1 h 4 min · 7,593 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The speaker argues that evolutionary biology and cognitive science show even simple organisms have adaptive cognition, and that life is driven by self-grasping and self-preservation, which he compares with the Buddhist twelve links of dependent origination. He links stress-response research to this and suggests liberation from the cycle is very difficult but possible. A question and answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 4m
UUID: a5908843-a7e5-41a8-81b1-30512957613d
Words: 7,589
Perspective. So I’m going to tell you a little bit about myself and my qualification to even talk on this subject because I don’t think that you should take my word for anything anyway, but you sure certainly shouldn’t take it because I’ve been hanging around the dharma for however long I have because I mean I certainly don’t have any attainment. So why should you think I have any any qualification to say anything on this subject? And I’m hoping that I will at least engender a small amount of confidence in you based on on what I’ll now tell you. Very clearly the inspiration for all of the work that I’m going to be describing and my involvement in it and and my pursuit of it has been Khensur Rinpoche who inspired me and encouraged me to do a PhD many years ago.
And that PhD turned out to be fairly unusual from both of our standpoints. It sort of surprised us both. And it it turned out being a more or less western whoops, woah. That was quick. It was a a western philosophical and scientific argument in favor of looking at really really really simple organisms to get clues as to what cognition actually is because in as as Sylvia pointed out, in the West we really don’t know what cognition is.
We say, you know, the mind is the brain and that sort of leaves takes care of it. But when you start looking at things like fruit flies and ants and things like that that don’t have proper brains, they have neural nets, then we use different language. And there are a lot of people who will say that those are cognitive, there are other people who will say that you need neurons in order to have cognition. What I was saying was let’s basically take, I mean, being specific, I said let’s take the Buddha at his word and say, you know, all sentient beings have minds, let’s go right to the bottom and take a look and see if they do. And what I I was really going doing it to rule them out, really.
But what I found was, this is really bizarre, this is from another presentation so the timing may be that be automatically timed, is what the science shows actually is that bacterial responses are far more flexible, they’re more complex and they’re more adaptable than generally believed and they’re they’re that way because they’re they’ve been they’ve evolved under with the same kinds of pressures that mammalian cognition has. That means, you know, the requirements of sex, the demands of cooperative living, and navigating an environment in which there are many deceptive signals as well as confusing signals, also known as epistemically polluted environments. And all of these things basically significantly shape our behavior and it is it’s we’ve been finding in the last ten, fifteen years that they these same factors influence bacterial behavior. Also, the information processing systems that generate bacteria behavior share remarkable mechanistic similarities to those that generate behavior in in mammals. These are not simply conceptual similarities.
They’re also macro molecular similarities, general chemical kinds of processes. And that genomic comparisons have shown us that molecular mechanisms for generating now we’re talking gross consciousness. Gross mind here, we’re not talking about very subtle mind, we’re not talking about extremely subtle mind, we’re talking about really really gross, the gross really body bound stuff. Okay? That’s what we’re talking here.
And and that these are deeply conserved. And this is probably gonna race on. Bacteria show all of these capacities. Now if you take a really quick look down the list, they’re gonna look really familiar. And I’m more I’m more than happy to provide this to anybody afterward if they want to.
I’ve I’ve given this talk now probably the the talk relating to this in about five different half a dozen settings including and cognitive scientists and biologists, nobody even questions this. Nobody even questions this. This is really non controversial. Okay. So that led me to posit a way of approaching cognition from a western scientific understanding of it because we have such trouble understanding suggested that we take what I call the biogenic approach, which is basically you look at the biology first, you see what it takes to make a living, you start simple, you scale up and you integrate from different levels.
This proved to be a fairly attractive proposition to a surprising number of people and as a result here at Adelaide we sponsored foundations for a cognitive biology project for three years. Now that project was basically an aim to devise a conceptual toolkit for describing cognitive phenomena across diverse phyla. So if we’re talking about memory, you know, at a very basic level, we’re talking about retaining information for a non zero period. Now if you wanna talk about episodic memory or autobiographical memory or anything like that, you’re talking about enrichments on this basic capacity. Okay?
