not my fill but I still find it very interesting. If you look at pretty much any language around the world, know, not any language.

If you look literally at any language around the world, time is something that we are in. So, I will wait until five p. M. Before I’m going home. I’m going to have dinner at eight.

I’ll wake up tomorrow at seven a. M. Whatever the case is, I have to wait till that time elapses. So, time is container that we will operate in. And people have taken this view right up until the present day that there’s not a single language in the world that doesn’t have time as a container.

So, going back to yesterday’s discussion about language, you could argue one of the universal principles that language has is that time is always present and is a container within the language. However, having said that and this is just by coincidence really, I was doing a quick search on the internet and I think this occurred in May. The Amondawa people were the first contacted outside the world in 1986. And researchers from the University of Portsmouth, this is in The US and the Federal Reserve in Bordonia, which is in Brazil, and this is in Brazil by the way in the Amazon Rainforest, have begun to analyze the idea of time as it appears in the language. And what they found out is that time doesn’t exist.

We’re really not saying that these people are without time or outside time, so they’re not time lords as part of you know the Doctor Who series or anything like that. Rather what we don’t find is a notion of time as being independent of the events which are occurring. They don’t have a notion of time which is something the events occur in. So this is quite phenomenal. It’s very interesting.

I mean I can’t imagine how I would even work in that language. But the idea is that when they talk it’s not that something will happen at a certain time, it’s that something will happen. So, they still perceive events, causal events occurring and they can still talk about the future, but it’s not as if there’s some overlapping container, some dimension of it, which is quite interesting. So again, it does disprove this theory that, at least in my opinion, that there is no single item you can pinpoint where there’s something universal about language. People did actually, and I did until just very recently, believed time was one example, But that in fact has now also been disproven.

So, I guess going back to the two philosophic treatments, I’m not dismissing Kant’s view because I think we can, we all have this impression that, it’s very hard to say, but whether animals actually perceive time or not is something that would be speculation, but we as humans do basically perceive as if time is a container, whether we like it or not, that’s how it basically is. And that is why basically what I think the majority that people follow is this concept of Newtonian time. So, is basically a measurement of a sequence of events and how you actually measure time is quite interesting. There’s a lot of research has gone into basically how do you determine what a second is. I don’t know if people know how it’s measured nowadays.

It’s based, I have to say I can’t remember myself exactly in detail, but it’s relating to the decay of particular atom or something like that. How fast it actually decays because it’s the most stable event. The problem is with time, how do you say what is one second? What do you use as the benchmark? And in fact is there isn’t really any benchmark you can use, it’s quite interesting in that respect.

Okay, so for our purposes, we’ve covered two of the three things I need to look at. The first is a view on reality. We’re assuming that we’re just perceiving everything as being as they are. We’re not making any further judgment calls on that. In regards to time, we’re going to say that it’s linear, unidirectional and basically a dimension that we exist in.

So people would say, hang on the second Einstein show that time is not linear and you know, etc, etc, etc. Really just going back to the premise, what I want to do is be able to construct a model that shows, as I mentioned before, that it’s possible for all sentient beings which are infinite in number, to reach enlightenment. And from my background, from a modeling background, when you create assumptions, you want those assumptions to be preferably the most restrictive as possible. And this would be the most restrictive possibility for defining time. If we allow time to go back, so it’s multi directional, we can go back in time through some wormhole, etcetera.

It doesn’t dismiss the credibility of the model. In fact, it makes it even easier to prove. So the best thing to do when you pick out assumptions is making this restrictive as possible and less preferable as possible in the sense of making the model not work. If you can do that, then it becomes more robust. Okay.

So the number of sentient beings, I’m going to spend a little bit of time on this because other than showing you this model, it leads to a couple of other very interesting conclusions. There’s a class of questions which can be answered all at once, which I only realized this through my discussions with Khensur Rinpoche, and as I mentioned, took me a couple months to realize this. Okay, so the number of sentient beings. How many sentient beings are there? And the answer is that they’re infinite.

