TBI Symposium — 2016-08-06

TBI Symposium (Ilia Durovic)
TBI Symposium (Ilia Durovic)
TBI Symposium — 2016-08-06
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 06082016Session 1 Symposium 2 – KR.mp3

UUID: 2b0c985e-501b-4444-b1fd-0b67963250b5

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: TBI Symposium

Date: 2016-08-06

Duration: 1h 12m

Words: 9,031

Some new faces as well, you know, and I would like to thank you to take some time Saturday morning. I know it’s not easy. It wasn’t easy for me this morning either to come to attend this presentation. This is the seventh year of the symposium. As you know, seventh years are always critical years and this is a critical year.

This will be the last symposium at TBI. Next year, for organizational reasons, we will not be able to hold a symposium at TBI. Tenzin will brief you on the developments as soon as they are formalized. And in the future, we will continue annually to have, teachings at TBI given by non resident teachers or perhaps myself if there is a request. But the format of the symposium has become too heavy, in the times we live in.

I am simply unable to get the speakers. So this year I had to call on the kindness of an old friend in Switzerland, you know, who very kindly prepared a presentation for us. We will try to show it here today. But when your old friends from your past university life stop answering your emails, then you know that perhaps you have overextended your welcome. So, I thought that ending on a topic like this one is a particularly appropriate way to end since altruism is central to Mahāyāna Buddhism.

And therefore, since this is, the last symposium, let us try to make it a particularly good one. So as you know, this year, at TBI, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen is focusing on the presentation of altruism in bodhichitta within Mahāyāna Buddhism. Then I thought it would be very helpful to, in our own small mind and life conferences, which is basically what the symposium has become, try to draw on material from evolutionary biology, cognitive psychology and so forth to see what contemporary scientific developments have to say about empathy and altruism. And I would therefore like to extend, my gratitude first to Pamela Nyhan, who has accepted to present the topic from the standpoint of biology and to my old friend Vasilis Aidolivo from the University of Bern. Those of you who know who Professor Taborsky is, he’s a world known specialist in evolutionary biology, will appreciate that she is his student.

So I would like to extend my thanks to her and to all of you again for coming. So let us, for the time being, set aside our Buddhist perspective. And let us be like children starting to study this topic with an open mind. Why is compassion and altruism relevant? And I thought this quote from Helen Weng, who’s a member of, Davidson’s team at the University of Wisconsin, is particularly interesting.

Compassionate altruism of great interest because of its great role in successful societies. A society which is not built on compassion or altruism disintegrates. We will talk a little bit today about the role of cooperation and empathy in the constitution of all animal societies, both insect societies and societies among birds and mammals. Now it is important, and I would like to point out here that much of this is first, I’m not a specialist in the field. And secondly, much of this is very much cutting edge, so positions may change.

But it is important to distinguish in biology between two types of altruistic behavior. And Vasilisa will develop this this afternoon. I think Pamela will talk about it as well. The first enhances genetic fitness, in other words, the survivability of the individual or the species. And the second potentially does not.

Now the first is broadly known as kin selection, or nowadays perhaps kin selection, according to some, has been replaced by group selection. And you find it within social insects such as bees, ants and so forth. There is a Darwinian explanation, in other words, explanation from the standpoint of the theory of evolution, for the cooperation of ants, bees and so forth. When a bee, for instance, to protect its hive, stings an intruder and basically commits suicide, as you know, since the abdomen of the bee is torn out in the process. This can be explained in terms of enhancing the survival of genetic material shared with the bee by the other members of the hive.

This is not problematic for evolutionary biology. And therefore, it is not terribly interesting for us if we are Buddhists. What is fascinating are those cases of altruism in which there is no clear evolutionary advantage or you have to really struggle to find one. And that includes two cases known as direct and indirect reciprocity. Direct reciprocity basically means, I scratch your back, you scratch my back.

Now this is, broadly speaking, clearly evidenced in the animal world. Vasilis’s work and Taborsky’s work demonstrated the existence of direct reciprocity among rats. It’s quite astonishing that a rat should be able to have such a high level, of understanding of cooperation. Indirect reciprocity is mainly present within the human species. We do find evidence among animals such as sparrows.

Indirect reciprocity means, I’m going to do something really nice for Richard. I’m going to bring him a piece of cake because I really want Nick to do something for me. And if I bring Richard a piece of cake, Richard’s going to say something nice about me to Nick, and it’s going to come back my way. This is indirect reciprocity. Astonishingly, sparrows seem to be able to engage in indirect reciprocity.

There’s an interesting study by Ekstein on the topic. So with insect societies, we are dealing with a classic case of either kin selection or group selection. These are extraordinarily complex societies, but it is not clear that empathy as we know it, in other words, the capacity to feel for another, is present at all. Certainly we would find it very difficult to put in evidence. There are, however, very strong cases of cooperation in the insect world, highly sophisticated instances known as targeted cooperation, where ants, for instance, and this is just a very recent study, will not just help another ant in difficulty, but will identify specifically what is causing problems for the other ant, in this case nylon webbing, and try to cut or remove that.