And the network involved in the end more than this, philosophers and scientists in multiple disciplines at I think we’re over a dozen universities now. And some of the things, some of the people involved in this are absolutely, I mean couldn’t have ordered it on a plate, are people who are absolutely top in their field. Ralph Adolphs at Caltech is one of the top two experts on social neuroscience and emotion in the world. He trained with Antonio Damasio and he’s, you know, he still still works with him. Janet Wiles is at Queensland, and she is her her area is language, and by the way, she’s very interested in Buddhism.
So she might be worth considering at some point in the future. She couldn’t get enough of Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen on our one day conference, she just met him and they just talked talked talked for the next ten minutes, fifteen minutes. And she’s got a number of publications. Colin Allen is sort of the grand old man of cognitive science trying to get cognitive scientists who are trained in mathematics and the Turing machine, the artificial intelligence model to start looking at actual animals. And Carl Craver wrote the recent book on what, you know, what constitutes an explanation in the neurosciences.
There’s we’ve got Trust me, I’m the least accomplished in the group. And one of one of the This is This poster is just an example from the conference we had to show you the direction in which we were going. It’s like, you know, trying to make people think about mind in really really simple systems. Okay. The biogenic approach brought me into close contact with evolutionary biology because it’s intrinsically evolutionary.
And I like Ilia reacted really badly to the entire sociobiological, which really is Dawkins. It’s Dawkins more than than Wilson even. It’s it’s it’s Richard Dawkins. Richard Dawkins. And so the first paper that I wrote on it was about, you know, basically saying if altruism cooperation is found throughout, you know, throughout the living world.
I mean, the most successful the most successful species, ants, bees, termites, humans are are really really cooperative, in fact, altruistic, really, you know, self sacrificing. Also bacteria who sacrifice themselves in the growth stage for others, then why is it such a puzzle? You know, why don’t and so I was using bacteria as an example on that. The other one is, this is this is a real anti-Dawkinsian rant, and it appeared in this this book this year. And I mean, if if anybody’s interested in in a trashing of Richard Dawkins in a really principled scientific way.
I had to strip all of the rhetoric out of it because the editor of the volume was a real fan of Richard Dawkins and in fact had written a defense of him against one of his leading critics. This led me weirdly into the realm of stress response biology. These two wonderful men, John in Perth and Milton Cohen in Sydney, contacted me in late two thousand and eight to ask me if I would think about in evolutionary terms a syndrome called fibromyalgia. It’s chronic widespread pain with a whole bunch of other different kind of comorbidities that troop along with it and I had absolutely no expertise in this area, I said sure if you think I could be of help I’ll try. And that got me thinking about the nature of the stress response and cognition, so when I was invited to give a paper at an evolutionary workshop near Vienna in 2010, basically what I did was I started connecting the dots between cognition and the stress response.
And what that work has now resulted in after two years of hard slog is this evolutionary stress response hypothesis for chronic widespread pain, which has just been published in pain medicine. It’s my first scientific publication, so I’m really really excited about it. And some of the ideas that all, that come from the wheel of life are the model for this. So there’s a lot of Buddhism that’s been sort of smuggled into this hypothesis hypothesis that nobody would guess. And as a result of that, I have, I now have a visiting research fellowship at the social epidemiology and evaluation research group.
This is the head of the group who who likes me for my philosophical skills because he says anyone can learn the detail which is quite encouraging. And so how this all relates to this presentation is that what I’m hoping to show is how evolutionary theory combined with the findings of contemporary biology illuminate the tremendous difficulty involved in achieving liberation from suffering. And why the path to cessation is truly a hero’s journey. I mean these are not metaphors. It’s real.
When when it when when when when those who have achieved liberation, we’re talking we’re not talking about enlightenment at all here. We’re not talking about the refinement of the subtle and very subtle minds to its highest capacity. We’re just talking about getting shut of this. This body, this life, the cycle of of rebirth. Okay.
So in order to do that, we’ve got to talk about what we mean by evolution in both cases. This as many of you know is the wheel of life, the famous Tibetan iconic representation of the description of how things are. And the thing in this case is cyclic existence existence and how we come we come to experience suffering at multiple timescales across multiple lives, across one life and within every moment, within every instant. It is also, if you want to put it in scientific way, it’s a mechanism, an explanatory mechanism for how things got that way. And these are called the 12 links of dependent origination and those links are that go around the outside of the circle but all the action that really drives it is in here.
