TBI Symposium – Seminar Session 2 (1 – HHDL

1 h 25 min · 11,230 words

TBI Symposium (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Symposium (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Symposium - Seminar Session 2 (1 - HHDL
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The speaker teaches the Buddhist truth of suffering, covering the three sufferings, the eightfold and sixfold subdivisions of suffering, and the mechanics of subtle impermanence drawn from physics and Abhidharma. He also explains the four features of karma, why karma increases over time and why prayer for others cannot remove it. The talk ends with a long question and answer session and advice on committing to Buddhist practice, including taking refuge in the teachings.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 25m

UUID: 6651619a-cd1e-41f7-9f03-84c615636f02

Words: 11,226

Yes. So if you have problems with your roommate or with your partner, that’s not saṃsāra. The suffering which arises from that, the afflictions, that is saṃsāra. If you get a parking ticket that is not saṃsāra. Right?

So we hear saṃsāra used in a very very mistaken way in Buddhist centers. So within cyclic existence the foremost truth we’re trying to escape from is a truth of suffering. And here it is interesting that there are some philosophers who have come really to a Buddhist position without sharing any aspect of Buddhist culture and one I like very much is a French philosopher, He says, from this standpoint, Buddhist first noble truth which teaches that all life is suffering, seems alas to correspond to our experience far better in the teachings of the different monotheisms. Suffering is measured as unhappiness is measured as in the marvelous book, The Spirit of Atheism. I think it’s translated in English now.

The Little Book of Atheistic Spirituality. Then it is interesting because this is someone who comes to an understanding of some of the core Buddhist principles from a totally non Buddhist secular perspective. And I think this gives a lot of corroboration to the fact that it is really a given reality. If you have a fair bit of life experience, these sort of teachings don’t really appeal to the young. But if you have a fair bit of life experience, that life is ultimately of the late nature of suffering is something which resonates.

It does resonate. Now, the definition of the noble truth of suffering in Geshe Gyeltsab’s Namshe Nyingpo, the first volume on the perfections, is it is a truth from the standpoint of the thoroughly afflicted, in other words it’s not a truth, right? It’s called a truth but it’s not a truth, which is differentiated by being specified by the four and these are the four features of the first noble truth, impermanent suffering, the emptiness of a self of other objects and the selflessness of persons. This is obviously a Mahāyāna presentation of the Noble Truth of suffering because reference is made to the selflessness of phenomena. And here we will only talk of the two first characteristics.

We’ll talk of selflessness probably at the end of next year. We’ll finish a presentation of definite emergence this year, cover bodhichitta and the three principles of the path for most of next year and start talking of selflessness and emptiness at the end of next year. And in this respect, I will heavily emphasize definite emergence, bodhichitta and an understanding of impermanence and I will deemphasize an understanding of emptiness in the view because I think it is not realistic to hope for an understanding of emptiness in a context like ours in Buddhist centers. One can gain a beginning of an understanding but an understanding of impermanence is much more powerful and beneficial for the mind and there is far less risk involved in it. The last time we spoke of coarse impermanence as you remember, in other words death.

And I said that when we speak of impermanence we must distinguish between course and subtle impermanence. Teachings and course impermanence are part of the path shared with the being of the small scope. And you remember I asked you, what teachings on subtle impermanence would be part of? They are part of the past shared with the being of the middling scope because it is one of the four characteristics the Four Noble Truths. And simply it is much more difficult to understand, or it was in the past, more difficult to understand subtle impermanence and coarse impermanence.

A normal person understands coarse impermanence, death, just through the experiences of life. Then subtle impermanence up to let’s say two three centuries ago with the advent of modern technology and modern science was very difficult to understand. Without microscopes, without the basics of modern physics, it’s very difficult to explain to the only person that this world changes instant by instant. It is not something that person will accept. So coarse impermanence is therefore a subset of impermanence.

All composite phenomena change instant by instant and that instant by instant change leads eventually to the destruction of the phenomenon considered what we know as the cessation of the continuum. That is coarse impermanence. So it is precisely because my body is changing instant by instant and has been doing so for fifty five years, fifty four years plus nine months that in a couple years hopefully, you know, quite a few couple years but there’s no guarantee, this body is going to disappear. Now the disappearance of this body is an inevitable consequence of this body’s change instant by instant and every one of us in this room is in exactly the same situation. So I’d like to draw now a little bit on physics to understand subtle impermanence and first to try to understand the maximal rate of change which is physically possible and we have to introduce some concepts.

First, the shortest distance known in physics, actually the shortest distance possible, so called Planck length. I won’t inflict the numbers on you but it is infinitesimal. It’s 10 minus 20 times the diameter of a proton. Now according to quantum physics this is the shortest possible dimension in the universe for a variety of reasons and this shortest dimension enables us to define the shortest period of time which is Planck time. Planck time is five and some by 10 minus forty four seconds so it’s basically 44 zeros followed by five.

Now what is extremely interesting is that all this is the shortest interval of time possible. The shortest interval of time measured is far greater. Approximately 10 followed by thirty zero times greater. And when it comes to our experience of change, our experience of change is an experience which is far closer than this. So what we have in other words is a universe which potentially could be changing much faster than the present rate of change known.

And our observation of the rate of change is even slower than that. And that’s of considerable interest for us. And we have a beginning of an understanding, excuse me, of the rate of change which we can perceive, which is known as the fusion threshold. The fusion threshold is the interval of time between two sensory signals after which they appear as inseparable and it depends on the sense concerned. So the fusion threshold for sight, for hearing are different.

But what is shocking is that the fusion threshold is incredibly high compared to the actual rate of change. For the visual consciousness it’s approximately twenty to thirty milliseconds. So you would have that you can see that with electrical light, basically 50 instances of change per second is close to the fusion threshold. That’s why neon is so unpleasant, coarse neon is so unpleasant with the eye because it’s close to the fusion threshold. Can see something is happening.

Anything which changes faster than 50 times a second seems continuous to the eye. With hearing, the fusion threshold is far lower. Two to five milliseconds. So we can distinguish sounds separated by only two to five milliseconds. And if we put this in a chart, you can see that there is a huge filtering process going on, with a maximum physical rate of change is approximately one, a couple of changes every ten minus forty four seconds and we perceive changes occurring between two and thirty milliseconds at a time.