The problem that we come to is that there are a number of different types of infinities. So, let me ask you this question first of all, and this is, I know this is a metaphorical description, but nevertheless I’ve read somewhere and I have to say, if I was one of my students I’d mark them down because I haven’t actually cited where I got this reference from. But as many grains, there’s number of, the number of sentient beings are as many grains of sand as there are in the Ganges River. So, first of all, can we count the number of grains of sand in the Ganges River? We can estimate, but I go one step further.

I’m saying if we really applied ourselves, we could, we could. There’s nothing stopping us getting every single grain of sand and counting it. I know it sounds ludicrous, but it is possible, right? It is feasible. So, and is it infinite in number?

It’s finite. Is everybody happy with those terms? There’s a definite number. Okay, so what I’ve written down here is that there it’s both countable and finite. Everyone happy with that?

Okay, next one. As long as the Ganges River. And I’ve got, there’s a multiple choice question. So, a third of you will get it right hopefully even if you purely guess it, alright? So, is it 800 kilometers, 2,500 or infinite?

See I hear a few people saying B. 800. I had, I was very fortunate when I was a child and I lived in many different countries and for those of you who have never been to India, I would say it’s one place you should go. Not necessarily for a holiday, but just to open up your eyes. It’s an amazing place and I only took two pictures.

This is obviously at the start of it and this is further down. I don’t know what city that is. Well, the answer is and I actually to say this is I didn’t really calculate this correctly. I thought it might be a slightly high number. All all of these answers can be true.

Sorry? Has tributaries. Well, yes, it has tributaries. That’s true. But ignoring that as well and you might have heard this before.

So this is quite a Yes, sir. Yes. Well, okay. Let’s let’s go back. So, with regards to to this quote here, I really don’t like it.

I think it’s a metaphorical quote. You shouldn’t take it literally. Obviously, the number of sentient beings everywhere else I have seen has been referred to in other ways that would indicate it’s definitely infinite. So, I’m just put this in here to actually illustrate that this is both countable and finite. Is that okay with you?

So, what I’m wanting to do actually through these examples and show different types of infinities which I’ll just come on to now. So, how can all these three be correct? Well, you’ve probably heard of this term, how long is a piece of string? So here I’ve got a piece of string and if I measure it from the start to the finish, it’ll be, I don’t know, it looks like maybe fifty, sixty cent centimeters, something like that. But if I held one end and pulled it down, would it become longer?

Yes. This has been a problem that’s caused wars in fact and with when demographers try to work out the length of a river, it becomes extremely difficult. Because for example, the reason why I put this picture here, you can see that it’s it’s meandering, it’s waving. Well I can get my my ruler and put a big fat line right down the middle. Right?

That would be one measurement of it. An alternative would be to actually literally get a piece of string and follow that river down. And that become much more longer. In fact, I can’t remember what two countries it was, happenings in Latin America where part of the borders between two countries was determined by the split between the river. And so, the both, geographers from both sides of these two countries measured their land perimeters, and they came up with vastly different numbers.

And the reasons being of course, one took a very crude measure to stuck a ruler, and the other basically tried to do a measurement of it. So they started having a bickering debate about, well how long is our borders and what are you trying to steal from us. So it can be a very tricky phenomenon here. So the reason why I so put down infinite is because at the limit, if you actually measure every single little crevice and turn, you’ll be going on infinitely measuring the length of the river. And I can prove this in another way, because some of you might say, oh no, that’s not true.

There is a definite length. So, I’m gonna show you another way of doing immeasurable as the space in the sky. So going back to the lady there, you mentioned about space. Can we count space? No.

So in mathematical terms we call this uncountable and it may be infinite. There’s a debate in physics whether the universe is bounded or not. I’m gonna leave that aside. It’s not my area of expertise. But what I want to do is show something again that where infinities actually surround us all over the place and we don’t even know it.

Which is quite amazing really because again we perceive things as being solid and finite when in fact they are actually infinite. And here’s a very classic example that people show this in first year math sometimes just to prove a very simple point. And I promise there was no maths in this presentation, but I lied. I’ve got a couple of little, a little math questions here. So here I’ve got a square box and each side has two meters in length.

