Awakening Heart — 2016-05-07

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awakening Heart (Ilia Durovic)
Awakening Heart (Ilia Durovic)
Awakening Heart — 2016-05-07
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2016-05-07 – KR.mp3

UUID: 416f058b-3fc1-4179-a104-545eef3362db

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2016-05-07

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 7m

Words: 8,893

Welcome everybody to the second for Ilias seminars this year on the three principal aspects of the path. We all know Ilias, so I don’t need to introduce him other than to say how fortunate that we are to have the loudspeaker for our teachers joining together east and west perspectives. And so thank you once again, Ilya, for your hard work. And, of course, we also think of your dear mom who passed away recently and Kenser Lobson Palden. Palden.

Thank you. And so we can dedicate the merit of today to a good rebirth for them both. So without any further ado, we all know the routine, a short break halfway through. And I’ll just hand straight over to you, Ilya. Thank you.

Thank you very much. Then the three principles of the path, you probably know, are the essence of Jitsongkapa’s teaching. So perhaps it’s not surprising that we have the essence of TBI present. And I hope the numbers don’t continue dwindling, otherwise we will have the innermost essence. Then we have to see, you know, where we go with that.

So I’m delighted to see you today. Thank you. Thank you very much. Three principles of the path is as we’re seeing the very essence of Buddhist teachings, so really teachings like this are pure Buddhist teachings. I believe most of you are Buddhist by the looks of it except maybe one of you, I’m not sure.

You are not. Then I think apart from your name, excuse me. Apart from Jane, I think probably all the other students here are Buddhist and therefore before teaching of this caliber we should take refuge together and generate whatever motivation we are comfortable with to receive these teachings. It doesn’t have to be a Mahayana motivation but at the very least it should be a motivation of the being of the small scope and we won’t recite in Tibetan. I prefer that these recitations be done in English so you understand something.

And please stand up if you are Buddhist and you want to take refuge and if you recite these words you become Buddhist. That will make three prostrations to Buddha Shakyamuni and our teachers. Now I’ll give you the refuge formula in Sanskrit. It’s easier for us than in Tibetan. The meaning is evident.

I take refuge in the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha until I attain full enlightenment for the sake of all mother sentient beings without exception. Yeah. Then since you are all Buddhist and most of you are Lojong students of the center, I’ll put you a bit more on the spot today than I usually do so and I’ll use the opportunity to ask you some questions. It’s beneficial you know. It’s not a lot of benefit in it just being a show.

So the core Buddhist understanding of our situation is summarized by Ariadeva in the 400. The high suffers in their mind or the simple suffer in their flesh. Daily is a world overcome by these two sufferings. Here overwhelmingly you suffer in your minds. Most of the students come here because of some form of mental distress.

It can be existential anguish, it can be psychological distress, we have cases of people with mental problems. This is the suffering of the high of the wealthy. As Westerners we belong to the wealthiest societies probably mankind has ever produced. Then just as we suffer in our minds, the poor suffer in their flesh. In Australia you have little true poverty, but much of the world experiences appalling levels of poverty and there’s a main form of suffering is physical.

These two sufferings are actually identical, they manifest differently. One manifests at a more subtle level, the mental level, out of insatisfaction, unsatisfied expectations which lead to anger, to depression, if this is uncontrolled the mind spirals out of control and then, you know depending on the proclivities of the person, they lash out against others or they lash out at themselves, start using drugs, start using alcohol, you know. We see this throughout the West. In poor countries, the suffering is physical, then the lashing out is physical as well. Violence, wars, you look at world news it’s fairly self evident.

As for the tragedy of rich countries, I just read today in The Guardian that, actually in the New York Times, that life expectancy in America, United States is at its lowest in the last fifty years and this is overwhelmingly due to heroin addiction. Heroin addiction has exploded in The United States largely because people rely on the opioids to fight first against pain and then against psychological problems and they get addicted. Then in Australia, you know the epidemic of ice the country is experiencing, Australia has always had major problems with alcohol, this is nothing new, these are all drugs. And these drugs are an attempt to respond to mental suffering, sometimes to physical suffering. Sometimes people drink to forget physical pain, you know.

My father was a military surgeon in World War II and he told me that he had five minutes to amputate. If he amputated in more than five minutes, the patient would die of shock because they had run out of morphine. The Yugoslav army had morphine for two weeks, you know, and the Germans invaded from the North, the Italians from the South. What they did was they would strap the patient on the table, these were big strong men from the mountains, and they would bake them as drunk as they could make them without killing them. And then the surgeons had to work, they had to amputate, I don’t know if you can imagine what this involves, amputation and ligature of all the blood vessels plus cauterization in five minutes, you know.

And the clock was ticking after five minutes the patient died of shock. So in those cases, obviously you drink against physical pain. But these are temporary solutions. Alcohol solves nothing, it creates problems of its own. Drugs solve nothing, they create problems of their own.

