Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 06082016Session 2 Symposium – HHDL.mp3
UUID: e6e07125-158c-405f-bd6d-8ec85d523315
Teacher: —
Collection: TBI Symposium
Date: 2016-08-06
Duration: 1h 35m
Words: 12,168
So we can begin the second session, the development of empathy and altruism in Mahāyāna Buddhism. Thank you. You. Maybe we should close the door, think quite a few of our students are a bit chilled. So I would like us to try to keep in mind what we talked about during the previous hour as we start seeing how empathy and altruism are generated in the Mahāyāna.
A couple of points which are worth making is first that there is a particular relevance to Mahāyāna Buddhism in the generation of empathy and altruism precisely because Buddhism in general, Mahāyāna in particular consider that these states of mind can be generated. It is not that empathy and altruism are absent in other great religious traditions such as Christianity but there are no particular techniques to generate them or enhance them. For instance Christ’s messages on, love and compassion are among the most powerful, we have. Certainly the Sermon on the Mount, broad swathes of the Sermon on the on the Mount could be endorsed by all Mahāyāna practitioners but nothing is really said about how to generate love for others altruism, compassion. One is encouraged to have it, it is praised, it is lauded but how do we train this?
So what we saw from the previous presentation is that we are biologically preconditioned to be able to generate altruism and compassion. From the standpoint of Buddhist philosophy, if Chopal returns to Sera, he will study this in fourth year, the notion of the base on which bodhichitta can be generated. It’s astonishing how accurate the presentation in Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen is. Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen says that some beings are able to generate altruism, some specific categories of sentient beings and some are not. And human beings are one such base.
Certain animals are, other animals are not. Now this is something we saw very clearly. Excuse me a sec, I just forgot something. I’ll be back in one minute. So this being the case, how do we generate empathy and altruism in the Mahāyāna?
Empathy and altruism are fundamental to the Mahāyāna. As Nāgārjuna says whether you are or not a Mahāyāna practitioner hinges exclusively on whether bodhichitta has been generated or not. Everything else is subsidiary. And here we have to ask some very interesting questions and I will represent material I have already presented at TBI with a different slant. Because what we are being told in the generation of bodhichitta is that it is possible to artificially generate a spontaneous motivation.
Now is this something which is possible? Certainly from a contemporary western standpoint it is not. Helen Weng’s studies, with Davidson’s team suggest it might be. Helen Weng as you remember found that through training the mind in compassion by meditation, compassionate and empathetic reactions occurred more frequently and spontaneously when exposed to the suffering of others. This is very very alien to a modern western outlook.
We are generating, I’ll talk about it later, what amounts to an instinct to replace our pre existing instincts. And this must be done in an incremental way. Therefore we have to generate initially what is known as a contrived motivation followed by what is known a spontaneous motivation or uncontrived motivation. The contrived motivation is generated through effort repeatedly and through habituation with this contrived motivation eventually we are taught in Mahāyāna Buddhism that a spontaneous motivation takes over. So generating a contrived motivation amounts to hammering a piece of iron into shape.
Probably none of us have experiences at the forge but if you did you would know that you need two things. You need great heat. In other words great heat here is concentration, specifically calm abiding and you need a strong right arm, you need effort. Repeated application. The greater the heat and the greater the effort the faster you can shape this bar of iron into a plow or a sword.
Without heat it’s impossible, without concentration it’s impossible. Without repeated effort it is also impossible. Now the teachings on meditative concentration have probably never been developed as far as within Buddhism. The refinements of the states of meditative concentration, how to generate them, their characteristics. There is no Indian tradition which has developed them this far and the non Indian religious traditions at best have a sense of the possible impact concentration might have on ecstatic experience but no clear sense of how they’re generated.
Now a contrived motivation and these are perhaps most fundamental points of this presentation, must be generated incrementally and can only be generated by generating all the motivations leading up to it. This is what is known in Tibetan Buddhism as the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path. We have become so familiar with the concept we don’t appreciate its steps. It is not possible to short circuit the generation of such motivations. It is basically the same thing as walking from here to the Adelaide Market.
You do not get to the Adelaide Market by jumping. You have to walk one step at a time. If the previous steps have not been taken you will not be able to take the subsequent steps. It is not possible and the mapping of these levels of motivation has been in my personal opinion the uncommon contribution of Tibetan Buddhism. We have this gigantic, those of you who looked at the Kangyur or even studied the Kangyur and the Tengyur, in other words the totality of the Buddhist teachings.
We have this gigantic throve of material. It is very difficult to understand what fits where. And the creation of a concept of graduated stages we owe to one of the very great thinkers in the transmission of Buddhism to Tibet to Atisha. But the work once Atisha basically laid out the ground plan, the work was performed first by the great Kadampas, what is known as the Tenrim and fundamentally by Je Tsongkhapa in Lamrim Chenmo. Now Lamrim Chemo and Lamrim is therefore not an arbitrary dogmatic template.
It is a template of mental development to pass from a series of contrived motivations to uncontrived motivations. And it is really a feeling, it is my personal conviction, it’s a feeling of all of the Tibetan scholars certainly in India that it is not possible to leapfrog parts of the path. You will simply not get there. As westerners we love shortcuts, it doesn’t work. Right?
So an actual contrived motivation itself can only be generated incrementally. In other words if your goal is an uncontrived motivation you need to generate contrived motivations to get there and these series of contrived motivations can only be generated step by step. If we are thinking of changing our fundamental makeup, then you can see what the challenges is. A great Bodhisattva is a being who instinctively responds with compassion to whatever event occurs. What we mean when we speak of a spontaneous or uncontrived motivation of bodhichitta is that if someone were to rush on this great bodhisattva wielding a knife and this has become quite common unfortunately in our world, the instinctive reaction of the bodhisattva will be compassion for that being and an enhanced wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of that being.
The greater the violence of the deed from the standpoint of the being the greater the power of the bodhichitta generated within the bodhisattva. Therefore such bodhisattvas mentally cannot be harmed. Physically they can. Whether it is possible to become a being like that is an open question. Obviously the Buddhist scriptures teach us that it is.
Are there beings like that is a question we have to ask ourselves. We can train, we can become more compassionate beings. Can we change who we are so fundamentally that when violence, because in violence that self cherishing is the most powerful right, when someone threatens your life the instinctive reaction is to fight back. When violence, great violence occurs is it possible to transform ourselves before this obviously so much that our instinctive reaction is profound compassion for the perpetrator of the deed and a desire to help him which is all the greater because of the violence he is ready to inflict on us. It’s not easy.
So at this point we are separating, we’re following different paths from neurobiology and what we covered until now. According to neurobiology this is not possible. We are basically if you wish totally reengineering our brain. It’s not possible. I don’t think any neurobiologist would think that you would be able to totally evacuate amygdalic reactions.