Now this calls for very high cognitive capacities. Probably in the present state of biology, the ants do this to enhance the fitness of the community. It’s not clear that ants have a warm and vibrating feeling of empathy for other ants. Probably not. And therefore, this need not concern us too much.

What does concern us is cooperation and empathy among birds and mammals. And here I had to put a picture of Frans de Waal on the screen. Frans de Waal is the greatest living primatologist, specialist of the great apes, and has studied their social comportment for years. He has done remarkable work on empathy and cooperation. And you should have, as a handout, his synthetic article on, cooperation.

Now, de Waal obviously subscribes to the evolutionary position, but he endeavors to understand how precisely cooperation and empathy appear and develop among birds and mammals. And we will see this is hypothetical, but still there is a broad consensus that this is probably how it happened. So, for return benefits, in other words benefits for the person or the individual engaging in altruistic behavior, they must be experienced by the organism. Evidence is accumulating that this mechanism is phylogenetically, in other words, physiologically ancient, probably as old as mammals and birds. Perception of the emotional state of another automatically activates shared representations, causing a matching emotional state in the observer.

This is the root of empathy. I am empathetic, let us assume, with Chris, who is, at present struggling to keep up, with the presentation and taking notes, because my hand cramps when I see him writing this quickly. In other words, I share certain experiences with Chris. We will talk about the neurological mechanisms which underlie this later. It is open to question whether if these neurological mechanisms did not exist, such empathy would be possible.

And we will talk about something which I think is critical, which is just how archaic these mechanisms are. They go back to the very dawn of the appearance of mammals. Now I won’t have time to go into that today, but we can see if we study the zones of the human brain which are activated when one meditates in compassion, that these are not recent zones. The insular certain areas of the so called mesolimbic nucleus are some of the most archaic zones involved in the reward mechanisms. In other words, and we will try to talk about it today, compassion and altruism, empathetic feeling, are not recent developments.

They are archaic, and they play an extremely important role in our species. So I will propose one model of empathy. It is one of many, the perception action model of empathy, developed mainly by Stephanie Preston with the help of Frans de Waal. And it hinges on the idea that motor mimicry, in other words, the capacity to imitate another’s behavior, gives rise to emotional contagion. And emotional contagion then triggers sympathy, in other words, concern, and eventually perspective, in other words, cognitive empathy, and targeted helping, where you actually try to help another in a way which addresses their problem.

Then when we speak of motor mimicry, we have expressions in English, which make it clear we do understand what it means. For instance, you will read in the papers, let’s say in the present day, you know, reassessment of welfare. Don’t criticize another until you have walked a mile in his shoes. Now that actually refers to motor mimicry. When you imitate physically the behavior of another, you become close to them.

You become so close to them, you can identify with them. You experience what they experience. That gives rise to empathy and then to more advanced forms of empathy, such as compassion. Now, the mechanism involving the appearance of empathy seems to involve initially emotional contagion, then sympathetic concern, and then perspective taking or targeted helping. Emotional contagion is a particularly archaic mechanism.

We do find it in almost all mammals and birds. It just refers to the spread of an emotion in a group, typically fear. You see a flock of birds, one bird gets frightened, and all the birds fly away. Then, I don’t know if any of you have experienced this as human beings. A friend of mine did.

Very interesting. He’s a Buddhist monk, a very good Western Buddhist monk. It seems he attained calm abiding, to give you an idea. So we do have Western monks who go very far. And we were talking once in Dharamsala, and he told me he was at the Hotel Olympia in Tehran, at the time of, the Iranian revolution in the late nineteen seventies, ’79, I think, when, whatever.

One better not develop too much on those topics these days. And obviously, the revolutionary guards were everywhere. They were arresting everyone, and he was quite philosophical about it until the rumors started that they were coming to Hotel Olympia to arrest all the Westerners at Hotel Olympia and detain them. And he told me, he said, I thought I controlled my mind, but a wind of panic spread among the Westerners, and I was carried off by this wind, and I had no control. Now this is emotional contagion.

Suddenly, and it is a mechanism which is far more archaic than our cortical mechanisms, we are carried away by emotions we have no control over. Then these things appear in periods of great stress. Hopefully, you will never experience them. If you do experience them, try to be mindful after. During is not possible.

Now emotional contagion, in other words, this group feeling which appears largely out of fear, gives rise to sympathetic consolation. You empathize with another precisely because you have shared an emotion, and as a result, in this case, you have a classic picture, which is always shown by Daval. One male chimp has been beaten in a fight, and obviously is not thrilled about it. And a much smaller, perhaps female chimp, is trying to console him. The female chimp, in other words, feels what the male chimp feels.

It’s dangerous, as you know, to, come close to a male chimp who is in a state of aggressivity. These are dangerous animals. And yet, she is trying to bring down his level of fear and animosity that is even more striking in this picture. Then without any type of anthropomorphism, I think we can nonetheless say that this looks a lot like consolation. And consolation then leads to targeted helping.

Targeted helping means that understanding the predicament of another, in this case, a baby elephant, the mother elephant in this case, tries to help the baby elephant in a way which addresses the problem. So targeted helping calls for high cognitive levels. Emotional contagion does not. You feel what the other birds feel fine. But targeted helping implies that the member of the species who helps understands the problem and tries to address the problem at the root.

