Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 110730-005.mp3
UUID: 67d5c773-d599-4109-92a7-8fbb2a19ef5a
Teacher: —
Collection: TBI Symposium
Date: 2011-07-30
Duration: 48 min
Words: 4,521
How to identify the mind? That is very difficult. I mean, how to identify the mind? It’s very difficult. I mean, is possible to gain calm abiding with the mind as an object.
It is the most difficult object to use for the attainment of calm abiding. So I believe Geshe Rabten used it as an object. It’s got uncommon advantages because as it’s a non material object, it then prepares the ground for meditation on emptiness, where one basically conflates as it were, calm abiding and especially insight focused on emptiness. But they say that the biggest problem is identifying the mind. And then as Lopo Yinjin pointed out, the mind’s nature traditionally is said to be clear cognitive.
Clear means non material. It’s a cognitive component which is hard. Because how do I we identify cognition separate of the object being cognized? If I take for instance my eye consciousness perceiving the orange color of this cup, the first instance of the eye consciousness perceiving the orange color of this cup must somehow be separated from the orange color of the cup which is perceived. Perceived.
It’s a cognitive act we are talking of. If we try to concentrate on that eye consciousness and we concentrate on the orange color of the cup, which is in the wrong object. So actually identifying mind is very different. I think maybe that is what Pamela is addressing. I think it’s a marvelous example.
I had not thought of it. It’s an even stronger case because the the order of magnitude of the difficulty is just huge. There were cases I brought up in the reincarnation seminar. One I brought up, one I didn’t bring up. The case I brought up was a case of the great Indian mathematician Ramanujan, who basically at an early age with very little formal mathematical education was able first to formulate theorems which are far beyond the Indian mathematicians he was in touch with.
And eventually was sent to Cambridge and became one of the foremost mathematicians of his age. Another case I didn’t bring up in the symposium or the conferences on reincarnation was a case of a young black slave who spontaneously started playing the piano on the plantation where he was kept. And as you can imagine, educational opportunities for slaves are rather limited in the South in America. He was fortunate to have enlightened masters who didn’t think that a black hand touching the piano contaminated the piano. And he actually became a child prodigy.
He composed his own works. And what is striking about this young child is that he was blind. Started playing the piano blind. Wow. The case is famous.
Then the reason I didn’t bring it up is because he was autistic. So autistic children have exceptional abilities. I didn’t want that to interfere with with the issue. Did I just mention like, in animals, in chimpanzee, they can’t actually speak English, but you can teach them to sign. So chimpanzees can sign.
You can teach them to sign and they have some development of understanding of language. Also from my own experience, I have a Burmese cat and she understands very primitive signs and signals and you probably find that with dogs and particularly so. There are things we don’t know yet and also about language. I sort of believe that there is some kind of genetic element there. I was trying to point out this morning was the two examples, which is pre verbal ethics and the acquisition of language, is that the self evident model of acquisition of skills by children, the way it is presented to us, is anything but self evident.
I mean, is, I feel, something of excuse me for the term, a con job going on, where anything which poses real problems is just switched under the shell and shifted around. In the case of pre verbal ethics, there’s a real problem. Because if one accepts the standard paradigm, there is no clear explanation for where this ethics comes from, except the genetic one. But then that raises at least as many problems as it solves. But it’s very complex behavior to transmit genetically, to put it mildly.
Then how is it acquired? Then in the case of the poverty of information argument, it’s the same problem multiplied by 1,000. Because not only is the mode of transmission unclear, but it is unclear what could be transmitted which would help the child to make sense of a stream of a priori meaningless sounds. Because if you put yourself there’s a marvelous cartoon by an American cartoonist whose name escapes me. It’s the owner scolding his dog.
So the owner is speaking to his dog as we would do. Gary Larson. And he says, Fido, this is the last thing you should have done. You’re not gonna have supper today, Fido. And then you see in the dog’s mind, what the dog understands.
Blubbity blubbity blubbity. Fido. Blubbity rubbity So this is what a baby understands. How does the baby construct meaning? And what I was trying to drive at this morning is that it is presented to us as completely self evident, but a baby learns to speak in two years.
