1 h 19 min · 9,003 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Pamela Lyon, introduced as a long-time student of Khensur Rinpoche, argues from evolutionary biology that empathy and altruism depend on physical closeness and cooperation. She cites self-sacrificing bacteria, social insects and aphids, and criticises gene-centred views such as Dawkins’s. She says she believes in development and karma. The question session covers epigenetics, cancer, sentience and the difference between life and mind.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 20m
UUID: 119f03d7-b0c0-4a3b-9b64-1a9462947661
Words: 8,999
Welcome back everybody. I hope you’ve enjoyed your lunch and perhaps I might turn the air conditioning off so that we don’t go off to sleep. But I’m sure that what Pamela has to say will ensure that we don’t. Pamela Lyon is a long-time student of Khensur Rinpoche and background as a journalist, philosopher, independent researcher with an affiliation with Flinders University. So it’s my pleasure to hand over to you Pamela.
Is it is it On now. On. Yeah. Is it on? Yeah.
Okay. So I’m always a little bit worried about my voice because when I was in when I was in school, starting in primary school, I was always the narrator because my voice could carry to the back of the room. So what I’m really afraid of is is basically booming you out. Okay. So we’re talking about empathy and altruism.
And just as as a way of beginning, I think that we’ll take a look at the original meanings of the word, because both words are relatively recent coinage. They’re not that old. You would think that they would be old because empathy and altruism have been around a long time, but there apparently weren’t really words specifically to describe them the way we use them now. The first one, I think, maybe not, wait a minute. It’s not working.
It’s not working. Help. Wait, does that just turn it on? I think it might have done. Hang on.
No. There we go. Can you see it yet? No? Okay, there we go.
Okay. Empathy, which literally means feeling into another, was coined in English in the early twentieth century using Greek roots, to translate a German word, And Ilya will appreciate how difficult it is to come up with words that that match, what’s occurring in another language, and empathy entered English as as one of those kinds of translations. And in Greek, it means basically in feeling or feeling into. Altruism was coined in the mid nineteenth century in France based on an Italian word with a Latin root, which means to this other. So it’s giving precedence to another.
K. Now these two terms had a very, very, very difficult time making it into biology. And there are many reasons for that that have to do with anthropomorphism and and that sort of thing. But it became almost impossible after this book was written by this man. The man in question is E.
O. Wilson. He was a professor of zoology at Harvard. His specialty was ants, is ants. He’s a giant in the field.
And with the book Sociobiology, he introduced the idea of applying the lessons of biology to human behavior. He is famous for introducing the idea of what is called the gene’s eye view of evolution or the gene centric view of evolution, which is that essentially that genes are more important than learning in shaping behavior. And he was saying specifically that this was also true of human behavior, no matter what the the influences of culture were. Now, you can imagine that this had a radical effect on popular culture. And the idea that suddenly we were sort of the puppets of our genes came into currency.
And this began as a debate in Harvard, basically, between three different professors. And it spilled out into the wider world in just like an amazing array of books. Books and books and books, of which this is just a very small sample. And the sort of definitive work on what the sociobiology debate was about is this book, Defenders of the Truth, which is actually quite readable. If any of you are interested in catching up on evolutionary theory and where it stands, this is this is a good place to this is a good place to start.
But suffice to say, it kicked it it ignited a firestorm amongst intellectuals, not just in evolutionary biology, but across a number of fields. And they base it basically split people into two almost mutually exclusive warring camps. And the camps were really ideological. And the main the main thing at issue initially was nature versus nurture. It’s like how much of it is genes, and how much of it is your conditioning?
Your development, your conditioning. Much is it, is it mother’s fault really? Or is it really in your genes? And so this has all kinds of implications for racial differences, gender differences. It was inflammatorily political.
In the social sciences, it became codified under the notion of the units of selection, which made it sound a whole lot more neutral than it actually was. But the basic difference was a clash between people who favored the individual approach to evolution or the collective approach to to evolution. And the way this was played out was that individuals, not groups, were selected and that specific genes within individuals were selected, not whole genomes. That that was basically the divide. And because there were no models to understand this, they went to economics.
They relied on economics as the source of inspiration for understanding this, you know, how behavior is generated. And economics, as we know, is a really exact science. All of its assumptions are really, really well grounded in empirical theory, not. And so the models they chose were basically game theory. I can’t begin to describe to you what game theory is, but it is something that you can turn into mathematics.
And that’s why they liked it. But the essential idea at that point was that individuals were rational actors maximizing utility, whatever utility means. And even economists can’t tell you that. And they can’t. I mean seriously, it’s a scandal.
It’s a scandal. If there are any economists in the room, I expect you to support me on this. And the fact of the matter is that even when these assumptions started to be tested in real behavioral experiments with real life human beings, they proved to be really, really wrong on a whole lot of levels. So basically as you can see here, if it’s individual versus collective, if the models are economic, we’re not very far away from capitalism versus socialism. And this became one of the underlying motives between behind who was on what side, which is not a really great look in a science, frankly.