Then more refined people travel to forget their problems. So it’s a great characteristic of developed countries, isn’t it? The Swiss did it a lot, in Australia I think it’s more or less a national addiction, you know. If you have money and things aren’t going well, you go someplace exotic. And then obviously, the more exotic the destination, the further away, the more ego boost there is naturally because everyone knows you’ve been to Europe or to England or to Norway, you know, and it boosts your standing in the community.

These are also ways to forget suffering, right? They don’t solve anything, one wastes a lot of money, you know, and time, and at the end of the day one is left basically with nothing. These are all human attempts to respond to the predicament Aryadeva identified. The highest suffer in their minds, whereas the simplest suffer in their flesh. Daily is a world overcome by these two sufferings.

Now the Buddhist answer is fundamentally different. We as westerners, I suppose we are almost primed to respond to all problems by physical means. It’s sort of a natural predisposition and it’s been very positive for the development of our civilization. But there are fundamental problems which can’t be solved in this way. And the Buddhist answer is to focus on our response to the exterior world instead of focusing on the exterior world.

The core of Buddhism is this. So, someone very famously asked the second Dalai Lama, what is the difference between dharma and non dharma? What is Buddhism and what is non Buddhism? And the second Dalai Lama had a magnificent answer, which goes beyond all sectarian divisions and really encapsulates the essence of the teachings. He said, what helps the mind is dharma, What does not help the mind is non dharma.

So what Gyrabi helps the mind is the mind’s transformation by itself. And it is these techniques of the mind’s transformation by itself which are the Buddhist teachings. There are other great religious traditions which have tried to follow this path, but I think Buddhism is unique in its absence of mythology, its strongly utilitarian stance and its reliance on logic and experience. These are features of the Buddha’s teachings. The Buddha famously said to his disciples, bhikshus, in other words monks, do not accept my teachings because they are uttered by myself, accept them or examine them in the self same way as a goldsmith would examine gold through cutting, rubbing and burning.

Now it is this critical stance which we need in our relation to the teachings. So this critical stance we have in worldly affairs, it’s not something which is alien to us. No one in this room is going to sign, let’s say, a mortgage for a house or business contract worth let’s say half 1,000,000 or $1,000,000 without calling in accountants, lawyers, in the case of houses conveyancers, maybe several conveyancers. In other words, in worldly affairs we are extremely critical. In what concerns our mind and spiritual affairs, we are remarkably naive.

Now it really should be the opposite. Worldly affairs are transitory, things pass. My mother was a wealthy influential person, now last Wednesday she was incinerated, what is left is a little bag of ash, Nothing else is left. What has gone on is the mind. And her situation, her predicament, is a predicament of every one of us in this room.

So, we should focus on being critical, investigative, demanding as far as our spiritual development is concerned. In material affairs we should be relaxed. It’s better to do it like that. So then, the three principles of the path are all involved with mental training. These are three aspects of mental training which were identified by Jetsong Kappa and there’s an ongoing debate whether it’s Jetsong Kappa himself by revelation of Manjushri but I personally like to think it’s Jetsong Kappa himself.

These are three core elements of mental training which underlie everything else. Then you know them so I just put them for record, you will note that two are part of the means component of the path, in other words our motivations, and one is wisdom. In your opinion, which of the two components is more important? Chris? Out of means and wisdom.

Why? No. Someone else. Yes, but with wisdom alone you can achieve neither. So which is a more important?

Does the question make sense? Why not? Please. Exactly. In other words, without means you can attain neither liberation nor full enlightenment.

You may have wisdom but you will not attain either liberation or full enlightenment. Without wisdom, you will definitely not attain liberation nor full enlightenment. Therefore there are three principles of the path and the question which one is more important and whether the method or the wisdom component is more important is a meaningless question. It’s a misleading question. I have to ask you those questions from time to time, right?

I have to sort of lead you on the wrong path to encourage you to think a bit. In other words, both are needed simultaneously. You need the method and the wisdom, the path aspect of the path together. Now this text, the three principles of the path is a particular, it’s different from the Lamrim text, so we’ll talk about it during this presentation. Lamrim was written to be read by a large number of students.

This was a Tibetan called Tsok shei was public. The three principles of the path was a letter which Je Tsongkhapa wrote to one of his closest disciples, the Lord of Tago, actually of royal dynasty, Nawang Dagpa. Then the big question which has troubled the Geluk authors is whether this letter was really meant for the rest of us. In other words, who is the trainee of the three principles of the path? Was it only Nawang Dagpa, Lord of Tsago, who by all accounts was an exceptional practitioner, he’s the author of the commentary on Bodhicitta vivarana for instance or is it something which applies to the rest of us?

This is something we will talk about and as a result because it is a letter, because it is an oral instruction, it focuses on the pith, in other words, there are huge waves of lamrim which are not covered in the three principles of the path, they are implicit. What is focused upon is the essence and it is presented at the beginning in a circular fashion. It is extraordinarily subtle, it’s difficult to believe that someone could write a letter in verse like this, it’s astonishing. Where the first verse as we saw last time teaches Guru Yoga. Then we will see in a couple seconds, the following stanza actually is an introduction, a very indirect introduction to the three principles of the path and then the qualities of the disciple are mentioned.