And that is, those are the three poisons of ignorance, in this case it also means indifference, not the technical meaning of ignorance, it means that too, but it also means indifference. Desire and attachment and aversion hatred. And how all of those mind states influence, how they influence actions which become propensities for further actions which is the activity of karma. And then how to, there’s an explanation of how to cut the cycle which is liberation and that is through the wisdom of knowing how things actually exist. Okay, Darwinian evolution on the other hand is similarly a description of how things are, it’s about the diversity of the living world.
And it explains the diversity diversity in form and function as arising from heritable changes accumulated usually over generations, sometimes they can be very very rapid. Excuse me, I’ve got a cold. In response to environmental change, that is pressure on making a living. And it’s also a mechanism for how things got that way which is natural selection and the premise of natural selection is that more offspring are born than can survive given limited resources and this results in a struggle for existence. Darwin never said survival of the fittest.
Never said survival of the fittest. He never once in all of the origin and its multiple editions used the word selfish once. Never. Ever. Ever.
Selfish is what Dawkins brought to the story. Okay? That sociobiology. Darwin never said it. Okay.
And that that struggle for existence under the pressure of environmental change, differences in form and function become apparent between individuals and those differences that enable organisms to survive and pass on their genes are selected. And as these changes accumulate populations of species begin to diverge. So these things generally happen at the margins where two populations come together and one will be under more pressure than another because of the marginality of the habitat And so beaks will change over time or or or the thickness of the epidermis will change over time. Coloration will change over time. And behavior also changes over time.
Okay, the central implication of Darwinian evolution is that all living things extant today arose from single celled ancestors and that there is an underlying unity amid the diversity. What works is conserved. I was gonna use the example of olfaction because people almost never use it but I’ll check and see how much time I’ve got at the end. What I wanna point out is that Drosophila melanogaster, a fruit fly, is telling us most of what we know now about the circadian rhythms and those systems are highly conserved in us. They use molecular things.
Aplysia, the sea slug, has taught us most of what we know about memory, the basics of memory. C. Elegans, the nematode, It associative learning in the nematode is mediated by serotonin in the same way it is in humans. Not exactly the same way, but you know, haven’t got the real estate up here basically, but you know, it’s working with it. Rodents are telling us so much about the stress response, about memory and learning, about the the impact of of early maternal handling and and and early infant development and how that affects the stress response and that sort of stuff.
It’s it’s amazing what we do to rodents. It’s just so horrible. Completely impossible to imagine because basically we can’t tinker with primates anymore because we recognize how close they are to us. And this is an archer fish and it is also it’s a it’s a tiny it’s a tiny fish that basically shoots its prey. Sorry.
Shoots its prey from the water. The prey is in the air, it shoots it from the water. It is a complex behavior that is both innate and learned. An archer fish has to watch another archer fish do it in order to learn it. How do they know to observe what’s going on in their little pea brain?
We have absolutely no idea. But some of the visual filtering devices that are used in archer fish are also how humans process this visual information. So what we’re looking at is that what is conserved works, what works is conserved. In the case of olfaction, whether you’re talking about insects or whether you’re talking about humans, there are two synapses. That’s it.
Two synapses, two neurons, synapse to synapse from the detection here and a sophisticated processing in the brain. You know like in in the memory centers, in in the emotional centers, that sort of stuff. Two synapses, insects humans, same. Remarkable. All across all across the living world, the the sense of smell is remarkably conserved.
The human genome project was a huge wake up call about how unspecial we really were. We were expecting about a 100,000 genes to be identified with the numbers now 29,000, which is not very much. Potatoes have more. And that humans and mice share about 89% of their genes which is why they’re such good models for us but they’re bad models in other ways. And humans share about 20% of their genes with daffodils.
And potatoes has more genes. Okay. So the points of contact that I’d like to highlight here is the centrality of change in both both accounts. Evolution just really means change. It doesn’t mean progress toward anything, it just means change over time.
That’s all it means. There’s no progress. You know, everything is equally evolved. Know, bacteria are not primitive. They’re really really really optimized living machines.