Now the person who became the attack dog of the nature side of the equation, the Gene’s Eye view, is this fellow, Richard Dawkins, who many of you may have heard of, who wrote a book called The Selfish Gene in such muscular prose that basically men, males in philosophy and males in evolutionary biology and that sort stuff just fell all over themselves saying, this is exactly right. And this is basically what he was saying, that we are survival machines, robot vehicles blindly programmed to preserve the selfish molecules known as genes. This is a truth which still fills me with astonishment. Okay. Now this book was unbelievably influential.
And it when people talk about neo Darwinism, this is generally what they’re talking about. It really isn’t neo Darwinism. That’s actually something else, but we’re not gonna go there. But it’s this selfish gene view that has permeated so much of biology, but which in recent years is really coming, it’s meeting the challenges that have always been there but are really now piling up, piling up. Basically neo Darwinism is not spoken here.
I am not a gene’s eye view person. I believe in development, and basically by saying I believe in development, that means that everything is not given at birth. I’m also a believer in karma. A great deal is given at birth even in simple organisms, but individual differences matter. Karma matters and actions matter even in really, really simple animals.
And the closer we look at even unicellular organisms, the more and more differences we see between them. We used to think that they were sort of because our our methods were, population based, we thought they all basically behaved the same way. But once we were able to start looking at them on an individual level, we started we started seeing how much individual difference there is between them. Okay. So let’s get back to empathy and altruism.
Now, with empathy, you’re looking you’re looking at feeling into or feeling with others. In biology, you have to be close to others before you can do this. Similarly with altruism, before you can put the welfare of others before your own, you have to be close to others. And in the natural world, this means you are physically close to others. It’s physical proximity.
I don’t know what’s going on in the mind of a bacterium even if they have one, but I don’t think that they’ve got a theory of mind. I don’t think that they’re feeling their way into each other. It’s because they live close together, they act together, and they cooperate, they have sociality, they have social behavior, that they can be altruistic, and I hope to show you that right now. So the reason why we’re gonna be talking about altruism rather than empathy is because of the problem of other minds. Famously in philosophy, I cannot prove that Nick is conscious.
I can’t prove that he has any feelings. I can’t prove I can’t prove any of that. I have to take his word for it. I have to listen to what he says. I have to observe his behavior, but I have no access to what’s going on in his mind, so I don’t know.
I don’t know. So we operate with with human beings. We operate on a principle of charity that because they look like us, they act like us, they have similar brain structures, that they are like us. Okay? When you start talking about animals that are radically different from human beings, you start running into problems.
And the problem of other minds becomes almost insurmountable, and that’s when people say, oh, that’s anthropomorphizing or oh, that’s this or that’s that, even if you’re looking at basically just behavior. So what we’re going to be looking at here are eusocial insects. Eusocial means truly social, and that means that they live together in colonies. They’re all over each other. They live in really close proximity.
And these are the these are the animals, these are the insects that are engaged in altruistic self sacrifice. They’re willing to die for each other. And that includes honeybees, and ants, and termites, and aphids, but also surprisingly, certain types of bacteria. And we’re going to start with them first. And that tree looking structure is a fruiting body.
And that fruiting body and the sludge that you see around the base of that tree like structure are probably dead cells that have killed themselves. So just to give you an idea of the sociality of of bacteria, this is an oral biofilm. We know now that most bacteria are highly social. They don’t live on their own. They have all kinds of ways of of communicating with one another, of actually fooling other bacteria into thinking they’re communicating, you know, that somebody else is communicating with them.
They’re they’re extraordinary. This is an oral biofilm. This is what you attempt to brush off your teeth every morning and evening. And it will be back the next morning and by the evening because it’s an extraordinarily robust community. There are hundreds of species living together.
These these kinds of biofilms have been described as like cities, and they are like cities in a whole lot of different ways, not least because everybody lives off everybody’s secondary products. Like a waste product here is food for one there, a secondary metabolite that’s used to signal here is also food for somebody over there. So it’s one of the most blatantly interdependent communities you can can imagine. Okay. So myxobacteria were the first bacteria bacteria to attract naturalist attention mainly because they construct fruiting bodies.
And we’ll look at that how they do that in a minute. This is these are photos of a lot of different fruiting bodies by different myxobacteria. The myxobacteria are like the primates of the bacterial world. They have they have the largest repertoire of signal, signaling proteins. They are they are the most cognitive of the bunch.
They are just incredibly interesting. They they hunt certain types of them, hunt as wolf packs. They attract they attract prey to them. They surround them and build things around them and then and then kill them. They’re really nasty.
And but they undergo this incredible transformation from single cells aggregating together to fruiting bodies, and that is when nutrients decline. And during this process of building fruiting bodies, a proportion of the cells commit suicide. It’s the technical term for it is autolysis or autolysis, and it basically means self lysing. And so and basically, they spill their guts. They basically rupture their cell wall, and they they let all of their interior, constituents spill out, which, if you’re doing this in the laboratory, up to ninety percent of the cells of the population will will, autolyze.
And that’s because of the really dramatic stuff that they use to do do starvation. It’s like, it’s a massive shock. So they all just go, it’s really bad. You know, like so everybody dies. Almost everybody dies.