And yet this is what we’re saying. This is something which is worth thinking about. So spontaneous motivation is like a vast river. It means no particular effort from our part, it flows. Such a motivation is neither generated artificially nor incrementally.
It however can only arise after very long habituation, The generation of contrived motivations. It takes lifetimes. One of the weak spots of our presentation of the Lamrim in all Buddhist centers is that the students get the sense that somehow it happens fairly rapidly. That one studies the various paths and somehow having studied them one has realized them. And I always like to remember His Holiness meeting with a very great Tibetan practitioner, you know.
It’s very humbling really And this old monk when he met His Holiness was asked by His Holiness what attainments he had at the end of his life. He said well he had meditated fifty sixty years and he could say one thing that his capacity for compassion had increased. That is very powerful. That’s a true practitioner. Because that is a sign of someone who actually assesses the state of his own mind.
Then that capacity is carried over into future lives which we as Buddhists accept. One does not start again from the beginning. Every one of us in this room comes in this life with something. Now if we look back on our own past and most of us are unfortunately in the 40, 50, even 60 year old range, I mean we can be honest about ourselves. So if we look at ourselves when we were young I think we can get a sense of what we brought in this life.
Every one of us can. Now what we brought in this life is something we brought from the past life. In our next life we will bring something from this life. What we bring is up to us. We have, at present we have choice, we have control.
It’s not carried over easily and this is what Khensur Rinpoche taught repeatedly. How much is carried over depends on concentration. Now strong concentration we can train in. Calm abiding is another story but strong concentration is not impossible. With strong repeated concentration because these are our true friends to develop our mind.
As I was giving the think this is a marvelous picture, I like pictures in this matter. Hammering a piece of iron into shape, you need heat and you need repetition, those are your two friends. Heat alone you can’t do a lot. Repetition alone it’s basically a very painful process if it happens at all. Heat, in other words concentration and going at it every day or if you can’t every day every week, it will carry over.
The more heat, more concentration the more will carry over. Then in the next life instead of starting let’s say from here we start from here. Then it seems like a painful process but as His Holiness says frequently that’s all there is. So what therefore are the differences between contrived and spontaneous motivation? Contrived motivations must be generated anew incrementally each time.
From a Buddhist standpoint, if the motivation is not generated, the deed does not lead to the wished for consequences. The deed depends on the motivation. Spontaneous motivations do not need to be generated. We have at present spontaneous motivations for instance the motivation to survive, the instinct of survival. If heaven forbid someone were to jump on Chris or on Deva they would fight back.
They wouldn’t even think the spontaneous motivation, spontaneous instinct of survival. So we do have spontaneous instincts. From a Buddhist standpoint they have been trained in countless. They are very powerful. Now we want to replace these problematic spontaneous instincts with beneficial spontaneous instincts.
And we do have a base. That is the important point from the previous talk. We have a neurological substrate which allows this to be done. It is fairly evident that some beings, let us say for instance snakes, lack the neurological basis and probably lack the social basis for generating such motivation as well as the cognitive capacities. And therefore the definition of a spontaneous motivation is beautifully given by Je Tsongkhapa in the Three Principles of the Path.
When through meditation, that’s a key point here, nary one instant of longing for the marvelous of psychic existence arises and the day and night as Geshela pointed out in the dream state therefore the mind striving for liberation arises then renunciation will have been well generated. Now this is the definition of spontaneous renunciation. The same definition could be applied to spontaneous bodhichitta. Your standard, your criterion can be one of two I let you choose. The motivation is spontaneous and here’s the easy criterion.
If it appears in the dream state or the motivation is spontaneous if you’re in Paris during the terrorist attack on the Bataclan and your spontaneous motivation is to help the terrorists, to lead them to full enlightenment and I think it’s easier in the dream state isn’t it? But it is very helpful to test and the Geshe’s do this, the great practitioners do this, to test where you are by putting yourself not now but later when you have trained the mind putting yourself in difficult risky situations. That shows where one is. Until then one does not know. One does not know.
So as I said in more senses than one the generation of uncontrived motivations, these are definitely renunciation or bodhichitta amounts to creating new instincts which substitute themselves to the instinct of the survival of the individual of the species. Whether this is possible or not is open to question. From a scientific standpoint it is impossible, probably, because the field is still being investigated. Now what are motivations and I’d like to open a brief parentheses within minds and mental factors. Some of you have studied Lorig, it should be more familiar.
We won’t cover it in too many details. There are two types of consciousnesses main minds and mental factors. The main minds have an object. Mental factors are all the subsidiary minds surrounding the main mind which have the same object. And typically they include emotions and all that.
So the main mind just focuses on the core of the object. And the mental factors apprehend the subsidiary factors. Now main minds can either be conceptual, in other words they rely on a mental image, all our thoughts are conceptual. In this room right now everything we are doing is basically conceptual except the act of seeing the screen and listening to the conference. Apart from that your thoughts, probably most of your emotions are all conceptual.
And non conceptual minds, non conceptual minds are visual consciousness apprehending the white curve of the table, the auditory consciousness hearing the sound and so forth. Now what exactly is the link between the main mind and its associated mental factors? They are like the palm of the hand and the fingers of the hand. There are five shared factors. They have the same base and the same object.
Same thing as point two really, minor distinction. Same aspect, same duration and same substance. And it is best understood if I were to take an example. Let us say we look at this vase of yellow flowers and I have always wanted to receive yellow flowers, let us assume. Thank you Chris.
Looking at the yellow flowers, a powerful emotion of happiness arises. We have a main mind which is my visual consciousness seeing the yellow color of the flowers and its shape and at the same time and with a similar aspect to that mental consciousness we have an emotion of happiness. Now, if that consciousness is non conceptual the mental factors are non conceptual. If that consciousness is conceptual the mental factors are conceptual. They last for the same period of time.
They have the same object. One is a main mind which focuses on the global appearance of the yellow flower, a visual consciousness, the other are mental factors. Now from a Buddhist standpoint what matters are the mental factors. All afflictions are mental factors. No affliction is a main mind.
Then I won’t enter into this too much the 51 mental factors except to point out that at present when we speak of bodhichitta what interests us is one specific mental factor, the mental factor of aspiration or wishing. And there are numerous debates about bodhichitta which we will cover very briefly here whether Buddhichitta is indeed a mental factor which is my personal opinion or whether it is a main mind. Both positions have been kept. So basically the jury is out because within the greatest scholars of ancient India for Asaṇga and Vasubandhu bodhichitta is a mental factor. In other words it’s a wish, it is subsidiary to the main mind, let’s say focusing on the yellow color of the flowers.