Now this figure two to thirty milliseconds is an empirical figure. It’s very recent research on the fusion threshold and what becomes very interesting is when we look at Abhidharma. Keep in mind that the ancient Buddhist practitioners did not have access to laboratories. So if we look at Abhidharma Kosha, Vayabhashika defines the shortest interval of time called the Ksana, the instant, as one sixty fifth of the time it takes for a strong man to snap his fingers. Then I thought I would measure.

I’m reasonably strong, splitting wood helps. So I snapped my fingers continuously as quickly as I could. Alright and measured the duration. I could do 31 finger snaps in ten seconds, which means you have zero thirty one complete snaps. So the snap occurs and the fingers move back to their position.

Right? Then you have to divide this figure by two because time is wasted in the backwards motion of the fingers. We assume it takes the same time. So we have approximately zero one seconds for the actual finger snap. You divide by 65 and you get 1.5 ms which is precisely the fusion threshold for the auditory sense, two milliseconds.

This is quite extraordinary because Abhidharma Kosha was composed around let’s say the fifth century And when Abhidhamma Kosha teaches that the most of the rate of change is one sixty fifth of a finger snap, what it is teaching is the fusion threshold for the ear sense, which seems to be the shortest fusion threshold there is. And this is one of the numerous elements which really corroborates, I would say, the scientific foundations of Buddhism. The attempt to gain a scientific empirical understanding of phenomena. And fundamentally from our standpoint what matters is a fusion threshold. The actual rate of change of phenomena is neither here nor there, we cannot perceive it.

Now, the second characteristic of the first noble truth is suffering. And we must distinguish as you know three types of suffering. The suffering of suffering which will be the suffering of cancer. The suffering of change which is what we know as happiness. And all pervasive suffering which is the suffering of existing as ordinary beings.

The first suffering is easy to understand, everyone recognizes pain as suffering. If you don’t, then excuse me but you need some help. Then the second one poses major problems. Typically non Buddhists view it as a sign of obduracy from Buddhists to assert that all pleasant experiences are the nature of suffering and the best cases it’s just a form of verbal allegiance. And then to assert that existence is suffering is seen as ridiculous.

It is precisely because we don’t understand this that core aspects of the teaching do not resonate with us. So we have to first get a sense of what we are talking about when we talk of pleasures and this is my own hierarchy of pleasure, very simple one. At the bottom of the list we have the animal pleasures which are basically mediated by limbic neural mechanisms. Nature forces us to find certain things pleasant because otherwise we do not reproduce, that’s the case of sexuality, we die of starvation, or we do not get rid of our waste matter, urination and defecation. Therefore, all of these are made pleasant so that we engage in them.

Otherwise, if it was not pleasant to have children, no one would have children. It’s a huge burden. It is made pleasant and numerous fantasies are erected around that just to encourage people to enter into that. And above this we have the social pleasures which we find among the apes. Social pleasures such as grooming conversation and then specifically human experiences of pleasure, abstract intellectual pleasures and the highest form of pleasure which is meditative equipoise Samādhi.

This is the most difficult pleasure to counter. It’s a pleasure which I think scientists experience. Some mathematicians describe the discovery of a new theorem which calls for extraordinary levels of concentration and analysis which we would call insight as a blissful experience. Now these are all pleasures and the question is, if we look at our own life, how we can understand the Buddhist presentation of suffering. So I plotted here time in abscissa and intensity of painful stimuli inordinate and this is just one possible human experience.

The intensity of painful stimuli increases and this is actually directly perceived as a suffering of suffering. When the intensity of painful stimuli is more or less constant, this is a neutral sensation. When the intensity of painful stimuli decreases sharply, this is happiness, the suffering of change. The faster the rate of decrease, the greater the happiness. Then the whole process begins again with neutral sensation, an experience of suffering.

Again, the sharper the increase, the greater the suffering. A decrease, the sharper the decrease, the greater the happiness. This is the Buddhist understanding of the two first sufferings. The suffering of suffering and the suffering of change. Now, for the suffering of suffering it seems pretty self evident.

For the suffering of change is this valid? Is all pleasure just a reduction of suffering? We can see already if we pinch ourselves or if you want to turn this into a group experiment get a strong friend to pinch you. Then as he pinches the pain increases, right? This is an increase in the suffering of suffering.

If he stops pinching quite suddenly there’s a sensation of great relief. The more sudden the cessation of pain the greater the sensation of relief. This relief is happiness. There’s nothing else than that. Now here we’re talking of physical suffering.

The same thing is true mentally. For instance, I don’t know, mean, Christophe studied engineering, some of you have been to university, we had a when I went to university we had a very heavy load of examinations. I know that you would just you would put yourself on this regimen preparing for the exams, you know, just at one point I had 16 I remember, one year, you know. You just go from exam to exam to exam to exam and when it stopped there was an extraordinary feeling of happiness. It’s just like you just went like the world was beautiful and the grass was green and everyone was kind.

I think you remember that. Okay that is the suffering of change. Suffering has ceased, it has ceased very brutally and as a result we experience this as happiness. Now when we take this chart and we throw in an additional factor which is a pain threshold, you can see how this corresponds to our daily experience. This is a threshold of attention.

So in daily life, our minds filter out a majority of pleasant and unpleasant sensations just to enable us to function. We are not aware of everything. As a result, everything which is beneath the pain threshold is just not noticed, it’s inattentive. When it, and is basically neutral, right, When a stimuli rises above the threshold of attention, it is perceived as pain, a neutral experience, and a sharp decrease is perceived as pleasure. Here you can see the pain would be less than here, simply because the rate of increase is less than here.

These two experiences of pleasure are approximately identical and this chart explains why when people engage in mindfulness meditation, one of the first experiences they have is one of great physical pain. If anyone of you has done a mindfulness retreat, Satipatthana retreat, you will have seen that within minutes of sitting down your entire body starts itching. And the more you train in mindfulness the greater the itch. Now the mindfulness is not causing this itch to appear what happens is that the threshold of an attention if you wish has dropped and pre existing itchiness has become apparent. Now probably, it’s my private opinion, mindfulness for westerners is the best way to gain a foothold in Buddhism because when you focus in this way on your experience you can really see that your core experience is one of suffering.

The body is suffused with suffering. The mind is suffused with suffering. What we think of as happiness is a reduction of the suffering. Either physical or mental. And this enables us to understand what all pervasive suffering is.