Can someone tell me what’s this area or what’s the size of the area of this box? Four. Is everyone happy with that? Okay, it’s four. Thank you.

Very good. Excellent. You pass. What about the perimeter size? Eight.

Is everyone happy with that? So it’s going to be two, four, six, eight. Okay, very good. What happens though if I change things slightly and instead of saying I’ve got a perfect lines. I actually have a box that looks like this.

It still has two meters in length and width, what’s its area? This is not a trick question by the way. You can get this one right. What’s its area? Four.

It’s still four square meters, right? What is its perimeter length? It’s changed. Has gone up or down? It’s gone up, right?

I’m gonna take it to the limit. Imagine for every these, every part of these zigs and zags, there’s another zig and zag in between that and another one inside that. If that’s the case, what’s the length of the perimeter? And this is true, this is mathematically correct. It’s immeasurable, it’s infinite.

So, very interestingly, yes ma’am. That’s alright. No, that’s what’s phenomenally interesting. Yes, but every zig that goes up is counteracted by the zag that goes in. I agree with you, but what I’m saying, because I’m a very poor drawer here, is that for If we were, for example, to zoom into this little bit here, you’d actually have this.

And if I zoom into, well, I zoom into that bit there, I’d have again more zags and zigs. If that makes sense. And it goes on infinitely. If you have that, you can stretch out that that piece of string if you try to mold it infinitely, it would never end. So this is a simple proof and this is the case for most items.

The chair that you’re sitting on, the mat that’s on the floor, which is very good example because it’s rectangular in shape, looks like you can definitely measure the area of it, which you can very easily, but if you were to measure every single little string that sticks out, etc, it will very likely, or it would have an infinite perimeter. So the reason I put that in is to highlight that basically infinity surround us all over the place, and we don’t even realize it. And you can lead mathematically, this is definitely correct. This is no, you know, magical trick or anything. This is a a fact that basically, perimeters can have an infinite length, but the size with inside it can be finite.

Okay, so in the example here what I’ve got is a what you could say basically is an infinite perimeter, but the size of the area is definitely finite. Okay, good. So, I’m going to go one step further now and this is exploring some maths that, and again I’m not really going to do anything in detail, that was devised in the late eighteen hundred’s by a gentleman called George Cantor. And he created what we refer to as set theory and in fact the elementary number theory that all started from him really. So it’s basically in the last one hundred and fifty years that we actually understand how numbers interesting.

There is some mathematics that can be traced back to some Indian Hindu texts. Probably in around year 200, but I can’t know if I pronounce it correctly, Isha Upanishad, something like that. Basically, there are some mathematical texts that explain some very interesting items about infinity, but it was never really developed outside of the religion. So I sort of leave it aside. What I want to highlight, and this is very crucial again to the result I’m gonna get.

I’ve got to see what I don’t carry a watch with me. This is my little mobile. Okay, good. So if I have to work out a couple of things that I need to show you later on, there’s one thing we have to determine is that there are also different, not only is there different types of infinities, you can have what are called countable and uncountable infinities, but there are different sizes. So the classic example I’m going to show is with numbers.

Everybody’s happy counting to five? Very good. So, these are integers right? Integers we refer to as whole numbers. In other words it’s just like whole number.

Is there a largest whole number? No, we can go on forever and ever, right? Okay. Can we count to these? We can count them, right?

So, what we will say is that whole numbers, integers are countable and infinite. So everyone happy with that idea? We can count these numbers, but they are infinite. So it’s gonna take us an infinite amount of time to count them. However, there are also numbers which are uncountable and here’s an example of one and these would be real numbers.

In between the number one and the number two, there is a countless number of other numbers in between them. If we use decimal places. So for example, I could put down 0.001, 1.0002 and so forth, right? But in fact I could go back as many decimal places as I like. The point I’m trying to illustrate here is that between the number one and number two, there’s also an infinite number of what we call rational real numbers.

Is everybody happy with that? So, here we have a situation where we’ve got two infinities. One infinity are an infinite set of whole numbers. One, two, three, four, five up to infinity. I’ve also got another set of infinities, which are numbers that go into decimals.