For Haribhādra it is a main mind and this is actually the position of the great, textbooks of the Tibetan monastery so I was always at odds with my classmates on this one. You’re entitled to have your own position. There are some arguments but the main argument is that is such a precious mind it can’t be subsidiary. That doesn’t really cut the ice. You have to basically function on the basis of logic and analysis.
A motivation is a motivation. Then motivations are mental factors. If bodhichitta is not a motivation what exactly is it? It gets very awkward. So my position is actually a minor position within the Geluk tradition the position of Khedrupje, Je Tsongkhapa’s closest disciple and certainly the greatest scholar in the Geluk tradition, for whom bodhichitta is a main mind And he defines bodhichitta in his commentary on Abhisamayālamkāra as a main mind which is motivated by desire for the welfare of others and assists desiring perfect enlightenment.
Then think for yourselves whether if you were able to generate uncontrived bodhichitta, in other words if you’re able to generate an instinct which is striving for full enlightenment for the sake of others substituting itself to the instinct for individual survival whether such an instinct would be a main mind such as the visual consciousness focusing on the yellow color of the flower or a subsidiary mind, a mental factor. It’s something you have to think about very carefully. Both positions have been endorsed by great scholars of ancient India and very great Tibetan scholars. J. J.
G. Gilsing the author of the monastic texts of Sera Je considers that bodhichitta is a main mind. Khedrupje considers it’s a mental factor. Then I won’t enter into many details regarding the lineages for the generation of bodhichitta except to point out that there are two different lineages Both eventually fused in Atisha, initially both were taught by the Buddha one explicitly or implicitly. The sevenfold causal generation lineage is dominant in Asaṇga’s tradition in the works of Maitreya, Asaṇga’s teacher and Asaṇga.
The interchange of Sef and others which Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen is teaching here is predominant in Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvali, his precious garland, in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara and was transmitted to Atisha by Suvarnadvipi his teacher from Sumatra. These two lineages lead to exactly the same result the generation of bodhichitta. One was public the causal lineage, one was secret, the equalization interchange of self and others. It is said that the causal lineage leads to a weaker generation of love and great compassion then the equalization interchange of self and others. There are specific reasons for this.
So here since Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen is covering the equalization interchange of self and others I wanted to cover the causal lineage because it ties in very well with the material we saw in the previous hour. Many of you know the causal lineage. We have one foundation, equanimity. We normally have six causes and one result. These six causes are a series of states of mind we have to generate incrementally and in sequence to give rise to this new instinct we are trying to generate.
bodhichitta which is a mind, which is a mind which for the sake of others is striving for enlightenment. This becomes an instinct. So initially we would train incrementally starting with equanimity which is the foundation we shall talk about it shortly and then the causes must follow in sequence except and Je Tsongkhapa pointed out this is a very interesting point for causes four and five. The sequence of generation of love and great compassion is uncertain. You can generate love before great compassion or you can generate great compassion before love.
In my own case I always felt that it seemed to make more sense to first generate compassion and then generate love then the other way around. But that’s a personal predilection if you wish. Now here to actually generate uncontrived motivations, it is vital to use an actual base for meditation, another person. It is not possible to generate anything by meditating on the sequence in the abstract. One can meditate on this causal sequence in the abstract for all one’s life it will lead nowhere except a memorization of the sequence.
And this is one of the critical points which Je Tsongkhapa makes in Lamrim Chenmo. If you train in these attitudes only using a general object like all mother sentient beings, which is how we basically meditate, you will seem to generate these attitudes but you will not be able to actually generate these attitudes towards anyone. Once you have a transformative experience towards one person, you may then gradually increase the number of individuals you visualized within your meditation, finally taking all beings in general as your object of meditation. So this is one of those numerous oral instructions which, suffuse Lamrim Chenmo. I cannot recommend too highly the detailed study of Lam Chemo if you want to achieve something in your practice.
This is really a key oral instruction. We must take one person as a base for the generation first of impartiality then recognizing beings as one’s mother then recollecting their kindness and so forth. Otherwise our mind will not change. So the generation of equanimity is actually a preliminary we owe to Kamalaśīla in his Bhāvanākrama. It probably was implicit before but Kamalaśīla is the first which makes it explicit.
It is like leveling the ground before building a house. If So one doesn’t level the ground, if one doesn’t have good foundations then from the beginning one will be close to some, one will be further away from others and as a result when one generates let us say love or compassion there will be more love for one and less love for the other which is obviously not the goal. The first step is to generate equanimity. And to do this we have to distinguish between the people we know. Majority of the people we know we are indifferent to.
We are indifferent probably to most of the world and to most living beings. Then towards friends we experience desire. Friends here include relatives, children, partners, what not. Towards enemies we experience hatred. So here we have to level all of this And what exactly are the meditations which are used to level these emotions?
They seem to have been taught initially in Tibet at Samyang by Kamalaśīla so there’s really no clear trace of their being taught in ancient India. I’m sure they existed but no no evidence. And the key here is as Lamrim Chenmo puts it, to understand that we are identical with others in our wish for happiness and our fear of suffering. This is the core identity we share with others. It’s a very transformative experience if we actually think about it truly.
For instance, we frequently get a TBI questions of students who have difficult experiences with others at work, in the family, etc. Then there are many ways to transform the mind when those difficult experiences arise. When we think of death and impermanence and so forth but the most powerful is to generate what amounts to empathy at the thought he or she is just like me. He or she wants to be happy. He or she is mistaken but the desire to be happy is there.
Then even if that person is very upset it doesn’t make a big difference. We see it as part of their quest for happiness. When we see the tragic misfits of society drug addicts, alcohol abusers and we think he is like me. As my mother always said there but for the grace of God go I. It’s a very powerful line for a Christian.
Yeah, but for the grace of God go I. Who am I to judge? He or she wants to be happy. I want to be happy. And he is selling drugs?
I could have if the circumstances were different. No one in this room I think can say that for sure if they could have a different background, different education, if they had been treated savagely by their parents instead of having been treated well they would not have ended up as drug dealers or worse. No one can say that. Then once we have that sense, we have great empathy for others. They are largely the product of circumstances of their environment.
Our circumstances were better, their circumstances were worse. We are like them in wishing to be happy. They are like us. It is just they’re going about it the wrong way. How can you be angry with someone for being mistaken like that?
Not possible. Then a strong feeling of compassion arises for the person on this space. And then the second way to generate this feeling of equanimity which is more in keeping with Kamala Śīla, but this calls for belief in past and future lives is to think all these beings, some are indifferent, some are problematic, all have been friends and if we believe in past lives is very powerful. I forgot he or she was my friend, it was my friend, I forgot. But my forgetting should not affect the friendship.
If you have an old friend who meets you after many years and he looks at you with happiness and joy and you don’t quite remember him and he says you forgot me how do you feel, it’s awful right? You forgot me. Oh yes, yes yes yes. I think you don’t want to say the name but you’re not quite sure. So here it is not the distinction between friend and enemy which you should eliminate.