They don’t have bizarre courtship rituals, and they don’t have, you know, all sorts of problems with, you know, teenagers and that sort of stuff, but they, you know, but they they’re they’re as evolved as we are. And in this centrality of change, both both accounts seem to note that there is there’s a same, there’s a general character of the adjustment of the minds perception of its situation with its external circumstance. And, but when you ask internal or external to what, you then are left with this notion of the self. And it both the self is is is It’s more implicit in Darwin, but it’s absolutely inescapable. And that is that all ordinarily lived experience, all ordinary behavior takes place in reference to the organism, which is itself.
Now there are different conceptions of self here. In the Buddhist sense, the the mistaken I is the mistaken apprehension of an entity that exists over and above the five aggregates of form, feeling, etcetera. And over and above the label that designates those aggregates as the basis of the label. Darwinian or biological self is the total material organization that supports the organisms continued existence. And, but the thing that joins the two of them is this is this really really strong sense of self preservation enhancement which basically is self grasping by any other name.
Unfortunately, the self grasping nature of life is too often equated these days with Dawkins extremely muscular and utterly misleading metaphor in the selfish gene. Genes are not selfish, they haven’t got the means to be selfish. Although Dawkins says his narrative is is metaphorical, he makes it sound like it’s not when you read his book. And And he says it’s authentically Darwinian, it I can’t I I don’t see I don’t I really don’t see any when you read Darwin and you read Dawkins, they’re two different guys, really different guys. And so my feeling is this is a sociobiology and a Dawkins free zone.
So also that I don’t I also want to make clear that Darwinian evolution isn’t the only kind of evolution there is. It’s just one. It’s one type of it’s one mechanism amongst many in evolution. But that’s another story entirely, but Darwin is is the face of evolution as it were. So I’ll use him.
But life’s bottom line basically is that you hang in there whatever it takes. You do everything possible to to keep going. Unless a higher orders order existential goal is at stake. You know, the the idea of the spider that you know that gives himself over as a meal so he can mate with the female. Basically, they really don’t wanna be eaten.
They do try to avoid it. They just frequently can’t. Same with praying mantises. Very very If they can get out of it, they will. Okay.
So what is life? The short answer is we don’t know. And we’re serious. We may be looking for it on other planets, but there are over 50 definitions of life. And they all sort of cluster around whether you put reproduction most uppermost or whether you put metabolism up uppermost, but I think the most plausible answer really is comes from Maturana and Varela.
Varela who’s already been mentioned as the as one of the inspirations and moving forces behind the mind and life institute. Interestingly, his relationship with his mentor, Maturana, fell completely apart as a result of Buddhism. He tried to convince Maturana of Buddhist principles, Maturana just wasn’t having anything having anything to do with it. But one their plausible answer is autopoiesis or self production. And I’ve only outlined three of the of the processes that are involved here.
And that is that living things are organized systems that they produce the parts and the network of parts to constitute their structure. Structure. Okay. So if a Boeing seven seven four seven was autopoietic, it would be manufacturing its ailerons and the chairs that you’re sitting in and all the instrumentations while it’s flying. Okay?
It would be manufacturing all that as it goes along. Okay? This is really weird. Life is really strange. There is nothing in the non animate world that does anything remotely like life.
And these parts do this by converting matter and energy into chemical forms that do work thereby maintaining self production. And the system is causally open to its surrounding milieu, it has to be, but it is also organization ally closed. What this means is that causal interactions with the surroundings are absolutely crucial. No being is an island. No being can exist without than its milieu.
It needs needs to secure matter and energy without which everything grinds to a halt. It also means that the relation to self, to milieu has to be continually assessed. And this is where this is the basic argument of the stress response hypothesis that our pain article is based on. That there are basically three kinds of states that all organisms have to assess at any kind, at any given time. You know, the circumstances now is one of three kinds of things.
The first one is it is it tolerable? Is it acceptable? Is it okay? If can I function in this particular situation? Which is kind of neutral, indifferent, okay.
The second one is, is the situation intolerable in some way? Is it threatening in some way? Is it challenging in some way? If so, you have to the organism has to do something now. If it’s a stressor, the organism acts.
It has to. Because its its entire history of self grasping, its lineage of self grasping as as it were, says that if you don’t do something now, it could be curtains. And the last last one is, is the situation rewarding? You know, is it, you know, where where you are, is this gonna take you to a better is this gonna take you to a better better level? And if so, go for it.