But in nature, it really is only generally about twenty to thirty percent, but that’s still a significant proportion. Why this why this happens is unknown, but based on the behavior of other bacteria, it’s assumed to provide nutrients. Because moving building fruiting bodies and transforming into spores, which allow them to live live to another day when conditions are better, is highly energetically costly. It’s it takes a lot of energy to do this. And in addition to those who that commit suicide, there is a proportion of the cells who that become sentries, which means that they also die.
So that there’s a significant proportion of the cells that die in this process, And nobody knows if there is a signal that is sent out to make them die, why they die and not others. That that that whole process is completely mysterious. Now, I have I’m going to try something a little bit tricky here, if you’ll just bear with me because this is so much better. This one here. I’m going to run I’m going to run a film that runs about a minute.
Now these, the the the sort of like white colored stuff on that side are Myxococcus xanthus. And inside the dark circle is, is E. Coli. The oscillations are amazing. It’s it’s it’s massively coordinated action at the level of pairs.
It’s it’s an extraordinary thing, the rippling. So all those things that look like indentions indentures, they’re actually three-dimensional things. Not a single living E. Coli is left. I think that’s pretty amazing.
But what’s also not left, if you look at the stuff if you look on, you know, the stuff on the left, there there were still there were still some activity on on the left. And the reason why that is, is because there are there are cells dying all around the fruiting bodies as well. They can’t they can’t detect those in the Oh, sorry. I really shouldn’t have done that. I shouldn’t have done that.
Really sorry. Let me let me just go through this really quickly and get back to where I was. Because on the left, when the fruiting bodies were formed, were also cells. Once once E. Coli are depleted, there are there are Myxococcus xanthus cells that are that are are splitting themselves open.
Probably only about 20% because there was a whole lot of there was a whole lot of nutrients there. Okay. So the thing that you were seeing in the rippling and everything like that, what you were seeing were these golden rod shaped cells coordinating with each other in pairs in an extraordinary dance, really, of switching around like this and then switching around like that and then moving out and pairing up with somebody else. And what they do is is like if you put your two fingers like that, you’ve got you can line your knuckles up together. What they do is they line up protein complexes together.
And they register the fact that that’s been linked together, and then when that’s when that’s been done, they then go off to another partner. But this is just an extraordinarily choreographed process by which they form these things, which are every single little one of those little squiggly things is a is a bacterium. And they’re made of tens of thousands of them. And inside, they completely transform like like a caterpillar turning into a butterfly. They completely transform form into into myxospores, which are long lived.
But, and this is not Myxococcus xanthus, this next one, but it’s just so incredible. Is this is, this is Chondromyces crocatus, yes, which is also a myxobacteria, but it’s just it is the most amazingly complex thing. All the myxospores are in those, rust colored things. That’s obviously, that’s not their they’re trying to make it like their color, but it’s not really. And what you see behind them, I’m not entirely sure if this is a composite.
Because that behind them looks very much like that. And that’s artificially colored, so I’m not entirely sure. And that looks like a sky and that can’t be. So I’m a little bit worried about the provenance of this, but I know that the chondromyces it’s an accurate picture. And so another bacterial form that engages in autolysis and are specifically, are known to be cannibalized, is Bacillus subtilis.
And this is quite a beautiful bacterium. And one of the interesting things about Bacillus subtilis is if you can see the stuff in the middle, you know it’s kind of all tangled and stuff like that. And you see the stuff on the out the peripheries, you know they’re sort of loose and moving out like that. Well all the guys on the on the peripheries can feed and grow as much as they like. But the people, you know, but the but the said the people.
Oh god. That was anthropomorphism. The the cells at the core slowly starve if they don’t get any nutrients. So what they do is they have on the on the surface of every cell, they have an they have ion channels. And ion channels are what make neurons in our brains, in our hearts, in our gut, in our spinal spinal cord communicate with one another.
And bacterial ion channels were studied to learn what how ion channels work, nobody knew what bacterial ion channels did. And in bacillus subtilis, they found that they do exactly the same thing that they do in neurons. They generate an electric charge. And so the electric charge goes from the center out to the periphery, it’s propagated through the cells to the periphery, and that signal basically says stop eating. Stop eating and let some nutrients come in.
And so all the cells on the periphery stop, the nutrients are allowed to diffuse in, the cells in the core eat, and then there’s some other signal, nobody knows what it is yet, that says it’s okay to start again. So they start growing again. But that is a mechanism that’s used in neurons, that is used in the complex behavior of microbes, which are my favorite things. Rinpoche said, All sentient beings have minds. So I looked at the simplest ones I could find to rule them out and I was just gobsmacked.
You know, and I’m still gobsmacked. So I’m a little bit twisted this way, but but but the micro microbiological community is coming around and and I’ll let them convince everybody else. That’s really good. Okay. So next we’re gonna be talking about ants.
And ants are ants and termites are among the most successful social species on the planet. They obligately cooperative. That means they have to cooperate. They can’t say I want to be me. They are obligately cooperative.
And some ants’ nests can cover hundreds of kilometers, interconnected ants’ nests. Now here’s a classic example of where kin selection falls down. Kin selection, which is a gene’s eye view, will tell you the only reason why they all cooperate is because they’re all genetically related. The problem is when they start looking at these really large colonies, they’re not all genetically related. There’s actually a lot of mixing going on.