We have people who behave in a friendly way and people who behave in a hostile way. It is our reaction of anger or desire we should eliminate. If we are to say that someone who beats us is the same as someone who gives us, let’s say in my case a donut, because I’m very fond of donuts, then that is irrational frankly. Because certainly in this life there is a clear difference between getting beaten on the head and getting a donut. But the goal is to eliminate that reaction of animosity towards the person who beats us and of great affection for the person who gives you a donut.
So having laid out this foundation we have to recognize all sentient beings as one’s mothers of yours. And this line of reasoning is one that’s why Gesheera asked me what I thought would be best to teach here to generate bodhichitta and I suggested the equalization interchange of self and others because over the years we have seen that the sevenfold cause and instruction is very problematic for westerners. They like its being structured but the premise, the base premise that every sentient being has been one’s mother at some point in the past is something they can actually never accept. And I remember one of our students coming to me, just a couple months ago, very proud actually, she said to me, I have mathematically demonstrated using what was it, Markov matrices I think, that all mother sentient all sentient beings cannot have been a mother. And she showed me the demonstration.
I was in a long email contact with a professor at the University of Adelaide and a mathematician were trying to demonstrate the same thing that all sentient beings could not be a mother. Finally he demonstrated it was possible, she demonstrated it was impossible. Then I said to her look, mean all you have done is evacuated one of two lines of reasoning for generating bodhichitta for yourself. Unless you can convince yourself that it is not only possible but necessary you will never generate bodhichitta this way. So then it seems to me this line of reasoning is too problematic for Westerners.
Largely because the belief in past and future lives in the full sense is absent. And the equalization interchange of self and others is much more beneficial. Because even if people actually never become Buddhists, in other words never believe in past future lives and karma, through this line of reasoning of the equalization itself and others they can become better persons. They can become kinder people, warmer people, that is of benefit for the future. Then probably whether Buddhism actually does spread in the West or not that is an open question.
So this line of reasoning, the causal reasoning is one which is alluded to by a Sangha, I have difficulty seeing a place where you have not been born, gone to or died in the distant past. I have difficulty, it’s a classic Indian way of saying I cannot see. I have difficulty in seeing any person who has not been your father, mother, uncle, aunt, sister, master Abbot Guhu or someone like Guhu. And here a key point in the generation of the first cause for bodhichitta recognizing all beings as one’s mothers of yore is accepting past and future lives and accepting that in a previous life every single being was extraordinarily close to us. Now for many of our students the relation with their mother is highly problematic for some reason.
Then it can be any other member of the family with whom they were close. It’s clear. It can be their father. For many Eastern Europeans were raised by their grandmother, be their grandmother, their uncle, even a teacher in school but whether this leads to the generation of powerful bodhichitta or not is an open question because as we said when we visualize all sentient beings as our mothers we basically stimulate oxytocin producing circuits in the mind. Whether they will be stimulated to the same degree by seeing all mother sentient beings as your greengrocer is open to question.
You may have been very close to your greengrocer but I don’t know. So this line of reasoning is problematic for Westerners for numerous reasons including family relations. However, if it is possible, if one has had a good family upbringing, if one is close to one’s parents, the figure of the mother is much more powerful than that of the father. And you remember that from the Harvard Health Study. Closeness to the mother is a stronger predictor of health in at the end of middle age and closeness to the father.
Probably simply because we are raised by our mother. You know if everyone of us if I look back at the kindness of my own mother it’s astonishing. Astonishing. So the next step is to recognize the kindness of one’s mother and the kindness of one’s mother in non human form. So in human lives it’s quite straightforward.
The kindness of a mother bear to her cub, of a female lion, a she lion to her cubs. Or these extraordinary pictures from Pompeii. Excuse me, from China, my apologies. Thought it was Pompeii. There’s a famous one from Pompeii in the museum as well.
A mother who was buried by an earthquake and who died sheltering her child. So while you see that your relatives are engulfed in the ocean of psychic existence and now as they’ve fallen into a pit of fire, there is nothing more shameful than to work for your own liberation. Neglecting those whom you do not recognize due to the process of death and rebirth. Chagdor means slant on recollecting the kindness of mothers. The only reason we do not recollect it is a process of death and rebirth.
Very interesting. So how should we recollect their kindness and it is here I think that the Tibetan contributions to Buddhism have been huge. The Tibetans have fleshed out and formalized the Indian meditation techniques in an extremely skillful way psychologically. Using visualization, Lamrim Cemo described this process as follows, one imagines one’s mother’s clearly in front of oneself And one thinks not only has she been my mother at present but she has been so an incalculable number of times beginningless cyclic existence. And then one brings back to mind the memories, the actual memories of the kindness of the mother.
Disease, suffering, teaching you, in my case how to tie my shoelaces I remember that very clearly. Could not tie my shoelaces without my mother’s kindness. Well, as I said to all of you we are at present having a conference. I speak thanks to my mother’s kindness. You hear and understand thanks to your mother’s kindness.
I learned to speak imitating my mother’s mouth. You learn to understand listening to your mother’s speech. All of us in this room will be animals in the zoo without the kindness of our mothers. Those of you who have difficult relations with your parents, please think about this. By cultivating a remembrance of your mother’s kindness you will not remember it just in words.
Recognize that other friends and relatives such as your father or your mother’s. You see the extraordinary emphasis on the kindness of the mother which I think is tying in with these very powerful neurological circuits we talked about earlier. Then you spread this from friends and relatives to those towards whom you have neutral feelings and finally your enemies. In other words, you start with the easiest. There will be tremendous psychological resistance to generating this recollection of the kindness of the mother towards enemies.
You must break down the psychological resistance. It starts by generating it towards those to whom you are already close. Then those who are indifferent to you and then your enemies starting with those towards whom you have the least hostility and moving up heaven forbid but maybe some of you have you know extraordinarily vindictive enemies you know, moving up to your extraordinarily vindictive enemies. Repaying their kindness, and this picture is quite evocative, this is a Chinese man in Taiwan carrying his mother suffering from Alzheimer’s to the hospital and feeding her in the waiting room. Here we recollect the kindness of all mother sentient beings and we generate a very strong sense that they wish happiness like we do, they fear suffering like we do, but they do not understand.
They are totally crazed. They are blind. And they have no guide, in other words no teacher. They’re approaching a frightful precipice which precipice? That of the lower rebirth but even in this life the precipice of drugs, of alcohol, of crime, madness, mental problems.
So many of us students have mental problems. And if our mother cannot place hope in us then whom? It’s a very strong realization this one. If we do not take responsibility who does? And normally this should create a very strong sense of obligation and courage.