And to the the extent to which people go for it, individuals go for it, whether you’re whether you’re a mouse or whether you’re human, is really highly variable between between individuals. But this is sounding pretty familiar I think. And that is this this tripartite continuum of tolerance which sounds really sounds really technical is really basically the three poisons. And when you start looking at the you know, there’s always the danger of she who’s in possession of a hammer, all the world looks like a nail. But once you start looking into in into biology, it just it’s really really clear.
Everything. I mean, everything is responding in this way. Okay. I’m just going to refresh everybody’s memory here. I’m not gonna go into what the how these things work, but I just want you to refresh your memory on what the 12 links of dependent origination are.
It begins with ignorance and that’s that misapprehension form of ignorance which leads to action and and the propensities for action which shape a consciousness when it comes when it comes into the world and that’s that’s the both it’s it’s it’s physical form and it’s it’s it’s it’s mental nature. By the way, I’m an ontological agnostic. I don’t believe in the word material. I don’t think anybody knows what they’re talking about when they say material. And until they do, I’m just, you know, I’m a Buddhist.
But I but I don’t know. I I don’t know what physical means anymore. I I just don’t. And there’s a whole process of of of of having particular types of sensory bases that which then come in contact with the world in in, I would put in Darwinian terms, in species specific kinds of ways, that generate feelings in particular types of ways, that a craving for something and then a grasping at it, a clinging at it, and that is at its very base the the reason that anything, sentient beings exist at all. And that leads to birth, aging, and death.
Okay. So if you cut off ignorance, you basically cut that, the whole shebang. But here’s the problem. Life is just self grasping. It’s life is constituted by self grasping.
Sorry, just in case you missed the point. And the lineage of self grasping on this planet alone is 3,850,000,000 years old. Okay? To understand what that means, the planet as a planet has only existed since 4,500,000,000. That means that life got started just as soon as it could.
We don’t know whether it was a hot, you know, was really really hot or whether it was a bit cooler. There’s a lot of, you know, there’s a lot of special speculation about this, but the lineage is really old. And from the moment that it could be characterized as life, autopoiesis, it was grasping at self preservation, which is basically what the anti Dawkins rant that I I engaged in was is about. But there’s another problem and that is that the response the stress response runs the show. That may sound really weird because self grasping is attachment.
It’s a desire to be. So it would seem that it’s desire, but we don’t recognize it because we’re really only finding out how much it actually runs the show. And I’m going to provide three lines of evidence here, not so much on the high degree of evolutionary conservation because I haven’t got time for that, but I’ll bring in some psychological literature and I’m also going to point out the discovery of the role of the immune system in normal cognitive functioning. And this is actually this area here is where my current work is really and connecting it to this. Okay.
This is really stunningly awful. In psychological terms, bad is always stronger than good, always stronger than good under normal circumstances. If you’ve got a masochist, different story. You’ve got a sadist, different story. If you’ve got an addict, different story.
But those are all distorted, disordered states. Okay? Under normal circumstances. This is a long quote from a extremely detailed and extensive review of the literature by Roy Baumeister and his team. Roy Baumeister is probably the leading expert on self regulation and emotional self regulation.
And his his work is is is very very very interesting, which gives gives a really appalling look into what we’re up against in our day to day lives in modern society, modern western society, and how it really isn’t suited to us at all. We’ve made this world in which we cannot thrive, it’s kind of weird really. But in brief, bad emotions, bad parents, bad feedback have more impact than good ones and bad information is processed more thoroughly than good. The self is more motivated to avoid bad self definitions than to pursue good ones. Bad impressions and stereotypes are quicker to form and more resistant resistant to disconfirmation.
Once they’re there, they’re really hard to get rid of than good ones. Hardly any exceptions indicating the greater power of good can be found. That means that anything that is bad is remembered better and it has more influence on your future decisions. Okay. Now, if we’re talking about what constitutes bad circumstances, they don’t have to be horrific, they don’t have to be life traumas, they don’t they’re they’re in fact, a lot of them are just really ordinary everyday experiences.