It is quite astonishing, mean I have read quite widely in world religious literature and I have frankly never seen something this rich. So the beginning of the three principles of the verse is the homage we covered last time. I prostrate to the noble gurus which teaches Guru Yoga. And then three verses. The meaning of the essence of all of the teachings of the conquerors, the path praised by the holy children of the conquerors and that gateway for the fortunate desiring liberation, I will explain as best I can.

Each one of these verses, each line in other words, teaches one of the three principles of the path. The first line, well the title obviously, but the first line teaches Guru Yoga. And then the first verse of the recapitulation, the meaning of the essence of all the teachings of the conquerors teaches definite emergence. The second, the path praised by the holy children of the conquerors, Bodhicitta, and the third, and that gateway for the fortunate desiring liberation, teaches the view. Finally, even though Je Tsongkhapa was doubtless the greatest scholar of his age and probably the greatest practitioner as well, and have had a direct vision of Manjushri.

He adds, and it’s quite astonishing, I will explain as best I can. An extraordinary statement of humility. And what we will discuss now is why each of these three verses in the recapitulation refers indirectly to the three principles of the path which will then be explained in the body of the text. So in a more systematic way, this is the beginning of the outline of the preliminary section. We have the name of the treatise and the section which concerns us now is the homage which we covered last time, recapitulation of the three principles of the path, and the pledge to compose.

The homage as we said was Guru Yoga, the recapitulation alludes to the three principles of the path, and the pledge to compose is merely I will explain as best I can. This is the commitment to write the treatise or to write in this case a letter which eliminates interferences. So why is the first verse here the meaning of the essence of all of the teachings of the conquerors, a verse which alludes to definite emergence or renunciation and what is definite emergence? We shall cover it very briefly since Je Tsongkhapa gives an introduction I would like to give one too and then we will go into it in much greater depth. And I will be happy to go into the view in even greater depth if one of you is left.

The view is difficult. The view is difficult. Then there are three types of definite emergence. You have what we normally know as definite emergence which is a definite emergence of the middling scope, which is specific to Buddhism. It is a wish to attain liberation, in other words to be freed from all the afflictions for one’s own sake.

But we have a definite emergence of the small scope and in complete thought of definite emergence which is a prelude to fully characterize definite emergence and this is the wish to turn away from the vanities of this life. Now this is shared with almost all the great world religions. We find this in Christianity, find it in Hinduism, in Judaism it’s more debatable and Islam is also more debatable, they are much more focused on the law in this life but certainly in Christianity it is present. And in most of the Hindu schools it is present as well. And finally, the greatest form of definite emergence is the definite emergence of the great vehicle, definite emergence for others.

This is bodhichitta. Just as I myself am a prisoner of cyclic existence and I’m transmigrating powerlessly, likewise so are all beings and then definite emergence is extended to all. I must help others, they are not indifferent to me. We are intimately related, have been so since beginningless time. In my present state I cannot help them, I must attain a state in which I can do so, such a state exists, it is called full enlightenment, this is what I will strive for.

That is bodhichitta. So you can see that definite emergence can be declined in three modes. The mode of the path of the being of the small scope, of the middling scope and of the great scope. So let us start with definite emergence of the small scope, incomplete definite emergence, it’s not full definite emergence. It is taught further down by Je Tsongkhapa in two verses.

This life of lesion endowment is hard to find and it does not last. By habituating the mind, turn away from the fleeting appearances of this life. We’ll cover this verse in much greater detail in a couple of months, but I just wanted to present it first. This verse teaches how to generate mere or incomplete definite emergence. How in other words to turn away from this life?

Now we were speaking of transforming the mind earlier and how it is the main means to eliminate mental suffering. The first step is to become indifferent to this life. It is profoundly liberating to be able to walk away from the preoccupations of this life. That does not mean to become irresponsible, but no longer to become emotionally involved. It’s a source of great peace and this is the beginning of the peace which Buddhism has to offer.

And one turns away from this life simply because as Nagajuna says beautifully in his letter to King Gautamiputra, this life is beset by many misfortunes. It is more impermanent than a water bubble in the wind. Actually, inhaling and exhaling, in other words being alive after waking from sleep is extraordinary. Now in Australia, Australians have had a very good run for some twenty years and it’s easy to forget that things change. When they change, the teachings on impermanence become particularly cogent.

And the material change then has an impact on family life, has an impact on the financial situation. Eventually it has an impact on mental health and physical health. There was an old student of Rinpoche, he wrote me a couple of weeks ago, he wanted to invite me to an event in Adelaide, and I said, so how have you been? It’s been two three years now you know. He’s Swiss actually.

And he said, well, my financial situation collapsed, I was separated from my wife and she divorced, and then I had mental problems. Then, the first, the collapse of the financial situation that, dharma cannot help you. You have to learn self control and contentment. If you live above your means, you’ll crash and burn. Then separation and divorce, dharma can help you because those occur because of afflictions in the mind of the person.