Most extreme case of empathy I know is the reaction of elephants upon seeing the skulls of other elephants. Elephants, at that point, seem to enter in a very contemplative state. They have a reaction which is different from their reaction when they see the skulls of buffalos or oxes, which are broadly speaking similar. And they move the skull left and right. There is therefore, it seems, a sense of commonality, and we cannot say this for sure, but perhaps an awareness of death.

And I couldn’t resist, as Richard know, I love my Latin proverbs, to quote this old Latin proverb, of the dead, nothing but the good. So in this case, and this is very hypothetical at present, this is the Wallace hypothesis, are there cognitive features which lead to the appearance of empathy? And I said this is very hypothetical. This work is ongoing, so it may be put in question. One of the most interesting hypotheses is the so called co emergence hypothesis.

The hypothesis that the capacity to recognize oneself is necessary to generate empathy. And this recognition of oneself is tested in animals with what is known as the mirror test. Now, a series of, animals seem, overwhelmingly mammals, but birds as well, seem to have succeeded at the mirror self recognition test. Elephants have, dolphins and orcs have, and interestingly enough, blackbirds have. Whether it is true or not that this is a necessary condition for empathy is open to question.

It would make sense. Now, this being so, are there neurological foundations for empathy? And what are they? And we will try to start at the cellular level and progress upwards. Then obviously, you all know of the close relationship professor Davidson from the University of Wisconsin and His Holiness the Dalai Lama have forged over the years.

Davidson is one of the foremost researchers in the, effects of meditation on the brain, the neurophysiological effects of meditation. But it is the work of another member of his team, professor Lutz, which is of particular interest to us, since Lutz researched the effects of compassion on the brain and studied what areas of the human brain were activated during compassion meditation. And we will talk about this a little bit later. I would like, at present, to start with the basic constituents, the cell. And once again, this is pretty much cutting edge, controversial and quite theoretical.

What might be, at the neuronal level, the foundation for compassion? So we said that if we rely on Wahl’s hypothesis of the perception action model, the foundation for empathy was motor mimicry. Is there anything at the neurological level which, if you wish, is in charge of motor mimicry? And it would seem, certainly in monkeys, the evidence is mixed in humans, that there are neurons, known as the mirror neurons, which are involved in the imitation of movements done or made by another. Now, this is fundamental in the learning process.

In other words, it is fundamental also in the process of participation. If I sit like Nick, I feel like Nick. If Nick sits like me, or Jabba Chibel sits like me, he starts to feel like me. For this to be possible, we need some mechanism which enables us to imitate what another person does. And the research on the mirror neurons is strong as far as primates is concerned.

The evidence is much more mixed for human beings, simply because in the case of the primates which were studied, it is possible to insert electrodes into individual neurons. For ethical reasons, is not possible to do this with human beings. And therefore, as Kimner points out, one of the big problems is that with human beings, we are limited to the data which we get from magnetic resonance, which is much more nebulous. In either case, mirror neurons are neurons which are discharged either during the monkey’s own movements, or when the monkey perceives movements by another party. In other words, they respond both to individual action and to the perceived action of another.

They might be the constituting blocks of motor mimicry. If their presence and activity in human beings is confirmed, then they are found in, apes, especially the smaller apes, throughout the brain. Now as I mentioned, one of the big problems, obviously, in the study of human beings is an ethical problem. We are not able at present to test individual neurons in human beings. And this leads to some very interesting research.

And this is perhaps, one of the first times during which I think we can say that there is a major positive input from neurobiology to Buddhism. I often felt that it was a very one-sided relationship where, to be honest, we were breaking through open doors as Buddhists when we studied neurobiology because much of the material is well known. This, however, is fascinating, what we’re coming up to. And that is the evidence of different neurological substrata for emotional and cognitive empathy. In other words, neurologically, emotional and cognitive empathy are two fundamentally different things, and the research was mainly done at the University of Haifa by professor Simone Shamay-Tsoury.

She was fortunate or unfortunate enough to have access to victims of war wounds with major cranial damage, and was able to study the impact this cerebral damage had on their empathetic reactions. And what she found was that there were two different empathetic systems, An emotional system, which would be involved in the emotional phobic reactions we talked about earlier, emotional contagion, which involves the inferior frontal gyrus, and a cognitive system involving the ventromedial gyrus. These are two different areas of the brain, both cortical areas, in other words, the front of the brain. And, the empathetic reaction was assessed in individuals who had damage to the IFG and the VM. And a clear difference, and it’s these two first parts of the chart which is interesting, were noted.

People who had damage to the VM scored sharply lower as far as cognitive empathy was concerned, but there was no difference to emotional empathy. People who had damage to the IFG scored higher for cognitive empathy and lower for emotional empathy. So it does seem that neurologically, emotional and cognitive empathy are fundamentally different things, related but different. And therefore, Shamay-Tsoury says, these results provide strong support for the existence of two behavioral systems for understanding others. An emotional matching mirroring system, that is what triggers the reactions of panic, for instance, we talked about involving the MNS, and a more advanced system for understanding cognitive states involving the VM.