They’re not countable because I don’t even know how to start them off. Now, which one is bigger? A or B? B. Can everyone see that?

B is definitely bigger than A. We’ve now proven that one infinity can be larger than another. Is everybody happy with that idea? Again. B bigger than A?

B is bigger than A because within Are you happy here with with whole numbers? One, two, three, four, five. Okay, so this is a set. We call these sets a whole set of numbers which are whole. They don’t have decimal places.

In between the number one and two though, I can create another set. That set are sets of decimal places, and I can go back infinitesimally small in terms of the number of decimal places I take it to. So between the number one and number two, there’s an infinite set there. Does that that sort of make sense? Between two and three there’s an infinite set.

Between three and four. So my question then is, which infinite set is larger? A or B? B by default must be larger. Can everyone see that?

It sounds a bit you know, a bit perplexing. In fact, this is high level mathematics. In fact, when you start doing the proofs it’s not that easy. Intuitively the way I’m proving it sounds quite straightforward, but actually to prove it takes a number of other steps. But basically, there you go.

You’ve it, we’ve now basically got to a stage where we can show that one infinity is larger than another. Okay, good. So we’re gonna set that aside for the moment and move on. So if you have any questions, just shout out. Yeah.

That’s alright. Very, very, very good. Very insightful and I’ll come back to your point later on. It’s a very good point. So, you say you’re not very good at maths but what you’ve mentioned there is very insightful, definitely.

Okay. So really what I wanted to show you there is that a set of integers are countable and infinite, while the set of real numbers are uncountable infinite. Actually I don’t care less about integers and real numbers, they’re just as an example. What I wanted to show you is that some infinities we can count and others that we can’t. So, for our purposes, so when I say for our purposes, it’s an assumption I’m making.

Sentient beings are accountable infinite set. And the reason why I say they’re countable is because we can literally count. Now I know you’re saying well that’s you know you can’t count the number of bacteria if we believe bacteria also have you know occlusions, etcetera, etcetera. But the fact is, well, if we put our minds to it, we could really. Okay?

It is possible to count. Can we count space? The answer is no. So that uncountable, right? So there’s a differential there.

Same with real numbers, they’re uncountable because we don’t know where to start, yes? Integers, are they the whole numbers? They’re the whole numbers, they’re the whole numbers. So we’ll, I won’t ever refer to them again, I just needed them as an example. For time we’re going to say it’s infinite.

It may or may not be countable. This is quite interesting from also from my field of research. I deal with what’s referred to as discrete time series analysis. It’s very hard to work out even from a physics perspective whether time is continuous or discrete. It looks to us as humans as if time just moves like a smooth, you know, silky.

You can’t say where one point ends and the other finishes. But in fact, we can’t prove that. So whether we use time as being countable, like oh here’s a moment, here’s another one, here comes another one, that’s what we call discrete. Or we say it’s continuous, one moment doesn’t, just blends into the other basically. Actually is sort of immaterial to the conclusions I get.

So I put down it may or may not be countable. It doesn’t really make much difference. Okay, so now I take a bit of a leap of faith. And the reason I’m doing this is because what I want to do is actually come to the crux of the answer. And because I’m not showing any maths, I have to try to show the ideas intuitively.

So if I, if it sounds a little bit more vague than what I’ve been about before, I apologize and just please speak up and I’ll try to explain. So, the solution I’ve come to uses something called fluid dynamics and in fact in particular there’s a set of equations which are referred to as the Navier Stokes equations. There are a number of equations in mathematics. These are diff they’re called differential equations. And these equations explain how fluid moves.

So probably the best example is, hopefully this will work. I’ve got a little applet here. We go. Let’s see if that works. There we go.

Okay. You’ve probably seen this as a screen saver. Did everyone see that? Basically, this looks like water. A wave, so I say droplets in a a steel tank basically fading away.