So if one is kind to one’s partner, normally that doesn’t happen. Mental problems, dharma can definitely help. Mental problems are a clear sign of lack of dharma. Right? Because it means a person has no control whatsoever over the mind.

Then I was very sad for this student because I thought you know he is a Lojong student of Rinpoche, so I encouraged him to come to the center but he has not returned. Then more than this, the Buddhist teachings cannot do. So if one leads a life in keeping with the Buddhist teachings, life of simplicity within one’s means of contentment, the problems in this life will be reduced. That I can guarantee. And in addition, even should problems occur and they do happen, people do fall sick, you know, I mean there’s no guarantee we won’t get cancer, there’s no guarantee we won’t get Alzheimer’s, Even when problems happen, the mind is at peace.

So a mind which is very reactive is a mind which is not at peace, an unsubdued mind. Then one should try to subdue one’s mind for one’s own sake initially. So how does one proceed to try to turn away from this life? I put it in chart form, I think it’s always helpful to do it like this. The object of abandonment is this life.

Now if you think already just that statement, the object of abandonment is this life, many people will turn and run away from TBI screaming, right? So I hope you will not. The means are meditation on a human rebirth of leisure and endowment and on death and impermanence and the object of attainment is a happy rebirth. Now the means are twin and it’s a very powerful combination. First we meditate on having something very precious.

Then we meditate on the fact that it’s going to be taken away from us. When you train your mind in this way what happens? The first thing you want to do is to try to prevent the precious component you have from disappearing completely. And you try to find means to do this. So what we have which is very precious is a rebirth which is karmically potent with freedom, that is what a human rebirth of lesion and armies is.

We actually have for a very short period in the cycle of lives we have had, the possibility to inflect the cycle of lives. Most beings do not have the possibility to inflect the direction of the cycle of lives. I have dogs, they have no control whatsoever over future rebirths. Most animals do not, think probably most human beings do not. A human rebirth of leisure endowment is not a mere human rebirth.

So, if at present we are experiencing great difficulties, mental difficulties, physical difficulties, this comes from the past. Psychologists trace it back to early childhood, but it can be traced much further back. Many, many lives in the past. If we do not want to experience this again, this is the point where we have the possibility to change. And that is what is meant by precious human rebirth.

So we shall talk today of a human rebirth of lesion and dharma. It’s a difficult topic because presented correctly one has to talk about karma, which I will not do. And next time we’ll talk of death and impermanence. The two I think are the most helpful meditations for us in our present state, especially death and impermanence. It is much more helpful to set all your sadhanas aside and all of the advanced tantric practices, just fulfill your commitments and focus on death and impermanence until the mind changes.

So Valence was asking a couple of weeks ago, how to meditate on the Lamrim and Geshela gave an excellent answer. The overview meditations are good to familiarize oneself with the topic, but the mind does not change as a result of Charcot, of overview meditations. What changes the mind is focusing on a topic for so long as it takes. This is how KJPWK practiced. If you train like this, you will not finish meditating on the Lamrim in one life, it will not happen.

If you are able to become a being of the small scope in one life, that life has been very well spent. Because that outlook will carry over into the next life. You will be born as a being of the small scope. You will start thinking as a child in this way. Then to become a being of the great scope in one life it’s not going to happen.

Don’t delude yourselves. It’s simply not going to happen. So here we study the totality of the path to become familiar with the totality of the path which you have to follow for probably thousands, maybe tens of thousands of years for some of us. But the true practice is when you and we’ll talk about this shortly, identify where you are in terms of your mental disposition. Who are you really?

Are you a worldly being? Most of us are. Are you a being of the small scope that is rare? Are you a being of the middling scope? I probably don’t know any.

And then what should you meditate upon to progress from that one step up? And then you focus on that until there is realization. It takes years. That is mind training according to the Lamrim, everything else is just for future usage. We are not able to practice tantra, we do not have the skills, we don’t have bodhichitta.

Without bodhichitta and an understanding of emptiness, is no tantric practice. So excessive focus on tantric practice is misguided practice. Our goal must be initially to try to build a mental capacity and it’s a painstaking process. There was a very great Tibetan monk who met with His Holiness, it’s very beautiful what he said, And he’s he was in his oh, he must have been almost 90. And His Holiness said, so how did you spend your life?

And this monk said, well, basically, the last sixty years or so I spent in retreat. Thought, Very good. What retreats did you do? And he said, I just tried to enhance my capacity for compassion. And so I said, Has there been results?

And he said, Yes, there’s been improvement. That is very good. That is very good. That means that life was well spent. So what is a fully characterized definite emergence then?

Jitsongkapa mentions it in the following verse a bit further down in the text. This is what we know as renunciation reflecting over and again on the infiability of causality, in other words the four general features of karma you are familiar with And on the suffering of cyclic existence, then these are the general and the specific sufferings, the three sufferings, six sufferings, the eight sufferings, the suffering of each realm. Turn away from the futilities of future lives. Then this, this is an extraordinary level of realization. As a very old old friend of mine, Moengeshi Ishigawa, he was disciplinarian of Sera Je’s, very fine Geshe, well in his eighties, 85 or so now, you know, we were talking once at Sera and he said to me, if only I could become an Arhat, I don’t have the capacity he said, but I think my goodness, what an Arhat is.