Then there are numerous other areas of the brain which are activated. We will not have time to talk about them today. The amygdala, the so called reptilian brain, the insula. Lutze’s research found that when Matthieu Ricard meditated on compassion, the insula was heavily activated. It is clear that complex Buddhist meditations on compassion will trigger a multiplicity of different areas of the brain.

And it is my private opinion that this is the great weakness of Davidson’s research. The great weakness of Davidson’s research is not on the neurological end, it is as far as the identification of the different types of meditation involved is concerned. So Davidson’s team would benefit greatly from getting a couple Geluk Geshe’s on the team, preferably meditators as well, because it is not sufficient to distinguish between concentration and analytical meditation, which is basically what the team does now. We expect, we should expect, that there would be major differences in the parts of the brain activated if, for instance, one generated compassion by means of the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, which is grounded in unawareness of the kindness of one’s mother, or if one generated it by means of the equalization interchange of self and others. And you need a specialist to be able to point out these differences.

So it is what is sorely lacking at present in Davidson’s research. They know that several areas are activated. What is activated by what? They cannot identify, because the meditator, is a subject, is never asked what precisely the breakdown of the meditation is. So Shamay-Tsoury, therefore, distinguishes clearly between emotional and cognitive empathy.

Consider that emotional empathy is a more primitive form of empathy, which is present very early on in the mammalian world, within rodents and birds. Cognitive empathy is a far more sophisticated level of empathy, present in the apes, the great apes in particular, and points out, and this is I think what is fascinating, that the core neurological structures behind emotional and cognitive empathy are different. In other words, you can experience or you could experience emotional empathy without experiencing cognitive empathy. Theoretically, you could probably experience cognitive empathy without experiencing emotional empathy. Now what is extremely interesting, and if you have time, I really suggest that you watch a marvelous program chaired by all of all people by Alan Alda, which is in your bibliography, on evolutionary biology.

So he has all of the heavyweights. Edward Wilson, Sarah Hrdy, Xavier Perchon, they’re all there. It’s a one hour program. It’s absolutely fascinating on this material. Then obviously, there are strong disagreements, but I think you would benefit greatly greatly by watching it.

So what is absolutely fascinating is that empathetic and altruistic mechanism activate extremely archaic parts of the human brain involved in the reward pathway, specifically what is known as the mesolimbic pathway. The mesolimbic pathway is a part of the human brain which is involved in all addictions, whether it is gambling addiction, cocaine addiction, I don’t know what other addictions there are. Let’s say in Australia, horse racing addiction maybe. If she has to go to Melbourne to watch her horse races, then the mesolimbic pathway is activated. The mesolimbic pathway is one of the most archaic pathways, in the brain.

It is involved in the release of dopamine, one of the main neurotransmitters. And what is absolutely fascinating is that this pathway, which is actually going to be used to treat severe cases of depression, depression is typically due to, an insufficient amount of dopamine in the brain. So you can treat it surgically, it’s a radical form of treatment, by stimulating electrically the mesolimbic nucleus. So this part of the brain is involved in altruistic activity, and that is what some of the recent research indicates. This research was mainly undertaken by Jorge Moll, and what he wanted to study was why precisely people engage in altruistic behavior which has a very high cost for them.

And he devised an experiment in which people would anonymously donate a certain amount of money, and, their brain activity was monitored by, functional magnetic resonance. And what he found is that the mesolimbic reward system was massively engaged by the act of giving. Now this is fascinating, because we would assume and we know that the mesolimbic pathway is activated by the act of receiving. So, if, I was given another cup of tea and I was being examined by functional magnetic resonance, you would expect the mesolimbic pathway to illuminate blood flow to increase in the area. But what is fascinating is that if I were to give a cup of tea to Susan, my own mesolimbic pathway would be activated.

And this is demonstrated incontrovertibly. In other words, altruistic activity makes us happy at a very fundamental level. Now in Moll’s experiment, participants were entitled to receive a fair amount of money, 128 US dollars, if and only if they didn’t do anything for others. The more they tried to help and to give to others, the less money they would get. So normally, you know, if you adopt this sort of rather primitive evolutionary viewpoint, which is current in the popular press, no one would give anything to anybody.

Right? It’s exactly the opposite which happened. Moll found that all participants made costly decisions, sacrificing 40% of their potential endowment. And what he found was that as they made these costly decisions, the mesolimbic pathway was activated. In other words, they profoundly enjoyed being able to help others.

Now I would put it to you, and I know I’m quoting controversy by bringing this up, that this demonstrates pretty much the inanity of economic analysis of the benefits of altruism using the prisoner’s dilemma, which always seemed to me particularly arcane and unconvincing. Vasilisi will talk about it this afternoon. The prisoner’s dilemma is a classic dilemma involving two prisoners, certainly not in Australia, who face long jail sentences if they do one thing and short jail sentences or release if they do something else, and what the optimum strategy is. It was investigated by, a very famous mathematician, Axelrod. So he developed the optimum strategy for the prisoners who want to get out easily.

And this is used by economists to explain the conundrum of why people donate money to others. Why do people engage in activity which is a priori harmful to themselves? We have a very simple biological answer now. The neurological answer is that they help others because it makes them feel profoundly happy. And that this is, and I will talk about it at the end of this presentation, this is hardwired into who we are, or at least those of us who are nice people.