All pervasive suffering is all of this. It is the fact that we pass from increases in suffering which are understood as suffering, to decreases in suffering which are understood as happiness, to neutral states which are states in between. Then Comte Bonville, French philosopher, he’s a very sharp man. I think he never saw this chart, don’t think he did because it’s my own but he said this is what life is for the neutral spots. He said the rest is awful and this is someone with a very good mind.

It’s a very very good mind This goes a long way to explain the pleasure of music which caused me problems for a long time when I was young. If you listen to music why is it beautiful? Yes but music itself. Yes, you could even be more precise than that. All music is about the ordinance of discordance and concordance.

Discordance is physically or utterly painful. If you have anyone who has done music you play Re and Mi together, what is it in the English notation? D and E together on the piano. It’s a discordant chord, right? I I see Joe has some experience.

Okay. It is discordant. It’s unpleasant to hear. The longer it lasts the more the pain increases. The unpleasantness increases until you have a resolution of the chord.

The resolution from disharmony into harmony generates a sensation of pleasure. The greater the discordance and the longer it lasts the greater the pleasure. Which is just a cessation of pain. You have to ask them what the experience is. I I have no experience.

Now we should not enter further into this I would suggest to you to reflect on your own experiences of pleasure, physical and mental pleasure. And to be pragmatic in other words to take the real experiences of physical pleasure such as sexuality or food or defecation for that matter and ask yourself what is pleasurable about this? Why is it pleasurable? Then take your experiences of pain and ask yourself is there a difference between these two? Then I won’t talk about it too much here but there’s a very interesting point made by a neurologist two or three years ago in an article.

I brought it up at TBI. He said that neurologically there’s basically no difference between pleasure and pain. They basically view it in the same way. Then this gives some ground for the Buddhist position. Now as far as the varieties of suffering are concerned, this is something some of you are quite familiar with.

We have the specific and the general sufferings of psychic existence. The specific sufferings are normally dealt with at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope and the general sufferings at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. So we have already covered the threefold subdivision. We have an eightfold and sixfold subdivision and probably meditating on the eightfold and the sixfold subdivision is what will change your minds. The threefold subdivision, suffering subdivided and suffering of suffering, change in all pervasive suffering is a marvelous theoretical framework.

But what changes the mind is meditating on the eightfold and the sixfold subdivision because it is very germane to our experience as sentient beings and human beings. The Eightfold subdivision is generally said to be somewhat more specific to human beings. It involves four core experiences of birth, aging, sickness and death. These are core experiences and you will note that it is generally during these experiences that people want the solace, so if I was perhaps more sarcastic, I would say the satisfaction of religious ritual. Religious ritual.

All the great religions in Buddhism is perhaps alone in this respect have some type of consecration of birth, sickness, aging and death. Birth and death especially. We at the centers we see a steady demand from our students for this type of consecration, blessing, solace which is very alien to Buddhist thought. Very alien. There’s no baptism in Buddhism, there’s no right of marriage of any type, there’s no extreme unction of any type.

But these are peak experiences people have and the demand is there. The demand for prayers for the sick during Lama Chöpa is actually alien to Buddhist thought. Prayers for the sick can be performed by one spiritual teacher or family members. But the demand from our students is so great that we keep performing it. Even though it’s almost in direct contradiction with what Buddha Śākyamūni taught.

Then we have an additional four experiences which are something we all have encountered repeatedly, encountering what is unpleasant. Not encountering what we expect to be pleasant, not getting what we want and the general suffering of the five aggregates. This is added there for very specific textual reason. Now these three experiences here are perhaps the core of mental suffering among human beings. They all arise from lack of contentment.

We expect something, often unrealistic, we don’t get it and experience mental suffering as a result. The greater the expectation and the greater the discontent and the suffering. If we eliminate these extravagant expectations we eliminate therefore a very important part of suffering. It might be expectation of recognition on the job front which we don’t get. It might be expectations for a partner which we don’t get.

It might be expectations certain age from our children which we don’t get. It might be expectations of health which we don’t get. It is normal to be sick at a certain age. It is normal to die. It is normal to have ups and downs financially, it is not abnormal.

It is not normal to gain money continually. And for myself I find the six fold subdivision of suffering extremely powerful. The first fault of psychic existence is a fault of uncertainty which is precisely that we never know how things are going to unfold. The second fault is a fault of insatiability, in other words, our personal lack of contentment. Nothing is ever good enough.

No friendship is ever good enough. No job is ever good enough. No house is ever good enough. No relationship, no religion. I mean the one question which is well known to put, if you’ll forgive me for formulating it like this, His Holiness Dalai Lama in a tizzy, is a question which westerners ask regularly.

What is the best practice? A case one gets extremely irritated by this question. Extremely, I have seen it. Then, it is a typically western question. There is a best practice and only the best is good enough for me.

Right? That’s what is implicit in this question. This is a thought of insatiability and then if we believe in reincarnation and we reflect on reincarnation, the notion of dying over and again and being reborn over again is an awful one. Then in my case I would add one which is going to grade school over and again. If you can imagine, life after life learning to read over and again.

You can see how this idea of psychic existence as a repetitive endless process which never leads anywhere will be something which would be awful. And then the two last faults are particularly pregnant. The fault of falling from the high to the low repeatedly. This is a profoundly human experience. You’re on top of the world, you’re doing very well professionally, you’re well off, you have a beautiful wife, a beautiful husband, a house in the nice part of town, the best brand of cars and suddenly it turns out either your business goes bankrupt or you have borrowed too much, it is all taken away.

And overnight you go from being someone who is respected, who is appreciated, people stand up when you come in the room, to someone people don’t want to look at. People cross the street when you walk. People murmur behind your back, you know him or her, you you hear, Was in the advertiser or whatever, you know. Now this is a profoundly human experience. Probably everyone in this room has lived to something like this on a greater or lesser scale.

And the thought of being alone is perhaps the most tragic human predicament because I think animals often are unaware of solitude. Ducks seem to be but many animals not. They do, they do. We are alone at key moments of our lives. Death is a solitary process.

I have been with a fair number of people who have died. The person dies in a shell. Very difficult to communicate. Then we ourselves will die alone. Whether we are surrounded by others or not makes no difference.

We’ll be reborn alone. We’ll be reborn someplace far removed from where we are now with people we don’t know and start again from scratch. Then everyone in this room has parents, those who are not ordained have partners, some who are ordained have children and we make constant sacrifices for these people. Constant sacrifices. But not one of them is gonna go with us to the next life.