And this is very humbling, isn’t it? We talk of the Mahayana until we’re blue in the face, largely because there’s no understanding of what the Mahayana is. It is very fine glyphi, know, circle of the protector of Hayagriva, former, you know, disciplinary master of discipline of the monastery, who acknowledges that he finds the path of the being of the middling scope daunting. And then there is real mental training, which is a true assessment of one’s true capacity, not a fantasized assessment. So the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the middling scope is all lives and obviously when we think of all lives we think of the suffering lives but it’s abandonment of the happy lives which is difficult, isn’t it?

And the means is meditation on causality, in other words that karma is certain and so forth and on the sufferings of cyclic existence as a whole. The object of attainment is liberation. Then for these meditations to bear any fruit, we must first believe in the existence of all lives otherwise it’s not going to happen. So if we don’t believe in the existence of samsara, in other words of reincarnation, there’s no liberation because we not want to escape. You don’t escape if you don’t believe you’re in jail in the first place.

And then, we have to actually understand causality and suffering and suffering is very difficult to understand. Not the suffering of suffering but the second and third sufferings. The suffering of change and more pervasive suffering. The suffering of change is what we all call happiness. Then to view happiness as suffering is very difficult.

Probably none of us does because if we did we would live differently. It can only be done through experience. Then I often feel that the best thing we could encourage many of our students at TBI is to leave the center, earn a lot a lot of money and get a life, and live a bit. Once you have a lot of money and you have a life, and you enjoy life, you can understand the suffering of change. But you’ve got to have the experience.

As long as there are unresolved fantasies, if only this, if only that, it doesn’t happen. And that’s why it’s interesting, personally I find it very interesting that some of the great Buddhist practitioners of the past were very wealthy people. Buddha Shakyamuni, Atisha, Nagajum is a very wealthy family, you know. Then obviously, they would have seen the vanity of things, right? I had a very interesting experience of this in my own life, know, after I had taken care of a lot of family interests, I decided to take some time off and I had always wanted to sail.

So I got a very fancy yacht, you know, and I had my own crew and a very beautiful girlfriend, everything in other words. Money, the boat, the girl, you know, the US passport, everything, you know. And I thought I would be happy, right, especially the boat. My mother asked me, she was quite worried, she said, Bobi, who comes first? Me, the girlfriend, or the boat?

I said, naturally, you. I said, the boat comes second. But this boat became a source of great suffering because my crew was a bit unruly, you know, and I was running a dry boat for obvious reasons, you know, when people drink on boats, have accidents. And I was sailing in the Irish Sea and they went and they got drunk in Dublin like nothing. Then they came back, couldn’t run the boat, you know.

And I finally had to fire them in Wales. And then this boat which is supposed to be a source of relaxation after a lot of work became a very big burden and a big teaching. It is through things like this that one understands the suffering of change. The boat went from being something I looked up to, to something which is a huge burden on my shoulders. So I’ve been fortunate in my life, I have had a lot of money.

As a result, what people dream of I have done. And I can say for myself, it is empty. But you have to have those experiences yourselves. Or have something close to it. And if you don’t, there’s always going to be a nagging part of you which is going to feel you’re missing out.

Right? Then as we grow older, this understanding dawns easier. As we grow older, more has been taken away from us. There’s less to look forwards to. The body is no longer a source of pleasure but a source of suffering.

Then the understanding of the suffering of change comes easier, but we can’t do a lot about it anymore, can we? There’s ten years left to live, twelve years, fifteen years, we have headaches, don’t remember, that is difficult, right? So the key for us to practice is to blend the teachings with our experience. If this blending occurs, then our practice will be powerful. If the blending does not occur, we end up with the situation of many of our students where it is some sort of dogmatic system they study like a framework to structure themselves and it’s not applied to one’s life.

And as a result, we get situations we’ve had and I’ve seen in quite a few centers now of people who were Buddhist, had everything, refuge, bodhisattva vows, tantric vows, and then suddenly the person disappears and six months later someone says, oh, they’re over there, they’ve become evangelical Christians, that was one case, or Muslims, that was another case. Then if that can happen, it is obvious that the teachings were merely an intellectual game. They were not lived. And by not being lived I mean it was never connected to the person’s life. Once it’s connected to one’s life, then the teachings are very powerful.

It is not possible to leave the teachings easily at that point because one sees as Rinpoche was telling me once, he said you see the benefits. One sees the benefits for oneself. Then others, something even greater than that. And finally, the third form of renunciation definite emergence, bodhicitta. We know it refers, this verse refers to Bodhicitta because it is a path praised by the holy children of the conquerors and the holy children are none others than the victors, the Bodhisattvas.