How does this happen? If there’s no transmission of structure, then the people who say the empiricists who say who say there is no transmission of structure must provide reasonable mechanism. My contention is that the mechanisms they provide fail the test of simplicity. And there are other simpler mechanisms. Then the fact that these other simpler mechanisms, which in this case of reincarnation, is reincarnation are not considered, is a case of bias.
True, it’s said that our non human rebirths are many more like rebirths in hells and as ghosts and animals, But it also goes on habituation as well, so that for us, for beings born in a human level and become habituated, develop strong habits for what in terms of life as a human and is providing they keep a certain level of ethics, they would tend to keep being reborn as human so that experience will tend to accumulate and so on. Human experiences are quite common then? Being born as a human is quite common? In the broad sphere of things, no. Because it’s said that the saṃsāra is like a pyramid and by far the most numerous are hell beings, then ghosts, animals, animals far more numerous than humans, then humans.
And humans are the first level of the upper realms, so the fortunate realms. Beings that do maintain a certain level of ethics will tend to reincarnate on that level. So there’s billions of humans in our world now. And this Yes. Well, it’s hard to say where each being has come from.
They may have just come from the animal realm or even the ghost or the hell realm. Or they may be descending from the desire god realms or the form realms. Yes, that’s another issue, especially literature, there’s the Human rebirth to start with. Precious human rebirths are exceptionally rare, Rinpoche says in the texts thousands. Human rebirths, there are a couple billion people in on this planet.
Why is a human rebirth rare? Its causes are rare. Why is ethics necessary to obtain a human rebirth? The key feature ethics is self restraint. So training in self restraint enables us to get a rebirth in which the practice of self restraint is possible.
The effect is similar to the cause. The key feature as Pamela pointed out this morning, this afternoon, excuse me, of animal rebirth and animals in general is the incapacity for any type of self restraint. Ethics is self restraint. So training in merely one type of self restraint is sufficient sufficient to lay the grounds for a human rebirth. As for a precious human rebirth, which means a rebirth where one actually encounters fully the teachings in the broadest sense of the term, one has the freedoms and the endowments, then there are numerous conditions.
But this idea of lower rebirth is an extraordinarily uncomfortable one for Westerners. There’s a lot of resistance to taking it on board, and I think the best way forward is first to think that certainly animal rebirths are evident. We can see them around us. Then either animals have consciousness or they don’t. If they don’t have consciousness, then we have to posit some sort of cutoff point in the hierarchy of beings.
We alone have consciousness, no animals have consciousness, or we and the great apes have consciousness, nothing below has consciousness. And if we’re gonna posit a cutoff point, we have to explain why we’re positing the cutoff point. If we can’t posit a cutoff point, that means all animals have consciousness. Then obviously, are a gigantic amount of animals. If we take the insects far more than human beings.
The problem is all the teachers say once one is reborn as an animal or as a spirit or a human being, there is almost no way out. Once that happens, it’s only through a past karmic imprint accumulated previously when one that one was in the higher realms that one can get out. Otherwise, is trapped. Take a dog, a dog creates dog karma all his life. And it’s this is not a, you know, this is not a trivial number of people.
So if if we can be reborn as a part and 2,000,000 is not a Well, the Buddha in one of the Jātaka tales was a plum tree. You know, it’s not I I have a question actually. And and Ilya just said something that really triggered triggered to me why the why it’s so important. I was wondering if I was wondering if it was possible to be a thoroughgoing materialist, which I’m not, To be a thorough going materialist and still be highly ethical. Now, one of the one of the examples you brought up was Noam Chomsky.
Noam Chomsky’s materialist. He’s also an extraordinarily ethical individual. Now, do you chalk that home to his Jewish upbringing? Or do you chalk that, you know, to what extent does his his materialist view, you know, bear on this? Now, I I think that, you know, I I can see how materialist ethic could could lead to, you know, hideous, you know, nihilism could lead to hideous consequences, like, you know, like the concentration camps and stuff like that.