This is why within the 10 Kadampa jewels the first of the three diamonds is a diamond of no foundation. The diamond of walking away from the family. The family is one of the biggest obstacles to practice. Family obligations are huge burden. This is why some of the really top teachers in Australia, Geshe Doga, for instance, encourages his students to stay alone.

Simply because experience has shown Western students cannot handle together a relationship and some type of spiritual practice. The couples are typically mixed. You know, one of the two partners resents the time the practice takes, you know, from the relationship. And these relationships, when we think how little pleasure they give and how much they cost, is it worth it? Like all of you are what, well the average age, many of you in their sixties I’m sure you can see this, right?

And those of you who are in their thirties maybe it’s difficult, the hormones are still bubbling, right? But the moment you go around 45, 50 and you have one or two divorces behind you and kids which have turned badly or may be turning badly, then is it worth it? People change, don’t they? Basically the best is to be alone. Then, if one is with someone, one has to accept a lot of risks.

So here in the West, the solitary path is ordination, right? This is considered the gold standard in Buddhism. Here in the West ordination is not really accepted. It’s a big burden for those who are ordained. Then the person has to see.

But generally speaking if one is single and content being single one is better off staying single. And then this is my private opinion, which may be very alien to most westerners. It was popular three centuries ago, it’s still popular in Asia. I think if you are going to settle down with someone, the arranged marriage is the way to go. No emotions.

It’s practical arrangement, living arrangement. And because the emotions are out of the circuit, you can make an intelligent decision. Now obviously this is something most of us are unable to do but typically the Asian marriage until recently because it was arranged involved the parents who often had a much more realistic view of what was happening, of the compatibility of the two persons involved. And, you learned to love the other person. You learned to appreciate their qualities.

And the western idea of marriage is a fundamentally problematic one. One turns a romance into a marriage. Then I think many of us can see the damage. So, sorry this is a large parenthesis to answer your question. I wish you good luck.

You’re at the age where one dreams. I’m at the age where one looks back and one sees that basically a lot of a human life can be wasted. A lot can be wasted. What’s the divorce rate already in Australia? Fifty percent?

More? Try. Try. Good luck. Good luck.

What would you think of a business venture with 50% failure? Would you? Emotions. Emotions, right. That’s okay, know, I mean you are here in a Buddhist temple to hear the Buddhist view of things.

I think it’s worse among Western Buddhists. Much worse. Western Buddhists are extraordinarily unstable. My goodness. Much worse.

Western Buddhists by definition are people who have already changed religions. That’s a big factor of instability. No, that’s that’s difficult. So let’s move on. We won’t be able to cover everything but we’ll try to do something on causality.

And here we have to distinguish between two types of causality. Exterior causality, which is basically physical causality and interior causality, which is basically what we would call karmic causality. Now I was going to talk about causality in physics but we’re going to skip that. The one important difference between interior and exterior causality is that exterior causality is not something which amplifies over time. Interior causality does.

I just want to point this out in Lamrim Chenmo, it’s a very interesting point. It’s one of the four general features of Karma we will talk about. Another factor which is very troubling is the importance of motivation in interior causality. Now, to a physical experiment, if I maybe not the cup, but if I take the laser pointer and I drop it from let’s say one meter 50 in height, whether I wish to drop it or not, it will hit the ground at exactly the same time. My motivation is irrelevant.

It’ll be broken or not irrespective of my motivation. This is not the case for karmic causality and one has to wonder why. So we will cover then briefly the Buddhist understanding of causality, we’ll see how much we can do in the time we have left. As you know there are four general features of causality or Karma. Karma is definite, is an increasing function of time, one does not experience karma which has not been created by oneself so there’s no universal karma here And karma is indestructible unless purified.

Then the definiteness of karma is really something which is revealed to us by Buddha Śākyamūni. It is not something we have a direct means of understanding ourselves. Buddha Śākyamūni through his omniscience saw that virtue in past lives led to happiness in future lives and non virtue in past lives led to suffering in future lives. And he therefore, based on the consequences of happiness and suffering, labeled certain types of behavior virtuous and non virtuous. I personally am not terribly fond of the terms virtuous and non virtuous because they bring a very strong Christian heritage which is stranger or alien to us.

Perhaps beneficial non beneficial would be better. But the key here is that it has really nothing to do with morality as we understand it. It is a law of interior causality. And this explains why certain types of behavior can lead to very major problems even though if you call them non virtuous it’s a bit odd. For instance, if you offer prostrations the wrong way with splayed hands you create the karma to be reborn as a spider.

And this sounds really bizarre. But actually it is a result of habituation. Typically one offers not one but thousands, tens of thousands of prostrations. Then one is getting accustomed to one’s body being a certain way. Likewise, if one offers prostrations and hits the ground, I don’t think anyone here does that but supposedly it was done with one’s hands as fists, one creates a karma to be reborn as a cloved animal, a cow for instance.

Again one is doing nothing wrong. But one is engaged in behavior which gives rise to considerable suffering down the line. Karma is also an increasing function of time and this has been a big topic of debate at TBI. I have no clear answer as to why that is the case. I’ve always felt a good metaphor for karma was chaos theory.

You’ve all heard a bit of chaos theory that small actions in a specific type of system lead to huge amplification such as a butterfly batting its wings in China giving rise to a hurricane in South America a couple years later. It’s exterior. It may contribute but I was speaking with Gesheva about this and there’s really there are quotes in Buddhist Sutras where Buddha specifically teaches the amplification of karma but no explanation is given. And I often thought KL theory might sort of suggest this because there are some factors required for chaotic motion. The first is a sensitive dependency on initial condition and the second is recurrence, in other words, a feedback loop and both seem to be present in karma.

Then karmic amplification is a bit of a loaded topic. The Tibetans were not very good at mathematics, actually there was no mathematics. So Lama Zopa Rinpoche believes that Karma doubles over time, in other words it’s linear function of time, then my suspicion is it’s an exponential function of time but I have no particular grounds for this. It’s just everything Buddha taught does not seem to indicate linear increase. Linear increase is steady over time, exponential increase is slow and then becomes extremely rapid.

Then one does not experience the results of karma not accumulated and this is one of the very strong arguments against prayers of mediation by others. For which as I said there is such strong demand in Buddhist centers. If one is sick, that sickness is a result of one’s own karma. The suffering of sickness is a direct result of one’s own karma. Then before the sickness declares one can purify or not purify, that’s up to oneself.