Then obviously, there are vehicles for the transmission of these emotions. As you know, the brain is basically an electrochemical mechanism. The chemical vehicles are known as neurotransmitters. We won’t enter into them in detail. Their balance or imbalance is fundamental to the health or the state of disease of the human brain.

Typically, imbalances in dopamine, for instance, or serotonin affect dramatically, cognitive capacities and emotional stability. But what is interesting is that there is one neurotransmitter, which is heavily involved in mother child bonding, which is central to the experience of altruism, and this is oxytocin. So by the way, that was the chemical, developed formula of oxytocin. And, again, this is really cutting edge. This is the latest study I found on the topic.

Jorge Barraza found that empathy was associated with an almost 50% increase in oxytocin from baseline, and that this response was stronger in women than in men. Then I just opened up parentheses here. It links us with the second talk I’ll be giving this morning. Since most of us in this room are Buddhists, or at least have received Mahāyāna teachings, can you see how skillful the technique of development of bodhichitta by means of meditation on the kindness of the mother is. If our experiences linked with our mothers trigger the release of oxytocin, and we use the recollection of these experiences to trigger large the release of large amounts of oxytocin and to extend this commonality or closeness with our mother to other living beings.

Can you see how skillful these meditation techniques are? It’s quite quite humbling when you actually analyze this, you know. So after this very, very extensive introduction, I will address the core topic of this talk, altruism and mental health. But first, I would like to bring up some interesting data on altruism and physical health. And it is quite fascinating.

There have been two studies which have clearly demonstrated the link between altruism and physical health. The first, and these are difficult studies to make because they are made over thirty years, is a study of some 100 young men from the early 50 classes of Harvard. So keep in mind, we’re dealing with a certain socioeconomic milieu. Harvard is to The United States, but Oxford and Cambridge are to The UK. These are not disadvantaged young men.

They typically will be upper class, very upper class. And it is important for what we will be talking about. They were given questionnaires about the perception of the love they felt from their parents, not for their parents. Thirty five years later, so they were basically almost sixty, ninety one percent of those who did not perceive themselves as having had warm relations with their mothers had diagnosed midlife diseases, as compared to only forty five percent of those who reported a warm relation with their mothers. Eighty two percent of those who felt warmth and closeness with their fathers had such diagnosis, as compared to only fifty percent who reported high warmth and closeness.

All one hundred percent of those who reported low warmth and closeness from both parents had diagnosed diseases in midlife. I put this in chart form to make it a little bit easier to understand. The incidence of midlife diseases, in other words, heart problems, ulcers, alcohol abuse, I don’t know if cancer is included, probably, in the late fifties, in the light of early life relation with the parents. So this would be early life, here would be pre teen. Right?

A cold relation with the parents leads, thirty years later, to massive physical deterioration. Cold relation with both parents. The mother is obviously far more important than the father in this matter. A cold relation with one’s mother leads in ninety one percent of the cases to important midlife diseases, whereas a warm relation with the father or the mother leads to a dramatic drop in these midlife diseases. So perhaps this gives a strong corroboration, as any I can think of, to the Asian outlook on filial piety.

The most important determinant for health seems to be how we see our parents. It’s quite striking, isn’t it? And the second research, which is very interesting, it basically develops on this, if you wish, is the particular impact of altruism on one’s own health. And as all major advances in research, it basically occurred when the researchers were investigating something very different. It’s a team from Cornell University in The United States, which was investigating the impact of socioeconomic status on the health of women.

And they expected to see that low socioeconomic status was correlated with poor health, and high socioeconomic status was correlated with high health. And they found there was basically no correlation at all. So sit down a second and ask yourselves, if this research is confirmed, what precisely this means for the welfare state. What is the premise of the welfare state? That health and happiness are correlated with what?

Greater materials. Yes. Yes. Exactly. And the state basically makes a major effort to ensure that citizens in need receive all the material help they can get.

Now if this research is confirmed, there seems to be little or no correlation at all. The correlation between the health of these women over, what was it, some thirty years, was a correlation with whether or not they were involved in volunteer organizations. In other words, whether or not they were involved in altruistic activity. If they were involved with volunteer organizations, and you can see this very clearly in this chart, then less than forty percent experienced thirty years later major illness, and more than sixty percent obviously did not. If they did not belong to volunteer organizations, more than fifty percent experienced thirty years later major illness.

Now this goes a very, very long way to confirm the Buddhist understanding of happiness. You have all probably, or most of you have attended teachings by Geshe Jampa Gyotsi. And a leitmotif, and I always notice when he says that people, I think metaphorically, look up at the ceiling and sigh, a leitmotif is that we have to make a distinction between physical and mental happiness, but that true happiness is not physical but mental. And it tends to slide on the back of most Westerners like water on the back of a duck. Right?