At this point we generate love which is the foremost armor. The armor with which Buddha Śākyamūni in this beautiful Indian painting actually defeated the demons, the Maras. He did not defeat them through the practice of Yamāntaka. He defeated them through love. Love is the supreme protector.
Once again when we train in love we start with those we are close to and we move outwards to the majority of mankind we are indifferent to and finally to our enemies. And here you can see that within the causes we have four equanimity is normally not treated as a cause but it is four causes. Equanimity recognizing all sentient beings as one’s mother, recollecting their kindness and repaying their kindness. Once that is generated either love or great compassion arises. Which one arises is open to question.
Normally it’s love and great compassion in that secret. Love is the wish for all sentient beings to be happy. When you love someone you want them to be happy. Compassion is a wish for them not to suffer but the sequence in which they arise is open to question. As Je Tsongkhapa says beautifully in Lamrim Chenmo with his eyes said these key points to Je Tsongkhapa’s own meditation And here great compassion arises.
All of you have attended many teachings. Does anyone know in the room what these two pictures are allude to? Little mouse in the turquoise. There was a very great Kadampa Geshe, Geshe Langri Thangpa, one of the greatest And he meditated on the suffering of psychic existence and on compassion continually. Then, you see, when we attend teachings we like teachers who smile and laugh.
He’s always praised for smiling and laughing. Rinpoche was criticized for being too stern. Rinpoche learned to smile and laughed. Then Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen, the advice Rinpoche gave to Geshe Jampa Gilsson when he came to see was Giggle. That’s a Geshe Jampa Gyatso when I knew him he like that but he doesn’t play well with Western students you know they see like to see immediate proof of the happiness Buddhism gives.
Then Geshe Langri Thangpa was called blackface because he always meditated on suffering and compassion and then obviously you know it was dark. And his students complained they said we have so few disciples because you are so unprepossessing you know. And then one time he was meditating on suffering and looking at his mandala set There was a big turquoise and a little mouse was trying to lift the turquoise but didn’t succeed. And then Sims asked for the help of another little mouse and the two of them struggled with the turquoise back to their home and he smiled. They say it’s the only time Geshe Langri Thangpa smiled.
So here the key to generate compassion is renunciation And the key to renunciation is meditation on one’s own suffering. Obviously if we don’t believe we suffer these meditations are totally ineffectual. So we have to understand what suffering is. I don’t have time to enter into that in detail here but we have to distinguish between mental and physical suffering. And it is only through generating a powerful sense of our own suffering that eventually great compassion will arise in our mind stream.
When we understand that others are just like us, there is no difference. And here great compassion as we said is an uncontrived experience. It must arise spontaneously. We see this distinction the great Indian text. We see it clearly in Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama.
When we spontaneously feel compassion which has a subjective wish to completely eliminate the suffering of all sentient beings just like a mother’s wish to remove her dear child’s unhappiness, Then your compassion is complete and is therefore called great compassion. So in the Theravada immeasurable compassion immeasurable love are created. In the Mahāyāna love and great compassion are generated. Is there a difference or not? If there is no difference then the Theravada should give rise to bodhichitta, the causes are created.
If there is a difference, what is the difference? Does any of you have an idea? Sorry? Yes, you’re very close. Love is only for oneself.
Compassion only for oneself. What about the Metta Sutta? The Metasutra is a sūtra recited by Theravada monks in Thailand. sūtra of Love, beautiful sūtra of Love. We should not deprecate the Theravada.
Read the Metasutra. So? Not quite but you’re very close once again. Yes. That is the case why is it called immeasurable love in Theravada.
It’s not immeasurable if you only love your relatives. If Arhat only loved their relatives they would be like ordinary beings. I mean ordinary beings love their parents. Theravada has immeasurable love and immeasurable compassion. The difference is central.
The difference is that Theravada does not consider it realistic to act on this basis. The Hīnayāna considers the Hīnayāna has great, has immeasurable compassion, he has immeasurable love. These are great beings if we could be it would be extraordinary you know. I mentioned many times here you know because I sometimes feel very awkward with the presentation of Mahāyāna teachings. We are sort of, excuse me for the casualness of the term, pooh poohing great spiritual traditions.
One of my old friends at Sera, he was the chant master of the Hayagrīva Protector Group. Excellent Geshe, Geshe Ishigawa. Very humble. Old old Geshe. One time he said to me very quietly he said you know I wish I could be an Achat but I don’t have the strength.
This is very humbling. We talk about the Marianne but honestly the meaning is not there. The Theravada Arhats, Theravada practitioners train in great compassion, they train in immeasurable compassion immeasurable love. But they don’t consider that attaining full enlightenment for the sake of benefiting all sentient beings is a realistic goal because they don’t consider all sentient beings can be benefited. And therefore they don’t consider all sentient beings can be benefited.
And therefore as they consider the goal unrealistic they just generate these two states of mind and stay there. And therefore they do not generate as Pamela said, wholehearted resolve. That will, that decision, I will take responsibility, here you need a strong sense of I. This is a classic case where you need a strong sense of I, a sense of strong self confidence. Courage is called for here and here one generates bodhichitta.
Once wholehearted resolve is generated bodhichitta follows very rapidly. And bodhichitta is defined very simply in Abhisamayālamkāra. To have generated bodhichitta is for the sake of others, not for one sake, for the sake of others to wish for full enlightenment. So here the goal is for enlightenment, the object of attainment, the motivation is for the sake of others and that is probably who we are all deficient. If we aim for full enlightenment it is for our own sake.
If we aim for full enlightenment for our own sake by definition we will never attain it. By definition. Because the accumulation of merit for full enlightenment only arises independence on an infinite number of sentient beings. So, irrespective of the so called Mahāyāna and Tantric practices we engage in, those practices neither lead to liberation nor to full enlightenment if the causes are not generated. You can practice Yamāntaka for all your life and create the causes for being reborn as a spirit in the shape of Yamāntaka.
As Atisha said. Someone was asking Atisha what is the benefit of Tantric practice? He said: Without the motivation none. There is a spirit at the border of Tibet in the shape of Yamantak, I had to exercise. So, in our own practice what should the priority be?
The priority has to be to generate these powerful uncontrived motivations. As my first teacher Geshe Rabten said, he was the finest Pramāna scholar Tibet produced in the last century and also perhaps perhaps the most advanced meditator in the Gelug tradition. He said after years of study I have concluded the only thing worthwhile is bodhichitta. Then as Nāgārjuna said in the bodhichitta vivarana there is no other means in existence for establishing one’s own welfare and that of others. The Buddhas of yore beheld no such means apart from bodhichitta.
This therefore should be the goal of our practice. Everything else should be subsidiary. Training in definite emergence is subsidiary. It is a training in definite emergence because we need definite emergence to generate great compassion as was explained. And we need great compassion to generate bodhichitta.