Others cannot purify for us, it is not possible. It will be very nice if it was possible the enlightened beings would have done it for us a long time ago, it hasn’t been done. Once the sickness physical or mental has declared it is very difficult to purify. I’m not saying it’s impossible, it’s very difficult. Generally, it is considered almost impossible, the direct cause is present, it has given rise to the result, then one has to experience the result one can attenuate maybe.

That’s as far as one can go. And for this reason there is really no prayer of intercession in Buddhism simply because there is no omnipotent being who could intercede and prevent the karma from maturing. Now this is very different from Hinduism. In Hinduism for instance, Ishvara, God is basically above karma. Then he chooses to intervene or not in a function of the prayers of the devotees.

It’s a very, from a Buddhist standpoint, it’s a very odd system where karma functions until you pray to Ishvara in his many forms, Vishnu, Brahma, Krishna, whatever, and he intervenes and the flow of causality stops and then it resumes after. But that calls for the existence of a being which is above God, above karma. And karma unless purified is indestructible. So we carry with us karma from tens of thousands of past lives which has yet to mature. Male.

Ah yes yes yes yes yes. Well, we from our side we are when we make that prayer, we are profoundly transforming our own minds. Purely on us. There’s no benefit to sentient beings to your making or not making that prayer. But down the line, if through that prayer you are able to attain full enlightenment then you will have the maximum capacities to help sentient beings, not infinite.

But you will have capacities such as for instance telepathy to see the mind of another what they want, how to speak to them, how to help them. You may see the past lives of another person which is very helpful to be able to modulate what one teaches but those are not the capacities of a God. Buddhism is is quite harsh. It’s quite harsh. I mean, all of us would like to think that prayers for others are beneficial and in some certain very limited circumstances they are.

With people who are very closely linked karmically, parents and children, teachers and disciples, there is an efficacy of prayer for the other. Apart from that, prayer is efficacious for ourselves. And the Buddhist focus is not on prayer but on meditation. Because meditation is a transformation of the mind by itself. So here we are in a different mental universe from the monotheistic universe.

Where God basically listens to the prayers of living beings and if a living being is close to God and pleases him then God helps. It is not the case that if we pray to Buddha he helps and if we don’t pray he doesn’t help. It makes no difference to Buddha whether we pray to him or not. No difference at all. So these are very different mental universes.

Then I was going to talk to you about the modalities of karma but I think maybe we will leave that for next time and it might be more helpful at this point to take your questions. It’s a fair amount of material we have covered. Yes? You were talking about the different forms of suffering before and the suffering of change came up. And I was just wondering about flow.

I don’t know if you’ve heard about people who get into flow through maybe doing a certain sport or people might say I’m in the zone. Ah yes I’ve heard that. So I’ve noticed maybe some people who study can sort of get into that Where zone as would that fall within the different types of suffering? Well, I haven’t looked into it but basically it’s well known that physical and it seems mental exercise activity triggers the release of neurotransmitters such as endorphins which are closely parented to morphine, then, it’s well known for joggers for instance or marathon runners, that would be an instance of the suffering of change. Suffering of change.

Those experiences are very similar to those you have with the opiates. Our entire brain is designed to push us in certain directions which are not to our advantage. Which are to the advantage of the specie and may or may not be to our advantage. Reproduction is a classic case in point. Reproduction having children.

So if people actually thought about children, especially nowadays, and made a cost benefit analysis, I think we’d be severely under populated. Then we don’t. We’re taken over by emotions, we are actually our brains are designed for this to happen. As a result we have children. Then after that the regrets start, right?

To a greater or lesser degree. Do you have other questions? Is an instance of the suffering that’s all pervasive the ignorance that grasps itself? Yes it would be, yes definitely. But that ignorance is also an affliction.

Then as an affliction yes it would be. The old pervasive suffering is basically the fact that we are prone to the other two types of suffering. We are prone to the suffering of suffering. We are prone to the suffering of change. No.

Then you see Thessalonians has said repeatedly and I think it is it is really perhaps the central point. I haven’t talked about it because it’s not a presentation of Four Noble Truths. That the key is the existence of this, of the truth of cessation and of the path. That’s the key. So if one analyzes carefully the truth of suffering becomes quite self evident.

The truth of the origin of suffering is more difficult to understand. But the big question is, is there a way out or not? That is not easy. Is there a state of liberation or not? Now, there are several wrong views which are associated with the truth of cessation one of which is that cessation is a temporary state of affairs.

So we can all imagine a cessation where we wouldn’t get angry for twenty or thirty years. Right? Or twenty or thirty lifetimes. But is it possible to attain a true cessation which means anger never ever arises whatever the circumstances? That is the question.

Then not to get angry for 20 or 30 lifetimes or 2,000 lifetimes, that is not a cessation. That’s just an anger has become non manifest. That for instance would be a byproduct of calm abiding. You gain calm abiding, anger and desire become non manifest. You don’t experience them.

You don’t experience them for a very very long time. You keep practicing calm abiding you will not experience them. But if you stop practicing calm abiding you will lose the capacity to enter in calm abiding. It can happen in one life, it can happen certainly over several lives, then the anger and desire come back. They were buried but not destroyed.

So the key question for the Buddhist teachings to be true is that there is a truth of cessation. It is actually possible to abandon the afflictions. So they never ever come back whatever happens. And then once one has satisfied oneself that there is a truth of cessation then one seeks for the truth of the path. And then all the Buddhist schools are in disagreement.

What exactly the truth of the path? What is emptiness? What is selflessness? But this issue of the truth of cessation is the most important one. Because if there is no such thing as a truth of cessation there is no meaning to much Buddhist practice.

Personally, basically the nature of mind. The nature of mind. If you reflect on the nature of mind as an impermanent phenomenon then you can see how it would be possible to put an end to the manifestation of certain aspects of this phenomenon. And then you have to examine very carefully because it’s not one or two afflictions, it’s all afflictions. And the key is to ask yourself are the afflictions random, depends on events, or do they have a core cause?

I think most Westerners believe that the afflictions anger, desire and so forth are random. It depends on you meet someone who treats you badly anger arises, you meet someone who treats you well desire arises, friendship. But is there a root cause in the way we perceive the other person or not? Now here there’s a fair bit of corroboration from psychology. As Juan has always mentioned an american psychologist, Ekman I think is his name, who found that when people were angry 90% of the negativity they attributed to the other person was superimposed from their own side.