So we pay lip service to it, that’s as far as it goes. But this type of research, which is difficult to make because you have to follow subjects for thirty or forty years, seems to indicate that the core Buddhist premise that the foundation of happiness is mental is true. And that this mental happiness trickles down into physical health, and obviously as a byproduct of physical health, you have all of the material advantages of this world. Wealth as much as is possible, success in one’s studies, success in one’s relationships. So this is quite haunting, and it really is the type of research which should be engaged in much more because it calls in question really all of the premises which underlie social engineering these days.

Let us now address the issue of altruism and mental health. And here, I expected to find much more data than I found. So you will see I found a lot of data indicating that the absence of altruism is strongly correlated with mental disease, but actually very little strong data linking the presence of altruism with mental health. And I almost have come to wonder if there is a bias against investigating the topic. I have almost once come to wonder.

There’s a discipline called positive psychology, which obviously is such a minor subfield of psychology that I had, for one, never heard of it, which investigates the correlation between altruism and positive states of mind and happiness. But the studies are few and far between. So let us start with an understanding or a presentation of altruism in the light of neurology and of some philosophers like Daniel Batson, who has worked very closely in cooperation with neurologists. And Jean Decety, a French neurobiologist, is perhaps the leading researcher in the neurobiology of altruism nowadays. So Batson defines altruism as feeling empathy for a person in need, which evokes a motivation to help that person in which the benefits to self are not the ultimate goal of helping, they are unintended consequences.

Now if we adopt this as a definition, it restricts considerably the field of investigation. And as mentioned previously, I think we can take this distinction on board, even though it is not one which is present in Buddhist studies. Empathy can and must be subdivided between cognitive and affective empathy. Cognitive empathy, I did not define previously. It is basically the capacity to see the world as another person sees it.

So our capacity to put ourselves is in another person’s shoes. It calls for a fair level of cognitive capacities. Effective empathy is the capacity to respond with the appropriate emotional state to the emotional state of another person. They are different. Now, the mental disorders which seem to be related to the absence of cognitive empathy are bipolar disorder, in other words, what used to be known as manic depressive disorder, and borderline traits, and the mental conditions involved with the absence of affective empathy, obviously a much more worrisome, psychopathy, psychopathology, and narcissism.

Now it is fairly well known that the absence of empathy is clearly linked with psychopathology. Decety says that some twenty three percent of prisoners in maximum security facilities, show distinct lack of empathy, as opposed to one percent in the population at large. So there seems to clearly be a correlation. But as I told you, while the absence of empathy is clearly correlated with mental disorder and eventually social maladjustment, the presence and development of empathy and altruism are more dimly correlated with mental happiness and social adaptation. A very interesting study which confirms this is a study, an f m r I study, of the brains of, patients, affected with psychopathy.

And it was found that when they were viewing another in pain, the centers of the brain involved with empathy were not activated. In other words, absence of empathy is a neurological disorder. And this is corroborated by the, rates of psychopathology among those who are incarcerated. Then as I said, there is little evidence that altruism benefits mental health. There have been some studies like that of Carolyn Schwartz, But the data is, I would say, fairly loose.

And the main interpretation for the benefits altruism has for mental health is simply the outward focus of the altruistic deed. So this is something we have direct experience with in Buddhist centers. In my case, it’s been more than thirty years, thirty five years now, I have been involved in Buddhism. And it is very clear that people who suffer from depression benefit greatly from engaging in altruistic deeds. The best treatment for depression is actually to help others.

It contextualizes one’s problems. What seems huge becomes actually quite trivial compared with the suffering of others. And one of the characteristics of depression is narcissism. The person is just totally focused within, on their own self. Now when one moves outwards to help others, that inward focus disappears.

And this is why, for instance, when I was in India, I had a lot of young Westerners working for me in a couple of big projects, and all left the projects significantly significantly happier than they were when they had come in. Just working with others, seeing the suffering of others which are so far greater than theirs, brought their own problems back to a much more manageable size. So this is probably one of the strong theoretical, it’s untexted, explanations of the mental health benefits of altruism. And now I must ask a question which, from a Buddhist standpoint, amounts to breaking through open doors, but which is not self evident for scientists. Can one train in empathy, compassion and altruism?

Because if one can, one should, based on the evidence we saw, and if one can’t, then why bother? And there have been studies by members of Davidson’s group, Helen Weng in particular, which supports the possibility that compassion and altruism can be viewed as trainable skills rather than stable traits. And I don’t claim to be able to interpret these fMRI charts of the human brain for you, but according to Wang, they demonstrate an important change in the activation of the, altruistic supporting zones, in other words, the VM, the IFG, in the brains of trained meditators. And in particular, what one does see is that once one has meditated on altruism and empathy repeatedly, then the activation of these emotions, since this is after all what they are, is greatly facilitated when one sees the suffering of others. Now there has been no study, and I wish someone would engage in it, on the benefits of meditation on compassion and empathy in psychopaths, in cases of psychopathology.

Is it possible to train a brain which is obviously deficient in this respect or not? A priori, I would imagine it is, but it would have to be tested. And finally, I would like to end with a question, a rather provocative question. Hisuer Sai Lama has consistently said, and one of the more provocative things he says, because I always see everyone, especially westerners in the audience, wince when he says it. That religion is for the benefit of man.