Training in the view should be subsidiary. First frankly because for most of us understanding the view is very difficult. Certainly Prasadhika Mādhyamika view is almost impossible without a lot of study. Understanding bodhichitta is not difficult. It can be done.
Then generating it is something else. So these two lineages, the sevenfold causal instruction and the equalization interchange of self and others were fused by Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche. So I think the 11 step instruction of Pabongka Rinpoche is the supreme means to generate bodhichitta. It is longer but it is both more powerful than any of the means separately and the steps are very clearly delineated. And this is this 11 fold sequence.
Starting with equanimity and then you can see what I put in yellow are the steps which come from the equalization interchange of self and others. And in blue those which are exclusive to the seven fold causal generation. And if you have a blue marker on a yellow rectangle then those are shared steps. So you can see here that the uncommon specific steps to the sevenfold causal generation are these three steps recognizing all sentient beings as mothers, recollecting and repaying their kindness. This is the uncommon crux of the sevenfold instruction.
It will be very powerful for you if you come from a traditional Buddhist culture and believe in past and future lives or have a profound natural belief in past and future lives. And if you come from a society or a family where the mother and parental closeness is very important. If these two criteria are present, this sevenfold causal generation is perhaps the most powerful means to generate bodhichitta for you personally. If they are absent and it is a case for quite a few of our students then it is preferable to train in the equalization to change of self and others. If however you are able to do so, the best is to fuse both.
And here what you do is you start basically by training in the sevenfold causal generation up to the point of repaying the kindness of mother sentient beings. And there you have three uncommon steps before generating love and compassion. Steps eight and nine as a generation of love and compassion. You inject here the three preliminary trainings from the equalization interchange of self and others. In other words, first equalization of self and others, then recollecting through numerous lines of reasoning the faults of self cherishing and recollecting through numerous lines of reasoning the qualities of cherishing others.
And at this point when you generate love and compassion, you generate them using the oral instructions on Tonglen, which are not part of the sevenfold cause and instruction. So you link the generation of love with visualizing yourself giving happiness to all sentient beings and by happiness we refer here to your own merit, own possessions in your own body. When the possessions in the body are easy, the merit is difficult. There’s always a niggling part of ourselves which thinks they should have been accumulating their own merit. Right?
And then we take upon ourselves and that is training in compassion or inhaling the suffering of all sentient beings and their physical and mental suffering that’s one thing but we also take all their karmic imprints. And we do this with the firm intent that when we give it is no longer ours. So if you have mental reservation I’ve heard this many times during teachings on this topic it does not happen. Don’t be as my mother would say an Indian giver. I don’t know if you use that expression here.
Give with one hand and take back with the other. And when you take the sufferings of others upon yourself, really you have to visualize that they mature. The depression, schizophrenia, anxiety, cancer, poverty, health problems, all this matures on yourself and you rejoice. The more you rejoice after these two activities the more powerful the practice. Now if you do it well and perhaps I will contradict here what you have heard in some teachings, it will happen, not fully but some things will happen and that is good.
If you’re not able to think like that you’re not practicing the Mahāyāna. So to say you give but really you don’t give and you take but really you don’t take is non practice. You give and you take. And for this we need courage. And this courage comes from the realization that we are not strangers to each other.
Such a courage you will not have for someone who is a stranger to you. Such a courage you will have for someone who is so close. Probably in this room every one of us would jump in the fire for their mother. Probably, without thinking. Then we have to reach a point where we jump in the fire for others.
Then I will skip because we have little time. What we wish to generate is therefore this state of mind which Nagajuna describes in the bodhichitta vivarana. Just as those Bhagavan buddhas and great bodhisattvas gave rise to the mind for great enlightenment. Likewise I as well will give rise to the mind for great enlightenment. From now onwards until I reach the essence, in other words for enlightenment.
And we must be able to take the pledge, the great pledge of Śāntideva. During the intermediate eon of famine, may I become food and drink for sentient beings? They say this is a pledge of the Dalai Lama. Then I wanted to thank you and I’m open for your questions. Yes and if it’s now heaven forbid we should not have the panel if it’s on the program.
Pamela would you please would you please come? We have a panel. That’s a good question. Then the panel has convened. Okay.
The panel has convened. To what end, I’m not sure. That I don’t know. I will just I will just sit here and nod. Nod sagely.
Go ahead. Yes. As you answer questions. Then I will nod sagely too? No.
It’s a tall order. The Mahāyāna, it’s a tall order. The first thing we have to ask ourselves is, is this true or not? Is this real or not? Is it possible to become like that or is it just a fantasy in some Indian texts?
For that we have to ask ourselves, is there someone like that now? I think this Holiestad Dalai Lama is like that. And you have to check for yourselves. Can great, I mean, immeasurable love be a natural to a child when we don’t teach them and they have this great compassion developed by themselves. Yes.
Because I see some, you know, they give money to beggars and without, parent teaching them. They just see it and they say, can I give money? Yes, that depends on previous karmic imprints. Depends on previous comic imprints. I knew of a little child who gave all his mother’s money in school and he got into big trouble.
So that depends on the karma. And the opposite is true. And you have another child who has a very young child enjoyed stealing. Great delight in stealing. They are rare.
The the ones the children really, really small children, they’re they’re predominantly, their instincts are toward fairness Yes. Toward fairness and toward sharing and giving. Yes. Yes. They kind of have to be trained out of it.
Because as you were saying in your first seminar, empathy is hardwired into us. And that’s really, really apparent in normally functioning children. When I say normally functioning, that means children who are not psychopaths. There’s a study by Karen Wynn from Yale on this topic that little children at three months of age manifest a clear preference for those who are helping others Yes. Over those who are harming others.
It’s very striking. So this is unlearned, obviously. Right? At three months, how do you know anything? That’s striking.
Are either of you familiar with is it Kristin Neff and her work on compassion versus self esteem? I think she said that and she’s drawing on Buddhist thought that in The States in particular where there’s been an emphasis on teaching self esteem, there’s been an increase in narcissism as opposed to compassion which has more an emphasis on considering the commonality of suffering. I’m not familiar with the work but I would imagine it is a misguided response that approach in America to the prevalence of depression. The way to handle depression is not to foster self esteem. There’s a big difference between self esteem on the one hand and self confidence and courage on the other hand.
The way to handle depression is to encourage and that really there’s a lot of data now to encourage the practice of altruism and helping others. That really helps. Then to create this inflated ego which is fragile and this is what most of the self help books seem to teach, that is of no benefit. There’s a big difference between an inflated ego and courage. Courage is realistic.
It’s based on a correct assessment of who one is in one’s capacities. Then it will withstand pressure and inflated self esteem will collapse under pressure. There seems to be a confusion and perhaps I have too, being confused about you said to have courage you need a strong sense of I and a strong sense of self at least. And so there seems to be the idea of negating the wrong eye, negating the ordinary conventional eye that can be what is heard as opposed to needing a strong sense of self for the sake of others. In our present state Excuse me, please.