There’s basically 10% of problems from the side of the other person and this person who, you know, I don’t know, forget forgot a tea bag with sugar on the counter is on the receiving end of negativity which makes them look like a Waffen SS or whatever, you know. But this is the experience of anger we have. Desire the same thing. Then some Buddhist schools go further and they say it’s basically 100% which comes from our mind. If that is the case then we have to analyze whether there’s a root cause for all of this or not and if there is, if we cut the root cause, the problem is solved.

If there isn’t a root cause then nothing can be done. Could you tell me what the name is of the you were speaking about once you’ve renounced family and relationships you called it a diamond and then you said there were two others something to do with embarrassment and something to do with The first is the diamond of no foundation. What’s the overarching name for this system and then The 10 jewels, innermost jewels of the Kadampa system. This was a secret teaching which was passed among the Kadampa Geshe in Tibet for several centuries. It really underlay their lifestyle and led to these extraordinary degrees of renunciation we find great yogis like Milarepa for instance.

Jampa Gyatsen quoted last week this marvelous line from Milarepa. A lay person came to Milarepa and he said to Milarepa, you know in the valley people say you are insane. And Milarepa answered to the world Milarepa is insane and to Milarepa the world is insane. A very powerful statement because really from the standpoint of Milarepa and I think you can take that as a standard of a true practitioner there’s no middle ground. If you’re with the world then you are against true practice and if you’re with true practice you’re against the world.

And most of us are in between obviously. The other two after the family? Oh, the diamond of non embarrassment and the diamond of befriending wisdom. Non embarrassment means to have no shame. So some very great Geshe’s, you know, after they finish their studies, when they start focusing on transforming their mind in-depth, they will basically literally take the appearance of a Geshe who’s drifting around the Barkhor and they are often on the receiving end of an awful lot of criticism from others.

And this is used as the foundation of their practice. And Śāntideva was like that. As you know Śāntideva when he left the monastery in the eighth century he wandered around all of India naked, you know. It’s difficult to do that. His awareness has great praise.

Right now the Buddhists don’t do that but in the Jain tradition, one of the two Jain traditions, the Digambara, the sky clad, give up on clothing. And at certain interface meetings in India His Holiness has been next to Digambara yogis who have wandered on the roads of India for thirty, forty years. Stark naked. You know? There’s no shame.

And the person is not of this world anymore. Right? Or for us it’s very alien. Probably. You see we are completely under sway of the eight worldly dharmas, right?

All of us. Gain and loss, happiness and unhappiness, praise and blame, fame and ignominy. It’s all about money, gain and loss, happiness in this life and unhappiness. People come to Buddhist centers to pacify their minds, right? Happiness and unhappiness.

Praise and blame, people who stay everyone is trying to get praised by the teacher, everyone is afraid of blame, right? Fame and ignominy, you start publishing and then you try to be more over the Internet, books, etc, right? Gain and loss. Well the translation of that stance is difficult but I translate it as gain and loss. There is a problem because we don’t really understand the difference Nāgārjuna made between praise and blame and fame and ignominy.

So I looked at it several times and my feeling is praise and blame refer to the personal experience and interaction with others of praise and blame and fame and ignominy to the experience in society. Reputation. So pleasure and pain is that not part of it? The pleasure and pain are something completely different that’s nothing to do with the eight worldly dharmas. Pain you would experience even as an arhat, right?

If an arhat walks on a thorn and there is pain but there’s no suffering, the body experiences pain. There’s no mental suffering in response to that. Otherwise the perception will be false, right? Because much of our experience of suffering is mental. Is that by recognizing a pain or a pleasure?

I made an experiment once to see if this was true or not because you’ve got to check these things. And I felt I walked out on limb on this one but I had to have a cavity drilled and filled in a molar, you know. And I thought I’d do this without anesthesia and I’m going to see, you know, if I can separate pain and suffering. The dentist was Vietnamese so he was understanding but he became quite worried as we’ve seen it. So you know when they start it’s not too bad, right?

And they start going in, you know, and you really feel like vomiting, right? And then fear sets in. So it’s at this point I basically reflect in the Chitamatra view. And my mind was very peaceful and the pain was still there. It’s just really shaking up here and you know you But the mind was completely at peace and as a result even though the pain was there the experience of pain was greatly lessened.

Then I thought, okay, clearly the mental component in the experience of suffering is huge. Then whether it’s 100% of the experience or not I cannot say. But it was in this case easily 70 to 80%. Once I started holding those reflections that there was no distinction between the mind and the observed phenomenon, etc, then the pain became so manageable just in the background, you know. Then I saw Geshe Raptan, my first teacher, enter in calm abiding and doing an examination of the spine for metastasis and they inserted electrodes in the spine and passed electrical currents which normally would cause spasming.

None of this happened. So the degree of mind control of the body is huge. You see we don’t understand the benefit of this approach as I was telling Chris over the break because we live in very wealthy, cosseted societies. So no one in this room is going to be in the situation of being terminally ill and unable to afford any treatment. It doesn’t happen in Australia, right?

No one in this room is going to be kidnapped or worse because of their race or their faith. Again it doesn’t happen. No one in this room is going to go hungry and starve without any control. So for this reason these teachings of mental transformation, that’s what Buddhism is, they don’t really carry a lot of weight because we believe the physical environment is under control. People turn to Buddhism once their physical environment is no longer under control.

Once the doctors say, well, you know, it’s metastatic cancer, the liver is terminal, you know, it may be a couple of weeks. Then they come, right? It’s too late, you know. So this idea of control over the environment has become a big problem. My question is about the suffering of change and your personal opinion on the neurological happenings that go on with people who get into the flow or into the zone.

Because for me I can see two different things. One person does something that is enjoyable and actually beneficial for the body such as training the mind in study or something like that and obtains this feeling of happiness and then in a different case someone does something to the extreme such as extreme jogging or marathon running which is actually because of its it’s at the extreme end is actually damaging the body and they also at that time experience some kind of happiness and euphoria which is similar to the first but I’m interested in the neurological things that are going on between those two different states. I can’t answer your question. I’m not a neurologist. I mean, I’ve done some work on this to prepare my conferences and basically, Sorry?

Just suppressing the pain. Well, you have the mental experience of pain and suffering and the neurological correlates of that experience of pain and suffering. Then these neurological correlates are mediated by chemical substances, neurotransmitters. There’s more than half a dozen now. Serotonin, dopamine, oxytocin, acetylcholine, each mediates a certain type of experience.