And that always raises the question of how do you know your relative? You know, how do you know your relative if you’re if you’re an ant? Now some of them say it’s a it’s a volatile chemical hydrocarbon on in the cuticle that covers the body. But I mean, it’s not like they’re getting a genetic readout or anything. It has something to do with the conditions in which they were raised in that particular nest.
So that’s quite interesting. Here is an example of a leafcutter ant’s nest in Brazil into which 10 tons of concrete were poured, and it’s now being excavated to see how large it was and what its structures are like. And those nodules that you see, those are those are living areas, but they’re also nurseries, they’re also fungus farms. Because leafcutter ants are one of the few agricultural species on the planet, which of course includes us. And they they, cultivate a particular fungus that grows on on on leaf matter.
And so there’s a lot of waste that has to be moved, and those that deal with the dump don’t ever come back into the main nest because they might have parasites. And so what you see are a really, really heavy division of labor between different casts. You’ve got a worker ant, a soldier ant with a massive head and mandible, and a minima of which I think are looking after the larvae. But all of these are sisters. They’re all female.
Males are only used for reproduction. And that is probably also why eusociality works in insects, because they’re really all just one sex. I’m not saying that women work all that well together, sometimes they don’t. My worst boss was a female, my best boss was a female. But this is a fact, they’re all sisters.
Okay, now one of the interesting things about ants, and this is not just by the soldiers, it’s also by regular workers as you can see here. They have this capacity, it’s called autothysis, which is where they have these really strong muscular contractions and it basically rips open their abdomen and they spill out this sticky corrosive substance that kills them, but it also kills the enemy that they’re fighting, which is usually a predator. And sometimes if the contraction is strong enough, it can spray a number of predators so they can kill more than one. And the other thing that ants engage in is something called altruistic self removal. And that means if they’re sick, if they’re old, if they’re parasitized, if they’ve got a parasite inside them, they will leave the nest.
Leaving the nest is suicide. They can’t live outside the nest. Which brings me to an extraordinary this I mean, I’m not just calling it extraordinary. You know, the biologist called it extraordinary too. This is Carebara perpusilla, you can’t really see the ant.
It’s it’s almost the best shot is in the in the top left. They’re they look almost exactly the same color as as the surrounding sandy soil. But what happens here is that every evening the nest is closed from the outside, not the inside. And they believe the reason why it’s closed from the outside is because, as you can see here, you get much better coverage. You know, if ant is basically kicking back, they really, really close the entrance, so no predator can see that it’s there.
And from one to eight ants close the nest, and because life outside the nest is impossible, it’s basically a death sentence. And there is some speculation that older ants are the nest closers, because they’re on their way out anyway. But nobody’s kicking them out of the nest, that’s the point. Nobody’s telling them to go because they sense a parasite, or because they’re sick, or because they’re old. This is a self organized behavior.
Nobody knows why. But if you’re talking about hardwiring of an altruistic behavior, you don’t have to look any further than here. Termites. We have the same situation. You see the warrior cast here.
The the head of of the soldier is almost as large as the body of of the workers. And in that, you know, that that autothesis process, they have in instead of in the abdomen, they cross their mandibles and press down like that which cracks cracks open a gland in their heads, and that squirts it out, but also that kills them. It’s often used in tunnel defense. And they also engage in altruistic self self removal. And as you can see from that termite mound from the top end, which is a very, very common site in Australia, they build extraordinary structures that have air conditioning.
There’s a lot of flow through ventilation. The the the architecture is really quite extraordinary. Bees. They also engage in altruistic self removal. Ilya this morning mentioned the stinger.
If you see here, this drone is has just implanted a stinger and you see as she pulls away, part of her guts come out. And she will continue to fight until she’s dead. And when when that part of her her intestines is is pulled out, it sends out a pheromone that brings other bees. So that also attracts other bees to the defense. Bees also have something called altruistic policing because sometimes a girl just has to be me.
And a drone, a worker will decide to reproduce because they can reproduce. And invariably, they produce males, which are only good for reproduction, and so they’re a drain on the colony. And the the mother wants to look after her young, so that’s a drain on the colony too. Her her labor is invested in her offspring, which she shouldn’t be having, instead of looking after the nest. And they literally beat the renegade up.
They really, really monster the bee, and they’ll eat the larvae. So there there’s there’s a there’s a high price to pay if you if you step outside if you step outside the needs of the group. Aphids, I was really surprised to see, are also self sacrificial, are altruistic. In these this structure you see, the the red structure structure is is a a gall, and you see these little arrows, they’re not very visible, but they’re trying to point to individual aphids that are coming to plug the hole. They use their bodies to plug the hole.
So that little fluff that’s on them is is also is also a repair material. Apparently, menopausal females tend to guard the entrance, so they have a post reproductive life like humans do. I didn’t know there was an insect existing that had a post reproductive life, but apparently aphids do. And some will immobilize a predator by gluing themselves to its body, which obviously kills them as well. So the bottom line is that the most successful and numerous species on the earth are social.
They’re cooperative, and they’re obligately altruistic. We have a lot of reason to believe that this kind of sociality is really, really old. And there’s no reason to assume that altruism is recent. Stromatolites, which are if you can see the the smaller picture is a is a fossil, but it’s a more recent fossil. These the striated rock are fossil stromatolites that are potentially billions of years old.