Man is not for the benefit of religion. Then, Yesorius has said, if religion and spirituality help, we should engage in them. And if they don’t help, then we should walk away. And there is in this respect a very troubling study by Jean Decety on the impact of religiosity on empathy. The study was highly controversial.

5,800,000,000 humans representing 84% of the worldwide population identify as religious. This is basically most of mankind. The relation between religiosity and morality is a contentious one. Here, we assessed altruism and third party evaluation of scenarios depicting harm in 1,000 and some children, aged between five and 12 and six countries. The religiousness of their household and parent reported child empathy and sensitivity to justice.

According all across all countries, parents in religious households reported that their children expressed more empathy and sensitivity for justice. This is a parents report in everyday life to non religious parents. However, religiosity was inversely predictive of children’s altruism and positively correlated with punitive tendencies. Together, these results reveal the similarity across countries in how religion negatively influences children’s altruism, challenging the view that religiosity facilitates prosocial behavior. Now, one caveat I would like to bring up immediately is that, and this is a weakness in all studies of this type, it’s a weakness in Davidson’s research, I suppose it is a case of tunnel vision.

Not all religions are equal. So here, what is unstated in Decety’s research is I think he is talking of the religions of the law. In other words, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, which I think to a lesser degree, but Judaism and Islam are religions of the law, of the revealed law. Then that they should be inversely correlated with empathy and positively correlated with punitiveness is not terribly surprising. Whether this applies, for instance, to Buddhism or Hinduism is an open question.

Because he has not distinguished between the religious backgrounds of the families, in my opinion, the research is vitiated. In my opinion. Having said this, it is provocative. So let us try to make a synthesis, and then I will, answer your questions as best I can. The first point I would like to make is that cooperation is central in the creation of complex societies.

These are all societies, animal and human. And you will note in my bibliography, I I think it is helpful to shake people a little bit. I gave, the link to a video of Ayn Rand, so maybe apart from Pamela, no one knows in this room who Ayn Rand is. Ayn Rand was the apostle of ultra liberalism, I suppose you could say libertarian anarchism. And she actually is an American philosopher and writer of the nineteen fifty sixties, very influential with some books Atlas Shrugged and so forth.

They made it into a movie, a very nice movie with Gregory Peck. And in one interview, and it’s really worth watching, and it’s worth it’s worth watching her face, to be honest with you, to see what that type of outlook does to a person’s face after forty, fifty years. She basically hammers her fist on the table and says altruism altruism is evil. Altruism is evil. You know?

So I really would encourage you to watch a video in the light of everything we said, and wonder, with that sort of outlook, set religion and Buddhism aside, is the creation of a complex society possible? Is the creation of any society possible? So that was the first point I wanted to make. The second is that cooperation in the animal world can be non empathetic. It has, in those cases, as goal, the enhancement of genetic fitness, or empathetic.

Empathetic cooperation is present in some mammals. Not all cooperation in mammals is empathetic. There are cases, let’s say with the, Somalian, rat mole, in which a cooperation is non empathetic and is basically designed to enhance the genetic fitness of the group. Now what is particularly interesting to us is that humans are hardwired for empathy. This is this is who we are.

Someone who is not empathetic is not fully human. There is damage. And it is possible that mirror mirror neurons provide the neurological substratum for empathy via motor mimicry. Those of you who are interested in the issue of mimicry, I cannot recommend too highly the work of the French anthropologist René Girard. It is all translated in English.

He spent some forty, fifty years of his life investigating what he called mimetism, in other words, mimicry, and the genesis of human society. It’s fascinating work. And finally, cognitive and affective empathy in humans are controlled by different areas of the brain, and therefore probably are fundamentally different experiences. Now what is striking based on what we saw is that altruistic behavior leads to biochemical rewards mediated by the most ancient reward pathway of the brain. This is fascinating.

This shows that from an evolutionary standpoint, altruistic behavior is fundamental to the species. Altruism has major long-term health benefits. There is, as I said, strong evidence that the lack of empathy is a marker and perhaps a cause of psychopathology. There is limited evidence that altruism enhances mental health. And what is self evident to us, altruism and empathy can be enhanced through mind training.

Then, it’s an awful lot of material to cover in an hour. There are things I wish I had had time to enter in in greater detail, such as various parts of the human brain involved in, the generation of experiences of compassion. There was no time. I also wished I had been able to make a clear distinction between, consciousness, which is a nonmaterial phenomenon, and what Koch calls the neurological correlates of consciousness, which are the parts of the brain activated when one thinks or engages in certain activities which are material. These two coexist, cooperate.

For course, levels of minds are necessary for each other, but neither can be reduced to the other. That’s what I wanted to cover with you. Then, if you have questions, I believe we have a short half hour. Perhaps I’ll have to check the schedule because I am, as all of us, at the mercy of the schedule. We have half an hour, don’t we, Chris?

I’ve got here 10:15. Ten there we have ten minutes. Just a quick one, Elliot. The, how do you say it, the mesolimbic system engaged in the pathway of altruism and similarly with addiction. Sorry, yes.