For instance, if you have a low rate of serotonin and dopamine you will be depressed. If you have a high ratio of serotonin and dopamine you will be manic. Then a balanced rate of these two neurotransmitters gives rise to more or less a balanced personality. So this is the chemical mechanism which underlies this. Now these are basically chemical byproducts of a mental activity.

If you wish the brain and the mind entertain the same relationship as a computer and electricity. Electricity to perform its functions needs to be within a computer or machine, whatever type of machine. A computer which is not plugged in the wall does not function. Then what you are asking is there a difference neurologically between contaminated and contaminated experiences? Basically, that’s what you’re driving at.

I don’t know. I don’t know. The Buddhist goal is to attain a state of permanent happiness as opposed to transitory happiness. Transitory happiness is of the nature of the suffering of change. Because as it declines, it causes suffering.

Then permanent happiness would not be of the nature of the suffering of change because it would never decline. Does such a state exist or not? That’s the question, right? When you say contaminated and uncontaminated and I agreed I wasn’t thinking that that was to do with contaminated and uncontaminated virtue or anything like that. No, in the ordinary sense of the term, not in the technical sense of the term.

But basically the relation between mind and brain and the study of that relation is in its infancy. Most neurologists consider that there is no mind, there’s only brain. Buddhists consider that there is a brain and a mind. The nature of the relation is open to question and what bridges the two is open to question. The reason I brought up flow in the first place is I watched Jampa Kedrup at Sera Je and the way he studied and it seemed like he always would get into this flow with his study.

And he was in this state of mind where he seemed extremely happy and he just wouldn’t stop. And for me it was the opposite. Well, there there is is an experience associated with analysis. Analysis is insight, right? If you engage in intense insight at a certain point you will give rise to a pliancy born from insight.

That’s an experience of great happiness which is due to analysis. Then the people who tend to do well in pure sciences typically they have this experience. They would not call it insight or appliance you’ve borne from inside but the experience is there. And mathematicians for instance describe this without knowing what they’re talking about. It’s an insight born, it’s a pliancy born from insight.

I think everyone who does well in studies has something close to that. Probably Jampa Kedrup has that sort of experience. It’s just very, very pleasant to study. And you have the same type of pliancy born from calm abiding, right? Same thing.

Any other questions? Then what I would suggest is, since many of us in this room are new to Buddhism it’s something you can still afford to do, to sit back and put everything on the table and ask yourself, is this true or not? It’s a question which is I think sorely lacking among westerners who come to Buddhist centers. Just sit back and we’re not talking of the existence of Mount Meru or the four continents. Okay?

But the basics. Most of you have a good sense of the basics of Buddhism. We’ve tried to cover them. Here Geshe-la has covered them. You have to sit back and ask yourself, is this true?

You have to move away from your commitment because there is a point where people will have a very high vested commitment to believe it is true. Then at this point it becomes difficult to have that distance. And that profound conviction that something is true is what carries us in our practice. If that’s absent then we don’t go anywhere. Then if it is not true then I would propose that you draw consequences from that.

Maybe there are other things you can do with your time. One does not have to be a Buddhist, doesn’t have to be a Christian, one doesn’t have to be religious nowadays. But, it is really very very much for your benefit to be able to say unambiguously yes. My mental experiences of the nature of suffering. Yes.

It’s true. Or, It’s false. You have to decide. It takes time to decide, have to study, to reflect, but you cannot spend your entire career at TBI or any Buddhist center in a state of nebulous indecision because you will be harmed eventually and the centers are harmed by this type of behavior. So we don’t need to fill the centers with people.

It’s unnecessary. But we do want that those who can be stable or will not be stable. But we have too high a proportion of instability, far too high. And that comes from not asking the core questions at the beginning. So really ask yourself that now all of us have access to a marvelous source of information known as mister Guru.

So check with mister Guru. Check with, you know, what the Buddhist teach about suffering, about the suffering of change. Are there corresponding notions in neurology? What the Buddhist teach about the nature of matter? Are there corresponding notions in physics or not?

Then if this is totally at odds with what is known in modern science maybe you’d be better off going someplace else. So, are you saying you necessarily have to take a position? Eventually you have to. You see, at the beginning of a thesis one studies, one can take a position at the beginning, one doesn’t know. One comes to teachings without taking position.

One is not a Buddhist, one attends teachings six months, one year, two years, three years, maybe. At a certain point, you have to cut. The Tibetan for the disciples to cut the string. You have to cut. And you have to have the courage to cut.

The lack of courage not to take a decision. Now for Westerners now this act of taking a decision, this commitment is very difficult for a variety of reasons. But they themselves are harmed if they don’t do this because all of us we have a limited amount of time. And the Buddhist community is harmed as well. So eventually after one, two, three, four, however many years, once you have studied these topics and you owe it to yourself to study them well, so we have a very good Geshe here, if you are seriously interested you owe it to yourself to come to every teaching, take notes, to think about this.

At a certain point you have to stop, put it on the table and ask yourself is this true or not? Do I believe this or not? Then if you believe it how much do I commit? If you don’t believe please leave. Okay?

We have no need for tourists in the center. There’s too many. It’s better for your families. You might look at other religious traditions. His Holiness Dalai Lama does not encourage westerners to convert to Buddhism.

There’s a very major reason for that and we have a couple of minutes. I’ll tell you the story. I’ve told it many times but it’s worth mentioning because His Holiness repeats it each time. His Holiness had a disciple, personal disciple, a Polish lady, in the early days, so we’re talking of 1959, 1960, 1961, just after the exile. And she became Buddhist, took refuge, bodhisattva vows, tantric vows, all the initiations, did all the retreats and as far as the Tibetans were concerned she was a dyed in the wool Buddhist.

And then in the late sixties on her deathbed she abjured Buddhism, asked for a Roman Catholic priest to come in, confessed all her sins, to re enter the Roman Catholic church and received extreme unction from the priest. And His Holiness has said from his standpoint this is a huge waste. This was someone who was from Roman Catholic culture. If she had stayed Roman Catholic, then she would have been a very happy Roman Catholic. There’d be no need to give a lot of extra work to the poor priest.