The oldest stromatolite and the oldest multicellular structure built by bacteria is believed to be 3,800,000,000 years old. That means the Earth formed at 4.5, and just as soon as it could, life was up and running and cooperative on this planet. And here is an example of living stromatolites at Hamelin Pool And WA, which is like the Mecca of stromatolites on the planet both for fossils and for living fossils. And the final message really is that altruism and love, because love and empathy can’t come from anything else but altruism. At what stage empathy enters the picture as something that can be registered, we don’t know.
But it is our as as Elias said, we’re hardwired for it. And not just us, a whole lot of other creatures too. Mostly in mostly mammals. And the reason why I’ve thrown in a couple of cross species snuggles is that according to kin selection, this should not happen. It shouldn’t happen at all.
Different species should not have a fellow feeling at all. It takes a whole lot of mental gymnastics just to justify it, which indicates to me that the theory has got to be wrong. But there you go. And I am extraordinarily grateful to my precious teacher without whom none of this would have been possible. My entire life as it is, is the gift of my teacher and I don’t know what more I can say about that.
Now if you have any questions about why I’m not a neo Darwinist, I’m perfectly willing to answer that. But I’m also willing to answer any questions you have now. So what is Neo Darwinism? Well, Neo Darwinism is it’s basically the gene’s eye view of of evolutionary biology. It’s like the gene is primary, and it’s the genes that basically, you know, in its most extreme, which is the Dawkins view, I am just a vehicle for my genes.
There are replicators and there are vehicles, and I’m a vehicle for the replicator, but it’s the replicator that’s primary. And it’s not just the genome, it’s specific genes that are beneficial in some way. Could you say something then about epigenetics? Yeah. This is one of the reasons why I’m not a neo Darwinist, is that the entire landscape of genetics has shifted since basically the year 2000.
And what happened in 2000 was the completion of the Human Genome Project. The first draft of the Human Genome was released. And while everybody was saying what a great accomplishment it was, what wasn’t spoken of so openly was what a shock it was. Because the dogma that had inspired the Human Genome Project was one gene, one protein. And the human genome just blasted that right out of the water.
The other thing we were assuming is that humans were going to have a whole lot of genes proteins. If if a nematodes had 29,000, we’d have a 100,000 or more. Right? No. A daffodil has more genes than we do, protein coding genes than we do.
A potato has more protein coding genes than we do. What we have are are regulatory genes that change the expression of of how the genes are used. And that’s one of the things that actually bacteria are fabulous at. They have this incredible, you know, compact endowment that they can use in all kinds of different ways. They are much better at adapting to novelty than we are.
You know, just basically on a on on a genetic level. And so what we also found out as a result of that so, you know, it’s not genes r us because the the whole, the whole process of of genetic expression is really heavily influenced by what we do. And and those those effects are called developmental. You know, it’s like there’s genes and then there’s development. Development is like it’s kind of like karmic formations or mental formations.
It’s like the garbage can aggregate in which everything that doesn’t fit in the others goes. And development is sort of like that. It’s like everything else other than other than actual genetic material. So for example, if you have a rat pup or a mouse pup that is raised by dam who is basically cold and not nurturing. Because rat pups actually have to be taught how to nurture.
They they they form like little straw dolls and stuff. They they actually are kind of taught to to nurture. If if you’ve had if you have a dam that’s, you know, been isolated from other rats and she doesn’t know how to lick properly, doesn’t know how to lick the pups properly, those pups, their their reactivity to stress is really, really highly activated. And that activation can be because of the patterns in which the genes are expressed, there are little chemical tags that get put on the genes, and those chemical tags get inherited by the next generation. So some of this stuff is generational.
That’s called methylation, patterns of methylation. There seems to be in in the Dutch hunger winter, right after World War two, the women who were starving in The Netherlands who gave birth their children were extraordinarily efficient at putting down fat. Efficient. It was like things are really really bad out here. It’s like anything you get, turn it to fat immediately.
And so their children had a tendency to be obese. They had more cardiac problems and that sort of stuff. And this has carried on to the grandchildren. I mean like to the to subsequent generations. Now, we don’t know how long it takes to run through that kind of an epigenetic cycle.
There are people who say that the autism epidemic is in part the result of of activated stress responses, which arguably would have epigenetic effects on the next generation. Although the mechanism of epigenetics in humans is not as clear as it is in rodents and others. Does that answer your question? Yes. There are huge amounts of stress in our western society with technology, etcetera.
And Bruce Perry, a American psychiatrist, did a lot of work of maternal deprivation with children who didn’t get that, you know, if the mother was stressed then the children would in adolescence develop antisocial behavior and so that critical relationship in the very early, whether it’s in the womb or but if there was one figure in the child in the infant’s life that showed love then all the oxytocin and everything else, was a protective factor for antisocial behavior later on. A lot of that’s really highly speculative. And the thing is is the whole business about antisocial behavior, what what high reactivity to what a what a highly geared stress response will get you is reactivity. It’s the reactivity that’s considered antisocial by us, by the society. If we we are asking we are asking our our our young people to fit into boxes that they were never that their biology never built them to fit More severe things like sociopathy and Sociopathy is absence of empathy.