How do we actually generate these these very nice pictures? Well they actually come from these differential equations that were developed about a hundred years Navier and Stokes worked out a way to explain how droplets of water would diffuse over time. The thing is, like most significant mathematical theorems, actually haven’t proved how they actually function in this example in three dimensions. I won’t go into too much detail, but essentially speaking, it actually forms one of what’s referred to as the clay, the Clay Millennium Institute prize. If you solve this question, you get a million dollars.

So there you go. In fact, of the seven questions that have been posed, only one has been solved by, basically by a Russian who lives in St. Petersburg. He’s quite mad. He lives with his mother and doesn’t mean that you’re mad if you live with your mother, but he’s about 50 years old.

He used to work for the University of St. Petersburg. Basically relinquished his position. He was entitled to the million dollars for another problem set that he solved and some other things he’s turned everything down. So he lives in abject poverty and he works just by himself.

And what he’s focusing on at the moment is something very interesting. I won’t go into too much detail because it’s a side issue. He’s trying to measure the in three dimension space of cylindrical objects and it’s proven impossible to do. So basically he’s trying to measure what he refers to as emptiness, but I’m not trying to relate that to the concepts of emptiness in Buddhism, but there is an interesting phenomena with trying to measure space and it becomes very impossible to do. So there you go.

So what my purpose I use this for is actually to derive the solution. And I’ll explain it a number of ways and you can do through as I mentioned, a continuous process or a discrete process. I’m more happy with discrete processes, so I’ll explain how that would work. Let’s say you start off with one enlightened being. And this is a very simple way of explaining it.

And that enlightened being is able to ensure that two other sentient beings that he or she comes in contact with also becomes enlightened. So that will be represented by these two points here. And if each of those also are able to to ensure that that they are able to get two people, two beings to become enlightened, then you’ve basically got four and the number grows exponentially. In fact, this is referred to as a binomial model, where you only have to allow two, two objectives to occur from a single point. Can everyone see that basically what you have, and some people call it a binomial train, this is an elaboration actually, it doesn’t really look like this, but it gives you a good context of what’s happening.

You can actually end up with numerous different types of outcomes just from one point. And in fact, in the field of research that I work in which is in derivatives, which basically sort of led to the global financial crisis I might add. We actually use these mathematics to actually what we call backward induce the price of what we call options today for what they will be in the future. I should point out they never work out very well, but that’s what we do. So, another example of what I’m trying to give a feeling for without going through the maths, is you might have heard of this concept of six degrees of separation.

It’s been proven physically. There’s actually a documentary that was done on it. You can find at this point in time at least, anybody else around the world through contacts that you know of or that someone that you know of or someone that someone that you know of know of. So in other words basically, if you want to get in contact with someone who lives in Outer Mongolia in a small village, it is possible by passing that letter to a friend of yours, a colleague of yours, who can then pass it to someone else, and after six transfers, you’ll be able to deliver it to that person. And that’s actually been proven physically.

And there’s a lot of research that goes into this is relating to what’s called network theory. Again, something that I won’t talk too much about. Another thing you might have heard on TV is YouTube videos that go viral. How do you have a situation where one or two people watching a YouTube clip and then suddenly the whole of the world is basically focusing on it, and that’s at least how it would come across. And basically it relates to basic, to essentially how information transfers at a very rapid place, if it’s not hindered.

With the flow of fluid in the example I gave you before, you saw there was a dissipation. That means eventually the water tank would settle. If there is no resistance, then the ripples will actually grow larger and larger and develop into a tsunami. Of course, we have resistance due to gravity and general dissipation in the world. In the model that I devised, and I do actually have a handout here where I did try to again simplify it, but I did go through a little bit more of the mathematics.

So if you’re interested, you’re welcome to pick it up after. A model whereby there is no resistance. Now, you could argue there is some resistance. One of the things that sort of I find interesting, the fact that basically as time goes by, adverse karma is compounded. There’s more karma than there was ten days ago or than there was a billion years ago.

So you could argue, that might be a resistance factor. That as time goes by, there’s more karma which causes issues with basically in reaching enlightenment. But I sort of left that out because it wasn’t necessarily essential to the whole argument. Okay, so there’s just a couple more slides and I’ll see you on do for I’ve got ten minutes, so that’s alright. This is another way of picturing it and again I won’t go into too much discussion of the actual model.