No. What I was going to actually say to you was, isn’t there a difference between self efficacy Mhmm. And self, you know, self esteem, worries about self esteem? I mean That’s good. One one of the things that really struck me when we went to Tibet with Rinpoche was that you came across these young Tibetan nomad children who were had such a sense of self efficacy that they were out looking after the animals at age seven and eight.
And really felt, you know, I can do this. I can do this. I mean, you go to the monastery and, they think they can fix the electricity. And that’s not always right, but somehow nobody gets killed. Okay, alright.
Maybe that’s not so. But but but there’s a but there’s a feeling of self efficacy That’s exactly it. That is not, you know, self esteem. It’s not self love. Yes.
It’s a much better term. It’s self efficacy. I would abandon self esteem Yeah. And opt self efficacy. Definitely.
Definitely. And I think that that whole field arose out of basically behaviorist psychology. The behaviorism Skinnerian psychology told us that you could be infinitely conditioned. Nurture became the central tenant of whether you’re okay or not. Nurture.
Then the mother got it in the neck because it’s always the mother’s You know? And and so your childhood nurturance became really, really, really important. And that just went off the rails pretty much. But to answer your question, Chris, for us as ordinary beings it is not possible at present to I’ll use some more casual terms, to live the method and the wisdom aspect of the path at the same time with the same mind. It’s not possible.
Fully enlightened beings can. In other words, when we are aware of the interdependent nature of the eye we are not able simultaneously with the same mind to generate a strong stable eye. The two are different things. Now when we’re training in the method aspect of the past, we actually need a strong eye. If you want to generate wholehearted resolve, think of what it means.
It’s much greater than the courage of a soldier who alone launches himself against enemy troops. One is taking responsibility for everybody and one needs courage. Courage and strength are virtues actually some of the 10 strengths of Bodhisattva which are greatly underplayed in the Western Buddhist community. They are some of the greatest virtues for Tibetans Simply because if someone is strong and courageous, like Milarepa, even if they are misguided, even criminal, Milarepa basically was a serial killer, that strength and that courage is a ground rock on which you can build. If there’s no strength in courage, you can’t build.
So that is necessary. I have an example of growing empathy and self esteem in my sister, who at one time was described by her son as the most selfish woman in the world. However, some ten years on, she is now courageous and supportive of my mother who’s in deep dementia in a nursing home. And she’s a volunteer there at the nursing home. And she’s blabbed.
She’s just blossomed. All of us can change. Then the two things we need is to believe that we can change and to know in what direction to change. Do you have other questions? Please.
It’s a personal question and I find it a little embarrassing. May I ask your advice? Have a strong antipathy with a particular person. It’s a person that’s important in my life and I’ve tried to make myself understanding and forgiving and I’m completely unable to do it. It seems like it’s a profound blindness within myself and I don’t know where to go with that.
When we have these innate emotions towards another person with no clear explanation in this life, which is I assume what you are talking about, then the first step is to understand that they may not come from this life. These may be linked to emotions and experiences in previous lives. Then the activation is uncontrollable. It comes up and it is very irrational. One gets hostile or angry thoughts which are totally unwanted by the behavior of the person or from their side the opposite, hostile and angry thoughts for us which nothing in their life or our life seem to explain.
This is a clear sign of maturation of comic imprints. Then if the maturation is full blown, the best is to move away. If it is not full blown, it must be addressed at the root. One must purify the comic imprints. There are several ways to do it.
If one is a Buddhist, one can engage in purification practices like recitation of Vajrasattva mantra, which really does eliminate these automatisms. Then if one is not a Buddhist it helps a lot to think, well, these harmful experiences, these harsh words, maybe even heaven forbid these blows, they all come from my own past karma. In a nutshell, what I did to another has come back to me. It is a wheel of sharp weapons. If I have the strength to bear it, it will no longer be experienced in the future.
One does not have to be a Buddhist to think that. Then that exhausts the non virtuous karma. Then as far as purification is concerned, I know at least one case is very striking. It was a young girl I used to know who had a very very difficult life And eventually, there were virtuous comic imprints, but there was a lot of non virtue. She did retreat after retreat and offered hundreds of thousands of prostrations.
Prostrations. And this person completely changed. It’s a different person. Different person. She was a prostitute, a drug user.
She had been sold as a prostitute in Holland by Albanian dealers. Then she escaped to England. It’s a harsh life. By Western style, it’s a very harsh life. You know?
And when she escaped, there was a contract put on her head. You can imagine, right? This person eventually went to India, trained her mind, there was like a spark there, you know. And then probably because she almost died, she had a very bad car accident, the skull was damaged, the limbs were damaged. She did the Vajrasattva retreats, She offered more than 1,000,000 prostrations in Bodhgaya.
Then, this is a different person now, a pillar of one of the country traditions. A very great poet practitioner and a westerner, like everyone of us in this room. The one difference I would say with us is a very stark experience of suffering. Therefore, it can be done. Now in our own lives, I think everyone of us has had this experience.
You meet someone, you have a natural sense of attraction. We call it love at first sight. Right? Falling in love is that. Or you meet someone and you have a natural sense of animosity.
Those are karmically determined. The first step to take control of our life is to study past and future lives, the works such as those of Stevenson, get an understanding of how it functions. Once one realizes something like that is happening, then one understands that we’re not fully aware of the baggage we have. It doesn’t go back to early childhood and stop there, as western psychology teaches. It can, but in most cases it goes way back.
Until we are aware of how far back it goes, we will never be free. We will reenact patterns of behavior which to others are self evident. Everyone who is around us can give us a very accurate description and list of our mistakes. Right? We ourselves can’t.
If want to know yourself, ask others. What do you do wrong? And then, that comes from the distant past. Then we purify. So I did, you know, 100,000 Vajrasattva mantras.
I was very very surprised to see the difference in my my personality. There were automatisms I had which disappeared. Some for instance may be linked to the mode of death. The mode of death in the previous lives, very important factor. If you were killed by someone which unfortunately is not uncommon, when you meet that person or their reincarnation of future life, you will have automatic fear and anger.
In my own case for instance, it seems that I suffered from great thirst in the death in my previous life. Then, when I was a teenager, I drank a lot of fluid, abnormal amounts of fluid, tea, just huge amounts. Until eventually, understanding that this might be the cause arose, At which point, it ceased to have power over me. So that is how we can gain freedom. When we speak of liberation, we’re speaking of freedom.
Freedom for us and freedom for others. And the key in the case of that person you’re talking about is to understand that just as they are like that, so am I. I hope that helps a bit. I’m just speaking to you previously, Ilya. You mentioned to me one time that cancer Rinpoche showed the deeds of a great body sufferer.