That’s more likely to have a genetic component as well as nurturance, I think. It’s it’s yeah. I mean, you can blame mothers for a lot, but but and we do. Boy, don’t we just. But although there really should be a statute of limitations, think.
But I I think I think genetic endowment has a lot has a lot to do with it. Mean, how how do we explain this incredible rash of of of people on the spectrum? I mean, it’s never been heard. I mean, it’s it is absolutely unheard of in human history. But so is the level of infertility in supposedly, from a standpoint of gene theory, really fit people.
Because they’ve got money, they’ve got material resources and that sort of stuff. They should be the most fit, but they’re not, reproductively. Which is another reason why Gene’s eye view can’t be right. Yep. This is most probably more of a statement than a question.
Things can’t always be explained because sometimes things can’t always be explained because sometimes the nurturing is right but that’s where you’ve got to believe in karmic imprints. Oh absolutely. Just talking about the bacteria and everything else, something that I found that was very interesting. We don’t seem to be able to combat cancer because it’s always changing. Now you’re talking about this working together, you’re mostly talking about good bacteria but then when we talk about bad bacteria that forms and creates itself, and they say we all have a tendency.
We all have dormant cancer within ourselves. And when you’re talking about that interconnectivity, there’s good and bad within ourselves There’s no such thing as a good cancer. Well We’re we’re constantly our our immune system is constantly stepping bad bacteria, isn’t it? No. Bad bacteria bad bacteria, so called, they can switch.
I mean, like, right now, the thing that kills a lot of hospital patients, staphylococcus aureus, it’s on your hands, it’s in your mouth, it’s in your body. I guess that’s what I was talking not infecting you because it’s in balance with others. It’s when there’s an imbalance and one just says, one’s got like a shot at an ecological niche and they just go berserk. And that’s what creates an infection that has to be combated. But there is no cancer that’s good.
All cancer is basically selfishness run riot. That’s what it is. It’s a cell or a group of cells saying, I’ve got to be me, and I don’t care about the rest of you. But it just highlights change. That’s what I’m saying.
It just highlights change. Yeah. But it also highlights how if the collective in our bodies isn’t working together, it can be compromised really, really, really easily and thoroughly. Yeah. Based on all your research, what do you define as being sentient?
I’m glad you asked that question, Jad, because I’m I’m discussing the possibility of I’m floating this with you, Elliot, publicly now. Is I’m discussing with others the possibility of a sentience project. Of looking at the different the different Buddhist texts on sentience coming up with because as what I understand, it’s quite contradictory. It’s it’s a bit oozy. And there is no with with in in Western sense, it’s feeling.
And because of the problems of other minds, that’s all over the shop. So my personal view is that once you’ve got an organism that is responding to the three poisons, you’ve got attachment attraction, you’ve got aversion, you’ve got neutrality, I think that you’ve probably got a sentient being. But the implications of that are really, really uncomfortable because it means that there is no free lunch in a contaminated realm. We’re all eating other sentient creatures. You know, we’re all we’re all living off contaminated everything, which a lot of people don’t like the idea of, but it’s the logical end point of that view.
What would be the purpose of the cancerous cells in killing their host? What’s the purpose of Ebola killing its host? There is no purpose. They just do it. They do it because they can.
There’s no sentience there or no? No. No. No. No.
No. No. No. It’s just a system that hasn’t been checked. And then once the system starts rolling, it starts it starts acquiring stuff.
It starts bringing stuff into itself. It starts making blood vessels. It starts, you know, shoring up the means to keep itself going. And it’s got no interest. Has no interest in anything else.
Just the same way Ebola a virus that just replicates and replicates and replicates and replicates until somebody is basically hemorrhaging internally and bleeding from their nose, mouth, eyes, ears, everything. You know? What’s the point of that? Well, the virus then goes back into the environment, and it starts in another host. Cancer?
One could say that it goes back into the environment upon the death of of of the host and reconstitutes into something else. But it’s not a sentient being. It’s just a process gone crazy, which is kind of like apprehending self. You know, once you apprehend self, you got you got a process that’s really out of whack. You know, it just rolls and rolls and rolls and rolls and rolls, and a fundamental mistake was made, and everything just flows from it.
Nobody did it on purpose. It just happened. Yes? There’s some very interesting research by Professor Prigogine. You speak up a little bit?
There was some very interesting research. There was some very interesting research by Professor Ilya Prigogine. Thank you. It was prize of chemistry Please. Please.
Loudspeaker, this is stable equilibrium. Yep. You have a second state of equilibrium. Unstable equilibrium. Your potential energy is maximum.
Yes. This is a state of equilibrium. He found in nature, or in chemistry actually, that certain crystals clearly manifested states of unstable equilibrium. Yes. And to answer Nick’s question, I have always felt that you could actually define life thermodynamically as a state of unstable equilibrium in which a closed system, it can be a cell, but it could be a virus, maximizes its state of order at this expense of the environment, a state of unstable equilibrium.
Then on this basis you can distinguish between life and sentience. Because I think, personally, sentience can be defined in terms of quantum mechanics, as whatever is able to cause a collapse of a wave function. Because it’s one of the big problems now in the discussions with biology that we are not able to distinguish life and sentience clearly. You you we can. That’s a really good point, and thank you very much for that.