Here on this flat line, I’ve got time. And as the lady pointed out, time has is beginningless and also endless. There’s no reason why to say there’s there’s an end of time if there’s also beginningless time. So this line actually just goes on back to the left forever and ever and ever. Also, there always has to be a point where there is at least one enlightened being.

So in beginning of this time there is an enlightened being. So if I have on my what we call vertical axis, the proportion, the percentage of sentient beings that are enlightened, it’ll vary between 0100%. So what Y referred to as zero and one. You always have to ensure that it never reaches zero in beginning this time. So, again, I won’t go into too much detail.

Asymptotically, at the limit it derives to beta, which basically means you always have a fraction of being which are enlightened. That’s all that we need to know of. But very interestingly, as long as there’s no resistance, you can actually reach an infinite point in time where here things grow exponentially, where all beings can be enlightened. And I said before, I’m not going through the mathematics, I’d just rather provide an intuition behind it. This is actually something quite interesting.

What it’s saying is that you can reach an infinity within a finite space of time. That’s what it’s basically saying. And using the assumptions that I’ve gone through in this presentation, basically, which more or less adhere the very minimal assumptions that are required. It is possible for all sentient beings, which are limitless in number, to reach enlightenment at a finite period of time. So, at that point in time, I thought, okay, well this is good.

So, this thing’s at least put my mind at rest a little bit before, because you have to remember before I said, well you can’t reach an infinity. In fact, you can. It can be proven. So then I went to Kensal Rinpoche and I decided, well let me go one step further, let me try my luck. And I thought, why can’t I work out if I know how generally the shape of the, and this is basically beings reach enlightenment.

Of course, it’s not going to be something like this, but essentially it’s just a graphical illustration. If I can work out two reference points, that means two points in time working out the proportion of sentient beings that are enlightened to those which are not enlightened, I can actually derive where we are in time and when all beings will be enlightened. Of course, I knew this, I wasn’t going to get an answer for it, but I thought well what the heck, I may as well try my luck. So off I go Tenzing actually translated for me, thank you very much, and we had a bit of a debate about a number of issues because one of the other things I wasn’t sure of about whether there are infinite number of beings because the infinity that we use mathematically is very different from what I think the Tibetan language utilized. So, we didn’t really end up with any conclusion, at least I thought from discussion.

But what Khensur Rinpoche told me was the following. For every enlightened being there is a Buddha and you might have heard this before. In fact, you know for every atom there is a Buddha, anything where you look around there is a Buddha inside you could say and to me that really ruined everything. And I sort of walked away thinking okay this is gonna mess everything up. Why does it ruin everything?

If the proportion of enlightened beings increases relative to the unenlightened, how can there be one to one relationship? So remember, I’m saying back here, there’s a point in time where there’d be 90% of all beings being enlightened, right? And 10% being unenlightened. Because as time goes by, more and more beings are becoming enlightened. So you got a point in time where there’s only a few left at which will then you know also become enlightened, reach Buddhahood.

So that can’t, to me at least when I first thought about it, couldn’t be the case If there’s always one Buddha for every enlightened being. And it was only I have to say some weeks ago that I actually worked out in a perfect sense. So I would This is the last thing that I’ll explain for today. The And way to do that is through what’s called Hilbert’s Grand Hotel. So we’ll start off with a standard hotel and this hotel only has actually three rooms.

And all three rooms are occupied and a person shows up and would like to be accommodated. Can this hotel accommodate? Not a trick question. No, right? It can’t, right?

If there are three persons already or three groups of people already in these hotel rooms then the next person that comes along unfortunately is going to be very unhappy and have to be walked away. But Hilbert actually created a grand hotel, a very special hotel. And this hotel has an infinite number of rooms. And he put outside on his, you know, on the lawn a notice saying there are no vacancies, but guests are welcome. And the reason being is as follows.

You walk up to the reception reception and say I’d like a room and Hilbert goes well they’ve got a problem. All my rooms are actually full. But don’t worry. I’ve got an idea. I’ll move the person that’s in Room 1 to Room 2.