I think it’s important to have examples in life to be able to look up to in order to be able to practise better. Can you just talk a little bit about why you would think that way about Rinbuchet because you had some close experience with him and also Pamela as well. You’ve had some close encounters and experience with Rinpoche. Just to give us an insight as a view into what your experience was with Rinpoche, most likely a body sufferer? No, you’re going first on this one.
I think one of the features of Rinpoche which is extraordinary was that Rinpoche never despaired. Then you have to put yourself in the shoes of someone that kills Rinpoche who was actually a reincarnate lama of the Nyingma tradition, not recognized but acknowledged, who became abbot of Sera Je, who was the foremost scholar of Abhidharma and Tibetan grammar of his generation, the foremost Vajrayoginī practitioner of his generation, and who was basically sent in exile to Adelaide. I mean, from the standpoint of a great abbot, imagine what Adelaide feels like. You put the abbot of Sera Je Rinpoche was a teacher of everybody, of of everybody who counted at Sarah.
Rinpoche transmitted the in Dharamsala. It is done once a generation. He bears the name means lineage holder. And then he came in this small town, and I was told when he taught tenants, there were two, three people attending. Oh, there were maybe six.
Six. Okay. Inspector, there were six people attending. But it started out with 50. And he stayed here for years.
And I remember the one piece of advice when Rinpoche gave me, which is very difficult well, for me, very difficult to practice is, he said, if there is a benefit for one person, you must stay. Clearly that is advice of Bodhisattva puts in practice. Then in addition to that Rinpoche had experiences which are very humbling. He talked little about them, as you may have heard during his retreat which Vajrayoginī appeared and made offerings to Rinpoche. Himbauchi was said to be the foremost heroic practitioner after his death by His Holiness of Dalai Lama.
By came, came, came, to visit Khensur Rinpoche in his own home which he only did with one other teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, my root teacher. Then all of this suggests that Rinpoche had very high realizations. If he did not generate bodhichitta then who did? Then more than that it is difficult to know. Mean, Rinpoche had the paranormal powers that I know from the accounts of students and my own experiences.
And when one student in Singapore was on the edge of suicide, he himself was not in Singapore. He sent students from Taiwan to Singapore to help that student. More than that, it’s difficult to say. Robert T. Would always say things to me in oblique way.
He would say, had a dream. Then he’s the way he described his dreams is very undream like. He had visions of Khensur Rinpoche after Khensur Rinpoche’s death. Kensington Gensington appeared, and he described it as a dream. Khensur Rinpoche walked into light behind Rinpoche’s back.
And Rinpoche said to me, he said, I told him, wait, wait, I will come with you, but he was already gone. Then I knew Rinpoche was going to die. You know? Then Rinpoche had clear visions of the future of his students. Those of you who were close to him, you would see.
When you ask Rinpoche, if you were very close to Rinpoche, Rinpoche would go quiet. His eyes would go upwards, be a long pause. And he would be going very far in the future of the student. Years. To give advice, which was of great benefit to him, whether the student followed the advice or not, that there is no control.
You know? And Rinpoche was really the the the bodhisattva who took care of those who in many cases I would have thought were beyond taking care of. Yes. So my first creation with Rinpoche was a complicated one because I was quite annoyed with Himachal. I was involved with a big project in India.
It’s a creation of Sera IMI and I wanted a multistory building. So I could set aside the funds for multistory building for at least thirty months. And Jampa Kelsang, who was Rinpoche’s disciple, I was not Rinpoche’s disciple at the period, went to ask Rinpoche for advice. Rinpoche said it’s better to do just one story. I was really annoyed because I thought this is going to hinder development in the future.
At the end of the day, what a stranger do to prevent a sponsor for making a donation. Then, I just kept my my mouth shut, you know, and we built one story and no one came. And after two, three years, thought, my goodness, You know? Thank heavens we didn’t bear fruit. And, you know, the three of us would be sweeping 30 rooms, you know, all the time.
And that it’s at that point that my outlook because there are many teachers. You don’t know whose school. My outlook in Rinpoche changed. I thought, yes. Yes.
This is someone who sees far. More than that, I could not say at the period. And then Rinpoche started sending students to IMI. And I remember one of the students, he had tattoos basically from his toes to the tip of his nose. I looked at him, I thought, my goodness, you know, now what?
Right? You know, this one is not gonna last. And he became a very good monk. And then again, I thought, okay, these are these are the signs of a great being, that we remain at the level of ordinary appearances such a being sees far. Then I thought, this is an uncommon teacher.
And then when Rinpoche asked me to translate for him, the first translation was a Tārā initiation, and I accepted. And that is the first time I saw Rinpoche’s powers. So I I had been very, very close to Kensington, you know, with my root teacher. Student, a great scholar. More than that I did not know.
I came in the room and there were like billows, billows of green wind and light coming from my project. You could barely move in the room. There was an Indian disciple and I thought, my goodness, what a yogi. And then after that I had faced Himachal. And then the relationship was built over time.
Himachal asked me, I was in the fortunate situation to sponsor teachings. What I wanted to sponsor, then I wanted to sponsor the transmission of liberation in the palm of your hand which is almost lost. I received it directly from Pabongka Rinpoche if you can imagine. Then I sponsored the publication in which it gave the teaching, I asked permission to translate. Then obviously you establish a strong link.
So once you meet a teacher like that then you have to be greedy. Then you have to make a very strong link, the stronger the better, over and again. The Rinpoche has given me many advice over the years. As the advice of all great teachers, it is difficult advice to practice, but what I find is that Rinpoche’s advice over the years is the best path. And that is that is really the sign of a holy being.
Then from our side we have had something like this at TBI. I think many of our students were not aware. You had to be an Indian to know. Those who could rely, they have gone very far. Our old students who have stayed on, have gone very far.
And the likes of Rinpoche, we will not see again. The conditions are not there. Those beings are no longer created. I hope that answers your question. Repertory was much more discreet than some of my other teachers who had extraordinary capacities and manifested them.
But if you have faith in his soul as the Dalai Lama, I think it’s difficult not to. Then how can you not have faith in someone like Khensur Rinpoche who is so close to him? Then Pamela, excuse me, spoke a long time. You were much We’re longer than I out of time, I would think. Well, actually, perhaps I can check.
I mean, it’s five past twelve. No. Why don’t we stop? And I’ll I’ll say something after my after my talk. Sounds very good.
Does that sound alright? Can you hold? Okay. So we’ll break for lunch which is we’ll resume at 01:30 and then Pamela will commence at 01:30. At 01:30, right?
Yeah. Good. If we can thank Ilya and thank Pamela as well for being on the panel in the usual manner.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- four maras du zhi (Tib)
- The four external and internal hindrances or obstacles to our spiritual progress. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.