Then what exactly is bodhichitta? Bodhichitta is a mind which is very difficult for us to understand because it is a wish for something which is rooted in empathy. It is rooted in the wish to help others. We have a partial wish to help others as long as it doesn’t cost us too much but to become a bodhisattva who basically does not value himself or herself in the slightest and is exclusively focused for others, it’s very difficult for us to understand. And bodhicitta is defined by Maitreya, in probably one of the most famous verses of his Abhisamyalamkala, as to have generated the mind is for the sake of others to wish for utter full enlightenment.

There is nothing else to this in bodhicitta. You wish for full enlightenment for the sake of others. If you want to assess whether Bodhicitta is present or not in other spiritual traditions, you have to ask yourself, does full enlightenment exist in those traditions? What is meant by full enlightenment? And is there a training in the wish to attain it for the sake of others?

I think overwhelmingly the answer is no. Now on what basis is bodhicitta generated, in other words a mental base is compassion, this is a famous verse of Maitreya’s Mahena Sutra Namkara, it’s the foundation on which bodhicitta arises. So compassion, we have. Great compassion we do not have. So what is in the process of training by means of bodhichitta?

The object of abandonment here is self cherishing, in other words egoism. Then the means are the two means of generation of bodhicitta, the sevenfold causal means which you have studied many times and the equalization and interchange of self and others which Gesheera will be teaching here. And what does one attain? One attains full enlightenment. Again we will study bodhichitta in much greater detail in a couple of months.

So this is just in the context of the introduction to the three principles of the path, a reminder for most of you. Finally, the last verse of the introduction alludes to the view and that gateway for the fortunate desiring liberation. Why does it allude to the view? Because the three principles of the path are written from the standpoint of prasanika madhyamika and for prasanika madhyamika, the prasanika view is indispensable to obtain either liberation or full enlightenment. So this is the fundamental difference with the other schools of tenets such as Svatantrika madhyamika for which you have three different views to attain what is known as the enlightenment of the three categories of beings, hearers solitary realizers and bodhisattvas.

For prasanika, without the prasanika view, there is neither liberation nor full enlightenment. This is very daunting because what is being said is that someone who relies only on any view from Vaibhashika to Svatantrika Madhyamika will never attain liberation let alone full enlightenment. Now this calls for a lot of analysis, a very very strong grounds for this position which is quite quite challenging really because it’s not just a matter of verbally endorsing the Prasangika madhyamika view, it’s a matter of having the pure Prasangika madhyamika view. And in Tibet, let’s say at the time of Jitsungapar, there were fundamental misunderstandings regarding prasankhamadhyamika which Je Tsongkhapa cleared up. Now in a nutshell, the reason for which without prasankhamadhyamika as a view, one cannot attain liberation, let alone full enlightenment, is because with any other view in which there is even a smidgen, an iota of clinging left.

In other words, there is an object which has some existence from its own side. That object can act as a support for clinging. That object can act as a support for attachment and that is sufficient to preclude attainment of the view. It is only prasanika madhyamika which teaches that all phenomena without exception are mere mental imputations from the side of the subject. This position is very difficult for us to understand.

Svatantrika Madhyamika is much more comfortable and most Geshe’s at Sera actually are quite honest about it, they, you know, consider themselves photographers. A Geshe Yamaguchi said to me, I find view very difficult to understand. My natural view is, he said, because I just think there is something from the side of the object. Then little, very little, but there is something. Is saying there is nothing.

So force what are the academic for those of you who have done tenets, exterior phenomena phenomena in general are not truly established but they are established by their own characteristics. In other words they have characteristics, components like the components of this book on which basis they exist independently of the mind imputing them. Then things get very complex. It’s a little bit out of the level of this presentation but basically Svatantrika Madhyamika asserts that this book arises at the intersection of the mind imputing it and of the characteristics of this book. The book has characteristics from its own side and there is a mind imputing book on those characteristics and the conjunction of those characteristics from the side of the book and the mind imputing book on those characteristics defines a conventional mode of existence of book.

Prasangika Madhyamika says, this book has no characteristics from its own side. It is exclusively the mind imputing book on the basis of imputation, which itself has no existence from its own side, which is a conventional mode of existence of the book. So why it is not possible to attain liberation liberation by means of Svatantrika Madhyamika but only by Prasangika Madhyamika, you have to study tenets in great depth, you know, and then it raises many many questions. Does it mean that there is no one in the Theravada traditions who has attained liberation? Does it mean that there is no one in Tibet before Je Tsongkhapa’s time and after Gurinpoche who attained liberation of full enlightenment?

Then obviously no. There are Theravada practitioners who attain liberation. There are great beings, Gurung Pajek himself, great beings after him, before Je Tsongkhapa’s time and after the other traditions who attain liberation. But, most of the Gelukpa scholars such as Tugen Chukin Nima, the author of very nice general presentation of tenets translated I think in English as crystal mirror of tenets or something like that. The library of Tibetan classics, says that in those cases, the practitioner by himself or herself found true prasanika madhyamika view.