But I’m not sure that it’s a foregone conclusion. And one of the reasons why I think this, and I didn’t realize I thought it until today, is that and this is something that that Sylvia mentioned earlier about empathy is that that also sparked this memory. Is that there are experiments with mice that show the precursors of empathetic behavior in mice who are highly sensitized to pain when they’re in the presence of a cage mate, not a stranger, only a cage mate who’s demonstrating pain behavior because they’ve been shot with something that’s making them hurt. These experiments, by the way, it’s these experiments have been elaborated upon. They’re Canadian experiments by in the lab of a guy named Dale Langford, if you’re interested.
In which they have shown that a mouse in one cage and a mouse in another cage, the mouse in the second cage is writhing in pain. The mouse in the first cage will approach that mouse and be as close to it as it possibly can for reasons nobody knows. But it looks like the precursors of empathy and they will only do it if they know the mouse. It’s been a cage mate. It’s not a stranger.
They will only do it if they are female. Only females do it. Males do not do it. And only females will approach other females. They will not approach a male, which is interesting.
But the point I’m trying to make is that the foundations for for empathy appear to be present in lived mammalian experience. Okay? So there is a basis for some ethic there, possibly, once you get to a kind of a a kind of a being that can reflect on its own experience. So I’m not entirely convinced that an a materialist viewpoint will necessarily ipso facto lead us to the concentration camps. It’s it’s a much more direct route, but I think possible to live an ethical it it is possible to live an ethical life if you’re a materialist.
There are a lot of people who are ethical, who are materialists. And the only way out of that is by chalking it home to some earlier cultural influence and I’m not sure I I don’t know if that’s right. What do you think? I don’t personally believe that being a materialist means that with one is unable to lead an ethical life, I think it is perfectly possible, like Chomsky, to be an extremely ethical man and a materialist. However, I think as a system of thought, materialism does not lend itself well to ethics.
When it lends itself to ethics, it lends itself to a utilitarian type of ethics. And you see the materialist philosopher such as Peter Singer, who are who is one of the leading nowadays. When He’s an extraordinary principled man. He’s an extraordinary principled man, but when they develop an ethics as in practical ethics, they develop a strong utilitarian ethics with, for instance, the consequences we all know, which is Peter Singer’s positions on euthanasia. Singer is one of the philosophers who has said that from the standpoint of a pure materialistic ethics, discrimination between human beings and animals is unwanted.
And therefore, if it is legitimate to treat animals as non persons, then in the same way, one should treat human beings who are mentally deficient as non persons too. Now this is precisely what happened to the Nazi Germany. This line of reasoning which is abhorrent, is a strong utilitarian stance. It is in the interest of society that these people not reproduce, there were campaigns of forced sterilization of mentally retarded people. It may be in the interest of society as a whole that these people not be maintained, and the interest of society is dominant in the utilitarian ethics.
Now this is a direct and clear consequence of materialism. I do not think as a materialist, you can make a strong case against utilitarianism. I don’t think so. No. And I’d like to know which one it is.
But let us not forget that Peter Singer’s later philosophy grew out of animal liberation Okay. Which was a clarion call But I you know that for Peter Singer united is igniting the interest of other species. Peter Singer is a remarkable man. Yeah. But Peter Singer’s positions are very delicate.
No. I’ve argued against him. Right. Now regarding materialism, I think we have no choice. Yeah.
That is the problem. His Holiness of Dialogue teaches on and on about secular ethics, not because His Holiness believes in secular ethics, but because nowadays, basically, everybody is secular. Yeah. Mean, we actually have to have conferences in Buddhist centers on path and future lives, which normally is completely unnecessary. Someone who comes to a Buddhist center normally believes in this.
If we have to have these conferences here, it shows a scale of the problem. I know he’s got his fans here, but I have to say in some medical linguistic circles in Sydney, he is kind of a person non grata for various reasons. I’m just pointing that out as being a devil’s advocate. So whilst Ilya has given a great view of what he’s presenting, I suggest you have to, like you would everything, take a pinch of salt. So I think I have to agree with you when you talk of individual cases.