And on her deathbed she would have died happily a Roman Catholic. Instead, it’s ten to fifteen years of her life which from her standpoint at the end were completely wasted. Then from a Buddhist standpoint, when one takes this type of major commitment and one breaks it there are very heavy karmic consequences. We may believe or not believe in karma but there are consequences. If one takes refuge, bodhisattva vows, tantric vows, initiations, relies on a teacher and we’ve had many cases at TBI it’s like every year there’s a couple of people walking away from the lot Then for the person this is very heavy and for us as Buddhist communities it’s very problematical because we cannot create stable communities.

That’s why His Holiness has said the time has come to eliminate confusion. There’s too much confusion among Western Buddhists so we have to be very clear what Buddhism is, what Buddhism is not. Then people can be Buddhist or not, I mean it’s not, excuse me, the only game in town, it’s not and we don’t want to be the default option. But if they are Buddhist they should be pure Buddhists. Then that’s up to you.

The same thing, you see, we expect from our students the same standard you expect from others in your relationships. Right? This doesn’t concern the monastics. But if you’re in a relationship with someone, you don’t want them to string you along, do you? It’s a form of lying, isn’t it?

Right? They sort of string you along like this trying to get something from you, you know. Maybe residency, maybe some money, you know. Just there’s nothing else they can do in their lives. They keep stringing you along and they tell you all the right things and then one day they’re gone, right?

And it’s considered in worldly affairs it’s awful, isn’t it? Then our students shouldn’t behave like that to the centers. And then we’re gonna have to address the issue at present of the students who change their mind again and want to return. I have to talk to Tenzin about this. Whether we allow them to return or not is gonna be a very big question.

The time has come to put some barriers. So from your side, obviously the center is open to everybody. The general teachings are open to everybody. You don’t have to be a Buddhist. You can come, you can attend for years on end.

Before you commit please think carefully from your side. The more time you spend the better. Right? And then, once you commit consider that the door is closed. In worldly affairs you can’t sign a mortgage with the bank and then change your mind about the conditions and stop paying your mortgage, right?

What happens when you do that? I believe that the times are so degenerate now that sometimes people are forced into those positions. It happens. It’ll always happen, that’s a given. But not with this amount, this frequency.

I mean, that it happens, it happened when I was young, it happens with the Tibetans. But now we’re dealing with substantial proportions. You know. And it’s really really awkward, you know, it’s a I see the difference in the outlook towards Westerners in my own life, you know. When I was young I remember Geshe Rapten and Geshe Tubten Geshe Pema.

Whenever a Westerner made a mistake they say, Yeah, but you’ve got to understand they don’t know, right? I mean it’s all new to them. They’re just NGs, you know. If they knew they wouldn’t, this was what I heard. Now I remember hearing His Holiness, what was it?

I think it was in Varanasi in 2010 asking the Tibetan Geshes and the monks assembled not to abandon the Westerners. I remember Jesus only saying that. Please do not abandon the Westerners. I know there are problems but please, you know So this is a result of our fickleness of unreliability and this is in thirty five years. Right?

I mean I started I was 19. From your sides obviously all of us have different lives, experiences but please, you know, take your time, don’t rush. We have initiations, refuge is coming up. Generally speaking, if you have any doubts, don’t take it. Right?

If you take it, it’s a lifelong commitment. In the case of Bodhisattva vows it is several lives. If you have a lot of doubts about the existence of past and future lives then it’s not the time to go that route. You know, you can always take later. Once you take, you must try to continue to be involved in Buddhism.

Now when you take refuge I’m sorry I’m going a bit over time but this is a very basic element here. You take refuge in the teachings. That’s the key. The other refuges are subsidiary. Buddha is a subsidiary refuge.

He imparts the teachings. The Sangha is a subsidiary refuge. They practice the teachings. If you take refuge in the teachings, you must attend the teachings. If you do not attend teachings, it amounts to a degeneration of refuge.

So to take refuge and to disappear means refuge was never really taken. And it’s clear that people have difficulties in their lives but I know people with major responsibilities who are able to attend one teaching a week. Then it is possible. Until you reach a point where you can teach yourselves and that’s another story. So thank you very much.

Yes Monica? If the teachings for some reason or another aren’t available anymore and you’ve taken refuge then what happens in that case? And that is not your fault, obviously. That is a different situation. Obviously, if we were no longer able to provide teachings, if it was not possible to get teachings on the web then you function with what you have.

But refuge is in the teachings. You see the teachings as protecting you against suffering. That’s the commitment, right? Then really attendance to the teachings, at least one teaching a week, should be non negotiable. Then, if you have no other questions, thank you very much.

Thank you so much Ilya for once again as I said at the beginning informing and challenging us and helping us to understand what Buddhism is all about from many different perspectives. And as we thank Ilya we can also be dedicating the merit that we have gained from today. Join it with the aspiration which is of all holy beings for the elimination of suffering completely and as a cause for us to bring that about eventually. So thank you. Indeed let us dedicate these merits.

Those of you who are Buddhist, let us dedicate them to all sentient beings attaining full enlightenment and to the spread of pure dharma in Australia since we are all Australian. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
four continents
In Buddhist cosmology, the four continents around Mount Meru, one at each cardinal point; ours is the southern continent, Jambudvipa (Rose-apple Land). LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Where would the experience of being in the 'zone' fall within the different types of suffering?

It would be an instance of the suffering of change. Physical, and it seems mental, exercise triggers the release of neurotransmitters such as endorphins, which are closely related to morphine. This is well known in joggers and marathon runners, and the experiences are very similar to those had with opiates. The brain is designed to push us in certain directions that are not necessarily to our advantage. They serve the advantage of the species and may or may not benefit us. Reproduction is a classic case. If people thought about having children and made a cost-benefit analysis, especially nowadays, the world would be severely underpopulated.

Are pleasure and pain part of the eight worldly dharmas, and does an arhat still experience pain?

Pleasure and pain are something completely different and have nothing to do with the eight worldly dharmas. Even an arhat experiences pain. If an arhat walks on a thorn, the body feels pain, but there is no suffering, because there is no mental suffering in response to it. Otherwise the perception would be false, since much of our experience of suffering is mental.

If the teachings are no longer available for some reason after you have taken refuge, what happens to your refuge?

If teachings become unavailable, that is not your fault; it is a different situation. If it were no longer possible to provide teachings, or to get them on the web, you simply function with what you have. Refuge, however, is in the teachings. You see the teachings as protecting you against suffering, and that is the commitment. So when teachings are available, attending them, at least one teaching a week, should be non negotiable.

Scroll to Top