You go into the shopping, you know, you go in to get some shampoo and you’re not quite with it, maybe you got a little low blood sugar or something like that, and suddenly you can’t remember what you’re supposed to be buying, why you’re buying it, whether you’re happy with your current shampoo, there’s 50 different types and you go out with nothing. Right? Okay. Well, what you’re what what I’m going to show you now is just a just a very very quick panoply of the kinds of things that happen in our everyday lives that come up as bad. They may seem normal, but they come up as bad.
Social isolation. All of our technology that makes us have to work so much faster than we really can. Relations at work, overload, joblessness or feeling precarious, moving, any kind of movement, big change, grief, it’s all really quite a bit much and frequently multiple stressors are happening at the same time. Okay. Now here’s a real kicker, uncertainty is a stressor.
Your body responds to uncertainty, the mental state of uncertainty as though it were a threat. And there’s converging evidence from animal research, clinical studies and neuroimaging that suggests that the need for control is a biological imperative for survival. The perceived presence or absence of control has a profound impact on emotion, cognition and physiology. Tasks that involve choice are always more enjoyable. In a nursing home study in the in the mid seventies, they found that residents who had even small choices had improved mood, quality of life, and longevity.
Learned helplessness, a phenomenon that was discovered in the mid sixties by Martin Seligman who’s one of he and he and a co worker. Martin Seligman is now sort of the leading cheerleader for positive positive psychology. But learned helplessness is just a total feeling of lack of control that that no matter what you do, it’s not gonna it it will not avail. And this has massive effects on autonomic arousal, your your pattern of of heart rate variability, your stress hormone release, immune function and adaptive behavior. And the problem is is that life is uncertain.
So uncertainty is a given. We don’t have very much control and a lot of the control that we think we have is illusion. One connection with cognition here is that uncertainty appears to improve memory and learning. Cichlid fish are an African fish and they’re cooperative breeders and they’re really quite smart. And there was a recent study of of cichlid fish and life over over their lifelong learning that showed that one change in, I’ll put these all out, that whoops.
A single change in food availability, it could be positive or negative, all it had to do was change. Made those fish who were in that treatment better lifelong learners. They learned things faster, they they were more responsive to novel objects in their in their environment. Those fish that had a regular routine, you know, food delivered on time every day during their developmental period, weren’t quite as fast. And the idea here is that if you are in unpredictable environment, you have to learn things that are new in your environment really fast.
So that this is this is a very very recent recent experiment and there are developments going on with this, and there are similar types of studies that are being done with rodents. Okay, in psycho neuro immunology, which is now the study of of brain behavior and and the immune system. As recently as twenty five years ago, it’s the same thing as Sylvia was talking about with the no new neurons, you know, doctrine. Now we know that we we have that we have we generate neurons all through our adult lives. Until about 25 ago, the medical profession thought that the brain was an immune privileged organ.
The immune system just didn’t operate there. Now we know that it operates, it not only operates in the brain, the brain probably has its own immune system. And there are brain cells that synthesize elements of the the immune system. And what what is most striking about the the work in the last ten years, ten, fifteen years, and there’s just heaps and heaps and heaps of this stuff coming out right now, is that elements of the immune system are involved in learning and memory, specifically in neuroplasticity. That’s a this is a synapse.
This is where all the action takes place in in learning and memory. It’s it’s it’s the junction between dendrites, two dendrites of, the dendrites of two neurons. Basically you have neurotransmitters that are released from the synapse and then are picked up by the other side but there’s also an electrical charge that moves across this so it’s both chemical and it’s electrical, the messaging system. So the two major things that are involved in neuroplasticity which Sylvia mentioned this morning are Long-term potentiation, that means it activates the neuron or depression inhibits the neuron and synaptic scaling which is means by which an individual neuron sort of evens out the weights of the various synapses on it so that, you know, over stimulation on one particular synapse won’t throw the whole thing off. So that it is no longer functional within the network.
Okay. But what it’s also showing is, okay, so in in these processes you have basically immune messengers that have been are the harbingers of inflammation. They’re also used to excite and depress the activity at the synapse of which is totally, I mean nobody expected that. Not only that, these cytokines, these messengers called cytokines are also really really heavily involved in neurogenesis, the generation of new neurons and whether or not they become functional. But what neuroplasticity shows really clearly is that we can dramatically alter habitual responses.