We can actually identify life over and above far from equilibrium states and self replicating far from equilibrium states. And that’s through the redox chemistry that is done by an organism. That’s already an extant organism that’s already got something like a replicative mechanism. Something like a contained chemistry that is constantly turning over. What I think is the difference between a living system and a non living system, and this is profoundly mysterious, and I think it has everything to do with mind.
That’s the uncomfortable implication for the materialists, I think, but it’s a hole big enough to drive a truck through, is self self preserving. Once you’ve got self preservation, you’ve got a whole different ballgame. You have, you know, you have not only DNA, but you’ve got DNA repair. You know it’s like sunlight, it’s actually damaging. So we’ve got all these little processes that will shore up DNA because it’s gonna get broken.
Right? We have stress responses for lack of oxygen, for too much oxygen, for too much heat, too much, you know, the wrong pH. All this sort of stuff, we’ve got all these, you know, systems upon systems upon systems, which in human beings are, you know, like monumentally complex. But even in a bacterium are amazing, to protect this thing, whatever it is, so that it will continue to exist. Viruses don’t do that.
Viruses don’t do that. See, we don’t there’s a huge debate about where viruses even come from. There’s there are people, you know, like Eugene Koonin, who says, you know, it was viruses first, and then we, you know, we grew cells out of that. But there’s there’s another school of thought that says, no, we had cells first, and then some cells just stripped away, stripped away, stripped away, stripped away everything they didn’t really need, and all they did was just replicate, replicate, replicate, replicate, replicate. Why?
Because they can. But they can’t do it without a host. They can’t do it without a cell. So these are huge mysteries. I think the real critical difference between a rock and a living thing is self preservation.
And that has everything to do with the self another distinction that mind makes just reflexively, you know, mistakenly. And so you get these massive you know, sequences of of of evolution of distinctive lineages of self grasping. You know? It’s like frogs. Frogs have their own lineage of self grasping.
Bacteria have their own lineages of self grasping. Lions have their own lineages of self grasping. And it’s just, you know, it’s self grasping all the way down. But where the original grasp comes from, that’s a mystery. But I think that that has something to do with the the co traveling of mind and the potential for physicality.
But that’s just my the idea that I’ve come to through looking at this stuff. Yep? Do wanna say anything about the problem with plants? No. Because bacteria came before plants, so anything that can be said of bacteria has to be said of plants.
And the the the well, apparently, I do wanna say something about plants. You know? Is that is that, you know, we now know that, you know, that that what plants are doing, they’re doing it really, really slow time scales, really slow time scales. And whereas, you know, a yogi can see, what is it, sixty-five mind moments in a finger snap? The fact of the matter is plants are working at like sixty-five mind moments in a finger snap slower, and they’re just moving really, really, really slowly.
So you can’t really detect what they’re doing except over much longer time scales. Know, you you look at the flower in the morning, you see that it’s open, you see it in the evening and it’s closed. But you didn’t see it close. You know, it was just one state and then it was another state. And and there are now films of of plants, you know, like beans and things like that.
They start growing up, and they start whipping around like this, and whipping and whipping and whipping and whipping until they grab onto something, and then they’re off and off and away. And if two things are whipping and whipping and looking for the same thing, if one hits, the other one go won’t start whipping in another direction so it doesn’t interfere. And they respond to acoustical signals. They warn each other of predators. It’s like if one starts getting eaten they’ll send off all kinds of pheromones, basically help help help help.
Nobody can help, but the other ones can start transforming their chemistry so that when the predator finally gets there, they’re gonna have a nasty shock. So, yeah, includes plants. Yeah. It’s a really strange and wonderful world. I mean, our our our self grasping has just created an astonishing an astonishing realm.
And then you look at the cosmic level and the the patterns of the way in which galaxies move around each other, replicating spirals within. Spirals within spirals within spirals. Yeah. And and it’s sort of Fractal universe. So then in terms of Ilya mentioned quantum physics, I guess you get into the tantric realm.
You know, what what on earth is going on? Well, I I can’t say anything about that. But in terms of quantum physics, I mean, the mere fact that the, you know, the electrons and the atoms of this of this laptop, and particularly this glass, are not entirely contained in the glass. You know, that they’re that that electrons are smeared out clouds of probability. I mean, what does that mean?
You know, it’s it’s a very, very we live in extraordinarily baffling baffling world and consciousness made it. You know, to me, it’s really really clear that that this was made by consciousness. To have bees and ants and others giving up their lives for the greater good, guess, I always thought, well, that was because they were, you know Programmed to do it. Yeah. Why only 20%?
Yeah. And and so the you know, what we’ve been hearing about bodhichitta and exchange of self rather, it touches down on what the unit that we are looking at. What is defining anything because if every system is simply a boundary which is defined in language, you take language out and labeling. I guess it gets down to what is the essence of There is no essence. There are no essences.
It’s all merely labeled. I find a problem thinking of bacterium as self grasping. We spoke before about mind having an influence on health. Yep. People that are nurtured, people that have warmth and the results of those tests.