And I am very sympathetic to that standpoint. In other words, there have been in Thailand, in Burma, great Theravada practitioners, Se Mahasi Sayadaw was recognized by Geshe Raptan as an Arhat who attained liberation but even though prasanika madhyamika is not taught in those countries, they had through their own examination to develop a pure understanding of prasanika madhyamika which didn’t call itself prasanika obviously. Then on that basis, he would attain liberation. So you must study very carefully. Those of you who are seriously interested in these topics, a good place to start if you have the, courage is Ketub Jay’s which is translated in English as I think a dose of emptiness, translated by Jose Cabazon.

It is an absolute masterpiece and what KDOJ does is compare emptiness in the various schools of tenants. So, to understand the view, we must have some historical context. We must understand what the different schools of tenants were in ancient India. Now in India, there were six main schools of tenants and the multiplicity of unorthodox schools of tenets. I’ve listed some here with their founders in the period where they were founded.

You would note that there was a critical period in the generation of Indian philosophy sometime between the sixth and the fourth century BC, which oddly coincides with the period when Greek philosophy arose. And why this is a case we do not know. Now if we have a more analytical study of the schools of tenets, what you can see is and this is my own work, this is very very schematic. You would find, you could find thinkers in each of these schools who would have positions which aren’t really in keeping with the subdivision. The schools of Indian philosophy are subdivided into the pre Gangetic tradition, so those which basically are pre sixth century, which include the Vedas, the four Vedas of ancient India.

And the Gangetic traditions, which are basically all the great traditions we know as Indian schools of meditation and so forth in the West. Now these Gangetic traditions are subdivided to Brahmankar, Upanishadic and Darkshamas. The Brahmankar are orthodox Hindu traditions focused mainly on ritual for the attainment of liberation. The Upanishadic traditions are this group of sannyas, of renunciant mendicants which arose and the dates here are very difficult to give exactly but around the seventh century BC in the Basin Of The Ganges and which for reasons we do not understand all were characterized by a very strong rejection of this world and of what they called samsara, cyclic existence. This is a common locus and all strove for moksha.

Now the Upanishads are a bewildering collection of texts which were written much later but which collect the sayings of these great beings. Basically everyone agrees on their predicament, everyone agrees on the goal and everyone disagrees on the means. So it is very striking the level of disagreement. And it is within that milieu that Buddhism is born or manifests. Now whereas, if you look at this chart, can see in red, the, traditions which do not accept the authority of the Vedas and which therefore are possibly not necessarily but possibly atheistic.

And in blue those which accept the Vedas overwhelmingly Indian religiosity is rooted in the Vedas, the four Vedas, which are to Indian religions what the old testament is to us. But yoga and Samkhya do not accept the authority of the Vedas and are not necessarily theistic and three Indian traditions are atheistic Buddhism, Jain and the materialists. They still believe in the existence of cyclic existence as object of abandonment, they believe in the attainment of liberation, but they do not accept that there is a God who basically administers karma, that is the understanding of orthodox Hinduism nowadays. Brahma, Vishnu or Shiva administers karma. How this works gets very complicated.

But it is clear that an understanding of the infallibility of karma as we understand it cannot be upheld with that viewpoint. There is some sort of balancing act between God and karma. Typically, karma operates and you find this very much in India nowadays. Karma operates but if you pray to God he can step in and there is this hiatus and karma stops to operate for a while. You know, this seems to be the understanding.

So what are the core shared assertions of these schools of philosophy apart from the materialists? All believe in samsara. All believe samsara is suffering and all agree that ignorance is the root cause of samsara. And all assert that there is a liberation, a moksha or we say nirvana in Buddhism, which is freedom from suffering. So in this respect, the Indian schools have the same relation with each other as it is say, the great Semitic religions.

In Judaism, Islam, and Christianity, everyone agrees the world was created, everyone agrees that God created it, everyone agrees there’s a mass judgment, everyone agrees God revealed the law in a book, it’s complete agreement. Then in which book the disagreements begin, right? Who was the greatest prophets? Everyone draws their swords, but the basics are the same. The problem for us is we are passing into a radically different mental universe.

These are core elements here and the existence of samsara is obviously the existence of reincarnation. So what are the differences between the Indian darshanas, the viewpoints? The fundamental one is how do we attain higher rebirth or liberation. Everyone agrees it has to be a goal, especially liberation. Some say by ritual and sacrifice.

This was a dominant view in India I’d say up to the seventh century, non Buddhist view. Some say by faith, this is the bhakti traditions, the devotional traditions which appear in India around the ninth century, like you have heard of the Hari Krishna movement in the West, it’s a bhakti tradition. You attain liberation through faith and Krishna, you know. Some say through meditation and wisdom, this is also an ancient tradition. Find this in yoga, you find this in Sankhya, you find it in Buddhism.

The second subsidiary question is, why is there a word? And is there a self? In other words, everyone agrees we reincarnate but what reincarnates? Now apart from Buddhism and the two materialists, the two atheistic traditions, which is Jain and Lokkaryatta, everyone else agrees there is an odd one, there is itself. So His Holiness made a very nice analysis of this.