Room 2 to Room 3. Room 3 to Room 4 etc, etc, etc. Right up into infinity. And so Room 1 will become vacant. So there I’ll be actually be able to accommodate you.

The next day Hilbert actually has a coach load of tourists arrive. But this coach is also special. You have to excuse my drawings here. This coach is very special because actually it has an infinite number passengers in it. And the infinite number passengers arrive at the reception and Hilbert you know is exhausted working at how he’s going to deal with all of them, but at the same time you know thinking oh well this is going to be good money for me, so I definitely want to find a way of accommodating them.

He ponders a little bit and then comes out with a solution. Because he’s already got a fully occupied hotel, right? I’ll move the person that’s in Room 1 to Room 2. Room 2 to Room 4. Room 3 to Room 6.

What I’m doing here is multiplying every number by the number of two. Whenever I multiply a number by two, I get an even number, right? What the upshot of all this is, is I’ll end up with all odd numbered rooms being vacant. How many odd numbered rooms does Hilbert have? An infinite number.

So basically, this coach load of infinite number of passengers and tourists can be accommodated within Hilbert’s hotel. The reason why I’ve given this example is because Hilbert, and this is in the late eighteen hundreds, showed mathematically, if we put it in in in mathematical terms, infinite sets have subsets of the same cardinality. What does that mean? It means that if you have an infinite it’s quite difficult to explain actually.

If you have, probably going back to the numbers that we looked at before. Let’s say the circle represents all the numbers, all real numbers, so that basically are decimals. Plus also whole numbers. Is everyone happy with that? So, all real numbers include integers, include whole numbers.

If I just look at the subset, the subset of these real numbers would be whole numbers, so the numbers two and four for example. They are also infinite. Is everybody happy with that? It is possible to align every single whole number with a real number for an infinite period of time. Well, for infinitely and beyond.

What it’s basically saying is something that sounds very counterintuitive. You have two infinities, one infinity is larger than the other, but nevertheless you can put one by the side of the other. So in other words, the whole argument about whether there are infinite sets, infinite number of sentient beings or not, basically, is proven by the fact that it’s also said that for every enlightened being, for every unenlightened being there’s a Buddha. For every atom there is a Buddha. That by default proves there’s an infinite set of infinite sentient beings and also that they also can reach enlightenment.

So the whole class of questions that relate to infinities within Buddhism, at least the way I see it, can be answered through this. Which is phenomenal because just to remember, these statements were obviously made thousands of years ago, yet the proofs of this have only been realized in the last hundred and fifty years, which is quite interesting. So the final thing that I will mention that I also find quite interesting that the model gives is that there are two states that that the, I won’t call it, saṃsāra, I won’t even use that word, that this can be in. So, a state where, where the model, how should I say it can be in. A state where some beings are not enlightened and a state where all beings are enlightened.

I’ve done various calculations with my colleague in mass and basically what it turns up is that the model returns for most of the time, sentient beings will spend half of their time in a state of enlightenment and half of their time in a state of unenlightenment. But because you’re dividing infinities, you can go one step further and actually argue that all beings spend an infinite amount of time in both a state of enlightenment and an enlightenment. Which I find quite amazing. So there you go. And that’s the end of my talk.

Thank you very much. Thank you. Yes. Sorry? I didn’t explain that primarily through lack of time, but essentially speaking, because you can count sentient beings, set that we’re looking at is all sentient beings whether enlightened or not.

The subsets are unenlightened and enlightened beings. Because that they are subsets of the same, there you can count them on a one to one basis. Basis. This is the way to look at it. This is all sentient beings and you have let’s say unenlightened and enlightened.

Because and you have to, you have to, you just have to go with this unfortunately. Because they are subsets of an infinite set, they are also infinite. And so you can always place them on a one to one basis. Even if there’s only 1% of beings left which are unenlightened, it’s infinite, you can still count them put them next to a Buddha, one for one. Hopefully that answers your question.

Thank you. Thank you for listening. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top