So what do you base your labelling bacterium to self grasping? Fifteen years of research and peer reviewed articles No, in in peer reviewed articles in scientific journals. That’s what I base it on. Yeah, but I’m talking about relating the actual label, self grasping, to what they’re actually doing. They wanna live.
They wanna live and they’ve got all kinds of devices within the cell. Each individual cell has got a whole repertoire of ways of dealing with stress, different stressors. But is it for the cell itself to survive? Or is it for us to survive as a host? If you’re talking about a bacterium, the bacterium wants to survive.
Whether it wants to survive, it’s striving to live. And all of its machinery, except when it kills itself for others. All of its machinery is geared toward continuing to live. It wants to be. Look, Jad, it’s really hard to come at.
It’s really hard to come at. I can see where you’ve got a passion with the bacteria. Yeah. No. No.
It’s have compassion for them because they’ve got zero degrees of freedom. Well, it’s actually not zero. It’s probably point zero one. Yeah. But it wouldn’t exist if it wasn’t for the bacteria.
We’re we’re all made of how how much percentage are we They say they say I still can’t find out where this number comes from, but it’s it’s repeated over and over and over again. So it must be true that we are basically 10% us. 90% bacteria. Yeah. Don’t you think The ratio of our cells to bacterial cells on on on on our skin, in our bodies, is one to 10.
And what you’re saying is our mind doesn’t have control over our bacterium. Oh, no. If anything and this is the really scary bit. I mean, what what bacteria do in every other every other, organism they inhabit, they basically they they play them like violins. They they they alter the way their genes are expressed, they alter their behavior, they do and we have no idea what they’re doing to us.
We’ve got to assume that they’re doing something. So maybe if you have an imbalance of particular bacteria in your gut, you’re going to get irritable bowel syndrome or something like that. But we have no idea what they’re doing holus-bolus to us. So the way we live our life does not affect bacterium in our body. Everything affects the bacteria Everything.
In your It almost sounds like you say they’ve got a control of their own. But they do in the same way that your liver’s got control of itself, and your kidneys have control of their cells, and your lungs have control of their cells. What happens, you know, what what happens at a molecular level in the heart is very different from what’s going on in your lungs. And those are just parts within larger parts within larger parts that you then have you have a a whole body experience. But your liver’s not trying to hurt you and your kidneys aren’t trying to hurt you.
They’re doing the best they can. It’s like your mother. She did the best she could under the circumstances. And so the intention is just to keep going. It’s just to keep going, keep on keeping on.
How they do it and whether that ends up hurting you or or helping you is really not their concern. It’s your concern, but it’s not the concern of your liver and it’s not concern of the bacteria in your gut. They’re, you know, it’s it’s like there’s no leader. You know, this is this is one of the this is one of the illusions of mental consciousness is that we have this idea that there is something in us that is perpetual and it’s calling the shots and it’s doing everything. And it really is an illusion.
That doesn’t mean that isn’t that isn’t to say that you can’t decide you wanna train to become a bodhisattva, which is a really, really heavy thing to try, which is, As Ilya said, it’s turning back your biology. Generally speaking, all of this is just organizing itself interdependently. Does that make sense? I’m sure it’s not satisfying. No.
I’m sure it’s not satisfying. You don’t have to agree with a thing I say. Yeah. Good. Perhaps You don’t have to.
Perhaps the the conversation can continue over afternoon tea. Stopping me. This is so much fun. No. No.
No. No. You had a you had a fair old run. We have to connect everything for Vasilis’s talk, and we have a scheduled phone call for Switzerland at 04:00. Okay, when does this happen?
04:00. Okay, right. So we have to connect everything. Okay, good. Thank you.
If you could join me in thanking Pamela for an incredibly interesting meeting. There will be panel discussion at the end of the day, so formulate your questions and finish off then. Thank you very much. Yes, I am pretty weird.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is Neo Darwinism?
Neo Darwinism is basically the gene's eye view of evolutionary biology, in which the gene is primary. In its most extreme form, which is the Dawkins view, a person is just a vehicle for their genes. On this view there are replicators and there are vehicles: a person is a vehicle for the replicator, but it is the replicator that is primary. It is also not just the genome that matters, but specific genes that are beneficial in some way.
What can be said about epigenetics, and why does it matter for how we understand genetics and inheritance?
Genetics has shifted since about 2000, when the first draft of the Human Genome Project showed that the "one gene, one protein" dogma was wrong. Humans do not have more protein-coding genes than a daffodil or a potato. What humans have are regulatory genes that change how genes are expressed, and this expression is heavily influenced by what we do. These influences are called developmental. In rodents, pups raised by a cold, non-nurturing mother show highly activated stress reactivity, because chemical tags (methylation patterns) on the genes are inherited by the next generation.
How would you define a sentient being, based on your research?
The speaker is discussing a possible sentience project to compare the different Buddhist texts on sentience, which seem quite contradictory and rather vague. In the Western sense, sentience is simply feeling, and the problem of other minds makes that notion very unclear. The speaker's personal view is that an organism responding to the three poisons (attachment or attraction, aversion, and neutrality) has probably got a sentient being. The implications are very uncomfortable, because it means there is no free lunch in a contaminated realm.