Both of you draw on individual cases to counter a general argument. That’s right. Yeah. So the argument ad hominem is one I we do not use. I don’t draw on individual cases.
Here, I was giving a theoretical stance. I think for someone who is a religious practitioner of every any dominant religion in which there are teachings of ethics, there is something which will limit the damage they are ready to do to another person, the unethical behavior they are ready to engage in. Unfortunately, it is not always, sometimes it’s very seldom powerful enough. Unfortunately, if one is a strong materialist, and one has to be a consequent materialist, not a soft materialist. A full self avowed materialist for whom life starts at birth or at conception and ceases at death, and the mind is an active purely activity of the brain.
There is no clear philosophical reason not to harm another person. Somerset Maugham famously said that his ethics amounted to doing what he wanted with due regard to the policeman around the corner. This is a very, very articulate formulation formulation of of immaterialist ethics. I would put it to you that this is the dominant ethics, probably in Australia nowadays. Yours is considered one of the least religious societies in the Western world, and it is probably the dominant ethics in much of Europe.
Europe. The United States issue is more complicated. Now I am not saying by any means that all religious practitioners are ethical, nor am I saying that all materialists are unethical. What I was saying with these two experiments is pointing out that since there is of any way a natural trend towards entropy in human beings, a natural trend towards the worst, The presence of these barriers is very important and when they are absent, the worst can be expected. I mean, we are in the twenty first century, all of us were born in the twentieth century.
We have account for the fact that on record, the twentieth century, which is most civilized century in history, is the most violent. There has not been massacres on the scale of the 20 century in any other century in history. So if one talks from the standpoint of the enlightenment, which seems to be your case, you have to account for the fact that material progress, education have been rising, and yet there has never been so many atrocities. And I would put it to you that it is due to secularization. Thomas Kuhn, who studied the history of scientific revolutions and found that scientific paradigms do not change gradually.
And that is the problem we are facing right now. In the same same way as there wasn’t a gradual change from the from the geocentric system to the heliocentric system, but there was a sudden switch which occurred. In the same way, I think our present scientific strongly materialistic paradigm would not change gradually. I think the evidence is piling up. I think there is a lot of evidence from ESP myself.
Pamela has pointed out the evidence from cognitive behavior in unicellular organisms. I think what will happen is that that evidence is just going to keep on piling up and at a certain point something will snap. I, to be honest with you, do not believe very much in dialogue. In what? In dialogue with the scientific community.
I mean, I’d like to say I did. I know it’s like the consensus opinion that this leads us somewhere. But if you look at the great pioneers like Stevenson or Robert Jahn’s work in PEK, where you have leading figures of the scientific establishment who were heads of departments in top universities. Stevenson at University of Virginia, Robert Jahn at Princeton. These are top American universities.
They were basically destroyed when they investigated something which was strongly at odds with a dominant paradigm. So if someone inside the community who is articulate, who publishes in peer review journals can have no lasting impact, then I think our chance as scattered Western Buddhists with limited credentials is very small. It is, but that’s why the Mind and Life Institute is so important because it started off in the late early 90s with nothing much happening and the attempt to establish credibility in the scientific world. And so now, in the last five years, this has happened. So they have established credibility because the Varela Fellows who were experts in their areas of research have been published in peer reviewed journals.
Now this is a sign in science that they’re accepted. If it’s peer reviewed, then the people who reviewed those papers had to accept accept them as being valid and if the information was published in well established scientific journals, for example, such as the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, that’s supposed to be the peak journal. If you’ve got your article in that, well you pretty much made it, I mean, getting into the mainstream. So what’s happened in the last ten years? These things are moving into the mainstream.
Once it’s in the mainstream and funding’s obtained from reliable sources and you’ve got reliable facilities and universities participating, I showed you, That list was only part of a list. There might be 20 more universities that are accepting this. So America now is taking the lead, which it usually does. There are a couple of places in Europe. Australia hasn’t got anything like that.