The mesolimbic system related to altruism and also addiction, how is it that the, negative effects of addiction don’t apply? The mesolimbic pathway is just a neural pathway which provides rewards to the organism when it engages in behavior which is deemed favorable to the organism. Then, drug addiction, and alcohol addiction basically misuse the pathway. You know, precisely cocaine affects for instance the mesolimbic pathway, I don’t know. I know it does affect it.

The details I do not know. But those are classic cases of misuse of a neurological pathway. So some might say that, looking for the high from altruism is a form of, selfishness. Well, all our behavior is selfish. If you take the strict Buddhist standpoint and the definition of self cherishing from a Buddhist standpoint, in this room not one of us engages in altruistic behavior, you know.

It could be opposite to what we are. At the same time, it is clear that there is behavior which is more selfish and behavior which is less selfish. It is also striking to me that we are primed to cooperate. And there are major rewards in our cooperating with each other. Biological rewards.

Now this is certainly as far as cooperation based on empathy. We’re not talking about cooperation designed to enhance genetic fitness. Cooperation based on empathy, which is characteristic of the higher organisms, vertebrates, mammals and birds, is rooted in empathy. Empathy is rooted in emotional contagion, the sense of a common emotion. Feel like in this room, we have, at present, a low level of emotional contagion going on.

We are a community. Then, I suppose it’s unavoidable. We are so attuned to the negative effects of addiction that if I point out the relation between altruism and pathways which are abused by addiction, you will make a link. But the link is simply due to the existence of intoxicating compounds we may not have had access to in the past or in more circumscribed areas. Yes, Richard.

You referred to that Harvard study, the Harvard study that you referred to which demonstrated a correlation, a strong correlation, it seemed, between perhaps the empathy of the parents and the physical health of their children. Is there no correlation between the physical health of the people and an empathy that one might perceive to be what gives effect to the existence of the welfare state, creating a safety net for the population at large. I don’t think so. I don’t think that we have this direct sense of gratitude to the welfare state. We have to our parents.

I mean the welfare state is an abstract entity, generally speaking I mean I’ve really only known two strong welfare societies, The UK when I lived there in Australia. Both are characterized by very strong senses of entitlement. In other words, you owe this to me. There is no gratitude at all. As a result there are a lot of what in America we call freeloaders.

I gather in Australia you call them leaners. Right? It’s kinder I suppose. Sorry? Blodgers.

Okay. Blodgers. It’s even blunter than in America. But there is no sense, I mean you’d have to examine this. You’d have to make a study frankly.

Among people who receive benefits who are heavily dependent on benefits. Is there a strong sense of gratitude towards the state? I wonder whether this is a generational difference, whether perhaps the perception of those who were brought up in the fifties and early sixties might be different to the the the view of those who were brought up at a later time when the feeling of entitlement would be stronger, perhaps as a result of just continuation of of the same. Probably, I can say. The studies haven’t been made.

Yes. Yes. Yes. Is. And it’s it’s a holding study.

I thought it might it might shake you up a little bit. You see, I come from a very warm family. I mean, small, very close. And one thing which has struck me over the years in Switzerland to a degree, but here it is very extreme, is the lack of closeness between parents and children. And a hostility from the side of children towards their parents.

And when you investigate, you find that this hostility is totally unwanted. Based on what the person tells you it’s difficult to know otherwise. But that basically the parents are working as hard as they can, doing the best they can. You know. And then, if this arises from a very strong sense of egoism and entitlement from the side of the child, then obviously this has an impact mentally and it would seem physically.

Simon had a question. I just wanted to ask if you’d seen any studies say on genetics being linked to empathy. So the Caspi study suggests that the short form of some genes leads to very violent psychopathic behaviour and it’s been corroborated by some monkey studies as well in The US. So what they’re suggesting is that the short form of some genes predisposes people to, I guess, very violent behavior. I’m not sure if it’s linked to to empathy.

So I was just wondering if you’d seen any of that sort of genetic study. I haven’t. I would like to point out some interesting, things however. First, violence and empathy are not only not incompatible but closely linked. Edward Wilson pointed out in an interview that the fundamental aspect of empathetic behavior is war.

I mean, when you go to war, is you and your fellow soldiers against the others. And, I mean, even in the Gospel of John, you have this famous passage, there is no greater love than to give one’s life for another. Obviously it’s drawn from the military context at the period. So you cannot oppose empathy and violence. And this is why the Buddhist perspective that we have to distinguish between biased and unbiased empathy is fundamental.

Biased empathy, which is what we all experience, it’s me and my kin against others, is actually in its strong form the root of violence. For instance, my own family is a military family, so my ancestors were warlords, dukes of Montenegro for seven centuries. Then the capacity for violence was extraordinarily developed. You have to be very violent. At the same time there was strong empathy.

You had to stand by your men. And this for us is interesting. So, you might have a situation where you have shortened genes, I’m not aware of the study, you mentioned, which are present with very high empathy. And you might have a situation when you have these shortened genes which are present with a complete absence of empathy. Both would be possible.

Can we just, perhaps hold that question, Jambo, and, because we’re running a tight schedule and we don’t want to run into the next speaker who is also here. So please join with me in thanking Ilya for this particular segment. And thank you. And we’ll reconvene in fifteen minutes. Thank you very much.

And Ilya referred to the handout and I’ll chase that up for you.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top