I think the text is untranslated, so I translated it for you. With standpoint of fame, Sankhya, Buddha Shakyamuni’s dharma and the dharma of the Jains do not accept a creator. From within these three, both the Sankhyas and the Jains are similar to the Buddhists. They assert that happiness and suffering arise in mere dependence on causality. However, to the difference of the Buddhists, they assert a permanent unitarian independent self, which enjoys happiness and suffering.

Not only do Buddhists not accept a self arisen permanent being, which creates happiness and suffering, in other words a God, but in addition, they also do not accept a permanent unitary and independent self, which is the enjoyer of happiness and suffering. So it’s a bit dizzying. Let’s put it in a simpler form. If we look at the four non theistic traditions who do not believe in the God. Buddhism, the Sankhyas and the Jain.

The Sankhyas no longer exist but the Jains still do. It’s a small but very influential religious movement in India. All believe in karma, this complete agreement. Then Sankhyas and the Jain also believe in an atman, in other words a soul. The Buddhists do not.

And there is some shared elements between the Buddhists and the materialists. Both believe in no self but unfortunately the materialists in addition don’t believe in karma. So it is probably for this reason that for modern westerners it is fairly easy to turn to Buddhism because we are culturally materialists, so we believe neither in a soul nor in karma. And the only thing to modify is a belief in past and future lives in karma. And the non Buddhists have always accused Buddhists of being crypto lokaryatas.

Even though Buddha Shakyam when he criticized the lokaryat of you very sharply. So this is a dizzying part. I promise it’s going to get easier after the break. Then even though these schools accept the existence of karma, there is a substantial difference, I won’t I won’t enter into it too much, into what is understood by causality. The early Buddhist schools, the Hinayana schools, speak of true change.

What they mean by true change is that phenomena really change. It is not an illusion. All Indian schools of thought consider that the change which we see is just an illusion and therefore cause and effect are of one nature. It is one of the fundamental divides in Indian thought. For the Buddhists cause and effect are of different natures.

It’s a fundamental position. What that means is that once the effect has been produced the cause ceases to exist. The effect arises in the destruction of the cause. There is true change. Imagine what it means for yourself if we assert true change, true impermanence, that things can never go back to being the way they were.

In Indian thought, apart from Buddhism, the belief is in illusory change. Change is just Maya, it’s just the illusion which is created by God. So this is all a little bit dizzying but it leads us to what I wanted to show you which is the process of training in the correct view. The object of abandonment is grasping at a self if your goal is liberation or grasping at a self as well as its seeds, the karmic imprints, if your goal is full enlightenment and the means is only meditation on selflessness. Then in the great Indian tradition, everyone disagrees with everyone else.

It depends on to proverb, know. So it was like that in Tibet too. They said, one valley, two lamas. Two lamas, three views. And it is like that to this day.

The Reddens are very good at disagreeing with each other and there is a very strong emphasis on developing one’s own view. And this is a little bit what you see those of you who attend Salaam, who attended Tenetz. The goal is not for the teacher to transmit his own understanding to the students. The goal is for the student to learn how to think and to train and gain his own understanding, even if it is different from that of the teacher. And the final verse in this recapitulation of the three principles of path is the pledge to compose.

I will explain as best I can. So if we go back a bit, you can see how profound this group of three verses is. The meaning of the essence of all of the teachings of the conqueror which alludes to definite emergence, fully characterized definite emergence. The path praised by the holy children of the conqueror, bodhicitta, in other words, the definite emergence of the great vehicle and that gateway for the fortunate desiring liberation which by alluding to the view, implicitly alludes to the view of all of the schools of Indian philosophy which is rejected and within the non theistic schools of Indian philosophy, in other words Jain, Buddhism and the Lokaryatas, the Buddhist specificity. And this is really the key I think for a westerner to becoming a very sincere Buddhist, it is to be able to understand what is the Buddhist view and what is not the Buddhist view.

The Buddhist view is a middle ground, a middle way. A middle way between what? It is a middle way between this and this. It’s a middle way between complete materialism, no self and no karma, which is actually the view of almost all the westerners who think nowadays and the teachings of a soul which you find in Sankhya, in Jain, in Vedanta and so forth. So in Sankhya Jaina Vedanta, the existence of a soul and causality is taught.

In Lokaryata there is neither soul nor causality. Buddhism asserts what? It just asserts causality, but no self. Something transmigrates but it’s not the soul. They’re in disagreement with the other Buddhist, the other non Buddhist traditions.

What transmigrates? The mere mind. On the other hand, it is not the case that nothing transmigrates and there’s nothing before death and nothing after death, and they are in disagreement with some materialists. It is for that reason a middle way between the extremes. Then I think we’ll stop here for the tea break.

I’m sure you need a little break, I do too. And we’ll reconvene around 03:15 if it’s possible.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Samkhya drang chen pa (Tib)
Early non-Buddhist philosophical school; the so-called "enumerators," because they advocate a definite enumeration of the causes that produce existents. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top