We can reprogram. And that there’s actually quite a bit of top down control on what then becomes automatic behavior. But in in the beginning, there’s there’s there’s substantial top down control. What makes humans special, I think, I think ultimately what we’ll see in terms of in terms of the human animal, is that we can choose to change our habitual processing. We alone, you know, there might be some self help dolphin out there that, you know, that, you know, is trying to find its, you know, true self, but generally speaking, the evidence isn’t good.
We seem to be the only species that can choose to alter our behavior in reaction to our biology. And the first person who noticed that was Aristotle. Who by the way was not a thorough Platonist. You should have never mentioned them in saying, they’re very very different philosophers. Plato was his teacher, he had to go along with some things, but he didn’t go along with most of it.
Okay. The problem is the problem is our our psychology. Because when in doubt, our default position is do nothing. That means that people tend to defer to the default position, that’s the status quo, when the difficulty of making a decision is increased by conflicting alternatives. I found this bit of research when I was looking at doing a paper on the authority of science and why nobody seems to be wanting to be listening to scientists on climate change.
And this is a really really powerful bit of work. And the reason for this is that change of any kind involves costs, it involves sacrifices. It means changing, moving out of your groove and doing something else that requires effort and it requires time which nobody’s got and why should I change anyway? And we are intrinsically loss averse. We are actually more skittish about losing something than we are anxious to gain something.
We will bank, we will we will try to mitigate our losses even when the immediate reward seems greater. And that’s why we basically discount immediate gratification for future reward on a par with pigeons, which is not very well. There are certainly athletes and musicians and dancers and and and pianists and musicians, you know, who who who spend hours training themselves for performance. But they’re called elite for a reason. They’re very rare.
The mass of humanity doesn’t do it. It’s like it’s gotta be a huge reward in the future to start discounting now. And the longer the period is to the reward, the more likely you’re not you’re to discount it entirely. Okay. So what’s the take on?
First of all, the task of basically pushing back our biology is monumentally difficult. It requires sustained daily effort and periodic failure has got to be part of the deal because you’re basically trying to turn back three point eight five billion years of self grasping. And I mean, that’s got to account for at least one countless eon. You know, I mean, it’s a long time. It’s a long time.
Second thing is that neuroplasticity shows us that we can dramatically alter habitual responses and if there’s something in the future what I’ll I’ll look at it, I’ll I’ll try and dig some some more stuff up on on that because because it it is the hopeful message. It is the hopeful message. And there’s a lot of and going along with that is there’s a lot evidence for the ability to control top down consciously our autonomic systems. Yogic practice, lying on beds of nails, walking slowly across hot beds of burning coals, all that stuff is amply documented. And that’s basically a state of mind, tummo, a state of mind that alters, completely alters the physical state.
So there’s quite a lot of evidence for that. So why should we even believe that liberation is possible? First of all, scripture tells us it’s possible. The biographies of the great teachers indicate it’s possible. And these are events that aren’t reported by one person like Matthew, Mark, Luke and John.
They’re actually, you know, they’re coordinated accounts taking in numbers of different stories. And living exemplars show it is possible. And so I think we should go for it, myself. And thank you and if you’ve got any questions, we’ve got ten minutes. On what?
Helplessness paradigm. But it’s also present in dogs. Develop Thanks for that question. Basically, you just allowed me to get up on another one of my hobby horses, and that is the paucity of evidence that genetics actually does all that much in relation to our ending phenotype. I mean, one of the great scandals of the Human Genome Project, which people are now just beginning to talk about, is that there were all these promises of gene therapies, and we were going to find a gene for this and the gene for that and you can read it in any newspaper every other week we found the gene for this, we found the gene for that.
None of it basically tracks at the phenotypic level. Very very little of it tracks at the phenotypic level. So you could have an underlying genetic predisposition, but I think what’s much more, where the data is much more convincing is, it is the mother’s fault. I’m afraid to say, you know, I didn’t want it to be the mother’s fault but I’m afraid it is. The state of the mother when the child is in utero has a huge effect on their stress reactivity, everything, their resilience, everything like that when they come out.