That’s why I urge anyone who’s involved in the area to try and do collaborative work. Also The UK, nothing’s happening much there but it’s hopeful that something might happen because I didn’t mention, but there is a first time conference on compassion that’s occurring somewhere in The UK again in I think the March, early April, and it’ll be followed by this first conference on contemplative science. The fact that there is now a specialty called contemplative science has to be revolutionary. So, you know, I think you should take that on board, and I think there is hope, but as Ilya said, the change is slow, but part of the area that scientists are working in and in collaboration with the Buddhist adepts is fraught with difficulty because you have to make sure your experiment has validation and is accepted by other scientists so that it could be reproduced. It doesn’t matter what you’re doing in science, it’s the same thing applies.
That is the crucial point. Also I think it is a difficult issue that just finding a dialogue between these different disciplines. But I think it’s up to us also to be aware of the data, be aware of what is being said. Because often the claims that are made within science go beyond what is actually there, what is feasible, what can be done. And I think it’s up to us also to be aware of the underlying assumptions of what is being said, and to be aware that we do live in a materialist world that does tend to present just one aspect, one style of information to us.
And there’s a danger that we just get used to that and think, oh, well, that’s all there is. And there’s a tendency for us to become a little bit nihilistic if we’re not careful, and we need to analyze what data is being presented and what value there is there. I think this is an ongoing issue. We can’t just take it on hearsay or face value. We do need we need to be honest individuals.
We need to keep the scientists honest as much as we can. And be aware of the issues and not just accept what is given or what is stated or what is broadcast in the media or in the newspapers or magazines to realise that all of this plethora of information and data that is presented, we don’t simply have to accept on face value. We need to investigate. Okay. I’ll try and make it useful then.
I think that I I agree with Ilya that that dialogue is has really, really, really limited value. I think that the amount of energy that goes into organizing it, trying to get everybody singing off the same page, and that sort of stuff. And you you read some of the results of it and you just go, what were they thinking? I mean, you know, they were just talking, you know, across at cross purposes. Consciousness at the Crossroads is one of those books.
It was a dialogue with the Dalai Lama and Patricia Churchland, who’s a famous materialist, was like, they weren’t even speaking about the same thing. It was really really weird. So I think the best way to do it is to smuggle it in under the cover of darkness. You know, you and as as Geshe Phelgye said, so it’s the Buddha’s idea but you’re gonna get credit for it. And I said, that’s right.
So you smuggle it in. And, you know, when when I first started doing my PhD and I looking at bacteria, everybody thought I was nuts. By the time I was finished, people were talking about this like it was it was a done deal. It was like there were because there were there was science in other places where this was coming to the fore and I mean I was just one of many many voices. You know, the the the stress response hypothesis is based on the three poisons.
I mean seriously, based on the three poisons. And, you know, one of the commentators of that said, this is a really great model. It’s like, well, not mine, you know. So I think you smuggle it in. You smuggle it in and then when accepted you go, oh, by the way, and one of the ways that’s been done is in primatology.
There was a there was a great Japanese primatologist named Imanishi, who was a Buddhist, he was Japanese. And he he was looking at at at the the behavior of Japanese macaques and he thought he saw culture happening there. Cultural transmission of of ways of doing things from, you know, mothers to children and that sort of stuff. Well, in the in the West, this was just heretical, know. I mean, it was before Jane Goodall, you weren’t supposed to name animals, animals were just, you know, machines, you know, it couldn’t possibly be culture and there was a paleontologist, very famous paleontologist, this is a problem with peer review, who went to Japan and tried to tell Imanishi why he was so wrong and then came back and wrote something in nature, which is about as mainstream as it gets on how misguided Japanese primatology was.
And now we recognize that there is cultural transmission in chimpanzees, bonobos, macaques, whales, dolphins, you know, and a number of other species. So that’s an that’s an instance where a Buddhist idea really got some legs on in science. So it’s not all materialist claptrap. That’s all.
Key terms in this teaching
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
- upper realms
- The three higher realms in samsara of human, asura and sura. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.