This is true of rats, mice, dogs, cats, wolves. It’s true, it’s looking like it’s really true of humans and once you’re out, what happens within the first eighteen months of life also sort of sets those, sets the baseline settings for your circadian rhythms and also for your stress response system which are both coordinated by the hypothalamus and they’re really really really sensitive to developmental influence. So I would say the dog that doesn’t develop learned helplessness and it was about ten maybe twenty percent of the people who of subjects that were in Seligman’s original experiments didn’t develop learned helplessness. This is when they’re they’re given they’re given shocks, they they first get conditioned to you know, with a shock to to learn how to do something, but then after a while, they start getting shocked no matter what and then they just sort of stop doing anything. They just sort of, you know, nothing I can do is going to help.
And they get and this is now the paradigm for depression. This is the animal model for depression. Anytime you read a story about animals being tested for depression, they had to do this to the animal first in order to get the symptoms. Okay? And so I think it’s I think it’s possibly genetics but we don’t know, but it’s sure it’s it’s it’s the contingencies of development, you know?
Just make one of it, I mean, I don’t know, someone else might want a question, but Ilya’s got one. It’s just about the immune system. By the way, there’s an immune, there’s inflammatory model of schizophrenia that’s being developed. I don’t know if it’s true, but it’s Yeah. And the and the prefrontal cortex for those who aren’t aware, it’s yeah.
Yeah. But but basically, it’s it’s executive function. I mean, but It’s the emotional cortex. Prefrontal. Prefrontal.
Okay. Yeah. Anyway. Part of the limbic My this is not going to be a satisfactory answer. Like I said, when I looked at bacteria, I didn’t expect to find what I found.
Bacteria are older than plants. Plants respond in very similar ways to bacteria over but over much longer time spans and they’re not quick, they’re really really long and most of the actions under the ground, so you don’t see it. This has uncomfortable consequences for a Buddhist view. My personal feeling is that the sentience life distinction is going to collapse. And I think it’s going to collapse the way Mount Meru collapsed.
The way Mount Meru collapsed. I think that once I think that I also think, perhaps arrogantly, that once life and sentience are understood more closely as being so so united, then rebirth is going to be it’s not going to be that difficult. The next question is, what is for you and how do you measure the birth? I think what is sentience for me is because I can’t know that anybody in this room is experiencing pain. You may look like you are, you may say you are, but I can’t know that for fact.
And we can’t know that about any other individual because our experience is our experience. It is private and we only have if we only have exterior behavior to go by, you can’t you’ve gotta you’ve gotta remove self report because a cat can’t report it, a dog can’t report it, you know, they don’t have the language for saying it. Although rainbow trout, when they’re injected with bee venom, react very very similar to primates. They rub their lips and they sort of rock back and forth and they lose their appetite and they their hearts beat really fast and they lose their appetite for a while and they’re kind of listless for a while and then they so it’s it’s that kind of sickness behavior is really really common. And it was first found in mammals, now it’s found in in in rainbow trout.
And when this was found, you know, biologist in Wyoming, big fishing, sport fishing states said, oh they can’t possibly be feeling pain because they don’t have the part of the brain that feels pain in humans. Is that justified? I don’t know. So I think that if it looks like a duck, it acts like a duck, it walks like a duck, it reproduces like a duck, it has feathers and all that sort of stuff, it’s probably a duck. So if you’ve got something that’s got memory, sensing, basic awareness, you know the ability to attend to something and then to be confused, you know when things change.
To anticipate, to be able to make decisions under uncertainty which you know all that kinds of stuff does, which is all about knowing, cognizing, you know, objects, then I think it goes all the way down. I don’t think we’re gonna end up in a panpsychist. I don’t think atoms are sentient. I think that there is a division. I don’t but I just don’t know how that works.
I I think that inanimate matter is inanimate. I but I don’t know how that works. Yeah? Oh, I’m sorry. Lily, you were first, weren’t you?
Go, Lily. I’m afraid so. So I’m not I’m I’m I’m I’m a bit of a heretic on that point. Yeah. I don’t think that in the desire realm there’s any free lunch.
I don’t think we get off scot free anywhere in the desire realm. I think that everything we touch is involved in suffering. You know, like we inflict suffering in almost everything we do. This whole the whole shoot and mash came into existence as a result of contamination and you can get free of it, but
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- inner fire tummo (Tib)
- The energy residing at the navel chakra, aroused during the completion stage of Highest Yoga Tantra, and used to bring the energy winds into the central channel. It is also called inner or psychic heat. LYWA
- Mount Meru
- The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.